Professional Documents
Culture Documents
jirii<\'
<\'~:lj~~ ,
C~-~~~ ~~tM\! ~~O'f \!t~ ~ll'r~ ~<J..'iji ~ll''1l~~ ~~tr~~ \!~~
~"IJtr'1 ~O{~ 9f~~t~ ~~~f5~C'Sf~~t;{r\! ~r~ I ~~'1<\'t~~ ~R5
~~~ cm!~rO'fo{,<il~~~~ ~tr'l'~ :lj~~J~ ~tCO'f1
~r~~ f\!if;{ c9fr~r~O{I ~ 9f~if"l ~-~~ ~~, \!l~ ~~
I!lIDO{<il<\'~'1ilf~<\'~,"
15!\!<il<\'
O{tf<!>
~~O\tr~~ ~~~'t~ ~ll'r~ ~9ffs ~~1 \!)
.•.~ ~~~I}
9f~~<roriT <.!1"-~~, ~~ 9ffll"l!OT~~. ~~tr;~~ Clt tnr 'lIt'lfm filc5"
~lIf~, "'1"Pftlf"- ~tr~J-'f5~i{",~~ ~t'1C"l~111 ~'! ~"l "~'t1!tm 1ftfffi-'8~~ I"
·~
<\~ 'lt~'i!J '1"'Pjif'<Il~~ '<Il~1'i! ~~~tc~, C'l~ '1<\ <i.~,,,)~<\ ~~~c'R!
'121m mrt"l~~ ~~O{~t~~ ~tf1t~<\I
'fm
" ~HI 'ft1@r<ti~f;l\tr.",~ "cfOl:i~~ ~~<.II ~~11lC'lJ ~ ~Wlt1
~t~ ~l'tVi<\l~1
<!l~ ~Ol:~Ol:~'t<l~
~ n~ ~~t 9fft;~- ,
~~ \!I~ <!l~~ ~9ft1l11
I<~~ ~f .•~ ~ ~t~I
\!I~ 1W! ~~ ~tf~ ~~ ~ ""t<\~"'t
~'l ~~ lltlfJ ~~ ~~
"~c~,,
~~ ~<!l~ I
\!It <Ii f.lf»L~ ~<.I ~~a'\ ~~
\I
I
\!It ~t<\l~ ~(][ ~Ol:~Ol:'lt~~,
~ '1\~~~ ~ ~to{ I",
~a'\t'€ca'\~
~~~ u"
,,~~f~~ ~t'5t'l 9ft"€1l1
••~" \!I<l5$C1l1fi1",<tiro I ~ .*~ 'Itf~\!i ~ "<\IT<u~<It <\I1(I
~ 1{Clij~~~$ ~~~ "\!I~ ~Ol:f~ ~9f~~'" ~<ti ~~ ~ '6
~'\llf llf~~ \!I~ <\1m 9fC~ \!I~ D~~"t~ ~'I~{<tt~a'\~ ~R1 ~~J~
~ m~1 ro~ ~<m ~ "'~m~ I <tit'lJ~f.I~ ~ ~9f<ti~ l:5~
'l~ I ~~m~~"9ff"6~'lc5f~ ~'lItw <ti~~ C~ 'l'l ~D0l:19ft-em ~m~, ~ ~@, <tif<l~~<ti c~'5tc<t 9f~0{ '€ 9ffi{~"i ~~l,{tt~, ~~ ~
~t~ <ti'4J~t~t~ if~~ .*a'\t~1lft~ ~~~i!t'l ~t~i ~C""l~C<t5tOl:
eft'll 9ft"€1l1~
~ C1Ufilfl ~11\ 9fttm~ I" [ '~ro<l5tOl:~t~~ <lt~t"i1 ~~~' ]
ffl ~a'\t'€a'\ 'e ~iJJt'll Di$tC~~ <t5~CIf~f<lc""l~ \!It C~, ~~l,{ ~
~ '111\ ~~ 5i~ ~~ f.l1{~~~ ~"€ ~CiI~lftm-
'l~f~'l ';5t~t~ ~~JtIf1 ~~~1 ~st <t5C~Ol:Ol~ I ~, ~~a'\ 'lt~'11 ';51lft~~lij Ol:t~ ~DOl:1
~ ~Hi <t5t~l~'l "i~ <tifilc~ 9ftftt~tc~O{I 9\t~Pl<ti <l'f~ ~,~~ ~If~ ~f5~ " ( ~) ~lfO\ (~~H-~lr ) '"i~1
O\t~<t5~ ~lc~ ~~~8 ~'g~ C~'lt~ (~t~t<t5tOl:) m~'lil c'lt'1tl.l~tc~ p.) ro~~ tl1 ( <Ii) ~~a'\ cm~
~ta'\t-e'1 "c~t~~1" ~1 ~c~t9fClfllf<tt~'1~ ~r;0{1<tiC~Ol: I ~~ ~t~t~ ~'l ~R1 r ( ~) ~~ futil 'l~<ttlf
'ifa'\'lto{ l:(~'l"9\~ l:59fCIf""l
'€ <I'~9t~ f(!jil.lt~"It9\~o( \!I<I'~ <t5t~ut~ I ~lirt ( I:l) '!ft<\~a'\.ro( ~~178 ) ~~~~t~
'l~C"t~ '€ ~~ ~D0{1"Cij<t5'R~O\t'lt~" ~r;0{1<tit"l ~~'\~ ~'g~, t~tc~ ~ttar~~'G ~flOI't~
( 8) c~<lt~
~~9il,{ <tit~;\1 <\fo(~~~l.lti~'1
(t) ~t~~tf~ ( ",) i.~~ ( ~) ~~~~
~ '\"1 ""l~t~~ ~t~ ~<Ii~O\ ~t{iO{t~1 <t5f<l C<titt~"l'1~t~Ol~~ I H
c~tt"i~t< ~) ~t"i~ ~
~t~'l~tl.l "lt~t'11 'lt~~" $C~ ~t <I'~ ~APtc~ ~C""l~ ~tC'1tDOl:i ~~~tc~ I ~" ( '«) O\f~~~~
~Cl.l~~c~ ~t'1t-eC'1~ '!{ti!tl.l'ift~i~t~Ol~tl~ -e "r;~~\!)'1" <t5tC"lJ~~D~\!)1 ~t ( ~) ~WtC~ ~~~taj ( ~f.I<Ii '{N )
\!I~t "lJf;e; I ~~ ~~C<ti ~t~O\~t~e~~ 'lt~ C~ Di1tt'l f~'111l ~'1, ~~1 ~1711\ ~~ Di$tm ~c~~clltm <lif<l-
<t5ftt<\t~~'lI "~t~\!i~" <l't<\l~~C~ f.r!{fal~~ ~~"l t;!;';;\!i <t5~"i I ~~tt~ ~ ( ~) ~t~t~lf ~ ( ~~ ) ( ",) \!ifIl~
,~~t'l
<I''4J~t~~ "l~aj ~Cl,{t~ ~C~- (~) ~~ ~t'"
"<t5~ 'l<l ~<I'(][<tir.,l.l1~ "lt~ I ( ~) ,<fl~ c'SftC'I ffi'€~
- ...•
~ cfI<l5~<tifi{D~f~<li ~tR II ( ~) Ol:'€'lt~~ ~ ( ~~i:~, ~f.NI ) C~~ "<tit'€~
~~tt~ "l'lt~'1 <t5'l11
l~~ ~~ I (s) ~~(~~~~) ~~'l1
\!lnt ~ ~~~tf;{'lt~ f~~~II" i69fC~ <ft<lJ~~ 1(7::1I1
"i~$!1 ~tt"i~ "~~O{t~" <l1 "\~<tit~o1't" 'D'l~<l5t<.l
~t <ti~\!itl.l••~~" ""l<lfDi$~~ "'4J~ "';5'11' ~~ <U<l~ ~l,{I '~~ ~, ~~<.I~ ~"lllf ~ ~m ~~ ~r;'li~ ~~ ~~ W'! ~
~t~ "~ftt fit"!', f<1i'l.lt9flf
'Di$t~ "''41 ';5t1l1~t~i <\t~'1~ ~t~ C<I'tOlC~ajtl,{ <\J'l~~ ~C\ t~t<.I ~tt~tDJ I ~Cj\!i ~<ti ~ ~~~ ~~~ '1tt~ ~9f~~ fWr-{ I
"l1 I t;!;'(3'~'lWt~ 9ft~ f<fi~frf;{~t<iii ~t~O{~~t~ <\~"It<l~ 'ltR~J~'lt~lf 'I ~~ .• t~O{ ~'1.~C"'~ f<llP~ \!It \~ ~~~tfiii;'f \!I't~ '1<l5a'\\~ 1l.fl~~ ~
9fttl,jtc~Ol:I t;!;~ ~~ ~t~~ ~ ~ Dim'l fSi'1t~ ~l:(l ~t~ 'l-,<f:stt't ~~ ~ t'l~t~ ~ $~'1 ",fntti: I \!It .'<l5tt<lJ \!i~~ D1i~
. ~~mt~ I ~t~t~ "r;ott"l\!i~"<tit~ ~~~~ ~'gtC<lf~f'G~ ~<l~ ~t~,~ ~~l,jtti: I ~ ~ ~.. ~OIR[ ,f<l~'1 9ft@1l1 mI ~~.lf ~W'l "<l5tfii~~" "€ "~·t~1-
etRs!; ~'4'l fife<ti H ~ Ol:t~,c"I~~ fife",'€ ~~s 9j~1 "ltt I ~t \!It "'~~ . ittltt" ~ "€ 9\t~~~ C'<l5tOl:mD'll <I~mOl: 9ft'€~ lftiI 0l:1 i ~ ""l~'>i
~APtc,* ~~ ,~'" ~tOl1~"l ~l,j"itt I <\~"lt<\~ ~tt~ ~O\1 ~l.ltt~,-~tf 'l~<2\tt~~~~<.11 "€ R~~~ fu",t ~ ~l:(tO\ ~~M ~ \!I<I~~~~
Dll.mc~ ~ti6~to{ lllIort~ ~f\!i <fC~"i~ $tt~ I <\~'ltt0l:~ .mc~ Olt'l "i-e~tf~
]
f;{.t~ Cl{ ~tO{t~~ 'Clf'l9ft~~' '\!t~t~~ '\!~"'.t~ O{t~~~ '~'t~-;rt1t1'
~cfOflfi;U1~- ) ~~t~t'il ~ ( I!ltC"ltllt~i) ~lllft~if
"5t~Jtt~ lef~~'IlWt~J (8) 31~QftQf
''10{( ~ ~t~ ) S~'il~aj
\!I.flf", 'ilt"'t~~ .\!~"' \'11 ~C~, ~.~f\5'ifC'lll -.t'lJ "1j'f~~" ~~ f"t'lllt~t~J <\fcr~ ~~nt~ I .~ ~~~C'f~
''f~~<\~t~ ~<\t'1 ,i ~ m; C\!~i{@11~0{1f,~1. 'iltc~ 'iltt~ ~~1l ~Cil'ft'!1ft"l
~~tt~ clf~1~tll I lfN"
"ltO\1~ I!l~~\!, ~f1f '1Pl ~~ fD?;~, ~9fR'~ NC'! f'fm '1~~o{-
~ft~-"lt1fl '1ajCl,J
~~tt~ II"
~~"t lef\5t~~ '1~ m'1 ~'fI \!I.~tO\~ ~~ 1!lR~~ ~Rf<l:J I!t~ 1f1l9l ""m~ ~~ Q ~~O{ II
~~~t~ I 5i.mt1\~ l!lR"ltllt'11~"lt~ I!l~~ '€~~"l ~tt~ ~f.{ ~~ I!lll~'fi~~ ~'il ~C~ ~~ I
~~~ 'if~ C'ilt"lilf1
~~ II"
~~llt~"l I \!t~~ ~5·11- "'fIt "l'ilt"l1,
" .~O\~'f~," "I!lt'f1\," "~t~t'J.'t
'!Ift~~t~ \!I~'13i",
~~~ <1:1
~t~~ .~ I ~f.{ '.~ ~~~, "ltt'il~ ~~ I \!, • ~mt~ C~"l~ "~~aj" \!I.~ s'Gl.t~J I ~t~\!J ~"1rll'if ~tt~~ ~
Di~~ ~f<!m 'ilt'fI I!lMRt'13i1,<ft~aj ~t~~if '€ "lt~~ ~~~ ~~ lltffistc~J~ s'S').tC<fJ~ em ~~ <\~~t5'to{ I f.~fifOl ~~ \!t~tll @wtC'f @~i
,.~~m ~ ~~ \!I\! fffi l!lRajtD~ ~fillltt~"' '1M1l1'13it~ ~ ill 'ft~\!J ~leftlllf 'ltc~<f, l:I<!{t~c~ CDf{fr ~\!JtflflI CD~tll~~tt'il~ ~t6'/.{ 'lt~'\;J
'!ft~t~~ "'fI~~aj1" \!I.~ ~~~ ~~~. ~ I ~t'f \!tCaj~ @~9ffe, ,~ ~1l ~t'ilt~ 'ilt\li~ '!IftR~ ~~ll~ ~~O{ ".(N
I I!l~'€ I!lCo{<\S ~"6~ I!l~-
,.to( ~~ 'fto{ ~~ @f%~, ~ <l:1l1~~
.t~~ ~~ I!lt~,~ ~~~ ~ r~\! ~~~tt~ I c.tOf ,.~ ~t~"' 'iN ~fu'\!~'1~tll-e 9ff'€1l1f'tlltc~ I ~~O\
fWl 11l~ ~C~ '!IftCajtf%~~~nt~ I '!ft~fo{~ ~~m(1 ~~ \!I~ ~~1l 11l~0l"lt~ ~f'l1l Caj~1\!I.~ ~~\! ~N 9ff-el,J1f'tllt~, ~ ~.,ef
\!QjJ111~0{-e
~\!~O{t~ I
~ ~.Qf ~mr \!I~ ~~C<f", Ol1,~-e ~~~ leff'l1faj~m '\!'.M'1", ~~1l1fl
~ajfs;rj @~'fJ ~~t<l:~~~ ~ I, wt~t~ ~fD~\!I~~'ft"'- -'{i! f.I~iI '11:01
I!lt~ O{1
lJ:~Qf~~ I
~t'f-'il'M<l' ~ ~ ,fi1 ,'ft9fr ,~~~ I!lt'{aj "
'1Ol~') lefJt~~t~t1l ~~ ~t'f ~'ll ~1 I 'f~Qlf( C'ft'{aj) ~fi;1l1 I!lt~ ''fQlf<\"l'ilT~I
~fO{ ~~'1~
ljiff.{, ~~ ~t\!l 'if'1 11F, \!It<\:f.{ ~~'1 ~tlft~ ~." I!lt~ c.M II
(
•
Ol~orr"ll!l{t~ttll(~ ~~, ,~t~
~iS c~~1 ~lf'CU ~",1 ~'C~
~!1i
~ ~ ~ ~~~~
J<iV :i1 ~ -t ..01
.•...•.
~~@ <i1
~ j'ft~ ~ ~ ~ ~ • rt 2~ ~ ~
;~~~~~
;
a- ~1 ~.1JC01/'
• •
~
:;t ~
.s.
.J/ll
.£
-w~
.J/ll ~
.J/ll
~
j'ft
.•...•.
~
.•...•. - ~ ~ ~.
~-4
~~~
~
~
; ~f
~ ~
~
- ~ . Jt
rl
..01 ::!
:of> ~
..t<l -t
2
!~~~~
:iP JS1 ~
UI ~
-t
A
~
~
Sr
~
I
~
Ji. ~
~ :iP
J-
:iP
~
;;/) -'Ql :g
:4> ~ .b1
..:t
.A:I
..!.J
!
"""""
--
-
6
.•
<:,.
-:-=---=-~~
- -
------ - - ~
''''l~
~Cif~ ~c\;1, 'Qj't'15j;t~ '€~ ~<t<f '6ic~~ f;jc~!li ~t~ ~~t~ 'lCliI'S '<fii~
~lff~'Ii~ "tTR" ,,'1'!l' 'lfifC'15~liiJf~~ ~5i~'l1 ~'1C<fi"1 'lC~ ~cQj'l: <l~ ~ ~
~i'1~i <fCll.,~c~'S{ 'Qj't<fi~t~'S'1~ ~Clli
~t~ ~~)Sl ~C~ 'S~t~ :JjC57 :JjC57 C<t'O{ ~tf.l' <!ltf~ '«0{ '«0{ ~'t
ift9fC<!l~I \K~ CJffifc<fi ~~ ~.~ 'O{~ C~tco{ll f~ ffi~ ~~ ~C~~
~~'S ~~ 'O{"I1lfC~C~; ~~ C<I' ~O{ ~"C~~ C~-CO{"t1 I
, -'It''lt~, ~..,t~ I I5(f\S~~ \StC"<lil'~~ ~\ijSl ~., c~~t~lI W19f<liI ~~t."I ~~C'i!i ~~?:~'Si ~tiS!C~<.\''li<lif~1{~ '€ i!t"1{MC~~~f~<.\' <i'raoT
~~C\!i
~t~ C"lC~ 9f~C"'1 I C9f~"C"l C9f~"C"l C"lC~ '1~C~ \!i~ c1{C~ I C"l ~ ~~C"l<.\' \!l<fS~ -r.\!i0\' I5(IfJt~ I5(t~'& ~~ I ~fh I.!l~ -r.\!i0\' ~c9f 9ft~J fs~1-
~~, ~~, ~~-rf/9fC<li~ ~{ C"ii~~tC<fS ~1)~~tC"<l "<lt~ <liC~ ~ft<fStf.! ~~ ~ ~ ~ ; @~ 'l~lftc~~ ~CIfJ ~iSft~1, 15(~~ ~IfJf<I\ij ci!t9t~ ~If~ ~~ I ~~Q' ~IfJ
<litf-! I "''9J::~t?:~~'ltc~ ~;:;K<fS-'€~ ~C~~ c~t9f I ~sfr~, l)t~1'5'f~ ~t'l '5'f~1"<l~I1Jf~ ci!t9tg: ( C9f~ ~~t~) @~"<lf<lC"I~ iStc« ~1%-
f<li~ I5(mJ! I.!l\!i~~ 15("<l'lt"iiC"<lt'f<fS~~ ~ W)9f<fSC'lO\'-'lc'Wt~ ~~J9f~~ I ~t~ ~~ I ' ~~ \!l~ ci!t9t~ 'l~~Jl <5{f'\!i'It"1{t~ ~., f<i;~ "<l~1{t"l 'l~'\!ii~ "<It\!it"<lg:cCj
~1,~-f<1'~C\!i~ ~~C\!i 9ft?:~ 0\'1C'I I C'I ~f)C"<l~ I ~tf)"c\!)~ ~C"<l \!itC<fSI I5($T~f~11I ~ <l~ ( ClfC"ltPl"lto{ ) I \!l~ f<l«~ ~~C"1{ "<lt~.,t~ I5(t~'& ~~ ; \!I'lli?:'! 'l<\l'.,
~~c~tcfl1t~t~ <fSC~ C'l C"ii~C"<l I ~c~t~O\' ~raoTTII"<l'\."<If'lC~<fS~C"<l c:~~t"C<fSt~~ I ~"I ~ ~~lftc~~ ~ClfJ ~~1 ~~'it<fSt~ 'ft~~ <l5~~t~~ I I5(Qfo11~<liC'lliCiJl~~C"iig:
C<! c<1'tc"l1 ~'1tc~ ~t1)C"<l~ C'I I ~c~ti!lfo{ I5(W~: \!it~-I5(\!)J~ I5(t~ ~~t~"' I 9ft~"'9jftl<li'l~~C<li I5ltiS!'lt~lft~<1' ~1 "ltc~ I5(Fs~\!i <fS~1 ~~ ; f<ls~ ~~1 '!\i~c.,
<rt~'1t~ I!l~ C<! ~til?O\', ~f\!i?:~t'f <fS~C\!i ~C"<l \!itC<fSI ~~t~ I5(fit~:~t~ ~ ~ C!t~'1~'<PfI lfC~~ O\'tc~ 'Mf"f~ 'l~lft~ i'r~
~fftc~~ 'l'fCj'l~c~g: ~9f~, "rt'l<1'~9f
c'l'f., c<!o{ ~tSl f~t~ ~9ff"t~~ I C'<It.,tcG' c~~ ~CG'tC~ \!it~ ~"C'l. @~cat1 I5li~O{: !t~lh ~~~1C"tt<!'l 9fiijif\!i ~t9fO{ <{s~"<ltst cbetC<fS '~t~lft~<i' 'It"1{~1' "5!t~Jl ~"iitOf
~Jtst~~ ~9f "<llfC., c'l'f"C~ 1 'ltm~J"<ltrf/-<.1t'lli'l 'l~~ <{S~t.,~\!)~ C"ii~1flmI~ <lifi:c~c~ I \!I~ Cl)~t~ ~ciSft~t~i!t9t ~Slt~O{ "<lfo\~tift -m{st 'lf~ \!I<fS"1{'\!i
'€ \!I<fS
~~O{ <fSC<.\'I
I5(t~ I Di<.1fwc<1'\!itc"ii~ ~~t"-C~~11 \!itc~ f.!~~l"II5(\!iJtstc~ C'lt<m1 ClrI
~~~tSl. ~C~ l)"c""C~-"J!"ItO\' ~ 9f~~' I f<1'~ 15l~ 0\'1I c<lit~ "ii~roSl ~C~ c~ ~~t~~tt,9ff\ij~ \!l~ I5(tta;ts"l~ Ci!t9t 'l~~~ <fS'<I1 ~"l: ~"l: "<l"'1~~~tc~ I l{~"l
"<l~ "1{~:~ C<fStcSlfoM "l:.~0\' I5lC'Ia "l:.\!i0{f<I~« %ftO{"C\!i~« I!l~"<l~ I,ffilf ~~ffl fo\r~~ c..,t<1'-'l1{tc~~ "{fCfSl ~c'fJ 'l~ '<I~~9f~~ ~~ \!)~"l 'l~t~~~f<I"ii'l'f'! ~~tC<fS
<fSSlC~ ~C"<ll!l~ \Stil?O\'t f;{1{/~\StC"<l~~9ft~\!i <fSSlC\!)~C"<lI5(~Jil)t~~ l~f~ <!\!) ~1t. Ci!l'lt'l~'<l~. ( ~t"l <fS"lij;-~~ ) "<!c""l I ci!t9t,~~ '''\!i: "5!fo11f~<fS1%fe~ ~9fSl ~f9t~
fTt~ I ~"l'l'f"C~~ C"ii"tf'l'~c~ ~C\!) ~C"<l~"l'l'fC~Sl~tc~ I······ ~Ol, C<li~ ~~"iit~, C<li~~~, c<{S~<l5c.,~ "1{tM<fS,C'li~ <l5C"~ ~Pl<li ; ~9t 'l~~~
{
..• ~C"l 9f~c~, ~C"l '1~C~ ~9fC<{sSl C'l~ ~"l~Sl <{S~1I 1!l<fS<{S"5!'i!iJ~1t \!it~ ~"'\!i: l5(~o11~<li 1%fe~ .~9f~ ~tf9f'\!i I ~C"<l 'l<lifiJl\!l~ 'l~'<l~ C<\I''«.,~ "f17!<fS
f<lil'~ c<!fw"l I5(fit-f<l~C"<l~itf9fC~ 9fC~f~..,. C'l 15(f.!~t'l c"ii"t-C~C"1{Sl rf/>;f1 .~ I ~ "\$j\!), c"It~<{S '€ c"Itf<!C~~ ~9f ~'l <fSC~"l1 I \!l<fS~ l5({o11f'\!i<li ci!t9t~ "1{ClfJ
"1{CO\'~C~, '!\~J~ "'9f~~"<l~ ~C"l 9f~C~, f<llft~<fS1c.,m~Sl C~~<lit~~ '!\tiltm· •• C"I'IlIC'l~"<l1~~~ .rtf\!i~ '!\i"ii{ "I~~l f<lr~:1 ~~oltf'\!i<l' If'c.,~ I5(~J"ii~~~ \!l<1:~"iii:'[-
.. ~~~/<.\' ~~ ~nr Cl)tc~<.\' '€9f<.\' f"ii"C~~f~r.~ c~ ~tt~ <rt~~ ~~<.\'~1 ~ AA{~ '1tf'liJ ~"t'\!i: ~C"ii~ ~'fJ ~t~o11f\!i<fS~~~ ~9f~~ ~~ I ~fu~tc'l ~~t<.\'
~~~ t -
9ffj1 c~~ C'l~ <li\!)~"l I5(tc'l'f ~."C~ C'l'C., C"ii'€~1~~~C<fS ftI~.,\StSl~ I 15{c~ I \!lC~~ ( Engels ~)1781r~: ~m'ij~ \!l«~<1'tcSl~ 15("<l~1
"<l9"l1~IfC~
vft9f"C<fS<.\'
f<I-ft{ ~O\' ~~~t"ll ~?:~ ~C~ ~"<liiji ~~ ~~c~~ "1{c\!i1<li~0{~ ~~: A bourgeoisie split into two monarchist sections adhering
~t Wodynasties. () 0 ) .
'
~11
~ -
~ <!J«~\!lC~OL'l, Jrtc~ \!I<fS~ 1C~~1 ci!t9tC'li ~~ 15(trfc>cfg:~~ ~~~ '1~'li
~ ~~~ "'~It -- tn;:
~ '€ "<lTi:'[~I~'«O\':
.••• "
Repu 'b hcan
. .
factIOn of the bourgeoisie
and M .
onarchist bourgeoisie" ( :>:> ) I ~ec~t'1 '€ "5!tC"1{ft1<{Shl~:{\!i\!jSl C\f"l~~c~
~. I 1\
arl Marx-"Class ~truggles in France" ; translated by F. Engels p 12.
~~I M
, arx and Engels-"Revolution and Counter-Revolution, p 44
~)"l
'fi.'j~~ .~t9jO{'tf5<;('l':.'<l~( party politics ) l!l~ ~t"1~cr~ ~~~l ~t~~ I l!l .'PINl~ccr~ ~?:'1T<{t~ClfQ ~Oft~ C<11<\"'I <t?:'1l'S(c~ml1~~ lfilf10\~~l ~~~
~~~ '(gnl '5:«r~~ 'lt~tf'Sl~ c\!t9t ~tf Pr~~ <>t'{j'5:(~'l~~'1f<l1%:1~~<l'l~ ~~tclfS( <>tC'1l'
l!l1ilJl ~'$ '5ltl:ilft"lOf~fit<\t"1 '!;j'1JlfC~~ C<ll:"t~t~Clf~ ~tc'<fS(
9f~~~ 'l':.,«C~M~ ~sr; ~Clif'$ <Sj~ <>t'{j~~1 ~<>t~J f<{'(gt~<tIBlsr1C~"1~ '"""C<.lt'!;fOl
~ot~"l-l!lC~1:'\?:'lQ" <.!I~f<1?:~~'l
\St~c~~ l5{~lc~<.\'5lt?:ilft"fo{
C9f"t<(l"I '<4
~((,<>tt'fo{ ~tO{~f"f ~tsr~t~O{ <tIQ'/; <tIt~'1~~R~ l:KO{t~<>tt'fO\<11ttr
'oS <l~CO{<;{ -"=<>t~?:llT'!;fJI ~~ fl>f~~"i "ftc~€ ~~O{ lf~~t'Sf~ C\!t9t~ ~t<ltc~Q
~~ '1"1,'"' \<110
C\!t9t'l~~ ~mC'f~ <l~~~ ~~Sf1 ~tf~~<l I <>t~t~l!l~ '5:(t<>tt~: f<l~:!~ ~ "'1:~~~ ~S(iOf~~1,{t~1:'\~~O{~iStWj:~ 'l'lfSf.c\!t9'i~~ I5{tCilft"lo{
<rc~~~<>t <>tfl~~
f<l~:1 ~~mc\!t9t ~:{r:\!t9t~MC1i C"tt<l'1mCSf l!l1i~~ J ~T*'fQ" f<l9\r•• ~ .rrr <!tlfJI <.!l~C"l~~i ~falr."l-e sfalC<{O{lC~, "~f~~tc~ \St<{<\t~ <Ut~m
'(g~~Q"
'f"l~M l!l<11~!ltts~~srl ~tc~ I ~t~c~ ~'tci!j"9tQ"
~tf 'l"9\"C~ <lRsrti(r .tfc~l 'en 1 Interpretation of, History) <>t"Dtc~~?:<fi ~t<l~<{'t~1 (Feeling)
(Ideo Ogl '" r-_
'l1i"f 'f"f 'oS 'l~'ftCSl~ ~O\tiSt<l l!l<tl~~<tItc~Q"I ~~Hl '\!t9t~N fucSl 'I ,-rl t'" 9f"Dtc~ ~tc~ >5It'<f( Interest), '5(Hl ~f~~t?:'lS\ 15{~~f~<fi<\Jt~Jt~
.JI~':. ~,~ " """
'lcs~O{; C'l~ f<i~CSf~rf~'fi~<tI 'l~'$j~ ~~<l ~ OIlI l!l~ 'Sl~ f<lc~<{'1 ~fip.11~ .t
(RIS orl
'cal or Economic InterpretatIOn of HIstory)
_
<>t"6tc~ ~tt~
,/
<!<8'
l!l~ 'l~'lJ1 ~ 'l~iftcSl~ "ltc~ <>tBlS~ ~~C"f'oS15{~'iiC'l~ O{tt~ ,\!t9t~t~ 'l~~ f.l~, ~t~'8 <>t"5tc~~C<fi-~t~ I <.!I~~tc<\CI'f~1 ~tSf,~ @~Sf<ut~JT~'l<\<lC"'rl
<.!I~~
cl>~l ~~C"f'oS~"l~: c\!t~~~ 'l~'«~ I
~1\~ PlM~ ~~ (~8) I .
'5:(~')c~ iSt~~<lC'lfl!l~ 'l~'lJll:K~~ ~<>t'lt~'t <tIfitSft~"l I c"ttPl~ ~ f.! • iSt~~S( ~<I~C~Q C"lt~ C<lN,C<\ll3<l,
~"'ij~to\ <\1 ~~to\ <r41t<{"l~~~1,{t,~..!l<!~
~'1'l~~ <rfi <>tfil<\~O{
'l'BlSll O{tO{l
~~~ ,"tt<lC'1~~t~ ~~c~f.lwf~ <>tt~<lt~ ~~r.~c~ <.!I~~'<lJ~ f~ ~O{'(g~<:1~1,{t'C~
l!l<!~ \!j~ ~O{~C'Qs\9\"5tc~ f~ ~~i<!
<fifil~tf~ I 15{~~~ 'l~l'ftc~Q"f<l'1."f I5{~J~o{~ ~'l"f~jO{ ~c~ 'R.~
C<t1".li ( Dialectics) f<1~~to{ ~t~i ~~A~ ~'oS~l If<:1<t'~I ~~, <.!I~".j~iSt?:~ ~f~
'o{<l-C<lll3<!'
'f"l2l~f~~ '5(~~t~O{~ ~C"f l!l~ ~~J I5{tc~I ~~Sf w~sr "t~ ~~~-~~I
C'fi0{ ~t"lc<!~W<{c~Q"j
c<\t".lilf~ ~~'1 <fiC~ (~~)? C<tIO{
~<tI ~"f (ft"t ) 'l~\; <II I!j<tl~ 'l\!:J ,~ <\~~to{ ~t~~~ <.\t'Sl;{tf~<11
'5:(lc~t<1lO\
'l'~ ~"l~: c\!t~~~
C<lc'$~ ~t~o{1itCii'f C<IT".li '8 ~O{ lf~t<{ii'ffl ~'ll? l!l<!':.~lfPI,~ ~~C\! ~rt{Olft"lO\
<l1 c\!t9t-'l':.~t~ I ~~TQ"I5{t'l"f ~<>t <>ttf<;\<>tlf-.t~
'5:(<\~t~~iStC<!"l..~t~~
<>t~J~ <lJ<{'lt~ '8 wfil~~ fi.~ 'Sit~~M c<!~Q" ~t~ C<{lp<!? ~~~ ~ftl.ltC1ilI ~i~l1,{ 'If'&~ ~s~1 ~~tC<fi <\Jt~~ <t-fic~?:~; <£i~'8i'1J~'5lt'l"l ~<>t
l!l~ C<l, lfC~~ I5{t<\~'1 c\!t9t 'l~~t~~ f;{~~ '5(tc~ I I5{t<\tQ"~<tI ~"f ~ f'l~~tc" '''lt~ ~C<tJ~~r.t. <>tt~c~c~ I Diale ctical Materialism-<.!I~ <\Jt~J1-
'S?tl% 'l~~~ ~ClfJ <l{t\!tc~~ <!t~c~~ M~tCSl~, 'l~ O{toTt,N~,'Sit~ c<\ll3<l,iSt <lite"! l!l~<tItc~~ <lJt<>ttc~ l!lC~"l't <!f<1l{~?:~O{:"In Modern History,
C<lt5il,<tIt<>ttM~, <fi~Q" <>t~, Q"t~-'lcO{~ 21~f~ 15{'l~~J 'l~'ftSl f<l~t'Sl <l5~ atleast, it is therefore proved that all political struggles are
~~1 @~ <ut~J1 'qt~t~ c<!t'f~~J~'ll I l!l~ 'l':.'<\sO{
~SfC<tIO{,
~t~ ~t~~l C<!"! 'Iliff,{ class-struggles, and all class-struggles for emancipation in the last
<!Jt~rt'oS~l~
l!l~"'l»>tr<fi~ c~i5fil~ <.!IC~'1.C'lQ" ~Q"1 m~c~<>ttc~I f~f;r~ resort, despite their. necessarily political form~ .. turn ultimately
~'oSr.~tc<>t~
<.!I<{~ : "The Middle Ages had at
<fitc~r~~<(~tQ"f<i~C'll<lMC~C~O{ on the question of economic emancipation. Therefore here a~
ched to theology all the other forms of ideology, philosophy, politic least the state-the political order is the subordinate and civil society
jurisprudence and made them sub-divisions of theology. It thereb -the realm of economic relations-the decisive element"(~~) ~~C~~
constrained every . social and political ~ movement to take od' ~to\ ~t~;{t~'fi '5(tr.ilft"lO{~M ,l!t9t-'l~.m~ Q"'r~,'5(fr~ elf"! Pf Q"t'Sl~f~~
theological form. To the masses whose minds were fed wi 9\,f~ ~l '10{-;f~~ ~~?:<\, <.!I~.~~ '5:(c<>t'1l'l
'l'llt'Sl, ~{j~ l5{~l~<tI ~~WO{~
religion to the exclusion of all else, it was necessary to put forw ,~ 'f~c","S\<\n<>tH~ <!~ .~~ ~~~l I1t~t~~rc~ I <.!I~lf~ii'f.<\Jt<>t~~ ''!;ft~~
their own interests in a religious guise in order to produce a gr 'fltcOlit"!Oj'<l1 ''li~'fiftl<11 I5{t?:O\ft"lO{'
~<>t f<1fiS:I~ Ilt<;\<1<l5fi1,{tc~I 'tit~~l
agitation" ()-:l), ~~~ ~'fl<ic~'fxfO{"tt~, m~f<t'!jjjO{,I5{t~O{
"!t~ ~~~C<{l'8 \!l~~ f~ ~9fIDI l:frO\t~<>tt'f~o{Q"
C~~ 'l'~ ~tQj1,{~ ~~C<{-~~ ~~~~ ~Sl
"tt?:~~ 'l~~ Jr ~MC<tIlf~"ttc~~ "tt~i ~~1 ~'
'l':.c<{t~~ ~Q1 ~i1tc~, <.!I<l':. f<lf\5l\ ~t'Sl~f~~ I5{tcilft"l~O{~
~"I, 'l»>tfs"1t"ll c\!t9t~M <.!I~t!i~tC<{ ~-~ 'ft~
<.!I~'Sl~
~C~J~ 'lt~t~~ 'oS ~tSf~f~~ l5{Vilftii'fo{
'f~-'5{tcoIft"lcO{~
~<>t$~'1 '9\"t 'fiBlCii'f~t~ "~t~l~" ·~c~ <.!Iq~ ~f~:I~tt<\
~<>t <rt<.\<1 ~t~i ~ficaj ~~
~fi<tl ~<>t <>tRut~ 'tiCQ"(~f~~<tii~ .~~ ~~1,{tc~ ~~~tC'l <>t'{l"l~ l!l<l5~
( )~ I Eptgraphica Indica-Vol II. No. Va
)0:> I F. Engels-Ludwig Feuerbach, p 19, )a I "I~ ~l\~ L. F. Ward-Adpplied Sociology Jl'1~Boudin-Marxism <:liZ'll
I
'iSt~~')~ ,,~t~ 9\~1 ~"9jN '@ M,\~c.,l ~f~t'l ~S ••
'\5{~;fI~~ Ci!t9tf<l"f?s:lifr;~ ~~~~ ~ )\ <!l~ci!!(9t~~ ~~~t~ ~~ ',~ 9~ ~t~ \!j')~ ~iSft~1 ci!!(9t <!l~0I'(3<!l~S1 ~tjU i!!('l1fitC$l~lI"'lIo1'ter!\9t~C9f
"1tr:~ '\5{fi5f~\!j~t~ll ~9f ~~tCOJ ~~t~ ~t~~ .,1 C<fO{,C"t~9fiiJ~ <!l~ '&{ ~ O\~ I ~~., -r;t~"lt"I") ci!!(91c~<!l~ ~ott~ '~~1' ~~1 ~~ I ~~c~
'\5{~;\1f~~ <fliC~ ~9foft~ ~~ ~~C~ I ~~OJ I!~ ~c~t"l"~ ~crr;i!!(9te\f~
~ 111?t ~~ ~f~lI ~\!it'l~ccr f~fs\!i ~~mc~, <!l~'!li"lJ~~C"l~ ~C'IJ :Ij'l1ci!!(9t-'iSt~
W~H ~~~J1 ~~NtOJ ~fu~ ~~C~ \!~OJ ~~TIrI-ci!!(9t~\!j ,fui (~~tt ~
~6"'''i..~''''1
7rn O{t~I ~tc~ <!l~f<!~1\~C~ m'e2t\ftfil~ I5{t<1~'1
~~t~ ~<\IS ~~1
~\ftfil~ ~ ~"f1~ ~~1) ~~~ ~~C~ I <!l~ ~r;"I <!l~~~ '\5{~~ ~~ fO{C~\f~~tc~~ ~O{t~~ ~~~1 foI'I/o{~cr~~c~ ~t~;\1f~C'lf'Cijj stf.l~1
~I 1"1'
i5tt~ ~'1t~ ~"lJ ~~'l ~ <!lr;~,,'f.Communist Manifesto-C\!j f~ '1fi1r: '8{ff.lt~~; c~~ ~t~~~t<1ttif~ O{tc~, C<f~ ~~iftRl<i'~t~ .\tel( I ~~ ~cr~~~
.' ~t~
between
e~'1~~ ~~1 ~~t~OJ I
the classes
~~~ ~'Mr;~c~OJ, «Altogether,
of the old society further ('
in many ways the co
co1lisi ~O! ~9l-es~O{1 9ft~m ~~lit~
~ ~~ f<!9fC'lf'
~C'llt~ ~fiC<1 I
fo1~C"1C~ '1~'lft~ ~C~
'1t~litRl~
9ftfi!C<l, ~~O{ ~~l,\tCif~~
~'l1~1 \!i~0{15{~~\!j ~~C<1 I <i'n1'1
of development of the proletariate. The bourgeoisie finds i .~~<i' I5{tCi\ft"lo{~~,~~~J1-"I~BCif~I5{tc~"fo{f<l'"fI \!it~tCifQ ~tc~ 9ffilDtM\!i
involved in a constant battle. At fIrst with the aristocracy, Ia ~ I ~C<1~t1f!~15{~~0I C<!i<1"!
I5{t~'!iitOJ'1"Pf:{~t~O{ '5{t~t"lOl ~~ ~~~Jt~fil~-
on with thOSe portions of the bourgeoisie itself, whose interests ha ~~ '!ftr;0lft"f0{
l!\~~~t~tCif9 ~tc~ 9ffist~\!i ~'ll" (~~) I \!i~9f 'iSt~C\!i~~t~;ftf~~
become antagonistic to the progress of industry; at all times wi ~t"IO{~'M '1~~"f~ C~9tCifQ'lftc~ foI~t~~ I5{tt~"'O{ I f<\i~ '1~~Jt~fil~ ci!!(9t
the bourgeoisie of foreign countries. In all these battles, it s 'II.(t~~'l-Ci!f9t~I5{t~OJ lj1~1 \!jt~ttif~ ~tt~ 9ffill)t~\!i ~~<1 \!it~ ~~s ~~C'"
compelled to appeal to the proietariate.···The bourgeoisie itself .. ·furni ~~~ <!l~".!t~~Wl~ ~~t"fo{" i5t~c~ I
shes the proletariate with weapons for fighting the bourgeoisie" '!{ l!\~ ~'lC~ ~t~OI~t"f ~~C\!j ~~O{~t"! 9f~J~ i5~\!')~ '1~tc~~ ~~tC<1~ ~f~~
'1,~t~O{~~W~ c~9t ~~r~~ ~~'l~ I5{CO{<{I"
f<l~~ ~"Istfil~c~~ ~1\~~ ~~~~ ~ ~~t~'IJ '\5{~'l~'l~~1 ~~""I <!l~'5{~~~0{ 9ff~~tf~~t"f C~~~ ~t~~ 15{t1l~1~~
~~m~9t ~~t~\!j ~~~t~~~ ~C~ I \2t~c~ e~ ~~m~sr;"f 15{N;~~C~ ~C'f • -1l~0{ ~~e~ (anti-thesis) I5{tc~ \!j~ ~~t~ f.l~~~'l ~~C"I '9J:.0IP\"I0{
~~9f~ ~~.m~
l)C"f ~~~1 c~9t~~ eli ~~ 15{~"t~llf-tC$I~ 15{~~~~ "R9f>if'~l)~'l m ( Synthesis ) ~~C<1 I
~t~tC\f~ ~~ ; ~~ ~t~t~ ~<{I""I ~m~~C\f~ ~:Sf~tr;\!l9t~ ~~~~ SC"f~cr.~ l!\'lfC9 ~~\!')~ ~t~t~~ ~<1~0{~ C"l~ 9flfJtt~~ 15{~'l~to{<lS~1~~ I ~~
~~~~9t~ ~~~ I <!l~ ~i}) <!l~~~~~ ~~1 ~"fstfil~cs~ ~~t~J~t~ ~l, ~~ ~1 cw~~t~, 'iS~C\!i~ '1~~ <!l~0{'€I5{CO{~~tto{ C<\ll~<l~~ \!iltC~, ~to{ C<fto{
<!l~i5tc~ f.lc~~ "R9fC'lf'~ <\ifil~~ 15{~~~ \2t'Mstfi!Cl,\S ~ ~~~~m~
~~ ~Cijj ~.,9jIi~~ 15{<l~~ 9£.c~~ "R<1N3\!i ~~'lltc~ I ~C'IJ 'l1C'IJ i5t~~ <!l~-~tit'll~t'€
fO{C'!li~ rom~I ~~ <!ifil'lltc~, f~~ ~~) <!l~-~t~~t~ l5{i5tC<1
i5t~~ <!l~~t\!j')~\!i1 15{~~J'e'
<!l~~~J '5t~C\!i~ ~~~to{ ~t~.,1f\!i C~(![ ~."cfi5tc~ ~~~J I ~~tt~ ~1\!i( ~~C'i!i 9ftt~ .,t~ I ~~~ q~1 ljt~ Cll 9fT"fCif~~~c~ ~t!Jf"fti5t~~'1 ~OI9fif~~
c~9t ~'%~~~~~rn
«iC"f ~'lc~9t ij~C~~ ~t~;\1~<{I" ~~OI ~'?g<1~ ~~C\!iC~ I ~~ ~~1 \5'i'r{ ~~l.l1 <1t~"'1 ~9f <!l'l'~T\!i')~~i 15{~0{ <l'fil~tt~ <!l'l~ ~~~t~~ ~~O{
'1~m1 ci!!(9t~'M ~~ ~t~ ~"Pfr~ '1CD\!iO{
~~C\!iC~ I ij"Pff'8"rtatt ei!!(9t~~ ~~ ~~1 t5'€i 9flfJtc~ ~:\7~ ~~~tt~ I <!l'lf'c'l C~~~ ~~C~'Si "tt'lo{, I5{tiSJ~~'1
f~Cif~ '1~~~ ~Jt'\!i '\5{tc~I ~t~~\!iTf3l~ '\5{N;~t~ ci!!(9t~~~~ ~h1 oilt ~~;frf~~ '\5{tifto{
~ifto{, O{t.,1 ~~tc~~ 'Sit~~ 5{tt~"fo{ '(3 ~f~~to{ <!l'l~ ~~~tcO{~
'1,~~ ~t~ ~Sj ~t~~ l)t~ I f<!;s"tt"l""r~Wt~t~i!f9f~ ~C'IJ ~~r-tc~ ~tfal~. f4-'1 ~ et~\!i')~ <!l~Sfl~~~tQ ~tOJ ~~ ~~C~~ I ~~m~ ~t~c~~ ~tr:~
'\5{~~ 9,(~9ff~~ if"! "~t~~~Ift" <!l<1~~t~t~1 ~tc~~ I5{t~9f~J ~ f~l i5t~~~ "R~1\ ~~C~ C<1tr:<l'~ <!l~9f~rit~ <!l<R ~9f"fRli ~C~ O{t~I '5{~~
~~, '5\Rl ~filift~ <!l~~ \!it~\f~ ~~\ft~ 1.~~')~ tC~t~tc~9t~ 15{~"t~ ~t6)O\~tcQ'j~~o'\l~1 ~Ih<!l~~ ~9f"l~ <l'fil~tf~c"'O{I f,,~ ~~~ ~t~t~1 ~~~
«~~iftfi~ ~tc{~" O{tc~~~O{"f<l~cf~filc\!jc~ I f~ \2t'1ltc~ ~crc~9t '1~~~ ~9f~ o.il1 ~~ <fl W~~~ <!l<l'llit~~\!i1 (Cultural nationality) '5{~ <l'fil~t~c"'01 I
2li5t~ ~t9fO{ ~~ ljrn. 'is"R~c\!j~ ~t~ ~~~~ ~l,lci!!(91~ 15{~ c~t~ f.I~ ~cft~'l1~ ~~:{ '''f~f~ <\1 ~m"~ '\5{~~1<1ccf~-1l~~ ~"Pft\fo{~c~ ~f~~~~1
~~C~, <!l~~ f.lfi~ ~fut~ ~ ffi~ '1~fil<\i ~C~ ~~cljt~ ~~1 ~~~ I 'It'fol~~t~"! I ~f~~~ ~~c~ Cif~1f~~
~~O{ "f<lstcSlI5{tc"ltl)0{1 c~,~~.
'iS~~ f~"1t~ c~9k~ ~tc~ ''''If'J <!l~'€ ~~~ fol~f~ ~ O\t~ '\fiI1tt ~ Clf"tt~, c"!t~m, ~"Itst~ ~~~ ~folm l)~C~ ~~ ~\fto{ ~R1~tt~ I
\!j~ 1lC'IJ m"'9\fi~ ~~'<l~ ~C~~ I 9ft"5t\!iJ 15{~~ Cifl't ~~ 1C~i11 ~~ <\cfCiSif~tf\!jCiSif ~f\!i c~1 15{tr;~~I <!l~ «i~c'1 'iSt~ <!l~~f~
~~ \ F. Engels-"Ludwig Feuerbach". p 94. ()") "Manifesto of the cmmunist Party"--Martin Lawrence publication pp 18,19-
<t'f<\"~<\'t~D~ ~~ )
( Nati~nhood ) .,tc-s~'11{{ ~~ I l.!l~iSf~~ '5t'il~ I.!l~ '"l~1:\1-~r~1l', ~~1l
'l~J\!itSl" 'l~'<l~ C'l '11{C~ <!t~711 C\fC"lSl"
~'1m$~ rrr~~ ~'1J~C~~ ~CO{ 'S
,~~ C~~ I5t~\!iC~ C~~" c~~fat~ ,t<{ 1{t~ (A geogra.phical expre
J1"~ ll~t<\'tC~I~ @9(ll:. 9f~~fit<lS1 ~D0{1 ~r.~ f5tCilC~ I Rr~c~sr1 fil~O{
I5{t~J1~IfTO{~fitC\!i m~Ol; I I.!l~ Pl-sfu; ~~c<tQ ~c.,. I5{tc~ C"!'Pl'l-~r~ I
llt~<f~ ~tc'f~ C'l 'llo{C~ I5{t~€ @C~7f ~C~ NC~ ~to{ I 9ft~C<R: '€ "<f~Sl",
'l~~ I.!l~ ~~c~~TiSfoTtR5~ f<FltcOl;~~t~HI ~ '5{f ~r'& ~~ I
" ~ . _ f;O{~t~
rtC~ \!3~0{ ~<{ ~C~C~-ll~T<\'t<!J ~t~i 5ll\!3 Ol;t:zI <!~1 <!t~"IJ,
~~~ CDI
CiSft?;~T~tiI~'t~ C~~9f ~Qtc'1Q Ar~:l ''''iSft~')~ '€ C~1{ 'i~c~~ iSfT~
~" <fi~C<t~ I!l~ c~0{1 I5{t~tCIf~ Rf~~ iSf')<{[O{~<t~i~ ~C~ <n'lJ I
I.!l~ ~~T'lt iSfTf~~ ~~~\!3 ~ft!?;\!i 9ftft!~t~"I, ~t~TQ ~T9f "'ItiSf'€ cif"! ~~C'!
~ -.r~'1I!l"(~ ·-l5{t1{tCIf~
• <\\!3/1{t0{~tC"~ 'It~\!iJ ~~?;il ~ci ~'ITrj~ 9f!%[1{Sl"'ltf~J
~ Ol;t~, 51?;", C~-~~tcQ '1~"?;~ ~t~T?;IfQ l51<lt~ I.!l<!~,., iSftr\!3~~ 9fN~
-t'" -.rC~ I5{t1{tCIfSlllto{Pl<\' c~t~tc~tc~ I <!t~~ is[J<!O{lltwtil \5{~~ 15{"t~~1
~~~~'I . . ~
~,,~~~ 'Off~o{I.!l~~ ~1fT0{ ~ft!~K~, iSfT9ftCo{
C<!T~\>fi C~ ~~tc~ Dtft! \if
~~-"ItPr\!3 <il~~ ~~')<l~ iSf')<!Co{~
c~t?irc~~ \!3~?;"I1I5{t<!~~~tll I C'l~ ~~?;'1~
ArIz co;t~ 'l'~~ I.!l~~~ ~ft!~11.!l~ I5{f\!3@$ iSfT;;§)l,j\!3t~t<!~9 <!~1{tcO{~ '~
~r.Pl-~~ 15{"t1lt(;lf~
~"1<lC0{'€ '!t~C~J ~1:jtO{\!3~l5{t~il-C<f~ ~ 'S?;i I ~ \!int
iSftf~~ @~ mm~,c~ m?;<t CSiT9ft;\i' ~~to{ ~T: foIc~?;<! ~~~1
lftiI '!{t~tCifQ"~t<!Jc<!t't '€ ~'J<\O{~~ "lf~T<!\!3~ 1lto{Pl~\!3T~ ('1T~,?;~~Si ,?;'ll~ )
<lM~T?;~O{: "Buddhism has made Japan what it is to-day" (~'l) I
m<\' ~(C~ 9fi¥?;<!, 1!l?;\!3~'" C"O{~
I \!ilC\!3 <!Jflg>'1\StSl" I!l<fl"'fl~~TC"lST 15{'1~t"l ~
~ I ~f<nl f.\C<!lRlllC,,-e N"I C'l~ ~~T~ ~rh "'IT~T~11 \!iT~ 0{~0{f)5t ( <.!l<\~
WI<!r"r RC:srsr ~~~Sl" 'lf~9f ~SI RC'Sf~ R~C~-e \5FI~ C~?;~ f?t~~i[, I!l~
~~ ~ ~t<!J- ~f)tc~ <!'lC" I5{t:sr "lISl"'1 "<f~C\!3~ ~C<! I 0{~0{f)?;~~ ~f\!3~1 '''I\!3
I.!l~ "l\!3 <!~'i~ ~ ~~., ~R- 0{~0l;~~ C'lo{ ~$tt1i 'Si'll$~'1 ~
1{~mJSl" o{il,-I!l~ 'lf~"i I5{TC<lC~Sl",~fi-f4<!tC~ST, ~liTT~ I5{t"lCO\t~I I5{T<!tSl"
O{<tIO{f)~~ 'Si'll-"l\!3~tt1l~ @~'l~ <lt~TafI ~~~ 'I ~~~ ~1fC~ I.!l <l~~
~~,. ~Ni<t>1C<!JSl"15{~-'i~'lfi, 15{'fl(r.t\!31, Cl)~OltSl"\!3"1'W\!it'€\!itc~ CO{~I I!lN~
~~?;~O{ I
,~ ''4.,t..fl~ ~"'€ ~t~ C<llT?;"O{1
e~tc0{1 ~~ ~f<I\!3t~ ~t"Q" ~~~~ ~W\!i
O{~'lf)C~~ z.'im:~J~ ~f~~~ 9fft!1{t9f ,1.!l~0{~~ N?;o{~ llt9f~~ ~~
~ I I!l~ ~tsrC'1 '1~'1~ i:N "<!'rt <!T~~?;"o{Sl"
~~i ~O{ ~ft!?;~ 'lfo{, ~tt~ 15{t"5~
N~ C~C~ I.!l~~ A9filiSfo{~ I I5{tll~1~., ~~, ~~ ~\!3~~ 15{t?;~ iSfC'll~?;i:ji{.
~ <!iTsr'1'O\~ I I5{tmif~ CIfC"l (~-eC~TC9f-e) C'I ~~ <lT~o{~' ~C.,O{ ~~~
I.!l~ "l\!i<lC~ 15{t1{t?;IfSl"
~t<1, l5{t~ttlf~ 1l'1%, "'It1lt(;lf~ 'iT~J?;<{T't I5{Ci{~ 9f
~ I 15{~~ <!t'll~t'1~ I!l~ ~if""t'fl I5{t?;<!~'€ @~1l @~'lT~~ l5{t~tC'ifSl"~~ ~~,
~~~ I ~ C'i 9fft!<l\!3CO{~'1JSl" ~\!3 ~~ 0{~0{f)?;~~-e Ift"O{~ ~ ~~
~C"lsr fil'~ ~~O{ <U~ '€ f<!<!ii9fl5{t~tcif~ \!i~~ ~~ ~t~~'1 ~sr~ 011I "'ITll"ST1
<miSf~, ~tQ" ~-lft"O{ "'Itmlf~ l5{tiSf~t~ llto{lf~\:3 "~C'it~{" \!3t'~ ~'I.O{~",
~i.~ ~sr~ig ,~~ ~~~tll, ~ ~ilTo{ f<I?;"l~ 9f~t~-e 0{1I CQ"i1ltJt~ @~t'l '€
~~m l.!l<flItJf .~~t'1 i{i{; ~11.!l~ .il~ "r\!3 <!~~r.Sl"~l.!l9ft?;Q"
I.!l?;'l e"'lT~ f;!, <!I(~ ••
~~ '1~0lf)C5t~€ ~A-fDc~ ,<\rr~J I
I.!l~ I.!l~ "f~ <!~'l?;~~ <!t~t<1') ~O{C~ ~~COl;~C~~"lf~ ~ir~~C~, \!it-e O\<!TO{D~~
~~~ "r\!3~~~
'"
~~~ ifto{ \5ItllSl"1l!l~tC"'~ <!~"l'l~<.l1"lISl"'1~~<! I
• f~~-e ~t'!, l5{t~tCifQ" iSfT~~~tt<!tI:f \!i~0{ 9f~~ (,lr'l(t ) c"<!'f-t ~c~
~, C<!it1.f<lC"f<l ~9(ajT'5 "<fC~~"1 I I!l <fI"<!J$C~ ~C~ ~?;~ 15{t~ ~~Sl" CIf"rc~?;~~
;g:i}}
<l5t"l <lCill\5{"t'Sill~t <f5rr~J~ ~~
"'IC9f~1 ~\l~ I
O{~O{~~
15{t~~1 ll~t'1t~ ~
9fiTt'f'1 ~C~O{ ~~O{ 1{~"
\!3~0{
<!i 1l~~
lI~t'lRt'lf'11
• 9filN'to{~~ iSf'1J;;tSl" C<!IfO{tC<ltl:f
'€
I5{t~to{ '€
I.!l~ ~C'1 ~~'1l)C"I -sf5 1l"tQ'jErlfl'l~'Si0l1 c;IT~tll'l~ I ~t~ 'l~"1 C~~ 9f~t'"l f1If.Ir
C?'IC~~tv I ~tOlt~O\fl!..c~~<li C~~~~ 5fl)<\itv ~~ 9f~~ '<f~t~ "l<lf <li'C~ f!l~Cl1
'1t1)'il\!i'1c~ ~C<'I, I.!l-st~, 0{~P1~1fl1f1,fiS \!I'l P; c~l '5jtC"Ol<li1~t~ ~tl,{ I ' ~
~'1b~<:! 9ft~~l ortc~ 9ft~~ c2iC<lilItl,{ I -ftiS ~ ~C"I f~~ ~~'l ~C'll ~ I
"~PI~c~fif"Ol'O\t'll'ltiS5fW~1l ~'1S1 ~t~C<!i ~1Itl,{,,1 I N;~C"Il~ '5{t~ ~C,,~ 'lClfJ"€
~" ~~l:'<t'''fit"Ol'IlH'il ~tf<li fi!Cl,i ~t~ C~C~ Cif~; ~''Si"OlI.!lC1f~\1~i ~t~ R~t'(C<l'
'1~ 1l"t~., ~t~t<;'{ Dt~ 'lt~<'I ~t~~ '5j"l~1 ~l,! 1l"t~ S'lt~~ 'il~-1l~ st<:! ~~ (;7f
~Cil, "llt~ ~tt~., I c~c~lItl,{~C'llC"l~ clft<litt'l I
'Ilt1l"C<il
--
\]
ToI~t~~~~~O{ Rr;(!ft~ ~r;a'I-e \59fn-! OIt~ I ~t~'1 Olt~~~ utta'l~ ,~~, ~."3{t~ C'l ~~~t~ <fir;~ 15~7j, c~"~"\1-"l"l~-c5t"l~"\1 1 '5I"1-"It-"l1!
<l19ft~"t lii'SlO! Ca'lt<fS<l~~l?i I "ltig~tr;iS C"lt<fS<i~~r;l?i,~ 9ft"ll)n-! Pl~ ~~ Ol~l O{~~ J'!~~ J'!\!51i~c~~"l, ~t~~ C:3l<fi<jl~C~ '5I"t~~ ~~Ca'li 9fJtt~gjtC;"\11 c~~9f
S"l~<i 0111 ~l)r;<it~i§ ~tR;~~ ~t~<f -e:t"t~1 C'if~C~ ~C<l, ~~~ ~C<i Pl~~~_ iP'!1 \'li \!5tr:if~ ~9f-~9f ~Cl?i 1
~c~ "c~t~ "It.,t\11 ~t~ I "\1t~ <i~ '<I"C"\1
~l)~<i I "l1-.,1!"
'C~
I s'1.<fi, s'l<fi 1 ~wPl~t~ ~H1I5(tc~, ~Wfut~ I I5(t~1- e<fi ~1~ I"
~t~ ~., t;tta;~ I C~O{ f<l9I1f\!5tCif"\1m~cOI '5I"tcJ'!OIt~ \ ~9f1! ~Ei7c~ c~~t~ ~t~~~t"\11 '1t"l1-
C~ 7
'-e <it<i1, "ltc~ OIt1{~ C<fif'<l1 I5(tc~ '€c~-'€~ f<l; R9f'if ; <£l~ <£l~I 9ftM ~~~c.,1 ~~~a'I ~'19f'1 ~f\!5r;~ I ~~~ - ~Cl)1 'l'ft~~ st'lit~ st<fi1 C'<l~\ffm~
1{1~~i§~ ~~ <jl~ <fiC~ ~~a; I
<£l<jl'Sl0l ~9f'if '<l~C~ 1 <£l<l'~Ol~ st<l'1 c~c~~\1"lt~ ~C~ f5tc~ \SI~ <£l~~tOl~ ~tc~ C~Ca'I 9fC~
c~~ CSl)tc~-'sa;- sa; ~a;nr I' ~9ft'l9f st<i<fitc~ c'<ft'¥t~ca;tt<fi I ~P\~<£l'li<it~\!5Wf"\1 ~C<{S \!it~r;~ C'if~C." ~t~9f"\1 c'!\SI~<fi\!"\1 '!\!5~ ~~ f;!~~~
~\!ji~ <fiC~ ~c~ f5tc~ "t~C<fi~ ~9f~ ~~C<i I c'<ft~tt<jl ~t'19fC'1 mCl?i '€~1 I "l~C<li iS~<l1
&t"1l<fit~a'I~ "l~'~ C~\!5, ~t1U "<fS~0l~C~ I5(tt~, ~~\!5a'1~t~ I OI~Pl~C~~ "I~C<I' ~g Cll 9fJtr:"I~t\1r;If~ ~C<fi \!5tf<fic~ ~ca;-9fC~"\1 "l"lf, ~<tlCa;Olf<fiOli,<£lCll
stt9f ~lfU~ ~9fC~~ ~~l)1 ,~,~ <fiC~ C~C~ ~. C~1 ~C~ ~tc~ 1 ~~ ~~~-'SI ~~C\!i ~~<i, Pl9f1f \!5t~~ ~~ I '5I"t9fOl\f?;'1T Cll ~t'<l'r;<i,~'l'f<itOl~tr;<!, ~~1 <fi~r;<io{~1
if"t ~t~a'I C<lC~~~C~ I "t~C~~ Cf)C~"lt~ ~ta'l I ~t~t"\1 ~9f~ ~., 'l'ft~ I' c~t~1 m~i I m~c..,\SIt~ c'<ft~t~ 'l'ft~ 'lt~ I fol~~
~R!;~ ~f~c~tf5t\!5t~ <£l~~1 C<iST~~ C.,C~C~ 9IJtt'l~t~CIRl .~COl I ~<iSCa;~ CJ ~Ci>f, ca;.,-.,t~., f<fi~~t~ 1 ~
~Cl?i-~tOl nrr:<I' ~t~t~ ~~<fi ~tf<ml ~ 1{"I f9r~COl f9rfl?iC~ ~-e~ c~t~~ 00- ~t~~ CIfr;~<{S
'5I"f\!5\!ji1l'<I'C~~ ~t1l.,'l'fc~~ ~Ol~t~a; 15'M ~t~i I Ol~Pl~ 'l'ft~r;~
~C.,t~ nrC<fi 1 ~tc~ ~t\!5 ~C~ '€~l c~t~t~C.,tC<jl ~~tc~ I Ol~Pl~-e CliC~~ ~ cif<it~ '5I"tt'l'f "ltc~~ fifc'l' \!5tf<l"~ '5I"t~ <£l'<l'<it~C'fC~ f;!Ca'l I &tC"'il~ 'ta'lt,!1{t~:l
C~C~ 1'[~ "Rffic~ Cm~1 ~t~~ ~t~C" 1'[~ f;{<i~ <fiC~ <M'Ca'I-"~C<i <£l~nrOl '€tl!1 "*151"I~<fi, 'lca;t~ "\1tM ~ft;1;~ sa;a; 'l'f~") I ~rs"l\!5") ~t~Ol'l'f~ c~tl;~ '!t~'l I
~~I"
~t~~ 0l1-~'€~~ ~~ f0\\!5t~ <£l~ ~ ~c~f~a'I I' C,! <ia'lCa'I- "~9ff;{ ~t ,'Itt I5(tllff~ 9f*t"l ~~l) a;tc'l'f Olt~ I Ca'lC~~ m\!55m"l ~~l) I f\!5'l f1lf;{~ '5I"tc'l'f
"15~ 7" Ol~Pl~ "?f~~~\!5 \!5tf<H~ ~l"lIH~Ca'I- "15~ y" Cllt~ f<t>c~C<fitc:g~'lt~COl nrc~ <£l'<fi
'lt~~ \SItf9rC'l~ ~~COl '5I"t<it"\1 c'V~ f~ <it~tc~~
~Cl?i, ~t'iftQj\!5 '5I"tc~, ~l" '5I"tCl?iI ,€wC'if~1;t~~ ~tf<f<jl C9fT~ fifc~ ~C<i15l~~ I fifc~ 9fJtC'lg;t~ t'<l c'<lib ~ 'l1 1 ~tc~ llt"\11'l'f~t~ ~tl; ~~"ttc., C~COl COlC~ '€fifc~"\1
~ ~~1 "lt~t"lt~ ~Ca'I-'€CI!~ <fi~'€ f<iS~ ~ca; ~~Ol f<f ~~<i f' C1{~Sl 'lt~cIl ~t~"'l'f"\1 \SItc'! \!5t"\11<£l<!''if~1 ~~ ~~1{ ~....•
r;9f I \!5t"\19f"\1
~r;l;1 ~ 91- <£l"<fil)i
l
"~<I' <fi~ I" \5{~l;t~ C"l~~1 'ltc~ 1f"tl)t~ I <£l~Cl)1 1UC9f C"lt<iS~OIc~..J1 ~~ Ol1I C'<I'tOl~ r;9f ~Ol
• l
"~t~~ ~a'I'€ ~~ ~M c~t~<fi11 ~M 7 <tl~~1 c~t~~ ~r¥r~ C~tC5 ~t~i~ st"\1 1 RC<tl'a'IC<i"lt~ ~~.,~~ :~C<fi 9fts~i) ~t<i1~ C<1t"<fiC<l...J1I....•'!"<fin.,
'!C~ ~"ltC'if~ 1 ,€wCI!~f<1s~Ol~ I C,! <tl~~1 "lt~t"lt~ <fi~<i\SIt~~1 I" <£l<fi~~9f .• ~ <£la'l\!5t~t~ c~r;~ I 'ltc~ f\!5Ol~ c~C~ ~ 91 ~"?f; '!tc~ NOlCt)~ c~c~ st~r.l)
C~C<fi C'l ~t<it~ <i~c"-"~C<i C'l <tl~i¥1, '5I"t"<i~ ~C<l, C'f~Pl c~fifOl I" 9ft5' <tl if"t ~f;!Cl; 9ftR\!j"); '1t~~ st~Cl)~ 9ft5"l\!5")"\1f\!5Ol st~~01 f;!r;~ ~t~OI~
a'lfis;\!i f;!\!5t~ f9r~c.,~ fifc<fS~tf<fic~ C'<l~~ ~t~~ ~tc~~tOlc~ c'if~f~- 1t5l;t~ 1 -.!I'<l~ 9fts~1 9fCOl"\1~f;!Cl; C'<lt<tlt~ 'l'ft~ f;!r;~ 9ftj)"l~") I '1'<1'tta'l"\1
csf5~ ~~~a'I-"~'€-~'€-~"lN \SIt'€ I" f;{c'Sl~ t~C<I' C,! ~<fS ~O{ <iJ~ "K~~~..... C9f ell C<fi"\1t9t<it'1"\11'51"tt'!-\!5t"\1t~"Rf"\1r;<i
I <£lC"<fi<itC"\1
~H'1 "<fSC"\1 ftt~r;~
~~a'I 0111 ~~ ft-lf") <i~ <jlC~-\!5t~ ~~~t~~ ~'19fC'1' ~~~t~ <jl~ ~ ~ I CSC9f~ <i~-Sa'l-Sa'll f~~ ~~ ~~t~"\1 CIlr;'<I'~ftr;9j1( ~\!5 1%~~~ 0111
:'5I"t~~~-4t.,t~1-15(~ I" \!5t~9f~ C~ C'if~tC\!5'5I"t~~ ~C.,~~ ~t~ .•."ll 1{t~~tci§ C<fi~ <iC,!011I CI5\!5C"\1~
<iC~ '5I"tl) ~.., I ~<fStCa'i lltt~ c~tOl "\1<fiC~CIf~
C~ ~t~ ~~~t~ "<fiC\1 ~~a'I-"9fts~\!5") ~t'lOl~~1 ~t~OI~ 9f~1I\?r ~~1{~~ \SI~ I5(tf9fr;~ ~'li ~~C~ c9fT~r;~~ ~C<i, ~t~ m~ 9fr;~ ~t~'l'ftci§ ~'!I
~ '
~~'!I" ~ ~r..ca; l5{if9tc~~ ~t~1 Olt~; '5I"tf9t~ J'!tc~<i O!t~ ~c~ i <fitc~~ ~t~1
~~
] 'l~1~-*<tj1f
C'Tt\l;t~ o'Sit~'1?;~<!l<\'iI5ltOl19f1l'l1 ~frn <!l'lS~l5ft~t~ 0f1 c~t'lS I5ltPl~ <lIt1(
~~"'t, 1tD'1~! .1tD'I~' <'!t~ fUftI"I,'art-t; fUftl"l !
~1l>"'<i / ~~Q'( OIJIPr~c~ fft~~C"1{~ ~t~tl.l , <\'i~ c<lINt~ 'i!{tillfC"1{?t;\Wt"1{1
'Sit~~t~1 -!j~'l ltffi<'! c~t~~ "Itlk~ Clft<\'it~Ol~'It"ltOl I f;{\!it~ c~f~ll'
r 'l.~c«"<15~ CIf~ m~ Of/ C\!i1? .
t;f<ll~ ~~<'!N~<'! / \!I<\'i<lI<'!<!I"
lJ'Si~~~ ~lJ~ iSi<'!i;~c<'! "I~<'!,Cl:{1'll1:qt1(~t
~ 9fC~<!l~~1~~ 'Sit~1l I5lt\S51I \!I~to{CQ,(C~ ~\!io{'1t~ar I!C~ \!I"<!I"
is!t~~ "1{j-"<I5tafrQ
f~~~ C~~<lI~'Si<lt~ <f'C~ it~1 illf<'!
~c~ NC., I o1~Pl~f;{Cillf:q~~1;lJii;~~ 'tC.,
C>1'<ftCOf
~ti1l'1~~ ''If.{ Ol~<'!<!t~I \!I<f1;j~tl;-e C'l~Ko{ \!iltc~-I5l~ <tIaf~C~~
'{to! I
~~Cll~ NOl, ~~t1 C~~~ i;~~~, ~<\'i~ ~t'{1~1.,t~t~ ~c~tillfOlI
~~ ~tQ ~~'€ R#I ~l.l / 'Si~'Il:'Sit~ \!I~ "IC~ "St~ ~tc1;I "tf;r ""l~af<tt~"1l1 <fita1'T~
~K~1l I5lt~ "lt~<'!1:q~'fI5ltc~ C\!i<'!-<fta1'T
C'I~~ I C'li:lt'l "<I5C~ ~tC'l~~ <\Q'jCi! ~ f;l~~ ~T~I C'll'l ~~<!K'Il:~ /
f<f Pr~~ C"<I5'1Ol
?
<!{t~ <!I~tc~ ~9f1 'Ii~tC~1 .15ll~ 'l~~t'l <fit~t~ \!it, 'f~ c~fi¥t~ ~1 f;{nr \!It'l
~~<'! Ol~Pr~-C'f'{1 C'f"lt'l <f~~ <I<'!~ar,~tar I 15ll"lf;r ~tar? \!I~~Ol<fS~ ?
~tCll~ \!I<I~"It~"ltC<f <lifr.or1
f;{c~ ·-Rt~c~, C'l~tOl<ft~C'Illt'l~
<\'i~~C~ C'lt1;QIft~'lQ
"<!I"t~<!tC~
"<I5tiS!N~~~
"lt~<lI I
I
\!itCif~ Ifli~
<!l~tOl<\StQ
"I1if~ ~
~ti~ ,~C~~
1l~~ Cif~ ~tc~ /
9ft~'ll~'11
~~~ 'Sit~'{1m'1tclfQ
iSi~ 011~f$c~ 'O{QPr~
1tS'I\!i') I
"It~C"l 011/
1tl>'1~') I
'lC~ ~t<Jft f.l,~ ~tl¥t"<l5tN;~Q'(~
~tQj""~CafQ
Th~ ~~~~ar-C'l~ C'I~ Ol'1f<'!'1t~~rt"ltQ / C~1"'1toft '€CifQ ~if~ C\!i1 ~~~~ lft~tO\ffic~ ~a;i i;N;C~ \!IC'l"I~ar C\!i-"1{t~~ I
i;~~ "ItPr~'{1 fifm~ /
",~fJ!~<!"fCar-'{1 c<!.,~ 1lc;{ "<15'~Nf<\' C\!i1 f;r\!it~, <!I<tI~1 1;t'lO{j f.lC\!i~C<t
C'I~ oftf.,"1{lI5li'<DifJC'I~~ I CDt~ Qt~t~
~~-~~carc1~<tt~ I5lt~~ CDt~ C\!itC<'!0{1/
( ~'1"1:)
'ltc~ if"l1;1'<!t~illfI ~~o{\!I~t~Ol"1{R~~~<'! l>Qj~~I \!I~<I~ C'l W~~:q, 9ftl>lI\ft
\!it~"l~~ <lC~Jt"ltllJ~
~ "I fO{~~~t<lt~ "I~~ ~tiS! Cif~1 ~~ \!it~ 'lC~ I \!I~ fi!.~"l~t<!t~ 'l"1{~OlQf1!~
~
"<I5C~~ \!I<flJi~t~1 '\C~ ~t~ I <ut"ltQ1;j f;r\!it~ ~<lI~~ I C'l C~~'l <!C"-Pl~~~
\!I~ 'lU11lc"l'( ~C"I ) 'N~~"1{' ( fif~~'1 ) ~~ !
cif1f, 0{1/
o{~Pl~f<t;~ illf<!t<! C~"ICo{·""lClfJ"ltl:fJift'4f.l~1f ClliCar' .rrf~j'~j lit'l ~
~ar C"1{~ / \!itC<f~ ;;star a;K~ / \!it~ C<I~ f~ o{~/ CiSitC~'lji
c'Ith ~t~~tl
~~Jf\)-:-~~~
ft>.~oftM"1{j"It"l jlS'~~C~,~'{Caf 'Ii~') <l'C~/ o{~C<f~c~~taf / -Rt~~iSitQ f1!~~ il'rdn ~~m~-~~~tt~~~t~ f~teft
<!t~~ c~Caj CIf, I5lt~ -Rt~:q~iSit~~~ ~tCif~-1 ~ ~f;r.jt~ 'fl~ ~t"l-Dtill ~O{, ~0i8o-~t~<\;', ~0i88 :.
I5lt"lC'Wf<\'i~ C<lIto{
aft'S O{t~/ o1~~<!~c~~tCaf I5ltillfC'f c1lth ~t~;;s~ / \!it~-et
"For these years the symbol of France has been silence. Silence
'ljil;<rt~ ;;star I
among her crowds, silence in her homes,··· silence because the
'lji1;<f')-eI5ltiS! <tS'fff~I5ltC'l~ / "It~~ ~~Ol~t"1{ f<f~ ~D C"IC~C~ C<ltlt~ I
German officer is billeted in the next room, silence because the
'lStrn-'<lQ1:qt~t"ftl.l C~iSiRtajf~C"lj f~ \!itC\!i I5lt~<ftaf'l~t~ 'l'l~~ Olillfl,\!i~~
children daren't say they 811': hungry, because every evening the
Dt~ ~ ~C~ I "t~ \!I<fNo{ :qcar€ ~"f ~t'fC\!i ~t'!C\!i, "I5lt'€~~C<\'i<\'i~ ~C"fllt'l bOdies f th •
o e hostages who fall, make of every morrow a day of
<t>~C<!Ol
O{t~Pr~illf'),"
nationallUourning." ~*~-"-!j~ "<I5c~<!I"fU<!~~ ~~ ~tiif f~af ~\!it'll: ~"<!I" ,
I5lt~'{1~<!~ C"IC~C~, \!I"<!I"~O{tf~ lli1;<ftC<f~~ ~C<! tfl~Q '<fC~C~ ,
~~ ~~~1 o{l~~, \!it~ ~~ ~ ~~~T~ ~tiSi~-<tIt~'1 tflc\!iJ<\'ifU~~ ~~\!i \!I</i1;j
~'c
15l0lJ1l~~ ~C<! ~~ \!I"<I5~'!~ \!IC'! f;{~0{ . iftN;~ \51<!~~ I \!I"4tOl <:l ~'llT~ l5l~mC<f 9,(~c~ ~c~, C~C"1C~~~~j;;sc~f~Cif~ <tIQ,(t'€:qCaj0{1I "l~
oTtM"1l1 m~ 15lt'f<!t~9f~1;tCff~ ~ I
~~ <2lt'1fflC\!i~~ 2ff~~Cif~ ~ 'l~Jt~ I5lt~ "I~<!\!i" ~~fU 'l'<ft"f ~ illftm
~~' NC~ f.l\!it~ I fOR'illfQ
"IC<lI1;
cQ,(C<f~N;1;j <l~ '<f~ Cif~ ~Pl~ I c-tt~ ~<ftt"l~ NO{ I"
<!l"<!l"1;l
~ -e~tl>1(tc~ C'f / C1liSi<!t1fu~ro"fOf / IfK~ If''ll;1 "1t~ / Of~ 'he Oft~-tr-I5l~~ . ~TCiif~ \!I~ <t9~j Clf-e~1 ~c~c~ C;;S~C<fiR f<\'~~ ~ut out
C'l~'O{ CQ,(C<f'~C'l ~~t<'! 'Sit~~ "Itt"l' ~o{illfo{"Im'!~t~ \!IlU....c"I, 5ft~c~ C IAlght ~\!I~ ~~<t>~ I f<li~ -!j~ ~'fU C5'C"I 1l~1 ~~~t'll: ~Kar DCafC~
<l"fafO{IlPr~I f;r~~ ~?;~ar '<I,f~c~~t~""flfCaj I
~ ~~ l5l~t~ "It1U/'ltOlClfQ15l~<iO{/~~~c~tlf-'f~~t'l, c~ 'l~$'ll' CO{WC~
,.~
C1{Ca;
'€ llt~<[ '41f<!i~ ~~ <fiC~ '1'1'~ ~C'1' ~t'l{tclf~ ';5{tca,tSJ f<l<[~I" ~~~ ItItit~Olif ~~9ftC~ ~~51'll ~f;{ I ell "5{~tq C'l{t~Ol<.!l<fim~ifif1f7i!lit'\!i'1l!~~<fitc~~
(
l!{'1'O'!~Co{
';5{tliif€'c}jt}jt~~~' ,.,1ljj" ~t~1 ~r;lJC~ <.!l~-"<.!lf"ll!l ~~c~~ 1li'flt : ••~ "!~~ I \!i~ ~~J~'ifrt~ li~WI I!{~itr.;c;;~ C'lf-C(Jf
<.!lC'ifitrlJ9ff~'\!iC'ififCl{t~lit;;
~r~~TCOlif ~tO{tc~"il'l ~'l{tq~ ~<!>~ ~t~ <.!l~~llrOltSlllClfT llt~<[ <[1 ~i m ;:~ :!J,~'e.'lt'lt~~~' 'i!lii'\!i11l
~r'\!igtr:Ol'~9ft~~~ ~€mif '1'&T'1'Oft
~f%'\!i<fi~a;J
~~ :'<!."l e'lt'lt~ffli1' 'l~J9f'if -1t~r;'l~i!li~€ elflCTI~
9jf~\!iCif~ i!;f~ 9fCi¥A,~~'€ fQ'<.!l<fi-
~~f\!i til f<1l~C'lll'l1tlJ~'1~ ~a; '5!t1ltcliif'5!WIWrCOlSl
ci!lil'ii ~~ ~f\!i.gtc~Sl Olt'll<1lif'l
<1lCifOl
C'lf-~ I"
'<.!lf1!~tfU<1l
Cif1'!l~~ I' '€lJtcifO\'c~f1~ , C1;iif
"!~T~"!tr;'1'~~'1 <fiiftif ~~t~
CJftllt~ffl~' <2{'<!.'ll I5t ~">, - ~
~c~~., I ~ITI:>~'!tr;0'! ~~~tOlt~ ~tVT
<.!lif~'<l1l~9{~ ~'8~tif ~ \5l~r.ifllf <1l~1~Sl t~~ ~t:sr<!ilr;~J'1'J~\!i~ ~~ tR ~1:>1l!'l~J 100~lN\!i ~O{1 9fc~ I!{<l:~~tsTf<f2JnT ';5{'liljt~'t
~"!~ ~'8lJtv ~tif~ ~~iC'1' Ci!lil'ii~ 'C'lt'll~~if" ~'<l1l lI~l'>\f'\!if.l~tf5'i5 ~~ ~~ 'c'l1"tt~fflc'\!i'Clf'~"lt~t~' lI~T ~~r;'l~ ifl~ ~a; \!i~~ '\!itM<fitl! ~ti!Jil
~ Clf~~~l;;
~'l~8 'ftt., ~tif ~~lif 9J:~ '>\~J~ f'\!if., <.!l~ 9fCif \5l~~'\!i e'<lC<fi ~t~ ~ o(~ '€ "5{lfTt9f~'l'i~CIf'<l:
"ll~h Olt~ 9ft€~1 mI C<1llCrq~e'lr;~
~~ ~t~~~~ n< /
~tSJf<l'ID1~"t"1.,COl~ f~fu 61f'\!i~l ~C~;; I <.!l~0l 9j~J~ <.!l~ lfifCOlif~ ~ ~·10l€ W.:I.:I 'Ii., C~~ ~IT~ 'Ita; 9f~~ Ctll~J'\!it~ '1C5f~'\!i1l
'<.!lPl~tffl<!i ~c~
C'lt'lt~fU' i!li"1f~'\!i ~~ ~CIfJ<.!l~~r~ ~t&lO\'\!i~I )IT~~ 'Itea! ~ ~t~ ~C~Ol I <.!l~€ 9f~ ~17IT~'!tcO'! SltCi!li:!!t7ftO'!
f~ 'ClI1'11~~if' ~~1l
'l~'1~ f;{~tf5 - ~.
~STf<l~lf<l"lliflf C~Ol~)iJ~t'l C<1ltali3p
~ f<t-.,tr;\!i '~~t., <.!lPll!r~qs-C'ltllt~~ '!{1f ~ffl ~~ ~OlI <.!l~ ~c~ ~~ ~~~ l'\!if;{ '!~-lI~9{f~ ~r:.,;;'€
~~~., ~ ~t~ta!/r~' ~t9jOl ~C~;; I <.!l~~ "lt~1 f~lItc~ ~'lT ~,€l tv ~~ <!It1f1 ~ .•:~ <2I~M~ "Rrn€C~~1 ~fu~1" 9ftcHtl! f;{~fil\!i~te'i *'1'~'1t'''<fi
~Qj!;<!5~t1lt~'i!l '~f1!vrfS<1l e'ltllt~~~' <fitr;~ '5!~~t~ '5!tr;'! I f<!i~ '!l~~ ~ ~SlC'\!iOl
1 I!{COl<!l' ~t., <.!l9ffJ!~t~ 'l"P(tIfO\'~i5~€ ~~~ 9fr;~ ~a; I
~'lt~ffl ClI '5!~~tlf <fl'\!iJt~Jto( <!5C~ I 9fC~ '<1lt.,~qs- ~~ ~f~lJl ,"l"P\tml ~21'1ilf "lt~1 ~~~ "5{tCifl"5{COlr;~
i5i~~')lJ ClItllt~~~ ~i5t9ff\!i 9fif';5{7if'\!
r· C'ft'1i~fa~ ~m=r .••-;:+ot.,,"'f';. •....•
~~~ __ .,..._ ~.;... .
I.!l~ ~~Qj?;"1J ~ -e 9\pg~ <!~ ~~~OIT I.!l"l~C~ I.!l<!i<li
~C~ ~tsJ ~ 9\~
RajOl~'1~ I.!l~ c'5'fh?;<!t~"" ,~f~~tOl -e ~t~ ~Zn: Olt~ ,~Ol <!i'C~ "il~'1 .• 1Ilt'f <!tt~ If'"! ~~~ 'c~t'lt~fflST' '1~t9ff~~ <!iC~O{UI~~ 9\t~ CitC"l NC~ N~
f<tl~ ~~ f<l1f~~~tt!J ~'Ilt\f~ ~~~t~ ~c~~Ol~ I <!i~ '!lM"11 ~ ~f"l"1t~ Clft1II' ~ f<t~c~ 'c'!tm~ffl . ~f~folR~ <!iC~O{I
I.!l~ '!It''D~J ~~ ,f~qs ~f~~to{ C~ '!ltlltclf~ </i~ <1:~ :1J"Pf1f'!l~~: f"l~ ~ )Ir"~'ilc<; C~''f. f~c'Jf9f' (\,;'8~qstCQ'[ ~R ~~<1:~S!'C'!t'll~fflST' ~"Pftlfc'liST 9f'Cif
<'I'~l \5tcQjt\5tt<1:\';9fajf~ 0{1<!i~ca; \,;'8~'1..~c~~
<tltc~ '!ltlltCIf~ I.!l<tlfw"l ~~ ~ ~CQ'fo{) ~rST '!l't9f0{ 9ff~qst~t<t5 'c'!t'!l~ffl~' ou~t~~ qs~tQ' '!t~i1f~ !)to{ I
If~ 'Sf~t<1:~~ <lS"\K~~C<1: I ~rOl-M"@tCOl~ :1J1l~ C~Cili I.!l~ ~f~~t"l~\1 c~~ ~ ~lIf\!i 1!l~'lrc"ST 9f'fu!<f1 ~<fitM~ ~ca; ~f\!igtCO{ST O{tll ~l'C~ "\!jPl~t~qs
~ ,<\R~r ~~ '!!~c~~ "l'll--!jq5lltJ:l <1:'ca;~ <1:C~ I C'ltJflt$ I!{~ C<\~a;" <lCQ'[~ 19ft ~ I c~ O{t~ ~~I::l~'!tQ'[ 9f't~ <1l<!i~tO{1SCQ'[
~~~ <1:~\1'!lwt. ~ '117" '!tta;Q' ~It~ iSi~llt~1 "O~O{(' ~~r~t~ll ~~?;;;;tw 111-" ~., I ~"'~8 ljiC"'I 'c'!f~~ffl' ~f\!~tST m~~~~ <1:t~~ ~~'!<1: ~Ofa;C~J
11l~ ~f~~tto{ST 9f~0{ <mfo{ I ~c'Wte;l ~ca;O{ '!l<\~ ~tST \';~M'lltll CiSit'Jf I'~~ '1~.-r~1f~9ff~ 'iSt: 'll'tll'ST C'!t'll~~~ O{tc~STI5fTc'5'f1"ST~ta;'"l'lf c~t'5'f <l'ilt~ ~~t<l
<1:~C~~ f~f;{ C~lT; \,;~f"fll~~ ~ffl~ C~tCT;~ M~lST9ff\!i ~'!tC<1: <1:t~aj1CifC'"t -.cto:{ I Jt .fl~t<f \5I~'itcST ~"'~~ 1ftta; ~t'!lit!j1~f~ fll~<lH 9f'~ 'c'!t'i~~'~ <l~lltO{
~lll~~, '!lt~O{ ~ ~t~JM~tST ~~ ~t\1 ~~Q'1'5'f ~f~~~~ ~qst'"t c9fl:'ll~a; -e ;rt1{ "nt"'! ~Pi~$~c'!r'!T~ffl ~'lji C:<i5fa;"~~ ~~ I
~ '!ltl:'5'f~ \5t~?;~ST <\ICH~ .flt~O{ ~t~~ ,!C~ ~tQ' ~C'<I~ 9fftt~ '<IC~I :. 'C'rtljt~~i1' ~f~m'l"ST c'5'ft'{jtST~C<f STriSi~cllQ' '!lt~~a;J ~<1:~ <2t\!J'l1' ~aj I
f~fOl lK'<I~~c~t'5'f 9ft0{ <1l<1:~~tQ' ~~'!~~~1, "lw~a;l, $Jt~C'5'ftMi\f '€ fic~t tt{C~tll C~C~ iitf"1''1J~ ~~ f'li~ f~"'I~ I f'li~ <lSliSi ~~tQ' '1C~ ~c~ C<it<lll
'!t~:.<fI1f9ff"SCiiST<!itc~ 9t~CIfC"l~ ~t"l'! '!"PfCIfST ~Q' \,;~'e> <\ICQ'I clfm <1:<f: c1f'l ~ ~rli''ll ~l~ '!ij~ili9f C"1'CiliC~ Ift~ lj~ ~~'1 qsC~ MCl1..f)- ~lc'Si~ <litt~
CQ'tllto{'!l~CQ' ~9ft~Q' '<Ii;tl:"l1Q'~'<I1l c<1:mrfol<1i9f~f~ '!ttM~tQ'~ ~t~Jf<\'WtST \!1' 'IfI"l1 <J~1 ~'<Ij I <uf;e;5'f\!i~rc<1: c~ti¥Tsr C'5'fti¥tsr <1:~ ~tSl'1..~Cll~ }jC~ <1ll C~
CiSitt'JfST\';C~~C~l'5'fJwto{ I I$ct~ cllt~ ~a; ~Cll \!il'~ ,~O{ 1l0lfi~~ ~tsr <1la;I 1StQ'\!<1:Ctfcl1ti;t~\5tC<1:
I.£lCIfC"l<!iC,!~ f~f;{ ~DJf~ '!l~..f)-ajCo{~ iSi'lJ 'l~C~~ <'lI'lltC'!Q'<'lI~~il J[~ ~~ ~t'Sf'1..~llCiil ~•••t~ <1l<li~ <2tC~t~J I '1<1:iSitsr*sr~ ~'<I~ ~C<!i~ ~~ljt~
'!t~~<1: <!i"\t?;ajO{
I C'l~ ~t'!Cqs ~t~ 'lt~ '1~foIqs ~9f' C1f<\tQ'i9i'lT~ Ci9itC'Jf~ ~ Wl9f~ f;{C'5 <1lC'! <1lCqs<ltCQ'~"Pftc~Q' '!ttll7jt~t~<'I' <l't~~l~ \,;~~ m
'Ii'! I
~ffl~ c<lStch l,mt~ ~fr' ~?;"1 \';c~'1;{t '1\51 '!lt~~ ~srl <1l~~tto{ ci9il1Jf
'!tf\5~l~C'1 <1:C"1O{: "~fif <2(~ <\IST1~sr <1l~ ~tO{~t~J 9f'ilJi;cO{ '!lt~C\Rl aj~J<rI c'It'lt~ffl~ 9f't'Ifi~\!r'Ifi Q't~·'1~t9ft~<1i~t<.1' '!t\5t<1:'!t~J~ 1lt~t'ir<f ~ \,;~~ lIfif
'i!C<1:'!tr~ttlf~ \,;'8Q' ~~ - ~ll '€ <2(~f~ I - '!t{t~ ~Wf~ST' l'ftf'l1'~J fi~ '" III('1e1 ~<ft~'If <iR1l ~tll <1lf'5'ft'll
<1lC1f c'! ~to{ ~~'1. qs~\!iO{ I <f<i1 <1:t~a;J <1lC~
15f<1:a;~cO{
'!tt~~ 'c'!t'lt~fflQ" 'aj~~ STt~l ~C\lC~ <1l~-"<1lf"lsrl ~~c~~ ~'fJl ~~ iJ~~ I ~~ <$I)JMl1rt~ ~'<It~~ 15f~~'.'fC"lST 0R~ UI clf~sr 9f'f~\!iCl1Q' C~'5'flfto{
~n~TCo{Q' iMtO{tc~~<t ~i1t<\~ ~t~C<1: '!ltST <1l~ ~lltO{tST ~ClfJ ~t~~ ~1 fqsi m ::~ ,I!l~".'1tiJt~~Sl' 'iSit"\!i)'ll~f~~te"l' ~9ft~~"\!i ~~m<.1' ~gOT1 ~~~ <l'Q'a;I
~~f\!i ~1 f'li~ c~'5'ftsr 'l<i~ ~aj '!lt~cIfST '!l~'l~nO{ST C"1Ji I" ~ :'<J,'il. C'ltiJt~~i1' '!~J9f'ii 1t~C~\1iSi'lJ~ CIf"ftsr9jf~~?;'if1l 'iStqs 9fCi¥A, ~fIf~ I(i'<!i<'l'-
Ci!liT'Jf <!i~ <2(f\!i~lC'1STO{til<lS"Q'1
<~uO{ '<!iPH!tfh C'l1'll~~ I' '€llttSTOl~lt~ , ~ 'l'5J ~iJtC<1:~~'1 <\I~tQ' <2t~t~ \,;C~~'.'f I ~17"<. mea; ~ST<1itO{t'<l~tVT
<1l~~'<I~ *,9ff~ ~'€~tST ~ '!l~r.~tlf <!iQ'1 ~lJ t~~ STt~'litcllJ <1:J~\!in ~~ ~~ffl~' 12l~~ ~l~\!i)sr '1~J foI~lro-~ ~O{ I 9fCst '!l<f~ <2(tDrf~tsr 15f'lt'it<.1''l
'!l'l,![~ ~'€srtlJ ~t~~ <2(~tH Ci9it'Jf~ 'C'lt'!trfflST' ~'<I~ lj~t9f'~ f.i~t~'! ~~ Sl~ 'c'lt"lt~fflc~' C~ '~O\t~t~' lj~J 1t~c'IQ'?rR5 ~a; \!itQ'~ ~tM'litsr <.1'tiS/1
~ 'l~8 :1Jtta; ~tQ' ~~jQ' 9J..~ 9f~J~ f~fO{ UI~ 9f'CIf '!lr:~~ C'<IC<!i~r~
~ ~ Cif~<fr~~~ '€ "!i{lfJt9f<1i<1:t~Cii<f''It?JftQ'O{t~ 9f't~sr1 I C<\I1<l~ C'ICo{Q' m
~~ ~t~<1i~'7J
~tDmlID1 ~"1'1ajCOlST f~fe 61f~~l </iC~O{I <1l~0{ 9jllr~ <!i~ lfQ'C"l"ST~ ~ C'lo{~ ~17"..:I~t<'! C~C<li~17% 'Ita; 9f'~~ c~t'5'fJ~tST :1JC~15{'lJ~~
~~ ~t~ <1iC~O{
I <1l~~ 9f'CQ'~""171t 'ltca; STtciSi~'.'fta; f~ 'c'!l'!l~fflst' <2t~
'11lP!~lffl<lSC'ltijt~fU' i9i'1f<1:"\!i
'!ltc~ ~tQ' ~C'IJ <!i~~t~ ~t5)o{\!i~ I ~17<'~ '1ttq
iJ~9f~ ~~rf5 - +,: +,: .
~DJ~~rf<t"l~1f C~"l~1 ~~t'! (</itO'f~<\S f<l'ajtc~ 'Q'~ta; <!iP!'llr~<f c'lt'!r~ffl <!Ilf tit ~" ~O{I <1lST'!ltc'5'f <1:~ <1:~ST1~10{ 'l~-'l\5t9ff~ ~CajO{ '€
• • ~t1fC"l<.1;
'1t~~-'1~ttiSf ~~~ ~~"I ~C~ ~~C~CiSiQ~C1fC"l~ I!i{tN~ '€ ~tinl ~<{CO{
. ~~.,tc~ I ~t~ <f'C"! ~CIfC"lQ ~~nc;n ~M~-<{J<{'1t~C1fSl"l!t~fq:~ -I:5:!f~Q 9j~,€
~t<.1;9fC<.1;
~~ ~fgj"T, C~Mm<f', 1:5:j~~~ ~~Q 1:59f~S('1~t<.1;C~ iSft~'1S{ iSf'1'l?:"ls(
,t~;,rJ '€ "l!t~0{~1 C~C~ ~D"O{l>~'c~ ~",., 15l«~ ~S(tCO{l iSiP\1ftQQl '€ ~t<.1;1
'In., "l~"l <2I~S( ~'1~to{ 'll'CQ <2It'1 ~lWC~~"!-~tc~ ~., C"I~ I l!i{ts( ~tQl
~11l1fit., ~t~1 ~~CQCiSis(1)C!l'tc~ 'l~,t~ ~C"!lC~"II ~~ ~~~ c~t"'Pft.n ~~O{~~a;fT
,~c~ ~'Oif~t~l, ~~t"l~, c~tf<l~1cS( ~C'l «'lf~ <f'Q"!~~O{ ~tClfs( 'lCllf ~~~S(
I.!l~lf'" ~«9Wt~ ~?f ~'''!~t~t"!l I ~'Qt~ C'lDt[O{S( ~~ ~fu"!ll c~t"P!t"I"'t~
~TI••t~ I <.!I~~«9«R~ 'l~tciSi~ ~~iSio{ ~~to{ ''!'If''1~t~ ~~ '€QC<f'"I~ ~ ~t~~~
~~ fitc"!!~fD?:"!l C<.1;C~~COif"l;~f.l"~ l!i{t<J;t<.1;
<2IQ\~~t~t~1 ~~~ <lHl f.l"~tc~<.1;iSi'lJ
~~c~~C~ "l'0if'lf ~t<t'l '1i~t~J <t?:~~C"l"l I <.!I<.1;
~<.1;~t<.1; J
''!'If'''t~t~ 15l«~~ C9fcOif"l
~"Pjtofl ~t~ C9fT1!jC~'~~tSltiSil' ~9ft~c~ 'l-mf;!~ ~QCOifo{
I <.!It "!~~tc~Q
~~"t'f~Qt~ I5lllli ~''''llt~tSl ~fil~ C9ft~tQ ~tiSi 9f~«t<.1;( Benimadhab Chatterjee
-A Short Sketch of Maharaja Sukhmoy Bahadur and His Family.
pp. 1·3 cQja I:59fC~~~<l<.1;'1C9fC~~ ) I I!i{tQ€ ~~~1 f<lc"l~ ~Pl~ ejP!lftQ'l~C"l~
~fl~t~ 'If<( I ~tR '€ 9ftt~9\t~nf iSiP\lit~ «~C"I<.1; 1:5~9ff\$"I~~ "l;t"<!f'1~ C~l~<.1;tiSi.
~~~S( ~~"!ll f~~ ~~ ~~tcO{l iSiP\lft~ ~~"Ie ~~c~~~~c~~ c~tc~ ~1 ~rPlC~
~~COj", I 9fOift~~ lC~Q l!i{tc~ ~~ ~~C"l~ "Qt<tt~t~ Plt.~ P1Qt~cliiT"'t~ f<lll'C~
~~ ~~ ~Caj"l '€ ~~C~~~ 'lQ<!>t~ 1ff"'~9f1!j DtC~ m~t~J ~C<.1;~c"'O{I ~~