You are on page 1of 518

5

? +fQW y

H9AwyG

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q O Z@

:H9AwyG GP$ iO$C

?T}L h= #| ~$h A9}zgyG ~%A*GO6 B+"fh r+!9ZAyG ~%y Bq"xYo #}yz


k
GO(Fh 9%zsC ($h- 9%g<GQh a9Z! Gh ~%qyGh U;L G 9%}dg| :a9YhC
IOVh #+qzAM}yG dG(sC #| uJyG ?pQg| )zf UQJyG -Q9Zf}G gP$ )p
Qd"yG )p O%GyG dP<h ,GQk +Dv >zayGh Q=ZyG )zf {|9JyG ,xyP )yE )fGOyG
Q9Zf}G gP$ {D| )p uJyG f{p O<Gh}G >z_h OFG(gyG ?sQ9q|h a9Z! G )zf
Os YO=yG f{p Of9T}yG {v s H(za}yG ~df GPEh OIGh Og< OIGh :E &pQg* 9}zs
. y9%+zf {*(gAyGh 9%+yE I9fOyG JQDvh JQDv
.| &y(SQ e;w<h )y9g@ uG e;w< H9AwyG KAApC ~C
)1 (

VVV

.))

|;S

9AwyG QGO /W( )!9}+yG Q*R(yG #<G ?|;gzy )24( uzMyG )zf uJyG Q9D*E

G H

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

v u t s r q p o n m{ :)y9g@ &zyG d9s


.}w

C B A @ ? > = < ; :G F E D
{ :)

y9g@ d9sh

.}

- , + * ) ( ' & % $ #{ :)y9g@ d9sh


;:9876543210/.
KJIHGFEDCBA@?>=<
.}
PONML

f e d c b a ` _ ^ ] \ )y9g@ 9s
srqponmlkjihg
syxwvut
{ :

d h

.}

:|

&zyG d(SQ d9sh

: &!{p gO%V hC gBQ GPE uJ< d(t* fC S9"yG ?=$Q ~vOIC #g"}* : :Cz
O}IC gGhQ y~+dg< QvP* hC uJ< d(t* fC bRQ #| Of9=* :h {FC #| HQt*
.)Qv9V O}IC N+WyG gO9pC( K+JY O9"S9<
:| d9sh
:d9s ?&Tq! 9!OIC QtJ* r+v &zyG d(SQ 9* G(y9s &Tq! ~vOIC fQtJ* :z
e(* &y {Fh Rf &zyG d(t+p ,&+p d(t* : ~C d9t| &+p &+zf &zy GQk |C iQ*
:d(t+p ,S9"yG ?+WL :d(t+p ?GPvh GPv )p d(t@ fC xg"| 9| :?|9+tyG
O}IC N+WyG gO9pC( K+JY O9"S9< &F9| #<G gGhQ y)W< fC uIC B"v i9*{p
.)Qv9V

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9s
9}| LQM* )AI d9=MyG ?iOQ uG &"wSC &+p U+y 9| #||| )p d9s #|z
.)2318( {+zjyG AGhQC )p )!9=y}G &JJYh gQ+ih OhGO (<C gGhQ yd9s
)1 (

| d h

9 y {$C IQ9Zf :d9=MyG ?iOQ


.y&+p d(t}yG #| {JAT*h &"f H(A* fC d9s 9}| &FhQLhz )\9tyG d9s
.Q " G

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

$ # "!

?+}v9Jy

#|h 9"Tq!C QhQV #| u9< P(g!h gQqjAT!h &"+gAT!h gO}J! u O}JyG fE


fC O%VCh &y iO9$ ;p {z]* #|h ,&y {]| ;p uG O9 #| ,9"y9}fC J98+S
k
uG )zY ,&y(SQh gO=f GO}J| fC O%VCh &y x*QV : gOIh uG :E &yE :
~+$GQ<G #+}*QwyG #++="yG #+y(SQyG &*(<C )zfh &=JYh &yB )zfh &+zf
k
.GQk +Dv 9}+zT@ ~zSh {v dBh #+zSQ}yGh A9+=!:G h+= )zfh {+f9}SGh

kjihgfedcba`
UTSRQPONMLKJIH
cba`_^]\[ZYXWV
tsrq ponmlkji
~}|{zyxwvu
dB[

p!@
!vuw

]102

?*6G :fGQn }fp

p!@
!v

]1

!@
!|u

x
?*6G :A9T"yG[

p!@
!|v

O}J| iO$ iO%yG Q+Lh )y9g@ uG H9Av E*OJyG bOYC f{p -:Og< 9|C
,p ?y;\ {vh ?y;\ ?fO< {vh ?fO< ?COJ| {vh 979COJ| Q(|}G QVh |
.Q9"yG
.yO9tAfC hC {}f hC d(s #| 9%+yE HQt* 9|h Q9"yG #| u9< P(g!z

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?qF9_ )zf a(s(yG raM* : {J"yGh bQqyG >Av ,p EI9=yG fE


&@9}S rzA< :h AG($}G Q+jA< Q+jA* : iQap ~+tAT| K\Gh )!9<Q H%"|
IO9*RyGh aPJyGh Q++jAzy ?z<9s >$GP}yG h+}Gp &+yE #+=TA"}yG a;AL9<
jPyG {+GyG #| ?*GQyG ~zTA* {+F {wp ?qF9ayG gP$ H%"| A9"DAS9< O*OGAyGh
fEh xyP< ~%y f(pQAg* ~$(qy9M|h .f(fOA=| : f(g=A| ~%p &t=S
.~9Oy9| d9JA!G )zf fDQG* : xyP h| #wyh AGOgyG ~$hP<9!h ~$hOTI
?qF9_ hC Ky9ZyG rzTyG Y9=@G hC ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C 9%}SG ?qF9ayG gP$h
QZf #| W9<Q ,ph Q}AT| O9%F ,p ?qF9ayG gP$ Bzch E*OJyG {$C
Q(%dyGh QZ"yG 9%y uG #}\ Osh ~%y #+Fh9"}yG h+= O\ eGQwyG ?<9JZyG
iC .?+F9"yG ?qF9ayG ,$h IQ$9dyG ?qF9ayG ,$h IQ(Z"}yG ?qF9ayG ,%p I9G"yGh
)zfh .,y9g@ uG {]q< raM}< BTzp a9Yh}G gP$ #| &< 9%AqYh rYh
fG ?qF9_ haAT@ ~y Q(ZgyG Q=f ?qF9ayG P$ 96 JQ| ,AyG #J}yG #| ~iQyG
9| ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C #| ~8C G(fOG 9}y IQf9V:G fE )AI GQkhR 9%+yE >TA"@
k
,p Ky9ZyG rzTyG H%"}y ~%Aqy9M}< G(pQAfG {< ;*(_ GhO}Z* fC G(f9aASG
rzTyG Q+=g@ {dp y~wICh ~zfG 9"=$P|h ~zSG rzTyG >$P|z ~%y(s
9!QZf A9F )AI .~$Q+i &+p ~%vQ9W*: &+yE #+=TA"}zy 9Zk y9L Ky9ZyG
BFQMp O*QqyG H%"}yG GP$ )zf d9JA!Gh (aS KOJp )>F9GgyG QZf(
9$Of9Sh ?+qzS 98C #+}zT}yG N*Q9@ ,p IQ| dh}h )fO@ ?qF9_ S9"yG )zf
9gk TA| d9G}yG U+y ahQdy cQ9=}yG ,qzTyG >$P}yG Q9WA!G xyP )zf
.989+=y
JGP

)1(

)p )y9g@ &zyG

< 9$QvPzS HF9A!h H9=SCh ?Zs &y U+=zAyGh d9JA!:Gh (aTyG GP$h )1(
. QLB QGOYE

fP z

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

10

{$} iQL}G d(Y}G ^g<h J9qZyGh A9}S}G ,p ?+qzS JQ%czp


?*Q+qw@ ?+FQ9L ?j=Y &+fO@ jPyG ,qzTyG H%"}yG Bj=Y 9%"wyh .?"TyG
,p QWA"@ 9%zgF -?=*Q|h IQ+aL- ?}+df J9!9w|E xyP )zf 9$Of9Sh
9| f9w| ,p ?J!9S UQqyG GhOFh f9p ~+W%yG ,p Q9"yG Q9WA!G H9=WyG W9ShC
?zIQ| G(V9fh ?+tAyG H(zSC G(|OMASG :Eh Gh(fQ* ~y KzT}yG LhQMzy
?+}+@ #<G e9| G d(t*- ~zgyG ,p #+MSGQyG )zf ~$A9qL #+!9c a9g]AS:G
#+I ?f9}Gzy ~%Aqy9M| JQ%c d9Ash r+S {$C G(!9v 9}y LQG(MyG xyPvhz
)193(U JG(="yG yS9"yG QDvC ~%pQg* ;p e(+yG 9|Gh S9"yG f(zAt* G(!9v
#+=* y!!,!9<Q ~y9f #| cQO uz y~zgyG ,p f(MSGQyG ~%pQg* #wyh )"g*z
~79qZ< LQG(MyG f(pQg* : S9"yG QDvC fC uJ< ,qzTyG e9| G ?+}+@ #<G
#+}zT}yG d9Aty ~7QV9=}< ~$Q|C GhQ%d* )AI ~zgyG {$C O"f ?phQg}yG
~%qYhh QAiG #| ~6 QAi9p f(+qzS ~8C G(fOGh S9"yG )zf G(T=y GPE r+wp
k
G(\9pCh #++qzS 9L(+Vh #++!9<Q A9}zf ~8(w< ~$O+G}@h ~%qYh ,p ky9<h
?t+tI #f ?zqjyG h| xT"AzyQ9%cE #| ~%]g< O"f fhQ* 9}< ~%IO| ,p
:jQF}G e9| G d9s 9}*Otp ?"TyG ?}FG )zf GP$ Bq* ~yh LQG(MyG OtAg|
k
e9| G f9v :Of e9|E )zf LQL Os )FQ9L O9%AFG iCQ #}y )j="* ;pz
v Sh ?f9= h=h LQMp GQk F9F hG
fC )j="* ;p #+}zT}yG d9As {JASGh &q+S {
,p &c9qyG #TJ< :h &|9+Y eGhO< :h I;ZyG ,p &|9+s d(a< :h &@AGQt< QAj*
.yLQG(MyG >$P| &=$P| f9v GPE ~zgyG
f(T=z* #*Os9"yG Ot!h #+"f9ayG #g_ ~%"f G(pQZ* )wy ~8G >+GgyGh
G(!9v (yh ~%+qy9M| f(}%A*h {< ~+df uAph Q+aL Q(a@ GP$h ?+qzTyG IA9=f
)1 (

uza@ fG x"| {=t* :h ~%"f hpGO* #| O: GhQ|Oh GhQGph #+}zT}yG G(z@9s (y )AIh )1(
uJzy ?<Qi izp S9"yG J("s )p A9fOyG f(tJAT* #*PyG fhO$9G}yG ~$ {< LQG(L ~%+zf
. f(gFGQ &+yE 9!Eh &zy 9!Gh QZgyG GP$ )qzS 9%W+g* )AyG gP$

11

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)!9=y:9v S9"yG Y9=9< QZgyG iOOG|h 9%A}FGh #*QY9g}yG ?+qzTyG N(+V


#f G(!9<G Os GP6 ~8C fhQO* 9|h e9wJzy ?"$GO}yGh A9FQ 9< R9< #<Gh
~zgyG ,p #+MSGQyG e97G f9p ~$QF9}\h ~$9*G(! ,p 9| GhQ%cGh ~%A8+=L
.YGOA<:G {$C HCO ?"TyG ?}FGh
S9=y 9%S9=y ($ -9$Q9aLG IQDv h|- ?fO=yG gP$ ,p 9| QaLC fE :d(sG
.,}zf OhOI ,p ?+|;S G ?|}G N*Q9@ ,p KOJ* ~y KOI ($h ?+qzTyG
9*k QgVG iQgV}Gh 9+k FQ9L )FQ9MyGh 9+k yRAg| )yRAg}yG f9v Otzp
k
)FQ9MyG hC 9+k "S ;D| ^pGQyG )}TA*h Q|}G >zt"* fC 9|C 9+k ]pGQ )]pGQyGh
&+zf uG ?}IQ -,!9=y}G &=v !- ?*QZf ?"Ap K=YC jPyG #+=}yG A;=yG (%p 9+k qzS
:E 9$Q* ~y Bz=sC GPG ?"AqyG fEz d9s #| bOYh y?*QZf ?+FQ9L 98Ez d9s 9}y
.yS9"yG {v 9$BQ JQ<OC GPEh ~y9gyG

{$C IO9gv- GQk +Dv f(qzAM* IOOgA| W9}!G 9!QZf LQG(Lh


&+zf G(tq@G 9}+p f(!h9gA* ~%pz rzTyG H%"| ?qy9M| )zf f(tqA| ~%"wyh
e9wJyG )zf LhQMyG )zf f(tqA| ~%p y&+p G(qzALG 9}+p 9]g< ~%]g< QPg*h
?*:(< aGQAf}G eOf 9qk zS GhQQs Os ~%p -GOk IC f(DAT* :h e9wJyG h+=?g+=a< H9=S}G gP$ dhCh -LhQMzy 9=k =S G(|Og* #y xyP Og< ~C e9wJyG
9| Q+j< ~wJyGz ?<9JZyG QZf LQG(L &zJA!G jPyG >=TyG Uq! f(w* d9JyG
#| ?*(Az|h ?=+Gf bQ_ QGQi}G )zf gQ*Q}@h xyP J9=CG ,p ~%yh yuG dR!C
QA< )yE Y9=:G A9fOE )yE ~zgyG {$C )zf HPwyG )yE ?yO}G b9"f: ,y
m
)zf 9"qsh fE ,AyG ?}F9tyG QLB )yE ...9%MT|h 9%MzSh 9%q*Q;h U(Z"yG
~$AG($C upG(* 9| ~zgyG {$G e;v #| f(gaAt+p ?*98 9%y aQg! ;p 9%A*GO<
v
-#_G(=y9< ~zfC uGh- GQk $9c #fPCh ~%"| xy ~zS #|h AG($}G {$C IO9gv
uG ~wI OJFhG uG dR!G 9| Q+j< ~wJyG {JASG GPE :E Qqw* : ~v9JyG fz<
-AG($}G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

12

)yE {ZA}yG O9"S:9< )1(?=_9s ~zgyG {$C O"f e(zg}yG {+ZqAyG )zf )y9g@
yQ9qv Q+i ~8C 9"}zSz QLB d(t< x+zf LQM* &< GPE | uG d(SQ ?<9JY
&+zf f(tza* 9| GP$h ?g+< 9"s9"fC ,p ~%y U+yh ?+fQV ?*:h ~%y U+y #wyh
QF9S 96 W9"@ )AyG ?+fQWyG ?|(wJyG #| g(zLh ye9| G #f f9|RyG Q(jVz
:h O;=zy )fQWyG ~v9JyG ?*:(< OAg* : ?y9JyG gP$ ,qp ?|9gyG J9*:(yG
~$h OtgyGh {JyG {$C )yE Q|}G {tA"* P8"+Ih ghQqw* ~y (yh )AI &Ag+=<
...&"++g@h e9| G dRf f(wz}* #*PyG S9"yG g(Fhh A9SDQyGh A9}zgyG
)2 (
IOIGh ?f9= h\(yG GP$ ,p ?+|;S G J9f9}GyGh ?|}G f(w@ fC )j="*h
J9f9}GyG fCh ~$O(t* #| )zf ~%"+< 9}+p f(tqA*h OtgyGh {JyG {$C 9%SGQ*
9| h=ay9< e(zg|h y{D|}G {JyG )yE d(Y(zy )aSh ?zIQ| f(w@ fC )j="*
.A9|OyG ?sGQE ~C ...A9|OyG ?sGQE ~C A9|OyG ?sGQE -:{D|}G {JyG ($
HQ9: {tI ?|}G BzgF J9f9}G< ?|}G B+zA<G Otyz d9s #| bOYh
rAyG GPE )AI IQATA| ?q+g\ CO=@ ,%p e;S G ~S9< ?azTyG )yE d(Y(zy
Q++jAy Q(%A< BgS S9}JyGh ?q_9gyG &s(T@ hpO"}yG H9=WyG #| OOf 9%y(I
LQ< fC E=z@ 9| ~C O9%GyGh ?+z$9GyGh ?+}v9Jzy 9%}%p :9%I;S h}AG}yG
O*Q_h {+As #+< H9=WyG #| GOkGOfC 9$AGQh ?qzM| MGQGy9< ?"MD| ?vQg}yG #|
o
GPw$h ~+d"AyG IO9s 96 M(z* JGQ9gVh e;IC {+=S ,p xyP {v Q+SCh
gP$h QLB )yE ~zT| Oz< #| ?+CQ9wyG ?<QGAyG {tA"@h I9Sz}yG Q}AT@ x+yGhO
~%zgF jPyG h=A}yG i(%yGh )fQWyG &tqyG ,p hsO}yG QtqyG 9%==S ?y9JyG
Q+qwAyG Qwpz Qd!G y9%%Fh #f ?J+JZyG 9%+!9g|h ?+fQWyG U(Z"yG f(pQJ*
.y)}+JTyG /O
k

{Gg@ ;p ;Zq| )y9g@ &zyG fPz< &!9+< x+@z+Sh )1(


~%]g< A9"Ch -?<Qj|h ?sQW|- ?sQqA| ~79f9= B!9v fEh )AI ~%s9q@G xy QTq* GP$h )2(
. ~%"+< J9p;MyG B!9v 9}%| ^g< )zf
.

13

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

&+zf ~$ 9}f G(gFQ* #y A:|$ f9p ?g*QWy9< ~wJ* ~v9I OFh (y )AIh
&vQAy &!hQqw* IQ9Ap d9< )zf xy Qa< : J9i(T}< &+zf f(FQM+S {<
IOJA}yG ~|:G #+!G(s ,p cGQAV;y IQ9@h Q9qwzy I:G(}y9< IQ9@h O9%GyG ?]*Qp
?}F9tyG NyG ..?"*9%ZyG ?yhO< &pGQAf9< IQ9@h ?+="F}G JG(tzy &A!9fz< IQ9@h
.,%A"@ #y ,AyG
9fk 9=@G ~%+zf LhQMyGh e9wJyG Q+qw@ 9qk zS GhQQs ~8E ~w@GQ]Jy {sC ~yC
S9=gyG )"< hG ?+|C )"< e9wI Eg< (yh )AI #+t<9TyG LQG(MyG #| ~%qzTy
#< hQ}fh ?*h9g| ~$ 9"|9wI f9v (y {<- IQY9g}yG ?+|;S G ?|}G ~wJy
)!Oz< ~%+zf f(FQM+S {s}G )zf hC -~8hQqw+S 9}%"f uG )\Q U9gyG
k
.>+jy9< 9=Q U+y GP$h J9%=WyG
e;S G ~+y9g@ )zf LhQMyGh b9q"y9< ~%}%A* {s}G )zf hC ~$Qqw* ~yC
h+}Gy K*QGAyGh MQGyG ?*GQ {|9Ih ~$Q9wpG >ash dh}G ~$Qd"| &IhQh
#< f9}Df fC Q=AfG {< .QZgyG GP$ ,p ~%+|(wJ|h ~%|9wI e;S G {$G
~yh ?+|;S G ?p;MyG ,p I(Gp &Ap;L Q=AfG- 9|k (zd| {As jPyG
f9qf
k
g(zAsh &+zf G(FQL #*PyG {gF {< .Y9= Gh ["yG xyP< 9qy9M| 96 OAg*
k
.IO+VQyG &AS9+S #| e;S G MhQ )yE HQsG 9}zc
k
-?azTyG )yE d(Y(zy- 9qzS e9wJyG Q+qw@ GhQQsh LhQMyG GhQQs A:|%p
&+yE 9!Eh u 9!Eh ~%FhQLh ~%}wJy J9+D+I #f f(DJ=* xyP Og< G(J=YGh
.f(gFGQ
?+$GQwy ~%y;jASG 9%}$G IOf {|G(f ~$Q9wpC Q9WA!G )zf ~$Of9T*h
Pq"@ P8"+Jp IQC}G JQWASGh ~zdyG hsh fE xy9< 9}p ~%|9wJy ?*QaqyG S9"yG
f9qf #< f9}Df OVGQyG ?q+zMyG )zf LhQMzy >y|}yG z=S #< uG O=f ?S9+S
Q|}G GhQ%cGh ~wFGQ|C )zf #gayG ,p GhAO<Gz &f9=@: d(t* f9v Otp
yQ|}G GP$ )yE ~$(fOGh S9"yG G(z+}AT@ Qw"}yG #f ,%"yGh ahQg}y9<

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

14

~%z%Fh ~%"c #TIh ~%A=+ay e;wyG GP6h Q$9d}yG gP6 f(fOM"* ?|9gyGh
v
.9$(=w@QG U9g}y :E ~%|9wI ~%+zf bzS 9| uG fC
k
v
L9GJyG )zf (fO* ;FQ h}S &!Gz iQZ=yG #TJyG #f )!GQ=ayG ihQ
a9M! 9}!E ~A+@C ~wTq!C #| ~w!E {gq@ : &y d9tp )?L9GJyG 9| cGQOC 9|h(
fC ihQ Otp Q*R9"MyGh IOQtyG ~w+zf )y(A* fG J9| hC L9GJyG dRf fE
)y9g@ &y(s #| P(Lz| GP$h y~w+zf )y(* G(!(w@ 9}vh ~wy9}f ~wy9}fC
p@
! ! xu

& % $ # " ! ~ } | {o
.

]30

)('&%

?*6G :iQ(WyG[

#f X}f}G ByzSz d9s O(S}G )<C #< Q(Z"| #f N+WyG (<C LQLCh
~%Ag}S 9|
? *6 9 g !} p
o )y9g@ &y(s
o
>Avh y~$QGQV ~%+zf Q|C S9"yG OTp GPE :f(y(t* ~%Ag}S d9s ?&+p f(y(t*
rS(* #< O}J| &+yE >Awp d9}gyG Q(F &+yE (wW* rS(* #< O}J}y NlC
Qw"* fG )Y9g}yG {}g* #}y )j="* U+yh &+p ~A!C 9| QvP@h x<9Av )"jz<
.ye;TyGh H(!PyG e(V #| :E &+p ~A!C 9| QC ~yh ?<(tgyG
)y9g@ uG gOGQC Qm |}- &}zd< ?|}G )zf rS(* #< L9GJyG bzS Otyh
#TJyG iCQ 9}zp -#AqyG gP$ h| rzTyG {|9gA* r+v aQg! )wyh ?|~y
k
IOf9tyG gP6 :OAT| ~%y KZ! xyP >=T< &A*:h #| S9"yG Q|P@ iQZ=yG
x@ ~y uG #| ?<(tf L9GJyG fEz ~%y d9tp y~w+zf )y(* G(!(w@ 9}vz ?+qzTyG
G(<(@h ?!9wASGh YQ]@h ?<(A< 9$(z=tASG #wyh r+Ty9< uG ?<(tf G(z=tAT@ ;p
VQJ* gBQ #}y xyP d9s &!G #TJyG #f K+JY O9"S9< xyP B=Ch yg(qw@
.rzTyG O"f LhQMyG #f ,%"y9< IOf9tyG gP$ W9=@QG {|zAp LhQMyG )zf
f9vhz Q+TyG ,p )=$PyG &"f d9s jPyG L9GJyG #f #TJyG &y(t* e;wyG GP$h
k
k
k
k
k
G(ZICh rzTyG ^g< gQqv {< y...A9|Ozy 9v9qS 9D+=L 9+=Y9! GQ9=F 9|(zc
k
,p ~+tyG #<G e9| G d9sh ,;+As ryC #*QWfh ryC ?F9| kz=p GQk =Y {As 9|
]129

G :e

G[

15

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9=gyG c(z| {gF fC ,p )y9g@ &A}wI {|z@hz :)253/1( IO9gTyG QGO M9Aq|
Q(Y ,p JQ%c ~%y9}fC fzv {< ~%y9}fC U"F #| ~7:hh ~$AGQ|Ch
fEh ~%+zf ByOf G(yOf fGh ~%v(z| B|9tASG G(|9tASG f9p ~%v(z|h ~7:h
xyPv ~7:(p ?g*OMyGh Qw}yG &+p Q%c fGh ~7:hh ~%v(z| JQ9F GhQ9F
~$O"f ~%y9| ~7:hh ~%v(z| Bg"| 96 G(zM<h ~9Oy uG b(tI G(g"| fEh
,p &!(tJAT* : 9| &!(qg]AT* #}| GhPLG fEh ~%+=y 96 G(zG< uJyG #|
S(w}yG ~%+zf B<Q\h &!(tJAT* : 9| c(z}yG ~%"| JPLC ~%Az|9g|
I(ty9< ~%"| c(z}yG &FQMAT* r+g]yG #| &!(FQMAT* 9| {vh rF9c(yGh
)zf )y(* fC ?+%y G ?}wJyG ,p U+yh ~%y9}fC Q(Y ,p JQ%c ~%y9}gp
fhQtyG Q9+L dh}G QOZyG f9v 9}yh ~%T"F #| f(w* #| :E Q9GqyG QGQV}G
)<z@ uG ?}wJp I:(yG ~%y B<9V G(<9V 9}zp xyPv ~7:h B!9v 9$Q<Ch
k
#f ;]p R*RgyG O=f #< Q}fh ?*h9g| {D| f9|R}G gP$ {D| ,p 9"+zf )y(* fC
l
#| {vh ~$QOs )zf 9"z=s #| I:hh 9!QOs )zf 9"@:h {< Q}fh Qw< )<C {D|
o
o
H9=yG GP$ ,p gQwq< Qp9S GPE ?"ap &y #|h 9$9]At|h ?}wJyG >F(| #*Q|}G
uzMyG ,p 9}v &+p ?"_9<h IQ$9c QOtyGh A9]tyG ,p IQF9S ?+%y}G ?}wJyG iCQ
#f Qm9f gQGOsCh &A+]sG #| 98k +V fC OS9qyG x"d< #d@ fC c9*{p AG(S Q|}Gh
?}wJyG g(Fh ~@C )zf ?gsGh gQGOsCh )y9g@ &A+]sG h+= {< ?jy9=yG ?}wJyG
fC 9}v 9%vGQOE #f 9%qg]< ?<(GJ| ?q+g]yG d(tgyG #wyh HG(ZyGh
a9g]yG d(tgyG gP$h U}WyG A(\ #f 9%qg]< ?<(GJ| ?+V9qMyG Q9Z<}G
GPE T9qMyG fG 9}v By9sh Bta!h By9Yh &+p By9F {_9=yG 9%pO9Y GPE
Q9Sh Q9_ {+zyG e;c &pO9Y
O

)1 (

~ z d | {v +v zv yG #v | hv av s 9v %v |R:h

.y v v v

&vvF(vv]vv< Q9vv%vv"vvyG 9vv$9vvWvvfC Xvv+vvp9vvqvvL

&+zf LhQMy9< ~zT}yG f9azTyG ~zc Hy9g*o fC #+=yG bzjyG #| f9v xyPyh
. S(

|9tyG )p 9}v ?g*OMyG )zf uza*h bzMyG ($h H(WyG #|

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

16

Q|C GP{p ?+Zg}< Q|z* ~y 9| &Af9a< JA9F fC ?jy9=yG ?g*QWyG ?}wI #| f9v {<
&Tq! ,p f9v (yh {< &+zf LhQMyG YQW* ~y 9}v 9%+p &Af9_ YQW@ ~y ?+Zg}<
f(w*z d9s | uG d(SQ fC
?q*PI #f ~zT| ihQ Q(GqyG {$C #|
~6(zs d9FQ ~%+p e(t+Sh )A"T< f("AT* :h iGO6 fhOA9 : ?}FC iOg<
fE !&zyG d(SQ 9* h"YG r+v Bzs d9s U!E f9}DF ,p #+_9+WyG H(zs
xy9| PLCh cQ%c HQ\ fGh Q+|;y h+a@h h}T@ :d9s ?xyP BvQOC
yh_Ch h}S9p
:C ?+qzTyG )yE H9TA!:G ,p bO9ZyG ,qzTyG 99C x+zf uG uJ< )y {tp
:h iGO6 fhOA9 :z | &y(s 9!QZf e9wI )zf b9=a!:G e9}@ u=a"*
iOA9 : jPyG Q+|}G GP%y h+a!h h}T! fz< 9!Q|zp xyP h|h y,A"T< f("AT*
&y(s f9v fGh yxy9| PLCh cQ%c HQ\ fGh &A"T< #AT* :h ,="yG iO6
f9}DF ,p #+_9+WyG H(zs ~6(zs d9FQ ~%+p e(t+Shz ~zSh &+zf uG )zY
k
k
e;v &!: &+p xV: h\Gh ($h GOF )"g}yG K]@G AGQ|~y 9qYh yU!E
.~zwyG h|G(F )@hC jPyG K+ZqyG #+=}yG
k
(%p KFGQyG ($h ~%y #+Fh9"| ~%+p f(|(t+S d9FQy 9qYh f9v fGh
~%A"f #*PyG ~$h ?y9SQyG gP$ ,p ~%Ag"! #*PyG LQG(MyG ?f(}G}y rYh
~"%F HG(<C )zf I9fOz y9"A"Tyz< f(}zwA*h 9"@OzF )"< #|z iQL}G ?*GhQyG
.y9%+p g(pPs 9%+yG ~69FC #|
k
GOQ ?+FQ9MyG Q9wp}G )zf OQyG H9AwyG GP$ LGQLE #| aO%yG U+y
f(MSGQyG 9!D9}zf 9!9qv Otp -O9%GyG {]pC #| GP$ f9v fEh- GQk V9=|
e;v ~%|;v Og< U+yh #+}+DgyG #<G e9| Gh R9< #<G e9| Gh )!9=y:G e9| 9v
g(t"Ag| K=YCh QIO!Gh A:|$ OhOQ< )FQ9MyG QwqyG bQV xyPyh QvP*

)1(

. y

~w+zf )y(* G(!(w@ 9}vz ?y9SQ hFGQ

)1(

17

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

PLzp ~7|S GhQAT* fC f(yh9J* gQ9%cz< f(JG=A* G(!9v #*PyG


.fhQhGO*h
~%zp ~7GOtAg| ,p A:|$ Xs9"* fG H9AwyG GP$ VQi #| U+y- QQvGh
,p 9$QCGh &A+!h &y9gpCh &yG(sCh gO9tAfG #f Q|G {v {F9S uGh( fhOtAg* 9|
H9AwyG LGQLE >=S #wyh )Q+L hC QV #| &y hC &+zf >z: 9|h J9g}AG}yG
rzTyG H%"| G("+< 9}"+Jp- Q<9v}G A:|$ OhOQ< uzgA* >+Gf Q|C ($
#| e;f}G )zf Q%VG BJ=YGh f9=vQyG ~9h9Aq< Q9Tp S9"zy g(J\hCh
.f9pQgyG {$C ~%y 9$O}Ih fGQ+"yG
#| ~%"}p #+za=}yG IO9gv G(}Tt!G ~8G :E #+qy9M}yG A:|$ #| f9v 9|
h+}GyG e9|C G(atS GP6h A9FQ:9<h ?"$GO}y9< ?"TyG ?}FG ~7Gh &Tq! K]p
?f(}G| BT*9w@h GOk *OF 9w+Aw@ QdA"@ iQLC ?qF9_ BAwSh- G(qWw!Gh
fC ?|(fR}yG ?+qzTyG 9%A=T! )zf B+WL 9}zp -?C;DyG ,$OC B!9wp ~%"|
Os ~$9$h G(pQf 96 ,AyG ?Ap;yG gP6 :E X+f ~%y Q}AT* #y ~$h K]Aq@
:E fhQOZ* :h ~%+yE ~%A=T! f(fO* G(!9v #*PyG QZgyG ?}FG O* )zf G(yPL
dOg* g(=TI 9| )yE ~+tTyG ~$Q+wq@ ~$GO$ Q+=wyGh Q+jZyG ,p ~9CQ #f
:G(y9tp ?qwyG
,p iQ9}! : #J! -)?C;DyG N(+WyG )"g*(- ?"TyG ?}FG ~$ A:|$ ~g!
~$Qqv Otp e9wJyG GhQqw* ~y fEh ~$h ?+p;L ?yzT}yG gP$ #wyh xyP
?"TyG Q9Z!G N(+V ~$h ?+qzTzy ~%A=T!h ?+}zgyG ~%AFQO ,p ~$ #}| ~$Q+i
bGRQyG O=f N+WyG - Qv9V O}IC N+WyG - )tqyG O|9I N+WyG(- ?*O}J}yG
N+WyGh u=S}G ?*O(gTyG )Aq| ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+WyG xyPvh ),q+qf
fhQh "* Gh

)1 (

uT! ~%+zf LhQMyG eOfh e9wJyG h| {|9gAyG )p ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C H%"| fC >+GgyGh )1(
)zf G(tq@G ?8FQ|h -QQvGh- ?8FQ|h ?yRAg|h LQG(L #| ~%y #+qy9M}yG fCh gOIh
. )y(s bOY )zf rtAy iQgV;y J:9t}yG hFGQh e9wJyG )zf LhQMyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

18

y t@ fC f(g+aAT@ {%p LQG(L 9"!z< 9"!(}%A@ :G(y9s ~C )a+t"WyG #+|}G


)tqyG O|9I N+WyG )zf G(y(tp LQG(L #J! 9"v GPE- LQG(L ~8E A:|$ )zf
gP6 ~8C G("ch LQG(L ~8E ,q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+WyGh Qv9V O}IC N+WyGh
k
.d9t* 9}v SCQ< 9SCQ G(FQL Os ?z+JyG
yu9< :E I(s :h d(I :z d(t! fG :E Q+wqAyG GP$ e9|C #J! xz}! :h
uJzy f9fP:G eOfh iCQzy >ZgAyGh i(%yG {gq* r+v IO9TyG 99C ~A*CQC
H%"| Y9=@G ~89< ?]*QgyG ~9h9fO< 9"!GPB Gh~| #*PyG A:|%p .&<9JYz<
N+WyGh -d9s R9< #<G N+WyGh -d9s )!9=y:G N+WyGh- rzTyG A9}zfh rzTyG
k
.?~8hQvPA* )A| ?"TyG Q9Z!C N(+V GO<C fhQvP* :h -d9s #+}+Df #<G
f9v ~%J]q@h {< ~%yP< #++!9<QyG N(+WyG ih9Ap fhOG* 9}"+I
k
xyP #| :O< ~%"wyh- ~%qs(| G(gFGQ* fC ~6 uF;yGh ~%+zf VhQq}yG
f(w* fC #| O< :h -{*O=yG #f EJ=yG ,$h :C iQLC ?t*Q_ )yE GhzGy
#| d9< jP A,V )zf G(gsh 9}<Qp ~%yG(sC ,p G(WAq+zp -9+k qzS {*O=yG xyP
OFh f{p &FhC d9}I &<9WA| e;v c9"$ f9v 9}<Qp :Eh &< G(tzgA* fC #w}}yG
k
k
GQhRh 9<Pv ih9AqyG K<O@ fC #w}}yG #}p :Eh )?F9I ~$9pOI( B}g!h 9%=p
{$h G(@9|Os G(T+yC xyP #| h!9}yG 9|h &+yE ?k <(T"| QW"@h 9%=I9Y )zf
uh f9v 9| f9wp &J]q*h &+zf HPv #| >S9J+y gQ=s #| B+| LQM+S
.Og< #|h {=s #| Q|}G
A:|$ #f Y9pOzy H9AwyG GP$ -&|Qvh uG d(J<- LQL Otp 9"$ #|h
AGQApG :h #+TyO}yG U+yO@ ~%Tq!C #f G(gpO* fC f(g+aAT* : #*PyG A9}zgyG
?"TyG Q9Z!G ?f9}Gy #+=TA"}yG #J!( 9"Tq!C #f hpO"y xyPvh #+<P9wyG
:h ~7P|;@h N(+WyG A:|$ )zf e;S G e(zf 9"+tz@ #*PyGh ?*O}J}yG
k
A:|$ VGQfC #f Y9pOyG ,p b*QqAyGh b(tgyG IQg| )~$G(S 9L(+V 9"y aQg!
fCh #++zf )zfC ,p G(!(w* fC uG dzT! G(|Os 9| )yE G(]pC #*PyG A9}zgyG
G( (

19

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Aq| :h #+yO=| Q+i ~6 9"tJz*o


?gY9! ?+t! Q<9v}G A9}zgyG A:|$ ?JqY Q%d! fG H9AwyG GP$ ,p 9"\Qjp
Otzp u*hR@ :h Q*hR@ :h U+yO@ 9%+p U+y 9%At+tI )zf ,$ 9}v V9+=yG
k
k
:h xyPv ~%=TJ!- 9vk (zSh 9tk zLh :(sh ;}fh GOk9tAfG #++!9<Q A9}zf G(!9v
?"Ap I9fO G(!(w* ~zp ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C d(YC )zf G(!9vh uG )zf ~%+vR!
fhQ%d* #+%F(< G(!(w* ~yh Q(|}G I:hh J9g}AG}zy Q+qw@ :h u*Qq@ :h
k
k
:G(sC ?tzj}yG aQjyG ,ph- :G(sC #zgyG ,p f(y(t+p -f("a=* 9| a;L
,p ?]*QgyG Q+$9}GyG 97CQs IQ9+TyG rJZyG ,p ~7:9t| ,$ 9%p .jQLC
aGQAf:Gh e9wJzy ?+"zgyG J9g*9=}yG 9%+ph 9+!OyG O;< QF9Sh R9GJyGh QZ|
Q+j< f(}wJ* ~8z< ~%}zf h| J9=S9"}yG ,p ~%y ?8"%AyGh ?+fQWyG ~%A*:(<
: G(!9vh yB+iG(ayG e9wJyGz ~A!G f(y(t@ 9}v ~%"f f(y(t* :h uG dR!C 9|
xyP {vh J9=S9"}yG h+= ,p e9wJzy f(fO*h :E UQqyG #| ?YQp f(vQA*
#| 98k +V ~zgyG {$C #| OIC ~%+zf Qw"* ~yh 9+!OyG A9}zf QZ<h h}S B; ~A*
^g< )zf A9}zgyG ^g< 9$PLz* f9v ,AyG PL5}yGh JGO9tA!:G IQDv h| xyP
?"$GO}y9< :h ?y9}gy9< OIC ~%}%A* ~yh f9|R}G {v ,p A9}zgyG IO9f ,$ 9}v
.9$Q9}C B@B Os ~%|9*C #w@ ~y ?*QhQJyG ?+FQ9MyG >SGhQyG PE e9wJzy
AGP*5y &Tq! VQfh )y9g@ u &Tq! Y9< #|- e97G )zf OIC DQG* r+vh
G(T+yC e9wJzy ?"$GO}y9< -IOOgA| JGQ| {< IOIGh IQ| U+y {Atzyh {<
#| IOOgA| YG(!C QG< ?z+qv B!9v ~%|9*C I(fOyG gP$h O+I(AyG I(fO H9JYC
kz< )AI >Y9"}yG H9JYC #| ~%g*9W* #}|h ?fO=yG N(+V #| JGhGOgyG
^g=< hpO* fG #*O<9g< )wz}yG QZtyG ,qc(| Q9=v ^g< dh9I fz< Q|}G
JGQ| IOf IQ9GJy9< aPs Otyh
)tqyG O|9I N+WyG {Aty #+*Q(Fz}yG
#g_h IQ| #| QDvC d9+Ai;y VQg@h AG($}Gh YO=yG Q9Z!C ^g< #| HQ\h
.&A"|h &z]q< g9G!C uG #wyh &A=sQ ,p #+wTy9<
.#+!(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

20

9%vQ; B!9v ,AyG Q+$9}GyG >]i fC {s9f {v O"f e(zg}yG #| {<


#| f{p e9wJyG >]i #| A:|$ )zf GQkQ\ OVG f(w@ B!9v ?fO=yG N(+V
k
k
f(_Qq*h 9}+df ;a< S9"yG gOg* {_9=< hC uJ< e9wJyG #| ~v9I e9|C rt*
{$C IGO9g|h | d(SQyG ?+$GQw< 9}%A| rt* #| 9|G &+zf A9"DyGh &IO| ,p
h+= #| ?"gzyGh AGQGOR~y {AtyGh AGP*}G h| &\Qg@ ?}7 ,%p A9+yh}Gh B+=yG
#g"}* : :Cz | uG d(SQ d(s )yE 9!A9}zf Qd! &zv xyP e9|Ch S9"yG
:h {FC #| HQt* : &!9p gO%V hC gBQ GPE uJ< d(t* fC S9"yG ?=$Q ~vOIC
. y~+dg< QvP* hC uJ< d(t* fG bRQ #| Of9=*
m
bMSG #|h S9"yG )yE uG &zvh uG bMT< S9"yG )\QC #|z :| &y(sh
. yS9"yG ?!|| uG g9qv uG 9\Q< S9"yG
k
QGRGyG #<G 96 H9FC 9@9+<G ~wy QvPC ?|Ot}yG gP$ ~ALG fC {=sh
^g< #| g9*9fQ ^g< &+yE )wW@ Osh O($ #< #+gAT}yG #f )aTsQTyG
-:&y9}f
)1 (

)2(

~vv v vwv v v y9v v v gvv vv pC A(v v v S #v v v f ~vv v vv Ao v v v }v v v !h


~vvvvvvvwvvvvvvvy9vvvvvvv}vvvvvvvfzvvvvvvv< :E ~vvvvvvvwvvvvvvvy9vvvvvvv}vvvvvvvf
y~ vv vw vv vy9 vv v< ) vv vz vv vf dO vv vg vv vyG Q vv va vv vM vv v* ~ vv vy

~v vv v vwv vv v vy9vv vv v } vvv v vgvv v vv vy Qn(r v vvv v Gn vv v vv vyG ~vv v vv vAvv v vv v=vv vvv vTv vvv v !
9 vvv v}v vv vp ~v vv v%vv v +v vv vyE Q(vv vG vv v yG G(vv v= vvv vTvv v "v vv v@ :
?vvvvvvvvf9vvvvvvvvS ~vvvvvvvvAvvvvvvvvwvvvvvvvvzvvvvvvvv| (vvvvvvvvy u9vvvvvvvv@

9fOyG A:|$ fPC ,p IQ+LC ?T}$h


k
l
-#*QLB S9!C )yE ~wyG(sC GhRg@ fG -GO<C OIC ~wfR9"* #yh- ~wy
~w+zf VQAg* #yh -9}%y fGO #|h >as O}J| &+LGh >as O+S >@9wy9v
~8(=; ~A!Ch u+yC ~%+yE ~wG%"| hRfh uZyC ~6 ~w@GO9tAf9p- 9sk ;_G Ol IC
: GP9}zp ~%=s9"| QvP<h ~%"f Y9pOy9<h ~%=J< )y9g@ uG )yE f(<QtA@h
:I

. 168

~sQ )!9=y~y ?J+JZyG ?TzTyG Qd!Gh ~$Q+ih &F9| #<Gh iP|QAyGh O}IC gGhQ )1(
. 5886 Q+jZyG h|9GyG K+JY )2(

21

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9|G GOk <G Ol IC ~wfRq* #yh OIC ~wfR9"* #zp GP$ ~Azgp fE -~%+zf fhQZAt@
9"y G(fO ~wy d(t!h I(t< ~w$(Fh ,p NQZ"Tp ..9"L(+V 9|G -9"L(+V
k
#}y d(t!h ?8FQ| hC LQG(L hC Q+qw@ ?}FC GO<C G(!(w* #y ~%p 9"L(+V
.
?*6 Qt=y pq p o n m lo 9"qy9M*
]111

G :I

n n n

G[

O+TyG
KGQAyG

dO9f /&=Avh

u+tJ@

e9gyG

IQGOE

RvQ}yG

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!G ?f9}Gy


www.adelelsayd.com :

)!hQAwy

h s ( } yG

{ + }*

mohhoss@adelelsayd.comm :

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

22

"

? O}J}yG ? TyG

Q 9Z C

?f9}G< r QgAyG

QgA@ fCh O<: H9AwyG GP$ ,p xy gQvPzS 9}| ?"+< )zf f(w@ )wy
CO<Ch 9%L(+V dG(sC #| 97zW!h 9%y9FQh 9%G%"|h 9%pGO$Ch ?f9}GyG )zf
:?f9}GyG IzW! #f e;wy9<
. ,@z* 9|
)\9tyG )zf O}J| N+WyG >Av *
,p f9JA|:G B*OC fC Og< IQ$9ty9< JQ]I 1926 ?"S ?+!(* r+Y ,p
&!9J=S uG OGQC hC ahQdyG )"@O9tp ,fG(SC ,p ?+FGOA<:G ?SGQOyG IO9%V
- IO+tgyG OS9ph {%GyG J9}zc #| )"FQM* fC OGQCh ,?*GO%yG )y )y9g@h
)g| fGQLBh 9!C 9"+=p -9%"| )!Pt"*h xyP {v #| )"FQM* fC )y9g@ uG OGQC
#*P$ Bg}S ,?g= e(* f9vh ?|9gyG ,$9t}yG #| ,%t| ,p S(zF
)Tq! )zf BgFQp I;ZyG 9*O|+y OGT}yG )yE f9=$GP 9}8E f:(t* #+t*OZyG
Og< I;ZyG cQ@ )zf xz}I jPyG 9| )Tq! 9* xJ*h :9%y Bzsh ,?}F;y9<
{LOC : 9@k (s(| 99ODC ,HGQWyGh e9gayG )zf xYQI 9%+zf ?Z*QI B"v fC
#+Zf} :Bzsh I;ZyG )zf ?+"yG JOtf ~C #|h ?QL6G Bs(yG ,p Bs(yG
B+=yG )yE >$PC )AI )!GQdA!G :#*P$ ,vt*OZy Bzsh ,#+gzyG f9a+WyG
,;gp xyP Bzgqp ,jQLz< ,vzf ,AyG )T<;| dO=ASCh ,?g}Gzy {TAiCh
i(s ,f9TzyG uz_ e9|{< GP{p ,UvQV h|9F ($h OGT| HQsC )yE 9"=$Ph
k
,OF9T}yG A9=aL ,p {=s #| gO%fC ~y 9|;v d(t* ,Y;_:G hSGh ,?GJyG
,H9Gf G OF &< B=Gfzp ,&+p QtAT*h >ztyG )yE Pq"* ~%TyG &|;v fzwp
,qp .ShQOyG #| SQO :h ,JG(zZyG #| I;Y #f xyP Og< hat!C ~yh
f(COJA*h ,A9WgyG I;Y Og< OGT}yG e9|C f(qt* ~%]g< B*CQ IO}yG gP$
: E+I )yE 9gk += f(pQZ"* ~C ,9+k z| f(COJA* G(!9wp ,?+g= A9W!E Q|C ,p
a

)1(

)!9DyG OOgyG ,fhQWgyGh ?+!9DyG ?"TyG yO+I(AyG ?zG|z

)1(

23

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Og< 9}+p B}zfh ,~6 iO%f HQty h=ay9< ~%g| >$PC #vC ~yh ,jQOC
~S9s )zf N}G I(%s ,$h f9AT=yG YQ9V ,p I(%s )yE f(=$P* G(!9v ~8C
{$C O9tA!9p .?"TyG >Av #| H9Av ,p fG(L}G OIC 9%+p ~%y CQt*h ,?+y9JyG
GQk +Dv ~%+zf OT* &!} ,uJyG Q9WA!G #| ?q+L f(TF(A* G(!9v #*PyG u*QayG
,p fhQwq* fG(L G ;gF fGQ|}G fGP$ ,I(%tyG A9\(\h ~%sRQ HG(<C #|
{v 9%+p f(g}AG* ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= QGO 9%+zf uza* QGO A9W!E
,~%"+< 9}+p 98(SQGOA*h ?"TyG >Av 9%+p fhCQt*h ,A9WgyG I;Y Og< ?z+y
Og< G(aL ~C ,{|9WyG QhQTy9< fG(L G #| Bz<(s ?=+_ IQwp gP$ B!9wp
fG(L G {v MQqp 1926 ?"S Q=}T*O ,p QGOyG B8W!Ch ,jQLC I(aL xyP
#|h ,A9W* #| QZ"* jPyG uG #| GQk Z! 9$hQ=AfGh ,9}k +df 9Ik Qp xyP<
{}g@ ,$h e(+yG xyP #| ?f9}GyG JQ}ASGh ,dP| #| &y U+zp uG gQZ"*
k
Sz< : GOOf 99O* )zf )y9g@ uG iO$ )AI ,S9"zy 9%"++=@h ?"TyG QW"y OG<
?f9}GyG ByGR 9|h Og< 9}+p Q9Z!}G IQ+L #| G(J=YC ,fG(L G #| &<
)yE U+FQyG P9AS}G ?z+]p Qp9S )AI ,Y9T@:Gh eOtAyG ,p 9}k FGO ,$h xyPv
k
,xyP #| G(J! hC JG("S K;C 9%+p Ew}* fC uG )]sh ,R9GJyG O;<
fG(L G eRI #wyh ,O(vQyG #| A,V IQAqyG gP$ ,p ?f9}GyG iQAfGh
~%zgF ?"GyG ~%y fz< ~%Tq!Ch ~%yG(|C #+"||}yG #| iQAVG uG fC ~$O9tAfGh
.?Y9ZL ~6 f9v (yh ~%Tq!C )zf ?"TyG {+=S ,p fhQC|*
P9AS}G ?z+]p O9f fC )yE ,?"w|C ?C;C )yE 9%y;L ?f9}GyG BztA!9p
&@9+I {v B!9v fEh ,fG(L G h| O9%GyG )yE O9gp ,R9GJyG #| U+FQyG
9%y B!(vh ,?f9}Gzy 9!k (!9s xyP Og< h\h ~C .?"TyG QW! {+=S ,p GOk9%F
xyP< BgT@9p ,9$Q+ih ,IO*OGyG QZ|h IR+GyGh ?=tyG :9%"| IO*Of YhQp
#| #+z+zs GQk q! G(!9v fC Og< ry}G hOg* fG(L G OOf PLCh ,I(fOyG ?gsQ
.{=s

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

24

,p ~$h .~%=J! G(]s fG(L G #| Qq! QvP )"@(q* : GP$ QvPG #+Ih
P9AS}G A:|$z SCQ )zgp ,aQ9Y 9%"f ~%pQZ* : fhO$9G| ?"TyG {+=S
)|;S G ~y9gyG ,p ?"TyG f9vQC #| 9"k vQ uJ< f9v jPyG 9\Q O+VQ O+TyG
dh}G {]qyG &y f9v jPyG Q(Z"| O(}J| N+WyGh ,?Y9L QZ| ,ph ,?|9f
,p G(vQAVG #*PyG fG(L G #| QvPC ~C ,?*QO"wS G ?"*O| ,p ?"TyG QW! ,p
O}IC #TIh ,Q+MyG M9=Y f9}Dfh ,r*QV Ky9Y O}J| :?f9}GyG U+Sz@
9gk += )y9g@ uG ~%}IQp ,O+}JyG O=f {]p iR9GIh ,),<hQs(v< Q(%W}yG
k
{gFh ,~%z$C #| GQk +L ;$Ch ,~$QGO #| GQk +L GQkGO ~%yO<Ch ,?gSGh ?}IQ
o .~$G(D|h ~$QtAT| ?"GyG

zyxwvutsr
.

]23

?*6G :HGRn I}G[

p!@
!wx

%$#"!~}|{
VVV

25

? +fQW y

%@O+tfh

,tqyG

?f9}GyG

O|9I O}J|

/N

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

aG O C

+WyG

?z ]p

:9%@O+tfh

?f9}GyG

aGO$C

QWyG S9FQC h+= #| Q%a}yG [y9MyG O+I(AyG )yE S9"yG I(fO -1


k
&Af9_ ,p {D}A* ,9sO9Y 9Jk +JY 9=k I )y9g@ uG >I )yEh ,&=FG(Vh &!GQOCh
&ApQg| ~%+zf >G* 9| dhC )yE ~$O9VQEh ,&+8h gQ|C O"f a(s(yGh ,gG(t@h
&y x*QV : gOIh ghO=g* fz< {Fh Rf ~6Q )yE ~$QGQp ($ :#*OyG GP$ #|
c

` _ ^ ] \ [ Z Y R X W V U ST S R Q
cba
{

.[51-50

9* P y G ] }

:J QG

&zv fBQtyGh .?=F9V {v #| &y ~7O9=f GhOQG+y ~6Q G(pQg* fz< xyPh
e(* 9%zg:h ,d9}f}G b=; ,AyG >FG(WyG gP%y MQV -gQRG|@ &g| ?"TyGh
k j i h g f e d c b a ` _o GQ(D"| A9=$ ?|9+tyG
-

]48

?*6G

:A

x
9T"yG[ p!@
! y}

rqponml

2 1 0 / . - , + * ) ( ' & %o
.
?*6 O 9}y p3
]72

G :I F

G[

9AwyG K*QY :#++p9ZyG &+g=! #| ~%"*O PLC )yE S9"yG O9VQE -2


9}%}%p :E IQL6G ,p ~%+G"*h 9+!OyG ,p ~$OgT* #y &!} ,?"TyG K+JYh
K+JZy9p ,HG(ZyGh zaMyG {}AJ* S9"yG dG(sC #| 9}$GOf 9}p ,9}%f9=@Gh
,p d9! 9}%|h ,&zF9s f9v 9| 9*k C ,&!;a=< 9}wI 9| {_9=yGh ,&AJZ< 9}wI 9|
e(* O=gzy QdA"}yG AGRGyG ($ #*Oy9p ;Q9=vEh d;FE #| Q+$9}GyG S(q!
k
k
iO$h uG d(t< xT}AyG kz=| )zf -9<9tfh 9<G(C- >@QA* ($h ,?|9+tyG
.9}%"f aGQJ!:G hC | &y(SQ
,H

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

26

?A=yC 9%"f O+J| : ?"TyGh H9AwyG U(Z! fC )yE ~$O9VQE -3


96 b+"* fC uG ?}wI B]s ,AyG U(Z"yG gP$ Q$9c ,p Q(ZJ| uG #*O
&<9W@ 9| Y9=@G #f ~$98h ,9%f9=@G ~%|Ryzp ,~$9+!Oh ~%"*O ,p &tzL M;Y
hSh 9| &gSh f9}* 9< &=zs fz}_G #}p .&z*hz@ A9jA<Gh ?"AqyG A9jA<G 9%"|
~7;*hz@h ?+p(ZyG AGQ$ {wp .f9TI{< ~%+g<9@h &<9JYCh ,|d(SQyG
{FO :E ($ fE :9"k _9<h GQk $9c ?"TyGh fBQtzy fz< ~$G(fOh ,~79JaVh
.9%+zf A9]tzy ?z}yG gP$ AGOfC &SO ,&y(SQh uG )zf K*QY HPvh
. ?ztAT| {F9SQ ,p ?f9}GyG &Ayh9"@ {*(_ xyP ,p e;wyGh
k
)zf {}J* ,9Jk +JY 9sO9Y 9=k I | uG d(SQ >I )yE I(fOyG -4
k
&@;|9g|h &|9wICh &@O9=f ,p &< AGOAs:Gh ?"TI I(SCh ,,zfC ;D| gP9<G
)zf &y(s ~*Ot@h ,&<9JYC Q|Ch gQ|C &+zf #w* ~y 9| {v ?=!9G|h ,&s;LCh
` _ ^ ] \ [ Z Y Xo &zF9s f9v 9| 9*k C d(s {v
fCh .

)1(

:Q

("wyG[

p!@
!z{

edcba

!~}|{zyx
.

]7

?*6G :QWJn yG[ p

]56

?*6G

Oy

Oy #| &+yE >IC f(vC )AI ~vOIC #||* :z :| &y(s #|h


.y#+g=C S9"yGh &Tq!h
,p I(tVh 9+!OyG ,p ?wz$ uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG fC )yE ~$O9VQE -5
k
gP6 b+J* 9fQV ~%y dR!C E+I gO9=f ?JzZ}< ~zfC uG fCh ,IQL6G
(%p I9+JyG f(8V #| fzV iC ,p gQ+i YQW| {wp .979%F h+= #| ?JzZ}yG
Osh .?Zy9L &y f(w@ fC )j="* ,AyG &s(tI ,p g9*E YR9"| &!9J=S &+zf OAg|
g hh g Gh

&+zf &zyG ?}IQ {+v(yG #}IQyG O=f P9AS~y

?+p(ZyG gP$h ,J9+p(Y :9%"| QOY )1(

27

? +fQW y

)('&%$#

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

4 3 2o :#+=}yG iQ9w! G H(zS}G GP6 &y(t< 9vQV xyP )}v S


q
. ]21 ?*6G :iQ(WyG[ p= < ; : 9 8 7 6 5
k

o :,y9g@ &y(sh

]31

?*6G :?<n (Aq yG[

fQV 9}y ~%y G(yPh ,&T*Ot@h HQyG ~+dg@ ~$(SOsh ~$(}df ~8{p
uI &Tq"y ~fR #|h .~%y &!(fQW* 9}< fhO=gA* PE &< fPz* ~y 9}| ~%y
fEh .uzMyG )zf ?"}+%yG AGOQ &fR9!h uG )zf ?*QqyG ~dfC Otp h*QWAyG
k
o #+vQW}yG #| f9vh ,9<k Q &y GPMA| f9v )fO}yG GP%y OIC H9GASG
G(

98

]44

@?>=<;:

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

s O"f a(s(yGh ,Q(|}G J9COJ|h YO=yG ?=!9G| )yE I(fOyG -6


&@9+I ,p &< A9F 9| {wp yOQ (%p 9!Q|C &+zf U+y {}f {vz :| d(SQyG
&y(ty ,?|9+tyG e(* )yE #*O< U+zp &< Jz* ~y 9|h ,?f9TyG e9+s )yE #*O (%p
o &+yE 9%yR!C ?*B QLB ,p )y9g@

d(

UTSRQPO YXWV
)1(

]3

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

Q P O N M L K J I H G Fo :&y(sh
.
?*6 ?+C9Gy p@
! ! v} R
]18

G : n

G[

O$ ?<Q9J}y hOgyG 9%SO ,AyG IOS9qyG OF9tgyGh J9pGQMyG ?<Q9J| -7


uF9tJyG )yE S9"yG ?*GO$ )zf {}gyGh ,?"TyGh H9AwyG ,p gQZI jPyG uG
k
k
.:OF :h 9wV {=t@ : ,AyG ?+"*OyGh ?+!(wyG
IOIGh {v ?a=@Q| ?*hQL}Gh ?*(+!OyG ~79+I fC )yE S9"yG O9VQE -8
uI fBQtyG Ih;A< W9<Q i(sC f9Aa=@Q| 9}$9Azvh ,W9<Q uChC iQL}9< 9}%"|
i

?+]s}G H9Av 18 ~sQ 1344U/2L ~zT| y;}f {}f #|z :eqzyG )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

28

QqwyGh cQWyG #| QPJyG {v QPJyGh ,&< {}gyGh gQ<O@h &}%ph ,&@h;@


IO9=gyGh O+I(AyGh IO+tgyGh f9}* G )yE IQO9=}yGh ,&"| QPJ*h &qZ* jPyG
iQvPyGh IQ=gyG OGO}ASGh ,uzL #| &+yE (fO* 9}< uzMAyGh .9%+yE (fO* ,AyG
k
o &At+tJ< 9q*Qg@ &yR"| d9s 9}v &!} ,&"|

?N>M=L<K;J:I 9H G F E D C B A @
SRQPO
k

,p gQC} 9!9+< d9s 9}vh ?*6 (Wy p!@


! zw
V U T S R Q P O N M L K Jo S(q"yG
ba`_^]\[ZYXW
]52

G : iQ

G[

]122

?*6G :e9gn !}G[ p!@


! vw w

SQyG iO6 Q"AT* ~y >zs {vh ,B+| (%p fBQty9< 9+J* ~y >zs {wp
.~zd| (%p
)t@ ~F9}@ hC VGQ|}G #| ,qW@ 98C ~$(A* 9=k GI gP9<9p xyP )zfh
xyP Q+i hC ,~$Q(=s )zfh )@(}yG RF9"F ,p &@AGQs hC ,?vQ< gD9"AsG hC #+gyG
k
.GhR$ &"*Oh uG J9*B P9<G #| &g+= GP$ fE :d(t! .&\Qi #| U+y ($ 9}|
#| Q*PJAyG OVC QPJ* &!C ~zf :gQ<O@ uI gQ<O@h &@h;@ uI fBQtyG ;@ #|h
9%CQG(A* ?+"Ch O+y9t@ ,$ 9}!Eh ,K+JZyG #*OyG d9= B$(V ,AyG J9pGQMyG
.Q+"| H9Av :h iO$ :h ~zf ;< uG ,p 96 f(yO9G* Q+wq@ Q+i #| S9"yG
IQqj}yGh Q+My9< &zf9p Ofhh Q+MyG rYh )y9g@ uG fC )yE ~$O9VQE -9
#+g* ~yh ,QGOyG A(Sh ?"gzyG &+@B QP!Ch QWyG rYhh ,IQL6Gh 9+!OyG ,p
: ,AG(S )|9TyG CO=}yG GP$ e9|C S9"yG {< 97GP< ?|C :h ~89+fz< 9Yk 9MVC
{ z y x w vo .j(tAy9< :E )}GfC )zf )<Qgy {]p
d(

{zyx
&z}f &< za< #|

"
!
$#"!~}|

?*6G :BzZq p[ p@
! ! y{
x
z &!Ch ]123 ?*6G :A9T"yG[ p
]46

~}|

29

? +fQW y

9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0o
.

]101

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

=T! &< YQT* ~y

y&

?*6G

:f

("||}yG[

p!@
!vuv

P$ eQv}G d(SQyG u=a* fC :#*QhQj}yG #+zp9jyG X9t*E ,p ,qw*h


)"+zS ,O}J| B"< ?}_9p 9*z :9%y d(t+p ?}_9p IQ$9ayG &Ag]< )zf CO=}yG
k
.y98+V uG #| x"f )"iC #zp )z}fGh ,B8V 9| )y9| #|
,I:9=| Q+j< J9|QJyG c9%A!Gh f9+ZgyGh b(TqyG fC )yE ~$O9VQE -10
e9IQ}G ?zYh I9vRyG A9A*Eh I;ZyG e9sE #| {Y(* fC &< uG Q|C 9| has h|
)y9g@ &y(s xyP )yE Q+W* QL6G e(+yGh u9< ~89}*E eOgy ?|R: ?G+A! ($ 9}!E
G

v u t s r q p o n m l k jo
p!@
! yu y x w
.

]40

?*6G :f9sQqyG[

#| S9"yG 9%+p WQ(@ ,AyG cQWyG HhQ\ ,p ~%_Q(@ )yE hFGQ xyPh
G(p9Lh gOIh &A}IQ G(FQh ,ghQOsh &< G("|B ~8C (zp ,uG Q+j< uzgAyGh {=s
Q9A%AS:Gh ?Js(yG IAQGyG gP6 &@9|QI G(w%A!G :h ,gOhOI GhOg@ 9}y ,&<GPf
~8C- ?t<9TyG ~|}G 96 PLC ,AyG H(!PyG >!9G< &< B=D* fBQtyGh ,K\9qyG
)zf dO+y ?|Ot}yG )yE ?G+A"yG ?=T! H(!PyG )yE cQWyG ?=T"p #+vQW| &< G(!9v
O=gyG >zi GPE &!Ch ,f9a+WyG )Ih #| 9}%"| {wp ,f9wq"* : f9|R;A| 9}8C
.cQWyG )yE gQG* fC O< ;p ,?+Zg}y9< #+%AT* )AI
k
,9+8 hC B!9v GQk |C :gO9=f uG eRyC ,AyG J9|GRAy:G fC )yE ~$O9VQE -11
o ~6 ?}IQ :E BT+y

-,+*)('&%
543210/.
.

]185

?*6G :IQn t=n yG[

{=t* : ,OIGh A,V ($ 9}!E ?"TyG ,p hC H9AwyG ,p 9%"| OQh 9| fCh


k
k
,^g=< Qqvh ^g=< #|B #}| (%p :98+V cQ@h 98+V 9%"| PLC #}p ,?FRGAyG
9$Qv +Y 9| 9%y9a<E {+I #| ~$(pQv gp A9}zgyG ~S9< S9"yG )zf 9$(!(v$ #| fCh
#*PyG f(|QG}yG ~%p -I9vRyG W9tSEh I;ZyG W9tSE ?z+Jv- #w@ ~y fzv

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

30

&+p ~$ 9| >=S Q9"yG ,p ~$Q|C d9<h f(sP* #+I ~6 f(fhOM}yG QQt+S


9tk za| IQ=f :h . ?*6 QgWw y p@
! !~~ g f e do ~%y(t<
&zv GP%p ,>$GP}yG ^g< )yE 9%A=T! hC ,&tqyG >Av ,p {+JyG gP$ OhQ(<
k
.98+V uJyG #| )"j* : {_9<
A9"=yG hpQh ,Q(=tyG r*QW@ eQJ* PE | d(SQyG fC )yE ~$O9VQE -12
,{+C9}AyG ?|9sEh 9%+zf LQTyG O9t*Eh OF9T| 9$P9<Gh ,9$(J!h H9=t< ,9%s(p
96 KT}AyGh Q(=tyG d(I aG(ayGh ,~%y QP"yGh uG fhO #| #*Q(=t}yG A9fOh
)yE uG &At}* jPyG ~zdyG ,%p- -QP!Ch d(SQyG &"| QPI 9}| xyP )yE 9|h~$AG($C upG(* 9| ~wJyG #| 9$(T=z* fC f(za=}yG dh9I 9}%| -?|9+tyG e(*
k
d9s PE OTq| d9\ :E &]t"* : 9}wI ~wI | &!{p ,?"TI YO< 98C #+}fGR
: ?A<9C A9+V}G uF9tJp y979COJ| Q(|}G QVhz y?y;\ ?fO< {vz :|
?+z$9GyG {$C &zgp fE 9!k 9}*E f(w* : cQV &!z< uG &qYh jPyG cQWy9p .Q+jA@
?+z$9GyG {$C g9@C fE 9vk QV )t=* ~C ,?+|;S G ?|~y f(=TA"}yG ?+!9DyG
9tk I f9v GPE :E 9tk I &zgG* : &"+g< A,V {gp )zf S9"yG M;aY9p !!,yh}G
fEh ,H9AwyG )zf ?GI ~%y9gpC BT+yh ~%+zf ?GI H9AwyGh ,&Tq! ,p
k
.9g+= VQ}G ,p #| 9%+zf ~%tpGh
O: : :&y d9tp ,#}+yG )yE 9+k zf Eg<z :|k ,="yG fC ~zT| ihQ Osh
~S9< f(}+t* r+v 9=k Gf 9+p .)1(y&AT}_ :E :9D}@ :h ,&A*(S :E 9pk QW| GQk =s
u
.?| uG d(SQ Q|z< ($ &|O$ 9|
gO:hCh ,zf
f(w* fC >G* &F9}SCh uG J9qY #| ~%qs(| fC )yE S9"yG O9VQE -31
?qY {w< f9}*E #| :f9TI{< ~%g=@ #|h &<9JYCh | d(SQyG rs(}v
dhR"yGh #+gyGh O+yGh ?+s(qyGh AG(AS:G #| ?"TyG K+JYh fBQtyG ,p JA9F
h| {+ag@ hC {+D}@ hC {*hz@ fhO< ,9$Q$9c )zf 9%+yE 9|h xJ]yGh
]99

G :AG

n n

G[

~zT| gGhQ

)1(

31

( ' & % $ #o

( W yG[ p

:iQ

? +fQW y

:,

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

y9g@ &y(s Q9]JASG


.

?*6G

]11

Q+j< uG )zf d(s {+agAyG hC {*hzAyG f} J9qZyG #| ?qY iC QvP O"f


J9qZyG gP$ QvP #| uG OQ* ~y (yh ,K\Gh Qqv &+=WAyGh {+D}AyGh ,~zf
k
:h .&< f9}* G )yE I(fOh 9"y 9qk *Qg@ fBQtyG ,p 9$QvP 9}y &"+g< :(yO| 9%"+g<
,~zgyG #+gy9<h IQOtyG O+y9< O(Zt}yG f9v (yh .| &y(SQ f9Ty )zf JA9F
?i;< ,p 9"k g_ xyP Ogyh ,9$QGQwAy YGO c9"$ f9v 9}y :A;+AS:G AG(AS:9<h
&!9J=S &yR"| &qZ* jPyGh .&< U9L )"g| &"| eqy {wy A9F jPyG fBQtyG
p@
! !yw 4 3 2 1 0 / . - , + * ) (o &!z<
.

)!9g}y d9a<Eh &g\G(| #f ~zwzy r*Q; :E

]42

?*6G :BzZq p[

;*hzAyG gP$ {$h


?fB

QtyG

9s 9| Q$9d< PL}G f9v e9%p}G dh9"A| )zf (zg* e9t| GP$ f9v 9}yh
>gy :Q$9dyG GP$ #f baWyG ?yh9J|h ,?|;TyG u*Q_ ($ &+p &y(SQh
.Q9"y9<
)zf ?|G(tyG ~%y {dAy ?y(FQy9< ~%wT}@ H(Fh )yE S9"yG O9VQE -14
- #FQMp Q+L}G O%gyG ,p {ZI 9}v ,~9O*C #| e9|RyG Bzq* ;p ,A9T"yG
9| :E #T=z* : ,J9*Q9f J9+S9v YQG(WyG ,p J9}F9$ -9$k Qv hC 9fk (_
,?+!O}yGh ?*QJyG ~S9< Q9GqyG #| #8V #| #%=I9Z* ,AGQiEh ?"Ap #$O*R*
)AI eQ9J}yG )zf IQ+jyG dA9]A@h ,d9FQyG #| I(M"yG [s9"A@ ByGR :h
~$Ch dhC #| xyP fC h| .Q+w! Q+i #| #+@z* 9| #+@z* fQZp ,BV;@
.?t<9TyG ~|}G 96 uG PLC ,AyG H9=S}G
A9T"zy ~%I9}S ($ :&A|(CQFh AGOyG {YC fC )yE S9"yG O9VQE -15
uG d

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

32

BZgASGh ~%S(q! JOTqp .9%+yE 9|h J9}"+Sh [sGQ| #| ,$;}yG O9+@Q9<


AGhO :E B!9v 9}v ?+p9gyG )yE 9$O+g*h S(q"yG gP$ ,qW@ #yh ,L;gyG )zf
.?J+JZyG ?"TyGh fBQtyG ~%p #| :>*Qs OF gDGhOh .d9gqyG #*OyG
- OIGh {FQ ?*GO$ )yE 9"| uph #}p 9"A+j< ,$ gP$h ,9"A*9i ,$ xz@
.&y )<(ap -&Tq! (yh
~%A*GO$ )zf GQk FC S9"yG dzT! : ,,gT! I(%Wy :h ,{}g! dm9}y :
#|B #}y Q+L uG HG(Ch &@Qqj|h &A}IQh uG HG(C )j=! 9}!Eh ,~$O9VQEh
k
.fhQ<9ZyG :E 9$9tz* :h 9Jy9Y {}fh
k
)zf ?|9tAS:G )yE 9%=I9Y hpO@ Uq"y9< 9}k F9s :9I #*OyG f(w* fC O*Q!
k
fC Q+j< ,f9TzyG 96 cQJA* 9c9qyC : ,QWyG ?=!9G|h Q+MyG {gph ,?t*QayG
.fGOF(yG ,p QCC 9%y f(w*
,p 9$QV : ,Uq"yG ,p ?"+!z}_h >ztyG ,p 9"k +t* #*OyG f(w* fC O*Q!
,9+!OyG 96 {v|@ ?pQI #*OyG f(w* : fC O*Q! ,f9"S}G )p IOI :h ,#a=yG
k
.H(+GyGh #FGRMyG &< ~}@ 9sRQA| :h
{}g@ ,%p ,9sk R@Q| #*OyG JP<G ,AyG J98qyG gP$ S(q! KzZ@ fC O*Q!
~%tzT@h #+JzZ}yG #*O ,p #ga@h ,(qZyG Q+wg@h (GyG O9TpE )zf
#| &zAT@ 9}| 9$D9|h 9$R=L 9%y ~zT+y 9$Q9Z<z< ~%tyR@h ,OGOJyG 9%A"Tyz<
k
k
.GQ9! ~8(a< &< uG ~}* ,9AJS #+zp9jyG #+z$9GyG iO*C
fCh ,&+p f(sQqA* :h ~%"*O f(}+t* IOIGh ?|C f(}zT}yG f(w* fC O*Q!
u*QqA< f(!(w+p ~%"*O f(sQq* ~%AzgF ,AyG J9fR"yG gP$ ~%"+< #| dhR@
k
.^g< Sz< ~%]g< bhP* 9g+V #*OyG
?}zv f(wAyh ~89azS ry9Sh ~89}*E u<9S )yE #+}zT}y9< Y(FQyG O*Q!
.&FGOfC ?yP< )zqTyG ,$ GhQqv #*PyG ?}zvh ,&F9+yhC IRg< 9+zgyG ,$ uG

33

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9y

~S9< B}+sC ,AyG e9"Y}Gh B+iG(ayG gP$ ~aJA@ fC O*Q!


VQ}G bQ9W| ,p BD=!G ,AyG ,#+qy|}yGh >AwyG ~S9<h #+Jy9ZyGh
#fh 9%Af9_h 97O9=f )yE &@O9=fh uG O+I(@ #f S9"yG BpQZp .96Q9j|h
96 ~TtyG )yE &< ~TtyG #fh 96 ?!9gAS:G )yE &< ?!9gAS:G #fh &+yE ?fGQ]yG
,9%AIQ\z< aG(ayG )yE &A+=< aG(ayG #fh ,9%+yE QP"yG )yE &y QP"yG #fh
aQg* : fC O*Q! .9%+yE ~v9JAyG )yE &y(SQh &<9Av )yE ~v9JAyG #fh
9%+yE f(fRq*h ,J9}z}yGh KQG(wyG ,p 9%+yE fhzGz* ?+=+i I(s f(}zT}yG
&"f ~%pQZ* ;p ,&y x*QV : gOIh )y9g@ uG I(s :E J9<QwyG rWwy
o O9Y &A}IQ ?I9S #f ~$OZ* :h ,aQ9Y
A + h}G

:9876
FEDCBA@?>=<;
.

]186

?*6G :IQn t=n yG[ p@


! !v}{
n

pT S R Q P O N M L K J I H Go
.

]88

?*6G :O($o [

9$DQt+p S9"yG #+< ?yhO ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= {F9SQ f(w@ fC (FQ!h 9"$
Q+MyG &"f RGJ+p 9$O*Q* #}f 9$RGJ* :h 96 hqA"+y g9LC 9%+ag*h ~zT}yG
o )y9g@ &y(s e(}f ,p -uG A9V fE- 9$(FQ9s {LO* )AI

*)('&%$#"!

~}|
Q|n Rw yG[ p@
! ! v}

&<Q (qf )yE Q+tqyG &=Avh


,tqyG O|9I O}J|

]18

?*6G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

34

9 Og < 9|
$

,q+qf

bGRQyG

O=f

h v7v

/N

Og y y

dh}G O

+Wzy

G ) h} G

? Ty
"

?y9t|

Og<h #+zSQ}yG aQVC )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh #+}y9gyG HQ u O}JyG


9!AGQs JGQ]Jy eOt! ?vQ9=}yG ?zG}yG gP$ #| OOf dhC QhOY ?=S9"}< &!{p
{+=S )yE G(gFQ+y )yh}G ~$Q(Zf ,p #+}zT}yG ?y9I #| IP=! {\9p:G
Q(! #| rF9JY N*Q9AyG ~%y QaS #*PyG ~$OGOFC u*Q_ G(G%A"*h ~%p;SC
.~%z=s OI} #w@ ~y
&}y9g|h gOhOI G("+=@h e;S G hFGQV ?|}G gP$ #| {FGh}G aQf
O+I(yG h="}yG )yE ~%"*O Q|C #| fhQP*h f(@z* 9}+p f(gFQ* r+v G(pQfh
&< xT}ASG #| {]* : jPyG uG H9Av .#+A}yG uG {=J< G(}ZAf9p ,p9ZyG
oo :&+p )y9g@ uG d9s jPyG e(Zg}yG ~*QwyG &+=! ?"T<h &F(\ )zf Q9Sh
9}6 {}gy9< ~%Tq!C GhPLC 9}v p!@
! y w v u t s !@
!x r q p
f9wp ~6(zs ?V9W< uG #*O by9Lh ~%S(q! JQ%_h ~%IGhQC BqY )AI
.~8h|V h+= ,p ~$Q9gV
&jz=* fC &+yE O%fh ~zgyG ?}g"< &+zf uG ~g!C Osh &Tq! OG* ~%"| ~y9gy9p
O9=}yGh ?+"*OyG ?p9tDyG QW! ,p &*QAg* ;p A>gyG GP6 e9+tyG )yE GQk a]| S9"yG
#| a(L :h ?=$Q :h ?=iQ Z;=yG #f gOgt* :h Q(L :h Q(Ap ?+|;S G
?!9ZIh ?+IhQ I(s >TAw* f9}* G Ih;I HQVC jPyG >ztyG f} f9azS
k
k
GP$ f9a+WyG O$9F 9}%}p ;+=S &FG(iE )yE OIC OG* ;p 9+!9<Q GQ(!h ?+"*O
k=Y Os 9=k zs fCh .&@O+tf U}* hC &A}*Rf #$(* fC &y M9A* #zp [zM}yG
h]M* fC )<z+y ,gAGO*(S Bwz| )AI e;S G ~+y9gA< h=W@h uG ?j=Z<
f9azTy h]L 9|Og< uJyG ?}zw< Q%GyG ,p Q9=F Xa< >$Q* hC Q$9s ?azTy
xyP fCh .O9=gyG )YG(! gO+< Q9=F Q9%s xz| &!C ~zfh &"| &p(L OAVGh &<Q
k
k
k
.f9+Zg< gRQ9<h uG iO9f #| 96 aPt* ?GFzA| GQ9!h 9AzZ| 9q+S &"| uzM+y
.

35

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~ : ?|(y uG ,p a9M* :
k
?J+Z!h 9ik ;<h GQk W!h 9dqI #*OyG )zf #+|G(s xyP< A9}zgyG f9v
rWvh gO+*z@h uJyG ?<9YE ,p 9+zf ;D|h S9"zy IhOs Q+L G(!9vh ,GOk9VQGh
9}< HG(ZyG &Fh ~%y G(qWw+y S9"yG ~$OZt* .;}fh :(s &s9$RGh {_9=yG
O*R*h ~%A%=V {*R*h ~%Azi ihQ* 9| ~9Oy GhOG+p | ~%+=! #f g(CQh
Q|C ,p {LO* #w* ~yh ,#+zSQ}yG O+S ?g*QW< ~%tzg@h ~89}*Gh ~%"+t*
#| IQGO G d9FQ 9|C gOI O"f rshh gQOs {v aQgp &z$C #| U+y #| 9+AqyG
k
IOV ,p ?+fQyG fhOtqA*h ?|}G ?vQI f(=sQ*A9"ap 9c9t*C G(!9wp A9qzLh e9wI
,p 9| f(<CQ*h 9$R(f OSh 9$G(AT| hpQ )zf f(z}g+p IRfh #$hh A9LQh
.QWyGhO9TqyG Pp9"| fhOT* G(!9v {< xwq@ hC d;J!G #| 97hQf
A9}zgyG KF9Z"y ~6(zs Y9T@G &Fh {}vC )zf ~%A}%}< e9+tyG #| ~%"w|h
G(!9vh k*RyGh {aMyG #| xyP< G(}ZAf9p A9}wJyG O9VQ: ~%f9}SC KAq@h
A9jY:G #fG(g"A}* ~zp uG?=sGQ|h ?!9|}Gh ?pQg}yG #| ~+df >!9F )zf
#| GhOQ:h OJyG #| xyP< [zM+p eQG}< ?pCQ ~$PLz@ ~yh &y(=sh uJzy
B}dA!9p IAGQ=yG #| >*Q}yG U*Bh ?!GO:G #| Q=yG #|zp i($ hC ?+=Zf {v
9%y B}zSCh )\Q #f 989azTy B"fPCh9%A|(wI )yE B!z}_Gh ?|}G d9I
uqLh e;S G AG(y hq@QGh VQ}G ~|C GhO9Tp 99O*z< 9%|9|R BtyCh 9$O9+s
fBQtyG IQ+S )zD}yG IQ+TyG G(ttI Otp ?z}Gy9<h ~y9gyGA9J!C {v ,p uJyG ~zf
IQ+TyG >Av &< J~A|G 9| xyP ?G+A! B!9vh e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf ,="yG uzLh
?*O9}yG ~$G(s )zf )]sh e;S G AGOfG dP )AI QMph OG| #| N*Q9AyGh
.~$QhOY ,p ~%d+i G(qLCh G(!9wAS9p ,?*("g}yGh
?GJy9< hC r+TyGh I(ty9< &z$Ch e;S G #| {+"zy {+JyG ~%A+fC 9}zp
G(T=zp U+=zAyGh ^+j=yG SOyG M;S i(T"yG M;TyG )yE GhO}f f9TzyGh
a9+SC ?+WLh >*QyGh f("dyG ?+WL ?+tAyG YhQO< G(fQO@h b9q"yG ?|} xyPy
. F

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

36

;L G(g\hzp fGhOgyGh QqwyG #+"a=AT| ,#*O$9G}yG #| #*Q(+jyG


~6(zs Gh~|h I9fQyG )zf ?+fQyG QhOY GhQihzp ?"AqyG ~8(j=* #+}zT}yG
e9wJy9< ?tDyG hpQh A9L:G b<GhQ ~+a; )zf G(y9AIGh Q(|}G A9+yhz< ?"+j\
A9%qSh KGOI:Gh QGQi:G #| xyP )zf ~$Of9Sh #AqyG #| )AV HhQ]<
.~%y9D|C #| ?|C (z< : #| e;I:G
fhRj* IQ}p .jQA@ &z$Ch e;S G )zf ~79}G$h ~79=Ch ByGR 9|h
{D| IQ+JyG e;ch xWyG LQI ,p ~$(gs(+y S9"zy 98("*R* ,AyG &=WyG M;T<
IQL6G ,p &A*DQ Q9w!Eh &@9qY {+ag@h )y9g@ uG e;v uzM< d(tyG YGOA<G
d(tf )zf 96 G(y(ASGh 9$(!GR ,AyG &=WyG #| 9$Q+ih | ,="yG ?f9qV ,q!h
k
k
I;ZyG &+zf uG d(SQ )yE GQhR 98(=T"* E*O9IC f(zJA"* 9!9+ICh .A9aT=yG
#| E*OJyG #q< {%GyGh ?zqjyG {$Ch QGQi:G h|9T| )zf 98(tz*h e;TyGh
>T! 9| {wy f(jZ* {< &<hPw|h &J+JY #+< R++}AyG f(g+aAT* : #*PyG
)zf HPwyG )zf OIC DQG* : &!E ~%"ch IGhQy9< ~%"c #TJy | &+yE
} | {o gOfh RG"*h &"*O QZ"* fC :E )y9g@ uG )<z* #wyh .YQW}yG
{_9=yG YQZ* fC :E uJyG )<z*h ?*6 QGJy p!@
!~ # " ! ~
&dqIh #qyG GP$ IA;w< ?*GhQyG A9}zfh E*OJyG d9FQ #| O9t"yG O* )zf
9IQF d9FQyG dG(IC #f rWwyGh {+LOyG #| {+Y}G R++}@h &"*hOA<
KGQ+}yG GP$ G(z}$C Og< #| ~zgyG d9FQ ^g< fC :E ?zqih ?dt* ,;*Og@h
)zf GhQ+T* ~yh d(Y}G )yE YhQqyG OQ ,p ~%qzS {=S G(wzT* ~yh #+}DyG
xp}G e;c ~$Q}jp IGQAq}yG E*O9I}Gh &=WyG OQ ,p #+yh}G EI9=| A(\
J:9}AI:G #| GhQDvCh ~%DI9=| #| Q+Dv ,p G(a=MAp U+=zAyG ~%+zf )j_h
#+%=W}yGh #+pQJ}yG e9|C ~%A}zv Bqg]p 9%+yE ?F9I:h 9%y )fGO : ,AyG
.#*OJz}yG
,p aGQJ!Gh ?}zwyG ,p bQq@ #| e(+yG ?+|;S G ~|}G &A; MRQ@ 9| fEh
d

]9

G :

p G[

37

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

xyP {v U+y .~$Q+i eOtA* #+I AGQ(yG )yE QLz@h Y9pOyG ,p rg\h iCQyG
9}k zf ~%AaL Q+jy ~%v(zSh Ky9ZyG rzTyG KGQ@ #f ~%Azqi ?G+A! :E
.;}fh
k
f(}zT}yG gAGRC O= 9q+M| 9FGhQ O*OF #| #*OJz}yG &=V BFGQ Otyh
O+v GhOQy ~%t*Q_ G(wzSh Ky9ZyG ~%qzS dG(sC )yE G(gFQ ~8C (yh
#+_9+V 9%+yE u=S Osh :E e(+yG YGP@ ?%=V #| 9| &!{p ~$Q(J! )yE #*OF9wyG
A9}zf ?zFC 9%za<Gh 9$OQh 9%qshh )yh}G Q(ZgyG ,p #+t<9TyG #*OJz}yG
G(!9v 9}| e(sC iO$ :h ~%z+=S #| OVQC {+=S ;p .?tF9p ?fGQ=< rzTyG
&+p 9%tq@h &y Ih;@ )y9g@ uG H9Av )yE I(fOyG ,p Q+MyG {v Q+My9p .&+zf
#*P6 9+AqyGh ?*GhQh ?*GQO | ~zwyG h|G(F >I9Y ,qaZ}yG E*O9IC )yEh
U+y iPyG O9VQyGh M;qyG ($ GP%p 9}%+zf S9"yG d9}fC VQfh #+zY}G
.O9VQ gOg<
O+g< #|R P"| GP6 QgV #}}y ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fEh GP$
f9v 9| 9}+S : J9pGQMyG Kp9w@ ?f9}GyG JCO=p &F;fh gQOZ| BpQfh
| ,="yG ?"S )yE 9%pQW* #| {vh 9%F9]fz< hFQ@h OF9tgy9< 9%"| 9tzgA|
H9AwyG >I )zf ~%8W"@h &*(="yG aQ9g}y9< ~$Q+"@h Ky9ZyG rzTyG u*Q_h
.?+=Zf Q+i #| 9}%}wI )zf dhR"yG )zf ~8Q}@h ?"TyGh
u*Qa< f9v 9%z}f fC Q+i iO}J}yG Q("y9< H(ztyG IQ9!9< ?f9}GyG B|9s
IQ$9ty9< ?qzAM}yG 9%A*O!C ,p )tz@ ,AyG JGQc9"}yGh JGQ\9J}yGh ShQOyG
jPyG QZgyG GP$ ,p ?F9Jy9< aGh :h a9v Q+i iQ@ 9}v xyPh 9%+IG(\h
O9TqyG u=_h J9pGQMyG JQWA!Gh O9Jy:G &+p Qq_h #*Oy9< {%GyG &+p ~f
.VQ}G Y9tYC
QW"yG u*Q_ iQL}G u*QayG ,p f9g|:G #| 9%y O<: fC ?f9}GyG JCQp
uG A9W!E H%"ASh u9< ?"+gAT| i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| xyPy JQ9AL9p r+yzAyGh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

38

#| rzTyG u*Q_ ?}SQA| e9+s Q+L 9}89+< )zf e(t@h ?"TyGh H9AwyG H8
AGOC )zf #+!G(tyG #| G(TSCh OfG(tyG #| G(g\h 9}< ?"+gAT| E*OJyG d9FQ
)y9g@h &!9J=S uGh )\Q}yG {}v}G &F(yG )zf #*OyG k+z=@h ?y9SQyG gP$
.{+v(yG ~g!h uG 9"=TIh .{+=TyG AG(S )yE iO9%yG
,q+qf

Qy O=f

bG R G

?+|;S G ?g*QWyG ,p [ZMAyG H*QL

39

? +fQW y

"

)1(
? TyG

,pOG(WyG

Q9Z C IO

(qY

/N

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

+tf

+WyG

? z ]p

Og<h ...uG d(SQ )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh ...u O}JyG


?t<9a| ,$h ,9%f9=@C 96 xT}A* ,AyG ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C IO+tf gP%p
,?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C ,IQ(Z"}yG ?qF9ayGh ?+F9"yG ?sQqyG IO+tgy -uG O}J<:u+p(AyG u9<h d(t"p
QOtyGh ,QL6G e(+yGh ,&zSQh &=Avh &AwF;|h u9< f9}* G 9"@O+tf *
?"TyG &< JA9F hC ,fBQtyG &< ua! 9| {w< f9}* G xyPvh ,gQVh gQ+L
.?J+JZyG
hC &Tq! 96 rYh ,AyG )zgyG J9qZyGh )"TJyG A9}S}G u fC OtAg!h *
;{+ag@ :h ,&+=W@ :h ,{+D}@ :h ,r++w@ Q+i #| ,| &y(SQ 96 &qYh
-rzTyG gQTp 9}v ,hq@QGh ;f iC ;TQgyG )zf i(ASG -&!9J=S- &!Ch
.9%}zg! : ?+q+w<
?"TyG xyP< JQ=LC 9}v- 9+!OyG A9}TyG )yE dR"* -&!9J=S- &!Ch
9}v !f9w| {v ,p &}zfh ,A9}TyG ,p uGh ,9%}zg! : ?+q+w< -?J+JZyG
9}v ,A9W* r+v uq"* f9A_(T=| gGO* fCh ,gO+< eOB uzL -&!9J=S- &!C #||!
k
k
k
,IRfh I(sh ,IQOsh ,9}zfh ,GQk Z<h 9g}Sh ,9%Fh -&!9J=S- &y B=D!
k
:-&!zV {F- &!{p ;&< u+z* jPyG &F(yG )zf ,&@9qY #| xyP Q+ih ,9|;vh
:

]11

?*6G

( W yG [

:iQ

( ' & % $ #o

y9g@h &!9J=S- &"f ,q"! 9}v ,&Tq"y 9%A=CC ?qY {v u B=D! #J!h *
{$ :{+s GP{p ,U(Z"yG &"f BAwS 9}f BwT!h ,&Tq! #f 9$9q! ?qY {v
-,

9TyG OOgyG fhQWgyGh ?SO9TyG ?"TyG O+I(AyG ?zG|

. SO

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

40

?f9_ &"f BwT! {< ,&+q"! :h ,&A=D! ;p &"f J(wT| GP$ :d(t! ?~TF u
.u

9}y d9gp ,Q<O}yG xy9}yG uy9MyG ($ -&!9J=S- uG fC OtAg! 9}v *


o
,f(yzT* ~$h ,{gq* 9}f dzT* : ,#w* ~y zW* ~y 9|h ,f9v A9V 9| ,O*Q*
uy9Lh ,O9=gyG uy9L uG fCh ,b(zM| Q+i uG e;v fBQtyG fC OtAg!h
.
? *6
9p9Zv y p!@
!~{
o :,y9g@ &y(ty ,~%y9gpC
IQL6G ,p ~6Q fhQ* #+"||}yG fz< f9}* G :?"TyG Q9Z!C IO+tf #|h *
!@
!ww
o :,y9g@ &y(ty ;QO=yG ?z+y ,p Q}tyG iQ* 9}v
) (o :,y9g@ &y(ty ;?*DQyG gP$ #| f(|hQJ| ~8{p Q9qwyG 9|Ch ,p!@!wx
]96

G :J

G[

_^]\

|{z yxw
.

]15

?*6G :#+qp qa}yG[ p@


! ! vz
q

-,+*

?+Zg}y9< [t"*h ?f9ay9< O*R* ,{}fh d(s f9}* G fC OtAg!h *


~y 9| ,GQk p9v U+y #+}zT}yG #| QF9=wyG >w@Q| fC ?"TyG Q9Z!C OtAg@h *
k
k
,&@Q+=w< uS9p ;&!9}*{< #||| ($ {< ,9%}wJy GOI9F hC 9%y ;JAT| #w*
fEh ;&y IQ9qv ,%p 9+!OyG ,p 96 >s(f fEh ,&+zf uG H9@ 9%"| H9@ f{p
Qqi A9V fEh ,&<Pf A9V fE :&zyG ?8+W| ,p (%p OI :h ?<(@ Q+i #| J9|
.#*Oy9MyG h| 9%+p gOzM* ~y #+<Pg}yG h| Q9"yG ,p &<Pf fEh ,&y
:h ,U(Z"yG &< JQ=LC #| :E ?"Gy9< #+}zT}yG #| OI} O%W! :h *
.U(Z"yG &< JQ=LC #| :E Q9"y9< OIC )zf O%W!
#wyh ,uG :E 9%}zg* : ?}@9MyGh ,~+@G(My9< d9}f}G fC ;xyP f9+<h
#| f(w* fC A,T}yG )zf a9M!h ,?"GyG {$C #| f(w* fC #TJ}zy (FQ!
.Q9"yG {$C
#}f (qg*h ,A9V #| &+p uG HPg* ,uI Q=tyG HGPf fC OtAg! 9}v *
o :,y9g@ &y(ty ,A9V
.

IHGFEDCBA

41

MLKJ
? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9<k GPf 9+!OyG ,p ~%y B=Czp . ?*6 Qp9i p@


! ! y{
&< B=C 9| )zf Q+w!h Qw"| dG|T< #||!h ,Q=tyG HGPf ($h ,,WgyGh hOjy9<
o :,y9g@ uG d(s h| | uG d(SQ #f Q=MyG
]46

G :

_
^
]
\
[
lkjihgfedcba`
.

]27

?*6G :~+$GQ<E[ p!@


!w|

: ~%zFC A9F GP{p ,;FC b(zM| {wy QOs -{Fh Rf- uG fz< #||!h *
&y(ty ;&zFC A9%A!G xyPp ,{As hC J9| fEh ,f(|OtAT* :h ?f9S fhQLzAT*
p3 2 1 0 / . - , + * ) (o :,y9g@
dB[

]154

?*6G :fGQn }fp

9| )zf ;jQ=wyGh iQjZyG ?f9TyG J9|;f #| B=C 9| {w< #||!h *


,L(Fz|h L(Fz* LhQLh ,96Qj| #| U}WyG Y(zav ;U(Z"yG &< JA9F
,Q*R"MyG {At* e;TyG &+zf ~*Q| #<G )T+f dhR!h ,d9FOyGh ,?<GOyGh
~}* uG O=f #< O}J| &}SGh
iO%}yG Q(%ch ,>+zZyG QTw*h
k
k
k
k
U(Z! ,p xyP B=C 9}v ,9}zch GQ(F B8z| fC Og< ,:Ofh 9aTs VQ}G
.?J+JZyG ?"TyG
fCh ,uI QWJyG fCh ,uI Eg=yG fCh ,uI J(}yG fC OtAg! 9}v *
,p #| Eg=* uG fCh ,9%+p >*Q : ?+@B ?f9TyG fCh ,uI fGR+}yGh WGQZyG
fCh ,#+F9"yG #| (%p &"*RG(| BztC #}p ;#*RG(| IQL6G ,p fCh ,Q(=tyG
)}dgyG ?f9qWyG :9%}dfC IOOgA| J9f9qV &yh ,| uG d(SQy ?A<9C ?f9qWyG
?Y(ZM| ?f9qWyG gP$h ,~+dgyG rs(}yG A9"f #| S9"yG ?IGQ ?|9+tyG e(*
#| Q9"yG {LO #| ^g< LGQLE ,p iQLC ?f9qV &yh .| uG d(SQ<
.?"GyG ,p #+"||}yG J9FQO hpQ ,p iQLCh ,#*OI(}yG
9+!OyG ,p ?f9qWyG | uG d(SQ dzT* fC ~zT}zy R(G* : &!{p GP$ h|h
.| xy(SQ ?f9qV )"sRQG ~%zyG :d(t* {< ,&< Q+GAT* hC &<(!P IQqj| hC

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

42

xyP (J! hC
_o :,y9g@ &y(ty ;9gk as Q9"yG ,p OzM* &!{p 9vk QW| J9| #| fC #||!h
.

ponmlkjihgfedcba`
x
.
?*6 9T"y p!@
!y} r q
]48

G :A

G[

?z}yG #| LQM* jPyG ($ Q=v}9p ;QjYCh ,Q=vC :f9f(! cQWyGh


#| [zL #}p ;xyP (J!h ,A9*QyG Q+T*h uG Q+j< rzJy9v QjY}Gh
[zL #|h ,Q9"yG &y B=Fh Q=v}G )zf J9| #|h ,?"GyG &y B=Fh #+vQWyG
{LO ,&<(!P )zf ?JFGQ J9"TI h| QjY}G ^g< ,p hshh ,Q=v}G #|
&@98+S &< BJFQ )AI QjY}G QDv #wyh ,Q=v}G #| [zL #|h ,?"GyG
,QjYC GQk +Dv f9v hC ,Q=vC f9v GPE O=gyG &< PLG|* cQWy9p .Q9"yG {LO
.&< PLG|* : Q+DwyG U;L G >!9F ,p {+ztyG QjY}Gh
:{Fh Rf uG d9s 9}v ;~%y (fO!h | uG d(SQ H9JYC >J!h
,

C B A @ ? > = < ; : 9o
QWJy p!@
! vu O N M L K J I H G F E D

G[

]10

?*6G

Py (p ,,<9JYC G(=T@ :z :| &y(ty ;?<9JZyG #| GOk IC >T! :h


k
,y&q+Z! :h ~$OIC O| kz< 9| 9=$P OIC {D| uq!C ~vOIC fC (y gO+< )Tq!
uq!C #| fC OtAg"p ,?"TyGh H9AwyG ,p JA9F 9}v ~%=@GQ|h ~%zF9]q< Qt!h
gOg< #| uq!C #}| {]pC {@9sh ..?+=*OJyG KzY ($h- KAqyG {=s #|
G(!9vh- QO< {$} d9s uG fCh ,Q9Z!}G #| {]pC #*QF9%}yG fCh .{@9sh
{LO* : &!z<h ,y~wy JQqi Otp ~A8V 9| G(z}fGz :-QWf ?g]<h ?F9}C;C
/ . - ,o :fBQtyG xyP< Q=LC 9}v ,IQGWyG B; h*9< OIC Q9"yG
uG d(SQ xyP< Q=LCh ,
?*6 KAqy p4 3 2 1 0
fC ?|}G rzS &+zf h=C 9}< Qt!h ,?F9}g<QCh ryC #| QDvC G(!9vh ,|
j G

]18

G :

r n

G[

43

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9}Df ~C ,
Q}f ~C ,
Qw< (<C 9%+=! Og< ?|}G gP$ {]pC
J9%|C &FGhRC )y(A!h ,| uG d(SQ B+< {$C >J!h .,
)zf ~C
.?"GyG ,p &FGhRC #8C OtAg!h ,#%"f uG )\Q #+"||}yG
9| fC OtAg!h ,YR9"AyGh a;AL:G #| ?<9JZyG #+< QGV 9}f xT}!h *
&]g<h ,f9Zt!h IO9*R &+p &]g<h ,HPv &]g< xyP ,p ~%+yE >T!
,f(=+Z| 9|{p fhO%AG| ~8} ;fhQhPg| &+p ~$ &"| K+JZyGh ,K+JY
: xyP h|h ,xyP {v ,p U;L 9< ~%y O%W! #J!h ,f(8aM| 9|Eh
{F9]qyG #| ~%yh ,H(!PyG #| e(Zg| ~%"| OIGh {v fC OtAg!
f9v : ,A9+=!}G Og< uzMyG Q+L ~%p ,hsh Os 9| ~%y Qqj* 9| ,J9"TJyGh
:h ,#||| :E ~%=J* : ,?|}G I(qYh ,fhQtyG Q+L ~%p ,~%zD| f(w* :h
.d9\ hC up9"| :E ~%+p #ga* hC ~%]j=*
J9|GQw< bOZ!h ,,yh u (%p )t@ #||| {v fC ?"TyG Q9Z!C OtAg@h *
,p ~|}G ry9S #f Q(Cz| ($ 9}v ;~9O*C )zf uG 99QG* ,AyG A9+yh}G
.f9TI{< ~%y #+g<9AyGh ?<9JZyG #f B<9C ($ 9}v hC ,9$Q+ih r%wyG IQ(S
f9a+WyG 9$Q%d* Os ,AyG ?+!9a+WyG ?sQ9MyGh ,?+!9}* G ?|GQwyG #+< bQq!h
.S9"yG )zf 96 f(T=z+p ,#+y9FOyGh ?fOA=}yG #| &F9+yhC O* )zf
hq"yG &+p OtAg! fC &+zf >@QA* : #||}zy ?*:(yG J(=C f{p GP$ h|h *
hC )Jy OGS hC hvQ #| &!{p ,JGO9=gyG #| A,W< &+yE &F(A! hC ,Q]yGh
,OFGOWyG ,p ~6 K9jASG hC )yh hC ,=! Q=t< a9_ hC ,uG Q+jy QP! hC ,B+|
gP$ #| {gp {w< f(w* &!{p ;&zyG :E &+zf QOt* : 9| uG Q+i #| >z_ hC
k
k
.J(}yG {=s H(A* fC :E uG gQqj* : Q=vC 9vQV 9vQW| d9gp}G
,

)1(

?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C IO+tfh ,A9+yh}G J9|GQv IQf9V}G ^g<h ?yRAg}yGh ?qS;qyG Qw!C
. ?"TyGh H9AwyG #| ?+fQWyG U(Z"yG &+zf ByO 9}v 9$O(F(< f9}* Gh 979=CE

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

44

9}Ts {S(AyG f{p ;R(G* : A9+yh}Gh A9+=!}9< {S(AyG xyPvh *


u9< f9}* 9< {S(@ ;dh}G :f9}Ts (%p YhQW}yG 9|C ,Y("}|h ,YhQW|
)yE B+=}yG ~$GhB #*PyG ?C;DyG E*OJv ,?Jy9ZyG d9}f}Gh ,&y(SQh
;&@9+I ,p | &F9fO< {S(@ ;,!9DyGh .&A+fhQW| )zf h}G| GP$h ,Q9jyG
?*Q9GyG B=z_ 9}vh ,~%y )tTAT* fC | d(SQyG #| )<GQf}G >z_ 9}v
GP$h -A9fOyGh Q=ZyG #+< 9$Q+Mp ,uG 9%+p9g* fC- YQZ@ B!9v ,AyG AGO(TyG
,
Q}f ?p;L ,p xyP B=C 9}v ,| &@(}< hat!G Os &F9fO< {S(AyG
.
S9=gy9< {S(AyGh
,~$Q+ih A9+yh}Gh A9+=!}G JGhP< {S(@ {v (%p ;Y("}}yG {S(AyG 9|C
hC ?F9I &yzT*h uG d(SQ Q=s )@z* fC ~zT}y R(G* ;p ,e(zg| ($ 9}v
.Q\ rWv hC >!P fGQqi
HJyG ?|9sEh ,Qw"}yG #f ,%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G H(F(< #||!h *
k
k
,GQ9Gp eC G(!9v GQGQ<C ,e9wJyGh AGQ|}G h| O9+f}Gh h}GyGh ,O9%GyGh
OTGyG h}AG| ?|9sE )yE )gT!h ,?J+Z"yG dP=!h ,?f9}GyG )zf ep9J!h
O"f QwWyGh A;=yG O"f Q=ZyG )yE (fO!h ,?"TyG &< JQ|C jPyG OIG(yG
OtAg!h ,d9}f}G #S9J|h b;L}G eQ9w| )yEh A9]tyG Q}< 9\QyGh ,A9LQyG
.?z\9p b;LCh ,?Zy9L IO9=fh ,?J+JY IO+tf ;#*OyG Y9= fC
~y 9| e9wJyGh AGQ|}G )zf LhQMyG :h ,?"AqyG ,p LhQMyG R+G! :h *
uG #| 9!O"fh ,{*hzAyG {=t* : jPyG K*QZyG ($h ,MG(< Qqv ~%"| QOZ*
.?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C IO+tf ,$ 9}v f9$Q< &+p
)zf | &y(SQ )zf I;ZyG >FhC Os uG fC ?"TyG Q9Z!C OtAg@h *
$ # " ! ~ } | {o :,y9g@ &y(ty ;#+"||}yG gO9=f
;f

]56

?*6G :HGRn I}G[ p!@


!z{

)('&%

45

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9| {vh ,d9= Gh Q9ZAL:G &Fh )zf ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C IO+tf gP$
fC ?"TyG {$C #| OI} R(G* : ;?+F9"yG ?sQqyG IO+tf #| O}AT| g9!QvP
fCh ,?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C #| 9"zgG* fC uG dzT"p ,Q+Dv hC {+zs ,p 9%qy9M*
O}J| 9"+=! )zf cQ9<h ~zSh uG )zYh ,?J+JZyG IO+tgyG gP$ )zf 9"A+}*
.&=JYh &yBh
, p O G (W y G

(qY

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

"

)1(
? TyG

46

Q9Z C I

(fOy ~%@O9%Vh

?f9}GyG

A9}zgyG dG

(sC

#f G(y9s

a9sh G IQGRh

(yG

IQ G R
jh9

"WyG

{ vh

d9}F /N

+WyG

? z ]p

y ?S9+S fEh ,9%F9W!E P"| ?yOAg| ?f9= ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C fE


)zf dOC U+yh ?yOAg}yG ?+|;S G J9+g}GyG h| fh9gAyG )zf e(t@ ?yhOyGh
9%"|h J9+g}GyG gP$ h| 9$Otf ~@ ,AyG IOOgA}yG J9f9}AF:G i(S xyP
.J9]p9J}y9< I(fOyG ?!9|C )yE 9%"| #+zD}| ~]< IQGR(yG QGQsh ?"TyG Q9Z!C
.v$1415 eQJ|
IQGR( G

$R}G

(gS O+S

{ vh

/N

+WyG

? z ]p

:d

9s

B|9s Os ?+<9G* Gh ?yOAg}yG J9f9}GyG #| ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C fE


~+IQyG O=f )zf O}J| N+WyG ..,T"! ;p Q$R}G J:9FQ a9AvC )zf
Q9Z!C ?f9=h Q$R}G ($ )S9S}G ~$OFGQh {+v(yG #}IQyG O=f N+WyGh
)yE (fO@h ..uJyG #*OyG )yE (fO@ ?yOAg| ?+<9G*E ?f9= ,$ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
aO%y9p PGPpC A9}zf Q$R}G #| d9FQ 96 e9s jPyG 9}!Eh ..bO9ZyG O+I(AyG
?"Sh r+"JyG #*OyG ~+y9g@h uJyG #*Oy9< eRAz! 9"|O 9| IOIGh ?*9jyGh OIGh
.| d(SQyG
.

O+I(AyGh i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| JGOzG|h - ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= ?*(a|

)1(

47
R9<

? +fQW y

#<

uG

O =f

#< R*RgyG

* (gTyG ?+<QgyG

y? O

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

O=f N WyG ?|;gyG ?I9}S


?wz}}yG

e9f

)Aq|z
:d

9s

?+"S ?+|;SE ?f9= fGO(TyG ~C QZ| ,p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=


,c(zTyGh O=gAyGh ,O+I(AyG ,p I(="yG L9%"| )zf uG )yE (fO@ ,?+qzS
uh- 9%"f ahQg| ($ 9| GP$ ,?"TyGh H9AwyG )zf AGQ=yGh A:(yG Otg@h
,AyG J9g}AG}yG gP$ bSh ,p ?tJyG #+}zT}yG ?f9= {D}@ ,%p -O}JyG
?=z_h A9}zgyG #| GQk +Dv 9tk zL ~6 uG hq! Osh ,{J"yGh bQqyG YG(!z< Hg@
Q9Y 9}!E y?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=z ~S}G GP$h ,S9"yG ?|9fh ,~zgyG
Otfh .?z]}yG AG($}Gh YO=yG 9%AzLO ,AyG bQqyGh J9f9}GyG e9|C &< R+}AAy
uG ,p >JyGh ?"TyGh H9AwyG )zf 9}!Eh ~S G GP$ )zf U+y AGQ=yGh A:(yG
.uG ,p ^j=yGh
Qg
?wz}}yG

y?

*(WyG

e9f

+|;S

OgS

) Aq |

#<

(AvOyG

?I9}S >Aw}<

(J=yG

G K

O}J|

Q9WAT}yGz

?zG| Q QJ@ U

+FQh

9s
~%y O%W! U9MVC 9%+zf e9s &A}IQh uG {]q< ?zG| O+I(AyG ?zG|
i(="yG iO%yG ~S9< B8W!C P"| O+I(AyG ?zG|h ,u+p(AyGh M;ZyGh Q+My9<
#*PyGh ..&!G(LC gOf9Sh y z )tqyG O|9I N+WyG ?z+]p 96 e9s P"|h
?J+JZyG IO+tgyGh O+I(AyG )yE S9"yG G(fOh ,GhOOGp ~$OfG(S #f GhQ}V
.9%zv 9+!OyG Y9t< )yE &A}IQh uG {]q< ~7(fO JOA|Gh QZ| ,p
:d

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

48

& @;p

Q}f N WyG

?|Qw}yG ?w}< E OJyG

y?

+|; S

QGO

?g|9GyG

?SQO| Q O|z

e9f

#+ | Ch

9s
J(Y 98(v )yE ?p9\ 9< ,?+|;S G ?|}G e(}$ {}; O+I(AyG ?zG|
k
e(}$ 9]*C {}; ,%p ,IP(gWyGh J9pGQMyGh cQWyGh YO=yG ?<Q9J| ,p i(s
.~$O\ c9; ,AyG JGQ|G|}yG #| #+}zT}yG ?+f(@ ,p cQ9W@h ?|}G
:d

*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG
jQ

(WyG

?wz}}yG

UzG|

9"+=! #+zSQ}yG aQVC )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh #+}y9gyG HQ u O}JyG


?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= f{p Og<h .#+g=C &=JYh &yB )zfh O}J|
H9JYC 9%AS9FQ )zf >s9g@h )tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG 9%TSC ,AyGh
O}J| N+WyGh {+v(yG #}IQyG O=f N+WyGh ,q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+WyG ?z+]qyG
h+}GyG )zf uG ?}IQ ~+IQyG O=f )zf O}J| N+WyGh )gp9WyG O+G}yG O=f
uG &!9fC #*OyG Q(! J(qY O}J| N+WyG ?z+]p 9%SCQ*h f6G 9%+zf e(t*h
9"M*9W| iOy ?Y9M<h r*QgAyG #f ?+"i 98C >TIC 9}+p ?f9}GyGh ,gOOSh
?}F9s uG 9%tph ?f9}Gy9p .uG ~%dqI 9!Q|C I:h ~%z=sh 9"F9%Fhh 9"F9}zfh
fG(\Q ?<9JZyG fOy #| Ky9ZyG rzTyG H%"| )zf {Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOy9<
e;S G N+Vh {="I #< O}IC e9| 9v f9TI{< ~%+g<9@h #+g<9AyGh ~%+zf uG
?gS ,p ?f9}GyGh .uG ~%}IQ H9$(yG O=f #< O}J| e9| Gh ?+}+@ #<
f(gyG O* O| )yE L9A; 9$Q(a@h 9%aaL )|9"@h 9%fhQp IQDvh 97(fO
OF9T}yG A9"<h e9A*}G ?y9qvh I(fOyG #*O9+| ,p Q+MyG {$C #| IOf9T}yGh
hza* #}| (FQC )"!Eh .I(fOyG >Avh {F9SQyG ?f9=_h ~zgyG ?=z_ ?*9fQh

49

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

GyG ,p uG cQ9< IQ+MyG ?f9}GyG gP$ ~fO {+=S ,p h+aAT* 9| dP< &+zf
.>+G| h+}S &!E )aMyG OOSh

O(%

& =Av

O+}I #< uG O=f #< Ky9Y

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

50
?

(="yG

*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG

OGT}yGh

eGQJyG
U

?wz}}yG

OGT}yG

+FQyG

fh

|W y

?|9gyG ?S9FQyG

> Aw|

9"+=! #+zSQ}yGh A9+=!}G aQVC )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh gOIh u O}JyG


.Og<h ..#+g=C &=JYh &yB )zfh O}J|
?+qzS ?+g= ?+<QgyG QZ| ?*Q(%= ,p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?+g= f{p
?t*Q_ )zf ?"TJyG ?df(}yGh ?}wJy9< &y(SQh uG )yE 9$D9]fC (fO*
?z+]p u=S}G 9%T+FQ O(Fh P"| 9"*Oy ?phQg| ?+g= ,$h Ky9ZyG rzTyG
QW"< 9%F9]fC ?aSG(< ?+g}GyG e(t@h , j )tqyG O|9I O}J| /N+WyG
.?gp9"yG >AwyG h=_h ?+qzTyG I(fOyG
,p Q}ATAy ?+g}GyG gP$ ~fO )yE f9TI Gh Q+MyG {$C (fOC ,!{p GPy
o ~79"TI #*RG(| ,p xyP uG {gF 9%Ay9SQ AGOC

+*)('& 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . - ,
.

]20

?*6G :{|q R}o yG[ p

...up(}yG uGh

j(="yG

OGT}yGh

eGQJyG

eGQJyG

OGT}yG

fh|Wy e9gyG

OGT}yG >+aLh e9|E

{+=TyG

uG

O=f #< O}J|

U+FQyG

51
H

? +fQW y

%"|h ?"TyGh

uJyG

)zf ,AyG
?|

A9Ap Gh

?+}zgyG

}G

K(J=yG IQGOE
A9}zgyG Q9=v

v$1415/3/13

?S9+Ty

?tJyG ?f9}GyG

Gh

,$

?+}v9Jy

9|

rzS

?S9FQ ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}}yG

?8+%y ?|9gyG ?!9|}G

N * Q9 @ h

)16872(

~s Q

i(Ap

Og<h ..gOg< ,=! : #| )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh gOIh u O}JyG


)yE OQh 9| )zf A9Ap Gh ?+}zgyG K(J=zy ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG Bgz_G Otp
.O;GyG O}IC QqgF #*OyG r+S /,AqAT}yG #| e9gyG )Aq}yG ?I9}S
)4206( ~sQ< A9}zgyG Q9=v ?8+%y ?|9gyG ?!9|}G #| ?"GzyG )yE d9J}yGh
.v$1414/9/16 N*Q9@h
k
,p 9!O"f QhO* N+WyG ?I9}S( &Z! GP$ :G|S )AqAT}yG dzS Osh
A9FQy9p W9t"yG ^g< d(I bjyh dOF 9%Tq! ?+qzTyG ?f9}GyG #+<h fGO(TyG
k
k
.&"*O ,p 9%tph 9}zf ~v9*Eh uG 9!OGR 9"y 9%J+\(@ ~wAI9}S #|
#f I(L G ^g< LQL ~w*Oy ?phQg| ?f9= ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=
~w@OzF )"< #| ?f9=( 98z< 98(qZ*h 98(=99 GhQ9Yh ?f9}GyG bL
I(L G A:|$ rYh GPw$ )Q9"yG ,p g(pPs ~69FC #| ~wA"Tyz< f(}zwA*
)zf GOk9}AfG ?qZyG gP6 ?f9}GyG gP$ )~+tAT}yG &t*Q_ ~$9*Eh uG 9!GO$(
:,@6G ,p [MzA@ ~$O9gA<G H9=SCh )?"AqyG E*OI( f9}+yG #< ?q*PI E*OI
&!hQ=Ag* ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!z< fGO(TyG ,p ?+qzTyG ?f9}GyG ?+}T@
.?y9]yG J9f9}GyGh HGRI}G #| 9$Q+jv HRI ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= .?fO<
?+qzTyG I(fOyG a(qY ,p 9sk 9tW!G KOIC Y(\(}yG GP$ N+WyG ?I9}S
G(zgF &+"_G(| ?|9f Oz< ,p O+I(AyG )yE I(fOyG IQ+T| b(g*h b9f Os
:

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

52

rt* H9=WyG #| ?f9}GyG gP$ )yE )}A"* #| BzgF {< .~%y 9Gk %"| ?+p(ZyG
I(fOyG haAT@ ~y GPE dD9TAyG Q9Y {< ?uJyG #| h| iQO* : Q9AJ}yG rs(|
r+wp 9%Tq! )zf BtW!Ch #+z+ztyG 9$OGQpC h+}: fGO(TyG ,p ?+qzTyG
Q%d+S uG fz< uG A9V fE e9AyG #+t+yG h| ?~y9gyG A9J!C ,p #+}zT}yG h}GAS
.)#*OyG AGOfCh {_9=yG Q|O*h uJyG
,p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fz< B<9FC A9AqAS;y ?"GzyG ?SGQO Og<h
L9%"| )zf uG )yE (fO@ ,?+qzS ?+"S ?+|;SE ?f9= fGO(TyG ,p ~C QZ|
H9AwyG )zf AGQ=yGh A:(yG Otg@h ,c(zTyGh O=gAyGh ,O+I(AyG ,p I(="yG
#+}zT}yG ?f9= {D}@ ,%p -O}JyG uh- 9%"f ahQg| ($ 9| GP$ ,?"TyGh
uG hq! Osh ,{J"yGh bQqyG YG(!z< Hg@ ,AyG J9g}AG}yG gP$ bSh ,p ?tJyG
?f9=( ~S:G GP$h ,S9"yG ?|9fh ,~zgyG ?=z_h A9}zgyG #| GQk +Dv 9tk zL ~6
,AyG bQqyGh J9f9}GyG e9|C &< R+}AAy Q9Y 9}!E )?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C
.?z]}yG AG($}Gh YO=yG 9%AzLGO
?"TyGh H9AwyG )zf ($ 9}!Eh ~S}G GP$ )zf U+y AGQ=yGh A:(yG Otfh
.uG ,p ^j=yGh uG ,p >JyGh
hC GP$ ,p )gS #|h ,~%A}zv u*Qq@ :h ,~%sQq@ R(G* ;p GP%yh
f(AqyG #| GP$h ,&Tq! ~zch ,~%+zf iOAfG Otp B+t}yG HRJAy9< ~$9|Q
| ,="yG iO$ ~SQA@ ,AyG #+}zT}yG ?f9= u*Qq@h rZyG YOY ,p
O*Q* #| )yE J9qAy:G eOfh ,#zgyGh QTyG ,p uG i(tA< 9"Tq!Ch ~w+Y(!h
S9"yG #+< gQW!h hp9"yG ~zgyG #| OhRAyG )zf UQJyGh ,?}zwyG u*Qq@
Q*PJAyGh ,&@9qYh &F9}SC ,ph &@O9=f ,p )y9g@h &!9J=S uG O+I(@ ?Y9M<h
.u+p(AyG u9<h e;S G )zf ~v9*Eh uG 9"A=C .?z]}yG bQayGh cQWyG #|
,,,,~zSh &=JYh &yBh O}J| 9"+=! )zf uG )zYh

53

? +fQW y

)1 (

9Ap

Gh

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?+}zgyG K(J=zy ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG

9< #< uG O=f #< R*RgyG O=f U+FQyG

O*R (<C uG O=f #< Qw< /(]f


N+WyG dB O}J| #< uG O=f #< R*RgyG O=f /(]f
fGR

(q y G

fGR

(p #< Ky9Y /(]f

. )v$1411(

? " Ty

QqY OOf :O+I(AyG ?zG|

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

54
j

(AqyG )zf

u zg@

)fO< h}: )zf e(t@ ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fC fGO(TyG ,p S9"yG ^g< #c
)zf 9$AGQ<h 9%F:h Otg@ ,AyG iQL}G J9f9}GyGh HGRI}G QF9Tv )<RI
#|h 9%f9=@G eRz@ ?f9_h h}S 9%=tg* Q|}G )yh ?g+=v ?g+< 9%yh ?+}TAyG gP$
gO+tf )zf Q}ASG fGh ?+g}Gv 9%vQ@ (y )"g*( #+sQ9}yG #| Og* 9%+zf LQL
gP$ {D| GhQ9CG xyPyh .?+z$9F ?A+| J(}* &!9p ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C H%"|h
k
gOt! ,p hFGQh- ;+Zq@h ?z= zaL GP$h fGO(TyG ,p ?f9}GyG #f J9%=WyG
- 9%G%"| - 9%pGO$C - 97zW! y?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=z ?y9SQ {+ZqAy9<
?g|9F #| gGQ(AvO ?y9SQ ,$h Q$9ayG O}J| O}IC /Q(AvOyG OGOfE )9$O(%F

QtyG eC
?+qzS I(fO ?f9= ,$ fGO(TyGh QZ| ,p ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fC f9+< &+ph
#| ahQg}yG OhOI ,p e9d"yG GP6 aQAg@ h=ay9<h ?yhOyG e9d! #| ?tD="|
,p ~%Af9_ >: #*PyG Q(|}G A9+yhC e;S G O;< ,p e9wJyG Q=Ag@h YQWyG
^*QJAyG :h r+Ty9< ~7P<9"| :h ~%+zf LhQMyG R(G* :h ahQg}yG
?A+| J9| gO;< ~v9Jy &g+< &t"f ,p U+yh J9| #|h gQ+j< :h e;wy9< ~%+zf
e9| G #f f9|RyG Q(jV ?*Qd! I9fO &< d(t* 9}< f(y(t* ;p &+zfh ?+z$9F
{FGO< ~$O9tAfG ,p ,$ J9f9= f(!(vw* 9%+zfh 9!QZf LQG(L 9$9"=A* ,AyGh
?g+< J9f9}GyG gP$ AGQ|} f(w* &+zfh >F9jyG e9| G d9}f9< e9+tzy ?+zIQ|
?+zIQ}yG ehRy xyP {v9V9|h ?*O"Fh ?f9_h h}S 9%=tg*h -G(}fR- ?+fQV
-?}F9tyG J9|(wJyG )zf H(C(zy ?YQqyG BJ"S fE f(Z<QA* ~C- I9fO}yG
v
f9p :Eh IQ(ZyG gP6 )f9}GyG {}gyG f(+!9<QyG A9}zgyG YO< >=TyG GP%yh
{}gyG f(fO=* ;p O(}J| Q|C )fQWyG fh9gAyG fC GOk +F f(}zg* A9}zgyG
upG(}yG )f9}GyG {}gyG {< b;_{< xyPv &!hR+G* :h b;_{< )f9}GyG
)yE (fO* : jPyGh ?f9ayGh Q+MyG )zf S9"yG h}G* jPyGh ?"Tzyh H9Awzy
.j

55

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q+i )zf AGQ=yGh A:(yG Otg* :h I:(yG )zf LhQMyG )yE :h HRJAyG
.?|}G bQq@ ,p O*R* :h &y9}fCh e;S G
:h ?*QS &+p f(w* :h h}AG}yGh ?|}G Q%c ,p #g_ IGOC f(w* :h
d(t* ?"TyGh H9AwyG xyP )zf dO O(}J| ($ {< &+p A,V : GP%p &*O"F
409.UQ$9ayG O}J| O}IC /O y?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=z ?y9SQ >I9Y
{c ,p rzTyG H%"| B"=@ ?*(fO ?f9= ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=h
?pQg|h fPz< ?}F9s ,$h >ZgAyGh )<RJyG h}GAyG #f IO+g< )fQWyG fh9gAyG
?"GzyG i(Ap JQOY {+ZqAyG GP$ (J! )zfh yfGO(TyGh QZ| ,p J9azTyG
R9< #< R*RgyG O=f N+WyG ?S9FQ< ?}FGOyG

VVV

)p x+@z+S ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= )p ~zgyG {$C dG(sC 9!QvP fC Og<h


k
Q9Z!C ?f9= ~S9< 9!9+IC ?z*P| ?f9}Gzy rsG(|h dG(sC ?+y9AyG J9JqZyG
hs(* &"wyh -)tqyG O|9I N+WyG ?z+]p ($h 9%zD}* #| ~S9< 9!k 9+ICh- ?"TyG
k
:($ dG|TyGh e(zg| ($ 9}v &ZMW< U+yh ?f9}Gzy 9T+FQ &AqZ<
?rsG(}yGh dG(s}G gP$

>T"@ #}y

P$ QGOYE #f #+y(8T}yG A9}zgy9< ?|9@ ?pQg| )zf Q9tyG f(w* )wzp


A9}zf ?8+$ A9}SC xy QvPC Q|}G )y(y JGO+*zAyGh J9g*9=}yGh J9!9+=yG
9%dqI9p v$1356 ?"S i(="yG iO%yG ?zG}y dh}G OOgy9< JQW! 9}v ?f9}GyG
k
.)y9g@ uG A9V fE 9%+yE L9AJAS 9}AJp
g

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

56

"

)1(
? TyG

Q9Z C

?f9}F

A9}zf

?8

+$

OF9T}yG XAq| ,,y9|QyG ~+zJyG O=f O}J| N+WyG .Q$R}G A9}zf #| ,,tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG .?+fQWyG ~v9J}y9< )\9tyG ,Qv9V O}IC N+WyG .?g*QWyG ?+zw< SQO}yG ,,!9=tyG e;TyG O=f O}J| N+WyG .IQ$9ty9< e9f efGh ,j(T+f H9$(yG O=f N+WyG .>+aLh e9|E ,Q}+M| O}J| O}J| N+WyG .?g*QWyG ,p [ZMAyG H*QL ,,q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+WyG .>+aLh e9|E ,,s9=yG O=f ~+$GQ<E N+WyG .>+aLh e9|E ,jO}I O}J| N+WyG .>+aLh e9|E ,e;TyG O=f O+}JyG O=f N+WyG .

. v$1356

?"Ty 1 OOf i(="yG iO%yG ?zG|

)1(

57

? +fQW y

(\(}yG )yE

J 9f

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{ LO |

O+tf ,$ ~7O+tf fC ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C IO+tgy 9!QvP #| Q%c


gP$ MQW! fC 9"pO$ U+yh f(fO* 9%+yEh f("*O* 96 ,AyG Ky9ZyG rzTyG
h+= ,p ?"TyG {$C d(YC u+=a@ ,p 9"L(+V dG(sC QvP! fC hC ?z|9v IO+tgyG
?*OtgyG 9*9]tyG #| Q+Dv ,p N(+WyG dG(sC h+}: )yE 9"t=S Otp O9tAf:G 9*9]s
,p ~%yG(sC J9AV h= ($ EJ=yG GP$ ?<9Av #| aO%yG 9}!Eh {\9pC N(+V
,p I(fOyG ?I9S #f 9=k F9i K=YC ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C d(YC #| e9$ {YC
rzTyG >$P| )yE B}@ : ?z+LO H$9"|h ?+FQ9L Q9wpC &zJ| {Ih- 9"!9|R
H%"}yG GP$ ?<Qi uG )yE (wW! 9"J=YC Oty -gQT*C 9|h A9fO G :E ?zZ<
- O9tAf:G d(YC ,p >Aw* 9}"+I -rS~yh- ~%"| GQk +Dv f{p gA9+fOC bSh
d(Y~y J9qy9M}yG O: u+=aAyG O"f &"wyh QvP@ ?qy9M| &+zf PLz@ O9w@ :
Og< eRgyG 9!Otf jPyG GP$ ,p Q\9I 9!O"f d9D}yGh -K\(@ fC #| K\hC
.&J+\(@h &"++=@ )zf -~zgyG {$C IQ9WASGh- )y9g@ &zyG IQ9MASE
eC ?g|9F #| IO+tgyG ,p Q+ATF9}yG ?FQO {+"y ?|Ot| ?+}zf ?SGQO )p *
)zf &zyG O=f #< up(| >y9ayG 9$OGOf{< e9s ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}}y9< iQtyG
:aGQV9< SOv
:#| {v ?Ws9"|h OhGO R*RgyG O=f O}J| /O.C
.OVQ}yG R*RgyG O=f /O .C ,,G+|OyG Q}f #< &zyG O=f /O .C
QvP y?+qzTyG IO+tgyG QW! ,p )tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG O(%Fz fG("g<
k
.v 366vY :&+p d9tp y~%y KZ"yGh ?}F:G ?f9_z fG("g< 9DJ=|
I

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

58

,!9DyG
%y

EJ=}yG

"

KZ yGh ?}F

}G

?f9_

Ofh Q|}G )yhC ?f9_ ($ ?yzT}yG gP$ ,p ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C H%"| fE
k
)y9g@ &zyG Q|} :9DA|G ?"TyGh H9Awy9< #+wT}A| G(|GO 9| ~%+zf LhQMyG
.| &y(SQ Q|}h
` _ ^ ] \ [ Z Y X W Vo :,y9g@ d9s
e

onmlkjihgfedcba
x
.
?*6 9T"y p!@
! z~ q p
]59

W
W
G :A

G[

g+_Ch G(g}SGz | &zyG d(SQ d9s :d9s


xy9| #< U!C #fh
. y?=+<R &SCQ fzv )W=I O=f ~w+zf {}gASG
Y9_C Otp )"f9_C #|z | &zyG d(SQ d9s :d9s
IQ*Q$ )<C #fh
[g* #|h )"f9_C Otp Q+|}G ha* #|h ,&zyG )Zf Otp )!9Zf #|h ,&zyG
. y,!9Zf Otp Q+|}G
)zf ?f9ayGh h}TyGz :d9s | ,="yG #f
Q}f #< &zyG O=f #fh
;p ?+Zg}< Q|C GP{p ,?+Zg}< Q||* ~y 9| ,gQvh >IC 9}+p ~zT}yG AQ}yG
. y?f9_ :h h}S
Q9+Lz :d9s | &zyG d(SQ #f &"f &zyG )\Q xy9| #< a(f #fh
QGQVh ,~%+zf f(zZ@h ~w+zf f(zZ*h ,~w!(=J*h ~8(=; #*PyG ~wA}FC

fEh G(

)1 (

)2 (

)3(

~sQ<

9 GyG H9Av- &F9| #<Gh

,-O %

/7142

~sQ<

9wI}G H9Av-

,-e

9 M=yG

iQ

gGhQ )1(

. 2860

~sQ< ,-IQ9| G H9Av- ~zT|h /7137 ~sQ< ,-e9wI}G H9Av- iQ9M=yG gGhQ
. 4763 ~sQ< ,-IQ9| G H9Av- ~zT|h /7144 ~sQ< ,-e9wI}G H9Av- iQ9M=yG gGhQ

4747

)2(
)3(

59

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

S 9* :{+s .~w!("gz*h ~8("gz@h ~w!(]j=*h ~8(]j=@ #*PyG ~wA}FC


#| ~A*CQ GPEh ,I;ZyG ~w+p G(|9sC 9| :z :d9s ?r+Ty9< ~$P<9"! ;pC &zyG
k
k
. y?f9_ #| GO* G(fR"@ :h &z}f G($Qv9p &!($Qw@ 98+V ~w@:h
A9F GPE :E e9| G )zf LhQMyG R(G* : &!C )zf Bt=_C ?yO}G h+}Gp
k
.9tza| R(G* ;p xyP Q+i 9|C f9$Q< &zyG #| &+p MG(< Qqw<
)zf ?=FGh &y(SQh &zyG ?f9apz :&zyG &}IQ ?+}+@ #<G e;S G N+V d9s
&y(SQh &zyG Y9_C #}p ,~%Af9a< &zyG Q|} ?=FGh Q(|}G I:h ?f9_h OIC {v
#| gPLz* 9}y :E ~%g+a* : f9v #|h ,&zyG )zf gQFzp &zy Q|}G I:h ?f9a<
#| IQL6G ,p &y 9}p ;~$9Zf g(g"| fEh ~%f9_C g(afC f{p ,d9}yGh ?*:(yG
. yb;L
hC GQk < ,e9| G h| ~F9s V9| O9%GyGhz :-&zyG &}IQ- O}IC e9| G d9sh
m
h| fGO+gyGh HJyGh ?g}GyGh ,dO9f dOf :h QF9F Q(F &za=* :h GQk F9p
k
{Fh Rf &zyG g:h #}y O9+t!:Gh ...A9+t@C :hOf IQQ< G(!(w* ~y fEh ?}F}G
9Fk Qp xy &zyG {gG* ,xq+T< &+zf LQ< :h ?f9_ #| GOk * YR"@ : ,~vQ|C
Q|z< f9azTyG cQ|C f{p ,ha@h h}T@ {< f9azTyG )zf LQ< :h ,9Fk QM|h
&g"}@h &+zf LQ< fC xy U+yh &g+a@ fC xy U+zp ?+Zg| {Fh Rf &zy ($
. yf9Ty :h O+< ?"Ap )zf #g@ :h ,&tI
?g}GyG E*OJyG H9JYC iQ*hz :-&zyG &}IQ- )!(<9ZyG d9sh
,GQk F9p hC f9v GQk < ;~zT| e9|E {v rzL JG(zZyG #| 9}$Q+ih #*O+gyGh
~%y A9fOyG fhQ*h ,IQGp IQ(F G(!9v fEh ~%g| IQqwyG O9%F fhQ*h
d( Q

)1 (

)2 (

)3(

23999

~sQ< O"T}yG )p O}ICh ,4804 ~sQ< ,-IQ9|

9Av- ~zT| gGhQ )1(


. )17,16/35( ih9AqyG Y(}G| )2(
. )46 :U( d;Mzy ?"TyG :Qd!G )3(
G H

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

60

r+Ty9< ~%+zf LhQMyG fhQ* :h ,M;ZyGh u+p(AyGh M;Y 9<


)AI ?+i9=yG ?8qyG d9As fhQ*h ,r+JyGh Q(GyG )yE dOgyG #f dhOgyG ~%"|
. ydOgyG e9| G ?f9_ )yE hFQ@
?+]tyG gP$ ,p rzTyG -&zyG &}IQ- )tqyG O|9I N+WyG upGh Otyh
&F9fOh &!9|R ,p e9wJyG )zf gD9"Ch &@9<9Av ,p gP$ Q%d* f9v E+I 9$Q+jv
9$QW!h ?g+=yGh IQZ"yGh O+*zAyG {F9SQ ~%y &y9SQEh ,OGOTyGh M;Zy9< ~%y
. j(="yG iO%yG ?zG| d;L #|
k
)yE L9AJ* {}G| &"wyh ;+= 9=k +_ 9|k ;v ?y9SQyG Og| gQvP jPyG GP$h
O$G(WyG QvP< 9}!Eh f9+=yGh MQWy9< U+y d9=5y {+ZqAyG GP$h {+Zq@
k
~C ?*Qd"yG ?+I9"yG #| 9+k qzS ;YC 9"| AQ}yG )"=A* fC BT+y ?+]ty9p d9D|}Gh
hpGO*h gOtAg* 9}< f9T! G xT}AT* fC fzWyG {v fzWyG {< 9+k z}f &+zf LQM*
JOGORG 9}zv H9=y9< A9"Af:G OGOR* &!C rzTyG O"f IOf9tyG {< &+yE (fO*h &"f
k
k
($ jPyG I:(yG )zf LhQMyG u*Qay 9s;iEh #AqyG H9=y GOS &+yE ?|}G ?F9I
d9FQ 9%"| Hyhh #Aqzy HG(<C BJAp Osh xy9< 9}p- #*OyGh 9+!OyG O9Tp {YC
#| ~8C f(fO*h {< ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C f9Tz< f(COJA*h 9"@OzF )"< #|
{< )yh}G Q(ZgyG LQG(L ,p IO(F(| #w@ ~y ?}S gP$h E*OJyG {$C
~8C 9$Q+Tq@ ,p KFGQyGh y?*Q=yG Q+L d(s #| f(y(t*z 9"!9|Ry JQLOG
GP$ d(I A9}zgyG fO!O* fC xyP uJAT* :C | &zyG d(SQ E*O9IG f(y(t*
GP%p e9wJyG :E eOM* : e;wyG GP$ fE &y(t< dPM| x"yPM* :h -{Y}G
&y GOkQ xyP< ,qvh ,qzTyG {Y}G GP6 AGOAf:G eOf )zf )"=| r=L &y e;v
GhCQ fEh ,

)1 (

)2 (

)3(

rzTyG IO+tf )1(


3 OOf 20 OzG| xyPvh )18 :U( 12 OOf ,16 OzG| i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| Qd!G )2(
. )294(

. )14 :U(
.

?"Ty9< fhPLz* :h 9"<Q H9Av 9"=TI f(y(t* G(!9v >y9_ )<C #< )zf )zf G(FQL #*PyG )3(

61

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{< ~$OIh e9wJyG )zf IOF9f BT+y IOF9qy9p xyP #f aQayG 9"+]iC fEh
)zf IOF9f ,$ xyP h+= #| ~$C {< )yhC H9< #| ?+fQyG )zf IOF9f ,$
,p xyP f9v 9}zv #+}zT}yG O;< f9|}Gh #|}G ~f 9}zwp 9$Q9WA!Gh I(fOyG
A9+fOC #+< eGOY KOI 9}zvh ?"TyGh H9AwyG )yE I(fOyG Q9WA!Gh ?JzZ|
#++!9<QyG I9fOyGh I(fOyG )zf u++]AyG ~@ 9}zv ?}v9JyG J9azTyGh #*OyG
- ~zgyG ShQOh OF9T}yG )zf H9=WyG d9=sE #| ?g!9| ?"Ap eGOZyG GP$ f9vh
~A"v fE #|}9< uIC #+t*QqyG izpz d9tAf:G ?+WL -ShQO JOFh fE GP$
Qd!9p QFGRGyG {D| Oz< )yE cQd! BqyC fC )yE ?F9I ,p BTy B!Ch yf(}zg@
O+gTy9p IQ=f 9%+p xy #w+yh 9$Og<h ~v9JyG )zf LhQMyG KGOIC {=s 9%+yE
.gQ+j< efh #|
Q(AvOyG d(t* .&Ash GP$ U+y Y(\(}yG GP$ ,p e;wyG fE {F9s d(t* Os
JQ9_ GPEC ?fPE &Ash )A| &zyG f9J=Sz &zyG &}IQ UFQ< e;TyG O=f
GP$ ,p e;wyG fE ?#|}G hpQh )\(qyG B}f GPEC ?A9|OyG BwqSh ShDQyG
?Y9L e9*}G gP$ ,p ~zgyG ?=z_h A9}zgyG {=s #| rDw*o fC >G* Y(\(}yG
#| ePGQV &|9|R O9s H9=yG GP$ ,p iQwp K(z@ #| S9"yG #| e98qy {ZI 9}y
{$C IO+tf )zf G(V(Vh O9TpE 9}*C GhOTpzp ?z+LOyG J9$9::G H9JYC
HGJyGh IOS9qyG &=WyG #| g(tyC 9}< Q+aMyG H9=yG GP$ ,p ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG
h}TyGh ?g+=yG Y(\(| fEz d(t*h A:|$ O(Fh Qw"* #}< QAj@ :h .IOS9wyG
.yOIC &+p xwW* ~y ?f9ayGh
hC &+zf ~$ 9}< ~%q+"Z@ #| )WM* ~%+zf QATA| 9|E #+zFQ OIC &!{p
.&+p S9"yG 9| iQO* : {$9F
&zyG {+=S #f S9"yG OY #f G(%A"+yh f(qFQ}yG A:|$ )y9g@ &zyG uA+zp
k
hC ?+$G(yG &=WyG gP$ {D}< IOS9qyG ~%=$GP}y 9G*hQ@ hC ~6GRI} ?|OL )y9g@
k
.&zyG #| iO$ Q+j< ~%FG($} 9f9=@G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

62

y QWyG U(Z! ,p {|zA* fC M;qyGh I9G"yG &Tq"y OGQC #| )zfh


O=gyG f9p 9!9azS &+zf i(%zy {gG* :h 9%y #fP*h 96 {}g+p H9=yG GP$ ,p
QDvCh .Q%a}yG YQWyG &< A9F 9}y 9gk =@ gG($ f(w* )AI f9}*:G ?t+tI kz=* :
)zf {tgyG ~*Ot@h i(%yG Y9=@G AGQF #| ($ 9}!E H9=yG GP$ ,p S9"yG O9Tp
.y?"TyGh H9AwyG A(\ ,p e9wJyG ?z|9g|z U+q"yG &<9Av hFGQz {t"yG
Q9Z!C ?f9= N*9W|h A9}zgy U(Z! uJyG >y9_ 9* f6G x*O* #+<h
PFG("y9< 9%+zf ^fh 9$PMp ,qzTyG {Y}G GP$ u+=a@ ,p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
.y#GyGh U!}G #+_9+V #| cP9fCh h}T@h CQt@ 9}< &zyG xgq!
IOQG( G Y

63

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F ?g*9=| ,p ?|9%yG ?+M*Q9AyG ?t+C(yG gP$ f6G xy QvPGh
ydh}G bhQ9pz O;=yG
)?

xz}y ?*O}J}yG

+|(}gyG ?+g}GyG

O 9t g E(

?"S Q=}T*O 20 ,1356 ?"S dG(V 17 upG(}yG #+"C:G A9T| ,p


?z+]p ?S9FQ< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy ?+|(}gyG ?+g}GyG JOtg!C
#+<h U+FQyG ?z+]p ~zwAp ?f9}Gzy ~FGOyG U+FQyG )tqyG O|9I N+WyG P9AS}G
Q9WA!}G #| I(fOyG Bjz< 9|h d9}f}G #| IQGO G UzG| &< e9s 9| A9]f~y
bhO"ZyG #+|C IQ]I eOt@ ~C QTyG ~@9wp >sGQ}yG ~C ?f9}GyG {+vh g;@ ~C
.?f9}GyG ?+!GR+| VQfh
1937

-:,@69v

?G+A"yG B!9wp

J9<9MA!:G

?+z}f B*QFC ~C

{+vh ,q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+WyG )1(


.,!9C {+vh ~V9$ #+TI iO"pC O}J| )2(
.bhO"Y #+|C f9}+zS Ky9Y iO"pC O}J| )3(
.QS ~@9v O*R* 9<C iO"pC >$P )4(
.>sGQ| #+TI iO"pC r+azyG O=f )5(
.(]f fGOgS Ky9Y iO"pC O}J| )6(
.(]f fG(\Q iO"pG O+S )7(
.(]f ?V9wf iO"pC r*QV )8(
.(]f O}J| iO"pC uG O=f )9(
.(]f )\9tyG )zf iO"pC O}J| )10(
.(]f f9}+zS gO=f iO"pC O}J| )11(
.dhC

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

64

]f )!G(zJyG O}J| iO"pC f9}Df )12(


.(]f Q(V9f uG O=f O}J| )13(
-:~$A9}SG ?+@6G ?*O"p}G JGQ]I IQGO G B"+f Osh
.(]f RgyG (<C O}IC f9]|Q )14(
.(]f gR}I O}J| N+WyG )15(
.(]f iQ(wS ~+$GQ<E Ky9Y )16(
.(]f O}J| &_ O}IC )17(
.(]f i(+zJyG bGRQyG O=f )18(
GP$ xz}yG ?y;F )yE U;LEh A:h ?+sQ<?f9}GyG BsQ<C ?=S9"}yG gP6h
)yE G(gpQ@ fC (FQ! QZ| #*O<9f A9"|}G Q+=v )y9g}yG >I9Y IQ]Iz 9%Z!
.y?+wz}yG IOTyG
9$O9tg!G ?=S9"}< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy ?+|(}gyG ?+g}GyG fC
dh}G bhQ9qyG ?y;Gy A:(yG [y9L eOt@ IQGO G UzG| H9MA!: i("TyG
?"Tzy GQk Y9!h e;S5y 9"k ZI gA9t< {+a* fC uG dzT@h e;S G )|9I
~C y,tqyG O|9I O}J| :?f9}GyG U+FQz R*RgyG gQZ"< gO*|* fCh ?*O}J}yG
:?+wz}yG iGQTyG #| )@6G OQyG ?f9}GyG Btz@
?"TyG Q9Z!C ?+g= U+FQ )tqyG O|9I O}J| P9AS}G eQAJ}yG IQ]I
9| )zf )|9TyG QwWyG A9]f}G JGQ]Ih ~w@Q]I Z;<{< aQW@C ?*O}J}yG
xz}yG 9!:(| ?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]Jy J9+"}AyG bO9Yh A:(yG #| &"f ~A<QfC
...~dg}yG
.(

A
.vv24v

9"|}G Q+=v

Y )yh}G ?"TyG 8 OOgy9< JQW!

65

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

:?|9$

?+}v9Jy

?dI;|

9v fEh IQGO G UzG| A9]fC #}\ Qv9V O}IC N+WyG ~SG QvP* ~y
?+fQWyG ~v9J}y9< 9+k \9s {}g* f9v &!} GQk d! ?f9}GyG A9}zf ?8+$ OIC
JGQGOE UzG| A9]fC #}\ G(!(w* fC I9]tyG )zf QdJ* f(!9tyGh
. 15 OzG}yG hFGQh J9+g}GyG
)yh}G ?"Tzy )!9DyG OOgzy ?+I9AApG ?y9t| )tqyG O|9I N+WyG ?z+]p >Avh
#|R P"| e;S G I(fO #f e;wyG 9%+p d9_C v$1356 ?"S dh}G iO9=
#| IQ+L h| BTSzpz :&y(t< d9t}yG ~ALh
gQZf )AI | uG d(SQ
O}JyGh 9%y K=YCh .B]| ?"S #*QWf (J! #| ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= )!G(LE
AG(y B; i(]"* uG O}J< K=YGh .9$Q+ih IQ$9tyG ,p YhQp IOf u
-jRyGh ~S:Gh i(fOy9< :- ?J+JZyG ?*O}J}yG ?"TyGh [y9MyG O+I(AyG
Q=g}yG f9TzyGh ,IQwqyG gP$ IO+yh i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| gP$h .{+zs Q+i OOf
,AyG yM;Y:Gz BLC ,$h .?aMyG gP%y ~SGQyG ~ztyGh i(fOyG gP$ #f
k
k
GQh9G|h iQtyG ez< e9t}y9< 9pQWA| B"v e(* eGQJyG uG Oz=< 9$QOYG B"v
OVGQyG xz}yGh KzZ}yG e9| G ?y;F ?|(wJy 9|k O9Lh aQW}yG uG B+=y
.gO*OT@h gQZ!h gO+*z@ uG eGOC )O(gS dB R*RgyG O=f( [zM}yG
H9WyG xz}yG ?y;F )y(A< BzcC ,AyG IO+gTyG ?YQqyG gP$ R%A!} ,!Eh
gP$ ,p xz}yG e9|R &|;ASGh ?*Q(ASOyG QZ| O+y9t| )dh}G bhQ9p( Ky9ZyG
k
Q9Z!C ?f9= ~S9< eOszp -OVGQ 9}FGO ($h- OVQyG #S Z(z=< ?!(}+}yG e9*}G
e;S5y &dqJ* fC ~*QwyG uG dzSCh &Ay;Gy [y9MyG A:(yG ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
k
k
SQO!G 9| A9+I: &tp(* fCh #+}zT}yG f(+f &< Qt* fCh 9dp9Ih 98y9v QZ| ,p
,p e;S G hFQ* fCh JGQw"}yGh YO=yG #| &s(S e9s 9| &@9|Eh #*OyG #|
I9+JyG upGQ| {v ,ph IQGO Gh SQGO}yGh ~v9J}yG ,p &A!9w| )yE QZ|
O\ ~%A}zv h}G* fCh 9gk += #+}zT}yG c(z| O*|* fC &yzSC 9}v .?*QZ}yG
f

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

66

&yzSGh .Oy9MyG gRfh Oy9AyG gOG| e;S5y ~6 O+g* fCh ~$hOfh uG hOf
fCh IOVGQ ?q+JZyG gP$ {gG* fCh ~+tAT}yG &z+=S )zf 9"@G(aL OOT*
uG )zYh ~zf Q+j< uG )zfh #*OyG ,p d(tyGh {yRyGh zaMyG #| 9$Of9=*
.~zSh &=JYh &yB )zfh O}J| 9!O+S )zf

fC

,tqyG O|9I O}J|

?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= U+FQ

67

? +fQW y

vv24:12v
?|

bhQ9qyG

}G

1356

?S
"

?S9+Ty

Gh

Og y y

2 O

?+}v9Jy

G ) h} G

? Ty
"

MGQpC

+ (@

xz}yG ?y;F ? y

? fQWyG

J;qJ<

&AazTy

#S iOq}yG 9%w+z| Z(z=< GQkhQS ,e9*}G gP$ ,p {zJyG {=C QZ| BT=y
.b;L}Gh #*OyGh e;S G &< RfCh .gO+*z@h gQZ! uG eGOC OVQyG
iO9= 23 B=TyG A9T| ,p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= BzqAIG Osh
#| Q+p(yG OOgyG e9gyG RvQ}yG QGO ,p h}AF9p .~+dgyG KO9JyG GP6 )yh}G
e;S5y GAkOQ &zgG* fCh .bhQ9qyG ?y;F ,p cQ9=* fC uG f(yzT* ,YhQqyG
k
,#+"||}zy 9}zS f(w* fCh ,bhQ}yGh ?sO!RyGh O9Jy G iOG(f #| &z$Ch
k
.#*QA%AT}yGh #+sQ9}yG )zf 9<QI
bhQ9qyG

x z}yG

#_(yG ?|OL ,p &+J]AyG )zf &=gV O$9g*

U+}MyG A9T| Y9*P}yG ,p &=gV )yE xz}yG ?y;F KO;


:d9tp )yh}G
BgaASG (y iO(<h .?+JAyG >+_z< ~w+yE Eg<C H(=J}yG )=gVz
)=I QpGhh iQwV u+}f #f 9gk += ~wy HQf} ~w"| OQp {v ?Jp9Z|
.A:(yG bO9Yh >JyG [y9L #| i(J! g(}A*O<C 9| {wy iQ*Ot@ ~+dfh
9| {w< ~w+yE )]pC fC -?*Q(ASOyG )AazS JQV9< Osh- )!QT+y &!E
?dp9J}yGh ,?*QZ}yG ?|}G #+!G(sh Q(ASOy eGQAIG #| )Tq! &+zf B"_h
)@9+I rsh )zf ~vO$9fC fCh .&+\GQC ?|;Sh #_(yG d;tASG )zf
)AI 9%z$C IO9gSh 9%A}zv A;fEh 98zV RGRfEh O;=yG ?|OL )zf iO(%Fh
.O+G}yG 9%+\9}<h 96 IQ*OGyG ?!9w}y9< IOy9MyG 9!QZ}y Qqd!
iO = 21

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

68

9 < p 9=AfG {v {=s #_(yG Ky9Y eGhOyG )zf iOFGQ f(w* a(Tyh
k
eO9L dhC ~wwz|h &|GOL ~%zvh ,gO("F ~%zv .#_(zy xz| 9g+= QZ|
,p 9+k !9q@ ~vQDvC &*Oy ~w|QvCh ,&=FG(y ?*9fQ ~vOVC &+yE ~w=IC #_(zy
.#_(yG ?|OL
fh9g@h ,j(tyG {v Qp9]@ >zaA* #_(yG OG| fz< ~wIQ9YC )!C )zf
IA9"$h N|9V Rf #| 9%y g(FQ! 9| IR*RgyG 9!O;=y utJA* )AI J58+%yG h+=
.?z|9V IO9gSh ?}FGO
IQw=}yG #TyG gP$ ,p )t@9f )zf )tz@ fC JA9V Os uG IOGQE B!9v GPEh
Q(gWyG {v QgVC ,!{p ?+y(8T}y9< Y;a\:Gh ,xz}yG J9g=A< V(%"yG A>f
.>FG(yG AGOC {+=S ,p ?+J]@ iC O"f rsC #yh .J9=FG(yG #| )zf 9}<
.#_(yG IO9gSh ?|}G Q+L u+t;h
k
G(zg: fC ~w@9fR!h ~wy(+| a;ALG )zf 9g+= ~w< >+$} ,!Eh
.f(z}g@ 9}+p uG G(tA@ fCh ,#_(yGh >FG(yG ~vQ9gV
,A|} iQwV [y9L #f HQfC fC e9t}yG GP$ ,p )=FGh #| iQCh
9|h ghO<C 9}y f9}yQ=yGh ?+p(yG )A|(wJyh eGQwyG >!9F}G 9%p(+\h IR*RgyG
.A:(yGh U;L G J9*B #| &!hO=*
{+="yG )=gV
.u9< )AtC {=tAT}y9< uCGh ,~wF:(< Q(Mp ,~w< RAg| ,!E
k
.OT!h Rq! ,9g| {}g"yh ,eRgyG O_("zp
.y#_(yG )+J+yh

A " z .Q

69

? +fQW y

A9}zgyG

> FG

(< e(t*

A9}zgyG

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

N V

x+z}yG ?y;Gy KZ"yG #|

>I9Y IQ]I ~%M+V ~%SCQ )zfh ,r*QWyG Q$R}G A9}zf eOs


?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]Jy ?*Q9vP@ ?*O$ )iGQ}yG N+WyG Q=v}G P9AS}G ?z+]qyG
dh9"A< )yh}G iO9= 22 ?g}GyG e(* G(pQW@ fC Og< xyPh .~dg}yG xz}yG
:?+@6G ?}zwyG Q=v}G P9AS}G ?z+]p )tyCh .?+wz}yG IOF9}yG )zf AGOjyG
y?y;GyG >I9Y i:(|z
9"k +=| ;&+Ih 9jk z=| | GOk }J| 9!:(|h 9!O+S &A}wI BzF uG Q9ALGz
o ?}g"yG &"*O< uG ~@Ch ,&*O$ 9Jk \(| &<9Av
K+JZyG E*OJyG ,ph ?*6 O 9}y p
Q(|}G QVh | O}J| iO$ iO%yG Q+Lh uG H9Av E*OJyG #TIC fEz
.y979COJ|
~wwz| A9=fz< ~wAy;F Y;a\G ?=S9"}y GQk9vP@ Q$R}G A9}zf iCQ Otyhz
&+zf QOt* 9}| :h ,QW=yG h"Y #| BT+y ?*O6 ~w+yE G(|OtA* fC O+gTyG
f9azTyG >I9Y u 9}< IQvP| f(w@ fCh ,&!9J=S uG O"f #| ,$ {< ,QW=yG
,&!9J=S uG H9Av ?*Q9vPAyG ?*O%yG f(w@ fC GhQQs xyPy .b(tI #| ~w+zf
.yE*OI #| | &y(SQ #f KY 9|h
uG b(tJ< ~vQvPC ;?*O%yG gP6 ~wAy;F )yE eOt@C 9!Ch ,!E- i:(|z
.gO9=f b(tJ<h )y9g@h &!9J=S
?+fQzyh ,jO$h #+< 9}< {}gyG uIh ,,8h Q|C 9}+p ?f9ayG uI ua
g:h #|z K+JZyG E*OJyG ,ph .9$O9gSEh 9%y Q+MyG Q+p(@h 9%"+< dOgyG uI
q
>GAIG ~$Qtph ~%AzLh ~%AF9I fhO >GAI9p #+}zT}yG Q|C #| 98k +V uG
.ygQtph &AzLh &AF9I fhO &"f uG

SRQPO YXWVUT
]3

G :I F

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

70

?"TyGh H9Awy9< e9ZAf:G )zf ?+fQyG {}I i:(| 9* uG b(tI #|hz


#+< 9$QOs ?gpQh ?|}G IRf )yE ?zY(}yG ?gp9"yG d9}f}G )yE 9$O9VQEh
&}+y9g@ ,p OF(* :h .IRgyG )zf UQJyG OVC e;S G UQI Otp .~|}G
&"| HQt* 9| >$GP}yG #| gQ+i ,p OF(* :h ,~+y9gAyG gP$ #| OVC ($ 9|
.y~+y9gAyG gP$ )zf UQJyG ,p
>I xy ~*O* fCh cQZ!h x!(fh xA*9fQh x*O$ )y(A* fC uG dzSCz
.y>+G}yG h+}TyG ~g! &!E &y(SQ >Ih uG >J< x=zs ~}*h ,O9=gyG
k
k
A9}< gOzF )Tv Os 9q*QV 9qJZ| &Ay;F )yE &Az+]p eOs xyP Og<h
nr q
.,!9=+WyG h=*OyG #<: yd(Y}G h|9F )yE d(Y(yG Q+T+@z H9Av ~C >$PyG
:d9sh QwWy9< &Ay;F 9%z=tAp
y9%+zf UQJ* ?*O$ gP$ fEz
u*R9sRyG O%g| N+V f(+gyG (<C O(}J| N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]p d9tp
yGQk LP #*Ozy 9!:(| 9* uG xzgFz
yQ}f 9"y f9v fEz &Ay;F H9Fzp
k
)y(}yG ~g! &!E .GO+gS xwz| {gFh cQ}f ,p uG O|C :A9}zgyG d9tp
Q+Z"yG ~g!h
O+*zAyGh QZ"y9< xz}zy #+fGO G(pQZ!Ch &Ay;F ~%Jp9Y xyP Og<h
[zLC )iGQ}yG N+WyG ?z+]qyG >I9Y )yE eOt@ )j(="yG iO%yG( ?zG|h
?J+Z"yG gP$ h\(| {gG* fC uG dzT@h .aQW}yG rs(}yG GP$ )zf ?8"%AyG
xz}yG {=J< #*OyG {=I {gG* fCh .~*QwyG f9w}y9< bhQ9qyG xz}yG >zs #|
.d9Z@}G ~FGO

71

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

| hS9Ay Ogy y

)9:2U # (

,zf

G O

?+}v9Jy

G ) h} G

? Ty
"

O|9I N WyG u zg@h

?g|9GyG ?g}GyG ?=aL

Q$R}G h|9GyG N+V Q=v}G P9AS}G KzZ}yG e9|


v$1356

?"S IOgtyG

hP 12 e(*

Q$R}9< 9$9tyC ,AyG

,p

Q+=MyG ,{]* : jPyG ~+wJyG ,Q$9tyG R*RgyG ,QO9tyG )zgyG u O}JyG


k
,&!GQqi {$zAT! &< GO}I gO}J! .d9gA}yG Q+=wyG &!9J=S )T"* : jPyG
;?tza}yG ?+<(<Qy9< OI(@ uG :E &yE : fC O%W!h ;&!G(\Qh &qaf K"}AT!h
,&A*9fQh &!9TI9< ~$O|Ch ,&@QOt< uzMyG CQ<h ;IRgyGh d;Gy9< OQq@h
~AL #| ,~%z}vCh uzMyG {]pC )zf 9%}@Ch JG(zZyG {]pC )zZ!h
IhOs {]pC f9vh ;gO9%F uI uG ,p O$9Fh ;?!9|}G iOCh ,?y9SQyG
&<9JYCh &yB )zfh &+zf &|;Sh uG JG(zY O}J| 9!:(|h 9!O+S ,gO9=gy
~89azTy Bg]Lh ,~|}G ~%y B!GOp ?*GO%yG ~zf gOg< #| G(z}I #*PyG
k
.9}+df ~%+zf uG {]p f9vh ;H9sQyG
{ :,y9g@ uG d(t+p Og< 9|C

4? >3=2<1;0:/9 8 7 6 5
JTISH GRFQ/PEOD
C
B
A
@
N0MWLVKU

5 4 3o :,y9g@ uG d(t*h
O 9} y }
BA@?>=<;:9876
.
?*6 {J"y p!@
! ~| D C
[16-15 :I F

]97

G]

G :

G[

{=t* : 9}k *Qv ;dPyG aQg* : GRk *Rf e;S G >V S9S}G GP$ )zf
&< G(p(_h ,gOG| MhQY GhO+Vh ;gRf AG(y G(gpQ IQQ< eGQv &z}Ih ,~+]yG
G("Ap rzL ~$Og< #| rzL ~C ,f9w}yG h+pQ f9azTyG Pp9! ,b9p6G )p

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

72

~!9j| Q|}G G(=TI ,{+=TyG G(z\h JG(%WyG G(g=@Gh ,,!O}G I9+JyG VQg<
k
aQ@h ,f(wSh ?fO 9%+p JGPz}y9< IA(z}| 9+!Oh ,YR(@ 9<;SCh ,~Tt@
#f AG($}G ~%ApQYh ;~6(zs BTtp xyP ,p O|}G ~%+zf d9_h ,f(G|h
.&+yE G(!z}_Gh dPyG )zf GhQ=Yh ,~%y9I JA9Tp ,%y G iO%yG
,Q9f #*OAyG fC f9a+WyG ~%y d(Sh ,&zF9]ph e;S G d(YC #| G(zz;
#+!G(sh S(q"yG HP7 e9wIC #| uG YQV 9|h ;OF9tgyGh e(ZyGh I;ZyG fCh
96 xT}AT* fC u+z* : BzL fhQs #| ?+t< :E BT+y 9$OgT@h I9+JyG ~d"@
~%y d(S .?gA|h IPy #| 9%+p 9|h I9+JyG )"g| aQf jPyG #*O}A}yG {FQyG
JG(%WyG ,p d9SQAS:Gh QT+}yGh Q}MyG fCh ;Q9f #*OAyG fC f9a+WyG
.?+!O}yG UG(L #| ?Y9Lh ;?*QJyG #| Y(! ?+I9< G ,p S9}j!:Gh
#f G(pQZ!Gh ,~69Av GhP=!h ,~%"*O G(vQAp Q9f #*OAyG fC ~%y d(S
k
.?yPzy ;D|h ~|~y 9=8 GhQ9Zp ,{\9qyG uzMyGh ,Ky9ZyG {}gyG
;GhQ=Ag* ~zp Q=gyG ~%|9|C Bg<9A@h ,GhQ<OA* ~zp QP"yG ~%+zf ByG(@
: #| ~%+zf bzSh ,a(MyGh Y(GyG S9=y G(t*PCh ,?}zwyG ~%+zf BtJp
o ~%+p uG a9M*

IV UH G
F
E
D
C
B
A
T S R Q P O N MXL KWJ
.

]112

?*6G :{J"q yG[ p!@


! vv w

O+g< I(Gp 9}%"+<h ,?+I9! ,p f(}zT}yGh ?+I9! ,p e;S G K=YC GP6


: #}y GhO%|h ;JG(%WyG G(I9=ASGh ,~%"*O G(vQ@ :aGQ_}Gh iO}yG
IRgyG aQg* : #*O e;S G fC G(y(t* fC 9%z$C ?y9I #| :E f9*O}G f(pQg*
A9j=yGh QT+}yG K+=* #*O (%p ,?z*PQyGh ?z+]qyG #+< R+}* :h ,?|GQwyGh
#*O .9%"f #zg@ J;G|h OFGQFh ,9%}d"@ #+!G(s xyP ,p &z$}h ;Q}MyGh
,p Q(GyGh e9d"yG ,p )\(qyGh ,Q(GqyGh I(VQyGh ,QhRyGh HPwyG K+=*
)j=yGh ;b9tWyGh u*QqAyG >+y9SCh ,b9q"yGh O+wyG ,p #"qA* #*O ,e9wI}G
I

73

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9Jy Gh ~C Gh ,O9"gyGh
,?p(yz| ?phQg| #+}zT}yG #+< JQ9Y ,AyG {FGPQyGh e9C6G #| g(J!h GP6
k
#| GPLC e;S G Q(Z*- ?\(j=| IQw"| e;S G #*O ,ph A;tgyG O"f ,$h
.e;S G 9$Q(ASO ["< 9%"*O ?|(wIh ,e;S 9< #*O* Q(%= ?y9I
GP$ U+yC ,e;S G )zf #+}zT}yG #| ?*9"F f(}zT}yG 99C GP$ U+yC
k
I9+JyG O*Q@ ?|z< #TJ* :h ,&+zf GhQ=Z* fC A;tgy9< {}G* : 9]s9"@
#| iO7h A9W@ #| 96 {]@ xA"Ap :E ,$ fE ,&+yE #wT@ fC SCQyG ?f(pQ|
q p o n mo #*Qp9jyG Q+L B!Ch 9"}IQGh 9"y Qqi9p 9"+yh B!C A9W@
.O

"!~}|{zyxwvutsr
.p* ) ( ' & % $ #

#2" !a~,}+|*{)z(y'
x &%$

~*QwyG &y(SQ d(sh uJyG uG d(s ~w"*O )p G(g}SG :f(}zT}yG 99C


{ :)y9g@ uG d(t*
{ d(t*h }

?
>
=
<
;
:
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
{*R* 9\
9wIz< Q* ~y #}f 9}* )q! Qty Qt* ] @
Q uG e

fB

GQ

OZ* #| b9q"y9< rZ*h ,?"+!z}_h 9|;TASG &=zs ~}*h gQOY #f LQJyG


.uG d(SQh uG )yE )fGOyG #f
| { z y x w v u t s{ iQLB ?*B )p d(t*h

,+*)('&%$#"!~}
;:9876543210/@.}A K J I H G F E D C B A @ ? > = <
.[33-32

:aG

Q f} G]

: (%p f(yhzA}yG &+p dhz@h ,&s9pB JOA|G 9}%| f(}zT}yG 99C #*OyG fE

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

74

P$ :h ,?J|9GyG ?+I9<:G gP$ :h O9Jy:G GP$ :h ,uFG(=yG gP$ {}AJ*


~zf )zf e(t@ ?z\9p ?+!O| {}AJ* 9}!Eh ,OI O"f rt@ : )AyG JG(%WyG
z+$ 9|h uG ?"*R< hA}AyG {}AJ* ,~*Qv {\9p uzLh ,Ky9Y {}fh {|9v
J9=+ayG ~%y {J*h Qw"}yG #f ~$9%"*h ahQg}y9< ~$Q|z* :J9=+_ #| gO9=gy
.EF9=MyG ~%+zf eQJ*h
GhPt!Ch ,~w<Q #| IQqj| )yE G(fQ9Tp f("||}yG 99C e;S G ($ GP$
{s} IQ<9jyG ~|}G xz$C uG fC G(}zfGh ,?wz%AyGh Q9|OyG H9=SC #| S9"yG
.e9C6Gh QhQWyG gP$ #|
k
)zf G(|(sh ,9}+tAT| 9Gk 8 9%y G(g\h ,9Jk \Gh 9t*Q_ ?z+]qzy G(aL
; : 9 8 7 6{ f9azTyG I(sh dOgy9< uG Q|C 9}v &ASGQI
g

.}

Oonmlk
{ }

?"+=yG J9*6G gP$ )p Ky9ZyG ~wJyG OfG(s h\h uG fE :f(}zT}yG 99C


I H G F E D C B A @ ? > ={ ?J\G(yG

XWV UTSRQPONMLKJ
hgfedcba`_^]\[ZY
.
9T "y }
qponmlkji
[59-58 :A

G]

?!9|C ?+fQWyG r+y9wAyGh ,?!9|C QTy9p :&+zf ?dp9J}yG >: 9| ?!9|}Gh


ahQg}y9< Q|}Gh ,?!9|C 9$Q+ih IO9%WyG )p uJyG d(sh ,?!9|C ~y9gyG ~zfh
.?!9|C dG(s}Gh d9gp}Gh e9wI}G )p dOgyGh ,?!9|C Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh
OtgyGh {JyG {$C &+zf uq@G 9|h ,f(!9s &y(SQ ?"Sh ,f(!9s uG H9Av
O"f OQyGh ,f(!9s ?"TyG )p :h H9AwyG )p 9Zk ! ry9M* : 9}| #+}zT}yG #|
?!9|C #+!G(tyG gP$ {vh ,f(!9s ?+zwyG &|9wICh ?|9gyG #*OyG OfG(s )yE YR9"AyG
{ &<9Av ~wJ| )p ~w+zf dR!Ch ,9%+zf ~wdqJASGh 9$9*E uG ~wfO(ASG
,

75

.}

Gh

;|{zyxwvuts
? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

?+}v9Jy

,p 9| QVz &A|Ch &<9JY} ~*QwyG ~w+=! HOC G(g}SG :f(}zT}yG 99C


#yz a(MyG #| >ztyG hzM* jPyG hy9MyG yhy9L #=Fh hy9$ KV {FQyG
9%+yE )fOo IO9%V ~Av #|h .Q9"yG &y uG >F(* )AI QhRyG O$9V eOs dhR@
.yQhRyG O%V #}v f9v
?}F}h &y(SQyh uz d9s ?&zyG d(SQ 9* #}y 9"zs y?J+Z"yG #*OyGz
.gQtJ* :h &yPM* :h &}zd* : ,~zT}yG (LC ~zT}yGz y~%A|9fh #+}zT}yG
&y9|h &|O :eGQI ~zT}yG )zf ~zT}yG {v -gQOY )yE Q+W*- 9"%$ i(tAyG
.y&\Qfh
k
k
:&zyG ?"gy &+zgp I9<9J}< GOIC ~%+zf Q|zp 98+V #+}zT}yG Q|C #| )yh #|z
k
~zdyG f{p ~zdyG G(t@Cz yQ9"yG &zLO* )AI :Of :h 9pk QY &"| uG {=t* :
fC )zf ~%z}I :~wz=s #| xz$C KWyG f{p KWyG (t@G .?|9+tyG e(* J9}zc
.y?!9a=yG BT8< 98{p ?!9+MyGh ~v9*Gh ~%|Q9J| G(zJAT*h ~$A9|O G(wqT*
U}AyG #|h ,S9"yG ?!h|| uG g9qv S9"yG bMT< uG 9\Q U}AyG #|z
.yS9"yG )yE uG &zvh uG bMT< S9"yG 9\Q
~v9*Gh uG )"tph yH9GI uG #+<h 9%"+< U+y &!{p e(zd}yG I(fO G(t@Gz
.~*QwyG &+=! b;Lz< uzMAyGh &@9\Q| )zf {}gyGh &"*O< xT}AyG )yE
VVV
Q

$R}G

N V ?=aL

)zf )tqyG

O|9I N WyG u zg@

;S G K"| 9| )zf GOk GS u fhQM* ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=h


O+g* Q=v}G KzZ}yG e9| G xyP &y e9sCh ,~zd}yG (GyG GP$ ,p &=$hh
,IQ=yG gO+< ~+t*h ,&AG6h &t!hQ uJyG uG #*O )yE hFQ*h ,&@OF e;S5y
e

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

#| )zg*h ;e;S

76

OfC &|O$ 9| ;?+q+"JyG ?z}yG OfG(s #| bO9ZyG &!9Tyh


.YO=yGh J9COJ}yG &AAqLC 9| &@(Y
~%y #*R #*PyG &F9+fOC #| :E )}dgyG &A=w!h e;S G ?=+Z| f9v 9|h
,&y(SQh uG #| S9"zyh ~%Tq!} Q+MyGh iO%y9< aQfC ~8C {%GyGh QhQjyG
&< fPz* ~y 9| ~d"yGh #*OyG #| G(fQW* fC {%GyGh QhQjyG GP$ ~%y d(Tp
G(|O$h ,&}wI uG )zf GhOQ )AI IQ+Z=yG )}fh )jyG ~6 iO9}@h ,uG
iO%yG {+=S gO9=gy g9]@QGh ,?}g"yG &< ~@Ch uG &}wIC jPyG #*OyG OfG(s
.O9VQyGh
fhO B<Q\ Os >GJyG fC #| &< G($(| 9| -OtAg! 9}+p- xyP dhC f9vh
o
;p ,98hO BtziC Os HG(<}G fCh ,?}wJ}yG ?*(="yG ?"TyGh R*RgyG H9AwyG
?jzyG e(zf #| eqI 9}%|h ,&tph A9vPh ~zf #| )@hC 9}%| OIC h+aAT*
k
,GQ(G%| fBQtyG GhP<9p ,96GOBh 9%=+y9SC #| #t@Ch ,98("ph ?+<QgyG
J:9<Rh ,Q9wp}G J:9DJ< G(g"sh ,Q+L ($ jPy9< )!OC ($ jPyG G(yO=ASGh
AGQB 9%"| B"w}@h 9%J+<9Z| Jzq_zp AG($}G gP$ H(ztyG BqZgp ,AGQ6G
O: ~zp 9%=Tv 9%+zf fGQh ,9%J+@9q| Bf9\Ch 96G(<C Btzizp ,d9FQyG
k
Ky9Z< 9%g| hqA"@ ~zp {%GyG e9tSC 9%+p B}w;h GPq"| 9%+p fBQtyG uF9tI
~yh Y(F #| )"j@ :h #}T@ : ,AyG AGQ6G gP$ #| 9$AGPi BzgF {}gyG
BSQO .#+zSQ}yG O+S E*OI U(Z!h .#+}y9gyG HQ e;w< AGPAi:G {=t@
G(T+zp ~$O"f gO$9g| JQCOh 98(pQg* G(T+zp ~6(zs ,p fBQtyG ~y9g|
&=vG(v BzpCh ;98(pQg* G(T+zp ~9O*C #| &|;fCh &A*(yC Bgshh ,98hQ}g*
~zc Y9}AFG O"f &T}V BqTvh ;98(+J* : xyPzp ~%S(q! b9pB #| IQ+"yG
9$(yRfh ?t+tJyG f9azS #f )I(yG U(Z! G(gzL ,98hQZ=* G(T+zp ~%FGQB
#| 9%+zf LQM* dGR* ;p J;*hzAyG JGQ9i 9%+zf G("Vh ,#+t+yG ?*:h #f
e98y eG(sC )zf r+]yG dhR! ~%+zf ByR! .#+}v Og< #+}v ~%V(+F
G AG

77

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9Awy9< ~$O"f xT}A}yG ,eGQv Gh d;F G #| 96 u+z* 9| Q+j< 9$(z|9gp


?]s9"A}yG AGQ7y Ozt}yGh ,d(tg}yG #| &tI S(M=| Q$G(c >I9Y ?"TyGh
H9AwyG {$Ch ,d(=t}yG {\9qyG ($ ~9Oy ?Ap9%A}yG Q9wp}Gh ?\Q9gA}yG
P O No f(Y(t"| ~9Oy d9%F 9$Q+i )zf 9%Y(Z"y f(|Ot}yG ?"TyGh
H

^]\[ZYXWVUTSRQ
.
?*6 Qt=y p@
! ! vx ` _
]13

G :I

n n n

G[

9gk +V G(J=YC )AI f(!(Aq}yG IOzt}yG x8yhz< iO9}A* Q|}G dGR 9|h
?J\G(yG ?GJ}yG G(qy9Lh G(qzALG .f(IQp ~9Oy 9}< HRI {v 9<k GRICh
#| i(%yG f9a+V #w}@h ,~+tAT}yG uG WGQY G(sQ9ph G(sQApGh ,#+tA}zy
VQ}yG {jzj@h ,,VG(JyGh MhQWyG X9qyz< fhO=gA* G(J=YC )AI ~%S(q!
GP$h d;I GP$ HPwyG ~%A"TyC rZ@ 9}y G(y9s )AI ~6(zs ,p d9]gyG
,p )yh}G ?+z$9GyG IQ+S )yE GhO9fh ,HPwyG uG )zf GhQAq+y eGQI
?+vRyG A9|Oy9< | d(SQyG &@9|C 9| cQWyG #| G(+ICh ;J:;]yGh J9pGQMyG
~@9L &!9vQC dRyR 9| ?+"C(yG OfG(s #| G(gpQh ,eGQwyG IQQ=yG &<9JYC #|
aG(ayG ,p 96 f(8$9]* e9"Y}Gh f9Ch}G J(+< G(|9sCh ;e;TyG &+zf A9+=!}G
9| d(tyG aQLR #| ~%"+_9+V )IhCh ,eGQJyG uG B+< A9fOyGh KT}AyGh
~$h ,uG O9=f #| #+Jy9ZyGh B+=yG dB ~S9< e9jayGh A9}$OyG O"f &< BFGQ
}
{ ;9%"| ABQ< uGh
Q9asC #| Qash Oz< {v 9$D;< ~_h 9$QV ~f )AI B+iG(ayG xz@ JQDvh
)AI ~6(zsh ~%ShAQ ,p NQph f9a+WyG V9<h ,x<Q A9V 9| :E e;S G
#f gA9<Eh gQ=v ~%+p Nq!h ;~%}dfh ~%}Jyh ~%|O #| IQas {w< BFRA|G
k
Q9=ICh >%y (<Ch {%F (<C 9$OshC 9}v 9!G(f 9<QI 9$hOshzp uJzy Y(]MyG
.| ,="yG )zf ~8G(LEh O(%+yG

&6543210/.

#Aph J9*GPE #| B+iG(ayG x8yhC #| iO%yG I9fOh f(JzZ}yG d9! ~vh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

78

SQ< 9+k Sz@ #*OyG GP$ #f HPyGh O9%Gy9< u f(}F9tyG Q=Y ~vh
: uJyG )zf ?}F9s ?|}G gP$ #| ?qF9_ dGR@ :h ,&z=s #| A9+=!}G &!G(LGh
.xyP )zf ~$h ,uG Q|C )@z* )AI ~%yPL #| :h ~%qy9L #| ~$Q]*
YR9"| ;< QZgyG GP$ ,p iO%yG e9|E (%y )iGQ}yG Q=v}G N+WyG fGh :C
OQG(V OQ*h ,9%"*O Q|C ?|}G gP%y OOG+y uG gQ9ALG jPyG ($h hpGO| :h
k
I(tyG GO}AT| ;OVQ}G u*QayGh e(s}G {+=TyG )yE #*OF9JyG dG(\h #+%F9AyG
H9WyGh Ky9ZyG xz}yG &y;F #| ~C &!9J=S uG #| O+*zAyGh xyP )zf
bhQ9p xz}yG #*OyG QY9!h e;S G Rf dO9gyG e9| G uG ?f9_ ,p A,V9"yG
.gQZ!h gO+*z@ uG eGOC
~+dgyG e9| G xyP 96 xZ* uJyG ?}zw< ?*hGOyG ?LQZyG xz@ fGh :C
O9Tqy M;ZyG &+qp ,uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG )yE G(gFQG fC :&zv ~y9gyG Y9}SC
uG OhOI ?|9sE )yE G(gFQG ,#+JzZ}yG {v )zf gQ|C )ZgASG jPyG ~|}G
d(tgyGh H(ztyG ,p VGQ|C #| &"| (wW@ 9| {v #| ?+!9T! G (G"@
A9|OyGh dG(|}G eq; uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG )yE G(gFQE ,e9TF}Gh b;L}Gh
#| ?qF9_ 9}6GPf GhO%VCh IOIGh IQ| (yh ;&zyG OhOI G(}+sC ,VGQf}Gh
;Q9%"yGh {+zy9< 979+I [j"@ ,AyG hFG(qyG xz@ #| ?|}G K*QAT@ #+"||}yG
J9*B #| GhQ@ Q+=MyG ~+wJyG AGhOy e;TAS:G )yE ~wTq!Ch ~w<(zt< GhO(f
.f(yh}G ~wqzS &< OgS 9| ?+p9gyGh A9qWyG
QtATAS )AI JhOh ,JhOh ,JhO ?LQY {F}G N+WyG 99C uGh xz@
,p 98hQ*O* 9|k 9*Ch 9|k 9*C 9%y S9"yG bQa* fC Og< ,QZ| ,p uG A9V fE
h|9G}< PLzAS xyP Og< ,$ ~C ,Q+wqAyG f(z+a*h 9%+p fhQwq*h ~%ShAQ
9| 9%y f(=+GAT+S Og< ~$ ~C ;~%IGhQC )zf i(tyG 9$Q(! bQW+Sh ,~6(zs
fC ~zg* E+I d(t* jPyG )iGQ}yG ~+wJyG KzZ}yG e9| G 96 KF9ZyG eGO
Q+L bhQ9qyG Ky9ZyG xz}yG O%f fC aQg* jPyGh ,f9I Os d(tyG Bsh
| uG d(

79

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9gyG e9| G GP$ O* fCh ,uJyG e;S G J(Y &+p hq@Q* fC ?+I;Y O(%gyG
.uG A9V fE e;S G hFGQVh e;S G f(!9s P+q"@ )zf iO*}G i(sC ,$
dR!C 9}< G(}wIh uG OhOI G(|9sC #+I Ky9ZyG 9"qzT< Q=Ag! fC fB Otyh
#|}G O* ~%+zf uG bT<h ,e;TyG {=S )yE 9+!OyG I9+JyG ,p GhO%p uG
{< ;R9GJyG ?*O9< JO9fC ,AyG ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?|(wJy9< Q=Ag! fCh ,f9|}Gh
?+WI(yG #| &+zf ,$ 9| f9w| {v ,p 9pk hQg| f9v 9| Og<- IQ*RGyG {vh
?|9s{< ?*O(gTyG ?|(wJyG 97O9fC dG(|}G >zSh A9|OyG xqSh ?+G}%yGh
: 9}< f9|}Gh #|}G ,p d9D|}G HQ]| uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyGh ,uG OhOI
9}k zfh GQk ]; -f(}fR* 9| )zf- O;=yG ~dfC 9w*Q|C :h 9<QhC {$C &< ~zJ*
.?+!O|h
Q< )yE QZ| ,p #*OyG ?"+qS Oso h ,uG ?vQ< )zf QS :,iGQ}yG e9| G 99C
xA|9fR< 9""*O ?|;S )zf f9"8}_:G {v #8}a! ~+fR Q+L B!zp e;TyG
.cG(sh cO*Ch uG cOOS .x@O9+sh
>zs #| ,uG &F(y ?Zy9L ~wy 9%y9s uGh Oty :f(*QZ}yG 99C ~A!Ch
Q+L .f(}zg@ : 9| ~zg@h ,fhQ@ : 9| iQ@ ?JY9! ?=+_ Uq!h ,bO9Y
hsGh 9%"f VGQf Gh >w"AyG QVh ,OIC {v {=s ~wy 9%t+t;h 96 {}gyG
9}y ~v(fO* #| ?<9GASG G(fQ9Sh ,~wTq!C G(G!9p :C ,OIC {v {=s ~w<
,?gF9_ ~wS(q!h ,?+fGh ~w<(zsh ,?g|9S ~w!GPB uG {gF .~w++J*
.e;S5y gQOY MQW* &*O9 fC uG OQ* #|h ,uG iO$ iO%yGh
dO

,tqyG O|9I O}J|

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

80
v$1356

dh G bhQ9p

?S y
"

h} G

? Ty
"

G 7 O

Og y

Ky9ZyG xz}yG ?y;F

gQZ"< uG gO*C
e;S G Q9CB

#| 9%< )+J* ?+|;SE ?"S #T*z

yS9"yG

&+T! 9| Ky9ZyG rzTyGh

&=zs uzg}yG ,uG IO9=f ,p rV9"yG ,dO9gyG xz}yG #| QZ| JO%V


)zf &Adp9J|h ,&gFGQW< &wT}@h e;S G )zf &YQI J9*B #|- OF9T}y9<
&g\G(@ #| fhQ* S9"yG zAq* ;p ,O+g< #|R #| O%W@ ~y 9| ,&|9wIC
,&=vQ|h gQ+T| ,p ~%y &@Gh9T|h ;&=gVh &A+fQ ?ay9M}y &yR"@h ,jQ}gyG
&%F(< ~%y hO=*h ,,I )yE )I #|h ,OGT| )yE OGT| #| ~%"+< &zt"@h
&y IR+| : ,~%|9t| &@O9=fh &@;Y ,p e(t*h ,?sQW}yG &Agz_h ;K}TyG
,,|;S G h\G(AyG GP6 &@R+| 9}!Eh ,U9L UzG| :h ,U9L TGQq<
d9D|h ,?}IQyG MhQ xyP #| ?=TAw}yG ,uG ?f9_ ,p ?8V9"yG Uq"yG xzA<h
~zT}yG {FQzy {D| #TIC xyP {v ,p 9<k Q9\ ;U;L G (qYh ,?tqWyG
,p #*OyG h| &IhQ JQSh ,&=zs ?V9W=< e;S G Ih;I BFRA|G jPyG
.&"| eOyGh MhQyG iQ9G|
#+< OF9T}yG ,p ?g}GyG AGOC O"f Ky9ZyG dO9gyG bhQ9qyG xyP rt* ~y
9+!OyG f(8V ,p 9+zgyG ?t=ayG 9Yk (ZL- S9"yG QDvC fC OFh {< ,&A+fQh &=gV
Os ~8Ch ,~$O"f ;&A*GO$h &tzLh &<OC ,p uJyG e;S5y QCC : -?|}G #|
G(T! )AI ,?D*OJyG ?+!O}yG #@9q| ~%ApQFh .?+G!Qp G O+y9tAyG ~%A=zi
#+gy9< &!hQ* G(J=Yzp ,e;S5y ~$Qd! BTwfh ;~%A+|;SGh ~%A+sQV
;GQ(q! e;S G #| xyP ~$OGRp ;W9aJ!:G QOZ|h ,QLzAyG ?zf :?+<Qh}G
:h ?f9= e;S G h|9G| #| O%W* : ~$QDvC f} xyP ,GOg< &A*GO$ #fh
{+ztyGh ,98k +V &@9*Bh e;S G hFGQV #| &g}S bQa* :h ,GOk +f :h ?g=
O"f ($ jPyG Q9tyG hC >+aMyG IQ(Y ,p &zD}@ xyP #| 98k +V O%V GPE ~%"|

81

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)tz* 9| )yE BqAz* :h ,&"| h}T* 9}< z=g* ;p ;GQk +tI GQk +jY h|9TyG GP$
OGT}yG ,p S(zGyG d9_C ($ GPE Q|PAyG {v GQk |PA| gO%WAy x!E {< ,&+zf
Os ,~@z| ,p Q9ty h}AT* UzF ($ GPE rpzAyG {v rpz@h ,?=aL h}AT*
:&AwT* #| Q9tyG GP$ )yE Eg=+p ~y}G &=zj* Otyh ,fBQtyG #| gQhO d9_C
has )yE &8Gz@ ?J+Z< &+|Q*h ,?+S9s ?}zw< >+aMyG GP$ )yE Eg=*h
O"f uG QvP< eQ=yG GP$ &< rs(* 9| ?f9GWyG #| &y #w* ~y f9v GPE ,E*OJyG
.?+}zgyG ?+|;S G ?f9GWyG xz@ ~$O"f jPyG ~$ {+zsh ;gOI
d9JyG xz@ )zf &@Q%cC ?SGQO &=gV ?+Tq! Ky9ZyG xz}yG ?y;F SQO
,p O|}G &+zf d9_h xyP ,p GhO9}@ ~$ GPE >sG(gyG ~Lhz< IQP"}yG ?}y|}yG
.&@9*5< Q+vPAyGh uG QvP #f Og=yG
,IRgyG H(C?+"*OyG h|9G}yGh Uy9G}yG xz@ U=z* fC gQd! >s9D< iCQp
9| -x8yhC B"Ap ,AyG- 9+!OyG ?$9Fhh ;xz}yG ?6C #| 9%+zf ^+q* fCh
Q+vPAyG uAq+y ,J9Z!:Gh A9jY:G )zf h|9TyG ~iQ* :;Fh ?fhQ 9%=Tw*
,xz}yG ?}df &Ag]LC jPyG >ztyG )yE &< Eg=Ap &"| B|QI 9}y9_ ,AyG &!PC
.&A6Ch UzG}yG ?$9Fh &@Q]ICh
,qaZ| O}J| N+WyG Q=v}G P9AS}G- )"*O SCQ Q=vC xyPy Q9AL9p
?gS #+< &y uG h= ~y9f Q=vCh ,9+!OyGh #*OyG ?}df &+p {D}A@ -,iGQ}yG
?w"Ih ,>ztyG ?f9GVh ,AGO}G d9=h ,d(tyG ?I9Zph ?}wJyG I(sh ~zgyG
9| :9+!OyG ?$9Fhh ?yR"}yG (}Sh ;Q9+AL:G #TIh ,jCQyG ?y9YCh ,?S9+TyG
?<9%| ;?|}G JGO9Sh e(tyG ?+zf #| OV9JyG h}GyG xyP Uq! &< ~}*
k
#| ~%+zf ?yR"A| J9*6G xzAy f(g}AT+p ;GQ+s(@h #*Ozy :;FEh Q+vPAzy
?g\h #+FQ9tyG x8yhC Q9jY #| ~%+yG IOf9Y: ;{+zGyG N+WyG GP$ (zf
RvGQ}yGh >Y9"}yG #|R #|RyGh IO9}yG QZf QZgyGh .#*QvP}yG x8yhC
.?*(+!OyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

82

WL ,p UzG* ;~*QwyG &ZMW< UzG}zy ?fhQyG xz@ {zvh


x8yh} f(w+p ,#+Jy9ZyG rzTyG HOCh ,#+A!9tyG J9Z!Eh ,#+"||}yG
&TzG}< ~%+fGQh ~$O+S fhQ* PE ,QvPyG )zf d9=s G ,p IhOs #TIC IO9TyG
:,y9g@ &y(s ~%|9|C utI Os gQ+vP@h Q=v}G N+WyG E*OI )zf &A+zw< &y9=sCh
Y(

tZsYrXq p o n

7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . - , +o
o &y(s
p8

w
v
u
fedcba`_^]\[

p@
! ! vz $

o :,y9g@ &y(sh

]73

? *6 G

:f

9sQqyG[

]2

? *6 G

:d

]15

9q !} G [

p@
! !|x

n
?*6G :IOGTv yG[

xz}+p ,Q<9"}yG #| A9SDQyGh IO9tyGh A9qzMyG g(zA* fBQtyG f9v xyPvh


9!k 9}*Gh ,~%A*GO$ )zf ?*GO$ &< fhOGOR*h ,~7O8pCh ~6(zs #+g|9TyG )zf
d9=h ,b;L}G d9}v #| ~%+zf k=T*h ;~%"+t* )zf 9"+t*h ,~89}*G )zf
BFQLC ?|C Q+L &< G(!9v 9| S9"yG h|h uG h| {}gyG M;Yh ,B}TyG
)yE IRgyG Q<9"| #f ByO@h .fBQtzy #+FQ9tyG ?t=_ BzqT@ 9}zp ;S9"zy
?yB JP<Gh ,e(TyG [LQz< uG J9*B Bg+<h ,Q<9t}yGh RF9"GyG Uy9G|
k
Y9\h ,fBQtyG ?fhQ B=$P ,9+!OyG Y9A| QGy ;+Ih ,bGR@Q;y 9==Sh X+gzy
JOTph H(ztyG BTsh ;&<GOBh &s;LC BJ|Gh ,g9*9Yh BV;@h &dfh
h+%| )zf f(w* )AI 98k +V h|9TyG :h Q9tyG fBQtyG )"j* : GPw$h .Y9=ayG
,jO%yG &< f(jA=* ,#+tA}yG #*QvGPyG #"S )zfh ;#+Jy9ZyG rzTyG
JOfC VQ}Gh JG(}TyG 9%\Qf J9"Fh ,&!G(\Qh uG IQqj| &< f(FQ*h
.#+tA}zy
A9+IC #| )I ,p Y(=SC {v S9"yG h=h ,?"TyG gP$ Ky9ZyG xz}yG 9+IC
~%y )zG*h ,&@9*Bh u9< S9"yG QvP* ;gOF9T| #| OGT| Q=vC ,p ,IQ$9tyG
9| ;&A}dfh e;S G d9= #| -,iGQ}yG Q=v}G P9AS}G- bO9ZyG &!9Ty )zf

83

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?+z$9GyG O+y9tAyG xz@ #| ~$Pt"* 9|h ;?<P9wyG ?+!O}yG xz@ #@9q| ~%+T"*
&@9+I ,p uG O|Ch ,AGRGyG {]pC ?|}Gh e;S G #f uG gGRGp .?wz%}yG
k
k
cQ9<h ,&}y9g| ~+t*h &SQGO )+J*h gQ9"| e;S5y hpQ* ;*(_ GO|C ?vQ9=}yG
k
cQWyGh ?fO=zyh .GQk Y9! A9+=!}G O+S ?"Sh O+I(Azyh GO*|| e;S5y &+p uG
k
k
.9|O9$h 9g|9s ?+"C(yGh
VVV

9s ~C ?zG}yG )p gQW!h SQOyG [+MzA< )tqyG N+WyG e9s Otyh


eGOC ,,iGQ}yG N+WyG ,Q=v}G P9AS}G KzZ}yG e9| G E*OI [+Mz@ GP$
&A}zw< 9fk O9Yh uJyG #f 9gk pGO| uG g9t<Ch ,e;S5y gO+*z@h ,&t+p(@ uG
.gOIh uG :E 9%+p )WM* : 9+zgyG
9}<Q J9}zv ^g< #f (qg* fC &yzSCh ~*QwyG Q9tyG K+}ASC ,!Eh
fC (FQC )!C Q+i ,N+WyG J9}zv [! BdqI 9| )!} ,jO"f #| 9%AjY
.9%"| A,W< {LC ~yh ,gOY9t|h N+WyG )!9g| )zf Bdp9I f(vC
H9WyGh ,dO9gyG xz}yG 9!:(| ?y;F Q}f ,p {+a* fC uG dzSCh
9}| 9%y9D|} &tp(* fCh ,?vQ9=}yG ?"TyG xz@ 9+IC jPyG ,uG ?f9_ ,p A,V9"yG
O}J| ?"Ty GQk Y9! 9"M+V ,p cQ9=* fCh ,&=!9F Rg*h e;S G fzV #| )zg*
&Fh B$(V ,AyG YO=yG ?<Q9J| #| gCO< 9| ~}A+y 9"+t*h I(s gO*R* fCh :|
QZf ,p e;S G O(g* )AI ,&}y9g| JQ+ih ,gQ(! BqTvh ,e;S G
hat* bhQ9qyG Q}f f9v e(* ,dh}G gO%f ,p &+zf f9v 9| )zf bhQ9qyG
#+_9+V 9%FhQ ,AyG ?+"C(yG J9pGQMyG xz@ #| O+I(AyG )}I )}J*h IQGWyG
{ zo 9%"| AGQ< f(Jy9ZyGh ,#+Jy9ZyGh A9+yh}G ~S9< U!}Gh #GyG
:d

)1(

.iQ(

WyG IQ(S #| J9*6 GQk +Tq@ SQOyG f9vh )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

84

-,+*)('&%$#"!~}|
p@
! ! { 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . !@
!z
.

,tqyG O|9I O}J|


k
GOF e9$

u+zg@

Q*QJAyG U+FQ ?z+]p >z_ ~+tyG SQOyG GP%y )y9AyG e(+yG ,p )?zG}yG(
gOGT}< #*Q\9JyG )yE >z_ -#*O<9g< IQGO%yG OGT| >+aLh e9|E ($h
?=S9"}< ~%F:h f;f #*O<9f QZs )yE &g| G(=$P* fC ?g}GyG I;Y Og<
9}v ;?F9}T}L (J! G(!9vh 9gk += G(=zp ,ShQOyG gP%y xz}yG ?y;F Q(]I
.Q=v}G P9AS}Gh xz}yG ?y;F )yE O+*zAyG J9pGQjz@ G(zSQC
-

85

? +fQW y

vv15:4v

"

? O}J}yG ? TyG

Q=v

}G

1356

Q 9Z C

P9AS G

?S
"

?S9+Ty

Gh

Og y y

7 O

?+}v9Jy

G ) h} G

? Ty
"

?f9}F Oph

? z ]p

6 "%*

#| ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= #| ~+df Oph dG(V 2 OI}G e(* &F(@
P9AS}G ?z+]p ?z<9t}< G(pQW@h ,fG(zI )yE #*O<9g< ?f9}Gzy e9gyG RvQ}yG
,qaZ| O}J| N+WyG ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG QY9!h Q$R}G h|9GyG N+V Q=v}G
MQV ?}zv ?f9}GyG U+FQ )tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG ?z+]p )tyCh ,,iGQ}yG
,Q=v}G P9AS}G ?z+]qy Q9=vEh d;FE #| ?f9}GyG xz@ H(zs &"w@ 9| 9%+p
9| )zf ?8"%AyGh ,cQ9=}yG O+gy9< ?8"%AyG [y9L ~*OtA< f(pQWA* 9gk += ~8Ch
e;S G fzV 96 uG hpQ* ,AyG ?+"*OyG ShQOyG gP$ ,p Q=v}G N+WyG uG uph
#| Q=v}G N+WyG &+yE (fO* 9| #+}zT}zy utJ* fC uG f(yzT*h ,gQOs )zg*h
,p IOIhh ;{}gyG ,p IOIhh ,~zgyG ,p IOIhh ,IO+tgyG ,p IOIh
;f9]|Q Q+i ,p ?|9f ShQOyG gP$ f(wAy N+WyG 9!:(| up(* fCh ,H(ztyG
k
.GQhQSh ?a=i ?p9v #+}zT}yG H(zs ~| jPyG ~+}gyG hq"yG #| 9%y 9}y
.A9fOyG [y9Lh QwWy9< ~%A"TyC ua!Ch
,Ky9ZyG xz}yG ?y;F I9+I ,p O}* fC u [y9MyG A9fOy9< &A}zv ~AL ~C
?z+]p ,p cQ9=* fCh ;A9LQh IO9gS #| &+yE (=Z@ 9| gO%f ,p QZ| {+"* fCh
iQf #| OW* fCh ,9tC(@ bhQ9qyG ?y;G< &AzY ,p O*R* fCh ,Q=v}G P9AS}G
97GQ}C #| S9"yG R(q+p ,Ky9ZyG ~zgyGh Ky9ZyG xz}yG h}AG+y ?zZyG gP$
.~g"yGh JGQ+MyG >+_z<

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

86
. 17 ,11 ,10 v

1356

?S
"

Og y y

9 O

G ) h} G

? Ty
"

Ky9ZyG xz}yG

Q=v

}G

P 9A S G

,iGQ}yG ,qaZ|

?z ]qy

O}J| N WyG

?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]I J9qY u+Ch )}zf d9Z@Gh HQs #f JQ=L


>G* ,&g=a< GQk +L &@OF(p ,u+p(AyG ?}g! &y uG eGOC dh}G bhQ9p xz}yG
.S9"yG &+yE hzaA* 9}| QLB VQi i} : ,{+= &!} &tWg* ,&@GPy Q+MyG
uIh ,&@O9=f uI u iO|+y &Tq"< (zM* fC &y Pz*h ,A9*QyG gQw* (%p
{="yG ?*9i ky9< ?+I9"yG gP$ #| (%p ,uG 9\Q 9%+p f} uG ?f9_ >J*h gQwV
.OZtyG ,p aQWyGh
k
k
)zf )y(AT*h ,&=zs &+zf xz}* 9sO9Y 9!9}*E )y9g@h &!9J=S u9< #|||
&+yE iO9 9}v H9=S}G ,p PL}G Og< &!9J=S uG )yE gQ|C V(q*h &Tq! h+=
.YQWyGh {tgyG
~%q@ )zf UQJ* ,uy9MyG ?}df e9|C 9gk V9L rt*h ,f(wyG d9= >J*
{ )y9g@h &!9J=S uG d(t< Q9=AfG &y ,#"Sh QGQSC #| &+p 9|

CMB LA " K J I H G F E D
Z Yt< XuzMW
V
U
T
S
R
Q
P
O
N
#`_^]\[
A
uG d(

*h

a ` _ ^ ] \ [ Z Y X W V &!9J=S
n m l k j i h g f eId c b
po
[191-190 :fG

Q}f dB] }

.}

~@9L >J*h ,dOgyGh uJyG d9= &+p f}h ,Q+q L &!} e;S G >J*
>I b(q*h A9<6G >I b(q* ,b(zM}zy >I {v b(q* 9=k I | {SQyG

87

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Qt* fCh &D*O9IC h}T* fC &y Pz* .IQ+WgyGh A9sOY}G >I b(q*h A9"<}G
,p jP}G d9}AIG )zf gQ=Yh &Af9GW< H9Gf}G OVC >Gg| ($h ,&@Q+S
Q+Tn < hyh &yh ,&@9qYh &zF9}V {w< >Gg|h ,uJyG )yE I(fOyG {+=S
.
H9aMyG #< Q}f bhQ9qyG IQ+S ?Y9M<h ,eQv}G d(SQyG H9JYC
k
GOF ?a+T< ?tF9qyG 97(s )zf ,$h ,?*(s ?+|;SE IO+tf bhQ9qyG IO+tf
OIGh &yE .e;wyG A9}zf (WI #| :h ?qS;qyG f9*P$ #| QCC 9%+p U+y
f9Ty )zfh &<9Av ,p &Tq"< &Tq! rYh 9}v ,d9}wyG J9qY h+}G< rZA|
O"f 9%ApQg| ,p rt* AGRGzy QGOh ,~%At+tI ~zg< uG QCzASG ?wF;|h ,&zSQ
#f fhQP"|h fhQW=| {SQh ,?J+JZyG IQ%a}yG ?"TyGh ~*QwyG fBQtyG OI
,qzS IO+tgyG ?+I9! #| (%p d;]yG #| ?+!9T! G P9t!Eh ?*GO%zy G(Dg< uG
.H%"}yGh >$P}yG
u U;L}G MhQ )zf ?z}AW| ,HGO6Gh f9vQ}G ?z|9v I;ZyG iO|*
9<k 9TAIG f9]|Q e(Z* &Ay;Fh ,uJyG JGP )yE 9%g+= {iG(WyG #f YhR"yGh
>gWyG aQg* ,J9F9JyG ihPh A9qg]yGh )|9A+yGh AGQtqyG )zf rag*h ,u
iOG(yG IO$9W|h HJyG ?]*Qp AGOC )yE b(V &yh gQDvC {%G*h &]g< xyP #|
,| O}J| QW=yG O+S &+p LQOh ,e;S G ?z=s &+p )"<h ~+$GQ<E gQ9ALG jPyG
.f9sQqyGh iO%yG #| J9"+<h S9"zy iO$ uG H9Av &+p dR!h
.?]*QqyG gP$ AGO} &tp(*h ,?+y9jyG &@9+I ~*O* fC uG dzSC
(%p ,e;S G QF9gV )zf &YQIh ,?g}GyG I;Zy &Ay;F LhQL QCC 9|C
)yE ~%=*Qt@ ,p QJTyG {gp ?+|;S G ?f9}GyG ,p {gq* ,jO}yG O+g<
#*O )zf S9"yG( {F9tyG {D}yG )"g| uG gO*C bhQ9qyG utI Osh ,#*OyG
.)~%v(z|
&AsO< IQ(ZyG gP$ RGQ<E )zf Q*Os Q$9}yG Q(Z}yG ?W*Q fC #cCh
C

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

88

9qy9< e;S G uG RfC .,F9fO )zf O*RC :h ,IO(%g}yG


?=S9"}< QOY jPyG yQ(Z}yGz #| U9MyG OOgyG #f d9t}yG GP$ 9"zt!(
.)O+gTyG )wz}yG fGQtyG
.bhQ

89

? +fQW y

? QZ}yG ?|

}G

O+gTyG )wz}yG
k

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

MGQ p C

fGQty9<

#| ?=+Ws ?zI QZ| JO@QGh ,GQk $9< :9qAIG ?*QZ}yG ?|}G BzqAIG
9| {D| bs IQ$9tyG O%W@ ~yh ,O+gTyG )wz}yG fGQty9< 9Fk 9%A<G ,J9"*RyG
MQqyG #| I(W! ,p S9"yG iQ@ B"wp :f(}+}yG fGQtyG GP$ ,p JO%V
)t+S(}yGh ,IQ(W"| ?s9qL e;f}Gh ,IQW=AT| &+p g(F(yGh ,QhQTyGh
.H(=J}yG Ky9ZyG xz}yG I9+J< rA7 J9f9}GyGh ,?+GWyG 9%|9j!z< MOZ@
gP$ {D| OWA; ~yh ,{|9WyG MQqyG GP$ {D| {*(_ O%f #| QZ| Q@ ~yh
r"9 f9T!E {v iQ@ B"wp ,IO+gTyG ?=S9"}yG gP$ ,p JOWAIG ,AyG #+*;}yG
k
k
A:hh 9Y;LEh 9=I ?}gq| H(zs #| IQO9Y ?8"7 &Tq! r"9h ,&=I9Y
,&IGQpC MGQp}G gP$ fz< QgW* ~%"| {vh dh}G bhQ9p H(=J}yG x+z}zy
k
GR|Q H(=J}yG QZ| x+z| Q9Zp >zs {v ,p Bzjzj@ )bhQ9p( ?=J| f}
.A9LEh ?=J| &IGQpC JQ9Yh A9L:Gh ?=J}zy
^FGQqyG AGOC ,p >gWzy )zfC ;D| Q9Y uG &dqI bhQ9p xz}yG ?y;Fh
,p #+}zT}yGh HQgzy I(SC
dh}G bhQ9qyG f9v 9}v ?+"*OyG J9=FG(yGh
.ehQJ}yG )zf ragyGh Q+tqy9< Q=yG ,ph ?}IQyGh dOgyG
)yEh ragyG )yE L9AJ| {wy 9dI U9MyG &y9| #| uG &dqI {gFh
.?+|;S G ~|}G #| ~zgyG
K=YC )bhQ9qyG( f} fGQtyG GP6 QW=AT@ QZ| ,p ?+|;S G J9+g}GyGh
#*Ozy &=I #| &Ay;F #f &pQg@ 9}yh ~zgA}yG ~zT}yG H9=Wzy IhOs Q+L
.?*(="yG ?"Ty9< &v9T}ASGh
)}SC hpQ< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= eOtA@ IO+gTyG ?=S9"}yG gP6h
fC Q*OtyG )zgyG uG )yE &F(A@h iOq}yG x+z}yG TQf )yE )!9%AyG JGQ9=f

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

90

QZf {gG* fCh u+p(AyGh OgTy9< 9!k hQt| &!GQs {gG* fCh &A*9fQ #+g< g~w*
.#+}zT}yGh e;S5y Rf QZf

91

? +fQW y

Of

52 O

Ky9ZyG xz}yG

13 , 12 v

#|

?Jy9Y

16 A

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

RGy ?g< Qy ? Ty
G

"

(f O

)yE #+}zT}yG dh}G bhQ9p Ky9ZyG xz}yG ?y;F 9fO f9=gV 15 e(* ,p
&=]i hpQ* fCh ,~y9gyG )zf &A}IQ QW"* fC 9}%+p uG f(yzT* #+AgvQ I;Y
.97;*hh HQJyG QV #| S9"yG K*Q*h &At|h
uG d(SQ f9vh .g9\Q*h uG &=J* Ky9Y {}f )yE ?Jy9Y I(fO ,$h
f;AAt* f9t*QqyGh QO< IhRi ,p | f9vh I;ZyG )yE YRp Q|C &<RI GPE |
y9"Dizp E+jAT! xA}IQ< e(+s 9* )I 9*z gO(GS ,p &<Q dzT*h )zZ* 9}F9s
(fO* IQ+L}G ?gvQyG #| Y(vQyG Og< U}MyG JG(zZyG ,p B"t* | f9vh
.#*Qp9wyG #| #+i9ayG #*Q=wAT}yG )zfh #+}zT}yG #| #+qg]AT}zy

~%y9}fC G(ZzM*h ~6(zs GhQ%a* fC #+}zT}yG (fO* | f9vh


)zf ~$QZ"*h HhQwyG ~%"f uG rWw+y ,uG )yE &F(AyG ,p G(sOZ*h
\ [ Z Y X W V Uo )y9g@ d9s 9}v ,#+}y9dyG
:,y9g@ d9sh
?*6 HJy pb a ` _ ^ ]
:,y9g@ d9sh
?*6 OfQy pY X WV U T S R Q Po
u

]41

]11

G :

G :

q n
q

G[

G[

A @ ? > = < ; : 9 8 7 6 5o
&|9tA!G #| )y9g@ uG [s 9}| xyP Q+ih pF E D C B

#f ~%+$9"@ eOfh ,H(!PyGh )Y9g}yG #| f(=Tw* G(!9v 9}< #+\9}yG #|


)zf uG ~%"gzp ,uG OhOJy ~9Og@h ahQg}y9< Q|}G ~%A|9sE eOfh Qw"}yG
@ ?> =
< ; :9 87 o &F9+=!C f9Ty

K J I H !@
!|} G F E D C
BA
ahQg}y9< fQ|zAyz | d9sh p!@
!|~ Q
P ONML
Q_ uJyG )zf &!Q_zAyh ~y9dyG O* )zf fPLzAyh Qw"}yG #f f(%"Ayh

Gk C

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

92

9}v ~w"gz* ~C ~wy >+GAT* ;p &!(fOAp ^g=< ~w]g< H(zs uG #<Q]+yh


.y~%"gy
GQk |C :Ky9ZyG bhQ9qyG ?y;F #| ?Jy9ZyG I(fOyG gP$ fQ9s (y GP=Jp
?z+zyG gP$ ,p (yh ,Q9}tyGh Q}MyG J9!9Ih b(TqyGh (%zyG QhO b;i{< 9}k *Qv
#| uF9f &gpQh &A<9GASG fhO f(w* : )AI A9fOy9< 9%+p uG )yE G(%F(@ ,AyG
QZ| ,p ?l gt< u=@ ~y ,AyG QhOyG gP$ >=T< &<GPfh &aMSh uG >]i dhR!
9%s;i{< QOZ* ~*QwyG gQ|C f9v hC .A9<(yGh f(f9ayG d(zI 96 BzI :E
~7G(fOh ?Jy9ZyG ~79}zv OgZAy IO9=gyG J(+< ,p #+Jy9ZyG A9fO Bsh
.uG bL9T| #| Q$9_ (F ,p ?sO9ZyG
k
fC - IQ+Dv J9=S9"}yGh - bhQ9p Ky9ZyG xz}yG ,p GOF ~+dgy A9FQyG fE
U+8=yG uG HGPf Q9%"yGh {+zy G A9!B dR"AT@ ,AyG Q|=yG gP$ #| S9"yG ~IQ*
e;S G I9+I 9%+yE O+g*h O+gTyG gO%f ,p 9%vQGOA* fC uG {gy .QZ| )zf
.97QLBh 9$9+!O ,p gQw@ 9| {v #| 9$Pt"*h ,j(tyG &!9azSh IR*RgyG
.>+G}yG >*QtyG h+}TyG ($h ,&|Qvh &"}< xyP uG utI

93

? +fQW y

54 O

Of

v16,15v

?} Qv ? shQ9p ? wz|

18 A

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

RGy ?g< Qy ? Ty
G

"

IQ = |

&A"S )zf -uJyG ?|9s{< gQZ!h uG gO*C- bhQ9qyG xz}yG ?y;F iQF
e;S G QC5| A9+I UQqyG R9%A!G ,p d9D| eQvC &=gWy HQ]* fC ,p ?=+ayG
.~%"f uG )\Q #+g<9AyGh ?<9JZyGh | ,="yG #"S #| gOtAg* 9}< AGOAs:Gh
Osh .H(=J}yG &w+z}< -~%"| H9=WyG 9Yk (ZL- iQZ}yG >gWyG ~@z+p
)zf iQZ}yG H9=WyG #| Q+Dv {=sC PE ?Jy9ZyG IQOtyG gP$ Q9CB BJ\h
{gp )yE IQO9=}yGh J9f9}GyGh h}GyG Q(]I )zf ?dp9J}yGh I;ZyG ?|9sE
?y;F UQI IOV ~%S(q! IQGQs #| h+}GyG O%W*h .JGQ+MyG #| Q+Dv
{=s ~$Q+jY )zf ("JyGh ~%+zf ragyGh &=gV ?JzZ| )zf bhQ9qyG
#+}a@h ~%"f jP}G O9g<Eh ghQw}yG hpO ,p O$9GyG {*(ayG Q%TyGh ,~$Q+=v
.~zd}yG {+zyG hatv 9%"Ap ~6 b+; ,AyG OFGOWyGh #J}yG e9*C ,p ~6(zs
IQ]I )yE Y9}AS:G ~*QwyG f9]|Q Q%V ,p &Ay;F d9}fC Q<C #|h
xz@ ,~*QwyG uG H9Awy Q+TqAyG ShQO ,p Q=v}G P9AS}G ?z+]qyG >I9Y
9%A|9fh ?|}G A9}$O OF9tf K+JZ@ )yE Q=v}G N+WyG &+p uph ,AyG ShQOyG
| uG d(SQ &< HOz@ jPyG fBQtyG HOC #f ?!9< Gh ,9%AY9L #| Q+Dvh
.S9"zy BFQLC ?|C Q+L G(!9wp QGQ<}G &=JYh
e9g_E ,$ :e9gyG GP$ ,p ?}*Qv ?"S )+J* Ky9ZyG xz}yG ?y;F ($ 9$h
k
O(FC f9vh ,S9"yG O(FC f9v jPyG | uG d(SQ< 9+Sz@ #+v9T}yGh AGQtqyG
&+p >iQ 9}+p ?=iQh ,fBQtyG &SQGO*h {*Q=F g9tz* #+I f9]|Q ,p f(w* 9|
QFC #| [t"* : gQFC {D| &y f9v 9}k F9Y Qap #|z &y(t< | uG d(SQ
k
.y98+V ~F9ZyG
?p9+]yGz ~S9< e9g_:G xyP f(w* fC ?}*QwyG ?+shQ9qyG b;L}G JA9Vh
GhQMq+p ,~%S(q"y RfCh ~6(zty MhQCh AGQtqzy Q<C xyP f(w* )AI y?+wz}yG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

94

u+t; )zf UQJyG OVC UQIh .H(=J}yG x+z}yG ?p9+]< G(pQW@ ~8z<
G(<("* fC #*Q*O}yGh #+dp9J}yG )yE gQ|C QOYzp ~*QwyG )|9TyG )"g}yG GP$
~$Q(gV ~A* )AI ~%"+< S(zGyGh AGQtqyG x8yhz< A9qAI}G ,p &Ay;F #f
{]qyGh J9=%yG xz@ #| uG g9=I 9}< x+z}zy 98k +"%p .?}*QwyG ?p9+]yG xzA<
.~+dgyG
?F9JyG OVz< ?|}G fE ,JGQ+MyG {gp )yE YQ9T}yG x+z}yG 99C :Og< 9|C
AGPj< d9"@ : ,AyG ?tJyG ?=+ayG I9+JyG ?}g! 9%y ~AAy 9%IGhQCh 96(zs AGPi )yE
#| QZ| ,p #*OyG ^%"@ fC xAy;G< IO(tg| d9|6Gh .>TJp e9TF}G
QhOh ~+zgAyG O$9g| ,p gP(q!h &!9azS ~*QwyG fBQtyG )yE O+g@ fCh ,&@(=v
uG ?}IQh uG ?*GO$ )zf >gWyG ~+tAT*h uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG O(g+y ~v9J}yG
.?p9+]yG uI ?p9+]yGh hp9"yG AGhOyGh >+ayG AGPjyG ($ xyPh ,#+"||}zy
Q_9M}yG #| 9$Pt!Ch ?=+ZgyG ahQdyG gP$ ,p x+z}yG 99C x=gV cQGOAp
x"+g* fC uG dzSC .9+!OyGh #*OyG ?!9|C cO* ,p uG h\h Otp ,xy9%}yGh
g(Fh ^+=@ e(* x%Fh ^+=*h uG )\Q* 9}< 9%tI AGOCh 96 A9p(yG )zf
QF}G #| c9afCh ,;]ph 9t+p(@ bhQ9qyG 99C uG cOGRh ,g(Fh O(T@h
Og< cO%f ,p ?|}G {*O=@h O+*zAyGh QZ"yGh #+w}AyGh IRgyG 9+!OyG ,p ?<(D}yGh
)zf ?|9tASGh ?f9_ 96Q Q|C #f f9+ZgyGh b(TqyG Og<h ,9"k |C a(MyG
k
#vf GOvgv<h uG ^vFGQvp )vzvf ?vdvp9vJv|h ,uG OhOvJvy ?v|9vsEh ,#v*OvyG
FEo HG(C #| {$C &y ($ 9| IQL6G ,p c9afCh ....&|Q9J|
p!@
!| P

O NM L K

J
I

H G

]7

?*6G

:J

(=w"gn yG[

95
13 )v$ 1359

? +fQW y

?GJy

G jP (

?g< Qy ? Ty
G

"

G #

60 O

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Ogy ? I9AAp p >Av


Q9
G

G ,

e 1941

)~@5}yGh JGR9

"GyG

YO<

, p ) |; S

#*OyG

~wI(

fG

* "*

("g<

9p QMyGh YO=yG gP%y ?+f9}AF:G f(8WyG Q*Rh Qd! G(%Fh fC Og=p


h*QWAyG ?|(wJyG BzgF (y GP=Iz d9t}yG ?*98 ,p ?zF9s ?zG}yG Btzf
k
k
i(TyG WGQZyG )zf S9"yG {}I ,p 9%y GQ(ASO ;+Zq@h ?z= )|;S G
{< cQA* 9|h PL|* 9| 9%+p U+zp ^g=yG YO@h &|9wIC ^g< PLz@ : E+J<
)yE {+=S HQsC &z+=Sh ?+ZgAT}yG ?+tzMyG 9"\GQ|C h+}Gy A9qVh iO$ &zv
~|}G #| 9$Q+ih ?|}G gP$ fC (yh J9|R}G L;fh J;wW}yG {I
VQ| Og< BJZy ?"TyGh H9Awy9< {}gyG )zf 9$(z}I IO9s BsRQ ?+|;S G
{gy #wyh ?*QJyGh IRgyG #| )yh}G 97Q+S JO9gyh L(f Og< B|9tAS:h
razyG &yzT! &jy9< ($ 9%+p u Q|} ~+tyG #*OyG GP6 PL}G #f 97O9s aGQZ!G
,,,?=s9gyGh
J G

k
k
GOF GOF e9$

{+*P@

?8"7 hC ?g*9=| #| ?YQp iC fhR%A"* 9}k FGO ?f9}GyG N(+V fC 9}k FGO eI;!
)yE O;=yG e9wI I(fOy ?YQp 98hR%A"* d(sC - YQWzy ?tpG(| ?S9+Ty O+*z@ hC
fhQ|z*h ahQg}yG ,p f(g+a*h f(g}T* ~%p - ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG u+=a@
{< 9}k v9I f(tp9"* :h ?f9_ #| GOk * f(fR"* :h Qw"}yG #f f(%"*h ahQg}y9<
{v ,p e9wJzy f(fO*h Ky9ZyG rzTyG H%"| #f fhQOZ* &zv xyP ,p ~$
fhQW"* :h Ky9ZyG rzTyG iO$ f9v 9}v #zgyG ,ph Q$9dyG ,p K"T@ ?YQp
.~%G%"}y f(qy9M}yG {gq* 9}v ~%+zf ~8(=y|+y e9wJyG >y9D| S9"yG )zf

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

96
v$ 1370 e

Qv9V O}IC Q*QJAyG )zf


Q

$R}G

QJ |

1 O

Ogy

G 15

Oz G } y

aQW}yG

N V

~+zS O+G}yG O=f N+WyG Q=v}G P9AS}G

?"S ?GJyG jP 26 OI}G e(* M9=Y ,h=azy OOgyG GP$ OGOfE A9"CC
?"TyG Q9Z!C 96 QW=AT* iQW< rJZyG BfGPC )1950 ?"S Q<(AvC 8( 1369
QhOY ,?|9f VQ}G Q9asC ,ph QZ| ,p f(}zT}yGh ,?Y9L ?*O}J}yG
O=f N+WyG Q=v}G P9AS}G ?z+]qyG >I9Y IQ]I #++gA< ~*QwyG )wz}yG Q|}G
k
.Q$R}G h|9Gzy 9M+V ~+zS O+G}yG
H9AwyG &tp ,?pQg}yGh &tqyG ,p ,?t+tI ~+df P9ASC Q=v}G P9AS}Gh
9| ~%+zf bOZ* #*PyG ,QZgyG GP$ A9}zf ,p {F;tyGh OGQp}G #| ,?"TyGh
,p 9"*CQ #| hShC #| ($h yfO=yG &+tpz Ky9ZyG rzTyG Q<9vC ^g< &< rYho
k
g9*GR| RQ<C #|h .~%yG(sCh A9%tqyG >$GP| )zfh ,?"TyG )zf 9f;_G 9"F9}zf
IO|9GyG ?+=ZgyGh O+ztAyG ,q!h ,rzTyG >$P|h ?"Ty9< xT}AyG ?}+dgyG
?"Gy ?S9FQ ,p ~C ,?*QZ}yG Q9*Ozy 9+k Aq| f9v #+I ,gGh9Aph .#+g| >$P}y
k
k
k
.9g"t| 9}+zS 9J\Gh )"g}yG GP$ 9%+p RQ=* ,Q$R}9< i(AqyG
o
o
iO%yG ?zG|( ~%AzG| KAAq@ fC y?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!Cz &< QW=AT* 9}|h
A9V fE ?vQ9=}yG ?*:(yG gP$ Q=M< ,O*OGyG 9$O%f ,p ,O*OGyG 9%|9f )j(="yG
x
,e;S G ?}zv A;fE )yE {+zGyG P9AS}G uG up(* fC 9%+p f(FQ* ,AyG ,uG
f(}zg* ~$h .,|;S G h*QWAyG QZ! )yEh ,JGQw"}yGh YO=yG HQI )yEh
: ,d9tC A9=fC #| &=I9Y {}J* 9|h ,Q+=v QaL #| ~+dgyG >Z"}yG GP%y 9|
q
.d9FQyG #| A9}dgyG :E 96 e(t*
e9t}yG )yE A9"DyGh QwWyG ?*(yC f(gpQ* y?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=zh

97

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

xz| ydh}G bhQ9pz xz}yG 9!:(| ?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]I e9t| ,~*QwyG
f(yzT*h .Q+=wyG ~$P9ASC )yE Q+aMyG >Z"}yG GP$ O9"SE )zf ,{+"yG iOGh
k
k
k
.A9fOyG h+}S &!E ,GO*|| GQ(Z"| ,Q+Mzy 9tp(| ,&Ay;F A9t< {+a* fC uG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

98

1950 / 11 / 19

up } y
G(

G 1370

QqY OI
9

}G

e(* ,

^g<h iQ=wyG ?zJ}yG YQp A9]fC #| G(k ]f 38 e9gyG RvQ}yG QGR


9$Q]I ~7GQ]Jy i9V ?zqI B}+sC E+I )zf (<C ?zJ| YQp A9]fC
P9AS}G ?z+]p {qJyG KAApG ~C e9gyG RvQ}yG IQGOE UzG| A9]fC ^g<
?f9}GyG aGO$C 9%+p #+< ?}zw< )tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG e9gyG U+FQyG
fCh &@9+I upGQ| {v ,p OTp jPyG iQZ}yG h}AG}yG L;f {F9Shh
| &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av )yE IO(gy9< :E I9G"| :h zGz| :h {+=S :
G(=ZgA* ;p #+*O|9I G(!(w* :C ?zJ}yG YQp A9]fC h+= )YhC ~C
:h xyP #| Q=vC f9T! :h N+V :h e9|E :h ~y9f :h U+FQ d(ty
k
| &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Aw< 9}FGO xT}AyGh >ZgAyG f(w* 9}!Eh QjYC
fC >G* f9T! G fEh i(%yG h=A*h raM* gQ+ih e(Zg}yG gOIh &!}
k
.| uG d(SQ &< A9F 9}y 9g=@ gG($ f(w*
r+v 9"k +=| YQqyG U+FQ O9gS}G (<C O(}J| P9AS}G gOg< #| ~zw@ ~C
,p ~%y uG #w| r+vh &z+=S ,p Bgsh ,AyG J9=tgyGh YQqyG gP$ IzW! B!9v
9%I9TAvGh 9%z+yP@
A9=aMyG JGQ]I #| {v 9}%=tfCh
YQp {+vh O*R (<C O}J| N+WyGh ?f9}GyG e9f Q+@QwS )gp9WyG O9VQ
.e(zgyG QGO ?+zw< >y9ayG QGO*hO O(=g}yG O=f N}Gh ?z+=tyG
uG ?vQ< )zf GhQp9S ~C A9T| ?gS9AyG ?f9TyG B!9v E+I {qJyG ,%A!Gh
.jQ=wyG ?zJ}yG )yE
VVV

99

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

>ZgAyGh O+ztAyG B<Q9I r+vh ?f9}GyG I(fO f9+=y Q=MyG GP$ JQvP
#+< bQqyG aQgAy cQd! Bqy #| QDvC )yE ?F9J< BTy x"cCh N*9W}zy
.?+qzTyG I(fOyG #+<h ?+<RJyG JG(fOyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

100
v$1370
OG

?S
"

A9}zf

dh C

h<
+

Q 3 O

Ogy

G 15

Oz G } y

N V

Q]I ehOt< QZ| - 1370 ?"S QqY 11 A9C;DyG e(* ,p - BpQW@


r+azyG O=f N+WyG #< ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+WyG :?I9}TyGh ?z+]qyG >I9Y
O=f #< O}J| N+WyG e;S G N+V #< #TI N+WyG #< #}IQyG O=f N+WyG #<
.jQG%yG QWf )!9DyG fQtyG ,p ?+<QgyG IQ*RGyG ,p e;S G OOG| ,H9$(yG
~+zTyG ,>ztyG )vRyG YQ(yG &+tqyG ?tDyG ~y9gyG ($ :~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+WyGh
h| f(8WyG {v ,p O(gS dB R*RgyG O=f xz}yG ?y;F &< uD* jPyG ,QOZyG
)zf 98(8V IQGOE ,p e(t@ 9}!E O(gTyG #<G xz}yG ?y;F ?|(wI fz< ~zgyG
,?*O(gTyG ?wz}}yG hFQ| ($ :~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+Wy9p ?+fQWyG e9wI}G
.O(gS dB R*RgyG O=f xz}yG ?y;Gy #+|}G )"*OyG Q9WAT}yGh
9}*R9v}G ^g< #| A9qWAS;y QZ| )yE - uG &dqI - Q]I Osh
.?+p9gyGh A9qWyG &y uG {Gf ,?a+T=yG
,&AI9}Ty ?zp9I ?<Oz| ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}zy V(q}yG Q*R(yG e9sC Osh
>I9Y IQ]I ~%SCQ )zf ,QZ| A9}zf {\9pC #| ?}*Qv ?=M! 9%+yE 9fO
h|9GyG N+V ~+zS O+G}yG O=f N+WyG Q=v}G P9AS}G ,&+tqyG ?|;gyG ?z+]qyG
N+WyG ?I9}S )zf A;]qyGh N(+WyG Q9=v #| Q+DwyG e(* {v OpG(A*h .Q$R}G
,&}zf ?t=S #| GhQ* 9}< #+W$O"| &@Q]I #| f(FQM+p ,~+$GQ<G #<G
#| &ATy9G|h &ApQg}< G(pQW@ ~8C (y f("}A*h ,gQOY ?gSh ,&Tq! ?I9}Sh
QC}G >+_C cQAAS QZ}y N+WyG ?I9}S IQ9*R fC :uJyG ,ph .{*(_ #|R
.QZ| A9}zf Uq! ,ph &Tq! ,p
uG &gA| ?zF9f ?+p9fh ,QZ}< ?=+_ ?z*(_ ?|9sE N+Wzy (FQ"y 9!Eh
.#+}zT}zy GQk LP g9t<Ch ,&@9+J<
I

101

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

N+WyG ?z+]q< IO+_(yG N(+WyG ?s;f )yE cQd! Bqy} Q=MyG GP$ JQvP
.IO+tgyGh H%"}yG IOI(y GQk d! QZ| )yE &|hOt< ~%IQph ~+$GQ<E #< O}J|
xz}zy ?+y9AyG ?]*QgyG ?f9}GyG N(+V eOs QZ| )p gO(Fh A9"CC )ph
.uG xtph fmzA< 9$CQszp bhQ9p

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

102
v$ 1370

"

Q 7 O

$ # "!

]Qv9V

? S >F

"

O}IC N+WyG Q*QJAyG )zf

? O}J}yG ? TyG

Q9Z C

?f9}F 9

xz}yG ?y;GyG >I9Y

Ogy

G 15

Oz G } y

aQW}yG[

%A|Os ,AyG

IQ ] I

?] QgyG

)yE

~dg}yG xz}yG 9!:(| ?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]I


&@9vQ<h uG ?}IQh ~w+zf e;TyG
.?+zgyG ~w@OTy A:(yGh U;L G J9*B ~*Ot@ Og<
?f9= A9]fCh U+FQ - )|9TyG ~wAy;F e9t| )yE GP$ hpQ< aQWA*
.?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C
IOf9T| )zf 97zW! P"| {}g@ ,AyG ?f9}GyG gP$ fE :?y;GyG >I9Y 9*
?I9}TyG #| ?+|;S G MhQyG E<h K+JZyG #*OyG S9"yG ~+zg@ ,p ?yhOyG
~*Q;h )\(qyGh r"gyG #f 9}k FGO Og=yG h| .Q|}G )yhC ?f9_h Q+MyG >Ih
.?"TJyG ?df(}yGh ?}wJy9< uG {+=S )yE I(fOyGh xAqyG
uG &Fh :E 9%z}f AGQh #| )jA=@ :h kA=@ ~y ,AyG ?fOG(yG ?f9}GyG gP$
98(8V h+= ,p Q+TyG )zf 9%Tq! JPLC ,AyG ?f9}GyG gP$ .IQL6G QGOyGh
d(SQyG &+zf f9v 9| )zfh | uG d(SQ #S 9| )zfh uG Q|C 9| )zf
JCQp .9}%+yG(I BAqz@h 9%+"+f BJAp Os ?f9}GyG gP$ .gD9qzLh &<9JYCh
AGOfC #| J9vQJyG ?}d"| aGQ_}G ?v(=J| IQ|G|| JCQ .JCQ 9| d(%y 9*h
f(z}g* IOI;}yG ?qV;=yG #| ~C #+sQWAT}yGh iQ9Z"yGh O(%+yG #| e;S G
.Oz=yG gP$ ,p ?+|;S G Q(ZyG #| )t< 9| )zf A9]tyG )zf

103

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9*9a| #+}zT}yG A9T! .A9T"yG #| GhP<G - ?y;GyG >I9Y 9* - A:|$ fE


?|(|}Gh ?+FhRyGh B+=yG ,p 9%Awz}| #| 9$(FQLzp .~%\GQiC P+q"Ay
Q+L d9}fC 9%y g(}fR 9}+p cQAW@ - A9D=MyG A:|$ #+tzA< B=$Pp .d9q_}Gh
-JGQ=}yGh J9+qWAT}yGh bG(S}Gh VQ9g}yG #| - &zv O9Tph QV ,$h IGh9T}y9< >y9a@ 9$(gpO ~C HGRI}Gh J9+g}GyG 9%y GhzW!zp 96 G(FQO@ ~C
>y9a@h ?f9ayG B+< A9jyEh J9FhRyG OOg@h b;ayG O++tA< >y9a@h d9FQy9<
?*(]f ,ph {< ?yhOyG rF9ch h+= ,p &g| IGh9T}yGh {FQyG ?vQ9W}<
.f9}yQ=yG
OI h\hh A;=yG GP$ hpOy ~w< E+jATAy ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fE
.#F9}yG E=gyG GP%y
?<9D| QZ| ,p GP$ KOJ* fC Qw"AT@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fE
?Aqy &"f QC|@h :E e(* )]}* : jPyG Ky9ZyG xz}yG 9%SCQ )zfh #+}zT}yG
.?}*Qv ?+|;SE
jPyG #*OyG #f OhPyG #f #*OyG d9FQ e9! Oty .?y;GyG >I9Y 9*
.bhQ9qyG Q+i #*Ozy #}p .J9FQOyG ~%A%yCh r+iQyG ~%zjVh &< f(zvzA*
:969Z! ,p Q(|}G h\(@ &"| ?}zw=p .eOtA! &<9IQ )yEh YRq! &AI9S )y{p
HG(DyG &y uG QLO+Sh .gQZf ,p e;S G Pt!C bhQ9qyG fC N*Q9AyG QvP+Sh
.~+zS >zt< uG )@C #| :E f("< :h d9| hq"* : e(*
{FQyG uzL Os iO$ ~C &tzL A,V {v )afC jPyG ~+wJyG ~+zgyG uG fE
IO:(yGh {}JyGh ?+FhRzy ICQ}yG uzLh #WMyG b9WyG {}gyG #| fzWyG GP%y
&z}fh {FQyG fzV #| ~dfC {}fh fzWy &!Eh IQS}G #*(w@h {qayG ?*9fQh
?+JyG QF9}]yGh #+A}yG uzMyG ihP #+Jy9ZyG d9FQyG ?|~y eOt@ ,AyG ,%p
.#_(yG >J< IQ|9gyG

?+fQWy

9|

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

104

9| 9}$h {FQyG )zf 9| 9%+zfh {FQzy 9| 9%y f9T!E ICQ}y9p


&"*(w@h &tzL >S9"* fzVh {}fh ?q+ch )zf GP$ {gF Osh .AG(S #*OyG
9%"*(w@h 9%tzL >S9"* fzVh {}fh ?q+ch )zf gP$ {gFh .gA9]fCh
f9v fEh QL6G Y("yG #| {]pC #+f("yG OIC f(w* fC #w}* :h 9%F9]fCh
?SBQ< :E ?f9= up(@ fC :h e9d! ~A* fC #w}* : &!C ~zg* jPyG &!9J=S uG
~wJ< 9%F9=f9< e9+tyG )zf QOsC &!C ~zg* &!} {FQzy ?SBQyG gP$ {gF Os
.&tzLh &"*(w@
~a; #zp gO9=f b(p Q$9tyG ~+wJyG ~+zgyG ?"S )zf ICQ}yG BFQL GP{p
xyP Og< KzZ@ #y ,%p ?"+wT}yG ?|}G gP$ :E 9%g| ~a; #yh 9%Tq! :E
.B+=yG LQ9My KzZ@ #y 98C 9}v B+=zy
&yh &"*O &y bQWyG fEh .gO+y9t@h &|9d! &y HQjyG fE .?y;GyG >I9Y 9*
.#*OyG xyP )zf )"=}yG gO+y9t@h &|9d!
QZ!h e;S G x< uG RfCh bhQ9qyG 99C e;S G cQOCh bQWyG cQOzp
.#*OyG x<
.9"|GQAIGh 9"y;FG ~+df d(=t< ?y;GyG >I9Y 9* G(z]q@h
. 1951 ?"S SQ9| 2 upG(}yG 1370 ?"S dhC O9= 24 ,p GQk *Q;
e Ch uG e C

105

? +fQW y

v$ 1370 f

]Qv9V

9=gV

O}IC N+WyG Q*QJAyG )zf

8 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 15

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

aQW}yG[

cQ9=| fGQs

Otf ~@ 1951 ?"S (*9| 6 upG(}yG 1370 ?"S >FQ 30 OI}G e(* ,p
&=J* 9}y &tphh ,uG &dqI dh}G bhQ9p xz}yG ?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]I fGQs
N*Q9AyG GP$ #|h ,bO9Y f9}*Q! :?T!}G OG}yG ?z+zS )zf - g9\Q*h
.?*QZ}yG ?*Q(ASOyG O+y9tAyG >TI yQZ| ?wz| ?y;Fz BJ=YC
,f(}+}yG fGQtyG GP6 9%F9%A<G #zg@ ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=h
up(* fCh ,jQZ}yG >gWzy Q+L eOt|h OgS iQW< f(w* fC uG #| ?+FGQ
,#+}zT}yG f(+fh 9}8(+f Qt@ ,AyG ?Jy9ZyG ?*QPyG 9}%sRQ*h #+wz}yG uG
#| ~*(tyG #*OyGh iO%yGh uJyG u*Q_ ,p OOT* fCh ,&"| MhQ< 9}$O*|* fCh
.| &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av
9%Z! ?=S9"}yG gP6 ?8"7 ?+sQ< xz}yG ?y;F )yE ?f9}GyG BzSQC Osh
:,@}9v
A9"|}G Q+=v )y9g}yG >I9Y IQ]I
[zLC ?+wz}yG IOTyG )yE G(gpQ@ fC (FQ@ ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=
xz}yG ?y;Gy &"| {gG* fC uG ?zF9S ,O+gTyG )wz}yG LGhRy9< )!9%AyG
MhQ< xz}yG uG O*C ,#+}zT}yG f(+fh &"+f 96 Qt@ ?Jy9Y ?*QP ,~dg}yG
.&"|
,tqyG O|9I O}J|

?f9}GyG U+FQ

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

106
1371

"

? O}J}yG ? TyG

? S Qq Y
"

Q 9Z C

IO$9g}yG A9jyE

rs

2 O

Ogy

G 16

Oz G } y

(|

#|

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= {jAW@ : GP9}y ,S9"yG #| Q+Dv dA9TA*


,p #+p9A%yG 9!O*Q@C :&y d(t"p ,&yzT! fC 9"zF9S )zf fEh ??+"_(yG hC ?S9+Ty9<
: ,b9tVh O9Tp ?S9+TyG fE ?f;p W(tSh ,f;p I9+J< HGRI}G >v(|
IO9=gyG ,p ~6Q f(}zT}yG OI(+y {}g! 9}!E .?|P :h :E uG ,p >sQ@
i(tAyG f(w@ fC )zf &y(SQh uG G(g+a+y {}g! .f9}* G uI &< G("||*h
~%F9"<Ch ~%Tq!Ch ~%yG(|z< &z+=S ,p GhO$9G+y ~$(fO! ,gOIh u ?+WMyGh
.&"*O #f Y9pOzy ~6Q ~$9fO GPE
IQd"yG gP$ ?+"_(yG )yE Qd"! : 9"!C O+< ,f9}* G #| 98{p ?+"_(yG 9|C
uG {gF 9}p ,OhOJ| u+\ e(%q| ,p 9$9"g| QZ; ,AyG A9%z=yG IQ+ZtyG
~y9gyG #*O e;S G f(w+y fBQtyG dR!C {< >TJp QZ| #*O e;S G &!9J=S
)yE Qd"!h e;S5y 9"_h &zv ~y9gyG f(w+y #+sO9Y O$9G! #J!h .&zv
: yR+zG! Gz )yE Qd"!h ,Q=v}G )|;S G #_(yG #| ARF 98C )zf yQZ|z
AGOfCh &y(SQh uG AGOfC ~8C )zf {< ,>TJp #_(yG AGOfC ~8C )zf
f9_hC #| #_h 98} {< ,QZ| 98} QZ}y fhO+w* : ~$h ,e;S G
u+tV fGO(TyG ,p f(zgq* xyPvh ,9%y fhO+w* ?=T"yG gP6 ~%p ,e;S G
#*O* ?yhO {vh ,f9ATv9=yGh ,fOQ}G bQVh bGQgyG ,p xyPvh ,QZ|
:C ,uG d(SQ GOk }J| fC IO9%Vh uG :E &yE : fC IO9%Vh e;S 9< 9$(z$C
?W=Jzy G(vQ@ ~8C iQ@ :C ?~%y9g!h ~9O*C f(}Dz*h ,O(%+yG f(zyO* ~$GQ@
9}8} Uz<GQ_h ?sQ< )zf xyP G(<Ch ,9%y;tASG 9+y9a*{< ?zAJ| B!9v ,AyG
QZ| G(}zT| : ,ghQ<OA+yh GP$ f(}zT}yG ~%q+zp .?#+@O9%Wy9< f9ta"*
{< QZ| ~S9< : R+zG! G O$9G! ~%qyG GP6h ,&zv ~y9gyG G(}zT| {< >TJp

107

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

e do :d(t* u9p .uG ~S9< ~$O$9G! :{FCh {=!Ch )}SC ($ 9}<


qponmlkjihgf
~S9< 9"y {}f {v f(w* fC fBQtyG 9!Q|z* GP6 ?*6 ?<(Ay p!@
! yv r
]41

G :

n q

G[

#+}zT}yG (fO!h ,&+p 9}< uG f(g< {}g!h ,fBQty9< #||! #J!h gOIh uG
...~$9+!Oh ~%"*O ,p &< PL}G )yE
)1 (
OQC ,AyG
,Ay9SQ ,p &AzGS 9| ~w+y{p :IO$9g}yG A9jyE #| 9"qs(| 9|C
?|(8W}yG IO$9g}yG gP$ IQ(wW| ?|(wJyG BjyC Otyz Q$R}G N+V )zf 96
rs(}yG GP$ O*|! ?"TyG Q9Z!C #J!h ,IQF9qyG GQAzG!G h| QZ| 97Otf ,AyG
99C ,: :R+zG!5y d(t@ fC ?*QZ| ?|(wI &< Bf9aASG jPyG QGyG Y9GWyG
#| ~w}zc Q+! #w}! #yh ,?yPy e(+yG Og< #+wAT! #y ,f(=Y9jyG I9jayG
k
,gO%f f(< : fC uG h| GO%f H(ztyG eQ=@ fC >G* #wyh .?+!9C IQ| 9"s9"fC
IRfh I(s ,p 9!P=! Otyh ,O9%GyGh ?*O(=gyG ,p gOIh &y S(q"yG f(w@ fCh
.yf9a+WyG h| rzJyG P="! fC uG O$9g"zp ,R+zG! G ?qy9J|
9"k F9L U+y xyP O*|* : #| Q=Ag!h ,O+*zAyG {v ?|(wJyG O*|! #J"p
.&y(SQh &"*Oh u 9"F9L xyP {=s {< >TJp #_(zy
g(Fh ,p uZ=! f6G #J!z IQ(vP}yG ?y9SQyG ,p &A=Av 9| CQs9p ^|G ~C
bQW| Q(gV ,p iOJA!h ,,fO}yG R+zG! G aQV ?"gzy9< ~FQ!h ,R+zG! G
9%+zf P(JAT@ ,AyG QWyG i(s ?S9}Ih ?+}I Os(A@ ~FGRfh ,?|GQwy9<
#+< d(;h ,eGOs G )yE hpO@ ,AyG I(tyG xz}! 9gk += 9"Ty #wyh ,GQAzG!G
QZ"< O+*zAyG I(s .f9}* G ,$ I(tyG xz@h ,rIRyG e(* QGQqyG #+<h iO"GyG
Q(qwyG hOgyG GP%y 9!O9%F ,p uG f(f OW"! 9"!E .9"g| uG fz< #+t+yG I(s ,uG
?&zyG Q+jy cQWyG 9%yPC S(q"<C ?f(gyG OW"! ~=p ,QZ"yG ,p &+yE YQ]!h
gy &zyG dzT! ,?g=a}yG )yE 9=*Qs &zyG A9V fE eOtASh ?y9SQyG gP$ &zyG f(g< B}@ )1(
. S9"zy 9%FGQLEh 9%g=_ )p up(* fC g(fO!h

f( G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

108

O*Ch ,?+"C(yG Q(=s 9%+zf ~D: H(zt<C ??+Zg}yG 9%AC(yh ?WI9qyG 9%AT!Oh
#| u9< 9%zZ@ : MGhQz< eC ?Q(}MyG 9%AzVh ,Q(=tyG )yE ?fGQ]yG 9%AyPC
} | { z y{ uG d(s f(}zT}yG 99C G(g}SG ?Q("yG ?gVC fBQtyG

-,+*)( '&%$#"!~
;: 987 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / .
G F ED CB A @?> =<
T S R Q P O NM LK J
I H
_^]\[ZYXWVU
kj i h
gf e dc b a `
.
HJy }
n ml

[42-38 :

G]

?"TyGh H9Awy9< e9ZAf:Gh ,K+JZyG f9}* G )yE #+}zT}yG (fO! #J!


#| f(}zg* a(Sh ,uG {+=S ,ph uG ~S9< ~$O9%F f(w* fC )yE ~$(fO!h
a(Sh ,d(SQyG #+< 9}v J9t<(}yG h=TyG #| rIRyG e(* QGQqyG fC :#*OyG
*
)( ' & % $ # " o uG d(s ~6(zt< fhQ<OA*

6 5 4 32 10/ . - @
! ! vz , +
f9}* 9<h p!@
!v{ @? > = <; : 987

OqyGh ?+J]AyG )yE gQ+i u<9T* ;a< iO"F {v #| ?|(wJyG O: GP6


9| ?|(wJyG OgAyh ,uG )yE #+<GhC #w"yh ,K+JZyG f9}* 9< KzTA"zp
fPC GPE O9S6G gP$ uza"@ a(Sh ,M;Ty9< OQp {v O}Ayh I(s #| Bf9aASG
,>fQy9< &@GQwTg| #| {*O@h ,Q+FRy9< hOgyG >$Q@ 9%"*Qf #f O9%Gzy
MGO"@ f9}* G i(s ~6(zs ,ph 9!9=vQh :9FQ 9<9=Vh 9=+V f(*QZ}yG uza"+S
,e9_6G dRyR* 9S9}I fGO+}yG )yE f(tza+S ,f9+jayG i(s {v 9%|9|C
#< U!C &y9s 9}y GO*OQ@ho 9p9A$ fGO+}yG ~6(zs ~}ASh f(ZJyG cO@ ~FGRfh
R+zG! G {@9t"zp .yOIo C fhO 9$OFC ,!E !! ?"GyG K*Qy 9$k Ghz OIC e(* Q]"yG
.AG

109

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

#_(yG ~S9< : - ~$Oy9G"yh ,>TJp QZ| AGOfC : uG AGOfC ~8C )zf


(=< :h ,&Aw*Qf #+z@ : GOk9%Fh ?SOt| 9<QI 9%"zg"y ,uG ~S9< #wyh
LQG(< hC ,Q|O@ JGQF9_ J9*9jyG #+<h &"+< d(; :h ,&A}+wV :h &A}*Rf
($ uGh ,uG 9"g| f} ,9qT! d9=GyG rT"@ J9qS9! hC ,GQ9! QJ=yG {+;
.Q9=GyG Q9%tyG R*RgyG i(tyG
)zf 9<QI 9%"zgAyh ,Q+LG(}yG xz@ eO%Ayh ,(%zyG QhO ?|(wJyG uzjAyh
&!9}*{< H9=WyG [zM* )AI ,#+"F9MyG iO*C )zf HQ]Ayh ,JGQw"}yG
,QqdyG eRAg}yG ,QZ"yG )zf ~}Z}yG ,I(tyG eQ9gyG O9%GyG )yE uJyG O*OGyG
k
k
GOIGh 9<RI f(w! fC O*Q! ,?"GyG K*Q fGO+}yG ,p &y9a<C uW"AT* jPyG
.IOIGh ?}zv )zf h}AG*
)zf A9}fRyGh >gWyGh ,f(SDQ}yGh A9SDQyG ,9%zv ?|}G f(w@ fC O*Q!
a `_
^ ]\ [
Z YX W
o :&zyG d(s
-

l k ji h
gf
e d cb
xwvutsr
q p o nm
( '&% $ # " ! ~}| { z y
ED C
BA
o :&y(sh
?*6 ?y 9G}y p@
! ! ww + *
)
#| f(w! fC O*Q! :h
?*6 O 9}y p!@
!z{ K J
I HG
F
<;: 9 8 7 o ~%+p uG d9s #*PyG f9a+WyG HRI
.
?*6 ?y 9G}y p!@
!v~ E D CB A
@
? > =
]22

]56

]19

G : O

G :I F

G : O

G[

G[

G[

?S9+TyG #| u+]yG b9a"yG GP$ ~$QZJ* #yh ,?"TyG Q9Z!C {}g* GP%y
.,zqTyG GhQqv #*PyG ?}zvh 9+zgyG ,$ uG ?}zv f(w@ )AI GhCO9 #yh

{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f


?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy dh}G {+v(yG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

110
IO

$9g}yG

A9jyE

9T| ,p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG RvQ}yG IQGOE UzG| h}AFG
VQgASGh - 1951 Q<(AvC 23 upG(}yG v$ 1371 eQJ| 22 A9C;DyG e(*
-:,@z* 9| QQsh IQ+L}G JGQ(aAyG A(\ )zf Q\9JyG rs(}yG
k
.;|9v GO+*z@ IO$9g}yG A9jyE O+*z@ -::hC
k
M9qwzy dh}G rZyG ,p G(!(w+y ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C OGOfE -:9+!9C
.R+zG! G O\ ~%Tq!Ch ~%yG(|z< uG {+=S ,p O9%GyGh
k
HQJyG f;fE )yE ?+|;S G H(gWyGh iQZ}yG >gWyG EI -:9Dy9C
.e;S G ?}zv A;fEh uG {+=S ,p ~$O9%F f(w+y #*Q}gAT}yG )zf ?+"*OyG
9%D< ,AyG O9TqyGh ?+"C(yG Q$9d| ?<Q9J| )yE ?|(wJyG I(fO -:9gk <GQ
.?SOt}yG HQJyG gP$ ,p u H(ztyG [z< )AI Q}gAT}yG
k
k
.&y(SQyh u 9"F9L ~$Of9T* hC R+zG! G fh9g* #| {v Q9=AfG -:9T|9L
~7(+<h ?*R+zG! G J9GA"}yGh hF9]=yG ?g_9t}< ?|}G ?=y9a| -:9Sk O9S
.xyPv ~y9dyG ~%qs(| ,p ~%vQ9W* #|h Q9}gAS:G H9!PC ?z|9g|h ?+y9}yG
A

111

? +fQW y

v$ 1371 )!
~wJ

*h

Y QW

e;S

5y

9D y h <

Q 4 O

u QayG

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 16

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

(JTpC

{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]qy


?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F

dhC

{+vh

9=WyG #| )}dgyG ?+=y9jyG )zf Qa+T@ QZ| ,p ?+"*OyG J9f9}GyG O9w@


#| I(tyG ?v(%"| MGQGy9< ?"MD| 9$BQp ,QZ| )zf g9"+f BJAq@ jPyG H9=WyG
,JG(%WyG IO9=fh ,A9}fRyG &+yz@ )zf ~F9tyG )"C(yG )S9+TyG #I9aAyG xyP
,AyG ?A+t}yG ?+<RJyGh J9FQOyGh >Y9"}yG {+=S ,p O+wyGh r!OyG d9AtyGh
e9IQC #| H(ztyG #+< 9| Bgash ,Qf9W}yG )zf B"Fh ,b;L}G JOTpC
- uG {+=S ,p : ,&+<Ch Oy(yGh &+LCh N}G #+< BsQph ,IO(}yGh I(L}G
&T=yC J(i9ayG ,{+=S ,p ,f9a+WyG {+=S ,p {< - f9}*Eh ?=J| uG {+=Sh
IQ(aS}G &Aqzih ,{a=yG IQ(Y ,p ?+"C(yG &@Q(Yh ,?|9fRyG H(C ~$(yG
,Q$9d}yG AGQh 9| Ba="ASG GPE B!Ch .jQt=gyG )"_(yG O9%GyG )V(<
L9%"| 9%y HGRI}G gP$ {v JOFh ,b9}f}G )yE ?qV9wyG IQd"yG BzSQCh
{gFh ,uG H9Av Q+j< ~wJyG 9}$ ,9%+yE )gT@ IOIGh ?*9ih ,OIGh
gP$ #+< {Zq* 9| B}C 9}p ,cGP hC HRJyG GP$ )zf 9qsh iQGR(yG >Z"}yG
.9%F9}fR A9}SCh ,9$D9}SC :E HGRI}G
S(q! )zf 9%A*9"Fh 9%A8+aL {< 9$QCC ?+z$9GyG ?+<RJyG gP%y f9vh
.#+*QZ}yG
GP9}yh !?}t"y9< 9%_(T*h ,?"gzy9< bL9TyG >gWyG 9%=Q+p ?|(wI >$P@
,979+J< a9A%yG H9MY O*OGyG ?|(wJyG >v(| ,p Q+T* ~C !!jQO* :
("Y ,$h ,GP9}zp 9%y u+qZAyG #| rv}G OfGQ ,9%AyGOg< QF9W=yG O+<Qf
>9 )AI f(=$GPyG 9%+p bW"* J9dJy :E ,$ 9|h ! iQO* : !??=$GPyG
{FGQ| QG(pn ,,yh}G &< h+V 9}< 9%g+V B=$P GP{p ,9$Q+j< 9=k y9a| >gWyG
,H

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

112

Uq"< GOk f(A| GQO9$ ,9$O}J< BJ=S ,AyG g9qWyG Uq"< 9$9*E 9"f: ,>]jyG
Uq"< Q(Gy9< 9%}wI 9Af9! ,9%=vG(| LQ6 ,p u+qZAyG 9$9|OC ,AyG rv}G
GPw$h !! iQO* : ?GP9}y .9%AyGOg< JQW< 9| IQDv #| B=Z! ,AyG ?"Ty}G
kn o
fC fhO A9]j=yGh ?=J}yG #+< ?yhO H(ztyG JOi )AI !! IQ| {v ,p x+yGhO
r v n
. !! B]j<C GP9}yh ,B=IC GP9}y ~zg@
&!9%vh gQ9=IC ?+J\ e(zd}yG >gWyG GP$ f} ?GP9}y f(}zg@C #wyh
Q+_9SC ?"AqyG ,p g9|Qh ,f9%wyG ?+"Ch gOF9tf &+zf JOTpC ,&F9}fRh
uJyG &"*O< ($ ;p .A9}fRyG B+iG(ayG uJyG SOs #f &< {\h ,Q9=I}G
n
?+|;S G IQd"yG &+r yG(In 9| )yE Qd! ($ :h ,#||* 9+zgyG &}+t< :h ,{qJ*
)+;C !! gOfG(s cO@ eC ,#*OyG ~+t@C &A|(wI #| &+"g* ;p ,IOOT}yG ?=F9ZyG
vn
AaO U"@ 9}y ,$h ,?}+A+yG 97Q$R )zf R%: eC ,gQC5|h e;S G O9G|C
)AI 9$G(ja< B=w@ eC ,&Ag*QW< PL6G )yE I(fOyG )zf #+g@C !! e9}v}G
?}*QGzy 9+p !! H9$Q G I(aS #| IQ(fP}yG ?qA%yGh ,?}y9JyG ?T}%yG
#| >gWyG GP%y 9*h ,&A+iG(_h &+zf >gWyG GP$ f9%v 9%IQAFG ,AyG AGQw"yG
b9}fC )p IQtAT| ?+"*OAyG I(tyG fC #+I )p !! &z@9s ?*9"F &+zf >T; {+As
I(tyG gP$ O(Fh )zf O$9V HQsCh K+JZyG &+F(AyG O*Q@ 9%"wyh >gWyG GP$
A9}zgyG J(Y hq@Q* fE 9}p ,?+="F}G ?<QV}G xz@ #| >gWyG rs(|
f9azS J9| )AI E=L 98z< iO9"* ?ZzM}yG ?+"*OyG ?f9}GyG OG(s #+ZzM}yG
gP$ )yE ?dgy9< f(AqAz* A9}zgyGh IO9tyG B+zp .S(q"yG )zf ?<QV}G gP$
,uJyG #| &!(}Aw* 9| Q9=I}G &}zg*h ,uJyG #*Oy9< >gWyG fhO(t* ,IQ=gyG
?g*QV :E ?g*QV : fCh ,?"TyGh H9AwyG #| PLC 9| :E #*O : fC ($h
~wI : fCh ,fBQtyG Q(! #| ?8+]| 9S9=sC f9v 9| :E f(!9s : fCh ,e;S G
.e;S G ~wI :E ~y9gyG KzZ*
)yE &F(A* MGQp ,S(q"yG )zf ?+"C(yG ?+<RJyG ?*9"F rtD}yG H9=WyG iCQ

113

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?}zdyG gP$ ,p Q("yGh uJyGh ,AGOzy AGhOyGh ,MGQGzy ~Tz=yG &"| OW"* #*OyG
?+"*OyG J9f9}GyG iQ@ 96 GPEh ,HGRI}G O* #| Bzq* e9|Ry9< GP{p ,?+F9TyG
,GP6 9S(q! QW=AT"y 9!Eh ,fGO+}yG KTAw@h ,H9=WyG O(t@h ,?"f}G &F(@
>gWyG IO(f ?=s9f -9ts Ih GQk +L f(w@ fC uG dzT! ,AyG- ?=s9gyG K}z! O9w!h
,gOIh #+}y9gyG HQ u ?Zy9MyG ?*O(=gyG HGQJ|h ,#*OyG IQ+dI )yE &zv
fC {+=S ,ph ,?"TyGh fBQtyG iO$ #| h*QWAyG f(w* fC {+=S ,p O9%GyGh
.9+zgyG ,$ uG ?}zv f(w@
#| {+zs aGQJ!G iCh ,IQ+aL d9tC J9g=@ ?+"*OyG J9f9}GyG )zf #wyh
&A*9"F &y f(wAS ,| &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av #| #+=}yG uJyG #f ?f9= ?*C
J9f9}GyG gP$ QPJAy ,#+}zT}yGh e;S G )zf )!9GyG gQaLh ,IQ+aMyG
#| ?+"C(yG KGQ@ f(%y|* ,A9}fRyG &+yz@ dO=p .HGRI}G xy9T| xzT@ fC
,QWyG e;S 9< #+Z<QA}yG ?"TyCh O* ,p f(g]+p ,A9<6Gh N(+WyG
96 f(A%=* J9*QAq|h 96 98("ga* ?|(}T| QF9"L ,O+wyG ?+"*OyG J9f9}Gy9<h
e;TyGh iO%yGh uJyGh Q+MyG )yE ~y9gyG IO9+ty KzZ* : &!C ,$ ,e;S G
.e9d"yGh h*QWAyGh ,f9}* G #| ?*h9}TyG ~+tyG {wy 9+zgyG {D}yG )yE ,IRgyGh
H9AwyG #| iO%yGh uJyG ?%Fh B%F(@ ?+"*O ?f9= {v fC (y uJyG #+t*h
)zf GQk9ZfE Q+T@ I(sh yf(}zT}yGz ~$ IOIGh ?f9= f(w"Tp ,?"TyGh
,~zdyG {J| dOgyG {;h ,?+"C(yGh O9Jy G )zf ?tf9Y dR"@h ,cQWyG
f(gy9< uGh ,QqwyGh cQWyG {J| f9}* Gh O+I(AyGh ,{_9=yG f9w| uJyGh
?+"*O ?f9= {v ~w* fC )zf Q*OtyG &!9J=S uGh ,9$9fQ* QZ"y9<h ,9$O}*
uG )yE I(fOyG {+=S ,p xzTAp ,&"*O #| uJyG ?%Fh 9%%F(* fCh ,Q+My9<
` _^]
o fhOA%}yG ?}F}G &<9JYCh ,| uG d(SQ &wzS 9|

o n m l kj i
h
g
f
e dc b a
p@
! !{y {
z y x w vut
sr
qp

dB[

]64

?*6G :fGQn }fp

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

114

?gS9Ay ? Ty
G

"

{ZqyG

?}zT}yG ?|}G )yE

Of

G 12 O

=y Oy

1364 i( " G i

(tyG

O}J|

H9=V b9D+|

?"S IOgtyG jP #| 14 ,p | O}J| H9=V iQ(V UzG| h}AFG


,~y9gyG A9J!C h+= ,p #+}zT}yG ?y9I e9f &F(< VQgASGh v$ 1364
?+|(tyG >y9a}yG U9L &F(< VQgASG 9}v ,~%"| ?+="F}G dhOyG rs(|h
:,@z* 9| QQsh ,J5+%yG rzAM| 96 JO9! ,AyG
k
)zf {F9S(yG {w< {}gyGh ,?z_9< 1936 ?"S IO$9g| Q9=AfG -::hC
.,="FC Q+! {v #| {+"yG iOGh Q*Q;
o
k
CRGA* : ;v )|;S G #_(yGh ,IOIGh ?|C #+}zT}yG Q9=AfG -:9+!9C
k
hC )S9+S O+s {v #| ,&"| Q=V {v Q*Q; ,p 9g+= &F9"<C #|9]@ )yE I(fOyGh
.jO9ZAsG hC iQwTf
,p ?+|;S G H(gWyG ?+t<h #++T+!hO!}Gh #+"+aTzqyG O+*z@ -:9Dk y9C
&F(< ?*O(%+yGh ,?+="F}G hF9]=yG ?g_9t| )yE I(fOyGh ,,"*OyG ~$O9%F
.U9L
O\ ?+_GQs(}*OyG dhOyG >Zg@ )zf NQ9ZyG L9GAI:G -:9gk <GQ
,p ~%"|9]@h ,~%t+CG(|h ~$O(f(y ~%qzLh ,f9w| {v ,p #+}zT}yG
.~%+zf IQa+TyGh ~$O9=gASG ?yh9J|
9$O9%F ~+fO@ )yE HQj}yGh bQW}yG ,p ?}zT}y G ?|}G I(fO -:9Tk |9L
M9G"y ?|R;yG I(tyG Q+p(@h 9%p(qY ~+d"A< ?=ZAj}yG 9%s(tI {+=S ,p
:,@z* 9}< xyPh ,~$O9%F
9$Og=*h ,9%A+}Ih ?|} G ?y(FQ< xAq* jPyG )tzMyG {zJAyG ?Jp9w| )1(
#+!G(tyG {J| ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG d;I{< xyPh ,gQZ!h uG ?*9}I #f

115

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)};h ,9+zgyG ?+s;L}G 9%zD}< ?|}G IO9gS {qw@ ,AyG ,$h ,?+g\(yG
)}SQyG A9j=yG )jz* )AI ,?fOGQyG 9$OhOJ< dG(|}Gh VGQf}Gh MGhQ}G
)!9i}G #| ?fGP G Q%a@h ,Q9}tyG QhOh [sGQ}yGh J9!9JyG uzj@h
O9g@h ,A9T"yG )zf H9GJyG VQq*h ,IQfGOyG J;G}yG O+t@h ,?g+zMyG
.B+=yG ($h 96 uF;yG 989w| )yE ICQ}yG
>Y9jy G &<9G* fC #| h}GyG #w}A* )AI ?+S9+TyG HGRI}G {I )H(

Ok IGh 9qY
QW"< xyPh .~%s(tI ?pQg|h S9"yG #+< d(J* jPyG {%GyG ?Jp9w| )L(
)AWy 9Sk 9SC )"*OyG ~+zgAyG {gFh .J9t=ayG #+< ?+|;S G ?+"_(yG ?p9tDyG
~+zgAyG {IGQ|
e9}A$:G #+<h ?|}G #+< f:(J* #*PyG VQ}yGh QtqyG ?Jp9w| )O(
)]t@h .Q+tp {wy L;gyGh J(tyG {qw@ ,AyG I9vRyG VQq< xyPh .9%s(tJ<
.?+f9}AF:G bQG(qyG )zf
.?+"_(yG J9f("Z}yG h+GWA< iO9ZAs:G Q9}gAS:G ?Jp9w| )v$(
E=@ ,AyG ?+|;S G ?t*QayG )zf 9*k Q9=FE iQwTgyG O+"GAyG {gF )h(
.IRgyG MhQ
k
G(_Qp ,AyG ?p;MyG Q|z< e9}A$:G )yE ?}zT}yG ?|}G I(fO -:9SO9S
jPyG dh}G e9|:G ~%Tq!} GhOF(*h ,jQ=wyG ~7OIh GhO+gAT* )AI ,9%+p
&!h9g* ,?z|9v ~zT}yG ~v9JyG ?azS &y f(w@h ,&@Q9VE f(=z*h ,&< fhQ}@z*
?phQg}yG IO+VQyG QY9"gyG #| ~$Q9AM* OtgyGh {JyG {$C #| iQ(V UzG|
,e;S G ~+y9gAy 9tph ?q+zMyG ~S9< &}wJ* #| Qas {wyh ?*9qwyGh i(tAy9<
.U9L iQ(V UzG| IOf9T|h
Ky9Z| ,p Qd"zy 9gk |9F 9+k |;SE GQk }@|| HJyG ~S(| Q9=AfG -:9gk <9S
.G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

116

OG|h e;S G IRf {qw* 9}< ~$Q(|C ?pO &+F(@h ~%AS9+S Q*Qt@h #+}zT}yG
I(fOyGh b9D+}yG GP$ )|;S G ~y9gyG k+z=Ay ?=*QtyG &AYQp R9%A!Gh ,#+}zT}yG
.&t+t; )zf {}gyG )yE
)1(

)cGQOASGh

u zg@(

~$Qt!h &F9* )yE &qyC #| ~%s9D+| )zf | O}J| H9=V upG(! yj(="yG iO%yGz
xz@ ~%+p #*Q=w| ,9"gaASG 9| gP+q"@ )zf ~%g| {}g!h ,&< A9F 9| {v )zf
,p ~%Y;LE ~%+zf Qw"! :h .b9D+}yG GP$ ~%+zf Bz|C ,AyG ?=+ayG MhQyG
O("< #| b9D+}yG ,p 9| fC )yE ~%IQ9Z! fC >J! 9"wyh .&+yE f(fO* 9| {v
k
dPyG ?y9I #| [zMA@ )AI ?+|;S G ?|~y GQ(ASO f(w@ fC f(=J*
jPyG )S9S}G VQjzy ?+y9@ JG(aL :E ,$ fE :9%+p ,$ ,AyG O9=gAS:Gh
>FG(V #| O+I(AyG O*Q: ($ xyP .f9*O}G QF9Sh {< ,e;S G &+yG 9fO
~y9gyG uzL #| ?+F9jyG ?zgyG gP$ .gOIh uG IO9=fh ,9%fG(!C h+}G< cQWyG
J9f9}GyG ?+t< :h ~$ : ,~%s9D+| ,p fG(L}G x8yhC 9%y VQgA* ~y
k
J:9I #| ?y9I &+zf u=a"@ #y #+}zT}yG #| GOIC fC #*OtAg| ?+|;S G
fC h| ,>GgyG OVC &y >Gg! 9}| ?"TyG 9%AIQVh fBQtyG 9$QvP ,AyG cQWyG
&fG(!C ?p9w< cQWyG P=!h [y9MyG O+I(AyG )yE ?J*QY I(fO 9gk += 9%Y(Z!
,~8zV ?gpQh ~7Rg< #+}zT}yG X9qAIG ,p QV9=}yG >=TyG &zgG+y &!E )AI
W V U T S Ro A;Fh ?IGQY ,p d(t* PE ,~89azS I(sh

ba`_^]\[ZYX
onmlkjihgfedc
p@
! ! zz w v u t s r q p
.

]55

?*6G :Q("wyG[

9v 9*k C uJyG O*|@ )%p #+qy9M}yG h| 9%z|9g@ ,p ?f9}GyG rs(| f9+=y ?y9t}yG gP$ JQvP )1(
:h xyPv ~%=TJ! ~F: ?|(y &zyG )p )W< : &< {|9gyGh {F9tyG )zf {_9=yG OQ@h &zF9s
.&zyG )zf ~%+vR!

117

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

zg}y9< ?zgyG b<Q gOIh &@O9=g< ~$9*E &@QZ! &!9J=S b<Q Otp
~C .;*(; 9%"f :h ;*O=@ 9%y O: #y ,AyG &A"S xz@h ,>=T}y9< >=TyGh
,p IQZ"yG ,$h &A}IQ #| OQay9< Qqv #| ?*6G e9AL ,p Of(@ r+v Qd!G
?|}G fC #+}zg| Q+i {\9p}G fG(L}G ~zg+yh IQL6G ,p IQqj}yGh 9+!OyG
?*C ,p uG Q+i IO9=fh cQWyG :E OfG(tyG #| 97Rf )zf )@C 9| ?+|;S G
uG d9s 9| IQ(aMyG #| ?yR"}yG gP6 #w* ~y (yh ,cQWyG GP$ Q(Y #| IQ(Y
pk j i h g f e d c b a ` _o &"f {Fh Rf
x
fC #| QDvC x%A"@ &@9|QI #| ?|QI )zf Q9j* : &!9J=S u9p
?*6 9T"y
?t+tJyG )zf ~$O+S ($h gQ+i )yE S9"yG aQZ"+p O+I(AyG H9"G< E=g*
.~g"yG QF9S #| &< f(gA}A* 9}< ~%+zf ~g"}yGh
9| {gq@ e(+yG #+}zT}yG #| ?tI9TyG IQDwyG f(w@ fC ~w+zf #}dg* :h
{tfC G(!9v HQgyG )vQW| fE {< ,IPty9< IPtyG hPI ?+z$9GyG {$C &zgq* f9v
uzMy9< )y9g@h &!9J=S HQyG OQq* jPyG ?+<(<QyG O+I(A< G(vQW* fC #|
#
" !
~}| {o ?@9| Gh A9+I Gh bRQyGh
gOGQpE ($ jPyG ?+$(y}G O+I(@ ,p ~%vQV f9v {<
?*6 Q|Rw y p$
f9v E+I ,e(+yG )}zT| cQV #| rLC - {v(AyGh IO9=gyGh A9fOy9< &!9J=S
O*Q: eOg< :E ~%vQV f9v 9|h .#*OyG &y #+ZzM| uG G(fO Q]yG ~69YC GPE
G(y9tp - IO9=f ~%AIGQZy 9$(}S Osh - uG Q+i I(fO >FG(V #| ?*O(=gyG
?f9qV 9%"+g< ,$ xz@h ?*6 Q|Rw y p! ~}| {z y
o
k
9S9=y e;S G GhO@QG #*PyG x8yhC 9%+zf OGRh .#+Jy9ZyG ?_9Shh #*OtAg}yG
,J9pQyG {$C JG(|}G #| - uG Q+i G(fO ~8C ~6(zs ,p f9}* G {LO* 9}yh
rzv #| &+p Q<9w* : 9}| Q]yG rWvh hq"yG >zF ,p - JGQw!h aQ9g|
?8<h}G gP$ f9<E ,p 9Yk (ZL H9=tyG {$C J9I9S )yE H9$PyG &Tq!
&"| fQaqA* JG(}TyG O9w@ 9| &+!Pz< h}T+p OyG(| 98(}T* ,AyG ?+s;L}G
.GO$ d9=GyG Q<h VQ}G uW"@h
,d(

]48

]38

]3

G :

G[

G :

G :A

G[

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

118

#+z|9gyG ,&*O6 #*OA%}yG dhC G(!(w* fC >G* | O}J| H9=V fE


k
9!E ,?w}< &A|9sE dG(_ | (fO* f9v e:E ?*hQyG #+g< GPE GhQd"+zp ,&A"T<
IAGQsh ,&A"S ,p &tqAyGh d(SQyG IQ+S ?SGQO GhO+g* fC #+ZzM| ~$(fO!
dR! fC O%f #| A9g= ?*QW=yG H9Av &!C A(\ )zf &+zf dR!C jPyG H9AwyG
#|R iC ,p ,&"| NzT!G Otp 9$GOg@ #| GOkhOI OI Osh ,?f9TyG e(t@ fC )yE
9"T=z@ fE e(|P| cQWyG YG(!C #| ?+z$9GyG ,p &|P 9}p .Q%c S9=y iz<h f9v
9}v 9"y gQZ! eOfh 9!9*E uG f9+T! #| gQ9CB ?=@QA|h ,&GF9A! 9"+zf ?gsGhh &<
#| ~%g| uG rs(|h ,f(}zT| 9!E G(y9s #*PyG {+TyG A9Di ,p 9|9}@ d9JyG ($
.f(<P9wy ~8C O%W* ~%+zf &FGOfC b+zT@
k
gQ+i AGhO ~%+qW* #y jPyG #+}zT}yG AGhO fC #+}zg| Q+i 9]*C G(}zfGh
?yh|| Q+i ?"TyGh H9AwyG U(Z! &< JA9F 9| S9SC )zf uG ?pQg| ($ aQf #}p ,9%t*Q_ Q+i S9"y9< G(wzS hC 9%t+tJA< G("g* ~y #}| ?zag| :h
hC N+Wy ?+=Zf Q+j<h ?*hQh {tg< | &y(SQ &< &pQfh &Tq! &< aQq f 9}< uG
9}+p iOQA* fC J9%+%p #+=@ GPE uJyG #f aQG(ZyG #| #*P$ Q+i hC >$P|
,AyG xz@ ,A9}TyGh VQ}G 9%"| H]@ R9M| #| e(+yGh f(}zT}yG &+p iOQ@
)yE ~A%:G {< ?zgyG {YC G(ZMW@ fC ~w@9qp 96QI )zf ~wTq!C ~Aqsh
fC >J! )IG("yG >gWA| e9t| GP$h ,IOI )zf ;v fhhGO@ VGQf}G
OOgyG ,p IQ(W"}yG ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= O9=| ,p GRvQ| &+yE ~wAqz!
.j(="yG iO%yG #| )\9}yG
,U;L:G ~w@(fO ,ph ,?|9tAS:Gh Q+MyG ~w+p OtAg! 9"!C O%W* uGh
k
jPyG O9TqyG xyP O\ IOIGh ?%=F 9g| f(w! fC #+Z*QI OF #J!h
KZ"< &"f S9"yG hzt* ~y fE jPyGh ,QJ=yGh Q=yG ,p Q%c )AI iQWASG
.~+df e(* O%W| #| ~%y {*(p #+ZzM}yG I9fOyG efhh ,#+JY9"yG

119

? +fQW y

=y Oy

j( " G i

e9gyG

OF9tyG

G 12 O

(8"%* ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 16

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

Q9Z C

?"S UaTiC 6 upG(}yG 1371 ?"S IOgtyG jP #| 15 A9g<Q}G e(* Q%c


?z+]p ~%SCQ )zfh ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= #| Oph {<9s 1952
HQI f9vQC AG(zyG IQ]I )tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG e9gyG U+FQyG P9AS}G
,?=S9"| efhh ?8"7 ?}zv U+FQyG )tyCh .?JzT}yG JG(tyG OF9s >+G! O}J|
:&Z! GP$ H9aM< ?<(JZ| ?f9}GyG aGO$C #| ?MT! &y eOsh

$ # "!

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F :#|


?JzT}yG

]9

]44

OF9tyG :,yE

f9+<h ,uG H9Av :9%G|9!Q<

4 32 1 0/o
pK J
I HG
F ED o

?*6G

?*6G :{J"q yG[

&y(SQ

JG(tzy e9gyG

:AG

Qn S

G[

p5

97x (fO ,p ?=FGO ,$h ,fQs h<Q #| QDvC P"| B8W!C ,AyG ?f9}GyG gP$ fE
n
QvP@ fz< aQWA@ .9%G|9!Q< #f O+; : ,uJyG ~%y(SQ iO$ )yE #+}zT}yG
~%DgA<Gh ,#+}y9dyG I9j=yG #| Oz=yG GP$ P9t! uG ~%]+s #*PyG d9a<}G
&Ay9sEh ,&@(=v #| &< V(%"zy ~%|OMASGh ,#*OTq}yGh O9TqyG #| gQ+%aAy
d9a<C #| #*O$9G}yG {GS ,p ~%F9}SC {+GTA< ~%|QvCh ,&@QDf #|
.e;S G
iO%yG #| J9"+<h S9"zy iO$ uG dR!C jPyG - fBQtyG fC :~$QvP@
&+\Q jPyG ~8(!9sh ,#+}zT}yG Q(ASO 9}$ | d(SQyG f9+<h - f9sQqyGh
#|B #}y uG #}\ Osh .f(!9s :h Q(ASO 9}8hO #| ~%y U+y ~6Q ~%y

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

120

9G"yGh IQL6G M;ph ,97Rfh 9+!OyG IO9gS :{}gyGh IO+tgy9< h=@Gh xyP<
?=+My9< - e;S G )fO* ($h - 9}$Q+i )yE ~v9; #| Of(@h .96GPf #|
.~y9c .uS9p .Qp9v :&!z< &}Yhh ,fGQTMyGh
#| U+FQyG f9w| OOJ*h ,&<Q #| O=gyG rs(| OOJ* jPyG ($ fBQty9p
#| xy9}yGh ,ICQ}yG #| {FQyGh ,e(wJ}yG #| ~v9JyGh ,ShDQ}yG
.?"+!z}_h #|C ,p &tI uI jP {v )yE iO|@ fC S(q"yG r+9h .Q+F}G
,$ )Azy iO9h .&@9pBh h}AG}yG VGQ|C h+= Hy9g* jPyG ($ fBQtyGh
)yE QF9Zp &t*Q_ Q+i #f M;YE {wp &"_9<h f9T! G Q$9c KzZ*h .e(sC
9"*O*C #+< {Do }yGh .AGQ(yG )yE S9wA!G (%p &!hO #| ~$(A* eOt@ {vh ,O9TqyG
,p {D}yG HQ]| B!9v .?SOt}yG O;=yGh HQgyG IQ*RF :96QsCh .IQ\9I
)zf O(gTyG #<G xz}yG ?y;F ^=s #+Ih .J9|QJyG c9%A!Gh O9TqyG
,9I;Y 9$O9Tph ,9"|C 9%p(L dO=@ ,uG OhOI 9%+p e9sCh ,9%|9|R
k
9_9W! 9$O(vQh ,)"i 9$Qtph ,9!k GQ}f 96GQLh .?|9tASG 9%F9F(fGh
k
.9=ZL 96OFh .9|Ot@h
?|C Q+L Ky9ZyG 9"qzS 9}6 f9v | 9"+=! ?"S gP$h .uG H9Av GP%p
.u9< f("||*h Qw"}yG #f f(%"*h ahQg}y9< fhQ|z* :S9"zy BFQLC
n ml { IRgyGh QZ"yG uG ~w@|* f(!9tyGh Q(ASOyG 9}$(zgF9p
I

| { z y x w v u tsr
qp o
[ Z Y X W V U T S R{ } }

gfedcba`_^]\
utsrqponmlkjih
Wwv
. ]55

~wzgFh ,{}gyG Ky9Yh f9}*

G bO

?*6G

:Q

( "yG [ }

9Y ~wsRQh ,{|}G ~w< uG utI

121

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

] \ [ Z Y X W V U{ :~%+p d9s #}|


h+}GyG uphh } e d c b a ` _ ^
.&

=JYh &yBh O}J| 9"+=! )zf cQ9<h ~zSh uG )zYh .O9VQyGh OGOTzy
&@9vQ<h

uG

?}IQh ~w+zf e;TyGh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

v$ 1372 I

122

Ogty

G jPh dG(

11 , 10 fGO

Ogy

G 17

Oz G } y

?f9}GyG Q9=LC

*Q(%}F

QZ| ?

U+FQ >F9!h ?*Q(%}GyG U+FQy ?8"7 ?f9}GyG 9%AzSQC ,AyG ?+sQ=yG IQ(Yz

yAGQR( G

9 JAyG [zLCh )!9%AyG {Fz< eOtA@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=


O9TqyG QY9"f #| 9$P9t! ~%Tq!C G(yP< #*PyG QZ| d9a<} J9+"}AyG bOYCh
f(yP=*h IR*RgyG I9+JyG u*Q_ ,p Q+TyGh 96 V(%"yG #f 96 Ogt@ B!9v ,AyG
#| 9$Q+%a@ #| ?"TyG Q9Z!C &+yE )gT@h &=; 9| )yE 96 Z(z=yG ,p ~%Tq!C
~vO}*h gQZ"< ~vO*|* fC i(tyG uG dzT@h ~69!PCh ~%$9=VCh R+zG! G
{v )yE {+=TyG uG &zgF jPyG K+JZyG e;S G RGRfz< ~wtp(*h &"| MhQ<
.IQL6Gh 9+!OyG ,p M;ph Q+L
J+

,tqyG O|9I O}J|

?"TyG Q9Z!C J9f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG

123

? +fQW y

v$ 1372

(yG

AGQR

UzG| U

+F Q

? S Qq Y

2 O

"

eQAJ}yG

O TyG

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 17

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

)y E

~S9< OyG(}yG ?|9sE ?=S9"}<h ,h+}GyG gOW"* jPyG M;Y G AGQh 9*k QF
O+TyG )yE 9pGQjz@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG RvQ}yG bQ<C ,,@(}yG
#| #+}zT}yG OF9tf Q+%a@ &+p f(FQ* AGQR(yG UzG| U+FQ eQAJ}yG
I(tyG iQZ}yG >gWyG ,p f(w* )AI ,cQWyG fQOh YO=yGh J9pGQMyG
:&Z"< ($ 9$h .Q+%aAyGh M;Y G Bsh ,Bs(yG GP%y #+<(za}yG f9}* Gh
>+G! O}J| AG(zyG O+TyG IQ]I
?T+SOh ,?+"Ch ?fO< #+Jy9ZyG #| )@(}yG ~S9< OyG(}yG A9+IE QGQ}ASG
b(zM}yG IO9=f )yE ,,JyG uy9MyG IO9=f #f #+}zT}yG aQZ@ ,?+p(Y
?fO=yG gP$ #*OyG ,p G(SO #| i(%y H(ztyG ~%"| O=gAT@h ,B+}yG
~Azgp 9}v ,~%+zf ?z+LO ?fO< {v #| #+}zT}yG OF9tf GhQ%ap ,?!(gz}yG
~%"*O ,p uG ~wJ< ~$hPLh ,~%s;LCh ~%S(q! Q%a@ ,{}J}yG ?fO=<
uJyG ,p 9+zgyG 9%zD| ?+!9T!5y utJ* 9]$9! 9*(s 9=gV GhO: ,~$9+!Oh
.QF}G ~dfC uG O"f xyP< ~wy >Aw*h ,IGh9T}yGh dOgyGh f9}* Gh
,YO=yG gP$ #f ,%"yG ,p ?]+qAT| &+zf uG JG(zY d(SQyG #f E*O9I}Gh
k
.g9\Q*h &=J* 9}< 9}FGO {}gyG )yE U+FQyG uG uph
?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

124
1372

? S >F
"

Q 7 O

Ogy

G 17

Oz G } y

?f9}GyG Q9=LC

?=S9"}y e9gyG RvQ}yG 9%zSQC ,AyG J9+sQ=yG IQ(Y


fGO(TyG ?+s9q@G eGQ<E
IQ$9tyG

>+G! O}J|

AG(zyG

U+FQyG IQ]I

-1

>gWyh ~wy )!9%AyG bOYC ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= eOt@


eqJ*h b(tJyG f(Z* 9}< fGO(TyG ?+]s {I ,p ~wy uG u+p(@ )zf {+"yG
uG ~vOGR .~wA+"_h bOYh ~wAy(a<h ~wY;LE #| :E xyP 9|h .?|GQwyG
Q}gAT}yG #| [zMA*h ,~|}G #+< &A!9w| {+"yG iOGh C(=A* )AI 9tk +p(@
.gQ9CBh &F;}fh
iOGh

,tqyG O|9I O}J|

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= e9f U+FQ

9|
O%}yG #}IQyG O=f O+TyG IQ]I -2
f9|QO eC ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C U+FQ O}I uG O=f N+WyG IQ]I -3
{Jy uG u+p(@ )zf )!9%AyG bOYC eOt@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=
{gG* fC )y9g@ &yzT@h .b(tJyG eqJ*h ?|GQwyG f(Z* 9}< fGO(TyG ?+]s
.VQ}G )zf ?+|;SE ?|C ~dfC {+"yG iOGh >gV #|
f QO eC i

,tqyG O|9I O}J|

?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= e9f U+FQ

125

? +fQW y

f GO
f GO

%AzSQC ,AyG ?+sQ=yG

(Ty9< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG

(TyG ?+s9q@G

eGQ<E

"

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

(Y

IQ

Q9Z C

?=S9 }<

iOG

?f9}F

(yG )}+fRy

QZ|z >+G! O}J| U+FQyG AG(zyG -1


yf9|QO eCz iO%}yG #}IQyG O=f {+zGyG e9| G -2
Qd"yG {=s 9"=FG(p 9%p9as f9Ih ~vO(%F JQ}CCh ~wSQi H9_ Osh f6G
bQWyG N*Q9@ #| O+g=yGh >*QtyG )\9}yG )yE Qd"! fC )j="* {=tAT}yG )yE
k
gGQ!h GO+g< &!hQ* jPyG O9%GyG e(+y fGh}G #+J* )AI ?dgyGh IQ=gyG O}AT"y
k
iO*C 9%AaL ,AyG OhOJyG U}a!h HR: ?<Q\ bQG(qyG )J}! cGP|(*h 9=*Qs
k
T9fh #+}zT}zy )}Ih e;S5y GO%| {+"yG iOGh T9f f9+jayGh JhQ=GyG
f9}* G ?a<GQ ~%a<Q@h e;S G ?}zv ~%g}: uG {=J< #+}ZAg| gD9"<C
.f9TI G ?*GQ ~%zd@h
y

9iC Q}f rS(*


?"TyG Q9Z!C Q+@QwS

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

1372

?+}v9Jy

126

?S y
"

>+G! O}J|

AG(zyG

9}F 9C h <

h} G i O

)!

%AzSQC ,AyG ?+sQ=yG

U+FQyG )yE

f G O ( T y9 <

Q 5,4 fGO

Ogy

G 17

Oz G } y

(Y

IQ

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F

QZ| >+G! O}J| AG(zyG U+FQyG


~A*(Sh ,>+=JyG ?*QJyG ~zf ~AgpQh ,^+j=yG f9+jayG MQY ~A|O$
&p(qY #+< ~@OIhh ,9=k I ^j=yGh ,9"k |C a(MyG ~AyO<h ,fGO(TyG ?z]g|
rFG(ayG GhOI(@ fC ~w< Q*OGp .~wg| uG O*h ,eRfh ?}wJ< IQDg=}yG
~$hO; ,fBQtyG ?*GQ B; h+}GyG f(w+y ,,|;S G #*OyG ~S9< IOOgA}yG
.e9!}G Q+L ?"S
:

1952 / 11 / 24
e

z< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG RvQ}yG


fGO(S f9|QO

127

? +fQW y

Q_ G

S GQ $

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

(L

{+zL O}J| N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]qy

9a"a< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F U+FQ


,"*OyG O%g}y9< P9ASC

,p QGQI}G IQ(DyG IO9s 9%+tz* ,AyG J9J*QZAyGh >aMyG {|zA* #| fE


)yE 9%zv aO7 B@9< 98C &fhQ+y O;=yG N*Q9@ #| ?}S9JyG J9dJzyG gP$
#f 96 iz"yGh 9%S(q! M;YEh ?|}G gP$ J9*("g| O*O: ($ OIGh A,V
?}*QwyG IO9GyG I9+JyG H9=Sz< PL}G )zf 9%z}Ih .Q9jZyGh ?g]yG #_G(|
(}TyGh Uq"y9< ?tDyGh K+JZyG f9}* G #| ~*(s S9SC )zf e(t@ ,AyG
.JG(%WyG Q9\hCh J9pGQMyG U!O #f MhQn y9<
iO9}yG eOtAyG fC IQap A9qYh IQwp >s9C #f IO9tyG A:|$ iCQ Oty
IO+g< 9_G(VC &z+=S ,p Bgash IQ(DyG &< B+"f jPyG iO9ZAs:G T9gA!:Gh
OF9tgyG #| S9SC )zf 9+"=| #w* ~y 9| OGQ_}Gh QGQtAS:G &y #}]* :
Q%aAyGh a(MyGh rg]yG #| )Tq"yG QQJAyGh ?z\9qyG b;L}Gh ?J+JZyG
fC Bf9aASG Os IQ(DyG fC >%p :Eh J9$QAyGh e9$h}G UFQ #| iQwqyG
B+t< ~C J9=+_h hA| #| I9+JyG ,p 9| {v 9"y Qp(@ fCh GQZs9"| {wy )"=@
?<P9wyG e9$h}Gh ?z_9=yG J:9+My9< uzg@ #| &+zf ,$ 9| )zf ?+Tq"yG 9"Ay9I
9%A=T!h 96G(<C Q+i #| Q(|}G f9+@E ,p ?J+JZyG IQaqyG #"S #f aGQJ!Gh
)"j* {%p r+"JyG #*OyG &< A9F jPyG uJyG IO9F #f Og<h 969=SC Q+i )yE
eOt@ #| IQ(DyG 9"A=TvC 9| )zf X9qJyG h+aAT@ {$ hC iO9}yG aQAyG GP$ 9%"f

9LQh
?=aL ,p a9sh}G Q*Rh iQ(s9=yG N+WyG ?z+]p d(s GQk +Dv )"=GfC Oty
fC i(="yG Oy(}y9< d9qAI:G ?=S9"}< Q*QJAyG ?8+%y )T+FQyG Qt}yG ,p 9$9tyC
.Q+wqAyG uFGQ_ Q++jAy9< dh9"A@ )AI O(W"}yG d9}wyG #| 97hQP kz=@ #y IQ(DyG
?A

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

128

Py 9S}G &!} IQ(DyG #| ~$}G >!9GyG ($ GP$ fC iQ! #J! {<


O+I(yG f9}]yG ($ {< Q++j@ {v &+yE ,%A"*h M;YE {v &+zf e(t* fC >G*
.S9wA!:Gh QDgAyG QaL ?"|B iQ=wyG 9%A*9i )yE 9%t*Q_ ,p IQ(DyG Q+T@ f}
,p ;*O=@ :h >+y9S}Gh ~d"yG ,p GQ++j@ 9%At+tI ,p BT+y IQ(DyG fE
~*(t@h QwqyG H$9"}y K+JZ@ A,V {v {=sh :hC 9%"wyh Q$9d}yGh d9wV}G
.b;L}Gh IO+tgyG O9=| #| L(g}yG OS9qzy
I9+JyG uFGQ_ #| GQk +Dv Q+j@ fC IR+Fh ?=tI ,p Bf9aASC ,AyG IQ(DyG fCh
AGQh 9| )yE OA}@ fC 9%y O<: ?S9+TyG e9"YCh d9}yG B+iG(_ 9""+< ~a; fCh
A9]tyG )yE aO7 ?*Qwp IQ(C CO=Ay S(q"yG b9}fC ,p {jzjAAp Q$G(dyG xz@
?|C 9!Q+Yh 9"@9*("g| OTpCh 9!OF9tf H9YC jPyG &*(WAyGh NT}yG xyP )zf
.e9$h}Gh J9$QAyG )zf X+g@
[Jqy9< Q9wp}Gh OF9tgyG ,p KGQ@ #| 9!O"f 9| )yE hFQ! fC O*Q!
h| 9tk TA| 9%"| f9v 9}p K+JZyG #| rFGRyG R+}"y u+sOyG f9JA|:Gh K*QWAyGh
k
I9+JyG hsGh h| 9}F;A|h ~+zTyG Q+wqAyG H$9"|h ?J*QZyG #*OyG U(Z!
K|9F i($ #f GQkO9Y 9%"| f9v 9|h .&+zf 9"YQIh g9"+t<C O(F(yG U+|G(!h
.g9!P=!h g9"]pQ ^*Q| d9+L hC ?<P9v ?pGQL hC
)zf ~$A9]s a9sh}G Q*Rh O+Tzyh IQ(DyG IO9ty S9"yG O}Ih 9!O}I Oty
k
.{}J}yG ?fO< 96 )"g!h ;*(_ GQk $O QZ| ,p {D}@ Bzc ,AyG ?fO=yG xz@
L;gyG GP$ {D| 9%g| iOG* : E+J< IQ(aMyGh f9|R}G #| ?zgyG #wyh
)yE O+g@h gQhPF #| O9TqyG GP$ )zf )@z@ ?*(s ?<Q\ #| O<: {< )FRGyG
.?+p9fh ?JY #| &@Otp 9| ?|}G gP$ ?*("g|
(zjyG xyP #| 9q!B 9$9!QvP ,AyG &A=aL ,p a9sh}G Q*Rh O+TyG 9wV Otyh
d(I &!(GT"* 9|h ~+df iQvP< ~%F9qAIG O"f ?z%GyG ^g< &+yE O}g* jPyG
j G S

129

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

O@ :h {< N*Q9AyG uF9tIh I9+JyG hsGh )yE B}@ : J9$Q@ #| &A+ZMV


U*Ot@ ,p I:9j}yG xz@ fC &@O9+S h| iQ! #J!h ?+t+tI ?}df )zf
^g< ,$ Q+_9S}G d9a<z< ~%tJz@ ,AyG Q(ZyG xzA< ~$Q*(Z@h U9MV}G
,p ?|}G gP$ BgshC ,AyG O9TqyG ShDQ #| SCQ ($ {< ?|}G gP$ &+!9g@ 9|
?IQ\C )zf ?+y9gyG H9=tyG gP$ S9"yG e9sC 9}p d;]yG #| IQ+Dv HG(<C
9%+p f(zZ* OF9T| 9%"| GhP<G :h 9%"+*R@h 9%ApQLR< G(}A$G :h )@(}yG
#+qF9L #+FGQ ?fGQ\h Y(WL ,p 9$O"f f(qt*h 9%+yE f(GJ* JGQGR|h
,AyG OyG(}yG 9%y(I f(}+t*h #+<GQtyGh QhP"yG 9%+yE f(z}J* #+zS(A| #+=y9_
.J(t}}yG (zjyG GP6 #*QCzA| :E ?|}G gP$ 96 B+zA<G ?fO< rMSC ,$
)yE S9"yG (fO@ B8Ap 9| ,AyG ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= f{p Og<h
a(MyG {|G(f #| QQJAyGh ?+"C(yGh cQWyG >FG(V #| [y9MyG O+I(AyG
HGO$z< xT}AyGh .e9"Y~y ?yPyGh U9MV}G IO9=f #f gR"AyGh rg]yGh
~%A|Ot| ,ph QGQ<}G IQ(DyG IO9t< >+%Ay J:;]yGh YO=yG ?<Q9J|h ?z+]qyG
&y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av ?|}G gP$ M;YE ,p ~$OFGQ G(zgG* fC Q*R(yG N+WyG
I;ZyG &+zf d9s 9}v ?"Ap {v #| f9|}Gh d;\ {v #| ?}ZgyG 9}%p |
.y,A"Sh uG H9Av G(z]@ #y &< ~AwT}@ fE 9| ~w+p BvQ@ Otyz e;TyGh
9%A}%| f(w@ #+MSGQyG QGQI}G A9}zgyG #| ?"Gy r+yz@ )zf G(z}g* fCh
?+"*OyG uF9tJyG [+z<h Ky9ZyG 9%qzS &+zf f9v 9| )yE ?|}G gP6 Y(FQyG
P O NM { J9pGQLh YO< #| 969Vh {+LO #| 96 uZy 9}|
d

\[ZYXWVU T S R Q
HJy }
e dc b a ` _ ^ ]
:

G]

.[41-40

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

130

Ogy

4 O

G 1373

? S 9D y h <
"

)!

Q 18

:rJZyG

)zf

Oz G } y

J9t+zg@

+ $ 9F

? < Qi ? z

{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]qy

?n An %r =n yG gP$ IQ+=v ?g|9F ,p f(!9tyG d9FQ OI } ?+f(=SC ?q+JY JQW!


?f(}G| ,p 9""+!G(s 9"G|OC fC Og< ?+|;S G ~d"yG )yE Y(FQyG fEz :A9"fQyG
?+gFQyG )"g| )zf i(a"* )yhOyG h}AG}yG 9%+zf Q+T* ,AyG #+!G(tyG
?+<Q@ &+yE {vh jPyG P9AS}G xyP &y9s 9| [! xyP yQ(aAyG #"Ty ?]$9"}yG
~%A|C 96 f(|OM* ,AyG ?Jy9ZyG ?%F(yG ~%%+F(@h ,9"<9=V #| u*Qp
,?+f9}AF:Gh ?+tzMyGh ?+"*OyG ~+tzy 9+zgyG {D}yG u+tJAy f(gT*h ,~%"_hh
9| Q+L f9wp .dOgyGh uJy9< I9+JyG J9+]sC #| ~%+zf VoQn gr *o 9| ~*(t@h
: uG ?fQV fCh ,uG #| dOfCh ~wIC )yhOyG h}AG}yG fC g9*E ~%}zf
?+gFQ uG H9Aw< ~wJyG fCh ,Q+MyG ?\9pE :h dOgyGh uJyG ?|9sE h+aAT@
!! &F9!Qsh P9AS}G O"f b;MyG ($ Q(aAyGh ?: ~yh ,Q(aAyG #"S ^$9"@
k
)zf dO* 9| &"| rWASC )zgy ~*QwyG &}SC )yE ;*(_ iQZ< [MV Otyh
rn
fGQ+I ,>ztyG hF(| aQayG JOOQ - g9qSC 9*h - )!C O+< .&"*Oh &|(s
&zD}y QPf U}z@ dh9J* #| OG+p ,~zT| Q+i f(w* fC OhC B"v PE ,>zyG
IO9%V ,p &}S{< >TA"* &!C )zf dO* &}SC JOFh )"wy .&y QPf #| IQ9CC
B"v .&+yE #+=TA"}yG ^g< ?+gFQy9< &A%=* jPyG K}TyG #*OyG GP$ )yE O;+}yG
#| 9%pQg! ?"W"V :d(szp ,9+k f(+V hC ,9+k !(+%Y hC ,9*R+zG!G f(w* fC OhC
k
!!QZ| )yE &A+T"G< 9]*C O;+}yG IO9%V ,p >TA"* &@OFh )""wyh ,O(tI
,|C {FQ ?*QqyG gP%y aQAt}yG {gy :,F9TyG ~zJyG I(qi ,p d(sC JOfh
f9}* G #+< hC ,QWyGh Q+MyG #+< hC ,{_9=yGh uJyG #+< R+}* : ,QwqyG
J9T}$ JO9vh .~%yO}yG A9AWyG ?}Afh r\(yG K=ZyG uzp #+< {< ,QqwyGh

131

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

x
&!C iQvP@ :(y ,rY9f )IhQ ~$ #| &+p 9!C 9| ^g< )"f MhQ@ ~zJyG
!!IQ+=v ?g|9F ,p f(!9tyG SQO* P9ASC
GP$ {D| f9v GPE H9=WyG ?g+]y9* :,s9}fC #| )S}G M9Y B}Ch
.!&q+tD@ )zf aQW* P9AS}G
fC )zf ?"+< ?y:O dO* IQ%a}yG ?}wJ}yG uG ?g*QV P9AS}G &< B6 9| fE
k
I(aS ,p )<QjyG )j=zy ?g!9MyG ?z+yPyG ?*O(=gyG >JAT* dGR* : 9t*Qp 9"|
?g*QV #| S9"yG )zf ?}y9dyG &@(t< &\Qp 9}+p ~V9jyG Q}gAT}zy ,&@hQ=F
)zf AG(gV 9<QI 9%IQA:h ,?z*PQyGh )j=yGh QWyGh ~zdy9< ,qA;h {q;
.?|GQwyGh aQWyGh ?z+]qyGh bTtyGh Q+MyGh dOgyG J9SOt|
?|GQv GhOCh #*PyG I9j=yG I9jayG A:|$ O+=f {d! fC )!(!9tyG xyP 9"| O*Q*
fG(%yGh rTMyG 9$(|9Sh ,IA9!OyGh {qTAyG ^+]I )yE 96 Gh($h ?+!9T! G
{d! fC #*Q}gAT}yG f(!9s ,p hz]A}yG P9AS}G GP$ 9"y O(* ,Q*Q}yG dPyGh
#*PyG x8yhC #| ~$Q+ih 9T!Qph 9vQ|Ch GQAzG!: d;i}Gh O(+tyG iQ9SC
Q+|O@h .#+}zT}yG A9"pEh .e;S G OCh )zf G(!9v E+Ih .G(!9v P"| f(z}g*
bQR}G eOyG &sQf K(z* : iQW< U"F {v c;$Eh ,HQgyGh ?<hQgyG
.!! E+=MyG
&< #*O!h .gOtAg! 9}+p f(w! fC )<QjyG )j=yG ?yGOg< QW=}yG GP$ 9"| O*Q*
9"@9+I A9"< &+zf ~+t!h ,&zFC #| O$9G!h ,&y B=M!h ,&+p Qwq!h &< #||!h
{+=S &< O=v gn !h ,9!O:hC &+zf rW"!h ,?+S9+TyGh ?+f9}AF:Gh ?*QwqyGh ?+"*OyG
9}< hC .&< QWv <n 9}< O*Q* .HQgyGh #+}zT}yG #| ?|O9tyG d9+F~y {=tAT}yG
)"q@ )AI X+g! fC &A+iG(_h &!9ChCh HQjyG e9"Y} &A*O(=f &y &AfQV
,&Wa< iQ9SCh &@G(%V O+=fh .O(tJyG g9aSh HQjyG ?*O9| S;IC ?t+zMyG
.!e;dyG gQ(F >vG(| ,p ~s9}tyG ?z}Ih

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

132

9}gAS:G f(!9s P9ASC 9* :


9%"| {qFC ,AyG 9%A=Ch B=Chh ,?sQW}yG 9%A]8 QZ| B]8 Oty
97Q(C JQ9Ch ,HQgyGh #+}zT}yG O9G|C iQPyG b(p 96 Btyz@h ,xA+iG(_
Bg"Y ,Q}gAT}zy Y("MyGh ?*O(=gyG I9fO )zf B]s ,AyG IO+G}yG ?vQ9=}yG
#| e(}T}yG J9AqyG )zf ?zqaA| :h ,I9+JyG ,p ?g|E f(wAy : ,GP$ QZ|
HGPgy9< 9%_(T* {+yPyG >v(}yG AGQh IQF9S :h .#++<QjyG x@O9S IOF9|
: ?*(s ?|Rg< OG}yG GP$ QZ| Bg"Y 9}!Eh ,: : ,OhQWyG ?zp9tyG O;F
bT=Ayh ,dOgyG QW"Ayh ,Q+MyG S9"yG #+< h+WAy ,~zgyG Uw"@ :h .[w"@
G("||+p ,{=TyG i(S ~6 xzTAyh ,AG(S ?}zv )zf {wyG h}GAyh ,?}IQyG
.gOIh uG ?=J| ,p ~*QwyG A9L G ~6 (}T+p ,~6(zs &y B=<h ,gOIh u9<
,AyG ~7(=v #| 9$Q+ih QZ| ,p 9gk += #+}zT}yG V98 xyP QZ| Bg"Y
B+=D@ )zf eRgyG ?sO9Y ~%g| {}gAyh ,&AsO!Rh gO9Jy{< ~%+zf HQjyG 9$9"F
,?}*Qv ?yGOfh .bO9Y f9}*Eh ,[y9L O+I(@ #| uG &fQV 9| ~F9fO
~$O9G|C HQgyG )yE O+gAy xyP QZ| Bg"Y .?z|9V ?=J|h ,?z+=! IGh9T|h
hT@ ?z\9p I9+I O9G*E )zf ~%g| {}gAyh ,#|RyG )zf OyG(MyG ryG(TyG
x+zf xT|zp .?z|9WyG I(L}9< ?p9pQ ,O(yG ?sQW| M9TqyG 969IQ ,p {wyG
:h ~zT| iQ9}gAS:G x+Ih )yE )jZ* #y !!O+TyG 99C cG($h x*CQ
I9+Jy9< 9$O}@ uG ?*9fQ f} ,rqa"@ #yh ,JOs(@ IhPF ,$ 9}!{p ,,<Qf
h+}GyG eRAfG Osh ,?Jp9w| IQ<9Y ?}*Rfh GOk9t@Gh I(sh 9Sk 9}I ?zgAW}yG
9vQ|Ch GQAzG!9< : ,gOIh i(tyG u9< f9}* 9< ?z|9wyG ?*QJyG fGOW!
.!!9T!Qph
: ,d9|h eO #| &z+=S ,p f(yP=* 9}< gOIh uG O* #| 9$(y9"* fC G(|RAfG
.?+fGOA}yG ~%|9"YC {v9+$ ,p Q(M=yG bQ; fC cOIh B|RAfG #| O* #|
?g*QV #| ?"TyGh H9AwyG ,p 9| BSQOC :,!(!9tyG P9AS}G 99C )y {s ~C
!!Q

133

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

O* : #| )zf ?pQG(yG 9%y;c ("; ,AyG ?g*QWyG gP$ ?IQ%a|


bQ(@ I9+I ~%y ut;h - #+}y9T| G(|GO9| - HPgyG 9%zTzT< ~9hQ@h
#wyh ,JCQs f(w@ fC 9|E ,x!C #shC .~*QwyG e;TyGh ?"+!z}ayGh ?"+wTy9<
v n
k
f(!9ty A9}Y A9+}f ?+=Zf #| cQwp )zf )Wi 9}y 98+V JCQs 9}| &tq@ ~y
~zT}yG &"| CQ=* 9}<h ,&< 9%A}7G 9}< uG ?g*QV ~%A@ Bn Ir Qo pn ,OJz}yG HQjyG
k
,rW< #||@ ~zp ,98+V CQt@ ~y f(w@ fC 9|Eh .O+VQyG {s9gyGh ,uJyG
k
H9AwyG #| #+t+yGh uJyG AGO%ASG &qzw@ fC cQwq< 9"\ cG(6 B}wJp
,#++<QjyG xA%yB f(!9ty &}fR@ jPyG dOgyG O9=| dhC )AI Bqy9Mp ,?"TyGh
~ZMyG ?*Qp i(S 9%+p h}T@ ~y ?+]s ,p ?y9%Gy9< hC i(%y9< B}wI PE
)"G}yG Bz}v In h ,e(zdyG ~ZMyG {_9< ,~*QwyG uJyG )zf B"fzp ,A9tz=yG
!!~+8zyG )!9GyG QRh &+zf
hC OzFh ,bQ9TyG O+y has #| uG OhOI &@QvP 9}< O*Q@ x!C K}yC O9vCh
#| ?f9}GyG ?*9}Jy b;MyG Q+=MyG ~+wJyG gOI 9}| 9}$Q+ih ,,!GRzy ~FQ
GP$ {=s ($ 9}!Eh ,>TJp GP$ ($ e;S G U+y .&@G(%V )j<h OQqyG I(aS
#|B GP{p ,IQL6Gh 9+!OyG ,p O9=gzy M;Yh U;LEh f9TIEh dOfh O+I(@
aQAt* hC ,?sQTyG )yE L9AJ* #| O: #zp ,uG &fQV 9}< G(z}fh ,&< S9"yG
l v o o
fh9g@h I(LC e;S G ,p ?f9}Gy9p ,uG OhOI #| OI &+zf e9t* &< 9|
:h O+S 9%+p U+y ,AGQ]yGh AGQTyG ,p ?}+IQ I:G(|h ~IGQ@h {p9w@h
g(LCh i(ayG )zf B+=* hF9F :h ,{+yP )zf )ja* R*Rf :h ,O(T|
Otyh .uJyG #*O< #*O@ : ?f9= {v ,p iQ@ 9}v ?}MAyG &"a< (wW* ~zT}yG
9|(* haAT* ~zp .#+"TyG J98| &@(sh &!(!9sh &y9}< )<QjyG x@(i9_ O%F
gOg< #|h | d(SQyG 9|C ,Ky9Y h}AG| :h ,?Jy9Y ?|(wI O9G*E
,p OgT@ ~y ?+!9T! G fC ~%y N*Q9AyG {GS Otp ,&*O6 fhOA%}yGh ,&<9JYC
,IO+VQyG ?+"*OyG ~%A|(wIh Ky9ZyG ~%}wI ,p &< JOgS 9| {D}< 979+I
, 6 f("*

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

134

xz@ ,p IOIG(yG O+yG h<9YC )zf Og@ ?+f9}GyG hC ?*OQqyG ?}*QGyG O9wAy )AI
9%y iR< ~FGQF #| &< h}T! 9}| GP$ #*zp ,?z\9qyG ?Jy9ZyG J9g}AG}yG
9%y($ #| N*Q9AyG YRq*h !??+<QjyG x@9g}AG| ,p ?f9S {v ?+!9T! G 96h
?>+$QyG
{}g* :h ,&<Q Q+i )tA* : f9v cGP"+I ~zT}yG f} xyPv xyP f9v Oty
>+sQh O+VQ ~v9I i(tAyG gP$ #| &y f9wp ,&"| :E a9M* :h ,&%F(y :E
h}AG}yG O+xVo ?*(tyG J9"=zyG gP$ #|h ,dR* fC #+<h &"+< d(J* f9dt*
~%zyG gOzG* hC &=Q* 9+!GR :h ,gO* hat* 9sk Q9S ~v9JyG OG* ~zp ,,|;S G
BatS #+I ?ztyG xz@ f{p GP$ h|h ,O+yG h<9YC )zf IOhOg| ?z+zs ?zs :E
9%+zf e9t+y ,B"F 9}< ?+\GQ aQAg@ JA9Gp ,,"*OyG Q+}]yG 9%+p et+ASG
A:|$ #w* ~zp .f9}* Gh ?qgyGh VQgyG ?+SOs uG )tzAp ,{@9tyG OJyG
,M9}GyG OQ GPE )AI ,~$RFGQi 9%+p BV9_ ?dJy 9*9J\ :E G(|QFC #*PyG
I9G"}< (!9vh ,uG )zf G(<Pw* fC G(<Ch g(IQAFG 9| ~%Tq!} GhQqj* fC G(<C
,&< G(pQAfG 9}f d(w"yG {< ,HPwyG I9+JyG I(%V ~%y Bf(_ (y OJyG #|
Osh uG G(tz* fC )zf 9=k Q hC 9gk ashC GOk zF HGPgyGh J(}yG G(=JASG ~%"wyh
!!IOIGh ?<Pv uG )zf G(<Pv hC ,IOIGh IQ| &A!9|C G(!9L
xz@ ,p}87 6 5
4 { }\ [ Z
{
;p ,?+|;S G ?f9}GyG X+g@ ?}+IQyG I:G(}yG gP$h ,?sO9ZyG I(L}G
&@O9=f ,ph ,?=IC uG H9IQ ,p {wyG {< ,H9T!}9< :h ,H9TI}9< aQV
gP$ ~w<9T!C fEz | &y(s z=! x@z* ~yC ,f(z}g* &z+=S ,p O9%Gzyh ,I(LE
U+y ,g|z}@ ~y Y9ZyG r_ eOB Oyh ~A!C 9}!Eh ,OIC )zf H9=T< BT+y
{Fh Rf uG fEz :&y(sh y Ky9Y {}f hC #*Oy9< :E OIC )zf {]p OI}
)1 (

)t%+=yGh O}IC

)1(

135

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QF9ph ,,t@ #||| .A9<69< 9$QMph ,?+z$9GyG ?k +v=n fo ~w"f >$PC Os


~$ 9}!E ,eG(sz< ~$QMp d9FQ #fO+y ,HGQ@ #| eOBh ,eOB ("< ~A!C ,,tV
o
9%p qo !5< hpO@ ,AyG f;gr Gr yG #| uG )zf f($C #!(w+y hC ,~"%F ~Jp #| ~Jp
v
y#A"yG
.gQtJ* :h &yPM* :h &}zd* : ~zT}yG (LC ~zT}yGz :&y(sh
g9LC QtJ* fC QWyG #| Q|G >TJ< -gQOY )yE GQk +W|- 9"$9$ i(tAyG
~yC ~C !? y&y9|h ,&\Qfh ,&|O eGQI ~zT}yG )zf ~zT}yG {v ,~zT}yG
D C
B
{ :&!9J=S d(t* PE ,A9atzy9< )}S}G ,%y G Q=yG GP$ z=! x@z*
?\9+p ?}IQyG )yE GOk +F kYG ~C !?}I
HG
F E
~w!G(LEz ~$Q+ih eOMyG #f | &y(s #| 9!k 9TIEh 9tk pQ {%"@ iO"yGh Q+MyG
,{vz* 9}| &}ga+zp ,gO* B; g(LC f9v #}p ,~w*O*C B; uG ~%zgF
#|h y&"g+zp ,&=y9j* 9| &qzv f{p ,&=zj* 9| &qzw* :h ,U=z* 9}| &T=z+yh
- &!9LOh gQI )yh Osh - &< A9F ~C ,&|9g_ &|O9L ~vOI} h"Y GPEz :&y(s
k
hC ?zvC gO* ,p h]+zp , 9$(qW| e9gayG f9v f{p ,{vz+zp ,&g| Ogt+zp
GP$ {D}< ?+!9T!5y ?+f9}AF:G I9+JyG uG ~fO* r+v {|z@ ~C
y#+AzvC
v
cQ@ #|h ,&ACQ(zp :9| cQ@ #|z | &y(s ,p #+< xyPh #|9]AyGh {p9wAyG
:9| cQ@ #|h ,~%Tq!C #| #+"||}y9< )yhC 9!Cz &y(s ,ph y9"+y{p ;vn
)f9}AF:G f9}]yG ($ GP$ y,vzfh ,vy{p ,9fk 9+\h 9"k *r On cQ@ #|h ,&z$~p
)1 (

)2(

)3(

)4 (

)5 (

)6(

)7 (

)8(

Q=wyG )1(
. iP|QAyGh OhGO (<C )2(
. ~zT| )3(
. OhGO (<C )4(
. ?=I9Y ?qV QOs )zf ;+zs iC )5(
. ~zT|h iQ9M=yG )6(
. ~zT|h iQ9M=yG )7(
. iP|QAyGh OhGO (<C )8(
.

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

136

Qp ($ 9}!Eh ,96 ?k !q 9| ?yhOyG 96 {]qA@ ?J"| U+y &!E &A}IQh g(}S ,p


KQJyGh d9}yG ,p I9vRyG uG VQp GP$ b(ph .#*R(g}zy 9%+zf SOt|
)yE HO!h ,#+v9T}yG e9g_E JGQ9qwyG #| Q+Dv ,p VQph ,e9g!}Gh
&!C (yh f(!9tyG P9AS}9* ,&<Qy O=gyG &\Qt* 9\k Qs ?sOZyG {gFh ,J9sOZyG
V U{ &!zV {F &y(s ,p >JyGh ?}IQyGh d9}GyGh d;GyG bGQVE K}y
eOt* 9| {gG* r+v ,Q+=wyG )zgyG uG )yE iQ@C }[ZY
X W
n r o nn
k
&+zf #}* hC #]* hC ,Q+tqyG ?|GQv GP$ Og< TOMApC !? &y 9\Qs Q+tqyG )yE
~*QwyG &<Q VQt* &!C #s(* #||| #*P$ aQAt* {$hz !? )"jyG ~zT}yG g(LC
,p ?+f9}AF:G I9+JyG J9J}y ^g< .Q9}gAS:G f(!9s Q(AvO 9* GP$ !?)"jyG
k
k
hC ,?sQTyG )yE L9AJ* #| 9J+JY 9t+=a@ GP$ u+=a@ Og< O: {%p .e;S G
Osh ,?+L5A}yG ?f9}GyG gP$ bQT* #| fE :C !?gO* B!9L GPE &"f QPAg! #|
has ($h ?&zyG &fQV jPyG OJyG iO+S 9* uJAT* A,V {v uG Q|z< &y Bzqv
n
&!z< 9%y dP=yG rYp hohn .A9agyG Q+L 9%y dPp <o ,AyG O+yG GP$ uJAT@ 9}p ,gO*
fC :E uJAT@ 9| ,?=I}G &!G(LE #| #+yP9=yG B!9Mp ,uG )yE eOt* VQs
ky9=yG Q=yG #|h ,?+|;S G ?f9}GyG f9Lh ,&y(SQh uG f9L Otp ,QA=@
iQLC O* &y )t=@ xyP h| #wyh ,gO* hat@ fC ?f9}GyG xzA<h &< ?}IQyG
k
k
GQ(gVh GQk wph 9!9}*E Hh9GA+p ,?}C6G ?!9+MyG #| uG i(tA< 9%+}J* &zgy
k
MQY )"=@h ,u9< uJyG f9}* 9< 9%Tq! )"=@ ,AyG ?f9}GyG gP$ h| GO9%Fh
.?sQTyG OI GP$ ..cQAW}yG 9$O9%Fh ,?gFGQyG 97(Lz< )}S}G ?+!9T! G
,&< {}gyG >G* uI &!Ch ,9!RyG OI ,p uG ?}wI K}z@ Q(AvO 9* xzgyh
,{+}GyG fGQw!h O(JGyG ,p Q(GqyGh ,Q+}]yG J(| )zf ?y:OyG #}p
{@9t* fC >G* jPyG &\Qf ~zT| {v gGQ* VQf xA6 ,?f9}GyG gP$ ?!9+L
LhRA* ~y jPyG OI {gGp ,OJyG GP$ ,p ?jy9< uG ?}IQ Bz: Osh ,&!hO
IhR"yG &< JO=ASG GPE ?IhO"| GP%zp ,&=Q< Q|zp LhRA}yG 9|C ,IOzF ?F9|
- )<z* LhRA}yG d9< 9| ~C ,&y9Jy ?*9fQ &"f uG rqMp cGP 9|C ,?|Q9gyG
V

137

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)zf ~}Y Os AGQw"yG &Azgq< gGQ@ :C ,E+=MyG >%A"* fC :E ->+ayG gO"fh


#+=yG &y;I gO"gp !?969T!Ch ?f9}GyG gP$ VGQfC eO9 :(g| {d* fC
fC :E )<C &"wyh ,?*G(jyGh ~C G d(Jw}yG eGQJyG GP$ )tA* fC &< h+aAT*
{qTAT| ,?+}+%=yG T9+_ 9%sQg*h VGQf}G X%"* 9*k Q9\ 9Sk QV 9!k G(+I X+g*
k
)fQ* ,~y9T}yG h*O(yG h+atzy GP9t!E XI(yG GP$ {As #| O<: f9wp .IhR"yG
.?|9gyG I(L}Gh ?y(FQyGh I(M"yGh IAhQ}yG MGQ|h f9}* G )}I ,p
iz}c )!9|}G hpOh ,9%\GQfCh ,?+!9T! G H9T!C uG )}I OJyG GP6
#+=F Nayh ,A9atzy9< VQ}G &Fh Q}jp x!(!9s 9|C ,cQ9=}yG LGhRyG )yE
.!!M(qT}yG eOyG )yE iz}c H9FPyG hpOh ,AGQw"yG ?}*QGy9< ?+!9T! G
9}p ,gzGp GPE &+zf iO9gyG {As VQgyG >I9Zy K+=* iO+S 9* x!(!9s
iQ@ :C ~C ??}*QGyG )yE >i9TyG XI(yG GP$ {At* fC uG )zf )<z@ xy9<
GhCQ ~8C fhO%W* O(%V ?g<QC 9$GQ* fC ,?}*QGyG gP$ J9=C uG VQp r+v
?g<QC #| IO9%WyG gP$ VQp ,p !??}zTAT}yG ?T*QqyG )zf hR"* XI(yG
&y9"* : )AI ~zT}yG VQf uG h\h ?g+pQ ?M|9V IhQP &*C )zf xy #+=A*
#+=* IO9%WyG gP$ VQp ,p {< .&A+SOs uyCh ,&Aqf bGQVE ,p {d*h ,jPC
k
.?WI9qyG gP6 VQf ~Y(* fC )\Q* :h >J* : uG fC 9+zF xy
rt* ($h ?g<QC #| ?f9= gO%W@ fC :E )<Ch ,,i9=yG #zgASG GPE )AI
#+}zT}zy uG {gG* fCh O< : f9v ,#A"}yG 9%J+s &A+!G(+I #| hR"*h &A}*QF
.~%J]p 9}v &<GPf O(%W< g(J]q*h ,~%zAs 9}v g(zAt+p ,;+=S &+zf
,LGhRyG )yE &=+Vh &<9=V )gT* ,dh}G )|;S G h}AG}yG )yE B*CQC
H(W* 9| &"f h}S GPE )AI ,~zT}yG &+LC VQf fhO ~zT}yG rt*h
uG ~%}zf 9}v
?*6 ("wy pB A@
? o 9"k ||| d9s ,&A+SOs
,?v(qT}yG VGQf}G gP$ B!9wp x!(!9t< {}gyG ?G+A! 9|C ,Q("yG IQ(S ,p
H9+!}G )zf #+|GQA* )@;yG uSG(qyG A:|$h ,?|(zD}yG H9T!}G gP$h
]16

G :Q

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

138

9 Py Qj* h+atyG )fGQh ,u*QayG ?fQ9s )zf #%|(Jy bR}@ SGQ\}Gh


&+"+f #+< 9%SQAq* 9=k FP OhQWyG &@9Wy OFh fC QMq* {< ,&!9gas SQAq@ fC
aQV #=%A"*h ,QhOMyG #}aJ* b9TqyG A:|$h !?}*QGzy #+AwI9]yG
.J9}y9JyG iQGPgyG
#|B Oty :HQjyG B+iG(_ O9=f xg| h}T+yh ,Q(AvOyG 99C h}S9p :C
?yGOgyG fCh ,?|GQwyGh OG}yGh IRgyG I9+I fC ,QZ| Q+ih QZ| ,p f(}zT}yG
#| h=! xyP {v fC G("|B ,?+p9ZyG ?+!9IhQyGh ,?+|9TyG ?=J}yGh ?sQW}yG
#*OyG GP6 :E ,&zv )!9T! G {< )|;S G ~y9gzy eG(s : fCh ,uG ?g*QV
.VQ}G &Fh )zf f9T!E {v &AyGOfh &*O6 ~g"* ,uJyG
xyP {=s ,$ 9}!E {< ,>TJp f(!9sh ?g*QV ?yzT| BT+y ?yzT}yG fE ~C
)zf >y9i uGh ,9}%"| A9W* 9| &Tq"y f9T!E {v QAM+zp ,Qqvh f9}*E ?yzT|
.gQ|C
HF Gi

139

? +fQW y

v$1375

>F

:?fGP Gh

Q : ,!

9Dy h <
G

rJZyG

ye ; S G

($

?yhOyG

Of

Q )7:4( OG

)zf

?S9+Ty

}G

Gh

20

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

+zg@

J 9t

#* O z

{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f P9AS~y

o
($ ?yhOyG #*O fC )zf &+p [v ! Osh ,Q(ASOyG IQ(DyG d9a<C QOYC
G(IGQ #}| ,&<9!PCh Q9}gAS:G r+FGQC )zf IQ(DyG B]s GP6h .e;S G
H9!PC f9v Otyh ,QLB >!9F ,p e;S Gh ,>!9F ,p IQ(DyG fC f(}fR*
fhOv|*h ,9%zv ?+|;S G H(gWyG #+< r+FGQ}G gP$ f(D=* #*Q}gAT}yG
?*QZ}yG ?*Q(%}GyG #*O fC )zf 9$Q(ASO ,p 9tk za| ["@ #y IQ(DyG fC ~%y
?+|;S G H(gWyG #+<h QZ| #+< 9| )zf A9]tyG GP6 fhO*Q* ,e;S G ($
#*Qw"A}yG Q%d| ,p IQ(DyG d9a<C Q9%cEh ,I(L}Gh )<QtyGh IO(}yG e9IQC #|
?<Q\ Q(ASOyG A9Gp .&|O$ )zf #+z|9gyG ,&FO9=| )zf #+\9tyG ,uJyG #*Oy
k
IQ(DyG d9a<C fC B=D*h ,r+FGQ}G gP$ d;\ OO=* GQ(!h ,x8yh} ?+\9s
,e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf O}J}y ,$ 9}!Eh ,f(fQqy BT+y QZ| fz< f("||*
#*PyG uJyG O+I(Azy ,$ 9}!Eh ,QGJyG hC ,f9T! G &y|@ ,AyG ?+"C(zy BT+y
?g*QWy ,$ 9}!Eh ,HQjyG ?g*QWy BT+y .QW=yG uy9L ?+%yEh ?+<(<Q< f("*O*
H(gWyG #| ih9fOyG gP$ ~%AfOL #*PyG ^g< f9v Otyh ,&!9J=S uG
fC ~%y Ov|! 9"wp ,r+FGQC #| Q9}gAS:G &< )W| 9}< 9"!hQ+g* ,?+sQWyG
#w}* : ,#+gV9L uG iO* #+< G(qt* fC )zf f(YQJ* #*PyG IO9tyG A:|$
k
.gGO$h gQ(! )zf uG iO* #+< f(qt* jPyG #*OyG GP%y GhQw"A* fC ,GO<C
Q+Z=yG QZ=yG O"f 9!9v fEh ,#+qzAM| #+%F(< {}g* Q}gAT}yG f9v Otyh
n
)zf ["yG IQ(DyG cQA@ fC )yE QZ| ,p 9"$ (fO* f9v !!IOIGh IQ(Y jrhnP
#*O fC )zf ["yG fC ~%"| 9}k fR ,GP6 e;s}G ^g< )yE f(I(*h ,GP$
{+=S ,p 9|Os 9!Q+S b(g@h ,jQt%tyG 9"< O(g@ ?+gFQ e;S G ($ ?yhOyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

140

P$ H9AwyG ^o g< bOv Y Osh !!#+*QZ}yG #| ?qF9ay H9]iEh ,IQ9]JyG


O\ ?"zgAT| hC ,?+qL HQJyG fhQ+D* ?+! A(T< hC ;%F- G(IGQp ,~fRyG
jPyG ($h- Q}gAT}yG >$P*h !!e;S G ($ ?yhOyG #*O fC )zf ["yG
>Av 9| ~9Q*h ,?+|;S G H(gWyG )yE >$P* -&<9Av )yE GP6 )IhC
f9v GPw$ !!IQ(DyG d9FQ #| )I(< :E G(=Av 9| ~8C ~%y Ov|*h ,x8yhC
fC ,$h ,&< #||@ jPyG uJyG )zf BZ!h ,IQ(DyG JA9Gp ,Q9}gAS:G {gq*
9}| ["zy GQk +%a@ y,}SQyGz ?}zv BpPI 98E )AI !!?yhOyG #*O ($ e;S G
x8yhC d9|B )zf GP6 B]tp .&pGO$Ch &@9*9i (}S ,p &y ?+z:h ,&<(W*
#+< 9| hatA* fCh ,?+<QjyG ?+=+zZzy IA9=| QZ| f(w@ fC fhO(* G(!9v #*PyG
&=zs i(a* #| {wy JOvCh ,?+|;S G H(gWyG #| &!G(LEh ,QZ| >gV
n n
,&"*Qf #f OhP@h ,g9}I )}; #*Ozy IQ(DyG fC ,e;S G O\p {LO )zf
m
.&A}zv )zg@h
G

141

? +fQW y

9=gV

)f

k
9]

*C ?+p(ZyG

( 1372

?S
"

8 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 17

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

bQayG A9jyEh

8WyG Q*Rh IQ]I ?S9*Q< ?"Gy r+yz@ z=! ?*QZ}yG rJZyG ,p 9!CQs
fC GP$ )"g|h ,?*QZ}yG O;=y9< ?+p(ZyG bQayG ~+d"@ )zf {}g@ ?+f9}AF:G
9"gFQ (yh .9%+zf ?dp9J}yGh 9%}+d"@h bQayG gP$ )zf A9t<;y ?%GA| ?+"yG
,A;=yG QOZ| B!9v 98C 9"}zgy bQayG gP$ N*Q9@ ,p 9!Qd!h ;+zs AGQ(yG )yE
?+S9+TyG HGRI}G #| QDvC ,O;=y9< KQG(wyGh >F9Z}yG d(zI ,p 9=k =Sh
QS~y 9%t*Qq@h ,OGQp~y 9%A+AW@h ?|~y 9$QQ]< 9"}+zT@ h| ,?zJ"}yG
.J;F9gyGh
~7(+< ~+}Y )yE fhPq"*h >gWyG OGQpC #+< fhQWA"* bQayG d9FQ fE
,K+=tyG ~%y f("TJ*h ,~%"+< ~%|(}S f(Dq"*h ,~%zFO< ~6(zsh ~%y9}fCh
J;=fRMyGh IP(gWy9< ~$Q9wpCh ~%y(tf )zf GhQa+T* )AI Qw"}yG f("*R*h
.J9|GQvh JGRGg| #| ~$OGOF}h ~%Tq!} g(}fR 9|h ,J9pGQMyGh
,bQayG d9FQ #| ~$O(=g}y f(=ZgA*h ,~%y(I d9%GyG S9"yG rAz+p
k
{Z* Osh .&Azsh &zFO IQDwy 9gk =@ ,;$9T@h 9=k Zg@h ,IQDvh ?zs f(@h9qA*h
?+"*OyG QF9gWyG {+ag@h ,A9|OyG xqSh M;Ty9< {@9tAyG ?FQO )yE >ZgAyG
)zf VQ}G ,p fhOTq}yG A:|$ GhOAfG )AI ,uG J(+< ?|QI QGO$Eh
H9Aw< xT}AyG )yE 9fO &!} ?*OG|qyG ?*Q*O| iQs iOIE ,p ?g}GyG >+aL
k
;ag| ~%y 9*k OJA| ghQ=Af9p ,e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf &+=! ?"Sh )y9g@ uG
k
GhO9vh ,Q="}yG &< G(=zsh &+zf G(|9tp .?8+!OyG ~%At*Qay ;a=| ?8+TyG ~%A"Ty
QqL #| ?JzT| I(s JQ]Jp ,&"*O QZ"* #| QZ"< uG Ofh :(y &!(zAt*
.?+i9=yG ?8qyG gP$ >jV )zf B]sh {IG(TyG
k
#| 9@G(|Ch A9+IC ~$hO=gp ~$(z\Ch S9"yG d(tf bQayG d9FQ OTpC Oty
~8C ~$(}$hCh ,~69AfC ,p G(JT}@h ~$Q(=s )yE G(GIh ,uG fhO
f(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

142

P! ~$(vQVzp ,~6Qv f(FQq*h ,X+gyG {=S f(z%T*h bRQyG ~%y fhQT+*


( '& %$# " ! ~ }{ YQ]yGh YQRyG ,p
k
GQ

.}

11

0/ .

, +*
)

?"S d9a<E )zf f(z}g* ~%p ,Q(|}G I:hh uG f(<Q9J* bQayG d9FQ fE
uG Q|C >TI J9==T}yG )yE ?*O|}yG H9=S}G {+ag@h ,f(wyG ,p )y9g@ uG
UQ<}Gh &}v}G AGQ<E f(g+aAT* ~8C S9"yG H(zs ,p G(gshzp ,&@OGQEh
Z
YX W V o :&zyG d(s #f ~$QF9Z< B+}fh ,~F9}AyGh YO(y9<

cba `_^ ]
\[ZY ; ^
]
\[
.ycQV ?y(AyGh ~F9}AyGh )sQyG fEz :| uG d(SQ d(s #fh pd

,AyG ?|(wJyG >FGQ\ )zf ?|Ot| ~%A=*Q\ f} ?|(wJyG f(<Q9J*h


OOT+y #*OAT* QTg}yG {FQyG 9"*CQ {< ~%"|Ch S9"yG Ky9Z| )zf Q%T@
&+zf B=Y :Eh ,S(|9GyGh Qt=yG &y QJ"*h c(*OyG &y K<P*h &M+V ?=*Q\
uq!h YQRyG bQih ,bGRQ}G &"f Bg"|h ,A9}TyG HGPf &+zf dR!h J9"gzyG
&ty9L fhO #| 9<k Q &M+V P<9p ,f9"GyG HG(<C &%Fh ,p BtziCh ,YQ]yG
&Fh #| HQ9 ?gTyG GP QS(}yG 9"*CQh ,9=k I OVC hC uG >Jv &=ICh &sRGQh
;}%| &Jy9Z| ;ag| gO(=g|h &M+V )yE Qq*h ?+|(wJyG dG(|}G {ZJ|
k
$ # " ! ~} { ,&<Q )yE ;k +=S &"| GPMA| &y9}fC
.HQsC ~9C
QS }%
,O;=yG AGOf} U+SG(F G(!9v bQayG d9FQ ^g< fC 9"COJ* N*Q9AyG fE
Oty {< .A9}$OyG d(tf )zf fhQa+T* ~8C ~%}zgy fhQ}gAT}yG ~6 {Z@9p
O}IC {a=yG ($ ?D*OJyG Q(ZgyG ,p Q*QJAyG A9}fR #| ~+fR )zf GhQa+S
{+zyG d(_ f(z*9}A* G(zch Q+=wyG {Ay9< &A}+L ,p ~%g= )AI )<GQf
c o :,y9g@ uG d(s G(T!h ,f(zp9i OG(tyGh hOgyG ~%}$Op f(ZsQ*h
,{+zyG d(_ [sQh {*9}@ #|:
? *6 9 q !} p h
g
f ed
[57 :AG

]60

G :d

G[

G]

143

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Og< f(!(w* ;pC= .f7y 9%|:B )!9g! 9"yR9|h O;=zy ?=w! ,p G(==T@ xyP<h
~%gq"* : e(s ~8E .?d;J!:Gh IO9< 9< #*Q*OF - QDv #| {s ($h - GP$
,9+!OyG ~7Qih ~$QF9Z< B+}f Otp .KF9Z"yG ~%+p QC|@ :h ,efG(}yG
HGRI}G ~8G(LE h| hq! 9| :E ~%g| hq"* ;p ,JG(%WyG ~%+zf JQa+Sh
~+d"@ f(!9s QhOY fEh ,fBQty9< YR(* :9| f9azTy9< YR(* PE ,?zJ"}yG
fz< #+zF9qA| 9"zgG* ?gFQ Q+i )yE 9+F98 9%zI f(!9s ~C ?+S9+TyG HGRI}G
?|(wI fEh ,,y9g@ uG A9V fE 9%zI 9%=tg+S ?+p(ZyG bQayG ~+d"@ ?"Gy
)zf ?dp9J}yGh QT+}yGh Q}MyG h"| {+=S ,p ?tp(| JG(aL JQ9S IO+VQ
)zf A9]tyG ,p 9"FGO"y ?=+GAT| O<: #+"_G(}yG ~+s hpQh b;L}Gh dG(|}G
7 6 Wo O;=yG OgT@h S9"yG K*QAT* )v e9gyG Ky9Zzy bQayG gP$

CBA@? >

=< ;:98
.

)1(

]22

?*6G :f9}n ty[ p!@


!ww

Qv R*RgyG O=f

rF9ay9< - ?*O(gTy9< O+I(AyG QGO< P9ASC

?f9}GyG N(+V h| #+*O(gTyG A9}zgyG Qd! ?%Fh O9;G

9tzy #+<} ?y9t}yG gP$ JQvP


.~%+zf &zyG ?}IQ

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

144
1373

?S y
"

9}F

h}G iO

5 O

Ogy

Oz G } y

G 18

JCQs

, < h Q+ !
k
yGO<C

Q} @

|| ,p

(z]@ #zp &< ~A}ZAfG

fE

~y9S

9|

9| #TIC

M;Y H9aL

| uG

,=! O}J| ~wy

cQ@

Otyz

8Wy ?yhOyG Q*Rhh )|(tyG O9VQ G Q*Rh ~y9S M;Y Z9ZyG &Fh
9}< gCO< Osh - )<hQ+! ,p Otf jPyG )|;S G Q}@|}yG ,p 9<k 9aL fGO(TyG
:d9tp &sQp #| #+}zT}yG H9YC 9|h r@9w@ #| e;S G &+zf [!
bQq@z ,$h :C ?+|;S G ?|}G f9+v JR$ ?<Q\ Q=vz< e;S G >+YC
Q|C f9%p ?*(tyG IOI(yG B}a;h 9<k GRICh 9gk +V G(J=Yzp #+}zT}yG ?}zv
~%Azvzp ~%+zf 96QI Q9}gAS:Gh QWyG i(s B"zfCh S9"yG )zf #+}zT}yG
k
fGQ+DyGh OS}G d9Jv ~%y9I f9wp >gV Og< 9=gV ~%AyPASGh ?|C Og< ?|C
.?}*OtyG ?}wJyG 99hQ@ ,AyG ?C;DyG
?+|;SE ?|C dhC Q9}gAS:G {vC e(* 9gk += 9"zvC Oty f(}zT}yG 99C GPw$h
.f(zp9i 9%"f #J!h
#| #+*;}yG JOQVh #+aTzp {+FGQSE B}%AyG >*QtyG U|}9< &!C {<
,AyG VQ}G gP$ ~%Az@ ~y {+FGQSE fC ?J*QY 9%y(sC ,!Eh HQgyG 9%F9"<C
VQ}G gP$ {v B}%AyG {< HQgyG #| ?z+ztyG #+*;}yG gP$ 9%wz}@ B!9v
f(sQq| ~$ 9}y9_ VQ}G A9J!C ,p ~zT| f(+z| ?F9}T}MyG 9%wz}* ,AyG
?sO9Y IO(f uG )yE ~zT| f(+z| ?F9}T}MyG A:|$ O9f (y uGhh f(zp9i
G(=$Q :h VQ}G ,p ~%y uG #w}y ~%a<GQ@h ~$O9;G )yEh ~7O+tf )yEh
.H9jyG O(SC
f(

qponml

}
]46

?*6G

:d

R Q P O

9q!}G[ p
n

N
o

145
:fG

Qn }fp dB[

? +fQW y

p!@
! vx ~ k

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

i
hg
fedco
]139

?*6G

t* ~y9S M;Y Z9ZyG )]|h


k
QZ| ~w"_h #f ;+zs ~wCOIC fC ~+dgyG e(+yG GP$ ,p )y G(J}SG
)\GQC Q=Ag* &!C e;S G ?}df #}p QZ| ~w"_h d(sC 9}"+I )y9iC BTyh
k
.~zT| {wy 9"_h #+}zT}yG
9%+zf fz< 979JqY QaT* N*Q9AyG CO< P"| BTIC fG(L G 99C QZ| fE
N*Q9AyG J9JqY 9"=zs GP{p 9%y uG gQOs Os uJyG GP$ .&*O|@ fC >G* 9tk I
k
f9*O}G &+yE JzGyh &< B}AIG jPyG zGz}yGh )}JyG 9}FGO B!9v 98C 9!OFh
QDvC e;S G B}I 98C {< #*Q+Dv A9+=!C OG| 9%\QC JO$9V Osh ?*h9}TyG
9}< G(TIC Osh QZ| A9"<C 9"*CQy E*OJyG N*Q9AyG J9JqY 9"=zs GPEh .IQ| #|
M9qw<h IO+G| QGhOz< G(|9tp HQgyGh #+}zT}yG ~8G(L b(tI #| ~%+zf
9}yh eOtAyGh ?]%"yG H9=Sz< PL}G )zf ~%A!(g|h ~8G(LE Q*QJAy Q*Q|
utJAy {< .?;9p :h ?*R9i BvQ; 9| {+"yG h<9"| )yE QZ| T(+F BvQ;
Q9}gAS:G g9: #*Qh9GA| I(LC #+< e(t@ fC >G* ,AyG ?}*QwyG ?a<GQyG e9+s
.,="F}G
9%a<Q* f9v jPyG O+tyG #| 1952 ?"S (+y(* 23 ,p QZ| BZz< 9}yh
,p ~wJA@ B!9v ,AyGh >T! hC ?zZ< ?*QZ}zy B}@ : ,AyG IQS}G gP6
fC Og< &+p JQwp 9| dhC f9v 9%"| Q9}gAS;y #w}@h 9$A9"<C dPAT@h 9$Q+Z|
#| &+S9t* 9}| gQQJAy fGO(TyG 9%t+tWy 9$O* O}@ fC QQJAyG u*Q_ JCO<
JOAVG 9}zvh ?=+$QyG ?vQg}yG JCO<h Q9}gAS:G {c ,p f9+jayGh ~zdyG
#| #$(* ~yh fGO(TyG ?*QI u+t; )zf GQkGQYG QZ| JOGORG I(Ts ?vQg}yG
O\ {LGOyG M9qwyG ,p IQ+aL QGhOC #| &< Q}@ B!9v 9| fzWyG GP$ QZ| eRf
uJ< GOk +_h 9!k 9}*E #||@ 98z< 9*k hO| 99CQ QZ| B"zfC {< OF9=yG O%gyG H9!PC
:d(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

146

O%AT@ d9tA!G IQAp GQk(p CO=@ fC >G* &!Ch ~$Q+Z| Q*Qt@ ,p #++!GO(TyG
{|9wyG )@GPyG ~wJyG ?SQ9}| #| #++!GO(TyG #+w}@ 9}%"| dh }G :#+\Qi
9%A"zfC 9}v Q+Z}yG Q*QtAy &"| O<: jPyG O*9J}yG QJyG (GyG ?8+7 )!9DyGh
#| ?+!9a*Q=yGh ?*QZ}yG ?*QwTgyG JG(tyG >JS H(F(< ?J*QY QZ|
fGO(TyG Q+Z| QQtAS ,AyG ?+T+SzAyG ?+g}GyG J9<9MA!G AGQFE {=s fGO(TyG
f(w* fCh fGO(TyG #|C #f ?y(8T}yG ,$ 9$OIh ?+!GO(TyG JG(tyG K=Z@ fCh
Bzc GPw$h ?+!GO(TyG ?|(wJyGh )!GO(TyG f9}yQ=yG #+< JG(tyG gP$ IO9+s Q|C
J9<9MA!G #| &< ~@ 9}< ~ApQf ~wzgyh fGO(TyG 9%t+tV {FC #| Kp9w@ QZ|
d9tA!:G IQAp ,%A"@ fC (FQ"y 9!Gh .~wJyG Q(|C fGO(TyG A9"<C )y(@ 9$;@
#yh ,&@Rfh &A*QI {|9w< &+p >+=JyG fGO(TyG ~g"* jPyG e(+yG utJA*h
.&zv e;S5yh 9+t*Qp O+f e(* {< >TJp fGO(Tzy O+f e(* e(+yG GP$ f(w*
:QGQI}G fG(L G 99C
u+tV {wy ?=J|h b(Vh ?q%y ,p 9"<(zs (q7h 9!Q9Z<C (!Q@ QZ| ,p 9"!E
{wy 9!O* O}"y 9"!Gh {< )<Qfh )|;SE Oz< {v ,ph {< 9+t*QpC ,p 9"F9tVC #|
#+<9JA| I(LC 9gk | {}g! )y9g@h 9!O* ,p cO* J9$h 9"g| ~s &y d(t!h ~%"|
k
fCh 9"<(zs #+< ry|!h 9!O(%F OI(! )wyh 9g+= 9!O;< QQJ! )wy #+!h9gA|
i(s &+zf Qa+T@ ~y9f e(+yG ~y9gp .O9tI}Gh Y9}_:G 9!Q(%c AGQh )|Q!
9"+zgp 9%+p >*Q : ?+@B ?f9TyGh QOjyG MhQ &"| f9w| {v ,p #}w@h QWyG
x<9WA@ fC iO*}G )zfh KGOI}G 9"}$O@ fC {=s ^%"! fCh h}GA! fC e(+yG
GP<h &Tq"y >J* 9| &+L} >J* 9"| {vh U(YQ}yG f9+"=y9v raZ! )AI
?+}y9f HQI ,p ?+!9T! G &y VQgA@ Os jPyG >+$QyG QaMyG hpO )zf i(t!
?<hQgyGh e;S G {c ,p ?}*QwyG IOI(yG gP$ utJA@ 9|O"fh .IQ|O|
k
k
iC 9"| >gV iC #| OAg| iC d9"* #yh .QWyG i(s e9|C 9g+"| GOS K=Z"S
{< )\9}yG ,p d9JyG f9v 9}v &SQAq* Ok IGh GQk(C &|9|C OG* #y &!} ~"j|
a

147

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

P8"+Ih 9%"| {v {FC #| Q(D@h OIGh S9TIz< U; fGQ+C 9%zv ?<9i OG+S
uGh : >TJp 9"Tq!C 9"+}I Os xyP< f(w! #y OTyG GP$ e9+s utJA* 9|O"fh
HGQMyG #| ?*QW=yG 9!Pt!C Os f(w!h &zv )}y9gyG e;TyG 9"+}I Os f(w"S {<
.Q9|OyGh
k
:;F9s &<9aL ~y9S M;Y Z9ZyG ~ALh
k
cQ@ .GO<C (z]@ #zp &< ~A}ZAfG fE 9| | uG ,=! O}J| ~wy cQ@ Oty
G(fR9"@ :h &z=J< G(}ZAfGh uG )yE GhQqp uG d(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av ~wy
d(s G(g}SGh f9v IQ(Y iC ,p f9+jayG G(|h9sh - ~wJ*Q >$P@h G(zWqAp
:&zyG

} | { z yx w v ut
sr
qo
+*)( '&% $ @
! !v|x #
" ! ~
?*6 Q}f
p!@
!v|y 2 1 0
/ .- ,
.]174,173

G :fG

p dB[

uJyG J(Y 9%+p Eg=!G 9}y9_ ,AyG QZ| fC )zf uG O%V} ,!Eh
fz< ?"||| e(+yG rtAy ?<hQgyGh e;S G #f hpOAy Bqsh 9}y9_ ,AyGh ?*QJyGh
98Ch .#+"||}zyh &y(SQyh u IRgyG fz<h uG O"f #| QZ"yG fz<h uI uG
#| ?t*OY ?|C {wyh u+tV >gV {wy 9$O* O}@ fz< O%gyG 9%Tq! )zf PLzAy
.?*QW=yG Q+Lh ~y9gyG e;S {FC #|h QQJAyGh ?*QJyG {FC

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

v18:12v

Gh

?+}v9Jy

6 ,5 O

148

Og y

G v$1374
)1(

(g S

GO

ahQg}y9<

? S ? 9Dy

Q|Bh

"

+!

xz}yG

,jO%yG

uG

) yE

9}F

Gh ) h}G iO

19

Oz G } y

9 I

YGO

#| &< ~g!Ch

OVQyGh Q+MyG fhO*Q* #*PyGh ,e9wJyGh A9SDQyGh IO9tyG OAt+zp &=p


,?sO9Y uI ?}zv -&t+p(@ uG eGOC- O(gS xz}yG ?y;F 9%y9s Otzp .S9"zy
HzD@h .#*h9jyG OVQ@h ,#+y9]yG OQ@h ,#+zp9jyG es(@ ?J+Y 96 M9Yh
or
)zf UQIGh ,9$Q<O@h 9%z@9p .#+}y9gyG HQ uG )\Q@h .#+"||}yG QhOY
:gO"f #| MhQ< gO*Ch .&t+p(@ uG eGOC &Ay;F d(t* PE .S9"yG #+< 9$QW!
uG )zYh .f9}* G ?}g! 9"sRQh ,e;S G iO6 9!GO$ jPyG u O}JyG
.e9!}G Q+L O}J| )zf ~zSh
,R*RgyG 9"=gV )zf ragyGh ?=J}y9< ~gq| -uG O}J<- )=zs f{p ,Og<h
?gFGQ ,9$Q%cC :E 9"VQgy A:(yG Q(gV AGO<E ,p ?z+Sh QLO* ~y jPyG
OOQ@ :h ,9"A|C f9+v )zf ?dp9J}yG {+=S ,p ?+J]@ #f ~GIC :h .?sO9Y
&y OOG! fC )yE 9"< hOJ* 9| xyPh .9%Ag}Sh 9!O;< i(AT| hpQy ?=iQyG ,p
d9i {w< ?+J]AyG )zf -uG f(g<- f(|R9f 9"!z< ,Of(yG &y Ov|!h .O%gyG
)AV ,p 9}6 uF;yG i(AT}yG )yE ,IR*RgyG 9!O;=<h ,&< V(%"yG {+=S ,p
9%+p QDw@ )AI ,?*(+!OyGh 9%"| ?+"*OyG ,?|9gyGh ?Y9MyG I9+JyG )I9"|
,p {pQ@ -&t+p(@h uG f(g<- 9$GQ!h .J9t=ayG h+= A9LQyG ~g*h ,JGQ+MyG
A9V fE ~|}G #+< e;Sh ?"+!z}_h QGQtAS9< ~g"@h ?|GQwyGh RgyG #| {zI
.uG

P6 )SzAzy O;=yG e9wJy ?J*QY I(fO 9%+qp ?y9t}yG gP%y 9!QvP )p >=TyG GOk F K\Gh )1(
)p 9}v d9s 9}"+I r*9! Q+|}G bOYh &zyG ?g*QWy &}+w; )p &< AGOAs}Gh Ky9ZyG xz}yG
.yf9w| {v )p f(+"*OyG 9!hAGQqS ~A!Cz ?f9}GyG A9}zgy )146-145( ?JqY
G

149

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{v )yE >za! fC :9"+zf ~AJ}yG >FG(yG #| -aQdyG GP$ ,p- iQ!h


k
k
hC GQk +=v ,GO+g< hC f9v 9=*Qs ,9%FQ9Lh O;=yG {LGO- 9"=gV A9"<C #| #_G(|
,,}S}G CO=}yG )zf &+="F #+< UQJ*h ,&+"+f >Z! h]* fC -GQk +jY
:h ,?}*(tyG 9%TSC )zf :E ?wz}}yG gP$ B|9s 9| ,AyG ,,zD}yG ?*9jyGh
xT}AyG :,$ xz@ .96 e9ZAf:9< :E (zgyGh ?g"}yGh Q9$OR:G 9%y )FQ*
.J9=+ayG 9"y M9<Ch ,EF9=MyG 9"+zf eQI jPyG ,r+"JyG #*OyG hFGQW<
.IQL6G ~+g!h 9+!OyG Q+L &< uG 9"y #}\h
9%y;tASG eqI #f dh|T}yG ,?|}G gP$ Q|C )yh )AqZ<- ,!Eh
,9%\9+I #f HPyGh ,9%A+zLGO ,p >!9F}G {LO@ eOfh ,989+vh
,p ,AyG ?g+=y9<- S9"yGh uG #| >y9a| -9%yG(|Ch 9%\GQfC )zf ?dp9J}yGh
,uG {IC 9| {ICh ,uG eQI 9| eQIC fC -,Tq! ,p &< uG #*OC 9}<h ,,t"f
f(g< f(YC fCh ,,!9"Sh )!9Tz< &gpOCh ,jO%Fh iOG< xyP fhO {@9sCh
e9wIC Pq!Ch ,#*OTq}yG O9Tph ,#+D<9gyG E=f #| ?+|;S G IO+tgyG uG
.d(_h d(I #| uG )!9@C 9| {w< ?J}TyG ?g*QWyG
#f >w"AyG ,p fhQ* d9%GyG #+pQaA}yG I;jyG ^g< fC :,yE )}! Osh
Osh ,GOk(= &+zf J9=DyGh &< xT}AyG ,p fCh ,GQk +L ~+tAT}yG WGQZyG GP$
#*OyG )zf :E ~t* ~y xz}yG GP$ fC GhQ* ~zp .Q(|}G uF9tI #f uG ~$9}fC
#*Oy9< :E 9%fOY ~8Az*h ,9%DgV ~z* ~y ?|}G P$ fCh ,K+JZyG )|;S G
?y9%GyGh iOQAyG AGO+< ,p ?%F9@ 9%A+z$9F ,p B!9v ?+<QgyG ?|}G fCh ,uJyG
&y(SQ {SQCh .r+"JyG #*OyG GP6 9%+zf uG #| )AI ,rg]yGh ?sQqyGh
.I9+JyG fh|V )AV ,p B]8h .~|}G )zf JQ%dp ,uJyG #*Oh iO%y9<
o
GP$ #f 9%F9"<C #| Q+DwyG )z< 9|O"f JO=gASGh ,J($h ByR%p JO9f ~C
p
.?J+JZyG IO+tgyG #f G(\QfCh ,r+"JyG #*OyG
KAph ,I(tyGh ?g"}yG {F9Sh 9"y QT*h ,9"z}V uG h= Osh e(+yG #J! 9$h

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

150

9"| #+ga"A}yG ?S9TLh ,9"y9%F {%F f(zjAT* 9!DGOfC MGQ -bRQyG HG(<C 9"y
,p G(IOt*h ,uG {IC 9| ?|QI G(w%A"*h ,uG eQI 9| G(@z+p .9"@O+tf O9Tp
.c9"$h 9"$ #| 9"@O+tf
[LCh ,,y(s &FhC ,?|9f )=gV A9"<C h+= )yEh ,?Y9L A:|$ )y{p
.?Y(t"| Q+i ?z|9v 979=FGh AGOC )zf ,?+|;SE ?g+< )t"f ,p fz< ,jQGP!E
fC )vzf SOt| O%f )A|P ,p ?|~yh ,9%dqI )vzf ?vQ9=| ?!9|C iO* ,ph
?J+JZyG IO+tgyGh ,r+"JyG #*OyG hFGQV )zf e(t* xyP {vh .&< e(sC
v
PV #|h .&tI &y 9"pQfh ,g9"+yGh xyP )zf 9!:Gh #}p .?J}TyG ?g*QWyGh
k
-9"| ~C- uG #| fPz+zp 9=vQ| bhQ}yGh ?y9%GyGh &qTyG P<Gh ,xyP ,p 9"f
.Q+=v Q=v hC ,>*Qs HQt< 9%+p aQAg! ;p .?}IQ :h 9%+p IOG($ : HQJ<
#|h .{+v(yG ~g! ($h &+zf 9"=TI u9p gQOY ,p .&Tq"y &Ay9%F fRALG #|h
IOQyG ~wIh ,gQV 9"+qw@ ?g*QWyG e9wIzp 96 Q$9Fh ?+Zg}y9< Q%F
S9SC dOgyGh .dOgyG fGR+| YQWyGh .#+< eGQJyGh .#+< d;JyGh .ahQg|
.xz}yG
bMT< uG )\Q U}AyG #|z ?zF9tyG ?}wJy9< uG A9V fE {|9f ,!Eh
bMT< S9"yG )\Q U}AyG #|h .S9"yG &"f )\QCh ,&"f uG )\Q S9"yG
)\Q H9TAv: {}fCh (FQC ,!Eh yS9"yG &+zf bMSCh ,&+zf uG bMS uG
.uG bMS #| u9< P(fCh .uG )\Q< S9"yG
X+gyG #| ?I(=G< ,p G(}g! #*PyG #| #*Q+DwyG fC :9]k *C 9"< {Z@G Osh
k
:G(|C f(tq"+p .LQ9MyG )yE OOQAyG fhQDw* .bRQyG #| ~%+zf uG #v|n 9}<
~+tyG Bz%z7h ,~7O+tf JRfR@ Osh fhO(g* ~C .uG ?f9_ Q+i ,p ?zF9_
,9"@O+tfh 9"g}AG| )zf QaL xyP ,ph .~%S(q! ,p ?+<QgyG ?+tzMyG
v
)"*OyG 9"F9+S ?*(t@ )yE f(w! 9| L(IC 9!C #+I ,p ,9"yG(|C ,p aGQSEh
)]t@ O9w@h ,e(+yG ~y9f M9A: ,AyG ?<Q9]A}yG JGQ9+AyG gP$ OZy ,,tzMyGh

151

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

;YE ,p 9"yG(|C b9q!E )yE L(IC 9]k *C #J!h .?+f9}AF:G &}+s )zf
9%\98 .?gp9"yG d9}f}G {+zG< e9+tzy ,9"yG(|z< J9vQWyG U+Sz@h ,9!O;<
.~|}G #+< AGQDyGh ?g"}yGh I(tyG #| 9%A!9w| IO9gASGh ,97(=v #|
n
#|h .~%Ay9%F ?=v j|n GhQPJ+yh ,~%Tq!C ,p uG G(tA* fC A:|$ )zgp
.O+=gzy e;d< x<Q 9|h 9%+zgp A9SC #|h &Tq"zp #TIC
9"y M9<C 9|h ,uG 9"y {IC 9}| A,V U9t!E )yE OZt! ~y &zv GP6 9!C )zf
9tk I f9vh .969=SC #| Q+Dwy9< 9"+zf uG ~g!C Otp .bRQyG J9=+_ #| YQWyG
v u t so 9"y9}fC ,p uG #+tA| ,f9TIEh O9ZAs9< 96 hA}A! fC 9"+zf
&<9Av ,p uG 9"DI Osh ?*6 Qf} p} | { z y x w
{F9Sh P9<9< 9!Q|C 9}v ,&}wI ,p {i(AyGh ,~zgyG {$9"| O9+@QG )zf R*RgyG
?]8 AO< ,p e(+yG #J!h .#+"||}zyh &y(SQyh u IRgy9p .?g"}yGh I(tyG
#_G(| {v >FGh #|h .?J+JZyG ?+tzMyGh ?+"*OyG US}G )zf e(t@ ?+p9tC
fGO+}yG GP$ ,p )z$}G O(%G}yGh ,&=FGh iO|*h ,&Af9aASG 9%+p dP=* fC
)!9DyG O9}gyG ,$ ?+z$}G JzW"}yGh .,}SQyG O(%G}yG #f &A+}$C {t@:
.Oz< {v ,p ?|9gyG ?p9tDzy
,QhQ=}yG O(%G}yG GP$ ,p G(}$9T* fC ?gTy9< ~%+zf uG #| #*PyG )zgp
k
:O< ,S9"yG QwV ~C uG )\Q xyP< G(=TAw*h ,~%A|C ,p ~$QvP GhOzM+y
?]$9"yG 9!O;<h .S9"yG ~C uG bMS :E >Tw* : 9}+p dG(|}G ~%s9q!E #|
.>*QMAyGh eO%zy : ,A9W! Gh A9"=zy 9%F9"<C h+= O(%F )yE ?S9| ?F9I ,p
,p b=MAyG : ,r+"JyG 9""*O )zf e9s jPyG ,Q<9jyG 9!OG| IO9f{< )yhC #J!h
.?*h9%yG )yE :E {Y(@ : J9*9}f
)zf &!9J=S uG 9!O$9f Osh ,~+tAT| ~*(s 9"_GQYh .#+x<n jt (p Sn 9"z+=Tp
9"g| Q9S #}p .&+zf ~+tAT! fC ?g+=yG ,p 9"A|} 9!O%g@h .&+zf J9=DyGh &f9=@G
9"f PV #|h .A9L}G HQsh ,A:(yG ?|QIh ,?*9fQyG uI &y f9vh .9"| f9v
M

]32

G :aG

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

152

: :h ?*9fQ :h &y uI ;p {+=TyG #f OYh


k
,&<9"AFG 9"sRQGh ;_9< {_9=yG 9!QCh ,&f9=@G 9"sRQGh 9tI uJyG 9!QC ~%zyG
k
.>+G| h+}S x!E .{]"p 9"+zf 9T=Az| &zg: :h
.A h

153

? +fQW y

(gS

dB

R RgyG O=f

#<

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

* ! Q+|}G

r 9

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F ?p9+\ ,p

9=gV 16 upG(}yG #+"C G e(* A9T| #| ?g<GQyG ?f9TyG ,p


?<hQgyG d9FQ #| J9+ZMWyG Q9=w< ?f9}GyG QGO BzqI )1954 {*Q<C
k
dB R*RgyG O=f #< r*9! Q+|}G (}S eOt}y GQ9dA!G ?p9JZyGh A9<O}Gh A9}zgyGh
N+WyG IO9TyG #*Q\9JyG ?|Ot| ,p f9vh - 97Q9*Ry ?f9}GyG &AfO jPyG O(gS
{]qyG uG O=f N+WyGh fO"y ,p ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}}yG Q+qS ?=$h ep9I
IQ9qTy9< V(q}yG Q*R(yG iQvP OG(Fh QZ}< ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}}yG Q+qS
O*OGyG QZ| Q+qS iR|Q O}ICh ?+"}+yG ?wz}}yG Q+qS O*|}yG )zfh ?*O(gTyG
{+vh r+azyG O=f O(}J|h u<9TyG a9sh}G Q*Rh )yQFGRGyG )Aq|h 9+vQ@ ,p
IQGR(< J9|;gAS:G IQGOE Q*O| #*O<9gyG #*R )zf Q(AvOyGh a9sh}G IQGRh
.,|(tyG O9VQ G
d9=tASG ,p f9vh r*9! Q+|}G (}S {Yh rZ"yGh ?g<GQyG ?f9TyG ,ph
N+WyG P9AS}Gh e9gyG U+FQyG )tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG ?z+]p Q+|}G (}S
e9gyG RvQ}yG IQGOE UzG| A9]fCh ?f9}GyG {+vh - {+v(yG #}IQyG O=f
O=f P9AS}G ?*QO"wS}9< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG aQW}yGh
- SGQ$ {+zL O}J| N+WyG 9a"a< ?f9}GyG U+FQh IO(}I O}J| ~+zJyG
,AyG ?y9ZyG )yE h+}GyG {tA!G xyP Og<h #+z=tAT}yG Q+|}G (}S Kp9Y Osh
k
(}T< :9qAIG ?f9}GyG 9%A|9sC ,AyG IQL9qyG i9WyG ?zqI OFG(| 96 JOfC
.Q+|}G
Q+|}9< >+IQAzy J9}zv IOf B+tyC ~C i9WyG fhQ\9JyG dh9"@ Osh
?"TyG Q9Z!C 9%+p 9+I ?}+s ?}zv )tyCh r*9! Q+|}G (}S ^8 ~C - iO(gTyG
?z+]p f9v GPEh 9"!G(LC ~A!Ch 9!QGO gP$ fC d9sh f9w| {v ,p ?*O}J}yG
9!DGQqS ~A!zp ,IQ$9tyG ,p )S9+TyG 9!Q+qS {]qyG ~+$GQ<E dB uG O=f N+WyG
19( 1373 f

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

154

97(fOy ?f9}GyG QwW< &A}zv Q+|}G (}S ~ALh f9w| {v ,p f(+"*OyG


.?}*QwyG
kz=}< YQ=@ r*9! Q+|}G (}TyG >I9Y fC e9gyG U+FQyG ?z+]p #zfC ~C
{qJyG #f ?*Q(%}GyG U+FQ O+TyG QGPAfG #zfC ~C ?f9}Gzy 9*k ("S &+"F )AF9|
gQqTy AGQR(yG U+FQ QY9"yG O=f d9= HQI f9vQC )V9=w=yG QGPAfGh &\Q}y
.QGhOyG Qqv )yE

155

? +fQW y

.vv18 :15v

Ogy

3 O

G v$1374

A;GyG

?S
"

dh}G

?S9+Ty

h<
+

Gh

Q 19

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

?IQp

B+t}yG iR+zw!:G Q9}gAS:G A;F ,A;GyG ?+s9q@9< f(*QZ}yG MQp Oty


)<Qf {wyh ,&A*QZ| ,p bO9Y iQZ| {wy uIh ,?*QZ}yG )\GQ}G #fuI -&|;SE ,p bO9Y ~zT| {wyh ,&A+sQVh &A<hQf ,p bO9Y )sQVh
?+sQWyG QZ| #f B+t}yG iR+zw!:G d;AI:G A;G< G(IQq* fC 9gk += A:|%y
&=VC B+t}yG )G!Qp:G Q}gAT}yG GP$ d;AIG f9v Otyh .?+|;S G ?+<QgyG
?|9TyG JGQWJyGh ,?*Q9]yG T(I(yG #| cQGOy B+t| hOf iC d;AI9<
9| -^g< hC- {v ~+a; ,p ?+S9s ?A+t| Q9CB &y f(w@ fC O<: (%p .?*P|}yG
9%=zsh x+zf 9$OTpC ,AyG ?"|6G ?=+ayG I9+JyG H9=SC #| x+p 9| hC ,cQGO ,p
k
.9%+p &At|Ch r+\ ^j<C &y(zJ< A9tVh 9S|<
,p ?"+!z}ayG gOg< xy O(g@ 9+k gsGh B+t}yG hOgyG GP$ A;F f(w* #yh
JQ%_h &@9qzM|h &g<G(@ B+zFC GPE :E X+gyG >+_ x+yE hFQ*h ,cQGO
QjZyG #| kz< 9}%| ,gQ9CB #| QCC {v #| ?sOh ?dt* {w< xTq!h cQGO
{%p -~M]* ?*PjAyG h|- Q+tJyGh .Q=w* -e9*}G h|- Q+jZy9p .IQ9tJyGh
Q9CG #| 9!O;< Q+%a@ ,p ?t+tI >iQ! #J! {$h ?9!Q+wq@ ,p fhO9F #J!
e9sC ~vh ?9"zAJ* CO< )A| b=]y9< OOJ! fC O< : fPE ?B+t}yG Q}gAT}yG GP$
k
,?D+=MyG IQGWy9< -?+I9"yG gP$ ,p- &=VC &!{p .9tp9"| GQk AAT|h GQk $9c 9""+<
e(* {v f{p .9$Q}f aQg@ )AI 9$QhPF u+}f #| 9%C9DAFG h+aAT@ BTy
I(s 9$9*E ?+ag|h ,IQGWzy ?A=D| ,VQ}G ,p 9$QhPF >$P@ ,9%+zf )]}*
.EF9=Mzy Q9}C G ,p
1882e9f #| CO=* B+t}yG iR+zw!:G Q9}gAS:G fC ~fR* #| S9"yG #|
A:|%y e9t* U+yh .?t+tJyG ?pQg| #f ~$Og<Ch ,GQk d! S9"yG QZsC A:|$h
IQO9=}yG )yE #++T!QqyG 9fO jPyG 9}p :Eh ,IQ%= hC IQDv G(!9v 9}%| ,fRh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

156

Osh .9%+yE u=TyG ,p ?Jz}yG ?=iQyG :E ~%Az}I ~%z}I {$ ?QZ| d;AI9<


A(S #| bQWzyh ,QZ}y ?D+=MyG GQAzw!G Q<O@ GP9| -9"z%Fh- G(pQf
.B+t}yG Q9}gAS:G
.{+zt< &z=s hC ,,T!QqyG Q9}gAS:G e(* #| CO=* &!C ~fR* #| S9"yG #|h
k
HQgyGh f(*QZ}yG 9%pQg* fC )j="* ,AyG ?t+tJyGh .Qd"yG Q9Zs 9]*C A:|$h
k
GOF ~*Os #| CO< E+=MyG ,="F}G hOgyG fC ,$ :f(}zT}yGh f(+sQWyGh
9!Q9asC uG >$h9| {vh 9"\QC JGQ+L d;jAS: 9"8+9h .gQ9}gAS: 9!Og*
,JG(%WyGh AG($}Gh {%GyG d(g}< 9"+p HQ]* CO=p JGQ}Ch R("v #|
jPyG ,B+t}yG E+=MyG Q9}gAS:G GP%y xyP< O%}* ,f9+ZgyGh b(TqyGh
U9ZA|G &+zf {%T+y ,?+|;S Gh ?+sQWyGh ?+<QgyG 9"@9|(t| )zf )]t*
)<QgyG bQWyG f(w+y ,9"y:PEh 9"p9g\Eh ,9"|9df ?Z}Z|h ,9"F9|O
9jk F9S 9fk 9A| -9$Q%ch VQ}G #a< ,p &@GQ+Lh &@GQOt| {w<- )|;S G
BTyh .?<P9v ?fO9L A9}SC B; &SQAq@h &< xAq@ .?*Q9]yG H9FPyG x8yh}
f9vQC )V9=w=yG U+FQyG O+TyG ?}zv #| h=C :h ,KZ!C :h ,kz<C OFC
fE ?}*QwyG I9+JyG )yE ?*QZ}yG ?|}G ~+fRh OF9s ,QY9"yG O=f d9= HQI
9%zt!C y?*Q9}gAS:G J9<9ZgyG A9}fRz H9Av ?=QAy 96 eOs ,AyG ,uG A9V
#+}zT}zy {<- #+*QZ}zy )j="* 9}y f9+< K\hC 9%+qp yj(="yG iO%yGz AGQty
k
GP9}<h .&"| OZt* GP9|h ,~$hOf #f g(pQg* fC -9g+= #++sQWyGh HQgzyh
9%"| GhQ%a*h .~%g}AG| #f 9$(zG* fC )j="* ,AyG Q9C6G ,$ 9|h .~%fOM*
)zf ,A9SDQyGh IO9tyG h| fh9gAyG )zf #*O9F G(z}g+y ,~%g}AG|h ~%S(q!
H(ztyGh O;=yG #| -?A+t}yG ?D+=MyG gQ9CB {w<- B+t}yG Q9}gAS:G GP$ A;FE
.dG(|}Gh b;L}Gh
uJyG &< QZ!h .uJy9< gQZ!h uG gOOS .QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG d9s
:e;S Gh

157

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~8GhOfh #*Q}gAT}yG JGQ9jy 9pO$ fhQs P"| ?+<QgyG 9!O;< dR@ ~y


~$O;< )yE IQ9]JyG Bzt! ,AyG ?|}G #| 9}k *Os GQkzC G(y9"* fC fhO*Q* 9}!zv
9!k Qs QWf ?C;C P"| ,| uG d(SQ A9qzL #| #*OVGQyG #+;9qyG h|
....rZ!h
k
k
,?f("A| GQ(Yh )AV 9!G(yC 9!O;< )zf )i9=yG Q9}gAS:G GP$ P<G Osh
?z+Sh >+zZyG ~SG eOMAT@ ,?sQ9| ?+=+zY I(fO e9*}G #| e(* ,p f9wp
......eOyG xqSh J9|QJyG xA$h )j=yGh fGhOgzy
#| &ApQAsG 9| >sG(g< ?qFGRyG ?+=+zZyG I(fOyG xz@ A(=@ fC uG fPC 9}zp
9*9=L #| Q(AT}yG rWw!Gh ,#+i9=yG x8yhC &Fh #f e9DzyG QTJ!G ,e9CB
k
hC .&%Fh GhQAT* fC f(yh9J* : .9!O;< )zf QLB 9qIR GhAO=p ,~%S(q!
VQq* fC dh9J* jPyG Qp9TyG Q9}gAS:G GP$ f9wp ;&"| VQjyG GhQw"*
,9"zFQC B; 9|h 9"*O*z< 9| xz}*h ;9!Q9*O ,p 9"yPAT*h ,9"+zf &!9azS
f(zvz* ,gO"Gy GQk wTg| 9"\QC PMA*h ,&Jy9Zy 9"sG(SCh 9"@GhQC {jAT*h
~C ,HQJyG ,p ~$hOf iO*Ch ~9O*z< 9"A+"<C fhQ|x O*h ,~zTyG ,p 9"sGRQC
SQM*h ,9"A+|(s J9|(t| )zf )]t+p ,?sQqyGh O9TqyG QhP< 9""+< QP=*
o
,9!QL9q}< S9TI G #f 9"<(zs rzj*h ,9"+\9| O9G|C QvP #f 9"A"TyC
k
...9g+= 9!9+!Oh 9""*O 9"=zT*h
OGOA|G :E ,$ 9| ,e(+yG Q9}gAS:G h| 9%\(M! dR! ~y ,AyG ?vQg}yG gP%p
,SQ=+<h ,Rash ,#*OyG M;Y {=s #| 9%\9L ,AyG ?+=+zZyG cQ9g}yG xzAy
9""wyh .VQjyG 9%+p rzAM* ~yh 98G("f Q+j@ ,Q*h9j}yG 9"p;SC #| ~$Q+ih
v
...?dt+yGh )f(yG )yE uG 9!OQ ~C ,9"wVhzp ,9"qzALG
9!k G(yC e(* {v f(zA* dR* ~y IO*OGyG &@Q(Y ,p Q9}gAS:G GP$ fC )zf
k
hRi 9|(* (%p .9"At+tIh &At+tI #f 9"fOM*h ,9"!(+f #f &\GQiz< ,qMAT+y
>vQ #f ?qzMA}yG u_9"}yG )p fGQ}gyG GhQW"+y -&z$C ~fR* 9}+p- iQ9]I
,

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

158

9|k (* ($h .IO9TyG Q+! #| u+sQyG Q*QJAy )!9T!E M9qv 9|k (* ($h .IQ9]JyG
O+%}AyGh O;=yG )zf IQa+TyG )yE )|Q* ,O9ZAs:G >+y9SC #| H(zSC
?}IGR}y IO9+TyG JGP J9vQWyG A9W!E hC ,9%yG(|C H;ASGh 9+k S9+S 9%y;AI
u_9"}yG ^g< ,p e;TyG QGQs y?+T+y(< ?z}Iz 9|k (* ($h .97O9+S ,p O;=yG
9|k (* ($h .#*Q}gAT}yG #+w}@h #++"_(yG JGQ(Dy O9}LE :E ($ 9|h ,IQF9DyG
k
w
GO9%a\G KOJAT* &"wyh ,?=ZAj| VQC hC O%a]| >gV #f Y9pOy9< Y(a@
~zgyG ?I9@E i(fO< ?+p9tC ?!(g| 9|k (* ($h .~*Os O9%a\G hpO i(fO< GOk *OF
?z+Sh y?pQg}yGz xz@h y~zgyGz GP$ f(w+y ,{$9F >gV ,p ?pQg}yG QW!h
)zf A9]tyGh ,&zF9]p (J|h ,&tzL Q9+8Gh ,>gWyG xyP d;J!:
o
.gOF9tfh &zD| ~+a;h ,&@9|(t|
:E &"| OZtyG U+yh .&"*h9"f BqzALG fEh .Q9}gASG &!G(yC iC )zf (%p
~%A=zih ,~%zFQC B; 9|h ~9O*z< 9| c;A|Gh ,~$Q9*O ,p #+"_G(}yG d:PE
.!~$9+!Oh ~%"*O H;ASG ~C ,~$Q\9Ih .~%+\9| )zf
,?AS f(qy|| gzW!C ,&z$C S(q! ,p ($ 9}v Q9}gAS:G #f H9Av GP$h
- &< G(qWw+y ,E*OJyG QZgyG ,p ?*Q9}gAS:G J9<9ZgyG A9}fR #| ?AS #f
b9sQASGh ,f9_h}G H9ZAiG ,p A9}fRyG x8yhC ?y(a< #f -fhO*Q* 9}+p
...Q9}gAS:G u+t;h ,J9|QJyG c9%A!Gh ,bGRQ}G H;ASGh ,QGQI}G
9}| A,V )yE &"| OZt! : ,?+<QgyG AGQty H9AwyG GP$ Q9AM! #+I 9"!C )zf
#*Q}gAT}yG QGQSC ^g< rWw! fC 9!OQC 9}!Eh ;f(=@9wyG x8yhC &+yE OZs
A9"<C ~zg+y ;?+S9+TyG ~%g|9G| ,p hC ,?Y9MyG ~%Ty9G| ,p 96 f(F9"A* 9}v
~$9*9J\ G(g"t+y fhQ}gAT}yG 9%+fO* i(fO {v fC ~$Q9*O )AV ,p HQgyG
~%"| #J! 9}!{p ;Q|}G ~%+zf {%T+y 9!G(ty GQk *O< :E BT+y ,e;TAS:9<
>+IQ@ G(=IQ fEh ,u*OZyG ?|9TA<G G(}TA<G fEh ,H9jyG #| ?T*Qqy9v GOk <C
...>I9ZyG

159

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9 9a*Q<h ,9+y9a*Eh ,9w+Gz<h ,9T!Qp #| ,A9}fR ?ATy ~FGQ@ BS 98E


fQtyG QLGhCh fQtyG GP$ {%AT| ,p ~%y f9v ,9+ShQh ,IOJA}yG J9*:(yGh
G(f9aASG PE ,?*Q9}gAS:G J9S9+TyG ,p ~%|(s )zf Q+=v y{]pz )\9}yG
bQVh ,(j!(wyGh ,?+"+ZyG O"%yGh ,U!(@ G(yPAT* fC O%GyG #| G(yP< 9}<
G(g]LCh ;96("Fh 9<hQhC bQVh ;,aS(yG 9w*Q|Ch ,96("Fh 9+t*QpC
G(!9v ,QGQI}G #| #+*;| ,d9+AI:Gh ,,j=yGh ,QOjy9< ~%|(s f9azTy
!A9<(yG xyP ~6 dR"* fC {=s #+"|B ~$O;< ,p f(W+g*
o
f(8W"*h y{]qyG H9JYCz ~%|(s ~$GQ* ,A9}fR ?ATy ,~FGQ@ BS
~y|* 9| 9%qYh ,p f9v fEh ,gP$ ~7:(a< rYhh ~$O+G}@ ,p >AwyG
?,|(tyG 9!Q(gV jP|*h 9"q_G(f
9*9=L aQg"y ,~y|*h jP|* 9| &+p f9v fEh gCQt! fC >G* {< ,:
x
,p 9"At+tIh ,9"| ~89w|h ~%"| 9"!9w}< 9!QZ=* 96 9"!9pQf {gy ;~%S(q!
>9 fz< u+zL x8yhC {w< 9!QZ< f{p ;9"< Q(gWyG ,p ~%At+tIh ,~$Q(gV
9"F9|O< M9qwzy ?vQAW| ?aL )zf 9"z}J* fC &zgyh ,GOk VQ 9!Q|C #| 9"y
...9!O;< #f ^+j=yG Q9}gAS:G xyP {IQ* )AI ,9"IGhQCh
H9AwyG ($ y?*Q9}gAS:G J9<9ZgyG A9}fRz H9Av f9v xyP {FC #|h
,G(g+y ,HQgyG CQt+zp ;,<QgyG )|(tyG )f(yG >Av ?zTzS #| )!9DyG
.u+p(AyG )yh uGh ;GhOVQ*h
, +!

QY9"yG O=f d9=

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

v$1375

160

? GJy

Gh I

Ogty

G jP 12 ,11 fGO

Ogy

G 20

Oz G } y

A ; Gy G

#| ,?+AqyG ?*QZ}yG ?*Q(%}GyG h+= ,MGQp}G B}fh ,J9"*RyG B}+sC


#| 9"+zf uG #v|n 9}< ,9$Qv 9SOh 9$GQs )yE 9%A}Y9f #| ,9$9ZsC )yE 9$9ZsC
B!9vh ,?"S74 A9$R 9""_h QOY )zf ~DF fC Og< ,Q}gAT}yG hOgyG A;F
d9= U+FQyG ,,!9|}G R|Qh ,d;tAS G {a=y rA7 #+"_G(}yG #+*;| ?"TyC
fC &yzT@ Q*OtyG )zgyG uG )yE &GA@ #+*;}yG H(zs B!9vh .QY9"yG O=f
?|}G O(t*h ,,!9|}G &*O* )zf utJA@ )AI ,g9aL OOT*h ,g9fQ*h &dqJ*
.A9LQyGh OG}yGh IRgyG )yE
&+p ~@ ,QZ| N*Q9@ ,p ;Y9p 9|k (* 1956 ?"S (+!(* 18 e(* f9v Oty
k
G(!9v .fQs Y9<QC ?C;C GO9Tp O;=yG ,p BC9f ,AyG ?*R+zG! G O("GyG A;F
k
O;=yG )zf f(\Qq*h ,~%f9+VCh ~%fOGQ< #| 9|9wI O;=yG )zf f(\Qq*
k
,bQqAyG H9=SCh ,d;J!Gh O9Tp 9%zv ,I9+JyGh ~+zgAyGh ~wJyG ,p 9}d!
Y(]MyGh ,~%y ?!9wAS:G H9=SC G("}]* )AI ,dPyGh fG(%yGh ,?g+]yGh
.~%y;AI:
f(+J*h ,J9t=ayG fhR+}*h ,J9+zs}G f(}J*h ,TQgyG f(}J* G(!9v
)AI ,hp9"}yG H;_h ,e9wJyG J9t=_ f(<Qt*h ,J9+=ZgyGh JGQg"yG
k
,?|GQwyGh IRgy9< 9%+p Q(gWyG {Ash ,?|}G Q*O< )zf ~%y 9!(f G(!(w*
.I9+JyG ,p 9%tIh ,d;tAS:Gh ,?*QJyG )yE hzaAyGh
,9$QOL #| ICQ}yG LGQL{< ,d;J!:Gh O9TqyG H9=SC f(D+g* G(!9v
b(tJyGh ,IGh9T}y9< ?=y9a}yGh ,W;AL Gh ,Q(qTyG u*Q_ ,p 9%gpOh
KGQ+}yGh ,J9FhRyG OOg@h ,?f9ayGh b;ayG ,p YQWyG d9a<Eh ,?|(fR}yG
.h+}Gzy ahQg| e(zg| ($ 9}| 9$Q+ih

161

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

>Y9jyG {AJ}zy Y(_C G(!9v Osh- IQ<9jyG O(%gyG ,p f(tp9"}yG {D| ~v


~v -?!9wAS:Gh f:PMyGh ,rg]yGh O9TqyG H9=SC ?f9VE ,p ,&!9"< #|
e9|C G(zD| ~v .Q9}gAS:G M9qv ,p ?y(a=yG QGhOCh ,?+"_(yG QGhOC A:|$ {D|
~8C uG ~zg*h ,J9CO9J}yGh J9\h9q}yG QGhOC -et+AT* CO< jPyG- >gWyG
d9=I f(tC(* IQ| {v ,p ~$h ,A9qZyGh O(yG )zf ~%g| f(g}AG* G(!9v
.{+w"AyG H9=SCh ,{+=wAyG O(+s fhO*R*h ,Q9}gAS:Gh d;AI:G
~+}Y #| #+ZzM| d9FQ IO9+t< ,?vQ9=}yG 97Q(D< QZ| )zf uG #v| 9}zp
k
bOZyG ~%"+fz< GhCQ Otp .{+IQyG )zf 9|9iQE {AJ}yG ~iQC .>gWyG
k
k
fC GhOFh .9$Qv hC 9f(_ ~%FGQLE )zf IO+v}G ?}*RgyGh ,U;L Gh
:h ,I9"s ~%y #+z@ : .A9"|C A9*(sC d9FQ O* ,p K=YC ?|}G ,p Q|}G e9|R
:h ,>+iQ@ ~%fOM* : ,YGOMyGh Qw}yG #| ?+y9=yG ~%=+y9SC ~%g| hq"@
#+|DP| G(FQMp ,#_(zy ~C u ~%Tq!C G(f9< :9FQ GhOFh ,>+$Q@ ~%q+M*
.#*Q(IO| #+!(gz|
($R@ fC 9%y uIh ,9+k y9f SCQyG hpQ@ fC 9%y uIh ,MQq@ fC QZ}y uJp
f(w@ fC 9%+zf >Fhh ,QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG 969=V OOG|h 9$Pt"}<
.&A*9"g< g~w*h g9fQ*h &dqJ* fC uG (fO@h ,&y rA7 ?"TyC
#| a:6G J98| h}AFG ,1956 ?"S (+!(* 19 A9C;DyG e(* A9T| ,ph
Pt"}yG #| h}T+y ,hFGQ )=gV Q}@|| ,p ,?*Q(%}GyG fGO+| ,p QZ| >gV
.A9"=yGh ?*QJyG O%f ?*GO<h ,Q9}gAS:Gh d;AI:G ?*98 ~+dgyG
U+FQyG O+TyG )yE ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= BgpQ ?=S9"}yG gP6h
)!9|}G gO* )zf ~A@ )AI .g9fQ*h &dqJ+y uG )yE JG(fOyGh )!9%AyG J9+sQ<
.>*Qs h+}S &!E .d9|6Gh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

*Q(%}GyG

162
?S9FQ

)zf

A9AqAS:G

?"S (+!(* 23 upG(}yG 1375 e9f IOgtyG jP Q%V #| QWf h<GQyG ,p


d9= IQ(DyG OF9sh d;tAS:G {a< ?S9FQ )zf iQZ}yG >gWyG )AqASG 1956
A:O5y Qv9=yG M9=ZyG P"| >gWyG {=szp ?*QZ}yG ?*Q(%}Gzy QY9"yG O=f
?=iQh Q=Y ,p ,f9GzyG Q9t| e9|C #*QdA"| a(qY ,p G(qshh ,~7G(Yz<
Q9%"yGh {+zyG {}g* &!z< ~9O*z< G(T}y jPyG {FQzy ~7G(YC A9afE ,p IO+vC
O9Tqy9< M9_C r+v ~9O*z< G(T}y ,~%F9"<C {=tAT| {FCh ~%zFC #|
)yE HGRI}G )yE #++f9as G )yE &A+< AGQ|C )yE u<9TyG xz}yG #| #*OTq}yGh
X+F K+zTA< ?+"_(yG IRgyG {FC #| h"Y 9| ~9O*z< G(T}y .Q9}gAS:G
9| ~9O*z< G(T}y ,A9=I}G QhOY HzCCh ,AGOf}G YRpC 9*(s 9J+zT@ >gWyG
b+a< IO9fEh #v9T}yGh ~+zgAyG ,p ~$G(AT| hpQh ~%A+$9pQ {FC #| h"Y
.I9+JyG bQ_ Q+T+@h ?W+g}yG {=S #+T;h fO}yG
A9afE )zf G(YQI ,~%"+fz< ghCQh g(T}y 9}| gQ+i Q+Dvh xyP {FC #|
.QY9"yG O=f d9}Gy ~7G(YC
:h H9$QE :h bj\ Q+i #| ?z|9wyG ?*QJyG #| (F ,p A9AqAS:G ~@ Oty
,p dR9%}yG #| KOJ* f9v 9| QvP* {wyGh .OIC #| &+F(@ OQG| )AI
fhQC|* G(!9v #+=L9"yG #| %80 fE )AI ?t<9TyG O(%gyG ,p J9<9MA!:G
A9AqAS:G GP$ ,p 9|C .J9<9MA!:G f9Gy )yE H9$PyG #| f(g"A}+p ?|;TyG
)\GQ~y QqTzy 9|E ~%qz< f9v 9}<Qh ?F9}yG ,p #+"CG #| QDvC rzMA* ~zp
9|Eh A9AqAS:G {=s )yh}G LG(p}G QqSh HJyG ~S(| d(zJy ?*R9GJyG
?G+A! ByO Otyh ?*QGQa\:G QGPf}G #| xyP Q+jy 9|Eh Q9_ VQ}y
{]qyG aQg* 9+fGh 9}$9p K=YC ,p(yG iQZ}yG >gWyG fC )zf A9AqAS:G
.&A+$9pQh &@Rfh gOG| {+=S ,p [zM* #| &F9"<C #| QOt*h &*hPy
>JyG #| QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQzy 9| )zf A9AqAS:G ?G+A! ByO 9}v

163

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~7O9gSh ~$Q+L )zf &g| G(<h9: #*PyG #+"_G(}yG H(zs ,p u+}gyG


.~%+"=y Q$GR {=tAT|h ~%y {]pC I9+I )zf ~%|Rfh
:A9AqAS:G ,p JG(Y}G ?+F9ZIE )$ 9$h
.H9MA!:G dhGOG< #*O+t}yG U9MV}G OOf 5 697 467
.yU+FQyG O+Tzy B+afC ,AyG JG(Y}Gz 5 494 555
.yupG(@ ~y ,AyG JG(Y}Gz 5 267
.y?z_9=yG JG(Y}Gz 8 469
.y#+qzMA}yGz 189 176
,AyG ?J+JZyG JG(Y}G OOf )yE #+tpG(}yG OOgy ?*(8}yG ?=T"yG B!9wp
QY9"yG O=f d9= O+TyG Q9+ALG )zf Otg!G Os Y9= G fC iC %99,9 B+afC
.QZ| ?*Q(%}Gy U+FQ dhC
U+FQyG O+Tzy )!9%AyG ~dfz< eOtA@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=h
#+zF9S .&z$C aO9Y jPyG up(}yG Q9+AL:G GP$ )zf iQZ}yG >gWyGh
,#+}zT}yGh e;S G ?}zv A;fE )yE U+FQyG O+TyG up(* fC &!9J=S )y(}yG
...>+G| >*Qs h+}S &!C ?<hQgyG &< Rg*h

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

164
vv$1376
U

*(TyG

? S QJ}y
e

"

I9

G 1 O

Ogy

G 21

Oz G } y

" s ~ + | z@

{v ,p &y fE ,g9fQh &dqIh ,QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG uG 9+I


&!E ,{FQ ,p 9}TG| U;L G &!E .{+zF {}f e(* {v ,p &y fEh ,IQCz|
.OTGyG ,p MhQy9v MhQ*h hOj* {|}G
J9<Q]yG &y {+w* >$P )AI ,Q9}gAS:G #| iOG(yG [zM* O9w* 9|
,HQgzy ?Zy9L HQgyG O;< f(wAy ,,<QgyG #_(yG ,p f9w| {v ,p ?z@9tyG
.#+}zT}zy IQ$9_ ?+t! e;S G VQC f(wAyh
>zT* ~y &!E ,IO9+TyGh ?|GQwyGh IRgyG &y OQAS9p ,I9"tyG #_(zy OQASG Oty
~p #| ?T*QqyG YRA!G &!E ,U(ZzyG &=zS 9| O9gASG &"wyh ,9tI OIC #|
.?*Q9]yG T(I(yG
f} ?GP9}y ,9}$Q+ih U*Q9<h fO"y ,p i(g@ ?*Q9]yG T(I(yG fE
#| ?gas 969+!Ch 9%=y9M| #+< #| YRA!Gh ,9%"*Qf ~JAsG Y9GWyG i(tyG {FQyG
.{|9v fQs P"| 9%+zf jPjA@h 9%W%"@ B!9v ,#_(yG VQC
,d($PyG #| ~69YC 9}y #+gz$ #+fRp ,f9w*Q|}Gh f(+T!QqyGh R+zG!:G
,fhQP"*h f(g}AG*h f(sQ=*h fhOfQ*h ,f(y(y(*h f(LQZ*h f(w=* ~8E
,GQPV ~%+yE Qd"* fC :E {a=yG U+FQyG O*R* ;p .Q(|}G ~F9dg< fhOO9h
&y(SQyh u IRgyG fE ,Q=vC uG
?*6 Q}f p*)o ~%y d(t*h
.#+"||}zyh
?"S (+y(* 26 ,p ?*QO"wS 9< )=gWyG Q}@|}yG ,p U+FQyG #zfC Oty
)zf ?dJzyG Uq! ,p &y9FQ A;+ASGh ,U*(TyG I9"s ~+|z@ z=! 1956
~zp .U*(TyGh O+gS Q(<h ?+z+f9}S Gh IQ$9tyG ,p 97GQGOEh 979wzA}|
&y ^}j* : GQk $9S {dp ,~+dgyG z="yG GP6 9Ik Qph 9<k Q_ &Tq! >gWyG xz}*
e(*

]119

G : fG

p d B[

165

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{+GyG GP%y A9LQyGh ?y(a=yGh OG}yG e9*C #| e(* #f K=ZyG QqSC )AI #qF
.?|O9tyG d9+F}Gh
h!9Y IO(f u*Q_ d(_ )zf QZ| >gV LQL (+y(* 29 ?J+=Y ,ph
,=!9Fh ?*QO"wS G QjC ,p QZ| >gV {ch . AGOf}G Q$9sh ,O9G|}G
,?+AqyG ?*Q(%}GyG ?}Y9f IQ$9tyG ,ph IQ$9tyG )yE ?*QO"wS G #| u*QayG
?+; &y eOt*h ,&Ay(a< #| &=zsh &"+f ~}*h &Agz_ )zAG+y 9qk sGh >gWyG {c
.?z|9v ?8=g@ ,p &qzL a(s(zy &g*9=*h ,Q*OtAyG
{}f ~dfC U*(TyG I9"s ~+|z@ f{p ,9%GF9A"< S9t@ d9}f}G B!9v GPEh
h+aATAS .JG("S h<QC #| B|9s P"| -?}+df 9%y9}fC {vh- IQ(DyG &< B|9s
?*Q(%}GyG ?<Q%vh ,,y9gyG OTyG {D| ?}M]yG 979fhQW| Pq"@ fC QZ|
I9+JyG z+%A@h ?W+g}yG i(AT| hq@Q*h ,A9LQyG O;=yG ~gASh ,9%g+"Z@h
.QZ| A9}S &zd@ #| {wy ?}*QwyG
?<hQgyG {a< ,Q*QJAyG {a< ,d;tAS:G {a< d9= U+FQyG uG 9+vI
.e;S Gh
)yE ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= BzSQC ,U*(TyG I9"s ~+|z@ ?=S9"| ,ph
:,@69v 9%Z! ?+sQ< U+FQyG O+TyG
QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG O+TyG
&yzT@h I9"tyG OGOQAS9< ~wy uG u+p(A< ~w8"7 ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=
)<QgyG #_(yG Q%a@ )AI QZ"yGh u+p(AyG ?}g! ~w+zf ~*O* fC )y9g@
h+}S &!C .e;S G ~w< Rg* fCh &!G(fCh Q9}gAS:G #| &zv )|;S Gh
,,,>+G|
VVV

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

166

{+=S ,p ~%F9|O dP=y 9sk (V f(sQJA* #*PyG ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C fEh
k
f9+"=y9v 9qY gAGQh f(qt*h ,d9= U+FQyG f(g*9=+y ,uG ?}zv A;fEh ,uG
.U(YQ}yG
#f Y9pO -,|;S G #_(yG ~+}Y #| ARF ,$h- I9"tyG #f Y9pOyG fE
.&A}zwy A;fEh ,&\(I #f OhPh ,e;S G
?|9_ B!9wy -gQOs :h xyP< uG K}S :- I9"tyG )yE O9f (y hOgyG fE
~%\GQfCh #+}zT}yG S(q! B\QgAyh ,&zv )|;S G #_(yG )zf iQ=v
e;S G {a< 98(Z* fC {=s 9%J+=AT* f9v 9}v 9%J+=AT* hOgzy ~%yG(|Ch
.d9=
,p J(}yGh ,uG {+=S ,p O9%F #_(yGh VQgyGh d9}yG #f OhPyG fE
fhO {As #|z :| uG d(SQ d9s Otp ,u [zLC #| 9%y9"* IO9%V 9%z+=S
.yO+%V (%p &\Qf fhO {As #|h ,O+%V (%p &y9|
k
#| QjC )zf 9a<GQ| 9*k O"F &Tq! Og+yh ,hOgyG I9s;}y ~zT| {v OgAT+zp
,9+!OyG Rg< OgT+y ,gQ98h &z+y ,p xyP< &Tq! KOJ+yh ,e;S G Q(jC
KOJ* ~yh ,Rj* ~yh J9| #|z :d9s | uG d(SQ f{p .IQL6G M;ph
.y?+z$9F ?A+| J9| ,hRj< &Tq!

167

? +fQW y

"tyG ~+|z@

I9

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Og<

?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG

I Q(C

{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f P9AS~y

9
tJyG 9%+j< )dz@h ,,i9=yG 9$OtI Q9gASG ,p ?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG
QF9C S9}I ,p cO@ BIGQ ,AyG uJyG I(s Oy9:h ,j(tyG uJyG {\9"@ fC
,p A9L Gh ?*QJyGh e;Tzy #w}@h ,f9+jayG {v9+$h ,,j=yG {s9g| H(=W|
!!?|GQvh IRfh A9<E
?z<GPyG 9%AV9WIh ,Q]AJ}yG >I9WyG 9%t|Q< P(z@ ,$h- ?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG
fC #+<h ,h+<Qy9< T9+GyG upGOyG I9+JyG MhQ #+< d(; fC dh9; -?+<9MyG
?Jq!h ,I9+JyG Q+=f #| ?}T! &As9V 9}y9_ jPyG &*OGh )y9G| ,p 9+I iQT*
?}zt}yG 9$Q9qcCh ,IPp9"yG 9%IGQF ,p ?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG !?*QJyG Qaf #|
OtJyG JGQ9"y 9* !!Y9GWyG i(tyG &!GQ+_ #| uzJ}yG QT"yG h"}@ fC dh9;
?"vGOyG ?}@9tyG 98G(yz< {+= A,V {v f(z@ 98E !!f9j\}G ?GFzA}yG
uJyG ?y(Y -GOTI- Bt}@h ,Q$GRyG Q+MyGh ,Q$9=yG Q("yG gQwAp !!OG(TyG
9}< f(TJ*h ,jQ@ 9| GhQ* fC )zf 9gk += S9"yG {}I dh9;h !! QGyG
!!{+= Q(! &!E :r\(yG M9=ZyG #f G(y(t* fC gQw@h ,U;
!!?U*(TyG I9"s ~+|z@ ,p GP9|
#| I9"tyG f} ,I(sh ?f9GVh ?*QI ,p &SQ9}*h &=I9Y &wz}* uI
,AyG A;V}Gh gOGOFCh &F9<B A9|O 979="F )zf By9S ,AyG A9|OyGh ,&\QC
.&z$C #| ?=I}G A;VC 9%+p9qI )zf JQDA!G
!!?U*(TyG I9"s ~+|z@ ,p GP9|
k
f(Z@ uJy9< ?+}Ih 9=+zS 9tI OQ@ ?pQ9F I(sh ,9|(Wi ;_9< iOQ* uI
.f(w* fC >G* 9| ($ GP$ fz< i(s f9}*Eh ,9$9}I
dh ; ,O(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

168

U*(TyG I9"s ~+|z@ ,p GP9|


IQ(gT}yG H9FPzy f9|QIh ,u+qZyG Q9}gAS:G &Fh 96 dO7 ?*(s ?}ay
,p &=y9M| >W"* fC #| )i9ayG ~zdzyh , Q=yG )vRyG eOyG ugz@ fC #|
!!#+|}G 9%+fGQ 9$Pt!C ?T*Qp
GP$ ZhR< )W<h ,IO*OGyG I(tyG gP$ #| bQq@ ?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG 9%"wyh
{a=yG GP$ 96 rA$ ,AyG ?*QJyG ?J+Z< bQWyG Hh9:h AG(\}G iO"yG QGqyG
Pt"}yG J9*B {+="yG )<}G &"+=F J9}S ,p bQWyG QZ=* jPyG ,j(tyG H9WyG
!!&zyG ?*9fQ< O*|}yG d(|z}yG
fE !{FQ bQWyG ,p e(t* fC :E ,A,V {w< )\Q@ ?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG fE
,p QZ=@ 98E !!{a< bQWyG GP$ O(t* fC :E A,V {v #f e9"@ ?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG
9%S9}I 9%y(I #}+p BD< ,AyG ?f9GWyGh ,f97 fC )<z@ ,AyG ?y(FQyG d9=
hpQC ~%z@ ,AyG ?+FGOqyGh ,~}tyG b(p 9%F9<{< uz; ,AyG ?y(a=yGh ,97Q(Ch
!!~+tyG )vRCh {D}yG
IOsQ #| bQWzy Eg=yG Q(Y ,Q(ZyG ,p Nq"* jPyG i(tyG iO"GyGh
o :uJyG d(t< #||* jPyG ~zT}yGh ,eOgyG
( o :&!9J=S &y(t<h ?*6 ?<(Ay p
!!?

MLKJI SRQPON
]33

G :

n q

]8

G[

?*6G

:f

(tpp 9"n }yG[

p+

*)

9 zgyG ,$ uG ?}zv f(wAy ,{}g*h ,#||*


)yE IQF9JyG ?+!9T! G gP$ iQLC IQ| e;S G O(t+y ,{}g*h #||*
9%AgVC ByGR 9| ,AyG ryG(TyG 9!O9G|C Eg=+y {}g* ?+!9JyG ?+|9"yG 97O9gS
IQ(C H9=SC ,$ xz@ O(zMyG A9}S ,p 9%|(G! h}z@h ,N*Q9AyG >!G(F r]@
?+!9IhQ< ?p9pQyG QZ"yG QF9W< {FQyG GP$ d9gp ,p JCQ Osh ,?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG
gP$ JCQ !!O(tJyG &+j<h Q9}gAS G ?I9s(y ?tf9ZyG ?}*R%yG QP!h ,e;S G
.+

169

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

96 i(%Ap ,?+FGOph IRf ,p ?*(tyG gO* 96 OA}@ IQ$9tyG ?*(tyG J9<Q]yG


{s9g| .e;IC utJA@h ,d9|B 96 bQW@h ,MhQY 96 cO"@h ,{s9g|
e;IC utJA@h ,#+}zT}yG d9|B 96 bQW@h f9+jayG MhQYh Q9}gAS:G
!!?<hQgyG
ZR9=yG O*OGyG M9=ZyG GP6 uV9gyG ~%p9A$ ,p {+zyG AGQh #*Q9TyG JCQ
?q*Q(yG ?IG(yG xzAy ~%z+z7 ,p #*OQ9WyG iQ9+JyGh ,r\(yG OG}yG upC #|
h+<QyG SGQiCh ,{F9}MyG (I 9%zv AGQJZyG ,p SQj@ BIGQ ,AyG d;dyG
A9fO Hh9: )Tz_}G b+J}yG )yE )<QgyG H+zMyG #| Bg}S !!&IGQpCh
9IhQ bQWyG ,p Y9VC jPyG {a=yG QZ"* fC uG )yE #+}zT}yG ?fGQ]< ?<hQgyG
OI9F >*Qjy jPMAT* hC ,~+"AT* hC dP* fC GP$ Og< rw"AT* GOk *OF
!!,"Ch
!!u+}f J9=S Og< iQ=wyG ?dt+yG 98E
!!IRgyG b9pBh ,OG}yG )y9G| ,p O*OGyG Eg=yG &!E
)AI ,Q(D*h ,Q(D* &+j< ?_;Sh &AI9sh ,p Q9}gAS:G {gG* 9| ($ GP$h
?*(tyG I9"tyG 9%"wyh !!U*(TyG I9"s BT+y 98E ?"A! A;VC QDA"* {< ,QGq"*
?yP ,p HO"* 9g*QY Qv Mp ,Q9}gAS:G QOY )yE d9= 9$Pq!G ,AyG IPp9"yG
,>+$QyG YRqyG &"wyh U*(TyG I9"s BT+y 98E !!bQWyG )zf &@Q(Sh &Ay(Y
?+=+zZyG ?+"C(yG hF9]| B]sC ,AyG ?+|;S G ?dt+yG #| Q|O}yG uztyGh
!!9T!Qph GQAzG!Gh 9w*Q|C ?+=+zY .IOI9GyG
#+}zT}yG fC -~%p #| ?+t< 9%y B!9v fE- ?+"C(yG gP$ ~%qAzp :C
k
fC )zf ,IRfC G(W+g* fC )zf #+9 :h #9 : 9}+}Z@ G(}}Y Os ,HQgyGh
.e;Sh ?*QIh ?*GO$h uI {SQ 9%zv I9+JyG G(<(G*
fP{< (=M* #y jPyG {gW}yG GP$ ?+AqyG gO+< {}J* QY9"yG O=f d9= fE

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

170

9}*Eh IOs(A| ?}*Rf ~%zvh 9<hQhCh 9+SBh 9+t*QpC #| #+*;}yG &g|h ,uG
.u9< i(s
9%t*Q_ ,p rt@ #y uG f(g< d9= 9$O(t* ,AyG ?|Q9gyG I(tyG gP$ fE
)zf ~}Y jPyG uJyG I(s 98} 9%t*Q_ ,p rt* #| {v Q|OAS 98E ,OhOS
.QZA"* fC

{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f


?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= {+vh

171

? +fQW y

v13:11v

Og y

4 O
)1(

b9D

,q+qf

b G R Q yG

G v$1379

+ |h

?S9+Ty

? S QL 6 h <
"

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q 24

Oz G |

CO = |

O=f N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]qy

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG

V {v HQ uG fz< NSGQ f9}*E IO+tgy9p ,{}fh d(sh IO+tf e;S G


k
k
gOIh &y uI 9%fG(!C h+}G< IO9=gyG fCh ,GQk +<O@h 9wz|h GQk *Ot@h 9tzL &w+z|h
)"TJyG A9}S}G &!9J=S &zp ,{SQ| ,=! :h HQt| xz| 9%+p &vQW* :
.?J+JZyG ?"TyGh H9AwyG U(Z! 96 JA9F ,AyG 9+zgyG J9qZyGh
AGOAsG JA9F 9}v U(Z"yG gP$ Q}@ fC ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= iQ*
9%+zf dO@ ,AyG 9%+!9g}< 98hQTq+p 98hQs Q+Lh ?|}G gP$ rzT< 9%+p ~%"|
I;ZyG &+zf ,="yG f9Ty B!9vh fBQtyG dR! 96 ,AyG HQgyG ?jy ,p ?t+tI
:h {+ag@ :h r*Q; Q+i #| uG )yE 979+q+w< ~zgyG ^*(q@ h| e;TyGh
?*6
(W y p
o {+D}@ :h &+=W@
)zf )y9g@ &y JGP< f9}* G #| eRz* ~y 9}v gO9=g< uG &+=W@ xyP #| eRz* :h
.9%%"v ,p V(MyG #f rwyG h| ,?t+tJyG
&|;vh ~%Tq!z< ~%"| ~6 ~IQCh &tzL #| &Tq"< ~zfC uG f} xyPh
U(Z"yG OQG(A@ fC {+JAT+p ?jy9=yG ?}wJyG &!9J=S &yh .&"+<Ch e;v kz<C
IQ$9c ?t*Qa< &@9qYh uG A9}SC J9=CE )zf E*O9I}Gh J9*6G h<9AA@h
&+zf &y(SQ OZt* hC 9%"| uG OZt*h ?t+tI &+zf ByO 9| Q+i OGQ}yGh ?J\Gh
9| )zf ;+yO &|;v #| >Z"* fC Q+i #| ?*R9G| f9g| )yE e;TyGh I;ZyG
k
,QwqyG I(sh {tgyG #| gO9=f &fOhC 9| )zf GO9}AfG ?*R9G}yG )!9g}yG #| OGQC
I(sh &|;v ?I9Zph &A}IQ ?gSh )y9g@ &}zf d9}v h| uqA* : xyP f{p
A,

]11

G :iQ

G[

('&%$#

O|9I N+WyG I9ph Og< ?f9}GyG ?S9FQ )y(@ fC Og< -&yG &}IQ- N+WyG 9%=Av )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

172

&y(SQ &< ~%pQg*h &Tq"< ~%pQg* fC fhO uG ~%vQA* f}h ,&A}wI ky9<h &!9+<
VQ9g}yG O(Fh eOgy ,;+=S QT*Ch ~%y Q+L ,&+I(< e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf
Sh9Shh J:9+MyG :E ,$ 9|h #+$GQ<h ?yOC 9$(}fR ,AyG ?z_9=yG &=Wzy
k
.GQ+=v G(zf xyP #f uG )y9g@ ,#+_9+WyG
Q+i #| ?*R9G| f9g| )zf 9%yhz@ hC U(Z"yG gP$ #| 98k +V OJF #}p
uIh &@9qYh &F9}SCh uG J9*B ,p OJyC Otp &+zf 9%yhz@ 9| )yE OVQ* {+yO
h
g
f
e dco :&y(t< xyP ,p #*OJz}yG &< uG Of(@ 9| &+zf

"

! ~}| { z yo ?*6 BzZp pj i


.
? *6
Q f} p ! @
!v}u ( '&
% $ #
]40

]180

G :aG

G:

n q o

G[

Ok +v(@ J9qZyGh A9}S}G J9=CE ,p H9AwyG U(Z! #f ?"TyG JOGR Osh


Bzgp 9}v ,&g\G(| #f uG e;v aQJ* dhzA| {v d(s )zf B]tp 9!k 9+<h
.9%+=! ?g*QW< 9%=f;@h 96Q H9Awy 9%q*Q; ,p O(%+yG
9| 9%fG(!C h+}G< )y9g@ gOGQpEh u IO9=gyG U;LE 9]k *C ?J+JZyG IO+tgyG
&+yE ?<9!:Gh uG )zf {v(Ay9v 9%"| #a< 9|h HJyGh I9vRyGh I;Zy9v 9%"| Q%c
ahQg}y9< Q|}Gh ?C9jAS:Gh &A}t!h &<9tf #| a(MyGh &A}IQy A9FQyGh
,p {LO@ ,AyG b;L}Gh d9}f}Gh dG(s}G #| xyP Q+ih Qw"}yG #f ,%"yGh
{wy f9vh #*OyG ,p 9%yR9"| B@h9q@ fEh IO+tgyG {LO@ 9}v ,e;S G )}T|
.Q9C6G #| 9%g=A* 9|h O9=gyG #| 9%+zf rs(A* 9| >TI 9%Z< ?FQO 9%"|
9%ay9M* :h ?"TyGh H9AwyG #| O}AT@ ,AyG ?Zy9MyG ?}+zTyG IO+tgyG fE
)yE 96 u fGO #| Eg=Ay J9pGQMyGh YO=yG fG(yCh cQWyG >FG(V #| A,V
,p 9+k y9D| ;FQ &"| {g:h ?+|9TyG HGO6Gh ?z\9qyG b;L}Gh Ky9ZyG {}gyG
H9AwyG IO9F )zf f9v {}f fEh O*OS &y(tp d9s fEh dOf ~wI fE I9+JyG
e;S G S9"zy MQW* gQ%d}p .IQ+S Q+L &"| GhOFh S9"yG QV9f fEh ?"TyGh
&@O+tf B!9v hC &"+t* rg\ #|h ,&tzLh &z}fh &y(t< 9+z}f GQk +Tq@ gQTq*h
G

173

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

OAf:Gh QhQjyG &+zf >zi hC J9pGQMyGh YO=yG #| Q+Dv 969V Os ?y(LO|


c(wWyG &+zf By(ASGh &=WyG &+zf Bj_ hC A9}TyG )Ih ry9L fEh &*CQ<
.{+=TyG AG(S #f {\h u*QayG J9+"< ,p PLCh OGh {v ,p HQ\ e9$h}Gh
,p e;wyG #| fhQDw* ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= OG! xyP {FC #|
,p ~7(SC ,I(SC Q+L xyP ,p ~%yh ~%A<9Avh ~%=aLh ~%ShQO O+I(AyG
uG A9+=!C gQZ!h &+I(< uG #| fhO*|}yG M;Y G IO9sh iO%yG ?}FC xyP
.e;TyGh I;ZyG ~%+zf &zSQh
~ZAg@ fC 9%Tq! )zf JPLC Os ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fEh GP$
9%"+fC >Z! Ky9ZyG rzTyG IQ+S {g:h | &y(SQ iO6 iOA7h uG H9Aw<
k
AGQB #| ;*O< &< )\Q@ :h 98+V xyP )zf QC|@ : ;}fh :(sh IO+tf
|{ z y o :,y9g@ &y(t< ;}f ,?qFGRyG ~%FG($Ch ,?y9]yG d9FQyG
J9*6G #| g9"g| ,p 9|h p)( '
&% $ # " ! ~}
#f ,%"yGh ,ahQg}y9< Q|}G #| &< uG 9%|RyC 9| B|RAyGh ,E*O9I}Gh
?f9}GyG ?S9FQ< )yE JO%fh ,Q=Zy9< )YG(AyGh ,uJy9< )YG(AyGh ,Qw"}yG
)tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG ?z+]p ,u<9TyG 9%T+FQh ,QZ}< 9%TS|| I9ph Og<
Q+L O+I(AyG QW!h ,#*OyG )yE I(fOyG #f gGRFh ,?gSGh ?}IQ
iO$ )zf ?f9}Gy9< Q+SCh >FG(yG GP6 e(sC fC )zf 9|GRy f9wp ,AGRGyG
QW! ,p uG I9\Q| A9jA<G ;e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf &y(SQ ?"Sh ,uG H9Av
k
.uJyG IQZ! ,p fh9gAyG CO=}y 9t+t;h ,&"*O
k
k
,OVQyG 9"}%z* fCh ,GOVQ 9!Q|C #| 9g+= 9"y r9 fC uG G(FQCh
.~+dgyG )zgyG u9< :E I(s :h d(I : &!{p ,{}gyGh d(tyG ,p HG(ZyGh
OG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

174

>F

Og y

Oz G } y
?zG}yG )p A9F ?f9}Gzy )q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+WyG ?S9FQ O%f )p
)1(
: )@6G
:($ .~+tAT| ~%V ~*Qv #_G(}< bQWyG )zf uG #|h
Q 7 O

G v$1379

?S
"

24

QY9"yG O=f d9}F

Np9!h ,Q9}gAS:G ~aJ|h ,O+=gyG QQJ|h ,?<hQgyG {a<h ,IQ(DyG )Ap


Os9fh ,~y9gyG Y(<Q ,p e;TyG QW! )zf Of9T}yGh ,QFGRGyG ,p IQ(DyG MhQ
)H!hO!9<( ,p f9T! G b(tI QQt|h ,,}zTyG X*9gAyG {FC #| JGQ}@|}yG
{v #| Q9}gAS:G KS9|h ),!(*Q<( Q}@|| ,p QW=yG ?|GQv )zf ep9J}yGh
,>TJp ~y9c xz| OQay &@Q(D< ~t* ~y .Ky9ZyG #_G(}yG GP$- Qh9G| Oz<
k
I9G"yG r_9V )yE HQgy9< {Z* )AI &+p Q+T* ;*(_ 9F9%"| {}I {<
.A9LQyGh IA9"%yGh ~zTyGh OiQyG #|R )yE bQWy9<h
IOI(yG J9|(t|

~A@: IOI(yG f{p #+A| S9SC )zf Rw@Q* fC #| &y O<: A,WyG f9v GPEh
S9"yG Ky9Zy HF9A"yG f(wAy ?J+JY J9|Ot| 9%t=T@h ?z+YC J9|(t}< :E
o q nn
f9}*E .IOI(yG J9|(t|h .9%zFC #| M9qwyG f(]@Q*h MQqy9< QW=yG 9%qtzA*h
)v9V RqJA| X+Fh ,et* u*Qf >gVh ,?}+wI IO9+sh u9< bO9Y
.A9+phC fGQ+Fh ,M;TyG
:(yh .d9= I(LE Q*h9j}yG d9a<}G A:|$ O"f Qp(A| (%p u9< f9}* G 9|C
f9vh yQZ!z ?}zwyG #| QqZyG ?f9S (+y(* QGp ,p uG ~$QZ! 9| f9}* G
.R*RgyG QZ"yG
#| #+AZMz| #+Ay9t| iOIE )$h )9D*OIh 9}k *Os IOI(yG( fG("g< IQ(W"}yG ?y9t}yG ?*98
.
)tqyG N+WyG e;v

)1(

175

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q| >gWyG h| G(sGP IO9tyG A:|$ fC aQg* {wy9p ?}+wJyG IO9+tyG 9|Ch


#| ?"+< )zf G(!9v ~%+yE Q|}G dB 9}yh ,&< UJ* f9v 9}< G(Tw ICh ~zdyG
o v
fC {+JAT}yG #|h A,V {v ~%g| G(TT;h #+"_G(}yG h| G(G|O!9p ,Q|}G
x
:h &"f rqM* ;p i(Aw* gQ+i iQ*h ~wJyG )@|*o ~C Q9"y9< f9T!E i(Aw*
o ro
.&qZp "*
)<QgyG >gWyG fC OG! N*Q9AyG J9JqY >+ztA=p .u*QgyG >gWyG 9|Ch
dPCh .GQAzG!G xz| OS}G >zs OQ9WA*Q eR$h d(j}yG OYh Q9AAyG )j< ~aI
IQPtyG ?y9DJyGh ,9+yGQASG #| ?sR@Q}yGh ,&++y(|h fO*Eh f(+z<9!h U*(y
.#++!(%ZyG
k
,p GOgAT| ?zgFh ?JzS}G KOIz< y?<hQgyG d9=z gOhR Otp X+GyG 9|C
)yEh ,9]k *C IQ9GAzy ?*QJ=yGh ?*(GyG {+_9S}G 9"yh (GyG ,ph QJ=yG )ph Q=yG
9*- Q=Ag* x|;vh )|;wp X+GyG #f 98k +V d(sC fC h+aASC : OJyG GP$
k
-QG(GyG 9|C- gD9WpE KZ* : iQwTf QS GP$ f} #+}MAyG #| 9<Q\ -,"<
.d;%yG ?*DQ ,p 96 iOAt!h e9f {v 9%+yE Qp9T!h e(* {v ?w| )yE &GA! 9"!{p
o
eOh ,IQ9]Ih ?p9tCh ?jyh I9+Jzy A9| #| b<GhQyG eQvC fGO(Ty9< 9"a<Q@h
o
.#+|9+}yG QjyG .fGQ+GyG 9"!G(LE )s9<h .f9"=yh 9+=+y #f xyP {sh .#*Oh
9%"f xCOI} ?z+zyG gP$ IQ\9J| ,qw@ ;p .,"< 9* ?=+=JyG 9*Q(S 9|C
)@z+Tp #+aTzp 9|Ch .QG(GyG #TIh Hh9GAyGh {="y9< &zv ~y9gyG O%W*h
&y9s 9| d(t@ fC xyh )y KZ* xyP Og<h .HQgyG 9%z$} 9$OQAT! jPyG e(+yG
.d9= N}G
..,LC 9* xSCQ hpQG
MhQ 9"gVCh ,?yhOyG 9"}d!h Q}gAT}yG 9!OQ_h ,~wJyG O(}f 9"+SQC Otp
?<9JZyG #| Ky9ZyG rzTyG IQ+S )J! fC f6G 9"+zfh ,A9L Gh ,?yGOgyG
IQG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

176

9=gyG fC .uG cOVQC )"< 9* ~zfGh IOI(yGh O+I(AyG G(pQf #*PyG A9*(s}G
ro
O9gSE #f &zjW@ hC #_(yG (J! &=FGh f9T! G )Tp "@ A;%GyG ~%q* 9}v BT+y
n n r
IO9=gyG #| gR(JyG ?*9}Ih .#_(yG V9+I #f OOQAyGh O9%GyG {< gOz<
#|z | d(SQyG d(s IOI(zy &+gS ,p &+zf u=a"* d9= 9"=+=Ih .?\hQq}yG
y..96 {}f #| QFCh .9$QFC &y f9v .uG &Fh 96 )j=* ?"TI &"S #S
K+\(@h .#|RyG KOG(I )zf IO+tgyG Q+Tq@h {}gyG )zf ~zgyG u+=a@ GP$h
.O9=gyG Ky9Zy e9wI}G ?=Q@h ~|}G L9%"| )zf #*OyG
IO

e9AMyG

?}zv

QWzy xyh .,y uG {+a* fC -,"< 9*- (FQC 9!Ch .N+WyG d9s ~C
9g 9 @OIh ~AAyh gO9%F ~A+y QY9"yG O=f d9= )<QgyG H9WyG GP$ Q}f
H(gV #| 9"!G(LEh .B!Ch 9!C {< .xyP #f :(8T| gOIh d9= U+yh
S9"yG ,p QW"! fC O<:h .M9qwyGh )gTy9< f(=y9a| .{}gy9< f(qzw| HQgyG
.&A|9$ r_za* :h .&A|9s f9T!E )"J* ;p y...,LC 9* xSCQ hpQGz CO=|
O=f d9= ($ ~%"| OIGh {v )<Qf #_G(| f(+z| )AF9| bQWyG ,p OG"y
.&A|C O9gSE )zf 9YQIh .&A+"_h bOYh &A|9%Vh &@Q+i ,p .QY9"yG
O}J| N+WyG e9| G gP9ASG d(ty yQ(aTyG gP$ >@9vz )AqyG f5}_Gh
#| 9+ICh .{}f #| eOs 9}< .ShOQqyG ?"F &zLO*h . j )tqyG O|9I
v n
.IQqj}yG {$Ch i(tAyG {$C &!E .Q+L #| YQRh &|C #| QZ<h &"S
.b
h
k
. += "

jh

9|Q=yG O}J| O(}J|

QZ| GQ=W< eQw| Q}f ?SQO}< SQO|

177

? +fQW y

11 v

"

QY9 yG O=f

5 O

Og y

d9}F

)yE

G 26

?S9+Ty

Oz G |

Gh

?+}v9Jy

1381

? Ty
"

O}J| #++="yG ~@9L )zf I;TyGh I;ZyGh ,#+}y9gyG HQ u O}JyG


.#+}y9gzy ?}IQ uG &zSQC jPyG
,,Og<h
k
k
,>JyG (}S #f ;|9v 9sO9Y GQk +=g@ x!9+< #| ?}zv {v B!9v Otp
9| RfC x!9+< ,p f9v .MQGyG A9*Q=vh ,AGOqyG d;Fh ,?+J]AyG ?fhQh
9|h ,{Do |o #| ?+!9T! G &+yE G(q7 9| {=!Ch ,N*Q9@ #| HQgyG &+zf UQJ*
.~+s #| IO9+tyG ?}wI &tt; 9|h ,uzL #| &< R9A}@
A9qY #| I(L~y 9| {=Ch ,?}wIh f9"I #| I(<~y 9| {FC &+p f9v
IO+VQyG ?|9fRyG &< rZA@ 9| ~dfCh ,~*Qv Q< #| I("=zy 9| )}SCh ,?}IQh
.?|}G ?|OL ,p f9q@ #|
&@GQ=! ,p f9v Otp ,x@(Y h}T! #J!h Y(|Oy9< 9"<(zs BV9F Oty
I(<}G b9qVEh ,?|GQwyG ?+J*QCh ,IRgyG ?I9}Sh ,I(tyG d9=h ,~y}G d;F
.A9"<}G #| OQ}A}yG Q+Z| )zf ?}+dgyG
aPt@h ,?!9+MyG Q9vhC I(tyG I(Tt< Q|OAS x!C fhOtAg* fhQ+DwyG f9v
.>FGQMyG e(< ~}Jy9<
b(p f(w@ fC :E ?|}G gP6 ~+dgyG cQ<h ,?+|9TyG xA+!9T!E B<C #wyh
,Uq"yG b=\h ?}wJzy 9+zgyG {D}yG ut; fC :Eh ,f("dyG BSOI 9|
.JGPyG fGQw!h
?+<Qf eO gQas {v JQLOG x"wyh ,Q|O@h {At@ fC cQhOt| ,p f9v
9"@OIh ut;h 9!hOf )zf ~df}G QZ"yGh Q=v}G d9]"yG e(* O(f(}yG e(+zy
.| #++="yG ~@9L O}J| )<QgyG ,="yG &+yE 9fO jPyG uJyG ?*GQ B; iQ=wyG
|

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

178

>+=JyG N}G x!z<h ~+dgyG ~+fRyG x!z< - ~zwA@ B!Ch- 9!QgV 9|


HQgyG >Jy {+zF OTGA| u+t; x!z< GP$ h| 9!QgV 9}!Eh - >TJp
.IRgyGh OG}yG ,p HGPgyG ~%|;ICh ~%y9|Bh
)yE - e;S Gh ?<hQgyG A9"<C #J! - 9"gpO* a(S KOI 9| fz< uD"y 9"!Eh
f9}* 9< 9"<(zs rzA}@ fC )yEh ,9"@9*9ih 9"zD| )zf #+A}yG i(tyG X9qJyG
o :&!9J=S uG 9%\Qp ,AyG ?z|9WyG ?z+zGyG IOI(y9<
-

onml
9 zf

. "+

&\Qp Q|C ,p

< Qq! #yh ,9"y GhkOf fO98 #yh


o 9gk += f(zSQ}yG &+yE 9fO 9}< (fO!h ,jO9"! {d"Sh

KJIH
uG

qp

uG fP{ - W

.p

?IGOp #| b9qV G {v uqW@ 9gk += HQgyG H(zs fz< xIQ9Z"y 9"!Eh


e:B >Jy9< {}J* jPyG >+IQyG Q+=wyG x=zs #|h ,>aMyG I(Tsh ,A>gyG
fC bOZyGh U;L 9< X+: H(zt< uG )yE YQ]! GP%yh .~8GRICh HQgyG
IOIh x*O* )zf utJ* fCh ,c~w* fCh ,&!(fh gQZ"< d9= 9* uG cO}*
&!G(\Qh uG ?f9_ ,p IO*O}yG I9+JyG xy >9 fCh ,#+}zT}yGh HQgyG
.&z+=S ,p O9%GyGh
.>+G| h+}S - &!zV {F &!E
{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f
?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG

179

? +fQW y

1382
)1(

b9D

? S Qq Y
"

2 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 27

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

+}yG

QJ}yG #| 12 ,p 9$QGO< ?f9}GyG U+FQ 9$9tyC ,AyG ?g}GyG ?=aL ,p


b9D+}yGh )=gWyG b9D+}yG #f KO; )1962 ?"S ?+!(* #| 15( 1382 ?"S
Y9aASG Osh ,?=aMyG gP%y ?+pGh ?Y;L QW"< fG(L G >y9_ Osh ,,%y G
q o
,9%zGT* fCh ,9%z:QG ,AyG ?=aMyG ,p &y9s 9| {F QvPA* fC ?f9}GyG U+FQ
A9"DyGh O}JyG Og< d9s Osh .fG(L G VQj< ,q@ ?Y;MyG gP$ {gyh
:I;ZyGh
:d(t* &!9J=S uG f{p yOg< 9|Cz
e

x w v u t s r q p o n mo
.p# " ! ~ } | { z y

;v G(pQv I ~%"wyh .H9AwyG {$C &< uCGh jPyG uG b9D+| ($ GP$


.UM< #}C A9jA<G g(yO<h
n
o n
!>$GP rFGR f9azSh !QhQo i >tyh !QhOi 9+!O
G(zIC !&zyG H9Av {J| g(zICh yO(}zAyGz G(fOA<Gh ,IGQ(AyG O(%+yG aQI
.IQp9wyG ~$AGQBh ,IQF9GyG ~$AG($Ch ,O(tJyG ~7GhR!h fhOyG ~7G(%V
iO%yG f9w| .e;dyGh OtJyGh ?+$GQwyGh QWyGh {_9=yGh ?y;]yG G(zIC
.e;TyGh Q("yGh >JyGh Q+MyGh uJyGh
uG e

y9s 9D+}yG QOYC 9}y QY9"yG O=f d9= GhQqv #*PyG #+<h ?+qzTyG N(+V rs(| #+< fQ9s )1(
k
.?"TyGh fBQtzy ;*O< f(w+y gQOYC &!E
f(w* )wy )j="* 9}< &g\Gh >y9_h uI #| &+p 9| #+< b9D+}zy N+WyG VQf 9}"+I 9"%p
k
k
&zyG b9D+| #+=* &zgF iPyG >=TyG ($ GP$h 9"+zf &zyG gPLC iPyG b9D+}zy 9tpG(| 9s9D+|
.9"$ 9$QZALG )AyG &A=aL dhC )p )y9g@
G( h b

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

180

9Av G(pQIh ,O(%+yG #f 9$(CQh ,AyG ~$O9tIz< f(+=+zZyG A9Fh


A9Fh | O}J| ~%}@9Lh {SQyG Q+M< QF9W=yGh O+I(AyG ~y9g| G(T}a+y
.| O}J|
.{+=TyG AG(S )yE iO9%yG Q("yG A9F .#++="yG ~dfCh {SQyG ~@9L A9F
9%zD| ,p ?y9SQzyh ,~df}G 9$(}S ,p ?+!9T!5y ?M|9WyG ?}tyG A9F
Osh .?y;\ &*O6 9%=*Q@o :h .?|C gOg< k*R@ : jPyG f9sQqy9< A9F .,zf}G
.~%+yE dR! 9| S9"zy #+=! fC b9D+}yG uG #| 9"+zf PLC
9""+g* fCh ,f9+=yG #TI 9"*O9 fC uG )yE YQ]! - ?"TyG Q9Z!C - #J!h
.Q(! #| ?J}y )zf GQk AS dOT! :h ,Q+=f #| ?Jq! >GJ! ;p ,Z;=yG )zf
9%za< ?|}G )yE &|Os jPyG b9D+}yG #f ?+\9}yG ?=aMyG ,p ~v9"COI Otyh
.99CQ &+p iQAy 9%}+fRh
b9D+}< b=@Q* fC >G* )=gWyG b9D+}yG fE ?t<9TyG ?=aMyG ,p 9"zs Otyh
,9$9+!Oh 97QLB uG b9D+}y {g: fC )zf 9%DJ*h ?|}G &F(* fCh ,uG
.9$:hCh 9$GQLBh
i(tyG uy9L b9D+}< W9=@Q:9v U+y QW=yG e9|C b9D+}< W9=@Q:G f{p
.QOtyGh
,OTGyGh MhQyG )t"*h ,Q$9dyGh #_9=yG )+J* uG b9D+}< W9=@Q:G fE
.?+!;fh GQk S uG f(M* fC #+<h AQ}yG #+< d(J*h
: jPyG Q+Z=yG h+}TyG Q+=MyG ~+wJyG Q*OtyG i(tyG &yR! Os uG b9D+|h
.A9}TyG ,p :h VQ}G ,p ?+p9L &+zf ,q<
)yE ?|}G gP$ )\9| O9tp .A9g= ?*QW=yG O9gS h 9gk += QW=yG ?*GO%y &yR!
.b9p6G ~dfCh GQPyG )}SC b(p 96 uzIh ,O9G|}G YhQC
uG H

181

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9 y &< KzY 9}< :E ?|}G gP$ QLB KzZ* #yh


.>+"| O=f {wy iQvPh IQZ=@ ,%y G b9D+}yG ,p A9F 9| ^g< VQg"yh
>
=< ;:98 7 6 {:&!9J=S 9"<Q d(t*
a ` _
o :d(t*h .} D C
BA@?
. % hC

]256

gfe

?*6G :IQn t=n yG[ p


n

dc b

Q+%a@ .Q+}g@h Q+%a@h .O+I(Ay9< ?+z;h cQWyG #| ?+z< :?+z;h ?+z<


x+zf uG b9D+| VQq* GPw$h .f9}* G ?SGOt< Q+}g@h ,?+"C(yG U!O #|
.x%Fh uG )yE ~zTAy ,?=F9V {v #| :hC xTq! Q+%a@
QZ=yGh h}TyGh ?q_9gyGh Q(gWyGh >ztyGh ,QwqyGh {tgyG e;SE VQq*
?*(s IOIh e;S 9< f(wAy ,x"_9< e;SEh ,cQ$9c e;SE .f9TzyGh
.&*O=@ 9| h| &+q< 9|h 9%A+!;f h| 9$QS Hh9GA*
:&y(s ,p gO+I(@ ?t+tI uG b9D+| xy #+=*h ,&A+<(<Q ,p gO+I(@ x+zf VQq*

"

!6 54 3
$ A @ ?>

= < ;: 9 8 7

,p &!} :#F9v {v &+yE O}Z* jPyG O}ZyG }


?O*Q* 9}yh A9W* 9}y A,V {v QMT}yG xy9}yG uy9MyG ($ U+yC ,&+yE ?F9I
gQLO+y ,gO"f 9| Q+M< {M=* hC ,9<Q : 9<(<Q| f(w+p .Oyh #| u 9|h
5 4o :hC : GQk LB f(w*h ,9<Q : 9*(<Q| f(w+p OyGh #| u 9|h ,&"<:
.

,p

uG b

9D+| Q<O@h ,&A+$(yC ,p gO+I(@ x+zf

]3

?*6G :O*OJn yG[

p6

Qq* u9< x!9}*Eh

} |{ zy xw v u ts r
q
o :&y(s
R Q P!@
!v O
NM
o :,y9g@ &y(s Q<O@h p#
"! ~
.p!@
!w S

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

182

Ok }J| {gG! fC uG b9D+| 9"+zf VQq* :&zyG b9D+| #| ?+!9DyG IOf9tyG


9"k *O ~7O9=f ,p S9"yG f(w+y ,IhOtyGh I(S}G gOIh ($ {SQyG ~@9L
T S R Q P Oo IOIGh ?|Ch ,IOIGh ?*9ih ,GOk IGh 9=k zsh ,GOk IGh
G

]21

?*6G

:HG

Rn I}G[ p

VU

OtAg! >Av #| uG dR! 9| {w<h ,uG {SQ {w< f9}* G P$ h=A*h


uG >z_ 9| {w< f9}* Gh .&+p 9}< :E {}g! ;p .9%+zf #}+%}yG ($ fBQtyG
o &< #||! fC &y(SQ f9Ty )zf
fC

]\[ZYXWV
kjihgfedcba`_^
p@
! !w}z p o n m l
.

]285

?*6G :IQn t=n yG[

:h ?*O(9 uG dR! 9}p .e;S G #*O ($ &!E .OIGh 9gk += {SQyG #*Op
#*QW=| {SQyG gOg< #| >s9g@h M(! )zf e;S G dR! #wyh ,?+!GQZ!
.| O}J}< G(}AL )AI #*QP"|h gOIh e;S 9<
{SQ ~@9L O}J|h ,e;S G d(SQ )T+fh ,e;S G d(SQ )S(}p
k
.~%+zf &|;Sh uG JG(zY 9g+= e;S G
feo :&zyG d(s GhQ<O@ .IOIGh ?|C 9gk += #J! :?Dy9DyG IOf9tyG
HQ< #*O@ ?|C 98E .
?*6 ("||}y p!@
!zw l k j ih
g
9%yPAT* :h gG(S #| ?+WL 9%=$Q@ ;p ,OIGh HQ i(tA< ~ZAg@h .OIGh
.gQ+i #| a(L
k
d(s GhQ<O@ .uG )yE ~$Qtp ,p ?+SG(S 9g+= S9"yG :?g<GQyG IOf9tyG
.}
w v ut
sr
q p o n { :&zyG
h}AG| A9"< 9%+zf e(t* ,AyG IOf9tyG ,$ ?|9gyG I(L}G :?T|9MyG IOf9tyG
Q<O@h ?*6 QGJy p\ [ Z
o :&zyG d(s Q<O@h .?|}G gP$
:h ,&yPM* :h ,&}zd* : ~zT}yG (LC ~zT}yGz :| uG d(SQ d(s
]52

]10

G :JG

G[

G :f

G[

183

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QWyG #| Q|G >TJ< )JGQ| K;C gQOY )yE GQk +W|( 9"$9$ i(tAyG .gQtJ*
&\Qfh &|O .eGQI ~zT}yG )zf ~zT}yG {v .~zT}yG g9LC QtJ* fC
..y&y9|h
{sz< utJA* fh9gAy9p .>TJp ?+vGQAVG :h .>TJp ?+!h9g@ BT+y 98E
9| {w< :E utJA@ ;p I(L}G 9|C .?+vGQAV:G xyPvh &A}zwy f(w* e(%q|
98E .Q9D* Gh IOG"yGh ,IGh9T}yGh ?}IQyGh Q=yG &+zf dO@ 9}|h .&+zf dO@
.Q9Z!}Gh #*QF9%}yG )zf 9$9"g| d(SQyG u=_ ,AyG I(L}G
fC )zf {}gyG >G+p ,9%F9"< #| J9"=y ?|}G gP$ A9qg\ :?SO9TyG IOf9tyG
.Q+MyG {}f ,p hS(AyG ($ Q=yGh ,A:|6 Q=yG >G* iC .?*(s J9"=y f(w@
qp o n m l k
j i
Wo :&zyG d(s GQk <OA| CQsC

~ }| { z y x w v ut
sr
*) ( ' & % $ # "
!
6 5 4 3
2 10
/ .
- ,+
.
?*6 Qt=y p!@
!v|| = <; : 9 8 7
]177

G :I

n n n

G[

=I )zf d9}yG A9A*E eOs &!E {< ,>TJp I9vRyG A9A*E >za* : uG fE
?*9fOzy ~d! {v #| )}SCh Q+L ,%y G b9D+}yG Q< fC ,p >*Q :h
.9$OQ(AT! ?+f9}AF:G
G(FQM* fC ~%+zf QOs e(zd| u*Qp A:|$h :A9atzyG ,p e;S G iO$
< { ?A:|%y uG b9D+| {gp GP9}p ,~$A9<B G(pQg* fC fhO I9+JyG )yE
.&

)1(

HG
FE D C
BA@
?> =

#| ?=$Q ~6(zs rzA}Ap .rF;}yG A:|$ YO(! 9"!E .~vD9qzIh ~vDGQZ! iC


9}k *Q; eQJ* e;S

G fC G

Ok +F eJz@ xzgyh 9"*Oy #+phQg| A:|$ A9<B f9v GPE 9gk =_ GP$ )1(
k
.gP$ 9"|9*C )p ahQg}yG )"=AyG GP$ 9g_9s

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

184

Qq+p e;S G 9|C .&+zf GOk tIh h}AG}yG


:&zyG ,p ?z|9wyG I(L}G S9SC
~w!G(LEz ~%"f | O}J| e;S G {SQ ~@9L d(s Q<OA"y ?eOMyGh
,{vz* 9}| &}ga+zp ,gO* B; g(LC f9v #}p ,~w*O*C B; uG ~%zgF
.y&"+g+zp &=zj* 9| &qzv f{p &=zj* 9| &qzw* :h .U=z* 9}| &T=z+yh
,{D| #| QW=yG IQ9]I &< JA9F 9| hpQC ~df}G up}G GP$ aQ9W* #y
.?+!9T!Eh Q< #| &< QMq@ 9| )}SCh ,~+s #| BfQALG 9| )vRCh
4 o :?g<9TyG IOf9tyG
fE
?*6 ?<(Ay p87 6 5
.,yh #||}yG &+L} ($ #||| {vh .&+yh ?"||}yG ?f9}Gy9p ,&y )yh : #|
#| &y OG+S &!{p 9}f hC :9L hC .9LC hC .9|C hC 9<C &y OG* : #| fE
.J:9MyGh dG(L}Gh JG(L}Gh I(L}Gh J9%|}Gh A9<6G ?}zT}yG ?f9}GyG
.J9}gyGh e9}f}Gh
:&g|O rwqw*h ,&IQF )SG(*h .&zv &"f {}J+S {v
.?T<9gyG &|9*C ,p ?<PgyG I(zJyG ?}T=yG h+W+S {v
.?TF9=yG IOQ9=yG &@;+y ,p {|}Gh AaOyGh Q("yGh
9 87 6 5
4 o :,y9g@ uG d(s Q<O@
)zf &g}AG| ,p ~%G|O!

]71

G:

C
B

n q

fC V

G[

> =

JI

= <; :
9$O+t* : ?tza| ?|9f ?*:(yGh pz y xw G
F ED

Ok +s &< ~g!Ch f9}* G bOY i(S


)yhC 9!Cz :| d(SQyG d(s ,p ?*:(yG gP$ [F9ZL ^g< Q<OA"yh
,q y{p 9f9+\h 9"k *O cQ@ #|h ,&z$~p :9| cQ@ #| ~%Tq!C #| #+"||}y9<
vn
o r v
O:h}Gh .#*OyG y9"+y{p ;v cQ@ #|h ,&ACQ(zp :9| cQ@ #|z :&y(sh y,q zfh
.G

185

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{v G(z}J* fC 9%}v9Ih ?|}G )zf VQq* e;S G fE yf(gF9]yG {$}Gh


.J9| jPyG ~%+LC #f ?}+IQyG ?*:(yGh Q=y9< xyP
uG b9D+| Q< #| (!O* 9| )f9}GyGh )f9}AF:G f9}]yG u+CG(| ,p {%p
?&A}IQh gQ< ,p
?QOyG 9!O"fh .aOZyG OQ(AT! GP9}y
?d;JyG 9!O"fh ,eGQJyG OQ(AT! GP9}y
k
?GO<C Q(=@ : ,AyG f9}* G ?f9]< 9!O"fh QqwyG ?f9]< OQ(AT! GP9}y
fC 9"+zf VQq* ,%y G b9D+}yG fE ,#+}zT}yG Q+j< 9"AzY ?"|9DyG IOf9tyG
e;S G &Fh ,p f(gpQ* : G(|GO9| ~%Az|9g| ,p bTt! fCh #+}zT}yG Q+i Q=!
NM L K { GhkOf &+zf f("+g* :h ,GOk +v &y fhQ<O* :h ,9qk +S
.}

U T

SR

PO

W+g* fC 9}$Q+jyh )!GQZ"zyh ,jO(%+zy K+=* &!C #*O #| GQk < x=TIh
k
)WM! r+wp 9t$Q :h 9}k zc ~$OIC a9M* : ,#+"8}a| #+fOGh &A|C {c ,p
?>ZgAy9< ~%A@ fC
>y9a! #+I >ZgAy9< uJyGh Q+MyG )zf f(_9TyG I9j=yG 9"+|Q* r+v hC
?fBQtyG #| 9""+!G(sh 9"t+CG(|h 9"*O$ O}AT! fz<
?=F9ZyG IQd"yG d9}yG )yE Qd"! fC 9"+zf VQq* e;S Gh :?gS9AyG IOf9tyG
eQI GP%yh .uG d9| ($ 9}!E d9| {v fz< #||! fC 9"+zf VQq* .?J+JZyG
b9q!E >FhCh ,xyP Q+ih ,Q*P=AyGh ,aGQS Gh >ZjyGh ,?sQTyGh ,9<QyG
}&
% $ # " ! { &!9J=S uG d(s Q<O@h .(qgyG
G(

_^ ]
\[Z Y X W V U {
#| )yE &ag@ ~y GPEh ,O(JF O("v B!zp uG d9}< BzM< fE } `

?"gy x+zf BtI &@R"v fEh O(JGyG QF9F [y B!zp .&<Q )yE hC &tJAT*

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

186

9=f #f &g"}@h ,uG d9| bQT@ x!} ,uG


B Ao :&zyG d(s Q<O@ .9%JzZ* #}y VQ}G :IQV9gyG IOf9tyG
.gO

?*6G :A9+n =!}G[ p!@


! vu z

LK

J
I HG
F
E
D C

BA=!zp ,QZ+sh iQTv VQC uG 9%CQh ?Jy9Y ?|}G gP$ B!9v fC e(*h
.H+6 LhR {v #|
6 5 43
o 9"<Q d(t* :AGRGyGh ?+y(8T}yG :IQWf ?*O9JyG IOf9tyG
]105

]7

?*6G :?yRn yRq yG[ p

~}| {

]164

?*6G

:e

9gn !}G[ p

PL|* fC eQJ*h IQV9=| 9%zgG*h ,?+y(8T}yG OOJ* .uG b9D+| ($ GP$


cQA* : ($ ~C ,?f9qWy ?*9fQ eQG}yG #f rqM* hC ,eQG}yG >!P< Q=yG
k
.GO<C AGRF fhO< ;}f
:&zyG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG >G* :IQWf ?+!9DyG IOf9tyG
p
o &<9Av ,p 9"<Q d(t*

@?>=<;:98

]44

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[

y t< iQLC IQ|h }N ML{ :&y(t< IQ| B}AL Osh


gP$ #+< h}G* &!{p ,uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #}p }8 76
{
.&!9J=S d(t*h .~zdyGh uTqyGh QqwyG ,?T+TMyG ?!(gz}yG ?}+|PyG J9qZyG
:& (

r
q p o n m l kj

ih
g
f e{
i i h g f e d c b a `{ 9]*C d(t*h :} s
.}+ *
)( '
& % $ # " { }m l k

|{z

y9g@ d(t* ,jQ(WyG e;S G ~wI S9SCh


)|;S G ~v9JyG ,p WQAW* :h }EDC { :&zSQ ~@9My d(t*h
k
k
f9v fEh &y(SQ ?"Sh &<Q H9Aw< 9}+zf f9}* G bO9Y 9+t@ 9"||| f(w* fC :E
O=f ~w+zf Q|C fEh ,G(g+_Ch ,G(g}SCz | d(SQyG d(t* ,9+k W=I GOk =f
}

{ :,

187

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?=+<R &SCQ fzv )W=I


)y(| ~y9S f9v (yz :?p;MyG #f Q]AJ* ($h d9s GQk }f fC x=TIh
k
.yjQ(V 9%AzgF 9| 9+I ?q*PI
??}wJyGh Q+MyGh uJyG gOIh ($ uG &yR!C 9| fC ,p ~zT| H9@Q*C iQ@
k
e;S G )"< r+v #+<zp .;+Zq@ ,%y G b9D+}yG OfG(ty OhC B"v Otyh
9%"wyh .xyP Q+ih {}gyG )yE Qd! r+vh ,?y(qayG {|9f r+vh IQS}G
uG )zYh e;S G iO$ #| ?SOt| IQ9CC )yE IQ9V G 9"=TIh ,?g= ?=aL
.#+g=C O}J| dBh O}J| )zf cQ9<h ~zSh
.y

+!9DyG

?=aMyG

>+aMyG d9s d(SQyG )zf I;ZyGh A9"DyGh O}JyG Og<


9"zsh .,=gWyG b9D+}yG ,p 9"*CQ ^g< ?"TyG Q9Z!C #J! 9"zs Otp yOg< 9|Cz
KyG(Y aO%ASGh ,#*OyG MhQ OG|h ,Q+MyG #| Q+Dv )zf i(AIG &!E
#*O fC )zf b9D+}yG ,p ["* fC (FQ! 9"yR9| 9"!C Q+i ,&Jy9Z|h >gWyG
9"@9+I ?|9sEh ,&"| 9""+!G(s OGO}ASG H(Fh )zfh ,e;S G ($ ?*Q(%}GyG
fC u G dzS} ,!Eh .&TSC )zf ?*O9ZAs:Gh ?+S9+TyGh ?+f9}AF:Gh ?+"*OyG
9%\9L ?vQg| {v ,p QZA!G Otp ,gQ9ZA!G IO9gT< ,d9= ?|}G gP$ {a< hA}*
&!G(LE g(FQ* 9}< gQ9ZA!G L(A* fC uG #| (FQCh ,fGhOgyGh )j=yG O\
.f(}zT}yG
9"v jPyG IQTJyGh rg]yGh ?<5wyGh ?yPy9< Q(gWyG xyP )T"! : 9"$ 9"!E
?aJ| d(I hC ,?gztyG d(I e(J! hC ,{+"yG QZs QTF Q=g! #+I &< U=zA!
iRMy9< QgW"p ,~%AJzSCh ~%As9}Ih ~%A$9qT< R+zG! G iQ!h ,IQ$9tyG
?O}J| Y9=@C Q9*O >+zZyG Y9=@C {AJ* r+v :d(t!h ,Q9gyGh
OQ9WA*Q A9"<C dPAT* r+vh ,Q}f O9qIC ,{sQ$ O9qIC Q}gAT* r+vh
:

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

188

Oy ;Y A9"<C
&t+p(A< ~C ,uG {]q< GP$ .QCC #| QZ| ,p ~%y iQ! : e(+yG 9""wyh
.QY9"yGO=f d9= U+FQyG ?|}G gP$ {a=y
b<Q* fC ,p &tp(* fC - &zv xyP ,p &tph 9}v - uG )yE YQ\} ,!Eh
k
k
.Q=v}G QZ"yG utJA+y ,uG b9D+}< 9}wJ| 9a<Q ?|}G gP$ b9D+|
G(y9sh ,,yGRjyG N+WyG G(=9$ #*PyG rJZyG H9Av )zf >+aMyG OQ ~Cz
PLz! : 9"!} :9%TJ! 9}!E ?<(gZyG fC )zf {yOh e;S G ~d! u+=a@ ?<(gZ<
#+<h .{Wq"p ,u+=aAyG O"f gQDvC cQA!h &]g< PLz! 9}!Eh {wv e;S 9<
)"< A9qzL Y9aASGh ,jQ=wyG &AyhO ,p e;S G e9d! u+=a@ Q}f Y9aASG r+v
.f(yO9gyG ?+|C
,p f(wAS {FQy9< ICQ}yG IGh9T| fz< ~+dgyG &J*QZ@ U+FQzy QwV ~C
.?+"*OyG IO+tgyG Q9_E
?#* G M

189

? +fQW y

v$ 1385 e

+ ( Zy G

? p

QJ}y

G 1 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 30

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

+ (+WyG

u 9g @ ? f

?+p(ZyG O"f aQg* 9| ($ yO(}J|z P9AS}G gOG| 9}|h :{|9wyG f9T! G


.{|9wyG f9T! 9<
k
k
.;|9v 9!9T!E f(w* fC )"}A* 9"zvh
#*O ,p {|9wyG f9T! G ($ U+y ?+p(ZyG #*O ,p {|9wyG f9T! G fC Q+i
.?jy hC aQf hC {tf )yE &|(%q| #| rW< >TA"* : &!C 9}v ,uJyG
#<G d(s x< Q| Otyh .&!9J=S uG ($ ?+p(ZyG #*O ,p {|9wyG f9T! G
.yQ+=wyG f9T! Gz &!E uG #f y&Y(Zpz #| 111 U ,p )<Qf
Q+=wyG &<9Av )z+GyG ~*QwyG O=f ryC A9sQMyG IQ(aS}G gP$ {FC #|h
.y{FGh}Gh QLGh}G ?pQg| ,p {|9wyG f9T! Gz
>atyG ($ {|9wyG f9T! G fC uG xdqI ~zfGz :&+p &y(s ^g< x+yEh
f9v P"| OIGh ($h ,gQLB )yE &yhC #| O(F(yG c;pC &+zf QhO@ jPyG
~C yUF9"v ,p Q%d*h ,U<;| ,p Y(w"n @n &y ~C ,#*O<6G O<C )yE O(F(yG
J9qZyGh ?+@GPyG A9}S}G uJAT* jPyG ($ {|9wyG f9T! G fC ~zfGz :d(t*
#f Q=v g}yG &!{p ,,@GPyG )]At}yG ~wJ< xz}yGh ?y9Y}G b9tJASG ?+%y G
O"AT| 9%y U+y .JGQ9V G xzA< &Aq+ay )yE Q9W}yGh JGQ9=gyG xzA< &At+tI
iQ* : ,AyG IBQ}yG d9D| uJzy &y9D}p ,{|9wyG f9T! G :E O(F(yG ,p
~S:G IBQ}< :E &Tq! IQ(Y iQ* fC &"w}* ;p :Eh ,9%+p :E &@Q(Y [MWyG
>FhC )y9g@ uJyG f{p ,uJyG IBQ| 9]k *C {|9wyG f9T! Gh .&@BQ| (%p ,uG
#f KOJA* ~C y{|9wyG f9T! G ,p :E &@9qYh gD9}SC iQ@ :C &Tq! )zf
uG hC ?*O}J}yG ?t+tJyG ~$O"f ($h - ~zSh &+zf uG )zY - yO}J|z
?t+tJzy OT: ~dfC ($ jPyG {|9wyG f9T! G hC ,?*QW< IQ(Y ,p &!9J=S

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

190

:
o

& vvvv !GQ vvv v+ vvvv Sn ;vv vgv vv vyG xv vv vz vvv vp )v vv vz vvv vf QlOv vv v<
o
&vvvv!GQhO &vvvvy(r vvvvIn #vvvv| ;vvvvgvvvvyG )vvvvIQn vvvvy
o
n
& vvv !9v vwvv v|E Bl v vv =q vvv Dvv |o #vv v+vv wv v}vv yG TQvv gv vyG
&vvvvvvv!9vvvvvvv!O &vvvvvvvAvvvvvvvJvvvvvvvqvvvvvvv_ 9vvvvvvv<k 9vvvvvvv=n vvvvvvvIo :E
r n
&o vv !9v v|RC dRv v@ ~v vyh ,Q(v v$Ov vyG )v v"vv qvv @
o
& vvvvvv !9vv vvv vT vvvvv vy c9 vvvvv v" vvvvv v$ & vvvvv v|Q vvvvv v= vvv v v* Q vvv v v|}Gh
o
&v v v !G(vv v vvC {r v v vv Fn C &v v v "v v v | hv v v =v v v YC ,v v v p
&v !9v wv | cGP b(v p #v | {v < .Qv av tv y9v v
o
& vvv !9 vvv "n vvv <n g9v v]v vs 9 vv v| Pvv vqvv "r vv *o Mo(vv zv vyGh
)1(

?+%y

?v8v+v]v| d9v}vwvyG >vavs )vzvf Ul v}r vV


o r
jPvvvyG RvvvgvvvyG RvvvvQvvv| ~vvvc9vvvgvvvAvvvyG LhC
l
,v zv f 9v +v zv gv yG IQv ]v Jv yG b(v ph xzp v |n
o
G(vvvtvvvtvvvI fE gQvvvSzvvv< O(vvvF(vvvyG Uvvv+vvvy
gOvvv"vvvfh ,f9vvvv &vvv"vvv|h ,&vvv+vvvp {vvvwvvvyG
dOQv Mv v g;v f 9v }v S Bv ; uv zv Mvvy9vvp
~ vvvv v@9 vvv v M vvv v v &v vvv v*O vvv v y &vv vv vg vvv v =C f(v vvv vw vvv v yGh
gQ9vvv+vvv@ ,vvvp J(vvvwvvvzvvv}vvvyGh xvvvzvvv}vvvyGh
9vv}vvTvvyG b(vvp #vv| c;vv|}G &vvgvv+vvavv@h

Py )zG| #f IQ9=f ?*OI}Gz :?*OI}G #f KOJA* ($h - d(t* 9}v


~SG ,%p ,Q(%c &+p 97GQC|| #| A,Wy :h ,J9qZzy :h A9}S~y U+y
)zGAy U+yh .?+tzMyGh ?+tJyG JGQ9=Af:G #f IOQG}yG JGPyG ?pGQZy
B+T!h x@GP ,p BpQjASG GPE x"| ~@C Q%d| fG(v}G ,p ?*OI}G
fC Q+i #| B!C ,p B!C B"wp ,cQ$G(c #f x+p x< JPLCh ,x@GQ9=AfG
J(g"yG #| xy ($ hC ,?+tJyG a9Yh}G #| &tJAT@ 9}| A,V x+yE >T"*
($h .. fG(v}G ,p ?*OI~y GQk %d| ~@C ,f9T! G #| ?y9JyG gP%p ,?+tp zMyG
n w
GP$ ($ 979+z: )zfzp ,,y9G}yG Q(! )yE A9}gyG ?}zc #| JGPyG J:R"@ dhC
>Tn "yGh JGQ9V Gh A9}S}Gh a9Yh}G #f 9%$R"@h 9%]Jw }Ay )zGAyG
k
y9g+= JGQ9=Af:Gh
fC hC .{|9wyG f9T! G IQ(Y ,p )zGA* &!9J=S uG fC GP$ &"*O ?Y;L
n r n
f(w* Os {|9wyG f9T! G GP$ fCh .?+%y G ?t+tJyG )zG| ($ {|9wyG f9T! G
JG G

)2(

{|9wyG f9T! G 2vF 52 ,50U )1(


. {|9wyG f9T! G 1L 30U )2(

191

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

w* Osh ,OGT| ,p )zZ* 9M+V f(w* Os !! 9+k =+zY f(w* Osh ,9}k zT|
k
!!O=g| ,p ~!QA* 9t*Qa<
uG ($ f9T!E {v fC #| &< #*O* 9}y O+v(@ xyP Og< )z+GyG &y9s 9| {vh
U+y &!C Ov|+y {< !!O+vt}yGh uza}yG O(F(yG ($ !!9}k SGh ?qYh GOk(Fhh 9@k GP
- 9%+p uG f9v ,AyG ?*OI}G ?=@Q| ,p ($h )AI f9T! G O(Fh Q+i O(Fh u
k
,p !!?qY :h ,~S G :h ,#+wg@ &y U+y 9tza| GOk(Fh -f(+p(ZyG ~fR* 9}v
GP$ ,p bQqyG 9}p .uG ($ f9T! G f9vh ,f9T! G ($ uG f9v ?=@Q}yG gP$
O(JGyGh ?IGQZy9< ~TA* O(JGyG #+< bQqyG &!E ??+p(ZyGh ?+f(+WyG #+<
..up9"| O(JF ?+p(ZyGh ,K*QY O(JF ?+f(+WyG .?I9s(y9< ~TA*
.jQ@ 9}v ?+p(ZyG xyPvh ,?g+=ayGh f9T! G Q+j< aQAg@ : ?+f(+Wy9p
k
#f By9tp ,&y ?+$GQvh ,uG )zf GOtI O(JGyG JOGR ?+p(ZyG fC Q+i
!!9%zt@ ~zp ?+f(+WyG 9|C .uG ($ &!E f9T! G
O(JGyGh )f(+WyG O(JGyG #+< bQqyG f9+=y KzZ* Os {D}< Jz"yh
?+f(+WyG f{p ,?+$GO iQ9}gASG hC ,?+i9_ y,y9}SCQz )j< GPE :,p(ZyG
uG )\Q :U*Ot@h K+=T@ ,p ?zF9s 9}%"f )\QAAp ,?+p(ZyG 9|C .9}%"gz@
.#+@Q(ZyG #+@9$ ,p Q%d* -&!9J=S- uG 9}$ 9}8} ?GP9}y !! 9}%"f
U y9%"+f ($h A9+V}G Q%cC #| f9J=Sz :&zyG #f ;D| d(t* )<Qf #<9p
9}pz :u=S 9}v 9]k *C uG #f d(t*h y,<Qf #<: ?+w}yG J9I(AqyGz 2L 604
w n
w no
v no
J9s(zM}yG )}T| ,p iQ9TyG (%p ,uJyG OI ($h :E rV OJ*
~y9gy9p ,O(%W}yG #| O(%W}yGh O$9WyG #| O$9WyG (%p ,J9fO=}yGh
111 U yQ+=wyG f9T! G (%p ,&y Q<O}yG ~y9gyG MhQ ($h ,&@Q(Y
n
GP$ f9v O9}GyG BpQv f GP{p ,e9AyG r*QgAyG ($ OJyGh .,=zJyG W yU(Zpz
k
.O9}GyG GP$ #+f &!} ,u 9q*Qg@ r*QgAyG
f(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

192

Q+i GhO=f 9| f9Ch}G IO=f fCh .f9Ch}G #+f uG fC ~fR* y,z+GyGzh


x
d(zI ;< &y9}w< &!9J=S gO(Fh QTp zp pp ,#C(yG ~%"| O=f #|z :d(t* (%p ,uG
xz@ ?t+tI )y9g@ f9wp ,O(F(yG JGQP OGQpC #| OQp {v ,p LR| :h
.{|9wyG f9T! G 2 L 82 U y98hO=g* ,AyG f9Ch}G
#+< 9}Tt"| O(F(yG f9v 9}y &!C ~zfGz :&zyG :E &yE : MQW* ($h :d(t*h
um In h ,A9"qyGh eGOg!:Gh >zTyG &}wI uzL
O(F(yGh O9G* G &}wIp
v
:E :,$h H9G*Eh : :,$h >zS )zf ?+"=| IO9%WyG ?}zv B!9v ,A9t=yGh
f9Ch}G xz@ &< OGQ* &yE : :&y(s ,p &yE eqyh .uG :E rWy O(Fh : :g9"g|
,p gO(Fh QTy ~%y ?tpG(| 9$(}S 9}v 9%yE )y9g@ uG 9$9}S .98hO=g* ,AyG
,&yE &"+f ,p uJyG Q(%d< 9%"| O(=g| {wp .9tI ?%yB gO(F(< ,%p ,989+fC
,p h+}GyG OQpC ~C .?+$(y}G uw JAT| Q%c 9}D+I uG ($h .9%"+f )y9g@ &!}
uG :E GhO=g@ ;p .uG :E ?%y6G xz@ BT+y )"g* uG :E :&y(t< A9"DAS:G
- A,V O(F(yG ,p 9}p .J9%GyG {v &!{p ,?%G< O++t@ Q+i #| b;_ G )zf
.{|9wyG f9T! G 1 vF 89 U yJGO(F(}yG h+= #+f (%p )y9g@ uG :E
)1 (

)2 (

{J|h d9I O(Fh )]At* d(zJy9p . OOgAyG )]At* LR}yGh ,?+F9"DyG )]At* d(zJyG )1(
#||* &!} ,d(zJy9< )z+GyG Qqw* GP%yh . {s}G )zf #+8+V O(Fh )]At* LR}yGh
Qqw* O(F(yG IOI(< #||* )p(Y {vh . uy9MyGh uzMyG #+< ?tza}yG ?|9AyG IOI(y9<
yiQ=wyG &A+F9@z )p VQ9qyG #<G ~fR GP%yh . A)V {v #+f &zyG fz< #||* &!} ,d(zJy9<
#+}fGR ,gP$ f(zjAT* f(fGOMyG f(TyO}yG >$Ph ,d(zJyG i(fO #f &@O+tf gR"* &!C
k
,9$9*E ByR 9|hz ?+%y G JGPyG #f d(t* #+I )zf ,9$R"| 9"||| f9v VQ9qyG #<G fC 96
f} ,&Tq! #f d(zJyG )q"* &zgF &zyG #+<h &"+< ?|9AyG IOI(y9< &!9}*{p ydR@ ~y i9*Eh
. ?*Q+jyGh ?+F9"DyG eRzAT* -B"+< 9}v- d(zJyG
9}$ hC ,OIGh A)V ?t+tJyG )p 9}8} ,?+p(ZyG O"f btp ?+dqy ?z<9t| uzMyG {<9t* uJyG )2(
)p gQ(%c {=s &zyG #f ?+p(ZyG d(t* PE . ?+%y G ?t+tJyG )$ IOIGh ?t+tJy f9%Fh
uzMyGh &"_9< uJy9p uzL &!E Q(%dyG GP$ Og< &"f f(y(t*h . uI &!E uzMyG IQ(Y
.gQ$9c
.

193

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

y s )zf GQk Z| {d+S {$h ?GP$ ,p yO(}J|z P9AS}G iCQ 9}p


(y IO*OGyG ?+!9T! G 9"<Q9GAy 9=k +_ AGPi KzZ* fC #w}* )|;S G a(ZAyG
v
IO+tf ,$ xz@ y9g| ?+f9}AFGh ?+qTzph ?+!GOFh ?SGQO &ASGQO 9"TIC
IO9+ty )O(}J| P9ASC 9*( IO+tgyG gP$ KzZ@ {%p ,?+$(y}G ,p ?+p(ZyG
{$h ,9!O9G|Ch 9"@Q9]I IO+tgyG gP$ )zf )"=! fC #w}* {$h ?9"@Q(C
?#++|9TyG {D}yGh ?+vGRyG ~+ty9< 9"@9+I O}@ fC f(8MyG IO+tgyG gP$ h+aAT@
?{GgyGh ,d(%yG )<C IO9=f )yE (fOC Bqsh (y GP9|
k
?9g| yf(ASO;izh y#+y9ASz U*Ot@ )yE (fOC Bqsh (y GP9|
($ ?+i9ayG )y9}SCQyGh ,,y9}SCQ )f(+WyG fE :d(sC Bqsh (y GP9|
?jO(9 ~zT}yGh ,~zT| )=+zZyGh {+=! )vGQAVG
?+_GQtASQ}Gh ?+_GQt}*OyG O+G}@ )yE (fOC S9"yG #+< Bqsh (y GP9|
??+y9}SCQyGh ?+f(+WyGh ?+_GQshQ+=yGh
,uJyGh {_9=yGh ,jO%yGh d;]yGh f9}* Gh QqwyG SOsC Bqsh (y GP9|
.HG(ZyGh zaMyGh
.!!&zy9< GhQqvGh ,u9< G("|B .S9"zy d(sC Bqsh (y GP9|
#+gzyG yQ(qz<z iQvP ~%y SOsC #+aTzp )|9A* #+< Bqsh (y GP9|
.gGQvP U*Ot@ )yE ~$(fOCh
)zf )"!C B=CC GP$ Bzgp fE )"!C )y ~fR@ yO(}J| P9ASC 9*z ?+p(ZyG fE
!!?"+<h f9}*E )zfh IQ+Z<
:U(Z! #| B|Os 9| CQs9p yO(}J| P9ASC 9*z >*Q ,p B"v fEh
OG! Os ?S9S}G GP$ )zf IO*OGyG ?+!9T! G 9"<Q9: )"=! fC O*Q@ {%p
k
GO<C OG! #y 9"wyh .~zT| iO(%+yG fCh ,~zT| )=+zZyG fC i(fO OG}* #|
fEz :& (

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

194

zy GO! y#*hOz<z #| {gG! fz< )\Q* #| A:|$ #|


I(%Wy #+*;}yG b9"fC QMT@ ?+p(ZyG fC yO(}J|z P9AS}G )T! {$ ~C
9"<Q9I Otyh .~$9+!Oh ~%"*O ,p aQZAyG uI gOIh &y OIGh J(i9_
&y jPyG ($ btp yOIGhz ?+p(ZyG ,ph .?}zwyG QQJ"p ,?}tzyG QQJ"y Y9as G
.N+WyG &y9s 9| GhOOQ* fC :E yX*hGQOyGz #| a(y}G )zf 9|h ,e;wyG uI
IO9=fh &@(%Vh N+WyG i(%y f(yPAT| f(ga%| fhO=gAT| fhQMT| ~8E
IO9sh ,?|C I9}Ih ,IQ(C O("F G(!(w+y ,L9}$:G A:|$ KzZ+pC .&A}zv
!?d9+FC
k
k
f(<Q9J* 9|(s H9AwyGh #+sQWAT}yG #| iQ! fC 9!9+IC 9"AW$O Q+D* 9| fE
QaLC e;S G fC f("*O*h ,#*O &y #}| fhQMT*h #*OyG fhQtAJ*h #*OyG
a(ZAyG #f Y9pOzy fhOZA* A:|$ iQ! .H(gWyG I(s )zf )]s yf(+pCz
k
GhQgW+y ,y,|;SEz ?}zv GO}f &+yE f(q+]*h &!hOG}*h ,ky9< S9}I ,p
,~8GPBh ~6(zt< ~%+yE f(z+}+p ,e;S G #f f(=Aw* ~8C x+y9q}yG
e;S G )yE f(=TA"* #}| a(y}G a(y}Gh ,e;S G ($ GP$ fC ~$hQgW+yh
x t n k
GP6h ,e;S G ,p ?SOt}yG ?t+tJyG {D}* a(ZAyG fC QOt* #c 9+pGQjF
?+j< Q+aL QV #| f(A+=* 9| )yE #+*;}yG GhO(t* fC #+g"tv }yG )zf {%o Sn #dyG
.#+}zT}yGh e;S G )zf A9]tyG
O+wyG GP$ A9}fR fC &y )zGA* uJyG #*OyG GP%y O+wyG N*Q9@ QtAT* #|h
?|}G gP$ ~+s )zf A9]tzyh ,e;S G HQ]y 9}k FGO ?+p(Zy9< G(fQOG Os
h"t}yGh d(At}yG iOQhQ%TyGh )<Qf #<Gh L;JyG 9"=TIh .979|(t|h
;.!!?+}_9qyGh )!9j}zWyGh )!9SGQMyG
)zf JR9F IQv 9| ?fOL #gyC - 9%M*Q9@h 9%CGQ@ B=D* 9}v - ?+p(ZyG fE
?+!9T! G #| {g: ,AyG e;S G ,p 9+zgyG ?+!9IhQyG #+g| 9$("dp ,#+}zT}yG
sn
k
.QOjyG f(8MyG e9ZMyG Oy}G e;S G hOf ,$h !9<Q hC 9+!9<Q
.!!#+"+

195

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?+p(ZyG ,$ B!9v 9$O9=gASG ,p Q9}gAS:G IOf fC ~vQ=< ?+t*QpE G(zS


.!! #+t+yG Q=MyG ~$O"gp ?+f(+WyG #| #*Q9qyG G(zSh
k
k
.!!9D*OI ?+F9%=yGh ,9}*Os ?+"_9=yG G(zSh
d(YC ?+zv O+}f )yE &"f BpQZ!G GPE yO(}J|z P9AS}G )!QPg+y ~C
k
~+zJyG O=f Q(AvOyG - U*QOAyG [Z< ,p )y GP9ASC f9v &!C ~iQ - #*OyG
GP$ ,p #*OyG d(YC ?+zv O+}f 9* x*CQ 9| :jQLC IQ| &y d(s} O(}J|
.?#*OyG
?A9+V}G #+f &!E uG #f )<Qf #<G d(s ,p x*CQ 9|
?JGO(F(}yG h+= #+f &!E uG #f )z=GyG d(s ,p x*CQ 9|h
IOI(< d(t@ ?+p(ZyG fC &}fR )zf GQk Z| Q(AvOyG {d* GP$ Og< hC
k
k
d(t@ jP ,$ 9$h ?#*QqwyG #+< 9sQp c9"$ fC 9!9c O(F(}yG IOI(< : O(F(yG
.?JGO(F(}yG {v #+fh A9+V}G #+f &!E :&zyG #f ?IGQYh M(\h ,p
?sQqAyGh ,O(F(}yG IOI(< d(tyG #+f ($ O(F(yG IOI(< d(tyGh GP$
QqwyG #| ?+p(ZyG Pt!C &!C &< &+yE {+L Q+=wyG O+}gyG d9+M< a9_ ~$h 9}%"+<
.!!e+zjyG )"C(yG
IOI(< f9}* G #| HA"* GP%yh ,O(F(}yG f(wA*h e(tA* O(F(y9=p
9}< aQAg* fC )p(ZyG KGQAyG ^pQ Osh ,O(F(}yG IOI(< f9}* G ,O(F(yG
#+f ($ uG fC QQsh !! &Y(Z! {v #| 9gk | ehRz}yGh eR;y9< Q(AvOyG d9s
.O(F(| {v #+fh O(F(yG
.&< ~$9"j|O 9| ?+p(ZyG #f ,q"* OIGh ["< Q+=wyG O+}gyG 9"@z+zp :Eh
uV9f {vh ,O+}gyG Q(AvOyG P9AS}Gh yO(}J|z P9AS}G 9"yO* fC iO(< ~C
#<:h )<Qf #<:h L;Jzy B!9v ?+|;SE ?y(a< )zf ?+p(ZyG hC ?+f(+Wzy
.

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

196

9v Osh ,?yhOyG f9vQC ^*(t@ dh}G dh9I Oty ,jOQhQ%Tzyh VQ9qyG


H*R| ($ Qqv i(S &AyhOh e;S5y eOt* ~y GOk(JF 9+k AVOGQRh GOk(tI 9+k <(gV
.?+=+zYh ?+AVOGQR #|
9}p ,?+=+zZyG HhQJyG ^g< VQ9qyG #<Gh ($ QY9f Otp )<Qf #<G 9|C
?+=+zZyGh .>+zZyG f9SOt*h ,>+zZyG f;}J* 9}$h r+vh ,98k +V u 9|Os
f9v PE ,gOIh )T+f ?+<(<Q< B}wI 98C ,p :E )<Qf #<G #*O ,p ra< ~y
{v #+f uG f} ,A,V {v O=g@ fCh ,A,V {v ?+<(<Q< ~w; fC >FG(yG
.A,V
f9vh - >zI ,p f9a+Wy9v ~G! )a|Qs )S(G}p iOQhQ%TyG 9|C
iOQhQ%TyG iC - eQJ+y #*OyG M;Y &+LC #f ?<9+"y9< Q$9dyG xz}yG 9%}wJ*
,?+}_9qyG ?+S(G}yGh ?+=+zZyG )zf gQ9ZA!G IQ}C #| #*OyG M;Y k
,SQ9p L(zgy 9IGQ|h iOj| 9$Q9ZA!G LhC ,p ?}+dgyG ?yhOyG #| {gG+yh
9Fk 9W|C &A+Y("i B!9vh ,e;S G {J| ?+Y("jyG {J+yh ,?+}_9qyG ?sO9!Rh
?"TyC )zf &y9s 9| OOQ@ Osh ,IO*OGyG ?*Q(i9D+qyG ,p ?COJ}yG ?+!(_;p}G #|
GP$ {As ,p #*OyG M;Y OOQA* ~y GP%yh ,{=s #| ?qS;qyGh iQ9Z"yG ?+p(Y
.e1191 ?"S ,p OJz}yG
.GP$ Q+i )zf ,p(Y 9"yO+zp :Eh
.IhOsh I(SC 9"y A:|$ #| PMA! fC yO(}J|z P9AS}G O*Q* {%p
OF9s 9$QGp ,AyG hFGhQyG J9}zwyG gP6 QvP! u!9MyG e(}J+yG GP$ Og<h
k
:J9}zdyG gP$ OO=* GQ(! yQY9"yG O=f d9=z ,?|}G gP$
Q9"|h ,JG(fOyG {wy :9D| &@(fO {gG* fC ~*QwyG d(SQyG Y9aASG Otyz
~%+yE )In (}yG QLBh ,A9+=!}G ~@9L f9v Otp ,#+JzZ}yG #| gOg< )@C #}y
k
k
iOA9 9ZL9V &@Q+S #|h ,#+}v9Jzy GQ(ASO &@9+I #| {gGp #+zSQ}yG #|
f

197

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

f}Gh d9+F}G Q| )zf A9+I}G &<


k
9dfGh 9%"| PMA! : ~zp ,GQk =fh 9Sk hQO ?+|;S G I(fOyG ,p fE
9"AS9+S ,p bQAq! ~yh ?^g< )zf ?f9ayG 9Zf 9"]g< uW* ~y ,?GOk VQ|h
?9"zD|h 9"pGO$Ch
.?e;f}G 9"+zf &=AW@ hC u*QayG {]! 9| O"f e;S G iO6 iOA8 : ~y
k
GO* G(!(w@ fz< d(SQyG G(g+_Ch uG G(g+_C ,f(}zT}yG 99C ,HQgyG 99C
~A!zp G("7 :h G(sQqA@ :h ,~w}y9S #}y #+}y9T| ,~vGO9f #| )zf
.yf(zf}G
?+f9}AF:G ?yGOgyG H9Av ~*Ot@ ,p QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG d(t*h
. 1954 ?"S OQqyG b(tIh
YGQZyG O%W! ~y9gyG #| >!9GyG GP$ ,p #+}zT}yGh HQgyG #J! rt!hz
#+< ?=V9"yG cQ9g}yG >sQ!h ,?fOA=}yGh ?*O9}yG >$GP}yG gP$ #+< QhO* jPyG
f} >GgyG OVC >Gg"p ,>$GP}yG xz@ d(I 9%A|(wIh H(gWyG ^g<
P"| 9<QhC ,p ?qS;qyGh #*Qwq}yG {v JQ+I ,AyG ?f9}GyGh OQqyG ?zwW|
?F9}C;Ch ryC P"| 9!O;< ,p K+JZyG {JyG JOFh Os fhQs P"| hC #+!Qs
.?"S
v
,?+!9T! G I(L}G )yE (fO* | uG O=f #< O}J| )zf fBQtyG dR! P"|
{p9wAyGh ,~IGQAyG #| S9SC )zf ?+f9}AF:G ?yGOgyG O9=| {Zx q*h
f9+j_ Q+i #| ,?f9}Gzy e9gyG hq"yG {+=S ,p Uq"yG )zf Q9D* Gh ,j(L}G
.&A+@GPy Q9w!E :h &y d:PE :h ,OQqyG ?*QI )zf
.eG(

r
qp

on m l k j i
o
.pu t

zI #f e(+yG P"| G(DJ=* :h O%F #| G(yP< 9}< fhQwq}yG rAw+zp

d(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

198

{JyG 9!O"f fE ..h}AG}yGh OQqyG ?zwW}y iQLC


... ?"S ?F9}C;Ch ryC P"| 9"+=! )zf )I(yG &< dR! jPyG dh}G {JyG
.f(}zT}yG 96 #||* uI ?}zv gP$h y?+!9T! Gz ?zwW}y Q+L}G {JyG ($
KOJA* ($h )|;S G ~y9gyG #f Q(Z}yG ?zG| #| U9L OOf ,p d9sh
.?*QZ}yG IQ(DyG aGO$C #f
hqA"! fCh ,9!Q+j< egA! fCh ,9"+\9}< Q=Ag! fC - #+}zT}yG #J! 9"+zgpz
,p 9!O(%F rf9]! fCh ShQOh HQ9: #| rzS 9}< IO*OGyG 9"@9]8 ,p
u<9TA@ dhOyG JPLC Otp ,IQ+aL J9=FGh 9"+zf VQq* jPyG QZgyG GP$
E*OJyG ~zgyG )zf IO}Ag| 96(gV Q+My {}g@h ,,sQyG (J!h I(tyG (J!
~zgyG )zf e(t* O+G| {=tAT| (J! 9"t*Q_ PLz"zp ,?Jy9ZyG ?"+A}yG ?+<QAyGh
#v +v zv |9v gv yG hv | uGh ,~v FGRv gv yG bOv Yh ,U;v L G )v zv fh ,b;v L}Gh
.y#+ZzM}yG
O;< {v fC zW* ~y #|h A9V #| aQg+zpz :1954 ?"S ,p &y9s 9}|h
fC zW* ~y #|h A9V #| aQg+yh 9!O;< QQJA@ fC O< :h ,9!O;< ?+<Qgy9< ua"@
A9Sz=yG ,p I(L G fh9gA* fC O< :h I(LE VQ}G Y9t< )AV ,p #+}zT}yG
.IOWyGh
?y9SQy9< f9}* G #f b9D+}yG ,p OQh 9}|h
iO%yGh uJy9< 9%Dg< ,AyG ?+SOtyG &@:9SQh &zSQ<h u9< YRfRA* : f9}*Ez
.yf9w|h f9|R {v ,p f9T! G )yE
f9vh ~+dgyG 9%M*Q9A< 9$Q+vP@h ,O+G}yG 9%+\9}< ?|}G Q\9I b<Q #fh
.9%}y9g| Q9CCh ?t+tJyG gP$ RQ<C GAk(\ )|;S G KAqyG
k
k
.,IhQyG fGOF(yGh QwqyG #| GO*OF 9<(C 9%y h"Yh
..

199

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9s .| O}J| ?y9SQ #| iO$ )zfh .. )|;S G N*Q9AyG Q9_E ,ph


k
.?+!9T! Gh IQ9]JyG #f 9f9pO QGhO}G ~dfz< iQZ}yG >gWyG
.?+"*OyG ?+IhQyG ~+tyG #fh
h ,f9T! G ?*GO$ )zf IQO9s f9*O}G #| ?g<9"yG IOy9MyG ?+IhQyG ~+tyG fEz
{FC #| 9%y OhOI : J9s9_ &J"| )zfh ,f9}* G Q("< &@9+I IA9\E )zf
.?=J}yGh uJyGh Q+MyG
BpO%ASG ?+!9T!E JGQ(C B!9v 9$Q$(F ,p 9%zv A9}TyG J:9SQ fE
X9qAI:G ($ Q=v}G #++"*OyG #*Qwq}yG >FGh fEh ,&@O9gSh f9T! G aQV
.&Ay9SQ Q$(G< #*Ozy
HA"* 9}!Eh ,I9+JyG uF9tI h| eO9ZA* : ?+"*OyG J:9SQyG Q$(F fE
O\ #*OyG {jAT@ fC ?+gFQyG J:h9J| #| ahQdyG ^g< ,p eO9ZAyG
&A}wI h| eO9ZA@ &y JGQ+Tq@ d9gAp9< xyPh eOtAyG ?zsQgy &IhQh &Ag+=_
?f(+f(+WyG d(t* GP9}p .?+|9TyG ?+%y G
.b9D+}yG ?"Gy &AqYh jPyG Q*QtAyG ,p A9Fh
{Z@ fC #| f9}* G I(t<h ,e;S G Q9WA!G Og< ,?+<QgyG ?|}G B"w}@z
GP$ #| IQ(Y b9D+}yG RQ<C Osh ,&FO9=|h &Ay9SQ #| iO$ )zf IhQPyG )yE
k
IOy9MyG ~+tzy IQ(Yh .{=tAT}yGh Q\9JyG ,p {}gzy 9SGQ=! f(wAy ,,\9}yG
,,|;S G N*Q9AyG Q9_E ,phz :d9tp .O*OGyG 9"g}AG| 9%+zf e(t* ,AyG
#f 9fk 9pO QGhO}G ~dfz< iQZ}yG >gWyG e9s | O}J| ?y9SQ iO$ )zfh
.y?+!9T! Gh IQ9]JyG
)yE 9+!OyG I9+JyG ,p f9T! G u*Q_ ~+d"A< IQ+=v ?*9"f )"g* e;S G fEz
.yjQL}G I9+Jzy &t*Q_h &ty9M< f9T! G ?zY ~+d"A< &A*9"f >!9F
?+z:h #*OyG ?t+tI rWw< )"g! fC O*OGyG 9"g}AG| ,p 9"+zf >G*z
e

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

200

O*OGyG h}AG}yG ~+ty 9Sk 9SC IOy9MyG ?+IhQyG &A}+s f(w@ )wy &Ay9SQ Q$(F
k
k
ICQ}yG #+< IGh9T}yG ~AAyh ,#+"tAzy 9+S9SC GQOZ| AGQjyG ?g*QWyG f(w@ )wyh
.?+|;S G ?g*QWyG Q9_E ,p {FQyGh
O9gy ,~wJ}yG hFGQyG #+YQyG d(tyG GP$ ,p OQh 9}< ~zT| {v #|B (y
V U T S Ro :&!9J=S uG Ofh 9%y BttJAyh 9$OG| ?|}G gP%y
,

`_^]\[ZYXW
mlkjihgfedcba
pp o n
.

O+< jPyG QO9tyG Ofh &!} ,rzMA* fC #w}* : uG Ofhh .uG Ofh GP$
:A,V {v J(wz|
QZ| ,p ;=tAT| ?+f(+Wzy fC f("d* #*PyG x8yhC QvP! fC 9"y >+a* 9}v
,p ?+!9}yQ=yG ?8+%y9< ?f9}AFG ,p ?sQW}yG &AIGQY ,p ?|}G gP$ OF9s &y9s 9}<
d(tyG 9%+qp ,U+FQyG dG(sC QW"! eGQ$}G IO*QF #fh ,1965 / 2 / 25 e(*
#f ?|}G gP$ aQY fhO*Q* #}y eR9I Q*P;h ,O*OV O+fh 9%+ph ,{ZqyG
.y?+f(+WyG h| 9"@9p;Lz :fG("f B; eGQ$}G d(t@ .~*(tyG O+VQyG 9%"*O
h| {F9T}yG #| Q+Dv ,p rzAM! 9"!E( :QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG d9s
#J!h ,:hC #*Oy9< #||! #J! ,?*QPF J9p;L ,$ 9"@9p;Lh ,?+f(+WyG
,?+|(tyG IOI(yG )yE hzaA! #J!h ,J9t=ayG #| ?t=_ iC ?*Q(@9Aw*O ^pQ!
.)?t=ayG JGR9+A|G ,qZ! #wyh ?t=_ iC r"gy9< ,qZ! : #J!h
:eGQ$}G By9s .yjQLC IQ| ?+f(+WyG #fz :fG("f B;h
?|9%yG ?+zLGOyG 9*9]tyG #| OOf )yE QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG {tA!G ~C
#| G(FQL #*PyG #++f(+WyG #f ?z8S}G ^g< &+yE JQ9VC 9| 9%"+< B!9vh
:QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG d9sh )\9}yG e9gyG ,p J;tAg}yG
g

201

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

,p OIGh {tAg| c9"$ f(w* : fC Q(ASOyG QGOYE {=s 9*k QhQ\ f9v Oty
{v u=S Os e9| G )yE iQ(DyG Q(aAyG f{p iQLC ?+I9! #|h ,#GTyG
.J:9+MyGh JGQ(ZAyG
k
fCh ~%y9I KzZ"* fC #w}* #+f(+WyG #| GOOf fC Q(ZA! #J"p f6Gh
Q+wqAzy ?YQph I9+JyG H9=SC ~%y r+7 {}gzy ?YQp h}AG}yG ~%y KTq*
.b9D+}yG S9SC )zf O*OGyG
~+d"@ O9G*E f(+f(+WyG dh9I GPE &!E :QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG d9sh
fC ~%"| OIC dh9I GPE xyPvh ,b9D+}yG O\ f(w* a(S xyP f{p )f(+V
BwT@ #y ?yhOyG f{p ,?y9JyG gP$ ,ph ,#*Oy9< U}@ ?*O9JyE I(fO QW"*
.{=t@ #yh
.?f(+f(+WyG YO@Q* {%p
g9"IQV 9}< a(ZAyG fC &}fR )zf GQk Z| yO(}J|z P9AS}G {d* {$h
k
y.?IO*OGyG ?+!9T! G 9"<Q9GAy 9S9SC KzZ*
,O%F #| G(yP< 9}< fhQwq}yG rAw+zpz ?|}G OF9s #| ?}zwyG gP$ h}SG
y.h}AG}yGh OQqyG ?zwW}y iQLC d(zI #f e(+yG P"| G(DJ=* :h
.. {JyG 9!O"f fE
($ ?"S ?F9}DzCh ryC P"| 9"+=! )zf )I(yG &< dR! jPyG .. dh}G {JyG
!!fhQwq}yG rAw+zp ?+!9T! G ?zwW}y Q+L}G {JyG
!!f(pQJ"}yG U"M+yh
gQv (yh gQ(! ~A* fC :E uG )<z*h ,~%$G(pz< uG Q(! G(8qa* fC fhO*Q*{
.gQ(! uG ~A+Sh yfhQp9wyG
{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

202
v$1381

#*OyGh

9 Og< 9|
$

h v41v

4 O

Ogy

G 26

Oz G |

?p9JZyG

,$ e9*}G gP$ ,p 9%pQAt* fC #++qJZyG ^g< >J* ,AyG ?!(gz}yG ?fO=yG


k
fC #sh} ,!Eh .9+zgyG &zD|h ?SOt}yG &}+s #| 9+j< {+"yGh #*OyG )zf e(G%yG
G(!9v fEh ,?}+dgyG 9"@Q(C AGOfC OyC ~$ GP$ f(pQAt* #*PyG #++qJZyG A:|$
#f #*OFGRyG A:|%y CQt* #| f{p .9$Q9Z!C Qw <C ~8z< fhAGQA* hC f(}fR*
O%gyG J9}S #| #*OyG )zf e(G%yG fC #d* Os ,?+z$9GyGh ?y9%GyG
O+wyG GP6 ?}+dgyG 9"@Q(Dy #*OF9wyG A:|$ {gyh .&y9a<C fO*Oh,Q\9JyG
)zf )ZgAT@h ,e9IQ}G hat"Ap ,GP$ f(}zT}yG ~%q* fC f(=J* f(gz}yG
)yE f(fO* #|n A:|$ #| .J9*9jyGh d9|6G IOI(yG )zfh ,H(ztyG I(L}G
)fQ@ :h ,?+SOs ?+"*OyG ?z+]qzy iQ@ : ,AyG ?!9G}yG )yEh ,?g"t}yG ?I9< G
k
.!!9<GQJ| 9%y
,#++"*OA}yG #+< ~*Qv B+Y ~%y d9FQ QGOsC )zf ~G%A* #| ~%"|h
.&Tq! #*OyG )zf KG=@h ?Jt< ~G%AyG i(S ?t+tJyG ,p &pO$ U+yh
hC ,MG(=yG A(TyG hC ,MGQZyG Qqwy9< IQ%WyG aGQAsG dh9; JGQw! ~%"|h
>@9v GP%p ,| d(SQyG H9JYC Q+My XI9qyG A9G%yGh ,YPt}yG H9=Ty9<
Q9=yG O+%WyG f9qf #< f9}Df {+zGyG ?q+zMyG #f rJZyG iOIE ,p >Aw*
U9gyG #< hQ}f ~+dgyG K@9qyG #fh f9+qS )<C #<G ?*h9g| )I(yG >@9v #fh
&!C &"| ~%q@ 98k +!O GQk }i ~$Q}j*h ,#+*R9%A!:Gh ?+_GQtASQ:G A9"<C ~8C
.uG &"gy {%F )<z< ~%%=W*
,?+vGQAV:G #f hpGO* f9A%=yGh XJqyG GP6 &!C ?g| G >@9wyG #c Osh
J9< &zgyh ,#*Oy9MyG )zf O(zMyG e9t| ~JAt+S f9A%=yG GP6 &!C #c 9}v
,&+zf OQzy YQWAS ,AyG e;s}9<h ,&y9t| &COJ+S jPyG ~+dgyG ihOy9< ~zJ*
.f9a+WyG IQ%V B!9v fEh ,IQ%WyG xyP AGQh #| >Tw+p ,&"f Y9pOzy hC

203

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

OyC ,?+f9}AF:G ?yGOgyG AGOfC OyC ,IQ(DyG AGOfC OyC #++=@9wyG A:|$ fE
hC #*O}gAT| fhO+w* ~8E &A*(yC uq< fC {|z! jPyG Q+=wyG QZ"yG AGOfC
?|C 9"!C LQ9MyG ,p S9"yG )yE f(I(*h ,O+wyG z!OC IQp9dyG 9"@Q(Dy #+zp9i
AGQh 98BQt< aPt@h ,9%y(SQ Bt}@h ,96Q< Qqw@h 9%"*Oy Qw"A@ BIGQ
?|GQYh IOW< A:|$ PLC #| O<: &!z< #||! GP%yh .?+@9f ?*QMS ,p 9$Q(%c
f(Z*QJyG 9"!C ?|}G gP%y Ov|! )AI .&+zf #+i9=yG )zf uJyG >]i 9%+p
CR7 ?}zv :h ,#*Oy9< ?*QMS {a=yG IQ(DyG OF9s #| 9"g}S 9}p uG #*O )zf
k
b(p hq@Q@ #yz &y(t< IQ| JGP IOI;}yG QP"* 9*hO| &@(Y 9"g}S 9}!Eh ,&<
.ye;S G ?*GQ :E bQWyG GP$ ?*GQ
,&Ag*QWyh uG #*Oy O+wyG ,p ?|7yG gP$ :E f(<z* H9AwyG A:|%y 9}p
??z+zGyG 9"@Q(Dyh ,&<9Awyh ,&y(SQyh
?zG}yG gP$ 9"|QvC 9!C Q+i ,#+=@9wyG A:|$ A9}Sz< MQZ! fC O(! 9"v Otyh
f9}Df {+zGyG ?q+zMyG ~7G jPyG ?g| G {gyh ~$A9}SC QvP< 9%T!O! fC #f
k
ihOyG xyP &y9t}y OG* ~y GPE ,9qSB f6G &*OL ~az* {%F )<zv &!z<
b+J| ,p fGQatyG #| IQ+jY IQat< &=VC gOFh 9}!Eh ,&=sQA* f9v jPyG
.u+}f

, s (S O

M;Y

Q$9tyG ep9J| Q+=wyG P9AS}G &=Av jPyG ~+dgyG d9t}yG xyP 9!R$ Otyh
(<C O}J| N+WyG P9AS}G )zf ~G7 jPyG >@9wyG )zf GOkQ )s(SO M;Y
9%y9FQ fCh ,~+dgyG gQOs #*Ozy aQg@ IA9"=yG IQ(DyG fC d9t}yG GP6 Ovzp IQ$R
GP$ ,p A9F 9| ^g< x+yEh ,&"| {+"yG ~%"| OIGh Q_9M< bQa* fC #w}* :
. 1961/8/26 N*Q9A< ?*Q(%}GyG IO*QG< QW! jPyG d9t}yG
)1 (

Q+=wyG P9AS}G iCQ #f 9%+p 9"*CQ rzAM* A9+VC ~+dgyG d9t}yG )p OQh )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

204

&"V jPyG )S9tyG e(G%zy B}yz@ ,!E 9sO9Y Bzs GPE ?t+tJyG hOfC :
.yIQ$R (<C O}J|z N+WyG )zf )...( P9AS}G
N+WyG #f hpGOC fC J9}zwyG gP$ ,p dh9IC ,!E f9T!E #d* fC OhC :h
#f Y9pOyG {F9Sh #| xz}* N+WyG fC aQfC ,!{p &y rZA!C fC hC IQ$R (<C
.jO%F gO"f QZt* Os 9| &Tq!
JOZs 9| fEh Y(\(}yG ,p a;MyG J;+ZqAy VQg@C fC OhC : 9}v
)...( ?y9t| )Tq! ,p 9%AvQI ,AyG ?ZzM}yG Qf9W}yG ^g< #f Q=fC fC &+yE
.IQ+L}G
,AyGh O*Q=yG )yE 9%z}I ,AyG JGQ9TqAS:G )zf Bs(yG Uq! ,p OQC fCh
f9v GPE 9}fh )S9tyG e(G%yG GP$ )"g| #f ~%]g< aQfC S9!C #| 9%A+tz@
.Q$9dyG g9"g| #| QDvC gAGQh
H 9 A w yG

^ g<

9%=@9v VQgA* ,AyG IQ+L}G ?!h6G ,p )yh}G ,$ )...( ?y9t| #w@ ~y


^g< O"f QQJAyG ?}S BJ=YC Otp .#*OyG d9FQ #| {FQ )zf e(G%zy
{Yh Oty {< &y9FQ #| ?*QMTyGh #*OyG )zf e(G%yG ,$ H9=WyG H9AwyG
k
GQ(a@ Q|}G Q(a@h Ky9ZyG rzTyG )zf e(G%yG OI )yE ~%]g< O"f Q|}G
,p ?|(SQ}yG hC ?<(Aw}yG J9$9wqzy IO9| ?wF;}yG BJ=YC 9|O"f GQk +aL
AX"yG ?Y9Lh S9"yG S(q! ,p Oy(* Q+aMyG g9::G GP$h J;G}yG ^g<
k
k
f(w* )wy H9WyG K=YC )AI ?+gFQyGh #*OyG #+< b<Qy9< 9t+}f GQ(gV
k
#*OyG K=YCh ,&Tq! ,p &"*O YRG(! #| :hC [zMA* fC &+zf >G* GQkQJA|
k
GPEh ...eOtAyG &Fh ,p rt@h Q(aAyG O!9g@ ,AyG ?+gFQyG g(Fh #| 9%Fh
iQLC H9=S}h e(}gyG &Fh )zf H9=WyG O"f )"*OyG YRG(yG rg\ 9"dI:
rg]yG GP$ RRg* jPyG g9::G GP$ IQ(aM< UJ! fC 9"gaAS} ?qzAM|
#|h QQJAyG #| f(<QAt* 9}!E #*OyG #f Og=y9< ~8C H9=WyG QgW* jPyGh
.~y9gyGh h}AG}yG uJz* jPyG Q(aAyG

205

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

zaL ~+}gAyG

&A+pQJ< xT}AyG ,p f(gpO"* Os OGQpC #*OyG d9FQ #+< #| &!z< 9"}zS GPEh
xT}AyG ,p f(gpO"* ~zgyG d9FQ ^g< fC xyPv Qw"! : 9"!{p .&+zf 9Yk QI
GPEh ..&}+sh &}+y9g@h #*OyG f(]pQ* ~%zgG* jPyG OJyG )yE ~zgyG #+!G(t<
&+zf ~G%AyGh #*OyG ^pQy GQkQ=| U+y dh}G Y("yG #| OGQpC O(Fh f9v
#wyh &]pQh ~zgyG )zf ~G%Azy GQkQ=| U+y )!9DyG Y("yG #| OGQpC O(F(p
?ztyG A9aLC Y(}G}yGh IQDwyG {+}; #|h ~+}gAyG #| )@z@ IQ(aMyG

Og}yG

.IOh

QGI #*OyG f9v ?t+tI {$ iQ"y >*QtyG 9"M*Q9@ )yE O(g! fC 9"yh9I GPEh
9"g}AG| Q(a@ )zfh 9"+zf 9<k QI &y9FQ f9v ?t+tI {$h 9"|Ot@ {+=S ,p IQDf
...K+JZyG ($ UwgyG fC 9"*CQy
jQLC J9g}AG|

,p dh}G QhOyG 9%+p #*OyG d9FQ >gy iQLC J9g}AG| JOFh Oty
#*Q}gAT}yGh #++f9as:G #| H(gWyG AGOfC ?qy9J| ,p ?*QJyG )zf A9]tyG
GQk +Dv OGR jPyG #*OyG d9FQ &zgq* 9| bj\ B; e(t@ IQ+Dv JGQ(C B!9v )AI
.f(i9ayG e9wJyGh f(+f9as:G &zgq* 9}f
9"g}AG| ,p #*OyG d9FQ #w* ~zp xyP a;L )zf 9!O;< ,p Q|}G #wyh
d9FQ h=* ~yh S9"yG )zf ?!(+!OyG 97(aS OF9T}zy #w* ~yh Y9asE d9FQ
,p 9"g}AG| ,p #*OyG d9FQ f9v Oty {< ..fGQqi c(wY 9"g}AG| ,p #*OyG
.#++!9}DgyGh R+zG!:Gh #++T!QqyG ?<Q9J}y BFQL ,AyG a(qZyG ?|Ot|
&zy9< #||! #J!

,p 9!OFGQ u9< 9"!9}*E #w+zp ?yR"}yG &=Aw<h &zSQ<h u9< #||* >gV 9"!E
)zf G(|9s #*PyG d9FQy9<h uG #*O< 9%"| {ZA* 9| ?|9gyG 9!9*9]s ?Ws9"|

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

206

#| )zf I(TtyG )zf ~%YQI ~$9fO 9|O"f )AI #*OyG GP$ )zf X9qJyG
k
.gOhOI #f 9FQ9L &!("d*

207

? +fQW y

v16v

h}AG}yGh

Of

5 O

1961/9/23

N*Q9A<

?S9+Ty

? Ty
"

Gh

?+}v9Jy

G 26

Oz G |

#*OyG

v19vY i(="yG iO%yG


h}AG}yGh

v$1381

u+zg@h

#*OyG

)e(+yG Q9=LC(

#f ;t!

9wp:Gh >$GP}yGh AGQ6G #| ?qY9f JGQ9+@ bQWyG A9"<G )zf >7


Q$9d|h UJyG )zf O9}Af:G hC {tgyG hC hsG(yG hC ~zgyG JGQ9gV U=z@h
,f9*O}G #| {+"yG )yE ~7GQ9gV #| ua"}yG GP$ H9JYC [zM*h ?g+=ayG
#| G(zzJA+yh .JGQ9gWyG gP6 f9}* G )yE u9< f9}* G #| ~%Tq!C G(ZzM+y
..?*O9}yG Q9SE ,p G(W+g+y ?+IhQyG ~+tyGh ?+!9T! G )!9g}yG
,&T}V BiR< P"| )"| Otp ,#*OyG )zf IO*OF Q+i JGQ9+AyG gP$h
9=y9i 9%"| LQM* fC 9}FGO ?G+A"yG B!9vh ,d;J!:Gh O9Jy:G >$GP}<
gQ(!h uG MhQ #| uD="* &!} xyP ..IQ(%t| ?<(zj| ,$ )T}@h ,GQZA"|
O(+s ,p rSQAy MhQyG O(+s #| b;a! G )zf O}AgAp ,$ 9|C ,gQ(! ~A| uGh
f9T!G {v ~zT@h ..?a<GQ {v 9%"+< hat"Ap u*QayG GP$ ,p hpO"@h ,IO9}yG
...gG($ )yE
)yE &GAAp ,IQ+JyGh a(MyGh uztyGh ~y:9< ?+!9T! G U; 9| f9fQSh
#| OO=Ap J9s9ayG h+}: )zf QOt@h ,I(tyG K+@9q| xz}@ )AyG ?+!9IhQyG
Y9A}AS:G {F9Sh 9%y r+7h ,#|}G MhQ 9%+zf k=T@h 9%tzs ?+!9T! G
,f9|QJyGh u+]yGh B=wyG #|h ,OGO=AS:Gh ?+!9!:G #| 9%zWA"@h ,J9=+ay9<
...Sz+yGh rg]yG {|G(f ?t+sQyG ?+!9T! G 979T}z< KT}@h
?v+vf9v}vAvF G 9v79v+vI #v+v< Kv\G(vyG bQvqvyG ?v+v!9vTv! G Uv}vzv@ 9v"v$ #v|h
&+zf )y(AT@ h}AG|h ,?+"*OyG ~d"yG gO(T@ h}AG| d;c ,p ?*O9ZAs Gh
..Q

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

208

9T! G )zf f9T! G 9%\Qq* ,AyG AGQ6Gh >$GP}yG


?*9"gyG )zf &DJ* Q(ASO ,ph ,u9< f9}* G d;c ,p 9+J* h}AG| GP$
,&+zf ~wJy9< #+}F9tyG #+<h &+p OQp {v #+< i(T*h ,&}TG< ?*9"gyGh &IhQ<
{wyGh AG(S {wyG ,?+T"F hC ?+qF9ay ?+Y9L :h e(wJ| )zf ~v9Jy IR+| :
?*QJyG #| d9I Q+L )zf ~%"+< Q(|}G ~+tAT@ )AI 9]g< &]g< >sGQ*
.IGh9T}yGh ?yGOgyGh
,?yB &"| {gFh ,gP(q! &+zf HQ\ f9T!E Q9SE ,p X+g* h}AG| cGPh
#fh ,&@Qap #f gOg<Ch ,&A+@GP &"| YR!h ,?|GQwyGh ?*QJyG uI &=zSh
k
,&Tq! J9|(t}y GOs9p GO<C X+g+p ,,!9T! G Q+}]yG J(Y )yE Y9}AS:G
>$GP}yG #| &+zf &\Qp 9}<h &A8+W}< &}wJ* jPyG f9azTyG Q+SC GO<C {d*h
.AGQ6Gh
&@OGQ9< 9%+p aQZA*h ,&ztg< 9%vQO* 9}v &TJ< uF9tJyG cQO* h}AG| 9"$
d;jAS:Gh h}ayG gO(t* h}AG| c9"$h ..&Jy9Z|h &phQc >TI 9%q+w*h
OGQp}G #+< ?s;gyG e(t@h ,L9A! G S9SC )zf :E h}AG}yG ,p OQqyG e(t* :h
?yhOyGh ,&F9A!E Q+d! g9ag* 9| :E &y U+yh ,S9S}G GP$ )zf ?yhOyG #+<h
.&+zf AGRGyG Q*Ot@h L9A! G Q*Ot@ ,p iCQyG ?=I9Y 9$OIh
h}AG| c9"$h ,9]g< 9%]g< {}w* I9+JyG >!G(F fz< QgW* h}AG| 9"$
?Df9=yGh IO9}zy ?vQJ}yG ?s9ayG #f ;f9p iO9}yG 9%=!9F #| :E I9+JyG iQ* :
IO9}yG gP$ Bf9aASG 9| 9$:(yh ,f9+v IO9}zy f9v 9| 9$:(y ,AyGh ,I9+Jzy
...{}g@h )gT@h cQJA@ fC
&FO9=| Qp(@ h}AG| ..9%y 9gq! QDvCh ?+!9T! G )zf iOFC #+g}AG}yG iC
{v e(t*h ,~79*9i )yE G(zZ+y {|:9< &F9"<G H(zs ~}@h ,?+Tq"yG ?"+!z}ayG
&*R9GAp Q+L #| {gq* 9| )zf &=S9;h ,&z}fh &tzLh &!9}*E QGOt}< OQp
..f

209

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

A QI OQp {v >zT* h}AG| eC ..?GQV &*R9GAp QV #| aQAt* 9|h ,GQ+L


.?{|C ;< {}fh ,?*9i fhO ?vQI )yE &gpO*h
{gq* fC f9T!E {wy K+=*h 9%M*Q9@ #f ?|}G dRg* jPyG h}AG}yG xyP eC
#+< i(T*h ?{a=yG {D| #F9MyGh ?+J]yG {D| O;GyG &+p Q+Z*h ?A9W* 9|
...W9W"yG &FhC
Q+}]yG >_9M* #*O< #*O! fC ,{tgyGh ua"}yG )yE HQsC 9}9Ch
#| Q+j@ HQ9GAyG dGR@ 9|h ~zgy9< #*O! eC ,f9w|h f9|R {v ,p )!9T! G
ahQdyG ?&=I9Y 9%+p X+g* ,AyG ahQdy9< GO<C QCzA| ($h {tgy9< eC ?gOfG(s
gP$ Q+Cz@ OIC Qw"* :h ,?+f9}AF:Gh ?+JZyG ahQdyGh ??+|(tyGh ?+pGQjGyG
IQ+Dv ,$h ,&+zf ht@ 9|h SG(Jy9< #*O! eC ..Q+wqAyGh &+F(AyG ,p ahQdyG
?...9%A; ht* 9}y h\9L 96 QCzA| 9}FGO 9%=I9Yh ,YGOMyG
~yh ,?}wIh IQOs 9%s(q* #}y :E h]< : ,?=ztA}yG f9T! G ?g+=_ fE
,gOIh u J9qZyG gP$ 9}!E ,J9s(zM}yG #| OI} J9qZyG gP$ h}A:
#+<h OQqyG #+< d(J*h ,QI9"AyG #| ?+!9T! G ~Zg* jPyG ($ u9< f9}* Gh
)yE 9%gpO*h ,Q+MyG OY9t| )yE d(tgyGh Q9wp:G &F(*h ,gQ+i )zf iOgAyG
QV 9%+t* 9| 9%y ~SQ+p ,d(+}yGh r_G(gyGh J9fR"yG QOt*h ,Q(aAyGh EJ=yG
.d;]yGh k*RyGh YGQZyG
&!9+v u+t; ,p OG+p ,&Tq"< &!9}*E f9T! G O}AT* f9}* G GP$ #|h
HhP@h h}AG}yG OGQpC #+< b<GQAyG I(s f(w@ 9"$ #|h ..&A+ZMV #*(w@h
AGQiG dhR*h ,{p9wAyGh fh9gAyGh Q9D*:G )!9g| RQ=@h ?qzAM}yG bQG(qyG ~%"+<
.f9*Qf hC hF9F h}AG}yG ,p )t=* ;p ,?+J]AyG uzL i(t*h JG(%WyG
&@9=FGhh &s(tI {wy OOJ*h ?f9}GyGh OQqy9< #||* )"*OyG h}AG}yG fE
?*QIh {}gyG ?*QI ,&@GP< OQqyG f9}*E #| ARF 98} ?*QJy9< #||* 9}v
,& *

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

210

Q\ h}AG}y9< uJz@ : ,AyG J9*QJyG QF9Sh >TwyG


:d(t* PE Q+=g@ bOYC )!9g}yG gP$ #f U+FQyG O+TyG Q=f Otyh
.y#+}zT}yG #J! ...HQgyG #J!z
.yQL6G e(+yGh &zSQh &=Avh &AwF;|h u9< #||!z
.yjQLC QRh IQRGh QR@ :Ch ,&z}f AGRF {|9f {wy fz< #||!hz
9!9+vh ,&z$C ,p 9!9+vh ,&@GP ,p 9!9+v ?f9= {v ,p OQp {wy fz< #||!hz
.y..gOz< ,ph ?|9gyG &A+|(s ,p
Q9D*:9<h )f9}AF:G {p9wAy9<h ?+!9T! G I(L}9< xyP {v )yE #||!hz
.y?+!9T! G b<GhQyG u+C(Ay Q9+AL:G )zf ~F9tyG
.yuJyG GP$ rp9w* 9=FGh &+zfh - 9tI ?yhOyG ,p OQp {wy fz< #||!hz
GP$ rp9w* 9tI &+zf 9%yh ,9=FGh 9%+p OQp {wy ?yhOyG )zf fChz
.y>FG(yG
d:PG :h Q%s 9%+p U+y ,#+|(wJ}yGh e9wJyG #+< ?yO9=A| J9g=@ ,%pz
.yO+=gyG #| ?}M\ ?t=_h IO9TyG #| OOgyG ?z+zs J9t=_ :h bzT@ :h
{}g! 9}+p gQ(ASO ~SQA!h ,&+zf uG #*O* jPyG 9""*O< 9"!9}*G Ov|! 9"!Gz
.y9"|(tyh 9"Tq!z<
iO9Jy G AGQ%yG xyP )zf OQ@ ?=+_ ?}zv gP$ :yj(="yG iO%yGz :u+zg@
9!QW!h ,,\9}yG OOgyG ,p 9}%+yE 9!QVC fGPzyG f9=@9wyG &< jP$ jPyG
.9}$OIC )zf IQ$9tyG ep9J| )s(SO M;Y Q+=wyG P9AS}G OQ #| J9qaAt|
,#*OyG )zf #+}v9JyG UQI 9"y Ov|* 9| 9]*C ?}zwyG gP$ ,p {gyh
rZt!h ,#+"F9}yG H9AwyG A:|$ iO*C )zf IOW< HQ]! fC )yE 9!(fO*h
k
.#*OyG )zf GO9tIC Os(A@ ,AyG ~%"+fC ,p ~%|;sC
...GQ

211

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

,AyG B+iG(ayG gP$ ~aJ! fC )yE 9!(fO* 9| 9]k *C ?}zwyG gP$ ,p {gyh
H9AwyG #| O}AT}yG O(W"}yG )"*OyG M;Y G {+=S ,p IQDf QGI rt@
Q+=wyG Q*R(yG A9F Osh .?+p(ZyG J(i9_ B+iG(ayG gP$ OVCh .~*QwyG
,gP(q! &+zf HQ\ f9T!E Q9SE ,p X+g* h}AG| cGPhz :&y(s ,p &qY(<
#f gOg<Ch &A+@GP &"| YR!h ,?|GQwyGh ?*QJyG uI &=zSh ,?yB &"| {gFh
Os9p GO<C X+g* :,!9T! G Q+}]yG J(Y )yE Y9}AS:G #fh ,&@Qap
9}<h ,&A8+W}< &}wJ* jPyG f9azTyG Q+SC GOk <C {d*h ,&Tq! ,p J9|(t}yG
,p(ZyG h}AG}yG )zf bOZ@ ?}zwyG gP$ yAGQ6Gh >$GP}yG #| &+zf &\Qp
&FG($} GO+=fh 9|OL >gWyG #|h ,GO(=g| 9%yE N+WyG #| {gG* jPyG &zv
?DGy9v &M+V iO* #+< f(w* fC O*Q}yG )zf VQq@ ?+p(ZyG fE .&@G(%Vh
o
fC #| gQP;h ,N+WyG IOGQE ,p &@OGQE )"q* fC &+zf VQq@ {S9jyG iO* #+<
OyG(}yG ,p #+<GQtyG &+zf VQq@h ?+!;f YQWyG ry9M* gBQ fEh &+zf VQAg*
,p gOW@h ,N+WyG #| fP{< :E uG QvP* :C &+zf VQq@ {< N+Wzy 9$Q+ih
GP$ .f(gyGh OO}yG 9%"| U}zA* Q9GI}9< gQ+Z| b<Q@h ,,@(}yG )yE &@9+I
,,<Qf #<G &+p(Y ?*Qd"yG ?+p(ZyG 9|C .?+z}gyG ?+p(ZyG &pQAt@ 9| ($
SOt@h ,?+!(+%ZyG #*O KJZ@ 98C 9"=TJp VQ9qyG #<Gh )z+GyGh
uI ?}zv .?}F9s ?+p(ZyG gP$h ,e(t* fC )"*O M;Y #w}* :h ,f9a+WyG
.?z+zGyG &A}zv )zf Q+=wyG Q*R(yG #*Qv9V ,uG &F(y 9%y(t!

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

212
?|9

! ; f Ch

J9

J9

1373 f
?f9}GyG

!9+<

9] |

Q 9 O

Ogy

G 18

Oz G } y

Q 9 = LC

9+zgyG Q*QJAyG ?8+$ ,p e9gyG U+FQzy IQ\9J|


?"S (*9| 10( 1373 ?"S f9]|Q 7 upG(}yG #+"C}G e(* A9T| ,p
N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]p IQ\9J| Y9}S )yE 9+zgyG Q*QJAyG ?8+$ BfO )1954
Y(\(| f9vh .?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= U+FQ )tqyG O|9I O}J|
Y9}Ty #+"_G(}yG #| fhQ+Dv OWAIG Osh yQ*QJAyG #*O e;S Gz IQ\9J}yG
IQZ!h #*OyG HGO$z< xT}AyG )yE U+FQyG ?z+]p 9%+p 9fO Osh .IQ\9J}yG
IO9gS #| O;=yG Q+My &!(\Q* 9| )yE IQ(DyG d9FQ up(* fC uG 9fOh .uJyG
.A9LQh

213

? +fQW y

v$1373

(!C

JGO9TyG Q

? S ?GJy
"

e9t}F9tyG

j(="yG iO%yG

G hP 12 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 18

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

O TyG ?}zv

?zG| )yE

9qaL 9%+p JOF(p 9%FG(FC ,p BTq"@ ?+IhQ ?s9_ yj(="yG iO%yGz


,IQwqyGh iCQyG {+=S ,p O9%GyG eGO .~zd}yG u*QayG )zf r]@ uJyG #|
9| 9}wy GQk wWp IQ+Z< )zf uG )yE {+=TyG &+p OI(A@h ,Q("yG &"| uD=!G O9%F
k
.iCQyGh iO%yGh uJyG {+=S ,p 9t+p(@h 9}A*O$C
.f(|O9s &+zf ~A!C 9}+p f9gAT}yG uGh iC

&zyG ?}IQh ~w+zf e;TyGh


1954/7/18

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

214
v49v
?f9}GyG

3 O

Ogy

G 19

Oz G } y

Q 9 = LC

9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG )tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]p QGR
O+TyG ,1954 ?"S Q<(AvC 20 upG(}yG A9g<Q}G e(* M9=Y ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
98k "%| ?S9*QyG QGO< AGQR(yG UzG| U+FQ QY9"yG O=f d9= )V9=w=yG U+FQyG
.A;GyG ?+s9q@9<
Q

215

? +fQW y

v35v

A;GyG b9q@G

Og y

4 O

"

G v$1374

?S9+Ty

? S 9D y h <
"

?=S9 }< Q =wyG ;w

)!

Y Qp

Q}@

Gh

Q 19

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

||

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= B|9sC )!9DyG h+<Q 6 U+}MyG A9T| ,p


k
IOz=yG {$C &|C , U+FQyG I9G!h A;GyG b9q@G ?=S9"}< 9G+6 ;qI ;w"<
e9gyG RvQ}yG #| Q+=v Ophh ,IQh9G}yG O;=yG )y9$C #| IQ+qi Y(=h
B<Q9s 9}yh .IR+GyG QGO}wI ~%SCQ )zfh ?|(wJyG (<hO"| GPvh .?f9}Gzy
#| ?*9jyG #f ?}zw< {qJyG ?f9}Gzy ;w! ?ta"| U+FQ KAApG ?g<9TyG ?f9TyG
e9gyG U+FQyG >F9! {+v(yG #}IQyG O=f P9AS}G eOt@ ~C .Q}@|}yG GP$
P9AS}G eOt@ ~C .?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C I(fO ?t+tI #f ?}zv )tyzp ?f9}Gzy
k
?=S9"}< A9}Zf IO+Zs )tyzp ;w"< I(fOyG QW! ?"Gy U+FQ bRQ e;TyG O=f
B+iG(ayG #f ?+pGh ?}zv )|9J}yG GO! OgS P9AS}G )tyC ~C ,{qJyG GP$
?f9}Gzy e9gyG RvQ}yG >sGQ| )gp9WyG O9VQ P9AS}G ^8 ~C ,9$O9=fh
f9v ,97(fO 9%+zf B|9s ,AyG US}Gh ?"TyG Q9Z!C I(fO aGO$C VQgAS9p
YQp U+FQ iOVQ}yG )yOf P9AS}G eOt@ ~C .#*Q\9JyG ,p QC}G kz<C 9%y
{qJyG f9v Otp ?z}GyG )zfh .?j+z<h IQ+Zs ?}zv A9ty{< IO+Ty9< ?f9}GyG
YQG(WyGh J9sQayG J~A|G )AI &+zf d9=s G QDvh .QhQTyGh ?G%=yG g9Wj@
#f I(fOyG QW! ?"Gy ?}zw< {qJyG ~AALG ~C ,{qJyG f9w| )yE ?*O|}yG
.IQV9gyG ?f9TyG B!9v E+I ;w! ?ta"}< ?|9gyG JGQ}@|}yG
)1(

? O"wS}9< ?+W"}yG )p &y9+AiE ?yh9J| #| U+FQyG I9G!

. *Q

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

216
v51v
?f9}GyG

6 ,5 O

Ogy

G 19

Oz G } y

Q 9 = LC

QY9"yG O=f d9}F U+FQyG O+TyG

H9aL IQ(Y

;w"< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F U+FQ )yE

>*OyG O}IC Qv9V O+TyG


:Og<h ?vQ9=| ?+;
?=S9"}y &}+tAS jPyG {qJyG Q(]Jy ?+g}GyG I(fO QwWyG QpG(< Bz=t@
gP$ ?+=z@ iO(< f9vh .AGOAf:G KO9I #| )@9G"<h A;GyG ?+s9q@G h+s(@
QW! ,p M9G"yG ?+g}Gzy (FQC .9%t+t; fhO d(; {}gyG e9%| fC :(y ?=iQyG
.?*O}J}yG ?"TyG O9=|
&zyG ?}IQh ~w+zf e;TyGh

(y UzG| U+FQ

AGQR G

QY9"yG O=f d9=

217

? +fQW y

v$ 1385 I

S9

QL 6

"zy

9}F

G iO

f9

6 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 30

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

+<

\(yG #| #+w| S9SC )zf 9$Q|C dhC #| ?+|;S G I(fOyG B|9s Oty
)AI &F(y 9%k Fh {_9=yG ByR9!h ,AG(Ay:Gh V(}jyG #f Og=yGh ?IGQZyGh
k
#| ?GJy9< Y9"s G ($ GO<C {q* ~y jPyG 9%I;S f9vh .&+zf B]sh &At$RC
Vo I9FGO| hC ?<QG(| fhO ?"TJyG ?df(}yGh ?}wJy9< I(fOyGh ,gGQvE Q+i
M(

]256

?*6G :IQn t=n yG[ p


n

^]
\[
Z
YX W

#| ~$QPIh ~%FGOfC h| )AI dOgyG G(aT=* fC #+}zT}yG uG Q|C Osh


l{ :&!9J=S d9tp .fGhOgyGh ~zdyG )yE AGOf}G A:|$ ^j< ~6 hpO* fC

'&%$#"!

yxw
.}

"

v u
ts

r
q p on m
~ }| {z

&!Eh ?&F9"<Ch &F9+yhC #| &< r+wp ,&FGOfC #| &qs(|h e;S G iO$ GP$
:h ?!9+MyG )<z* #*O &!C )zfh A9J}TyG ?*(tyG e;S G MhQ )zf dO+y
: O(tI ?yGP!h QhOi #=F 98z< 9%j|O* {< .&z$} 9vk (zS :h 9tk zL 9$9\Q*
)yE GQkhR f(=TA"* #}| ~%S;ICh O(%+yGh #+tp9"}yG ,p :E ?+!9T! G 9%pQg@

;S G
O+s f9}* Gz :d9s &!C | ,="yG #f gO"T| ,p O}IC e9| G ihQ Otyh
. xAqyG
?"AqyG e9*C ,p gO"F OIC f9vh uG O+=f #< ?Jz_ O"T| ,p E*OJyG GP$h
k
g9%"p y&y9AiCz {FQyG d9tp ?&zAt@ r+v &y d9tp ,9+zf {At* fC ,p &!PzASC Os
.e

)1(

zAt+p &+zf OW+p {p9i ($h &=I9Y )@z* fC xAqyGz )@z* 9| &@GOQq| )p Q+C}G #<G QvP )1(
{gF &!zwp aQZAyG #f &=I9Y O+tyG h"}* 9}v xAqyG #f h"}* f9}* G fC :)"g}yGh
k
.GO+s xAqyG

. y&

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

218

E*OJyG ihQh ?Jz_


d9FQyG QGQIz< u+z* : 9}f gRGJ* 9| &!9}*E #| &y f(w* fC O<: #||}y9p
?!h9g|h ,GOk9Tp VQ}G ,p )gTyGh d9+Ai:Gh xAqyG #| &"f uG ,8 9}fh
gGhQ QLB E*OI ,p A9Fh .&F9+yhCh &F9"<C O\ ~7Q$9d|h e;S G AGOfC
.yf;p IQOi gP$ :d9t* ,?|9+tyG e(* AG(y QO9i {wyz
O}IC
#| i(t@ )zf BTSC P"| ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= BYQI GP%yh
iz"}< ,$h f9$Q=yGh ?GJy9< uG )yE (fO@ fC ?"TyGh H9Awy9< e9ZAfGh ,uG
,9$QS ($ 9%"zfh 9%"_9=v 9$Q$9c ,A9t}JyG ?+=ZgyGh A9+}gyG ?+<RJyG #f
9%|G(s ,?+"zf ?+}zS 97(fO ,uG >]i :E &"| a9< hC &+q< 9| 9%y U+y
,p KZ"yG [z<h uJy9< Q%: .?"TyGh H9AwyG #| ^+=yG HGJy9< Y9"s G
,QF9p OTI hC QO9i OtI 9%|9|R i(z* fC fhO ,U;LEh bOYh ?IGQY
" ! ~ } | { z o uG d(s 97(fO ,p 9$Q9gV
O NM
o )y9g@ &y(sh
?*6 9g!} p' &% $ #
> o &!9J=S &y(sh ?*6 rS(* pWV UT SR Q P
.

]153

]108

G:

G :e

HG
F
E D

?*6G :{J"q yG[ p

G[

C B A@?
.

]125

Gy ,AyG >+y9S}G gP$ IOW< Qw"AT@ -f9}*Eh bOY #f ,%p- gP%yh


~CEh ~79*9"F QRh e;S G Bz}Jp #*OyG ~S9< J9f9}GyG ^g< 9%+yE

Jz

)1 (

9%qWv ~@ 1965 ?"S ~FGQF #| #+}zT}yG fG(L G ?f9= #| KOI 9| O(Zt}yG )1(
OGOgASE #| -)!(|OfC GP9}y- &<9Av )p >as O+S Og< 9}+p 96 aQAfC )AyG )$h 9%_9=IEh
Q9=v d9+AiCh NyE ...?*Q+MyG Q_9"tyG HQ\h ?*(+JyG J5W"}yG rT"y ?f9}GyG
Otp 9"$ #|h ))!(|OfC GP9}y( H9Av hFGQ - ?+"|}Gh ?*QwTgyGh ?+S9+TyG J9+ZMWyG
upG(AyG eI:h -&+yE >T"* 9}| e;S G ?FQ=@ )zf ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= BYQI
d9+AiG Og< 9%=Av )AyG yxAqyG O+s f9}* Gz Qv9V O}IC N+WyG ?y9t| #+<h f9+=yG GP$ #+<
.y)VGQt"yG O(}J|z ?|(wJyG U+FQy fG(L G ?f9=

219

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9G|C #| 9"ttI 9| {v )zf )]t@ fC ?gW=yG 9%A}*QG< JO9vh ~79s9}I


.O9}f #| 9"+"<h
O* )zf e;S5y utJ* fCh ,{+=TyG AG(S 9gk += 9"*O9 fC dzT! uGh
.?yhOh OO|Sh Rf #| &y f9v 9| )QY9"yG O=f( OF9tyG f9T! G {a=yG
O

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

220

Q PJ@

#| ?f9}GyG YhQp h+= ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG RvQ}yG QPJ*
#| xyPvh ,?zJ"}yG J98+%yGh )1(J9f9}GyG X9fhh A9]fC ^g< {zT@
~$QPJ* -GQkhR- ?f9}GyG X9fhh A9=aL ?qY f(zJA"* #*PyG A;LOyG ^g<
k
,~$Q<9"| A;AfChC ~79g}AG| )yE {zTAyG #| A:|$ #| GOIC G("w}* fC #|
: )AI ,?|9gyG ShQOyG eC JGQ\9J}yG eC h}GyG >aMy xyP f9v AG(S
.{zTAyG xyP )zf J(wTy9< 9%Ag}Sh ?f9}GyG )yE G(8+T*

9 zJ< QGQs QOY )AyG #+}zT}yG fG(L G ?f9= O(Zt}yG )1(

.%

221

? +fQW y

v$ 1385
?f9}GyG

>F

Q 7 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 30

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

Q GO

ztyG QGO .?"TyGh H9AwyG #| IQ+Z< )zf uG O=g* ~zT| {wy QGO ,$
,cQWyG 9%C(z* ,AyG H(ztyG : ,&y(SQyh u bO9ZyG >Jy9< rzA}@ )AyG
.?f9}GyG #+< ?+$GQwyG e(}S Eq"@h A9]j=yGh O9tI}9< ~+j@h
,AyG : ,&p9M*h g(FQ*h uG >J* >zs 9%+ph Kp9Z@ ,AyG iO*}G QGO
.Q+|O@ )yE )]q@ IQ|G||h O(tI QOih ,e(}T| QG"L 9%+ph Kp9Z@
QGO .| &y(SQh uG )yE :E 9%"*O ,p >TA"@ : ,AyG ?f9}GyG QGO
H9AwyG )yE (fO@h ,A9"fQyG ?+=$P}yGh ,A9t}JyG ?+=ZgyG Bt}@ ,AyG ?f9}GyG
.?"TyGh
97(fO ,p ?J\G(yG ?+p9ZyG ?+!;gyG i(S 9tk za| aQg@ ~y QGO
,&+L} 9%+p OQp {v &y(t* 9}p .&+q< 9| 9%y U+y GP%yh ,97GA9tyh 979f9}AFGh
x+yEh 9"=!C x+yEh ,9"zv(@ x+zf 9"<Q .9gk += S9"zy QGOyG LQ9L &y(t*
.Q+Z}yG
H(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

222
v$1385 f
)1(

f9

+<

Og<

f9

9=gV

8 O

Ogy

G 30

Oz G } y

+<

9 =y I IOJA}yG ?+<QgyG ?*Q(%}GyG LQ9L #| J9<9aL 9"+yE BzYh


iO%yG( AGQs #| ~%]g< fC &y rS|* 9}|h .IQL6G iO9= OOg< g9!QW! jPyG
(fO! 9| 9%"| G(}%q* ~yh 98k +V 9%"| GhO+qAT* ~y hO=* 9| )zf ~%"wyh )j(="yG
.~%"f 9%gat@ fC ?zG}yG IQGOE JCQ Osh .uJyG #*OyG #| &+yE
f + G d(

.v 213-209v

Y u<9TyG f9+=yG O(Zt}yG )1(

223

? +fQW y

=y Oy

i( " G j

IQJyG IQF9DyG

G 3 O

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

G 20

?+}v9Jy

Oz G } y

QZ|

O%f ,p &ztAT}yG QZ| fC ~y9gzy QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG B=CC Oty
J9s9q@:G #| Otg@h A9W@ 9| {gq@ ?*QJyG ?tza| IQI BJ=YC ,IQ(DyG
K}T@ :h ,OIC #| ?*9Yh {=t@ : IQJyG QZ| fEh ,A9W@ 9| J9tqZyGh
.&A*9}I 9%+zf VQq* hC &A*9fQ B; 9%g]* fC OI}
J:h9J}yG h+= 9%A|GQvh 9%y;tASGh 9%A*QJ< IRAg}yG QZ| B]pQ Osh
J:h9J}yG h+= B]pQ 9}v 9+v9p(zS(w+W@ #| ?JzS}G AGQV #| 9%g"}y
.?tqZyG gP$ #f dhOgy9< 9%f9"s
K+zT@ fC :?J*QY ?*(s ?}zv QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG 9%"zfC Otyh
.WQV hC O+s fhO< f6G #| ~A* X+GyG
9"!{p ,O+s fhO<h WQV fhO< M;TyG OG! fC 9"gaASG fC Og< e(+yG 9"!Eh
P(q"yG )zf 9"+]sh ~wJAyG )zf 9"+]s xyP<h ?+t+tJyG 9"A*QI {}wAT!
.)="F}G
979p 9| V(g@ fE f6G h+aAT@ 98E 9%M*Q9@ )p d(; ?at"< Q}@ QZ| fE
{< ,a9g]ASG :h rg\ : e(+yG .9%I;T<h ..9%y9FQ< ?+"i f(w@ fCh
.QZ| KzT@ )AI eRfh ~+}Z@
G(!(w* fCh eRIh I(s )p ?+sQWyG ~|}G ?}zv h= )yE (fO* Q|}G fE
.O(%+yG QaL hpOy #*OJA| ?*(s ?%=F
k
)AyG d9=Jzy GO+F ~%"+fC G(JAq+yh .f(}zT}yGh HQgyG et+AT+zp :C
k
uGh ,OW@h uC(@ fC {=s 9%gas )zf 9g*QS G(z}g+yh ~%s9"fC d(I c9;
.~%tp(*h ~%"+g*
.A(S {v #| ~89Yh ~$O+< PLCh IQ(DyG IO9s uG uph

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

224

N*Q9A< .U+FQyG O+Tzy BzSQC )AyG ?+sQ=yG IQ(Y gP$h


QZ}< AGQR(yG UzG| U+FQ QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG )yE
,p ~vO*|@ - IQ$9ty9< e9gyG RvQ}yG - ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=
~vQZ"* fE .e9|}G )yE GhQ+Tp .X+GyG K+zT@ fzW< i(tyG )"_(yG ~wqs(|
)j=yGh ~zdyG i(s )zf ~vQZ!h uG ~wtph .~wy >y9i ;p uG
.Q9}gAS:Gh
1955/10/2

{+zL iOVQ O}J|


?<9+"y9< ?f9}GyG Q+@QwS

=y Oy

i( " G j
?f9}GyG

G 3 O

Ogy

G 20

Oz G } y

Q 9 = LC

U+FQzy ?8"%@h O+*z@

N+WyG U+FQyG ?z+]p #| IOF #| ?+sQ< QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG )tz@
:9%Z! GP$ QZ}< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= U+FQ ,tqyG O|9I O}J|
rv}G hpQ! ?pQW}yG ?=gwyG d;c B; ,uG ?}IQh ~w+zf e;TyGz
&yzT!h ,hOgyG H9$Q I(tyG OGOfE )p ?!(g}y9< ~vO}* fC uG )yE #+fQ9\
uG eGOC ,#+aTzp Q+%aAy ~wFG(y B; #*O$9G| f(w! fC 9"+zf #}* fC
.y~vQZ!h ~vO+*z@
:?+y9AyG ?+sQ=y9< QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG O+TyG OQh
^pQh X+GyG K+zTAy 9"AS9+Ty ~vO+*z@ {|9v #f ~wA+sQ< )p ~A<QfCz
.yiQ*Ot@h iQwV ~wzp #*Q}gAT}yG #| {LO@ iC

225

? +fQW y

97 , 96 v

~ Qv

20

?S9+Ty

OzG}y

Gh

?+}v9Jy

G 7 O

Og y

H9Av

K+zTAyG Y(=SC )p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG RvQ}yG ~$9S


O%gyG d9a<C &g"Z* iPyG QZ"yG >v(| )p 9%"| 9vGQAVG &+"F ?F9| kz=}<
)|9Ih 97Rfh 9%A|GQv fG(Z| 9%W+F ?*(tA< 9+k y9f ?|}G SCQ hpQy Q\9JyG
)!9|}G HPfC &+p 9%zv ?+<QgyG ?|}G {|z@ iPyGh 9%\(I #f OFGPyGh 9%\QC
#+aTzp VQC Q+%a@h )yh}G e;S G ?z=s #| ?+!(+%ZyG OQay d9|6G Q=vCh
.~%TFQ #| ?<hQgyG >zs
G(gpQh ?JzS}G KOIz< QGQ<}G IO9tyG gOhR iPyG ~+dgyG X+GyG GP$
GP$ fE .J9=tgyG ~M\C xyP {+=S )p G(zyPh J9FQOyG )}SC )yE &@9*("g|
AGQS G VQC OGOQASGh ?+<QgyG ~|}G ?|GQv IO9gAS: (FQ}yG ($ X+GyG
)AyG OF9T}yG Ey9C &zgFh &y(I uG cQ9< iPyG )Zs}G OGT}yGh LGQg}yGh
.d9IQyG 9%+yE OW@
PLz< 9"*O9"@ 9F(y9qyGh O+"S Q*Oh Kz=yG Q*Oh {+zMyG )p 9"FGO%V A9|O fE
>zs )p ?v(V Q9}gAS:G ~%g= iPyG b9p6G PGPV O9ih}G x8yhC #| QzDyG
.e;S Gh ?<hQgyG
~7OQ_ #*PyG #+8F;yG #| ?<hQgyGh e;S G )p I(L G x8yhC d9I fE
#| f(y9"* ~C 9%+p ~%zJ| G(zJ+y >!P Q+j< ~$Q9*O #| bQayG Y9as J9<9Zf
QqwyGh QqwyG )p OIGh {FQ >zs )zf 9gk += ~8} )\QyGh O+*zAyG Q9}gAS:G
~%\QC )yE ~$O+g!h ~%D+j"y 9!(fO* #*OQW}yG A:|$ d9I fE .IOIGh ?z|
?*("g}yG I(ty9< uG gO|C {S9=yG 9"W+F ,p ~%g| 9"z|Ch ~%z|Ch ~$Q9*Oh
gO"f #| MhQ< 9"@O9s O*Ch .?+J]AyGh ?f9GWy9< ~6(zs )zf b<Qh ?*O9}yGh
.>+G| Q*Os h+}S &!C 9$OG|h 9$Rf ?<hQgzy GhO+g* )AI

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

$ # "!

?+}v9Jy

226

wW| ?f9}Gzy {SQzp QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG O+TyG {]q@ Osh
:)y9AyG H9aMyG

k
GQ(

:?*O}J}yG

?"TyG Q9Z!C U+FQ O+TyG

X+GyG K+zT@ )p ~w"| ?}$9T| &+"F 100 kz=| ~A|Otp ~Az]q@


.iOq}yG #_(yG #f Y9pOyG {F9Sh d9}wAS:
.~wA+"_h bO9Yh ~vQf9W| {+=! )zf iQwV [y9L G(z=tAp
1956 / 2 / 9

QY9"yG O=f d9=


(y UzG| U+FQ

AGQR G

)vvvvvvvvvvp GQk vvvvvvvvvv*Qvvvvvvvvvv;

227

? +fQW y

1378 f

9=gV >F
h

Q 23

~ dgyG ?<hQgyG ~ fR

Oz G |

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)8 , 7( O

Og y

)y E

QY9"yG O=f d9}F U+FQyG

9!(}A+SG(p ,u9< i(s f9}*Eh ,~*Qv Q< #| &+zf uG ~vQap 9}< ~Az]q@
~y9gyG )p ?"TyG Q9Z!C - 9!Eh .?f9}GyG U+FQ ~+dgyG e;S G O+tp )p
~*QwyG ragyG GP$ )zf A9"DyG bOYCh QwWyG [zLC hpQ! - &zv )|;S G
Q}gyG ~wy >9 fC ?ZzM| ?+ph H(zt< &!9J=S uG )yE YQ]!h ,k<9TyG
,)|;S Gh )<QgyG ~y9gyG IOIh ~w*O* )zf utJ* fCh ,&+p cQ9=}yG O*O}yG
9""w|C 9| {}g! fCh ,uJyG O("F 9"++I 9| f(w! fC uG h| 9!O%f Ov|!h
?}zv f(w@ fC {+=S )ph ,IOy9MyG ?+|;S G O9G|}G Eg< {+=S )p {}gyG
.9+zgyG )$ uG
9"IhQY A9"< .eO%yGh A9"=yG {+=S )p ?<hQgyG ~+fR 9* xg| {}g"S
)<QgyG ~y9gyG [zM+y ,KGQ@ #| Q9}gAS:G rzL 9| eO$h .iQPyG ?M|9V
.&!9J=S uG Q|C 9}< &!(}wJ* &z$} )|;S Gh
9"zvh .up(}yG ~%z}yG OF9tyG B!Ch .?<hQgyG ~+fR 9* uG h| 9!O%f GP$
{|C ,~*QwyG cO%f )ph #+A*(tyG x*O* )zf utJ* fC ,uG )yE ?fGQ\
{+=TyG ~w< xzSh ~vO9%F )p ~vO*Ch ,uG ~wtph ,e;S G A9FQh ?<hQgyG
.#+}zT}zyh HQgzy ?z|9WyG IOI(yG .iQ=wyG ~wA*9i )yE iO9%yG i(TyG
&"+<h ,~wy gQ="| )zf 9%za<h dh}G I(fOyG OFGQ I(fO B!9v xz@
bO9Y #||| I(fO 98} ,H9GASG Os uG fC )p H9@Q! 9|h .uG #+<h
.u+p(AyGh OGOTyG uG ~w}%yC .f9}* G
)1 (

?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=

.-

)tqyG O|9I N+WyG OZt*

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

228
1384

+ %=yGz

y? F 9

H 9A w y

IOJA}yG

? S Ogty
"

*Q(%}GyG

G hP 11 O

Ogy

G 29

Oz G } y

+FQ O+TyG #| Q*Ot@

?+<QgyG ?*Q(%}GyG ?S9FQ


U+FQyG >Aw|

{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f O+TyG


:Og<h

?=+_ ?+J@

| O+*z@ #| ?+fG(yG xAy9SQ &< B\9p 9| U+FQyG O+TyG )tz@ Otp


?sO9ZyG Qf9W}yG gP$ )zf ky9=yG gQwW< x+yE Eg<C fC &@O9+S )!Q|Ch A9phh
.97O+tfh 9%M*Q9@ - y?+F9%=yGz x<9Aw< &@9pG(| )zf xAz}I )AyG
u9< 9%"+t+< (qZ@ )AyG ?+y9gyG MhQyG gP$ xy QOt+y U+FQyG O+TyG fCh
?*(tyG IQ+jyG gP$ x+p 9+k +J| | &y(SQ ?"T< xT}AyGh &<9Aw< {}gy9< (}T@h
.{+_9<Ch &=V #| ~*(tyG #*OyG )zf &< iQAq* 9| )zf OQyG )yE xgpO@ )AyG
~IGQA| {\9p h}AG| {c )p OGOTyGh u+p(Ay9< ~wy &@O9+S J9+"}@ h|
.IOy9L ?+<Qf ?|Ch
IO( h

,eGQAI:G

9]|E

A
Q

9+GyG O(}J|

?+zLGOyG f(8Wzy U+FQyG >Aw| Q*O|

QpGh h|

229
v$1375

? +fQW y

? S ? GJy
"

G iPh I

Ogty

G iP 12,11 fGO

?S9+Ty

Ogy

Gh

?+}v9Jy

G 20

Oz G |

~ Qv Q Ot@

?*Q(%}GyG U+FQ O+TyG ?*QJyG {a< #|


y?+p(ZyG

)$ gP$z

H9Awy

~*QwyG GP$ &<9Av {SQzp ?*Q(%}GyG U+FQ QY9"yG O=f d9= O+TyG {]q@
:{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f N}G )yE
:{+v(yG #}IQyG O=f N+WyG O+TyG
,,, Og<h ?=+_ ?+;
B"v Os y?+p(ZyG )$ gP$z xqy|| ,vyE cAGO$E QwWyG dRFC xy QwVzp
k
k
.O+!9S}Gh HGJyG )AW< 9%y GO*|| ,x@Qwqy 9+ph &+p
,IOF9TyG YO=yG )zf 9%Az}I )AyG xAz}I iQOY HzCC iPyG fC )zf
uGh ,A9aT=yGh LPTyG #| #*Q+DwyG ?z+M| )p QhO@ )AyG ?y9]yG e9$h}Gh
k
.#_(yG ?gpQ &+p 9}y 9g+= 9"tp(* fC dzSC
.QZ}y IRgyGh
1956 / 5 / 5

Q=vC

uGh

)p IQ$9tyG

U+FQ O+TyG )yE [y9MyG 9$QwV hpQ@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=h
#| ($h 9}+S :h &< RAg@h QMq@ iPyG ~*QwyG Q*OtAyG GP$ )zf ?*Q(%}GyG
hC d(t* 9}+p ?}wJyGh ?<9Y Gh fGR@:G :E &"f aQg* ~y {FQh ~+df {a<
k
,gQ}f uG d9_C ,uJyG H9TI )zf GO<C {|9G* : {FQ &!C :Eh ,{gq*
k
.~*QwyG &+gS )p 9}FGO &tphh ,&"*O &< RfCh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

230
[y9MyG

#*OyG

| uG d(SQ Y9=@G

)p :E U+y

K}TyG )<C Q$9dyG O=f N+WyG P9AS~y


r*QWyG )w}yG eQJyG e9|Eh >+aL

&@9+I d(_ )t=* &!{p &A"S aQg* ~yh | d(SQyG aQg* ~y iPyG fE
&|;v ~%qy ~%tphh ~7Q+Z< #+f uG KAp #}| gQ+i e(z* ~C &z%F )p b=MA*
dh9J*h ,~$QtAJ*h ,~%+zf OtJ*h ,xyP )zf ~$OTJ*h .&y(SQ e;vh
k
k
k
,?}F}G f(|QAJ* : ~8C :9<Pv 9}fGR ,S9"yG O"f ~%Ag}S g(W* fC GO$9F
HPv rZ"}yGh Q9tyG 99C x<Qh GP$h .?}F~y #*h9T| ~%Tq!C fhQ* ~8Ch
)p ?}F}9v ~8C G(fO* ~y ~8{p &y9+Lh #+wT}yG xyP Uq! &Av9I ,QhRh
O}IC :h )gp9Wy9v f(w* fC OIC )zf uG VQq* ~yh ,~$O9%AFGh ~%}zf
{}gyGh &}%ph &|;v Q<O@ S9"yG )zf VQp #wyh ,~$Q+i :h xy9| :h
.| d(SQyG ?"S )p VhQq| GP$ {D|h .&<

ty {=s ~zgyG H9<

9tp .xyP )p 9<9<

9M=yG Otf Osh


.{}gyGh
O"f xyP :E ~zf : | &y(SQ e;vh uG e;v ?pQg| ($ ~zgyGh
.A9}zg< &z$C :h ~zg< U+zp O+ztAyG 9|zp ,b;_:G
iOIE &y(s U+y #| d(t< {}gyG :O+ztAyG :Q*QJAyG ,p e9}%yG #<G d9s
#*C #| ~zg@ : B!Ch ,{F9tyG d(s d(=s ($ :d9qtyG d9sh .?GI ;< HGJyG
.&y9s
?GI ;< ?GJyG &< e(t@ : #| iCQ d(=s ($ :)!9v(WyG e9| G d9sh
?+fQWyG {F9T}yG )p G(qzALG - ?Dy9DyG ?yzT}yG -:d(JqyG O9VQE )p d9sh
d( G

:d

iQ

231

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

: &!C )yE ~zgyG {$C #| ?f9= >$Pp ?: eC 9%+p O+ztAyG R(G* {$ ,?+fQqyG
k
H(Fh )zf A9}zgyG Q(%=h xy9| >$P| )p )pGQtyG d9s .9tza| R(G*
.O+ztAyG #f )%"yG )zf Y9=:G eRI #<G )fOGh .O+ztAyG d9a<Eh O9%AF:G
)*CQ )p GhQd!9p >+YCh raLC QW< 9!C 9}!E :d9s &!C xy9| #f {t!h :d9s
:&@(| O"f d9sh .g(vQ@9p upG(* ~y 9|h ,&< GhPMp ?"TyGh H9AwyG upGh 9}p
k
)y Q=Y : &!C )zf 9_(S )*CQ< 9%+p B}zw@ ?yzT| {w< B<Q\ )!C JOOh
.W9+TyG )zf
(<Ch ,)gp9WyG xyPvh ,O+ztAyG #f )%"* xy9| 9"$9%p eRI #<G d9s
. ?q+"I
#f )%"* dR* ~y &!C gQZAM| dhC )p )gp9WyG #f )!R}yG ihQ Osh
O+ztAyG #| h"}yG fC ~zg@ GP6h )!9v(WyG e9| G d9s v$.G gQ+i O+zt@h gO+zt@
k
.Q(%}GyG >$P| (%p 9f9=E #w* ~y fE
:d9t* fC ?yzT}yG )p O}Ag}yGh :e9wI}G &<9Av )p iO|6G e9| G d9sh
xyP eOf {Y}Gh ,{+yO #| &y O< :h ,)fQV ~wI O+ztAyG RG(G< d(tyG
)|9gyG uI )p xyP RG(F #| eRz* :h ,&!9+< )yE L9AJ* g9fOG #}p ,{+yOyG
&y #| uI )p xyP RG(F ~wJyG #| &<(za| {+Z; )yE {Y(AyG #f RF9gyG
v$G .&+p Ozt| ($ 9}| ~@C &< &s(Chh ,&+zf QO9s ($h ~wJyG )yE {Y(AyG ?+z$C
&"f H9FCh xyP )zf #+\QAg}yG VGQAfG OQhC Osh
#f QJ=yG )p )WvQRyG g9wI 9| #TIC 9|h :gO9VQE )p )!9v(WyG d9s
~g! d9s f{p ??GI #| xy {$ :O+ztAy9< ~wI #}y d9t* :d9s &!C )!R}yG
,~zf Q+j< :d9s fEh ,O+ztAyG : gO"f xyP B=FhC ?GJyG f} O+ztAyG {a<C
:E xyP uG eQI Osh ,dG(|}Gh LhQqyG BJ<Ch A9|OyG BsQC ~zp :&y {+s

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

232

#| )}zg| f} ?GJyG aQfC ~y fEh B=YC )!C ~zfC 9!C :d9s f{p ??GJ<
: &!} x}zg| O+zt@ #| )yhC x}zg| ~zg| O+zt@ :&y {+s .A9}zgyG Q9=v
B+qL ?GJ< :E x}zg| {t* ~y 9}v ,x}zg| )zf B+qL ?GJ< :E d(t*
)AI xyPv ~C &}zg| ~zg| O+zt@ )yE &}zg| O+zt@ cQ@ ,~g! d9s f{p .x"f
r+v :&y {+sh ,&y(s ^t! xyP )<C f{p ,?<9JZyG #| ~y9gyG )yE )%A"*
k
QRiCh Q=vC ($ #| O+zt@ R(G* :h ,9}zf {sCh QjYC ($ #| O+zt@ R(G*
k
O(gT| #<G #fh y~y9gyG ?yR #| QPI &!Cz | uG d(SQ #f ihQ Osh ?9}zf
: &!{p ,Qqv Qqv fEh ,#|B #|B fE ;FQ &"*O ~vOIC fOzt* :z :d9s &!C
.v$G yQWyG )p I(SC

9 Q+ih ?+y(Y}G ~%=Av #| H9Av 9| Q+i )p GhQvPh A9}zgyG uq@G Osh


($ ~y9gyG 9}!Eh A9Ap:Gh A9]tyG )y(* fC R(G* :h ,~y9g< U+y Ozt}yG fC
9|h ,xyP :E ?GI : | &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av ?GJyGh ?GJyG >I9Y
.9}%+yE &gFQ}p S9+s hC Y9=E #| f9v
:$

:?y9SQyG H9Av

)p

)gp9WyG d9s

&<9Av )p d9tp ,&y(SQ #"Sh &+Ih Y9=@G S9"yG )zf {Fh Rf uG VQqp

JI
H GFED CBA @
{
X W
V U T S{ d9sh }C
O N ML
K
dc b
a ` _^] \[ ZY
r
qp o nm l k j ih
g
fe
7 6 5 4 321 0
/ . -{ d9sh }R ts
C
BA@?>
= < ; : 98
x w v ut
s r
q p { d9sh }fED
n m l kj i
h
gf
{ d9sh }{z
y

233

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

}| { z y xw v ut
s r
qp o
- ,
+*
) ( '&% $ # " ! ~
:987 6 5 4 321 0
/ .
[Zty }
E D CB
A@?> =< ;
x w v u tsr
qp o n ml { d9sh
.}
} |{ z y
:

G]

P
Q

[50-48

)yE ~$A9fO fC :?*6G gP$ )p S9"yG uG ~zfzp :)gp9WyG d9s


GP{p uG d(SQ ~%"+< ~v9JyG f} ,uG ~wI )yE A9fO ~%"+< ~wJ+y &y(SQh
&}wI fC ~%}zfC &!Ch ,uG VQq< &y G(}zS 9}!{p| )="yG ~wJy G(}zS
gO9gSE #| gD9"C {F &}zf )p u=S 9|h &}wI &\GQApG )"g| )zf ,&}wI
&\Qp ~wIzp ,gQ|C &f9=@Gh ,&A*GO$ #| &< &y O%V 9|h ,&t+p(@h &A}Zg< g9*E
fC ~%}zfC fC ~%y h}Gp ,&Af9_ 98C ~%|;fEh &y(SQ ?f9_ &tzL eGRy9<
~C ,&Af9_ &y(SQ ?f9_ fCh ,9g| &y(SQ Q|Ch gQ|C Y9=@G ~%+zf VQqyG
.v$C gD9"C {F .gQ|C Y9=@G | &y(SQ )zf VQp &!C ~%}zfC
uG

~AIh | &y(SQ ?f9_ S9"yG )zf VQp uG fE :QLB h\(| )p d9sh


~C uG H9Awy :E VQp &!E :d(ty d9t* fC R(G* ;p ,gQ|C Y9=@G S9"yG )zf
uG d(SQ< f9}* G {gF gD9"C {F uG fC #| 9"qYh 9}y xyPh uG d(SQ ?"S
,OGQC 9| )"g| {Fh Rf uG #f ?"+=| uG d(SQ ?"Sh ,&< f9}* 9< 9!hQt|
{gG* ~yh ,g9*E 9%g=@zp &<9Aw< 96 ?}wJyG fQs ~C ,&|9fh &Y9L )zf ;+yOh
.v$G .| &y(SQ Q+i &tzL #| OI} GP$
:?+@6G JGQ]}yG JzW!

#*Ozt}yG O(}F #|h

?+|;S G ?g*QWyG {J| ?+G!Qp:G #+!G(tyG d(zI -1


.?+fQWyG ~v9J}yG dO< IQ+=v ?+z$C ~v9J| A9W!E -2

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

234

;ayGh Y9\QyG )p ?+ZMV {F9T| IOf )zf ?+fQWyG ~v9J}yG QZs -3


.xyP )yE 9|h ?tq"yGh LGhRyGh
O* #| LQL JGQ*RgAyGh b(tJyG QF9Sh dG(|}Gh A9|OyG )p ~wJyG -4
.x8yhC fhO ?tDyG ~%+p Bg\hh f(!9tyG I9]s )yE YQWyG I9]s
9$O+tp #| RfC )zf 9}6 )w<} 9%=zsh A9T"MyG #+g< )y #}p
9%A|A;| eOgy ?+fQWyG ~v9J}yG ~wI #| #+}zT}yG #| Q+Dv Q|P@ -5
9*9]sh ,#|RyG GP$ Q+i #|Ry B!9v e9wIC )zf 979]s O(=h ,QZgyG MhQ
{wyh #|R {wy ?|9f OfG(s #w@ ~zp ,9%A]AsG dG(ICh ,?Y9L ahQc 9%y
~wJyG {FC #| ~$O:hC G(zAs A9<6G #| GQk +Dv fE )AI ~*QwyG fBQty9v ,S9!
k
,&FhR b(tI #| &+zf 9}y 9_9tSE #*OyG #| LQL #| ~%"|h ,?tq"< ~%+zf
k
JQDvh ,&FhR ?tq"< &y ?}wJ}yG ?=y9a| #| GQGQp O;=yG #| LQL #| ~%"|h
)yE VQ}G BG\ )AI ,#+|9J}yG >@9w| )p uTqyGh QhRyG O(%Vh {+JyG
.#+|9J}yG {+Ih I9]tyG O(= #| 96Q
#+}y9gA}yG ^g< fE )AI ,| uG d(SQ 9%"gy )AyG J;zJ}yG {}f -6
.E+=MyG VQjyG GP%y S(+Ay9v :9FQ PMA* iQtyG )p
e(zgzy #+}zgA}yG f{p ,O(}GyG >=T< )|;S G #*OyG #f Q+q"AyG -7
?+<Qh}G ?p9tDyG )p f(gz]A}yG ~%"| 9Yk (ZLh ,O*OGyG H%"}yG ,zf ?D*OJyG
.&+yE #+=TA"}yG #| : &Tq! #*OyG ?g+=_ #| xyP fC f("d* ?+<Qh}G e(zgyGh
.E*OJyG {tgyGh QwqyG {$C Qd! #| A9}zgyG W(tS -8
.9%"f S9"yG ~$O9g<Eh ~$Q+i ~$OYh ?"TyGh H9AwyG #f ~$Og< -9
?*O9}yG J9<(tgyGh #AqyG YG(!z< xyP >=T< ~%+zf uG >]i -10
.?+IhQyGh
b

235

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

P6 #*OyG #f ~$hQq! hC ~$(z\C #}| ~$Q+i QRhh ~$QRh {}I -11


.O(}GyG
:)y9g@ &y(s {D| )p ?*GO%yG eOfh {%Gy9< ~%+zf fBQtyG IO9%V -12
G

dc b
a ` _^]
\[
Z
Y X WV o
.
? *6 O 9 } y p ! @
!vuy m l kj
i
hg
f
e
]104

G :I F

G[

9}$Q<O@ eOg< ?"TyGh H9AwyG d9}$E -13


f9|RyG GP%y ?"TyGh H9AwyG ?+I;Y eOg< ~%"| )z}gyG aGQAf:G -14
.?|9+tyG e(* )yE gOg< 9|h
H9AwyG ~%p )zf QOt* #| O(Fh eOg< ~%"| )y(tyG aGQAf:G -15
.&+p 9| GP$ )ph ,9}%"| W9="AS:Gh ?"TyGh
.~$Og< O%AG| ;p ,?}F}G Og< #| uG ?}IQ H9< OS -16
OOG* #| ?"S ?F9| {v SCQ )zf Eg=* uG fEz E*OJ< >*PwAyG -17
.g(J!h y9%"*O Q|C ?|}G gP%y
f} ,9fQV e(+yG rs(yG )p ~zgyG {$C &tJAT* 9| ~%p9tJASG eOf -18
: )fQWyG )"g}y9< A9}zgyG 96 OZt* 9}!E A9}zgyG )zf ?p(s(}yG a9sh}G
>=T< eGQJyG G(zvzp ,~%y d;I Q+i &!hPLz* 9| Q9Zp ,)I;aY:G )"g}yG
.~%z%F
~%qyGh ?"TyGh fBQtyG Q<O@ #f S9"yG ~%+8 )p UTtyG ~%A69W| -19
,IGQ(AyGh {+G!}G )p Qd"yG #f )%"yG OVC f(%"* UTtyG fC xyPh 9}%+p
~@Qqv ~Azgp fGh ,GP$ ~wy U+y :H9AwyG {$C #| ~8G(L: f(y(t*h
H9< OSh eG(gyG )zf A;gAS:G :E xyP< GhOGQC 9|h )?T+"wyG ~wAJzVh(
Q+i )yE Q|Gh}9< {}gyG )p ~$Q+Zt@h ~%q*Q; G(pQg* ;8y ~%+zf ~zgyG
.xyP
.

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

236

)y9g@ d9s .)}gy9< Ozt}yG &qYhh ,~zgy9< dOAT}zy fBQtyG IO9%V -20

n ml kj i
h
g
f
edc b
a `Wo
A
o &<9Av )p 96Q]* )AyG d9D|}G )p )y9g@ d9sh
?*6 OfQy p!@
! v~
.
?*6
(=w"gy pD
C
B
]19

]43

K}TyG )<C Q$9dyG O=f

G :J

G[

G :

G[

237

? +fQW y

v28:26v
[y9MyG

?S9+Ty

Gh

Y | h <9T y Og y y
#

G O

?+}v9Jy

G ) h} G

? Ty
"

#*OyG

)O+ztAyG QQ\h(

QJyG >+aLh e9|E K}TyG )<C Q$9dyG O=f N+WyG O$9G}yG P9AS~y(
)r*QWyG )w}yG

)p Q<OAyGh ;Q+wqAyG aGQZ!Gh ,d(tgyG O(vQ O+ztAyG QQ\ #| f9v Oty


.?g<Q}G ?}F}G Og< uziC Os O9%AF:G H9< fz< d(tyGh ,?"TyGh fBQtyG
u*Q_ )p IQDf QGI #*Ozt}yG a(sh :O+ztAyG xyP QQ\ #| f9v Otyh
.?|~y eOt@ {v {+=Sh ,M;YE {v
)|;S G YQWyG {J| iQW=yG f(!9tyG {I fC gQQ\ #| f9v Otyh
#*OyG #| ?*(+!OyG O$9g}yG )p #+}zgA}yG )Zq@h ,ih9}TyG f(!9tyGh
,~%y9D|C O+ztA< ~%wT}@h ,f9|RyG GP$ A9}zf O(}Gy xyPh ;&y ~$Q9w!Eh
ahQc Q+i J9T<;|h ahQc 9%y B!9v G(]| eG(sC AGQ5< ~$PLCh
R+zw!:G A9}zf OIC d9s 9}v r_9MyG PL}G GP6 ~%p .f9|RyG GP$ J9T<;|h
fEh ?|OtA}yG fhQtyG {$C #| ;~$G(S AGQBh ,~$Q+i d(tg< f(W+g* :~%+p
.S9"yG h| f(W+g* QZgyG GP$ )p ~%|9TFz< G(!9v
dG(|}Gh A9|OyG )p ~wJyG Y9+\ :O+ztAyG gQv F iPyG ~+dgyG QQ]yG #|h
LGhRyG )p ~wJyG :E ~%y u=* ~y )AI #*Ozt}yG iO*C #| J;|9g}yGh
&=A"* ~y GPG #+G!QqA}yG )gT< 9]k *C >$P+S GP$h .J9tq"yGh b;ayGh
.~$OVQ )yE G(<(D*h ~%y(tf )yE GhO(g*h fhOzt}yG
)AI #*OyG d(I &=WyG IQ9CE #*Ozt}yG O(=h O+ztAyG QQ\ #| f9v Otyh
f(=za*h ,QZgyG GP%y ?+I;ZyG eOfh ~tgy9< &!(|Q* G(J=YC PG &z$C #|
O}J| 9"+="< ?y9SQyG ~AL uG fC IQhQ]y9< #*OyG #| e(zg|h .9}F;| GOk *OF

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

238

?|9+tyG e(* )yE f9w|h f9|R {wy 9Jy9Y ~*QwyG fBQtyG dR!C GPyh ,|
?"TyGh fBQtyG ~%p #w}* : :fhOzt}yG d(t* PE xyP )p9"* O+ztAyG #wyh
A9}zgyG )]| Os f(y(t*h &!(zz]*h 9}%+p ~%q* #| {v fhQqw* {< fhQw"*h
.~%qyG )zf fhQOt* #*PyG
Q9"}yG >I9Y 9\Q O+VQ O}J| O+TyG e(IQ}yG ?|;gyG 9!P9ASC QvP Osh
iP e9d! {}f ~%+yE >z_h ;?f9= Q$R}G A9}zf #| HOA!G 9V9< {+f9}SG fC
-&y uG Qqi- f9vh ,~v9J}yG )p &< {}gzy ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG #| OG(|
;GhRGgp gOz< )p )|;S G YQWyG )zf iQW=yG f(!9tyG )ja* fC )WM*
i(*OMyG &p9L 9| hshh .?"TyGh H9Awy9< ~%}zf eOfh ~$O+ztAy xyPh
($ ?+|;S G QZ| ~v9J| )p )T!QqyG f(+z<9! f(!9s K=YCh ,{+f9}SG
QF {$h ,GP$ #| OVC Q9"Vh Q9f izp ,&< f(}wJ* 9!D9"<C K=YCh ,Y9a}yG
.AG(S Q9}JyGh Ozt}yG fE ,O+ztAyG Q+i xyP
#| &+=! CQ<h ;)%"yG OVC &"f uG )8 iPyG #*OyG bQq@ O+ztAyG QQ\ #|h
F
ED CBA @?>o d(t* E+I ~%"*O #+sQq}yG
C
B A
@ ?> =
o )y9g@ d9sh
?*6 9g!} pG
,

]159

.p!@
! xw

G :e

G[

K J
I HG
FE D

)AyG ?}g"y9< Qqv ($h ,Q+wqAyGh {tgyG ?q+ch d9a<E O+ztAyG QQ\ #|h
PLCh ,Q+wqAyGh {tgyG ?q+ch Bza< GPEh ,fG(+JyG QF9S #f f9T! G 96 R9A|G
#| &8aLh ;gOVQh &+ih ,&"+}Sh &Di #+< R++}@ Q+j< h}T* 9| {v AQ}yG
#*OyG )p dG(sCh YO< &+zf {LO* &!} ,&"*O QF9Sh gOF9tf JOTp ,&<G(Y
k
uGh ,J(}* )AI GPw$ {d*h ,96G(Y GOtAg| 9%z=t* {< ,9<G(Y 9%"d+p
?> =<;!@
!vux : 9 876o GP$ d9D|C )p d(t*
)zf a(wgyG O+ztAyG QQ\ #|h p!@
!vuy ED C
B A@
~C B!9v (zp ,uG fhO #| 9%F9fOh 9%y QhP"yG ~*Ot@h ;9%z$C IO9=fh ,Q(=tyG

239

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q=s :h ,QGR@ ?=s B*CQ 9}y ,| &y(SQ e;vh uG e;v ~%q@h ,Qwq@ d(tf
k
B+=yG {$C A9}Sz< )}T| &+zf rwg* :9D}@ :h ,VQ}G )zf 9pQW|
.#+Jy9ZyGh
#$O+ztAy JGQF9< J9wA%A| #J=YC A9T"yG fC O+ztAyG QQ\ #|h
{sh ,VGQf}G Bf9]p ,O9TqyG )p 9]g< #%]g< O+zt@h ;J9+G!Qp:G
?<Qa]| bQWyG )p ?+f9}AF:G ?y9JyG BJ=YCh ~|}G IQ+LP ($ iPyG {T"yG
.A9"qyG hs(@h )S}Gh uztyG )yE (fO@
f(vQA*h ,~6QG(Vh ~$9Jy f(tzJ* d9FQyG fC O+ztAyG QQ\ #|h
Ej@h ;gQd"| K=t* 9}| ,~$QL9"| J9JAp )zf IQPtyG ?<9<PyG {D| H!Qp:9v
k
f9T!E &!z< &=I9Y Q(gV eOf ?TLh ?=Sh GQ9f O+ztAy9< )qvh ,&A*DQ< Uq"yG
iQ* &!Ch ,&A|}h &y U9MyGh e9gyG hq"yG &+p iQ*h {}g*h Qwq* fC >G*
k
.gOzs #}| [t!C &!Ch QwqyG {tAT| f(w* f} ;$C U+y &Tq!
)p ,9+!OyGh #*OyG )p QQ\ {v fC ?y9GgyG gP$ )p d(tyG iQ9Zsh
O+ztAyG 9Wp GPEh .O+ztAyG #| :9$Q+ih e(zgyGh b;L}Gh O9ZAs:Gh Y9}AF:G
k
.)O+ztAyG QPI9p( c;%yG 9%y 9ttJ| f9v ?|C )p
Gk

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

240

Y K}Ty < Q 9dy O=f N Wy 9t|

v24:21v

G ( C

[y9MyG

G d

Og y y

9 O

G ) h} G

? Ty
"

#*OyG

Qaq*h GOk }f I;ZyG f(vQA* ?f9= hC OQp {v #| CQ=A* [y9MyG #*OyG


.IQOtyG h| f(GJ* :h QPf Q+j< f9]|Q )p
9!R #| uG eQI 9| f(J+=* ?f9= hC OQp {v #| CQ=A* [y9MyG #*OyG
.xyP Q+ih Q}Lh
98(}T* 9fO< #*OyG )p f(fOA=* ?f9= hC OQp {v #| CQ=A* [y9MyG #*OyG
.?"TI
&ay9M* {}f {v #|h ,O=g* Q=s &+p OGT| {v #| CQ=A* [y9MyG #*OyG
.A9*Q
I:G(| {v #|h ;&zyG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJ* #| {v #| CQ=A* [y9MyG #*OyG
J(i9ayG )yE ~v9JA* #| {v #|h ,A9+}f ?+z$9F ?+=Zf {v #|h ;&zyG Q+jy
fh

>
=
<
;
:
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
]@?
}
|
{
z
y
x
+*)('&%$#"!~
{

]61

?*6G

:A

x
9T " y G [ }

.}

9"k F9v GOk IC iQ* fCh ,uG Q+jy dP* fC &< xT}A}zy )<z* [y9MyG #*OyG
k
f9v #| 9"F9v b(zM}< )SzA* fCh ,&"| &+yE >ICh ;&zyG #| ~dfC f9v #|
.| uG d(SQ Q+i
: 9| {gq* hC ,{gq* : 9| d(t* fC &< xT}A}zy )<z* [y9MyG #*OyG
lkj ih gf
e
d cba `{ Q||*

"

{gqyGh d(ty9< e;S

#p

.[3-2 :rZyG] }

onm

< 9J* QZgyG GP$ )p #+}zT}yG #| Q+Dv

G f( Q

241

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q=* [y9MyG #*OyGh ;S9"yG #| :h uG #| f(+JAT* :h ?<9aMyGh ?<9AwyGh


.~%+zf OQyG #f BwT* hC ~%A<Q9J| #f )\Q* : #}|h ,~%"| uG )yE
:~*QwyG fBQty9< f(D=g* -A9%qS ?z%F ~$h- ~zgyG A9+fOC #| Q+Dv
uG d(SQ #f ?A<9DyG ?J+JZyG U(Z"yGh ?+<QgyG ?jzyG ry9M* ;*hz@ &!(yh|*
~%"| Q+Dvh ,iQLC h\G(| )p ?s(T}yG 9%Tq! fBQtyG J9*B ry9M*h {< ,|
rg]y 96 f(qMAT*h ~$G($h ~9CQ OQG}< ?J+JZyG E*O9I}G fhOQ*
.?+p9gyG uG dzT! ,~6(zs k*Rh ,~%y(tf
#*OyG e(+yG K=YC Osh ;CO< 9}v 9=k *Qi O(g+Sh 9=k *Qi CO< [y9MyG #*OyG
?=zjy xyPh ,~7Q+Wfh ~%+z$C #+< )AI ,A9<Qi &z$Ch S9"yG #+< 9=k *Qi
.?"TyGh H9Awy9< e9ZAf:G eOfh ,#+y9]yG IQDvh ,9+!OyG >Ih i(%yG
9=k *Qi O(g+Sh :~%]g< d(s hsG(yGh ?jzy ry9M}yG O+g=yG {*hzAyG #| fEh
k
.?+|C )"< #| ~$Og< AGQ|:Gh ?<9JZyG O%f )p f9v 9}v GQk WA"| GR*Rf iC
k
k
fC OGQC yCO< 9}v 9=*Qi O(g+Sh 9=*Qi e;S G CO<z d9s 9}y | )="yG fE
k
#+< {J*h GOz< >*QjyG dR"* 9}v S9"yG #+< 9<QjAT| iC 9=k *Qi Q%c e;S G
76 5 4 3o :)y9g@ uG d(s xyP )zf dO*h ,~%"| U+y e(s
)p ?*9%"yG OI 9jy9< Q+=gAyG GP$ U+yC ?*6
p!@
!z : 98
.HGQjAS:G
,cQWyG >FG(V #| [y9MyG #*OyG GP$ fhQw"AT* f(vQW}yG f9v
k
)zf dO@ fBQtyG )p J9*B c9"$h ,GOIGh 9%yE ?%y6G f(w@ fC f(<QjAT*h
;&"_h #f O+g=yG )>*QjyG( ?jzyG )ph .| )="yG &< A9F 9| ~6GQjASG
)@z* f;p :d9t*h ,~%qyG O+g=yGh gQ+ih e;wyG #| a(yz}yG Q+ih >+GgyGh
.y?=*Qiz h= >FGQjy9<
#|h ?w| {$C O"f a(yz| Q+i iC y9=k *Qi e;S G CO<z | )="yG d(tp
C

]5

G :U[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

242

9}v AGP* G OVC ghPBh | )="yG G(|h9s xyPyh ;cQWyG #| ~%"*O )zf f9v
($ QF9$ )AIh ,&zAs )zf G(g=C )AI ?q*QWyG &@Q+S )p B=D| ($
dhC )p GQk S uG )yE (fO* | )="yG f9v xyPyh ,?<GQjyG )$ gP%p ,&<9JYCh
.&A<GQjy xyP {vh ,&<9JYC QDv )AI Q|}G
9}v S9"yG #+< &A<Qi )yE 9=k *Qs O(g* #*OyG fC iC yCO< 9}v 9=k *Qi O(g+Shz
Q|C )p e;S G f(fO* #}| Q+Dv )yE BCO; GPE x!{p ;e(+yG hsG(yG ($
k
#+=* ~y GP9}yh ,>*Qi A)V GP$ fE :G(y(t* )AI GOF xyP G(<QjASG O+I(AyG
9"F9<B )p GP6 9"g}S 9| ,f(zgq* xyPv 9!A9<B 9!OFh 9!Eh ?xyP A9}zgyG 9"y
#| xyP (J!h ,H9$(yG O=f #< O}J|h ?+}+@ #<G :E GP$ YOA=* ~y ,#+yh}G
)p B"g|C GP{p .~%}%p eOfh &< ~%CO; 9| ?<GQjy :E xyP 9|h ;e;wyG
k
)p | )="yG d(t* xyPyh ,GO*Q_ 9=k *Qi ~%"+< JQYh chQw!C &+yE I(fOyG
9%]g< )ph - A9<Qjzy )<(ap :yCO< 9}v 9=k *Qi O(g+Shz &y(s Og< iQLC ?*GhQ
hC ,S9"yG O9Tp O"f f(JzZ* #*PyG d9s ?&zyG d(SQ 9* ~$ #| {+sz
.yS9"yG OTpC 9| f(JzZ*
A9F ~C LQG(MyG fQs ~G! P"| &+yE JO9f #*OyG ?<Qi fC O(Zt}yGh
uG J9qY )p V(MyG QDvh ,J9qZzy fhQw"}yG ?+}%GyG ~C ,?yRAg}yG
{v f9vh ,9$QhO ?+!9!(+yG ?qTzqyG B=gyh ,OF9tgyG )ph ,9@k 9=CEh 9+k q! )y9g@
9%F9fO ~C 9%}+dg@h Q(=tyG ?fO=< Q|}G )%A!Gh ,J9qZyGh A9}S}G d(I xyP
K=YCh ?<QjyG B}Ap Q+=wyG &+zf H9Vh ,Q+jZyG xyP )zf )<Qh ,9%yQP"yGh
&< uG rYh 9}< f9}* 9< ~zgyG O+I(@ ($ iPyG [y9MyG #*OyG )yE )fGOyG
IO9=gyG U;LE ($ iPyG {gqyG O+I(@h ,{*hz@ :h r*Q; ;< &y(SQh &Tq!
k
k
H9tyz< R="* 9=*Qi )fGOyG GP$ K=YC- ;v(@h ?C9jASGh GQP!h A9fO :&zy
.#*Qp9wyG QqvC #| f(y9]yG gOg*h ,A(TyG
,Q9as}G {v B}f 9%"wyh ,Qas fhO Qas )p #*OyG ?<Qi #w@ ~yh

243

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QgyG IQ*RFh R9GJyGh e9WyGh QZ|h ;HQjyGh bQWyG xyP )p AG(Sh


k
,Y9aASG 9| {w< uG {+=S )p O$9F GOOG| 9%y uG ^+s fC :(y ;9%zv
k
u O}JyGh GQk ]Ih GhO< IQ*RGyG Y(<Q O+I(AyG ~f )AI ;gO9qIC )p cQ9<h
.gOIh
Otp .hW* gQ(!h Q%d* &@(Y PLCh QWA"* uJyG CO< Otp QZ| )p 9|Ch
N+WyG Q=v}G P9AS}G ~p #| ?LQ9ZyG O+I(AyG I(fO )(*OGQyG( Y9*P}yG 9"g}SC
#| O%W| )zfh dh}G bhQ9p Ky9ZyG xz}yG IQ]I )p ~+dgyG )iGQ}yG
.Q$R}G A9}zf Q9=v
#*OyG )yE 9%+p YGO {wp O;=yG QF9Sh e9WyGh bGQgyGh O"%yG )p 9|Ch
.&+zf H(]j| >*Qi (%p [y9MyG
dhC f9v 9}v gOG|h gRf e;S5y O(g* fC )=zs ~+}Y #| >IC )!E
E*OJyG {*hz@ #wyh &y {}g*h xyP O(* e;S G K+JY ~zT| {vh .Q|}G
.~zgyG {$C gQt* fC )j="* : bzi hC U+=z@ :?t+tJyG Q*Qt@h
d9ty gRfh gOG| )yE e;S G O(f :d9s 9}< | d(SQyG O(Zt| f9v (yh
k
G(gFQ@ :z d9s 9}yh yCO< 9}v O(g+Shz 9$(J! ?}zv hC yGR*Rf e;S G CO<z
)zf :E ?f9TyG e(t@ :z d9s 9}yh y^g< H9sQ ~w]g< HQ]* GQk9qv iOg<
iP d(I ShO A9T! J9+yE RA7 )AI ?f9TyG e(t@ :z d9s 9}yh yhwy #< hwy
)A|C #| e98p O=g@ )AIh -?+z$9GyG )p O=g* f9v ~"Y ~SG- ?ZzMyG
{FQyG K=Z* :~zd}yG {+zyG hatv 9"k Ap d9}f}9< GhQO9<z d9s 9}yh yf9Ch}G

T
H

)1(

: )bhQ9p xz}yG f9azS )p U+y ($h( )w}yG eQJyG e9|E K}TyG (<C Q$9dyG O=f N+WyGh )1(
{<- &"| 9pk (L hC &+yE 9qk yR@ &zyG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* : iPyG O;=yG xz| #f gP%v ?}zv d(t*
O}J| N+WyG QZ<h h}S B; QW"*h >Aw* e;wyG GP$ fC ~zfCh -xyP RG(F OtAg* &!}
h| )w}yG eQJyG e9|E )zf :h ?f9}GyG N(+V )zf : Qw"* ~yh ?*O(gTyG )Aq| ~+$GQ<E #<
.Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G )zf
& YQ I

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

244

t* #| VQ}G )ph ?f9TyG e(t@ :z d9s 9}yh E*OJyG yGQk p9v )T}*h 9"|||
.Q+Dv xyP Q+i )yE yuG uG
,e;wyG &Fh Q+i )zf | &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Awy f(yh|}yG )%A"* {%p
)zf HPw@ GP9}y :&y {+s Osh | uG d(SQ )zf HP9wyG d9s 9}v f(y(t* eC
9}!E :d9tp ?)qw*h xyP #f )"j* 9| &"f OQG(yG K+JZyG )ph | uG d(SQ
!&+zf : &y HPvC
9$DQt* : ,S9"yG #+< ?=*Qi 9$GQ@ BTyC ,i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| gP%p Og<h
9$Q*Q; U+FQ ?z+]p fC (yh ,[y9MyG #*OyG f(=J* #*PyG uJyG {$C :E
J;G}yG QF9Tv Q(%}GyG 9$G(9 )AyG J9p9MTyGh J9wJ]}y9< 9$~|
9%y f9wy ;gQ+i h"Z* 9}v ,9%+p Q(%}GyGh ?|9gyG #$GO hC )g9V9Ih( ?g+zMyG
#wyh ,9%|(* )p JOq!h a(y}G JGQWf 9%"| h=ayh ,QLB fzV e(+yG
)zf | &y(SQh &<Q 9\Q QC|| ;96 QhQT| ($h ,?<QjyG gP6 )\Q P9AS}G
k
.&y9D|C A9<Qjzy )<(_h ,&y 98+"%p ,S9"yG 9\Q
d(

K } T y G (< C

245

? +fQW y

K}TyG

(<C Q$9dyG

O=f ?|;gyG

J:9t|

)zf

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

u zg@

#*Ozt}yG O(= #|hz )yh}G ?y9t}yG )p &y(s #| N+WyG ?z+]p 9"$ gQvP 9|
?+|;S G ?g*QWyG {J| ?+G!Qp}G #+!G(tyG d(zI -1 ?+@}G JGQ]}yG JzW!
?|;gyG 9!P9ASC QvP Oshz ?+!9DyG ?y9t}yG )p xyPv &y(s #|h yNyE ...
#| HOA!G 9V9< {+f9}SG fC Q9"}yG >I9Y 9\Q O+VQ O}J| O+TyG e(IQ}yG
?+|;S G ?g*QWyG #| OG(| iP e9d! {}f ~%+yE >z_h ?f9= Q$R}G A9}zf
O}J| P9AS}G 9]k *C e;wyG GP$ {D| QvPh yNyG ... ~v9J}yG ,p &< {}gzy
)p 41 vY 14 OzG}yG #|9DyG OOgyG i(="yG iO%yG ?zG}< S(!Qf bO9Y
9%==S f9v uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG I9Sz|h -: d9s y~zgyGz fG("g< &Ay9t|
o
#| G(i(Z* fC )\9}yG fQtyG )p ~%"| >z_ 9|O"f #*Ozt}yG x8yhC #| u*Qp
k
k
)zf 9"z}Io G(=Tv 9}< G(Tz<C 9}zp QZgyG Q*9T* 9aT=| 9!(!9s #*OyG U(Z!
x o
)1 (
. y&z$C Q+i )yE OSh Q|}G f} xyP ?=+zGyG J(i9ayG #+!G(t< ~v9JAyG
.?+g\(yG #+!G(tyG IzW! #f IP=! AGRf}G AGQtzy #+=! fC )yE 9!(fO* GP$h

+Ty9<

)?S9

~wJyG(

&!C i(fO< ?g*QWyG e9wIC )zf LQM* ?+|;S G ?yhOyG AGQ|G ^g< f9v
N+V GP$ )yE Q9VC Osh ?S9+S LhQMyG GP$ )}T*h 9$O(t*h ?|}G S(T*
k
IQF9GyG J9S9+TyG #| 9fG(!C G(COIC 9}!E AGQ|}G ?|9fhz :d(t* E+I e;S G
?gFGQ}y ?g<Q}G >$GP}yG rzAM| #| Q$R}G A9}zf #| ?"Gy BzwV fC Q|}G {Yh {< )1(
:&+p A9F GQk *Qt@ ?"GzyG JOfzp ?+g\(yG #+!G(tyG gP$
k
VQ9g@ : 98C hC ?g<Q}G >$GP}yG OIC )p 9Z! upG(@ fC 9|E 9$O("=< #+!G(tyG gP$ fEz
Ky9Z}y ?*9fQ 9%+p O9%AF}G R(G* )AyG ?zSQ}yG Ky9Z}yG {+=s #| Q=Ag@ 98C hC 9%+p 9Zk !
.?*QZ}yG >AwyG QGO )p O(F(| Q*QtAyG GP$h yS9"yG
)zf Q*QtAyG GP$ iOY 9!OFh xyPyh .9%g*QW@h ?|}G )zf O+ztAyG )"F r+v ~A*CQC
.%90 ?=T"< ?t=a| ?g*QWyG fE f(y(t* 9}"+I 9!QZf A9}zf ^g< ?"TyC

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

246

>=TyG #+<v h yR(: : ~FGQGyG )zf J9<(tfh 9$PLG R(G* : dG(|C PLC #|
ahQg}y9< Q|}G #| YhQW}yG )p G(_Qp ~8}z d9tp GP$ )yE ~6 iOC iPyG
Z(T* E+I g(g\hh &]=s Z(T* 9| G(]=s (zp :Eh Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh
?fhQW}yG OhOJyG G(|9sCh ~%Tq!C ?S9*Q : uG #*O ?|9sE xyP< #+=y9_ &g\h
dOgzy ~%=+$Q@h ~%=+iQ@ )p #*QJA| O+g=yGh >*QtyGh h+\(yGh r*QWyG )zf
J9<(tgyG )yE :h ?f(\(}yG S(w}yG )yE G(F9AIG 9}y :&zyG &fQV iPyG
WGQZyG A9]AsG y#*O=gAT}yGh O+=gyG #| ~%dqJ* #| )yE :h IQF9GyG
?*O}J}yG ?"TyG ?g=a| 281 vY ~+tAT}yG
)p ?p;MyG JQ9Y 9}zpz 90vY ?"*O}yG {$C d(YC ?JY &<9Av )p d9sh
v
A9%tp #| gOzt@ #| A9]tyG ~%y Ozt@h S9"yG ?S9+S )yE G(F9AIGh S9=gyG Oyh
P8"+I G(F9AIG -:?yO9gyG ?S9+TyG )p 9+k p9v ~zgyG #| ~%g| 9| #w* ~yh bGQgyG
Q+Dv )p Q|}G ~c9g@h YQV ?*:h Q+i HQI ?*:h G(zgFh ~y9d}yG ?*:h )yE
&}ZL (fO* GP$h ?S9+TyGh YQWyG :d9t*o Q9Y )AI #+}zT}yG Q9Z|G #|
QL6Gh YQWy9< ~wJ* fC 9}k v9I Z(S ?S9+TyG )yE (fO* GP$h YQWyG )yE
.?S9+Ty9<
?"TyG ?pQg| )p GhQZs YQWyG )yE G(=TA!G #*PyG fC xyP )p >=TyGh
xqT@ )AI OhOJyG G(zafh b(tJyG G(g+\ G(}wI GPE IQ+Dv Q(|C JQ9Zp
GhQ9Y ?S9+TyG )yE G(=TA!G #*PyGh J9|QJyG M9=AT@h dG(|}G PL|@h A9|OyG
iPyG ~$Q+Lh ?"TyGh H9Awy9< e9ZAfG Q+i #| iCQyG #| Y("< f(S(T*
#|h i(tyG f(<9J*h i(%y9< f(}wJ* #| Q+Dvh dOgzy Q;h i($ ;< ~wJ*
.yxyP (J!h ~$(VQ*
)zf LQM*h f9a+WyG ~wJ< 9%FGQh #| ~wJ* ?Ap: ?S9+TyG BJ=YC Oty
)p ~wJ* : f9v >F9JyG fC x+y9}}yG O%f )p d9JyG kz< Oty #}IQyG ~wI
U9L &F(< Q9GAyGh f(*OyG {F9T| )p ~wJ* f9vh S9"zy Q+tIh {+zF {v

247

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

R*Qt}zy baMyG hFGQ y?S9+Tzy 9tk ph #wyh YQWzy 9tk ph :


iO*z< B+t< B!9v ?yhO Q=vC fC PFO"f AGQ|}G d9I B!9vhz iOhO(}yG d(t*h
QZ| )p x+y9}}yG ?yhO )$ ~8GhOfh QAAyG JGQ9i #| ?}+zS #+}zT}yG
9}$OIC #+}Ts )zf ~%AyhO f(!9s G(}Tv s G(!9v x+y9}}yG A:|$h e9WyGh
{Zq* f9wp KGQ+}yGh b;ayGh M9w"yG Q(|C )p &@QFGO QZJ"@ )ZMV f(!9s
.YQWyG e9wIC >TJ< 9%+p
)}Ts B; ?zLGOyG S9"yG f(8V h+}G< b+J* )!O| f(!9s QL6Gh
)zf 9|k 9}@ )"=| ($h .&zv ?yhOyG e9d! )zf Qa+T*h J9*9"GyGh b(tJyG
k
f(!9s #| O;=yG )p 9GFGQ f9v 9| fC )yE xyP aQaA}yG iR+w"GyG Q(ASOyG
G(!9wp f(}v9JyG x+y9}}yG 9|Ch 9*9fQyG ?|9gy :E #w* ~y )ZMWyG YQWyG
)p iO}J}yG YQWyG : iR+w"GyG f(!9tyG ?+ZMWyG ~$Q(|C )p )AI f(g=A*
.dG(I}G >ziC
#| iR*Qt}yG gGhQ 9| x=TI e;S5y VQ9g}yG ~%v(zS ?+q+v QOt@ )wy
B!9vh 9tk za| ~$O;< )p A9j=yG QhO e9+s )p G(!PC Os G(!9v x+y9}}yG fC
~dg| f9v ,?+|;S G ?yhOyG d9| B+< 9%zLO YO(* ?=*Q\ 9*9j=yG )zf B<Q\
)p RJ* ~zp ?yhOyG gP$ )zf ?y9f ?+p(ZyGh A9}zgyG #| ?+}+@ #<G QY9f #|
)|;S G #*OyG 9%+p f9v )AyG ?8+TyG d9JyGh ?=w"yG gP$ {v ~%"| OIGh Uq!
?Aj< ?+}JyGh ?q!}G ~7PLC M;Y5y )gT* ?+}+@ #<G e9| G e9s 9}y &"wyh
#f aQJ"| &+=WAyGh ~+TGAy9< d(t* {]| d9\ {FQyG GP$ fC f(Aq* GhOjp
gOt"< #+g<9AyGh ?<9JZyG )zf AhQG* &z$Ch a(ZAzy hOf rzTyG u*Q_
fz< ?t+zMy &@9qy||h &=Av fCh I;ZyG &qzL R(: ;p A9+VC #*OyG )p uzAM*h
)zf uzfh ?y9SQyG ?TS|| )75 - 74( U iOhO(}zy #*OyG O*O: ybQ;
?yhO #f &zt!h iOhO(}yG gQvP 9|hz &y(t< iO9$ #< h+<Q v Q(AvOyG xyP
&y9s 9| 9|Gh &g\h #T; Os ?+}+@ #<G O%f )p ~v9JyG {gyh ~zT}p x+y9}}yG
)1(

)357 / 3( i

?+g\(yG #+!G(tyG : ?+%y6G ?g*QWyG hFGQ

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

248

)AyG ?8+TyG d9JyGh ?=w"yG gP$ {v ~%"| OIC Uq! )p Rq J* ~zpz A9}zgyG #f
#| c9"$ f9v Otp Qd! ~+}gAyGh b;_ G GP$ )qp y)|;S G #*OyG 9%+p f9v
KY9"*h ?=w"yG gP$ &Tq! )p Rq J* #| iOtf aGQJ!G #| ~%+p 9| )zf A9}zgyG
.?s9ayG OhOI )ph ?}wJy9< e9wJyG A:|$
cQWyG ?69G|h O+I(AyGh ?"TyG ?*GQ hpQ< ?+}+@ #<G e9| G e9s 9}y ~C
d;]yGh A(TyG A9}zf #| Q+Dv &+zf h"Vh &\Q9fh &\QAfG YO=yGh d;]yGh
)p gQZ"*h gO*|* #| S9"yG ?|9fh A9}zgyG #| OFh &Tq! Bs(yG )p &"wyh
e9wJyG &yPL fGh 9$Q+ih bGQgyGh e9WyGh QZ| )p ?"TyGh O+I(AyG ?*GQ {}I
.v154vY ~YG(gyG y&|(ZL GhQZ!h f9+I}G >ziC )p
-:)!O}yG ?g=_ 15 vY y?+}wJyG bQayGz &<9Av )p ~+tyG #<G d(t*h
Q|z< :E ~$Q|C ~%y ~+tAT* : S9"yG fCh xyP Q(|}G I:h iCQ 9}zpz
k
;*(_ GQk V ~79S9+S Y9\hC #| G(COIC ?g*QWyG #| A:|$ &}%p 9| AGQh
k
k
YQWyG uF9tJ< #+z|9gyG )zf Rfh &vGQOASG QPg@h Q|}G ~s9qAp 9]*Qf GO9Tph
iQLC ?qF9_ B_QpCh xy9%}yG xz@ #| 9$P9t"ASGh xyP #| S(q"yG [+z<
9Azvh .&y(SQh uG ~wI )p9"* 9| xyP #| Bi(Tp ?qF9ayG gP$ Bz<9s
y&<9Av &< dR!Ch &y(SQ &< uG Eg< 9| ?pQg| )p 9$Q+Zt@ #| B+@C #+AqF9ayG
:?y9SQyG

?g=_

)308 / 1(

?*h9JayG

MQ9V d9sh

Q 9Gy 9S9 Ty9< ?vgv*QvWvyG )vzvf f(v\QvAvgv* IQvF9vGvyG c(vzv}vy9vpz


~$h - A(TyG Q9=ICh .&y(SQh uG ~wI )zf 98(|Ot*h 96 98(\Q9g*h
{+z; ?"}]A}yG IOS9qyG ~%AT+sCh ~%FGQ5< - ?g*QWyG #f f(FQ9MyG A9}zgyG
b;_Eh gQ=AfG 9| A9jyEh g9jyC 9| Q9=AfGh &I9<C 9| ~*Q;h &y(SQh uG eQI 9|
.xyP (J!h &tz_C 9| O++t@h gO+s 9|
I vF v v G J v v+v v v

)1 (

)zf VGQAf 9<z ~%y &qYh #| ~iQy9< yIQp9wyGz {t* ~yh yIQF9GyG c(z}y9pz &y(s eI:
.&y(SQh &zyG ~wI )zf 9%}*Ot@h y)?+g\(yG #+!G(tyG )"g*( J9S9+Ty9< ?g*QWyG

)1(

249

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QWyGh f9}* G uF9tI )zf f(\QAg}yG ?p(ZA}yG d9%F ~$h f9=$QyGh


YQV ?"}]A}yG ?+!9a+WyG ?z_9=yG J9p(WwyGh J:9+MyGh O+FG(}yGh bGhP}9<
#f V(gAyGh | &+=! f9Ty )zf &fQV iPyG &"*O d9a<Eh uG &< fPz* ~y #*O
c(z}yG )"g*( f(yh}G d9tp Uq"yG X(dIh f9a+WyG YOM< f9}* G uF9tI
GPE fhQL6G d9sh ?S9+TyG 9"|Os YQWyGh ?S9+TyG B\Q9g@ GPE )IQF9GyG
bhPyG VQ9g@ GPE bhPyG H9JYC d9sh {tgyG 9"|Os {t"yGh {tgyG VQ9g@
&|Ry #+yh}G Qqv #}p d(sCh yrWwyGh bhPyG 9"|Os YQWyG Q$9ch rWwyGh
.NyG ... ?fOA=}yGh ?+p(ZyGh #*Ozt}yGh #+}zwA}yG #| #*QL6G Qqw* fC
Y

?+!9}DgyG ?yhOyG e9*C d9JyG ($ 9}p x+y9}}yG QZf #f u=S iPyG GP$

?yhOyG e9wI h\h ?S9+TyG ~S9< 9]k *C {< GQk +Dv rzAM* ~y Q|}G d(t!
?yhOyG e9+s #| Qw=| Bsh )p ?+|;S G ?g*QWzy ?qy9M| #+!G(s IOf ?+!9}DgyG
K@9qyG O}J| ($ xyP< CO< #| dhC fC #+LQ|}yG ^g< ~fR {< ?+!9}DgyG
.)y9g@
?+"+a"aTtyG KAp iPyG ~+dgyG f9azTyG &Tq!
O}J| fC ?+zgyG ?yhOyG N*Q9@ )p )|9J}yG x< O*Qp O}J| >Av Otp
)!O}yG f(!9tyG O9=| h\h )e1481 - 1429( ?+"+a"aTtyG K@9p )!9DyG
#+gy9< #+gyGh #Ty9< #TyG iC ?+!O=yG J9<(tgyG dO<zp J9<(tgyG f(!9sh
f9}+zS f9azTyG 9%}@C ?J\Gh ?+q+w< ?*Ot"yG J9|GQjyG 9%\(f {gFh
y)!(!9tyG
. 178 vY ?+zgyG ?yhOyG N*Q9@
#f QOY Os dh}G )!9}DgyG h*QWAyG fCz &k @9JV u+qV Q(AvOyG QvPh

)1(

#f QtV}G Q(AvOyG d(t*h f(!9tyG )yE ?=T! y)!(!9tyGz >tz< &=+tz@ )p >=TyG ($ GP$h
gP$ G(afC f(+!9}DgyG e9wJyG f9v (yz #++T!Qqzy gO%f )p BJ"| )AyG ?+="F}G JGR9+A|}G
k
f9}+zS f9azTyG OG! 9"wyh GQPf ~%y9!OF(y ?}*R%yGh rg]yG d9I )p JGR9+A|}G
?+!9}DgyG ?yhOyG B!9vh )e1535( e9f )p ?+T!QqyG ?yhOzy JGR9+A|}G gP$ K"}* )!(!9tyG
.y97(s LhCh 9%A}df ?}s )p Bs(yG xyP )p

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

250

?"S )yG(I JG("S h]=< ?+"+a"aTtyG KAp Og< K@9qyG O}J| f9azTyG
9|k 9wICh IQGO5y 9}k +d"@ #}]A* )?|9! f(!9s( #f IQ9=f f9vh )e 1455(
OfG(tyG ^g< 9%"| Q+gAT*h ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG QvP* ($h J9<(tgy9< ?tzgA|
k
k
k
f9vh ;|9v 9+F9"F 9!(!9s KOJAT*h hsG(yG )p 9%"f OgA=* &"wyh .?+S9S}G
dO<z 98C QvP* ?+y9| J9|GQi OhOJy9< dO=ASG GPE ?|9! f(!9tyG h\Gh
QO$C &!C Q+i yJ9*9"GyG {<9t| )p ?S9+TyGz {+=s #| 98C iC y?+S9+TyG
k
gP$ )p OJyGh {+MyG ?sQS O"f :E OJyG e9t* : ?sQTyG )qp 9|9}@ b(tJyG
Og< 9!RyG 9|C ?d$9< ?|GQi )!9GyG ~*QjA< f(w* Osh O+yG hat< f(w* ?y9JyG
?|GQjyGh ~FQyG : ?|GQjyG &A<(tgp ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG e9wI} 9tk ph &@(=C
&A<(tf f{p QwTo yG GPvh LhRA| Q+i hC 9Fk hRA| )!GRyG f9v GPE 9}y 9gk =@ rzA<
9Zgy9< HQ\ #f IQ9=f &"wyh )\9tyG Q*OtAy cQA* : f(!9tyG ,p ($h Q*RgAyG
.y?+y9| ?|GQih
O}J| #f {t! 9| HPw* fC ?+%y G ?g*QWyG H9Av ry|| dh9I Osh
K@9qyG IQ+S e;S G AGOfC g(V Oshz d(t* f} Qa\G &"wyh
K@9qyG
~%F;AfG O"f ~8G(LE {As gOg< #| #+_;Tzy YQV &!C G(}fR 9|O"f Q+=wyG
xyP f(zgq* G(!9v ?z%GyG cGQ@}G #+_;S fC )q"! : #J!h ?azTyG TQf
y&"S hC GP$ {gp K@9qyG f(w* fC )q"! 9""wyh
#*R 9%\GQ|Ch 9%zzf JQDvh ?+!9}DgyG ?yhOyG Bqg\ 9|O"fhz d(t* ~C
97(=v #| V(%"yGh M;ZyG 9%y fhO*Q* ~8C f(fO* G(!9v #*PyG 9$DGOfC 9%y
)AyG #+!G(tyG xz@ ?+g\(yG #+!G(ty9< PL}G- 9$OG| ry9S )yE 96 IO(gyGh
#+}zT}yG H9Z| f9v Osh 9$hOTpGh 9$($(V ~C 9"%tp #| HQjyG 9%sQS
)yEh ?+!9}DgyG ?yhOyG A9]s )yE {zTA@ &+<Qh}G #+!G(tyG JCO< 9|O"f 9}k +df
Oz< )p #+"t@ dhC QOY e1840 e9f )qp )|;S G )<QgyG ~y9gyG )p 9%A*:h
k
)!9}DgyG J9<(tgyG f(!9s ($ GP$h ?+="FC QO9Z| #| &|9wIC GO}AT| )|;SE
.)e1810( ?"S )p QO9ZyG )T!QqyG )F9"GyG f(!9tyG #f Q+DwyG {t! iPyG

251

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

xyP< LQMp ["< :E ?<(tf : CO=}< PL}G f(!9tyG GP$ &COJASC 9| ~$C #|h
?<(tf 9+k F98 )jyC &!E ~C Q*RgAyG ~S9< )|;S G YQWyG &+zf iQF 9| )zf
f(!9s gOg< QOY Osh ?sQTyG )p O+yG has ?<(tfh 9!RyG ?}*QF )p ~FQyG
GP$ U=AsG Osh )1858( Ey9C )F9"F f(!9s ~C )1851( ?"S )p QLB )F9"F
{*Og@ 9%}$G IQ+Dv J;*Og@ &+zf BzLOC ~C )T!QqyG f(!9tyG #| &zv Q+L}G
gP$h )1915-1910( ?"S #+< ?LQ|| d(*P ?C;C &y QOYh )e1911( ?"S
f(!9tyG #+!G(tyG gP$ ~$Ch IQp9v dhO #+!G(s #| IP(Lz| d(*PyGh J;*OgAyG
k
)T!QqyG f(!9tyG #f ;t! IQ9GAyG f(!9s QOY )1850( ?"S )ph .)y9a* G
&|9wIC )T!QqyG {Y}G #f {t! &!C eI;}yGh )e1807( ?"S )p QO9ZyG
[! ($h 9%FhR S;pE O"f ?FhRyG b(tI )zf ["yG )p 9}v .QZ=@ fhO<
.?+|;S G O;=yG )p u=a}yG ?+ZMWyG dG(I}G e9wIC h| uqA* :
?*Q+|}G VGQ}G f(!9s ?+zgyG ?yhOyG JQOYC )1858( ?"S )ph
f(!9s )1913( e9f )p QOY xyPvh .JG(}yG VGQCh ?vhQA}yG VGQ}Gh
)!9}y}G f(!9tyG #f f(!9tyG GP$ U=AsC Osh ?*Q+|}G )\GQ}G )p d9tA!:G
k
GP$ QsC Otp .?+fQWyG KQ G e9wIC #f rzA< 9|9wIC iQT*(TyG f(!9tyGh
Q(vPyG #+<h ?FhRyGh LhRyG #+< IGh9T}yG ?*Q+|}G )\GQ}G d9tA!C )p f(!9tyG
.K9!}Gh
J9}v9J}yG d(YC f(!9s ?+!9}DgyG ?yhOyG JQOYC )1861( e9f )ph
d(YC f(!9s QOYh ?*QJ=yG IQ9GAyG f(!9s QOY )1864( ?"S )ph ?*Q9GAyG
f(!9s QOYh .)1911( e9f )p &z*Ph )1880( e9f ?+s(tJyG J9}v9J}yG
IO9}yG ?+s(tJyG J9}v9J}yG d(YC f(!9s R9FG Osh )e1906( e9f AGQF:G
e9f QO9ZyG ?J<GQ}yG e9d! #| )yh}G IO9}yG JR9FC 9}v ?+!(!9tyG IOF9qyG 112
IOF9qyG )"g*( ?*Q9GAyGh ?*O9gyG J9"*GO}yG )p ?+F9\QyG IOF9qyG )1887(
.)?*(<QyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

252

OfG(s ^g< J9gpGQ}yG f(!9s )p ~JsC )!9}DgyG YQW}yG fC eI;*h


k
GOY9s f(!9tyG #| 64 IO9}yG )T!QqyG )!O}yG f(!9tyG #| ?y(t"| ?+f(\(|
Q+DwyG {+ag@ )yE U(Z"yG xz@ JOC Osh Os9gAyG ?*QI CO=| Q*Qt@ )yE xyP<
)!O}yG f(!9tyG QOY )1876( e9f )ph ..?+|;S G ?g*QWyG e9wIC #|
f(!9tyG GP$ U(Z! JPLC Osh .?+yOgyG e9wI}G ?zG| ~S{< aQf iPyG
EJ=}yG GP$ )p 9%y 9"\Qf )AyG iQL}G #+!G(tyG #wyh )q"JyG &tqyG #|
.?zG}yG 9%A"}]@ )AyG e9wI}G #| GQk +Dv B]s9!
G(}aI xyP<h ?+<Qh}G #+!G(tyGh ?+<Qh}G IQ9]Jy9< cGQ@:G YOL Oty
GhQ+i Oty ~89+v eqJ*h ~%FGOfC #| ~%+}J* f9v iPyG #+ZJyG #ZJyG
fC ?G+A"yG B!9wp ?+!O}yGh IQ9]JyG ~S{< ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG e9wIC #| Q+DwyG
?qF9ayG Bf9aASGh ~$DGOfG ~%+zf bzT@h ~%AyhO B|R$h ~7OIh BsR}@
O=f f9azTyG G(gzMp ~wJyG IOS )yE {Z@ fC A9qMyG )p {}g@ B!9v )AyG
?"S )ph #+|R%"| 9%"| G(FQM+y ?+!9DyG ?+}y9gyG HQJyG G(zLO ~C O+}JyG
)"_(yG UzG}yG )jyC ?+y9AyG ?"TyG )ph ?+vQAyG ?*Q(%}GyG G("zfC e1923
iPyG Q(ASOyG [! Osh ?+fQWyG ~v9J}yGh e;S G N+V >Z"|h ?p;MyG
G(}wIC fC Og< ~%"wyh e;S G ?yhOyG #*O fC )zf e1924 ?"S )p ghQOYC
)yE fBQtyG G(=Q@h )e1928 Q*9"* 9( f(!9t< &tJyC O9=gyGh O;=yG )zf ~%A]=s
k
)AyG ?yhOyG BJ=YC GP6h ?+<QgyG #| :O< ?+"+@;yG ahQJyG G("=@h ?+vQAyG
?yhO fhQs IOf e;S G ?*GQ Bz}Ih e;S G ~S9< ~y9gyG B}wI
y?+!9}zf
9}v ~%y9I f9v iPyG x+y9}}yG e9wI A9}zgyG Qqv {$ :($ dG|TyGh
?B*CQ 9}v ~%y9Ih ?+!9}DgyG ?yhOyG e9wI A9}zgyG Qqv {$h JCQs
.~*QwyG Q9tzy ?vhQA| ?<9F G fC xV :
)1(

?+g\(yG #+!G(tyG : ?+%y6G ?g*QWyG )1(

253

? +fQW y

vv24:19v

#+}zT| G(!(w*

fC

:E

1356

?S

#+}zT}yG

"

?S9+Ty

Gh

Og y y

11 O

A Gh O

?+}v9Jy

G ) h} G

L ;f

? Ty
"

:z

Qv9V O}IC

Qv9V O}J| O}IC N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]qyG >I9Y ,utJ}yG ?|;gyG )tyC
d9qAI:G )p #+}zT}yG f9=WyG ?+g= QGO< ?+@6G IQ\9J}yG )fQWyG )\9tyG
?"S eQJ| 9 ?g}GyG A9T| )p ;e;S G OG| A9+IE ?f9= &< B|9s iPyG
1357

9"@9+; hpQ! fC :O*OF e9g< QW=AT! #J!h ,&< CO=! fC >G* 9| dhC
,~%A]8 OF9sh #+}zT}yG e9|Eh ,9$QMp h\(|h Q]| O+S )yE 9"+!97h
iPyG ($h ,gO+*zA< e;S G uG RfC ,dh}G bhQ9p ?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]I
&*O* )zf ?+|;S G ?|}G gP$ uG Eg=+S fC ?}*QwyG &Agz_ )p 9"}S(@
k
k
&A=+t! #}+< 9%y >%+S fCh ,9!zV 9%y uG {gG+S fCh ,GO*OF 9Dk g< #+AvQ9=}yG
k
k
eR9JyG xz}yG ($h .GOG|h GRf ?!9wASG Og< #|h ,I(s rg\ Og< #|
.uG A9V fE up(}yG
xz|o )p ,GOk *OF GOk %f {=tAT!h ,GOk *OF 9|k 9f {=tAT! 9!E :IO9TyG 99G
&wz| eG(fC #| ?*QG%yG ?"TyG SCQ< &+p {qAJ* e9f dhC GP$h ,O+VQ xz|
.uG A9V fE ,O+gTyG
#+"||}yG Q+|C )}S ybhQ9qyGz 9"|9|E f(w* fC J9=S9"}yG #S9J| #|h
,{_9=yGh uJyG #+< &< uG bQp &!} | uG d(SQ xyP< g9}S Osh ybhQ9qyGz
,?*(="yG IQG%yG #| )|;S G N*Q9AyG NQC #| dhC Q}f bhQ9qyG f(w* fCh
,9"y IQ9|C GP$ f9wp ;{_9=yGh uJyG #+< BsQp 98} 9%"| N*Q9AyG Q9ALG &!Ch
GP$ #+}zT}zy uG uph fC ,9!QhOY 9%y MQW"@h ,9"<(zs 96 #8}a@ iQW<h
k
,{_9=yGh uJyG #+< Q\9JyG 9!QZf )p &< uG bQq* ,bhQ9qzy 9qzL bhQ9qyG
.
Q}g< gRfC 9}v e;S G &< Rg*h

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

254

9C 9I e;S G N*Q9@ )p GQk CC 9$Og<Ch KOG(JyG RQ<C fE :IO9TyG 99C


:?yhOh OG| #| e;S5y e9s 9| {v 9}%+zf )"< ;fGQ+aL
QO< IhRi :9}%+!9Ch ,?"*O}yG )yE ?w| #| | uG d(SQ IQG$ :9}%yhC
AO< QO< IhRih ,QqwyG >y9M| #| e;S G JPt"ASG IQG%yG .iQ=wyG
.{+aAT}yG i(tzy ,#+wAT}yG r+g]yG ?fQY )$ {< M(AqyG ?;9ph YGQZyG
f(}zT}yG Q=Y PE ,IQG%yG :e;S G )p 9}$QaLCh #+CO9JyG i(sCh
iP}G fG(yC #| ~$DGOfC &+p #ApG 9| G(z}AIGh ,A;< #| &+p G(!9v 9| )zf
f9wp ,xyP< &y(SQ Q|C ~C ,?"*O}yG )yE IQG%y9< uG ~$Q|C )AI ,ghQw}yGh
: 9"zgy ,9}k +df GQk |C IQG%yG B!9vh ,?8V9"yG ?+|;S G ?yhOzy d;tAS G AO<
fC #*QF9%}yG )zf eQI Os uG f{p ,A9"fh IOV #| 9%+p 9| f6G cQO!
hC IQ}f hC HJy :E y?w|z gOz< ,yE ~%"| OIGh hFQ* ;p ;~7QG$ G(]t"*
OgS VQ| 9}y xyPyh .9%+p ?|9s G )yE GhO(g* fC ~%y RG* ~yh ;xyP (J!
fC B+WL Osz | uG d(SQy d9sh )w< YGO(yG ?GI )p ?w}< U9sh )<C #<
d(SQyG &y 9fOp ,?y(L #< OgS J9| 9}v 9%"| JQF9$ )AyG VQ}9< J(|C
#wy ,~69tfC )zf ~$OQ@ :h ~7QG$ )<9JY} ^|G ~%zyG d9sh A9qWy9<
)p(@ fC | uG d(SQ &y )CQ* :U9sh )<C #<G d9s- ?y(L #< OgS UF9=yG
.y?w}<
G(!9vh ,#+;9p ?w| G(zLO ,fhQ}Ag*h f(GJ* fhQF9%}yG f9wp
,&AF9I QOs )zf :E 9%+p ~+t* fC ~%"| OI} #w* ~yh ,#*QFGR 98(zLO*
)yE &Tq! b(A@h ,&!G(LEh &z$C iQ*h ,zW!h &+p Oyh iPyG gOz< iQ* ($h
&!} ;&@QG$ QGO )yE O(g+p &<Q Q|C h+a*h gG($ >y9j* ($ ~C ,g9=Y J9*QvP
fC :E ,9+!OyG )p A)V {v #f LQLh ,uG )yE &y9|h &Tq! Y9< Os IQG%y9<
&yzS iPyG )<GQf~y | uG d(SQ d9s 9| xyPyh .9+zgyG )$ uG ?}zv f(w@
#wyh KAqyG Og< IQG$ :z d9sh yO*OV 98zV IQG%yG fE xJ*hz IQG%yG #f
f O

255

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QG%yG )zf &g*9=* fC OGQC #}y d9sh yGhQq!9p ~@Qq"ASG GPGh ,?+!h O9%F
.y9%z$} B]| Os IQG%yG

fGz I

VVV

9 )p 9!9=$Q G(!(w+y GhQF99 ~y #*QF9%}yG IO9TyG A:|$ fE


#+<h ~$Oz< )p ~%y GQk(T+| xyP f9v Osh ,e9+ZyGh I;ZyG :E ~%y OZt|
IO9Sh VQ}G e9wI G(!(w+yh ,e;S G ?yhO G(}+t+y GhQF9$ 9}!Eh ,~%|(s
~%"| OIG(y f(w* fC Q+i #| ,~%+=! f9Ty )zf ~6Q ~$Ofh 9}< ?tC ,9+!OyG
k
IOI(yG AGQh 9+gS #wyh ;I9+JyG gP$ JGQtJ| #| A)V )p U9L h}a|
| { z y x wo 96 :E dhOzy e9+s : )AyG ,?+|;S G
,Q *OC

j ih
gfeo

]92

? *6 G

p!@
!~w ~
?*6G :f("||}yG[ p!@
!zw l
9+=!}G[

:A n

}
k

~$G(s ~C #+8| h]< G(!9v Osh


B<9DyG S9S}G G(g\(p ,?"*O}yG {$C #| ~$hQZ!h ~$hhB #*PyG ~8G(L{<
k j i h g fo ?+|;S G ?yhOyG d;tAS
uG

]52

wvutsrqponml
& % $ # " ! ~ } | { z y x !@
!}

3210/.-,+*)('
> = < ; : 9 !@!~ 8 7 6 5 4
KJIHGFEDCBA@?
.p!@
! vu O N M L

}zT}yG 99C
fhO*R* hC ryC ?F9| G(!9v | uG d(SQ ~%"f J9| #*PyG ?<9JZyG fE
GP$ GhzW!C #*PyG ~$h ,VQ}G A9J!C )p e;S G GhQW! #*PyG ~$h ,;+zs
fC iC ;f(+z| ?F9}g<QC #| QDvC fhOg* f6G f(}zT}yGh ,^*QgyG xz}yG
:f(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

256

{%p ;#++y9JyG #+}zT}yG #| a:B ?g<QC #| QDvC &qzL #+yh}G #| OIG(yG


#| d9a<}G A:|$ ~%y cQ@ 9}| ~9O*z< 9| G(dqI {$ ?e;S5y A9"i #| ~%+p
?f9azSh OG|
| uG d(SQ d(s #+}zT}yG )p ut; Os f(w* fC- uGh )WL} )!E
:{F9s d9tp ;9%AgZs )yE ?zv}G )fGO@ 9}v ~w+zf )fGO@ fC ~|}G xV(*z
,{+TyG A9Djv A9Di ~w"wyh ,Q+Dv P8|(* ~A!C {< :d9s ?P8|(* #J! ?zs #|h
~w<(zs )p uG #pPt+yh ,~w"| ?<9%}yG ~vhOf QhOY #| uG #fR"+yh
?+$GQvh 9+!OyG >I :d9s ?#$(yG 9|h uG d(SQ 9* :{F9s d9tp ,#$(yG
.yJ(}yG
Y(]MyG #f O("gyGh ,~%"*O< c9T}AS:G cQ@ :E ?zf #+}zT}y9< U+y
)p &y(SQ &"f #+< 9}<h ,&<9Av )p uG dR!C 9}< {}gyG #f VGQf Gh ,&y
b;L}G )p eC ,J;|9g}yG )p eC ,JGO9=gyG )p xyP f9vC AG(S ,&A"S
&]g< #f VQfC #}p ,e;S G #*O #| &zvh ,uG YQV #| &zv ,HGO6Gh
uzL #*O ($ 9}v ,f9azSh ~wI #*O e;S Gh ,&g+= #f VQfC Otp
,&+p xyP #| A)V #+< bQq* : ,MhQzy ?+sQ@h IO9=f #*O ($ 9}vh ,{F9]ph
,I9vRyGh I;ZyG #* bQp #| #z@9s} :dh}G ?q+zMyG Qw< (<C d9s xyPyh
.#*O@Q| 9%+g!9| ?<9JZyGh ($ )}Sh
{}gyG )yE fhO(g* :#+}zT| G(!(w* fC :E #+}zT}yG AGhO} L;f :
;&zv ~8zV )p &+=! ?"Sh uG H9Aw< f(wT}A*h ,~%y )]@QG iPyG uG #*O<
~$AG($C f(fO*h .:hz@ &!(vQA* :h ,GOk9"f &"f f(\Qg* : ,gQ+jYh gQ+=v
kj ih
g
feo ~6Q Q|} f(g]M*h ,~%ShDQ JGhR!h
.

]10

?*6G :iQ(WyG[ p!@


! vu
q

sr
q p on m l

V #| fzV {v )p #*Oy9< {}gyG )yE I(fOyG )p Q+ZtAyG ~CE

fh|

fE

257

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

U+y ;{Fh Rf uG iO* #+< xyP #f d(8T| ~zT| {v Q+=v ~CE #+}zT}yG
N o &y(SQh uG ?f9_ )yE I(fOyG #f VGQf}G )p uG O"f QPf ~zT}y

YX W V U T SR Q P O
; : 98 7 6 5 4 3 210o
GFE
DC
B A @ ? > !@
!vuy = <
o ~8z< uG ~%qYh #}v G(!(vh p@
! ! vu z K J
IH

]63

?*6G :Q("wyG[ p

<; F E D C B A @ ? > =
.

]39

?*6G :HGRn I}G[ p

S 9* G(y9s ,&Tq! ~vOIC fQtJ* :z | uG d(SQ d(s G(g}SG


,&+p d(t* : ~C ;d9t| &+p &+zf u GQk |C iQ* d9s ?&Tq! 9!OIC QtJ* r+v
?+WL :d(t+p ?GPvh GPv )p d(t@ fC xg"| 9| :?|9+tyG e(* &y uG d(t+p
.&F9| #<E gGhQ y)W< fC uIC B"v i9*{p :d(t+p ,S9"yG
k
d(t* fC S9"yG ?=$Q ~vOIC #g"}* : :Cz 9]*C d(t* | uG d(SQ fEh
d(t* fC bRQ #| Of9=* :h ,{FC #| HQt* : &!{p ,gO%V hC gBQ GPE uJ<
.O}IC &FQLC y~+dg< QvP* hC uJ<
F
ED C
B A@?
> =
< ;:
o )y9g@ uG d(t*h
uG d( Q

]36

?*6G :HGRn I}G[ p@


! ! x{

Q P O NM L
K J
I H
G

G F E D C B A @ ? > ={ &!9J=S d(t*h


WV UTSRQPONMLKJIH
fedcba`_^]\[ZYX
tsr qponmlkjihg
~}|{zyxwvu

Z
[

#"!
0/.-,+*)('&%$

Gh

258

\1
=<;:98765
4
3
2
F E^ D C B A ] @ ? >
Q PONMLKJIHG
] \ [ Z Y X W V_U T S R
ihgfedcba `_^
t s r q p o n m l k j
$ # " ! ~a} | { z y x w v u
?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

?+}v9Jy

.[65-58 :A9T"yG] }

,+*)('&%

2 10 / . - ,{ :)y9g@h cQ9=@ 9]*C d(t*h


? > =
<;:9 8 7 6 5 4 3
ML K J
I HG
F
ED CBA @
YX
W
VU T
S R QP O N
gf
edc b
a ` _^ ]
\[
Z
w vut
sr
qp on m
l kj
i
h
%$# "
! ~ }| {z y x
.
O 9} y }
+*
) ( '&

[50-48 :I F

#|

G]

QWf &gT* : Q+aMyG Y(\(}yG GP$ )p d(tyG A9q*E fE


QPJ* fG (FQCh ,IRF(| IQ9VC JQVC #wyh >aMyGh JGQ\9J}yG
?|C f{p ,?t<9TyG ~|}G Q9=LC #| &< ~%dfh 9}+p &tzL )p uG ?"S f(}zT}yG
E
o )y9g@ uG d9s 9| 9$DGRF f9wp ~6Q Q|C ^g< Bqy9L ~%z=s ~|}G #|

JG

Q P O N MLK J
I HG
F
.
? *6
Qf} p!@
!v{| WV U T
S
]167

G :aG

G[

9v Osh ,gQ|C ?qy9M| ~$QPJ* | O}J| H9JY} d(t* )y9g@ uG fE

G(!

259

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~%"f uG )\Q #*PyG ~$h ,&tzL #| &@Q+L ~$h ,&"*O e9wIC )}+t|
9| 9=$P OIC {D| uq!C ~vOIC fC (zp ,~%"| &+zf eQvC ~ATyh ,&"f G(\Qh
:~%y uG d(t* &q+Z! :h ~$OIC O| kz<

j ih
g f
ed
c b a `o
w v ut
s r
qp o nm l k
.p|
{ zyx
Qv9V O}J| O}IC

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

260

Qv9V O}J| O}I N Wy ?|;gy ?y9t| zf u zg@


C

#+}zT| G(!(w*

fC

:E

#+}zT}yG

A Gh O

L ;f

:z

~y Qv9V O}IC N+WyG fC 9+k zF 9"y K]A* IQ\9J}yG ?|Ot}y 9"@AGQs #|


)ph ?+fQV ?*:h &y #+}zT}yG Q|} 9+k yh gQ=Ag* f9v {< O;=yG xz| Qqw* #w*
)p GQk +Dv QQw@ ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C H%"}y )z}f u+=a@ GP$h ?g+< &y &t"f
J:9t| IQ%= H9Av #| ?y9GgyG gP$ )p raAsCh &@GQ\9J|h N+WyG J:9t|
.)433vY dhC ARF( :)z* 9| Qv9V O}IC ?|;gyG
Q$9d| #| GQk %d| QZ| )p iQ@ fC 9%shQ* : d;%yG rJY fC Q%d*
~v9J}yGh &F9}zfh Q$R}G O+< f6G e;S G AG(y fC iQ@ )$h e;S G
&!9azS fhQ%d}yGh gQF9gV A9+I{< f(}F9tyG ~8Ch 9%+qc(|h ?+fQWyG
>I9Y IQ]I ?*9fQ B; QZ| )p gOG|h gRf #| )t< 9}y f(dp9JyGh
bQWyG c(z| Q+=v yOG|p xz}yG 9!:(|z &|;fC hpGQh #*OyG Q+Z! ?y;GyG
.gO+*zA< uG gO*C )|;S G
d;$ d9=tAS 9%"< ?"*O}< &SCQ iPyG {qJyG )p 9$9tyC IQ\9J| )ph
OGOWyG #+"TyG gP$ )p 9"+zf #| Os uG fEz &y(t< &@Q\9J| )8C f9]|Q
9%y(%vh &A|C H9=Wy ($ IhOtyG ~g! )tAyG eR9JyG xz}yG bhQ9qyG 9"w+z}<
9*k OA%| YGQS JG(aM< OG}yG )yE &A|C O(t* ?}wIh 9!9}*E &=zs rz|o 9%L(+Vh
k
.)tC(yG &@hQg< 9wT}A| e;S G iO6
o
.yuG A9V fE 9"y {=tAT}yG f(w* fC &Agz_ #}+< (FQ"y 9"!Eh
fGOOgyG ?SO9TyG ?"TyG i(="yG iO%yG ?zG|h 695vY IQ%}GyG Qd!C
v$1361 ?"S dG(V fhQWgyGh QWf hS9AyG
?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= #| IQO9ZyG J9!9+=yG h+= fC xyP )yE r\C
OIC &AqZ< &AvQ9W}< B!9v ?8"%AyG hC ?g*9=}yG hC e9wJzy O+*zAy9< ?*O}J}yG

261

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Qd! IQGOE UzG| (]f #w* ~y fEh ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= A9}zf ?8+$ A9]fC
hC J9+g}GyG )p cGQAV:G ?+F9]tyG ?8+%yG A9]fC )zf QdJ* f(!9tyG f}
BgFQ GPEh IQAqy i(="yG iO%yG ?zG}y Q*QJAyG )zf 9pQW| f9v {< HGRI}G
RvQ}y9< #*Q\9J}yG OI} eOt* fC OGQC 9}"+I &@OF(y J:9t}yG IQ%= )yE
N}G 9"T+FQ )yE xyP Og< &ApQf Oshz )!9DyG ARGyG v 688-682vY d(t* e9gyG
?f9=( 9"Af9= Q\9J+y g9!(fO Osh ...fG(L G )yEh O|9I O}J| N+WyG
gP$ BzgF )AyG IQ\9J}yG )tyGh I(fOyG H9Fzp )?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C
OOgyG ?g<9TyG ?"TyG iO%yG ?zG| y..gP )$ 9$h 99O* #+< ?|Ot@ ?}zwyG
.v$1362 ?"S >FQ h<9TyG
?"TyG ?=Aw| ?g=_ Qv9V O}IC N+Wzy uJyG ?}zv H9Av )yE BgFQ GPEh
:Qv9V O}IC N+WyG d(t* .9$Og< 9|h 172vY
?pQWA| B!9v #+I ?}*OtyG ?*QZ}yG ?g|9Gy9< 9=k y9_ #+TI &_ N+WyG f9vz
QQt@h )
OG|p xz}yG ?y;GyG >I9Y IQ]I( :)OG|p Q+|}G (}S( ?S9*Q<
#+TI f9azTyG ?}dgyG >I9Y IQ]I OGQzp ?<QhC )yE ?Dg< )p &y9SQE
k
?}+s ?*O$ g9=Ih 9}k *Qv :9=tASG gQZs )p &z=tAS9p &A*9fQh &qag< &|Qw* fC
>+aL a9sh}G IQGR(y #+g<9AyG OF9T}yG A9=aL #| f9vh .)"g}yGh iRj}yG
f9vh f9<Rf OGT| >+aL iO%}yG O}J| N+WyG ($h QOAt| ~zwA| K+Zp
k
gQ]J* {+zF ~Mp {qI )p ?g}GyG I;Y )zf 9=cG(|
#+TI f9azTyG
.AGQ=wyGh AGQR(yGh A9}zgyG
Q|9gyG #*O<9f QZs #| >*QtyG )yhO=}yG OGT}< 9| 9|k (* ?g}GyG )zZp
MO}* fC >+aMyG OGQCh e(+yG xyPy >+aMyG cGP a9sh}G IQGRh B<O!h
Gk

)1 (

K\G(yG #}p ?"TyG ?=Aw| ,p QW"yG )zf ~F9tyG #| d9t}yG GP$ BzpC r+v iQOC : 9!Gh )1(
O}IC fC OtAg* Q9tyG {g: ?+F9tA!Gh ?*9"g< 9g"Y y?+z$9GyG ~wIz &}+Tsh H9AwyG fC GOk F
.#*Q+qwAyG N+V f9v Qv9V

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

262

#wyh {gq* fC &y uv Io h )#+TI &_ N+WyG( &|QvC 9}< g("* fCh f9azTyG ?}df
#| ?}F9s &y ~t@ ~y ?yR dRp MO}yG )p )y9jAyG >o I &=zih &AI9Zp &A!9L
)}f}G gA9Fz &A=aL A9"CC d9s PE )1(xAyR #| rLC B!9v 98C OtAfCh 9$Og<
N+WyG iOyGh I;ZyG gP$ O(%V #| f9vh y)y(@ 9|h &%Fh )p U=f 9}p
)p S9"yG #zg* I;ZyG Og< e9tp
9tk <9S Q$R}G {+vh Qv9V O}J|
fz< xyP 9$hO9fzp Q%dyG I;Y GhO+g* fG ~$Q|Ch ?z_9< ~7;Y fC OGT}yG
&!9J=S uG f} .9Jk *QZ@ : 9]k *Qg@ | uG d(SQ ~AV 9}< Qqv >+aMyG
O*O9"Y ^g< KOJ* ($h )}f}G e(Aw| eC #<G gA9F #+I &y(SQ )zf >Af
k
&D*OI #| ZQq* )AI ;+zs )}f}G #f VQfzp e;S G )yE ~$(fO* X*Qs
u}I}G >+aMyG GP$ A9F ~C ?}*QwyG IQ(TyG gP$ )p &y(SQ H9Af uG dR!zp
.u O}JyGh )"i &tz}@ #f ($h
f9azTyG ?}df uz}A< fC O*Q* {$9GyG
uG >@9f 9| )yE S9+ty9< &A}dgy ?=t"| Q9%cE O*Q* &!C h|9TyG ~$(* 9}< &IO}p
9]k *Qg@ #+wT}yG >+aMyG h"Y f9wp GP$ ?*9wI #| uG QqjASCh &y(SQ &+zf
>$P ~C &Tq! f9azTyG gQw"* #| ?|Ot| )ph ~zT| &< )\Q* : uG d(SQ<
($h
9V9< iQwV O(}J| {<9sh Q|9gyG #*O<9f QZs )yE CQ(p OyG(yG
)yE Q|}G hpQ* fC &"| >z_h cGP PE fG(*OyG U+FQ f9vh ~+}I u*OY &y
)AyG I;ZyG IO9fE H(F(< GP$ )p YQWyG ~wI &jz=* fCh f9azTyG ?}df
?!9|}G #| {}I 9| d(=s )p 9V9< iQwV OOQA* ~yh >+aMyG Qqw< Bza<
.I;ZyG IO9f{< YQWyG ~wI d(=s )p OOQA* ~y f9azTyG ?}df fC OtAfCh
: 96 f("*O@ )AyG gP$ ~w"+!G(s f} OJyG GP$ O"f rt* fC Q|}G O9vh
.yA9+fO}Gh )t}JyG u}I #| :h A9%qTyG &qS #| uG d(SQ )};
-G(}fR 9}+p- UQJyG OVC f(YQJ* #}| A(TyG A;LO &+p {LO ~C

.QO

9tyG O=f )vR O}J| >@9wyG )yE &F(| H9aMyG )1(

263

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)AI ~%|O$h A9}zgyG ~]$ )p (zjyG OVC f(zj*h OGQp}G b(tI )zf
{FQyG xyP f9vh &\(I #f HPyGh ~%"*O QZ! #f ~%Tq!z< ~$(zjW*
k
~%y iO|* Y(=A}y9< h<9AyG d9Z@G Q9=wyG #*Q9WAT}yG ^g=< ;ZA| >+aMyG
&!} )<C )zf IQV9=| ?J"F i(fO hpQ* fz< &+zf GhQ9Vzp J9|OMyG #| GQk +Dv
k
k
d9"* fC ~zg* ~y #| uqVCh f9azTyG fG(*O )ph OGT}yG )p 9+"zf 9=S &=S
A9]tyG d9FQ #| eGQv d9FQ rshh bjzyG QDvh Oz=yG Q9Ch A(S xyP #| )<C
k
HPyG )p IOIGh GO* G(!9v )a=sh ~zT| #+< ?pQW| rsG(| xyP )p )z$}G
iOyGh z=g* ~yh .~*QwyG &|9t}< O+g< #| (yh S9T| iC Q9w!Eh uG d(SQ #f
v
P9AS}G &t*OY &"f {vh {< Q9=wyG #| gAGQh #}< :h >+aMyG ?+]t<
.iO9V (<C x< O}J| Q+=wyG
GP$ ?}*QF )p YQWyG ~wI )p ~wAJ* #y &!C ?+]tyG )p )<C rs(| f9vh
k
ahQg| 9]*Qg@ (yh d(SQy9< S9T}yG ~wI f} .Q$R}G A9}zf )yE eQG}yG
9%+p ?J+JZyG EJ=yG ?at! 9}!Eh )=i hC B"gA| hC {$9F gQw"* : A9}$Ozy
&+zf )"G| &!C )fO}yG )!9GyG {FQyG #| QOY iPyG :?pQY ?*(jy ?+<Qf
U+y eC d9}gAS:Gh ?jzyG ?y:O< ~df}G d(SQyG e9t| ~*QwyG e9t}y9< ^*Qg@
9| ~6 #d* fC ?+WL Q$R}G A9}zf )yE GP$ )p {ZqyG L9AJ* :h ?^*QgA<
^g< iCQ 9%+p )qw* ?*(jy ?+<Qf ?at! )$ {< ?+=ZgyG #| &"| AGAQ< ~$
O]yG ?"d| ~$ {< uG d(SQy ?+=ZgyG ~6 #d* : #}| H!Qp}G #+sQWAT}yG
)yE ?+]tyG BzYh GPE &!C )zf &|Rfh
OyG(yG ~+}Z@ f9wp xyP #|
?jy )p ~7Q=M< GhOOJ+y #+sQWAT| AGQ=L HO! >za* fC B\Qfh ?}wJ}yG
f(w* ~C ?: eC ^*Qg@ ($C ?+<QgyG ?%F(yG #| >+aMyG e;v ?y:O HQgyG
?+WL Q|}G )p ?|(wJyG BzLO ~C .AGQ=MyG gQQt* 9}y 9tk =_ )F9]tyG {ZqyG
fG {=s 9%_9T< i(_h Q9aLCh KGOIC #| ?+]tyG gP$ AGQh #| f(w* 9|
&*RG* fC {=s 9+!OyG )p &|QF eQG}yG GP%y YO* ~y uG #wyh .A9]tyG 9$Qd"*
Og<h #+"S h]< Og< )SCQ )"+g< &A*CQ Oty :&zy9< ~Tszp iQL}G )p gAGRF

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

264

9"k +%| &A*CQ AGQ=wyGh A9}dgyG #| ~6 P: #}< GRk gAT| 9MqA"| 9+k y9gA| f9v fC
k
#+zZ}yG d9g! )tzA* IQ$9tyG OF9T| #| OGT| H9< )zf 9|k O9L .;+yP
.Q9jYh ?yP )p 9%dqJ*
f9v 9}p &+zf ?tqV : )"pQg* ($h &pQfC 9!Ch )!GQ* fC BzGL Oty )AI
9}y #wyh ?@9}WyG )zf (}T* {+="yG {FQy9p &+p ?@9}V :h ?tqWzy 9gk \(|
.y?df(|h IQ=f #| &A*CQ
&y9=< QaM* f9v 9| N+WyG fC 9+k zF xy K]A* Q+L}G d9t}zy x@AGQs #|h
?}dfz &=tz< :E #+TI f9azTyG QvP* : (%p 9sk ;_E ~v9JyG Q+qw@ ?+]s
>I9Y IQ]Iz OG|p xz}yG #f d(t* xyPvh &+zf ~IQA*h yf9azTyG
)p OOQA* ~y f9azTyG ?}df fC OtAfChz d(t*h y OG|p xz}yG ?y;GyG
k
IO9fG IOF9p 9}p GO@Q| ~v9JyG f9v (yh yI;ZyG IO9f{< YQWyG ~wI d(=s
:h {<- 9sk ;_E ?+]tyG gP$ )p fGQwq* 9!9v gOyGh :h N+WyG ;p fPE I;ZyG
~zw@ (y Q(Z@h &y A9fO GP$h Q|9gy9< &Ag"*h :E #*O<9f QZs N+WyG QvP*
H(zSz< &"f KOJA*C 9!O;< e9wI #| ~v9I #f f6G 9!QZf I9fO #| ?+fGO
A:|$ fC U"@ :h Q9tyG J9|(zg}y ?<9F G YOC ?rzAM| Q|}G eC N+WyG
f}z d(t* N+WyG fC {+yO< )|;S G YQWyG f(t=a* G(!(w* ~y e9wJyG
y...uG d(SQ )}; : 96 f("*O@ )AyG gP$ ~w"+!G(s

IQO9"yG IQOyG gP$

9V9<

iQ=Y

) p (@
iQZ}yG f9}yQ=yG

#TI #+<z@

iPyG AGQR(yG

)p

x+yEh

U+FQ

T Q g yG H 9 a L

)tz* ($h

9=Af:G )p h\(yG h| ?+w<R}G ?}wJ}< Qv9V O}IC N+WyG d9s GP9| Qd!G
#+!G(tzy ?*P+q"AyG ?azTyG ?S9FQ )zf e(t* QZ| )p AGQR(yG U+FQ fC
.?+g\(yG
Q

265

? +fQW y

Of

57 O
9V 9<

i Q=Y

v18v

21 A

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

RGy ?g< Qy ? Ty
G

"

#TI #+<z@

?+fQWyG ?+w<R}G ?}wJ}<

O}IC N+WyG P9AS}G ?z+]p )tyC 1359 ?"S dG(V 16 B=TyG e(* )p
9"k +<z@ ?TzGy9< ?+@6G ?}zwyG ?+fQWyG ?+w<R}G ?}wJ| )\9s Qv9V O}J|
:AGQR(yG UzG| U+FQ 9V9< iQ=Y #TI e(IQ}zy
k
;+D| &y ~zg@ ~y {zF >aM< U|C dhC h=C ~y9gyG YhQ {< QZ| BfhQo
?|OM< 9}k F9s &w+z| iO* #+<
9V9< iQ=Y #TI J9}p ,N*Q9AyG )p
?|}G N(+V &fQZ| O%V ;{p9I {qI )p TQgyG H9aL )tz* ,g:(|
QW"* Y9*P}yGh ,VQ}G ~|C QDvC (zD}|h 9$DGQ=vh 9$D9}dfh 9$(zD}|h
;FQ &+p QZ| JOtph ;gQZ<h ~y9gyG h}S #+< J9}p ;9%F9FQC )p &@(Y
o
AGOC f9TIEh ,U;L}Gh bOZyG &@9qY RQ<C ,d9FQyG #+< d9D}yG QO9!
)zMA* : ($ ~C ,&fQ9Z* J(}yGh J(}yG YQ9Z+y &!E )AI ,;|9v >FG(yG
)p f9v 9| YhQCh .>y9j* : QOtyGh QOtyG &=zj* )AI ,&+yE {vh 9| AGOC #f
gO+< fC QvP*h ,&@9+I )zf &YQI )T"* &!C ,gGQ*h J(}yG UJ* ($h &qs(|
)t=* fC )zf UQJ+p ,g:(|h &w+z| O* #| gPLz< aQW@ ,9}k *Qv 9<9aL
~A+y N(+WyG UzG| U+FQy &+ag+p ,&fQZ}< btT* : 9!(Z| 9}k F9s H9AwyG
.&<9ZfC I(sh &A9O< Q(]J< ,&A=$Qh &AfhQ rs(}zy eqJp ,&@h;@
:&y Qqih
>IC #| f9v Otzp ;9%=y9j!h 9$Oy9G! 9"v 9!k GRIC &+p 9"<9Z| Q9CC Osh
OzMyG QGO )yE 9=$Pp ,&+yE S9"yG >IC #| )<C f9vh ,iOyGh )yE S9"yG
{IGQzy uG dzT!h .rZ"yGh ?"TyG 9}%"+< 9| Rh9GA* 9}yh ;O9g+| )zf 9}8zv
k
k
k
.9+vR 9=+_ J9|h ,9+t! 9+t@ T9f Otp ,fGQqjyGh ?}IQyG ~*QwyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

)zf d9+FC

Gh

?+}v9Jy

266

_ @ )AyG ?T+q"yG IQ$(GyGh ?}+A+yG IQOyG gP$ x+yEh


9$A9qLE

Jz G(

r
o r
)1(
x
p AqyG O s

f 9}

9}$Q+i Q9as}G #| Q+Dv {< ,)<QgyG ~y9gyGh )|;S G ~o y9gyG Yqhx Qo


&tJyCh ,&y uG Qqi O+%WyG )VGQt"yG ,?}zwyG )"g}< {FQyG ,{FQyG d9+Ai9<
.#+Jy9ZyGh AGO%WyGh #+t*OZy9<
f6G 9!C 9|h &A}zv &+p d9sh A9]tzy 9%]g< eOs ,KGOIC xyP Bt=S Osh
~FGQGyG ,p e;wyG jQ+i CQt* 9}v CQsC B"v ,"wyh ,e9wI}G Ot! OOZ<
?f(}zT| &+p Oz< ,p #J!C :dA9T@Ch ?+S9+TyG
?+|;S G ?%F(yG #| Q|}G GP$ #+<C fC ,zf 9=k FGh fC B*CQ Osh
A:|$ ^g< jO9 uG {gyh ,QPAg}y QPf c9"$ f(w* : )AI ;?J+JZyG
.Y(FQyG )yE {+=S f(w* : fC {=s ~%"*O )yE G(gFQ+p ;#+|QG}yG LQG(MyG
.S9"yG A:|$ ?}F9s )p )VGQt"yG Og< GP #| jQO! 9|h
#| ?*B Q+i )p .eGQJyG Uq"yG {As )zf O+f(yG OVC Of(@ &!9J=S uG fE
f ed c b a ` _^o &<9Av
.

]93

?*6G

:A

x
9T"yG[ p!@
! ~x

m l kj

ih
g

,p GP$ 9}!Eh ,~y9gyG {=s {$9GyG 9%pQg* ,AyG e;S G J9+9O< #| GP$h
{@9tyGz 9$Q+ih J9sQTyGh KOG(JyG )p S9"yG #+< f(w* iPyG O}gyG {AtyG
k
.yGQk +=v GQRh >w@Q* &!C ~zg* ($h {At*
k
k
,~dfC &!zV cGPp ,&y(I ;*(_ :GOF 9!CQs iPyG ,)S9+TyG {AtyG 9|C
.QLB A)V xyPh
9S}G )1(

. 1949/1/2 S

267

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q L {gq* &!C OtAg* >ztyG )\GQ ,Uq"yG #8}a| {At* )S9+TyG {@9tyG
k
k
OtAg* ~y fE ,GRk F9F :;I ;}f {gq* &!C J9ay9j| #| &+p E< 9}< OtAg* &!{p
>G* e;S G #f LlQ9L Ol @Q| GP%p ,gQ+i &+p QZs )|;SE >FG(< e(t* &!C
)ph ,hFGQWyG )p ~%|9wIC &+zf u=a@ fCh ,#*O@Q}yG ?z|9g| {|9g*o fC
uG d(SQ H9JYC f(zAt* G(!9v #*PyG A9|OtyG LQG(My9v LQG(MyG ~$ f(!9tyG
LQG(MyG A:|$ Q$9dv ~$Q$9c f9vh ,Qqwy9< &Tq! )zf aQAfG #| f(fO*h
:&<9JY} d9tp ,~$GQ* fC {=s )I(y9< uG d(SQ ~%qYh Osh ,&"| GQk +L {<
: fBQtyG fhDQt* ,~%|9+Y h| &|9+Yh ~7;Y h| &@;Y ~vOIC QtJ*z
E*OI .y?+|QyG #| ~%TyG bQ}* 9}v e;S G #| f(sQ}* ,~%+sGQ@ Rh9G*
k
LQM+Sz 9]*C d9sh 293-292U 1L ~zT| K+JY )p iQOMyG O+gS )<C
Q+L d(s #| f(y(t* ,e;I}G A9%qS ,f9"S}G KGOIC e(s f9|RyG QLB )p
bQ}* 9}v #*OyG #| f(sQ}* ,~$QF9"I Rh9G* : fBQtyG fhDQt* ,?*Q=yG
~%zAs #}y GQk FC ~%zAs )p f{p ;~$(zAs9p ~$(}A+ty GP{p ,?+|QyG #| ~%TyG
1L ~zT| K+JY )p >y9_ )<C #< )zf E*OI .y?|9+tyG e(* uG O"f
;G k +

. 293U

< hat@ e;S

9 O< Q@ A| IQ+Dv )"g}yG GP$ )p E*O9I}Gh


r
.&t"f #| e;S G ?t<Q hzL Otp eGQJyG eOyG {JASG #|
#+< f(w* iPyG O}gyG {AtyG #| OVC ($ ,)S9+TyG {AtyG ~wI GP%p
&=!Py IQ9qv &"| U9ZtyG {gG* Osh ,&z]q< &"f uG (qg* Os {@9tyGh ,S9"yG
?dJy QLB )yE {gp 9| )zf Qw Zp |o (%p )S9+TyG {@9tyG 9|Ch ,&A}IQh &z]q<
r n n n
.dp9a<}G {gpp {gp &!C #d*h &< QMq* ,&@9+I #|
p
#+< f9v Otp ;*hz@ {}AJ* : ,)S9+TyG {AtyG )p [l ! QLB E*OI c9"$h
)AyG ,?+S9+TyGn ?|(ZMyG #| f9v 9| >y9_ )<C #< )zf #+<h eG(gyG #< Q+<RyG
o or
s
?9+zf xy {AsC :d9tp eG(gyG #< Q+<RyG )yE {FQ A9Gp ,{}GyG ?gs(< B%A!G
fz

G J +9 h ,I G(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

268

rn

: :d9s .&< xAp pr zp &p <p uo Jn yC :d9s ?O("GyG &g|h &zAt@ r+vh ,: :d9s
r
o
Q+<RyG E*OI( .y#l |p |r |o xAp qr *n : ,xp Ar qn yG Oo +r sn f9}* G fv Ez :d9s | uG d(SQ
.9"t+tJA< :{="I #< O}IC e9| G O"T| #| 1429 ~sQ eG(gyG #<
o n
#w* ~y {gp f{p ,IOv Qx yG Ip(v$o )p iOQA* fC #f #||}yG O+t*o f9}* G fC iC
k
.9"|||
uG O"f AGO%WyG {]p &y ,IO9%Wy9< uG &|QvC Otp )VGQt"yG 9|C
9$9"}@ ,uG d(SQ H9JYC #| Q+Dv 9$9"}A* f9v ?A+| J9| Osh ,~%A|GQvh
.)zgyG J9FQOyGh ~+dgyG e9t}yG uG O"f &y f9wp 9%y9! )AI H9aMyG #< Q}f
)zfh ,A9|OyG )zJAT| ?zAtyG LQG(MyG A:|$ )zf iRMyGh ~C G 9}!Eh
?I9<{< ?<QhC 9%+p JOQ@ )AyG I(%yG ,p 9!O;< iOQA@ fC O*Q*h ,~%"f hpGO* #|
fC O*QC :h ,f(zgq* 9| f(}zg* : ~8{p ;&A<(tf r+q< hC ;)S9+TyG {AtyG
.fhO*Q*h f(pQg* ~8z< ~%}7C
.uG iO$ iO%yGh
fE ;

269

? +fQW y

xAqyG O s

f 9}

?y9t|

)zf

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

u zgAyGz

9"$ #|z &<9Av ?|Ot| )p )yGRjyG O}J| N+Wzy 9|k ;v 9}k *Os JCQs Os B"v
y~zg!
)\9tyG Qv9V O}IC N+WyG fC aQg! 9"!Ez )yh}G ?g=ayG ?|Ot| )p d(t*
~%zAs #| fCh !!GQk9qv #+}zT}yG fG(L}G fz< i(Ap QOYC ?+fQWyG ~v9J}y9<
fC )j="* f9v i(AqyG gP$ QOZ* iPyG {FQyGh )GPv( ~%"| u9< )yhC f9v
k
k
y..9t+t; &g| iQFC GOIC >TJ! ;p xyP h|h A9}zgyG IQ|R #| OQa*
Bqsh )AI Qv9V O}IC N+Wzy ?|(fR}yG i(AqyG gP$ #f EJ<C Bzzch
f9}* Gz fG("g< e1949/1/2 S9S}G IO*QF )p 9%=Av )AyG &Ay9t| )p 9%+zf
~y iPyG ~+}gAyG )p &gshC )AI gGO| )yGRjy9< baWyG kz< Otyh yxAqyG O+s
#+}zT}yG fG(L G ?f9= Qqw* &!z< &}79p Qv9V O}IC N+WyG d9=< QaM*
{jW! fC uJAT@ : )AyG ?}%AyG gP$ #f GOk +g<h ybRy b=L f(y(t* 9}v GPw$z
k
)p QvP@ ~zp 9%f9+\h i(AqyG gP$ H9+i #| GOF B=Gg@ )"!{p 9$OQ< 9"Tq!C
?fO< JCO< fC P"| 9%+yE ?F9JyG U|C )p 9"v )AyG rsG(}yG #| rs(| iC
{v )fOAT@ B!9vh e9wJy9< J9f9}GyG eGOaYGh )S9+TyG {AtyG ?"Aph
G(!9v {< ?+S9+TyG J:9+Ai:Gh KzT}yG LhQMyG Q9+@ eO< )AyG ih9AqyG
h+= )p QvP*h >zs Q%c #f &!(dqJ*h Qv9V O}IC N+Wzy e;w< f(FR*
Qv9V O}IC N+WyG fC S9"yG OtAfG )AI LQG(MyG Qwqy {Y|@ )AyG J9qy|}yG
{+=S )zf &=Av 9| )yE Qd!Gh KzT}yG eGOZyGh LhQMyG J9f9}Gy Qd"}yG ($
)p O9%GyGh ?+|;S G ?f9}GyG )Aq| #}IQyG O=f Q}f /O QZJyG : d9D}yG
xyPv G(fOASGh {< yuI ?}zvz fG("g< JQW! )AyG ?}wJ}yG e9|C &AgpGQ|
k
iPyG Bs(yG )p ~$Qd! ?%Fh O*|* Qv9V O(}J| /?+<QgyG N+Wy 9|;v
)p 9Zk ! Q=Ag@ )AyG yxAqyG O+s f9}* Gz i(AqyG gP$ G(=+j* fC &+p G(f9aASG
uS9* #f KOJA@ :h x+y9}}yG e9wIh AGQ|C #f KOJA@ : )%p Y(\(}yG
- QQvCh )fQWyG )\9tyG Qv9V O}IC N+WyG {< ?+z+< VhQp #f :h Q9AAyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

270

C {=s QZ| ~wI )t+tI [MV #f KOJA* -)fQWyG )\9tyG


k
bhQ9p xz}yG e9*C QZ| AGQR(y 9T+FQ f9v 9V9< )VGQt"y9p( ?+g\(yG #+!G(ty9<
)zgqyG ~wJy9< AGQR(yG U+FQ e(t* fC )aQg* : #}y( 9%Ash Oz=yG e9d! f9vh
iPyG ~v9Jy9p yf9}yQ=yGh xz}yG e9|C ?*Q(ASOyG #+}+zy &FGOC OQG}< O;=yG )p
U+FQ ($ 9*k Q(ASO ?z|9v ?+y(8T| d(8T| ($h AGQR(yG #+g*h {gqy9< ~wJ*
99C( ~wJ* )"g* )?+g\(yG( IOQ(AT}yG #+!G(ty9< ~wJ* iPyG ($h AGQR(yG
)\9tyG N+WyG gQqw* ~y xyP h|h e9gyG h*QWAyG )p uG dR!C 9| Q+j< )IO9TyG
~8 ?z}yG #| G(FQL #*PyG ~$ g(zAs #*PyG k fEh O+%V &!E &"f d9s {< )fQWyG
#| ?qF9_ ~$ 96 O(Zt}yG f9v i(AqyG gP$h .:;JASG g(zAsh eGQJyG eOyG G(zJASG
k
QGO!R9MyG G(zAs fC Og< ?f9}GyG {J< gQGQs )zf GOQ g(zAs #*PyG #+}zT}yG fG(L G
.g(zAtp ?f9}GyG {I QQtp ?+<9$Q G d9}f}G #| ?f(}G| G(=w@QGh
Qv9V N+WyG )zf 9}k s9! e;wyG GP$ >Av 9}"+I )yGRjyG N+WyG fC >*QjyGh
Og< ?y9t| >Av Os 9"=yG #TI &M+V fC )\9tyG N+WyG )zf &=]ih &t"I g9T!C
U9MyG e9d"yG H9=V #| ?f(}G| O* )zf e9gyG >F9"yG >Aw| rT! ?yh9J|
9!k G(LE G(T+yz fG("g< 9"=yG #TI N+WyG 9%=Av #+}zT}yG fG(L G ?f9}Gy h<9AyG
:)y9Ay9v f9v f9+=yG [!h y#+}zT| G(T+yh
>F9"yG IO9gS >Aw| rT! ?yh9J| KO9I :O*OGyG KO9JyG GP$ hsh
#| fz< JQgWp #+}zT}yG fG(L G #| f9v &=w@Q| fC OFGQGyG JQvPh e9gyG
#w}* : ~FGQGyG #| &y9D|Ch h+dqyG eQGyG GP$ >w@Q| fC #zfC fC >FG(yG
9$9<z@ I(L}Gh 9%|QJ*o e;S G f} #+}zT}yG #| :h fG(L G #| f(w* fC
)AyG ?}zwyG iOJA* fC &< OGQC 9}!E &!C utJ}yG #| {< KFQ}yG #|h 9%]pQ@h
#y ?"|6G QZ| #wyh yS9"zy f9+<z fG("f B; #+|(+< xyP {=s JQW!
&A|(wI h| IQaqyG ~+zJyG >gWyG fh9gA+Sh ?}+C}G J:h9J}yG gP$ 9%fhQ@
)zf A9]tyG )zf ~dg}yG xz}yG ?y;F {c )p &A"+!z}_h &"|C )zf ?Z*QJyG
O*O%AyG J9<9aL fC #+D<9gyG #| Q9jZyG x8yhC ~zg+yh IQ+aMyG IQ$9dyG gP$
e1952 IQ(

271

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

&=FG(< GQk(gV :E ~%"| GOIC O*R@ #y ~$Q+ih d9FQyG Q9=v )yE 96 f(Dg=* )AyG
?|OL )yE G(pQZ"+yh rS9qTyG gP$ #f G(gzt+zp &FGOC )zf 9|k 9@ 9Yk QIh
.O+q| hp9! A)V {}f f(g+aAT* G(!9v fE &z}f OhOI )p {v ~$O;<
#| ht* KOG(JyG gP$ #| KO9I iC Q=AfzS e(+yG P"| )"!C #zf} )!Eh
k
gAGPE )"gT* :h )ZMV )yE 9%F(| fG(L}G ?f9}G< d9Z@C &y u=S OQp iC
#| iO*Q: U9ZAL}G J9%F )yE >z_C hC U9Ztzy )Tq! eOsC fC :E
#| xyP Q<OA+zp A9*Q<}G A9pQWyG :E 9%tJAT* : )AyG ?*QZ}yG )A+T"F
uh {+LOyGh {+Y}G #f xV:h u+tJAyG rWw+Sh f(g+a*h f(g}T*
.9"=yG #TI yQ(|}G ?=s9f
Qv9V O}IC N+WyG gQOYC 9| #+< ~wJyG )p 9sk Qp O: {$ Q9tyG 99C
{F9$ bQp c9"$ f9v fEh -)1(9"=yG #TI N+WyG &y9s 9| #+<h )fQWyG )\9tyG
QdyG &+z}@ 9}y 9tk ph 9+k S9+S 9pk QZ@ f9v 9"=yG #TI /P9AS}G aQZ@ fC iQC B"v fEh )1(
#| Qd"| &+yE Q+W* 9| GP$h ?*h9%yG )p ~6 iO(* fC O9vh &+p G(gsh bRz| #| &Af9= LQM+y
{}gyG IQ+T| )p JGQ+jA}yGh B<G(DyGz &<9Av )p d(t+p #*QY9g}yG ?+=atyG iQd"| Q9=v
.v 258vY yQY9g}yG )|;S G
&y9FQ #| u*Qp e(t* fC )]At@ Os )|;S G {}gyG ?JzZ| fz< d(tyG Og=* :h GP$z
Q+w"yG Q%d*h )?+<9$Q}G JGQ+GqAyGh J:9+Ai}G OZt*( ?*O9%GyG d9}f}G gP$ ^g=<
&"w|C OVQyG #| ?zIQ| )|;S G {}gyG kz< GPE 9+k z}f xyP u+t; Og=* :h fhQLB 9%+zf
#++|;S G ?y9SQ QGQ}ASG ?JzZ}y 9Jk +FQ@ xyP #| A)V )p [LQAyG )zf uqA* fC &g|
.yIQ9CE :h X*(W@ Q+j< )?+!9}yQ=yG OZt*( Uy9G}yG gP$ )p
eOfz Q$9dyG )p )}zTyG )S9+TyG {}gyG {+Zqy g9*9Yh eOt* ($h :v257vY d(t*h
aQaAyGh (zjyG Q9gV B; ?+"zf ?!GOE e;S5y ?z|9gyG iQL}G {F9ZqyG ?!GOE )p WQ(AyG
:d(t* ~C yH]"yGh OZtyGh dGOAf5y ?+p9"| hO=@ d9}fC )p {F9ZqyG gP$ B_Q(@ 9}%|
CO=+zp )?+<9$Q}G )"g*( ?GqyG d9}f}G gP$ ^g< )zf u+zgAzy E*OI #| O<: f9v f{pz
k
&GF9A! #| f9v iPyGh &@9fO< {+w"AyGh e;S G h}s )p )|(wJyG H9$Q G ?!GO{< :hC
=9}y hs(A| {gp OQ {D}@ )AyGh IO9Ih ?+y9i hO=@ )AyG d9}f}G gP$ ?+g+=ayG
ah

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

272

zSz< ~zwA* #| #+<h )?"TyGh H9AwyG( YQWyG H(zSz< ~zwA* #| #+<


.?S9+TyG

H(

&!Ch &Ag*QV ~+wJAy 9%]pQ )p (zih e;S5y 97GO9g| )p aQa@ #| J9|(wJyG &SQ9}@
~+wJA< :E #+t*QqyG #| aQaAyG )yE ?g*QPyG OSh J9+fGOAyG gP$ ~TI )yE {+=S :
d9}f}G gP%y ?!GO G f} xyPh I9qGyGh I;jyG YOQ+p ?|}G )p &zyG H9Av ?|9sEh ?g*QWyG
QaTyG )p &zyG H9Av ?|9sEh ?g*QWyG ~+wJA< >y9a* &!C ,fO* #| fC >*QjyGh( ?*O9%GyG
)u+=aAyGh I(fOyG #+< f(=yG Og<C 9}p ?*O9%GyG d9}f}9< ?+<9$Q G d9}f}G rZ* u<9TyG
#Aqy9< )|;S G {}gyG ?I9S ~}@h {F9ZqyG gP$ h| ?|(ZMyG d9JyG ?g+=a< SQwAS
xz}* :h yQGhO~y dO9=A| h*R(@h u=T| u+T"A< u=S 9}v xyP f9v GPE :E ~%zyG LQ9%AyGh
f9$P}G )yE )fOAT@ ?T+TL ?+"_9< ?+t@ K]"* iPyG e;wyG GP$ CQt* 9|Og< ~zT}yG
-277vY d(t* ~C .{+v(yG ~g!h &zyG 9"=TI d(t* fC :E ?+|GQF G J9<9ZgyG >+y9SC
:uJAT* 9}< &zyG &z|9f v278

9}f}G #| Q+Dwy ?+G+@GQAS:G OY9t}yG OvB #| KOJyG r+c(@ )zf IQOtyG fC xV :h


R(; )AyG d9}f}9p .d9}f}G a;AL{< d9JyG ?g+=a< rzAM* GP$h ?+FRGyG ?*O9%GyG
k
#| &+zf h}G}yG #| 9$Q9=Af9< 9%A+fhQW| )p OIC iQ9}* :h ?|}G #| 9|k 9f :(=s
>Twyh O9%GyG ?]*Qp A9+I 9+|;SE 9%q+c(@ #w}* )AyG gP%p ?|}G rFG(_ rzAM|
?|9gyG UI )p kz=@ ~y )AyG d9}f}G 9|C :d9s ~C ..?+|;S G ?vQJzy O+*zAyG #| O*R}yG
9%+p ?vQJyG h"tAp ?+|;S G ?vQJzy ?+G+@GQAS:G J9*QhQ]yG #| Q=Ag@ 9%"wyh kz=}yG GP$
Uq!C #| {As #| 9%+p {As (yh )"g* y{$9GAyGh B}ZyG ($ 9%+p {Y}Gh 9%I9G! OQG}<
d;AI: ?g*QP JP<G (yh ?|(Zg| JGQOt|h dG(|C #| Y9\ 9| 9%+p Y9\h ?|(Zg|
J9*QhQ]yG #| 98z< gQZf O%AG| ~wI Os U+yC h!9}yG 9}p- ?+|;SE fGOz<
#| QOZ@ )AyG J9!9+=yG QTq@ fC h+aAT@ xyP )zfh -?+|;S G ?vQJzy ?+G+@GQAS:G
9!O%AG| Q]* )AyG ?+<9$Q G d9}f}G H9tfC )p IQ+=v J9f9= #|h #*Q(%W| U9MVC
?*QZf H%"}yG ?+qzS( f(w@ GPw$h O9%GyG ?]*Qp A9+IEh -O9%Gy9< 9%A+}T@ )zf
.96 9"!hQW=* )AyG )?%FG(}yG
d

273

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

k+TAT* fC Y9aASC 9| ~C &M+V &y9s 9| )yGRjyG N+WyG hz< GP9}y #wyh


#+fh ?z+zv >+f {v #f 9\QyG #+fhz d9s #| bOYh Qv9V N+WyG e;v
.y9*h9T}yG iO=@ bMTyG
k
&y9s 9}| 9=k *Qs 9|k ;v d9s &Tq! )yGRjyG N+WyG U+yC GO+g< >$P! 9"y 9|h
9| )wJ* 9}"+I &+yE Qd!G &Af9= )zf >zt!C 9}"+I xyPh Qv9V O}IC N+WyG
&+<RJyG ?<9Zf &+"+f #f ByGR fC Og< U9MV}G )zf ~wI r+vh &y KOI
k
k
:)yGRjyG d9s .Qv9V O}IC N+WyG ~wI #| 9=*Qs 9}wI
ghQ9CC #+}zT}yG fG(L G H9=V #+< hsh a;My B=Gf Otyh ....z
y?#+}zT}yG #| ?f9= #J! eC #+}zT}yG ?f9= #J! :($ eD9WA<
.d9< JGP HF9A! 9%y dG|TyG GP$ )zf ?<9F Gh
!dG(|Ch A9|O ?!9+Y 96 b=@Q@ HF9A! {<
#TI P9AS}G ?qy9M| fhQ* #+}zT}yG ?f9= ~%Tq!C f(=TJ* #*PyG f{p
k
k
!!QGQtyG U8<h Q9"yG )yE IO%}| 9t*Q_h &y(SQh uG ?qy9M| #| 9<Q\ )=+]%yG
9"< Q}p {+"}yG ?=gV #| 9=k *Qs u<9S O+S P9AS}G )z+|R h| Q+SC B"v Osh
#| 9"!C :($h 9"+p ~9CQ 9"f9}SE :E 9+<Ch #+!(Aq}yG H9=WyG x8yhC #| f9"CG
Osh 9"t*Q_ )p 9"+]}p xJ\h bT=@ ?f9S 9"| xyP aO9Yh !~"%F {$C
JQvP@ )"!C :E 9"!GPB )p xS9}A* fC {=s iQDyG )zf ?+<9"yG ?}zwyG #+"_ btS
e;S 9< >gz* fC )zf Rgp &< BIhC )AyG Q|Gh}Gh Q}yG AGOgyG GP$ e9*C Og<
o
#gz+p iQLC IQ| LQG(MyG ?S9+S OOGA@ fCh ,?G}TyG ?t*QayG gP6 &F9"<Ch
~$OIh ~$ &A!9a<h U+FQyG fC ~S9< ?~<h .f9+jayG {$C cQA*h f9}* G {$C
)1(

#|h )VGQt"yG GhQqv 9}"+I 9|Gh ($ ghQqv 9}y :E LQG(MyG ~wI ~%+zf u=_ 9| &!C eI:
- ~%+zf Qw!G #| )zf ~wJ*h {< btph ~%"f hpGO* : .&!{p ~%zAt< G(|9sh )VGQt"yG {=s
.a9Z!:G f(w* GPw$h .A9}zgyG IQ|R #| OQa* fG uJAT* &!z< -Qv9V N+Wy9v

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

274

s &+p bOZ* ~%+zf LQ9MyG fCh ??f9ayGh h}TyG uI ~%y fCh !Q|}G (yhC
?f9}GyG bQ9q* OIC U+y &!{p Q=Z+zp &$Qwp 98k +V gQ+|C #| iCQ #|z d(SQyG
k
uG )ty ?f9_ #| GO* hzL #|z &y(sh y?+z$9F ?A+| J9| :E J(}+p GQk =V
.y?+z$9F ?A+| J9| ?g+< &t"f )p U+yh J9| #|h &y ?GI:
9%COJ*o )AyG ?+}TGyG b(AqyG h"| )p JOQh 9%y9D|Ch E*O9I}G gP$h
f(}zT}yG )!9f Osh . e9wJyG )zf f(FQ9MyG ,?yhOyG )zf f(=i9W}yG
9}<Qh .#+}s9"yGh #+t!9JyG JGQ(C #| e:6G )TsC iQ=wyG ~%Ap;L B!9fh
.?zF9%yG J9\9qA!:G gP$ >=T< VQ}G )p )|;S G ~wJyG W(tS f9v
{$C ?f9= hC #+}zT}yG f9=WyG ?f9= hC ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fC 9|C
hC ~%g| )t=* #| )zf 98(t=a*h ~$QhO )yE E*O9I}G gP$ fhQG* ?qZyG
h+}:h ?+<Q@ H(zSC f9v f("GyG GP$ ~+zg@ fC O+< .f("F GP%p ~%+zf LQM*
OGT| )p ?g}GyG >aM* fC -)w=}yG hC- xJ]}yG #}p !S9"yG ^g< O"f
J98+TyG Qqw* IO9+tzy A:(yG fC Ov|* #| e9gyG RvQ}yG #| 9"zZp >tf ?\hQyG
)yE GhO9f IO9+tyG GhP<9! #*PyG fCh {F9]qyG uJ}* ?f9}GyG #f LhQMyG fCh
P9ASG )S(| rS(* O}J| Q(AvOyG )FQh ?g+=yG G(gzL ~8} )yh}G ?+z$9GyG
k
iC :&y d(t+y 9=!9F >+aMy9< [zM* IQ$9tyG ?g|9G< ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG
f(T=z@ r+vh ?(jzyG GP6 )ApC #*QL6Gh #+yh}G A9}zf #| #|h ?GP$ e;SE
d(

)1(

)2(

&zyG dzT! ~AzAs #| ~%"| ~AzAsh e9wJyG )zf {gqy9< ~AFQL 9}y N+V 9* GP$ f9v #*Gh
.#+yO=| Q+i | 9"+=! H9JYC &+zf &+ty 9| )zf g9tz! fCh B+=DAyG
k
:h ?f9_ :h 9g}S :h ?g+< : 9!O"f U+y O}JyG &zyh #J"p ?"TyG Q9Z!C )zf HPv GP$
?f9_ #| GOk * YR"! : ?yhOyG e9d! #| ?tD="| 9"Af9=h 9"AyhO U+FQy ?+fQWyG 9"Ag+< {< ?+<RI
Q(jW< d(t! :h {gqy9< :h d(ty9< : e9wJyG )zf LQM! :h ahQg}yG )p :E h+a! :h
#w}}yG #|h .f(=v9! WGQZyG #fh ?fOA=| J:(t}yG gP$ H9JYC fG OtAg! {< f9|RyG
.#gz* :h OQa* :h ?f9}GyG gPMA@ QGQs iC ,zf )fQV {+yO gO"f OQp iC VQAg* fG

)1(

)2(

275

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?8V9"yG S(q! )p d;]yG GP$ {jzj@ Otp !J9%+$h ?Qw"}yG iRyG GP$ #*OyG
9|Og< 9}k zT| xTq! #d@ {$ &yzT* -{=s #|- &y N} ~%]g< >Av )AI
#+"||}yG Q+|C ($ ?f9}GyG U+FQ fC VQq"yh ??f9}GyG a(qY #| BFQL
?f9ayG uI &f9=@C )zf &+@|* GP$ {%p ~df}G ?q+zMyG b(tI &y fCh
!?A9+}gyG
6 { &y uG d(t* A9T"yG ?g+< )qp uJyG GP$ J|* ~y uG d(SQ fE
uG d(SQ d9s d9s -9}%"f uG )\Q- Q}f #<G #fh }9 8
7
GP{p ?+Zg}< Q||* ~y9| gQvh >IC 9}+p ~zT}yG AQ}yG )zf ?f9ayGh h}TyGz
Q+j@ )AyG ?|}G fEz )yGRjyG N+WyG d9s ~C y?f9_ :h h}S ;p ?+Zg}< Q|C
)"!Eh .K*Q 9%y )t=@ :h d9I 9%y KzZ* : 9$A9*RC ICQ}yG Q+j@ 9}v 9%|9wI
dmGh A9t< )zf ?}zw< #+fC fC #| u9< P+gASCh 9| ~v9Jy ?+fGO f(vC fC Bt|C
#+y9FOyGh f9%wyG h"|C fCh ?f9ayGh h}TyG f(!9s MQVC fC )j<C 9| ?*9i QF9F
A)V ~v9I Q++j@ fE .e;S G )p &tqyG ?z+zs ?8V9! )zf &< d9+AI:G #|
~zgyG )p f(MSGQyG f9v Oty .QLB A)V up(| Q+i efGh #f aGQZ!:Gh
uG ?f9_ #| ~%Af9_ fhQ* S9"yG f9wp I(fOzy fhOQGA*h uG )yE f(fO*
.~%"f &ApQg| ShQO G(tz@ ~8}
f(!9s #f f(COJA*h IO9+tyG b(tI f(=za* {%GyG )p f(MSGQyG A9F ~C
9}v Q|}9p &=y9a|h &}fGR| )zf A:|$ #| 9+k fO r"fC BTyh ?f9ayGh h}TyG
.~%y hvQ! 9"!} I9j_ S9"yG ^g< :{+s
)yE fhQd"* #+}zT}yG fG(L}G H9=V #| GQk +qi 9gk = B*CQ Otyh ...
o
~M\ Y9}AFG )p ~$OIC d9s .QP; fCh SQO@o fC >G* IQd! y~$OVQ|z
fC O*Q* ?=+GgyG ?y(tyG gP6 f9vh yraM* : OVQ}yG fEz ?+T+SzAyG ?8+%zy
k
BsR|h ;gp ByPL Osh &pQZ@ ^g< )p OVQ}yG VQ9fC 9!Ch )"yPM*
JOFh yraM* : OVQ}yGz ?}zv fC h|h )!QY9"* rsh iPyG {FQyG U<;|

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

276

: IQ*QG< &FG(* 9|O"f >!P}yG V9gA|G &!C :E A9]f:G >ziC #| 9\k 9gA|G
Q+s(@ #+< f(azM* e(tyGh .97Qg| Q(%dy &< uZz@ fC gQw*h 9v9wp 9%"| OG*
.gG($ )p ?fQ9T}yGh &*CQy Y("MyG #+<h &y ?<9%}yG Q+p(@h OF9tyG
H(zSC )zf f9v )=+]%yG P9AS}G #+<h 9""+< a;MyG >W! 9| dhC fE
O;=yG Pt"@h ~F9tyG Q(ASOyG f9Z*h ?|9gyG J9*QJyG {qw@ {$ QZ| )p ~wJyG
e;S G ~wI i(a!h &zv Y(\(}yG GP$ {$9GA! eC ?OGQpC hC OQp OGO=ASG #|
UQJyG O*OV {FQyG f9v . iQLC fh|W< fG(L G ?f9= {jW@h ,&+p
BqyC Osh rFG(ayGh OGQp}G b(tJ< KGQAv}G {+zs QZtyG d9FQ I9\Q| )zf
9fk 9pOh IQY9tyG ?S9+TyG gP%y GQk9w"ASG y)S9+TyG OGO=AS:Gh e;S Gz )<9Av
-f6G- G(pQf &g| #|h )=]%yG P9AS}G {gyh .?J+JZyG e;S G ~+y9g@ #f
#| OIGh e(* JGP )y d9s .&zFC #| 9!($Qvh &+zf ~$9"}Y9L iPyG uJyG
iQ@ :C I(fOy9< f9}* G #| ARF OF9ty9< f9}* G fE :&+yE OVQ}yG d9FQ HQsC
.?-&!zV {F- &@GP< f9}* G )yE d(SQy9< f9}* G ~\ uG fC
k
k
!!9tza| 9f9=@G OF9tyG Y9=@G ($ I(S}Gh ?f9azy )z}gyG Q%d}yG f} xyP
)p d(SQyGh OVQ}yG #+< i(SC fC GP6 )"fC : :d(t* )COJ| cQOASG ~C
?*GQ {}J* iPyG {FQyG (J! A:(yG Qf9W| ~fO OZsC 9}!E ?f9ayG ?t+tI
k
!>TJp ;D| HQ\C 9!G I(fOyG
9}zp ?f9}GyGh fG(L}G #+< ?z|9g}yG iQG| ~SQo H(zS}G GP$ {D}<h
9%TJ* : {FQyGh ?=*QtyG uF9tJyG QZ=! 9"Tq!C 9"*CQh &+zf 9"+<z@h g9"<QjASG
9"At| &+zf QGQi}G 9$9q\C )AyG ?y9%yG gP$ #*Qt| Q+i 9=k +Z| hC 98k aM| &z|9g!h
!b9TqyGh Q9qwyG Bt}* 9}v 9"At| ,Bt}yG OVC {FQyG
)1(

iC

#| >GgA@ : xyPyh #+t+tJyG O;=yG e9wI ~8zvh f(pQZA* ~8E aQZAyG GP$ g9: d(t! GP9|
.~%tI ~%A=ZAiG 98C ,zf J9|(wJyG )yE fhQd"* ~%p ?|(wI iC g9: ~%y aQZ@

)1(

277

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

;* :h A)V )zf i(z* : uyGR}yGh JGQDgyG ~JAt* &g| #}< Q9S ~C


)}T* 9| y9"=yG #TI )"g* ryzp ...z 226vY N+WyG d9s ~C A)V )zf
#| VhQq}yG f9v d9AtyG )zf #+<QO| 9<k 9=V ~]* e9d! ($h yU9MyG e9d"yGz
H9=WyG A:|$ f9v Osh O(9h R+zw!G #| IGRjyG #+zAJ}yG ?z@9t| ~$OGOfE
k
)yE G(y(;h 9]g< ~%]g< {As Otp Og< 9}+p ?f9}GyG )zf ;+<h GQk V A9+qL}G
~%vGQOE )zf {*(g@ :h e;S G )p ~%y &tp: #| O* )p H9$QEh >*Q< IGOC
9!G(LE G(T+y ~8E -J(}* fG {=s- ~%+p 9"=yG #TI d9s Osh e9gyG Ky9Zzy
.9"=yG #f 9$9!QvP )AyG ?y9t}yG )yE Q+W* y#+}zT| G(T+yh
:?T+q"yG J:(t"yG gP$ Og< QQvCh
~+d"AyG d9FQ #f 9"=yG #TI N+WyGh )yGRjyG N+WyG gQvP 9| #+< bQqyG 9|
f9}* Gz U+q"yG &y9t| )p Qv9V O}IC )\9tyG N+WyG gQvP 9| #+<h U9MyG
N+WyG )yE O(g! fC {|C )zf d9_ iPyG u+zgAyG GP$ f6G ~AM!h yxAqyG O+s
.IO*OF ?y9t|h iQLC IQ| Qv9V O}IC
e

)1(

~+zS N+Wzy y?+|;S

9f9}GyGz ?aSG(< ,)yGRjzy E*OJyG 9"I9qv )p uJyG ~y9g| #| )1(


.)y;%yG

GJ

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

278

#* O % f #+ <

9%pGO$Ch ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= IzW! eGQwyG 9"FGQty 9"+< fC u=S
~%=TJ!- #_9=yGh Q$9dyG )p fhOtAg* 9}< 9%y9FQ eGRAyGh 97O+tfh 9%y9FQh
k
-?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C d(YC #| ;YC 9"+<h uG )zf ~%+vR! :h xyPv
xyP h|h QvPyG ?qy9TyG ~7:9t| )p 9+k t+=a@h 9*k Qd! 9"L(+V &|RAyG r+vh
QGQs QOY Otp ?}+df ?"J}< ?f9}GyG B+zA<G Otp gOIh uG 9%}zg* H9=S}
?+fQWyG ?+g}GyG )yE 9$OF9T|h ?f9}GyG ~]< QY9"yG O=f d9= U+FQyG #|
#*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG d(t* xyP )ph -9+k }SQ ?f9}GyG W9W! rs(@h?+g}GyG A9]fC ~$ ?"TyG Q9Z!C OF9T| )p f(z}g* #*PyGh ...z
k
k
JGQc9"|h JGA9ty BCOIh GO*hQ GO*hQ ~%g| f(azAM* GhAO<h ..?+fQWyG
JQ9Zp iQLC IQ| ?"TyG Q9Z!C O+fC 1972 ?"S )p ~C J9SQGO|h J9<9Avh
k
GP$ >=T< GOF ?+y9f ?=T"< ?+qzS -e9}Ay9< ?*QgVC B!9vh- ?+fQWyG ?+g}GyG
I(fOyG gP%y A9jyE &!Ch IQ+aL ?yzT| &!C )zf &+yE Qd"! 9"v iPyG L9|O G
OF9T| Q+i #| QWA"@ ?+qzTyG I(fOyG JQ9Y fC JQ}CC ?yzT}yG gP%p ?+zwy9<
?zLGO ?"TyG Q9Z!C BJ=YC 9}y &!C QLB g9:E )p JQ}CC xyPv ?"TyG Q9Z!C
Q+i OF9T| f(8W"* ?"TyG Q9Z!C I9fO CO< Q="| 9%y U+yh ?+fQWyG ?+g}GyG )p
y?+qzTyG I(fOy9< e(t@ ?+fQWyG ?+g}Gzy :h ?"TyG Q9Z!} ?g\9L
d(sC
iQLC IQ| )}SQyG {}gyG )yE ?f9}GyG JO9f
JGO9TyG U+FQyG O%f )ph
y)gp9WyG O9VQ N+WyGz JQ%Vh )gp9WyG O+G}yG O=f O}J| N+WyG ?S9FQ<
?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= f9Tz< ?t_9! f(wAy O+I(AyG ?zG| QGOY{< e9sh
k
Og< ~C )tqyG O|9I N+WyG A9"<C )yE ByB )AyG i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| #f ;*O<
.?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= #f BzZq!Gh uJyG I(fO ?f9= )yE xyP

)1(

.v10:9v

Y .v$1417 dG(V QV9gyG OOgyG )!9a*Q=yG i(="yG iO%yG ?zG|

)1(

279

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Og< ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= JQ9S )qzTyG H%"}yGh i(fOyG bMyG Uq! )zfh
9Yk (Z! ?|OtAyG gP$ Og< xy QvPzSh 1972 ?"S 9+k }SQ {}gyG )yE 97O(f
d(t"}yG( u<9TyG ~TtyG )p eGQwyG AGQtzy 9"+< Otyh O+I(AyG ?zG| #| J:9t|h
?zG}yG H9Avh ?f9}GyG N(+V rs(| H9AwyG #| )i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| #|
{Y}G GP$ O*|@ J:9t| 9!QvPh 9+k z}f O;=yG )p ?}F9tyG ?azTyGh ~v9JyG #|
:)@6G )p [MzA* iPyG )qzTyG
d(ty9< : ~%+zf LhQMyG eOfh ?+fQWyG ~%A*:(<h ~%Ag+=< aGQAf}G -1
.{gqy9< :h
&+p 9|h M;ZyGh iO%yG )yE uG ~%tp(* fC ?=S9"| {v )p ~%y A9fOyG -2
.?g*QWy9< ~wJyG ~%}%z* fCh O9=gyGh O;=yG Q+L
k
.~%s9q! #f ;]p ~%A"$GO| hC e9wJyG A9aLC Q*Q=@ eOf -3
gP%y J9=S9"}yGh UQqyG d;jASCh uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG )yE ~7(fO -4
O;=yG )zf uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG cQ@ IQ(aL f9+<h ~%y 9%"+*R@h I(fOyG
.uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG OFG(p f9+<h IQL6Gh 9+!OyG )p O9=gyGh
e9wJyG h| ?+fQWyG &a<G(]< Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G -5
.~%y KZ"yG ~*Ot@h
k
hC 9$9FhC >Y9"| G(y9"* )wy e9wJyG U(ZM< G(=Av 9| G(=Aw* ~y -6
k
H9JYC G(T+y ~%p xyP #| A)V )yE G(gS 9| ~8C B=D* N*Q9Ay9p :9|
k
#| ~v9I iOy ?!9w}< )dI ~%"| GOIC aQg! :h ?yhOyG )p >Y9"|
.e9wJyG
^g< )zf 9+k p9L f9v 9}<Q GQk |C Q%d! fC >J! Bs(yG Uq! )ph -7
O%gyG )p AG(S ~wJyG QZs #f GOk +g< e9gyG RvQ}yG #w* ~y- ($h :C S9"yG
QZf )p &!C GOk +F ~zg* ?+M*Q9AyG KGOI}G h<9A* #|h iQ(%}GyG hC )wz}yG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

280

OIC Y9aASC 9| xyP h|h ~%+zf >T; S9"yG S9q!C B!9v Q(ZgyG #|
J9f9= )yE >T"* 9}| A)V )p WQ(@ 9%L(+V hC ?f9}GyG d9FQ fC B=D*
: #zgyG )p ~%|;v f9v 9"L(+V fC xyP )"g|h- e9wJyG )zf LhQMyG
9}v ~$ {< -?f9}Gzy e9gyG RvQ}yG aQi )p QhO* iPyG e;wyG #f rzAM*
9| {w< M;Y G )yE )gT@ ?f9= ~8} ~%"_9=y 9tk pG(| ~$Q$9c f9v BqzSC
k
k
CO=* M;YE 9}!Eh btp 9+S9+S 9I;YE U+zp )"g| #| M;Y G ?}zv &+"g@
~%q<h )y9g@ uG YQV uph M;YE {v &+zf e(t* iPyG S9S}G ($h O9tAf 9<
.Ky9ZyG ?|}G rzS
&+zf &=AVG 9}<Qh ?t<9TyG J:9t}yG Q9s &dI;* Q|C c9"$ f{p xyPv -8
a9Yhz< &!(Ag"*h {+G=AyG GP$ {w< bhQ9p xz}yG #f f(COJA* GP9}y dzTp
k
IQZ"y #+z|9gyG A9}zgyG #| ;FQ f9v &!zvh &!hQ%d*h i(tAyGh M;ZyG
Y9aASG 9| iPyG xz}yG GP$ #f g9"pQf iPyG h| VQ9gA* GP$ U+yC .e;S G
.&=gV #| OIC &+zf x=* ~yh gO*QW@ ~@h OQ_ 9}!Eh &wz| )zf ep9J* fC
:)@6G )p [MzA* dG|TyG GP$ #f HG(GyGh
{}w* ~y )Ap f9vh gO%f dhC )p bhQ9p xz}yG #+< u*QqAyG #| O<:
~%SCQ )zfh S9"yG f9wp Ky9ZyG H9WyG Q%d}< Q%ch gQ}f #| #*QWgyG
k
&JVQ ~%]g< fE )AI GQk +Dv GQk +L &+p f(z||* GOIC )"DAT! : A9}zgyG h+=
&"f f(g+W*h &"f f(COJA* G(!9v 9|h &A+Jy P8"+I uz_Ch ?+|;S G ?p;Mzy
9}< &qZ@h 9"L(+V #| &+zf )"D@ )AyG J:9t}yG JQOY xyPyh Q+L {v :E
.&"f ~zg@
)zf H9WyG xz}yG h+GWAyh ?|~y ?}+df Ky9Z| u+tJAy xyP f9vh
YQV u+=aA< f(=y9a*h f(JZ"*h :E f(IO}* G(!9v 9| xyPyh QDvC eGRAy}G
k
.xy JQvP 9| ?t+tI )zf rtAy iQLC IQ| J:9t}yG hFGQh ;|9v uG
fC

281

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~%z|C rg\ {s hC- xyP a;L ~%y Q%c Bs(yG QhQ}<h ...#wyh
v
hC g(=S 9|h MG(=yG QqwyG Q%d* ~y &!} ghQqw* ~y ??G+A"yG B!9v GP9}p -&+p
k
.;D| QZ| J(i9_ 9* &y G(y9s hC g(}AV
k
#f f9|RyG Q(jW< f(y(t* hC &Ag+< GhOQ* ~yh ?f9_ #| GO* G(fR"* ~yh
#wyh -GQkhR ?+qzTyG )yE f(=TA"}yG 9"!9|R LQG(L d(t* 9}v- 9fk QV e9| G
)yEh f(|(t* uJy9< {< f(|P* : xyPvh f(IO}* GhO9f 9| ~8C eI;}yG
.f(fO* &|RG(yh O+I(AyG
k
Y9+\ )p 9==S B!9v ~wJyG e9d! )p IQ+Dv b(Ap xyP Og< KOIh ...
)zf A;+AS 9< X+GyG H9=V e9sh -97GP ?+wz}yGh {<- xz}yG TQf
~$ G(J=YCh ~%Ag+< )p &zv >gWyG {LOh ?*Q(%}GyG G("zfGh ~wJyG
fC ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C O"f e(zg|h -O;=yG )p ~wJyG )zf {gqy9< #+}F9tyG
.A9+V}G h+= )p e9| G ~wI &y ~wJyG )zf >zjA}yG
:d9tp )7/13( KAqyG )p QGI #<G ep9JyG xyP )zf Y9= G )wI {<
fCh &g| O9%GyGh >zjA}yG f9azTyG ?f9_ H(Fh )zf A9%tqyG h=C Oshz
.yA9}$OyG #+wT@h A9|OyG #tI #| xyP )p 9}y &+zf LhQMyG #| Ql +L &Af9_
>$P| {v #| f(g}G| ?}F}Gz :H9$(yG O=f #< O}J| N+WyG d9sh
:(yh A9+V}G h+= )p e9| G ~wI &y -fGOz< hC- Oz< )zf >zj@ #| fC )zf
)1 (

xz}yG >S )p iQ9=A@ rJZyG JPLCh ?|(wJyGh xz}yG f9azS rg\ )p 9=k =S B!9vh )1(
xz}yG rg\ ~iQ<h J:9+Ai:G )zf fG(L}9v LhQMyG J9f9= xyP hGVh &"| {+"yGh
k
#| GO* G(fR! 9| 9"L(+V fC :E- &gzM< rA7 )AyG JGQ$9d}yG e9+sh S9"yG )zf &!G($h
98k +V ~%qzw@ : d(ty9< 9%Ash LhQMyG )yE I(fOyG B!9vh -LhQMyG )yE G(fO 9|h ?f9_
f9v {%p .gO9Tph xz}yG ?S9+T< O*O"AyG )p ?*QJyG BzjASG )AyG ?p9JZyG ?}S B!9v Otzp
k
.gO"f 9}+p f(z|z* G(!9v eC &!zV GP$ xz}y ?f9ayG O* YR! #f G(g"A|G 9}"+I GOIC f(p9M* 9"L(+V
.A)V )p ?S9+TyG #| G(T+zp -?|C d9FQ G(!(w* ~yh ?z| d9FQ G(!9v ~8E d(sG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

282

9"|(* )yEO}IC e9| G {=s- {*(_ #|R #| S9"yG f} 9+!OyG B|9tASC 9| GP$
98k +V fC QvP A9}zgyG #| GOk IC f(pQg* :h OIGh e9|E )zf G(g}AFC 9| -GP$
.y~df}G e9| 9< :E KZ* : e9wI}G #|
k
LQL #|z y9f(pQ| IQ*Q$ )<C E*OI MQV )pz )!9g"ZyG e9| G d9s {<
.~zT| &FQLC y?+z$9F ?A+| &AA+}p J9|h ?f9}GyG bQ9ph ?f9ayG #f
fzvh &+zf Y9}AF:G hsh iPyG ?q+zMyG ?f9_ iC y?f9ayG #fz &y(sz d9s
h+= )p ?q+zL )zf S9"yG h}G*o ~y PE Q9as}G #| Qas iC ?q+zL OGQ}yG
~F9t< ~+zsE {v {$C {tASG {< ?+S9=gyG ?yhOyG A9"CC #| ?+|;S G O;=yG
v
Bzty e;S G {$C &+zf h}AFG ?q+zL )zf E*OJyG {}Io (y PE ~$Q(|z<
?f9_ )zf G(tq@G #*PyG ?f9}GyG #f LQL iC y?f9}GyG bQ9ph &y(sz &@OF9p
e;TyG {=S y~$hOf #f ~%_9Ih ~%A}zv &< Bg}AFGh ~%z}V &< ~dA!G e9|E
)1(

.)499/3(

Q $R}G

uFGOI )zf upOA}yG QGQGyG {+TyGz &<9Av )p )!9v(WyG d(t*h


:)512/4(

9Y Os &!C e(zg}p &pGQ_C Of9=@h &AgsQ Y9T@Gh e;S G Q9WA!E Og< 9|Chz
xyPv QL6G QatyG )ph f9azS hC e9|E )yE ?*:(yG -Q9asC hC- Qas {v )p
&A*:h )yE BgFQ )AyG gQ9asCh QL6G Qas )p )8 :h Q|C ~%]g=y Otg"* :h
&y ?g+=yG Og< ~%"| OIGh {wy ?f9ayG >G*h #+_;TyGh ?}F}G OOgA< Sz< ;p
QL6G QatyG >I9Y xyPvh &+$G(!h gQ|GhC &+p Pq"* iPyG QatyG {$C )zf
~wJyG f9v &z$C &g*9<h &A*:h &+p BA=C Os iPyG QatyG )p &fR9"* #| e9s GP{p
o
.>A* ~y GPE {At* fC &+p
Q

9%=Vh c9*Eh PFG("y9< &+zf ^gp H9$(yG O=f #< O}J| e9| G e;v GP$ Q=vC &zyG )1(
.#+_9+WyG J9T+=z@ #| 989p #+*RJyG

283

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Of9=Ay &A*:h B; d(LOyG :h &Af9_ QL6G QatyG {$C )zf >: :h


#| iQO* :h 989azS hC 9%|9|E Q=L 9%"| Of9=@ 9| )yE kz=* : Os &!{p Q9as}G
GP$h b9a* : 9}< r+zw@ GP$ d9JyGh ?f9ay9< r+zwAy9p J9| hC ~%"| e9s
&!{p GP$ aQf9p ..O;=yGh O9=gyG dG(IC )zf Y;_E &y #| {wy e(zg|
)p d9t* 9| x"f YOh ?yO}G &+zf dO@ 9}y u<9a}yGh ?+fQWyG OfG(tzy >S9"}yG
9|h e;S G dhC )p ?+|;S G ?*:(yG &+zf B!9v 9| #+< bQqyG f{p &Aqy9M|
uJAT* : B$9=| (%p GP$ Qw!C #|h Q9%"yG U}V #| K\hC f6G &+zf )$
&gFGQp H9=yG GP$ )p U+q! e;v c9"$h y9%ztg* : &!} ?GJy9< >_9M* fC
.
UFQ< e;TyG O=f Q(AvOzy e9wJyG ?z|9g| H9Av )p
fC fhO*Q* #+qy9M}yG f} GQk +Dv &y(I B!O!Oh &+p Bz_C Q|C GP$h *
eOfh ?}F}G Q(F )zf Q=ZyGh ?f9ayGh h}TyG )p YQWyG U(Z! G(pQZ*
~$h- e;S G O;< h+= )zf e(t* iPyG e9gyG ?q+zMyG )yE ~%+zf LhQMyG
?p;MyG W(tT< xyP #w* ~yh B%A!C Os )"g}yG GP6 ?p;MyG fC f(}zg*
QZf P"| H9$(yG O=f #< O}J| e9| G d9s 9}v {< e1924 ?"S ?+!9}DgyG
)p #+_Qq| G(!9v ~zgyG {$C h+= fC xyP )"g| -{="I #< O}IC e9| G
QZf A9F )AI -?+qzTyG A9+fOC )fO* 9}v- ~+dgyG {Y}G GP$ )yE I(fOyG
k
N(+Wp u9< :E I(s :h d(I :h 9=F9i f9v 9| g(M+W}A| &+p Q%cCh >F9GgyG
k
G(!9wp- hsG(zyh YQWzy ?tpG(| ~7(fO JQ%c GO+F GP6 ~%}zgy ?"TyG Q9Z!C
k
O*OF e;v GP$h -hsG(y9< ~%ApQg}y GQk CC hshCh YQWzy ~%f9=@9< 9dI OgSC
e;w< G(<QW@ Otp -~%"| IQC9v IQDv )zf hC- I(JZy9< )}T* 9| H9=V )zf
k
e9wJzy Q+qwAyG )$ ?tJyG ?+qzTyG fC GhOtAfGh 9"*O g("ch ?"AqyG A9=aL
d9}f}G gP$ R(|Q ~$ d9a<}G K=YCh Q<9"}yG )zf ~%=Sh ~%+zf LhQMyGh
H%"| )yE ?+fGOyG K=Z* Pm 8"+Ih y?"TyG JQw!Cz G(y9s OIC ~%+zf Qw!C GPEh
IQ9@ gO9tAfG )ph &A+! )p 9}%A| 9"L(+V rsG(| #| g9"J\hC iPyG rzTyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

284

#f Q+q"Azy IR$9GyG J9|97:G ?}F9s QLB )yE ...?y9}gy9< IQ9@h A9FQ 9<
gP$ {D| )p e;wyG #f A9}zgyG #| Q+Dv aRf xyPyh- uJ< #++qzTyG I9fOyG
A9|OyG BwqTp e9wJzy : ?|9gzy ?"$GO}yGh ?+tAyG B!9v IQ}yG gP$h -Q(|}G
x
QvP! 9"!Ez :d9s #| bOY Otyh .u9< :E I(s :h d(I :h f9_h}G Bf9\h
)p ?f9GWyG fz<h GhO9t* fC : GhO(t* fC >G* A9}zgyG fz< {\9p}G N*9W}yG
?%FG(| )p ?f9GWyG #f ?+}$C {t@ : H(TJ}yG Q+i S9}JyG ?%FG(|
?=_9M| {}W* {< e9wJyG ?=_9M| )zf QZAt* : uJy9< YOZyG fEh fGhOgyG
x!z< ?+fGOyG hC N+WyG 99C x+yE &F(* 9|k 97E fEh -xyPv Y9=@}Gh Q+$9}GyG
xy Q+L -I(fOyGh ?|}G #f ?}+df ?"Ap AQO h|- dP9MA| hC dPM|
Uq!C xt"f )ph uG )tz@ ~C A9"DyGh MO}yG xy d9w* fC #| e;S5yh
~$PLC hOgyG O+< #+}zT}yG #| iQSC hC ?|(Zg| ?}zT| dG(|Ch ?|(Zg|
H9=SCh e;S G {$C )zf 96 f(azTA* QqwyG {$} hFGQPh ,IOQ9< ?}+"i
.I(fOyG 96 f(<Q9J* b9q"yG {$}
)ph ~*OtyG )p ~%G%"|h ?f9}GyG N(+V( #f gQvP! 9"v 9| )yE O(g!h
:d(t"p )QY9g}yG
)p ~$QZf A9}zf QZ<h h}S B; f9v e9wJyG #| 9"L(+V rsG(| fE
9}v {< ^g< )zf ~%]g< A9}zgyG J9vGQOASG IQDv h|h ?+|;S G O;=yG h+=
k
#+*O|9I G(!(w@ : YhQqyG A9]f} d(t* f9v O|9I N+WyG fC 9t<9S xy Bzt!
)zf ~%]g< f(vQOAT* ~$ G(!9wp .{+yOyG G(g=@G 9}!Eh )!hOzt@ : )"g*
)yE Qd!Ch Qv9V O}IC N+Wzy ))tqyG O|9I #+<h )"+< )yE Qd!Gh( ^g<
9$Q+ih )tqyG N+WyG )zf )|(Zg}yG N+WyG OhOQh- uJyG ?J+Y J;F9T|
)qzTyG {Y}G GP$ #| ~%qs(| )t<h- J9vGQOAS:Gh J9Ws9"}yG #| 9$Q+ih
#| &!hQ=Ag* {< ~zgyG {$C #| OIC &+zf VQAg* : d(sC : -e9wJyG g9:
gGQ(AvOyG ?FQO {+"y JOfC ?SGQO #| S9=As}G GP$ x+yEh ?f9}GyG J9+<9G*G

285

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q$9_ O}J| O}IC Q(AvOyG OGOfC #| )IO+tgyG ~Ts( iQtyG eC ?g|9F #|


-:IP9AS}G aGQVz< hQ}f
k
y9pQW|z O}JyG QY9! #< O}IC O.C
yXs9"|z )!9+zgyG )zf O.C
?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=z fG("g< ?SGQOyGh( yXs9"|z {tgyG QY9! O.C
y)9$O(%F - 9%G%"| - 9%pGO$C - 97zW!( ?*O}J}yG
- ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= J9+<9G*Ez fG("g< )!9DyG {ZqyG )ph
gQvP 9| {gF Osh d(t* IO+tgyG )p ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= H%"| dh}G EJ=}yG
425-423vY ?f9}GyG J9+<9G*E #|
?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= iQ@ :?+fQyGh )fGQyG )I;Y G H%"}yG d(}V -4
~wJyG e9d! xyP )p 9}< I9+JyG )I9"| ?p9v )p uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG IQhQ\
. ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG ~+w; )yE (fO@h f9azTyGh e9gyG
M;Y{< e9}A$:G IQY9g}yG HGRI}G )zf ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= PLz@h
96 ~A* )AyG )$ 9$OIh 98C ~%"dy ,?+S9+TyG ?azTyGh ~wJyG f(8Vh ?S9FQyG
)zf e(t+p ?f9}GyG H%"| 9|C .)fGQyG )zf ~$R+vQ@ {v f9wp M;Y G
iQ@h ,?+s;L}Gh ?*OtgyG ?+I9"yG #| >gWyG M;YE &g|h )fGQyG M;YE
a9"8ASG )yE iO|* : #||| >gV fhO #| ~zT| ~v9I O(Fh fC ?f9}GyG
.IOVGQyG ?+|;S G I9+JyG
&y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Aw< ~wJy9< ?=y9a}yGz :fG("g< O+I(AyG ?zG| )p A9F
:&Z! 9| |
)1(

)2 (

#+t<9TyG N(+WyG O%f( #*O%gyG #+< ?aSG(yG U=At}yG ["yG GP$ {gFG fG )y K}SGh
.#*QY9g}yG N(+WyG O%fh
. 6U ,)yh}G ?"TyG - v$1406 eQJ| dh}G OOgyG :?<9GAS:G ?zG| Qd!G

)1(

)2(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

286

>gWyG UzG| (]f ?+pGh (<C O(}J| P9AS}G )yE e9gyG RvQ}yG {SQCz
IQhQ\ )p ?f9}GyG iCQ< IQvP| )"_(yG {}gyG ?sQh P+q"@ )zf ~F9tyGh
#+$GQ=yGh HGJy9< xyP IO*|| | &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Aw< ~wJyG )yE IO(gyG
($ d(SQyG ?"Sh uG H9Aw< ~wJyG fC )p xWyG hC dOGyG {=t@ : )AyG
{+=TyG 98C 9}v ?z+="yG d9}f}Gh OG}yG A9"< )yE {+=TyGh QZ"yG )yE u*QayG
. y9%A}zv h=h ?|}G a(qY O+I(@ )yE O+I(yG
?f9= J9"TI #| QvP* 9}|h :M;Y G )p )pQg}yG )}zgyG H%"}yG -5
9$Q9C5< O+I(AyGh IO+tgyG ~zf 9}+S : ?pQg}yGh ~zgyG ~%zgF ,?"TyG Q9Z!C
B!9v AG(S ?F9JyG >TI )zf h}AG}yG J;wW| {Jy {+=TyG )$ 9%zv
k
k
k
k
iQ@ 9}v ,GOVGQ 9+S9+S ;}f hC Uq"zy ?+vR@h b;L}G )zf ?+<Q@ hC GO9%F
{}gyG #+<h ,)\(qyGh Q(%AyG #+<h e;S G )p O9%GyG #+< 9sk Qp c9"$ fC
LhQMyG #+<h K+JZyG e;S G H%"| uph S9"yG M;YE &+p iPyG )S9+TyG
. rzTyG H%"| I9fGQ| eOf h| JGQQ=| :h J9i(T| fhO< e9wJyG )zf
#| BzgF ,?*(fO ?f9= ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= :e9wJyG h| {|9gAyG -6
~8Ch M;YE IGOC 9$Q9=Af9< ,e9wJyG h| {|9gAyG ?+q+v ?pQg| 9%G%"|
($h e9wJyG h| {|9gAyG )p rzTyG H%"| JP<9p ,M;YE )yE f(F9AJ*
iQ@h M;ZyGh ?*GO%y9< ~%y A9fOyG iQ@ )%p ,b=]"}yG K+JZyG H%"}yG
Q=vC OS9q| )yE iO|* :h )\(qyG Q+D* : 9}< ~%AJ+Z!h ~%qzL I;ZyG
u+p(AyG H9=SC Q=vC #| ($ HF9A"yG d9GgASG eOfh E*QAyGh )!zAyG fC iQ@h
. y9%y )y9g@ uG u+p(@ Og< M9G"yGh
)1 (

)2(

)3 (

OzG}yG v$1393 f9=gV #| #|9DyG OOgyG )1(


. 17-16U ,v$1417 dG(V QV9gyG OOgyG - ?+!9a*Q=yG i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| Qd!G )2(
.9%Tq! J9JqZyG :#+t<9TyG #+gFQ}yG Qd!G )3(
. 46U ,dh}G

287

? +fQW y

v$1395

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

? S >F Q V p O I Ay ?zG| QW
Q

"

!h

? sQ<

JGO9TyG Q(!C

O}J| Qs(}yG U+FQyG O+TyG

~w"| QOY 9| )zf QwWyG [y9L xy eOt@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=
?g*QWyG h| 9tk qA| f(w* fC O<: &!Ch IQS}G f(!9ty ?=T"y9< )|(tyG Q}@|}y9<
&yhC ^t"* gQLB f} )w=TyG >"*R IO+TyG dG|S >aV U}Az!h ?+|;S G
?yhO {D}@ IQ+qS ICQ}yG f(w@ fC {=t! : 9"SCQ )zf B!Ch #+}zT}v 9"!}h
?T+FQ hC ?yhOzy ?T+FQ f(w@ fC :h ?*QJyG ~S9< iQgA@ fC :h QZ}v ?}zT|
.#+}zT}yGh e;S G ?|OL )p u+p(AyG xy dzT! uGh .?+\9s :h AGQR(zy
?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG
)gp9WyG O+G}yG O=f O}J|
v$1396

)@6G O+I(AyG ?zG|

?S
"

dh } G

h<
+

Q O

Of p
)

QW!

?y;F )yE ?f9}Gzy e9gyG U+FQyG ?z+]p #| ?+sQ<


.JGO9TyG Q(!C U+FQyGh Oy9L xz}yG

)yE ?+sQ< ?f9}Gzy e9gyG U+FQyG )gp9WyG O9VQ O}J| N+WyG ?z+]p {SQC
JGO9TyG Q(!C U+FQyGh ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}}yG xz| Oy9L xz}yG ?y;F
e;S G ?|OL )p u+p(Ay9< 9}%y (fO* ?+<QgyG QZ| ?*Q(%= U+FQ
.#+}zT}yGh
:)@6G JQW! OOgyG

Uq! )ph

?+<QgyG QZ| )p #+!G(tzy )T+FQyG QOZ}yG 9$Q9=AfGh ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG


{*OgA< f(=y9a* >gWyG UzG}< 9=k F9! 130 fC ?*QZ}yG rJZyG JQW!
QOZ}yG )$ ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG {gG< iQZ}yG Q(ASOyG #| ?+!9DyG IO9}yG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

288

y :|%y uG dzT! {+zGyG {}gyG GP$ cQ9=! PE #J!h h*QWAzy )T+FQyG


U+FQyG O+TyG OV9"! 9}v- ~79"TI {GS )p GP$ ~%z}f {gG* fC eGQwyG
.cQ9=}yG gO%f )p {}gyG GP$ ~A* fC JGO9TyG Q(!C
HG(" G A

$ # "!

289

? +fQW y

J9

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

!9+<

f9

e9gyG

+<

RvQ}yG ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}F #|


?*Q(%}GyG U+FQ d9+AiG

U(ZM<

{qw* iPyG e;S G ~+t< AGO%ASGh ,gQOsh uG A9]t< {|9wyG 9"!9}*E h|


Q9Z!C ?f9= Qw"AT@ ...#|}Gh ?!9|}G utJ*h IOI(yG VQq*h ,I(L}G
)zf >@Q@ 9| fC #zg@h ,r"gyG d9wVC {v Q9w"AS:G OVC ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
k
e9wIC )zf 9FhQL {D}* JGO9TyG Q(!C O}J| {IGQyG U+FQyG d9+AiG #| xyP
:)y9g@ &y(s )p 96(zSCh &+yE I(fOyG u*Q_ K\hC &!9J=S uG f} ,#*OyG
pH G
F
E

C B A@?> o

Qg* :h ,iCQyG VQp )p r"gyG aQg* : e;S 9p . ?*6 {J"y


h"t}yG f9$Q=yGh ?GJy9< QG(JyG )yE (fO* 9}!Eh ...U9YQyG ?jy )yE dhR"yG
fC OI} U+zp ?G+A! )yE a;MyG aGQ_C &A"* ~y GP{p ,?q*QWyG ?%FG(}yGh
k
GQ9qv iOg< G(gFQ@ :z :| &y(ty QL6G )zf M;TyG {}J* hC r"g*
.y^g< H9sQ ~w]g< HQ]*
IQhQ]< ?|}G e;S G ~Zf #AqyG JOGRh H(aMyG B}%yOG GPEh
uz :d9s ?&zyG d(SQ 9* #}y :G(y9s y?J+Z"yG #*OyGz | &y(ty KY9"AyG
~wy )\Q* uG fEz | &y(tyh y~%A|9fh #+}zT}yG ?}F}h &y(SQyh &<9Awyh
k
G(}ZAg@ fCh ,98+V &< G(vQW@ :h uG GhO=g@ fC ~wy )\Q* :9C;C ~wy gQw* 9C;C
k
.E*OJyG y...~w+zf uG g:h #| G(JY9"@ fCh ,G(sQq@ :h 9g+= uG {=J<
9|9wI- h+}GyG iOA9 fC KZ"@ :?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=h
a

]125

G :

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

290

(yh .| uG d(SQ H8 )zf GhQ+T* fCh ,~*QwyG fBQtyG iO6 -#+|(wJ|h


,r+"JyG YQWyG &y &"+< iPyG gOI O"f {v rs(y ?J+Z"yG gP6 h+}GyG PLC
V UT S R o :)y9g@ d9s Otp .uG OhOJy Rh9: c9"$ f9v 9|h
xzT| G(wzT* fC h+}GyG OV9"! 9"!C 9}v . ?*6 ;ay pX W
GP$ #zg@ PE ?f9}GyGh .?|}G IOIh )zf 9c9qI ~79pQZ@ h+= )p dGOAf:G
9aL OOT* fCh ,9"p(qY OI(* fCh ,#AqyG 9"="G* fC )y9g@ uG )yE YQ]A@
)1 (
. O9=gyGh O;=yG Q+L &+p 9| )yE &tp(*h cQ9=| )"TI O}J| U+FQyG
]1

.v$1402

G :b

n q

G[

?"Ty eQJ}yG -dh}G OOgyG- O+I(AyG ?zG|

)1(

291

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q QJAyG ?}zv

)}%p O}IC /N+WyG ?|;gyG


Q+M<

d GR

9|

...QZ| H9=V

Og<hz uG d(SQ )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh ,u O}JyG


["* )|;SE Oz< )p 9"!C QvPA! fC >G* QZ| )p #+}zT}yG #J! 9"!{p
)$ ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG fC )zfh ,e;S G ($ )}SQyG &"*O fC )zf gQ(ASO
#| QZ| >gV #| )}dgyG ?+=y9jyG fC 9}v ..h*QWAzy )T+FQyG QOZ}yG
.~%"*O< #+wT}A}yG #+}zT}yG
)p HC {v fC )$ iQLC ?t+tIh ...9%+zf O+vzAyG #| O<: uF9tI gP$
QT@ eC {vh ,~%"*O< #+wT}A| ~$GQ* 9|O"f &@9"<h &F9"<z< QMq* Oz=yG GP$
.#*OyG GP$ HGO5< f(|RAz* 9$O:hC iQ@ 9|O"f MQq@h
Y9+]yGh IQ+JyGh bR}AyG #| O+I(yG Pt"}yG ($ uG #*O< e9ZAf:G fC xV :h
#| f9T! G iQAg* 9| {v #| LQM}yG ($h ,)Tq"yG HGQa\:Gh uztyGh
.gQGQtASGh &AIGQh &FhO$ )zf )]t@h &sQ|@ )AyG ?+Tq"yG {|G(gyG
NMo &!9J=S d(t* 9}v ,&< f9}* Gh &ApQg| )zf S9"yG uG Qap Oty

\[
Z YX

W
V

U T

SR Q PO
?*6
Qf} p]

Oy(* :E O(y(| #| 9|z | uG d(SQ d(t* 9}vh


{Fh Rf uG &SQi iQap Q|C #*OAy9p GP$ )zfh E*OJyG y...IQaqyG )zf
gP$ #f aGQJ!G ($ &"f Og=yGh #*OyG )zf LhQMyGh .S9"yG hF9=_ )p
.IQaqyG
- IQ+L}G JG("TyG )p 9"<9=V d(JA* fC ?=+_ ?+JY IQ$9c B!9v xyPy
)yE ?f(+}yG #| ...^+t"yG )yE ^+t"yG #| -1967 e9f ?Tw! Og<
bR}AyG #| i(tAyG )yE d;J!:G #| ..?y(FQyG )yE E"MAyG #| ..?|9tAS G
]172

G :aG

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

292

)yE &GA* 9"<9=V iQ! fC 9tI ?+JY IQ$9c B!9v Oty ..#*OAyG )yE Y9+]yGh
e9WAI:G )yE #%GA* 9"@9+Ap iQ! fCh ,)JzyG A9qfE )yEh OF9T}yG
AG(y {}I fC Og< QMqyG h\(| -9"@9+Aph- 9"<9=V K=YC )AI ..>GJAyGh
... Q+d"yG hat"| S9}J< &"*O )zf aQgA* CO<h ,?+|;S G ?]%"yG gP$
IR%FC bW"@h ..IQ+L}G KOG(JyG ht@ ~C ....eRAz*h ..Xs9"*h ...CQt*
S9"yG a(MA+p ..H9=WyG #| J98| h]< )zf ^=t@h ..#|}Gh ?_QWyG
xT}A| {v fC fhQ+DwyG OtAg*h ..#*OAyG #| f(p(MA*h ..e;S G #|
~$9Jy #| f(ZzMA* #+JAz}yG #| fhQ+DwyG ..gQ|C )p 9%k =AW| K=YC &"*O<
)p f(zZ* #*PyG ..H9t"yG hC H9GJyG #gzM* #%]g< J9+AqyG ..9%tzJ<
..h+}GyG O(T@ uztyG #| ?y9I ..X(Jz| {wW< ~$OGOfC {t@ OF9T}yG
f(GTyG )p &< )tz+y >*Qs 9}f )@z+S gQhO fC -zaL- Q(ZA* {wyG
.&@GP< O(Zt}yG ($ e;S G fzvh ..J;tAg}yGh
k
Oz< )p 9"yR 9| 9"!{p ..~wTq!C )zf G(!($ ..I(L}G 99C ;%| d(sCh
gP%y M;Y :h ..9%zv ?*QW=zy g9]@QG iPyG uG #*O ($ e;S Gh .)|;SE
#*OyG ~+y9gA< eGRAy:9p ,#*OyG GP6 B}ZAfG GPE :E 9%y M;p :h ?*QW=yG
.I9+I IQhQ\
:d(szp O(fCh

QZ| )p H9=WyG fE ?..&zv H9=WyG ~%A* {%p ..IQ+jY ?8p Bz\ GPE
)AIh ..?F9}g=S ~8C {+s u+tJAyG #$Q ~%+zf V(=t}yG fE ..Q+M< dGR 9|
~zT}yG QZ| H9=V )yE A:|$ ?=T! 9}p ..9gk += ~%pGQJ!G u+tJAyG B=CC (y
Q+M< )t=+Sh ..Q+M< dGR 9| ~zT}yG QZ| H9=V fE d(sC GP%yh ..#*OA}yG
. &zyG A9V fE
)1(

, 1402

?"Ty QqY -)!9DyG OOgyG- O+I(AyG ?zG|

)1(

293

$ # "!

? +fQW y

"

? O}J}yG ? TyG

*(wyG

Q9Z C

KGOIC

?f9}Gy

#f ?+<QgyG

e9gyG

?S9+Ty

+FQyG

f9

Gh

?+}v9Jy

+<

*Q(%}G<

QZ| ?

>zSh >%! ?}*QF B*(wzy )sGQgyG hRjyG


#+}zT}yG Q+ih #+}zT}yG #+<

JGO$9g}yG eGQ<E

~w I

Og=p ,QV hC Q+M< 9%y N*Q9AyG O%V Q(Zf )|;S G ~y9gyG )zf Q|
rIR ,#*OyG #f ~%pGQZ!Gh A9qzMyG rg]< ?+S9=gyG ?yhOyG BzJ}\E
OVC B!9vh - v$656 e9f ?+S9=gyG ?p;MyG )zf G(]tp 9+SB bSh #| Q9AAyG
k
k
k
k
,9=*Q<h ;Ash 9=8h 9=zS bGQgyG )p Q9AAyG {}f PE ,#+}zT}yG )zf 9gsh
.{+As f(+z| #f O*R* 9| OGOj< ?+|;S G ?}Y9gyG )p )zAtyG #| btSh
f9azTyG I(s ~%A%FGh ,e9WyG #*OY9s ,bGQgyG HQi )yE G(qIR 9}yh
QV Q9AAyG ?}*R6 B%A!E HhQI JQGOh .9]k *C e9WyG &g=A* f9v iPyG iQZ}yG
N+V ~%SCQ )zfh ,#+}zT}yG A9}zf HhQJyG gP$ )p cQAVGh .?}*R$
.)y9g@
?+}+@ #<G e;S G
#+}zT}yG #wyh ,OGOj< )p Q9AAyG iR9M| #| OVC N*Q9AyG {GT* ~yh
Q9AAyG HhQI )p N*Q9AyG {GT* ~yh- bR}| QV ~$(sR|h ~%S9q!C GhOQASG
~zp G(qg\h ,~8G(q"f Og< G(!9wASE ~8} xyP OGOj< )p g(zgp 9| e9Wy9<
)p ~%y(LO< Q|}G )%A!E ~C .JGQ9GAyG >8h dG(|}G >zS )yE GhzGz*
.e;S G
#+< HQJyG B!9v .e9f )A8| JQ}ASE )AyG ?+=+zZyG HhQJyG f9<Eh
9<QhC dhO #| #+=+zZyG #+<h ,?%F #| :9GS e9WyGh QZ| )p #+}zT}yG
f(+=zZyG {AIEh- ?G!QqyG #| ~$Q+ih 9+!9=SCh 9T}"yGh 9T!Qph 9+y9a*{v
fC

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

294

}zT}yG iO*C #| SOt}yG B+< YGRA!E ~%}$ Q=vC f9vh e9WyG fO| ^g<
,~$OF9s QSz< B%A!E IQ(Z"}yGh W9+|O )yE JOA|E ?"I9_ cQ9g| JQGOh
SO9TyG fQtyG )p xyPh )y9g@
#*OyG M;Y O* )zf ?}*R$ QV G(|R$h
.)iO;+}yG QWf )!9DyG( iQG%yG
>w@Q* ~y ,cGP"+I iQ9Z"yGh #+}zT}yG #+< IhGOgyG IOV h|h
B*(wyG {$C h| #+TI eGOY X+F {gp 9}v >zTyGh >%"yG #| f(+=+zZyG
.e9*}G gP$ )p
Rf9| G(=zSh ?}*QwyG J(+=yG J9|QI G(w%A!Gh ,QF9A}yGh c("=yG >8 PE
QF9A}yG )yE G(8Gyh ,9%+=vGQ #| JGQ9+TyG raM< x+$9! ,&"}C ;ih &=za|
)zf S9"yG e9$ ,OGOj< )yE #JWyG JGQ9+S )p Bz}I ,9=k 8 9$(=%"p
:h HGQV :h d9| ;< ,9!GOIhh J9pGQR AGQJZyG )yE GhQph ,~%$(Fh
.e9g_
#| ?=*QtyG dhQA=yG h<9"| )zf A;+AS:G B*(wyG M9+AFE #| aO%yG f9vh
hpQ 9}| - {+|Q< )!(+z| #| QDvC HA"* iPyG f9sQ=yG {tI ?Y9Lh OhOJyG
{+|Q< #+*;| ?T}L QOZ@ fC Bf9aAS9p dhQA=yG ~y9f )p B*(wyG fzV
k
.9+|(*
J9<9<OyG hpGO| bzT@ GP9}zp B*(wyG hRi #| OZtyG ($ xyP f9v GPEh
?<9<O ryC B%:E .GQ+|O@ ghQ|Op AGQ|}Gh A9%F(yG )I ?Y9Lh J(+=yG )zf
.I(tyG #| bj]yG GP$ ?%FG(| )zf i(t* : Q+jY Oz< ($h )B*(wyG hRjy
izp .g(vQ@ 9}| A)V )zf fh(z* : AGQJZy9< QGQqyG )yE )y9$}G Qa\9p
?#+"|B e(s )zf hsh iPyG ~zdyG GP$ #| GQk w! OVC ?}*QF
| &y(ty .&}zc #f ~y9dyG rw< Q|Ch ,~zdyG eQI e;S G #*OyG fE
r+wp ,9|k (zd| gQZ"@ GP$ uG d(SQ 9* G(y9s ,9|k (zd| hC 9}k y9c c9LC QZ!Cz
.#+

295

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~zdyG #f &qw@ d9s ?9}k y9c gQZ"@


#f Og=* : ,9Fk 9A!E ?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}}yG d(tI Q=vC B!9v 9}yh GP$
A;+AS G ?+i9ayG GP$ aGO$C #| f9v GQk A| (z+v 40 #| QDvz< B*(wyG d(tI
.?*O(gShC ?+A*(v B!9v AG(S 9%zv &at"yG )zf
: )AI ,9|v AGQFE P9<G #| O<: f9v ,?<9<O ryC B; B*(wyG btS 9}yh
.?*O(gTyG Q9<B )zf )y(AT*
k
xz}yG A9fOASE fC #+=A+y ;+zs AGQ(yG )yE IQd! )tz! fC 9"< QOG* 9"$h
k
gOyGh 9%|Q<C IO$9g}y GP+q"@ :E #w* ~y ?+w*Q|}G JG(tzy ,R*RgyG O=f #< O%p
QvP"S 9}v ?+w*Q|}G ?vQWyG h| Os9g@ 9}"+I )y9g@ R*RgyG O=f xz}yG
(J"< V9*QyG )sQV ,fGQ%dyG 9$Qt| f9vh ,Og< uG A9V fE ?+s9q@ G gP$
)zf YR9"A}yG ?+y9}WyG OhOJyG #| (z+v 800 Og< )zfh ,QA| (z+v 500
k
IO$9g}zy 9t=_ ?+w*Q|C JG(s (fO* fC O%p xz}yG #| 9fO< U+zp 9%yhQA<
B}}T@ #| f9$Pz< uzf 9}f Q9=jyG {*R"y ?qsh rt! 9"$h .{=s #| ?|Q=}yG
k
fC f9w*Q|5y K}S GO%p xz}yG fC ?\Qj}yG ?D+=MyG ?*9fOy9< ~$Q9wpC
)zf B*RyG u_9"| #+< ?p9T}y9p {+z]@h h+"W@ GP%p .#+|QJyG VQC G(TG"*
.QA| (z+v 1100 (J! ?|Qw}yG ?w| #+<h OhOJyG
.y

VVV

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

296

#+}zT}yG Q+ih #+vQW}yG

+ (}yGh

h | u CG

$9g}yG

J GO

~wI

#+}zT}yG #+< IO$9g| dhCh .u+CG(}yGh O(%gyG ^t! eQJ* e;S G


,?+=*OJyG IQ}f )p IQG%yG #| 6 e9f | uG d(SQ 9%|Q<C ,#+vQW}yGh
)@z* ~C e9gyG GP$ ?"*O}yG )yE | uG d(SQ hFQ* fC 9%_hQV #| f9vh
k
>Av )p ?J\(| iQLC 9_hQV ?+s9q@ G JQvPh ,{<9tyG e9gyG #| IQ}gzy
.X*Qs B]t! )AI ?+s9q@ G gP$ d(SQyG eQAI9p .?*(="yG IQ+TyGh ?"TyG
k
&y uG >Avh IQG%yG #| 8 e9f 9;9p 9<k Q9J| ?w| {LOh .9%"| | )="yG {z;h
.#+=}yG QZ"yG
G(g"}+y ?d*Qs )"< O(9 h| | d(SQyG 9%|Q<C iQLC IO$9g| c9"$h
- 96 bO"MyG QqI ~A* ~y )AyGh ,9%+p ~$ )AyG ?ta"}yG #| HGRI}G d(LO
,d9="y9< #+}zT}yG h| 9%+p G(tVGQ@ h+<9SC 4 ?"*O}yG f(vQW}yG QY9I 9}yh
#| ?"*O}yG d(LO< HGRI5y M9}Ty9< G(}$h uG d(SQ ?d*Qs ("< f9L
~%g= BsQph ,~%z}V BAV ?+@9f OQ9< K*Q< )y9g@ uG QZ! A9Gp .~%gs(|
)"< | uG d(SQ >s9f ~C .?}*R%yGh ?=+My9< HGRI}Gh X*Qs JO9fh
~$OQ_h ?"*O}yG #f ~$;FCh ,| uG d(SQ GhO$9f 9| ~%]t"y ?d*Qs
.9%"|
#| #+}zT}yG Q+i k| JGO$9g}yG e9+s fC )zf ?GJyG ?|9s xyP JQvP
.9%|GQAIE >G* u+CG(}yGh O(%gyG fCh ,RF9F Q|C Q9qwyG
VVV

297

? +fQW y

+ *

? w Q|

}G

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?vQWyG h| ?wz}}yG ? s9q@G

#+< b9q@ G {ZI .&y uG Qqi O(gS dB R*RgyG O=f xz}yG O%f )p
)zf e1933 ?"S iC v$1353 e9f ?+w*Q|}G J9vQWyG iQ=v #+<h ?wz}}yG
BG|O!G ~C .h<Q| {+| ryC 440 )p dhQA=yG #f >+t"AyG uI ?vQWyG K"|
?vQWyG iC )(w|GQC( ~S9< ?vQV B!(w@h iQLC J9vQV h| ?vQWyG gP$
:9%+p B}$9S )AyG J9vQWyG x+yEh ,?+w*Q|}G ?+<QgyG
~%SC #| %30 ?=T"< BvQAVGh 9"*QQqzw| ahC {*hC QO!9AS ?vQV -1
.(w|GQC
.(w|GQC ~%SC #| %30 ?=T"< BvQAVCh ,S9Tw! ?vQV -2
.(w|GQC ~%SC #| %30 ?=T"< BvQAVGh ,SQF (+! ?vQV -3
.(w|GQC ~%SC #| %10 ?=T"< BvQAVGh {<hC e(v9p )!(wS ?vQV -4
fGQ%dyG {tI rWv #f 1939 ?"S iC v$1359 e9f L9A! G CO<h
.iQLC u_9"| rWv xyP h=@ ~C H+zMyG )zf e9|Oy9<
~C )"+yQASE &+"F #+*;| 3 &A}+s 9| Rh9GA* : cGP"+I L9A! G f9vh
.9!(+z| 150 (J! 1958 e9f K=YC
OGO|E )zf GQk Y9s K=YCh L9A! G rs(@ ?+!9DyG ?+}y9gyG HQJyG B|9s 9}yh
.iO"%yG b+J}yG )p A9qzJyG {+_9SC
L9A! G )p ?vQWyG BaW! e 1946 e9f 9$QGRhC HQJyG Bg\h 9}yh
IR%y iO(gTyG dhQA=yG VQg@ GP%yh ,U*(TyG I9"s Q=f #qTy9< QOZ* f9vh
~y Q*OZAyG #wyh .e1956 e9f QZ| )zf fGhOgyG )p I9"tyG BtziC 9}"+I
~C GO+Y A9"+| )yE fGQ%dyG #| )#*;<9AyG( >+<9!}G bL A9W!E Og< rs(A*
.?+!9"=zyG ?+z$}G HQJyG ?G+A! bMyG GP6 {}gyG rs(@

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

298

(w|GQC ?vQV JzW!C fC O;=yG &< B}g! iPyG iO9}yG LGhQyG #| f9vh
560 d(_h H+zMyG )zfh e9|OyG A9"+}< V9*QyG b<Q* iPyG iO*OJyG bMyG
.GQA| (z+v
VVV

299

+ *

? w Q|

? +fQW y

}G

?vQWyG

#+<h

?wz}}yG

#+ <

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?|Q=}yG ? s9q@:G

)y9g| hsh )e1933 (*9| 29( v$1352 e9f QqY 4 e(* gOF ?"*O| )p
{D}| f9Az|9$ QAT}yGh ,cGP"+I ?wz}}yG ?+y9| Q*Rh f9}+zTyG uG O=f N+WyG
gQ9}DASEh B*RyG #f >+t"Ay9< ?vQWzy K}T@ )AyG B*RyG R9+A|E ?t+Ch ?vQWyG
.9%_hQV ~$Ch
k
gP$ JO| Osh( 1933 e9f #| GQ9=AfE e9f 60 IO| R9+A| G iQT* -1
)p ?vQWyG 9%A"< )AyG J5W"}yG h+= K=Z@ IO}y ?*98 )ph Og< 9}+p IO}yG
k
~+|zAyG O+q* 9}< xyP {*Og@ iQF ~C ?*O(gTyG ?|(wJzy 9wz| ?wz}}yG
.)?*(gTyG ?|(wJyG ?JzZ}y
GP$ )yE ~\h .?qY9"| M9<Q}G f(w* fC R*RgyG O=f xz}yG WGQAVE -2
k
rZ! #| QDvC d9"* Oz< iC )p ?vQV iC fC ;=tAT| K]@G GPE fE WQWyG
.IO9*RyG gP$ )p uJyG ?*O(gTyG ?|(wJzzp M9<Q}G
Osh >+zY &+zf A9"< e9t* :h .SGQFC :h UF9"v A9W!{< K}T* : -3
?}+df IOf9s 97OF(p .975W"|h 9$Q9a|h fGQ%dyG ?ta"| IQ9*R< )Tq"< B}s
.#+*O(gTzy %60 ?=T"< #+SO"%}yGh {}gzy #v9T| 96 9w*Q|C #| ?gas 98zv
(y ?vQWyG J5W"| #f Y9pOy9< 9w*Q|C e(t@ HQI e9+s ?y9I )p -4
.9%+zf AGOAf5y B\Qg@
GP{p .?+w*Q|}G ?vQWyG #+<h ?wz}}yG #+< ?|Q=}yG ?+s9q@ G [Mz| GP$
?ta"| Q9<B )zf A;+AS:9< ?wz}}yG OO$h .GQk +LC B*(wzy bGQgyG hRi A9F
I9+I )p ?|Q=}yG IO$9g}yG u+=a@ )yE O%p xz}yG Qa\G 9%yhQA< IQGRjy OhOJyG
?p9T}yG fz< ~zgyG h| -:- ?SOt}yG #v9|~y ?!9+L xyP Q=Ag* {%p gOyGh
.-~v1800 #f O*R* ?|Qw}yG ?w| #+<h IO*9J}yG ?ta"}yG #|
)y9g@ uG f} xyPh Q+DwyG d9< #f >+j@ )AyG J9|(zg}yG gP$ JQvP Oty

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

300

R*RgyG O=f xz}yG O%f JQY9fh ?z*(_ IO| ?wz}}y9< {}gy9< )"|QvC
~%zvh 9gk += ~%+zf uG ?}IQ- Oy9L xz}yGh {Z+p xz}yGh O(gS xz}yGh
Q+}g@ )p A9MT< dhQA=yGh ?wz}}y9< OF9TyG LGhQyG f9wp ~%+<C H8 )zf GhQ9S
{_9=yG {a=*h uJyG uJ* fC uG dzT! O*OGAyGh ?gS(Ay9< #+q*QWyG #+|QJyG
.u+p(AyG )yh uGh f(=zt"* >zt"| iC G(}zc #*PyG ~zg+Sh
~+IQyG O=f )zf O}J|

301

? +fQW y

~ IQyG O=f

)zf

O}J| N WyG

B * ( w yG

K GO IC

f9

+< )zf

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

u zg@

)zf

9=v ?8+$ rs(}y upG(}yG ?f9}GyG rs(| xy #+=* &@CQs iPyG f9+=yG GP$
k
.:hC GP$ ?*O(gTy9< A9}zgyG
k
k
k
k
Q9=v )p #gayG {%T+y 9=+j| hC 9=F9i f9v 9|9$ GQk |C f9+=yG Q%cC Otp 9+!9C 9|C
J9|97 9p :Eh {s}G )zf GP$- hsG(yG ~%p eOg< ~%|97Gh ?wz}}yG A9}zf
IO9+s #f A9}zgyG O9g<E 9%"| aO%yG f9v 9$QvP #f ~ztyG rg* )AyGh iQL}G
v
.~zS uG #wyh .~%pGO$C )yE G(zZ* fC #++vQJzy {%T+y ?|}G
k
GP+q"@ :E #w* ~y ?+w*Q|}G JG(tzy O%p xz}yG A9fOASG fC #+=* f9+=y9p
?+w*Q|}G J9vQWyG iQ=v h|
R*RgyG O=f xz}yG gOyGh 9%|Q<C IO$9g}y
9w*Q|C e(t@ HQI e9+s ?y9I )p )4( 9$O("< #| f9vh v $1352-e1933 ?"S
IQ| f9+=yG hFGQh y9%+zf AGOAf;y B\Qg@ (y ?vQWyG JzW"| #f Y9pOy9<
N+WyGh r+azyG O=f #< uG O=f N+WyG O%f )p B}@ IO$9g}yG gP$h iQLC
#< O}J| N+WyG h=ay9<h SQ9p #< O}I N+WyGh u+Af #< O}I #< OgS
:
R*RgyG O=f xz}yG f9vh ?+qzTyG I(fOyG ?}FB #| #*QLBh ~+$GQ<E
k
fC -f6G )AI- #cC 9| #*PyGh GOF Q9=wyG ~zgyG {$C ?tpG(}< :E GQk |C )]}*
k
.9"+qy9M| #+<h 9""+< 9| 9p;L ~%+zf
)AyG IO$9g}yG gP$ )zf ~%f;_E Og< LhQMyGh Q+qwAyG N(+V d(t* GP9}p
.
~+IQyG O=f )zf O}J| {+zGyG 9"M+V 9%+yE Q9VC
Q

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

$ # "!

?+}v9Jy

"

? O}J}yG ? TyG

r
qp

Q9Z C

?f9}F

#|

f9

302

+<

on m l k j i
{
}
x w
v ut

S )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh u O}JyG


k
#|}9< uG &!9Y R*RgyG 9!Oz< 96 Q}* )AyG ?t+sOyG ahQdyG #| 9s;a!G
?v+vzvLGOvyG KGOvI}G IQ(vavMvy GQk9vgvWvAvSGh e;vS Gh ?v}vzvTvyGh f9v}v* Gh
iPyG #*OyG ($h- e;S G )yE rT@ )AyGh O;=y9< b+; )AyG ?+FQ9MyGh
~} { :~%"f uG d9s ?|zv #+}zT}yG )yE -)y9g@h &!9J=S uG g9]@QG
.uG d( Q

.}

*
) (

'&

$ #

"

Otg"}yGh ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy ?*O9gyG ?|9gyG ?+g}GyG f{p


31 upG(}yG v$1413 dG(V 8 A9g<Q}G e(* #*O<9f &y(s YQ9V 8 e9gyG RvQ}y9<
fCh ,f9|}Gh #|}G #*O e;S G fC h=C ~y9gyGh ?|~y #zg@ e1993 SQ9|
.gO*h &!9Ty #| f(}zT}yG ~zS #| ~zT}yG
e;S G ~S9< bGQ@ fCh ,e;S G ~S9< #|}G OO9 fC I(s {w< Qw"AT@h
k
gO=f d(SQ GO}J| fCh uG :E &yE : fC O%W@ )AyGh ?}zT}yG A9|OyG
.&y(SQh
IO9gTyG BzI :E hs(| )yE {LO 9| e;S G fC h=C ~y9gzy #zg@h
k
k
.?|C hC 9A+< hC 9=zs hs(}yG f9v AG(S .&< #|RyGh
dG(|}Gh VGQfRyG f(Z@ )AyG )$ ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C IO+tf fCh
:d9tp &pQf e(< &qsG(| h=C )p #zfC e;S G d(SQ fCh 9%+};h A9|OyGh
~vQ%V )p GP$ ~w|(* ?|QJv eGQI ~w+zf ~w\GQfCh ~wyG(|Ch ~vA9|O fEz
I

303

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

P$ ~vOz< )p GP$
9"y A9"<C QZ| A9"<zp IOIG(yG ?|}G )p A9tV}G #+< QG(Jzy (fO@ ?f9}GyGh
~zS G K+\(Ay aO9%yG QG(JyG #| O<:h 9gk += 9!D9"<C QZ| ?_QVh 9gk +=
.K+JZyG
P=!h 9%A|;Sh ?|}G #|C ?|OL )p 979s9_h 979!9w|E {v O": ?f9}GyGh
.9%+p #| {v Oz=yG #|z* )AI A9"=yG Q+"AT}yG QG(JyG OfG(s A9SQEh a;L {v
R*RgyG H9AwyG )yE #+|(wJ|h 9|k 9wI QZ| A9"<C {v ?f9}GyG G(fO@h
c b a `{ :d(t* &!9J=S uGh A)V {v f9+< 9%+qp ,IQ%a}yG ?"TyGh
.yG

.}

mlkjihgfed

{v &"f aQZ* fCh ,9"k |B 9!Oz< {gG* fC &!9J=S u ?fGQ]yG rvC hpQ!
k
k
. OZtyG AGQh #| uGh .;+= GOQ uJyG )yE 9!OQ* fCh ,A(S
)1(

?"TyG Q9Z!} ?|9gyG ?+g}GyG

?+<9$Q

9+z}gyG ?=S9"}< )v$1413( ?"Ty IOgtyG hP QWf iO9JyG OOf :O+I(AyG ?zG| )1(
.QZ| )p

GJ

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

$ # "!

?+}v9Jy

"

? O}J}yG ? TyG

e9gyG

Q9Z C

304

?f9}F

RvQ}yG

U+FQyG >Aw|
f9+<

Otg"}yG ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy ?+|(}gyG ?+g}GyG Y9}AFE )p


e1997 Q=}p(! 27 upG(}yG v$1418 >FQ 27 U+}MyG e(* Q%c IQ$9ty9<
?df(}yGh ?}wJyG )zf e(t* )y9g@ uG )yE I(fOyG {}f fC Q(]JyG #zfC
:E B+< )yE :h &@OgSC :E >zs )yE BzLO 9| e;S G I(fO fCh ,?"TJyG
~%yG(|Ch #+"|zAT}yG A9|O d;JASG fCh .97OgSC :E ?|C )yE :h &@OgSC
no :)y9g@ &y(ty r+"JyG e;S G 96 A9F )AyG O9=}yG ?p9vh )p9"A* {}f
I

}| {z y x w vuts r
q p o
) ( ' & % $ # " !
~
.
?*6 O 9}y p*
]32

G :I F

G[

)p JGAGOAfG #| hsh 9| Qw"AT@ ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= f{p GP%yh


)I9"| {v )ph ~%+p )y9g@ uG YQV ~+w; )yE (fO@h .9$Q+ih QZs}G
?*GQ {gG* fC (fO! uGh .e;S G ?g*QW< f9|}Gh #|}G {J* )AI I9+JyG
#+ZzM}yG O(%F {zw* fCh QZ| Y(<Q )zf aQpQ@ #|}Gh e;TyG
.OGOTyGh u+p(Ay9< #+JzZ}yGh
OZtyG

9gyG U+FQyG

#*OyG Q(!

(qY O}J|

AGQh

#|

uGh

305

? +fQW y

"

? O}J}yG ? TyG

IQ

$9tyG

#*O<9f

Q9Z C

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?f9}F

e9gyG

RvQ}yG

? y( s

YQ9V 8

?*Q(%}GyG ?S9FQ #| ?+y9AyG ?+sQ=yG- ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= Btz@


:)@69v 9%Z!h
#*OyG Q(!

J(qY

O}J| /O+TyG

#*O<9f - ?y(s YQ9V )8( ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG
.IQ$9tyG
)<9$Q G e(G%yG KO9I )p ~w@9SG(|h ~w!h9g@ )zf h+}GyGh ~vQwVC
k
H(gWyG eqJ* fC )y9g@ uG 9+FGQ QZs}G ?"*O| )p hsh iPyG ,QO9jyG
.A(S {v #| ?+|;S Gh ?+<QgyG
-

cQ

9=| )"TI O}J|

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

306
v$1425

?8

"%AyG

gP

J QW

*Q(%}GyG

? S QL 6
"

! O+I(AyG

+FQy

9} F Of p

G iO

?zG|

)p

"%@

? Y9L ? 8

AT| )zf 9%fhQph e9gyG RvQ}y9< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=


?|9Mp )yE ?8"%AyG [y9M< f(|OtA* O+I(AyG ?zG| Q*Q; IQSCh ?*Q(%}GyG

i(

cQ 9 = |

) "T I

O}J| U

+FQyG

#_(yG VQC )yE d(Y(yG ?|;Sh ?+IGQGyG ?+z}gyG M9G! )zf


&tp(*

fC

{Fh Rf )y(}yG #+fGO

O9=gyGh O;=yG

Q+L &+p 9| )yE

307

? +fQW y

N WyG

eQV JGQ

: #|h &=JYh &yBh

+Gq@ #*O@ ?"TyG

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q9Z C

O}JyG
:Og<h
?"*O| )p M9+TyG {As KO9I Og< ,GOkOf #+"S ?"8}a| ?"|B QZ| B@9< Oty
o
~C ,?!9"wyG VQC #| K+=tyG &%F(< )qALG Os H9$Q G fC #vch ,QZs}G
?gT@ d;L ,qp ,uI;A@h h<9A@ H9$Q G KOG(J< 9%=gVh QZ| B8F(p
)p e;S G ~wI 9}p ,N+WyG eQV ~C ,Q$R}G ~C ,9<9_ ?CO9I B!9v Q%VC
O\ 9=k gVh ?|(wI #+}zT}yG )zf e;S G VQp GP9|h ,JGQ+GqAyG gP$
?b;L}Gh f(!9tyGh e9d"yGh e;S G )zf #+FQ9MyG A:|$
&Fh )p a(s(y9< f9|}Gh #|}G )zf X9qJy9< #+"||}yG )y9g@ un G Q|C Oty
uztyG ~%+p Q+D*h )\(qyG ~%qY )p KOJ* hC ,~%"|C YRfR* frC OGQC #| {v
k
k
:)y9g@ d9s ,J9f9= hC G(!9v GOGQpC ,#+}zT| hC G(!9v GQ9qv ,HGQa\ Gh
,g Gh

S )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh

uG d( Q

D CB
A @?
> = <; : 9 8o
P O NM L
K J
I
H GF
E
,
?*6 O 9}y p!@
! xx Y X W V U T
SR Q
]33

G :I F

G[

QJyG #| ?zf9q| ?<Q9J}yGhz ?<GQJyG hC ?<Q9J}yG ?*B ?*6G gP$ )}T@h


)zf #|}Gh ,J9p6Gh QQ]yGh iP}G #| ?|;TyG ($h ,~zTyG O\ )$h
.yd9}yGh Uq"yG
,e;S G QGO )p ?JzT| ?qF9_ LhQL :98z< ?<GQJyG A9%tqyG aQf Osh
,VGQf}G xA$h ,dG(|}G >zSh ,A9|OyG xqSh )\(qyG KGOI
.f(!9tyGh e9d"yGh b;L}Gh #*OyG xyP< ?*OJA| ,{T"yGh KQJyG c;$Eh
#*O$9g}yG hC ,#++|PyG hC ,#+}zT}yG #| ?qF9ayG gP$ f(w@ fC #+< bQp :h
f(tJ| {v )zf 98GhOf eGO 9|h ,e;S G QGO ,p xyP eGO 9| ,#++<QJyG hC
xyPv utJA@ 98{p ,J9f9}GyG #| ?f9= LhQM< ?<GQJyG utJA@ 9}vh .eOyG
,H

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

308

Xa<h JhQ=F {]p OGQp}G #| OQqy f9v (zp ,OGQp}G #| OQp LhQM<
(%p ,VQgyGh d9}yGh Uq"yG )zf ?f9}GyG 96 >zj* IQOsh I(s O*R|h
.HQ9J|
?<9Zfh ,{AtyG ?<9Zgv ,?qzAM}yG J9<9ZgyG ?<GQJyG e(%q| )p {LO*h
?<9Zfh ,c("=yGh J(+=yG )zf (aTzy U(ZzyG ?<9Zfh ,d9q_}G raL
,?"AqyG A9jA<G e9wJyG d9+AiG ?<9Zfh ,#6 Q(Gqzy iQGPgyGh J9"=yG raL
LhQMp ,HGhOyGh )VG(}yG {Ash YhQRyG a;@E ?<9Zfh ,#|}G HGQa\Gh
)zf ?FQ9MyG ?qF9ayG gP$ f} ,?<Q9J| Q=Ag* (J"yG GP$ )zf ?f9}GyG gP$
)AyG ?+|;S G ~+y9gAzy ?<Q9J|h ,>!9F #| ?f9}Gzy ?<Q9J| Q=Ag@ e9d"yG
.QLB >!9F #| 9%s(tI )zf X9qJy9< 9%A|;Sh ?f9}GyG #|C utJAy JA9F
)}T* &!{p ,?<GQI 9%"*O )zfh ?f9}GyG )zf LhQMyG GP$ )}T* 9}vh
;p ,u*QayG #f ?f9}GyG gP$ LhQM< f(gat"* S9"yG f} ,u*Q_ has 9]k *C
xA7 hC ,~%yG(|C >zT@ hC ,~$D9|O xqT@ fC ?+WL ,&+p fhQ}*
n
.&A%FG(| )zf ~%y IQOs : 9}p y f(\QgA* hC ,~%\GQfC
a9LCh ,u*QayG hash M;TyG {}I #}| | uG d(SQ CQ=@ Osh
aQV &y #w* ~y GP{p .y9"| U+zp M;TyG 9"+zf {}I #|z | d9tp ,#+"|6G
Og< aQWyG GP$ &y U+zp ,)I ($h #+}zT}yGh e;S G )yE H9TA!:G
#|z :d(t* | )="yGh ,&+zf J9| 9| )zf O=f {v Eg=* &!} ,9]k *C J(}yG
.y?+z$9F ?A+| J9| J9| ~C ?f9}GyG bQ9ph ?f9ayG #| LQL
Q|Ch ,&y(SQh u #+<Q9J| ?f9}GyG )zf #+FQ9MyG uG )}S Osh
YG(!C )Tsz< ~%+zf )]sh ,~%A"Ap )zf A9]tzy I(t< ~%%Fh )p a(s(y9<
?
> = <; : 9 8o :)y9g@ d9tp ,?<(tgyG
,

L
K J
I
H GF
E D CB
A@
YX W V U T SR Q P O N M

309

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?*6G gP$ dhR! >=S )p fhQTq}yG rzALG Osh , ?*6 O 9}y p!@
! xx
x o
:9}$Q+ih f9M+WyG gGhQ 9}y ,#++!QgyG )p ByR! &!C )zf ~$QDvCh
Gh(AF9p | uG d(SQ )zf G(|Os ?"*Qf #| 9S9! fCz
U!C #f
989=yC #| G(<QW+p {< G )"g* ,&+fGQ< G(tJz* fC | )="yG ~$Q|zp ?"*O}yG
,~8GO<C BJzY )AI 9%yG(<Ch 989=yC #| G(<QWp ,&+fGQ< G(tJzp 9%yG(<Ch
hatp ~6 A)Gp ,~%=z_ )p Eg=p | )="yG kz=p {< G G(s9Sh )fGQyG G(zAtp
)<} ?*GhQ )ph .yG(@9| )AI IQJyG )p G(tyCh ~%"+fC Q}Sh ~%zFQCh ~9O*C
uG dR!zp :d9s ,~6 )@zp ?p9s ~%=z_ )p | uG d(SQ Eg=pz :d9s :OhGO
?
> = <; : 9 8o xyP )p )y9g@h cQ9=@
.?*6G
?*6 O 9}y pA @
,eqzyG e(}g< Q9=Af:G {< ,>=TyG U(ZM< Q9=AfG :hz :)!9v(WyG d9s
uG d(SQ ?<Q9J| )$ ?*6G )p IQ(vP}yG uG ?<Q9J}< OGQ}yG :{+s Osh
?y:OyG fhO IQ9=gyG u*Qa< ,gQZf Og< #|h gQZf )p #+}zT}yG ?<Q9J|h
[AM* )AI ?%p9W}yG H9aL u*Qa< U+y ["yG OhQh f} ,S9+tyG fhOh
{+yO )yE ~$Q+jy H9aMyG ~+}g@ )p L9AJ+p dhR"yG O"f #+qzw}y9< &}wI
~6QJy GQk9=vE &y(SQh u ?<Q9J| #+}zT}yG ?<Q9J| BzgF 98E :{+sh .QLB
k
.>y9j* :h HQ9J* : &!9J=S uG f} ,~%A*P} 9}+dg@h
?<Q9J|h ,&gFGQV ?qy9M|h &+Y9g}< &!9J=S uG ?<Q9J| QTq@ fC )yh}Gh
)gTyGh ,&@(SC ~$h &}wI &A|C ~wIh ,)t+tJyG 9$9"g| )zf {}; d(SQyG
k
cQWy9p ,VQ}G )p O9Tp &!C &+zf bOZ* 9| {v )zf uza* GO9Tp VQ}G )p
xA$h A9|OyG xqSh ,VQ}G )p O9Tp u*QayG hash ,VQ}G )p O9Tp
uI Q+j< uG O9=f )zf )j=yGh ,VQ}G )p O9Tp dG(|}G >8h J9|QJyG
)p O9Tp Q98}G Q*(j@h Q9GV}G hash f9+"=yG eO$h VQ}G )p O9Tp
,

]33

G :I F

G[

]33

G :I F

G[

.VQ}G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

310

S ,xyP &"| hsh #| {v )zf uza@ ?<Q9J}yG fC ~zf GP$ QQt@ GPEh
{+zFh ,Q+Dvh {+zs {v )p ,QZ| Q+ih QZ| )p ,GQk p9v eC 9}k zT| f9vC
hC {AtyG #| ?*6G gP$ )p OQh 9| ($ xyP )p uG ~wI fCh ,Q+tIh
.yVQ}G #| )q"yG hC ,a;L #| {FQ}Gh iO*}G has hC ,>zZyG
)zf eC )$ >+@QAyG )zfC :?<(tgyG gP$ )p fhQTq}yG rzALG Osh
?Q++MAyG
a9LCh ,e;S G ?8p )p M;TyG Q%V #| :d9s S9=f #<G #f ?*GhQ )qp
vo
fEh ,&zAs A9V fE Q9+My9< &+p #+}zT}yG e9|{p &+zf QOsh &< Qqc ~C {+=TyG
.rzTyG #| ?f9= d9s d(tyG GP6h ,&zFQh gO* has A9V fEh ,&=zY A9V
Y9as )p :d9s S9=f #<G #f :dG(IC )zf ?yR"| ?*6G gP$ :Q(%}GyG d9sh
d9}yG GhPLz* ~yh G(zAs GPEh ,G(=zYh G(zAs d9}yG GhPLCh G(zAs GPE :u*QayG
#| ~%zFQCh ~9O*C Bgas G(zAt* ~yh d9}yG GhPLC GPEh ,G(=zZ* ~yh G(zAs
.yVQ}G #| G(q! d9}yG GhPLz* ~yh {+=TyG G(p9LC GPEh a;L
f(<Q9J* #*Pzy fG($h dP &+p 9| {v )zf J9<(tgyG gP$ Bz}AVG GPw$h
SR Q P o :)y9g@ d9s xyPyh ,bQayG Y9as ,&y(SQh uG
)q"yGh >zZyGh {AtyGh hatyG #| AGRGyG xyP iC
?*6 O 9}y pT
dPyGh fG(%yG 9"$ iRMyGh
?*6 O 9}y pT
SR Q P o
fC gQ$9ch
?*6 Qt=y pa ` _^
]
o M9]Ap:Gh
9+!OyG )p H9tgyG #+< 9%+p h= PE ,9$Q+i )Y9g}zy ?qy9M| ?<GQJyG ?+Zg|
k
)p | &y(s Q$9dy ry9M| ($h ,?<GQJyG >!Py 9d+zj@ ,IQL6G )p H9tgyGh
o
)!(g*9=@Cz :d9tp | )="yG O"f 9"v :d9s
B|9ZyG #< IOn9=fo E*OI
#}p A9T"yG ?*B CQsh ,G(sQT@ :h ,G(!R@ :h ,98k +V u9< G(vQW@ : fC )zf
(%p 9+!OyG )p &< >s(gp 98k +V xyP #| H9YC #|h uG )zf gQFzp ~w"| )ph
&<Pf A9V fE uG )yE (%p uG gQATp xyP #| 98k +V 9%"| H9YC #|h &y IQ9qv
AG(

]33

]33

]114

G :I

n n n

G :I F

G[

G[

G :I F

G[

311

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

w+p ,h*R(AyG >TI )zf xyP f(w* fC {}AJ*h .y&y Qqi A9V fEh
#| 9+!OyG )p ~zS fE IQL6G )p H9tgyGh ,>s(f #}y 9+!OyG )p iRMyG
gQ+jv O+f(yG GP$h ,)Y9g}yG QF9S iQG| ?<GQJyG ?+Zg| iQGAp ,H9tgyG
)zf a(L O+f(yG )p #wyh ,>!PyG GP$ Qqj* fC )y9g@ &yh ?8+W}y9< O+t|
.O+f(yG P9q! #| &+zf Of(A}yG
-u*QayG has hC ?<GQJyG ?}*QF- ?}*QGyG gP$ ?f9"V #| ~iQyG )zfh
~%"| G(z=t* fC #+"||}yG Q|z*h ,?<(AyG H9< #+<Q9J}zy KAq* )y9g@ uG f{p
uG d(t* ,#+}zTAT| GhD9F GPE ~%}FGQF ry9T< ~$hPLG|* : fCh ,~%A<(@
e dc b a ` _
^]
\[ Z
o :)y9g@
IQOtyG {=s ?<(AyG f} xyPv xyP f9v 9}!Eh
?*6 O 9}y p!@
! xy f
?q+d! I9+I a9"8ASG )zf eRgyGh ,>ztyG ?dt* )zf {+yO ~%"| #w}AyGh ~%+zf
btSCh ,uG (qf ~%z}V GP%yh ,&y(SQh u ?<Q9J}yGh O9Tp G #f IO+g<
b(tI 9|C ,?<(tgyG >F(AT* 9| G(=w@QG Os G(!9v fE &s(tI #| uI {v ~%"f
,?<GQJyG {+=s #| BT+y P8"+I ?<(tgyG f(w@h ,~%"f btT@ : 98{p O9=gyG
: ~%+zf )"G}yG )yE hFQ* xyP )p Q|}Gh ,U9ZtyG H9< #| #w* 9}!Eh
hC (qgyG eOyG )y(yh ,{AtyG ~A; ~%"f btS G(zAs Os G(!9v f{p ,~v9JyG )yE
)t<h {AtyG ~A;h >zZyG btS d9}yG GhPLCh G(zAs Os G(!9v fEh ,U9ZtyG
JPLCh hatyG btS d9}yG GhPLC Os G(!9v fEh ,d9}yG f9}\h U9ZtyG
>Zi xyP f} ,G(wz%ASG 9| ?}+s G("}\h ,~9O*z< B!9v fE ~%"| dG(|}G
~zg* )AI gO"f ~v9JyG &zgG* hC ,&<9<QC )yE aQZ*h ,~%y &wz| R(G* ;p
GP{p .969<QC )yE ?<(zT}yG dG(|}G GhO9fC GPE :E KZ@ : ~%A<(@ f} ,&=I9Y
?|9gyG ?JzZ}yG {FC #| #*OTq}yG #f )y9| uI W9tSE Q|}G G(yhC iCQ
.yd9}yG B+< #| g("}]* fC >Fh
9| :E #++|O6G b(tIh uG b(tI ~%"f btT@ ?<(AyG fC iQ=ayG Q9ALGh
f(

]34

G :I F

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

312

= P| O*|* 9| ?<9JZyG #f ihQh ,&z$C )zf gOQ+p &"+g< ~9O*z< 9}k F9s f9v
)@zp ,>y9_ )<C #< )zf O%f )p HQ9I O*R #< ?CQ9I fC )=gWyG #f :d9tp
,&+zf )<zp QqgF #<G )@C ~C ,)<zp &y #|zAT* fC &+yE >zap )zf #< #TJyG
Q+|C )y #|zASG :&y d9sh ,&+yE &}\h ,&"|zp )!GO}%yG U+s #< O+gS )@zp
!#+"||}yG Q+|C 9* :d9tp U+s #< O+gS g9@C IGOjyG )zf )zY 9}zp ,#+"||}yG
F
E D CB
o :d9tp ?&y(SQh uG f(<Q9J* #*PyG AGRF 9|
,& $

O NM L
K J
I
H G
dc b a ` _
^]
\[ Z
o :d9s ~C :d9s
:d9s ?O*R #<G ?CQ9I f9v fEh :O+gS d9s
?*6 O 9}y p!@
!xy fe
]33

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

]34

G :I F

G[

| (%p 9=k F9@ A9F Os O*R #< ?CQ9I GP%p :d9s ,O*R #< ?CQ9I f9v fEh
k
.9!9|C &y >Avh &"| xyP {=sh ,&g*9=p gA9Gp .~g! :d9s
,#+"|7y #+fhQ}yG ,&y(SQyh u #+<Q9J}yG LQG(MyG {wy I(fO gP%p
k
hC G(!9v GQ9qv ~%y ?|9f I(fO gP$ ,uI Q+j< ?8*Q=yG MGhQ~y #+t$R}yG
h\(< ~%y ?|9f I(fO gP$ -KGOI}G gP$ AGQh #| iQO! : 9!{p- #+}zT|
hC ,IQ(vP}yG ?<(tgyG ~%+p Pq"Ap ~%+zf QOt* fC {=s #| ?<(AyGh M;TyG
?J+Z! gP$h
? *6 O f Q y p i
hgo ,?Aj< J(}yG ~%+@z*
,b;LC :h #*O:h YQV 9$Qt* : JGQ+GqAyG gP$ fE :#+}zT}yG H9=Wy
#*QJA"}yG I9+J< iO(@h ,#+}y9T}yG Q9qwyGh #+}zT}yG #| A9*Q<}G {At@ )%p
~%IGhQz< JGQ+GqAyG >$P@ )zAtyG #| ?C;C A:|%p ,Q+GqAyG ?+z}g< #+}F9tyG
:)y9g@ d9s Otp ,~zT}yG {As 9|C ,Q9"yG >F(* &zAs ,?C;DyG #| {+As {vh
,#+ C

]34

G :

G[

g
f ed c

b a ` _^o
p! @
!~x m l k
j ih

Qp9wyG {As 9|Ch , ?*6 9T"xy


9%J*Q fEh ,?"GyG ?JFGQ MQ* ~y GO$9g| {As #|z :| d9s Otp ,~y9T}yG
9]k *C (%p ,&Tq! ?+z}gzy Pq"}yG {As 9|Ch ,y9|k 9f #+g<QC IQ+T| #| OF(+y
]93

G :A

G[

313

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)p 96 zF(A* gO* )p &@O*OJp IO*OJ< &Tq! {As #|z :| &y(ty ,Q9"yG >F(*
k
k
k
gO* )p &}Tp ~T< &Tq! {As #|h ,GO<C 9%+p GOzM| GOy9L ~"%F Q9! )p &"a<
k
k
k
&Tq! {Atp {=F #| iOQ@ #|h ,GO<C 9%+p GOzM| GOy9L ~"%F Q9! )p g9TJA*
k
k
k
.yGO<C 9%+p GOzM| GOy9L ~"%F Q9! )p iOQA* (%p
~8C #+}zT| G(!9v fE I9"GyG OtAg* ?J*QZyG U(Z"yG gP$ Og< {%p
)AyG QhQjyGh )!9|}G :E xyP {$h ??"GyG ~%y fCh uG {+=S )p fhO$9G|
o :~+FQyG f9a+WyG #f 9%+p uG d9s

ZYXWVU

]120

?*6G

:A

x
9T "y G [ p ! @
!vwu

x+zf B!9$ r+wp S9"yG MGhQz< B"%ASG fE ,&< QQj}yG H9WyG 99C 9*
c(}S #+I c(fOL Oty ,A9| &"d@ HGQS )p ?Z+LQ 9%yP=@ ,xTq!
k
:&zyG G(ty Osh I9"GyG A:|6 )!zvh ,?"Gy9< chOfh #+I c(fOLh ,GO$9G|

z y

xw

vu ts r
q
p o nm{
.
Q|Ry }
!
~} |{
[48-47 :

G]

9}zgyG ?ay9M| #| O<:h ,A9}zgyG ?Ty9G| #| O< : :H9=WyG QWg| 9*


~79%+F(@h A9}zgyG KF9Z! d(=s #| O< :h ,A9}zgzy Y9}AS:G #| O< :h
S9"yG {]y A9}zgyG :(yh ,~F9%=y9v S9"yG Q9Zy A9}zgyG :(zp ,~7GO9VQEh
876o :?*6G gP$ e(}f )p d(LOyG #| ~v9*E ~C ~v9*Eh ,u*QayG
,A

ED

C
B A@?> =<;!@
! vu x : 9

.p!@
!vuy

QZs &!C HQJyG Q9! d9gAVG Bsh )p &A}dfh e;S G ?I9}S #| fE


#+"|6G )yE 98GO+| #f HQJyG {t! #f )8h ,#+<Q9J}yG )zf HQJyG
#<G #f ,~$QF9A|h ~%g!9Z| )p hC ~7(+< )p hC ~$O<9g| )p #+"8}a}yG
?y(At| ?w| KAp e(* ICQ|{< | uG d(SQ Q|z :d9s 9}%"f uG )\Q Q}f
~8(v ?zgyGh ,yf9+=ZyGh A9T"yG {As #f )8 ~C ,{@9t@ gP$ B!9v 9| :d9tp

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

314

?zd"I )LC h+<QyG #< M9<Q E*OI )p | )="yG xyP< MQY 9}v f(z@9t* :
&A|Ot| )zfh ,9$GRi IhRi )p | uG d(SQ h| LQL &!C gQ=LC &!C >@9wyG
9}| ?y(At| ICQ|G )zf | uG d(SQ H9JYCh M9<Q Q}p ,O+y(yG #< Oy9L
~%tJy )AI 9%tzL #| f(=GgA*h 9%+yE fhQd"* G(qs(p ,?|Ot}yG B<9YC
:d9tp | uG d(SQ 9%+zf rs(p 9%"f G(FQq!9p ,&AzIGQ )zf | uG d(SQ
:h ?*QP f(zAt@ : &y {tp GOk y9L uJyG :~$OI} d9tp ,{@9tAy gP$ B!9v 9|z
k
.y9q+Tf
c9T"yGh f9=$QyG f9+=ZyGh A9T"y9< uJz* &!{p ?zgyG gP$ )zf A9"<h
f(}T* #}| d9AtyGh HQJyG G(yRAfG #*PyG #| ~$Q+ih )\Q}yGh N(+WyGh
Qw"! : 9"!C GP$ )"g|h ,~%yG(|C ?!9+Yh ~%|GQAIG >G+p ,#++!O}y9<
9$Q+i )ph fO"y )p xyPv 9$Qw"! {< ,9$OIh ?=+=JyG 9!QZ| )p JGQ+GqAyG
{As #f )8 e;S Gh ,#++"|6G #++!O}yG aO%AT@ 98} ,IQ(}g}yG Y9t< #|
.~zTyG ?y9J< r+wp HQJyG ?y9I )p #++!O}yG
AGQqTzy f9|}Gh #|}G Q+p(@ )zf {}f fC &A}dfh e;S G ?I9}S #|h
a9t* AGQ6G dO9=@h Qd"yG J9%Fh {t"y #+pQayG #+< f(gT* #*PyG {SQyGh
.HQJyG
d(SQ Bg}S d9s ~+g! &+<C #f )gGV}G O(gT| #< ~+g! #< ?}zS #f
9}v d(t! ::9s y?9}A!C f:(t@ 9|z :?}z+T| H9Av CQs #+I 9}%y d(t* | uG
.y9}ws9"fC B<Q]y {At@ : {SQyG fC :(y uGh 9|Cz :d9s d9s
?~6Q Q|C G(Zgp 9$(z%F hC ?9$(qy9Mp HGO6G gP$ H9=WyG ~zf {%p
.u+p(AyGh ?*GO%yG h+}Gzy uG dzT!
. {+=TyG AG(S 9"*O9 fC dzSC uGh
)1 (

.)v$1426(

?"Ty >FQ OOf &zyG &dqI ihO< ~+dgyG O=f N+Wzy d9t| O+I(AyG ?zG|

)1(

315

? +fQW y

&zyG

{ =S

)p

?"TyG
#*OyG Q(!

J(qY

O9

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

%GyG

H9<

O}J| e9gyG U+FQyG

P$ >I9Y )"COI d9s .S9*E #< OgS &}SGh )!9=+WyG hQ}f )<C #f
iC :| uG d(SQ ByzS :d9s .O(gT| #< uG O=f QGO )yE gO+< Q9VCh QGOyG
?iC ~C Bzs .9%Ash )zf I;ZyG :d9s ?{Fh Rf uG )yE >IC d9}f}G
)"COI :d9s .uG {+=S )p O9%GyG :d9s ?iC ~C Bzs .#*OyG(yG Q< :d9s
)!OGRy &@ORASG (yh | uG d(SQ #6
.)&+zf uqA|(
d9AtyGh O9%GyG 9%zFC #| K+<C )AyG ?+%y G ?}wJyGh iQ=wyG ?*9jyG fE
g

)1(

:d

~} | {

9q!}G[ p
n

z y

xw v

o :)$

O*Q* E+I ,?"AqyG KGOI U+yh ?"AqyG )zf A9]tzy O9%Gy9p ?*6
f(}wJ*h gQ|C f(}+t* u f(+J* IOIGh ?|C )!9T! G ~y9gyG f(w* fC &!9J=S
d9I i(tyGh ,?}IQy9< Q+tqyG 9+!O )"jyG 9%+p )fQ* ?|C .&fQV iPyG &yOg<
I(L}G A9qY )p IQTgyG ?f9S )p ~$9!O} ~$;fC )gT*h ?*9fQy9< r+g]yG
O=gyG ?=J| ,Uq"yG Qf9W| )vR@ ,?}IQyG #| OhO(yG ("JyGh ?=J}yG bOYh
{FC #| &fQV &!9J=S uG dR!C )AyG IO(W"}yG ?|}G )$ xz@ &!9J=S &<Qy
?*QW=yG )zf ?*9"F OIG(yG OQqyG )zf ?*9"Gy9p .?}+s OQp {wy {gFh ,9%F9"<
f9T!E {As ,9%zv ?+!9T! G {}W* OIG(yG OQqzy &<9=SC Of #+I Q+MyGh A9g=
A9+I}G {wy OGO|E ~%"| OIG(y I9+JyG H9=SC Q+T+@h OGQp}G {wy {As ?"Ap )p
!
~ }| {z y x w vo :&!9J=S d(t* E+I
uG

? *6 G

]39

O 9}n yG[

:I F

p*)

( ' & % $ #

"

.]32

Oy )p (zjyG H9Av hFGQ

.#* G

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

316

~%]g< #| 9%|QJp ~%\GQfCh ~%yG(|Ch #+}zT}yG A9|O e;S G f9Y


?GI )p | )="yG >aM+p &y(SQh uG #| fP{< :E {; ;p ^g< )zf
~w|(* ?|QJv eGQI ~w+zf ~w\GQfCh ~wyG(|Ch ~vA9|O fEz :d(t* YGO(yG
~zT}yG )zf ~zT}yG {vz :| d(t*h yGP$ ~vQ%V )p GP$ ~vOz< )p GP$
k
HQ]* GQ9qv iOg< G(gFQ@ :z :| d(t*h y&\Qfh &y9|h &|O eGQI
.y^g< H9sQ ~w]g<
iPyG O9TqyG ?*9i fC :E ,O9%GyG ?|C )$ ?+|;S G ?|}G fC h|h GP$
>*Qi )"g| 9%F9"<C ^g< )p iQS fC gP$ 9"|9*C )p ?|}G gP$ &< B+"|
k
JGQ$9d}y9< e9+tyGh GO9%F ?*QwTgyG J9<;t!:G ~%]g< &+p Q(Y O9%Gzy
?sQSh GOk9%F #+|(wJ}yGh e9wJyG JGQ(f rWwy Q<9"}yG eGOMASGh GOk9%F
k
k
A9ty{< #+"|6G h*hQ@h GO9%F d9+Ai:Gh GO9%F Q9qwyGh I9ZgyG ^g< dG(|C
k
O;< )yE #*OpG(yG M9+TyG {Ash .GO9%F ?|9gyG #v9|}G )p JGQGqA}yG
k
d;JASGh A9*Q<}G {Ash JGQF9ayG a9aAL9v xyP Q+ih GO9%F #+}zT}yG
k
)$h O9%GyG ?}zw< 9!9A6h GQkhR uZyC xyP {v .#+}zT}yG Q+qw@h dG(|}G
U}L JGQhQ\ S9"yG )zf eqJ* YQW< | &+=! Eg< uG fE {< ?8*Q< &"|
(%p 9%"| IOIGh OO$ 9| {wp y{tgyGh d9}yGh VQgyGh Uq"yGh #*OyGz
.&y(SQyh u HQ9J| uG YQWy ry9M|
GhO%Vh uG :E &yE :C GhO%V #}| GQk +Dv hshC >*Q}yGh >*QjyG ~%qyG GP$
k
G(gpQh JGhGOgyGh #I G ~%"+< Bgs(p (zjyG )p uG d(SQ GO}J| fC
.e;S G ~S9< xyP uZyC fC ?jy9=yG IQGQ}yG #|h A9|OyG BwqTp M;TyG
uG d(SQ fC h| ,O9%GyG ~S9< #+}zT| #| #+}zT}yG )zf M;TyG {}Jp
.y9"| U+zp M;TyG 9"+zf {}I #|z :d9s |
)zf ~zT}yG uI #| f} 9"At*Q_ )zf U+y iC 9"| U+y :QGI #<G d(t*
&y9As IOGQ &+zf M;TyG {}J*h &fhQ* fC : &!hO {@9t*h gQZ"* fC ~zT}yG

317

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

&zJAT* #| 9|zp .xyP {JAT* : #| uI )p GP$ )QGI #<G d9s ~C( &zAs hC
)1(
. eQJ}yG d;JAS9< Qqw* &!{p
e;S G )zf xyP< f(V(W* e;S G AGOfCh f(tp9"}yG PLC )AI GP$
.gQ|C )zf >y9i uGh &A=z_h &z$Ch
&"| Q*PJAyG A9Fh &y(SQh uG &|QI uG #*O )p (zi >*QjyG ~%qyG GP$
k
k
I;jyG :~%y(s xyP #|h 9D*OIh 9}*Os e;S G A9}zf ?yzT}yG gP$ {YC Osh
?"+< a9YhC ~%g}:h ?"+g| [F9ZL ~%"+< b<Q* Q(ZgyG QQw@ )zf ~$O:
9%"| cQAW}yG ?+z+Zq@h ?+y9=E 9pk 9YhC ~%y A9}zgyG QvP Osh ~%+p OQa@ O9w@
r]8\ #| LQM*z :| )="yG d(s 9}%g}G* f9qYh I;jyG bQp #| Q+Dv )p
f(fO*h e;S G {$C f(zAt* ,~$QF9"I Rh9G* : fBQtyG fhDQt* e(s GP$
f(qZA* 9}v ~*QwyG fBQtyG ~%p eOg< f(qZA* ~8C iC yf9Ch}G {$C
.#+}zT}yG A9|O d;JAS9<
: ~89Ty )zf fBQtyG QhQ| :E eI ~%y U+y ~8C OGQ}yG :ih("yG d9s
k
&tzg@ ($ H(za}yG f} ~6(zs )yE {Z* fC #f ;]p ~%s(zI )yE {Z*
)Q}f #<G d9s 9}v( ~%zgG* fBQtzy ~%}%p eOfh .>ztyG )p &f(s(< gQ<O@h
?+z< Q|}G O*R*h ,#+}zT}yG )zf 98(zgG+p Q9qwyG )p ByR! J9*B fhPLz*
f(=+g*h ?"AqyG )p f(gT*h A9}zgyG f(ZtA"*h .~%z%F h| ~zgyG f(fO* ~8C
#Ap f(wASz :d(t* | uG d(SQh xyP .O9%F )p ~8zv 9%"f #*Of9tyG
Q+L 9%+p )V9}yGh )V9}yG #| Q+L 9%+p ~F9tyGh .~F9tyG #| Q+L 9%+p Of9tyG
k
Pg+zp GP9g| hC zGz| 9%"| OFh #}p .&pQWAT@ 9%y aQW@ #| .)f9TyG #|
.&<
A9|OyG xqS #| QDw*h d9AtyG xyP Q}f #| {+a* O%GyG dP< f9v fE xyP
.y

xAqyG O+s f9}*

Gz

?y9t| )p Qv9V O}IC N+WyG e;v upG(* GP$h )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

318

:h .?"AqyG &+p JOGR O%GyG dP< OGR 9}zvh ?vQJyG #| Q+L f(wTyG Q9Y
&+gS Q}D* #}y f(w* xyP 9}!E &f9aASG #}y Q+Mzy )gTyG cQ@ xyP )"g*
LQG(MyG &< W9IC 9}y
f9qf #< f9}Df OVGQyG ?q+zMyG f{p GPy .GQk +L
#+}zT}yG iOqp A9|OyG xqS S9"yG )p ht* : )AI &ASGQI #| O"GyG h"|
.($ &|O<
{+ag@ )yE ?"AqyG )p HO! | )="yG fE )AI .eOB )"<G Q+L {gp xyPvh
k
gOI {ag@ )AI {=GyG &< HQ]@ iC )GOIC xq+T< VQgAT@ f}( d9AtyG ?yB
fC xyP #}C f9v (yh ?"AqyG )p d9AtyG {$C h| xgs(+p f9a+WyG &< x*Qj* ;p
{Aty cO* bT=@ ;p x<Q O"f G(G"@h ~C G #| CQ=Ap eOB )"<G Q+Mv f(w@
{AAt* f9|RyG QLB )p &"wy .{AtyG {TzTA* ;p &zv ~C 9< QL6G A(=*h .OIC
.{As 9}+p d(At}yG :h {As 9}+p {@9tyG jQO* ;p S9"yG
d9s :d9s &"f uG )\Q )S(| )<C #f &J+JY )p iQ9M=yG LQLC Otyh
~zgyG 9%+p hpQ*h {%GyG 9%+p dR"* 9|k 9*} ?f9TyG iO* #+< fEz :| )="yG
.y{AtyG LQ%yGh ..LQ%yG &+p QDw*h
k
S9"zy 9+p9v &zgFh &"*O ~@Ch &fQV {}vC Os &!9J=S )y(}yG fC h| GP$
)p O9TqyG #| G(Zz<h G(JzYh GhOgS g(}wI fE ,d9I {v )p ~%}wJ*
{gF xyPv e(wJ}zyh 9|k 9d! ~v9Jzy YQWyG {gF .~%y(I #|h ~%Tq!C
~v9Jzyh ,?|9tASG OGORAp 9%A|9tASG &< eqJ* ?+fQyG ?|9tASG O"f 9|k 9d! ~v9Jzy
{gFh .9$O9Tph 9%F9F(fG dhR*h ?+fQyG &< dOAg@ ?+fQyG O9Tp O"f 9|k 9d!
{< 9%I;Y )p &< ?|}G )t=@ &A|9tASGh )fGQyG M;Y O"f 9|k 9d! ?+fQzy
k
O9TqyG {t+p &< KzZ* )fGQyG O9Tp O"f 9|9d! ?+fQzy {gFh .&"| OGOR@h
&!9J=S uG &z}vC r*QWyG YQWy9p .S9"yG #+< O9VQyG QWA"*h Q+MyG OGOR*h
R(G* ;p .O9TqyG {*R*h M;Y Gh M;ZyG )yE iO|*h d9I {v )p ~wJ+y
&< fPz* ~y 9| YOA=@ fC xyPv ?f9}Gy :h &Tq! O"f #| YOA=* fC OI}

319

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

P$ f} .&@(fOh uG YQV ?JzZ}y &zgq* iPyG GP$ fC )fO* ~C .YQWyG


&\QC )p &fQV A9+IE )zf QO9s ($h xz}yG ($ u9p .&fQVh u9< #c A(S
qp o n mlk j { :d9s &!9J=S u9p .&!(vh
{ :{F9tyG ($h }r
($h })tW* :h {]* ;p jGO$ h=@G #}p{ :{F9tyG ($h }
.p' & %$#
" ! ~{ :{F9tyG
uG d(SQ &< {}g* ~yh S9"yG d9I &< KzZ* ;}f fC )fO* #| {wp *
.&f9=@G R(G* : d9\ YOA=| (%p )yh}G ?C;DyG fhQtyG {$Ch |
(%p ~zT}yG H9=WyG >FGh 9|C :Ky9Y #*OyG OgS .O d(t* ?J+Z! *
e9wJy9< eGOaY:G >":h OFGRyG S9}JyGh Q(%AyG #f Og=yGh fGR@:Gh {tgAyG
uzM* ~zT}yG OQqyG fC xyP ?+|;SE ?+<Q@ ~9hPh ~%Tq!C ?+<Q@ ~%+qw*h
~zT}yG h}AG}yGh ~zT}yG h}AG}yG uz< ?}zT}yG IQS}Gh ?}zT}yG IQS}G
.~w+zf )y(* G(!(w@ 9}q+vh ?}zT}yG ?|(wJyG Oz*
&@(s {}JA* fC #| rg\C ($h Q9+AyG e9|C ~zT}yG H9=WyG rt* fC 9|C
IOOgA| aGQ_C JGP IQ+aL ?=gy ?S9+TyG fC xyP Q9JA!:G ih9T| xyPp
e9|C eRJ< rt@ ?+}y9f i(s c9"$ fCh ?Y9L i(s~y :E f(w* : 9%+p R(qyGh
.e;S G )yE IO(gyG
k
IO+tgyG I(t< :hC &Tq! Og* fC ~zT}yG H9=WyG )zf f9v 9"$ #|h
.~+d"AyGh
G

WVUTSRQP YX

)1 (

^g<h BtzL 9| iQq@ B!}hz Qf9WyG d(tv f(w*h h"Z* iC uzM* ?dqz< Q(AvOyG OZt* )1(
f} QW=yG uI ,p yuzM*z ?dqy eOMAT@ :C {]p}G f9v fGh yiQq* : ~C uzM* e(tyG
.y{+vh A)V {v )zf ($h A)V {v uy9L &zyGz d9s &!9J=S &zyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

P IG

GhQ

Gh

?+}v9Jy

320

9Av #| )%A!G(
I

.IQ(%

(fO

uG

A}yG d9}f}9< HF9A"yG {GgAT* :h


.)308U ...?D*OJyG >+y9S}G
+

{ =S

)p

O9

%GyG

Py bQyG e9d! ,p )AI &!9J=S uG )yE I(fOzy O9%GyG YQV 9}!Eh


~%F9"<Ch )yG(}y9< 98k +z| e;S G N*Q9@ BzgF ?z+= I(fO (%p e;S G &qYh
~zgy9< IO9+TyG #| ~%A*O(=fh ~%zYC ~%g"}* ~zp A9}zf GhQ9Y #*PyG
k
YQWy 9|9}@ ry9M| ~%}zc hC Q9qwyG ?sQS hC M9+TyG {As f{p GPy ,{}gyGh
Q+i ?z|9g| fzW< ?*O(gTy9< A9Ap5y ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG ih9Ap #| {t"! xyPy .uG
#*O xyP h| ($h ?y(%TyGh QT+yGh ?I9}TyG #*O e;S G :~%y(s #+}zT}yG
rzAM+p GQk p9v f9v GPE #wy ?+|;S G HGO6G #| u+pQzy eGQv Gh ?yGOgyG
O(Zt}yG f9v GP{p .&< &|Qw* 9| a;AL9<h &y eQw}yG OZs a;AL9< ~wJyG
QqwyG #| &zt"*h e;S G )yE g(fO* )AI &"+< e9GT!G O9G*E O*Q* &!(wy 9+k fQV
9%y {F9S(yG fC ?g*QWyG )p IQQt}yG OfG(tyG #|h {+=! OZs GP%p d;]yGh
?|QJ| ?*9jyG B!9v GPEh ?z+S(yG B=Fh ?=FGh ?*9jyG B!9v GP{p J9*9jyG ~wI
>@QA* ~yh eGQv G )p )fQV O(Zt| #w* ~y GPEh .GPw$h ?z+S(yG B|QI
R(G* ;p &y9| hC &z$C hC &Tq! hC &"*O )p eQw}yG GP$ )zf QQ\ &vQ@ )zf
&|QI 9}| HGQWyGh e9gay9< ~%|GQvE 9|Ch .R9F QQ\ &+zf >@Q@ fEh .xyP
?+Zg| xyP< ~%|GQvE f{p R(G* : GP%p Q}MyGh Q*R"MyG ~Jzv ;fh {F uG
($ ~zT}yG )zf >FG(yGh uG uI )zf ~%tJy ~*Ot@h ~%y ?f9_h u
k
)9]*C ?"GzyG d(t@h( .fGhOgyGh ~C G )zf ?!9f G eOfh &"*O< xT}AyG
#+}zT}yG )zf ~7QZ!h ~%A=J| )$ ~$:Gh #| 96 Qqw* )AyG Q9qwyG I:G(|
f9+Wih e;S5y ~7(fOy ~%Aay9M| :h dOgy9< ~%g| {|9gAyG OQG| :
.))%A!G( e;S G QW!h Z;=zy ~%+yE QqTyGh ~%Ty9G|
i G

)1 (

9 GyG e9wIC #| ~wI e;S G )p bQyG )1(

.O %

321

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

y fO@h QqwyG &y #*RAy ~%+yE Qp9T* #| UQp ~"Aj@ QqwyG O;=p
d(I :h &"| ~$hQq"*h e;S G ~%y G($(W+y M9+TyG O(Fh f(}"Aj* A:|$h
.u9< :E I(s :h
Q+Dv 9%+p QaS ?z*(_ K9J<C 9%zYC ?q_9L J9J}yh IQ+Zs J9}zv gP$
)p O9%GyG #f E*OJzy 9"\Qg@ E+I IQ9V G JOQC )"wyh ~zgyG ?=z_ #|
IQ9V G )ph d9t}yG GP$ {D| &y hTA* : Y(\(}yG GP$ bT<h .uG {+=S
.OZtyG AGQh #| uGh ?*9qv
.&+ E g(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

+ (Azy

O I

322

K QY

QG

(I )p

e9gyG

+FQyG

wy 9=w"yGh ..?+|;S G ?|}G 96 Q}@ )AyG ahQdyG {c )p


A9tzyG GP$ #| 9"y O< : f9v ..IQ(}g}yG Y9t< #| Q+Dv )p ?|}9< BzI )AyG
..GQk +Dv QLz@ Os f(w* 9}<Q iPyG
d(Z"y {FQyG GP$ #$P )p QhO* 9}| Q+DwyG )zf &y;L #| aQgA"y
#| 9"< b+J* 9|h ..9"y9< {jW* 9}| Q+DwyG )zf &y;L #| aQgA!h ,d(G!h
>G* 9|h ,#+|(wJ}yGh e9wJyG d(I Q9wpC #| 9"y(I QhO* 9|h ..Q9aLC
)zf IO(F(}yG ?+|;S G J9f9}GyG d(Ih ..QL6G g9: 9}%"| {v )zf
Q9Z!C ?f9= rs(| #fh ...J9f9}GyG xz@ O(Fh &zD}* 9|h ...?I9TyG
AGRE ?"TyG Q9Z!C d(I Q9D* 9}fh ...J9f9}GyG xz@ #| ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
A9}zf e97Gh ,...?y9}gy9< ~%]g< e97Gh ,rsG(}yGh ...9*9]tyG #| Q+DwyG
H+zMyG dhO #| d9gp}G OhOQ >TI ~79$9:Gh ~%qsG(| Q+jA< J9f9}GyG
k
...?|(wJyG #| ?"TyG Q9Z!C rs(|h ...~%+@z@ )AyG dG(|~y 9=T;h
...~$O"f &zjW@ iPyG Q+MyGh ...&zD}@ 9|h ?+|;S G I(JZyG d(Ih
^g< )zf ^=tyG A9tyEh ...?"TyG Q9Z!C OF9T| ^g< ~]< ?|(wJyG e9+sh
...)O*R (<C QZ!( (fO}yG O@Q}yG ?+]sh ?+!9}zgyG d(Ih ...9$QY9"f
&zD}* 9|h ...f9}yQ=yG )p J9f9}GyG {=s #| ?vQ9W}yG ?yzT| d(I iCQyGh
QwqyG Q9WA!G #| ?"TyG {$C rs(|h ...?+|;S G ?g*QWyG u+=a@ )p xyP
96 e9+tyG dh9J* )AyG #+y(8T}yGh e9wJzy {AtyG J:h9J|h ...jQ+qwAyG
?*Q+Z}yG 9*9]tyG ^g< g9: e9wJyG dP9<h ...T(W}yG QwqyG H9JYC
k
Y9}S )yE 9gpO 9"gpO xyP {v ...e9wJzy A9fOyG IQhQ\h ...#+}zT}zy
9<k Ch ...9!k 9T!E ...9}k y9f g9"pQf iPyG {FQyG #| ?+p9WyG J9<9F G
?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG ,#*OyG Q(! J(qY O}J| N+WyG ?z+]p ...9!k ("I
:)y9AyG QG(JyG 9""+< QGOh ,?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C
KQG( Gh J

323

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)AyG KQG(wyGh J9=w"yGh ?+|;S G ?|}G 96 Q}@ )AyG ahQdyG {c )p *


)zf )tz}yGh H(za}yG QhOyG 9| :IQ(}g}yG Y9t< #| Q+Dv )p ?|}9< BzI
OGQp}G rsG(| Uwg"@ r+vh ?J9f9}GyG QhO 9|h ?~zT}yG OQqyG {$9v
??|}G 9*9]s d9+I e9wJyG J9pQZ@ )zf J9f9}GyGh
?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG #*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG ?z+]p d(t*
{wzp J9=w! 98z< ?|}G 96 Q}@ )AyG ahQdyG ?+}T@ fE :QZ}< ?*O}J}yG
,J9|QI d;JASGh A9|O xqS #| 9%+yE Qd"* 9}< J9=w! )%p ,f9%Fh ?z}f
r!zAS9p .~%p;SC )yE G(gFQh ~%"*O )yE GhO9f Os e(tyG fC #f ?:9! 9%"wy
?=T"y9< e9*}G gP$ )p ht* iPyGh ,hsh iPyG GP%p ,~%y &y9As hOgyG
QWyG i(s &< B+"|o 9}y {gp OQ ($ 9}!E VQ}G Y9t< #| Q+Dv )p #+}zT}zy
,iQLC IQ| O9f iPyG e;S G GP$ M9= G(J=w* fC GhOGQzp .IQ9TL #|
.&+zf GhR%FC Os ~8C G("ch
k
Y9t< h+= )p #+}zT}yG JG(YC fC xV: &!E :;F9s &Az+]p OQaAT*h
,..f9W+WyG )p 9"!G(LE ,..?"S(=yG )p 9"!G(LE :f(y(t* #*PyG VQ}G
~y|@ AGOY}G gP$ {v ,~y9gyG A9J!C h+= )p 9"!G(LE ,..Q+}Wv )p 9"!G(LE
9+k I dGR* : e;S G fC ~$QgW@h ,~y9gyG A9J!C h+= )p QqwyGh QWyG i(s
?=+My9< GhA9< Os ~8C g(zgp iPyG GP$ {v Og< G("c fC Og< ,~%S(q! )p
.iOZAyG IQhQ]< fhQgW* ~%p ,fGQTMyGh
I(fO )t=+y &< {Fh Rf uG fPz* iOZAyG GP$ fC &+yE &=A"! fC )j="* iPyGh
Q+DwyG f} ?GP9| {FC #| f(<Q9J* ~$ :f(yA9TA* S9"yG K=Z*h .O+I(AyG
~8C GhOFh 9}zp ...9"k *O f(pQg* :h ..9|k ;SE f(pQg* : A:|$ #|
o
o
?9!Q9*O #| OQa! 9}y ?9!D9|O xqT@ GP9}y ?{@9t! GP9}y G(yA9T@ ...f(z@9t*
f(z@9t* iPyG e;S G GP$ )zf f(pQgA* GhAO=p ..f(}zT| 9"!} :~%y {+tp
.&+fh )yE ghO9fzp .&zFC #|

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

324

)zf dO* &F(yG GP$ ,QLB &Fh 9%y 9}!E 9%+yE Qd"! )AyG J9=w"yG gP%p
>FG(yG 9| 9"Tq!C {F9T! fC )yE 9!OVQ* GP$h ,S9"yG )yE O(g*h bm9< e;S G
?9"+zf
#f ?+f(+WyG MGRC iPyG #| ?&zyG #*O )yE A:|$ hFQC iPyG #| dA9TA!h
fC ~$9%"* f9v iPyG f9+jayG GP$ ~%"f MGRC iPyG #| ?O;=yG gP$ &Fh
?&zyG :E &yE : :G(y(t*
..f9]|Q e(Y &!E ..IQ}gyGh HJyG )p A9tAy:G &!E ,uG )yE I(fOyG 98E
GPE 9"!C GP$ )"g| ..xyP )yE ~%gFQC iPyG GP$ ..I;ZyG )zf AGO"yG fE
edco :d(t* {Fh Rf uGh .e(tyG >zj* fC O<;p 9"|;S{< 9"+"AfG
fC

]139

?*6G

Qn }fp

:fG

d B[

p@
! !vx~

k j

i
hg
f

?pQg| ~7O+tf f(pQg+p ..~%"*O Q|C )yE S9"yG hFQ* fC ($ >FG(y9p


k
k
,uG Q|GhC )zf f(pQgA*h ..9}+zS 9pQg@ ~7O9=f )zf f(pQgA*h ,?J+JY
#}p yx$9: gO: uG eqIG ..xdqJ* uG eqIGz :| )="yG d(t< f(z}g*
($ GP$ ,&dqJ*h &pQg* {Fh Rf uG f{p &|Q9J|h &gFGQVh &"*O )p uG eqI
.&pQg* fC ~zT| {wy )j="* iPyG QhOyG
k
e9wJyG fE :;F9s &D*OI #*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG ?z+]p {YG(*h
&|;SE #f 98k +V aQg* : 9}k zT| {At* iPyG f} ;#*Qa]| ~%Tq!C fhOG+S
k
k
bO"MyG Uq! )p f(W+g* e9wJy9p ...~zT| &!} 9!9azS hC 9}v9I cQA* #y
h+}GyG )t=* )AI GP$ aQg* fC )j="+p ...f(}zT}yG &+p X+g* iPyG
.{Fh Rf uG )yE f(fO*
S9"yG #| Q+DwyG 9%zgq* )AyG ?+FG(WgyG J9vQJyG {v fC ~zg! fC O< :h
fCh ,..?+Twf HF9A! )yE iO|@ 98C &+yE I(fOyGh e;S G ?*GQ hpQ ~SG B;
)yE S9"yG OQh ,uG #*O< r*QgAyG ($ ?J+JZyG HF9A"yG )yE iO|* iPyG

325

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9 y Qg* iPyG ($ GP$ ...~6Q< ~%q*Qg@h ,&<9Av )yE ~$O9VQEh ,&"*O


.{Fh Rf uG #*O )zf f(pQgA* ~%zgG*h ,~$OVQ*h
{$h ...f6G ?I9TyG )zf IO(F(}yG ?+|;S G J9f9}GyG rs(| *
???+JY IQ$9c {D}* J9f9}GyG gP$ O(Fh
VQp {Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG fE :#*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG ?z+]p d(t*
gP$ f9+=y d(t* {Fh Rf uGh ,?*9qv VQp K=ZAp ,?|}G )qAw@ )AI #+f
WV UT SR Q P O NM
o :?+"+gyG ?+\QqyG
,S " G a

!
.

]108

?*6G :rSo (*o [ p!@


! vu }

] \[
ZY
X

tAy Q=yG )zf fh9gAy9< 9!Q|C Os )y9g@h &!9J=S IRgyG HQ f9v 9}yh

i( Gh

. ]2 ?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

~ }| {z

yxw

o :d9tp

&A; BFQO!G iPyG {Y}G ($ Q=yG SCQ< fh9gAy9p ,uG )yE I(fOyG Q=yG SCQp
.I(fOyG J9f9=
h]@h ,9Gk %"| H%A"@h ,N(+V O* )zf P}zA@ 9|O"f ?f9= {v #wy
K=Z@h ,I(fOyG {YC #f ~S:Gh H%"}yGh ,N(+WyG 9%zjW+p ,9}k SG 9%Tq"y
.9%A+fhQW| JOtp Os ?f9}GyG gP$
A:(yG Otg@h ,{Fh Rf uG )yE (fO@ 98(v #| )@z@ ?f9}GyG ?+fhQW}p
AGQ=yGh A:(yG Otg@ :h ,N(+Wzy A:(yG OtAg@ :h- I(fOyG gP$ )zf AGQ=yGh
JOtp GP{p ...e;S G )zf AGQ=yGh A:(yG Otg@ 9}!Eh ,...A9}S}G )zf
R(G* : ?f9= JQ9Yh ,e9+tyG )p 9%A+fhQW| JOtp -WQWyG GP$ ?f9}GyG
.e(t@ fC
)zf AGQ=yGh A:(yG Otg@ )AyG ?f9}GyG )$ e(t@ fC >G* )AyG ?f9}GyGh
9}%|h ,...9%y9FQ JOOg@ 9}%|h ...9$D9}SC BqzALG 9}%| .e;S G
,..e;S G )zf AGQ=yGh A:(yG f(w* fC O<;p ,9%L(+V H$9"| #| BG%A!G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

326

9%G%"| f(w* fC O< : ?f9}GyG gP$ .N(+WyG )zf :h A9}S}G )zf :


#*PyG ,)yh}G ?C;DyG fhQtyG {$C ~%q< iC ..?|}G rzS ~%q< ?"TyGh fBQtyG
?"TyG {$C OfG(s ~6 {Fh Rf uG )SQCh ,J:;]yG {v )zf GhOQ
.?f9}GyGh
{wp ,&+zf rzAM! fC R(G* : H%"}yG GP$ fE :;F9s N+WyG aOQCh
k
fCh ,9%G%"| Q+j@ fCh O< ;p H%"}yG GP$ Q+i 9G%"| 9%Tq"y Q9A< ?f9=
?C;DyG fhQtyG {$C &}%p 9}v ,| &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av )yE hFQ@
.&+zf A)V eOt* ;p- ~%L(+V &+yE 9fO 9}v : ..)yh}G
~%p ~7A9F )AyG U(Z"yG Q+i Q|C )p e;S G ?JzZ| fC G("c fEh
e;S G )\Qh ,&Ay9SQ ~@Ch ,&"*O {}vC {Fh Rf uG f} ;f(}$Gh
9Jk zZ|h 9Jk y9Y &zgFh ,#*OyG GP$ h\h iPyG ($ {Fh Rf u9p ,...9"*O
aQg@ fC J9f9}GyG )zf )j="+p ...?f9TyG e(t@ fC )yE f9w|h f9|R {wy
Up9"@ (%p ,uG )yE I(fOyG )p Up9"Azp GPw$ J9f9}GyG B!9v GPEh .xyP
Yo :d(t* #+I )y9g@h &!9J=S IRgyG HQ &+yE (fO* Up9"@ ,...Q+MyG
..f(!h9gA* A9=IC I(LE ~$h .
?*6 #+qqa}y p\ [ Z
uG )yE (fO*h ...QDvC Q+MyG h}G* iPyG ~9C Up9"@ ($ 9}!E ~%Tp9"@h
.?"TyGh fBQtyG 9$OhOI f(w* fCh O<: J9f9}GyG gP$h .bOCh {]pC I(fO
?I9TyG )zf IO(F(}yG J9f9}GyG {v #| ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= rs(| 9| *
?QZ| )p
k
I(fOyG J98+$ {v fC xV: &!E :;F9s N+WyG OQ* IO(%g}yG &A|9TA<9<h
a9sh}Gh Q$R}9v ?+}SQ J98+$ B!9v AG(S {Fh Rf uG ,yE (fO@ )AyG
A9tz@ #| {Fh Rf uG ,yE f(fO* I9fOv ?+}SQ Q+i J98+$ eC ,...~$Q+ih
)p 9"!(!h9g* 9"!G(LE ~8C QgW! 9"!C xV : ,...?zGT| J9f9= hC ,~%Tq!C
~8C )p xV :h ,{p9jyG Q+Z=@h ,{$9GyG ~+zg@h ,&A+Zg| #f )Y9gyG OQ
]26

G :

G[

327

Gh

& % $ # " !a~,}+|*{) z(y'x


? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

?+}v9Jy

t* &!9J=S IRgyG HQp A)V )p 9"qzALG f{p ,?}%}yG gP$ )p 9"!(!h9g*

:d(

.}

{Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG I(LC ($ 9}!E iQL}G J9f9}GyG #+<h 9""+< 9}p
9}$GOIE {Tj@ #*O+yG {D}v ~%zD|h 9"zD}p ,Q|}G GP$ )p 9"!(!h9g* ~%p
#|h ...?f9ayG )yE &A+Zg| #| {tA"*h ~%+yE h}AT* #}p , ...iQL}G
.~8h9g! #J!h ,Q|}G GP$ )p 9"!(!h9g* ~%p ,..~zgyG )yE &z%F
#| Q+Dv )ph 9*9]tyG #| Q+DwyG AGRE dP9MAy9< ?"TyG Q9Z!C ~%A* ^g=yG *
~vOQ 9}p ?yhOyG #|} A;}f ~8z< ~%"| ^g=yG rYh OI )yE rsG(}yG
?xyP )zf
U+zp H9ty}9< R<9"AyG 9|C :d(t*h O(%g}yG &FhO$ Uq"<h N+WyG OQ*h
aQg! u O}Jy9p ,H%"}yG )p ^g=yG 9"qy9L fE 9|Ch ,e;S G I9fO fzV
:h ,..~F: ?|(y {Fh Rf uG )p a9M! :h ,?J+JY ?pQg| 9"G%"|
~C gA9aLC cQ@C ..M;YE )yE L9A; A9aLC gO"f H(zS}G #| )"zgG*
iPy9v ,..A9"=GyG :E 9%zgq* : ?yzT| gP$ ,...#*QL6G A9aLC #f KO;C
H(+f #f ~%COJ+y &|9|C #+Ty9GyG cQA*h ,?Z"| )zAg*h ,GQk ="| OgZ*
~%F9aLz< #*Q\9JyG &FG(y 9fk 9GV f9v (zp ,A9"=GyG ?}S xyPp ,#+=F9jyG
hC GPv )yE Bg}SG :d(t* ~%"| OIGh {v LQM* )AI ,..IQ+Dv )$h
#| Q+j+p ....GPvh GPv f(w* fC )j="* )v(zS fC hC ...GPvh GPv B}zg@
.&v(zS
,

)1 (

< ; { )y9g@ d9s 9}v Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G ?]*Qp {a=! : )"g* )1(
9"tq@G 9}+p fh9gA!z -&zyG P9g|- Q+aMyG )fO=yG CO=}yG xyP< dO=AT!h } > =
.y&+

p 9"qzALG 9}+p 9]g< 9"]g< QPg*h &+zf

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

328

9tk +pQ f9T!E {wy f(w* fC &!(v )p QOs )y9g@h &!9J=S IRgyG HQh
f9vh f9azTyG ~zv (zp ,..b9pQ &g| S9"yGh ,..b9pQ &g| f9azTy9p
9}+p ~%}zv S9"yG e9|C f9v 9|h ,..&zgq* fC )j="* 9| )zf &}zv .gO"f
Q|C h= | d(SQyG f} ,M;Y G xyP )p f9v ,...g(zgq* fC )j="*
.)?J+Z"yG #*OyG( :&y(s )p #*OyG
k
rs(| ?"TyG Q9Z!C rs(| fC f("d* #*PyG fE :;F9s &Az+]p a9\Ch
! ~ } | { z o :{Fh Rf uG d(t< 9"!hQvP* dP9<
...

]153

?*6G :e9gn !}G[ p

' &% $ #

"

bM*h ,VQ}G )zf 9aL bM* ($h d(t+p GP$ MQW* | d(SQyGh
k
k
uG {+=S GP$( :d(t*h ,&y9}V #fh ,&"+}* #f ,gQG(F )yE GQ9jY 9_(aL
>I9Y -)9%+yE (fO* f9a+V 9%"| {+=S {v )zf {=TyG gP$h ,..&+yE (fO*
BT+y #*QL6G u*Q_ ..?g*QS 9"t*Q_ ..?zY(| 9"t*Q_ :d(t* {=TyG {v
.?g*QS
u*Q_ &!} ;uFG(gy9< 98k +z| 9tk *Q_ S9"yG &"c fEh ,uG u*Q_ H%A"! #J!
.#+}y9gyG HQ uG
k
v
J:;\ )p S9"yG WQh iPyG ($ Q|}G GP%p :P9< GP$ f("d* #*Py9p
)zf e9+tyGh ,..e9wJyGh #+_;TyG &Fh )p a(s(yG fC G("dp ,LQG(MyG
)<C #< ?*h9g| )zf e9+tyGh ,>y9_ )<C #< )zf )zf e9+tyGh ,f9qf #< f9}Df
{+=TyG )$ gP$ fC G("c e(+yG )yE ...e9wJyG QF9S )zf e9+tyGh ,...f9+qS
uG #*O fE {< ,..uG #*O< ?s;f 9%y BT+y {+=TyG gP$ fC h| ,?zY(}yG
?df(}yGh ?}wJy9< I(fO {Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG 9}!E ..9%]pQ* {Fh Rf
9}< &<(+f &+yE B*O$C f9azTyG O"f B"v fE &%FG(@ #}y I(fO ,...?"TJyG
~%z}yG ~+fRyG IQwph ,..QW< f9azTyG f} .M;Y G )p >iQ* &zgG*
fC ~zg! fCh ,&G%A"! fC 9"y R(G* : )!(fQp e9d!h ,..?+z$9F IQwp

329

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)yE L9AJ* ,..gOVQ* #| )yE L9AJ* ,...&!h9g* #| )yE L9AJ* f9azTyG


9fk (}T| )@(Y f(w* fC O<:h ,..gQhO< e(t+p Q|}G xyP< gQZ=* #|
k
k
:d(sCh ...&"f GO+g< ~zw@C fC 9|C ,..&g}T| )yE kz=* a(S &!C 9s(C(|h
A9aLC >I9Y Q+jyG GP$h gQ+i KO; B!zp &+yE {Z* a(S e;wyG GP$ fE
)p &gs(@h &"AqAp .gQ+i A9aLC #f KOJA@h ,gA9aLC cQA@ ;p ,..AG($Ch
.?"AqyG
k
)yE f(fO* #*PyG ~$ #+yP9MA}yG fE :;F9s &@9}zv N+WyG ?z+]p {YG(*h
^+JyG &tp )p )t="S :f(y(t* S9"yG #| Q+Dv ,..uG )yE I(fOyG cQ@
{TjyGh A(\(yG &tp )p )t="S :f(y(t* ~%"| Q+DwyGh ,..S9q"yGh
iPyG Q%aAyG ~zgA! :h ...Q%aA! : r+v ,GP$ )p )t="S ,...?<9"GyGh
x o
d(SQyGh ,&"| QjZ! r+v ..!?&vQA! r+v ..!?)y9g@h &!9J=S uG &< 9!Q|C
S9"zy f($Qw* A:|$ )yE Qd!9p !?)f9}* G QaV Q(%ayG( :d(t* |
)j="* ...uG #*O )p ~8("Aq+p ...~zgyG S9"zy f($Qw*h ,...IQ9%ayG
uG YQW< AGR%AS:Gh ..&"*Oh uG YQW< AGR%ASG e;wyG GP$ fC )yE G(%=A"* fC
.&zgq! fC R(G* : Qqv &"*Oh
uJy9< ?pQg}yGh K|9TAyG QhO I9fOyG #| 9!QhO f(w* fC )j="*h
QhO 9!QhO f(w* fC : HG(ZyGh uJy9< ?pQg}yGh fh9gAyG QhO ...HG(ZyGh
.eGO%yG Ot"yG
Q9Z!C QhO 9|h ...GPv )p ?"TyG Q9Z!C QhO 9| f(yA9TA* fhQ+DwyGh
JOFh (y )"!} ..&]j=! #J! dG|TyG GP$ ,GPv )ph ...GPv )p ?"TyG
?y9qwy GRk9%F {}fC fC ?f9}Gv iQhO {$ e9A*}G ?y9qv )p BZZ< Os ?f9=
fC S9"yG (fOC fC ?f9}Gv iQhO fC eC ...!?~$ G(zgp 9}v e9A*}G
G(8W!C 9}v J9TS|| A)W!C fC iQhO {$ ..e9A*}G ?y9qv )p ~$(!h9g*
d9I {Fh Rf uG KzZ* fC )zf {}gyG ($ ?f9}Gv iQhO eC ..!?~$

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

330

)zf >G+p GP6 e(t* #| c9"$ f9v GPEh ,~7GQjC OT* fCh ..#+}zT}yG
fEh ..&A!h9f d9FQ )yE L9AIG fEh ,..&A+afC d9| )yE L9AIG fE ..&!h9fC
{D| R9%F 9%y f(w* fC O*Q@ ?f9= {v #wyh ,..&@Of9S Q|C )yE L9AIG
($ U+y GP$ ...{}gyG Uq! {}g@h ...&+p 9%Tp9"@ ...iQL6G ?f9}GyG
.{Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG e(%q|
gP$ e9+s fE :f(y(t* #*QL6G {gG* iPyG Q|}G )yE f(fO* ~$
AGQ=yGh A:(yG fhOtg* ~8} ...YhQW| Q+ih )fQV Q+i e9+s J9f9}GyG
#| f(!h9g* :h ,~%Af9= ~SG G(G%A!G #| h| f(!9gA* ..A9}S}G )zf
.~%Af9= Q+i iQLC ?f9= ~SG H%A!G
?}zv fCh ,&+yE &=A"*h Q|}G xyP )p )fh )zf f(w* fC ~zT}zy )j="*
O*Q! 9"!C 9$9"g| ?yzT}yG gP$ ...GPv )ph GPv )p ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= QhO
aQg@ fC O*Q@ ?"TyG Q9Z!C #wyh ,...??"TyG Q9Z!C #| G(pQg* fC S9"zy
Q9Z!C ~S9< S9"yG {%F fC GhQ(Z* fC fhO*Q* ~$ ...?e;S G 9| S9"yG
Q|}G ($ GP$ ..e;S G ~+y9g@ S9"yG {%: fC #wyh Q+aL Q|C GP$ ?"TyG
Q9Z!C )zf aQgAyG OGQC #| )zf )j="* ,..GQk aL ~df}G {< ..Q+aMyG
fh9gA* fCh ..?f9}GyG h| X+g* fCh ..>$P* fC &+zf 9$QhO )zfh ?"TyG
{$ ?GP9}y aQfC ;p 9$QhO #f dzT* iPyG #wy ,..9%+p {}g+y ..9%g|
:| )="yG d(s )p GP$ {LO* fC )WLC ?{gq+S GP9| hC ?...9%=MA"+S
v
v
.y&< uG h}S h}S #|z
k
k
HQ u 9Zy9L ;}f ($ &< d(t!h &G%A"! iPyG {}gyG f(w* fC )j="+p
.#+s(zM}yG #| OI} &+p U+yh ,#+}y9gyG
iCQ ($ 9| ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= 9%"+< #|h J9f9}GyG #f Q+DwyG Q+CC *
?qf #| ~w"f ahQg| ($ 9}<h ?f9}Gzy e9gyG U+FQyG ~vQ9=Af9< ~wAz+]p
>TI ~79$9:Gh ~%qsG(| Q+jA< J9f9}GyG A9}zf ^g=y >T"* 9}+p )t@h
fC

331

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Os )AyGh ~%+@z@ )AyG dG(|~y 9=k T;h ,;D| H+zMyG dhO #| d9gp}G OhOQ
??~79$9:G Q++j@ )p QhO 9%y f(w*
~zg* {Fh Rf uG )yE )fGOyG fE :#*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG ?z+]p d(t*
&F(@ )AyG )$ I(fOyG 9}!E ,..dG(|}9< 9+;: I(fOyGh ...bGRQyG ($ uG fC
.dG(|}G
)wy iO* )p dG(|}G G(fO :S9"zy d(t! : ~+A+yG ?y9qv )yE (fO! 9|O"gp
#| gQh9F #}p ,..e9A*}G G(zqw* fC )yE S9"yG &FhC 9}!E ..9}k +A* {qvC
(fOC ;p ,..&zqw+p ~+A* #| 9=k *Qs f9v #|h y&z$} ~vQ+L ~vQ+Lz :~+A*
.xyP< e(sC iPyG 9!C f(vC )wy iO* )p dG(|}G G(g]* )wy S9"yG
,..96 G(|(t* )wy ,9%+zf S9"yG aQgA* {Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG GPw%p
;dG(|}G QO9Z| )yE 9"@(fO &F(A@ fC 9|C ..96 f(|(t* #| h| G(!h9gA+y ~C
k
fCh &=GW! fC )j="* Q|C GP%p ,d9}yG g9:G h| 9%GA| c(zTyG )p Q+jAyG f(w+p
,?"TJyG ?df(}yGh ?}wJyG 9%I;S f(w@ uG )yE I(fOyG J9f9}Gp ,&]pQ!
.d9}yG 9%I;S U+yh
I9fOyG #wy ...I9+JyG >Zf &!E :d9}yG #f f(y(t* f(*O9ZAs:Gh
.#+}y9gyG HQ u OQGAyGh U;L G ($ I(fOyG >Zf fC f(}zg*
,GQk +L ~6 uG OGQC Otp ~9O*C #| {Fh Rf uG &g"| fE ,?z+Sh d9}yGh
)WLC #wyh ,~w+zf )WLC QtqyG 9| uGhz :| d(SQyG d(t< #||! #J!h
;9$(Tp9"@ 9}v 9$(Tp9"Ap ~wz=s #| )zf BaT< 9}v ~w+zf 9+!OyG bT=@ fC
.y~%Awz$C 9}v ~wwz%Ap
f(gt* 9| Q\C ?f9ayG )yE H(ztyG f(fO* #*PyG {Fh Rf uG )yE I9fOy9p
KzZ* iPyG #}p GPE ,...S9"yG QF9S Up9"A* 9}v 9+!OyG )p G(Tp9"A* fC &+p
N+WyG ?z+]p aOQCh !?dG(|}G Q|C )p f(Tp9"A+S I9fOyG f9v GPE S9"yG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

332

xV ;p ,dG(|}G KzZ* iPyG #}p dG(|}G H9JYC uz}A"S 9"v GPE :;F9s
Rf uG )yE I(fOy9< f(w@ 9}!E ,IO9+tyG gP$h ,gO(t* OF9s )yE L9AJ* d9}yG fC
.{Fh
y~w+zf )WLC QtqyG 9| uGhz :| )="yG d(t* uG )yE I(fOyG Q|C #fh
9}!zvh | )="yG BwTp ?QWy9< Q+MyG )@z* hC uG d(SQ 9* :{FQ d9tp
#*Cz :d9sh ,&%Fh #f A9]IQyG KT}* PLC &"f iQSo 9}y ~C .&+yE )I(*
#wyh ,QWy9< Q+MyG )@z* : &!Ez :d9s uG d(SQ 9* GP!z$ :d9s y?{F9TyG gGQC
k
{D}yG | d(SQyG HQ]+p .y~z* hC 9a=I {At* 9| AGQ]MyG ?zvB #| fE
hC 96 J(}Ap ?}MAyG 9%=+ZAp GQk +Dv {vz@ ?<GOy9< d9}yG h}G< ~A9 iPy9<
.VQ}@
?"TyGh fBQtyG ~%G8 fC G(}zg* fC {Fh Rf uG )yE I9fOyG )zf )j="+p
)yE G(%GA* fCh ,dG(|}G H9JYC #| OIC &wz}A* fC : ,?|}G rzS ~%q<
.d9}yG HQ ($ {Fh Rf uG fC #+}y9f {Fh Rf uG
fC ~zg! ;{+zs {Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG )yE )@z* d9}yG fC 9!Qd! GPEh
&}+tS ~vOIC )}J* 9}v 9+!OyG gO=f )}J* {Fh Rf uG fEz :d9s | )="yG
.yA9}yG #|

333

? +fQW y

+ (Azy

O I

K QY

QG

(I )p

e9gyG

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

+FQyG

)\9}yG OOgyG )p e9gyG U+FQyG )yOC O+I(AyG ?zG}y K*QZyG gQG(I )p


?"TyG Q9Z!C )p ~$ #}| #*Q+DwyG d9< {jW@ )AyG {F9T}yG #| Q+Dv )p g(yO<
iO*C #+< ?J\Gh ?+zF 9%g\hh ?t+tJyG #f EJ=zy ?yh9J| )p 9%FQ9Lh
uF9tJyG rWv #*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG ?z+]p 9"g| {YG(* e(+yGh ...AGQtyG
k
uG YQW< AGR%AS:G #f 9COJA| O+I(AyG ?zG| ?z8SC )zf &@9<9FE d;L #|
fCh O<: uG )yE I(fOyG J9f9= fCh ,&zgq! fC R(G* : Qqv &!C f9+<h ,&"*Oh
d9sh ..d9}yG 9%I;S U+yh ?"TJyG ?df(}yGh ?}wJyG 9%I;S f(w*
HGRI}G e9d"v 9"Tyh ,Q9S 9}"*C uJyG h| Q+T! ?"TyG Q9Z!C )p 9"!E :&Az+]p
A9|O ?I9=ASG ?yzT| #| ?"TyG Q9Z!C rs(| #+< 9}v ,?\Q9g}yG g9:G PLz!
e9gyG U+FQyG K\hCh ,..&zgq! fC 9"y R(G* : Qqv xyP fCh ~zT}yG ~v9JyG
OvCh ..{Fh Rf uG ($ YQW}yG f} hFGQWyG #T* fC R(G* : f9}yQ=yG fC
k
...Q+DwyGh ,9tS9p f9v fEh #+}zT}yG )zf >FGh ~v9Jzy A9fOyG fC )zf
U9L &F(< ?"TyG Q9Z!Ch e9f &F(* #+}zT}yG d9< {jW* 9}| ...Q+DwyGh
:e9gyG U+FQyG QG(I #| )t=A}yG ARGyG d;L #| ~wg| &\QgAT!
W(aL ?|(wJyG #+<h ~w"+< {$h ??|(wJyG #| ?"TyG Q9Z!C rs(| 9| *
??qzAM}yG 9*9]tyG )p ?"TyG Q9Z!C rs(| )zf Q+Cz@ xyPy {$h ??I(Aq|
k
~v9JyG fCh ...QW< e9wJyG fC #||! #J! :;F9s gOQ N+WyG {YG(*h
9}!E #J!h ..9Ik ;Y &A|} O*Q* ~v9JyG fCh ...~%z}yG ~+fRyG ($ U+y
Rf uG )yE I(fOy9< 9%+p 9"}s ,?+}SQ JG("s #| uG )yE I(fOyG Q|C 9"G%A!G
k
H9< {vh ~%JY9"! ...#+|(wJ|h 9|9wI ?|}G KY9"! #J"p ,..{Fh
9}!E ..&vQA! : uG )yE I(fOyG Q|C )p 9Ik (Aq| 9"y Q9Zp {Fh Rf uG fPC
e9wJyG KY9"!h ..{Fh Rf uG gOFhC iPyG H9=yG GP$ )p )gT!
.h+}GyG KY9"! ..N(+WyGh H9=WyGh #+_;TyGh #+|(wJ}yGh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

334

)p Q+T! 9"!E :d(t+p ,9"Az8SC )zf ?+p9V OhOQ< N+WyG J9}zv H9T"@h
e9d"v 9"Tyh .Q9S 9}"*C uJyG h| #J!h ...{Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG
.uJy9< &<9Av dR!C {Fh Rf uG 9}!E ,?\Q9g}yG g9:G PLz@ )AyG HGRI}G
)zf &g| #J!h ,&g| u9p &g| uJyG f9v #}p ..Q9S 9}"*C uJyG h| #J"p
H9=WyG (fO!h g9=AV:G IQFGO h+S(@ eOf )yE #|}G d9FQ (fO! .uJyG xyP
.{tgAyG )yE
,a9sh}G )yE ?"TyG Q9Z!C OF9T| ^g< B}\ ?+\9}yG JGQAqyG )p *
~wzgp OQ 9}p ?"TyG Q9Z!C )yE f(}A"* #}| QY9"gyG ^g< )zf ^=tyG )tyCh
.?g(}A*O<C iPyG
)AyG OGQp}G ^g< )zf ^=tyG A9tyE #f 9|C :#*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG d(t*
)tyCh A9aLC Bgsh fE ,IQ$9c {wV JPLC 9| ?yzT| gP%p ?"TyG Q9Z!C )yE )}A"@
k
.9g*QS )%A"* Q|}G xyP f(w* fC {|z! #J"p ,~%]g< )zf ^=tyG
~8} ;?=F9Y ~7Qd! f(w@ fC #|}G a9Z| )p ~$ #*PyG 9"!G(LC (fO!h
J:9FQ ~$ gQQ\h gQaL d9"* #| dhC GP%p .g9=AV:G b9a! G(gSh (y
)yE #|}G (fO!h ,{tgAyG )yE H9=WyG (fO! 9"!{p xyPy ,~%Tq!C #|}G
~zc #}p .9!k RG(@ &!(v {gG* {Fh Rf uG fC ~zg* fCh ,iQJAyGh bOZyG
k
g9=A!G c9"$ f(w* fC O<;p .9g*QS &+zf )@z* &}zc {gG* {Fh Rf uG f{p
?%=WyG OQG}< S9"yG PL|* : fCh ...g9=AV:G IQFGO h+S(@ eOf )yE
ahQdy OfC f(!9s eGOMASG )p G(gS(A* : fCh ,f("dyGh c(wWyGh
)p S9"yG #||* fC ($ #|}G )zf >FG(yG fC G(}zg* fCh ..?+F9"DASG
,IQ+aL K=Z@ ?yzT}y9p >FG(yG xyP utJA* ~y GP{p ,~7(+< )ph ~%V9g|
k
,#|}G &< f(=za* 9G%"| ~%Tq!} G(G%A"* f} L9+AIG )p S9"yG K=Z*h
)p f(w@ fC R(G* : ?yzT| gP$h ,...iQAW@h Y9=@ ?yzT| #|}G K=Z*h
.?*Q9]I ?|C

335

? +fQW y

{$h ?&zjW@ iPyG Q+MyG 9|h ~vO"f {D}@ GP9| ?+|;S

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

JZyG *
.?I(JY c9"$
{v )p O(F(| Q|Ch ghQw| Q+i Q|C ?+|;S G I(JZyG fE :N+WyG d(t*
I(JZyGh ..QqwyG O;< )p O(F(| ..e;S G O;< )p O(F(| ...hs(|
#| hpGO< BT+y .IQ}AT| 97Q+T|h .{Fh Rf uG ($ 9$OF9s ?+|;S G
($ &!C OIC #c GP{p .J9+g= hC J9TS|| #| hC J98+$ #| hC J9|(wI
I(JZyG gP6 fPC iPyG f} ,QhQi GP%p ?+|;S G I(JZyG hpO* iPyG
.#+}y9gyG HQ ($ 9%gpO* iPyGh
k
..J9+=zTyGh A9aL}G #| Q+Dv 9%+p I(JZyG fE :;F9s N+WyG r+]*h
9}+p HG(ZyG )yE S9"yG G(%="*h G(%=A"* fC e;S G I9fO )zf )j="* #wyh
I(fOyG f(w@ : )AI ..9%+p G(z}g* fC ~%y fP|@ )AyG OhOJyGh ,&!(z}g*
{Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG f(w@ 9}!E ,..zaMyGh ?<QGAyG )zf ?}F9s
.{Fh Rf uG )yE I9fOzy OfG(s #| ?"TyG {$C g9SQC 9}| IO+qAT| ...IQF9S
ut; )wy 9$OVQ! r+vh ?IO(F(| B!9v GPE I(JZyG gP$ Q+T@ r+v *
.??fhQW|h ?+fQV JG("s )p ?z+="yG 9%pGO$C
k
#w}* 9}< A)V QDvz< ~A7 fC )j="* uG )yE I(fOyG fE :;F9s N+WyG aOQ*
&@QGQI ?FQO ^*Q}yG f(w* 9|O"f &!C :)"g}< Bs(yG ?q+ch &+}T! fC
,&=A"! fC O<;p ,&ztf )zf QC|+S IQGQJyG ?FQO )p Y9q@Q:G GP$h ,?gq@Q|
^*Q}yG IQGQI ?FQO )p Y9q@Q:G )yE &=A"* fC ($ >+=azy Bs(yG ?q+c(p
&y ?s;f : ..{FQyG )p ~yC c9"$ f9v GPE &+"g* : ..9%]qL )zf {}g+p
S9"yG {jW* fC O*Q* f9a+WyG fC )p [MzA@ ?yzT}y9p ..i(!9C ~yC ..GP6
.Bs(yG ?q+ch Q+j<
k
#| Q+Dv )p e;S G #| ~%FQ< A9aLC )p f(gt* S9"yG OG! ;D}p
,..?+|;S G O;=yG Q+i )p f(W+g* #*PyG #+}zT}yG ?Y9Lh ,~y9gyG fGOz<
G I(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

336

9 p Bs(yG GP$ )p &+zf )AyG ?q+c(yG )yE &=A"* fC O<: ~zT}y9p


~M]A@ ..~6 Bgsh ~y9d| #| G(=+YC 9}y ?G+A! S9"yG #| Q+Dv ,9%pQg*h
Rf uG )yE I(fOyG Q|C {wW@ )AyG )$ gP$ ~$O"f K=ZAp ?yzT}yG gP$
)zf S9"yG aQZ+p ,..Q|}G GP$ )zf ?=Z"| ~7(fO f(wAp ,{Fh
.O9VQyGh HG(DyG )yE ~6 PLz@ )AyG ?q+c(yG
)AyG aGO$}G BttI Os ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fC d(tyG h+aAT! {$ *
Og< 9%F9W!E #| aO%yG ?f9}GyG BttI {$ QLB )"g}< hC ?9%zFC #| B8W!C
?#+g=TyG 9%|9f ?"TyG Q9Z!C Z(z<
k
BttI Os ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= fC 9!Q(Z@ (y 9"!E :;F9s &Az+]p r+]*
{v )yE JO9f Os e;S G ?zd| fC 9!Q(ZAy 9%zFC #| B8W!C )AyG aGO$}G
k
.9%Tq! ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= {; fC 9<(za| K=Z*h ,..>zs {v )yEh B+<
.9%Aq+ch )y9Ay9< B%A!9p Btt; Os 9%zFC #| B|9s )AyG aGO$}G f}
k
:(sh GOk9tAfG uG #*O S9"y9< {J* fC 9%pO$ ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= #wyh
k
Y9T@Gh ,O9tAf:G K+JZ@ b9a! Y9T@9<h ,...~zgyG b9a! Y9T@9< ;}fh
b9a! Y9T@Gh ,cQWyG Og< O+I(AyG b9a! Y9T@Gh ,?+Zg}yG Og< ?f9ayG b9a!
.M9G! {+yO GP$ 9%s9a! Y9T@Gh ,?zqjyG Og< ?dt+yG
,RGgy9< 9"Tq!C ~%A! fC 9"y O<: ...Q+ZtAy9< 9"Tq!C ~%A! fC 9"y O<: #wy
,#+}y9gyG HQ uG #| KAp &!Ch ,KAp A9V GPE {Fh Rf uG fC ~zg! fC 9"y O<:
>J! 9"!} &=J! Q|C (%p 9!Q+i iO*C )zf hC ,9"*O*C )zf KAqy9< )@z* uG fCh
.9!Q+i iO*z< hC 9"*O*z< QWA"* fC uG #*Oy
(<C QZ!( O@Q}yG (fO}yG ?+]t< ?+\9}yG JGQAqyG )p e9gyG iCQyG {jW!G
k
Q9Z!C rs(| 9}p ,O@Q}yG GP$ {D| )p 9*CQ ?"TyG Q9Z!} h}T! ~yh ...)O*R
.?&y9D|Ch )O*R )<C QZ!( #| ?"TyG
,... 9O|+

337

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QI #wy ,..Q|}G GP$ #f 9=k +Av JQW! Os ?"TyG Q9Z!C fC #cC


Q9+@ ($ GP$ )!9}zgyG Q9+AyG f} ,..IQ}AT| HQI ?+!9}zgyG h| #+}zT}yG
k
,..e;S G )fO* #| iO*C )p )!9}zgyG Q9+AyG K=Z* 9!9+ICh ,...b9q"yG
~"%F )p #+tp9"}yGh #*Qp9wyG h}G* {Fh Rf uGh ,...Qqv Q9+@ K=Z+p
ry9M* 9| {v fC ~zg!h ,Bsh {v )p YQWyG d(s eQAJ! #J!h ,...9gk +=
.{_9< )zf &!{p bO 9}%| d(s )p YQWyG Q|C
>IC )""wyh ,...?as9Sh ..?z_9< ih9fO #++!9}zgyG A:|$ ih9fOh
k
...GPv d9s 9!;p fC {i9WyG ~%zjV G(zgG* fC )j="* : I9fOyG fE :d(sC fC
9}!E .{+_9<Ch dG(sC )zf OQyG )$ I9fOyG ?}%| K=Z@hx ...GPv d9s 9!k ;ph
o
A:|$ d9D|C )zf OQ! fC 9"Aq+ch f(w@ fC 9|C ,...~zg! fC 9"A}%| fC ~zg!
)@z@ {Fh Rf uG )yE 9"@(fO IQ+T| )p 9"!} ,...;p gQ+i hC O*R )<C QZ"v
G(gS(* fC fhO*Q* S9"yG #| GQk +Dv #wyh ,..b9a"yG h+S(@ Q+j< OhOQyG
.{_9=yG ?pQg| b9a!
&y9s 9|h .yQCO"+p QWyG QvP@ :h ,QWA"+p Q+MyG QvPGz :d(t@ IOf9tyGh
k
9$9tyC :G(sC fhOOQ* ~$h ,QQw|h ,..bs9S gQ+ih )!9}zgyG GP$ d9D|C
,..?z*(_ fhQs #| ?t<9TyG f9*O}G )p )AI S9"yG H(zs )zf f9a+WyG
k
k
...9+!9}zf f9|9$ f9vh ...9+!9}zf f(fQp f9wp .)gFQ f9T!E )!9}zgy9p
.#++!9}zf Q9qwyG {v f9vh
)yE (fO@h ,A;tgyGh {tgyG xqT@ ?]+j< ?A+t| ?+gFQ ?+!9}zgy9p
k
.{%GyG )yE S9"yG (fO@ ?+!9}zgyG ~S9< f(w@ fC GQ9f 9$9qwp ,...{%GyG
f9}yQ=yG )p ?vQ9W}yG ?yzT| #| ?"TyG Q9Z!C )p ~vQd! ?%Fh 9| *
?g*QWyG u+=a@ )p Of9T* Os xyP fC )ph ..9%y #+zD}| O(Fhh J9f9}Gzy
.??+|;S G
H

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

338

?z+Sh f9}yQ=yG f(v ?yzT| fE :?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG d(t*
IO(F(}yG H$9"}yGh HQ9GAyGh ,&"cC : 9| GP%p ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG u+=aAy
fC #cC 9!C :d(t*h QLB )@z* fC 9|C ,xyP )zf d:OAS:G )p ?J\Gh
)@(Y GP$ :&y d(szp .x@(Y )"afzp .xyPy ?z+Sh f(w+S f9}yQ=yG
.&+yE {Y(}yG u*QayG ($ GP$ fC #cC : 9!C #wy ..gPMp
GP%p hFGQWyG #T* fC &y R(G* ?+g*QW@ ?8+%v f9}yQ=yG fC OtAfG #| fCh
x
QOZ| )$ ?|}G fC #d@ fC R(G* ;p ,{Fh Rf uG ($ YQW}yG f} ;Qqv
9!Q(Z@ (y 9"!} .HG(ZyG (%p ?|C &@QsC 9|h ,#+!G(tyG QOZ| ..J9azTyG
~$(fO! G(y9g@ ,..G(qzALG 9!O"f W(y e(s fE :9"zsh ,A9+=!}G H%"| h| xyP
k
Eg< #*PyG e(tyG )p 9"zs (y ,...9fk hQW| 9_G(y K=Z+p ?+_GQt}*OyG )yE
f9Ch}G IO9=f fE :9"zty ?+_GQt}*OyG ($ H%"}yG fE ....| uG d(SQ ~%+p
)zf &G%"}< 9}k v9I ~wJ* {Fh Rf uG #wyh ,...~+zTyG H%"}yG )$
k
.&zv f(wyG )zfh 9g+= VQ}G
?iQ+qwAyG QwqyG Q9WA!G #| ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C rs(| 9| *
bQp dG(sz< S9"yG ?pQg| eOfh LQG(MyG Qwp #| YQp GP$ Q+qwAyG
fBQtyG #| ?yO}G f(=za* ~%zgF ~%+zf ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C OhOQh .d;]yG
.dG(s}G gP$ )zf ?"TyGh
,IQ+MyG fhQtyG )p 9$Q%cC )y9g@h &!9J=S IRgyG HQ J:;]yG gP$h
QhR* )!BQs ["< OIC QAj* fC R(G* ;p .9%+zf ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C H9Fzp
#| xyP Q+i )p hC .#+g| Q+qw@ )p ry9M}yG &y(s )zf {+yO GP$ fC &zF9s
k
.(zjyG ?}S GP$ fC g9=A!G )zf 9}FGO f(w! fC )j="*h .{F9T}yG gP$
k
~zT| h}AG}v ;D| QZ}v ?+|;S G J9g}AG}yG )p ?I9+TyG O(Fh *
.?~wy ?=T"y9< )"g@ GP9|

339

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

#| {gG* fCh ,&"*O eQAJ*h &Tq! eQAJ* fC ~zT| Oz< {wy >IC 9!C
.&|QAJ+p xyP< QgW+S KF9TyG fC xV:h ,..#+g| eGRAy9< eRAz* &+yE {LO*
A @?
o :d(t* {Fh Rf u9p d9}zy QOZ| ?I9+TyG fC 9""c fE
.

]28

?*6G :?<n (Aq yG[ p

F ED CB

P%p ..9%zFC #| Q(}MyG K+=* 9| {gq"p {LOzy QOZ| ?I9+TyG fC #dp


.{_9< #c
O(ph ~"Aj@ QqwyG dhOp .&}"Aj! fC )j="* QLB &Fh 9%y ?I9+TyG #wyh
: ,~%"*O #| ~$(FQM+y 9$Q+jy eC ?SGQOzy AG(S 9%+yE #+}zT}yG A9"<C
)yE hC .O9Jy G )yE ~%"*O #| ~$(FQM+y #wyh ,QqwyG #*O )p ~$(zLO+y
)@z+p ,xyP Q+ih 9!RyGh )Y9g}yG H9w@QGh ,Q}MyG HQV )yE hC .LQ=AyG
iPyGh ,..d(tgyG >_9M* iPyG #*OyG H9JYC #J!h M9+TyG A:|$ 9"+yE
K=Z@h ,..&+yE ~$(fO! :h ,..uG #*O ~%pQg! : ,...S(q"yG &}%q@
)zf A9]sh .{Ash H9$QE e;S G fC ~%pQg! fC 9!O"f )AyG ?q+c(yG {v
A:|$ fC )yE &=A"! fC 9"+zf )j="+p ,&"|z| &jz<C ~C uG e;v &g}SC #*C M9+TyG
&"f G(g}T* fC )yE ?F9I )p ~$h ,..uG #*O #f G(g}T* ~y ,..M9+TyG
.{}gyGh d(ty9< ~%pQg"p
H9JYC 96 e9+tyG dh9J* )AyG #+y(8T}yGh e9wJzy {AtyG J:h9J| *
.?~%y d(t@ GP9| T(W}yG QwqyG
rshh ,...YGO(yG ?GI )p ?pQf e(* rsh | )="yG fE :N+WyG d(t*
Oz< iCh ?...GP$ Q%V iCh ?GP$ e(* iCz :H9JYC dzSh ..QJ"yG e(*
)p ,GP$ ~vQ%V )p ...GP$ ~w|(* ?|QJv ~8{p ...z :d9s ~C y?GP$
#| OGT| eO$ #| OVC uG :E &yE : :d(t* ~zT| eO xqTp ,yGP$ ~vOz<
,A9|OyG gP$ M9=AT@ fC R(G* : Qqv A9|OyG gP$ ?I9=ASGh ,...OF9T}yG
A9F 9|h ,{Fh Rf uG gOGQC iPyG Q|}9< A9|OyG gP$ ?I9=ASG f(w* fC )j="*
G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

340

Uq"yG ?*9}Jy ,U}MyG d(Y}G gP$ ?*9}Jy :E {Fh Rf uG YQV


?*9}Ih ,...d9}yG ?*9}Ih ,...VQgyG ?*9}Jyh ,....#*OyG ?*9}Jyh
.{tgyG
S9"yG {gG+y A9F Os GP$ ?*9}Jy A9F iPyG YQWyG fC S9"zy Q(Z@ ;p
k
.9jy9< zaL G(8aLC A:|%p .&"| YRp )p
k
?}zv #| {$ .?*Q+Z}yG #+}zT}yG 9*9]s )p :P9< e9wJyG ^g< Q%d*
.?e9wJyG )yE 9%%F(@
)zf &"|zASC Os {Fh Rf uG fC aQg* fC ~zT}yG ~v9JyG )zf )j="*
&!Ch ,&yzT+S {Fh Rf uG fCh ,#*OyG GP$ )zf 9"k +|C f(w* fC )j="*h ,xyP
k
;|9f f(w* fC &+zf 9}!Eh ,..~|}G h}: )p {Fh Rf uG e9|C &y QPf :
A(\(yG #| ?+]s QjYC #| )|;S G YQWyG 9*9]s )p f(w* fCh ,uG #*O<
~%\GQfC ?*9}Ih ,#+}zT}yG Q9*O ?*9}I- ?+]s Q=vC )yE ...IQ9%ayGh
k
&*OZ@ fC ~zg*h ,uG #*O< ;|9f xyP )p f(w* fC )j="* ,...~%F9|Oh
#| f(w+p Kzq* fC 9|{p .&+p gQ=AM* {Fh Rf uG Q|C ($ 9}!E ?*:(yG gP%y
k
f(w*h ,Q9"yG {$C #| f(w+p {Wq* fC 9|Eh ,9}+df &<G(C f(w*h .?"GyG {$C
k
.9}+yC &<9tf
?~v9JyG g9: ~zT}yG f9T! G >FGh 9| *
:dh}G ~TtyG :e9TsC )yE ~Tt"* ~v9JyG g9: ~zT}yG f9T! G >FGh
?C;C )yE &+p f(}Tt"* S9"yGh ,..~zT}yG ~v9JyG Q9+ALG :)"g*h Q9+AL:G
?*:(yG Q|C #f ~%"| OIC rzMA* : ?*:(yG {$C ,Q9+AL:G ?JY9"| :e9TsC
)j="* A:|%p Otfh {I {$C BJY fEh ,...~CC &!hO #}< Btzg@ fE 98}
&!hO #| GhQ9ALGh KzY}G G(vQ@ f{p ,..KzY}9p KzY}G GhQ9AM* fC
,f(pQg* : 9| G(=vQ* fC )j="* ;p #+}zT}yG eG(f 9|C ,~CCh ?*:(yG JOtg!G
,...

341

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{$C #| JG(Y}G gP$ B!9v AG(S JG(Y}G OOgv ...?+_GQt}*OyG 9|C


f(G+9 ?+_GQt}*OyG H9JYC f{p xyPyh ...GP$ f(vQO* OtgyGh {JyG
?yzT}yG gP$ fhOg*h JG(Y}G L9+$ Bsh f(FQM* ~C ,..e9gyG iCQyG
.?8+S #w@ 9%GF9A!h ?F9}yG )p ?F9| ?zV9p 9%GF9A!
)p ($ 9}+p Q|}G )yh G(g+a* fC S9"yG >FGh f{p ,?f9ayG ?JY9"| ~C
9%]g< :Q|GhC #+< bzL f{p ,...&A+Zg| )p U+yh {Fh Rf uG ?f9_
,...?f9ayG Q|C )p &A+Zg| R(G* ;p ,...?+Zg| 9%]g<h ,...?f9_
.?+Zg}yG Q|C )p &Af9_ R(G* : 9}v
)t=@ )AI A9aL}G QW! eOg< {Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG )j="* xyPvh
9|O"f f9azTyG f} .9%I;YE KY9"yG )zf {%T* ,?+qM| e9wJyG A9aLC
fC >gZyG #| K=Z+p &+zf f9a+WyG f9g* ,...aQg@h gD9aLC Q%W@
($ GP$h &F9aL} JGQ<Q=AyG &y f(tzAM* #+tp9"}yG {$C #| ?!9a=yGh ,hFGQA*
.e9wJzy ?=T"y9< Oz< {v )p KOJ* iPyG
k
)vzvf >vFGh e9vwvJvzvy A9vfOvyG fE :;vF9vs Nv+vWvyG ?vzv+v]vp OQvavAvTv*h
k
f9v fEh &y A9fOyGh ,...9tS9p f9v (yh &y A9fOy9p ...#+}zT}yG
#f &gFQ* fC h+aAT* iPyG ,uG ($ &JzZ* fC h+aAT* iPyG f} ,..9}k y9c
9"!E {< ,...Q|C {v KzZ* iPyG H9=yG GP$ cQA! r+wp ,...uG ($ &+i
bzTA* fC gO*R* iPyG A;=yG GP$ #| f(w+p .Ak;< uG gO*R* fC >za"p &=zt!
QQv ]v yGh ,...O9v Tv p Gh O9v Tv qv yG 9v %v +v p Qv Dv wv +v p ,...?v |}G H9v sQ )v zv f
.uG YQV ry9< {F9T| gP$h ,..QGQ\ Gh
GP9| J9}zv K;C ?+S9+TyG ?SQ9}}yG -#*OyG {FQ- ~zT}yG OQqyG *
.?~wy ?=T"y9< )"g@
{gq* : iPyG ($ :~zT}yG OQqyG fE :#*OyG Q(! J(qY N+WyG d(t*

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

342

9 y #| &Tq!h &z}f )G"* &+p uG ~wI ~zg* fC Og< :E {}gyG


)p U+zp #*O {FQ GP$ ...9}k zT| Q9Y f9T!E {v ($ :#*OyG {FQh
{FQ ($ ~zT| {vh ,...#*O ~y9f e;S G )p 9}!E #*O {FQ e;S G
.{Fh Rf uG #*O S9"yG ~zg* iPyG (%p #*OyG ~y9f 9|C ...#*O
J9SQ9}}yG #wyh ,?yhOh #*O e;S 9p ,?+S9+TyG J9SQ9}}yGh
f9T!E {wp ,..r_9L Q|C 98{p 9!O"f 9%zt"! )AyG ?+<QjyG IQ(Zy9< ?+S9+TyG
iPyG Q|}G cQA* fC )j="* ;p &AS9+S J9+FRF #| ?+FRF ($ #+g| Q|z< rzw|
.QLB Q|z< {jW"* ~C .&< rzv
h}AG* )AyG h|9G}yG gP$h ,Uy9G}yG GP$ G(i9Y ?t+tJyG )p O(%+y9p
G(}$hCh ,..{Fh Rf uG fhO #| h*QWAyGh #+!G(tyG ?i9+Zy S9"yG 9%+p
#| Q+DwyG ~%qzL Q9Yh ,{Y}G )$ ?+S9+TyG J9SQ9}}yG gP$ fz< S9"yG
.e;S G I9fO
)yE 9"tp(* fCh &+yE 9!OVQ* fCh ,..uJy9< 9!QZ=* fC {Fh Rf uG dzT"p
.&@9\Q|h &A=J|
.~zSh &=JYh &yB )zfh O}J| 9!O+S )zf uG )zYh
.Q " G

VVV

343

? +fQW y

)1(

} )yhC

...Q| G

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?f9_

])=vGQ}yG d9}F /O[

?azTyG ?f9_ OGQp}G {=tA* fC eRzAT@ ,e(wJ}yGh ~v9JyG #+< ?s;gyG


98C )$G("yGh Q|Gh}G gP$ )p {Y}G f} ,9%+$G(!h 9$Q|GhC )p ?}v9JyG
GQk +S I9+JyG H:hO Q+S )zf {}gyGh ?f9}Gzy e9gyG Ky9ZyG u+t; OZt<
k
.9}dA"|
)gT*h f9v #| 9"k F9v gQ+jy Y(]MyG IQwp #| r!z* &g=a< OQqyG #wyh
Q|Gh}G Ba=@QG 9"$ #|h gRFGQih &@GhR"y GAk9\QE ?}v9JyG ?azTyG )zf OQ}Azy
GP$ Q9Yh ,ry9M}yG )zf hs(* iO9| AGRG< -?+!(!9tyG IOf9tyG- )$G("yGh
k
.?+s;L}G OfG(tyG #f 9$R+}* ?+!(!9tyG IOf9tyG f9vQC #| 9"vQ AGRGyG
,&@O9=fh u9< f9}* 9< )%"yGh Q|}G b=@Q* E+I )|;S G e9d"yG )ph
k
k
k
| O}J}<h 9F9%"|h ?g*QVh 9"*O e;S 9<h 9<Q u9< )\Q iPyG #||}yG f{p
k
)zf Ef9=yG {Fh Rf u &A=sGQ| )ph gQ+}\ )ph &Tq! )p OG* :(SQ
97Q}Ch {Fh Rf uG i(t@ &Tq! )p utJAAp ,&+$G(!h )y9g@ uG Q|GhC eGQAIG
u GQk |C ry9Lh I(%WyG &A=zi (y )AIh ,&+$G(! H9"AFGh )y9g@ uG Q|GhC Y9=@G
.&<Q &"f (qg* )AI ?<(AyG )yE YQ9T* &!{p )y9g@
fC OG! ~zT}yG h}AG}yG O(T* fC >G* iPyG )!9}* G uza"}yG GP$ #|h
k
&|QG< 9pQAg| Q|}G )yhC )yE eOtA* A9qMyG )p &A}*QF >w@QG iPyG )!9GyG
#*O )|;S G e9d"yG )p ?f9ayG )$ xz@ .9%T!O #| &Tq! Q+%a@ )yE )gT*
?f9ayG )y9g@ uG b<Q GP%yh ,)y9g@ uG )yE O=gyG &< HQtA* {}fh ,h=A|
X W Vo :9=k $GQ 9=k iGQ 9%+yE )gT* #||| #| :E 9%=za* ~zp f9}* 9<

hgfedcba`_^]\[ZY
.v$1413

?GJyG iP OOf O+I(AyG )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

344

Otp ?*6 9T"xy p!@


! z~ q p o n m l k j i
?f9_h ,&<9Av )p &"f )8h &< Q|C 9}+p uG ?f9_ H(Fh )yE ?*6G JOVQC
,)y9g@ uG YQV H(Fh )p [! )%p &A"S )p Q|Ch K\hh #+< 9}+p d(SQyG
U+yh &y(SQh uG ?f9ay ?+g=Ay9< Q|}G )yhC ?f9_ H(Fh )yE JOVQC ~C
f{p ,&y #*Pq"| uG YQV )zf #+}F9s G(|GO 9| iC ,d;tAS:G {+=S )zf
&+=! ?"Sh uG H9Av )yE G(}wAI9p Q(|}G #| Q|C )zf a;L ~w"+< KOI
9+!OyG )p Q+MyG G(=+ZAp #+"||}yG {+=S )zf ~A"v fE uJyG )yE G(zZ@ )AI
.IQL6Gh
f(z|9gyG A9}zgyG ~$h ,?azTyG H9JYC AGQ|}Gh I:(yG ~$ Q|}G G(yhCh
k
.~$9+!Oh ~%"*O Q(|C )p S9"yG ~%+yE hFQ*h ,9]*C
fC )qw*h I:(yGh ?}F}G ?f9_ )zf E; )AyG U(Z"yG JQ@G(@ Otyh
#| IQ9| G H9Av )yEh iQ9M=yG e9| G K+JY #| e9wI}G H9Av )yE hFQ@
:9%"| Q+qi ~F )zf rtAy ~zT| e9| G K+JY
#|h ,uG Y9_C Otp )"f9_C #|z | uG d(SQ d9s :d9s IQ*Q$ )<C #f
Otp e9| G )Zf #|h ,uG )Zf Otp )!9Zf #|h ,)"f9_C Otp e9| G Y9_C
. y)!9Zf
G(!9wp IQ9| G f(pQg* : HQgyG #| 9%+z* #|h X*Qs B!9v :)gp9WyG d9s
~$Q||* #| ?f9_ )zf ~%DJ* d(tyG GP$ | d9tp ,AGQ|}G )zf f(g"A}*
f(FQM* ;p O;=yG ~$:h GPEh 9*GQTyG )p ~%Dg< GPE ~%y O9+t!:Gh ~%+zf
. ?}zwyG bQAq@ ;8y ~%+zf
]59

G :A

G[

)1 (

)2(

9M=yG O"f iQ+|C eqz< #wyh &+zf uqA| E*OJyG )41/10( ?"TyG MQV- i(j=yG )1(
.IQ9| G c- ~zT| O"f )Q+|}G( eqyh e9wI}G
.)120/13( E*OJyG X9qy} &IQV O"f jQ9=yG KAp ,p QGI #<G ep9JyG g9wI )2(

c -iQ

345

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9q@ #| xyP )p 9}y I:(yGh ?}F}G ?f9a< | uG d(SQ Q|C 9}!Eh


)AyG U(Z"yG #| Q+Dv )p K\Gh GP$h ,O9TqyG {+=S bGQAp:G f} ,?}zwyG
r!z@ GOk =f Q+|}G f9v fEh ,Uq"yG )zf ?s9V B!9v fEh ?f9ayG )zf E;
.&Af9_h &y Y(]MyG #| S(q"yG
. y?=+<R &SCQ fzv )W=I O=f ~w+zf {}gASG fEh G(g+_Ch G(g}SGz
. yG(g+_Ch &y G(g}SG uG H9Aw< ~vO(t* O=f ~w+zf {}gASG (yhz
)$ 9}v Q|}G ?+$GQvh {TwyG O"f ?=FGh )|;S G e9d"yG )p ?f9ayG fE
A9LQyG )p )$ 9}v IOWyGh QTgyG )p ?=FGh ,&y U}JAyGh W9W"yG O"f ?=FGh
uG ?+Zg}< Q||@ ~y 9| >; 9}+p ?=FGh )$ 9}v gQw@ 9}+p ?=FGh ,QT+yGh
,?+Zg}< Q||* ~y 9| gQv hC >IC 9}+p ?f9ayGh h}TyG ~zT}yG AQ}yG )zfz
. y?f9_ :h h}S ;p ?+Zg}< Q|C f{p
~v9JyG #+< ?a<GQyG )$ ?f9ayG {d@ fC )zf ,f(}zT}yG h*9=* GP$ )zfh
&< {Z* ~y 9| d9}y9< Q9D8AS:Gh ~zdyG )yE ~v9JyG K"F fEh )AI e(wJ}yGh
.Q$9c MG(< Qqv )yE Q|}G
)p ?f9ayGh h}TyG )zf | uG d(SQ 9"g*9< :d9s B|9ZyG #< IO9=f #f
fC :E ,&z$C Q|}G YR9"! : fCh ,9"+zf IQCCh 9!QT*h 9!QTfh 9"$Qw|h 9"aW"|
k
. f9$Q< &+p uG #| ~vO"f 9IG(< GQk qv GhQ@
QO9s ~zT| {v )zf >G* {< ,&+zf J(wTyGh ~zdyG QGQsE GP$ )"g* :h
b G

)1(

)2(

)3 (

)4 (

E*OI #| )36/1837( ~zT| O"fh )7142,666,693( U!G #f iQ9M=yG &FQLC )1(


.g(J! QP )<C
.#+ZJyG eC #f )70-69/4( O}ICh ~zT| &FQLC )2(
.Q}f #< #f 1839M IQ9| G c ~zT|h 7144 ~sQ M e9wI:G c jQ9M=yG )3(
.)41-1709( IQ9|:G c ~zT| )4(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

346

>FGh Q|}G I:(y KZ"y9p ?fhQW}yG 9%zF9S(< ?Gy9g}yG )yE )gT* fC


)p :E f(w@ : ?f9ayGh ,>FGh Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}Gh
9"v 9}D+I uJy9< -d(t!- e(t! fChz :IO9=f E*OI )p OQh GP%yh ,ahQg|
.y~F: ?|(y uJyG )p a9M! :
e9d! )p xyPv f(w@ fC #w}* :h ?tza| BT+y Q(|}G I:h ?f9_ fE
GhQ|C 9| {v )p ?f9ay9< fhOQq"* : Q|}G (yhzp ?+fQV b<G(\ &}w; )fQV
9| GP{p ,e(wJ}yGh ~v9JyG ~w; )AyG ?+fQWyG OhOJyG )p f(f9a* #wyh ,&<
.?f9_ :h h}S ;p OhOJyG gP$ ~%]g< Rh9:
k
#| ;FQ ~%+zf Q|Ch ?*QS | )="yG Eg< :d9s )zf #f iQ9M=yG ihQ
fC | )="yG Q|C Os U+yC :d9tp ~%+zf >]jp ,g(g+a* fC ~$Q|Ch Q9Z!}G
k
GQ9! ~@OshCh 9=aI ~Ag= 9}y ~w+zf B|Rf Os :d9s .)z< :G(y9s ?)!(g+a@
Qd"* G(|9tp d(LOy9< G(}$ 9}zp ,GQk9! GhOshzp 9=k aI G(g}Gp ,9%+p ~AzLO ~C
k
,Q9"yG #| GQGQp | )="yG 9"g=@ 9}!E :~%]g< d9tp ,^g< )yE ~%]g<
| )="zy QvPp ,&=]i #wSh Q9"yG JO}L PE xyPv ~$ 9}"+=p ?9%zLO"pC
k
. yahQg}yG )p ?f9ayG 9}!E ,GO<C 9%"| G(FQL 9| 9$(zLO (y :d9tp
\ [ Z Yo :)y9g@ &y(s dhR! )p 9=k =S ?ZtyG gP$ B!9v Osh
x
.?*6G
?*6 9T"y p_ ^ ]
uG d(SQ fC U9gyG #< hQ}f #< uG O=f #f &J+JY )p ~zT| ihQh
k
.yY9aASG fE &ga+zp &=zs IQ}Ch gO* ?tqY g9afzp 9|9|E h*9< #|z :d9s |
fC 9!Q|z* ?*h9g| x}f #<G GP$ :?=gwyG HQ O=f #< #}IQyG O=f &y d9tp
<; : 9o :d(t* uGh ,9"Tq!C {At!h {_9=y9< 9""+< 9"yG(|C {vz!
,

)1(

)2(

]59

G :A

G[

zf uqA|
.S9=f #<G #f &+zf uqA|
.&+

)1(
)2(

347

? +fQW y

H
G
FED
.

]29

?*6G

:A

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

CB
A@ ? > =
x
9T"y p!@
!w~ O
NML
K JI
G[

?+Zg| )p &ZfGh ,uG ?f9_ )p &g_C :d9s ~C ?f9S uG O=f BwTp


:h f9v #| 9"k F9v uG ?+Zg}< gQ+|C gQ|C #| {wy ?|9f i(Ap gP%p &zyG
.?A=yG 9%+p [+Z<
Q(|}G I:(y ?f9ayGh h}TyG H(Fh )zf f(tqA| ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$Ch
-e9| G iC- &Af9_ H(Fh xyPvh :?+}+@ #<G d9s .uG ?+Zg}< GhQ|z* ~y 9|
,#+}zT}yG #| OIC O9tAfG ($ U+y ,uG ?+Zg| f9v fEh &< Q|z* 9| {v )p
&+p ~%+yE L9AJ* 9}+p f(vQ9W* A:|$ fC ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C >$P| #wyh
)AyG JG(zZyG #| 9}$Q+ih #*O+gyGh ?g}GyG ~%qzL )zZ"p ,uG ?f9_ #|
~%g| O$9G!h ,9%z+ag@ )yE )]pC ~%qzL {Z@o ~y (y 98} ,~$ 98(}+t*
)%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G )p ~6 f9gAT*h u+AgyG B+=yG ~%g| HJ!h ,Q9qwyG
,H(!P ~%y ?tpQ )p HJ* fC QOs (y f9T! G f{p OhOJyG ?|9sEh Qw"}yG #f
k
d9}f}G #| gQ+ih hRjyG xyPvh ,98+V GP$ gQ]* ~y f(GJ* GhA9F Osh
:E 9%zgp #w* ~y GPE r+wp ,QF9qyG xyP )p &vQ9Vh Q=yG 9%zgp GPE ?Jy9ZyG
.&F(yG GP$ )zf
k
YR9"* fC ;s9f #w}* : &!{p ~TtyGh ~wJyG )p dOgyG )p ~6 f9gAT*h
i(tAyGh Q=yG )zf f(!h9g*h ,~%}Tsh ~%}wI )p f(yOg* 9| GQk +Dv ~8C )p
. v $.C .fGhOgyGh ~C G )zf f(!h9g* :h
a;M< ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C H%"| ,dGOAf:Gh OZtyG H%"| ($ GP$
?8FQ}yG H%"|h >!P )!Oz< #+}zT}yG )zf f(FQM* #*PyG LQG(MyG H%"|
)1(

)2(

~sQ M IQ9|:G c ~zT|


.)240/2( ?*(="yG ?"TyG L9%"|

. 1844

)1(
)2(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

348

N*Q9@ h=A@ #|h ,&z}f #}y >!P f9}* G h| Q]* : :f(y(t* #*PyG
k
,~%|;sC &"f Q=g@ GRQ9< GQk $9c ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C H%"| OG* #+}zT}yG
.~%qsG(| gRQ=@h
#| {FQ )zf e+jA* gOF(p u*OZyG Qw< )<C )zf )}zS}G IRQ< (<C Q|
~zp :d9s ?&+zf e+jA@ iPyG GP$ #| uG d(SQ ?q+zL 9* :&y d9tp ,&<9JYC
?&zgq@ B"vC xyP xy Bzs (y :Qw< (<C d9s .&t"f HQ\} :d9s ?&"f dzT@
.| uG d(SQ Og< OI} xyP f9v 9| :Qw< (<C d9s ,~g! :d9s
~zT| {As )p &Af9_ >G* : GOk IC fC ($h 9"zs 9| O*|* GP%p :i(j=yG d9s
~wJ* :h uJ< :E Q|z* : &!} | uG d(SQ :E ,uI &!C ~zg* fC Og< :E
.dOg< :E
k
:A9%tqyG #| IOgy d9tp ,bGQgyG )zf 9+yGh f9v IQ+=$ #< Q}f fC )wIh
:~%]g< &y d9tp ?fhQ@ 9}p 96 {}fC Q(|C )p )yE >Aw* #+"||}yG Q+|C fE
u@G :d9s ?d(t@ 9| :iQZ=yG #TJzy d9tp cQ|C #| )zf ?g=AyGh Q(|z| B!C
#| xFQLzp ,GP$ cQ*QS #f xyR!zp c9@C Os xz}< x!zwp ,Q}f 9* uG
?f9_ : &!{p ,)Y9g}y9< u VQg@ fC c9*{p ,cQ=s u+\ )yE cQZs ?gS
. uy9MyG ?+Zg| )p b(zM}y
f(z}9 #*PyG ,hs(| {v )p f9azTyG O+=f )yE 9}%s(SC f:9D| fGP%p
O=f 9!C( :~%zF9s d(t+p 9%%Fh Q+i )zf ?f9ayG f(}%q*h ,?J+Z"yG >FGh
gQ+i )zf ht@ ?+g=AyG fC xyP< #d*h ,gOIh uG O=f &!C )T"*h !!)Q(|z}yG
xw o :d(t* )y9g@h cQ9=@ uGh ,fGhOgyGh ~C G )p x*QV ($ 9}"+<
)1(

)2(

]2

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

~ }| {z

Qw< )<C O"T| )p iRhQ}yGh )54( ~sQ O}IGh )109,108/7( )F9T"yG &FQLG K+JY )1(
.)68-66(
.)45/10(

?"TyG MQV i(j=yG )2(

349

? +fQW y

)1(

(|}G

I: h

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

"

? J Y9 |

])=vGQ}yG d9}F Q(AvOzy[

BzgFh e(wJ}yGh ~v9JyG #+< ?s;gyG ?g*QWyG B}d! r+v {=s #| 9"*CQ
#| &< Q(|z| ($ 9|h &+zf >FGh ($ 9}< ?+fQyG (J! ~v9JyG e9+s 9%S9SC
b(tI ?y9qvh ,dOgyG QGQsEh iQ(WyG H%"| eGRAyGh ,uG ?g*QW< ~wJyG
9%+zf >FGh ($ 9}< ?+fQyG e9+sh ,AGOAfG {v #| 9%A!9+Yh ,~79*QIh OGQp}G
G(@z* ~y 9| ~%+zf LhQMyG eOfh ~%+zf Q=ZyGh Q|}G )yhC ?f9_ eGRAyG #|
.uG #*O #| IQhQ]y9< e(zg}yG Q$9dyG MG(=yG Qqwy9<
f(<9D* #*OyG Q(|C #| Q|C ~%A+fQ d9+I ~79=FG(< Q(|}G I:h e9+sh
I:h (J! 9%=FG(< ?+fQyG e9+sh ,&"| A)V )p GhQZs ~$ fE f(=s9g*h ,&+zf
U(Z! JQQs )!9}* G uza"}yG GP$ #|h ,)y9g@ u ?f9ayG {+=s #| Q|}G
k
,#+|(wJ|h 9|9wI #+}zT}yG h+= )zf &A=FhCh ?JY9"}yG CO=| ?g*QWyG
k
9* #}y :9"zs -9C;C- ?J+Z"yG #*OyG :| uG d(SQ d9s iQGOyG ~+}@ #gp
#+}zT}yG ?}F}h ,&y(SQyh ,&<9Awyh ,{Fh Rf u :d9s ?&zyG d(SQ
. ~%A|9fh
#*OyG QGO| 9%+zf )AyG E*O9I}G #| E*OJyG GP$ A9}zgyG ^g< Of Osh
{}W@ ?J+Z"yG fC )zf dOp ,?J+Z"yG #*OyG fC | )="yG Q=LC Osh ,&zv
.f9TI Gh f9}* Gh e;S G d9ZL {}WAp ,&zv #*OyG
?}zv )%p ,&y M(Z"}zy Q+MyG IOGQE )$ ?z= #f 96 Q=g* ?}zv ?J+Z"yGh
k
. ;gph IOGQE Q+MyG g(F(< &y M(Z"}zy KY9"yG e9+s #}]A@ ?g|9F
)2 (

)3 (

QJ| dh}G OOgyG - O+I(AyG )1(


.~zT| &FQLG )2(
.Q("yG (<G iO}I:G u+tJA< )296( U ~wJyGh e(zgyG h|9F )3(
.v$1414 e

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

350

~7(fO g9: ?J+Z"yG >FG(< G(|9s Os {Fh Rf uG {SQ f{p GP%yh


.~%}|C g9:h
<;: 9 87 6 5 4 o :e;TyG &+zf M(! d9s
,

p!@
! {} *
)(

'&%

]62

?*6G :aGQn f}G[ p!@


!{w

>

o :e;TyG &+zf O($ d9sh


.

]68

?*6G

:aG

Qn f}G[

9gVE xyP )ph -?JY9"}yG- ?zf9q}yG ?j+Z< ?J+Z"yG ?}zv JOQh Osh
k
.9]*C Y(}G}yG #| OQp {wy uIh .Y(}G}yG g9: OQp {v )zf >FGh 98z<
k
k
)\Q* :9C;C ~wy bMT*h 9C;C ~wy )\Q* uG fEz | uG d(SQ d9s
k
k
,G(sQq@ :h 9g+= uG {=J< G(}ZAg@ fCh ,98+V &< G(vQW@ :h ghO=g@ fC ~wy
. E*OJyG y..~vQ|C uG )yh #| G(JY9"@ fCh
,u {}gyG U;LE :~zT| Q|G >zs #%+zf {j* : K;Cz d9sh
. y#+}zT}yG ?f9= ehRyh ,Q(|}G I:h ?JY9"|h
#| | uG d(SQ 9%zgF ,?+}$}G #| ?FQOyG gP6 ?J+Z"yG B!9v 9}yh
.9%+zf ?g+=yG ~A@ )AyG Q(|}G
A9A*Eh I;ZyG e9sE )zf | uG d(SQ Bg*9< :d9s uG O=f #< Q*QF #gp
.~zT| {wy KZ"yGh I9vRyG
{wy KZ"yGh BgaASG 9}+p )""tzp ,?f9ayGh h}TyG )zf :?*GhQ )ph
.
~zT|
Q

)1 (

)2(

)3 (

~zT| )1(
#f ihQh O+gS )<G #f #TI O9"S{< QGR=yG gGhQ y..GAkQ|G &zyG Q]!z &yhC E*OI #| ARF )2(
)3(.>+iQAyG K+JY hFGQ ?<9JZyG #| h=
&+zf uqA| )3(
.

351

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

x*QWyGh Oy(yG )q!h gO+I(@h &< f9}* G )$ {Fh Rf u ?J+Z"yGh


,d;GyGh d9}wyG J9qZ< gOGQpEh ,&< u+z* : [t! {v #f &9R"@h ,&"f
,&A}IQ )p h}ayGh ,&<GPf #| a(MyGh ,&+$G(! H9"AFGh gQ|GhC eGRAyGh
E*OJyG )p ihQ GP%yh ,IO9=gyG Y9= ($ GP$h .&+p ^j=yGh &+p >JyGh
. y)y KZ"yG iO=f &< )!O=g@ 9| >ICz )SOtyG
,b(zM| Q+i uG e;v &!z< f9}* G :)$ {Fh Rf uG H9Awy ?J+Z"yGh
.gOhOI ?|9sEh ,&}%p )p ?=iQyGh ,&@h;@ )zf {}gyGh
~+dgA< &}+dg@h &=JYh &yB ?=J|h &A=J|h &Af9a< | )="zy ?J+Z"yGh
.&*O$h &G8 Y9=@Gh &@Q+Sh &A"T< ?*9"gyGh &+8h gQ|C
h}AG}yG QGQtASG d(YC #| ~%A|9fh #+}zT}yG ?}F} ?J+Z"yGh
~v9JyG )zf >FGh )$h ,{Fh Rf uG Q|C )zf &|9+sh ,~zT}yG
.e(wJ}yGh
,&}wI )p {Fh Rf uG YQV eGRAy9< f(w@ &A+fQy ~v9JyG ?JY9"}p
k
b(tI ?*9}Ih ,;}f IQh9W}yG H%"| eGRAyGh ,~zdyG h"|h ,dOgyG QGQsEh
,~%+zf ?*:(zy {$C ($ #| ?+y(@h ,~$Q(|C {v )p ~6 upQyGh ,?+fQyG
.~%tJ< e9+tzy KzY}Gh
~y :E ?J+Z"< 9%aJ* ~y ~C ?+fQ uG &+fQAT* O=f #| 9|z K+JZyG )ph
.y?"GyG {LO*
uG eQI :E ~%y T9i ($h J(}* #+}zT}yG #| ?+fQ )z* dmGh #| 9|z
.y?"GyG &+zf
cQOAT}yG )ph ,i(tAyGh M;ZyG {$C #| Q+MyG ?!9a< A9tA!9< xyPvh
)1 (

#< )zf #f QIR #< &zyG O+=f &+p )87/1( )}D+%yG d9s )254/5( O}IG r+g\ gO9"SG
.r+g\ 9}$;vh O*R*

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

352

KzYC ($ #| OG* ($h ;FQ )y(p 98k +V #+}zT}yG Q|C #| )yh #|z
.y#+"||}yGh &y(SQh uG f9L Otp &"| #+}zT}zy
:>@GQ| )zf )%p Q(|}G I:(y ?+fQyG ?JY9"| 9|C
k
GQk I GQ9+ALG ~%}v9I f(}zT}yG Q9AM* fC 9$GO||h :Q9+AL:G O"f ?JY9"|
k
.iQ(WyG e9wI} 9tph
.yahQg}yG )p ?f9ayG 9}!Ez IOf9s 9%}w; :?f9_ ?JY9"|
#f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G )p 9%=FG(< ?|}G 9%+p e(t@ :O9VQE ?JY9"|
:J9FQO )zf 9%+p S9"yG ?=@Q}yG gP$h ?+fQWyG b<G(]y9< Qw"}yG
,#+<Qt}yGh #*Q9WAT}yGh AGQR(yG #| ~v9Jy9< b+; )AyG ?!9a=yG c9"%p
uG d(SQ ~%+p d(t* A:|$h ,&+zf Q+CzAyGh &JZ! )zf S9"yG QOsC ~$h
?!9a< ,f9A!9a< &y B!9v :E ?q+zL #| rzMASG :h )=! #| uG Eg< 9|z :|
e(Zg}yGh ,&+zf &];h QWy9< gQ|z@ ?!9a<h ,&+zf &];h ahQg}y9< gQ|z@
. y)y9g@ uG ~Zf #|
~$Q9+ALG )p A9SC fEh ,&y G(JZ! ~$Q9+ALG )p ~v9JyG KZ! fE A:|%p
k
.uG &}Zf #| up(}yGh ,&+zf &A+fQ bMSh &+zf uG bMS )p 9==S G(!9v
Q|}Gh f9+=yGh I(fOyG ?!9|C )y9g@ uG ~%z}v I #*PyG A9}zgyG c9"$h
?}FC ~$ A:|$h ,xyP< O%gyG ~%+zf PLCh ,Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9<
b<G(]zy 9tk ph &JZ!h ~v9JyG efh )zf ~$QOsCh ,M;Y G )p S9"yG
.~%y h=@ S9"yG 9}!Eh ,?+fQWyG
AGO%WyG O+Sz yQF9F f9azS O"f uI ?}zv O9%GyG {]pCz E*OJyG )ph
. y&zAtp g98h gQ|zp QF9F f9azS )yE e9s {FQh ,IR}I
)1 (

)2 (

.iQ
.)491(

9M=yG )1(

?J+JZyG Qd!Gh ?<9JZyG #| h= #f OQh )2(

353

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

: )p GhCQ fEh ,?+|;S G ?yhOyG )p OtgyGh {JyG {$C ~$ A:|$h


k
k
,~$(!h9fh ~$hOf9S GOGOS ~%+p GhCQ fEh ,KZ"y9< g(|(s 9F9F(fG Q(|}G
GQk qv GhCQ fEh ,ahQg}yG )p ~%Af9_h ~%A!h9g|h ~7QZ"< S9"yG GhQ|Ch
k
.e;S Gh f9}* G IQ+dI )yE ?|}G GhO9sh ,Q++jAyG I9fO G(!9v GQk $9c 9IG(<
K*QGAyGh ?!9$ Gh Q++gAyG )"g@ : ~zT}yG h}AG}yG )p ?J+Z"yGh
h| d(=t| H(C )p f(w@ fC )yh}9p GP%yh ,M;Y G )"g@ 9}!Eh ,Q+%WAyGh
g(dfh OIC ?J+Z! GhOGQC GPE Ky9ZyG 9"qzS f9v GPw$h ,M(Z"}yG QAS
.GQk S
fE :d9tp Qw"}yG #f &+8h ahQg}y9< f9azTyG Q|C #f S9=f #<G {8S
k
. &"+<h x"+< 9}+qp ;f9p B"v
: )!C fhQ@C :d9tp ?&}zwAp f9}Df )zf {LO@ :C :O*R #< ?|9S} {+sh
: GQk |C KApC fC fhO 9| ,&"+<h )"+< 9}+p &A}zv Oty uGh ?~wg}SC :E &}zvC
. &JAp #| dhC f(vC fC >IC
u+p(Ay9< A9fOh ?=J|h ?f9_ ?JY9"| ~%AJY9"|h S9"yG ?|9f c9"$h
.OGOTyGh
f9azTy 97(fOy ?<9GAT| I(fO )y f9v (y :rzTyG ^g< d(t* xyP )ph
.Q+My9< #+}zT}yG h+= >+Z@ 98{p ,#+}zT}yG
G("zg* fC :h Q(|}G I:h )zf G(FQM* fC S9"yG ?|9gy R(G* :h
: ,A9}zgyG #| OtgyGh {JyG {$} h=@ 9"zs 9}v ~$ 9}!Eh AkGOA<G f9+ZgyG
.#AqyG Bf9Vh )\(qyG B}f :Eh ,{gq< :h d(t< ~8(t=T*
I h

)1 (

)2 (

. 304U

~wJyGh e(zgyG h|9F


.~zT|

)1(
)2(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

354

| ~%}+zg@h ,~%Jy9Z| )yE ~$O9VQ{< f(w* #+}zT}yG ?|9gy KZ"yGh


?tqWyGh ~%y Q+MyG >Ih ,uJyG )p ~7QZ!h ,~7GQ(f QASh ,~%"*O
.NyG Q+=wyG Q+s(@h Q+jZyG ?}IQh ,~%y OTJyGh XjyG ?=!9G|h ,~%+zf
U}* ~y #|h ,~%"| U+zp #+}zT}yG Q|z< ~A9 ~y #|z E*OJyG )ph
k
. y~%"| U+zp #+}zT}yG ?|9gyh &<9Awyh &y(SQyh u 9JY9! K=Z*h
KZ"yGh Q+MyG >Ih i(tAyGh Q=yG )zf fh9gAyG H9G*E )p {YC GP$h
k
e9d"yG #+< 9J\Gh bQ9qyG iQ* ~|}G hsGh )yE Qd"* #|h ,S9"yG h+}Gy
b9q"yGh A9*QyG )p ~7Q=M< 9%+p ?S9TyG )$9=A* )AyG ~d"yG #| gQ+ih )|;S G
>+y9S}G {w<h KF9]qy9< e9gyG iCQyG )zf Q+CzAyGh Q+$9}GyG YGOLh
IQ(%W| )S9+TyGh ?S9+Tzy ~79q*Qg@ JQ9Y )AI ?fhQW}yG Q+ih ?fhQW}yG
: ?JY9"}yG ?S9+S ,~zT}yG h}AG}yG )p ?S9+TyG )$ gP$ #wyh ?yhGOA|
.YGOMyGh HPwyG ?S9+S
Q( C

)1(

Qd!Gh GOk F ?q+g\ 9%"wy IQ+Dv O$G(V &yh Q+jZyGh bSh}G )p )!GQ=ayG :?q+g]yG )1(
.)312-309( ?q+g]yG

355

? +fQW y

e ;S G

)p

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~wJyG

])=vGQ}yG d9}F Q(AvOyG[

#*OyG )zf e(t@ )AyG xz@ .?+|;S G ?yhOyG #f ?zTzTyG gP$ )p 9"}zw@
k
9"+<h ,GOk9%Fh GOk9VQEh I(fOh ,9}k wIh GP+q"@h 9tk +=a@ ~@9MyG )|;S G
USC 9!QvP ~C ,?*Otf ?+fQV ?+"*O ?yhO 98(vh .?yhOyG gP$ [F9ZL
?+!9<QyG ?+fQWyG )zf ~F9tyG )|;S G ~wJyG ($h ,9%+p ~wJyG ~F9fOh
OGQp}G b(tI {qw@h ,IGh9T}yGh dOgyG
O9=| )SQ@ )AyG ,IOy9MyG
o 9%zv I9+JyG )ph ~wJyG )p iQ(WyG CO=| )SQ@h ~79*QIh

lk
xwvu@
! ! x| t s r q p o n m
' &% $ # " !@
!x} ! ~ } | { z y

9%|G(s ?"+A| USC )zf e(wJ}yGh ~v9JyG #+< ?s;gyG ~+t@ )AyGh p!@
! x~
,Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}Gh ,?JY9"}yGh ,ahQg}yG )p ?f9ayG
fhQ|z*h Q+MyG )yE f(fO* ,S9"zy BFQLC ?|C Q+L RQq@ )AyG ?s;gyG )$h
&<9Awyh u ?J+Z"yG ~%"*O ,u9< f("||*h Qw"}yG #f f(%"*h ahQg}y9<
.~%A|9fh #+}zT}yG ?}F}h &y(SQyh
QW=yG aQg* : )AyG IQY9g}yG ?}d!}9< e9d"yG GP$ ?!Q9t}y 9"\Qg@ Osh
?*Q(@9AvOyGh ?+_GQt}*OyG UFQ e9d"yG GP$ #f 9"a|Ch ,f9|RyG GP$ )p 9$Q+i
)AyG Ih9WjyG gP$ 9""+fC #f dhR@ )AI ,?%yzA}yG ?+_GQs(+DyGh IO=AT}yG
~
}| {z y xw o #+%F9@ J9}zdyG )p 9"vQA@h ,gA9+\ 9"f >G;
.

]40

"!

?*6G :Q("wyG[ p

)="yG #|R )p #+}zT}yG ~wI iPyG ($ &"f KOJA! iPyG e9d"yG GP$
&+zf ^gy9< :E 9"y I9G! :h ,#+*O%}yG #*OVGQyG &F9qzL #|Rh ,|
k
)A"T< ~w+zgp ,GQk +Dv 9p;ALG iQ+Tp iOg< ~w"| Xg* #| &!Ez PFG("y9<
~v9*Eh ,PFG("y9< 9%+zf G(]f ,iOg< #| #+*O%}yG #*OVGQyG A9qzMyG ?"Sh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

356

?fO< ?COJ| {v f{p Q(|}G J9COJ|h


Os ~*QwyG fBQtyG f9v GPEh ?|}G ?|9|E )p I(="yG ?p;L ($ e9d"yG GP$
~SG b;_E {gzp ,uG Q|z< fhO9 ?}FC ~8z< #+tA}yG IGO%yGh A9+=!}G rYh
e9d! e9d"yG GP$ fC )yE IQ9V G #}]A* )|;S G ~wJyG e9d! )zf ?|9| G
.O9VQh ?*GO$
OF9tyG e9|5y ?|}G )zf >FG(yG Y9=@:Gh AGOAs:G )"g* ?|9| G eqy fE
I(fOyG e9|Eh H+GJyG e9|Eh I;ZyG e9|E (%p ,Q(|}G e9|R< xT}* iPyG
.O9%GyG e9|Eh
IO9+s )p | uG d(SQ {J| -?q+zMyG- e9| G d(zI )"g* ?p;MyG eqyh
#| ($ iPyG )I(yG )tz@ GOf 9| &|9%| {v )p | )="yG e9t| e(t* &!E ,?|}G
.I(="yG [F9ZL
)yE )fQWyG M;aY:G )p f9+|Q* 9}8E ,?t+Ch ?zY #+dqzyG #+< fE
:($ OIGh )"g|
k
,| uG d(SQ< AkGOAsGh 9+Sz@ )y9g@ uG YQW< ?+|;S G ?|}G IO9+s
.9+!OyG ?S9+Sh #*OyG ?SGQI )p I(="yG ?p;L :QLB )"g}< hC ,&"f ?p;Lh
#| gQ+i #f e9d"yG GP$ R+}@ ?|9$ Q(|C c9"$ fC r*QgAyG GP$ #| K\Ghh
:Q(|}G gP$ #| ,?}d!}G
?*:h )%p ?p;MyG IOIh )yE IQ9VE e(}gyG GP$ )ph ,?*:(yG e(}f -1
.e;S G Q9*O )p ~$Q+ih ,#+}zT}yG )zf ?|9f
?S9+Sh -#*OyG ?SGQI- #*OyG eqI ?p;MyG ?*9jp ,?*9jyG e(}f -2
.&< 9+!OyG
)1 (

.&

F9| #<Gh iP|QAyGh OhGO (<C

)1(

357

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)="yG- YQWyG >I9Y e9t| )p e9+tyG -3


.I(=! ?p;L &!} ,YQWyG
f9w|h f9|R {wy Ky9ZyG )|;S G YQWyG e9wIC u+=a@h P+q"@ -4
n o
n
,&< ~wJ*h uG YQW< ~wJ* e9d! (%p ,f9w|h f9|R {v O9Tp KzZ* iPyGh
.d9J< &"f LhQMyG R(G* :h
?g*QWyG f(w@ )AyG ?+fQWyG ?+|;S G ?|(wJyG )$ ?p;My9p GP$ )zfh
)zf #+}zT}yG {v 989azTy h]M* )AyGh ,9%"+!G(sh 9$Q(ASO ?+|;S G
.Q+=wyG )|;S G ~+zs G
9%pQf )AyG I(="yG ?p;L ,IOVGQyG ?p;MyG )$ 9%+"g! )AyG ?p;MyGh
k
k
9wz| ~C ,9\k (]f 9wz| JQ9Zp 9%+zf G(=zt!G ~C ,IQ+Zs IQAqy f(}zT}yG
k
d(SQ Ofh 9}v ,I(="yG ?p;L &+p O(g@ rzMA* #y Ofh )zf #J!h ,9*Q=F
fC A9V GPE uG 9%gpQ* ~C f(w@ fC uG A9V 9| ~w+p I(="yG f(w@z :| uG
~C ,f(w@ fC uG A9V 9| f(wAp I(="yG L9%"| )zf ?p;L f(w@ ~C ,9%gpQ*
k
k
fC uG A9V 9| f(w+p 9\9f 9wz| f(w@ ~C ,9%gpQ* fC A9V GPE uG 9%gpQ*
k
k
A9V 9| f(wAp 9*Q=F 9wz| f(w@ ~C ,9%gpQ* fC A9V GPE uG 9%gpQ* ~C ,f(w*
L9%"| )zf ?p;L f(w@ ~C 9%gpQ* fC A9V GPE uG 9%gpQ* ~C ,f(w@ fC uG
)1(
. yI(="yG
,#+}zT}yG I9+I #| e;S G >+j* fC IOVGQyG ?p;MyG H9+j< )"g! :h
{< ,OIC &< d(t* : 9| GP%p #+}zT}yG ~wI )p &A}%| #f )zMA* fC hC
,iQ=GyG xz}yG h| hC ,V(]gyG xz}yG h| {|9gA! r+v e;S G 9"}zf
E*O9IC B!9v 9"$ #|h ,#+}zT}yG hsGh #f e;S G H9+j< K}T@ : IQ(Z<
B!9vh ,#$hh rg\ #| ?|}G >+Z* 9}< | )="yG 9%+p z="@ )AyGh ,#AqyG
G

P6 ?|}G IO9+s )p

? +fQW y

-|

.)!

9=y~y )5( ~sQ ?J+JZyG Qd!G )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

358

~y9dyG ~zc )zf Q=ZyGh ,?+Zg| Q+i )p ?f9ayGh ,?JY9"}yG E*O9IC


H9< KAq* iPyG LhQMyG eOfh ,&+zf IQa+TyGh ,~y9dyG GP$ ~+GJAy ?z+S(v
&W+g* iPyG hsG(yG h| {|9gAyG )p {Y}G )$- MG(=yG QqwyG Q%d* ~y 9| ?"AqyG
.IOVGQyG ?p;MyG B<9i P"| f(}zT}yG
(%p 9$Og< #+}zT}yG ~wJ* e9d! {wp ,IOVGQyG ?p;MyG B<9i GPEh
#+I f(}zT}yG 9%z=t* ,?Zs9! ?p;L xz}yG ?p;L B!9v GP%yh ,[s9!
[t!h )fGQyG )p [t"y f(w* GP$h ,IOVGQyG ?p;MyG u+t; #f fhRGg*
k
.~w+zf )y(* f(!(w@ 9}v &!{p .9]*C ?+fQyG )p
Q+i )p AGQ|}G ?f9_ #| | )="yG &< Q|C Os 9| QQt@h V9qASG Osh
)p ~%Ag<9A| #| xyP (J!h ~$Q(F )zf Q=ZyGh ,~%AJY9"|h ,?+Zg|
9|h ,i(tAyGh Q=yG )zf fh9gAyG H9< #| &!{p ~$Q+i 96 e(t* : )AyG J9"TJyG
?+Zg| )p ~%Af9_h ,~%}zc )zf ~%A!9fEh ~6Pw< ~%t*OZ@ #| &"f )8
{+=S ($ GP$h fGhOgyGh ~C G )zf fh9gAyG H9< #| ($ 9}| xyP (J!h uG
)AI ,&z+}wAy :{s hC ,gQ++jAy f(}zT}yG )gT* [s9! e9d! h| X*9gAyG
.uJyGh dOgyG L9%"| )zf ~+tAT!h ,969Z! )p Q(|}G h]!
: ?q+zMyG fE :&y G(y9tp ??q+zL eC 9!C xz|C :H9aMyG #< Q}f dzS
9}k $QO #+}zT}yG VQC #| JPLC f{p ,uI )p :E &g]* :h ,9tk I :E PLz*
.?q+zL Q+i xz| B!zp ,&tI Q+i )p &Ag\h ~C ,QDvC hC {sC hC
{+=TyG

A G (S

f;wAyG

&+zfh

) yE

iO%* uGh

f9gAT}yG uGh

359

? +fQW y

&@9=FGhh

~zT}yG ~v9JyG

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

(tI

>FGh &z<9t* YhQW| uI {wp ,IOIGh ?z}gy f9%Fh >FG(yGh uJyG


aQ_ )zf J9=FGh 9%"| Q+DwyG )p #}]A@ &+$G(!h #*OyG Q|GhCh ,gDGOC #+gA*
?s;f )p 9Jk \Gh gGQ! 9| GP$h .QLB aQay b(tI 9%+_ )p aGQ_}G #|
eqI B; 9gk += LQO"@ ~v9JyG )zf b(tI ?|~zp ,?|}9< ~zT}yG ~v9JyG
&Af9_ H(Fh )p {D}A@ ?|}G )zf b(tI ~v9Jzyh ,&< 9+!OyG ?S9+Sh #*OyG
.&Ay9qvh &@QY9"|h &AJY9"|h
:~zT}yG

~wJyG

~v9JyG

b(tI ::hC

9=| #| CO=| Q|}G )yhC ?f9_ fC -{=s #|- 9"+< :?f9ayG -1


] \ [ Z Y X W Vo :&TSC #| S9SCh ,)|;S
O

]59

x
?*6G :A9T"yG[

p_

#| uIh y&< ~@|+y e9| G {gF 9}!Ez :&A|9|E #| YQp ~v9JyG ?f9_h
&zjW* iPyG iO9+tyG h\(yG xyP 9%\Qp ,?"TyG K+JYh fBQtyG ["< &s(tI
B\Qg@ :Eh ,)y9g@ uG YQW< 9%S(T* OF9s #| 9%y O< : :?|}9p ,~v9JyG
.Y9+]yGh b=MAzy
u*Qay9< ?azTyG )yE {Yh Os ~v9JyG f(w* fC ?f9ayG )p WQAW* :h
{}Aw| Q+ih >zjA}yG ?f9ap ,?<(za}yG WhQWyG {}wAT* fC :h ,YhQW}yG
?}F}G xyP )zf [! 9}v ,?=FGh QF9GyG e9| G ?f9_h ,?=FGh WhQWyG
f(w@ ?f9ayGh ,97O9+S ?g*QWzyh ,97OIh ?|~y eq; )AI xyPh ,A9%tqyGh
>: iPyG ahQg}yGh ,uy9MyG ?+Zg| )p b(zM}y ?f9_ ;p ,ahQg}yG )p
)zf QZAt@ : ?gSGh IQFGO )$h ,&qy9M* ~yh YQWyG upGh 9| :($ ?f9ayG &+p
)zf )"="@ )AyG Q(|}G {}WAy OA}@ {< ,?+fQWyG Q|Gh}G P+q"@ OQG|
,&+p ?gq"}yG &Fh iQO* : Q|z< ~v9JyG Q|C (zp :GP$ )zfh ,O9%AF:G
)p &f9=@G f} ,?+Zg| &!(v G(}zg* ~y 9| ,&Af9_ :?+fQyG )zf >FG(y9p

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

360

\9ty9v >FGh O9%AF:G {J|


dO@ )AyG ?+Zg}yG :)$ ?f9ayG #f ~zT}yG 9%+p h"A}* )AyG ?+Zg}yGh
,{*hzAyGh O9%AF G b9a! )p {LO* 9| 9|C ,9%}*Q; )zf YQWyG U(Z!
~zT}yG AQ}yG )zfz :9%$Qv fEh ~v9JyG ?f9_ 9%+p ~zT}yG )zf >G+p
y?f9_ :h h}S ;p ?+Zg}< Q||* ~y 9| gQv hC >IC 9}+p ?f9ayGh h}TyG
.hFGQ+zp u<9S h\(| )p {F9T}yG gP$ 9"zZp fC u=S Osh GP$ ,&+zf uqA|
eRG(y #| eR: ($ {< ,)9O< uJyG GP$h :O+*zAyGh IQZ"yGh ?!h9g}yG -2
u+t; )p &g| fh9gAyG ~%+zf )j="+p ,9|k 9|E f(}zT}yG )]@QG 9}y9ap ,?f9ayG
,O+*zAyGh ?!h9g}yG Q(Y #| IQ(Y ?f9ayGh ,YQWyG J9=FGhh ?|9| G OY9t|
.?f9ayG eRG(y #| O+*zAyGh IQZ"yGh ?!h9g}yG fC 9}v
?!h9g| eOfh ,e9| G )zf LhQMyG eOf :O+*zAyGh IQZ"yG Q$9d| #|h
#+<Q9J}yG hC I9j=yG :#| G(!9v AG(S ~%+zf J(wTyG eOfh ,&+zf #+FQ9MyG
D C
B A @ ? > = <o :)y9g@ uG d(ty
.)

]9

?*6G :JGQn GJo yG[ p

O NML
KJ
I HGF
E

h*9< #|z :d(t+p e9| G )zf #+FQ9MyG &Fh )p e9+tyG >F(* | )="yGh
&fR9"* QLB A9F f{p ,Y9aASG 9| &ga+zp gOG|p IQ}Ch gO* ?tqY g9afzp 9|k 9|E
.yQL6G u"f G(<Q\9p
bQq* hC ~v9Zf uW* fC O*Q* OIGh {FQ )zf h+= ~vQ|Ch ~v9@C #|z
.~zT| 9}$GhQ yg(zAs9p ~wAf9=
~%}v9Ih ~%|9| Q*OtAyGh ?=J}yG dP< #+}zT}yG )zf )j="* xyPvh
x
(%p &=Sh &A!9$E #| f(FQJA*h ,M;ZyGh Q+MyG &+p 9| )yE ~$O(t* iPyG
#| &tI )p(* fC >G+p -| uG d(SQ- ~%+yE uzMyG >IC e9t| ~%+p e(t*
,OGOTyGh u+p(AyGh ?*GO%y9< &y A9fOyG :xyP eRG(y #|h ,Q*OtAyGh ?=J}yG

361

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

O$ f9v GP$ )zfh ,#+}zT}yG h+= hq"yG ~g+p ,~%y >+GAT* fC uG )Tf
.AGQ|}G h| Ky9ZyG rzTyG
f} ,e9|5y 9%AzgGy ?<9GAT| I(fO )y B!9v (y :V9+f #< {+]qyG d9s
.O;=yGh O9=gyG B"|C KzY GP{p ,?+fQyG M;Y &<
?+fQyG )zf >FGhh ,?+fQyG g9: e9| G )zf >FGh )$h :?J+Z"yG -3
k
&=J* 9}| )$h -?JY9"}yG- ?zf9q}yG ?j+Z< 9!9+IC 9%"f Q=g* GPy ,e9| G g9:
k
,9C;C ~wy )\Q* uG fEz :| )="yG d9s GPy ,#+}zT}yG ?f9}Gy g9\Q*h uG
k
k
G(}ZAg@ fCh ,98+V &< G(vQW@ :h ghO=g@ fC :~wy )\Q* :9C;C ~wy gQw*h
~wy gQw*h ,~vQ|C uG g:h #| G(JY9"@ fCh ,G(sQq@ :h 9gk += uG {=J<
9"zZp fC u=S Osh ,~zT| gGhQ yd9}yG ?f9\Eh ,dG|TyG IQDvh ,d9sh {+s
.hFGQ+zp {tAT| d9t| )p ?yzT}yG gP$
:?yhOyG ?"*RL #| )y9| >@GQ O*O; -4
{}g* &!} xyPh ,#+}zT}yG d9| B+< #| &+qw* 9| ^=s )p uJyG e9|5y
J9=FG(yG AGO}h ,#+}zT}yG ?|OMy ZQqA* Q+FC (%p ,#+}zT}zy aQAJ*h
Q+d! &AF9I OT* 9| &y GhQp(* fC #+}zT}yG )zf >F(p ,&t@9f )zf I9tz}yG
.{}gyG GP%y &iQq@
k
:~%z}f Q+d! 9%"| 9}%S J9sOZyG )zf #+z|9gzy )y9g@ uG {gF Osh
,?*6G
?*6 ?<(Ay p| {
z
y x wo
QF9S )zf 9}!Eh ,9$OIh J9sOZyG )zf U+y ,#+z|9gyG A:|$ OIC ~v9JyGh
>@GQ &y OOJ* fC :?yhOyG )zf &tI #| Q9Zp ,?+|;S G ?yhOyG )p J9*:(yG
.&+yE ?y(v(}yG e9%}zy ZQqA+y ,&z$Ch &+qw*
xz}* &+p ~v9JyG f9v Bsh )p ?t+tJyG gP$ )yE {FGh}G f(}zT}yG #ap Osh
.~%+zf &< O(G* 9}< ?+fQyG h"t@ 9}"+< ,VQ}G Y9t< )AV )p O9=gyGh O;=yG
i

]60

G :

n q

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

362

Ty )yE 9*k O9i K=YC Qw< (<C rzMASG 9}y :d9s >F9TyG #< A9af #f
MGQGyG #< IO+=f (<Ch H9aMyG #< Q}f &+tzp ,96 QGA* HG(CC &A=sQ )zfh
!?&zyG d(SQ ?q+zL 9* O*Q@ #*C :&y :9tp
b(TyG :d9s
!?#+}zT}yG Q|C B+yh Osh ,GP9| h"Z@ ::9s
?)y9+f ~g_C #*C #}p :d9s
k
.&y G(\Qqp ,~%g| uza!9p ,98+V xy VQq! )AI uza!G ::9s
~y )ApQI fC )|(s ~zf Os :d9s Qw< (<C )yh 9}y :By9s ?WF9f #fh
aQAIzSh ,#+}zT}yG Q|z< BzjV Osh ,)z$C ?!(8| #f RGgAy #w@
.iQ9M=yG gGhQ .d9}yG GP$ #| Qw< )<C dB {vz+Sh ,~%y9| )p #+}zT}zy
k
&+zf QtASG iPyG GP$h ,f(!9s &}d"+p 9qzS OOJ* fC :9|E >@GQyG GP$h
{JyG {$C #| O9%AF;y h]M* fC :9|Eh ,9gk += IQY9g}yG dhOyG )p Q|}G
.f(!9tyG GP$ {D| #S {=s f(w* GP$h ,~v9JyG &tJAT* 9| O*OJAy OtgyGh
#| d9I iz< QLB u*Q_ #| K<QA* fC hC ,{}g* fC ~v9Jzy R(G* :h
k
.#+}zT}yG d9| B+=y (%p ,?*O%yG u*Qa< (yh 98+V >TAvG fEh ,dG(I}G
:| uG d(SQ H9JYC d9s Qw< (<C )yh 9}y :d9s d;$ #< O+}I #f
.&+"j* 9| uG d(SQ ?q+zMy G(\QpC
- Qp9S GPE gQ%ch ,9}%zD| PLCh 9}%g\h 9}%tzLC GPE gGOQ< ,~g! :G(y9s
,rzMAT* fC {=s uq"* f9v 9}v &z$C )zf &Atq!h -J;YG(}yG ?z+Sh )"g*
.B+\Q :Qw< (<C d9s
k
;|9f 9"y f9v #|z :d9s | uG d(SQ #f OGOV #< OQ(AT}yG #fh
&y #w* ~y f{p ,9|k O9L >TAw+zp 9|k O9L &y #w* ~y f{p ,?FhR >TAw+zp
b( G

363

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9S hC d9i (%p xyP Q+i P<G #}p ,9"k wT| >TAw+zp #wT|
H9TAvG &y M9<C 9}!E :9}$OIC :#+%Fh )zf dhzA* GP$ :)<9aMyG d9s
A)W< uq@Q* fC &y U+yh ,&zD| QFC )$ )AyG &Ay9}f #| #wT}yGh eO9MyG
.9$G(S
#wT| &y #w* ~y f{p ,?|OMyGh )"wTyG {|9gzy fC :QL6G &F(yGh
&y -QFzAT*- iQAw*h ,&zD| ?"%| &+qw+p &|OM* #| &y QF|ASG ,eO9Lh
.&z}f )p &|9t| IO| &"wT* #wT|
k
IO| A9%A!G ?y9I )p gOQAT@ ?yhOzy 9wz| #wT}yG f(w* ?y9JyG gP$ )ph
.?*:(yG
fE eO9tyG EJ=}yG )qp &@9=FGh #f :9|C ,~zT}yG ~v9JyG b(tI #f GP$
.uG A9V
.ybQ

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

364
~zT}yG ~v9JyG

J9=FGh

])=vGQ}yG d9}F Q(AvOyG[

)zf >Z"}yG A9=fz< e9+tyG )p {D}A* ~zT}yG ~v9JyG )zf Q=v}G >FG(yG
eqJ< e9+tzy ?z+Sh :E )$ 9| ?+|;S G ?yhOyG )p Q|}G ?*:hh ,&Fh {}vC
.{LGO@ #| #*Q|}G #+< 9| {qj! fC #w}* :h &< 9+!OyG ?S9+Sh #*OyG
:~zT}yG ~v9Jzy ?+"*OyG J9=FG(yG
:h #*OyG GP$ #f )zMA@ : e;S G #*O )zf ?}F9tyG ?+|;S G ?yhOyGh
)zf S9"yG EIh ,&+yE I(fOyGh ,gQW! )zf e(t@ )%p GP%yh ,&"| {Z"A@
#*OyG ?SGQIh ,J9=FG(yG >FhC #| GP$ Q=Ag@h ,gQF9gVh &gFGQW< eGRAy:G
:?|9$ IO*Of Q(|z< :E ~A* : &dqIh
:&}+zg@h ~zgyG k+z=@ -1
{F9Sh eqJyG GP%y {gFh ,#*OyG GP$ eqJ< )y9g@ uG {qw@ Oty
)p #*hO@h ,QhOZyG )p eqI #| ,f("||}yG gO9=f 96 e(t* ,IO*Of
)p &g= :~*QwyG fBQtyG eqI {F9Sh #| f9v xyPy ,~zgzy ~+zg@h ,>AwyG
)p e9| G rJZ}yG )zf S9"yG h=h ,Qw< )<C O%f )p OIGh rJZ|
)p #+COJ}yGh A9}zgyG O9%AFG :?"TyG eqI {F9Sh #| f9vh ,f9}Df ?p;L
.AGRF}Gh h|G(GyGh O+!9T}yG )p 9%"*hO@h ,Q9=L}G eqI
k+z=@h #*OyG U(Z! eqI ?+z}f QV9=* fC Q|}G )yh )zf )j="*h
,J9AWzy VQgA@ : )AI ,fzWyG GP$ )p ?yhP=}yG O(%GyG OI(+y ,~zgyG
,fBQtyG h}G< #*Q("yG hP gOg< #|h u*OZyG ~t* ~y (y d9JyG Q(ZA@ fC xyh
)zf {wWyGh W9t"yG h\(< ~*QwyG fBQtzy ?|OL #| ~$Og< #| &< e9s 9|h
)yE >Aw* R*RgyG O=f #< Q}f f9v Otyh ,&dqIh &@h;@ Q+T+Ay ahQJyG
:h ,9%g=h ?"TyG #*hOA< Q|C iPyG ($h ,&tqyGh #"TyG S9"yG ~zg* Q9Z|}G

365

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

O$9g}yGh SQGO}yG A9W!E &+zf >G* {< ,OJyG GP$ O"f ~v9JyG QhO rs(A*
{qw* fC &+zf >G*h ,A9}zgyG OGOfEh ,~zgyG QW! )zf e(t@ )AyG ,?+}zgyG
~%+Aq* #| S9"zy ~+t* fC &+zf >G*h ,fzWyG GP%y ~%iQq@ f9}]y ,~%sGRQC
.A9%tqyGh A9}zgyG #| #*OyG Q(|C )p
?|9sEh ,9%z$Ch YO=yG P="y ?|}G A9}zf #| &y9FQ< iOZA* fC &+zf >G*h
)zf #*OyG eqJ* )AI ,#*O!9g}yG k*Rh ,#+wwW}yG &=V OQh ,#"TyG
.IQtAT}yG &y(YC
OhOI {LGO #*OyG eqIh ~zgyG QW! )zf ~v9JyG QhO QZAt* :h
#*OyG VQgy J9+y9SQ G {SQ*h K(g=yG Eg=* fC &+zf )j="* {< ,?yhOyG
.~%+zf ?GJyG ?|9sEh S9"yG )zf
:#*OyG QF9gV )zf e9+tyG -2
,9%}+dg@h ,#*OyG QF9gV )zf e9+tyG :~zT}yG ~v9JyG J9=FGh ~$C #|
{+=S ~%y QT+*h ,QF9gWyG gP$ ?|9s #+}zT}yG (fO+p ,9%A*9}I )zf Q%TyG
9$OJG* hC 9%"| A)V AGOC )p {}9 #| >s9g*h ,{}v}G &F(yG )zf 9%FGOC
.9$Qw"*h
)AyG I;Zzy #+}+t| G(|GO 9| e9wJyG )zf LhQMyG #f | )="yG )8 Osh
Otp ,b(tJyG ^g=y #+g+]|h #+_Qq| G(!9v fEh ,QF9gWyG gP$ ~$C #| )$
f(wASz :d9s | uG d(SQ fC ?}zS eC #f :&J+JY )p ~zT| LQLC
#| #wyh ,~zS Otp Qw!C #|h , Q< Otp gQv #}p ,fhQw"@h f(pQgAp AGQ|C
.?~%z@9t! :C uG d(SQ 9* :G(y9s .yh<9@h )\Q
;pC G(y9s :)gGV}G xy9| #< a(f E*OI )ph .yG(zY9| :z :d9s
.yI;ZyG ~w+p G(|9sC 9| :z :d9tp ?r+Ty9< ~$P<9"!
O+q@ 9%A|9s{p ,9%A*Oz@ OQG| #| ~fCh {}VC I;ZyG ?|9sE fC xV :h

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

366

9 O$9g@h 9%}+zgA< Q|}G O+q@h ,9%""Sh 989vQz< {}v}G &F(yG )zf 9$AGOC
.~zgyG {$C &"+< iPyG &F(yG )zf 9%vQ9@ Q*Rg@h ,?}F}Gh OF9T}yG ?*9fQh
)yh e(t+p ,eGQJyG uG B+< )yE HJyG #fh I9vRyG #f d9t* GP$ {D|h
&+!h9g| u*Q_ #f 9%+tJAT| )yE 9%gpOh ,A9+"i}G #| I9vRyG {+ZJA< Q|}G
Q*RgAyG gQRg*h 9%g"}* #}| GQk %s 9$PLz*h ,9%+zf #+z|9gyG hC #+sOZ}yG #|
.
u*OZyG {gp 9}v ,9%g"| )zf ?g}AG}yG ?qF9ayG {@9t*h {< ,>S9"}yG
{=S Q+T+@h ,H+GJyG d9=tAS: &A8+7h eGQJyG Oz=yG ?*9fQ< ~v9JyG e(t*h
.u*QayG #|z< ?*9"gyGh J;YG(}yG
#+g*o h ,?GJyG iPh dG(Vh f9]|Q d;$ ?*DQ iQJA< -9]k *C- e(t*h
.QF9gWyG gP$ ?|9sE Q+T+Ay xyPh i(AqyGh ~+zgAyG Q|C )zf e(t* #| S9"zy
:Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G -3
fC xV :h ,~%"| OIGh {v IQOs >TJ< #+}zT}yG )zf >FGh ($h
&y 9}<h ,?azS #| xz}* 9}< gQ+i #| JGQw"}yG Q++j@ )zf IQOs QDvC ~v9JyG
I:(yG #| >FG(yG GP$ AGOC )p gOf9T* #| ~v9JyG #+g*h ,?f9ayG uI #|
)y(A* iPyG ($h ,>TAJ}yG ?q+ch {FGh}G f(}zT}yG aQf Otyh ,d9}gyGh
k
.xyP )p ~wJyG ?azTy ;}gAT| Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}G
:~zT}yG ~v9Jzy ?+S9+TyG J9=FG(yG
?|~y ?S9+Sh ,&y eqI )$ {< ,#*OyG #f ?wq"| BT+y J9=FG(yG gP$h
:J9=FG(yG gP$ Q%cC #|h ,&<
:YQWyG e9wIC uph dOgyG ?|9sE -1
:9"zsh ,?+|;S G ?yhOyG )p ~wJzy S9Szv dOgyG #f {=s #| 9"}zw@
j o .e;S G )p dOgyG S9SC ($ ,YQV 9}<h ,uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG fE
,$

367

? +fQW y

pts

r
q p

?S9+Ty

?+}v9Jy

o n m l k
.

)p A)V {v h]+p ,)y9g@

Gh

]25

?*6G :O*OJn yG[

Q|C h=A* iPyG :($ ,dO9gyG e9| Gh


.b*Qq@ hC WGQpE Q+i #| uG &< Q|C iPyG &g\(|
:fGQ%d| ?+|;S G ?yhOyG )p dOgyG ?|9s h
,#+fR9"A}yG #+< e9ZMyG hash ,#*QF9WA}yG #+< e9wI}G P+q"@ :dh}G
Q$9d}yG OIC GP$h ,e(zd| rg]* :h ,~y9c iOgA* ;p ,?qZ"yG ~g@ )AI
.)\(qyG ~g@ : )AI ,dOgyG QGQtp ?|9%yG
f9+<h ,~v9J}yG A9W!Eh ,xyP f(y(A* #*PyG I9]tyG #++g@ e9| G )zfh
.)\9tAyG ?+z}f ~d"@ )AyG JGAGQF G
gO9=f b(tI eq;h c9%A!:G #f uG eQ9J| f9ZAy OhOJyG ?|9sE :)!9DyG
.c;%ASGh a;@E #|
:e9d"yGh ?"+wTyGh e9gyG #|}G )zf X9qJyG -2
~%"|C f9}\h ,#+"_G(}yG ?*9}Jy IOgyG Og* fC e9| G )zf >G+p
.xyP )zf #+}F9tyG #++g@h ,~%A|;Sh
:#*OyGh ?yhOyG #f Y9pOyG -3
iC #| e;S G ?yhO #+|z@h O9%Gzy IOgyG Og* fC e9| G )zf >G*
,9$Q*(a@h T(+GyG R+%: {D| xyPy ?|R;yG {F9S(yG PMA* fC &+zfh ,AGOAfG
j ih
g
f edc o :)y9g@ d9s ,Q(jDyG #+Z;h
.

]60

?*6G

uG

:d

9q!}G[ p
n

on ml

?+fQWyG b<G(]yG uph ?yhOzy ?+y9}yG ?S9+TyG &+F(@ -4


#f d(8T| e9| Gh ,9%pQ9Z|h ?yhOyG OQG(| #f IQ9=f ?+y9}yG ?S9+Ty9p
:

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

368

y9g@ uG &fQV 9| OhOI )p ?S9+TyG gP$ &+F(@


)zf >G* {< ,>TJp &+!h9g|h e9| G u@9f )zf ht* : >FG(yG GP$h
> =o xyP u+t; {+=S )p Q(|}G I:h h| G(!h9gA* fC #+}zT}yG e(}f
.)

pK

JIHGFEDCBA@?

. ]2 ?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

~ }| {z

]58

y xw

x
?*6G :A9T"yG[

?+fQyG )zfh ,&tI uI iP {v G(ag* fC :&<G(!h e9| G )zgp


#| &+yE &gpO ~%+zf >G* 9| G(g"}* fC ~%y R(G* :h ,b(tI #| ~%+zf 9|
k
uG f{p ~%tI ~$(afCz :| )="yG d9s Osh ,9}y9c f9v fEh )AI b(tJyG
.)~zT|( y~$9fQASG 9}f ~%zF9S
k
.y98hQw"@ GQ(|Ch IQCC iOg< fhQAS ~w!Ez :d9sh
?&zyG d(SQ 9* 9!Q|z@ 9}p :G(y9s
.)~zT|( y~wtI uG G(yzSGh ~%tI ~%+yE GhOCz :d9s
h| ,uG ?+Zg| )p ~%A+Zg|h ,uG ?f9_ )p ~%Af9_ {+=s #| GP$h
.Qw"}yG #f ahQg}y9< Q|}Gh ,~%y KZ"yG QGQ}ASG
#| f(!(w+p ,f(tJAT* : 9| Q(|}G I:h #| G(=za* fC ?+fQzy U+yh
]
\[
ZY
X
W
V UT o :~%+p uG d9s #| U"F
GhO|* fC

]58

?*6G :?<n (Aq yG[ p@


! ! z}

b
a `_
^

9 | ~ 9}!{p ,~%FG($C >TJ< 9$(}Tt* fC dG(|}G I:(y U+yh


h | : OI afC : uGh )!Ez :d(t* | )="yGh ,9vk ;| G(T+yh ,A;vhh
k
.)iQ9M=yG( yJQ|C E+I h\C ~S9s 9!C 9}!Eh ,GOIC
k
)AI ,9t+sO 9<k 9TI &y9}fh &@:h >S9J* fC Q|}G )yh )zf >FGhh
HG(!h A " C $
k
" C hG C)

369

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)zf H9TJyG )p(AT* | )="yG f9v Osh ,~$A9aLC KzZ*h ,~%F(f ~+t*
.ahQZ}yGh LQMAT}yG )zf ~%=S9J*h d9}gyG
:?yhOzy ?|9gyG ?S9+TyG ~SQh #+qc(}yGh I:(yG #++g@ -5
)y(* fC &+zf >G+p ,?!9|}G gP$ A>f ht* e9| G )zfh ,?!9|C ?*:(y9p
:Eh ,I9<9J| fhO {}gyG GP%y gOG* #| KzYC d9}f}G #| {}f {v )zf
k
k
.&A!9|} 9g+]| 9"F9L f9v

| { z y x w v u t s ro
.

]27

?*6G

:d

9q!}G[ p!@
!w|
n

9| xyP #}p 9$DGOC >G* ?!9|C ?*:(yG fC )zf | )="yG ?"S ByO Osh
QdA!9p ?!9|}G Bg+\ GPEz :d9s | )="yG fC IQ*Q$ )<C #f iQ9M=yG gGhQ
&z$C Q+i )yE Q|}G OSh GPE d9s ?9%Af9\E 9|h uG d(SQ 9* {+s y?f9TyG
..y?f9TyG QdA!9p
e(* 98Eh ,r+g\ x!E QP 9<C 9*z :?G%y S9"yG bOY} | )="yG d9sh
.~zT| .y9%+p &+zf iPyG iOCh 9%tJ< 9$PLC #| :E ?|GO!h iRL ?|9+tyG
,9$P+q"@ )zf {}gyGh ?yhOzy ?|9gyG ?S9+TyG ~SQ A>f ht* e9| G )zfh
,?|9gyG ?+|;S G O9=}yG I9fGQ| h|h ?+|;S G ?+fQWyG Q9_E )p xyPh
Jz@ ~y E+I ?gSGh ?*Q*Ot@ ?azS xyP )p e9|5yh ,dOgyGh iQ(WyG CO=}v
.?+zv OfG(sh ?|9f O9=}< JA9F 9}!Eh xyP J;+ZqA< ?g*QWyG
{JyG {$C e9|Ch ,?|9f ?qZ< #+}zT}yG Q+$9= e9|C d(8T| e9| Gh
EJ=| xyP )p 9"yh ,&y9}fC #f &=S9; fC ?|~yh ,?Y9L ?qZ< OtgyGh
.QLB

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

370

! 9| C 9% ! E

!!?

k
...9tI

)yh}G )p O}JyG &y ($ :E &yE : uG ($h ,#+}y9gyG HQ u O}JyG


JGh9}TyG A{| O}JyG xy 9"<Q ~%zyG ,f(gFQ@ &+yEh ~wJyG &yh ,IQL6Gh
A9"DyG {$C ,Og< A)V #| B8V 9| A{|h 9}%"+< 9| A{|h VQ}G A{|h
:h ,B+afC 9}y h!9| : ~%zyG ,O=f u 9"zvh ,O=gyG d9s 9| uIC ,OG}yGh
.OGyG x"| OGyG GP hq"* :h ,Bg"| 9}y )ag|
9vk Q9@ -)y9g@ - )pOG(WyG J(qY 9!(LC 9"f {IQ Otp ...Og< 9|C
QLB f9vh ,?fO=yG P=!h ?"TyG QW!h ,)y9g@ uG )yE I(fOyG )p ?z+tC ?!9|C 9"y
>+=JyG ?"S #| IO9qAT}yG ?+y9jyG KF9Z"yG xz@ &@(| {=s &A<9Av #| QW! 9|
B!9v ~C ,#+g=C ~%+zf uG fG(\Q Ky9ZyG 9"qzS iO$h ?*O$h O}J|
H%"| 9%+p #+< &@(| Og< JQW! )AyGh J9<9MA!:Gh ?"TyG Q9Z!C #f &Ay9t|
Q+ih ?fhQW}yG {F9S(yGh {=TyG {w< ?*(+!OyG >Y9"}yG )yE #+f9TyG
~7QOs eOfh 9%z}I )yE f(gT* )AyG ?!9|}G ~df G(S9"@ Osh ,?fhQW}yG
)AI 9"JZ"*h ,9"fO(* fC {=s 9"+Y(*
N+WyG fzvh ,9%F9=fz< e9+tyG )zf
k
,9!Rh ?!9|}G gP%y f(}+t* :h ,f(z}g* : #*PyG H%"| 9!QPJ*h ,YOM"! :
k
.?|GO!h 9*RL ?=s9gyG f(wAp
k
9%y ;$C f9v #| :E ,?|GO!h iRL ?|9+tyG e(* 98Eh ,?!9|C 98E 9tk I
.&A!(g|h uG u+p(A< 9%+p &+zf iPyG iOCh ,9%tJ< 9$PLzp
k
,?*:(yG 9=y9_ A9F Osh- iQ9qjyG hP )<} | )="yG ?J+Z! B!9v Oty
k
,>J* #| )zf [*QI bO9Y >J| ?J+Z! -| )="yG A9af )p 9g|9_
: ,)Tq"y >IC 9| xy >IC )!Eh ,9qk +g\ cGQC )!E ,QP 9<C 9*z :&y d9tp
e(* 98Eh ,?!9|C 98Eh ,r+g\ x!Ez y~+A* d9| #+y(@ :h ,#+"CG )zf fQ|z@
K+JY .y9%+p &+zf iPyG iOCh ,9%tJ< 9$PLC #| :E ,?|GO!h iRL ?|9+tyG

.)1826,1825M( IQ

9|

G c -

~zT|

371

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

#fh ?+<9+"yG Uy9G}zy #+JVQ}yG #f ?+fQWyG b<G(]yG H9+i fE


| )="yG 9%zgF Osh ,IQ+aL IQ$9c ?|}G {D}* #| fhQ9AM* #*PyG #+=L9"yG
k
GPEz :d9tp ,?!9|~y 9f9+\ {D}@ 98} ;9+!OyG dGhRh ?|9+tyG e9+s HQty GQk *P!
Q|}G OSh GPEz :d9s ?9%Af9\E r+v :G(y9s .y?f9TyG QdA!9p ?!9|}G Bg+\o
.)59( ~zgyG c - iQ9M=yG .y?f9TyG QdA!9p &z$C Q+i )yE
k
YR"Ap ?|("yG {FQyG e9"*z ,9fR! H(ztyG #| YR"@h ,?!9|}G h+]@ GP6h
)1 (
YR"Ap ?|("yG {FQyG e9"* ~C , Bv(yG QCC {D| 9$QCC {d+p &=zs #| ?!9|}G
^q"p xzFQ )zf &AFQIO Q}Gv )2({G}yG {D| 9$QCC {d+p &=zs #| ?!9|}G
k
)AI ,?!9|}G iO|* ;FQ O: O9w@ ;p f(g*9=A* S9"yG K=Z+p ,GQk =A"| gGQAp
k
9| gOzFC 9| &ztfC 9| :{FQzy d9t* )AIh ,9"k +|C ;FQ f;p )"< )p fE :d9t*o
.&+zf uqA| .yf9}*E #| dOQL #| ?=I d9tD| &=zs )p 9|h ,&pQcC
O}IC .y&y O%f : #}y #*O :h ,&y ?!9|C : #}y f9}*E ;pz
.)154,135,3L(

KzY}G -Q9+ALG- ?+y(@ H(Fh


H(Fh Q9+AL:G O"f 9%+fGQ@ fC ?|}G )zf )j="* )AyG b<G(]yG bT<C fE
~dg| #f >+j* GP$h ,?*:(yG A9=fC {}; )zf QOs}Gh KzY}G ?+y(@
)zf UQJyGh O*OWyG Up9"AyG xyP iQ"p ,#+=L9"yG QDvCh ,#+JVQ}yG
,dG(|}G dP=< ,?fhQW}yG Q+ih ?fhQW}yG {F9S(yG )AW< >Z"}zy d(Y(yG
{D|h ,~7G(YC AGOGASGh ,#+=L9"yG #| A9aT=yG YGOLh ,J9*9fOyG r+Dw@h
)"*OyG )f(yG H9+i {c )p U9MV}G KzYC 9}k FGO RQq* : Up9"AyG GP$
uG e9|C 9%"f f(yzT+S ?}+df ?!9|C 98C f(JVQ}yG )T"+p ,?gp9"yG ?p9tDyGh
:

QC )t=*h )qW* MQGyG :Bv(yG )1(


.A9}yG #| J9f9tp &+p Q%d+p OzGyG >+Z* bQJyG :{G}yG )2(
.g C

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

372

~yh ,9%tI Q+j< 9$PLC #| )zf IQL6Gh 9+!OyG )p ?|GO!h iRL 98Ch ,)y9g@
.9%+p &+zf >Fh 9| O|*
HG(<C )zf #J!h )<9+"yG UzG}zy #+JVQ}zy d(sC GP$ {F}
f(|(tAS ~w!C f(}zg@ :C ,&+zf f(|Ot| ~A!C 9}+p uG G(t@G :J9<9MA!:G
{v #f )y9g@ uG e9|C f(yzTAS ~w!Ch ,#+!G(tyG #Sh h*QWAyG ?q+ch )zf
?|}G )p uG G(t@Gh &Ag*QVh &"*O )p uG G(t@9p ,)y9g@ uG YQV ry9M* h*QW@
:)y9g@ uG d(s GhQvPGh ,)y9g@ uG ?g*QV #f GhO+; :h ,~w@Q9ALG )AyG
?*6G :IOF9}n yG[

p@
! ! zu

+*
) ( '& % $ #

"

.]50

I H G F E D C B A @ ? > = Wo
XWV@
! ! z} U T S R Q P O N M L K J
hgfedcba`_^]\[ZY
o .p!@
! z~ q p o n m l k j i

z(y'x & % $ # " ! ~ } | {


.

]65

?*6G

:A

x
9T"yG[ p!@
!{z

,+*)

{}; )zf I(tyG ,?!9|}Gh I(tyG )zf >Z"| i} ?+I;ZyG QGO| fE


iO|@ xzg: )AyG ?!9|}Gh ,uF;yG &F(yG )zf &+zf e9+tyGh >Z"}yG A9=fC
,?*:(yG hC >Z"}yG OhOJ< ~zgyG GP$ )p {LO*h ,&tI uI iP {v )yE
,A9=f}G gP6 e9+tyG )zf IQOtyG ~C ,&< S9"yG ~w; 9|h uG ?g*QW< ~zgyGh
?yGOgyG I9fGQ| ~C ,[ZMAyGh ~zgyG {$C #| A9*(s}G A9"|}9< ?!9gAS:Gh
.I9<9J| hC ?z|9G| fhO 969<QC )yE b(tJyG d9Z*
k
q p o o :GPt"| A9F Osh QZ| xz}y e;TyG &+zf rS(* d9s
&dqIh &}zf )p &@;$|| B!9wp , ?*6 rS(* pu tsr
r
qp o n o :9%+<} ?Jy9ZyG ICQ}yG By9sh .&@(sh &A!9|Ch
]55

G :

373

? +fQW y

]26

?*6G :[Zn tyG[

pu

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

t
s

9 ty )zf GQkO9s 9Jk y9Y &!hQ@ #| Q9+ALG )zf G(YQIG :#+=L9"zy d(sCh
;Uq"yG AG($} hC ?zY hC ?<GQs {F} OI} >ZgAyGh ~v9*Eh ,?<9+"yG A9=fz<
98k +V #+}zT}yG Q|C #| )yh #|hz :Q9+AL:Gh H9MA!:G ?+z}f ~A+y(@ ~w!}
k
&y(SQh uG f9L Otp &"| #+}zT}zy KzYC ($ #| OG* ($h ;FQ )y(p
k
k
.9f(pQ|h 9p(s(| Q}f #f ~v9JyG &FQLC y#+"||}yGh
hp9"}yGh 9+!OyG {F} {FQyG GhQ9A< fC ?!9+MyG ~dfC #| fC G(}zfGh
~%yh ~%+vR* :h ~%+yE Qd"* :h ?|9+tyG e(* uG ~%}zw* : ?C;Cz :?Y9MyG
9%"| g9afC f{p ,9+!Oy :E &g*9=* : 9|k 9|E h*9< {FQ :-~%"|- ~+yC HGPf
.&+zf uqA| .yr* ~y 9%"| bg* ~y fEh ,)ph
k
#_G(| iQ+y &Tq! )yE GO+F Qd"* Q|}G GP$ )p {LO* f9T!E {v B+y 9+p
eOt@ A9}zgyG #+dp9JyG A9*(s}G A9"|}G #| f9v f{p ,9%+p rg]yGh I(tyG
B+y 9*h .?!9+MyGh ~zdyG ?*h9$ )p W(tTyG #f &Tq"< iz! :Eh ,u9< 9"k +gAT|
~$Q+i #| : ~%"| Q9AM+p A9*(s}G A9"|}G R+}* r+v aQg* 9"| OIGh {v
.?|}G Ky9Z}y ?*9fQ
:)y(* : ?*:(yG >y9_
?*k :(yG >y9_ f} ;)y(* : ?*:(yG >y9_ fC 9]k *C ?+fQWyG b<G(]yG #|h
:9< )tz* :h ,9%FGQh #| ?+ZMWyG >S9w}yG u+tJAy )gT* ,9%+zf [*QI
uq"* gGQ! GP%yh ,&t"f )p f(wAS )AyG ?!9|~yh ,96 e(t+S )AyG A9=f}9<
YOM* ?<P9wyG O(f(yG dP=*h ,&\Qi )yE d(Y(yG {+=S )p ?zF9ayG dG(|}G
>Tv {v {+Z;h &tq!C 9| ^*(g@ &}$ f9v &A*9i )yE {Yh GP{p ,S9"yG 96
.#w}|
k
GQO9s f(w* :C )WM*h ,9%F9=fC )p Qwq*h ?!9|}G ~df cQO* #| 9|C
,9%8=f {}; )zf S9"yG QOsC f(w* &!{p 9%=z_ )p gQ+i ~IGR* :h 9%+zf
e+ G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

374

9aL OOT*h &tp(*h uG &"+g* GP$ {D|h ,9%=S9w| )p h}ayG #f ~$Og<Ch


dzT@ : ,#}IQyG O=f 9*z :IQ}S #< #}IQyG O=gy | )="yG d9s
?yzT| Q+i #| 9%A+afC fEh ,9%+yE Bzvh ?yzT| #f 9%A+afC fE x!{p ,IQ9| G
.&+zf uqA| .y9%+zf B"fC
k
.y&+zf UQI :h &yzS GOIC Q|}G GP$ )y(! : 9!Ez :| )="yG d9sh
.~zT|
:d9}gyGh I:(yG ?=S9J|
xyPvh ,9tk +sO 9<k 9TI G(|Os 9| )zf I:(yG >S9J* | )="yG f9v Oty
IQ9GAyG ?SQ9}}< ~%y f(J}T* ;p ,I:(yG f(=S9J* fhOVGQyG A9qzMyG f9v
~%+zf f(=TJ*h ,9*GO%yG d(=s )zf ~8hQt* :h ?*:(yG H9TI ,zf K<QAyGh
)="yG d9s GP%yh ,YhQW}yG Q+i AGQC G #| ~%g"}y 9$Og<h ?*:(yG {=s ~%yG(|C
~C x+<C B+< )p BTzF ;$z :&Tq"y 9$OGQCh ?*O%yG {=s iPyG )yG(zy |
xDg=! ~yh 9+k yGh c9"Dg< 9}!Ez :)y(zy d(t* Q}f f9vh y?x+yE iO9 {$ Qd"@
.yGQk F9@
I:h {wyh ,J9<9MA!:G )p M9G"yG ~%y uG QOs #}y d(sC GQk +LCh
fC ~w+zf >G* GPyh ,?+fQyG Ky9Z| )p f(z}g@ AGQFC ~w!C G(}zfG :Q(|}G
,~%+zf G(y9gA@ :h ,~%y M9"GyG G(]qLG ,~6 G(tpQ@h >!9GyG ~%y G("+z@
dOgyGh ,~%y KZ"yG )p O%GyG {v G(yP<Gh ,~8hO HG(<}G G(tzj@ :h
f9v ,&<G(C f(FQ@h uG &Fh &< f(jA=@ xyP ~Azgp fE ~w!C G(}zfGh ,~%"+<
,Q9"yG )yE ~wz+=S xyP f9v ~@QZsh ~Ag+\ fEh ,?"GyG )yE ~wz+=S xyP
:E ?J+Z"< 9%aJ* ~zp ?+fQ uG g9fQASG O=f #| 9|z :| )="yG d(s GhQvP@h
T9i ($h J(}+p #+}zT}yG #| ?+fQ )z* dGh #| 9|z .y?"GyG ?JFGQ OG* ~y
.iQ9M=yG .y?"GyG &+zf uG eQI :E ~%y
.g

375

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

TyG ?!9a< GhQPIG


~w$(Fh )p ~w!(IOA}* #*PyG #+tp9"}yGh ,A(TyG ?!9a< GhQPIGh
~%"f ~w$(Fh ~@QOC GP{p ,~w=Y9"| )p ~A|O 9| ~wy9}fC )zf f("D*h
.~w\GQfC #| G(y9!h OGOI ?"Tyz< ~v(tzS
,~%JZ"< G(z}fGh ~%"| G(z=s9p YQ(yGh i(tAyGh ~zgyG {$z< ~w+zfh
:h ,)=! #| uG Eg< 9|z :d9s | uG d(SQ fC G(}zfGh ,~%+yE G("TICh
&];h ahQg}y9< gQ|z@ ?!9a< :f9A!9a< &y B!9v :E ,?q+zL #| rzMASG
.y)y9g@ uG &}Zf #| e(Zg}y9p ,&+zf &];h QWy9< gQ|z@ ?!9a<h ,&+zf
.iQ9M=yG
b<G(\ #f G(\QfC GPE S9"yG fC R*RgyG Q9tyG 99C ~zfG ..9|k 9ALh
;p Q+}\ hC #*O #| YRGh Q+j< Q(|}G gP$ )p G(\9Lh ,&|9wICh YQWyG
,&+zf G(pQ9g@ Qw"| )zf ~%g| #w@ ;p ,~%AvQ9W| )p :h ~%+p Q+L
:)y9g@ d9s 9}v xTq! ?Y9M< x+zgp :Eh ,&+p ~%vQ9Vh ahQg}y9< ~$Q|Ch
:A(

]105

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

w v utsrqo

BqLh ~$O(%f BFQ| Os S9"yG B*CQ GPEz :| )="yG d9s 9}vh


?xyP #| LQM}yG 9}p :G(y9s -&g<9YC #+< x=Vh- yGPw$ G(!9vh ,~79!9|C
~wAY9L Q|C )zf f(z=t@h ,fhQw"@ 9| f(fO@h ,f(pQg@ 9| fhPLz@z :d9s
.O}IC gGhQ .y?|9gyG Q|C f(fO@h -~zgyGh ?"TyG {$C iCQ|C x"f YOh ,xTq! ?Y9L Q|z< x+zfh ,Qw"@ 9| YOh ,aQg@ 9| PMp
.#AqyG d9I xA+< eRyGh ,?|9gyG
&!E .?!9|}G AGOC )zf 9""+g* fCh ,?y;]yGh k*RyG #| 9"}Zg* fC uG dzT!
.&=JYh &yBh O}J| 9"+=! )zf ~%zyG {Yh ,&+zf QO9tyGh xyP )yh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

376

? I9AAp:
+

?U FQyG

#| O*Q!

G v$1426 #

|9Dy Ogy
G O

GP9|

])=vGQ}yG d9}F Q(AvOyG[

Og<h &=JYh &yBh O}J| )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh ,gOIh u O}JyG


k
{*Og@ Og< 9gk SGh 9+k S9+S :OF ?+y9JyG ?zIQ}yG )p QZ| JO%V Otp
u*Qav )=gWyG A9AqAS:G IQ$9c #| d(JAyGh e1971 Q(ASO #| 76 IO9}yG
#+< #| QV9=}yG QJyG YGQAs:9< U+FQyG H9MA!G )yE ?*Q(%}GyG U+FQ H9MA!:
#| ?y9I Og< )S9+S LGhQ ?y9I #| xyP h=AASG 9|h ?S9FQzy KVQ| #| QDvC
{v ?*DQ #f Q=g@ ?+<9MA!G H|GQ=< #+JVQ}yG eOt@ )p GP$ )z: Osh ,O(}GyG
e(}f #+< iQwqyG dOGyG #| J:9I xyP h=@h ;?+z=tAT}yG ?zIQ}zy ~%"|
.?"$GQyG ?y9Jzy ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?*DQ d(I ?z8S}G JQDvh S9"yG
:QG(JyG GP$ f9v ~C #|h
~wy f(w* : GP9}y ?96 f(gA}A@ )AyG ?+=zTyG gP$ 9| :iQh9J| )y d9s
??+S9+TyG I9+JyG )p ?y9gp ?vQ9W|h )<9G*E QhO
?OZt@ )S9+S {}f iC :&y Bzs
.f9}yQ=yG )p HG("yG Q9+ALGh U+FQyG H9MA!G :d9s
.?+}$C QDvC Q|z< ~A8 #J! :&y Bzs
k
!!?+}$C QDvC :9=GgA| d9s
P=!h | d(SQyG L9%"| Y9=@Gh gO+I(@h uG )yE S9"yG I(fO ,)z< :Bzs
&|Ot@ b(g@h ~zT}yG h}AG}yG 96 Hg* )AyG J:;]yGh J9pGQMyGh YO=yG
.gQ9$ORGh
?)S9+TyG {}gyG )p ?+<9G*E ?vQ9W| #| h"}* GP$ {$h :d9s
:

377

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?JY9"}y9< :E ?S9+TyG gP$ )p cQ9W! : #J"p 9"Af9= ~S9< 9|C :&y Bzs
~y 9| ahQg}yG )p Q|}G I:h ?f9_h Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9< Q|}Gh
fC P"| #zg|h ~*Os rs(| GP$h ,?+Zg}yG )p ?f9_ ;p ,?+Zg}< GhQ|z*
9+k S9+S 9<k RI 9"Tyh I(fO ?f9= #J"p e1926 e9f ?f9}GyG gP$ BTSz@
?]*QgyG IOf9tyG )p Q++jAyG )yE )gT! #J! 9}!Eh ?azTyG )yE d(Y(zy )gT!
?"Sh uG H9Aw< {}gyG )yEh | d(SQyG H%"| )yE S9"yG I(fO< >gWyG #|
:E ?|}G gP$ KzZ@ #zp -?|}G gP$ rzS )"fC- ?|}G Y9=Eh | uG d(SQ
9!zp J9<9MA!:G h_9t! : #J"p iOQqyG i(AT}yG )zf 9|C ,9%yhC &< KzY 9}<
Q9+ALGh ~+zS ~%p )yE S9"yG (fO! 9""wyh H9MA!:G ?+z}f )p cQ9VC )Tq"<
;?!9|}Gh I(tyGh ~zgyG )zf ?+I;ZyG QGO|h ,KzY}G Q9+ALG &+p )fGQ* u+sO
ut
s r
qp o n m l o :)y9g@ d9s
.

rq p o

]26

?*6G :[Zn tyG[ p!@


!w{
n

;TyG &+zf rS(* f9Ty )zf )y9g@ d9sh

:e

]55

u ts

?*6G :rSo (*o [ p

{}; )zf ~$G(sCh S9"yG KzYC ?+y(@ #f f(y(8T| 9gk += f(}zT}y9p


I(tyG )zf 9"zs 9}v ?+I;ZyG QGO|h ,Q+Zt@ hC fh97 fhO ?!9|}G gP$
.?!9|}Gh
iO|* &zg: )AyG ?!9|}Gh ,>Z"}yG GP$ A9=fC {}; )zf IQOtyGh I(tyG
.&tI uI iP {wy
?!9|C 98Ez :| )="yG d(t* GP$ )ph ?!9|}G gP$ fzV QaLC 9|h ~dfC 9|h
.y9%+p &+zf iPyG iOCh 9%tJ< 9$PLC #| :E ?|GO!h iRL ?|9+tyG e(* 98Eh
.)1825M( IQ9| G c ~zT|
GP$ )ph 96Qs H9=SCh ?f9TyG WGQVC #| ?|}G )p ?!9|}G gP$ Y9+\h

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

378

9|h uG d(SQ 9* :{+s ,?f9TyG QdA!9p ?!9|}G Bg+\ GPEz :| 9"+=! d(t*
c iQ9M=yG .y?f9TyG QdA!9p &z$C Q+i )yE Q|}G OSh GPE :d9s ?9%Af9\E
.)59M( ~zgyG
k
k
VhQg}yG f(w* 9!9+IC #wyh ??9+=zS f(w* fC GP6 #||* #}< #d* {%p
)gT! 9"$h #+|(wJ}v 9"I(}_ h| >S9"A* : Q9wp}Gh H|GQ=yG #| M9A}yG
.&+yE K}a! 9| GP$h ,{+yOy9< O*|}yG &!9+<h uJyG )yE I(fOyG )yE
?~w@9I(}_ )$ 9|h :d9s
{$ ,9"Ag*QV h| VQ9gA@ : #+!G(t< ?}zT| ?+=zizv ~wJ! fC :hC :Bzs
dh9"A@ : #+JVQ}yG h+= #| ?\hQg}yG ?+<9MA!:G H|GQ=yG f(w@ fC {tg*
?+!9w|{p ??+|;S G ?g*QWyG e9wIC ?IGQY ry9< )AyG #+!G(tyG {*Og@ ?yzT|
hC QG(ayG f(!9s A9jyE &G|9!Q< )p KVQ| #| QDvC #zg* PE ;?I9A| Q++jAyG
k
)F9"GyG f(!9tyG OG(| {*OgAy O+g< hC >*Qs #| Q+W* GOIC OG! : 9}"+< &z*Og@
fC h| 9!RyG ?}*QG< ?tzgA}yG #+!G(tyG {D| e;S G ?g*QV ?IGQY ry9< )AyG
.96 {|9gA@ :h ?+y9=yG #+!G(tyG gP$ {D| ^pQ@ iQZ}yG >gWyG O+y9t@
U+FQyG O%f )p e1971 Q(ASO {*Og@ ~@ P"| ?*Q(ASO ?qy9M| X+g! 9"!E
H9MA!G O*O: :)yh}G ,#+@Qtp {*OgAyG {}AVGh JGO9TyG Q(!C u<9TyG
?+|;S G ?g*QWyG :?+!9DyGh ,)?+y9@ IO|( ?}zv #| :O< ?+y9@ OO}y U+FQyG
f(w@ fC )"g* GP$h ))T+FQ QOZ|( ?}zv #| :O< h*QWAzy )T+FQyG QOZ}yG
f(w@ fCh ?*Q(ASO Q+i B!9v :Eh ,?g*QWyG e9wI} ?tpG(| #+!G(tyG {v
?g*QWyG ry9< ?JF: hC h*QW@ QOZ* :Ch #+!G(tyG eC )$ ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG
.?+|;S G
9| #+!G(ty9p )!9DyG {*OgAyG #f 9|C ,f6G )yE u=a* dh}G {*OgAyG ($ 9$h
?+g*QWAyG Uy9G}yG )zfh ,Qs(}yG UzG}yG )p LGQO}G ?T+=I ByGR
.?qy9M}yG gP$ ?g=@ ht@ ?|(wJyGh

379

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

O@ ?y9a< #| >gWyG 9%"| )!9g* )AyG {v9W}yG #f GP9|h :iQh9J| d9s


?+\9}yG JG("TyG ?z+_ B}@ )AyG J9I;Y G xyPvh ?W+g}yG i(AT| )p
??f9}yQ=yGh ?|(wJyG )p ~wzD}* #| 9%S9SC )zf fhQ9A< ?}+s ~wy {D}@ :C
fC iQ! 9""wyh 9%"f dRg}< X+g! :h A9+V}G gP$ Qw"! : #J! :Bzs
IO(gyG )"g* :h M;Y G #| h"}* : ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG e9wIC u+=a@
fE {< ,?"}zgyG I9fO xyPy LhQ* 9}v ?}zd| ?+\9| fhQs )yE h}AG}y9<
?y9a=yG )zf A9]tzy ~df}G {+=TyG ($ &+yE (fO! iPyG u*QayG GP$ )p )]}yG
)zf A9]tyG )yE iO|* xyPvh ,J9I;Y G IO9*Rh ?W+g}yG i(AT| hpQyh
f{p ,Q+qwAyG )yE (fO*h e;dyG )p B="* Qwp {v )zfh H9$Q G IQ$9c
.?+|;S G ?g*QWyG H9+i ?+]s )zf iQ+qwAyG ~%G%"| )p fhRw@Q* A:|$
?"}zgyG #| GOk *R| f6G 9%W+g! )AyG ?zIQ}yG RQq@ fC &p9M! 9| a(LC fE
QQJAyG i(fO< 9"Ag*QVh 9"CGQAy 9$Q%c ?z=t}yG ?zIQ}yG )p QZ| Q*O@ fCh
)j="* iPyG LP(}"yGh )zf}G {D}yG gQ9=Af9< )<QjyG )w*Q|}G LP(}"yG u+t;h
#}| Q+Dv &y(I fO!O*h #+JVQ}yG ^g< &y LhQ* 9| GP$h ,iPAJ* fC
.#++I;YE ~%Tq!C f(}T*h M;Y G f(}fR*
)p I(LE 9"g| {< ,#_(yG GP$ )p 9!OIh X+g! : 9""wyh :iQh9J| d9s
??+|;S G ?g*QWyG e9wIC ~%+zf u=a! r+wp ,#+}zT}yG Q+i #| #_(yG
Q+i b(tI QO9Z@ : 9"Ag*QVh ,#+}zT}yG Q+i O(Fh Qw"! : #J! :Bzs
#| ~%s(tI U}@ : ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG #| ?g<9"yG #+!G(tyGh ,#+}zT}yG
.e(zg| )9O< Q|C GP$h O+g< hC >*Qs
&tqyGh ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG #| )I(AT}yG KGQ+}yG f(!9s u=a! 9"!E
Q+i b(tI U}* f(!9tyG GP$ {D| u+=a@ fE OIC {t* ~yh QZ| )p )|;S G
.#+}zT}yG
f h

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

380

9ty U+FQyG #| g(FQ@ iPyG 9}p :d9s


,&+"+f >Z! ?J+Z"yG gP$ {gG* fC eO9tyG U+FQyG #| gO*Q! iPyG :Bzs
u :d9s ?&zyG d(SQ 9* #}y 9"zs .?J+Z"yG #*OyGz :d(t* | uG d(SQ f{p
:| d9sh ;~zT| gGhQ .y~%A|9fh ,#+}zT}yG ?}F}h ,&y(SQyh ,&<9Awyh
k
k
:h ghO=g@ fC ~wy )\Q* :9C;C ~wy bMT*h 9C;C ~wy )\Q* uG fEz
#| G(JY9"@ fCh ,G(sQq@ :h 9gk += uG {=J< G(}ZAg@ fCh ,98k +V &< G(vQW@
.ydG|TyG IQDvh d9}yG ?f9\Eh ,d9sh {+s :~wy bMT*h ,~vQ|C uG )yh
.~zT|h O}IC gGhQ
e9}A$:G R+I )p ?g*QWzy ?qy9M}yG #+!G(tzy J;*OgAyG {gG* fCh
)!E ~zg* uGh ,#*OTq}yGh O9TqyG )zf O*OI #| O+< HQ]* fCh ,P+q"AyGh
S R Q P O N M L K J I H Go KY9"y
?eO G

]88

?*6G

:O

($o [

pT

381

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

v$ 1427
?

+F9DjyG #|R )p ?*Q+MyG

#|h &=JYh &yB )zfh

>F

? |C

S )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh ,u O}JyG


:Og<h ,g:Gh
fzV >+Ggp
?=I9Y ,{Fh Rf uG )yE I(fOyG AG(y ?z|9I ,O+I(AyG ?|C ?|}G gP$
{v ,p {+z%AyGh Q+=wAy9< fGP}G J(Y 9%+p (zg* )AyGh | O}J| )="yG iO$
{v ,p uG :E &yE : Q=vC uG Q=vC uG 96Q9j|h VQ}G bQ9W| ,ph ?z+yh e(*
.Q98 hC {+y #| ?f9S
?h=C ~y9gzy 97O9*Qh 97O9+Sh 9$Rf 9$Otpzp ?|}G gP$ H9YC iPyG 9|
" ! ~} o {Fh Rf 9"<Q 9%+p d9s )AyG ,$ ?|}G gP$ {$
? *6 G

: fG

Qn }fp

dB[

,uG d( Q

p*
)

'&

$ #
.

]110

~yh ,S9"zy BFQLC ?|C Q+L 9"v 9"!C e(+yG ^g=yG gOOQ* 9| K+JY {$
?Q+L #| IQP 9"+p Og*
{$C rZ! f(w@ fC | uG d(SQ h}_ )AyG ?|}G ,$ ?|}G gP$ {$
,p OQh 9}v ?"GyG {$C ,DzC 9%zgGp 9FQ 9}| QDvC {Fh Rf uG g9afzp ?"GyG
gGhQ( .y?|}G gP$ #| 9%"| f(!9}C rY ?F9|h fhQWf ?"GyG {$Cz :E*OJyG
.)iP|QAyGh O}IC
Rf &<Q &y d9tp 9%+zf ?tqV | uG d(SQ )w< )AyG ?|}G ,$ gP$ {$
9tk *OZ@ xyPh ,)~zT| gGhQ( ycD(T! :h xA|C ,p x+\Q"S 9!Ez :{Fh
xV : . ?*6 )J]y p!@
!z c b
a ` o :)y9g@ uG d(ty
r
f6G 9$GQ!h ,?z*(_ IQAp P"| ?|}G 9%W+g@ ,AyG #$(yGh rg]yG ?y9I fC
]5

G:

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

382

Q]@ ,9$QF9Z| )zf Q*R9"MyGh IOQtyG O9qIC #| ?y9DJyG bzT@ ,p IOTG|


w
iO"F {FC #| ,IRi )p Q+S}G )"+aTzqyG >gWyG Y(:h QY9;h rZt@h
:h >=TyG JGPy f9"=y Q|O@h HQ]@ 9$GQ! ~C ,#+aTzp ,p ?|h9t}yG &@QSC
k
!9vGQI ?|}G gP$ ,p OG!
,h\(yG GP$ Q++jAy Q+L #| IhPFh {|C #| ?]|h ?|}G gP$ ,p u=* ~yC
?bRz}yG GP$ #| LhQMyGh
Q+qwAyG AG(y ?z}I #| ?|}G gP$ #| ?y;]yGh ?fO=yG H9JYC OG! GP9}y
,p ?|}Gh ,uG {+=S ,p O9%GyG ?*GQ f(gpQ* ^pGhQyGh LQG(MyG #|
?u+}f J9=S
#f Y9pOyGh ?|h9t}yG R|Q ($ f9"=y ,p ^pGhQyG {D}| uG HRI Q9Y {$
?Q*Q}yG hsG(yG GP%y jOZAyG ,p ?|}G {|C IOf9tyG JQ9Y {$h ,?|}G gP$
^pGhQyGh LQG(MyG >zG* {$h ,Q+My9< QWyG ,@z* {%p ,J9%+$ J9%+$
9%M*Q9@ iO| )zf 9%A=w! H9=SC ~dfC #| {Y}G ,p ~$h ?|}G gP%y GQk +L
rZtyG Iz_h B; A9T"yGh d9q_}G #| A9*Q<}Gh A9qg]yG {gq* GP9| !?&zv
gP$ #| ?+JyG QF9}]yG H9JYC {gq* GP9|h ,A9T| M9=Y ?*OAg}yG fGQ+"yGh
~g!h uG 9"=TI :G(y(t* fC i(S jOQAyGh rg]yG #| ?y9JyG gP$ e9|C ?|}G
,O}Ag! gOIh &+zfh ,A(S {v #| 9"}Y9fh 9"+p9vh 9"=TI &!9J=S ($ .. {+v(yG
: fCh ,9"f &=]ih &At| hpQ* fC &+yE {%A=! ?fGQ]yG rvz< ,zGz! &!9J=S &+yEh
~+$GQ<E #}IQyG {+zL ,p IhOsh I(SC xyP ,p 9"yh ,9"| A9%qTyG {gp 9}< 9!PLz*
#+I ~%"f uG ,\Q &<9JYCh | O}J| 9"+=! ,ph e;TyGh I;ZyG 9"+=! )zfh &+zf
on v n
.{+v(yG ~g!h uG 9"=TI G(y9tp S9"yG ~%p(L
H

)1(

)2(

MyG H%"| {D}* &!z< &+zf ~wJyGh IOf9tyG ~+d"@ #| N+WyG rs(}y f9+< GP$ )2( , )1(
#+qy9M}yG )zf OQyG )p ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= H%"| )yE &=A"* ~y #| &=A"+y &A=Av u+zgAyG GP$h
.?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C >$P| #f ~$Og< f9+<h

LQG(

383

? +fQW y

:9}%"f uG

?S9+Ty

)\Q

Gh

?+}v9Jy

S9=f

#<G #f

9%y9sh ,Q9"yG ,p )tyC #+I ~+$GQ<E 9%y9s {+v(yG ~g!h uG 9"=TIz :d9s
k
G(y9sh 9!9}*E ~$OGRp ~$(WL9p ~wy G(g= Os S9"yG fE G(y9s #+I | O}J|
d9s ,Q9"yG #| ~+$GQ<E uG )G"p ,)iQ9M=yG gGhQ( y{+v(yG ~g!h uG 9"=TI
5 4 32 @
! !{~ 1 0
/ . - ,+
o :)y9g@
.p!@
!|u

QtyG ~69YC 9| Og< #| d(SQyGh u G(<9GASG #*PyGh &+=! uG QZ!h


/ . - , +*)( '&% $ o MGQGyGh
M

]174

?*6G :fGQn }fp

dB[

p! @
!v|y

2 10

,AyG ?*Q9GyG d9J< e(+yG | O}J| ?|C #| #+qg]AT}yG d9I &=VC 9|


9}k zc 9%y f(y(t*h 98(<Q]* ~$h 96 GhQ| Otp 98zW< h+\QyG )=ZyG uG ua!C
k
eC By9tp ,{+v(yG ~g!h uG ,=TI d(t@ ,$h ,BsQS ,B+!R 9!GhOfh
~%zyG :d9sh 9%+yE Qd!h Y9\QyG cQAp ,9%zD| ,"<E {g: : ~%zyG :)=ZyG
?qg]AT}yG ?|(zd}yG ?*Q9GyG gP$ xz}@ ~zp .)~zT| gGhQ( y9%zD| ,"zgFG
Rf uG )yE A(GzyG ,!9g| #}]A@ ,AyG ?}zwyG gP6 :E 9%Tq! #f hpO@ fC
Og< (yh &F9+yh} gQZ!h &!9J=S &yOg< ?tDyGh &F9]sh &}wJ< )\QyGh {Fh
.#+I
gO"f ~%AyR"|h ~8zV #| hpQ+y gA9+yhC )zA=* &!9J=S )y(}yG fC xV :h
~6(zs B=D*h gA9+yhC O*|* GP$ {F} ,>+ayG #| E+=MyG R+}*h ,&!9J=S
l@
! ! vx~ k j
i
h gf ed co :&y(t<

x wv u t
s r
qp o nm
!@
! vy u %
$ # " ! ~} | { z y
10/ . - ,
!@
!vyv + *) ( '&
.p!@
! vy w 8 7 6 5
4 32

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

384

#| fC 9!Q=M* | 9"+=!h ?f9TyG e9+s )yE 9$QSz< 9+!OyG ~g* A;=yG GP$ fE
:d(t+p &}$h &y9< {jW@ IQL6G f} 9+!OyG ,p ?}g"< PPzA* : xyP )fh
)A| fP G h}ASGh fQtyG ~tAyG Os - {+pGQSE - fQtyG >I9Yh ~g!C r+vz
:G(y(s ~%y d9tp | )="yG H9JYC )zf {tC xyP fzwp .yNq"+p Nq"y9< Q||*
.)&"TIh iP|QAyG gGhQ( y9"zv(@ uG )zf {+v(yG ~g!h uG 9"=TIz
O+I(AyG USC #| ,$ )AyG ?}zwyG gP$ &<9JYC ~zg* | )="y9p
d9tp )y9g@h &!9J=S &<Q &}zf 9}v &+zf {v(AyGh {Fh Rf uG )zf O9}Af:Gh

< ;:987 6 5 4 3 2{ :{Fh Rf


I HG
FE D C
BA
@?>
=
V UT S R
Q P O NML
K
J
ba `_^
] \ [Z Y X W
n ml k j i h
g
fe d c
.
9 q !} }
s r
qp o

[65-62 :d

G]

#}* {$h ,?*9qwyGh >TJyG GP$ #|h O+*zAyG GP$ #| e(+yG #J! #*zp
uG ?}g"< K=Z"p iQLC IQ| O\9gAyGh QY9"AyGh ry5AyG GP$ {D}< 9"+zf )y9g@
k
&}zd* : ~zT}yG (LC ~zT}yGz :| 9"+=! d(s 9"+p utJA*h 9!G(LE 9"+zf )y9g@
.y&}zT* :h &yPM* :h
o :{Fh Rf 9"<Q d(s 9"+p utJA* {$

uG

wvutsr
& %$ # " ! ~ } | { z y x
.

]103

?*6G :fGQn }fp

dB[

p(

'

{=J< 9"}ZAfGh | d(SQzyh u 9"=GASG GPE #w}| xyP fC xV :


k
d(s )=TJp {gq! ~y f{p ,9"< rZg* fC b9tWyGh bQqAzy K}T! ~yh ,9g+=
W
V U T SR Q PO N M L
Ko :)<Q

uG

]129

?*6G :?<n (Aq yG[ p!@


!vw~

YX

385

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

gf
e d c b a `{ :{Fh Rf &y(sh
w v ut
sr
qp o n ml kj i h
%$#
" !
~}| { z yx
4 32 10
/ . - ,+*
)( '
&
@ ? > =
<;
: 9 87 6 5

.[38-36 :Q|RyG] }

{=t* : uG )zf {v(AyG #TJ* : jPyG WQq}yG RF9gyG fC 9"+t* ~zg"yh


k
9MSGQ GOk tAg| #}]A* d(tyG GP$ f} {+v(yG ~g!h uG ,=TI f9TzyG d(s &"|
9+!OyG jQ|C #| hq"* 9| )zf UQJyGh {}gyG )yE hpO*h (fO* >ztyG ,p
j(tyG #||}yGz :| uG d(SQ d9s ,#+t+yGh f9}* G I(s #| GP$h ,IQL6Gh
xgq"* 9| )zf UQIG Q+L {v ,ph r+g]yG #||}yG #| uG )yE >ICh Q+L
GPv f9wy GPv Bzgp ,!C (y {t@ ;p A,V x<9YC f{p RGg@ :h u9< #gASGh
gGhQ( .yf9a+WyG {}f KAq@ (y f{p {gp A9V 9|h uG QOs {s #wyh GPvh
.)~zT|
&+zf )]s jPyG {FQzy | )="yG &y9s 9| &y d(t"p {S9wA}yG WQq}yG 9|C
,RGgyG )zf e(z* uG fEz :| d9tp {+v(yG ~g!h uG 9"=TI d9tp ?+]s ,p
(<C gGhQ( .y{+v(yG ~g!h uG ,=TI {tp Q|C x=zi GP{p U+wy9< x+zf #wyh
)O}ICh OhGO
?|}G JOtp {$h ?|}G H9YC jPyG 9| ,9"+zf Kz* jPyG dG|TyGh
~|}G AGO 969YC Os ?|}G fC :HG(GyGh ?9$Q(%ch ?|}G Rf #*Ch ,9%A*Q+L
A9DjyG {D| A9Di JQ9Zp ,^i9=AyGh OS9JAyGh ,9+!OyG ,p Up9"AyG #| 9%z=s
<;
:9 8 7 6 o &+p Q+L ;p &+tz*h {+TyG &z}J* jPyG
.

:f

]17

?*6G :OfQq yG[

pD

C
B A @?
> =

9<(C E*OI )p d9tp Q+Z}yG GP$ #f &<9JYC | )="yG KOv I Osh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

386

{ 9s 9tp y9%AgZs )yE ?zv}G )fGO@ 9}v ~|}G ~w+zf )fGO@ fC xV(*z
A9Djv A9Di ~w"wyh Q+Dv P8|(* ~A!C {<z :d9s ?&zyG d(SQ 9* #J! ?zs #|
,p uG #pPt+yh ,~w"| ?<9%}yG ~vhOf QhOY #| uG #fR"+yh ,{+TyG
?+$GQvh 9+!OyG >Iz :d9s ?&zyG d(SQ 9* #o $r (n yG 9|h :G(y9tp ,y#n $r (n yG ~w<(zs
.yJ(}yG
,9%z=s ~|}G AGO 969YC #+I 97O9+sh 97O9*Qh 9$Rf ?|}G JOtp Otp fPE
.uG A9V fE {+ZqAyG #| A,W< 9%y VQg! a(S H9=SC xyPyh
9%qg\ ~iQ ,%p ,dG(I}G #| d9J< ?|}G #| YRA"@ : ,%p ?*Q+MyG 9|C
#*Q$9c ,A|C #| ?qF9_ dGR@ :z QO9!h R*Rf &"wyh ,Q+L 9%+p dGR@ : 9%yP9<h
)zf ~$h uG Q|C ,@z* )AI ~%yPL #| :h ~%qy9L #| ~$Q]* : uJyG )zf
.)&+zf uqA|( .yxyP
o
f(JzZ*h ,S9"yG OTp GPE f(JzZ* #*PyG ?|}G ,p A9<QjyG ~$ A:|$h
:d(t* PE | uG d(SQ bOYh ,?<QjyG #|R ,p ?"TyG #| S9"yG gOTpC 9|
9| f(JzZ*o #*PyG A9<Qjzy )<(ap CO< 9}v 9=k *Qi O(g+Sh 9=k *Qi e;S G CO<z
.y,A"S #| jOg< #| S9"yG OTpC
l
n l n n l
n n n
n
.)~zT| O"f &zYCh K+Jp Y #TI E*Op I GP$ :)T+fp (<C d9s(
KzZ@ J:9t}yG #| ?f(}G| )=vQ}yG d9= Q(AvOzyh )O+TyG dO9f( Bzs
9$QvPC fC )A+! )p f9vh ?+fQWyG ?S9+TyG ~S9< H9Av )p ?f(}G| QW"@ )wy
9%AY;L &+qp xy &@QvP 9| B=MA!9p H9AwyG ~M]A* fC B+WL )"wyh
.969=yh
9*9]tyG gP$ )p [ZMA| )=vGQ}yG Q(AvOyG fC ~*QwyG Q9tyG ~zg+yh
#+< ?+|;S G ?p;MyG( fG("g< B!9v gGQ(AvOyG ?FQO {+"y 9$OfC )AyG &Ay9SQh
.)IQY9g}yG ~wJyG ~d!
hC : F d

387

? +fQW y

? | 9|

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9< ?tzgA}yG hFGQPyG OS

~v9JyG

)zf

Lh Q M y Gh

OGOfE
iO+"GyG
e 9 g yG

&+zf

Y9}AF:Gh

Qv9V

uG

O=f

.O

U+FQyG >F9!

OIGh e9|E >+Z"@

H (F h

9"$ #|h ,&< 9+!OyG ?S9+Sh #*OyG eqJy BfQV ?|9| G fC e(zg}yG #|
,?f9}GyG &< f(w@h ,H(ztyG &+zf h}A: OIGh e9|E O(Fh )yE e;S G 9fO
QI9"@ #| ~%"+< ht* fC #w}* 9}y ,a;AL:Gh bQqAzy I9fO| ?}F}G OOg@h
?g*QPy GOk S OIGh e9|E )yE I(fOyG e;S G ?g*QV #| f9v GPy ,b9tVh
?"TyGh fBQtyG #| xyP )zf ?yO}G ^g< ,$ 9$h ,a;AL:Gh bQqAyG
k
:~*QwyG fBQtyG ?yOC ::hC
p_ ^ ] \ [ Z Y X W Vo :)y9g@ d9s
.

S R Q P O

N
M L
K
.

]46

?*6G

:d

9q!}G[ p!@
! y{
n

]59

x
?*6G :A9T"yG[

o :)y9g@ d9sh

W V UT

?f9_h uG ?f9a< #+"||}yG ?f9= uG Q|z* #+A}*QwyG #+A*6G #+@9$ ,p


~%"+< YGR! KOJ* : )AI ,&Aqy9M| eOfh &A}zv )zf Y9}AF:Gh | d(SQ
.f9A*6G &"| JQPI 9| ht+p
gP$ ,p uG G(g+_Cz :?+!9DyG ?*7y &IQV ,p 9\Q O+VQ N+WyG d(t*
&y(SQ G(g+_Ch ,9$Q+i ,ph d9AtyG ,p M;qyG H9=SC )yE IOVQ}yG Q|Gh}G
uG e;wy #+=}yG &!E E+I #| 9$Q+ih d9AtyG f(8V #| &"f )%"*h &< Q|z* 9}+p

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

388

~wJyGh {}gyGh d(ty9< &y Pq"}yGh ,&"| )y9g@ gO*Q* 9| )zf &+yE dR!C iPyG
jPyG e9d"yG Y9= ,$ e9gyG OF9tyG ?f9ap ,d9AtyG ,p ?|9gyG IO9+tyG ?*:h &"|h
.)24 / 10 L Q9"}yG Q+Tq@( .yQqdyG f9vQC #| #vQ ($
#*QTq}yG ^g< d9s :&+="@ :?*7y &IQV Og< gQ+Tq@ ,p )}S9tyG d9sh
&< ~vQ|C 9}+p G(qzA< : :jC ?*6 9q!} pO N
o :)y9g@ &y(s ,p
H(Fh GP$ #| Q}DASG :d(t* fC {F9tyh :d9s ,~w*CQ uqA+y {< ,O9%GyG #|
&Af9_ ehRz< &!{p ,~%p;ALG hat*h ~$Q|C Q<O+y X+GyG )zfQ+|C >Z!
Q|C fEh G(g+_Ch G(g}SG :d9sh ,9*GQTyG ,p | &zgp Osh a;AL:G hat"*
.)121 / 13 iQ9M=yG( .y)W=I O=f ~w+zf
k
:?*(="yG ?"TyG ?yOC :9+!9C
~%S(T@ {+FGQSE ("< B!9vz :d9s | )="yG #f
IQ*Q$ ,<C #f -1
A9qzL f(wASh ,jOg< ,=! : &!Eh ,,=! &qzL ,=! xz$ 9}zv A9+=!}G
,~%tI ~$(afC ,dh}9p dh}G ?g+=< G(p :d9s ?9!Q|z@ 9}p G(y9s ,fhQDw+p
.)1480 / 3 ~zT|(.y~$9fQASG 9}f ~%zF9S uG f{p
?q+zMy h*(< GPE :E*OJyG GP$ )"g|hz :E*OJyG MQV ,p ih("yG d9s
eQJ* ?z_9< ,!9DyG ?g+<h ,96 A9p(yG >G* ?J+JY dh}G ?g+=p ?q+zL Og<
Otg* fC R(G* : &!C )zf A9}zgyG uq@Gh ,9%=z_ &+zf eQJ*h ,96 A9p(yG
e9|E d9sh ,: eC e;S G QGO BgT@G AG(S ,OIGh QZf ,p #+Aq+zMy
:d9s ,#+ZMWy 9$Otf R(G* : :9"<9JYC d9s :O9VQ G &<9Av ,p #+|QJyG
o
GP$h ,)IOIGh ?+I9!( OIGh htY ,p #+"C: 9$Otf R(G* : &!C jO"fh
d9}AI;zp Y(TV 9}%"+< Bzz<h #+|9| G #+< 9| Og< f{p :d9s ,&+zf h}G|
#f d(tyG GP$ jQR9}yG )wIh ,h_G(tyG #| LQ9L ($h :d9s .d9G| &+p
OS9p d(s ($h #+|QJyG e9|E &< OGQCh d(Y}G {$C #| #*QLzA}yG ^g<
y~zfC uGh .E*O9I}G b;_E Q$G(dyGh rzMyGh rzTyG &+zf 9}y ry9M|
,

]46

G :d

G[

389

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

F ~zT| )zf ih("yG MQV(


h*(< GPE &!Cz :)"g}yGh ,A9p(yG #| Q|C {gp yG(pz :QGI #<G d9sh
,!9DyG ?g+<h ,96 A9p(yG >G* ?J+JY dh}G ?g+=p ,?q+zL Og< ?q+zMy
.)497/6 iQ9=yG KAp(.y?z_9<
?|9| G ,p OIGh e9|E )zf Y9}AF:G #vS | &!Ez : ?+}+@ #<G d9sh
h| ,xyP Q+ih a(MyG I;Y ,ph A9tTAS:Gh #*O+gyGh ?g}GyG ,ph iQ=wyG
,p 9}y ,?+zY}G I;ZyG d(ZI )yE HQsC a(MyG I;Y ,p #+|9|E f(v
)zf YQ9WyG ?dp9J| fE ~C ,~}%yG BAW@h H(ztyG u*Qq@ a(L #| u*QqAyG
O\ )yE ,]q* Os 9}f gQFRh #+=yG JGP M;Yh ?f9}Gy9< e9ZAf:G IOf9s
?qy}G {F9S(y YQW* xyP {vh ,b=]"* O9w* : J9pQZAyG h+= ,p xyP
?f(}G|( y9]k *C d9gp}G #| ,$h ?sQqyG hFGQP #f QFRh ,d9gp}G #| ,$h
.)144 / 3 iQ=wyG ih9AqyG
?|9| G ,p OIGh e9|E )zf Y9}AF:9< Q|C YQ9WyG fEz :~+tyG #<G d9sh
I;Y f(v h| ,a(MyG I;Yh A9tTAS:Gh #*O+gyGh ?g}GyG ,ph ,iQ=wyG
u*QqAyG ?g*QPy GOk S xyPh ,#|}G I;Y d(ZI )yE HQsC #+|9|{< a(MyG
~dfC #| GP$h ,?}zwyG ry5@h H(ztyG Y9}AF: 9=k z_h ,YR9"AyGh a;AL:Gh
?*(T@ ,p )AI ,u*Q_ {w< &]s9"* 9| )yE ?g*QPyG OS Osh ,YQWyG OY9t|
.yQvP@ fC #| QDvC xyP O$G(Vh ,H(ztyG rzA< ;8y ,I;ZyG ,p rZyG
.)118/3 #+gs(}yG e;fE(
&zyG ?+Zg| Q+i ,p &Af9_h ~v9JyG )zf LhQMyG cQ@
~y9dyG ~zT}yG ~v9JyG )zf LhQMyG eOf ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C iQ*
k
IOTq}y GOS xyPh ,MG(=yG QqwyG )yE gQ(Fh &}zc {Z* ~y 9| ,QF9GyG
O;=yG ,p )\(qyG Q9WA!Gh ,A9|OyG ?sGQE #| &+zf >@QA* 9|h ,&+zf LhQMyG
.)231 U 12 v

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

390

z* 9| ?"TyG #| xyP )zf ?yO}Gh O9=gyG #+<h


)zf | uG d(SQ 9"g*9<z :d9s - - B|9ZyG #< IO9=f E*OI -1
)zfh ,9"+zf IQCC )zfh ,gQw}yGh bW"}yGh QT+yGh QTgyG ,p ?f9ayGh h}TyG
uqA|( yf9$Q< &+p uG #| ~vO"f 9Ik G(< GQk qv GhQ@ fC :E ,&z$C Q|}G YR9"! :C
.)&+zf
| uG d(SQ Bg}S :d9s - ,gGV}G xy9| #< a(f #f -2
w
w
f(zZ*h ~%+zf f(zZ@h ~w!(=J*h ~8(=; #*PyG ~wA}FC Q9+L :d(t*
.~w!("gz*h ~8("gz@h ~w!(]j=*h ~8(]j=@ #*PyG ~wA}FC QGQVh ,~w+zf
~w+p G(|9sC 9| : :d9s ,xyP O"f ~$P<9"! ;pC ,uG d(SQ 9* 9"zs :G(y9s
,@z* 9| gQw+zp uG ?+Zg| #| 98k +V ,@z* gBQp dGh &+zf )yh #| :C ,I;ZyG
k
.y?f9_ #| GO* #fR"* :h uG ?+Zg| #|
)1481 / 3 ~zT| &FQLC(
LhQMyG cQ@ :O+q@ ,$h ,)"g}yG GP$ d(I IQ+Dv E*O9IC JOQh Osh
h| ?+Zg}yG ,p &Af9_ eOfh ,ahQg}yG ,p ?f9ayG H(Fhh ,?}F}G )zf
?"TyG {$C E*O9I}G gP6 {}gyGh d(tyG )yE >$P Osh .9%"| ,@z* 9| ?$GQv
.?f9}GyG
: E*OJyG )"g|hz :gQvP u<9TyG IO9=f E*OJy &IQV ,p ih("yG d9s
GQk w"| ~%"| GhQ@ fC :E ~%+zf G(\QAg@ :h ~%A*:h ,p Q(|}G I:h G(fR9"@
k
G(y(sh ,~%+zf ghQw!zp xyP ~A*CQ GP{p ,e;S G OfG(s #| &!(}zg@ 9ttJ|
,#+}zT}yG Y9={< eGQJp ~%y9Ash ~%+zf LhQMyG 9|Ch ,~A"v 9| E+I uJy9<
d9s .&@QvP 9| )"g}< E*O9I}G JQ$9d@ Osh ,#+}y9c ?tTp G(!9v fEh
#| xyP )zf >@QA* 9| &+zf LhQMyG ~*Q;h &yGRg!G eOf >=Sh :A9}zgyG
,p 9%"| QDvC &yRf ,p IOTq}yG f(wAp #+=yG JGP O9Tph A9|OyG ?sGQEh #AqyG
:)

391

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~zT| )zf ih("yG MQV( y&F9t<


Q|C Os 9| - h\(}yG GP$ Q+i ,p QQt@h V9qASG Oshz :?+}+@ #<G d9sh
,p ~%+zf Q=ZyGh ~%AJY9"|h uG ?+Zg| Q+i ,p AGQ|}G ?f9_ #| - | &<
,p ~%Ag<9A| #| xyP (J!h ~%qzL I;ZyGh ~%g| hRjyGh ,~%}Tsh ~%}wI
,i(tAyGh Q=yG )zf fh9gAyG H9< #| &!{p ,~$ :E 96 e(t* : ,AyG J9"TJyG
?+Zg| ,p ~%Af9_h ~%}zc )zf ~%A!9fEh ~6Pw< ~%t*OZ@ #| &"f )8 9|h
o no
dGR* :h .fGhOgyGh ~C G )zf fh9gAyG H9< #| ($ 9}| xyP (J!h uG
($ 9}v #AqyG e9t@h ,M;Ty9< ~%+zf LQM* E+J< ,&"| Qw!C ($ 9}< Qw"}yG
?*(="yG U(Z"yG &+zf ByO 9}vh ,?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C d(YC #| ahQg|
uG Y9a* {< ,~%}zc #| f(w* 9| O9Tp )zf (<Q* jPyG O9TqyG #| xyP ,p
:ih9AqyG Y(}G|( .y&"f )8 9| cQA*h &< Q|C 9| {gq*h ,~$Q+i ,ph ~%+p
.)229 / 12

.)21,20 / 35

9azTyG ?f9_ H(Fh )zf A9%tqyG h=C Oshz :QGI #<G ep9JyG d9sh
#| xyP ,p 9}y ,&+zf LhQMyG #| Q+L &Af9_ fCh ,&g| O9%GyGh >zjA}yG
.)7 / 13 :iQ9=yG KAp( .yA9}$OyG #+wT@h A9|OyG #tI
- ?}F}G )zf LhQMyGh AGQ|}G d9As #f | )="yG )8z :~+tyG #<G d9sh
QWyGh ~+dgyG O9TqyG ?g*QPy GOk S ,I;ZyG G(|9sC 9| -GhQ9F hC G(}zc fEh
~%+zf LhQMyGh ~%y9As >=T< {ZI &!{p ,hsG(yG ($ 9}v ~%y9At< Q+DwyG
e;fE( .yf6G )yE QhQWyG xz@ 9*9t< ,p ?|}Gh ,&+zf ~$ 9| a9g\C
.)130 / 3 :#+gs(}yG
LhQMyG f(}zT}yG HQF Oshz :)}zg}yG )+J* #< #}IQyG O=f d9sh
~C ,uJyG fhO*Q* ~8C fhQ* f9}Df )zf S9"yG LQL ,QWyG :E &"| GhQ* ~zp
B!9wp uJyG f(=za* 9}!E ~8C ~%}dg|h ~$D9SDQ iQ* {}GyG {$C LQL
,?+|C ,"< ?yhO BTSz@h ,I(="yG ?p;L Bgat!G fC ,AyGh 9+AzyG Og< xyP IQ}C
f

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

392

QL ~C ,I9Sz}yG xz@ B!9wp &+yE Qa\G 9| )yE ,zf #< #+TJyG Qa\G ~C
#| jQC(wyG >+!z@ ,p OQh 9}y {+w"AyG( .yIQJyG ?gsh B!9wp ?"*O}yG {$C
.)99 / 1 {+_9<}G
e;S G JGQAp #| IQAp ,p IQ+=wyG LhQMyG OS9q| )}zg}yG OQS GPw$h
k
A9F GP%y ,?+|;S G ?|}G )zf gQ9CBh LhQMyG GP$ JGQ}C 9"+=| ,?}+dgyG
?sGQE h"}y ?+zF b<G(\ ?"TyG {$C ?}FC h\hh ,H9=yG OT< ~+wJyG YQWyG
k
.Y9+]yGh bR}AyG #| #+}zT}yG )zf 9c9qIh A9|OyG
L

393

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?"GzyG (]fh IQGO G UzG| (]f ihO< ~+dgyG O=f Q(AvOyG d9sh
IOgtyG iP OOf O+I(AyG ?zG}< Q(W"}yG &y9t| ?*98 )p e9gyG RvQ}y9< ?+}zgyG
:fG("g< iPyGh v$1416 ?"S
}

yf 9 | G h

#| } Gz

h\G(| ,p JQvPh ?*6G gP$ ,p QvP@ ~y ,AyG b(tJyG ~dfC #|h


v
v
.e(wJ}yGh ~v9JyG uI ,?+fQyGh ,fGQyG uI ~*QwyG fBQtyG #| iQLC
~v9Jzy {gF 9}v ,9ts I ~v9JyG )zf >gWzy {gF Os e;S G fE
:h ,dOgy9< ~%}wJ* fC ~v9JyG )zf >gWyG uJp ,9ts I >gWyG )zf
#| fC 9}v ,{Fh Rf uG YQV ,p :E dOf :h ,uG H9Av ,p :E dOf
,#*OyG :U}MyG J9*QhQ]yG &y ,}J* fC ~v9JyG )zf >gWyG uI
>Fh &tI >gWzy ~v9JyG iOC GP{p ,d9}yG ,{tgyGh ,VQgyG ,I9+JyG
A9+yhC ?f9a< ~|}G Q|C Os )y9g@ uG f{p ,&tI ~v9Jzy jO|* fC >gWyG )zf
^ ] \ [ Z Y X W Vo :&!9J=S d9tp ,Q(|}G
)1 (

]59

x
? *6 G : A 9 T " y G [ p

)Zf Otp ,!9Zf #|h ,uG Y9_C Otp )"f9_C #|z :| )="yG d9sh
efh 9}yh .)2(y)!9Zf Otp Q+|}G [g* #|h ,,"f9_C Otp Q+|}G ha* #|h
k
,f(+gyG 9%"| BpQPh ,H(ztyG 9%"| BzFh ,?j+z< ?df(| 9|(* &<9JYC
x
i(tA< ~w+YhCz :| d9tp ,9"Yhzp YO(| ?df(| 98zv uG d(SQ 9* :G(y9s
~w"| Xg* #| &!{p ,,W=I O=f ~w+zf Q|x z@ fEh ,?f9ayGh h}TyGh ,uG
k
#+*O%}yG #*OVGQyG A9qzMyG ?"Sh ,A"T< ~w+zgp ,GQk +Dv 9p;ALG iQ+Tp jOg<
,?fO< ?COJ| {v f{p ,Q(|}G J9COJ|h ~v9*Eh ,PFG("y9< 9%+zf G(]f

,uG

! ~ }

| {z yxw

{ A

9T"yG IQ(S #| 36 ~sQ ?*6G )1(


.}....

.)F

"

9T"yGh &F9| #<Gh ~zT|h iQ9M=yG )2(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

394

?y;\ ?fO< {vh


e;fC BpQpQ ,&tI ~v9Jzy >gWyG iOCh ,&tI &=gWy ~v9JyG iOC GP{p
.?|}G gP$ b(ph ,>gWyG GP$ b(p ,e;TyGh ~zTyGh ,f9|}Gh #|}G
~y (y ?|}G h"Z@ GP9| ?9%tI ,p ~v9JyG QZv s (y ?|}G h"Z@ GP9| #wy
k
#f ,Q=Zy9< e;S G 9!9Yv h ?&A|Ch &=gV (J! &+zf uG >FhC 9}< ~v9JyG ~t*
!&zyG d(SQ 9* :G(y9tp y98hQw"@ Q(|Ch IQCC f(wAS 98Ez :d9s &!C | ,="yG
iPyG uG f(yzT@h ,~w+zf jPyG fhO|@z :d9s ?xyP 9"| O%V #| Q|z@ GP9}p
. y~wy
~%+zf f(zZ@h ~w!(=J*h ~8(=; #*PyG ~wA}FC Q9+Lz :| d9sh
~8("gz@h ,~w!(]j=*h ~8(]j=@ #*PyG ~wA}FC QGQVh ~w+zf f(zZ*h
G(|9sC 9| ,:z :d9s ?r+TyG ~$P<9"! ;pC !&zyG d(SQ 9* G(y9s ,y~w!("gz*h
GhQ%d@h ,I;ZyG G(}+t@ fC ~wy f(!Pz* G(|GO 9| :jC , yI;ZyG ~w+p
,~%+zf G(FQ< ;p ,OF9T}yG )yE hOjyG #| ~w!(g"}* :h ,~w"*O QF9gV
?"TyG {$C f9Tz< 9%=Av ,AyG )IO+tgyG( ,p jh9JayG e9| G d9s 9"$ #|h
d9s ,)?*h9JayG IO+tgyG( v< B+}Sh ,&+yE H9TA!:9< BpQfh ,?f9}GyGh
)1(

)2 (

)3(

fO! :h ,GhQ9F fEh ,9!Q(|C I:hh 9"A}FC )zf LhQMyG iQ! :hz
{Fh Rf uG ?f9_ #| ~%Af9_ iQ!h ,~%Af9_ #| GOk * YR"! :h ,~%+zf
. y?+Zg}< GhQ|z* ~y 9| ?]*Qp
G(

)4(

F9| #<Gh iP|QAyGh OhGO (<G )1(


.g(J"< iP|QAyGh ~zT|h iQ9M=yG )2(
.~zT| )3(
.)428U( ?*h9JayG MQV Qd!G )4(
.&

395

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

^g< ,p A9F Os &!{p ,9"|9wI )zf A9fOy9< 9"Tq!C {jW"!C 9"y R(G* ;p
H(zs ,xz}yG xy9| ,uG 9!Cz :d9s &!C {Fh Rf uG #f ?t<9TyG >AwyG
,!hO=fG #wyh ,~wv(z| )zf A9fOy9< ~wTq!C G(zjW@ ;p ,jO+< c(z}yG
s
. y~w+zf ~%qafC 9tI
k
QGOY{< :h ,~zs IQv G< e9t@ ?}zT}yG ?yhOyG fC ~$(A! : fC 9g+= 9"+zgp
HQO GP%p ,f9}yQ< #| :h ,IO9+s UzG| #| :h ,U+FQ hC xz| #| QGQs
IO|AyGh ,,!zAyGh Q=Zy9< e9t@ ?}zT}yG ?yhOyG 9}!Eh ,O+g< ~$hh ,d9+MyG ,p
k
k
.9+s;LCh ,9+f9}AFGh 9*Qs wp ,(GyG ?8+7h ,?"+!z}ayGh
fC e(*h ,f(Jy9Y e9wI 9"}wJ* f} #+Jy9Y #J! f(w! fC e(*h
?yhOyG ?|9s{< 9"+zf uG #w}+o Tp ,?}zT}yG ?yhOyG ?|9s #+Jy9Y #J! f(w!
,JG(%WyG ,p #+sQ9i ,#+}y9c 9"|O9| #wyh ,uG YQV u+=a@h ,?}zT}yG
d(s QvPA"zp ,uG d(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av #f #*O+g< ,,Y9g}yG ,p #+sQ9i
.
?*6 9g!} p!@
!vw~
o :&zyG
)zf ~wy ~t@ ,~w<(zs ,p e;S G ?yhO G(}+sCz :d9s #| uG ~IQh
.y~w\QC
)1(

]129

G :e

G[

,+*)('&%

)430(

u<9TyG QOZ}yG )1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

396
9

%qWvh

J9

%=V

h+= )zf xf;_E Og<z -uJyG #f EI9=yG- ~*QwyG Q9tyG 99C xzgy
k
&AtS 9| )zf ?y:OyG K*QY &<9JYC )yE ?=T"yG K+JY 9tC(| xy &@QvP 9|
k
k
Q9=wyG N(+WyG A:|$ fC OtAg! 9"zgF 9|;v 9t<9S 9!CQs 9""wyh d(t@- y&zF}
)tqyG O|9I O}J| N+WyG ($ 9%p b;_9< ?+g\(yG #+!G(ty9< e9wJyG fhQqw*
:)y9g@ uG d(s ry|}yG QvP 9}"+I O+G}yG KAp H9Av )zf &t+zg@ )p d(t*
]50

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p@


! ! zu

+*
)( '
&%$#

"

9|OyG )p 96 f(}v9JA* #+!G(s ?G!QqyG e;v P<G #| &"| GQk Vh GP$ {D| fEz
&y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Av #| &y #+=@h ~zf 9| )zf 9%|Ot*h dG(|}Gh LhQqyGh
uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG )yE hFQ* ~yh 9%+zf QYC GPE O@Q| Qp9v xV ;< (%p |
e9+ZyGh I;ZyG d9}fC Q$G(c #| {}f iC :h &< )}T@ ~SC iC &gq"* :h
.y9$(J!h
Q+TqAyG IO}f &<9Av )zf Qv9V O}J| O}IC N+WyG &< uzf 9| xyPvh
GP$ 9!QZf )p f(zz]}yG &< >gz* 9}| -gQ+ih S9=f #<G #f- Q9C6G gP$hz
k
hC GQPf 98(zgG* #*OyG )zf ABQGyG #| ~$Q+i #|h ~zgzy #+=TA"}yG #|
QCC c9"$h .e;S G O;< )zf B<Q\ )AyG ?f(\(}yG ?+"C(yG #+!G(tzy ?I9<E
^g< h"Z* f9v 9}+p ,g9*E )LQG(MyG( ?+\9< G dGOF )p RzG| )<C #f
k
)yE GO}f ?g*QWyG ry9M* 9}< ~%F9]s ^g< )p f(}wJ+p Q(GyG #| AGQ|}G
k
.Qp9v IQ+=wyG >w@Q| fC ~%=$P| #| LQG(MyGh ,~wJy9< ;%F hC i(%yG
A:|$ Qqv #| fhQ* 9| )zf ~%tpG(* fC RzG| )<C #| fhO*Q* f(yO9G* ~%p
k
fGP$h r+Ty9< ~%+zf LhQMyG #| fhQ* 9}+p ~%y GQPf xyP f(w+y AGQ|}G
O+TyG )LC 9}%+zf >Avh )12026,12025( iQ=ayG 9}$GhQ fGQC}G
[! 9"$ B=CC fC B*CQp 9Jk *QY 9*k (s GOk F 9+k Tq! 9tk +zg@ Qv9V O}J| O(}J|
.y#+A*GhQyG )zf )LC u+zg@ ~C iQ=ayG )A*GhQ
A

397

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)tqyG( N(+Wzy e;v #| &@OQhC 9| cOGQ*Eh xyG|S )zf ?<9F5yh


k
:)y9g@h &!9J=S u9< 9"+gAT| d(sC )Qv9V O(}J| ,Qv9V O}IC
k
fG(LEz ?f9= ~%Tq!C )zf G(tz_C -9}*Os- R9GJyG O;< )p ?f9= JzW!
Q|}G ?GJ< O(gS dB R*RgyG O=f xz}yG )zf G(FQLh yuG Y9_ #|
9}| f9vh ?+qzTyG I(fOyG A9}zf ~%y iOZAp Qw"}yG #f )%"yGh ahQg}y9<
9}%}IQ- iQt"gyG R*RgyG O=f #< uG O=fh r+azyG O=f #< O}J| N+WyG &y9s
)zf d9=s}9< f9|RyG GP$ QLB )p OG! ?*O9< )zf #v| 9}y uG f{pz Og< 9|C -uG
I(s ~%"| f9a+WyG iCQh QWA!Gh ~%+p xyP QDvh &< {}gyGh e;S G #*O ~zg@
)AyG )yh}G ~%y9I )zf ~$OQ* fC ~%"| U8* Q+MyG )zf 9Yk QIh xyP )p
>y9s )p 9%zgFh 9%"*Rh ~%y 9%"Tv I QWyG HG(<C KAp )p PLzp 9%"| G(ztA!G
#|h ~+$GQ<E ?z}< f(wT}A}yG ~%p 96 PLC #| fCh #*OyG )p ?<;ZyGh I(tyG
.y#+gzyG O+v #| O(%g}yG ($ GP$h ~+$GQ<E ?z| cQ@ Otp 9%vQ@
A9}zf e97G :#+"*OA}yG ^g< )zf f9a+WyG {LOC 9}|h :d9s ~C
f9|QJy >=S GP$h ~%"f PL}G eOfh ~6 #dyG A(Sh ?"$GO}y9< #+}zT}yG
~zgyG )tzA* ;p ,f9w|h f9|R {v )p A9+=!}G ?CQh ~$ A9}zgyGh ,hp9"yG ~zgyG
v
KGQ+| )p O$R Otp g(zt! 9| {=t* ~yh ~%"f PL}G )p O$R #}p ~%"f :E
~%y ?*GQO : #*PyG #+a<9MyG ?z%GyG dG(sz< &"f V9AfGh #+zSQ}yG O+S
rzw| {v )zf >FG(p uG #*O )zf A9"|}G ~$ A9}zgyGh ,?g*QWyG e9wIz<
#}f GhQd!9p #*O ~zgyG GP$ fEz rzTyG ^g< d9s 9}v &z$C #f #*OyG PLC
~yh #+ttJ}yG A9}zgyG e;v #| X9qyC Q$G(d< uzg@ #| 9|zp y~w"*O fhPLz@
?f(}G| 9"AGI :d9s 9}<Qh &}%p )zf O}Ag* {< A9}zgyG )zf 9%\Qg*
GP$ f{p e;wyG xyP< gO(Zt| aQg* : ($h )!;qyG ~y9gyG e;v hC O+I(AyG
d9s (zp R*RgyG uG e;v &JYCh e;wyG ~dfC fC e(zg}yG #|h .d;\h {%F
Q+i )zf &yhv C hC g9"g| aQg* : eqy Q$9d< uzg@h ,fBQtyG :E {=t! 9| :f9T!E
,

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

398

#f fBQty9< )qAvG #| d9I GP$ f9v GP{p #+sQ9}yG LQG(MyG )$9\ Otp &z*hz@
OGQ* 9| :h 9$9"g| aQg* : ($h >AwyG X9qyz< uzg@ #}< r+wp ?"TyG
?9%c9qyz<
O+t}yGh uza}yGh r+g]yGh K+JZyG :E*O9I}G #| 9%+p 9]k *C >AwyGh
O9t"yG A9}zgyG #f )|9gyG PLz* ~y GP{p N(T"}yGh NS9"yGh U9MyGh e9gyGh
g9@h i(Wf b=L b=Lh ?]qyGh >$Pzy ?pQ9+ZyG ?yR"}< E*OJzy ~$ jPyG
)"jAT* &!C )fO* iPyG fC #+=@ GP$ aQf GPEz d9s ~C .9+k }f ?y9%F OmGh )p
QvP | )="yG f} raM| #+}zT}yG A9}zf #f PL}G #f O+I(AyG ?f(}G}<
k
:9%F A9SDQ S9"yG P<G A9}zgyG >$P GP{p A9}zgyG J(| ~zgyG ^=s >=S fC
k
.u9< GP9+f G(z\Ch G(z\ ~$G(Aq< GhPLCh ~$(yzSh
k
f{p &y ?f9ayG eOfh Q|}G )y(< #dyG IA9SE :9]*C f9a+WyG {LOC 9}|h
?f9ayGh h}TyG fhQ* : #*PyG ?+z$9GyG #*O #| ($h )Y9g}yG ~dfC #| GP$
)p ?"TyGh H9AwyG #| ?yO}G JQ$9d@ Osh &*CQ< O=AT* ~%"| {v {< 9"k *O
)AI gQw}yGh bW"}yGh QT+yGh QTgyG )p Q|}G )y(y ?f9ayGh h}TyG H(Fh
&A+Zg| eQJAp ycQ%c HQ\h xy9| PLC fEh h_Ch h}SGz :d9s
QQOyG hFGQ y&@O$9g|h &@Os9g| )ph &Az|9g| )ph &A*:h )p &+zf VGQAf}Gh
.)135-127/9( O9%GyG H9Av ?+"TyG
l
)tyGh xyP ~wy #*R ~zgyG )fO* #}| OIC f9v f{p ...z 9%=Av ?y9SQ )p d9sh
&!C G(}zf9p J:;]yGh YO=yG {$C ?t*Q_ ~wy #TIh J9%+=WAyGh J9w+wWAyG ~w+zf
&g| fC )fO* f9v f{p ~w"*O ~w+zf U=z*h gQ+v &+qM* 9| ~wy iO=* A(S N9q"|
k
&*Oy 9}< 9"+yE RQ=+zp ~%F9}zfh I:(yGh ?}F:G )zf #gayG )p ?"TyGh H9AwyG #| ;+yO
?"Sh uG H9Av #| ?g_9TyG #+$GQ=yGh ?g_9tyG HGJy9< fhQc9"|h f(z<9t| &y #J"p
#f VQ9g}yG OQ@h g9}f >ztyG #f (z: )AyG #+*O%}yG A9qzMyG IQ+Sh | O}J| &+=!
.)104/9( ?+"TyG QQOyG y&S9wA!G

399

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

&zJA!G 9}|h ...z fG(L}G )yE u+Af #< O}I #< OgS N+WyG >Avh
{$9TAyGh #+}zT}yG ?*:(< a9qMAS:G :#*QhQj}yG ?z%GyG A:|$ ^g<
.gQ+ih hRjy9< &+zf J9+Ap:Gh &Af9_ #f LhQMyGh #+}zT}yG e9|E ?qy9M}<
iP {v xyP aQg* f9w}< O9Tqy9< VQ}G )p )gTyGh {%GyG #| GP$h
:h ?f9}G< :E #*O : &!C e;S G #*O #| IQhQ]y9< ~zf Osh f9}*Eh {tf
Q|C )yh ?f9_ #f LhQMyG fCh ?f9_h h}T< :E ?|9|E :h ?|9|{< :E ?f9=
{+=S #f dhOgyGh O9=gyGh O;=yG )p O9TqyG H9=SC ~dfC #| #+}zT}yG
~zgyG {$C e97G #| A:|$ I;i #| hsh 9| xyP #|hz d9s ~C O9VQyGh iO%yG
Rf uG Q|G #| ~%+zf >Fh 9}< e9+tyG cQ@h Q+ZtAyG )yE ~%A=T!h #*OyGh
~zgyG {$C H9+AiG fC A:|$ QO* ~yh uJyG #| f(}zg* 9| f9}Avh {Fh
d9s #+=| K\Gh ~CEh #+pO AGOh {@9s ~S #+"||}yG VGQfz< &wqAyGh #*OyGh
A @ ? > = < ; : 9 8o :)y9g@
.)139/9( ?+"TyG QQOyG(
?*6
R I } p !@
!z} C B
fC Og< :)240-239/5( ?"TyG L9%"| )p ?+}+@ #<G e;S G N+V d(t*h
YO=yG {$C u*Qay ~%Aqy9M|h ~$Q+ih ?g<Q}G ?}F}G #| ~zgyG {$C dG(sC QvP
.ry9M}yG Q+qw@ )p
v
f(w*h dG(s}G ^g< d9s #| Qqv &!C ~$OIC #f {t"* Os #wyhz
{v Qqw* fC GQk qv d(tyG f9v GPE eRz* :h ,QPJ+y Qqv d(tyG GP$ fC gO(Zt|
J(=Dv #+g}yG [MWyG uI )p QqwyG J(=C f{p {*hzAyGh {%GyG h| &y9s #|
v $. G yh!G(|h WhQV &y xyPh &tI )p IQL6G )p O+f(yG
A9fOE U+yh -uJ<- #++qzTyG ~zgyG {$C #f ?=+ayG J:(t"yG gP$ Og<
.?IQ9=y9< ?z+zyG &=VC 9| :d(sC
9| ~%A*:(< GhOAg* ~yh -9"!9|R {$C #|- ~$QZf e9wI GhQqv v #*Py9p
]58

G :HG

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

400

Q$G(d< uzgAyGh O*OF H(C )p ?}*OtyG J9%=WyG Uq! )$ 9}!Eh O*OG< G(@C
#| U+y GP$h B*CQ 9}v ~zgyG {$C ^g=y c9"$ #| hC 9"$ #| IQC9"A| J9}zv
)yE :E iOC 9}y &%Fh )zf e;wyG ~%p (zp :Eh A)V )p ~zgyG {$C {+=S
k
:9!9+< cO*RzSh ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C IO9F
HQjyG OFG(| )zf G(<Q@ #*PyG d9FQyG #| ?f(}G}< 9!A9}zf )zA<G Oty
QZgyG ?jz< f(zD}*h )p9tDyG hRjzy hF;_h Q9}gAS;y IQS9}S f(z}g* G(!9vh
)zf A9]tyG fhO*Q* ?+I9<Eh O9JyE I9fO G(!9vh U|9MyG Q(<9ay9< )}T* 9|
f9}* G A9qg\ )yE ~%F9J*{< ?g*QWyG d(YC )p x+wWAyGh ?|}G gP$ #*O
gP$ rz< >=S ($ &< xT}AyGh #*OyG 9}!Eh ~89|Ry KzZ@ : 98C S(q"yGh
gP$ ?t+tI f("+=* A9}zgyG BzgF )AyG JGA9fO:G gP$ QLB )yE ..?|}G
9%G<O )AyG J:9t}yG #| f(y x< Q| Osh- 9$AGQh rt* #| ?t+tIh ih9fOyG
~$ A:|$h .IOI;}yG A:|$ )zf OQzy i(="yG iO%yG ?zG| )p 9!D9}zf
&=Av 9| )yE Qd!Gh ?+g\(yG #+!G(ty9< ~wJyG ?+]s )p 9!D9}zf ~%+"g* #*PyG
GhQd!9pz d9s ?sQTyG OI )zf &t+zg@ )p Q+TqAyG IO}f )p Qv9V O}IC N+WyG
9"+zf G(<Q\h 9""*O< G(=gy !!fhQ}gAT}yG fhQW=}yG 9!DGOfC 9"< {gp 9| )yE
~Cz d(t* &+yE h}ASGh &y(SQh uG ~wI 96 G(MT! ?|QG| ?!(gz| ?+"Ch #+!G(s
k
G(g\hh ~wJyG GP$ ^j< ~6(zs )p ~$(<QVG ,9"+yE f(=TA"* 9S9! 9"+p G(<Q
#F9}yG QZgyG GP$ >S9"* : S9s ~wI GP$ fE .QqwyG ?}zv ~%A"TyC ,zf
f9wp !~$QO"@h ~%A*QMS h\(| ~wJyG GP$ G(zgFh !?wA%A}yG ?+!O}yG QZf
yU(ZzyG #| a(y}G J98}< 9$OIh 9!O;< )p f(GTyG J~A|G fC GP$ #f
k
:E ~$O"f U+zp ~%"+_9SC #| GQk +Dv :9FQ ~%"| ByO9F Otyhz :d(t* ~C
^*Q| :E ($ fE eQG}yG fCh QZgyG GP$ >S9"* : GP$ )p fBQtyG ~wI fC
> o &"+g< ~wJyG GP$ )p &!9J=S uG d(s f(T"* ~C &<9tf : &F;f >G*
)1 (

xy JQvP #}f ~zwA* 9}!Eh e9wJyG #f ~zwA* : &!C GOk F GOk F K\Gh )1(

401

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9 y :|$ >$P* #*zp .... ?*6 O 9}y pC


BA @?
~+}Y #|h IO+tgyG ~+}Y #| )$ #+}zT}yG #J!- -9!O"f- ?yzT}yG
-&"f f(=iGQyG hC hatyG OI fhQw"}yG e;S5y f(=TA"}yG A:|%p f9}* G
&!z< f("||ApC .~g! f(y(t+Tp ?uzMyG GP$ uzL &!z<h u9< f("||@C ~%yzT"S
k
iO$ &!Oy #| fBQtyG GP$ &+zf dR!Ch uJyG #*Oh iO%y9< GO}J| &y(SQ {SQC
k
gP$ fz< f("||ApC .~g! f(y(t+Tp ?~$9+!Oh ~%"*O )p ~%y 9I;YEh S9"zy
.~g! f(y(t+Tp ?fBQtyG #|
?*6 O 9}y p; : o 9%"+g< ?*6G
{v )ph f9w| {v )ph f9|R {v )p S9"zy eRz| ~F9s uG h*QW@ fz< f("||ApC
.~g! f(y(t+Tp ?d9I
#}|- H9FC #| 9|C !?f(|(t@ YQV iC )zfh ?f(pQZ@ )!zp fPE
&"| 9"iQp Otp : :fz< J:G|TyG gP$ #| dG|S iC )zf -e;S G )yE >TA"*
#| fC -)|C hC rtD| {$9F hC ~y9f #| ~zT| {v #t*C Osh .gQ+Z| 9"pQfh
.IOQyG Iz}I )p iOQ@h e;S G #| LQL Otp y:z GP$ #| A)V )p d(t*
#yh GP$ )p ~%yO9G! #zp e;S5y #+=TA"}yG GOf #|h #+}zT}yG GOf #| 9|Ch
k
fC :E GO<C 9"f G(\Q* #yh 9"|B 9| {D}< G("||* ~y PE &"f E*OJyG )p ~$Q*9T!
k
.xyP #| u9< GP9+fh !~%y(s {D| d(t!
k
&!E- ?N+WyG ~zwA* #}f 9$Q+i )ph {< ?y9t}yG gP$ )p GOF K\Ghh
($ 9}< N+WyG 9"}7: xyP 9"}%p (y {< ?A9SDQyGh c(z}yG #f ~zwA* : h=ay9<
k
#dyG A)T@ fC u9< cP+fCh xyP #| g9V9Ih :hC &"f g9!QvP 9| )p Q< &"|
&y(s hFQ! fC 9"|Rz@ ?+}zgyG OfG(tyG {< xy9%}yG )p iOQAAp ~zgyG {$z<
MO| )ph {<- gQZf e9wI ?*:(< aGQAf:G )p &=Av iPyG K\G(yG Q$9dyG
OIC #| r+zw@ fhO<h- 9fk (aA| ~%"f Y9pOyG )ph {< -x< Q| 9}v ~%]g<
?d+qI Q9CC iPyG Q|}G J9|97:G hW<9< ~%+zf #+FQ9MyGh ~%+z@9s ~7G {<
&y9t| )zf u+zgAyG )p xy B"+< 9}v #+}zT}yG fG(L}G #| gAGQh #|h )yGRjyG
.!S " G A

]38

]38

G :I F

G :I F

G[

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

402

Qv9V O}IC N+WyG e;v fE {< O+g=< x"| ($ 9|h yxAqyG O+s f9}* Gz U+q"yG
k
x+@z* ~$Q+qw@ eOf #f ;]p ~%Ag*9=|h gQZf e9wI ?*:(< aGQAf:G )p
k
k
N(+V #| gQZf A9}zf JGO9S h| 9g}AG| GQk +Dv x+@z<h OGQq!:G )zf 9!9+IC
)p ~zgyG {$C #| OIC #| VGQAfG fhO<h ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9=
H(: B!9v e(zg| ($ 9}v ?zG}yGh -9$Q+i )p hC QZ| )p AG(S ~$QZf
: #| Q9=wyG ~zgyG {$C #| 9%+ph R9GJyG O;< ?Y9M<h )|;S G ~y9gyG
O}J| ?|;gyG N+WyG ~%SCQ )zfh 9%+zf G(tzfh :E IOQGh :h IOQ9V fhQQ}*
9qk +\ Q%VC ?AS #| QDvC QZ| )p {ch L;gzy GQk FGR A9F iPyG ~+$GQ<E #<
?!h6G gP$ )p iO%yG ?zG| hFGQ* iPyGh ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= )zf
.)v$1370 ?"S 15 ~sQ OzG}yG hFGQ( &@QvP 9| bGOZ| OG*
v
&y(s KFQ! fG 9"|Rz@ ?+}zgyG OfG(tyG {<z )y(t< Q9tyG QvP} O(fC
9\k Q9g@ c9"$ #w* ~y GPE r+wp 9\k Q9g@ ?}C f9v GPE GP$h yK\G(yG Q$9dyG
k
.;YC
:E xyP #f PW* ~yh ~zgyG {$C &+zf h=C 9| ($ N(+WyG &+zf f9v iPy9p
: uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJ* iPyG fC ($h :C LQG(MyG :E QQvCh- LQG(MyG
Qqvz g9"g| f9v gQqw< 9"zs fGh d;JAS:G hC O(JGyG &"| ~zf GPE :E Qqw*
f9vh #++qzS #w! ~y :Eh .Ky9ZyG ?|}G rzS #f xyP B=C 9}v yQqv fhO
>$P|h 96 uzgA! IO*OF ?Ap: #f fPE EJ="yh -GQkhRh 9<k Pv ?+qzTzy 9!A9fOG
.&+yE >TA"! QLB
)zf Qv9V O}IC N+Wzy u+zg@ #| Q+qwAyG N(+V &< dOASG 9}y ?+!9C O(g!h
&t+zg@ )p Qv9V O}J| O(}J| ?|;gyG &+LC e;w< gO9%WASGh Q+TqAyG IO}f
)zf LQM* fC O*Q* iQhQJy 9Tk q"A| cQ@C fC O*QC : )"!} .iQ=ayG )zf
)1 (

uJyG ?J+Y J;F9T| xyPvh )tqyG O|9I N+WyG )zf gQ+ih )|(Zg}yG OhOQ hFGQh )1(
.d(sC 9| ?t+tI )zf rtAy

403

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9Z!G ~SGz {}; ?Ap: &@R< )zfh ;FB fEh ;F9f fE &q+S GQk $9V ?|}G
.y?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
k
fC A)V {v {=sh :hC eI;* Qv9V O}IC N+WyG u+zg@ )yE Qc9"yG f{p
f9|RyG GP$ )M+W}A| {gqv {gq* :h S9=f #<G #f Q9C6G KJZ* N+WyG
J(=C 9%+zF9ty ?=T"yG ?A<9C Q9CBh E*O9IC #| ~%y bhQ* : 9| f(qg]* #*PyG
. )SGhQyG d9=GyG
k
J9*7y Q+Dv #<G e9| G Q+Tq@ )zf Qv9V O}IC N+WyG VQAg* ~y :9+!9C
?*6G fC Q9ALG ~C Q*QF #<G gGhQz gO*Ch iQ=ayG #f &zt! iPyG &y(s )zf :h
.yH9AwyG )p dR"}yG uG ~wI OJF #| hC H9AwyG {$C 96 OGQ}yG
k
- &+zf dO@ 9| )zf U(Z"y9< dOASG #| )zf N+WyG VQAg* : :9Dy9C
fhQTq}yG h=C xyP )zfh {< Ky9ZyG ?|}G rzS O9tAfGh gO9tAfG ($h r+v
-g9V9Ih- S9=f #<G d(s )zf VGQAf;y >Aw* 9| >Aw* N+WyG f9v (yh
#++y(Y}G ?t*Q_ )zf )zf hC E*OJyG {$C ?t*Q_ )zf ["yG OQ* fC dh9Jy
k
.yQqv fhO Qqvz IQ9=f )zf ;YC VGQAfG : #wyh
dO@ 9| Q+i )zf U(Z"y9< f(yOAT* #*PyG )zf N+WyG VGQAf9p fPEh
98(zgG* ...GP$ 9!QZf )p f(zz]}yG &< >gz* 9}|z ($ &@Q9=g< hC &+zf
k
k
- d;JAS:G )p GOF #+< GP$h y?f(\(}yG ?+"C(yG #+!G(tzy ?I9<C hC GQPf
fE xyP {f9p G(}C|* fC A:|$ )zf >FG(yG f9vh -f:PMyG #| u9< P(g!
~zgyG {$C iOy ?|(zg}yG h!G(}yGh WhQWy9< OJF fE ghQqw* fCh {gp
e;w< N+WyG O9%WASGh ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C xyP )zf h=C 9}v A9]tyGh
&< O%WASG 9}y :Eh 9!QvP 9}f ?A=yG LQM* : Qv9V O(}J| /P9AS}G &+LC
.Qv9V O}IC N+WyG
k
:Qv9V O(}J| P9AS}G d(t* 9t<9S &A"<C 9| ?t+tI xy Q%d* 9| x+yEh
Q

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

404

#}| #AqyGh >*QyG {$C f{p Og<h?y;]yG #| x+yE CQ<C )!E ~%zyGz
cQ@ )p f9azTyG {$} IQPg}yG U}z@ Os GP$ 9"!9|R )p e;wzy GhQOZ@
?g*QV Q+j< dG(|}Gh VGQf}Gh A9|OyG )p A9]tyG )ph uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG
O;< )p ?g*QV QqwyG {$C f(!9s ~$P9<G )ph &<9Av )p 9%yR!C )AyG uG
k
HG(Y &< iQ* 9*CQ 9}$P<G #*Q=MyG #*P$ )zf rsh 9}zp ...ye;S G
HAIG #}pz u+zgAyG QLB )p d(t* ~C A9|OyGh VGQf}Gh dG(|}G )p A9]tyG
IQZ! )p ?=iQ 9$9"g| Q+i )yE 9%pQYh 969< Q+i )p 9}$Q+ih #*QC}G #*P6
k
gO9=f )zf VQph uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG k*(T@ )zf :9+AIG hC f9azS
9"$ &A*CQ {%p yuG e9wIC #| ~wJy OI9GyG ~wI ?g*QWyG )p &}wJp
)AyG ?qF9ayG )zf OQyGh h+"WAyG &|;w< OZt* eC e9wJyGh c(z}zy VQgA*
k
HQjyG #+!G(t< ~wJyG ~v9Jzy f(i(T*z #*PyG ~$h 9t<9S 9$Q=L cA9F
HG(Y fhQ*h 9$9"g| Q+i )yE 9%pQYh 969< Q+i )p Q9C6G gP6 f(GAJ*h
>*QyG {$C #| ?f(}G| ~%p .A9|OyGh VGQf:Gh dG(|}G )p 96 A9]tyG
.y?+<QjyG #+!G(ty9< ~wJyG f(zJAT*h uG ~wI fhOJG* #AqyGh
e9wJyG Q+qw@ )zf dO* GP$ {$h ~zgyG {$C dG(sC ry9M* GP$ {%p
.???f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C #| #+MSGQyG A9}zgyG {+Zq@ fhO< b;_9<
u+zgAyG ?*98 )p Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG ?}zv f(pPJ* 9}k FGO ~8C )!9DyG Q|}G
Og< QqgF )<C ?}zv CQsGhz
&y(t< ?yzT}yG )p &=$P| #+=@ )AyG )$h
v $.G y{Zp d(s &+qp y{F9s d9s f9pz ,&y(s dhC #| 358:U
:iQ=ayG d9s
N+WyG d(s ?t+tI )zf rt@ )AI ?z|9v xy 9%zt!zSh

:358U

~y #| h+= #f xyP< Q=My9< ~f Os gQvP )y9g@ uG f{p :{F9s d9s f{pz


k
?9Y9L &AzgF r+wp uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ*
~wI iPyG uG ~wJ< G(!9v e(s #f xyP< Q=My9< ~f )y9g@ uG fE :{+s

405

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

vQ@ 9| {+=S )zf ~wJyG ~%vQA< ~8C ~%"f Q=Lzp #*OI9F &<9Av )p &<
k
u9< ($ &< GOI9F uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| {v )p d(tyG xyPvh fhQp9v
&<9Av )p &yR!C &!C &}zf Og< uG ~wI gO(JG< &!} S9=f #<G d9s 9}v Qp9v
.)358/10( iQ=ayG e;v )%A!G y)=! &!C &}zf Og< &+=! I(=! gO(JF Q+d!
y{Zp d(s &+qpz iQ=azy &y(t}yG gP$ #f d(t* Qv9V O(}J| N+WyGh
fC f(pQAg* : #}| c9*E ~C c9*Eh ydR%yG #| c9*E ~C c9*zpz xy d(sC 9!Gh
d(tyG ($ J9*6G ~%p )p -{%GyG )p #+MSGQyG :- ~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG d(s
O9%WASG >=T< U+y Qv9V O(}J| ?|;gyG rs(| ?+zGA< 9"$ 9"|9}A$Gh {ZqyG
&@zW! B!9v Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG f} {<- &|;w< Qv9V O}IC ?|;gyG &+LC
#| ?"+< )zf f(w@ )wyh ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!z< IO+_h ?s;f &yh ?+qzS
?zG| )p )tqyG O|9I N+WyG ?|;gyG &=Av 9| IAGQty c(fOC ?"TyG Q9Z!z< &As;f
O=f I9ph ?=S9"}< >Avz v24,23vY ?g<GQyG ?"TyG #| 48 OOgyG i(="yG iO%yG
.y#+}zT}yG f9=WyG ?+g}Gy e9gyG U+FQyG O+gS x< O+}JyG
?f9= QGO< BTSz@ Os #+}zT}yG f9=WyG ?+g= fG ?=S9"}yG gP%y QvP!hz
O(}J| /P9AS}G #+ZzM}yG #*Q(+jyG #+<9WyG )gT< ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C
k
/P9AS}Gh .?g|9Gy9< HGO}G ?+zw< 9=y9_ 9%T+Sz@ Bsh )p f9vh Qv9V iO"pC
?z+]p {G! 9}%yhCh .e(zgyG QGO< 9=k y9_ P8"+I f9vh fhQ9$ {]qyG )<C O}J|
?!9!QyG ?y9t}yG >I9Yh 9tk <9S Q$R}G {+vh Qv9V O}J| N+WyG e(IQ}yG
e(IQ}yG ?z+]p {G! 9}%+!9Ch .e;S G #f OhPyG )p IO(%W}yG rsG(}yGh
.fhQ9$ O}J| N+WyG
9Ik ;Y ~7Q+L #| &!C 9$Q+ih ?*Q$R}G W9Sh}G )p 9pk hQg| f9vh
IOV 9*CQ .?+|;S G IQ+jyG gP6 f9<9WyG fGP$ f(w* fC hQi ;p .i(t@h
.&< ~$hRj@ 9| IQDvh #+}zT}yG 9}8G(L ?+J+T}yG f9=WyG ?+g= AGQiE
- ?+|;S G IQ+jyG )p ($ #| ($h Q(}+@ 9V9< O}IC IO9gTy xyP 9+wWp
g(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

406

9"vh ?+|;S G ?*GO%yG ?+g= U+FQ #+TI Q]MyG O}J| O+Tzyh -)y9g@
9}zp >+aMyG #*OyG >J| P9AS:G O"f ?+qzTyG ?g=a}yG QGO )p h}AG!
Pt"@ #+}zT}yG f9=Wzy ?+g= U+Sz@ )p h}GyG GP$ Qwp 9}$G(wV JQQw@
IQwqyG fGQ(+jyG f9<9WyG E=p .#++J+T}yG f9=WyG ?+g= #| #+}zT}yG f9=WyG
k
k
fC GhQ9ALGh Y9}AF:G )p GhQwqp :(=sh 9FGhQ B+tzp 9}%+ASQO| bSh
J9f9}AFG IOf &+p GhOtfh ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= iO9! )p G(g}AG*
OGOR* IQ| {v )p f9vh .9%T+Sz@ ?vQI G(}d!h ?+g}GyG f(!9s 9%+p G(g"Yh
)%A!G )AI #+}zT}yG d9FQyGh f9=WyG )p ?*(tyG QY9"gyG #| IQDv f(g}AG}yG
.yHG("yG UzG| e9|C B!9v )AyG 9$QGO Q9G8ASG )yE 9$Q|C
Q9Z!C ?f9}G< Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG ?s;f xy #+<} xyP xy JQvP
:xyP xy #+=@ GP{p ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
eC ?f(+JaTyG xyP ~%p 9}v e9wJyG Qqw* f9v N+WyG {$ ($ dG|Ty9p
??f9}GyG A9}zf #| &L(+V H%"| Uq! )zf f9v
9"L(+V #f 9"zt! 9}v Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG #f &zt!zS 9}| 9%pQg@ ?<9F G
Q9Z!C ?f9= A9]fC h+=h Qv9V O}IC N+WyG /)tqyG O|9I N+WyG( #+t<9TyG
.)?"TyG
fG("g< ?"|9DyG ?"TyG y341 OOgyGz ?y9SQyG ?zG| )p &Ay9t| )yE BgFQ GP{p
.)62:60/1( J:9t}yG IQ%= Qd!Gh y?S9M"yG bG(SCz
:?}wJyG B+< AGQJZyG O%g|
?j+z< ?}zv -1940 ?"S Q*9"* raAt| )p- Q%d| {+f9}SEz )t*OY >Av
O%g| ($h f9+T"yG U=J|h AGQJZyG U=J| y#+T=J}yG #+$Qz 9%+p rZ*
Osh yIO*OGyG QZ|z )p ?+|GQA}yG AGQJZyG aQ9W| )zf ~F9tyG AGQJZyG
f(w+y ?Y9L &y9| #| &+zf uG ?}IQ OG|p xz}yG yiQZ}yG OS}Gz gO+V
~A* ~y &"wyh 9$AG(FCh 98O9g|h AGQJZyG hF9=_ f(SQO* #*PyG A9}zgzy ihz|

407

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

&@CQF )yE ?F9JyG IOV )zf &@9ph ~C ~y9gyG xz}yG VQ| #| VQf 9}y gD9"<
.IQ<9D}yGh ?}wJyGh IQ+Z=y9< eRgyG GP$ P9q!Eh &|Rfh &Y;LEh
AGO+=yG )yE 9"*h97 ?\9*QyG ^g=y y{+f9}SEz )LC B=JY 9}zv B"vh
?}$ #+wT}yG A9"=yG GP$ f9vhz d(t* ~C ...IQF9JyG 98GRIz< ?A|9ZyG IQqt}yG
IQWf )zf O*R* 9}< &_9IC Os &!C Bg}S Otyh
{+="yG xz}yG ~}$ #|
9%tI ?y(%G}yG QZ| AGQJY )yE &z$C iO|+yh 979$R"A| ,ph 9%+p e(t+y ?!OpC
.W9="AS:Gh rWwyGh SQOyG #|
&|Rfh &}zfh &wz| )p yOG|pz ?q+zL )yE y{+f9}SEz YQ\ Osh GP$
fC Q+MyG )yE 99O9$h 9%+|9Ih )zf}G QZ| >I9Y ybhQ9qyGz )yE &@Q+Z<h
?+<QgyGh HQgyG N*Q9@ Q$GRyG &wz}y O+g* fCh A9"=yG #| dh}G xz}yG CO< 9| ~A*
A9}zgyG #| ?zt"yG QtAT| &zgFh y?}wJyG B+<z zW!C iPyG f(|z}yG QZf )p
k
~y 9wz| ~zgzy G(TSzp )<QgyG f9TzyG )yE yf9!(*z ?}wI {t! G(=f(ASG #*PyG
.yQ%d| {+f9}SG )"g*z d9s ...f(|z}yG ?}df :E Q(ZgyG )p &yh9a*
Oy9MyG {tgyG Y9T@G A9FQ}G hTA| ~+df -i:(| 9*- AGQJZyG O%g|hz
f(qt* A9}zf ?g]< &+yE ~]* fC )p h}a! {%p ,&F9W!E )p Qwp iPyG
-i:(| 9*- QZ| )ph ??+<QgyG ?jzyG )yE 9<QhC e(zf ?=Q@ )zf ~$O(%F
fC ~%+zf Rfh dG|TyG #f {GMyG ~%g"|h {}gyG #f f9+T"yG ~$OgsC A9}zf
#| ~%+zf ^+q@ fC -i:(| 9*- h}a!C .ragyG AGOGAS9< ~zgyG G("+9
?}wJyG B+=y IG(! G(!(w+y ,9+!OyG e9aI #| ~%AF9I OT* 9| hSG(yG xz]p
~y9gyG )p QC}G E+I #| 9$R=* : GQk9CB ?|O9tyG d9+F~y G(vQA+p cO%f )p
.y?xAy;F :E ?y;GyG )p 9%s(q* :h xA}df :E )<QgyG
:Qv9V O(}J| d(t*
J(Y )yE &@(Y ~]* )<QgyG ~y9gyG )p Qwq|h ~y9fh >*OC {vh
.yHQgyG OG|h QZ| xz| KQGhz )yE ?z+="yG ?fGQ]yG gP$ )p {+f9}SE

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

408

hpQ@ ?+wz| ?*9}J< HO}Gh ~zgyG )}J+S bhQ9qyG fC &=zs )p #t+AT*h


#+sQWAT}yG A9+fO}G ?SQai #| A9<O}Gh A9}zgyG QQ;h O9=gAS:Gh ~zdyG &"f
9<QhC )yE ?zIQyG {]q< g(z}Ih g(s9_C 9}| HO}G U(t"|h ~zgyG {+zt<
9| ^g< -IQ<9D}yGh SQOy9< :- ?ay9M}yGh IQV9g}y9< 9%+p GhOhR@ #+"S h]<
RGgyGh IQhQ]y9< ~$O(gty ~%|(s #| HO}Gh ~zgyGh {]qyG H9JYC &z%F
~%gF9=_h UQIC &+zfh e(sC HO}Gh ~zgy9< ~$h &+yE GhQ9S iPyG {D| #f
.y9C9g=!G OVC &+yE
Qv9V O(}J| P9AS}G &=Av 9| JCQs 9|Og< u+zg@ )yE ?F9I )p x"cC 9|h
96 >Aw* f9v )AyG MhQyG Uq"< )bhQ9p xz}yGh OG|p xz}yG( &!9|R e9wI #f
Bzs fE GQk S x+qLC : {< )....K}TyG (<C / Qv9V / )tqyG( gQZf N(+V
9$Q+ih QZ| )p ~$QZf )p OF9TyG H(zS}G ($ f9v H(zS}G GP$ fE xy
{=s- H(zS}G Uq"< :E ~%v(z| #f A9}zgyG >Aw* f9v 9| ~$QZf {=s {<
P(g! ?*QZf ?"Ap K=Z@h ?+FQ9MyG ?C(zy9< I9fOyG H9aLh H(zSC K(zA* fC
9%+p eQ9 ?"Ap ~wAT=y GPE ~A!C r+vz
O(gT| #<G d9s -9$QV #| u9<
BvQ@ {+s A)V 9%"| cQ@ GPE ?"S S9"yG 9$PMA*h Q+jZyG 9%+p (<Q*h Q+=wyG
v
Bzsh ~vDGQs JQDvh ~vD9}zf B=$P GPE d9s ?cGP )A| :G(y9s ??"TyG
v
&tq@h IQL6G {}g< 9+!OyG BT}AyGh ~vD9"|C Bzsh ~vDGQ|C JQDvh ~vD9%tp
. y#*OyG Q+jy
e1912 - v$1331 ?"S BTSz@ )AyG ?+fQWyG ?+g}GyG f(!9s )yE B*CQC
H%"| #| #+Aat! xy JQALCz :)@6G )zf e(t* I(fOyG )p ~%G%"| f{p
:9}$h ?+fQWyG ?+g}GyG

)1 (

)zf a(s(| ($h 9}$Q+ih ~v9JyGh #TI QL6Gh K+JY 9}$OIG #*O9"S9< )|GQOyG gGhQ
)p )!9=y}G N+WyG QZgyG OOG| ?|;gyG &y9sz | )="yG )yE 9}k wI Y(pQ| &"wyh O(gT| #<G
.y4U f9]|Q e9+s

)1(

409

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9 zf LhQMyG eOfh ?yhOyG h| A9p(yG )yE I(fOyG )4(


~wJ< e9wJyG >y9a@ #wyh ~wI )yE )gT@ : ?+fQWyG ?+g}GyG )10(
.e;S G
k
QvP Otp 9!QvP 9| )zf ;+yO eOg! #zp #+}zT}yG fG(L}G ?f9= )yE 9"ztA!G GPE 9|C
.v78vY y?+fGOyGh I(fOyG JGQvP|z &<9Av )p &Tq! #f 9"=yG #TI P9AS}G
?azTyG iOy S9"yG ^g< &< )Vh ?+z+f9}S 9< gO(Fh IQAp )p &!C
B=Ch ?}%AyG gP$ )p u+t; &g| iQF &!Ch ?+wz}yG JGPyG )p >+gy9< g(}7Gh
xz}yG ?f9GV )zf 9%+p )"D* J9f(\(| &A=z_ )zf )z}* f9v &!Ch 98;a<
&A+; )yE ?+z+f9}S 9< xz}yG QhQ| e(* d9}gyG hGV &!C 9}v gQCz| OOg*h
)p >!9F:G ~%q* )AI xz}yG G(+;h ?qYQ}G )yE G(=$P@ eR:z ~%y d9sh
)p 9]k *C 9"=yG QvPh y~$O"f 9"|GQAIG O*R+p &=J!h 9"wz| eQAJ! 9"!C Oz=yG GP$
ryC #*QWg< BvQAVG #+}zT}yG fG(L}G ?f9= fC )237,235U( &@GQvP|
k
)zf 9wz| bhQ9p xz}yG >+Z"@ d9qAIG )p #+}zT}yG f9=WyG ?f9= h| {FQ
?g+=y9< G(qA$ ~8Ch &"f ?*9Y(yG hpQh gQ}f #| IQWf ?"|9DyG &i(z< Og< QZ|
9"=yG #TI /P9AS}G >Av Otyh .?+|;SE JGQ9gV GhOOQh ~+dgyG xz}zy
k
)yh}G iO9= 6 )dh}G bhQ9p xz}yG ?y;GyG >I9Y e9t| )yE( fG("g< :9t|
k
?y;F )p 9"y fEhz &+p d(t* GhR%: fG(L}G 99C fG("g< :9t|h v$1357 ?"S
k
k
k
(fO* xz|z fG("g< QLB :9t| >Avh y9ttJ| ;|C uG gO*C ~zT}yG xz}yG
fG(L G #| dh}G bhQ9p Ky9ZyG xz}yG ?y;F )yE- >+G* >gVh
IQY9g}yG J9f9}GyG N(+V #f {t"yG )p {+_C fC O*QC :h y#+}zT}yG
{< )y9g@ uG A9V fE ?+"jyG &+p xy &Azt! iPyG GP%p ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= N(+Wy
vo
.-1952 IQ(C e9+s Og< )AI H9AwyG J9<9Av )p iQT@ MhQyG gP$ JQ}ASG
9Gk %"| Og* ~%y ?=T"y9< &!}- &+zf ~$ 9| )zf G(zc ?"TyG Q9Z!C A9}zgp
k
k
k
e9+s Og< #c Otp ~$Q+i 9|Ch- GO<C &+zf LhQMyG ~%y R(G* : 9+qzS 9+"S
. %+

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

410

)p >as O+S >Awp- )!OC hC #+S(s H9s K=YC Os ~wJyG )SQv fC IQ(DyG
>+G! O}J| AG(zyG )yE ?I(Aq| ?y9SQ )1952 UaTiC 8( Q9=L}G IO*QF
{w< K}S iPyG Q(ASOyG fEz &y d9tp y?yO9f ?*Q(@9Aw*Oz )1(?|9s9< 9%+p &=y9_
HGRI}G O9Tp #wyh >TJp &A+V9Ih xz}yG O9Tp U+y O9TqyG #| hsh 9|
: Q(ASOyG GP$ fE ..9]k *C ..QGRhC #| ~%qF9JY &z}; 9|h ?S9+TyG d9FQh
{|9wyG ..{|9WyG Q+%aAyG ~A!C G(tt; ~y fE O9TqyG IO(f #| 9"A*9}I h+aAT*
:E ?+S9+TyG ?*QJyG K+=* :h iQ(ASO W9W! {v #| #+C(z}yG eQJ* iPyG
iO| ?]*Q| IQ*QV ?+i9< ?+i9_ ?*Q(@9Aw*O >gWyG GP$ {}AIG Oty A9pQWzy
)zf .Q(%V ?AS ?q+d! ?yO9f ?*Q(@9Aw*O {}AJ* ;pC O*R@ hC 9|k 9f QWf ?T}L
.ydG(I}G #| d9I iz< ?*Q(@9Aw*O Q=Ag* Q+%aAyG ?vQJ< ~w|9+s fC VQp
?*QJy9< >as O+S >y9_ )1952 UaTiG( 9]k *C Q9=L}G IO*QF )p ~C
OI )zf ~8} #+f(+WyG 9%+p 9}< f(GTyG )p B!9v )AyG ?+S9+TyG i(tyG {wy
)j="* #*PyG yA9pQWyGz #| ~8}h yf9+jayG f(Jp9w* G(!9v #}| ~$Q+jvz &y(s
d9t}yGh yQ9"yGh O*OJy9< ~$9tz! :h &GJy9< ?GJyGh iCQy9< iCQyG ~%fQ9t! fC
~7Gh yQGhOyG Qqvz KGOIC Bgsh e9*C ?C;C Og<h y9"q+< : J9vQIz fG("g<
#+f(+WyG ~F99 >as O+S YQ9Sh 9$Q+<OA< #++f(+WyG IQ(DyG IO9+s UzG|
k
k
GO%f f(<Q9J* ~8} U!Oy9< #+f(+WyG rYhh IQ(DyG IO9+s UzG| GO*||
.ye9*C P"| gQGp bQVC iPyG O%gy9vz
f9v )AyG ?zIQ}yG gP$ )p >as O+S #f {t"yG #| QDw! fG O*Q! :h
~zI Y9\ 9}zp IQ(DyG IO9+s UzG}< #F9wyG &=Aw| d;L #| 9%+p >Aw*
#*PyG 969JYC 9%z}JA* ~y E+J< IQ+=v IzF9q}yG B!9v )SQwyG )yE d(Y(yG
)zf >zt!G fC Og< ?=y9a}yG gP$ JA9F 9}!Eh )|;S G ~wJyG ?|9s{< &=y9a* ~y &!C eI:
.gO*|@ ~y )AyG J9g}AG}yG Qqw<h ~$Qqw< ~wJp IQ(DyG d9FQ
.?g*QWy9< A9}zgyG : #+S9+TyG ?}S )$ &<9aL )zf ?=y9jyG ?}TyG fC eI: {<

)1(

411

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q+qwA< J9<9AwyG BFQL G(yPL 9}zp ~7QZ"y Q+$9}GyG cQ; )zf G("$GQ
)yE I9+JyG IO(gy f9|RyG IQGOASGh ?+z$9Gy9< h+}GyG Bg!h- Q+$9}GyGh IO9+tyG
)p >=TyG ($ GP$h e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf d(SQyG ?Dg< {=s &+zf B!9v 9|
gP$ )p KOI 9}| -9%qs(| Q9%c ?t<9TyG J9!9+=yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= QGOYE
.?!h6G
.
Qv9V O(}J| #f E*OJzy iQLC IQ| x< O(fCh
k
#+=* 9%"| 9!(y xy JQvP Os )wz}yG QZgyG #f Qv9V O(}J| J9<9Awp
gO;< e9wI #| &qs(|
A:|%y #*O*|}yG OVC #| f9v IQ(DyG B|9s 9}yh
{$C rs(| e(zg|h( O;=yG ~wI ~%+yE dBh ~7Q(C BJG! fC Og< d9FQyG
/1( f9}+zS dO9f Q(AvOyG &@:9t| h|9F d(t* )>zjA}yG ~v9JyG #| ?"TyG
?yzT| )p -{+zs :E &}zg* :- d9gp QhO -Qv9V O(}J}y- &y f9vhz )34
9+k Yh #+fo iPyG -9"%| O9VQ- P9AS}G fG {=s JQvP 9}wp )fGQRyG M;Y G
QSC Osh &@hO! OGhQ #|h Qv9V P9AS}G A9sOYC #| f9v- TQgyG )zf
M;Y G f(!9s QGOYE O\ f(qt* #+}zT}yG fG(L:G ?f9= fC Qv9V P9AS5y
Y9aASG Qv9V P9AS}G #wyh &p9t* W(j]yG YG(!C )AV f(SQ9}*h )fGQRyG
gP$ G("=@ #*PyG #+}zT}yG fG(L}G HGI f;a=< 9"%| O9VQ P9AS}G h"t* fC
)zf A;+AS}G )p gOg< #| &@QSCh )zf O}J| N*Q9@ &y f9<Ch i(fOyG
xyP<h .)M*Q9@ QQ=| hC )fQV >=S fhOh uI &Fh fhO #+*QZ}yG )\GQC
9"%| O9VQ P9AS}G &"f Kp9! Otp 9*k (s GOk *|| )fGQRyG M;Y G Q9Z!G >TAvG
k
-?*QZ}yG ?S9+TyG N*Q9@ )p ($ #| ($h- Qv9V P9AS}G &< gOhR 9}< 9JzT|
.y?gY9"yG ?+M*Q9AyG #+$GQ=yGh ?j|GOyG HGJy9<

)1 (

9J"yGh )VGQt"yG )zf A9"Ch MO| 9%+qp &@:9t| IQ%= )yE hFQ9p O*R}yG JOQC GPGh )1(
.?+g\(yG #+!G(ty9< e9wJyGh )wz}yG O%gyG )p AGQR(yG A9SDQ Q$9| O}ICh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

412

?S9+S h+}Gy gO+*z@ )zf {c GQk v9V P9AS}G fG GP$ )"g| U+yhz :d(sC
)zf dO* 9| &"| QOZ* ~y &"wyh ?g*QWyG ry9M* 9| h=ay9< 9%+ph IQ(DyG d9FQ
.gQZf e9wJy gQ+qw@
&A|C #f Y9pOzy iQ=!G 9}"+I &!C :E 1959 &"S &y9tAfE #| ~iQy9< &!E {<
9%FGQh #| {}f )AyG ?yOT}yG Q9AS}G xA9 fC &t*Q_ {gFh ?+|;S G ?+<QgyG
G(ttJ+y 9"!9|R )p ~$(CQh Os fhQLB d9FQh f9|RyG #| ;L 9}+p d9FQ
iPyG ~+dgyG f9+wyG GP$ Q9%"* )wy 9"A|C )zf ?=zjyG {v ?+"C(yG ?+<QjyG ?p9tDzy
d9FQyG A:|$ rWwy
e9s 9}"+I d(sC y?yh9aA| fhQs )p 9!D9<B g9"<
H9Av -Og< 9}+p- 9%g= )AyG &@:9t| )p S9"yG e9|C ~%A*Qg@h ~%J]ph
iPyG QY9"yG O=f d9= #f Y9pOyG &\GQiC #}\ #| {gF yQ9}SCh {+_9<Cz
.v15vY d9tp ySGO+| xz}yGzv< H9AwyG )p &+yE R|Q
~p #| y?<hQgyGz ?}zv Pt"ASG iPyG ySGO+| xz}yGz >zs &=y9M}< d9"*hz
.y&z$Ch e;S G )zf ?d+qJyGh #j]yG O*OV b9pC )=+zY Uv9FG {v
^j* iPyG (%p &=Av GRk |Q R|QyG )t<zSh ySGO+|z 9|Cz 431vY d9sh
k
;+= GQk =Y ~%+zf Q=Z*h ?|}G J(s #| #+shRQ| ~%fO*h &y9D|C #f aQayG
k
)yE ~$GOgA* ~$QQ\ f} Q=ZyG GP$ )p A9SC Os &!C iQC 9!C B"v fGh ;*(_
rF;| {D| )p ~%fO(*h ~%f(= OWJ* fC GQk(vP| GQk +L f9vh S9"yG Q+$9=
bRQyG f9p ?y(qw| IQ(p(| )$ 9}v ~%sGRQC u=Ayh !!J9$9gyG ihPh )"|RyG
fC ?+fQyG #f d(8T}yG ?g=@ #}p S(q"yGh d(tgyG a;@E 9|C O9=gzy uI
k
GR|Q R|QyG )t<zShz &y(s )zf 431vY )p uzfh y&zFG(ih xyP QhQV 9%="G*
?+<QgyG ?*Q(%}GyG U+FQ SGO+| xz}y9< )"f {< ,:z X|9%yG )p &y(t< y&=Av
?JqY )AI 451 ?JqY #| &=Av 9| CQsCh 1965 ?"S )p P8|(* IOJA}yG
.xy JQvP 9| ?t+tI )zf rtAy 459
ySGO+| xz}yGz Q|C fC {tf )!OC &y f9v #}y #+<hz d(t* 467vY )ph

413

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?+<QgyG QZ| )$h( IO*OGyG IOGhQ_ f} yIOGhQ_z Q|C #| 9}$O"f ~$C


r+v )"COJp ..ySGO+| xz}yGz A9t=< 9$D9t< #$Q )1952 Og< ?+|;S G
)zfh ySGO+| xz}yGz )zf e(+yG &zv )<Qh}G )=+zZyG ~y9gyG >yzA* fC uqA*
&Tq! ~$(A+p )t*QiE Q(C N;T| )p f(pz}yG GP$ )@z* fCh IO*OGyG IOGhQ_
ySGO+| xz}yGz >za* LQL &!C gQ*O9}S &*Q@ 9}+p iQ* yf(|;@ #< Uv9FCz
GP$ yV(f Uv9FCz #| ?GQk +|O@ 9$Q|O*h yIO*OGyG IOGhQ_z bQJ* ~C &Tq!
{D}< ~zw@h QZ| iQs #| ?*Qs {LO (y ($h ?S9"yG )p &A}+s 9|h ?gOQG}<
Q+i A)V #| S9"yG gG(pC &+zf &zSQ@ 9}| QJ< )p bQjy &< ~zwA* iPyG
&=Av 9| NyE ...HQG+zp d(t! 9}+p xW* {tgyG &+qTyG GP$ f9v GPEh !e;wyG
.y

Q_z Q|O+y gP9+y G V9t!C B; #| LQL 9}!E ...z 580vY )ph


xz}yGz Uq! >za+yh )1952 IQ(C Og< ?+<QgyG ?+|;S G QZ| iC( yIO*OGyG
yUv9FCz {v S9q!z< K(zAyG #| y?+<QgyG ?+|(tyGz ?}zv Pt!C iPyG ySGO+|
.y)@:9t| ^g< )p 9%"f B"<C H9=S} 96 ua"* f9v HGPv
?qzAM}yG J;}JyG gP$ JA9F ~y BpQf GP$ BpQf GPEhz 149vY )ph
)<QgyG ~y9gyG )p ?q+JY Q=vC )p ?"*9=A| GQk(Y JP<G ~yh YG(!}Gh d9wV}G
?|GQv Pt"* fC Y9aASG Os QY9"yG O=f d9= fC ~%y K]@G fC Og< )|;S Gh
SQajA| )<QhC H9$QE {v &Fh )p &p(shh HQgyG IOIh )yE &@(fO< HQgyG
k
k
IQ$9dyG {F9S(yG gP$ Q+j<h iQLC 9!9+IC iO9ZAs:G Q9ZJy9<h 9!9+IC hRjy9<
)<QgyG {tgyG ?z=z< ($ OIGh fGO+| :E A:|$ e9|C u=* ~zp f9+gzy ?*O9=yG
...HQgyG I9+I )p IQ+L}Gh )yh}G ?a<GQyG ~+a; :Eh &Tq! )p &w+wW@h
.y?sO9Y ?ZzM| ?+<Qf O*C )p f(wAy ~9O*C #| BfRA!G ?TS|| Q=vC {LO+y
?}*R$ )AI {ch ?+qF9ayG ?"AqyG IQ9CE ?}%A< 1965 ?"S {tAfG 9}"+Ih
Og< &y d9s &}f fE Qv9V #}IQyG O=f P9AS}G d(t* 1967 ?"S )p QZ|
IOGh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

414

E+I #GTyG )p &jz< 9}"+I &LhO Os ?}*R%yG z=! fE #GTyG #| &FhQL


)zf O}J}< {=s #| &zgp 9| &AvQIh QY9"yG O=f d9}G< {gq* Q9}gAS}G
)yE 9$A9"<G hpOh ?|}G Q+|O@ #| O*R}y 9$Q|O ~C {LGOyG #| 9$G(AIE &AvQIh
~+fRyG (%p JGO9TyG Q(!C U+FQzy GOk F h+WA* (%p xyPy .A)V {v #| Sz+yG
{Y9qyG hpQ Oty :d(t* ~C &y h+WA* QZ! )yE ?}*R%yG d(J* fC Y9aASG iPyG
~c9g@h M9Aq!:G h9T}< ~+zTAyG h| &y h+WA* ...N*Q9AyGh 9+pGQjGyG #+<
&!C :E &AzAs )AyG ?f9}Gzy ?+"_(yG hpGhOyG Qw"* :h #+*QZ}yG O"f >F9iQyG
,~$Q|C Bz%Sh ~6 ~zf )zf B!9v yCIAz ?+w*Q|}G JGQ<9M}yG fC Ov|*
y{Z+pzh yJGO9TyGz Q<(AvC HQI )za< {As )zf {+JyG {w< hOgyG {}f Oty
&z$C bSh )p JGO9TyGh &@QSC #]I )p {Z+p ..9}9QGO iQtf )p
.v307:306vY ~zs ?Zs Qd!G .&W+Fh
)zf dOAT@ JGO9TyG {At< B|9s )AyG ?f9}GyG :&zyG f9J=S d(sCh
9}v- Q+TqAyG IO}f )zf u+zgAyG )p &+LCh Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG e;w< gQ+qw@
.-x< Qv |p
{t* ~yh ?+"_(yG ~%gpGhO Qw"* : (%p QLB iCQ &zp O(}J| N+WyG 9|C
~%p- ?+w*Q|}G JGQ<9M}zy A;}f G(!(w* fC Og=AT* )"g* ?+"*OyG ~%gpGhO
~zf #f G(@C 9| G(@z* ~y ~%+zf c(J]| H9=V ~$ 9}!Eh U+SG(F G(T+y
iCQ

)1(

P$h A;}f G(!(w* fC ~%"f )q"* f9v fGh ?+"*OyG hpGhOyG )zf upG(* : &!C xyP )"g| )1(
k
.)9=*Qs )!9=y}G e;v xy {t!zSh( ($ &!zvh )!9=y}G N+WyG e;v #| >*Qs
N(+V >Gg* : Q(%W| rs(| &yh ?+"*OyG ~%gpGhO )zf
~%tpG(* r+vh d(sC
.)gQ+i {D| IQvGPyG #| )J}* fC )j="* xyPyh( ?+|;S G J9f9}GyG
#| 29U e1991 ?"S y)!9FQGzy ?i;=yG QGQSCz H9Av )zf &A|Ot| )p &y(s )yE Qd!G
:?|Ot}yG
=A9V 9}< &tqyGh E*OJyGh fBQtyG )p d(t+p ?+|;S G J9f9}GyG d9q_C ~$Og< A9F {<z

415

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)p #wyh- ~%"_h f(|OM* ~8C fhOtAg* G(!9v {< -~%vQJ* #}< ?*GQOh
~y eC G(}zf- G(<C eC GhA9V -hOgyG J9aaM| fhPq"* ~$ Bs(yG Uq!
QzD@ fC JOGQC )AyG ?+w*Q|}G JGQ<9M}yG J9aaM| P+q"Ay IGOC G(!9wp -G(}zg*
.y{Z+ph JGO9TyGz Q<(AvC )za< #|
R(G* {$ -~+dgyG u9< xqzJASG- )uJyG #f EI9=yG( Q9tyG 99C
9| h+= QG9 fC Ky9ZyG rzTyG H%"}y &Tq! >T"*h a9Z! G )fO* >@9wy
)zf ?+V9J< uzgA* ~C -O*Q* #| iO* #+<h QpG(A| ($h- &"f Qv hR*h xy &@QvP
)$ 9}!Eh- e9wJyG Q+qwA< O+g< hC >*Qs #| &y ?s;f : VQjy B=Av H9Av
9FQ ~$h d9FQ #J! :d(t*h {="I #<Gh )gp9WyGh ?q+"I (<Ch xy9| &y9s 9| OQ*h ($
.d9FQ ~$h d9FQ #J! d(t+p &Tq! eqzyG GP6 | &zyG d(SQ ?<9JY )yE xyP iOg@ {<
{< QZ| )p )Wq@ Al9<h .A)V {w< ?!9%AS G A9<h ($ 9}!E ?GP$ 9"!9|R )p KOI A;< iC
:d9tp 9$Q+ih QZ}< dR! A9<h QvPh iQg}yG A;gyG 9<C &zyG ~IQh ,9$Rh9:
zvvvvvv<h VQC {vvvvvvv )vvvvvvp #vvvvvvF9vvvvvvv {vvvvvv<
9vvvvv$OvvvvvIh Al9vvvvv<h GQk vvvvvZvvvvv| [vvvvvL 9vvvvv|
.^g< b(p 9%]g< J9}zc )p d(tgyG B+t<h uzMyG LGQSh ~zgyG LGQS zqa!G
)p Q9=wyG ~%At+tI )p Q9jZyG O* )zf ?+|;S G ?+<QgyG ?|}G gP$ e(zg< ByR! ?=w! iC
9!k Qs QWf ?g<QC E*QG(| )p ~%A"TyC G(tz_zp f9|RyG r*Q9Z@ 9$9*E ~%AyR!C )AyG ~%=@GQ|
&Tq! #f 9fk 9pO d9s E+I )\QyG r*QWzy &zyG Qqih AGQOR Gh MOtyGh ?!9%AS 9<
:)d9s 9}< )yhC 9"A|C ~zf #f Y9pOyGh(
o
H;vvvvvwvvvvvyG &vvvvvJvvvvv=vvvvv"vvvvv@ QOvvvvv=vvvvvyG e9vvvvvtvvvvv|
iO9vvvvvf}G )vvvvvp )vvvvvzvvvvvDvvvvv| e9vvvvvtvvvvv| fEh
H9vvvvvvfC : )vvvvvv!zvvvvvv< G(vvvvvv}vvvvvvzvvvvvvf Ovvvvvvsh
J9vvvvvtvvvvvqvvvvvzvvvvv| H(vvvvv+vvvvvgvvvvvy9vvvvv< )vvvvv!(vvvvv|Q
o
G(v v v<9v v vfh ~v v v6(v v v+v v vf #v v v| )v v v!(v v vTv v vv
9vvvvvv=k vvvvvv+vvvvvvf )vvvvvvvp G(vvvvvvs;vvvvvv* ~vvvvvvy 9vvvvvv}vvvvvvyh
:xyP {=s d9sh
~zwA+p ?+|;S G J9f9}Gy9< &!(}T* 9| zW! 9|Og< #*OyG )p 9%jz=| ?!9%AS:G Bjz< {<z
9| NyC ...)$ 9| iQO* : &L(+V #f 9%dqI X9qyz< E*OJyG )ph fBQtyG )p ~%}zwA|
.&@9"F K+Tp &"wSCh Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG )zf
.d9s
!!d

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

416

)AyGh -9t<9S ~%At+tI xy B"+< #*PyG #+<QjAT}yG ?qF9_ )zf OQzy ?<(Aw|
H9AwyGz fG("g< JQW!h ~%+zf OQyG )p ?T+q! ?y9t| Qv9V O}IC N+WyG >Av
)1 (
. yQZ| )p #+!G(tyG QOZ| 9!(w* fC >G* ?"TyGh
&< d:OAS:G R(G* : 9}< f(yOAT* #*PyG A:|$ {D| 9| Q9tyG 99C iQO@C
#| {D}v -Qv9V ?zF9f #f {D}zy )<Q\ )p x< LQLC #yh- iO"f ~%zD| fE
?"TyG ?y9SQyGz Qv9V O(}J| N+Wzy yIOIGh ?+]sh OIGh >gVz ?y9t| CQt*
:9%+ph )412/1( IQ%}GyG Qd!G y1947 &+!(* 15
f(w@ fC :E O*Q! : 9"!C )$ :~y9g}yG ?"+< ?J\Gh ?+]s HQgyG ?+]s fEz
97Q*RF h]< :h ,OIGh iO"F 9%sGQf {AJ* : ,IQI ?ztAT| 9gk += 9!O;<
hC )!9a*Q< f9azS &=Z| )yE &g="| #| 9%z+! d9"* :h dhQA=yG c(z| f9azTy
ydhQA=yG c(z| f9azTy 97Q*RF h]< :hz N+WyG d(s fC #d+p y)!9a*Q< Q+i
{$C )yE e;wyG OQ (yh #+}DyG O+ZyG GP6 Q+a+p HQgyG IQ*RF e9wI )"g*
k
&< MQp 9}f a;AL}G e9}@ 9qzAM| QLB GQk |C ~zgy N+WyG e;v )!9g}< ~zgyG
uzg*h y9!O;< gP$z fG("g< 9%+z@ )AyG ?y9t}yG )p ?}zwyG gP$ Q+Tq@ )yE Qd!Gh
k
:;F9s )21/1( yf9}+zS dO9f Q(AvOyGz IQ%}GyG h|9F
>!9F}G A:|$ 9}!Eh )!Q=LC 9}+p O;=yG e9wI Qv9V P9AS}G )"g* :z
Qd!Gz 9"sG(SC 979GA"| hRjAy ~%g!9Z| 96 GhQ*O+y 9!O;< dhQA< fhPLz* #*PyG
.y)416/1( IQ%}GyG
#+=@h J9%=V &A=TI 9}| x\QAfG 9| rWwy ?z*(ayG ?zIQyG gP$ Og<
k
{+zJAyGh ?SGQOyGh EJ=yG e9|C ;*(_ O}Z@ : 98G gOIh uG O}J< xy
9%zt! )p 9"]pC )AyG ~%qsG(|h N(+WyG dG(sC #| ~wJ}yG )zf 9%\Qfh
.v428v

Y >*Qs #f x+@zASh )1(

417

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

xy g9"+< 9| ($h ->TJp- 9$(zF9s gOZs 9| )yE aQZ@ {< ~%"f 989+<h
)y9g@ uG ?g*QWy #*O!9g| #*OI9F ~8(=TJ* #}| ?f(}G| ~$OZs #|
.AG(S OI )zf YhQqyGh d(Y}G )p 9%"f LhQMyG )yE #+fGOh
.....f6Gh
OFC )zgzp &< x+yE )]pC fC 9Ik 9JyE )zf Kz* Q|z< cQ=L} xqs(ASC
9| xADD< 9}"+I BIQASG Otp :Eh- )=Gg@h )<GQjASE {*R* 9| cO"f
!!)"}$C
GP$h- Q+TqAyG IO}f &<9Av )zf ?+V9I Qv9V O}IC N+WyG >Av Otp
k
k
&=I9Y f}h .~zgyG {$C #| GOF ?z+zs ?zs iOy :E 9phQg| #w* ~y H9AwyG
J9"+T}MyG )p &MT! JOq!h &< u+z* iPyG Q9WA!:G QWA"* ~zp &z}w* ~y
o
k
IQvGP )p :E 9|9}@ H9AwyG Q=L )T!h eQZ"}yG fQtyG #| J9"+ATyG {FGhCh
H9AwyG #| ?+V9JyG gP$ BFQMASG IzGph Qv9V N+WyG KGQA< #+}A%}yG
{t! 9%+ph btp IOF9}yG IQ(S #| #+g<Q}Gh ?Dy9DyG ?*6G )zf u+zgAy9< ?Y9MyG
Q+Tq@ )zf &t+zg@ #| Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG &+L} 9|k ;v Qv9V O}IC N+WyG
.)349-348/10( iQ=ayG
k
!!>GgyGh ?W$OyG )zf Eg=* GQ9WA!E b9p6G )p JQWA!Gh
dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG ?+]s )p ~zwA* #| {v ~zsh f9Ty )zf BJ=YCh
?+g\(yG #+!G(ty9< e9wJyG Q+qwA< d(tyG #+M+WyG #f Q%AVGh 9%+p >Aw* hC uG
&+p QvPh :E Y(\(}yG GP$ )yE bQa@ H9Av #| 9|h {+Zq@ fhO<h b;_9<
: #}| H9=WyG K=Yzp ?|9gyG )yE xyP iOg@ Q|}G fE {< ,?+V9JyG gP$
: ~8C h| ?+V9JyG gP$ &@(I 9| ~%A"TyC )zf iQ: ~zgyG >za< f(pQg*
)1 (

?g=_ )p ;|9v g9"FQLC 9}<Qh GOk F H9AwyG d9ay :Eh g9!QvP &+zf 9"qsh 9| {v U+yh )1(
.?|O9s

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

418

9}$OI} GhQ* ~yh {< Qv9V O(}J| ($ #| :h Qv9V O}IC ($ #| f(pQg*


k
fC Y9aASGh ?+V9JyG gP$ LQMASG #| 9|C )GP$ Q+TqAyG IO}f )AI :h( 9<9Av
)zf {}g* &zgF 9| H9=S}G #| )@hCh >+GgyG H(zS}G GP6 9$QW"< e(t*
#| 9$Q+ih yxAqyG O+s f9}* Gz )VGQt"yG {At| )p N+WyG i(Ap A9qLE
xyP h|h GOk F >*Q|- >+Gf ->*Qi Q|C ($h- 96 c9"q;G )AyG J:9t}yG
&+yE BqAz* fC fhO< Q}* fC #w}}yG #| f9v H(zS}G GP6 9$QW! Y9T@9p
9!OtpC )AI >*Q| >*Qi >+Gf {v )zf &+p 9!O(g@ f9|R )p #J"p -OIC
.!?fPE O*OGyG 9}p 9"y(I QhO* 9}| Q+Dw< 9"S9TIE O(gAyG
Q|}9p ?t+tJyG A9qLE )zf d9+FC z_G(A@ fC 9"z=s (yh )AI #wyh ....
n
#+DI9=yG ^g< cQn WyG GP$ )p ht* fC QV Q*P! f9v g9"z=s fEh {=t* : iPyG
[+J}Ay VQgA@ )AyG )$h( ?+g|9GyG ?+}zgyG ~%zF9SQ fhQOZ+p #*O9GyG
)FQ9MyG >$P}yG GP$ hRf 9%+ph )9%A!9w| 9%y J98+$ {=s #| u+sO@h u+t;h
d(sC :h- >$P}yG ?=T! u+t; fhO< -)y9g@ uG 9}%}IQ- #+M+Wzy E+=MyG
.#+M+WyG )yE - ?+V9JyG
!!??t+tJyG A9qLE AGQh Bqsh )AyG gP$ I(s iC iQ@
k
d(sC- iO*}G #f GO+g< f9v N(+WyG A:|$ KGQ@ fE :{F9s d(t* Os
r n
f(YG(A* #*PyG iO*C eC ?t+tJyG #f #+DI9=yG iO*C ?#| iO*C fhOZt@
k
KGQ@ h= {FC #| dP< GO(%G| fC ~zg! 9"!} xyP d(sC ??t+tJyG A9qL{<
?}zvz ~S9< GQOY #+<9Av )p )&@:9t| IQ%= h=_ {=s( Qv9V O}IC N+WyG
)1 (

)2 (

9}%"f g9"zt! 9| )yE &+p Y(FQyG #| O<: 9%+p 9| ~%p #wy 9}%+yE ?=T"yG ?J+JY ?+V9Jy9p )1(
R*RgyG O=f #< #}IQyG O=f N+WyG &< e9s iPyG >+ayG O%Gy9< g("! fC 9"@(q* : xyP h|h )2(
J:9t| IQ%=z fG("g< Qv9V O}J| O}IC ?|;gyG J:9t}y >+ayG &g= )p {tgyG O9}I #<
.yQv9V O}IC N+WyG

419

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

xV )!OC &<(W* : 9|k R9F GOk9tAfC OtAfE 9!Ch y?+z$9GyG ~wIzh yuJyG
~%g= f9v 9}y #wyh 9"y Qp(@ 9| 9}%y Qp(@ #+<9AwyG IO9| h= )zf #+}F9tyG
9| GhQvP Otp )>+"GAyGh A9tA!:Gh RQqyG )zf e(t*( 9+k F9tA!G #+<9AwyG IO9}y
#| ?t+tJyG #f Qd"yG ^j< e9wJyG Q+qw@ #| ~7Qwp QW! )zf ~$Of9T*
N+WyG O9tAfEh Qwqy #+gFQ| 9J=YCh Q9a| {v f9<9AwyG Q9_h- )$ E+I
Ky9ZyG rzTyG )yE f(=TA"* #*PyG ~zgyG {$C {+=S #| GP$ {%p -Qv9V O}IC
IQ\9J|h yxAqyG O+s f9}* Gz ?y9t| QW"* ~y GP9}zp :Eh ?A)V )p ?"TyGh
d9D}yG {+=S )zf ..f9]|Q Q%V d9=tAS9< d9qAI:G IQ\9J|h ?*(="yG IQG%yG
?z|9v 9$QvP* ~yh y)tqyG O|9I #+<h )"+<z J:9t| RQ<C GP9}yh .QZJyG :
9}%+zf uG ?}IQ f9M+WyG 9}%+p Ky9Z@ #+AzyG #+@Q+L}G #+Ay9t}yG aPI {<
9}p - ?jy9< IA9SE ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= US|| )tqyG N+WyG )yE xyP< A9Szp
?f9}GyG {+vh f9}Df )JAp N+WyG ?z+]p {gF 9| GP$h ?xyP #| &pO$
Qv9V #+< QGO 9}+p )zGyG f9+=yGz fG("g< ?y9SQ )p ?z|9v J:9t}yG QW"y iQ="*
#+=+y u<9TyG ?f9}GyG U+FQ #*OyG Q(! J(qY O}J| N+WyG ~*OtA< y)tqyGh
{$- O}Ag}yG aPJyGh A9qL:G GP$ #| ?JzZ}y iQF 9| ?t+tI S9"zy
JGQ=gyG >wT@ 9"$ 9%p -)}zgyG EJ=yG ?JzZ}y eC ?+qzTyG I(fOyG ?JzZ}y
.9}$A9+fOEh ?"TyGh ?+qzTyG )zf M9"*h
k
9a<Q ~+sC )"zgF #+<9AwyG #*P$ )p &@QvP 9}y O}gA}yG A9qL:G GP$ fE
&!{p Qv9V O(}J| ?|;gyG J:9t| ^g< [M* QLB rs(|h rs(}yG GP$ #+<
O+S )zf 9%+p OQh | d(SQyG ?<9JY #f 9%+p 9gk pGO| iQ=!G Os f9v
k
fC h+aAT*h bRQ* 9+I >as O+S 9%Ash f9vh | )="yG ?<9JZy &=S >as
&!} Qv9V O(}J| N+WyG )zf OQ* fC )zf DQF 9| xyP h|h &Tq! #f hpO*
k
&!9+=y hTA* : e9t}y9p 9+!9C Og< 9|h 9+k !9C 9|C :hC GP$ ?"+=y9<h ?GJy9< OQ* f9v
:fG("g< J:9t}yG B!9vh
fC

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

420

?"S f(}zT}yG ?zG| #| dh}G OOgyG ?"+<;< ~wIz


.y1951 ?"S f(}zT}yG ?zG| #| )!9DyG OOgyG f9}*E ;< N*Q9@z
.y1952 ?"S f(}zT}yG ?zG| #| Ey9DyG OOgyG )<9JYC G(=T@ :z
.y1952 ?"S f(}zT}yG ?zG| #| h<GQyG OOgyG #*QAq}yG ?"TyCz
.y1952 ?"S ?y9SQyG ?zG| #| 974 OOgyG )tW* {tgyG hPz
d(t! gQZf A9<OC N+V ($ 96 e9s iPyG fC 9!O"f OhOQyG gP$ 9*GR| ~$Ch
;p #*Qwq}yGh A9<O}G ?jz< >Aw* f9v {FQyG fC )fO* #| ?GI {a="y xyP
W(+L #| )$hC ?GI )$h #++CGQAyG #| ~zgyG {$C ?jy )yE g(}v9;
OQyGh &qWv )y(@ iPyG ($ gQZf A9<OC N+V ($ 9$ d(t! xyP h|h J(=w"gyG
gP$ G(zgG* fC G(f9aASG r+v d(sC- !?d;]yG :E uJyG Og< GP9}p &+zf
iCh Qw| iCh -AGQtyG 99C 9%yR9"! )AyG gP$ I(s iC -f9+T"yG )_ )p OhOQyG
u9< :E I(s :h d(I :h {+v(yG ~g!h uG 9"=TI #J"p d9I ?*C )zf ?A9$O
)=Gg@h )<GQjASG {*R* 9| cO"f OFC )zgy xyP xy JQvP -~+dgyG )zgyG
.yEq"* fC QhOZ}zy O< :h QhOZ| ?Dq! )%p :Eh
.y1951

421

? +fQW y

&zyG

dR C

)q+qf

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9| Q j< ~wJyGz ?y9SQ ^t

b G R Q yG

O=f N+Wzy 9<Pv ?<(T"}yG

?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= U+FQ )q+qf bGRQyG O=f ?|;gyG N+Wzy >T"* 9| 9|C
Q+qwA< d(tyG #|
?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}zy e9gyG )Aq}yG >F9!h u=S}G
#<G e9| G #f e(zg}yG )qzTyG {+ZqAyG fhO< ?+g\(yG #+!G(ty9< ~v9JyG
&+zf HhPw| ($ {< ?A=yG &"f KZ* : GP%p ~zgyG {$C #| gQ+ih S9=f
uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG ?y9SQ )zf )f;_E Og< &A=Av iPyG f9+=yG x+yEh
)q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+Wzy 9<k Pv ?<(T"}yG

VVV

)q+qf

Qy O=f N+WyG ?|;gzy ?<(T"}yG ?y9SQyG )zf Bgz_G 9}"+I


gO=f Q<9Y #< O+gTyG N+WyG ?*9"g< y?"TyG d(I J9%=Vz ?y9SQ< ?tJz}yG
QGO ?g=_z ihOgyG )qaZ| N+WyGh i(AWyG O}I Q(AvOyG ?z+]p ?gFGQ}<h
:H9=S} xyPh N+Wzy 9%A=T! #| H9+@Q}G )"zLGO .yv$1417 ?"S ?z+]qyG
Q9Z!C ?f9= A9]f} &AtpG(| #|
N+WyG #f &pQg! 9}y 9%Aqy9M| :9%"|
P"| O;=yG e9wJy O+*zAyG {F9SQh J9g*9=}zy 9$QGOYE )p 9%T+Sz@ P"| ?"TyG
>F9! >Z"| {jW* N+WyG f9vh e1952 IQ(C e9+t< GQkhQ|h ?+wz}yG QZf
N+WyG >MA!Gh )tqk yG O|9I N+WyG )p(@ fC 9}zp ?f9}Gzy e9gyG U+FQyG
B!9v {< ?f9_ #| GO* YR! 9|h H%"yG Uq! )zf Q9S ?f9}Gzy 9Tk +FQ Y9= 9<
e9wJ< aGQAf G #f e;wy9< ?8+z| &AS9FQ B;h gO%f )p i(="yG iO%yG ?zG|
O*|*h h*9=* r+wp - YQWyG ry9< : )AyG ~79S9+S )p ~$O+*z@h O;=yG
k
.fhO@Q| gO"f ~$ 9|9wI r"9h
:)@6G 9%"| QvPC ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG ih9Aqy IQ(vP}yG ?y9SQyG ?qy9M| -2
bG R G

)1 (

?f9}GyG H%"| f9J\(* N+WyG ?S9FQ IQAp A9"CG )p 9}$QW! ~@ f9Ay9t| H9AwyG GP$ )p {<
.Q|}G ?+zF )zf rtAy 9}%gFGQp yIOI(yGz fG("g< O;=yG e9wI g9:

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

422

~sQ i(Ap
?&zyG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* : iPyG ~v9JyG )zf A9fOyG ~wI 9| :S
:Og<h &=JYh &yBh &y(SQ )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh gOIh u O}JyG :L
~%"+< ~wJ+p &A+fQ M;YE gO* )zf uG {gG* fCh u+p(AyGh ?*GO%y9< &y (fO@
.~zSh &=JYh &yBh O}J| 9"+=! )zf uG )zYh u+p(AyG u9<h .uG ?g*QW<
)5741( ~sQ i(Ap
&"| {=t@h Q=vC GQk qv Qp9v eC ~zT| ($ {$ uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| :S
?&y9}fC
p
o )y9g@ d9s :L
#wy ?*6 O 9}y pwo ?*6 O 9}y p} o ?*6 O 9}y
#| LQM* Q=vC uTph Q=vC ~zch Q=vC Qqv (%p GRk F9F gOtAfGh xyP {JASG fE
xyP ~*Q; OtAg* ($h QLB OZt| hC I(VQyG {FG #| xyP {gp fE 9|C ?z}yG
: QjYC 9tk Tp 9tk S9ph QjYC 9}k zc 9}k y9ch QjYC GQk qv GQk p9v Q=Ag* ~CB &!{p
.IQ(vP}yG J9*6G Q+Tq@ )p ~zgyG {$C xyP K\hC 9}v ?z}yG #| &FQM*
.u+p(AyG u9<h
~zSh &=JYh &yBh O}J| 9"+=! )zf uG )zYh
A9Ap:Gh ?+}zgyG K(J=zy ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG
)6361(

@?>=<;:98
]47

G :I F

G[

]45

G :I F

G[

?"GzyG U+FQ >F9!


)q+qf

b G R Q yG

]44

(] f

O=f

f9*Oi uG

O=f

U+FQyG
R9 <
.d9D}yG

#<

{+=S )zf

uG

O=f #< R*RgyG O=f

)5226( ,)6310(

~s Q

ih9AqyG

Qd!Ch

G :I F

G[

423

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{+ZqAyG WQAW@ ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C IO9F )zf iQ@ 9}v ih9AqyG gP$h
)q+qf bGRQyG O=f ~%M+V ~%"|h ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG Q9Z!C A9}zf &< d(t* iPyG
.9$hQOYC #*PyG N(+WyG #}\
N+WyG h+s(A< ?z*P| ih9AqyG ~C
?y9SQyG )zf uzf Os i(AWyG O}I Q(AvOyG B*CQ )"!{p xyPvh -3
k
?g*QWy9< ~wJyG #f 9\k Qg| f9v #| 9"$ N+WyG OGQ|z ;F9s )64U( ?|(fR}yG
hsh #| OGQ}yG U+yh dO=yG {+=S )zf I9+JyG f(8V h+= )p 9+k zv 9\k GQfE
v
&}wI eGO 9| #+!G(tyGh ~d"yG &y h\hh f9GzyG &y {wV (yh xyP ^g< )p
k
k
dGhR< dhR@ ?qy9M| VQG(gyG ^g=y ^g< )p ry9L #wy 9+fQV 9}wI e9gyG
d;]yG #| GP$ &}wI {< IQp9v &A|(wI f(w@ :h GQk p9v f(w* ;p 969=SC
.~zfC uGh f9}* G [t!h #*OyG rg\h i(%yG Y9=@Gh #+=}yG ~C Gh ~+dgyG
i(AWyG ~+$GQ<G #< O}I /N+WyG P+}z@ &=Av
&=$P}<h N+Wy9< S9"yG ~zfC #| ($h( i(AWyG O}I Q(AvOyG fzvh :Bzs
9%+p BiGRh eGOsC 9%+p ByR )AyG GOk F IQ(%W}yG ?+]tyG gP$ )p JGPy9<h
.)QZgyG ?"Ap BJ=YCh H(zs
N+WyG >$GP| #| QtAT}yG h| VQ9gA@ i(AqyG iCQ 9}zp )"<GQ 9| &<GQ Os
{< ~$Q+ih O9=gyGh #+}+Df #<Gh )!9=y}Gh R9< #<9v ~zgyG {$C #| &!GQsCh
iQ=wyG 97O}fC OIC ($h ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG #f IQO9ZyG i(AqyG h| VQ9gA@h
gP$ )p N+WyG #f 9"+t* &}zg* 9| upG(* 9}< 9%+zf u+zgAzy Q(AvOyG Qa\G

)1 (

9tp dO=}yG Q+qw@ ,zf ~zgyG {$C Y9=G ?+}+@ #<G {t!
YQWyG dO< hC &+zf h}G}yG d;JyG eQI hC &+zf h}G}yG eGQJyG {zI )A| f9T! Gh
OIC )zf )y9g@ &y(s dR! GP$ {D| )ph A9%tqyG b9q@9< GOk @Q| GQk p9v f9v &+zf h}G}yG
d9s ~C y&zyG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJzy {JAT}yG ($ iC y&zyG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|hz #+y(tyG
k
d9s #}p ....S9"yG )zf hC &y(SQh &zyG )zf HPwyG ($ dO=}yG YQWyG -9IQ9V.yYGR! ;< Qqv Otp &zyG YQV #| GP$ fE
: )267/3( d

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

424

{gyz fhO< yGPv N+WyG OGQ|z &y(t< eRFh QS9:h Y(a@ r+wp :Eh ?+]tyG
&y &ATy9G| IQDv #| N+WyG OGQ| &< QTp 9}| #+t* )zf f9v fE :E y)Tfh
)$ {< IQO9"yG hC ?=*QjyG {F9T}yG #| BT+y ?yzT| )p JGPy9<h &*CQ &f9}Sh
k
?"GzyG i(Ap )p ;D}A| b9p6G )p QWA"}yGh e(zg}yG &|;v N+Wzyh QZgyG ?"Ap
fC #cCh Q9GJyG O;< )yE Qp9T* fC {=s #| 9"*Oy e(zg| &|;v fE {<- ?}FGOyG
v
;YC 9%y fG OtAfC 9}<Q #wyh ?y9SQyG Qw! } &=zsh Q|}G )p Qd! (y Q(AvOyG
k
k
.:(s &< )\Qh {*hzAyG )yE Qa\9p xyP )zf eOt* r+wp 9tC(|
k
&y9s 9| {+yO< 9<k (Aw| ;YC 9%y fC #cC B"v ?y9SQyG gP$ JCQs 9}y :d(sC
IQ| dh} QW"@h &@9ph {=s 9%=Av ry|}zy ?y9SQz X|9%yG )p 61vY 9$QV9!
N+WyG k{gy ))Tq! )p( Bztp )Og< ?y9SQyG ?|Ot| )zf Bgz_G Os #vC ~yh(
9}k *Os zaL KzZ+y S9"yG #+< 9$QW"* fC OGQCh &A|Py ?FQ=@ &A+Yh )p 9%=Av
Q=* fC {=s ?+"}yG &AzF9gp ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG i(Ap )p S9"yG #+< QWA!Gh &+p hsh
)zf &\Q| )p N+WyG ~%"}AFC ?!9|C QW!h >FG(yG AGOz< gD9+yhC e9tp &A|P
GQk |C JOFh Q<9Y O+gTyG 9%=Av )AyG ?|Ot}yG Bgy9_ 9}"+I )""wyh . 9%FGOC
9$9tyC eC N+WyG O* bM< B=Av ?y9SQyG {$z iQ|C #| IQ+I )p )"zgF 9=k +Gf
?GP9}y .&@(Z< ?f(}T| IQ\9J|
?y9SQyG fG("f QvP fC Og< )4U( &A|Ot| )p d(t* ?y9SQyG QV9! f}
GP$ i(AJ*hz d9s yuG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG ?y9SQzh y?"TyG d(I J9%=Vz
AG($}G {$C #| ?"Tzy
#+\Q9g}yG 9$9tyC J9%=V ^g< )zf H9AwyG
k
9GGI :E J9%=WyG gP$ B!9v 9|h {t"yG )zf {tgyG f(}wJ* #}|h e;wyGh
uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG ?y9SQ 9|Cz d9s ~C ...e;S G AGOfC #| ?+$Gh
9%+p #+<h &y(SQ ?"Sh uG H9Aw< ~wJyG H(Fh #f 9%+p N+WyG KOJAp
)1(

)2(

9 =I9Y BJ]p ?|Ot}yG #wyh OJyG GP$ O"f Q|}G )%A"* fC #w}}yG #| f9vh )1(
.?*(jzyG &F9aLz< &"f {t!G 9!C IQPg| )2(

.%

425

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~8C #+<h uG dR!C 9| Q+j< #+}v9JyG J:9Ih uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG J:9I
)y9g@
V9pCh O9FC Osh ~%"| {v ~wI )p {Zph YG(!C ?C;C )zf
.#+|C ~%zyG ..gG(D| ?"GyG {gFh gGQC uG >+_h
?"*O| )p )y9g@ N+WyG 9$9tyC IQ\9J| ?y9SQyG gP$ {YC f9v Osh
Q(|}9< 9%A|OM< B}s GP%yh ?_QV}G k*QqA< B}tp fG("gyG GP6 rF9ayG
:?+y9AyG
.?+@(ZyG ?_QV}G #| 9%j*Qq@ -1
.&A|Ot| )p &=Av 9| NyE ...JGQ9=gyG #| 9%+p 9| ?Gy9g| -2
&y(s fC ?+<QgyG {$C #| ?y9SQyG gP$ CQt* #| {v &}%q*h &A}%p iPyGh
9|Eh O+g< GP$h 9gk | #+Ay9SQyG )zf 9|E O(g* y...?y9SQyG gP$ {YC f9v Oshz
($ GP$h yuG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG ?y9SQz )$h GQk LB IQ(vP}yG ?y9SQyG )zf
~y &!C :)!9DyGh Q(vP| HQsC )zf O(g@ IQ9V}G f} dh}G :#+==Ty KFGQyG
h| #+@Q| 9$QvP 9}!Gh y?"TyG d(I J9%=Vz h| y?y9SQz ?}zv ?A=yG QvP*
.?y9SQ 98(w< 9%pQv f )AyG )%p yuG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyGz
.)A=*Q )yE ?=*Qh )@Q+I )zf IQ+I xyP )"CQhzp
?<9FE gO"f OFC )zgy )q+qf bGRQyG O=f O(}J| /P9AS}G )yE BgFQp
fC B}%p iPyG b*QWyG 9|E gO"f OFzS )"!C #cG B"vh )Az8S} ?+p9V
Bg=_ iPyGh N+WyG O* bM< H(Aw}yG {Y}G hC &"| 9%iGQpE ~@ ?y9SQyG
: )"g*z #*Q|}G #| iC O(Fh 9|k 9}@ )q"* O(}J| P9AS:9< GP{p .&"f ?y9SQyG
?y9SQyG gP$ QOZ| #f &"| B}%qASG 9}zp yN+WyG O* bM< {YC :h b*QV
:)!Q+I 9}< )!Q=LC
fhO< Q+qwAyG ($ ?yzT}yG gP$ )p ~9CQ fC 9"pQfh( ~zgyG ?=z_ ^g< gA9F

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

426

)zf )O+yG bM< ?<(Aw| BT+yh( ?f(=a| ?y9SQyG gP$ ~%g|h ){+Zq@
&@(| {=s N+WyG cOyGh &=Av bQ(yG GP$ fC ghQ=LCh ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG ~SG &+zf
ghQW"* )wy )gO=f Q<9Y O+gTyG N+WyG ?=Aw|( ?z+]qyG QGO )yE >$P9p
~%+p ?tC ~%"| gPLzp gOyGh ~zf QW! )zf UQJyG {v [*QI {FQyGh(
f9v 9| f9vh ?z+]qyG QGO )yE Q|}G O"SCh )gQW"< e9tp Q(vP}yG QV9"zy g9afzp
O}I N+WyG ~SG QvP< H9AwyG IQ_ #*vR fC xyP )zf OGR {< .xy &@QvP 9}|
xyP Og< utJA* #}p H9Awzy #+gFGQ}v ihOgyG )qaZ| N+WyGh i(AWyG
N+Wzy H9AwyG ?=T! )p xyP Og< H9@Q* iPyG GP #|h N+Wzy O"SC 9}|
>T"* 9| ?gFGQ| #| O< : &!C GP$ {D| )p )fGQ* fC )j="* iPyG {Y}Gh
u+sO@h u+t; fhO< GPw$ PL|* :h &@9+I )p QW"* ~yh &@(| Og< N+Wzy
.~w"*O fhPLz@ #}f GhQd!9p #*Oh ?!9|C ~zgy9p
bQh

{Z@9p gO=f Q<9Y O+gTyG N+WyG h| KO;G fC O*QC O(}J| P9AS~y Bzs
k
f9w| G QOt< dh9ICz )y9AyG QG(JyG &"+<h )"+< QGOh- V9*QyG )p 9+q@9$ &+zf
k
k
y)=TI ($h )y9g@ u9< 9"+gAT| QGO 9}y 9ZMz|h 9=f(AT| QG(JyG QvPC fC
9tk <9S O(}J| P9AS}G gQvP 9}< )!Q=Lzp 9%t+C(@h ?y9SQyG QOZ| #f &AyzS
)p GP$ {D}< fhOAg* : E*OJyG A9}zfh -&< OAg* : Q|C GP$ fC &y B"+=p
)@z@ fC )qw* :h ?y9SQyG gP%y {YC O(Fh #| O<:h >AwyGh J9*GhQyG J9=CG
bQh )zf ?f(=a| B!9v (yh )AI ?=@9wyG ?y6G hC Q@(+=}wyG )zf ?<(Aw|
#| bQ(yG GP%p -?A<9C J9g+s(@ iC &+zf U+y 9}y9_ ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG [M*
&!(=T"*h fhA9W* 9| &+zf f(=Aw+p S9"yG #| Q+Dv iO*C )p ht* fC #w}}yG
e;wyG GP$ &"| h=_ iPyG {Y}G #*zp -~zgyG {$C #| fhA9W* #| )yE

427

9%=Av N+WyG

? +fQW y

9s

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

gs #<G N+WyG 9%AJZ< )!Q=LC :d9s .Q+aMyG


o
.B="F 9%"wyh ?}FGOyG ?"Gzy 9%}*OtAy
y:z d9s 9%zYC )zf N+WyG xgz_C {%p :Bzs
?"GzyG U+FQy 9=k F9! f9v N+WyGh 96 PLz* ~yh 9%="F iPyG #}p :Bzs
.i(AqyG QGOYE {=s ?|9%yG K9J<:G #| Q+Dv ?<9Av &+yE O"T* f9vh
?}FGOyG ?"GzyG )p ih9AqyG QOZ@ r+v aQg@ : B!C :d9s
.)?}FGOyG ?"GzyG QGQSz< Q+=MyG H(zSz< )g| ~zw@h(
.y?ih9AqyG QOZ@ B!9v r+v )!Q=LCz &y Bzs
f(gs(* G(!9vh i(AqyG y?"GzyG A9]fCz )zf )z}* R9< #<G N+WyG f9vz d9s
~g! :d9s ry9M| iCQ ~%]g=y f9v (yh )AI :Bzs ?Ws9"| fhO< 9%+zf
e97E GP$ :Bzs yIQ+L}G e9*}G )p JGPy9<h xyP {gq* f9v R9< #<G N+WyG(
{< d(sC fG B+T!h( uG P9g| N+V 9* : :d9s )q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+Wzy
.)?"GzyG A9]fC h+}Gyh R9< #<G N+Wzy e97Gh
h|9G}yG hC A9}zgyG Q9=v ?8+$ #f QOZ@ )AyG ih9AqyG fE :&y Bzs ~C
ih9AqyG )zf )f;_Gh )}zf OI )zf( ?}d"}yG hC ?a<GQyG h}G}v ?+%tqyG
.)?+g}G}yG
{*P )p QvP* {< QGQtyG hC i(AqyG )zf f(gs(* : QDvC hC (]f ry9L GPE
.?Y9L Qd! ?%Fh &y fC hC h"A|G &!G i(AqyG
.h+}GyG 9%+zf hs(*h i(AqyG QOZ@ ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG :E :)y d9s
fE d h

)1(

O(

9AS:G )zf GhQ9VCh Q<9Y O+gTyG #f O+g< u*Q_ #| JA9F dh}G )p ?y9SQyG xy9< OL
k
9}p O+gTyG ($ ;YC 9%y fC ,fO*h 9%"f hpGO* iPyG f6Gh O+gTyG O"f 9$QW"* fC O(}J|
?GP$ )"g|
P

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

428

~g! :d9s .{F9T}yG gP$ QaLC )p ry9M| iCQ ~%y f9v (yh :Bzs
&*R*Q<:Gz &<9Av )p i(AWyG O}I Q(AvOyG gQvP 9| ry9M* GP$ {< :Bzs
h| rzALG GPE ) R9< #<G e9| G( f9v :d9s 167vY y?*R9=yG #+gTAyG )p
d(t* fC QDw* ~zgyG {$C #| &y #+Ws9"}yG hC i(AqyG )p &y #+vQ9W}yG OIC
&+tqyG utJ}yG ?|;gyG 9"L(+V N+Vh 9"M+V ByzS yx*CQ ~7G x*CQ ~7Gz
k
eOsCh
R9< #<G e9| G #| 9"S Q=vC f9vh
)q+qf bGRQyG O=f )qzTyG
?f(g"Z@ r+wp R9< #<G N+WyG h| ~wJyG )p ~AqzALG GPE :i(AqyG )p &"|
xyPv 9!Ch yx*CQ ~7G x*CQ ~7Gz )zf QQw* ?Ws9"}yG A9%A!G Og< :)y d9tp
gQQt* 9}< i(AqyG QhOY( hC ~wJyG )p b9q@:9< Q|}G )%A"* )AI .&y d(sC
#}+p 9!O$G ~%zyGz &y(s a;AL:G O"f
QQw* f9vh )&tpGh #|h U+FQyG
.yB*O$
OGOfE #| )q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+WyG {F9SQh ih9Ap )yE BgFQ 9}"+Ih
O+yh d(t* 48vY N+WyG ?=Q@ )p JOFh gO=f Q<9Y O+gTyGh U*QOC #< O+yh
A9]fC h| rzAM* f9v &!C
bGRQyG O=f N+WyG )"COI Oshz U*QOC #<
f9wp Y(vQyG cGQO{< e9| G h| ?gvQyG cGQOE ?yzT| 9%"| ?z+zs {F9T| )p ?"GzyG
9}v ?;9qy9< :E e9| G h| ?gvQyG cQO* : e(|z}yG fC iQ* bGRQyG O=f N+WyG
)zf hs(* : bGRQyG O=f N+WyG f9wp gQ+ih iQ9M=yG e9| G >$P| ($
9"yh &"| VQjyG {J| )%A!G y?yzT}yG gP$ )p ?"GzyG #| IQO9ZyG ih9AqyG
:J9dI;| xyP )zf
?yzT| #| QaLCh Q%VC )$h uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG ?yzT| #DAT* ~y -1
.Y(vQyG cGQO{< e9| G h| ?gvQyG cGQOE
#| IQO9ZyG ih9AqyG )zf hs(* : bGRQyG O=f N+WyG f9wpz &y(s -2
.y?yzT}yG gP$ )p ?"GzyG
&< ~zf )zf (%p gO=f Q<9Y O+gTyG N}G aGQV{< h=_ Q|}G GP$ -3

429

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

rzL hs(* f9v N+WyG fC )fOGh Y(\(}yG )zf )}v fh )"f g9qLC GP9}zp
{wy )fGOyG 9| ?"GzyG A9}zf h+= )yE GP6 A9SCh ?gFGQ| fhO< R9< #<G N+WyG
xyPv B!Ch {< )@Q+I )yE IQ+Ih )A=*Q )zf ?=*Q OGORG GP$ )"zgG* :C GP$
.>+=zyG Q9tyG 99C
:?|9$ IOF9p

Y ?*R*Q<:G )p i(AWyG O}I Q(AvOyG d9s


Qqih - )q+qf bGRQyG O=f ?|;gyG N+WyG ?I9}S f{p ?=S9"}yG gP6hz
k
R9< #<G e9| G UzF Osh R9< #<G e9| G IP@9SC ?t=_ #| GOIGh Q=Ag* -&y
?|;gyG h| 9%+p Hh9"A* f9v IQAp &IhQV ^g< )yE h}ASGh &ShQO ^g< )yE
N+WyG dB ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| e9| G )Aq}yG h|9F )p )a+t"WyG #+|}G O}J|
k
.y9g+= uG ~%}IQ
)z}* f9v R9< #<G N+WyG fE d(t* fC {F9ty R(G* &@QvP 9| {v Og=p :d(sC
)AI h+s(AyG :E ~%+zf 9| ~C gG(Ap ))q+qf bRGQyG O=f e9| G ~%+ph( ~%+zf
BT+yC ?fPE ?"GzyG Y9}AFG IOF9p 9}p i(AqyG gP$ )p &!(qy9M* G(!9v fEh
iQJAyG ?*9i )yE d(Y(yGh u+C(AyG {FC #| ?+f9}GyG i(Aqzy ?8+$ )$ ?"GzyG
?"GzyG )p ~+df #g_ GP$ fE !!?OIGh OQp iCQ )p dRA< 96 r+wp
.-d9=< ~wy QaM* fC u9< ~vP+fC- 9$A9}zfh
)&zyG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG( ?y9SQ QV9! h| )AWs9"| )yE O(g!h *
.?|(fR}yG
.y)Az8SC )zf ?<9FE OG* ~yh Bzs 9| h}S fC Og<z :)y d9s
Qqv( d(t* #| ~%"}p rzTyG A9}zf O"f )AI ?+p;L ?yzT}yG :)LC 9*
{t! Otzp Q+Dv #<G Q+Tq@ )yE hFQGh )QjYC Qqv( d(t* #| ~%"|h )Qqv fhO
.LQG(MyG #| xyP< ($ {%p yQqv ~wJyG )p I(VQyGz O(gT| #<G #f

179v

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

430

Q+i {@9tyG Qqw* )="yG {%p yQqv &y9Asz | d(SQyG d(tv GP$ fC &y B"+=p
.yQqv fhO GQk qvz OZt* O(gT| #<G 9}!Eh .: :HG(GyG ?{JAT}yG
)<9Av )p O(F(| GP$h 9|k 9}@ xzD| d;JAS:G WGQAV9< d(sC 9!G :)y d9s
)S9=y G {*R|(
.?+p;L ?yzT}yG d(sC xyP h| )""wyh
9"tt; Q|C GP$h Q|}G GP$ )p ?"TyG {$C #+< a;L c9"$ U+y :&y Bzs
#+|Os}G #*QTq}yG h+= dG(sC 9"zt!h ?yO}G JGQWf xyP )zf 9!O"fh &"|
?*R9=yG ?g|OyG b*QV )p R9< #<G d9s 9}v ?yzT}yGh ?"TyG {$C #| #+COJ}yGh
k
.y55vY ?*R*Q<:G #f ;t!z
?}C #w* ~y 9| >!PyGh ?+Zg}yG OQG}< f(w* : Q+qwAyG ....z
.yLQG(MyG ?fOA=}yG >$P| GP$ a;Lh :d(t* f9vh #zg| Q$9c d;JASG
?Y9L 9+k q@9$ xg| ?yzT}yG gP$ )p ?Ws9"}zy hTA* : d9G}yG :&y Bzs ~C
d(I xg| )D*OI 9}!Eh d;JAS:G Q+qwAyG )p WQAW* x=$P| fE d(t@ fCh
?: eC {YC 9%y {$h ?y9SQyG u+C(@
-{YC 9%y U+y ?y(%G| ~g!- ?y(%G| i(Ap 9%+p ?y9SQ QW! R(G* r+vh
~zgyG {$C h| ?+f9}GyG IQ(%W}yG ?tC(}yG N+WyG i(Ap ^g=yG 96 ^s9"*h
e;v W9tSE ^g=yG GP$ O*Q*h -?}FGOyG ?"GzyG ih9Ap )"fC- R9< #<G d9D|C #|
e;v W9tSE hOGQC 9}v- &y {YC : e;w< ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG A9]fC N(+WyG
?+<QgyG ?+|(tyG Ot! &<9Av )p ~*Os &<9WA| e;w< K*QZyG K\G(yG R9< #<G N+WyG
GP$h ~%A"S gP$ -Qv9V O}IC N+WyGh )tqyG O|9I N+WyG h| G(zgp 9}vh
.~6CO
)f;p ...P+|;@( ?y(%G}yG ?y9SQyG gP$ QOZ| f(w* fG )qw* :C ~C
)1 (

)2 (

hFGQ+zp &+zf )"y9IC 9}| 98k +V &+p OFC ~zp yS9=y G {*R|z &<9Av )yE Og< 9}+p BgFQh )1(
.9"gs(| )zf O(F(| ($h IOF9}yG IQ(S #| J9*~y 9!Q+Tq@ )p xyPh )2(

431

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q+qwAyG I9fO #| ($ ~zgzyh - &+yE f(=TA"* iPyG N+WyG ~SG JQvPhz


.u+C(AyGh ?"+=y9< )fO}yG >y9a!h 9%y(=s )p rs(A! )AI
d(t< d(t* hGQ A9F GPE &!C ?*GhQy9< ~zgyG {$C #f e(zg}yG #| U+yC
m
v
GP{p IOhOQ| &A*GhQ f9p -?*(t@ iC- &=$P}y ?*(t@ &A*GhQ )ph LQG(MyG
.^g< b(p 9%]g< J9}zc B!9v {F:OyGh #FGQtyG gP$ Bg}AFG
k
.)9a*QV )"fC( Y(}T| )dqy :h )aL {YC ?y9SQzy U+y -1
k
)zf ;+yO GP6 )qvh )f;p N+WyG( P+|;@ O* )zf ?y9SQyG JA9F -2
k
N+WyG >$P}y 9%Aqy9M}yh 9+k !9C ~%=$P| O*|@ 98}h :hC ~%Ay9%Gy GQk d! 9$OQ
k
.9Dy9C
k
.9*Q; OVCh ~wICh B=CC )$h ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG i(Aqy ?]s9"| ?y9SQyG -3
k
.96 9}zf N+WyG A9"<} U+y -4
)AI QZ| )p f9v fC P"| N+WyG &+zf f9v 9| ^s9"* ?y9SQyG )p 9| -5
N+WyG #| #+<Qt}yG #| ($h i(AWyG O}I N+WyG fC {+yO< ?*O(gTyG )p QtASG
u+zgAzy g9fO 9| GP$h N+WyG >$P}y &Aqy9M| #+v< {< 9%+p 9}y MQAT* ~y
k
GP%y gQW! )zf O+gTyG N}G eO! xyPyh -9qT! 9%qT"* 9}< ?y9SQyG )zf
)zf &=@9f O(f9s #<G N+WyG fG )?t<9TyG ?q@9%}yG )p( )y d9s Otp u+zgAyG
&=T!h &y9s 9| ?JZ< ~zfC uGh- i(AWyG O}I Q(AvOyG u+zg@ QW"< &I9}S
)AyG ?|Ot}yG #f &@QvP 9|h ?y9SQyG gP$ IAGQty )A<Q: f{p O(f9s #<G N+Wzy
UT;C )"zgG* b*QWyG #| ZQq|h Y(}T| {YC 9%y ?y9SQyG fC 9%"| B}%p
?"GzyG bQh )zf 9%A<9Av #| GAkO< ?y9SQyG gP6 b+J* 9| {v )p )|Os hsG(|
)1 (

)2 (

)3(

q+qf bGRQyG O=f O(}J| /P9AS}G >zay GP+q"@ &}SG QvPC ~yh )1(
k
.)q+qf bGRQyG O=f O(}J| /P9AS}G >zay GP+q"@ &}SG QvPC ~yh )2(
k
.9g+= 9!A9}zf )zfh &+zf &zyG ?}IQ -&zyG g9p(@- O(f9s #<G N+WyG fC eI: )3(
.)

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

432

~C ...~C 9fk (}T| ;YC ?y9SQzy fz< &*(}AyG ~C ?}FGOyG


.f(gFGQ &+yE 9!Eh u 9!Eh hFGQ}yG u+zg@ #f dhOgyG )"}@ ~C 9%AgFGQ}<
bGRQyG O=f O(}J| P9AS5y Bzs Q(vP}yG h| ?}y9w}yG B%A!G fC Og<h
)zf {}g! fC 9"+zf >FG(yGh
OyG(yG )zf ?<hPw| ?y9SQyG gP$ )q+qf
#| f(zjAT}yG e;wyG GP$ {jAT* : )AI
N+WyG #f HPwyG GP$ ?_9|E
- {F9T}yG gP$ )p G(qzALG N(+WyG fC GhQ%d* fC fhO*Q* #*PyG YO=yG {$C
?J+JZyG #+}+DgyG #<Gh R9< #<Gh )!9=y:G ih9Ap ~%A<Q\ fC Og< xyPh(
#| h!9}yG 9}p )t+tI a;L c9"$ #w* ~y f9p -){At| )p IOI(}yG ?J*QZyG
a;MyG GP$ d;L #|h ~7(| Og< N(+WyG )yE 9%A=T!h ih9AqyG YGQALG
.Q+w! fhO< ~%fO< GhQQ}* fC f(g+aAT* d(J"}yG HhPw}yG )fO}yG
QTyG )p &=$P|h ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C IO9F )zf f9v N+WyG fC uJyGh
9| IQZ! {+=S )p A)V iz< ?+J]Azy OGOgASG )zf f9vh #zgyG )p &=$P}v
/ )tqyG -uJ<- Q<9v}G ~zgyG {$C #| &!G(LE {D}v xyP )p &zD| OtAg*
)!9=y}G -R9< #<G .... -SGQ$ {+zL - {+v(yG #}IQyG O=f- Qv9V O}IC
.~$Q+ih ..#+}+Df #<G k
QhOY HzCC 9!9+< QGOY{< )q+qf bGRQyG O=f O(}J| /P9AS}G e9s {gqy9<h
.f9+=yG x+yEh rzS Q+My rzL Q+L &zgFh uG &dqI ?"TyG {$C
9A

Ak % !Gh ...

VVV
iOyG(y uG dR!C

9| Q+j< ~wJyG ?y9SQ d(I K+\(@h e9$

)q+qf

b G R Q yG

f9+<

O=f N+WyG

Og< 9|C | uG d(SQ )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh u O}JyGh uG ~T<


{Y}G )p )$ ?+}v9JyG ?yzT| )p iOyG(y ?<(T"}yG ?y9SQyG gP$ f9p
?+}zgyG K(J=yG ?S9FQ &+zf Y(=a| bQh )zf ?=@9wyG ?y69< ?<(Aw| ?y9SQ
:

433

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

N+WyG #| 9$hPLC ~8C )!hQ=LCh ~zf ?=z_ bQ(yG GP6 )!A9F Osh A9Ap Gh
bGRQyG O=f N+WyG #| 9$PLC &!E ~%y d9s Osh
O(gs #< #TI #< uG O=f
9%y {YC #f BDJ< )!E E+Ih d9GgAS9< ?f9=azy 9%AFQLzp
)q+qf
GPyh- OFC ~zp
9%+zf iOyG(y h+s(@ hC )@(Y {+GT@ hC ?+aL IQ(YhC
)yE 9%A=T! ?JY )zf {+yO iC gO"f f9v #|h 9<Pv
iOyG(y 9%A=T! f(w*
ih9Ap )p IO(F(| )%p ?+}v9JyG ?yzT| )p gGh9Ap 9|Ch &< Jz+zp
iOyGh
v
QZ| )p O": O}IC )Lzp ?+z}gyG ?+I9"yG #|h -&g+s(@ 9%+zfh ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG
fC iOyGh f9w|{< f9vh f9]|Q HQI )p 1973 e9f {Ash 1968 e9f
GP$h 1967 e9f ?fGQRyG ?+zv #| &FQ< Og<h O+"GAyG {=s ?*O(gTzy gQ]J*
.y)q+qf bGRQyG O=f O(}J| 9%=Av f9gAT}yG uGh ~zgzy
v
hs(| )zf O(}J| P9AS}G &g\h ?z|9v ?t+tJyG )zF iPyG f9+=yG GP$h
gQ%d+zp ~zf gO"f f9v #|h h+}GyG &+zf hza+y )q+qf bGRQyG O=f N+WyG
.xyP &y )!Ch

:?dI;|

#|hz &y(t< u<9TyG f9+=yG )p O(}J| P9AS}G 9$QvP )AyG ?yzT}yG gP$
fC >IC yNyE ... 1968 e9f QZ| )p O": O}IC )Lzp ?+z}gyG ?+I9"yG
)q+qf bGRQyG O=f #< )1()~Y9f O}IC( )fGQRyG SO"%}y9p .9%+zf uzfC
Os f9vh- QZ| )p ?fGQRyG ?+zw< uJAyGh ?*O(gTyG #| ?|9gyG ?*(!9DyG PLC
^pQp )(wT!(+yG h=@( ?*O(gTyG ?SO"6 uJAz* fC e9| G gOyGh )zf VQf
?+T"GyG )zf {Y9JyG N+WyG f9w|{< f9v -QZ| )p &ASGQO )8C 9}yh N+WyG
h|h iQZ}yG X+GyG gOyh d(LO eOf )p d9AJ* fC gO:hCh ($ ?*O(gTyG
P8Ash QZ| U+FQ f9vh 1967 ?"S xyPh X+GyG &y(LO )zf upGh xyP
.)

>vQ| ~SG( ~Y9f O}IC

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

434

O"f QY9"yG O=f d9= ($ #| e(zg|h yQY9"yG O=f d9=z


.#+*Q+qwAyGh
U}L &+p Ew}+y iQZ}yG X+GyG )p gOyh O+": )zf N+WyG ?tpG(}p
:C -IO9%WyG &y uG dzT!- e1973 ?"S f9]|Q HQI )p {At* )AI JG("S
?+qzTyG )yE f(=TA"* #}| GQk +Dv fG ~zg! 9"!E- f(+qzTyG 99C ~w*Oy 98k +V )"g@
k
?|(wJyG fhQqw* #*PyG #+*Q+qwAyG #f ;]p -X+Gy9< b9JAy G f(|QJ*
k
g9: )z}gyG N+WyG aQZ@ ($ 9%p- J(i9azy 9+|9I X+GyG fhQ=Ag*h
)J]* e9d"yG GP$h ?|(wJyG gP$ Qqw* #| {%p -9%W+Fh ?*QZ}yG ?|(wJyG
IO}y #wyh ?"Ty :h Q%Wy : X+Gy9< gOyh b9JyE )zf upG(*h gO=v IPzq<
fC :(y O*R@ fC #w}}yG #| f9vh -U}MyG JG("TyG )yE BzYh- ?z*(_
&"<G ~IQh ?gSGh ?}IQ N+WyG uG ~IQ- H9Av {FC {wyh u=S &zFC
.-&@9"F K+Tp 9}%"wSCh
#*QWf #| f(wA@ I9fOyG ^g=y ?+@GP ?=Q@ )zf Bgz_G :{+*P@ *
k
)p &< e9s ;}f OG* ~yh- &Tq! #f ?+fGOyG 9%+p KO; H9wS(zp ?JqY
)wJ* fC :E &y9D|z< #+fhOM}yG H9=Wzy ?dfh IQ=f f(w* fC uJAT* &@9+I
X+GyG d(LO gQ9=AfGh X+GyG )p &A+Jy uzJ* fC ^pQ 9}"+I &@:(a< ~%y
#GS #| &y9tA!E {IGQ| gAGQs )zf [t* PLCh #GS r+vh iQ=v ?+Zg|
)wJ* PLCh -I(fOyGh k+z=AyG H9=V #| 9<k 9V &|9|E {gF r+vh #GS )yE
)yG(I #GTyG )p &AZs BzjWp #GTyG )p &M+V J9|GQvh &@9|GQv #f
N+WyG )!9<QyG 9"A|;f #f g9!QvP 9| b(T! &y9D|C )yEh &+y{p ?=QAyG #| %50
o
.?+qzTyG A9+fOCh uJ< ?+qzTyG N(+V #+< bQqyG aQg+y )q+qf bGRQyG O=f
.)\Q*h >J* 9}y ~v9*Eh uG 9"tph
fG(

435

? +fQW y

&zyG

dR C

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9}< ~wJyG( {Zp

?+]s ,p e;S G ~wI 9"+=| -)y9g@ uG fP{< - e;wyG KAApC 9}"+I


)q< : )AyG )}dgyG 9%A!9w| e;S G ,p 9%y ?+]s ,$h .uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG
o 98zV ,p d9s )y9g@ uG fC ,qw*h #||| )zf

=<;:98
@?>
_^]\[ZYXW
]44

]45

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

]47

+ *
) ( '&%

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

$#

)"!C :E - Og< 9}+p J9*6G gP%y #+A| ,qzS Q+Tq@ )y9g@ uG fP{< )@z+Sh
)yE I(fOyG ,p ?f9}GyG N(+V O%F 96 #+<C 9"F9}zgy ?y9t| Q9+ALG ,p JQAIC
)yE 9%g= ,p L9A; )AyG J:9t}yG gP$ IQDwy GQk d! uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG
O}IC {+zGyG N+Wzy IQ\9J}yG gP$ Q9+ALG )zf )iv CQ QtASG GQk +LCh JGOzG|
)QZ| ,p #+!G(tyG QOZ| 9!(w* fC >G* ?"TyGh H9AwyG( fG("g< Qv9V O}J|
uzgA@ GQk(|C 9"y B"+< 98C 9%}$Ch IQ+Dv IQ\9J}yG gP%y iQ9+ALG H9=SCh
9| )zf GAk9"<h A9}zgyG #| &!G(LE Qv9V O}IC N+WyG &=_9M* f9v jPyG hsG(y9<
Q+TqAyG IO}f ,p Q(vP}yG &|;v ~%q! fC h+aAT! IQ\9J}yG gP$ #| 9"}%p
: 9| N+WyG e;v G(z}Jp &}%p S9"yG #| Q+Dv A9SC iPyGh &%Fh )zf gQ+ih
9|h 9]k s9"A| N+WyG G("c g(}%p 9| ry9M* QLB &y e;w< G(\Q(f 9}yh &z}AJ*
.~%}%p A(S #| :E e(tyG ,@hC
.?|;gyG e9| G IQ\9J| f6G x+yEh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

436

"

? TyGh

H9AwyG

QZ| ,p #+!G(tyG QOZ| 9!(w*

fC

>G*

9TyG 99C
x
OVC #| Y(\(| ,p ~w+yE KnO;} ~w*O*C #+< d(D}y9< e(+yG BpQW@
m
k
o
- f(y(t* 9}v - H9AwyGh ,?z=tAT}yGh ?+\9}yG 9"@9+I ,p IQ(aL h+\G(}yG
?"TyGh Hl9AwyG( #l +p <q Kl *QY ,QQv Jn |o OlhOJ| ,A}zv foG("fh .&!G("f #| aQg*o
n
.)QZ| ,p #+!G(tyG QOZ| 9!(w* fC >G*
n
n
l
,p IQGOZyG Ogt| ~|}G #+< f6G Ogt@ ,$h ,,t|;SE Oz< Ql Z|h ,~g!
96h ,VQ}G A9J!C ,p f(}zT}yG Qd"* h"Z@ 9| )yEh ,e;S G xy9}|
n r n n
v ]@n fC uG Pn9n g|n h ,f(zw ]*n hC fhOA%+p ,fhOAt*
,9$Q|C Bwz| fC Og< Qo Z| {
p
p
n
q
v
o
n
q
:d(t* uG d(SQh ,&p zv ,|;S G ~y9gyG ~CE {}JAp ,98h|W< BztASGh
kv
v n n
n n r n o r
o r
,gOp g< #|p 96 {}f #| QRhh 9$QRh &+zf f9v ?8+S ?"S e;S G ,p #S #|z
p
p
.yAl,V ~$QGRhC #| [t"* fC Q+i #|p
!IO9TyG 99C
n
k
&yR!C 9}< S9"yG #+< 9}k v9Ih ,GQk *P!h GQk +W<h 9*k O9$ GO}J| {SQC uG fE
q
)yE Sn9"yG 9fn Onh ,&p zv #*OyG )zf gQ%n d+y uJyG #*Oh iO%o y9< &zSQC .&+zf
dR!Ch .~%Az|9g|h ~7GO9=f ,~$9+!Oh ~%"*O ,p ,~$Q(|C h+= ,p &Af9_
p
l
k
l
n
#| OIC ,@z* #yh ,9%z=s hFGQWyG #| ?g*QV 9%+yE ~o Tr @ ~y ,?z|9v ?g*QV &+zf
xyPh ,~6 ~o zfC ($h un zMyG uzL uG fv z< xyP .9%zD}< :h 9%"| Qm +M< gOg<
k
o n
.#++="yG ~@9L GO}J| fz<
n
o
e(}g< ,f9w|h f9|R {v ,ph ,?p9v S9"zy ?z|9wyG ?g*QWyG gP$ &zyG YQV
n
,Q$OyG )zf ?+s9=yG B!9wp.&< ?y9SQyGh I(="yG ~AM<h ,#+|}G d(SQyG ?Dg<
k
n
r n n n
n
fhO QZg< :h ,?m |C fhO ?m |z< ?Y9L #w@ ~yh .hFGQWyG h+= BMT!h
m
!IO

437

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Qo +jA@ : IO9=gyG f} ,979+FRG< ?zZv q| JoGO9=gyG B!9v xyPyh .Qm Zf


,p ,h}AG}yGh OQqyG fh(8V #| 9$G(S 9| f9vh .Q(ZgyGh Q($OyG a;AL9<
OfG(tyGh ,J9|(wJyG e9d!h ,?+S9+TyG {F9T}yGh ,?+!O}yG J;|9g}yG
k
k
n
)zf [v "n *o ~y ,?+|9S ?+vzv OfG(s ,xyP )yE 9|h ,J9<(tgyGh ,?+F9]tyG
q
QCzA* : 9}| ,Q+aMyG Q|}G ,p ,QO9"yG {+ztyG )zf :E ,9%+p YhQqyG {+Y9q@
.f9w}yGh f9|RyG a;AL9<
{}gyGh ?g*QWyG gP$ Z;<{< ,f(yhv }G f(}zT}yG ,Ko y9ZyG 9"qzS e9tp
q
)zf 9%|9wIC GhPq"p ,~89azS ,p fGOz=yG #| {LO 9}+ph ~%Tq!C ,p ,96
hF9s(yG )zf 9$OfG(s u+=a@ ,p GhO%AFGh ,dG(I}G h+= ,ph ,?p9v S9"yG
n
n
,?+%tqyGh ?+y(Y}G OfG(tyGh ,?t+sOyG YhQqyG 9%"| G(a="ASGh ,KOG(JyGh
k
o
IhQC 9"y G(vQ@ )AI ,#*OyG ,p U;LEh ,~zgyG ,p ?aT< #| uG ~$9@B 9}<
k
?k y9f ~$On g< #|n f9v )AIh ,~|}G hFGQV ,p ;+D| 9%y Oo Gp !n : ,?+g*QW@
.~%+zf
o
:h #*Ozt| )yh}G Q(ZgyG ,p Io9]tyGh eo9wJq yGh A9%tqyG #w* ~yh
q
:E ,A9}zgyG QDvC #+< Oo +ztAyG 9Wn pn ~C .#*O%AG| IkO9S G(!9v {< ,#*O|9F
#| fhOzt}yG f9v Otp xyP h|h .{+F {v ,p iO%o yG Kn +<9Z| G(!9v GOkGQpC
m n
o
n
o
AGQ|}Gh c(z}yG f9vh .~$O+zt@ ,p W9="AS:Gh u+=aAyG f("TJ* A9}zgyG
rp gr \n Qo Zf A9F fC )yE ,&< #+wT}A| ~%"*O< A9}zf A9}fRyGh OoG(tyGh
n
,p So9"yG hn *9An An p .#+z$9GyG AGQ|}G OGO=ASGh A9}zgyG rg]< ,#+}zT}yG
?k Y(Z"| BT+y YhQp ,p ,#*QLzA}yG A9%tqyG dG(s} ~%=Zg@ Ov AVGh ,O+ztAyG
p
aQf )zf ,"< A9}zgyG &a="ASG 9}| 9%"| GQk +Dv {gyh ,?"TyGh H9AwyG ,p
9%]g< {gy {< ,O9%AF:G O"f 979fGQ| ~y9gyG )zf >G* ahQdy hC ,#+vg|
.e(Zg}< U+y &!z< ,&zF9s &+p zaLC 9}|
)1(

btp QWyG )p h<9AAyG ($h ,?+AJAyG A9+y9<

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

438

Q|}Gh ,9"z+F u=S jPyG {+GyG A9F fC )yE ,u+]yG OAVGh LQJyG QDvh
k
k
,?+=Zfh GO(= fhOGOR* - ~$QDvC hC - A9}zgyGh ,^g< b(p 9%]g< J9}zc
k
o
o r
#f ;]p ,&@Q*9T| #f ~$O+zt@ ~6 Ogo t*n ,h*QS Qm(a@ )yE jQG* #o |RyGh
o
n
fC A9}zgyG )zf ,\9}yG {+GyG ,p AGQ|}G ^g< VQf Oty )AI .&t=S
k
)zf 9Yk QI ,?g<Q}G >$GP}yG #| &!(T=At* , 9+sfQV 9!(!9s S9"zy G(gn ]n *n
k
k
G(<zp ,9+Ash 9F;f f(w* Os ,h\G(A| >z_ ($h ,O+ztAyG #| G(qyp C 9|
n r
.~%"f VQn fzp ,GhQw"ASGh
;t! Br zt!o ,?=QA}yG ?o +G!Qp G #o +!G(tyG gP$ 9!O;< ,p 9"+zf Br zLO ~C
n
k
g(WAy BzLOp ,a
Q
f
h
C
I
O
9
f
h
C
#
*
O
#
|
,
9
6
9
"
y
?
z
Y
:
~
|
C #f 9+pQI
m
m
m
n n
n
v no k
n n ro
k
!!?+!O}yG )}T@ ?qFGR GQ(Ws 9"T=z@h ,9"@GO9f #| NT}@h 9!OF9tf
p
l
n nn
o
d9FQ 9%IhQ ,p Nq! Osh ,IQ\9JyG ?+|;S G ?+}zgyG ?]%"yG JA9F ~C
o
n
,gO=f O}J|h ,,w!9jp}G #*OyG d9= ~%A|Ot| ,ph ,~$QZf SGQ=! G(!9v
n v n
n r
n
n n n
s
:989+"< uChh ,9$OfG(s )SQCh ,9+z}f 9%y(YC h\hh .9\Q O+VQ O}J|h
o
k
JQ9Ch ,d(tgyG Bdt+AS9p .9g+= ~%"f uG ,\Q ,Qv9V O}J| jOyGh
r
Osh ,O9%AF:G H(Fh )l yE >o $n P*n #|n A9}zgyG ,p k=!n h ,O+ztAyG )zf S(q"yG
#| Ql +L &"wyh ,Q+Dv zaL &+p GOk9%AFG f(w* Osh ,GQk TA=| GOk9n %AFG f(w*
n r
.#*OyGh ?|}G )zf uG A9V fE iOFCh ,O(}GyG
!IO9TyG 99C
k
n
k
,:O< &< ,j=! : 9"!C ~fR!h ,9""*O )zf UQJ! ,f(}zT| 9g+= 9"!E
o
n nn
w
n
,IO9=gyG QF9gV #| 9"+p e9t* 9| Rh9GA* : &!C #d!h ,#*OyG ~%p raM! 9""wyh
o
)yE {o +vM*o h ,?z\9qyG b;L}G )yE I(fOyG #| Ao9=aMyGh X9f(vyG &< rA9 9|h
n
,?+f9}AF:G b(tJyGh ,?+!O}yG J;|9g}y9< #*Ozy fzV : &!C 9"| Q+Dv
)1(

K}TyG )<C Q$9dyG O=f ?|;gyG J:9t| )zf 9tk +zg@ vY 9tk <9S &@QvP 9| hFGQ

)1(

439

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?+zLGOyG ?S9+Ty9< :h ,HQJyG fh|W< &y ?n zY :h ,Q*RgAyGh J9<(tgyGh


l
l
o
n
,?S9+Sh #*O e;S G .f("d* 9| )zf U+y e;S G fE ,;v .?+FQ9MyGh
v
q
vo
n
l
,&zv ghPLz* fC :E &+g=A| #| )\Q* : ($h .f9azSh ~wIh h*QW@h
p
v
n
.&zv g9<C Otp &|9wIC ^g=< 9\QyG #| )<C #}p ,&|9wIC h+}Gy G(g]M*h
n
o
.fhO*Q@ 9| ~wTq!} GhQ9ALG ~C uG e;v G(g}SG

H
GF
ED C
B A@?
> =
< ;:
o
.pQ P O N
M L
K J
I
G
F
ED C
BA @
? > =< ; {
T S R Q PO N ML
K JI
H
cb a` _
^]
\ [ZYX W
V U
p o n ml k j ih
gfed
} | { z y x w v u ts r
q

.[51-47 :Q("yG] }

c b a ` _ ^ ] \ [ Z Y X W V{
qponmlkjihgfed
~}|{zyxwvutsr

"
!
/
.
,
+
*
)
(
'
&
%
$
#
\10
<
;
:
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
]@?>=
E
D
C
B
A
^PONMLKJIHGF
]i h\g[ Z
Y
X
W
V
U
T
S
R
Q
_`_^
f
e
d
c
b
a
t
s
r
q
p
o
n
m
l
k
j
"!~}|{zyxwvu

?+fQWy

-59 :A

9T " y G ] }

Gh

?S9+Ty

,+*)('&%$#

?+}v9Jy

440

.[65

9TyG 99C
Bo Tyh .GQk +Dv 9$(}@CQsh ,GQk +Dv 9$(}Ao g}S Os ,gQo |GhCh &p zyG Jo9*B gP$
l
n
l r
l
IQn =fp 9%+p ,?"+< ?J*QY ?}wJ| J9*C ,%p ,9%IQV hC 9$Q+Tq@ OOZ< f6G
v
n
9}+ph ,989+Zf hC 9%Af9_ #| ~wy9I ,p ~@Qwo phn ,9$(}Az|v z@ (y ?l dfp h ~wy
n
{< ,?m zZ< e;S G )yE Bw }o @ : #n +!G(t< f(}w; ~A!Ch ,9%y9+n Ip ~w+zf >G*
98C Bo Ir Qv Y GPE 9+k y9j| fo(vC : {< ,&]s9"@o h 9%|9wIC #| Qm +Dv ,p &+p9"@ ,$
9}v Bzt!o h B=Q@o 98C xyP ,e;S G )yE 9%"| HoQsC IQ\9JyG ?+!GQZ"yG )yE
r
r x o
o
o
n
,?+J+T}yG )yE >TA"@ ~|} Bg\p h ~C ByOf ,?m +"Ch #+!G(s #f ,$
~7GO9fh ~$OF9tf )yE Hnm QsC ,9+k "*O 9gk \h ~$On "f hr \n (@o ~y fEh ,Br !9wp
QZf ,p #o +!G(tyG gP$ 9"+zf Br <Qp \o Osh .GP$ {v ,p 9"vfn On gn <r Ch ,~%pQfh
q
9$D9}zf f9vh ,98k +V 9%Tq"y xz}@ : ?o |}G B!9vh ,J9}zc &zv f9v
.#*O|9F #+qg]AT|
v
BzLO Osh ,?+|;SE Qp +i ?m j=Z< 9%zv Sn(q"yG ko =Z@ JO9v #+!G(tyG gP$
o
JQ9Yh ,9%+!O #f 9%"Aq@ JO9v )AI ,9%A<QVzp S(q"yG )zf 9$OfG(s
n
n
o
,fGOyG Q9Y )AIh ,IQw"AT| IQw"|n Q(|}G #| Q+Dv ,p ?+|;S G OfG(tyG
{GM* hC ,rg]*n h #o =o Gr *n ,q |;S G S9S}G )zf h*QWAyG h\h )yE
no
r n
o
- ~$Qd! ,p - ~$(fO* &!C xyP !! ?*QMSh AR$ #| ,s;* 9}| ,X}w"+p
?m *O9< ?|} hn \ho &!C f(}fR* h*QW@ )yE ,9!k Qs QWf ?n C;C jQt%tyG Y(FQyG )yE
!!?m z$9F
x
o
n
o
k
aGQS G hC (zjyG >$P| rYp C 9}+p >$PC ,!C - IO9TyG 99C - G("d@ :
n rn
k
o
o
o
n
,BGF9Ih ByO9Fh ,,!O*Oh jGQn +Gp $p I(fOyG gP$ BzgF ,!{p ,d(tyG ,p
{w Gp !o #}| Ak9}SC ~wy Bo +r }v Tn y ,n }x Sn C fC Bo 8V (yh .Bo g}Sh Bo *CQh
!IO

441

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9}k zfh Ak9vPh ;]p ~%y aoQg!h ,eoQAJ!h


n
o v n r n
v
n
v
,p 9%+<hO"| #w|r C #+I Br In Qp p 9%zv Qn Z| fz< ~w@QvP fE f(=Gg@ :C
ro
GhQOZ+y #*Q}@|}yG G(g"t* fC ,#+"S h]< P"| ,?<QhC JGQ}@|| #| Q}@||
m
n
k
k
}#+!G(tyG QO9Z| #| GQOZ| f(w@ fC KzZ@ ?+|;S G ?g*QWyG fz< GQGQs
n
rl g\ 9!O;< ,p &"wyh ,c9"$ #l +=| Kl Ap ($ ~g! !9"k +=| 9Jk Ap B+@hoC 98C Br "vch
n
l n n
n
n
O;=yG ,p #+!G(tyG QOZ| ,$ 9$OIh f(w@ fC >G* 9"Ag*QV f} ,fG($h
.?+|;S G
,p ,{zf #| (wW! 9| Qo DvC ho FQ* 9%+yE ?+="F}G #+!G(tyG gP$ fC iQC ,!E
m
.xyP Q+i )yE ,9"Ay(FQ ,p ,9"Ap9tC ,p ,9""*O ,p ,9"@;|9g| ,p ,9"s;LC
n
o o
:iQC 9}| 9$Q9CB #| {D}yG ^g< ~w+zf [szSh
p
v
n n
l n l
,#+}Tsp 9"| #+qtD}yG #+}zgA}yG B
p }Ttp ,~+zgAyG ,p RQ9< #+p < QCC 9%y f9v
q
k
k
r
wo
k
k
,?+="FC ?+<Q@ G(<Qh ,9+!O| 9}+zg@ G(}p zf #*Py9p :#*QwTg| ~%AzgF hC
o o
n
r n n n n
n
,OfG(sh O9=|h ~d! #| Bg\h 9}yp h 9%y fhQZA"*h #+!G(tyG gP$ f(}dg*
m
n r n
o
,9%y ?+=ZgyG ,p aQT* ~%"| Ql +Dvh .eOtAyGh ?pQg}yGh ~zgyG {$C ~8C fhQn *h
9}wJ| 9Yk (Z"| f9v 9| )AI ,?+|;S G &Ag*QV #| 9%qy9L 9}y Q9w! Gh
k
.IQhQ]y9< #*OyG #| ?|(zg}yG e;S G J9+9O< )AIh ,fBQtyG ,p 9+gas
n
r
k
hC GhCQ 9}| g(T=AsG 9}SG &y G(fQALGh ,~%qg]AT*h Qn L6G u*QqyG jQOR*h
v n
Al,V e;S G ,p U+yh )#*OyG d9FQ( ~$(}Tp ,?+J+T}yG ?<QhC ,p G(g}S
n
v no
n
.9+!OyGh #*OyG {FQ f(w* fC &+zf >G* ~zT| {v {< )#*OyG d9FQ( )}T*
~%Tq!} GhQwAIGh ,?yhOyG d9}fCh I9+JyG d9}fC {v #| ~$(yRf ~C
k
,9+!OyG d9}fC #| A,Wy f(JzZ* : )#*OyG d9FQ( fC ~%"| 9}fR ,9%=Y9"|
n
o
n n
s
A9}zgyG #| a(y}G GhQo ZIh ,?pQg}yGh ?p9tDyGh ~zgyG #| ~%jz=| f9v 9*C
n
o vnno
r v n
GhQ|P@ hC G(G\ f{p ,~%y Uq"A| : )AI ,?+"*OyG >Y9"}yG g(}S 9}+p #+qtD}yG
k
w n
.e;S G ,p ?+!9=$Q :h ,9!9=$Q ~$(}fR ,#*OyG d9FQ ~8z< ~$(GI
.

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

442

9J JY 9 }zf GOv In ghOw Jo *n fC f6G )yE G(g+aAT* ~y 98k +V G(fOA<Gh


}S
|;S G A9]tyG 9%+zf GhQZsh )?+ZMWyG dG(I}G( g(}Tp
#| f(ZtA"* G(=$Ph ,&g\(| Q+n i ?yhOyG ,p g(g\h ~C .,vfp QWyG A9]tyG
w on
l
Q(|}G )zf IQY9s )YQWyG( ?dqy fC G("ch ,&!9azS #| fhOJ*h ,&pGQ_C
~C ,YQWyG #f LQ9L 9$GOf 9| fCh ,?+fQWyG ~v9J}yG U9ZALG ,p ?zLGOyG
o v
#| #+vg}yG Y("yG GP$ )zf uo za@ ?}zwyG gP$ fC )yE ~$n (n yG ~6 >$P
,p B*CQ Oty )AI !9$Q+jy eC ?+|;S G ?g*QWzy f9vC AG(S ,U9ZAL:G
q
k
fC h| ,?+z}yG Uy9G}y9< ?m Y9L Q(|C ,p y9fQVz ?}zv ,q }SQyG Q+=gAyG ^g<
v
#+}zT}yG X9qyC ,p yYQWyGz fC :&z%G* fC ~zT}y ,j="* : jPyG ,q 9O=yG
q
:E {D}yG GP$ Bo <Q\ 9|h .,q |;S G YnQWyG :E f(w* : e;S G O;< aQfh
r
w
n
.d(tgyGh S(q"yG ,p #+!G(tyG gP6 h=WAyG Qn CC ~w*Q}
p
!IO9TyG 99C
r
r n o n
n
n
,H(ztyG ,p Bzjzj@ dG(ayG #+"TyG ?|C 96 B}wp I GPE #+!G(tyG fE
n
9%+zf Br !n Qn |n h ,MohQyG 96 Br j=p Yo h ,A9]+< hC AGO(S GQk9CB 9%+p Br An w!hn
v
9%Ar jn =n Yn h ,?|}G S(q! ,p o QC}G C(SC JQCC ?o +="F}G #+!G(tyG gP$h .Uo qr "yG
o
k
k
k
r n nn
o n n
H(ztyG #| BfR!h ,?<QhC 9%+p Uwp @Qr @ ,Ay9v ,?AJ< ?*O9| ?*O9JyE ?j=Y
x
9%to sQ*o h Hn(ztyG {LO* ,q |;S G ho *QWAyG f9vh .&"| an(MyGh &p zyG ?k +WL
~n zp fn ,,\9tyG )]s hC ~v9JyG ~wIn GPE ~o zT}yG fn9wp .9*9!OyG #| 9$Qo %xa*o h
#+< xyP #f dh|T| &!Ch ,hn +a*o h hn }T*n fC &Tq! ?z+LO ,p gQ|z* &"n *O fC
k
9| )Zn fn frE &!C ~n zp fn h .S9"yG On "f :h|T| f(w* fC {=s ,?|9+tyG en(* uG jO*
n
,p rl aM| ,n \9tyG fC #t*C (y )AI ,&<Qy 9+k Y9f f9v ,&+\9s &< )]n s
o
n
k
fE &< &y ,n ]s 9| PLz* : fC &"*O {=sp #| GQ(|z| &y ,w]t}yG f9vh .&F9]s
{v gyh ,)vyE f(}ZA< ~w!Ez :| uG d(SQ d9s 9}v ,&tI Qo +i &!C ~zg* f9v
r
ho }SC 9}| (m J! )zf &y ,n ]p szs ,^m g< #| &AGJ< #n Jn yC fn(w* fC ~w]g<
k
, +
+s
r v n
g( h ,,

443

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

n n

Gh

?+}v9Jy

#| ?gas &< &y ho asC 9}!{p ,gPLz* ;p 98k +V &+LC up I #| &y Bo gas #}p ,&"|
.yQ9"yG
~y ,?+="F}G ?*O9}yG #+!G(tyG ?+<Q@ GhQd!9p .?|~y ?g*QWyG ?o +<Q@ gP$
9$Qn9CB G(p9Lh 9$(=$p Qn 9}!Eh ,~%"*Oh ~7O+tf ,p f(}zT}yG 9%|QAJ*
n v
,p OpOzyG #| iQ! 9| f9wp ,~%Tq!C ,p 9%Af9_ Hn(Fh GhOtAg* ~yh ,InQ$9dyG
?y9_E ,p ,y9jAyGh ,h|9a}yG Y9=@Gh ,,\9tAyG ,p aGQS Gh ,?|(ZMyG
v
n o w
QhO &zv GP$ ~fh ,e9wI}G P+q"@ #f ?+F9]tyG {+Jy9< )ZqAyGh ,JGAGQF G
k
o nn
r n n n
o
GhOtph ,{_9=yG )zf ~%S(q! JOQn | S9"yG fC xyP .9$Qn +ih ?+fQV ,A9]tyG
q
#| iQ! 9| f9vh .~$O9t| IOv 9}yG fp9a+Wyp G(TzSCh ~7p G(%V G(g=@9p ,~6n (zs
n
)AI ,?z+="yG O+y9tAyGh ,?+|9TyG b;L}9< Br qZn fn ,ImQF9p ImQp9S ?m +q I9<E
n n
o o
.?m wz%yG OQG(| 9!OQ(@ JO9v
p
!IO9TyG 99C
v
n q
#| 9}$G(s} #n w|n #*QwTg| hC #+t*Qp )yE ?|}G ,p #+}zgA}yG ~n Tr s fE
n
n o r nn
.WGQZyG AG(S #f 96 dOg*h ?|p }9< hOJ+p ,A9Ap Gh h*QWAy9< QCzAT* fC
o
x
q
#*OyG fC G("ch ,#*OyG #| BT+y h*QWAyG {F9T| fC G(}o zfo h G(}%pC ~8C xyP
{F9T}yG gP%y A9%tqyGh A9}zgyG VnQw gn @n fCh ,f9*O}G #| gQ+jv )|;S G
l
n
n
,p UTty9< ~$(%=v V ,~89azT< X9qAI;y ?+=Zfh ,~%+"g* : 9}y VlQw gn @
n n
,p G(gpO!9p ,?T+"wyG ?<Q9J| ,p ?+T!QqyG IQ(DyG O9=| ~%+zf Br =n zih ,?<QhC
k
9Jk Z! hC ,{m F9ty :(s G(g}T* fC G(r <n Ch ,~%"*Oh ~%Ag*QV Ov \ ~%A+=Zf
Bg\h )AyG #+!G(tyG QpGQip )zf ,#+}zT}zy #+!G(tyG f(go ]n *n G(=$Ph .KY9"y
!!E*OJyG h*QWAyG O9=| upG(@ 98z< ,~$Q+jy
9}+p ,~%"*O< f(=gz* G(=$Pp ,E*OJyG h*QWAyG GP6n 9"| u*Qp )zA<Gh
wn
n
,GhOOQ@h G(<Qa\Gh ,GhQq sCh GhQw!Ch ,G(|Qv Ih G(zIzp ,G(pQg* ~y 9|h G(pQf
,u*QayG zaLC &"wyh ,&< xT}AyG )zf UQJ*h ,e;S 9< #||* ~%"| Ql +Dvh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

444

9}$OyGh ?o |9gyG hn pO!Gh .E*OJyG h*QWAyG O9=| #| &=zs ,p HQp Vr C 9}<


o o
q
r n n
S9"y G Qo |C LQ|h .~7G(aL f(g=A*h ,~$AnGQ=vh ~7O9S fhOzt* ,~$AnGQh
p
p
n
o
O9=}< ?+f9}AF:Gh ?p +Tq"yG ~%\p GQ|C L;fp f(yh9J+y ~8E )AI ,G(<Qa\Gh
B
A@?> = o uG Ho9Av ~9O*C #+<h .E*OJyG h*QWAyG
A

R Qo ]44 ?*6G :BzZp[ h ]57 ?*6G :U!(*[ pF E D C


p^ ] \ [ Z Y X W V U T S

Qn <w On @n G(vQ@h ,~SG(}yGh ~@5}yG ,p &< ,"jAy9< fBQtyG #| G(r qn An vr G 9"|(s #vwyh
n
n
k
!GQ(G%| fBQtyG GP$ GhP<Gh ,&*O$ Y9=@Gh &+!9g|
,p Br Dv =p ,~FGQGyG Q=vC #*OyGh ?|}G uI ,p #+!G(tyG gP$ B|QFC Os ~C
)zf JrOf9Sh 9%Ar }n In hC ,#*OyG )zf OpQ}q AyGh O9Jy G MnhQ S9"yG #| Q+Dv
n
#| &+fO@ 9}< ,OS9q|h JmGQw"| #| gAnGQh 9|h Qn +W=AyG Bp }n In h .9%F9}!h 9%F9t<
~yh ,e;S G 9$9}I 9}v f9*O}G ?n *QI ,}J* #l *O OF(*o ~yh ,f9*O}G ?*QI
o
r n n l
.f(}zT}yG {gp 9}v 9$QhOY ~%y BJTpCh 9%+qy9M| BgSp h ?|C OF(@
k l
l
v
G(dqAJ* fC &+yE #+8F;yG )zf )<z* : (%p ,9g| ?yhOh #*O e;S G #wyh
n
)phn #+qp y9J| hC #*O$n 9g| G(!9v f{p .fGhOgyG #| ~%+}J* ($ {< ,~$OF9tg<
k
.~%+zf 9| ~%+zfh #+}zT}zy 9| ~%y f9v &y ?+fQ G(!9v fEh ,~$O%g< ~%y
k
v v )<z* &"wyh
,fhD9W* 9}v f(D=g* ,?yhOyG ,p ?yhO G(!(w* fC Ap9< G {
k
k
n
,?|}G ?|9gy BT+y ?Y9L 9s(tI ~%y fC f(fO*h ,~%"*O #f S9"yG f("Aq*h
Qp +i ?m g*QV )yE G(}v9JA* hC ,&F9]s Qp +i A9]s )yE G(r \n 9tA* fC ~%y fv Ch
#+}zT}zy Jpz*n ~y &!} ,GP$ #| Am,W< )\Q+y eo;S G f9v 9| ,;v .&Ag*QV
v
q r
x
nn
f(w@ fC :E G(\Q* :C ~$Q|Ch ,?p g"}yGh Rgy9< ~$A9F 9}!Eh ,fG(%yGh dPy9<
nnn
n n
o
n
IOQyG f} ,&zAs &"| LQL #|h ,&z=s #*OyG ,p {LO #}p .9+zgyG ,$ uG ?}zv
p
n
.)}dgyG ?!9+MyG YG(!C Qw V e;S G #f
n
k
l
GR9+A|G aQg* :h ,&}wI Qo +i ~wI gO;< ,p f(w* fC )\Q* : e;S G

445

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

&z$C Q+i #|p A9V #|n {< .&AyhO ,p gQ+i #m *O jPy :h ,&A+fQ )zf ,u="F}
n
n
r rn
n
nn
f(w* fC )zf ,&@O+tgy VQg* ~yh ,&A*9}I &J"| ,gO;< ,p f(w* fC
p
k
.gQ|C {v ,p &!(!9sh &}wJy 9g\9L
!IO9TyG 99C
n
o
n
)zf 9%A8V9! ?+<Q@ #f ?|}G Rn Gp gr @ fC E*OJyG h*QWAyG O9=| Qp CC #| f9v
o
{o Z@ ;p 9%SQGO| ,p 9*k Q9=FE #*OyG ~+zg@ {n gF dh9; fCh ,e;S G OfG(s
o o
n n o
,~%"*O Qn +i ~%}zg@h #+}zT}yG A9"<C ,<Qn @ SQGO| Oz=yG ,p OF(@ fCh ,&+yE
p
o n
9$OF9tf ,p 9%+zf 9<k QI f(!(w* ~C ,?|}G #| ~%MzTr Apn ,~%Ajy Qn +ih
n
hQo *O| )<z* fCh ,~%F9<B #| #+qg]AT}yG )\Q #f xyP f(w* fCh .96GOBh
p
r
n
e;S G ~+zgA< ~7Q|C PE ,aQ9g}yG IQGRh Q|} G(g}T* fC SQGO}yG gP$
9"+p f(}$(A* 9}<h ,QhQih Qm =v #| ~%Tq!C ,p fhQgW* 9}< ,#+}zT}yG A9"<}
.E*OJyG h*QWAyG O9=}< ~%A*9}I #| f("d* 9}<h ,#+yh r
m g\ #|
m
o
o
n
,HQjyG ,p O9Jy G ?+fGOh ,bQWyG ,p ?+!GQZ"yG ?+|9I ,$h ,?T!Qp fE
o
o
,~+dgyG 9%zFQ iCQ #+I ,#*OyG AGOf )zf iQ=wyG 97Q(C B|9s ,AyGh
{gF ,p OrOQA* ~y ,&A|C )zf do;J!:G )"n Fn 9| >n sG(f ,f9A+< d9VQ9}yG
q
h*QWAyG O9=| ,p Qwqp * ~yh ,SQGO}yG {v ,p 9*k Q9=FE #*OyG ~+zg@
.E*OJyG
n
~Sw Qn @n h ?<QhC O+zt@ ,p (q zjyGh ,?*O9}yG ?+!O}yG ?+<QAyG Qp CC #| f9vh
p
n
n
:E 9Jk +JY f(w* : )vg|9GyG ~n +zgAyG fC f9}* G ao9g\ #vc frC ,9$9aLo
.#*OyG #| N;T!:9< hC ,#*OyG ?<Q9J}<
v
o
r
r v n n
GP$ )zf f(<Q]*h ,~j"yG GP$ f(g*P* ~%"| gQn =vp G(y(@ #*PyG >$Pp
n
n n
v n n
o rn r n
fC fhO*Q* .?]jyG H(ztyG f(z+}AT*h ,?8V9"yG d(tgyG fh(%AT* ,Q@(yG
v
o
n
.#*OyGh ?|}G L9+S H9=WyGh ,H9=WyG G(fOM*

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

446

9| 9( 9=k *Qs Z;=yG IO*QF JQW! :d(sC 9}y {Dn |n HoQsC GP$
nq
)yE e(zgyG QGO ~\ )zf {}gzy aQ9g}yG IQGRh ,p Br qyC ,AyG ?"GzyG fC
o
n
QGQtASG {=s ,[+J}AyGh EJ=yG )yE L9A; {F9T| 9%|9|C dGR@ : ,?g|9GyG
w
QGOyG ,p ?SGQOyG OG(| h}A: {$h ,?+|;S G ?p9tDyG ?yzT|z 9%"| fCh ,iCQyG
o
,p KAq@ eC ?9%$(Fh h+= #| 9%+p [ZMAyGh ?p9tDyG gP$ A9+IE )zf
n
,~*OtyG 98(y #| e(zgyG QGO [zMA@ fC )yE ,IQJyG EI9=}zy IQjC H$9"}yG
q
n
.!?y97Qwph 9%G$9"| ,p ?+g|9F K=Z@h
~zT| {FQ 9%=I9Yh ,?+|;SE ?q+JY ,$h ,Z;=yG By9s 9| [w ! GP$
o
l
n
,f9*P%yG GP$ {D| &Aq+JY ,p QW"* : &!C aQfCh ,&|QAICh &< uCp C ,{s9f
q
q
o
n
n q no
k
!!&"| S9"yG >Gg* fC :Eh ,&+yE >T! #}| GQO9Y f(w* fC :E
9%+p JQ$ORG ,AyG ,?o +|;S G ?*Q$R}G e(zgyG QoGO ,GhQ=AfGh GhQd!9p
k
o
I9}Ih ~zgyG #+_9SC #| :9FQ Oz=zy BFQLC ,AyGh ,#*OyGh ?jzyG e(zf
O}J|h ,jQO"wTyGh ,Q(Z"| #TIh ,X*h9V R*RgyG O=f d9D|C ,e;S G
)zf LQ< fC 96 OoGQ*o QGOyG gP$ ,Q9G"yG H9$(yG O=fh ,~+$GQ<E O}ICh ,O*R
n
,?+|;S G ?p9tDyG #| ,~*OtyG 98(y #| [zMAAy ,9%}zfp )zfh 9%"*O
n
n
n
n
!!9$Q+wq@h 9%G$9"| ,p ?+g|9F K=Z@h ,IQJyG EI9=}yG EJ=Ay ,G(}fR
v
.E*OJyG h*QWAyG ?*9}I )p jQZgyG Qn +wqAyG &!(}T* 9| ?*9"F #| GP$ {vh
!IO9TyG 99C
#m *O #| ~wA|C ,p ,t< 9| )zf ,]t@ JO9v ?+="F}G #+!G(tyG gP$ fE
o
QFR@ ~yh ,9tk S9p &n "r @n ~y .A9|OyG BwqSo h ,VoGQf}G BJ+<zp ,uzLo h
o
n
k
.#+|QG}yG A9}fR LGQL SQGO| JQ9Yh ,f(GTyG BdAvG )AI ,9|QG|
o
n rn
r n
,Q+LG(}yGh [sp GQ}y9< Oz=yG ~A|Gh ,?y(FQyGh IQn +jyG S9"yG #| BfR!h
o
9| fhQ@ ~@QYh .Qn Fn OnRr |o : )AI ,A9T"yGh d9FQyG #+< W;AL:G Y9Vh
r v n
JQn T* 9}< ,>AwyGh J;G}yGh rJZyG ,p ,fhDQt@ 9| fhDQt@h ,fhQ@
)1941 SQ

447

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

BfR! 9}<h ,IQA%AT}yG IQp9TyG ?+I9< G #| B}n In 9}<h ,JG(%WyG {=o So #|


k
n
.GQk w"| ahQg}yGh ,9phQg| Qo w"}yG Q9Y )AI ,f9}* G H(ztyG #|
n x q
n n
,9%"f #+<GPyGh ,E*OJyG h*QWAyG O9=| )zf 9"| #+}F9tyG fC >Gf #|p h
m
n
v
9}!E .QO9"yG {+ztyG ,p :E ,9Ys 9L 9*k CQ hC ,;tAT| GOk9%AFG ~%y Oo :p O9w@ :
r o n
o
wn
hC JQn jY ,~|}Gh H(gWyG rzAM| #| ,#++<hQh}G AGQ5< L9GAI:G ~%}$
r nr
r v n
r o n
rn
fC 9"+<C 9"!zwp !! GQk Mp 96 ~%+j\p 9| fh|z}* ~C ,JQn tI hC BzF ,JQ=v
n vn
k
n
n xno
!!#*QLB ?}FC ~8hO #| PMp A"yp ,#+}zT}yG ?}FC Ozt!
p
!IO9TyG 99C
o
k
n
o
eQv I ,AyG Uq"yG {As ~C ,GO}f Ip;ZyG cQ@ e;S G ,p QFp9=wyG Q=vC fE
n
9}v 9"+zf >An vh ,Ik9+I U9ZtyG ,p ~wy &o zyG {gFn Osh ,uJy9< :E 9%zAs uG
l
v
r
n
n n
n
WQV ?"TyG ,p :h H9AwyG ,p OQ* ~yh .Uq"y9< Uq"yG fC 9"z=s #| )zf >Av
v
k p
o
#f (qgy9< &zyG fPz* ~yh ,GO}f {o AtyG f(w* fC :E U9ZtyG H(F(y
q
l
#| OIC xyP ,p ry9M* ~y ,gOIh eOyG ,vy(n yp :E Om I} U9ZtyG
p
gP$ f{p xyP h|h .#*Ozt}yG #| :h #*O%AG}yG #| : ,#+}zT}yG
n o
k
~yh ,uG &_QW* ~y 9_QV U9ZtyG ,p B_QVn ,96 f(}w; ,AyG ,#+!G(tyG
l
n
n
eOyG &< BI9<zp ,~+zTyG Qd"yG ,p &y h\(| :h ,#+}zT}yG #| OIC &< {t*
n
IO9}yG fC xyP .{AtyG ~FGQF IQDv #| iQ! 9}+p Q+=v Ql CC &y f9vh ,d;JyG
u=S h|z O}gyG eGOf 9< {@9tyG H9tf ,p B_QV )J9<(tgyG f(!9s #| 230(
9Tk q! {Asn #|z fC )zf BZ"p )234( IO9}yG xyP JOvCh yOYQAyGh QGQY G
k
hC IO<|}yG ?s9WyG d9jV}9< >s9g* OYQ@ :h QGQYE u=S Q+i #| GO}f
m
.y?As|}yG
o q
l
)zf eo9"! : ,?<9C(yG ?+<QgyG A9|OyG 9"sGQfC ,p jQ: ,?+|;SE ?|C #J!
u=S WQV ,{_9=yG WQWyG GP$ QCC #| f9v Osh ,QmzC #f Bo o wT! :h ,Qm @hp
>FhC {< ,9$QGO${< &o zyG fpPz* ~y ,elGQI Al9|O JQO$C fC ,QGQY G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

448

9%AyOC #f O9VQ G So9"yG )|n 9;h ,{AtyG ~FGQF JrQDv fCh ,9%+p Un9ZtyG
k
v
eOyG A9+yhC #| GQk +Dv f{p .O+gZyG O;< ,9+zgyGh )aS(yG QZ| ,p ?Y9Lh
n
Uo ~%y uG &zgF jPyG ~$QnzC G(y9"* : fCh ,~$;As A9|O {v a@o fC f(r Wn Mr *n
~%p ?*6 QS p_
^
] \[Z YX WV
n
o r n
,&|QF f(pQg* ~$h eQG}yG G(}J* fCh ,?}*QGyG Q9CB G(T}a* fC f(yh9J*
o
l
~FGQGyG {o TzTA@ ~C .~9O*z< g(y9"+y ,~%fQV ,p ~y9dyG f(!9tyG Oo *n &y9"@ ;p
n r nn n
l
o
o
o
g9=VC hC ?|9f ~$h ,eGQF G ?p yOC Qn *Ot@ f(8ap M* 9| GQk +Dvh .x+yGhO GPw$
o
n n
.f(!9tyG GP$ ~%+zfh &+zf )"F 9}< ,~%z@9s Qn +i f(y9"+p ,?m |9f
v n
v
n
v
,9%A|QIh 9%tI A9|OyG 9"+afCh ,9"<Q 9"g_Ch ,9"Ag*QV 9"}wI 9"!C (yh
n
BT+y ,AyG WhQWyG Op }gyG {AtyG ?}*QF ,p 9"vQ@h ,&g\(| Un9ZtyG 9"g\(p
n
?y(va}yG JGAGQF G gP$ 9"vQ@h ,?qq qM}yG ahQdyG )}v Tn *o 9|h ,uG H9Av ,p
q
(y ,?df(}yGh IQ=gyG h\(| &"| 9!Q%cCh ,dOgyG ?|9sE ,p 9"fQSCh ,IOtg}yG
: YQWyG On *n fqC {o @9tyG ~o zg*n 9}n yp ,9"k +< 9Zk t! {Ap tyG ~FGQF BZt"y GP$ 9"zgp
p
o ro
.&Azp q@
x
)zf 97o QDv Br "n F 9| ~wy {ZpC fC ?F9I ,< BT+y ,?sQTyG ~FGQF gP$h
#| fhDQt@h ,9%gF9dph 9%COG(I f(g}T@ A:hC ~A!C 9$h ,#|}G )zfh ?|}G
n
n r n
n o
,#*OF9gyG #+|QG}yG Q<9vz< B8z| Os f(GTyG fhQn @h ,e(* {v ,p 9$Q9=LC
k
(yh .9!9+j_ GhOGR 9"k GS ~$hOGR 9}zv ~C ,#+8V9"yG #+FOA=}o yG ~$P+|;A<h
w n
o
n
,&+zf &< &zyG ~wI 9}< bQ9TyG GhOIh ,~6Q #| ~%+yE dR!C 9| G(|9sC ~8C
?%v9p f9v hsh (y ~C ,?m sQS #f GOk IGh GQk =L G(g}T@ fC )yE f(p(vWA@n ~A"wy
Qn =AM* fC 9%g| [w zyG dh9J* : ,?l }S9I &p zyG ?n <(tf fqC xyP ,96 So9"yG QoOv "n An *
v
.&"ph gAn9vP
n r n q
v o n
o
n n
O9=| >S9"* : bQ9TyG Op * has fC fhQn * 9"| GQk +Dv fC aQfC 9!C ,~g!
nn
n
n
:C :d(t* fC :E ho +aAT* : f9}* G bO9ZyG ~n zT}yG #vwyh !E*OJyG h*QWAyG
]33

G :AG

G[

449

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

E*OJyG h*QWAyG GP%y 9tk Jr So


n
:h ,9*s(s f(=$Q* : ,#+"|6G f(fp hqQn *o ,#+|QG}yG #| an(y}G YnOn "n pC
k
o
n
f(w* Osh ,e9f {v ,p f9gat@ #*O* hC Om * ?*9}I {+=S ,p ,9q+g\ f(}IQ*
ml
o
o
S(q"yG #| JGQWf u$R@ Os &!C fhQ@ ~A!Ch ! ?eG(fC ?m g]< {v ,p xyP
?GJ< ,hq"@ :h Qq ]o @n : Os IQ$9d}y hC ,,uS9+S CO=| )zf am;AL:
.e9d"yGh #|}G )zf ?dp9J}yG
n
r
,p #n |}G ~o v9%p .f("o Go Tr @ 9| QOt< #+sQ9TyG #| f(gatAn Sn ~w!C G("d@ :
w
k n o
o
JRGfh ,OgyG ~%+ZJ* : I9Ts ~$(|QG| f9v Osh ,HQgyG ?*O9<h R9GJyG
v
?o yhOyG JA9F fC :E ($ 9}p ,~w"+!G(s {D}< ~%=*Oz@ #f ?t<9TyG J9|(wJyG
: ~C ,#o |}G >v AAASG )AI ,gOhOI B|9sCh ,uG YnQV Br g=@v Gh ,IQ\9JyG
q
k
o
.HJyG ~S(| ,p A9<QjyG #| f(w* fC :E ,c9"$ 9sQ9S O: O9w@
o
o
v no
eGQvE h\(| &!C #d* )AI eQG}yG #f &pp Q@ ?D*OJyG J9*Qd"yG ^g< fE
o
v
n
v
n n
R(G* : &!Ch ,btp >*OzAyGh ?+<QAyG H9tgyG #| OZtyG fC ,fO@h ,)"F 9}<
q
&y Uo }AzAp ,,!9GyG ?+Tq! SoQO >n FG(yG fC ~fR@h ,e9tA! G ,yE &< OZt*o fC
#|h ,&A+<Q@h &@zW! #|h ,?}*QGyG ahQch ,?Y9MyG &phQc #| Q*n P9g}yG
o
n
&< b+J* 9|h ,JmG(%Vh r_G(f #| &J!G(F ,p {}Ag* 9|h ,&\Q|h &AJY
n
)n Tp !h .)"| &< ~zfC ~wzgy 9}| ,xy9"$ 9| QLB )yE ,Jm9t<(| hC Jm9*Qj| #|
n
n
v r
,MQAFG >!P jC GhQn +y ,r*QayG SQOyG GP$ &+zf )v"G}yG G(SQO* fC 9$(zF9s
m
~yh .QgW* : Eo +I #| ,&"|z| ,p &+zf iOAg| ,&<p Qr Sp ,p GOkO%| fn(w* )AI
o
o
)yE 9|h &Ao +vTq!h &@zW!h &phQc &Ar zgF #r |v C :?*9fQy9< uw IC #+t*QqyG jw C GhQwq*
x
O]yG )zf f9v #r |v C ,&+zf 9+s"G| f9wp ,Qq WyG )yE YoR"r *n : ,9"k 8}a| 9FkO9$ xyP
k
?9+!9F f9wp xyP #|
o
v
,q< 9|h #+f}G ?"F9L ~zg* ($h ,~6 ~o zfC ($h un zMyG uzL uG fE
,p OnhOJyG YQV Osh ,?|n }G KzZ*o 9|h OnQqyG KzZ*o 9| ~zg*h ,QohOZyG
.!

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

450

Oo tAg+pC .{n *hzAyG {o }AJ* : K\Gh ,q <Qf e;w< ,:9w!h GQk FR fBQtyG
m
Up q! {F9LO< ~o zfC hRhQ=}y Q(+"TyG fC J9*Qd"yG gP$ {D}< 9"q | f(fhOM}yG
w n
v
?&zyG O"f #| fBQtyG GP$ fC ,p f(wW* ~$ eC ?&ty9L #| ,!9GyG
!IO9TyG 99C
n
n
q
r
o
fC Og< ,IO9}yG IO9=f #| &+zf B+"< 9}< ,BTzpC Os ?+<hQh}G ?+!O}yG fE
n
n
{o =tAT+n y &!Eh ,Qo(q*h ,zj*n ~y9gyG fEh .Br "n Fn 9| #+}zT}yG O;< )zf Br "n Fn
k
n
HQJyG Og< 9"pQf 9}vh .~|}G QF9Z| ,p ?zF9$ J
9m <;t!Gh ,GQk9=v 9CGOIC
w
n
OQAT! r+v f6G aQg"Tp gQDvC hC )S9+TyG 9"y;tASG OQAT! r+v ?+\9}yG
n
o
v
.uG A9V fE ,gOG| e;S5y O+g"Sh ,&zv ,vztgyGh ,sg*QWAyG 9"y;tASG
k
9!Ch ,#+!G(tyG )zf ?J|9F ImQ(C )yE 9+k fGO BTyh ,9+sy9+L ;FQ Bo Ty
{p }gyG )yE ~v(fOC ~w+p Bo }s 9}!E .&gq! #| Qo DvC fn6G rp "gyG QnQ\ fv C OtAfC
{gr Fn #|p ,O*Q! 9| )yE {n Z! )AI ,,q g+=ayG LQw OAyG ?"q T< ,HA"}yG O9%yG
:h ,#+|(* :h e(* ,p &+yE {Y(*o : GP$ fv C aQfC 9!Ch ,9"Ag*QV #| 9""+!G(s
.#+|9f :h e9f ,p
o
k
n
k
k
,!G(LE #+< Bo pQfo ,!{p ,9"@(fO #f ?%=V ho pQ@ ?}zv d(sC fC :hC O*QCh
k
k
hO=* Otp ,?Y9L ,fQWyG A9]tyG #fh ,?|9f A9}zgyG #f Y9pOy9< ,pQ9g|h
n q o
.OZt}yG GP$ #| (J! )yE ,@(fO dh|* fC S9"yG ^g=y
p
m
v
o
k
n
#+< 9fR9"@ &zgG! fC #| )}SC 9!OZt|h ,xyP #| Qo aLC Q|}G f{p ,;v
#| #+}zT}yG )zf HQ\o 9| hn pQ O*Q! 9}!E .#+t*Qp #+< GQk I9"@ hC ,#+AqF9_
u
o
.?+="F}G #+!G(tyG gP$ h\(< ,?m !9$E #| ~%Ag*QV B+ty 9|h dP
n
(fO! ,e;S G IQ+dI )yE On(g@ fC ?|}G (fO! ,uG Im(fO< ~v(fO! 9}!E
p o n ml { .uG ~wI 9}< h*QWAyG )yEh ,A9]tyG IOIh )yE
.}

| { z y x w v u tsr
q

451

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

H
GF
ED C
B A@?
> =
< ;:
o
? *6
RI} pQ P O N
M L
K J
I
. ]36

G :HG

G[

9| G(zgpG ~C ,?"p TyGh Hp9AwyG ,,q |;S G S9S}G )zf #+!G(tyG G(go \n
o r n
q o
l
n
.uG &Fh :E O*Q! 9"Ty ,f;p hC f;p 96 ~wJ+zp ,~A8V
!QZ| ,p f(!9tyG d9FQ 9*
o r
o
oQ|}G ~vO+<h ,Oz=yG ,p f9azTyG H
9JYC ~A!Ch ,,@(fO CO<C ~w<p
n
n
o
o
)zf 9%z*Og@ ,p f6G {}g@ ~w!9Gyh ,#n +n !G(tyG f(go ]n @ #*PyG ~A!Ch ,,o %"yGh
n
n
,p 9"*n O*C hr ]n ! ,~w"+<h 9""+< AG(S ?m }zv )yE G(r y9g@ .E*OJyG h*QWAyG O9=|
~o zfC #J!h ,9"v| #+!G(tyG QGQSz< ~zfC ~A!C .u #+ZzM| {r }g!h ,~w*O*C
q n
n
.Q9C6G YO<C 9"FQLC 9!h9g@ GP{p ,~w"| ?g*QWyG QGQSCh ?"TyGh H9Awy9<
>n ZgAyG YO"S ~wy do(sC : h ,~%FGQBh H!Qp G h*QWAy >n ZgAyG G(fo On
n
,9"zD| f(}zT| ~w!{p ,9"g| &y >ZgAyG )yE ~v(fOC {< ,9"=!9F #| e;S5y
o
~w"| {=t@o #yh ,?|9+tyG e(* uG jO* #n +< Ol IGh &"f ~wyG|Sh 9"o yG|Sh
o
o
,uG ?f9_ H(Fh ,p AG(S S9"y9p ,#*OyG d9FQ #| ~ATy ~w!z< ~w@QPg|
o
; : 9 8 7 6 !@
!}} 5 4 3 2 1 0o )yh}G #| Ql +L IQL6Gh
.p!@
!}~

9}< O+vtAyG )yE ~v(fOC ,q |;S G h*QWAyG )yE ~v(fOC #n +I ,!C G("d@ :
k
~%fhQp ,p A9%tqyG O+zt@ )yE :h ,;D| ~+G! #o <G hC #*O<9f #o <G &+zf [v !n
m
l n
LQn I &+p 9%"| Ql +Dvh ,?"TyGh H9AwyG ,p ?m Y(Z"| Qn +i 9$(a="ASG ,AyG
v n
v
k
l
o
GO+zt@ f9vC AG(S ,&+yE (fOC :h &zv O+ztAyG ^pQC 9!zp ,;v .O*OV
o
w
,#+!G(tyG h\h ,p HA"| Qo +i jOQqyG O9%AF:G ~C .#*QLzA}zy eC #+|OtA}zy
k
($ HA"}yG K+JZyG {}gyGh .OGQpC hC OlQp &< e(t* fC :9J| f(w* Oo9w* {<
n
n
n n
o
&o Fh Qn %n c ,AoGQ6G Bp yhGO@h ,Qo9wp}G Bp yOp(=o @ GP{p ,,q f9}AF:G Oo9%AF:G
.uG A9V fE ,HG(ZyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

452

9ty 9FQ #+_9SC #| ?l *(s ?l "Gy Q9A< fC :iQC 9}+p ?o +z}gyG ?o aMy9p
n
n
v
ImOzt| hC ,jCQ< ImO+t| Qn +i ,O*OGyG h*QWAyG OfG(s h]Ay ,?g*QWyG A9}zfh
o m
o
n
d(Y}G OfG(sh ?}F}G dG(sC 9%|9|Ch ,?"TyGh H9AwyG U(Z! :E ,>$P}y
m
YhQqyG #| b="AT@ ~C .~%zv f(!9tyG d9FQ AGQB 9$Q9d!C B;h ,A9%tqyG AGQBh
k
k
H9AwyG OfG(s B; {LO* 9}| ,~%phQch S9"yG d9Jy 9=S9"| ,9<G(Y gGQ@ 9|
k
k
s
.IQhQ]y9< #*OyG #| 9|(zg| 98+V ry9M* :h ,9Z! eO9Z* :h ,?"TyGh
w
k
r o
,9<9GfE ~vQhOY ~}* 9| ?g*QWyG uF9sOh e;S G QT* #| fhOGASh
p
h*QWAyG {+=S ,p Jm9=tf #| f(}$(A@ 9| fC fhQASh ,9!k 9}*E ~w<n (zsh
n q o q
o n rn n
n o
R9GfE ~w*O*z< f(T}zASh O+ztAyG O(+s #| hpp Q 9}< ,O%|h {yp P Os ,|;S G
GFE D o :)y9g@ &y(s bpGOZ}< f("||ASh ,fBQtyG GP$
f(! G d

o rn

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p


o
o
* i C I(
h
o
, G(
fC :,w
G
n n
h .
IGh
G e )
.

]48

ho *QWAyG GP$ h\(*o fC )yEx 9$(a< fC >G QL aL ~C


k
,?g*QWyG A9}zf #| :9FQ 9%zv ?+!(!9tyG ~w!9Gy p vQW@
|;S
o
o
?"Gyh ?+g*QWAyG ?"GzyG fp9GzyG gP$ ?|Ot| ,p ~wg| 9T}y Os zf
n
o
n
hC ,#*OyG U(Z! eO9Z@ ih9Ap hC #+!G(s QOZ@ : )AI ,9*9]tyG e;sC
p
o
.e;S G O9=| ,p9"@
o n
.O(%fh J
m 9s;f #| ?+="F}G dhOyG #+<h 9""+< 9}+p ,O(+tyG ^g< OGp ! Os
k
o
o
o
bQay9< &+p ~$9qAyG #w}* 9| &"}p ,9"g*QW@ {+=S ,p ?=tf f(w* #y GP$ {D|h
o
)t=* jPyG QoO9"yGh .?|O9tyG KGOI}G &gpQAS 9| &"|h ,IO9Ag}yG ?+S9+TyG
x
n
9"v| GhrCQ GPE ~r $o ~C .&z+yP@ )yE &o zyG un p(n *o )AI ,gOhOI u+\C ,p gQZJ!
xT}AyG )zf ~v(IO|h g(IO| {< ,hsG(yG Q|p }9< G(\o Qn ,?n sO9ZyG ?n |RgyG
.{=s #| ~$9"<Qv F 9}y9ayh .&<
9<k (zsh ,?k +fGh 9!k GPB Br pO9Y Os f(w@ fC (FQC ,~w+yE ,@(fO gP$
n
9%n y9|B Bg\hh ,9$Q|n C ?|}G ~w+yE Br zvn hn #*PyG ~A!Ch .f9}* 9< ?"8}a|

453

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9V fE ,~w< ,"c xyPh ,~w+p


n
o
orn
v
r n
A9}zf ,Q$R}G d9FQ (fOzTp ,G(<z@ fC u9< ~vP+fCh ,~A+<C GPE 9|C
n
n
,,y f(=+GAT+Sh ,e(zgyG QGOh A9]tyG ?SQO| d9FQh &y9FQ ,e;S G
~9O*z< ,fBQtyG ?*GQ f(gpQ+Sh ,~+dgyG {}gyG GP$ An>r fp f(z}J+Sh
n
r n n n
n
f(]%"+Sh ,e9f ryC e;S G Q9asC ,p ~zgyG M9=Z| Bz}I ,AyG ,?*(tyG
l
: d9FQ ~%+phm ,?|}G ,p eOtAyGh ,q sQyG Jp9vQI {w< {o =s #| G(]8 9}v &<
n
n
#+sO9ZyG fG(f}G fhOG+Sh ,9|k Rfh ?}wIh ,IkAn9qvh 9}k zf fhrQn9=n *o
.?p |}G J
p 9t=_ QFp9S #|h ,f(!9tyG d9FQ ~w"| ,#+ZzM}yG
r
n
o
s
iQ(ASOyG {+=TyG ,?g*QWyG QZ! #| )j=! 9| )yE {+=TyG f(w+S cGP PEh
p
n
~wyhp9Zn !o ~C ,96 Qn $9G!h 9%+p O$9G!h ,9"@n (fO ?|}G ,p Ev =o !n fC :,v}zTyG
o
k
k
.GQGQ| R(q"Tp IQ| 9"zWp #8yh .?|}G )yE 9%+p ~wAJ!h ,H9MA!:G ,p 9%+zf
9}< ,9"I9G"y ?n |Ot| ,9!Q|C dhC ,p 9"tqLC fE ,9"s9qLE #| {o gG"S {<
r n n
o
r n
o r n n
no
,9!(aL hsG(| 9"y GQk Zp =| f(w+S &!z<h ,eRgyG #| es(*h ,~}%yG #| Rqp J+S
p
n
o
q
n
k
n n n
.uG {+=S ,ph u 9Zy9L f(w+S 9"z}f fz<h ,9"8p aL h\G(|h
o
,9%Ag*QW< ~w; fC JQ9ALGh ,9"@(fO #f B+\Qh ,9"< ?|}G BtCh GP{p
o
k
o
fC ~v9*Eh 9"z+=S f(w+Tp ,f9}yQ=yG )yE 96G(! 9"| BzSQCh ,96Qy ?f9_
r
9}v ,~wJyG On +y9t| 9"+yE G(to zAo p ,Qo(ASOyG &< ,]t* 9}< G(r \n Qr @n fCh )\n Qr !n
o
n
w v {gq@
A9V fE- 9"|(ty ,qp ! ~C ,H9MA!:G ,p 9$OIC R9p GPE ,HGRI}G {
x
vn
n
.?"TyGh H9AwyG #| IO}AT| 9%zv #+!G(tyG {gF #|h ,9!Ofh 9}< -uG
r
jhP #| GQk +Dv 9"*CQ fC ,uG fP{< ,M9G"yG J
p GQ9|Ch R(qyG QF9W< #|h
o
o
n
o n
n
r o r
?|}G O(g@ fC f(FQ*h ,9"@(fO H9GAT@ fC f(r "v}A*h ,9"y(t< f(y(t* jCQyG
v
n
#| OZt}yG GP$ BzgF ?*(tyG J9+g}GyG ^n g< fCh ,9%Ag*QVh 9%"*O )yE
.9$OY9t| ~$C
.uG A

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

454

Q$R}G d9Fn Q 9*h


n
o
,9"A|}h 9""*Oy 9"+zf >G* 9| 9"pQf Osh ,{}gyG 9"zzsCh ,d(tyG 9!QDvC Os
n
o
v
A;fE {+=S ,p ?|}G IpO9t| #f fhRF9f 9"!C G(}fRh ,f("dyG S9"yG 9"< #ch
r
9"fhQo ,p G(r tn yCh ,>ZgAyG dp(jo < 9!(fRpCh .e;S G OG| IpO9fEh ,uG ?}zv
o
.f(w* fC >G* jPyG )"g}y9< : ,f(}%q* jPyG ~$9"g}< ,#*OyG d9FQ 9"!C
o
n r n
n nn
n
,fGh}G fB Osh .f(qZ* 9}v 9"!C 9"}p $h ,p ht* fCh ,U8+AT! fC 9!Ov )AI
r
n n
o
o
n v n
n
fCh ,9"A|Rf Otg!h ,9"A}$p RqJ! fCh ,d(tyG #| RF(!h ,{}gyG #| QDw! fC
r
9!Q+i h| #+vQAW| ,uG {+=S ,ph u en(t! fCh ,9%ztCC 9| 9"z$G(v #f ,tz!o
Q P O NM o .)yh}Gh IoQL6G ~wy f(wASh ,#*OQq"| hC
!

. ]40

T S R

?*6G :HJyG[ p

9TyG 99C Og< 9|C


o
n n n n on
n
d(sC fC {=s GP$ ,!9w| #f j9|Os dhR@ fC h+aAT| Q+i ,!OFC ,!{p
#}IQyG O=f O+TyG ,d(%G}yG ,wT"}yG ,w|;S G ~+fRyG d9s 9| ~wy
:,q =vG(wyG
u o
l
r
k
n
o
n
GOi >$P@ Oty K*QyG h| e(+yG B=$P fE ,OmGh ,p ?J+Yh uI ?}zv gP$
o
o :Ky9ZyG O=gyG d9s 9|h .O9@h}9<
!IO

10/.-,+ 6 5 4 3 2
. ]44

?*6G :Qp9i[ p

1360

?"S

1941

} h+<Q

dh G

?"S {*Q<C 3

~wyh )y uG QqjASCh

455

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

? z}gyG ?aMyG

?g*QWyG #| #+!G(tyG

S9=As:

~v(fOC #+I ,!C G("d@ :z :)89 U( )]| 9}+p ,IQ\9J}yG ,p Bo zs


#o <G hC #*O<9f #o <G &+zf [v ! 9}< O+wtAyG )yE ~v(fOC ,|;S G h*QWAyG )yE
k
?m Y(Z"| Qn +i 9$(a="ASG ,AyG ~%fhQp ,p A9%tqyG O+zt@ )yE :h ,;D| ~+G!o
v n
v
m
&zv O+ztAyG ^pQC 9!zp ,;v .O*OV LlQI &+p 9%"| Ql +Dvh ,?"TyGh H9AwyG ,p
k
o
O9%AF:G ~C .#*QLzA}zy eC #+|OtA}zy GO+zt@ f9vC AG(S ,&+yE (fOC :h
k
o
r o
l
n
hC OQp &< e(t* fC :9J| f(w* O9w* {< .#+!G(tyG h\h ,p HA"| Q+i jOQqyG
m
ByO(=o @o GP{p ,,wf9}AF:G Oo9%AF:G ($ HA"}yG K+JZyG {o }gyGh .OGQpC
n
o
n n n
.yuG A9V fE ,HG(ZyG &Fh Q%c ,AGQ6G B
p yhGO@h ,Q9wp}G
l
o
o o
n
d9FQ #+_9SC #| ?*(s ?"Gy Q9A< fC :iQC 9}+p ,?+z}gyG ?aMy9pz
n
hC ,jCQ< IO+t| Qn +i ,O*OGyG h*QWAyG OfG(s h]Ay ,?g*QWyG A9}zfh f(!9tyG
q
Ofo G(sh ?}F}G doG(sC 9%|n 9|Ch .?"TyGh H9AwyG Un(Z! :E ,>m $P}y ImOzt|
o
q
b="AT@ ~C .~%zvp f(!9tyG d9FQ AGQB 9$Q9d!C B;h ,A9%tqyG AGQBh d(Y}G
B; {o LO* 9}| ,~%phQch S9"yG d9Jy 9=k S9"| ,9<k G(Y gGQ@ 9| YhQqyG #|
o
n
#*OyG #| 9|k (zg| 98k +V ry9M* :h ,9Zs ! eoO9Z*o :h ,?"TyGh H9AwyG Op fG(s
.yIQhQ]y9<
ho ]@ ,9+zf ?"Gy 9%"| fo(w* ,OOgn yG InQ(p(| f(w@ fC >o G* ?"GzyG gP%p o
9}+p Qd"yG Oo +g@ ~C ,?+fQp fm9Gy #+< {n }gyG ~Tt@h ,H$9"}yG ~SQ@h Un So }G
.?t+sOyG ?+!(!9tyG ?j+ZyG ,p &i(Y ~C ,&=*P7h &t+T"Ay ,G(g\hh G(g"Y
k
9| GPE )AI ,,q }zgyG Ot"yGh EJ=yG h\(| f(w+y ,?|}G )zf ;|9v VoQg+p
o
o
QGOZASGh gQGQs ,?+g*QWAyG J9azTyG )zf VQf ,&+zf jCQyG Qv tASG
.&< {}gzy f(!9tyG
f9Gzy9< hC 9%Tq"< ,SQO@ fC ,&z}f 9+zgyG ?"GzyG )zf >G* 9| dhCh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

456

KzaZ|( E*OJyG d(YC ~zf {n F9T|h ,&tqyG d(YC ~zf {n F9T| ,?+fQqyG
un tJAp .?yO}G #| W9="AS:G H%"| O+I(@h 9%"| ?yzT| {v u+tJAy )E*OJyG
(J! #| ,HQgyG ?jy ,p ,!9g}yG )zf X9qy}G ?y:Oy 9%+p hFQ*o ,AyG {n F9T}yG
QvTv vqv}vyGh ,dhv |v}vyGh Kv*QvZvyGh ,U9vMvyGh eq9vgvyGh ,R9vGv}vyGh ?vtv+vtvJvyG
f9v Tv Jv Av S:Gh S9v +v tv yG HG(v <zv v ,d(v Y}G Ov fG(v s Qv F9v Sh ,{v }v Gv }v yGh
.xyP )yE 9|h ,?zSQ}yG Ky9Z}yGh
?+I9!h #A}yG ?+I9! #| ,&@p GhQh E*OJyG ?*GhQ Ot! ,p OfG(tyG ut;h
k
,&< PL}G >G*h L9GAI;y KzZ* 9J+JY E*OJyG &< f(w* 9|h ,O9"S G
k
.L9GAI;y KzZ* : 9q+g\ &< f(w* 9|h
p
l
A9}zgyG #| OIC 9%ttJ* ~y ,AyG ,?t+sOyG ?z+zGyG IOf9tyG ut;h
q
k
SO9TyG bQqyG ,p IRF(| 9%+yE Q9VC ,vpGQtyG fC :E ,~zg! 9}+p ,#+|OtA}yG
bQqyG ,$h )U!(@ ?g=_ 252 - 249U 1L( )bhQqyG H9Av( #| #+C;DyGh
&pQZ@ #+<h ,?|9| 9< &pQZ@ #+<h ,k+z=AyGh i(Aqy9< uG d(SQ aQZ@ #+<
9Sk QO 96 d:OAS:Gh E*O9I}G SQOy ,S9SC EJ< ($h .A9]ty9<
#+<h ,h*QWAyGh e(}gyG ?qY 9%y )AyG E*O9I}G #+< &< bQq+p ,9Jk +JY
?qY 9%y BT+zp ,?|9| 9< &"| 9pk QZ@ uG d(SQ #f JA9F )AyG E*O9I}G
Ky9Z}yG #| e9| G &< Q|z* 9| )yE 9%y9D|C )p hFQ}yG {< ,h*QWAyGh e(}gyG
k
f(w+p ,A9]ty9< | &"| 9pQZ@ ,?+FRF ?+]sC )p E*O9I}G #+<h ,?|9gyG
.))F9]tyG CO=}yG( 9!QZf )p )}T* 9| &"| b="AT* ,9%"+g< ?+]s #f E*OJyG
k
H9Av( )zf )IQV )p ?}+dgyG IOf9tyG gP$ {D| #| :9D| BttI Osh
. 242-240U )gp9WyG e9|5y )?y9SQyG
K+FQAyGh ?yO}G VQ9g@( H9< ?"GzyG ut; fC GQk CC &}dfCh {}f {Fw Ch
,O9%AF:G fGO+| ($ xyPh ,?t+tJyG )zf d(Y}G ~zf ($ xyPp )9%"+<
.W9="AS:Gh &tqyG S9SC ($ xyPh

457

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9="AS:Gh d:OAS:G 9%+zf )"=* )AyG OfG(tyG JOIhh ,GP$ ~@ GP{p


a;ALG )zf ,~%%tp )p A9%tqyG 9%+yE hFQ* )AyG ?|9gyG OfG(tyG )p Qd!
?"GzyG hC 9+zgyG ?"GzyG 97QsC )AyG d(Y}G OfG(s 9%+zf Bt=_h ,~%=$GP|
?"TyGh H9AwyG fGR+}< B!Rh ~C yE*OJyG d(YCh &tqyG d(YCz ,?|9gyG
.K+JZyG h*QWAzy &AtpG(|h &AJY )zf {+yOyG e9s 9| 9%"| PLCh ,?J+JZyG
9%FO9=| a;ALG )zf ,?+g\(yG #+!G(tzy ?|9gyG OfG(tyG ?"GzyG SQO@ ~C
)]t@ 9| 9%"| Q9AMAp ,?+|;S G ?+g*QWAyG OfG(tyG fGR+}< 98R@h ,9%fG(!Ch
k
,?"TyGh H9AwyG U(Z! #| 9Z! VQ9g* : 9}| ,gQ9+AL9< ?|9gyG ?JzZ}yG
OfG(s #| ?+S9SC IOf9s :h ,IQhQ]y9< #*OyG #| 9|k (zg| 98k +V ^s9"* :h
.)|;S G h*QWAyG
)zf {F9T}yGh YhQqyG b="AT@ )AyG OfG(tyG QtAT@ fC Og< ,&zv GP$ Og<h
bQayG >gWA@ : )AI ,?"+=yG ?J+JZyG #*RG(}yG h\(@h ,9%S9SC
{F9T}yG YhQp u=aAy ,?+fQqyG f9GzyG #+< &tqyG HG(<C ~Tt@ ,O%AG}y9<
)AyG ?J+JZyG e9wI}G 9%y h]@h ,JQsC )AyG OfG(tyG )zf 979+FRFh
k
k
.9_9="ASG hC 9Z! ?J+JZyG ?yO}G 9%+]At@
#| ,f(ZzM}yG PGPp}G A9}zgyG :E &< hza]* : ,~M\ Q+=v {}f GP$h
J9=iQyG )zf ~$Q9+ALG (}T* fC >G+p ,f(!9tyG A9}zfh YQWyG A9}zf
.&qg]* hC Q9+AL:G OTq* Os 9}| xyP )yE 9|h ,?+<RJyG AG($}Gh ?+ZMWyG
)yE O%g* fC R(G* ;p ,gOIh &y G(iQq* fC )yE {}gyG GP$ ~$(fO+Sh
k
)zf Q+T+y ,&+zf 9qsh &zv ~%Ash f(w* )AI ,gQ+i {}g< ~%"| OIGh iC
k
Bsh HQsC )p &"| O(Zt}yG VQjyG )yE ;Y(| 9Dk +DI GQk +S ,IOIGh IQ+@h
,#*Of9T}yGh A9]f}G #| IQ+Dv JGQWf Q9+ALG )yE (fO+Sh .gRFhCh
.?"S #*QWf #| {sC )p ~A* : GP$ {v h| &zgyh
,W

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

458

&+p ,?g*QWyG #| #+!G(tyG S9=As: ,?+z}gyG ?aMzy )=*Qt@ Q*(Z@ GP$


SQOyG h\(| h\(* fC :E ,&z+Zq@ )p hS(AyG h+aASC : ,d9= G #| Q+Dv
?*9"f #| d9"* fC (FQC .?+"|Ch :9+L : ,?gsGh ?t+tI f(w+y ,EJ=yGh
,HG(ZyG &Fh )yE iQ+i OVQ*h )!OVQ* 9| ,#*Os9"yG Ot! #|h ,#+DI9=yG
.)zf )qL hC )"@9p 9}+ph BIQAsG 9}+p
u+p(AyGh ?}ZgyGh OGOTyGh iO%yG uG dzSCh

459

? +fQW y

&zyG

dR C

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9| Q j< ~wJyG

#| LQM* GQk qv f(w* Os uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG fC e;S G 9LC ~zfG


#|h ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C >$P| ($ GP$h Qqv fhO GQk qv f(w* Osh ?z}yG
~zg* ~y eC xyP ~zf YO=yG {$C d(t< d9sh ~%=$P| #f LQL xyP )p ry9L
e(* )yE ?<9JZyG QZf #| )y9g@ uG H9Av Q+TqA< ~zgyG {$C dG(sC x+yEh
:)@}G O: Q+TqAyG >Av Bgy9_ GP{p GP$ S9"yG
o :)y9g@ &y(s Q+Tq@ )p S9=f #<G #f ?Jz_ )<C #< )zf ihQ -1

]44

@?>=<;:9

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

~y9c (%p &< ~wJ* ~y ,&< QsC #|h Qqv Otp uG dR!C 9| OJF #|z :d9s
.#TI ($h )166/6( f9+=yG h|9F )p iQ=ayG &FQLC yuS9p
k
o &y(s )p -9]*C- S9=f #<G #f Shh9_ d9sh -2
.y&+yE f(=$P* iPyG Qqwy9< U+yz d9s
? *6 O 9 } y p
y?z}yG #f {t"* : Qqvz eqy )ph
yuTp fhO uTph ~zc fhO ~zch Qqv fhO Qqvz eqy )ph
y&zSQh &=Avh &AwF;|h u9< Qqv #}v U+yh Qqv &< ($z eqy )ph
y?z}yG #f {t"* Qqw< U+yz Shh9_ d9sh -3
.y&zSQh &=Avh &AwF;|h u9< Qqv #}v U+yz Shh9_ #<G d9sh -4
yuTp fhO uTph ~zc fhO ~zch Qqv fhO Qqvz A9af d9sh -5
uTqv U+y uTph cQWyG Qqwv U+y Qqvz #+TJyG #< )zf d9sh -6
ycQWyG ~zdv U+y ~zch cQWyG
o O}IC ByzSz O+gS #< {+f9}SC d9sh -7
y?z}yG #| LQM* : Qqv :d9s ?QqwyG GP$ 9}p Bzs
?*6 O 9}y p

;:98

<;:98

]44

G :I F

]44

=<

G[

G :I F

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

460

r!9$ #<G J:G|S


&<9FC ?*6G gP$ #f {="I #< O}IC e9| G )!9AT=JTyG OhGO (<G dzS 9}yh
.)209U( &@:G|S Qd!G #+|OtA}yG A9afh Shh9_ d(t<
#f {8S O}IC e9| G fC )254/7( ih9AqyG Y(}G| )p ?+}+@ #<G QvPh
&]g< f9}* G {D| ?z}yG #f {t"* : Qqvz d9tp ~wJyG ?*B )p Q(vP}yG QqwyG
)1 (
. &+p rzAM* : Q|C xyP #| rG* )AI QqwyG xyPwp ^g< fhO
k
GOQ uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG cQ@ #|z K;DyG J9*:G gP$ )p O$9G| d9sh -8
.yuS9p ~y9c Qp9v (%p uG H9Awy
QsC #|h Qqv Otp &< GOk I9F uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|hz ?|Qwf d9sh -9
.)310/1( fQ9MyG Q+Tq@ QZAM| yuS9p ~y9c (%p &< ~wJ* ~yh &<
fGz #*QTq}yG #| ?f9= d9tp )310/1( Q+Tq@ )p
fR9MyG d9s -10
fGh ~zT}yG f} O(%+yG #| uG ~wI Q+i #|h Q9qwyG )p ByR! K;DyG J9*6G
dO*h c9J]yGh IO9Ash S9=f #<G d(s GP$h Qp9v &!G :d9t* : IQ+=v >w@QG
.yHQ9f #< AGQ=yG #f ihQ 9| d(tyG GP$ ?JY )zf
-166/6( f9+=yG h|9F )p iQ=ayG e9| G #*QTq}yG N+V d9sh -11
J9*6G gP$ ByR! :d9s #| d(s HG(Zy9< iO"f dG(s}G gP$ )yhCh )167
~$h ByR! ~%+qp J9*6G #| 9$Og< 9|h 9%z=s 9| f} H9AwyG {$C Q9qv )p
d9s f{p .)yhC ~%"f GQk =L 98(wp ~%"f Q=MyG b9+S J9*6G gP$h 96 f(+"g}yG
.)192/2(

X|9%yG )p u+zg@ * )1(


{=sh &+p rzAM* : &+zf h}G| Q|C 9"!9|R e9wI Qqv {$ uJyG >y9_ 9* &zyG cGO$ Qd!9pz
pH G Fo )y9g@h cQ9=@ x<Q iO* #+< a(s(| x!C ~zfC ~w; fC
:

.y

]19

?*6G :aQo LRq yG[

9 &zyG 9!GO$ 9<k G(F dG|Tzy Ofzp dzTASh

. c *C h

461

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9}< ~wJ* ~y #| h+= #f xyP< Q=My9< ~f Os -gQvP )y9g@- uG f{p :{F9tyG


k
?9Y9L &AzgF r+wp uG dR!C
iPyG uG ~wJ< G(!9v e(s #f xyP< Q=My9< ~f -)y9g@- uG fE :{+s
9| {+=S )zf ~wJyG ~%vQA< ~8C ~%"f ~$Q=Lzp #*OI9F &<9Av )p &< ~wI
k
($ &< GOI9F uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| {v )p d(tyG xyPvh ,fhQp9v g(vQ@
)p &yR!C &!C &}zf Og< uG ~wI gO(JG< &! S9=f #<G d9s 9}v Qp9v u9<
y)=! &!C &}zf Og< &+=! I(=! O(JF Q+d! &<9Av
o )42/2( fBQtyG Q+Tq@ )p )!9g}TyG d9s -12

<;:98

]44

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

@?>=

#<G d9s .#+vQW}yG )p ?*6G :-#TJyG d(s ($h- HR9f #< AGQ=yG d9s
LQG(MyG fC ~zfGh ,Qqv fhO GQk qv &< OGQCh #+}zT}yG )p ?*6G S9=f
{$Ch Qp9v (%p uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|hz f(y(t*h ?*6G gP6 f(yOAT*
:f;*hz@ ?*7yh y~wJyG cQA< Qqw* : G(y9s ?"TyG
~$ x8yhzp GOk JFh GOkQ uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|hz g9"g| :9}$OIC

Qp9wyG

.yfh

Qp9wyG ~$ x8yhzp uG dR!C 9| {w< ~wJ* ~y #|hz g9"g| :)!9DyGh


.y~zT}yG fhO uG dR!C 9| {w< ~wJyG cQA* iPyG ($ Qp9wyGh
:)367-366/2( Q+T}yG OGR )p
iR(GyG #<G d9sh -13
:f:(s ?*6G )p Q(vP}yG Qqwy9< OGQ}yGh
.)y9g@ u9< QqwyG &!C :9}$OIC
.?z}yG #f {t"* Qqw< U+yh ~wJyG xyP< QqwyG &!C :)!9DyG
k
uG fC ~zg* ($h &y GOI9F uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| fC H9aMyG {Zph
fh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

462

Q+i #| i(%yG )yE ;+| &< ~wJ* ~y #|h Qp9v (%p O(%+yG Bzgp 9}v &yR!C
d9s &!C S9=f #<G #f ?Jz_ )<C #< )zf ihQ Osh uS9p ~y9c (%p O(JF
.yuS9p ~y9c (%p ~wJ* ~yh &< QsC #|h Qqv Otp uG dR!C 9| OJF #|z
&y(sh )439/2( fBQtyG e9wIC )p
U9ZGyG Qw< (<C d9sh -14
f(w* fC #| (zM* :
?*6 O 9}y p
o :)y9g@
OGQ}yG f9v f{p O(JF Q+i #| ?}g"yG Qqv hC O(JGyGh cQWyG Qqv gOGQ|
#f LQM* Qqv GP%p uG ~wI &!z< Q9=L G h| gQ+j< ~wJyG hC uG ~wI O(JF
ByR! 98E d9s #| &yhz@ GP$ )zfh 9}k zT| xyP {=s f9v fE O@Q| &zf9ph ?z}yG
~wI Q+j< ~wI hC uG ~wI OJF #| fC f("g* 9"+p JQFh {+FGQSE )"< )p
G(zgp #+I {+FQSG ("< JQqv 9}v Qp9v (%p uG ~wI GP$ fE :d9s ~C uG
QwWyG cQA< f(w* Os ?}g"yG fGQqv f{p ?}g"yG Qqv &< OGQ}yG f9v fGh .xyP
)"g}yG ($ Q%c}Gh .?z}yG #| 9Fk Q9L &zf9p f(w* ;p O(JF Q+i #| 9%+zf
.yuG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| )zf QqwyG ~SG &s;_ dh}G
o )468/1( Q+Tq@ )p
ih9]+=yG d9sh -15
? *6 O 9 } y p
o &y GQk w"| &< 9"+%AT|
?*6 O 9}y p
&y(t< ~%qYh xyPyh gQ+j< G(}wI fz< ~$OQ}@h &< ~%A!9%AS:
~wJy9< ~%}zch .gQ9w! ~$Qqwp pwoh p} oh pm o
.&"f LhQMy9< ~%tTph &p;L )zf
xyP< ~wJ* ~y #| iC )64/2( gQ+Tq@ )p O(gTyG (<G d9sh -16
.&< ~%A!9%AS:
?*6 O 9}y p
o GQk w"| 9"k +%AT|
p
o )285/1( gQ+Tq@ )p )qT"yG d9sh -17
.
?*6 O 9}y p
o &< 9"k +%AT|
? *6 O 9 } y
K;DyG )p O(JGyG )zf {}J* fC R(G*z :Q(Z"| (<C N+WyG d9sh
]44

G :I F

G[

< ; :@
9 8? >
G :I F

=<;:98

G[

]44

]44

G :I F

G[

G :I F

G[

]44

@?>
= < ; : 9 8@ ? >
]44

G :I F

G[

]44

G :I F

G[

463

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Qp9wyG ($ uza}yG ~y9dyGh uza}yG uS9qyG f} 9tk S9p 9}k y9c GQk p9v f(w+p
J9*6G fE :?f9= d9sz )190/2( b+S(yG )p iOIG(yG d9sh -18
e;S G {$C )p U+yh O(%+yG #| uG ~wI Q+i #|h Q9qwyG )p ByR! K;DyG
.yQp9v :&y d9t* : IQ+=v >w@QG fCh ~zT}yG f} A)V 9%"|
?}+df ?f9= By9shz )456/4( R+F(yG QQJ}yG )p ?+af #<G d9sh -19
AGQ|C )p &"wyh uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| {v ?yh9"A| ?*6G :~zgyG {$C #|
.f9}* G #f ~%FQM* : ?+Zg| Qqv ?|}G gP$
fE rzAM* GP$hz )624/2( fBQtyG e9wIC )p :)<QgyG #<G d9s -20
&< ~wI fEh QqwyG >F(* &y {*O=@ (%p uG O"f #| &!C )zf gO"f 9}< ~wI
fGQqjyG )p ?"TyG {$C {YC )zf IQqj}yG &vQO@ >!P (%p ?+Zg|h i($
.#+=!P}zy
:&y(sz ?|Qwf d9sh )6/6( Q+=wyG Q+TqAyGz iRGQyG QMqyG d9sh -21
&=zt< Qw!C #| dh9"A* 9}!E
? *6 O 9 } y p
o
&!C :E uG ~wI &!9Tz< QsCh uG ~wI &!(v &=zt< aQf #| 9|C y&!9Tz< OJFh
&y(LO eRz* ;p &y cQ9@ &"wyh )y9g@ uG dR!C 9}< ~v9I (%p gO9]* 9}< )@C
.y~zfC uGh K+JZyG HG(GyG ($ GP$h ?*6G gP$ B;
oz )61/2( gQ+Tq@ )p Q+Dv #<G ep9JyG d9sh -22
k
k
k
GO}fh GO9"fh ~%"| GOZs uG ~wI GhOJF ~8}
?*6 O 9}y p
#| e(zd}yG G(qZ"* ~y ~8}
?*6 Qt=y p8 76
o 9"%$ d9sh
G(}zch G(qy9Mp &+p h+}GyG #+< ?<(AyGh dOgy9< uG Q|C iPyG Q|}G )p ~y9dyG
.yGhOg@h
Qqvz )1998/6( {*hzAyG #S9J| )p )}S9tyG #*OyG d9= d9sh -23
fhQ+Dv g9J! iPyG ($ &y O(JGyGh ?!9%AS:G O+t< uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~v9JyG
.y

]44

G :I F

G[

;:98

=<;:98
]44

]229

G :I

n n n

G[

G :I F

G[

=<

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

464

9=f #<Gh ?|Qwf #f ghQCBh


{v )p ?|9f )$ ?f9= d9sh )155U( gQ+Tq@ )p iRF #<G d9sh -24
uI )p QqwyG fC :E ~$Q+ih #+}zT}yGh O(%+yG #| uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|
.yf9}* G #f ~%FQM* : ?+Zg| Qqv #+}zT}yG
;p ~zT}yG 9|zp ..z )191-190/6( h|9GyG )p )=_QtyG d9sh -25
k
GOQ uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|h iC Q9}\E &+p {+sh IQ+=v >w@QG fEh Qqw*
k
S9=f #<G d9s Qp9v (%p e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf d(SQyG d(ty GOJFh fBQtzy
{v )p ?|9f )$ :#TJyGh O(gT| #<G d9s .GP$ )zf ?|9f ?*69p O$9G|h
xyP GOk tAg| iC Q9qwyGh O(%+yGh #+}zT}yG #| uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|
k
b9Tp #| (%p eQJ| >vGQ &!C OtAg| ($h xyP {gp #| 9|zp &y ;JAT|h
#<G d9sh &y Qqi uG A9V fEh &<Pf uG A9V fE )y9g@ uG )yE gQ|Ch #+}zT}yG
k
;gp {gp Otp ?*6 O 9}y p
o ?*GhQ )p S9=f
9|zp Qp9v (%p uG dR!C 9| h+}G< ~wJ* ~y #|h iC {+sh Q9qwyG d9gpC )$9]*
.?*6G gP$ )p {LO* ;p hFGQWyG ^g=< ~wJ* ~yh O+I(Ay9< ~wI #|
uG O"f #| &!C )zf gO"f 9}< ~wI fE :rzAM* GP$h .dh}G K+JZyGh
&vQO@ >!P (%p ?+Zg|h i($ &< ~wI fEh QqwyG >F(* &y {*O=@ (%p
>$P|h :iQ+WtyG d9s .#+=!P}zy fGQqjyG )p ?"TyG {$C {YC )zf IQqj}yG
)yE GP$ GRfh Qp9v (%p uG ~wI Q+j< ~wIh )W@QG #| fCz :LQG(MyG
.yiOTyGh #TJyG
:d9s &!C )=gWyG #fz )146/3( )!9g}yG MhQ )p )S(y6G d9sh -26
?Dy9DyGh O(%+yG )p ?+!9DyGh ?|}G gP$ )p 9%yhC :IOF9}yG )p )AyG J9*6G K;DyG
k
O(%+yG #| :9I C(SC f("||}yG f(w* fC GP$ )zf eRz*h .iQ9Z!G )p
O*OWAyG )zf {}I #+"||}yG )yE >T! GPE QqwyG fE :{+s &!C :E iQ9Z"yGh
.y&+p gOQ}@h g(Ag< QgVC ~zdyGh uTqy9< rYh GPE Qp9wyGh e+zjAyGh
.yS

]44

G :I F

G[

=<;:98

465

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

9 }y Q+Tq@ )p- 9\Q O+VQ O}J| N+WyG d9sh

-405/6( -Q " G

Gh

?+}v9Jy

-27
:)406

9| (J! e9wI}Gh hFGQWyG #| #+}zT}yG #| Q+Dv KOJASG Oshz


~%+zf uG dR!C 9| ^g< -96 ~wJy9<- G(vQ@h ~%z=s #| #*PyG KOJASG
fhOtAg* {*hz@ Q+i #| e9wI}G #| &<9Av )p uG dR!C 9| f(vQA* #*Py9p
>TJ< {v 9%]g< )p hC J9*6G )p uG &y9s 9| ~%+zf bOZ* &!{p &AJY
&y #fP| Q+i 9!RyG hC aPtyG hC ?sQTyG OJ< ~wJyG #f VQfC #}p :&y9I
k
.9gas Qp9v (%p &+zf QW=yG Y9\hC #| gQ+i {+]q@h g9*E &I9=tAS:
hC uJyG ?f9\E xyP )p f9v fE ~y9c (%p iQLC ?zgy &< ~wJ* ~y #|h
.btp uS9p (%p :Eh &+p IGh9T}yGh dOgyG cQ@
~v9J}yG I9]s fC fhOtAg* #+"*OA}yG #+}zT}yG #| #*Q+Dv iQ! 9"!Eh
k
o )y9g@ &y(s Q$9d< GPLC GQk9qv f(!9ty9< f(}wJ* #*PyG ?+z$}G
f(!9ty9< ~v9JyG )\9tyG Q+qwA< ~wJyG eRzAT*h
?*6 O 9}y p
9$(qyC G(!(w* ~y fEh ~8{p #+!G(tzy #+g\G(yG #+_;TyGh AGQ|}G Q+qw@
9|C ..96 G(}wJ+y e9wJyG f(y(* #*PyG ~$h ~8Pz< Bg\h 98{p ~%pQ9g}<
.ybs OIC &< {t* ~y {< #*Q(%W}yG &tqyG ?}FC #| OIC &< {t* ~zp ?*6G Q$9c
GP$ )p e9t}yG Q*Q; fC ~zfGhz f9+=yG AG(\C )p )a+t"WyG d9sh -28
&< GOkGQ| YQWyG )p uz_C 9}<Q 9%"| OIGh {v uTqyGh ~zdyGh QqwyG fC EJ=yG
:iQLC ?z}yG #| LQM}yG QqwyGh IQ9@ ?+Zg}yG
k
:9a<Eh {SQzy ?\Q9g| ?*6 O 9}y p
o
.?z}yG #f LQM| 9%zv gQqvh &tTph &}zdp uG e9wI}
9|k GQI >w@Q| &!C GOk tAg| ?*6 O 9}y p
o
k
y?z}yG #| LQM| Q+i &tTph &}zch gQqwp 9J+=s {f9p

:98

]44

]44

]44

G :I F

G :I F

G[

G[

G :I F

G[

=<;

=<;:98
=<;:98

Gh

466

=
<
;
:
9
8
Y OgTy 9s
OS9qy &\ Qi #| Qjy &}zg* Py {_9=y9< ~wI #+=}y uJy #|
@?>
?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

?+}v9Jy

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p


I

o 212v

i G

]44

:i

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[

G d h -29
G

]44

#f {t"* GQk qv f(w* Osh QqwyG {$C d9}fC #| uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJy9p
#|h H(!PyG QF9=v #| IQ+=v f(w* Osh .gRG(Fh &zI OtAfC GPE xyPh ?z}yG
.O*OWyG HGPgyG &zgp #| uJASG Os QqwyG d9}fC
o )y9g@ &y(s )p d9s )i(j=yG QZAM| 233vY( i(j=yG d9s -30

98

@?>=<;:

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

9SC #| fhO O(%+yG )p ?C;DyG J9*6G gP$ ByR! :c9J]yGh IO9As d9s
o &y(s )p
HR9f #< AGQ=yG #f ihQ .?|}G gP$ #|

;:98

]44

vo p 8

76

W
]44

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[

@?>=<

9=f #<G d9sh ,~%zv S9"yG )zf )$ :{+sh ,#*Qp9wyG )p 9%zv pw


Qqv #}v U+yh Qp9v &< (%p &zgp GPE {< ?z}yG #f {t"* Qqw< U+y :Shh9_h
fhO uTph ~zc fhO ~zch Qqv fhO Qqv ($ A9af d9s .QL6G e(+yGh u9<
? *6 O 9 } y p
o g9"g| :?|Qwf d9sh .uTp
O=f {8Sh .uS9p ~y9c (%p &< ~wJ* ~yh &< QsC #|h Qqv Otp &< GOk I9F
: uG dR!C 9| h+= )zf ht@ 98E d9tp J9*6G gP$ #f )!9"wyG )+J* #< R*RgyG
#| 9|zp uS9p ~y9c Qp9v (%p uG dR!C 9| h+}G< ~wJ* ~y #| {vh &]g< )zf
uG dR!C 9| ^g=< ~wJ* ~y ~C cQWyG cQ@h O+I(AyG #| uG dR!C 9}< ~wI
[! OQ GPE GP$ :A9}zgyG d9sh J9*6G gP$ ~wI >F(AT* ~y hFGQWyG #|
k
k
.v$.G .;p {*hz@ )p zaLC hC &+zf )qL #| 9|zp GO}f 9!9+f uG ~wI
S

]44

G :I F

G[

=<;:98

467

Gh

= < ;@:?9>
8 #+=* ~y QtO*"s~Qy}Ty )"g*
=
<
;
:
9
8
QWM|Ry 9s
}
@ ? > &< 9"+%AT|
? +fQW y

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p


.

]44

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

O 9}n yG[ p

)439/1( i

o )341/1( i

:I F

oh

? *6 G

O 9}n yG[

?S9+Ty

?+}v9Jy

G -31

GPE

Gd
k

]44

-32

?*6G

~$Qqv )p (Agy9< ~%y rYh pwoh


?"S )p(@ H9ZtyG )FQwyG )zf #< O}J| ep9JyG e9| G d9s -33
.)9$Og< 9|h 305/1( yf9qf #<G ?g=_ fBQtyG Bw! &<9Av )pz v$360
#| dR9! }
{ &y(s
ICOA=| ?ZtyG PE #++!GRyG OI )p | )="yG )yE G(}v9; #*PyG O(%+yG )p uG
m l k j i h{:9$DGOA<9p ~6 ?|(AM|h ~$QvP<
V UT S R Q { ($h &ttJ* 9| 9%s9+S )ph }o n
l kj i{ -#++!GRyG OI )p iC- }h g
{ }W
g(F(yG ~+}; )yE- ~FQyG ~wI ~$Q++j@ f9vh .9}%=Q )p &}wI iC }m
&MT"* ~y 9}k wI &y G(jyC GPE -GQk qv uG )zf ~$D9fOGh aG(ayGh HQ]yGh
{ d9sh ?ZtyG e9}@ &y;F {F b9S ~C &yR"* ~y 9| {*O=@ &+zf G(fOEh
{ &y(s )yE }
A9=p p8 76
o}
#| {+G!}Gh O(%+yG #| IGQ(AyG {$C #+tS9qyGh #+}y9dyGh #*Qp9wy9<
{ZA}yG gO"T< b9S ~C f(}y9S uG ?}g"< 9%AC;C #| f9sQqyG {$Ch .iQ9Z"yG
}
{ )y9g@ &y(s )p | )="yG #f HR9f #< AGQ=yG )yE
Q9qwyG )p )$ d9s pN
M Lo p8 7 6 o
]44

:I F

]44

L@?>=<;:98

A
8

JIHGFEDCB
L@?>=<;:9

@?>

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

468

)p ~$Q+ih )LQG(Mzy >ty ($( IGQWyG #| 96 HAJ* #}y d9t+o p )1(y9$OIh


f9sQqyG {$Ch ?h+}GyG #+< ?*(TAyG )p ~wAGI 9| :H(!Py9< ?z=tyG {$C Q+qw@
~8Ch VQp ~%+zf 96 ~wJyGh uI &<9Av )p ?yR"}yG uG e9wIC fz< f(}y9f
ByR!C #|h f(}zT| xyP h| ~$h f(=s9g| 9%Af9\E )zfh f(Y9f 9%vQA<
R(G*C .{J"yG {$C h+= ~$Qqw< H9@Q* : iQ9Z!h O(9 J9*6G ~%+p
~y IGQ(AyG ~wI G(fO*h | uG d(SQ G(}wJ* fC {=s ~8C ~$(A* ~$(A}y
cQA< QqwyG G(=F(AS9p ?&Ay9SQ O(JFh &@(=! OQ ~$Q\ :h ?#*Qp9v G(!(w*
cQA< Qqw* #+}zT}yG #| OI(}yG fC f(}fR@ 9}v #++!GRyG )p IGQ(AyG ~wI
.gO\ )yE uG ~wI
fEh ~%A!|| B+qvh ~$Qqv f9< &tt;h &}$(@ R(G* GP$ fE :G(y9s f{p
)p IO9*R ~wJyG ~$Q++j@ Q9Zp GQk9qv I(="yG OQ< ~wJyG {=s G(!9v {< :G(y9s
k
-9}zT| 96 Q9Yh- | O}J| I(=! {=s #| ~vQ+qw@ &Fh 9}p ~%y {+s ~$Qqv
9|k (}]| f(w* eC ?&+p U+y Qqv )p IO9*R f(w*C .uG ~wI d9}gASG &vQA<
eO%+p ??dJy IA9S{< {*(_ Q}f f9TIE b=J* eC ?&T"F #| U+y e;SE )yE
?"||| 97A9S{< IQp9v IOIGh Uq! f(w@ eC .dOgyG H9< )p g(}AzYC 9| &<
O(zMyG 9$Qqv >+Z"<h ??"GyG )p O(zMyG 989}*E >+Z"< >F(AT@ ?989TI{<
#| U+y :IGQWyG d9s f{p .d9JA!G K=sCh d9t| XJpC uGh GP$ Q9"yG )p
#J!h Q9=L}G x+yE &@OC iPyG ~FQyG )p ByR! ?*6G fz< 9"+zf HA; fC ?qZ"yG
.96 #||! :
k
{$C Q+i )p :R"| f(w* U+yC ~A8V ~wI iC )p g(zgFG :~%y {+s
~%z}g< {}f #| {LO+p ~%+p &yhR! f(w* fC R(G* ;pC :G(y9s f{p ?f9sQqyG
{$C O(%+yG ~FQ H9< OhOJyG H9Av )1700( ~sQ M )1327/3( &J+JY )p ~zT| gGhQ )1(
k
y9$OIh Q9qwyG )pz 9"$ &y(s #| :O< y9%zv Q9qwyG )pz ~zT| ?*GhQ )p #wyh ?|PyG
.)252/6( gQ+Tq@ )p Q*QF #<Gh )4448(M &""S )p OhGO (<C &FQLCh

469

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

&< G(}Sh d9gp}G )p ~%zD| G(!9v d9}wyG )p ~$hh9S GPE )z< :{+s ?~%g|
k
I9Zf G(!9v ~79qY h+= )p ~$hh9T* ~yh ~%y9gpC ^g=< G(z}f fEh GQ9qv
9}< GOk I9F hC uG )zf &< 9+k fO| uG ~wI O]< ~wI #| d(t"p .{gqyG xyP<
>T! hC &yGR!{< uG O%V Osh fBQtyG OJF #| f} Qp9v (%p &|9wIC #| &yR!C
cQ9=@ &y(ty gQqw< >@Q* ~y &+zf HPv #|h &+zf HPv Otp &yR"* ~y 9| &+yE
@
?> =
< ; :98 7 6 5 Wo )y9g@h
k
9vQ9@ f9v #}p ,GQk9qv ~$9}Tp ?*6 Q|Rw y p!@
! xw C B A
J9*6G ~%+p ByR!C #| ih9S Otp ?qZyG gP$ )zf &|9wIC )p uG dR!C 9}y
UQI &z}I #|h .uTqyGh ~zdyGh QqwyG ~SG uJASGh iQ9Z"yGh O(%+yG #|
~y9f ($h uG ~wI cQ@ )zf Uq! I(%V hC QzC Z(z< hC Q9"*OyGh ~$QOyG
#| dR!C 9}+p &<Qy bOZ| &g+"Y A(S #| QPI &@A9S{< aQ9f &!GhOg<
($h 9%+p ~$h9T* ~yh &< {}gyG &+zf VQAq}yG uJy9< 9%+zf O$9V e9wI}G
.&"f KqZy9< OG* ~y fE &A<(tf >F(AT@ &y9gpzp &<Qy U9f &|;SE )zf b9<
J(}yG &tJy #|h #+=!P}yG #| IQqj}yG >F(AT* #|h #+=F9Ay9< uJy H9@ f{p
:f9t*Q_ &y f9v ?<(AyG {=s
987 6 { )y9g@h cQ9=@ d9s fR(yG )p f9JFQyG :9}$OIC
]32

G :

G[

D C
B A @? > =
< ; :
) ( '{ d9sh
Q f} }
I HG
F
E
7 6 5 4 32 1 0
/ . - ,
+ *
.}
: 98
[9-8 :aG

G]

:h R(G* : dOf ($h Q+MyG #| 96 )@z* :h QWyG #| ?yOQMy9< )@z+pC


H9TAvG )zf KFQAy J98+TyG ?qv &< {tD+p Qqwy9< e(* IA9SE uJz* hC ~zd*
&=*Pw@h &y;F {F &+zf AGQAp:G )yE GP$ fE .J9"TJyG d9=F gQ}f d(_
&"+g< QqwyG ($ {< gQ|C ry9L #| Q+qw@h &}+dg@ )yE &"| HQsC &!9J=S

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

470

9V fE #+qy9M}yG )zf OQyG )p yOQG}yGz 9"<9Av )p &GGI MQW< &]Jz"Sh


.uG

)y9g@h cQ9=@ uG d9s fR(yG )p ?Ws9"}yG cQ@h (qgy9< {]qAyG :)1(QL6Gh

~ }| { z y x{ d9sh }q p o n{
,+ *
)( ' & % $ # " !
8 7 6 5 4 32 1 0/
.
.
Q _ 9p }
; :9
[33-32 :

@
A

&y(ty u<9TyGh OZAt}yGh ~y9dyG )p &zv #+}zT}yG )p ?y9J| : GP%p


O NM
o )yE p: 98o e;wyG b9+S Y9at!E Og< )y9g@h cQ9=@
|o &y(s )yE pY X WV U T S R Q P
.

]37

?*6G :Q_p 9p[ p


n

! ~}

!
,
+
*
)
(
'
&
%
$
#
"
9E8 D7C6B5A4L3 @
21
0
/
.
?
>
=
<
;
:
N
M
L
K
J
I
H
G
F
[iZhY
X
W
V
U
T
S
R
Q
P
O
M_^]\
g
f
e
d
c
b
a
`
w
v
u
t
s
r
q
p
o
n
m
l
k
j
&% $# " ! ~ } | { z N y x
O+ *
9ZAs: ~zdy9< )}S
) ('
)p

9Z"yGh O(%+yG )}S 9}v #+}y9ch GQk9qv IOIGh ?*B )p ~$9}Tp


~ }| { z y x w v{ J9*6G xz@

iQ

Gh

O 9 } yG ] }

[47-44 :I F

?<(AyG {=s J(}yG &tJy #}y )!9DyG u*QayG ($ GP$ )1(

471

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

w* Os QqwyG xyPvh gQ+i &< bQ9q* (%p ~SG &g= fEh ~zdyG fC 9"}zgp
~v9JyG f(w* fC R(G+p uJyG QAS :?jzyG )p QqwyGh .&}g"< f(w*h ,u9<
.Qp9v ($h 9%y GQk @9S f(w*h ~zT| ($h &|9wI: GQk @9S uG dR!C 9| Q+j<
)ZsC 9jy9< OI9GyG f(w+p .&AsQh QATyG ?s9qY )p QqwyG J9FQO rzA<h
#_9=yG Q+}]yG )p &qy9M| Q$9dyG {]qyG )p &g|9G| )Y9gyGh &\Qf
OZs #| )zf >$P* : 9| GP$ ?FQOyG )p f9+tAz* :h ?<(tgyG )p f9*(AT* ;p
.yL9GAI:G {_9=< ?=zjyGh L9GzyG #f HQ\Gh ?|9tASGh KZ"< uJyG
e(zgyG YG(!C )p f9+=yG )zf ?yGOyG fBQtyG Bw! H9Av #| {t"yG )%A!G
u+t;
H9ZtyG )FQwyG )zf #< O}J| ep9JyG e9|5y e9wI}Gh
.)f9qf #<G QGO( ?g=_ dh}G ARGyG iQG*(AyG iR9i #< )zf /Q(AvOyG
o )y9g@ &y(s )171/1( gQ+Tq@ )p e;TyG O=f #< RgyG d9sh -34
fhO O(%+yG )p 9$Og< f9A*6Gh ByR!
? *6 O 9 } y p
OGQC hC S9"yG QF9S )p ?|9f )$h H9AwyG {$C )p ByR! hC #+}zT}yG
~wJ* ~y #| hC iQ9Z"yG #+tS9qy9<h O(%+yG #+}y9dy9<h #+}zT}yG #*Qp9wy9<
k
.uTph ~zc OI9F Q+i f9v fEh Qqv GOI9F )&zyG dR!C 9}<(
:f9f(! QqwyGh :~+tyG #<G d9s -35
O9"fh O(JF Qqvh -2
{}f Qqv -1
#| GOk9"fh GOk(JF &< A9F d(SQyG fC ~zf 9}< Qqw* fC :O(JGyG Qqwp7
.&Fh {v #| f9}* G O9]* QqwyG GP$h &|9wICh &y9gpCh &@9qYh HQyG A9}SC
f(

)2 (

)1(

]44

G :I F

G[

=<;:9

Qf kz<z ~%y(s &"|h &=!9Fh A)WyG OI ($ #+gyG KAq< VQgyG :&\Qf )1(
.y&A*98h QqwyG OI )ZsC kz< OI9GyGhz )"g}yG f(w*h &=!9F
)61/8( HQgyG f9Tyh h= IO9| )1198/3( M9JZyG Qd!C Q$9dyG )p &g| h}AG| iC )2(
.h= IO9|

iC yiOG( G V

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

472

GTy9p gO9]* : 9| )yEh f9}* G O9]* 9| )yE ~Tt"+p :{}gyG Qqv 9|Ch
Q+j< ~wJyG 9|Ch f9}* G O9]* &=Sh )="yG {Ash rJZ}y9< ?!9%"S:Gh ~"Zzy
&"f )q"* fC #w}* :h 9gk as )z}gyG QqwyG #| (%p I;ZyG cQ@h uG dR!C 9|
Qp9v uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~v9Jy9p &+zf &y(SQh uG &tz_C fC Og< QqwyG ~SG
)q! Osh O9tAfG Qqv: {}f Qqv ($ #wyh uG d(SQ ["< Qp9v I;ZyG cQ9@h
gQ9F #|z* : #}fh Q}MyG HQ9Vh bQ9TyGh )!GRyG #f f9}* G uG d(SQ
Qqv &"f )qA!Gh {}gyG ?%F #| Qp9v (%p f9}* G ~SG &"f )q! GPEh &tFG(<
~w]g< HQ]* GQk9qv iOg< G(gFQ@ :z &y(s xyPvh .O9tAf:Gh O(JGyG
9"k $9v )@C #|z &y(s xyPvh .{}f Qqv GP%p )~zT|h iQ9M=yG( y^g< H9sQ
?g<Q}Gh O}IC gGhQ( yO}J| )zf dR!C 9}< Qqv Otp 9$Q<O )p ICQ|G hC &sOZp
y9}$OIC 96 A9< Otp Qp9v 9* &+L} {FQyG d9s GPEz &y(sh )#TI E*OI ($h
.)&+zf uqA|(
QqwyG gO9]* iO9tAf:G f9}* Gh )z}gyG QqwyG gO9]* )z}gyG f9}* 9p
H9=Sz K+JZyG E*OJyG )p &y(s )p g9"zs 9}< | )="yG #zfC Osh iO9tAf:G
9}$OIG {gFh &<9=Sh &y9As #+< bQqp .&+zf uqA| yQqv &y9Ash b(Tp ~zT}yG
k
l
iO9tAf}G : )z}gyG QqwyG OGQC 9}!E &!C e(zg|h GQk qv QL6Gh &< Qqw* : 9s(Tp
LQM* : 9}v ?+zwy9< ?z}yGh ?+|;S G IQFGOyG #| &FQM* : QqwyG GP$h
.f9}* G ~SG &"f dGR fEh ?z}yG #| HQ9WyGh bQ9TyGh )!GRyG
uG H9Aw< ?|}G ~zfC ~$ #*PyG ?<9JZyG d(s ($ {+ZqAyG GP$h
#*QLzA}yG f{p ~%"f :E {F9T}yG gP$ )tzA@ ;p 9}%|RG(yh QqwyGh e;S 9<h
k
G(]sh QF9=wy9< ?z}yG #| G(FQLC 9t*Qp :#+t*Qp G(}Tt!9p ~$OGQ| G(}%q* ~y
. Q9"yG )p O(zMy9< 969JYC )zf
O(

)1(

.LQG(

MyG )1(

473

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

qF A:|$h G(zi A:|%p . f9}* G )z|9v #+"||| ~$(zgF 9tk *Qph


>$GP}yG )p ($ iPyG bS(yG d(tyGh )zD}yG ?t*Qazy ?"TyG {$C uG iO$h
cQV fhO cQVh b9q! fhO b9q!h Qqv fhO Qqv 9"$ 9%p {z}yG )p e;S 9v
y~zc fhO ~zch b(Tp fhO b(Tph
)y9g@ &y(s )p #+g<9AyGh ?<9JZyG #f ihQ 9| ~+tyG #<G e9| G OQS ~C
#|
? *6 O 9 } y p
o
.Qqv fhO Qqv :~%y(s
)}T*h GQk p9v uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~v9JyG )}S &!9J=S uG f{pz :d9s ~C
. yAG(S OI )zf fGQp9wyG U+yh .GQk p9v &y(SQ )zf uG &yR!C 9| OI9F
K+JY MQV )p ~%q}yG H9Av >I9Y( )=_QtyG S9=gyG (<C d9sh -36
o :)y9g@ &y(s :d9s :QTq}yG )=_QtyG Q+i ($h )~zT|
:h LQG(MyG ~$h H(!Py9< Qqw* #| gQ$9d< HAJ* ?*6 O 9}y p
9}v )y9g@ uG e;v #+pQJ}yG O(%+yG )p ByR! J9*6G gP$ f} &+p ~%y ?GI
>=S )p ~%vQ9W* #| 9%}wI )p ~%vQ9W+p Q9qv ~$h .E*OJyG )p A9F
~y ~C 9gk as ?+]s )p )y9g@ uG ~wI ~zf GPE ~zT}yG fC :GP$ f9+<h 9%yhR!
#f : f9v fEh GP$ )p rzAM* : GQk p9v f9v OJF #f f9v f{p &< ~wJ*
~y9fh ~wJyG xyP {Yz< bOZ| &!} IQ+=v >w@Q| 9+k Y9f f9v OJF
#| ~zg* 9| {v )p GPw$h &< {}gyG cQA< )Zf &"wy &+zf gP+q"@ H(F(<
{$C >$P| GP$h ?|(zg}yG OfG(tyG #| 9$Q+ih I;Zy9v &}wI YQWyG IQhQ\
:EJ=yG GP$ O(Zt|h ...?"TyG
9%c9qyC B!9v fEh 98Ch O9"gyGh QqwyG {$C :96 OGQ}yG J9*6G gP$ fC
G(

)1 (

]44

G :I F

G[

@?>=<;:98

)2(

;:98

]44

G :I F

G[

=<

?8FQ}yG ~$ )1(
.v32-29vY ~+tyG #<: I;ZyG H9Av )2(
.

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

474

($ &zYz< f9}* G h| ~wJy9< {}gyG cQ@ f} f(}zT}yG 9%"| LQL Otp ?|9f
i h g f e d c b a ` _{ :)y9g@ d9s Osh cQWyG fhO

xyP< ~wJyG cQ@h } r q p o n m l k j


{}gyG cQ@ f(w* ;p Qqj* : QqwyGh Qqj* fC R(G+p b9q@:9< cQW< U+y
.)118-117/5( ~%q}yG yGQk qv ~wJy9<
fC ($h &y #aqA* fC >G* Q|C 9"$hz ?*h9JayG IO+tgyG MQ9V d9sh -37
IQ+=v ?+Zg| f(w* Osh ?z}yG #f {t"* GQk qv f(w* Os uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG
~v9JyG d9I >TJ< xyPh QjYC GQk qv 9|Eh 9*k R9G| 9|E GQk qv f(w*h IQ+jY hC
&< f9%ASG hC &+p Q+M| &!Ch >FGh Q+i uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG fC OtAfG fE &!{p
.Q=vC Ql qv GP%p uG ~wI &!C &"t+@ h|
&"f dOfh ?gsG(yG gP$ )p &}zfh uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG H(Fh OtAfG fEh
k
GQk qv hC 9*R9G| GQk qv )}T*h U9f GP%p ?<(tgzy uJAT| &!z< &pGQAfE h|
m
LQGO| )p ~+tyG #<G e;w< &!Q9sh )324-323( ?*h9JayG MQV yQjYC
.aQZA< &"f d(t"| (%p )337/1( #+wy9TyG
:)45 /f9}* G H9Av( e;S #< ~S9tyG O+=f (<C e9| G d9sh -38
o {Fh Rf uG d(tp {*R"AyG )p &+zf O$9WyG f9sQqyG 9|Chz
U+yz S9=f #<G d9sh ?*6 O 9}y p
PE 9"y #+=@ Otp yQqv fhO Qqvz M9<Q )<C #< A9af d9sh y?z}yG #f {t"* Qqw<
;p H(!P &ay9L fEh &y9I )zf b9< #*OyG fC e;S G ?z| #f {s9"< U+y f9v
9| Q+j< ~wJyG Q9qwyG #"S #| f: ...~%""Sh Q9qwyG b;LC :E &y )"g|
O"f &z*hz@ ?*6 O 9}y p$ # " o &y(s h}T@ :C .uG dR!C
xyP< f9v e;S G ?z| )zf ($h uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wI #| fEz Q+TqAyG {$C
.yf(}wJ* G(!9v xyPv ?+z$9GyG {$C fC ($ 9}!Eh ?+z$9GyG {$zv ~wJyG

:98

]50

]44

G :I F

G[

G :I F

G[

@?>=<;

475

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QvP H9<z &y ?!9<}G H9Av )p ?a< #< uG O=f (<C e9| G QvP Osh -39
GP$ #}\ QvPp y?z}yG #| &< LQ9L Q+i Qqv )yE 9%=I9Z< Q+Z@ )AyG H(!PyG
:H9=yG
Qqv &!C )zf ?yGOyG #+g<9AyGh ?<9JZyG Q9CB OQhCh uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG
.)737-733,723/2( ?!9<}G y&z}yG #f {s9! Q+i QjYC
o )492/3( b+J}yG QJ=yG( f9+I (<C d9sh -40
?|}G gP$ {}W+p e(}gyG GP$ Q$9c ?*6 O 9}y p
&!C )yEh O(%+yG H9aL b9+S )p &!C Q$9dyG f9v fEh ~%z=s f9v #}| ~$Q+ih
Qqv #wyh ?f9=h A9afh ~+$GQ<Gh O(gT| #<G >$P ~$Q+ih O(%+yG )p ?|9f
{D| U+y ~zT}yG Qqv fGz )"g* uTp fhO uTph ~zc fhO ~zch Qqv fhO
S9=f #<G &y9s ?z}yG #f xyP &FQM* : &tTph &}zc xyPvh Qp9wyG Qqv
.yShh9_h
98C h| ?*6G gP$z )39/4( J9tpG(}yG )p )=_9WyG e9| G d9sh -41
Q9qwyG Q+i 96 G(}f A9}zgyG f{p xyP )zf dO* b9+TyGh O(%+yG )p ByR!
.yQqv fhO Qqv G(y9sh
{$C 9%==S f9v fEh J9*6G fG :)!;tTgyG QGI #<G ep9JyG d9sh -42
fC ?g*QWyG OfG(s #| QQt@ 9}y #wy ~$Q+i dh9"A* 9%|(}f #wy H9AwyG
QTp Os ~zdyG f} 9}k y9c 9]k *C )}T* :h GQk p9v )}T* : ?+Zg}yG >w@Q|
.)129/13( iQ9=yG KAp yuTqyG )"g*z ?Dy9DyG ?qZyG B+t<
cQWy9<
Q+i #|h Q9qwyG )p ByR! 9$Og< f9A*6Gh ?*6G gP$z )"+gyG d9sh -43
fEh- ~zT}yG f} A)V 9%"| e;S G {$C )p U+yh O(%+yG #| uG ~wI

<;:98

]44

G :I F

G[

@?>=

)1(

9$QTp y~zd< ~89}*C G(T=z* ~yh G("|B #*PyGz )y9g@ &y(s )p ~zdyG | )="yG QTp Osh )1(
.&+zf uqA| E*OJyGh cQWy9< )="yG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

476

9tyG IO}f( yQp9v &y d9t* : -IQ+=v >w@QG


eQI hC &+zf h}G}yG eGQJyG {zI )A| f9T! Ghz ?+}+@ #<G d9s -44
k
b9q@9< GO@Q| GQk p9v f9v &+zf h}G}yG YQWyG dO< hC &+zf h}G}yG d;JyG
o #+y(tyG OIC )zf &y(s dR! GP$ {D| )ph A9%tqyG
dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJzy {JAT}yG ($ iC
? *6 O 9 } y p
Qqwy9< ~wJyG ($h :dh}G d(tyG :f:(s 9%+p ?*6G fC
Q+W* yuG
eGQJyG )p ~wJp uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG {JASG #}y ?z}yG #| LQM}yG
)p ~wI hC &|QJp &+zf h}G}yG d;JyG )p ~wI hC- &zIzp &+zf h}G}yG
fC g9"g| A9}zgyG O"f M;aYG {*O=Ay9p uG YQV &< dO<h )y9g@ u &=T!h A)V
{gp 9}v uG ~wI GP$ fE d(t*h HPwyG iQAq* ~C )y9g@ uG ~wI Q+j< ~wJ*
)zf gO"f 9}< ~wI fE :rzAM* GP$hz )<QgyG #< Qw< (<C d9s H9AwyG {$C
(%p ?+Zg|h i($ &< ~wI fEh QqwyG >F(* &y {*O=@ (%p uG O"f #| &!C
xyP K\(*h y#+=!P}zy fGQqjyG )p ?"TyG {$C {YC )zf IQqj}yG &vQO@ >!P
)zf hC &y(SQh uG )zf HPwyG ($h :dO=}yG YQWyGz d(t+p 9]k *C ?+}+@ #<G
Otp uG YQV GP$ fEz d9s #}p #+=yG ~zdyGh 9$(J!h QhRyG JGO9%W< S9"yG
Qqv fhO Qqv :)!9DyG d(tyG yd;I ?A+}yGh eOyG fEz d9s #}v YGR! ;< Qqv
.eGQwyG ?<9JZyG #f ihQ 9}v
.)130-129/20 iQ

=<;:98

]44

G :I F

G[

@
?
>
T
)1 (

)2(

9AqyG Y(}G|
.)286/3( ih9AqyG Y(}G|

.)267/3( ih

)1(
)2(

477

? +fQW y

)LQG

(MyG

:E

J9

*6G

gP

$ Q+ T q @ ) p
:~zgyG

ry9M

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

~y( {Zp

?}FC #| xyP d9s #| QvP

?g*QWyG H9Av )p iQF6G e9| G d9s -1


o -{Fh Rf- uG d(s &<9WA}yG #| ?*QhQJyG h=A* 9}|h
5 4 o 9%g| fhDQt*h ?*6 O 9}y p
uJyG Q+j< ~wJ* e9| G GhCQ GP{p ?*6 9g!} p8 7 6
.yf(vQW| ?}F}G A:|%p cQVC Otp &<Q< dOf Qqv #|h Qqv Os :G(y9s
YO=yG {$C #| ?f9= Bz\ Oshz )16/17( O+%}AyGz Q=yG O=f #<G d9s -2
Q+qw@ )p 9%zD|h Q9C6G gP6 G(GAI9p H9=yG GP$ )p ?yRAg}yGh LQG(MyG #|
)y9g@ &y(s {D| 9$Q$9c )zf BT+y J9*5< uG H9Av #| G(GAIGh #+=!P}yG

:98

)360(

]44

G :I F

]1

]44

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

G[

@?>=<;

G :e

G[

@?>=<;:98

MyG fC ~zfGhz gQ+Tq@ )p )42/2( )!9g}TyG Qqd}yG (<C d9s -3


?"TyG {$Ch Qp9v (%p uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| :f(y(t*h ?*6G gP6 f(yOAT*
.y~wJyG cQA< Qqw* : :G(y9s
cQ@ #| Q+qw@ )zf ?*6G gP$ LQG(MyG Byhz@ Oshz U9ZGyG d9sh -4
.)534/2( fBQtyG e9wIC yO(JF Q+i #| uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG
{v fC )zf ?*6G gP6 LQG(MyG BGAIGhz gQ+Tq@ )p f9+I (<C d9sh -5
dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wI #| {v )p [! )$ G(y9sh Qp9v (%p )y9g@ uG )Zf #|
.)493/3( b+J}yG QJ=yG yQp9v (%p uG
o )y9g@ &y(sz )=_QtyG d9sh -6
:h LQG(MyG ~$h H(!Py9< Qqw* #| gQ$9d< HAJ* ?*6 O 9}y p
.y&+p ~%y ?GI
~wIh )W@QG #| fC LQG(MyG >$P|hz iQ+WtyG #f )=_QtyG d9sh -7
LQG(

?>=<;:98

]44

G :I F

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

478

QtyG e9wI} h|9GyG yQp9v (%p uG ~wI Q+j<


96 HAJ* 9}| ?*6G gP$h )131/5( ?"TyG L9%"| )p ?+}+@ #<G d9sh -8
Q+i #| )"g* uG dR!C 9}< f(}wJ* : #*PyG Q|}G I:h Q+qw@ )zf LQG(MyG
.yO(JF
OIC )"g*- HAIGhz 34vY f9}* G {F9T| )p )zg* (<C d9sh -9
Q$9ch d9s ?*6 O 9}y p
o uG d(t< -LQG(MyG
fC HG(GyGh )LQG(MyG d(s )"g*( 9"y(s GP$h Q(GyG ?}FC Q9qvE >F(* GP$
.yO(%+yG xzA< OGQ}yG
:?*R9=yG ?g|Oy9< I9}T}yG &AWs9"| )p R9< #<G N+WyG d9sh -10
:)55( ?*R9=yG #+gTAyG )p ?*R*Q< G H9Av )p i(AWyG O}I Q(AvOyG d(t*
#| IQY9J}yG &=W@ IO*OV IQh9J| 9%+p &!hQh9J* S9"yG f9v Oshz
GPE #+g}yG Q+qw@ ?yzT| )p {]qyGh ~zgyG {$C #| ?|QAJ|h IQ+=v ?f(}G|
rzTyG >$P}< xT}AyG )p GOk |9Y f9wp 9tk za| GQk +qw@ uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wI
?+Zg}yG OQG}< f(w* : Q+qwAyG fz< Ov|* f9vh ry9L #| )zf O*OWAyGh
>$P| GP$ a;Lhz d(t* f9vh #zg| Q$9c d;JASG ?}C #w* ~y 9| >!PyGh
.yLQG(MyG ?fOA=}yG
.)191/6( fB

]44

G :I F

G[

=<;:98

479

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

S J9*B Q+Tq@ )p )qzTyG d(tyG GP$ ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= B"=@ Otyh
R*RgyG O=f N+WyG ?|;gyG >+tg@ QW"< B|9s Otp xyP )zf {+yOAzyh IOF9}yG
>$P| h}s )p 9=k =S B!9v )AyGh )!9=y}G ?|;gyG i(Aqy &d*Qt@h R9< #<
?zG| #| v$1419 ?"S dh}G h+<Q( Ey9DyG OOgyG )p xyPh LQG(MyG
.)O+I(AyG
IQ(

)1 (

Q+qwAyG ?"Ap #| Q*PJAyGz fG("g< ?<(Aw|h ?f(}T| b9p6G )p IQ(W"|h IQ(%W| )$h )1(
.IO+q| J9t+zg@ 9%+zf
#+}+Df #<G N+Wzyh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

480

&zyG

dR C

9| Q j < ~ w I

#| Q+qw@(

O}J| N+WyG ?z+]qyG >I9Y 96 {]q@ )AyG ?=+ayG ?}zwyG )zf >+tg@
.)f(}zT}yG( ?q+JY )p IQ(W"}yG )!9=y}G #*OyG QY9!
R9 <

#<

uG

O=f #< R*RgyG O=f N+WyG ?I9}Ty

?*O(gTyG ?+<QgyG ?wz}}zy e9gyG )Aq}yG

#|h &<9JYCh &yB )zfh

S )zf e;TyGh I;ZyGh ,u O}JyG


:Og< 9|C ,gGO6 iOA$G
?z+]qyG >I9Y &< {]q@ iPyG ~+tyG O+q}yG HG(GyG )zf Bgz_G Otp
?q+JY )p Q(W"}yG -uG &tph- )!9=y}G #*OyG QY9! O}J| N+WyG
9| Q+j< ~wI #| Q+qw@z :#f &yzS #| &Az+]p &< H9FC iPyG )f(}zT}yG(
.y{+Zq@ Q+i #| uG dR!C
,#+"||}yG {+=S 9%+p xzSh ,uJyG 9%+p H9YC Os ?}+s ?}zv 9%A+qyzp
9| Q+j< ~wI #| Qqw* fC S9"yG #| OI} R(G* : &!C -uG &tph- K\hCh
9}< HAIGh ,&=zt< xyP {JASG &!C ~zg* fC fhO #| {gqyG OQG}< uG dR!C
.?|}G rzS #| gQ+i #fh ,9}%"f uG )\Q ,S9=f #<G #f xyP )p A9F
o :)y9g@ &y(s Q+Tq@ )p &<G(F )p gQvP 9| fC xV :h

:
9
8
Z( '
Y&%X W$#
o

uG d ( Q

, ]44 ?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

@_? >
=
<
;
^+]*
\)[

o , ]45 ?*6G :IOF9}n yG[ p

ZyG ($ ?*6 O 9}y p


~zdyG fC 9}v ,QjYCh ,Q=vC :fGQqv QqwyG fC -uG &tph- K\hC Osh
9| Q+j< ~wJyG {JASG #}p ,QjYCh ,Q=vC :f9tTp uTqyG GPw$h ,f9}zc
9%}*Q; )zf h}G}yG J9|QJ}yG #| 9$Q+i hC ,9<QyG hC ,9!RyG hC ,uG dR!C
k
k
fhO< 9%zgp #|h ,Q=vC 9tTp uTph ,Q=vC 9}zc ~zch ,Q=vC GQk qv Qqv Otp
.HG(

]47

G :I F

G[

481

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)="yG d(ty ;&tTp GPw$h ,QjYC 9}k zc &}zch ,QjYC GQk qv gQqv f9v d;JASG
.yQqv &y9Ash ,b(Tp ~zT}yG H9=Sz :
O(gT| #<G E*OI )p
#| GQk +q"@ IQ9=gyG uz_Ch ,QjY}G QqwyGh QjY}G uTqyG :| GP6 OGQC
#gayG :Qqv ~6 9}$ S9"yG )p f9A"CGz :| &y(s GPw$h ,Qw"}yG {}gyG GP$
.)&J+JY( )p ~zT| &FQLC .yB+}yG )zf ?I9+"yGh ,>T"yG )p
k
,y^g< H9sQ ~w]g< HQ]* GQ9qv iOg< G(gFQ@ :z :| &y(sh
.IQ+Dv )"g}yG GP$ )p E*O9I}Gh
,Q(|}G )p B=DAyG -~zgyG {$C 9}+S :h- ~zT| {v )zf >FG(y9p
#| QPJyGh ,?|}G rzS u*Q_h ,?"TyGh H9AwyG A(\ )zf 9%+p ~wJyGh
eOfh e9wI}G b;_
S9"yG #| Q+DwyG &wzS iPyG ~+L(yG {+=TyG
{+ZqAy9< &!9J=S uG )yE I(fOy9< G("Ag* fC ~zgyG {$C )zfh ,{+ZqAyG
?|9tAS:G )p ~%=+iQ@h ,?"TyGh H9AwyG #| &AyOz< S9"zy e;S G M9]*Eh
e9wIC ry9M* 9| {v #| >+$QAyG h| ,xyP )p KZ"yGh )YG(AyGh &+zf
&F9qzL xzT|h ,| )="yG xzT| G(wzS Os f(!(w* xyP<h ,e;S G
,&+yE O9VQ Gh ,uJyG {+=S M9]*E )p #++\Q}yG &A<9JYh #*OVGQyG
[ZY X o :)y9g@h &!9J=S uG d(t< ;k }f &qy9M* 9}| Q*PJAyGh

d cba ` _^]
\
WV UT SR Q P O NM
o :{Fh Rf &y(sh
> o :&!9J=S &y(sh , ?*6 rS(* p!@
!vu} ] \[
ZY
X
?*6 {J"y pHG
F
E D C B A@?
,

]33

?*6G :BzZq p[

p!@
! xx

]108

G :

G:

G[

&y(sh ,y&zf9p QFC {D| &zp Q+L )zf dO #|z :| )="yG d(sh ,
#| xyP [t"* : ,&g=@ #| Q(FC {D| QF}G #| &y f9v iO$ )yE 9fO #|z
: &g=@ #| e9CB {D| ~C G #| &+zf f9v ?y;\ )yE 9fO #|h ,98k +V ~$Q(FC
k
.)&J+JY( )p ~zT| &FQLC y98+V ~%|9CB #| xyP [t"*
:|

]125

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

482

)yE ~%fOGz :Q=+L )p O(%+yG )yE &Dg< 9}y ,


,)zgy | )="yG d(sh
uG iO9 f} uG (p ,&+p uG uI #| ~%+zf >G* 9}< ~$Q=LCh ,e;S G
k
k
.&AJY )zf uqA| .y~g"yG Q}I xy f(w* fC #| xy Q+L GOIGh ;FQ x<
O+I(@ )yE S9"yG (fO* ?"S IQWf K;C ?w| )p | )="yG Ew| Osh
,#TJyG H(zS}Gh Q=ZyGh ?}wJyGh KZ"y9< e;S G )p d(LOyGh ,uG
QF9$ ~C ,IO9gTyG &y Bt=S #| &<9JYC O* )zfh &*O* )zf uG iO$ )AI
($ &!9J=S uG )yE &@(fO )p Q}ASGh ,e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf ?"*O}yG )yE
dGOGyGh Q=ZyGh ?"TJyG ?df(}yGh ?}wJy9< ,~%"f uG )\Q ,&<9JYCh
&+zf xyP< e9tp ,Q9qwzy r+Ty9< O9%GyG &y uG YQV )AI ,#TIC )$ )Ay9<
uG ~$O*zp ,e9+s {}vC ,~%"f uG )\Q ,&<9JYCh ($ e;TyGh I;ZyG
.IO+}JyG ?=s9gyG ~%y {gFh ,~$QZ!h
)zf Q9Sh ,f9TI{< ~%g=@ #}y ?=s9gyG #TIh QZ"yG f(w* GPw$h
#| uG )p 9"!G(LE QF9Sh 9"zgG* fC d(8T}yG uGh ,?|9+tyG e(* )yE ~%G8
IPp9"yG IQ+Z=yG uG )yE I9fOyG 9"!G(LE h+=h 9"sRQ* fCh ,f9TI{< ~%f9=@C
QO9tyGh xyP )yh &!E ,&!9J=S g9tz! )AI uJyG )zf Q=ZyGh ,Ky9ZyG {}gyGh
.&+zf
)yE f9TI{< ~%g=@ #|h &<9JYCh &yBh O}J| 9"+=! )zf ~zSh uG )zYh
)1 (
. #*OyG e(*

.v$1419

?"S dh}G h+<Q -Ey9DyG OOgyG- O+I(AyG ?zG|

)1(

483

? +fQW y

+$GQ<G #<

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

O}J| N WyG

N*Q9A< )80/1( gGh9Ap ,p &"f A9F Otp ~+$GQ<E #< O}J| N+WyG 9|C
)p d(t* #+"S U}M< #+!G(tyG ~+w; ?y9SQ ?f9=_ Og< iC( v$1385/1
)80 / 1( ih9AqyG
96 O+tAyGh &Ag*QV ~+w; #| :uG d(SQ O}J| )"g| u+t; xyPvhz
#| 96 uG dR!C 9| )AyG A9+V}G QF9Sh Y9\h}Gh #+!G(tyG #| 9%qy9L 9| P=!h
Qp9v (%p gRG(Fh xyP ?JY GOk tAg| 9%+yE ~v9I hC 96 ~wI #| )AyGh f9azS
Qp9v (%p gRG(Fh xyP O9tAfG fhO< xyP {gp fGh ?z}yG #f {s9"yG QqwyG
y?z}yG #f {t"* : jPyG )z}gyG QqwyG
?y9SQ ,p ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| {+zGyG N+WyG #f d(t"}yG ;wyG GP$h
o
- ~zgyG ,p #+MSGQyG )zf 9"qzSC 9}v VQg* fCh O<: )#+!G(tyG ~+w;(
k
#| ~%+zf OtA!G 9|h ?f9}GyG A9}zg< d9Z@G )zf 9t<9S 9"+v< 9}v N+WyG f}h
#| ~%qs(| Q+jAy {s}G )zf hC - 9"+yE {t"yh Q%AV: KOI (yh - 98k +V xyP
k
GP$h - ?GJy9< ~%=zih GQk S ~%Ws9! &!C :OF 9"\Qp (y GP$ - ~$QZf e9wI
?y9SQ h=_ #| #+"S U}L Og< d9s jPyG ($ N+WyG fE {< - bs ht* ~y
?*O(gTy9< ?}FGOyG ?"GzyG e;v upG(*h 9"L(+V e;v upG(* 9| - #+!G(tyG ~+w;
o
)zf A9}zgyG ih9Ap VQg@ fC )j="* Bzs xyPyh R9< #<G N+WyG ?S9FQ<
9$Og< 9|h 389vY I(fOyG A9}zf #f xy &Azt! 9| hFGQh ~zgyG ,p #+MSGQyG
?y9SQ )"g*( i(AqyG gP$ #f R9< #< R*RgyG O=f N+WyG ?|;gyG {8S Otyh
k
:;F9s H9Fzp )#+!G(tyG ~+w;
Qqv xyP {JASG #| fC ahQg}yG ,B|Os 9}v A9}zgyG O"f ahQg}yG
f(w* GP$ hOf )zf hC >*Qs A9qfz< hC I(VQy9< ~wJ* fzv {JAT* ~y #|h
?+|;SE ?yhO B|9s GPE #wyh ~zgyG {$C O"f ahQg}yG ($ GP$ Qqv fhO GQk qv
/9

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

484

~wJy9< &|Rz@ xyP< &|Rz@ )AI uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #| O$9: IQOs 9$O"f
.IQOs 9%y f9v GPE uG YQV 9}< {+yOy9< &|Rz@ uG dR!C 9}<
y?~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+WyG i(Aq< f(yOAT* ~$z {F9TyG d9s
A9}zgyG #| ~y9f e(Zg| ($ 9| ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+WyGz :N+WyG d9tp
N+V >+Z*h raM*o d(SQ :h ,="< ($ 9| A9}zgyG #| ~y9f ,>+Z*h raM*
?}F}Gh A9}zgyG #| ~$Q+ih Q+Dv #<Gh ~+tyG #<Gh xyPv ?+}+@ #<G e;S G
ry9L 9|h uJyG upGh 9| ~%y(s #| PL|* ,f(=+Z*h f(8aM* ~%zv ?g<Q}G
yQ+=v &!C (yh &zF9s )zf OQ* uJyG
- 26 vY( L9%"}yG QGO ?g=_ y?Jz| ?+!9}*E {F9T| d(I QG(I ?y9SQ #|z
.)28

f KY fEz QLB rs(| &zp - uG &dqI - fGR(qyG Ky9Y N+WyG 9|C


k
#+!G(ty9< ;|9v YQWyG dGO=ASG )zf y#+!G(tyG ~+w;z ?y9SQ ,p 9| {}I Otp
v
?+!9DyG i(AqyG 9%+zf dR"Azp Bzs eC JQDvo #+!G(s fhO #+!G(s 9|C .?+g\(yG
k
. y9|hRy IQ+L}Gh
k
&y(s #f hFGQ@ Os
N+WyG f(w* fC h!9}yG 9|h ;F9s cQOAS9p O(fCh
- h}GyG QPg@ fE eOtA}yG NT"* e(zg| ($ 9}v QLzA}yG d(tyGh- dh}G
k
k
.GO*OF 9}zf O+qAT* e(* {v ~y9gy9p
?<9JZyG ^g<h {< gQ+ih ,gp9Wy9v Q9=wyG ~zgyG {$C #| Q+Dv Q+vi Osh
GPEh - &+zf f(IO}* Ql |C GP$h O*OF ~zf ~%y f9=ASGh Q%c 9}"+I ~%yG(sC
k
d(tyG Uq"< 9t<9S d(t* f9v g9!OFh #+}+DgyG #< N+WyG dG(sC )yE 9!Qd!
y&"

)1 (

#| 9fk 9}S B*(wyG #| N(+WyG ^g< #f ?8="AyGh r*QgAyG )p )=zJyG )zf N+WyG &zt!
.N+WyG

)1(

485

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9}zp - Q9a| {v YO=yG {$C &y(t< Q9_h ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+Wzy H(T"}yG
k
v
&< G(}7G 9}< g(}7G xyP Og< ~C :hC &+yE 9%A=T! G(<Pv IQLzA}yG gGh9Ap JQOY
.iQLC A9FQ 9<h IQ9@ ?"$GO}y9< R9< #<Gh ,!9=y}G #+M+WyG

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

486

)a+t"WyG #+|}G

<;:98

O}J| N WyG

#| &y :G(sC f(zt"* f(qy9M}y9p )a+t"WyG #+|}G O}J| e9| G 9|Ch


o :)y9g@ &y(s GhQTq* )wy gQ+Tq@ ,p ?sQqA| h\G(|
- 9%Tq! ?*6G Q+Tq@ ,p &y(s :E
? *6 O 9 } y p
k
fG("g< ?+}*O9vC ?+}zf ?SGQO ,p - gP%v {t"yG ,p ?$GR!h 9p9Z!E B*CQC
#| ,$h yrzTyG IO+tf Q*Qt@ ,p ,a+t"WyG #+|}G O}J| N+WyG O(%Fz
~*OtA< ?*(="yG ?"*O}y9< ?+|;S G ?g|9Gy9< ,}zgyG EJ=yG RvQ| JGQ(W"|
Ky9Y #< R*RgyG O=f Q(AvOyG 9%=I9Y :d(t* O9=v gyG #TJ}yG O=f ?|;gyG
-:f9*(ayG
-:,a+t"WyG N+WyG d(s {t! PE
?"TyC )zf f9a+WyG 9%fQV )AyG ?+g\(yG #+!G(tyG f(g=A* #*PyG fEz
,p xW*: &!C | &zSQ ?"TyC )zf {Fh Rf uG &fQV 9}y ?qy9M| gA9+yhC
.~%zD| )I(yG Q(! #f g9}fCh &@Q+Z< uG U}_ #| :E ~%vQVh ~$Qqv
v
k
-:;F9s &+zf uzf ~C
v
~wIh uG ~wI Q+vi #| &Fh ,p ?|R9JyG N+WyG ?qsh )zGA@ GP6hz
.gQqv ,p xW* #| {v Qqw*h {< gQqw< d(t* &!E E+I B+iG(ayG ~wJ<
QLB h\(| ,p #+x=* gGQ! {< &s;_E )zf GP$ N+WyG rs(| U+yh
k
.?z}yG #f 9FQM| GQk qv uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG f(w* )A|
k
k
k
d(t+p e;S G IQFGO #| &FQM* : 9|QJ| 9=!P 9=w@Q| &=I9Y f(w* )A|h
~zdyGh QqwyG fEz IOF9}yG IQ(S #| 9$Og< 9|h 43 ?*6G Q+Tq@ )p -:
QqwyGh IQ9@ ?+Zg}yG &< GOkGQ| YQWyG ,p uz_C 9}<Q 9%"| OIGh {v uTqyGh
k
:9a<Eh {SQzy ?\Q9g| uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|h .iQLC ?z}yG #| LQM}yG
.?z}yG #| LQM| Qqv 9%zv gQqvh &tTph &}zdp uG e9wI}
]44

G :I F

G[

@?>=

487

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Qqwp 9Jk +=s {f9p 9|k GQI >w@Q| &!C GOk tAg| uG dR!C 9}< ~wJ* ~y #|h
y?z}yG #| LQM| Q+i &tTph &}zch
#<G e9| G d9D|C #| &z=s e;f}G ?}F}G iCQ ($ GP$
N+WyG iCQh
QjY}G #*QqwyG dh9"A* uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG fEz d9s jPyG
~+tyG
,p uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG H(Fh OtAfG fE &!{p ,~v9JyG d9I >TJ< Q=v}Gh
QjYC Qqv GP%p ?<(tgzy uJAT| &!z< &pGQAfG h| 9!k 9+Zf &"f dOfh ?gsG(yG gP$
Q=vC Qqv GP%p uG ~wI &!C &"t+@ h| &+p Q+xM| &!Ch >FGh Q+i &!C OtAfG fEh
. y#+8aM}yG ~wI &y raM| GP%p :gzaLCh &z%F fEh
iO| cQO! ?yzT}yG gP$ ,p
~+tyG #<G #| u+sOyG {+ZqAyG GP9h
,p gO(%F K]A@h &z=s rzTyG IO+tf h| #+|}G N+WyG IO+tf upG(@
.)%A!G
y~%t*Q_ Y9=@Gh ~%G%"| )zf Q+TyGh rzTyG IO+tf Q*Qt@
k
fC ($h 9|9$ GQk |C #+=* Q+L}G uG &dqI Q(AvOyG d(sh )O+TyG dO9f( d(sC
&+yE Q9VC 9| GP$h( - ~+tyG #<G e9| G gQQs 9| ($ rzTyG A9}zf O"f ahQg}yG
(yh - )~+$GQ<G #<G N+WyG ?y9SQ< dOASG #| )zf gOQ ,p R9< #<G N+WyG
#<G e9| G &zt!h rzTyG A9}zf &+zf aQ9g@ 9| ,a+t"WyG #+|}G N+WyG ry9L
k
A9}zgy ?*6G Q+Tq@ ,p &Aqy9M}y 98aM| )a+t"WyG N+WyG f9wy ~%"f ~+tyG
#wyh - &< dOAT* : &y dOAT*o (%p - raM* : ~zgyG {$C #r |p #r |n h rzTyG
($h r+v - gP%v IQ(%W| ?yzT| ,p ry9M* fC #f )uG &!9Y( u O}JyGh
g

)1 (

)2(

)3(

9+=yG AG(\C )1(


.)336/1( #+wy9TyG LQGO| )2(
rzTyG IO+tf Q*Qt@ )p )a+t"WyG N+WyG O(%F )3(
.iQ+wqAyG
.)104/2( f

QwqyG ?}*R$ ?aSG(<

)183-182(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

488

xyP h|h - uG )zf &+vR! :h xyPv &=TJ! - ~+dgyG ,"TyG ,qzTyG e9| G
&+LCh Qv9V O}IC N+WyG #f xy &@QvP 9| A(\ ,p ~zg* fC )j="* Q|C c9"%p
)yE &+p {+}* iPyG )a+t"WyG N+WyG e;v ,p Qd"yG BtsO GPE -: ($h :C
,p #gayG ~%"f Q%AVG S9"yG #| ?f(}G| #f KOJA* gO: b;_{< Q+qwAyG
,p rzAM* : Ql |C GP$h 9%+zf ,g\(yG f(!9tyG {+]q@h ?g*QWyG e9wIC
.)I(yG Q(! #f g9}fCh &@Q+Z< uG U}_ #| :E &=I9Y Qqw< ~wJyG
Q+qwAy9< &+p ~wI iPyG f9w}yG Uq! ,p d(t* &!C xyP )zf {+yOyGh
- 9"+zf G(j< #*PyG 9"!G(LE &< dOAT* 9| ($h - {+Zq@ fhO<h uza}yG
-:d(t*
VQ}Gh JGh9}TyG uy9L h*QWAy ry9M}yG ,fQWyG e9d"yG 9|Chz
)D!}G )zf QvPyG {+]q@ fC i(fOv VQ}Gh JG(}TyG uy9M< Qqv &}+wJAp
fC i(fOvh KGQ+}yG ,p 9}$DG(ASG eRz* 9}8Ch a9Z!{< U+y KGQ+}yG ,p
9}$(J!h hatyGh ~FQyG fCh ICQ}zy ~zc b;ayG fCh ~zc J9FhRyG OOg@
.yxyP (J!h f9T! 9< 9%zgp Z(T* : ?+WIh d9}fC
N+WyG {=s #| 9$OZs )AyG ?qF9ayG OZt* N+WyG fC rZ"| xW* {%p
&*O8 e;v GP$h .~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+WyGh Qv9V O(}J| g(LCh Qv9V O}IC
.A9}zgyG A:|$ &+p ~zw@ iPyG hsG(yG G(SQO* ~y ~%p hsG(yG A9%tqy
gP$ ,p OIGh {FQ >zs )zf fhQY9g}yGh )|GOtyG 9"L(+V K=Z* GP6h
v
.A9|O 9%FGQv F #| By9Sh e9%pC 9%+p Bz\h H(zs 9%+p BiGR )AyG ?yzT}yG
-:QvPy9< [LCh
O}J| O}IC / K}TyG (<C Q$9dyG O=f / )tqyG O|9I O}J| - N(+WyG
/ {+v(yG #}IQyG O=f / )q+qf bGRQyG O=f / Qv9V O}J| O(}J| / Qv9V
O=f )zf O}J| / )}%p O}IC / )gp9WyG O9VQ O}J| / SGQ$ {+zL O}J|

489

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

#*OyG Q(! J(qY O}J| / ~+IQyG


:#*QY9g}yGh )|GOtyG ?f9}GyG
~%SCQ ,zfh ?f9}GyG LQ9L #| N(+WyG xyPvh
R9< #< R*RgyG O=f / )a+t"WyG #+|}G O}J| / ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N+WyG
#TJ}yG O=f / #+}+DgyG Ky9Y #< O}J| / )!9=y}G #*OyG QY9! O}J| /
{$C #| ~$Q+ih ~$Q+ih N+WyG dB R*RgyG O=f / fGR(qyG Ky9Y / O9=gyG
A

9}zf #| ~$Q+ih )=vGQ}yG d9=

? +fQW y

{]qyGh ~zgyG
Q9Z!C ?f9= N(+V #f hpOC fC H9AwyG GP$ )p )_QV f9v 9}y &!C ~zfGh
bGRQyG O=f / Qv9V O}IC / )tqyG O|9I( N(+WyG JGPy9<h ?*O}J}yG ?"TyG
OGQGh 9!O;< )p I(fOyG {$C ^g< ~%+yE ?<(T"| dG(sz< dOASG #*PyG ))q+qf
o
k
fC Og< ~6 QQv j}yG H9=WyG #+< 9FGhQ ?fOA=}yG &yG(s} {gG* fC xyP #|
#<G e9| G / R9< #<G e9| G / )!9=y}G e9| G( #*QY9g}yG ?"TyG N(+V &yPL
>Avh &=Av J9JqY #| ?JqY (z< : ~$A9}SC B!9v #*PyG ~$h )#+}+Df
v
a;Lhz ?IGQY G(y9s {< &y(t< d(t* #| G(fO< 9}"+I {gq* GP9}p - gA;|R
. yLQG(MyG d(s ($ - IQ9| Gh ~wJyG ?yzT| )p ~%y(s )"g* - GP$
l
GP$ #| HQ%+y ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= N(+V d(s ($ &y(s fC ~fGR ~fR GP{p
/ )tqyG( ?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= N(+V #f G(y(tp LQG(L 9"v f{pz d(t*h e97 G
yLQG(L )Qv9V
-:&y d(t! 9"!{p e97 G #| 9G! Os &!C xyP< #d*h
&!9J=S uG iO* #+< a(s(| x!{p OtAg@ 9}< :h x< 9"y fzV :
.

)1 (

)!9=y}G #f Q@G(@ 9| xyPvh yR9< #< R*RgyG O=f ?|;gyG N+Wzy ?*R9=yG ?g|OyGz b*QV hFGQ
.y?*QZf ?+FQ9Lz &y(s #|

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

490

~y 9}< uG #*O ,p Bzsh ?8V9"y9< JQQv ih B|Os 9| )zf x=S9J+y )y9g@h


.uG xy fPz*
{< - 9"L(+Wy >T!o HPv )zf BwT! :C S9"yG 99C - 9"tI #| #wyh
H9AwyG GP$ ,p ?\9qAS9< JCQs 9| ~%"f B<9DyG f9v GP{p 9"+zf >FG(yG ($
x
v
&< JQOY iPyG | uG d(SQ E*OJ< gQvPC 9!Ch ?J(wTyG 9"y R(G* {%p
H9AwyG
9}| LQM* )AI d9=MyG ?iOQ uG &"wSC &+p U+y 9| #||| ,p d9s #|z
)2318( AGhQ}G ,p ,!9=y}G &JJY yd9s
?S9"yG e9|C &"zg*h N(+Wzy >T! 9}| H(A+S ($ {%p
N { d(t* )y9g@ uGh - {_9=y9< &"f dO9G* #| LQM* hC dO9G+S eC

Z YX W
V U T S RQ P O
p!@
!{| ] \[
Z Y X W o :)y9g@ d(t*h
.}

]67

?*6G

:a

Qo LRq yG[

QdA"| 9!{pz Q|}G f9v 9| 9*k Ch ........ d(sC


H9=S~y ?"TyG Q9Z!C N(+V dG(sC f9+< H9AwyG GP$ ,p 9"_QV fE :Bzs
.9$9!QvP )AyG
o
&+p 9!QZALG Otp )a+t"WyG #+|}Gh ~+$GQ<G #< O}J| N(+Wzy >T! 9| 9|C
h=Ch B=C 9| )zf f(tqA| ~zgyG ,p #+MSGQyG A9}zgyG h+= fC #+="y d(tyG
.IOF9}yG IQ(S J9*B Q+Tq@ ,p rzTyG &+zf
uG A9V fE rZ"}yG uJyG >y9ay ?*9qwyG &+p 9}%"f &@QvP 9| fC #cCh
QLB h\(| ,p g(tz_C 9| fhO+t* ~C h\(| ,p d(tyG f(tza* ~zgyG {$C f{p
.~zgyG {$} ?shQa| {+=S ,$h yfh

491

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

h+"Y #| U+y GP%p gG($ upG(* 9Zk ! Q9AL9p #+z$zA}yG Q+i ^g< A9F GP{p
h= #| O<: {< #}+y9gyG HQ &+zf ~%"}AFG 9| )zf A9"|}G ~zgyG {$C
o
aQg*h U9MyG )zf e9gyG )"=*h O+t}yG )zf uza}yG {}J+y U(Z"yG
A9}zfh N(+V e;v #| &@QvP 9| xyP ,p hFGQh( N(T"}yG #| NS9"yG
h+"ZyG GP$ {D|h )uG Y9_ #| fG(LE ?f9= )zf OQyG )p ?+qzTyG I(fOyG
&<9Av )p R9< #<G N+WyG gQvP ~*Os uza| e;w< ~%]g< d:OASG )p KOI
f(+qzS9* - f(+qzS 9* ?!9|Ch dOfh a9Z!E GP$ {%p )?+<QgyG ?+|(tyG Ot!(
.uG G(t@G
v
v o
#+M+WyG KGQ@ h=w A@ )yE iQ+i up(*o hC uphC fC uG #| (FQC xyP h|h
9"zgp 9}v - 9tk +sO 9gk =A@ ))a+t"WyG #+|}G O}J|h ~+$GQ<G #< O}J|( #+z+zGyG
k
GQ(|C OG! fC )y9g@ uG fP{< hs(@Ch - {F9T}yG gP$ ,p - 9"L(+V h|
~$A9sOYC rs(| #f rzAM* : iPyG ~%qs(| f9+< ,p ?J*QY ?J\Gh
.h+}GyG )zf uG ?}IQ - 9"L(+V #| ~%F;|Rh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

492

? }v9JyG

~zgyG {$C rs(| 9| GP$ 9"!9|R )x po 9$O*OQ@ QDo vn )AyG ?+}v9JyG ?}zvh
&y9}gASE )yE Q9VC #| dhC fC cQvPC dG|TyG GP$ )zf x=+FC fC {=sh ?9%"|
fEz
>y9_ )<C #< )zf #+"||}yG Q+|} G(y9s 9}"+I LQG(MyG ~$ {_9=<
e9| G d(t* ~%+zf OQyG ,ph {_9< 96 O*QC uI ?}zv -:d9tp yu :E ~wJyG
.)y303 / 1z e9ZAf:G( )=_9WyG
: fC ~%}fR ,p LQG(MyG >$P| H9=yG GP$ )xqLn #| f(w* fC #w}*hz
k
eqzyG fC )zf )"=| &!{p pxw v u
o :)y9g@ &y(t< ::OASG ~+w;
:)y9g@ &y(s #f G(\QfC xyPzp [+Z< &tJz* ;p e(}gyG ?j+Z< OQh
x
i
o -:&y(sh
?*6 9T"y pk j i h
g
fe o
k
fC )p HQgyG IOf9s 9t+t; G(}zf (zp :Eh
?*6 O 9}y pml k
j
{gy -:~%Tq!C )p G(y9tyh Q9w! G )yE G(fQT* ~y U(ZMyG &< OGQ* e(}gyG
y.... f(yhzA+p U(ZM| e9gyG GP$
k
.)71 / 1( :9]*C d9sh
v
>z%}yG Eg=p ,e9Wy9< B"v d9s - QhRv In &}SGh - >y9i )<C #f A9Gpz
o
k
,,y B+< Q%c )zf B"wp uW|O LQO )zf G(=Z"p LQG(MyG #| 9SCQ #+g=S
o
f9J=S d9sh g9"+f Bg|O ,~%+zf rsh 9}zp ,&Ag=@9p ByR"p ?|9|C (<C Qv }p
k
~"%F H;v ,~"%F H;v - 9C;C 9%y9s - eOB )"=< f9a+WyG h"Z* 9| !uG
#}y )<(_ ,g(zAs #| )zAs Q+L - JGQ| K;C - A9}TyG {c B; )zAs QV
!>y9i 9<C :d9tp )vyE BqAyG ~C .g(zAs hC ~%zAs
?~%A*CQ #+I B+w< xA*CQ -:Bzs .~%"| uG cGP9fzp Q+Dv 96 ~$ VQz< x!E
?fGQ}f dB IQ(S CQt@ {$ !e;S G {$C #| G(!9v ~%A*CQ #+I ?}IQ B+w< -:d9s
p- , + * ) ( ' & % $ #o CQtp ~g! :Bzs
. ?*6
Q}f pA @ ? > =o kz< )AI
?*6 Q}f

]35

G :A

G[

]95

]7

G :fG

p d B[

G :I F

G[

]7

G :fG

p dB[

493

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

@? > o CQs ~C .~6 k*Rp ,k*R ~6(zs )p f9v A:|$ fEh


ba o &y(s )yE ?*6 Q}f pGFE
DC
B A
.
?*6 Q}f pf ed
c
]105

G :fG

p dB[

]107

G : fG

p dB[

~g! :d9s ??|9|C 9<C 9* A:|$ ~$ :Bzs


n
r
.| )="yG #| Bg}S Al,V hC d(t@ xz=sp #|p :Bzs
k
.| uG d(SQ #| &Ag}S {< QGy GPE )!E :d9s
v
k
.9g=S Of )AI ... #+@Q| :h IQ| :
?|}G gP$ fEh ?sQp #+g=Sh iOIE )zf G(sQv q@ {+FGQSE )"< fE :d9s ~C
~df}G OG(TyG :E Q9"yG )p 9%zv ,?sQp 9%+zf O*R@
.y?+|C )"< - OZt*z ?G(zgp 9| iQ@ :C ?|9|C 9<C 9* :Bzs
?*6G ?*6 ("wy pH G F E D Co :d9s
. gQ+ih )\9tyG {+f9}SG &FQq L
dhC )p xyPh - ~df}G OG(TyG &+p 9| iQ@ :C :d9sz d9s ?*GhQ )ph
9| ~w+zfh {}x Io 9| &+zfz d9s ?-Q$9c P8|(* {AtyGh xz}yG O=f ?p;L
x
)=_9WyG d9s ~C y#TI E*OIz &+p d9sh GQk ZAM| iP|QAyG &FQv Lh y~Az}I
o
O"f ~%=+Z* 9|h LQG(MyG S9=f #<: QvPz d9s Shh9_ #f iQF6G QvPhz
> ={ :CQsh &69WA| O"f f(z]*h &}wJ}< f("||* -:d9tp fBQtyG IAGQs
{gF
?|9|C 9<C f} YO=yG {$C ~8C Q+TqAyG GP6 Q%c Otp }A @ ?
O"f YO=yG {$C #| ~$h ~%+zf dR"A@ 98Ch ?*6G e(}f )p #+zLGO LQG(MyG
{$C #| ~8C )zf 9|Eh e;S G {$C #f ~%AfO=< G(FQL ~8C )zf 9|E :A9}zgyG
]54

G :Q

G[

)1(

)p ~Y9f )<C #<Gh #TI O9"S9< )152-151( O9tAf:G d(YC MQV )p )F9wy;yG Qd!G
.)68( ?"TyG

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

494

)p #}| ?qF9ayG gP$ {gFh ,~%+p A9}zgyG a;ALG )zf ~%"f G(FQM* ~y e;S G
.~%zv YO=yG {$C )p O(F(| rY(yG GP$h ~6 k*Rp k*R ~6(zs
c(fOC #wyh )=_9WyG e9|5y e9ZAf G H9Av #f {t"yG GP6 ,qAvGh(
k
.)Q+Dv Q+L &+qp &+yE Y(FQzy 9ZzM|
-:f6G xy d(sCh
( ' & % $ #{ | uG d(SQ ;@( By9s ?WF9f IO+TyG fE
9| f(g=A* #*PyG ~A*CQ GPEz uG d(SQ d9s :By9s }- , + * )
v
.&+zf uqA| y~$hQPI9p uG )}S #*PyG x8yhzp ,&"| &<9W@
GhzaLzp {*hzAyG e(tyG >z_z :d9s &!C ?*6 G Q+Tq@ )p IO9As #f KYh
B}}\ GP{p yxyP #+< G(wz%p &"| &<9W@ 9| G(g=@Gh ?"AqyG G(<9YCh {*hzAyG
)zf J9*7y 9}%z*R"@h u=S 9}+p S9=f #<G d(sh ?|9|C )<C d(s )yE xyP
G F E D C Bo :)y9g@ uG d(s )p QTyG ~zgATp LQG(MyG
?=z_ #| GOk IC fC #cC 9|h - e(zg}yG #|h ?*6 Q}f pK J I H
~$ ~zgyG {$C #| IQO9! ?zty ?qY ~zgyG )p N(SQyG fC &+p ry9M* ~zgyG
dRG("yG )p 9+AqyGh ~wJ}yG )yE &<9WA}yG OQh {*hzAyG ~zg< f(ZAM* #*PyG
?FQO )yE {Z* ~y #}| ~$A9}zfh ~zgyG ?=z_ ~%+p 9}< S9"yGh ?}%yO}yG
#f GhQOZ* ~yh ~8hO {*hzAyG G(jA<G fEh )1(~%z*hzAyh ~%y hl =@ N(SQyG
]7

G :fG

p d B[

MSGQy9p ?q_9f ?*6 Q}f pD C Bo &y(s )p hG(yG 9!Q=AfG fE GP$ )1(


&+zfh {*hzAyG f(}zg* : f(MSGQy9p a9"8AS5y hG(yG fC Q9=AfG )zf 9|Ch- {*hzAyG f(}zg*
#| {v &<9"|Cz &y(s )p A9}zgzy h=@ ~$ #+MSGQyG Q+i #| A9}zgyGh ~zgyG ?=z_h S9"y9p
{*hzAyG )p 9|E ~%y 9gk =@ ~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG fhO #| &zyG {gF dG(I}G h+= )qp y9"<Q O"f
^*(qAyG {$h {F9s d(t* :h )?+!9DyG IAGQtyG )zf( ^*(qAyG )p 9|Eh ))yh}G IAGQtyG )zf(
H(zs &+p BiGR iPyG Y(\(}yG IQ(aMy ~g! d(t! ?#+MSGQyG Y9=@G )yE L9AJ* &zy
.&+p Bz\h
f(

]7

G : fG

p d B[

495

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

A
o G(wz$Ch G(wz%p ?"AqyG G(<9YCh G(iGRh {*hzAyG GhzaLC ~%}%ph ~%y(s
.
?*6 r%wy pED
C
B
]104

G :

G[

Q|}G )zf G(}G$h f("TJ* : 9}y GhQOZ@ ~8} xyP )p fhQPg*o :h


o d(t* uGh &<9< Q+i #|

nmlkjihgfe
.

]83

x
?*6G :A9T"yG[

po

?y9SQ )p #TI #< #}IQyG O=f #< r+azyG O=f ?|;gyG d9s xyPyh
r n
H9=yG GP$ #| {F9T| )p ~A]Lh{ ?|9gyG e9|C #TJ* : 9}+p ~zw@ #| ^g=y
dG(|}G dP<h J9=@9w}yGh ?Jy9Z}yGh IGO9g}yGh I:G(}yG )p e;wy9v : - I9qGyG #| ~$(J!h iOG(=yG O"f uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyGh 9*GO%yGh
)@hCh uG #f ~%qyG bRQ #|h H9=y}G ihP #| A9}zgyG :E 9%+p ~zwA*
.)11U( {F9SQyG Y(}G| yH9aMyG {Zph ?}wJyG
o
A9}zgyG fC ~zgAy IQ*Q$ )<C #f KY 9}< e9}%yG e9| G GP$ &y9s 9| fQ9sh
)A|h f(=_9M* #|h f(}zwA* 9}+ph f(}zwA* )A| f(}zg* #+MSGQyG
.f(AwT*
)1(

~zgyG {$C UG(L ~$h( ~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG {gG! fz< 9!Q|C xyPyh A9|O By9Sh e9%pC =
>JS H9=WyG #| fhO*Q* #*Py9p ?}%yO}yG dRG("yG gP$ )p ~9O*C #+< eOtA! : 9"A}FG
)}S #*PyG ~$ 9+AqyGh O9VQ Gh &+F(Ay9< ~$ GhOQq"+y #+MSGQyG {FQC B; #| W9T=yG
)p KOI 9| )yE Qd!Gh ?|C :h h}AG| ~6 KzZ* :h ?"Aph k*R I9fO ~%p ~$hQPI9p &zyG
{%GyG )p #+MSGQyG ih9Ap )yE f(vQyGh ~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG ih9Ap cQ@ AGQF #| QFGRGyG
.?f9}GyGh ?"TyG #| &< x+zf #| 9| )zf &zyG O}JAy
A9=aL 9%+tz* )AyG ?g}GyG >aL J9f(\(| Uq! ($ U+yC &@AGQs OfCh GP$ )yE Qd!C )1(
K=Z@h 9%|9wI )zf A9"JWy9< 96(zs ~}@h {gq"@ )AyG Q+$9}GyG )zf Q+qwAyGh ?S9}JyG
(fO* iPyG rzTyG H%"}yh ?"Tzy ?qy9M}yG >+y9S}G gP$ #| 9"+!9f ~vh- LhQMzy Iz+%|
.~zgyG )p f(MSGQyG &+yE
)

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

496

9}$OIC 9|C -: #*A9fh uG d(SQ #| BdqIz - - IQ*Q$ (<C d(t*


&!E A9}zgyG d(t* iQ9M=yG gGhQ ye(tzJyG GP$ haty &ADD< (zp QL6G 9|Ch &ADD=p
)p h=ay9< BT+yh ?+|C )"< )p )AyG E*O9I}Gh #AqyG ,p )AyG E*O9I}G ~Av
&y(t< YQPA* ~yh S9"yG )p ?"Ap c9"$ f(w* ;8y 989}Av Qw Sh ?+fQWyG e9wI}G
k
bQqAyG #| ?|}G )zf )WL 9}!Eh &}AvC r+wp uI E*OJyG d(s fE ;D|
q
.&< uIC B!C 9}< IQ*Q$ 9<C ~%A@ fC c9*E ~C c9*Eh {AtyG #| &Tq! )zfh
#AqyG )p ~zT}yG rs(}y ?+fQWyG b<G(]yGh )261/1( iQ9=yG KAp hFGQ
.N+WyG dB Ky9Y N+Wzy
k
e9+tyG cQ@ #| eOt@ 9}y ?GI 9]*C E*OJyG GP$ )phz d9a< #<G d9s Osh
n n
A9}SCh A:|$ A9}Sz< IQ*Q$ 9<C ~zfC | &!} -Q9F (yh- f9azTyG )zf
-~9O*C )zf ?|}G c;$ fC gQ9=LE h|- ~%+zf LhQMy9< gQ|z* ~yh ~$A9<B
Q9AL9p ~%Af9_ #| d9Z8AS:G )p HQsCh c;%yG )p OVC LhQMyG f(wy
E*OJyG O"f )11/13( iQ9=yG KAp Qd!G y#*Q|}G QT*Ch #+@OTq}yG rLC
.)7058( ~sQ
.yX*Qs #| ?}ziC O* )zf )A|C ?wz$z ($h
)yE f(=TA"* #*PyG I9fOyG #| Bo +ty #| {v (fOC B"v xyPyh -:d(sC
o
- )d(s Q+Zty h}T* : f9v fEh iQOs )zf ?"AqyG (zi #| rwqv}( ?+qzTyG
HG(GyG f(w*h Ky9ZyG rzTyG ~%q< ?"TyGh H9AwyG Y9=@G )$ ?+qzTyG BT+yC
- IQ+aLh ?|9$ {F9T| )p ?+qzTyG )yE >TA"* #| rzALG f{p d(szp y)z<z
~%+zf U=v yh - 9%+p V(MyG ~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG Q+jy R(G* : BqzSC 9}vh
fE JGPy9<h ?z}AJ| f(w@ Os rzTyG A9}zgy dG(sz< G(yOASGh ?"AqyG I9fO
9"v hC ~%|;v &+p {+< jPyG hsG(yG aQg! : IQ+Dv 9!k 9+ICh 979s9+S #| BfR!o
o
IQ+aMyG - {F9T}yG gP$ OQ< f(w* HG(ZyG U+yC ~79I;aY9< #+}z| Q+i
k
IGO9g}yGh I:G(}yGh e9wJyG )zf LhQMyGh Q+qwAyG {F9T}v GOF IQ+aMyGh

497

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

h}S 9%g=A* Q|}G )yh ?g+=v ?g+< &=I9Z@ jPyG )f9}GyG {}gyGh O9%GyGh
k
)p :GRyR BCOIC )AyG {F9T}yG gP$ NyG ... ?*QTyG 96 b+;h ?f9_h
gP$ OQ! fC )OtAg! 9}+p gQ+i HG(Y :h( HG(ZyG U+yC - )qzTyG rZyG
{gG! hC ~9O*C #+< eOtA! :h Q=wA! :h - ~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG )yE {F9T}yG
A9}zgyG O%V {< fhQ(%W|h f(phQg| uG {]q< ~$h ~%A!9w| ~8hO #}y
#| fQs {v SCQ )zf uG Eg=*z | d(SQyG d(t< f(+"g}yG ~$ ~8z< uJ<
x
;p ?fO=yG {$C #| f(w* fC OOG}yG GP%y R(G* :h y9%"*O ?|}G gP%y OOG*
k
k
k
fQtyG GP%y OOG| )zf 9!(yOp NyG ... 9*QgVG :h 98FQ| :h 9+FQ9L f(w*
Q+i - )q+qf bGRQyG O=f e9| G Q+i ,!9=y}G e9| G Q+i - R9< #<G e9| G Q+i
fQtyG SCQ )zf G(!9v #*PyG ~8} ~%+zf JQZAsGh )#+}+DgyG #<G e9| G
?"TyG {$C h+=h - uJyG {$C IO9%W< ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C O9tAfG )zf G(p(@h
Q+i hC IQV9=| IO9qASG ~%"| #*O+qAT}yG hC ~7P|;@ #| G(!9v QZgyG GP$ )p
.IQV9=|
k
)p ~%L(SQh ~%A|9|E )zf ;gp hsh Os #w* ~y fE - Y9= G ht* O9w*h
uG )zf ~%+vR! :h xyPv ~%=TJ! - ~$QZf {$C )zf ~%|Ot@h ~zgyG
.{F9T}yG gP$ h+= )p )gOIh uG {]q<h( G(}zw@ Os ~$h
- ~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG fzWv - ?g}AG| ?tqA| {F9T}yG gP$ )p ~%yG(sCh
?|9| G )p ~%ACQh #| A9}zgyG ~%tpGh {< - IOIGh ?yzT| ,p G(qzAM* ~y
#TJ}yG O=f N+WyGh N+WyG dB R*RgyG O=f N+WyGh fGR(qyG Ky9Y N+Wy9v
?}FGOyG ?"Gzyh A9}zgyG Q9=v ?8+%y ih9Ap JQOY {< .~$Q+ih ~$Q+ih O9=gyG
QG9 fC ?+qzTyG )fOv * ~zf >y9ay R(G* r+wp - ~%yG(sC O*|@ 9%"f ?tD="}yG
?]=*hQ {v #| ~*QwyG d(SQyG 9!QPI Osh ?]=*hQyG d(t< PLz*h ~%yG(sC
~G%A* fC OIC {wy R(G* : )AyG( ?|9gyG Q(|C )p ~zwA* &p9AyG {FQyG ($h
)~zgyG )p #+MSGQyG f(8V #| )$ 9}!Eh 9%+zf

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

498

{=s #| ~zgyG ~$9@C 9| Q+M< S9"yG dGR* :z d9s #| bOY xyPyh


K+JY O9"S{< Q=yG O=f #<G gGhQ yG(wz$ ~$Qi9YC {=s #| ~$9@C GP{p ~$Q<9vC
.| d(SQyG d9s xyPyh )1058( O(gT| #<G #f
. y~vQ<9vC h| ?vQ=yGz
. yQi9Y}G O"f ~zgyG U}Az* fC ?f9TyG WGQVC #| fEz d9sh
)1(

)2(

.d(

SQyG #f S9=f #<G #f K+JY O9"S9< 9}$Q+ih ~v9JyGh f9=I #<G &FQLC
.#TI gO9"SGh gQ+ih O9tAf:G d(YC )p )F9wy;yG gGhQ

)1(
)2(

499

? +fQW y

? }v9Jy ?y T| O

.) +

?9

%"|

~zgyG {

$C

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

< ?|Ot}y P Og<


G g

* #+

(|

rs

( d( C

9|

Y ?+zv )p IQY9g}yG >$GP}yGh IO+tgyG P9ASC- {tgyG QY9! /O d(t*


)p e;wyG -?+|;S G O(gS #< O}J| e9| G ?g|9Gy ?g<9AyG V9*Qy9< #*OyG
GP6 rzTyG #f QvP 9%y #w* ~y )AyG ?CO9JyG Q(|}G #| ?+}v9JyG ?yzT|
&@9qYh uG A9}SC )p rzTyG OfG(s )zf ?+]tyG gP$ 9"\Qf GPEh M;aY:G
?z}G}yG X9qy}G )t=@h 9fk QV 9%y {YC : eqzyG GP6 ?+}v9JyG fC OG! &y9gpCh
)}T* fC R(G* : E+I ?+q+s(@ &y9gpCh &@9qYh uG A9}SC fC xyPh ?z}AJ}yG
xyPvh | &y(SQ &< &qYh hC &Tq! &< rYh 9}< :E rY(* hC )y9g@ uG
?+}v9JyG ?yzT| f} KZ* : O+I(AyG e9TsC #| h<GQ ~Ts ?+}v9JyG fz< d(tyG
:f9+"g| 9%y
O+I(@ )yE OQ* GP$h )fQWyG Q|}Gh h*QWAyG )"g| )yE hFGQ :9}%yhC
K J I H G Fo :)y9g@ &y(tv )?f9ayGh JGO9=gyG( ?+%y G
*
) ( '& % o :)y9g@ &y(sh ?*6 ?+C9Gy pL
d( C

]18

G : n

]50

G[

?*6G :IOF9}n yG[

p+

O+I(@ )yE OQ* GP$h uzMyGh QOtyGh A9]tyG ?+}v9I )yE hFGQ :9}%+!9Ch
}8
7 6 { :)y9g@ &y(sh }j ih
g
{ :)y9g@ &y(tv ?+<(<QyG
i(fO )$h 9%y {YC : ?+%y G [F9ZL [LC ?+}v9JyG fC I(fO xyPvh
&@9qYh uG A9}SCh YQWyG X9qyC )yE OQ+p 9Jk +JY )"g| {}; Osh ?COJ|
&+zfh .OQ+p &+zf {+yO : )"g| {}; Osh ?"TyGh H9AwyG )p IOQG(yG
{YCh ?yRAg}yGh ?+}%GyG &COIC 9| {D| 9%zD| ?COJ}yG X9qy}G #| ?+}v9Jy9p
)#*(wAyG(h )~*OtyG(h )O(F(yG >FGh( {D| ?fOA=| X9qyC #| e;wyG
hC {_9=yG hC uJyG )"g}yG {}A; Os )AyG X9qy}G #| 9$(J!h )h!9ZyG(h
?zwW}yG X9qy}G #| f(wAp {_9< )"g|h uI )"g| :)"g* :#++"g| {}A;

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

500

?+}v9JyG ?dqy #f )"jAT!h YQWyG X9qyC )yE OQ@h {=t@ uJyG 9%+!9g}p
)"g* 9%|GRAyG R(G* : X9qy}Gh .g9"g|h &dqz< OQ* {_9=yG )"g}yGh .9$(J!h
9| 9%|GRAyG R(G* : &y9gpCh &@9qYh &F9}S9< {Fh Rf &zy9< uzgA* 9}+p X9qy}G
rs(A* : )AyG ?zwW}yG X9qy}G #| GPE ?+}v9Jy9p ,?"TyGh H9AwyG )p OQ@ ~y
#| #*QY9g}yG O"f 9%|(%q| (zM* :h IO+tgyG 9%+zf e(t@ :h #*OyG 9%+zf
.969"AFG )yh}9p ~$O"f OGQ}yG )"g}yG )p u}gAyGh ha"AyGh ?jy9=}yGh (zjyG
-V9*Qy9<

?g*QWyG ?+zv )p U*QOAyG ?8+$ (]f- f9*QqyG #}IQyG O=f O+y(yG .O -2


:d9s

#+}zT}yG #+< &y OG*h O(F(yG )yE Q%d+y ?+}v9JyG KzaZ| #w* ~y
k
d(YC )p MO9p {%F #| ?|}9< dR! 9| :(y HQW| {v #| #*O*Q|h GQ9Z!C
O+G}@h J9*9fO #| xyP fQ9s 9|h ?+S9s J;]g| #| 96 ~yC 9|h O9tAf:G
?|}G HQI )p AGOf}G {ihC #+Ih ,?CO9JyG J9JzaZ}yG gP$ {D}y
h+= )p &A<Q9J|h ~wJyG #f &A+J"A< GhO9!h O(F(yG )p e;S G uI G(atSzp
Q9! JQgASGh ?z|9WyG ?%FG(}yG xyP KQhC IOG($ fhO< I9+JyG J:9G|
~yh ,I9!}Gh ?}wJyG Q(! zqa!Gh ~%fGQS e(s {v #| fGO+}yG {LOh HQJyG
)zf US|}yG A9"=yGh {}gzy 9fk QA| IQ+Z=yG {$} ?+S9tyG ahQdyG xz@ YO@
I(t< ?I9Ty9< dR"@ fC ?sGQ=yG JGQ9gWyG gP%y M9@C 9}| K+JZyG )fQWyG ~zgyG
k
AGOf}G g(Fh )p &!hQ%W* 9I;S ?+}v9JyG I(fOzy #+}A"}yG ^g< P<Gh
?+!9}zgyG )yE I(fOyG OGOAVG Og< ~%y9}f} 9tk za"|h ~7(fOy 9Sk 9SCh
&!zV f{p {Y}G E+I #| O*OGyG KzaZ}yG GP$ f{p P8"+Ih .?+_GQt}*OyGh
9}<Qh ~+$9q}yG #| ?qzAM| 9!k G(yC 979+_ )p {}; )AyG J9JzaZ}yG ?p9v fzV
?g*QP P<Gh Q|}G U=Ay9p GOk(F(| #w* ~y )"g| )yE 9%]g=y ~%qyG A(S iOC
)p Y(s(yGh &|9wIC #f LhQMyGh YQWyG )zf OQ}AyG #| g9=tf O}; : 9| )yE
:E ($ 9| Q9gWyG GP$ fC uJyGh ,?@(t}}yG ?+fQWyG J9qy9M}yG J;}I
.?|}G rzS &+zf f9v 9}y ?J*QY IP<9"| ?J+JZyG IO+tgzy IQv9| ?}IGR|

501

? +fQW y

:?*O(gTy9< A9}zgyG Q9=v

?S9+Ty

Gh

?8+$

?+}v9Jy

J9<9FE -3

?}F}G #| OIC &< {t* ~y KOJ| {}f GP$


fO"z< ~*QwyG fBQtyG ?+g= U+FQ Q9qjyG O=f #TI >+%Y N+WyG &F(@
- S9"yG ^g< CO< :&+p d9s ?+<QgyG ?wz}}yG )p A9}zgyG Q9=v ?8+$ )yE dG|T<
,?C;DyG O+I(AyG YG(!C )yE ?p9\ 9< ?+}v9JyG O+I(@ QvP< ~A9 -I9fOyG #|
&zgG"p ;{LO* : hC ??C;DyG YG(!}G OIC )p {LO* h<GQyG ~TtyG GP$ {%p
k
Os H9$(yG O=f O}J| N+WyG fE :d9t*h ?&< ~A8 fC >G* )AI ;tAT| 9}k Ts
#| O+I(AyG )p fhQZt* S9"yG iCQ E+I ,&"|R )p ?+$(y}G O+I(A< ~A$G
E+I J9qZyGh A9}S}G O+I(A< ~A$G Os &"|R )p O}IC e9| Gh ?+I9"yG gP$
S9"yG CO=p f6G 9|Ch ,?+I9"yG gP$ #| O+I(AyG )p fhQZt* S9"yG iCQ
GP$ ?JY iO| 9}p ,&< ~A8 fC >G* xyPzp ,?+}v9JyG O+I(@ )p fhQZt*
?d(tyG
:9%y(t<

xyP )zf A9}zgyG Q9=v ?8+$

JOQ

Osh

9}S}G O+I(@h ,?+$(y}G O+I(@h ,?+<(<QyG O+I(@ :?C;C O+I(AyG YG(!C


O+I(@ )p {LO* uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyGh ,h<GQ ~Ts c9"$ U+yh ,J9qZyGh
O+I(@ )p ?zLGO IO9=gyG YG(!C {vh ,u IO9=gyG YG(!C #| &!} ,?+$(y}G
k
~y KOJ| {}f O+I(AyG YG(!C #| ;tAT| 9fk (! ?+}v9JyG {gFh ,?+$(y}G
:#+f(! O+I(AyG {gFh {=C #| ~%"| #wy ,~zg! 9}+p ?}F}G #| OIC &< {t*
,J9qZyGh A9}S}Gh ?+<(<QyG O+I(@ ($h :J9=C Gh ?pQg}yG )p O+I(@
{gGp {Zp #| ~%"|h ,?+$(y}G O+I(@ ($h :OZtyGh >zayG )p O+I(@h
.~zfC uGh ,u=S 9}v YG(!C ?C;C O+I(AyG
&!} cQWyG #f )%"y9< CO=*h ,&g+= ?+$(y}G O+I(A< e9}A$:G >G*h
A9+=!}Gh ,Q9"yG )p OzM| &=I9Yh ,d9}f}G h+= b=J*h ,H(!PyG ~dfC
Y9=@9< uG 9!Q|C Osh ,cQWyG #f )%"yGh uG IO9=g< Q|}9< fhCO=* ~%g+=
A

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

502

9}A$:Gh ,#*OyG Q(|C #| 9$Q+ih I(fOyG )p ~%G%"| )zf Q+TyGh ~%t*Q_


A9}S}G {+ag@h cQWyG f} ,f9|R {v )p >FGh ?C;DyG &fG(!z< O+I(Ay9<
QLB )p 9}$QaL OAW*h 9}%f(sh QDw* {< ,#*O(F(| f(yGR* : J9qZyGh
fhQ+Dv 9}%+yE I9fOyGh ,#+}zT}yG #| Q+Dv )zf 9}$Q|C )qM*h ,f9|RyG
.f(aW!h
k
,H9$(yG O=f #< O}J| N+WyG #|R )zf GQ(Zt| cQWyG Y(sh U+yh
OQh 9}v
O}IC e9| G #|R )zf GQk(Zt| J9qZyGh A9}S}G {+ag@ :h
,e(+yG #+}zT}yG J9g}AG| )p 9}%f(sh QDvh 9}$QaL OGR {< dG|TyG )p
~zgyG h|h ,9}$QaL #+=*h 9}%+p Y(s(yG #f )%"* #| )yE ?S9| ?F9J< ~%p
xyP {v ,&Ag*QV ~+w;h &+$G(! cQ@h uG Q|GhC d9DA|G )p ?|9tAS:G fz<
O}J| 9"+=! )zf uG )zYh ,cQWyG #| ?|;TyGh O+I(AyG u+t; )p {LGO
.~zSh &=JYh &yBh
QvP x+p uG cQ9< 9"M+V :)!9=y}G #*OyG QY9! O}J| N+WyG {8S -4
?+<(<QyGh ?+$(y}G :?C;C YG(!C O+I(AyG fC ~%+zf uG ?}IQ rzTyG A9}zf
O+I(@ ($ 9gk <GQ GOk +I(@ c9"$ fz< d(t! fC KZ* {%p ,J9qZyGh A9}S}Gh
?~wJyG O+I(@ hC ?+}v9JyG
gP6 f(!O!O* #*PyGh ?+$(y}G O+I(@ YhQp #| YQp ?+}v9JyG :H9Fzp
#+}zT}yG ~+zgAy U+y 9Ik ;S fhPMA* Q\9JyG QZgyG )p ?COJ}yG ?}zwyG
#| 9!Ch )S9+S M;S ($ 9}!Eh ,~%zv {SQyGh A9+=!}G &< A9F iPyG O+I(AyG
k
)"| QQw@ dG|S GP$ fC h| 9q!B Bzs 9| ~wy B=CC fC B8V fE GP$ {FC
k
k
.&+p #J! 9| )p 9"+]| B8V fEh &"f GQGQw@h GQGQ| HG(GyG
?}zv d9}gASG fE 9qk !B Bzs 9}y GOk +*z@ ?=S9"}yG gP$ {D| )p Bzs 9!C
?}F9tyG HGRI}G ^g< 96 [AM* )AyG ?+S9+TyG I(fOyG e9}@ #| ($ ?+}v9JyG
#| OGT| )p A9=aMyG OIC #+<h )"+< Bgsh ?Zs ?=S9"}yG gP6 QvPCh e(+yG
e

503

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

{Fh Rf u ?+}v9JyG d(I 9%zv ?=aL >aL ?g}GyG e(* ,uW|O OF9T|
&+yE B|Ot@ ?g}GyG I;Y #| )%A!G 9}y ?+%tp ?yzT| )p f9T! G GP$ zaLC
d9s ?"TyG a;L GP$h GPvh GPv Bzgp B!C )LC 9* &y Bzsh &+zf B}zSh
B!C uG f9J=S :Bzs ,&Azgp 9}< d(t* )q"JyG >$P}yGh )q"I 9!C )y
?<Q9J}y btp ?}zwyG gP$ f(z}gAT@ ~A!zp {Fh Rf u ?+}v9JyG fC B=aL
,?+|;S G ?g*QWy9< f(}wJ* : ~8} Q9qv ~8C e9wJyG #| f("d@ #|
QvPC 9!C f6G B!C GP9}zp ,~zT| {v {}W@ ?+}v9JyG gP$ fC ~wTq!C ~A+T!h
(fO@ 9| Bqy9L B!C GPv )=$P| 9!C d(t@ B!Ch GPv {gp d(SQyG fC xy
.&+yE S9"yG
9"v ,~$O"f ?+S9+TyG ?*9fOzy ?z+Sh ?}zwyG P$ GhP<G ~8C :(y #J"p
.
?*6 rS(* p987
6 o :9"zs
O+I(@ :?+}v9JyG Q+i 9%+ph ?+}v9JyG 9%+p 9%+yE S9"yG (fO! )AyG I(fOy9p
9| 9!QW! #*PyG #J!h &y(I f(!O!O@ 9| 9%+p {LO* ,IO9=gyG O+I(@h ?+$(y}G
)="yG fC f9}+yG #< ?q*PI E*OI :?+}v9JyG d(I f(!O!O@ 9}"+I &!hQvP@
{ ?*6G gP$ eGQwyG ?<9JZyG )zf ;@ 9}y |
9| uG d(SQ 9* uGh :)F9ayG ~@9I #< iOf d9s }
k
k
g(}A|QI :;I ~wy G(|QI GPE ~A"v ~ATyC :d9s ,uG fhO #| 9<9<QC ~$9!P<G
~vP9<G cGPpz :d9s ,f9v Otp GP$ 9|C d9s yg(}AzzI 9|k GQI ~wy (zzI GPEh
)yE GP$ {Yhh E*OJyG GP$ 9!QW! #*PyG #J! yuG fhO #| 9<k 9<QC ~$9*E
YOA=}yG fG("gyG GP6 IO9=gyG hC ?+$(y}G O+I(@ #| GAkRF GhQ(_ ~C #*QL6G
k
gO"f G(qsh ~8C :(y GP%v M;aYG )p 98+V iQC : 9!zp ,)S9+S VQjy
]65

G :

%$#

)('&

)1 (

Q+Tq@ )p Q*QF #<Gh )178U5L( &""S )p iP|QAyG &FQLC .#TI E*OI


Q+=wyG N*Q9AyG )p iQ9M=yGh )116U10L( iQ=wyG #"TyG )p )t%+=yGh )354U10L(
.#TI O9"S{< )106U7L(

)1(

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

504

9=gyG O+I(@ #| ARF 9qk !B JQvP 9}v ($h ,g9]At}< G(z}g* ~yh ?*9fO
9"AZs )p 9qk !G 9!QvP 9}v- {+s GPEh ,~$OI} uq@G 9| r+v uG fhO=g* ~$GQAp
I;ZyG &+zf d(SQyG d(s a;L GP$ ,?"TyG a;L {}g* GP$ ->+aMyG h|
Q9qwyG O\ btp BT+y u ?+}v9JyG ,GPv )=$P| 9!C :d9s ,e;TyGh
k
uG #f A9F 9| a;M< uG fhO=gA* #*PyG 9]*C ,#*OAg}yG O\h #+vQW}yGh
)p )!Q]J* 9| GP$ ,&A"S )p e;TyGh I;ZyG &+zf &+=! #fh &<9Av )p
.dG|TyG GP$ {D| #f HG(GyG
~Ts U+FQ- iQ9qtyG uG O=f #< QY9! Q(AvOyG N+WyG ?z+]p d9s -5
Oty :-~+Zty9< #*OyG d(YCh ?g*QWyG ?+zw< IQY9g}yG >$GP}yGh IO+tgyG
k
;}%| 9"k vQh O+I(AyG e9TsC #| 9+k T"| 9}k Ts c9"$ fE d(t* #| 9!QZf )p A9F
,?+}v9JyG O+I(@ ($h :C ~79q"Z| )p ghQQt* ~yh rzTyG &+zf rt* ~y
GP%p ?gOIh ~v9JyG ($ uG fC O*Q@C ,?+}v9JyG O+I(A< O*Q@ GP9| ~%y d(t"p
?*6 9g!} pxw v u
o )y9g@ d9s ?+<(<QyG O+I(@ #+|9]| #|
pU T So :)y9g@ d9s J9qZyGh A9}S}G O+I(@ #+|9]| #|h
~wI )zf dO@ ~wI IO9|h )~+wJyG( uG A9}SC #| f{p ?*6 ~*QJAy
f(w* )!9DyG )zfh ~v9JyG )"g}< ~+wJyG f(w* dh}G )zgp ,e9wICh
uG fCh u ~wJyG fC )zf dO* ~+wJyG uG ~S9p ,~wJ}yG )"g}< ~+wJyG
.~+wJy9< a(Y(|
#| GP%p &fQV )yE e9wAI:9< &tzL O=g@ )y9g@h &!9J=S uG fC OGQC fE 9|C
/ . - o :)y9g@ d9s ,J9qZyG O+I(@ hC ?+$(y}G O+I(@ J9+]At|
IO

]57

G :e

G[

]2

.
:)z*

]23

?*6G

:AG

Qn S

G[

9| xyP A(\ )zf QQt!

G :

r q

G[

p2 10

fC

#w}* 9"$ #|h

O| Q+ih O+I(AyG YG(!z< {$9F ?y9t}yG gP$ >I9Y fC ::hC


.9%tF9tIh 9%}+$9q}y

cQ

505

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

)p GhQZs Os 9%A}FCh ?|}G rzS fC ?y9t}yG gP$ J9+]At| #| fC :9+k !9C


~zp ,>FGh QLBh >FGh dhCh >FGh ~dfC &!C h| &fG(!Ch O+I(AyG f9+<
)AI d9+F}G h<9A@h fhQtyG )yG(@ )zf S9"zy g("+=* ~yh ~TtyG GP$ GhQvP*
.S9"zy &"+=p ?y9t}yG gP$ >I9Y A9F
k
Y9= Gh ?"TyGh H9AwyG xyP )zf dO 9}v Y9=@:Gh )SzAyG IQhQ\ :9Dy9C
e9| G ?"TyG {$C e9|E d9s xyPyh YGOA<:Gh KGOI G #f Og=yG IQhQ\h
.ye9|E &+p xy U+y 9| {t@ :h {t* ~y 9| {t@ :z O}IC
: )"g| ($ &zgFh QvPy9< gOGQpEh ?+}v9JyG O+I(A< e9}A$:G fE :9gk <GQ
)AyG bQqyG ^g< iOy ahQg| H%"| ($ uG :E ~v9I : )"g}< uG :E &yE
fC :E ,O+I(AyG )p ?*9jyG ?zZJ| {|9wyG e9}A$:G ?+<(<QyG O+I(@ )y(@
x8yhCh ?+}v9JyG ($h ?+<(<QyG O+I(@ YG(!C #| OIGh Y("< G(}A$G A:|$
O+I(AyG )p ?*9jyG &zgF )p raM| 9}$;vh 9gk += ?+<(<QyG O+I(A< G(}A$G
.IO9=gyG O+I(@ d9qiEh
~%y9qiEh ?+}v9JyG O+I(A< ^g=yG e9}A$G Q+=wyG zaMyG #| :9Tk |9L
~%+zf {SQyG I(fO dhCh rzw}yG )zf >FGh dhC ($ iPyG IO9=gyG O+I(Ay

;TyGh I;ZyG
k
g(COIC #*PyG x8yhC O"f b=@Q| ?+}v9JyG O+I(@ fC >TIC :9SO9S
k
: )?|9| G( ?yzT}< ~%]g< O"f hC O+I(AyG e9TsC #| ;tAT| 9gk <GQ 9}k Ts
.O+I(AyG ?yzT}<
Q(J|h ~%|9}A$G ?*9ih ~%y(YC #| dh}G {Y}G ($ ?|9| G Q|C iQAp
fC xyP ,9%z$Ch ?"TyG #f )="FC xzT| ($h ,i(fOyG ~%S(|9s )p &+F(AyG
dGRAf:G {$Ch ,~%"*O )p dh}G {Y}G )?|9| G( f(zgG* #*PyG ~$ ?]pGQyG
.~%=$P}y U|9MyG {Y}G g(zgF ?f9}GyG G(yRAfG #*PyG
.e

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

506

MyG 9%y9s Otp {_9< )"g| 96 O*Q*h {F9s ?y9t}yG gP$ d(t* Os :9gk <9S
.)fQWyG e9| G )zf LhQMyG 96 GhOGQCh {=s #|
r*QJAyG O* 9%Ayh9"@ Os O+I(AyG YG(!Ch O+I(AyG ?t+tI fC :9"k |9C
.U+=zAyGh
k
hC ?+Zg| hC uTp hC ?fO< &!z< Q|C )zf ~wJyG fC aQg! fC O<: :9gS9@
h!G(}yG A9qA!Gh WhQWyG e9+s Og< :E xyP< &=I9Y )zf ~wJyG )"g* : Qqv
.?"TyG {$C ?}FC O"f QQt| ($ 9}v
uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG 9$O\ G(zgF ?+}v9JyG O+I(@ ?yzT| fC :GQk V9f
k
#|h Q=vC 9vQV #+vQW}yG #| ghOfh uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~v9JyG b;_{< GhQqvh
.>@GQ| )zf uG dR!C 9| Q+j< ~wJyG fC e(zg}yG
iQ=wyG ?}wJ}y9< )\9tyG- iQ+]MyG Ky9Y #< ~+$GQ<E .O -6
k
~fR* 9}v O+I(AyG d(YC #| 9gk <GQ ;YC ?+}v9JyG BT+y :d9s -V9*Qy9<
~$h ?+}v9JyG #f f(COJA* S9"yG #| GQk +Dv fC &y rS|* 9}|h S9"yG ^g<
#Jy #| aQg@ : ?+}v9Jy9< fhO9"* #*PyG #| Q+Dvh )"g@ GP9| f(}zg* :
9!k 9+Izp ?+}v9JyG KzaZ| &+zf PLz@ 9Ak <9C CO=| f(w* fC #w}* 98k +V ~%y(s
9}< ~wJyG fC iQ*h uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG ?+]s )p ?+}v9JyG #f ~zwA| ~zwA*
Q+j< ~wJyG fCh &+zf uqA| A)V GP$h VhQq}yG ($ )y9g@h &!9J=S uG dR!C
G(zZp A9}zgyG f} zaL GP$h iO9tAfG Qqv gQ(Yh &!G(yC {w< Qqv uG dR!C 9|
#| LQL #| g(zgG* ~yh eGQI &!C OtAg* ($h uG dR!C 9| Q+i )p ~wI #}+p
fC iQ* #| c9"$h ,GP$ 9""|R )p #+}zT}yG #| Q+Dv &< )zA<G 9}| GP$h ?z}yG
98C )zf ?+}v9JyG #f KOJA* #| c9"$h O(F(yG IOI(< ?s;f 9%y ?+}v9JyG
#| c9"$h O*Q* 9| :E ht* : &!Ch -)y9g@h &!9J=S uG IOGQE 98C iC- IOGQ G
)p zW! O*OF KzaZ| ?+}v9JyG fC GP$ #| {Y9Jy9p xyPh GP$ #+< bzM*
#f ~zwA* #}| Q+Dvh ,?+<QgyG O;=yG )yE 9%"| QWA!G ~C zW! 9| dhC QZ|
.K\Gh )"g| Q+j<h e(%q| Q+j<h )fh Q+j< ~zwA* ?+}v9JyG
LQG(

507

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

P$h 9*9]tyG ~$C #| ?+]s )%p uG dR!C 9}< ~wJyG #f ~zwA* #| 9|C
#| {YC GP$ )y9g@ uG IOGQE #f ~zwA* #|h ,J9=FG(yG ~dfC #| >FGh
&!9J=S &!Ch A9W* 9| )zf uG A9V 9| :E ht* : &!C ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C d(YC
.O*Q* 9| ~wJ*h A9W* 9| {gq* &!Ch Q*Os A)V {v )zf
:d(t* fC ($h O(F(yG IOI(< ?s;f 9%y ?+}v9JyG fC iQ* #| :?+]s 9|C
Os eGO9}p &< uG ~wI Os eQG}yG #| hsh iPyG eQGyG GP$ hC {gqyG GP$ fE
.f(+y(zJyG &< d(t* bzi GP%p uG )yEh uG #| (%p &< uG ~wI
P9AS}Gh A9}zgyG Q9=v ?8+$ (]f- #+}+DgyG Ky9Y #< O}J| N+WyG -7
gP$ #f {8S -?*O(gTy9< ~+ZtyG ?ta"}< #*OyG d(YCh ?g*QWyG ?+zw<
)}T| B; O+I(Azy 9gk <GQ 9}k Ts c9"$ fC )fO* #| fz< :H9Fzp ?yzT}yG
#| &tq* : {$9F #| QO9Y YOA=| ~+Tt@ GP%p ,9fk OA=| Og* )?+}v9JyG O+I(@(
k
.98+V #*OyGh IO+tgyG Q|C
9}< ~wJ* uG fC ?%F #| ?+<(<QyG O+I(@ )p {LO@ ?+}v9JyG f} xyPh
.A9V
U+y (%p ~wI 9}< uG O=gA* fC &+zf O=gyG fC ?+$(y}G O+I(@ )p {LO@h
k
,?+$(y}G O+I(@h ,?+<(<QyG O+I(@ :)$h ?C;DyG O+I(AyG YG(!C #f 9FQ9L
.J9qZyGh A9}S}G O+I(@h
k
:;F9s H9FC ~%+zf OQyG ?+q+v #f {8S 9|O"fh
G(y(t* fC :E 9$9"g| U+y ??+}v9JyG )"g| 9| :~%y d(t! fz< ~%+zf OQ!
.?+<(<QyG O+I(@ GP$h u :E ~wJyG fE
.Q<O}yG xy9}yG uy9MyG HQyG ($ u9p
~$OZsh ~79+! ~zg! : 9"!{p MQayG GP$ IQ(aL f9+<h ~$OGQ| #f 9|C
.Q|}G GP$ IQ(aL Q*Ot@ 9""w}* : )y9Ay9<h
G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

508

?g|9G< 9+zgyG J9SGQOy9< P9AS}G- f:OTyG ~!9i #< Ky9Y N+WyG -8


k
:a9\Ch ?C;DyG O+I(AyG e9Tsz< 9!9+< eOs -?+|;S G O(gS #< O}J| e9| G
u ~wJyG :)"g| 9|h ?9$9"g| 9|h ?+}v9JyG ?+]s )yE O(g! f9+=yG GP$ Og<
YG(!C #| Y(! iz< .uG :E ~v9I : :~v9I ?}zvh ?uG :E ~v9I : hC
gOIh ~wJ* iPyG ($ u9p aQZ@ ($ YQWyGh ~wJyG fE ?9%tJz! O+I(AyG
($ &!C 9}v ?+%y G )p &y x*QV :h &y G ($ &!C 9}v ~wJyG )p &y x*QV :h
So )y9g@ d9s 9}v f(wyG GP$ )p aQZAyG )p &y x*QV :h aQZA}yG
u ~wJy9p
?*6 Q}f pZ Y X
W V UT
: &!C ($h {tAT| 9$9"g| ?+%y 9p ?+%y G )"g}< ?+}v9JyG QTq@ fC R(G* :h
9gk <GQ 9}k Ts ?+}v9JyG {gF fC #+=A* GP6h .uG :E &yE :h uG :E uJ< O(=g|
d9D| GP$h ~wJyGh aQZAyG )$ ?+}v9JyG f{p zaL GP$ fC O+I(AyG e9TsC #|
9}y QOt| :h uG :E bRGQ :h uG :E uy9L : :d(t@ 9}wp ?+<(<QyG ?zD|C #|
: :d(t@ ,uG :E f(wyG GP$ )p aQZA| :h uG :E f(wyG GP$ )p {ZJ*
: )"g}< uG :E &yE : :d(t@ fC 9|C ,GPw$ ,uG :E YQW| :h uG :E ~v9I
aQJ"| Q+Tq@ GP%p uG :E QOt| : hC uG :E aQZA| : hC uG :E ~v9I
O+I(@ :IO9=gyG O+I(@ Q9w!E )"g* xyP f{p &zF9s g9"g| OtAfG fE Q+Tq@h
uG uzL &zFC #| {< >AwyG dR!Ch {SQyG uG {SQC &zFC #| iPyG ?+$(y}G
p!@
!z{ (
'& % $ # o :;fh {F d9s 9}v uzMyG
uG :E &yE : )"g| fC OtAg! fC dG(I}G #| d9J< R(G* ;p
? *6
9* P y
bzTA}y9< &y G QTp uG :E &yE : QTp #| c9"$ f{p uG :E ~v9I : &!C
&!9J=S uG :E uJ< O(=g| : iC uG :E &yE : &!{p zaL GP$h aQZA}yG
:h )+J* :h bRQ* :h uzM* : xyPv &!{p ($ :E O(=g| : &!C 9}wp )y9g@h
{v )zf ($h eOgyG #| gOFhCh f(wyG GP$ uzL iPyG ($h ,($ :E B+}*
..~+zf A,V {w< ($h Q+=MyG r+azyG ($h ~+IQyG #}IQyG ($h Q*Os A)V
]83

G :fG

p dB[

]56

n
G :J QG

G[

509

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

9|Eh {$9F 9|E GP%p O+I(AyG e9TsC #| 9gk <GQ 9}k Ts ?+}v9JyG {gF #|h NyG
:h IO+tgy9< ~%y ~zf : #*PyG AGQBh ?qS;qyG AGQB #| AGQC PLC YOA=|
hC e9TsC ?C;C O+I(Ay9p .{t"* GP9| aQg* :h {t"* f9T!E &!C hC ?g*QWy9<
:Bzs 9}v ?+<(<QyG O+I(@ ,p ?zLGO ?+}v9JyGh ,9%y h<GQ :h ,btp f9}Ts
.uG :E ~v9I : :d(t@ ,uG :E bRGQ :h uy9L : :d(t@ 9}v
#| dhC f{p )u :E ~wI :( :GP$ KOI 9| dhC f{p u ~wJyG fC 9|C
>y9_ ,<C #< ,zf )zf G(FQL #*PyG LQG(MyG ~$ ?y(t}yG gP$ d9s
,p U9gyG #< hQ}fh iQgV}G )S(| (<C ~wI E+I -~+wJAyG ?+]s Og<
uG :E ~v9I :( :G(y9sh )zf X+F #| ?sQp LQMp ?phQg}yG ~+wJAyG ?+]s
bOY Otp ~g!h ){_9< 96 O*QC uI ?}zv( :)zf d9tp )uG :E ~v9I :
gP$ Og< JQF )AyG #AqyG ~dfC 9}p {_9< 96 O*QC uI ?}zv 98E
uG :E ~v9I : &!z< d(ty9p ?xyP Og< BwqS )AyG A9|OyG QDvC 9|h ?y(t}yG
GP$ f{p 979t+=a@ )p (zi f9v hC 9$9"g| Q+i 96 O*QC GPE #wy K+JY GP$
~wIC fCh{ )y9g@h &!9J=S &y(s d(yO}yh ,iO%yGh uJzy 9=k !9G| f(w*
'
& % $ # " o )y9g@h &!9J=S &y(sh }uG dR!C 9}< ~%"+<
co uG #| 9}k wI #TIC ;p ?*6 O 9}y p@
! ! zu + *
)(

wvuts
]50

x
?*6G :A9T"yG[ p

G :I F

]87

G[

x
?*6G :A9T"yG[ p

g
f
ed

9=f #+< e9wI}G #| &fQV 9| ($h )y9g@h &!9J=S u ~wJyG GP%p


#+< G(}wJ* fz< ~$Q|Ch | O}J| ?y9SQ< ~%}ALh &zSQh gA9+=!C {SQzp
? *6 O 9 } y p H G
F
ED o d9s 9}v ~%y YQV 9}< O9=gyG
f
edc b
a `_
o d9tp | O}J| ?y9SQ< xyP ~AL ~C
QF9S )zfh QZ| {v )ph QZf {v )p A9}zgyGh ?*6 O 9}y pg
f(zZq*h e;S G ?g*QW< f(}wJ* ?g*QWyG A9}zf f9|R}G Q| )zfh Q9Zf}G
uG H9Av A(\ )zf J9fR9"}yG )p f(zZq*h b(tJyG fhOQ*h e(ZMyG #+<
fhPq"}yG ~$ A9}zgyGh ,~v9JyG ($ )y9g@h &!9J=S u9p | &y(SQ ?"Sh
gO

]48

G :I F

]122

G[

]49

G :I F

G[

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

510

:E ~v9I :( &< OGQ* fC 9|Ch e9wI}G gO"F )p ;fh {F uG #f f(gs(}yG


dR* ?yR {v )zf VQAg*h 9%==T< A9|OyG d9T@h e9wJyG )zf 96 LQM+p )uG
.?*6G )"g| ($ U+y GP%p ~$Qd! )p zaL {v hC e9wJyG 96
?f9ayG #f G(FQLh G(tW!Gh
)zf )zf LQG(MyG VQAfG 9}vh
~%z@9tp )s9=yG )t<h ~%"| Q+=v ARF hFQh ~$9fOp S9=f #<G ~%+yE {SQCh
)zf G(}wIh .uG :E ~v9I : :?GJ< 9+zf GhQqv ~8} ~$O9<Ch
)zf
~C JQqv x!z< aQAgAp e;S G #*O #| BFQL B!C :G(y9sh Qp9v &!z< )zf
OS9qyG )"g}yG GP6 ?}zwyG gP$ #| uza!G GPw%p xg*9=! xyP Og< ~C H(A@
uJyG d(ty 9gk += 9"tp(* fC uG dzT! ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C IO+tf #f O+g=yG
.&< {}gyGh

511

? +fQW y

aQaAyGh

(zjyG

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

Q 9C C

PJ! iPyG H%"}yG IQ(aL ~zgAy )D*OI &< ~ALC 9| Q9tyG )LC OFC :
{F9]p xyPv ~zg@h 9!A9}zf d9s 9}v O9=gyGh O;=yG )zf ?8+TyG gQ9CBh &"|
?"TyG Q9Z!C ?f9= N(+V &G%A!G iPyG O+VQyG )qzTyG H%"}yG ?}dfh
f(MSGQyG 9%y gO}I iPyGh e9wJyG h| {|9gAyG )p - 97zW! P"| - ?*O}J}yG
)D*OI &< ~ALC 9| OFC : d(sC - AG($}Gh YO=yG {$C &y X9AiGh A9}zgyG #|
iPyG K*QZyG QGyG QG(JyG GP$ :E ?f9}GyGh ?"Tzy xf9=@G )zf uG O}JAy
^g< )zf #+}+DgyG Ky9Y #< O}J| )qzTyG &+tqyG ?|;gyG &+p H9FC
N}G gQW! iPyGh )v$ 1420 ?GJyG iP #| 17( e(* QFGRGyG #| #+zF9TyG
)j="* iPyGh U+q"yG &<9Av )p iQFGRGyG )!9]|QyG xy9}yG O=f N+WyG {\9qyG
)p A9|O #| QO$C 9}+p Q<9v}G A9}zgyG ih9Ap( &+zf hza* fC ~zf >y9_ {wy
?v+vfQvWvyG J9vtv+v=vavAvyG #v+v< ?vS9v+vTvyG )vp Qvdv"vyG cQGOv|( &v}v+vTvsh )QvFGRvGvyG
- #v *Qv Y9v gv }v yG LQG(v Mv yG ?v tv +v tv I )v zv f rv tv Av y )?v +v S9v }v Jv yG J:9v gv qv !:Gh
u+tWA< #+FQ9MyGh f9"=yGh ~zty9< #+FQ9MyGh f9"TyGh r+Ty9< #+FQ9MyG
.&y(SQh uG gR+G* : 9}+p f9TzyG ?y9_Eh e;wyG
Q

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

#+}+Df #<G

512

N WyG h|

#+*QFGRGyG

A9ty

? GJy
|
x8yh} ~w%+F(@h ~wAJ+Z! ,$ 9| -uG xdqI- N+WyG ?z+]p :{F9TyG
x
,#+}zT}yG IQ+dI )yE G(gFQh ,M;TyG G(tyCh G(<9@ ~C ,~6 QQi #*PyG
^g< fhOG* Osh ,S9"yG h| f(W+g*h ,~$OF9T| )p f(zZ* f6G- ~$h
~%Az|9g| )p S9"zy ~wAJ+Z! ,$ 9}p ,Q+jyG aQ_ #| LGQI G hC LQJyG
?f(z=tAT* r+vh ?~%Az|9g| )p S9"yG f(z|9g* r+v ?~%y ~wAJ+Z!h ,~%y
.GQk +L uG ~vGRF ?~%+yE ?=T"y9< O*OGyG (GyG GP$ ,p f(W+g* r+vh
~%+zf uG #q | #*PyG fG(L5y ,AJ+Z! ,#+}y9gyG HQ u O}JyG :N+WyG
-{Fh Rf- uG GhQwW* fC :~$Q9*Oh ~8O| )yE G(gFQh ,M;TyG A9ty{<
#+*QFGRGyG )zfh ~%+zf uG #| ?}g! gP$ f} ,A,V {v {=s ?}g"yG gP$ )zf
.#*QL6G
98(]J}* ,?t<9TyG ~$Q9wpC ,p G(W+g* :Ch ,u=S 9| G(T"* fC :9+k !9C
k
k
P(fC :G(y(t+zp ,9$hQvP@ GPE )AI ,9$hQvPA* :h ,~$Q9wpC #| 9|9@ 9]J|
.~+FQyG f9a+WyG #| u9<
~$h G(V9f GPE ~8} ,98k +V G(zgq* ~y ~8zvh S9"yG h| G(W+g* fC :9Dk y9C
Q]* GP$h ,~%"| Og<h S9"yG #| IQq! ,p G(t< G(zgp 9| G(zgp ~8z< fhQgW*
v$ 1420

G iP #

17 e(*

?|9gyG ?JzZ}y9<
9%p ,~%|9wJy rzTyG ?z|9g| )zfh ,?"TyGh H9AwyG ~zf )zf G(z=t* fC :9gk <GQ
jPyG ($h !#+"||}yG Q+|C 9* :f(|z}zy d(t* ?"TyG {$C e9|E
{="I #< O}IC ($
#}y &A=_9M| ,p ?+}+@ #<G e;S G N+V xyPvh ,fBQtyG uzM< d(tyG ,p gGPB
X W
V UT { :fhQ9$h )S(}y uG d9s ,9"k +y 9k <9aL O: ,&T=I
.

.[44-43 :&_] }

L`_
^]
\[
Z
YK

513

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

QW"| QOYh uz_ &F(< A:|$ G(tzA* fC :#*QL7y ?=T"y9< :9Tk |9L
,p 9Sk (=f hC ?+$GQv hC A9qF ~$hQ* :Ch ,~$(|Qw* fCh ,~6 G(IQq* fCh
,M;TyG h\h {=s d9Jy9v U+y M;TyG h\h Og< d9JyG f} ,~%$(Fh
.iQF 9| {v G(S9"A* fCh
k
k
,G(<Q9tA*h G(qy5A* fC )zf S9"yG f(DJ* -9]*C- I9fOzy ?=T"y9< :9SO9S
.O*OF #| I9+JyG CO=@h ,u=S 9| G(S9"A*h ,i(tAyGh Q=yG )zf G(!h9gA*h
A9tyEh HG(ZyG )yE ~%"| Q+DwyG Y(FQ #f -u O}JyGh - g9"g}S 9| 9|C
GP$ 9!QS Otp ,?yhOyG {=s #| e9gyG (qgyG #f xyPv 9"g}S 9|h ,M;TyG
,,s9=yG ,p ~}A* fC -{Fh Rf- uG (FQ! ,#+}y9gyG HQ u O}JyGh ,GQk +Dv
.?yzT}yG ,p ,*CQ GP$
- ?|(wJyG :)"g* ,d9=GyG ,p B+t< ,AyG ?+s9=yG ?+t=yG !N+V 9* :{F9TyG
)zf d9=GyG ,p G(t< ~%"| Q+DwyGh (qgyG BafC - N+V 9* f6G Bzs 9}v
.?|(wJzy f9|}G f(ag* : ~8C S9SC
?98("|z* : :N+WyG
,iPz< ~%=+Z@ #y 98C JOfh ?|(wJyG #wy ,98("|z* : !jC :{F9TyG
?98("|z* : :N+WyG
,iPz< ~%=+Z@ #y 98C JOfh ?|(wJyG #wy ,98("|z* : !jC :{F9TyG
v
:d(t@ btp ,$h ,iPz< ~%=Z@ ~y :,"g* ,G(yR! #*PyG ,p GP$ JPq! Osh
q
:d(t*h OOQA* ~%"| Q+Dwy9p ,?+g+=ayG ~w@9+I )yE GhO(fh ,M;TyG G(}zS
.UzG! 9|Eh dR"! 9|E )AI ,9"M*9W| #| i(Ap )yE L9AJ!
R9< #<G N+WyG i(Ap Bg*PC 9|Og< ?Y9L -u O}JyGh- dR! ~%]g<h
^g=yGh ,Q|}G GP$ RG(F eOg< )!9=y}G N+WyG i(Aph ,R9qzAyG ,p
k
?GP$ ,p f(y(t@ GP9}p ,Q|}G GP$ ,p 9v9V dGR :
,M

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

514

9| {wp :Eh ,e;TyG A9tyEh M;TyG h\h ~%+zf >G* &!C iQ! :N+WyG
&"f f(y(8T| ~8{p ,A9T! H9ZAiGh dG(|C >8h {As #| ~%F9t< )zf >@QA*
-u O}JyGh- 9"g}S Osh ,Y(FQyG ~%+zf >FG(yGh ,-{Fh Rf- uG e9|C
.>FG(yG ($ GP$h ,hFQ ~%"| Q+DwyG fC
)zf M;TyG )tyC #| QwW!h ,e9gyG (qgyG )zf ?yhOyG QwW! #J!h
.&A<9GASG
v
k
.?+g+=ayG ~79+I )yE G(gFQ+yh ,GO<C GP$ ,p f(wwWA* :h
,p ?z*(_ IO| G(]s Osh ,G(gFQh G(_Q(@ #*PyG [M* 9}+p :{F9TyG
)yE GhO(g* )AI ~$O9VQEh ~%}+zgAy {=TyG hq!C ,$ 9}p ,d9=GyGh ?*Oh}G
)p IO*O| IO| ~%"| {FQ )]t* fC {%TyG #| U+y &!} ,?+g+=ayG ~79+I
~$O9VQEh ~%}+zgAy {=TyG hq!C ,$ 9}p !?A,V #w* ~y fzv O(g* ~C d9=GyG
?~%%+F(@h
~%}+zgAy SQGO| ~%y zWn "r +p ,h}AG}yGh ?|(wJyG )yE hFQ* GP$ :N+WyG
.~%y9I >TI
hC A9T"yG ^g< fC ($ :?"AqyG gP$ ,p KOI iPyG O9TqyG #| :{F9TyG
H9ZAi;y #\Qg@ J9+AqyG
!d9=GyG fhOgZ* #*PyG A:|$ aQ_ #|
!?+p9gyG uG dzT! :N+WyG
,p V9%F G RG(G< i(Ap QOYC ~%]g<h ,{|G(I #%"| Q+Dwp :{F9TyG
gP$ ,p #gsh f6Gh ,#=ZAiG J9+AqyG A:|$ fC ... ?y9JyG gP$ {D|
)1(

9T!

Qf}Gh A9|OyG ~%y BzI Osh !#*O$9G| G(T+yC )1(


!!?9*9=S #+}zT}yG
.&zy9< :E I(s :h d(I :h ?*h9%yG )yE &"| QPJ! iPyG Q+qwAyG iO|* r+v ~A*CQC
fh

PMA* : GP9}zp dG(|}Gh

VG

515

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

T* #%"| Q+Dwp ,?zwW}yG


kz=* ~y 9| ,K+JY {}JyG V9%F{< J9=ZAj}yG A:|$ #$D9ApE :N+WyG
#w}* :h ,MhQyG &+p BMq! Q%VC ?g<QC kz< GP{p ,Q%VC ?g<QC {}JyG
.&F9t<E #| )yhC &_9tS{p ,xyP {=s 9|C ,&_9tSG
e9*C 9$(=zSh 9$(=ZAiG Os dG(|C ~9O*C ,p ,t< G(<9@ #*PyG #| :{F9TyG
o
?969JYC {%F Osh G(<9@ 9| Og< dG(|}G gP$ ~wI ,?"AqyG
,~%+zf eGQI 98C xV : #+"_G(}yG #| 9$(=%A!G ,AyG dG(|}G :N+WyG
)yE 9$hOQ* fC ~%+zgp ,&\Qfh &y9|h &|O eGQI ~zT}yGh ,~zT| #_G(}y9p
fC 9|{p #w}* ~y f{p ,G(@9| Os G(!9v fE ~%ACQh )yE hC ,~$(}zf fE 969JYC
o
.969JYC #f 96 bOZA* fC 9|Eh ,d9}yG B+< ,p {g:
.d9}yG B+< )yE 9%f9FQE #w}* : &!} ,QT+A}yG GP$ &zgy :{F9TyG
.-{Fh Rf- ~6 ~zg* uGh ,969JYC #f 96 bOZA* :N+WyG
#| G(gz_ #*PyG H9=WyG f6G !N+V 9* jQFGRGyG ~v9Jzy ?=T"y9< :{F9TyG
f(GTyG #| G(gz_ fEh )AI ,#LOyG ^g< ~%+p dGR: ~$QDvC f(GTyG
~v9JyG Q+qw@ ?yzT|h ,Q+qwAyG ?yzT| ,p f(}zwA* G(yGR: #wy ,~%"f )qfo h
:h ,&y ?g+< :h ,Qp9v ~v9I QFGRGyG ,p jPyG ~v9JyG GP$ fCh ,#+gy9<
f(zgG*h ,~8hQqw* ~8} ,Qw"| ,p :h ahQg| ,p : ?f9_ :h h}S
.Qqv VQC :)"g* ,VQC -N+V 9*- QFGRGyG
?Qqv QGO :N+WyG
,AyG #+!G(tyG fE :f(y(t* ~8} ,N+V 9* ~g! ,Qqv QGO ,jE :{F9TyG
k
A:|%y :hC ~wAJ+Z! 9}p ,?+|;SE #+!G(t< BT+y ,?+<Qi #+!G(s 9%+p
Q}Ag* ,@z* &!z< -N+V 9*- 9}k zf ,?g+< jQFGRGyG ~v9Jzy {$h ?H9=WyG
?e;S G QF9gV Q%d*h
?dz

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

516

zZ* : hC ,zZ* :N+WyG


?N+V 9* ,zZ* :{F9TyG
.~zT| ($ fPE :N+WyG
,p 9"$ f9v ,Q%V hC 9|k (* #*QWf ,yG(I #| 9"$ Q}AfGh )@Ch :{F9TyG
.?wz}}yG
{8S 9}y GP%yh ,gQ+qw@ R(G* :h ,~zT| (%p ,,zZ* eGO9| :N+WyG
LhQMyG R(G* ;p ,yG(zY 9| ,:z :d9s e9wJyG )zf LhQMyG #f | )="yG
?yzT}yG O(g@ fC O*Q* gQ+qwA< GP%p ,gQqv #| ,gQ+qw@ R(G* :h ,&+zf
k
.,fQV ~v9I ($h ,?g+< &zp ,9fPF
d(=s f} ,9%+p jPyG uJyG d(=s >G* #+!G(ty9p ,#+!G(tyG Y(\(| 9|C
Rf uG d9s Otp ,S9"yG QqvC 96 A9F (y )AI ,f9T!E {v )zf >FGh uJyG
- uG d9tp .}7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / .{ :{Fh
3 2{ :~%y(s #f BwSh .}= < ; : 9 8{ :-)y9g@
GP%p ,#+vQW}yG #| uJyG ?}zv {=s -)y9g@- f9v GP{p ,uI 98} ,}4
9}y f9a+WyG ?Zs ,p xyPvh ,OIGh {v #| {=t@ uJyG ?}zv fC )zf {+yO
:h ep9I uG #| x+zf dR* ~y ,SQwyG ?*B JCQs GPE x!E :IQ*Q$ ,<} d9s
jPyG jO(%+yG xyPvh ,| )="yG xyP {=s ,K=Z@ )AI f9a+WyG x<Qt*
)zf #+\Q}Gh ,h=YE )zf JGh9}TyG {gF uG fC IGQ(AyG ,p OG! 9!E :d9s
,gPFG(! hC &<9+!C JO< )AI | )="yG xJ]p -E*OJyG QvPh- h=YE
SR
Q P O NML
Ko :CQsh ,&y(ty 9tk *OZ@
?,

]67

?*6G :Q|n Rw yG[

pW

OtgyGh {JyG {$C Y9}AF9< &z*Og@ #w}* GP%p ,zaL #| &+p 9| 9|Ch
9| {=t*h ,uJyG ry9L 9| ^pQ+p ,#+!G(tyG ?SGQOh ,A9%F(yGh A9}zgyGh
.uJyG upG(*

517

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

P$ {F} ~v9JyG Qqw* fC 9|C


?#++T!Qqzy IQ}gAT| B+t< ~v QFGRGyG fC h|
.?"S 130 :{F9TyG
&!hv O iPyG f(!9tyG GP$ Q+j* fC #w}* {$ !>+_ !?"S 130 :N+WyG
.#w}* : !?9$9J\h ?+Wf #+< f(+T!QqyG
,f(g+aAT@ 9| {w< ,f(g+aAT@ 9}< ?"AqyG gP$ A9q_{< ~w+zf :A,V ~$C
.#AqyG QV #+}zT}yG ,t* fC uG dzT!
k
k
,IQ+Dv u_9"| ,p ;D| - N+V 9* - f6G H9=WyG ?yzT}y ?z}wAp :{F9TyG
,$ ?yzT| ,p f(\(M* G(yGR : ,IQ+Dv u_9"| ,p #wy ,u_9"}yG {v BT+y
k
,e9gyG h*QWAyG ,Q+qwAyG - N+V 9* ;D| - {F9T| :,"g* ,~%+zf IQ+=v
~C ,~w"| i(AqyG fhPLz* Os - N+V 9*- {F9T}yG gP$ ... ,"+gyG Q+qwAyGh
k
... ,"g* 9t+=a@ GPw$ ,~v9JyG )zf 98(t=a*
.K+JY Q+i GP$ ~%z}f :N+WyG
d(t* ,#+}+Df #<G N+WyG 9%y9s 9| ,LC 9* :&y d(t! 9}y ~C ,~g! :{F9TyG
k
~wI #| :e9gyG h*QWAyG :d9s &=Av ,p -;D| - #+}+Df #<G N+WyG #wy :xy
~wJ* : ~v9JyG GP$ 9!O"f f6Gh ,{+Zq@ fhO< Qp9v (%p ,uG dR!C 9| Q+j<
?N+V 9* ?yzT}yG B}%p ,Qp9v (%p ,uG dR!C 9}<
~wJy9< ?yzT| )zf ~wJyG :-~w+p uG cQ9<- d(sC ,9"}%p :N+WyG
.#+g| [MV )zf ~wJyG Q+i 9%+zf u=a"* jPyG
?yzT}yG )zf ~wJyG #+< bQqyG G(pQg* fC ~zgyG ?=z_ )zf >G* ,~%}y9p
Os #+g}yG ~v9JyG f} ,96 ~v9JyG )zf ~wJyG #+<h ,?yzT| ,$ E+I #|
#+}zT}yG e9wI >y9ih ,Q(|}G &+zf U=q z* #| A(TyG A9}zf #| gO"f f(w*
!?G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

518

x }* f;ph ,~%+zf g(x}n *o f;p ~%+@z+p ,YQWy9< ~zf ~$O"f U+y e(+yG
{F9T| h+= :d9s )1(#*Q=Ag}yG #+}zT}yG A9}zf ^g< fC Q@ ~yC ,~%+zf
~zfC ~A!Cz :| &y(t< Q|}G ~%+zf &=AVGh !{Lq O@ 9%+p YQWzy U+y I9+JyG
~$h ,~%+zf U=q z@ #wyh ,M;Zy9< ~y O%W! d9FQ GP$ d9s !y~v9+!O Q(|z<
,xyP &=VC 9|h ?g"ZyGh h!9Z}zy ?=T"y9< GP$ fC GhOF(y ,Q|}G G(z|z@ (y
9| ,?w| #| )@C | &!} ,&< ~zfC ~$h ,{M"yG Q+<z@ #f ~zw@ d(SQyG f}
f(@z*h {M"yG )yE fhOgZ* A:|$ iCQ 9}zp ,&pQg* :h ,A,V :h {M! 9%+p
x
9|z :d9s ,{}fh >g@ &+p f(w+p ,98(Jtz*h ?zM"yG fhQ<x |* ~C ,&I9tz<
9* :G(y9tp ,&+yE G(@zp ,?zM"yG JOTqp ,?"S g(vQAp ,y98k +V )"j* xyP #cC
,~v9+!O e9wIz< U+y ,~v9+!O Q(|z< ~zfC ~A!Cz :d9s !Q}AyG OTp uG d(SQ
9| O;< ,p A9}zgyG ^g< GhQ@ ~yC ,f6G f(T=q z* S9"yG ~C ,~v9+!O Q(|z< #wy
- &y(s &A%=Vh ,,y;jAS:G 9<QyG eQJ}yG :G(y9sh ?iQ9}DAS:G 9<QyG G(I9<C
.
?*6 Qt=y p8 76
54
3 2 o :-)y9g@
k
U+yC ,~y9gyG GP$ {D| gA9Fh ,?g*QWyG e9wIz< ;$9F f9v GPE ~v9JyG
?&z]*
q
.&z]* :{F9TyG
f9T! G &< Qqw* 9| G(zgp GPE Qqwy9< e9wJyG )zf ~wJ! : xyPzp :N+WyG
.?GJyG &+zf ~+t! )AI
?N+V 9* ?GJyG ~+t* jPyG #| :{F9TyG
.~$Qqw< ~wJ! : ?GJyG ~%+zf 9"}sC 9| 9"|O 9| :N+WyG
,yGhQ@ fC :Ez :Bzs f9]|Q ,p d(t@ -N+V 9*- xAg}S :{F9TyG
g(

]279

G :I

n n n

G[

#| ?t+Ch c9"$ fC JQvP Otp K}TyG )<C Q$9dyG O=f ?|;gyG e;v )zf )@9t+zg@ hFGQ
.?+|;S G ?g*QWzy ?tpG(| ?+g\(yG #+!G(tyG fC )fO@ {+f9}SC (*OMyG e9*C Q$R}G A9}zf

)1(

519

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

gy ?*DQ {D| :Bzs - QvPC 9}+p N+V 9* - Bzs ,?+"+gyG ?*DQyG :)"g*
-U}WyG iQ! 9| {D|- #+t+yG ~zf ~zg! :jC ,($ GP$ ! ~g! :N+WyG
k
k
.yd9}AIG &+p 9| 9J*QY ,9IG(< GQk qv
k*Qq@ QG(G< hshh yQFGRGyG ?yR9! ,p Q<9v}G ih9Apz b*QV #| )%A!G
.#+}+Df #<G N+WyG b*QWyG
.#+ G

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

520
)9

%"TI

uG d

zT ! (

?}@9MyG

9AwyG GP$ 9"FQLC y?J+Z"yG #*OyGz | ~*QwyG d(SQyG d(s #| 9sk ;a!E
k
.~*QwyG &%F(y 9Zy9L &zgG* fC )y9g@ uG dzT!h
Q+aAT| QV 9%"f Oy(A* rzTyG H%"}y ?qy9M}yG Q9wp}G gP$ fC e(zg}yGh
.-d9t* 9}v- QQWyG QjZAT| #| Q9"yG ~dg|h
QWyG ?*GO< (%p e;wy9< LhQMyG #| fhQPJ*o A9}zgyG 9!OFh xyPyh
>aMyG 9%A*GO< f9v :E f9w| :h f9|R ,p KO; ?"Ap #| 9|h ,&S9SCh
9"+!9f Otyh ~%+zf Q+$9}GyG A9"C Q+i :9< 9%y 969JYC ,tz* : )AyG ?+S9}JyG
H9=WyG Jz=f r+vh 9$Og< 9|h J9"+g=TyG )p >aMyG gP$ Q9CB #| QZ| ,p
k
k
k
A9=aL &< iO9"* 9}p - ?JzT}yG LhQMyG J9f9}Gy ;%S 9"+}C GO+Y &AzgFh
98zvh J9f9}GyG gP$ O"f gGOY OG* ~%=y9D| f9+<h e9wJzy Q+qw@ #| ?"AqyG
.?*9"g< ?|(SQ| QGhOC
9"$ #| fhCO=* : aQaAyGh (zjyG G(Gy9g* fC fhO*Q* #*PyG fC >*QjyGh
.?JzT}yG J9+z}gyG Q9w"ASGh >GW< fhCO=* {<
~%=Avh ~%=aL JRQpC #*PyG ~$ fhQw"AT}yG f(w* IQ+Dv 9!k 9+IC {<
~$Q+qw@ ,p ih9AqyG QGOYEh {< ~%=F9g| RGQ<Eh e9wJyG Ot! )p ~7:9t|h
~8Ez d(t* fC H9=WyG ^g< h+aAT* E+J< ?JzT}yG J9f9}GyG gP$
.yKOJ* 9| h+= )zf f(tpG(| Q|}G ?t+tI )p ~%"wyh #*Qa]| fhQw"AT*
)AyG ?+}zgyG J98+%yGh ?+%tqyG h|9G}y9<h {<( 9gk += A9}zgy9< >+8 9"!Eh
>$P| #++=Ay fzWyG GP$ ,p JGQGQs GhQOZ* fC .)ih9AqyG QGOYE 96 b+!C
cQA* : iPyG {+ZqAy9< e9wJyG h| {|9gAyG ,p ~%G%"|h ?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C
k
U9"| : ~%+zf 9=FGh Q|}G K=YC Otp 9%y;L #| Pq"* IQjC ?"Ap >I9Zy
.Q+aL OF Q|}G f{p 9!D9}zf )!QPg+yh ~%y
H

521

? +fQW y

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

?!GO{< QL6 fB #| JGQGQs QOZ@ fC GOk <C )qw* : &!{p


&!} J9SQ9}}yG gP$ RQq@ )AyG ?+S9S}G H9=S}G EA: fC fhO< JGQ+GqAyGh
Q+qwA< 9|E 969JYC O"f ?|R9F JGO9tAfG d9gp}G gP$ AGQh fC e(zg}yG #|
A9}zgyG uq@G f{p .J9g}AG}yG Q+qwA< hC ~6 f(SQAA*h ~8h9g* #|h e9wJyG
ZQqA* P8"+Jp ~+dgyG )"TyG {Y}G GP$ B+=D@ )zf {}gyGh Q9%cEh f9+< )zf
Q+ih #+}zT}yG - S9"yG {v - S9"yG I(fOy I9fOyGh ~zgyG ?=z_h A9}zgyG
e;S G ~g* )AI )y9g@ uG YQV u+=a@ )yE e9wJyG Q+ih e9wJyGh #+}zT}yG
.)y9g@ uG VQC f9}* Gh f9|}Gh #|}Gh e;TyGh
9

H $Q G

p!@
!}w q

p o nm l k j i
hg
o
]82

LK

?*6G

:e

9gn !}G[

J
I {

{D| ,p {ZqyG d(tyG &+p U+y h+v}| e;v QOZ* fC GOk <C )qw* : &!C 9}v
)yE f(=TA"* #| 9%+p rzAM* :C VhQq}yG {F9T| )%p IQ+aMyG {F9T}yG gP$
.?f9}GyGh ?"TyG {$C
k
&y )tz* : 9tza| 9|k ;v ^g=yG >Aw* fC IQ$9c )qA< fC )j="* xyPv
k
&+zf )"=*h &!(8V )yE >$P* ~C )q_9f )S9}I )y9gq!G e;w< >aM* hC :9<
k
.)y;fh GQ(Zs Qq jyG H9=WyG
9}%| QPJ< :E G(}zwA* :C I9fOyGh A9}zgyG #| Hl(za| GOk f9Zp f6G #}p
v o
- ?}zv HQh d9+F}G 9%CQG(A@ &@9}zv )t=@h J(}* {F9tyG f{p ahQdyG B!9v
)"=A+p e;wyG )"g| )g* : #| ,@z*h f9T! G 9%+tz*o ?z="s ryC #| QaLC B!9v
U+y >$P}yG eR: - G(y9s 9}k *Osh 9Gk %"|h IO+tf 9%zF9s ry9M*h 9%|RG(y
.>$P}<
,p J9t+zgAv IO(F(| - J9}zv #}p - IQ\9I xyP )zf O$G(WyGh

?+fQWy

?S9+Ty

Gh

?+}v9Jy

522

#+\Qj}yG ^g< 9%qtz@ - uG ~%}IQ- 9!A9}zf ^g=y >AwyG ^g< f(a<


{< &tp fhO<h ~zgyG ,p #+MSGQzy Y(FQyG fhO< IQ+aL GQk(|C 9%+zf G("<h
~%yG(sC #| B*CQ 9}| A9}zgyG A:|$ &+zf f9v 9| )yE )AI Y(FQyG fhO<h
.?+z}gyG ~%qsG(|h
~zgyG {$C e;v h| {|9gAyG ,p iPAJ* fC VhQq}yG H%"}v e;wyG GP$h
^g< Q$G(d< PLC #| )zf f(=+g* ?*O(gTy9< I(fOyG A9}zf 9!OFh xyPyh
?f9}Gy ~$Q*P; ,p KOI 9}v 9$Q+i hC O+I(AyG ?f(}G}v ~zgyG {$C e;v
gP$ 9%+p Bz+s )AyG ahQdyGh H9=S}G ~%y G(IQVh )uG Y9_ #| fG(LE(
k
GP$h GOF e9$ &!{p vY &+yE hFQ9p - r+!9ZAyG xz@ 9%==T< Bq"Yh J9}zwyG
9%z$C )zf ?+fQWyG e(zgyG ,SQGO iOy e(zg| ($h O(T* fC ,j="* H%"|
.dhR"zy H9=SC ?+!BQtyG J9*6G ,p c9"%p #+z$zA}yG
o
#+MSGQyG )yE Y(FQy9< 9!Q|C xyPyh OhQ(zy H9=SC i(="yG E*OJyG ,ph
{ ~zgyG ,p

hgfedcba`_^]\
utsrqpon
m
l
k
j
i
syxwv
.}

You might also like