Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Architect No#5587, Taiwan M. S. in advanced architectural design, GSAPP, Columbia M. Arch. National Chiao Tung University, Taiwan
Tel:646-492-9396 charimanyeh@gmail.com
Urban Filtration
Academic project in GSAPP Columbia Studio Critic: Kate Orff Site Location: Jamaica Bay, New York
Urban Filtration
Academic project in GSAPP Columbia Studio Critic: Kate Orff Site Location: Jamaica Bay, New York This project is a combination of a series of eco-restoration projects and a secondary water treatment system. Located in Brooklyn and Jamaica Bay, this project aims to restore parts of eco system into both the city and the bay by re-introducing several habitat-building species, while cleaning the water of the bay, softening the hard, unaccessible water front and arouse public concern toward the bay. This project tries to deal several problems in Jamaica bay: 1. Excess nitrogen level. 2. The untreated waste water from combined sewage overflow during storms 3. The Damaged eco-system in the bay 4. Erosion of the land-fills around the bay To improve the bay, this project is introducing a additional water treatment system performed by a series of eco-restoration projects: 1. Fresh-water marshes 2. Salt marshes 3. Oyster reefs
Issues: Excess Nitrogen Level Restoration of ecosystem Storm surge / sea level rising Prior Researches: Water Quality, Water Shed and Sewage Shed Oysters, Salt Marshes and Fresh Water Marshes Storm Surge and Sea Level Rising
Strategies: Restore water-filtering eco-infrastructure into the Bay and urban area Introduce semi-artificial wet lands into the bay and urban area to:
Accelerate natural wet-land-forming mechanism Decrease possible damage by storms/floods Reform traditional image of urban parks
Benefits: Cleaner water Healthier ecosystem Lower risk of major floods Diverse shore line condition
Technical means: Community rain/storm water reservoir Rain water recycling system Separated rain/gray water treatment system Semi-artificial salt/freah marches as:
Carbon sink Nitrogen filter Heavy metal catcher Natural habitant
Artificial oyster reefs as: Function Programs A local water treatment system devoted to treat:
Rainwater, storm water and gray water Out flows from water pollution control plant and combined sewage overflow.
Artificial wet lands and a semi-artificial wet-land-forming mechanism A series of urban parks and water piazzas
Positive side affects: Arouse local concerns toward the bay Recreational/educational values Help release pressures of current infrastructure:
Water treatment Water supply Sewage system Storm damage control
Location:
The project is located near the water pollution control plant in ward 26, Brooklyn. It starts from Linden Blvd. and will be stretched into the periphery of Jamaica Bay. The site is full of different conditions such as urban areas, a canal, 2 landfills, a water pollution control plant, a combined sewage outflow and the bay area. Land Use:
Water Quality
Excess nitrogen in water is now considered one of the most serious problems in the Bay. Citizen Groups are now reaching legal statements with NYC to : 1.Sewage treatment upgrade 2.Marsh restoration 3.Enforceable limit on nitrogen pollution The United States Environmental Protection Agency now considers pollution from all sources, include urban storm water pollution, to be the most important source of contamination in our natural waters. More impervious surfaces mean more urban storm-water runoff, which causes increases in water quality impairment
Residential Mix Use Commercial Industrial Traffic Public Facilities Parks Vacant Lands
SITE
Over-all Strategy:
Water Current:
The form of Urban Filtration project is representing the way water flow from the city to the Bay. The over-all strategy of this project can be broken down into 3 parts: 1. Urban area: Integrate existing park, streets and parking spaces into a rain water recycling and gray water treating system using fresh-water plants to treat water and restore the eco-system in urban area. 2. Estuary: A working water park that treats CSO & WWTP out flow while works as storm water reservoir as wel 3. In the bay: Restore oyster reefs into the bay that filter nitrogen and help forming new salt marshes.
INDUSTRIAL
MAIN STREET
COMMERCIAL
CSO (COMBINED SEWAGE OUTFOLW) & WWTP (Waste Water Treatment Plant) OUTFLOW
COMMERCIAL
RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL
BELT PARKWAY
SHOPPING MALL
OPEN WATER
A salt marsh forming mechanism preformed by oyster reefs : Oysters can work as efficient nitrogen filter . The idea is to deploy oyster reefs in the bay according to the direction of ordinary current going out the bay to slow down the water , give further treatment and to catch sediments and help forming wetland habitats in shallow water. The salt marsh restoration project also help soften the hard edge at water front, reduce the natural erosion of landfills and thereby improve water quality.
WATER PARK A working landscape : Deploy marsh bed units into the channel while creating an artificial estuary to treat CSO (Combined Sewage Outflow) and WWTP (Waste Water Treatment plant) outflow. This area has a capacity to keep WWTP outflow in the site for two days and have additional reservoirs able to accommodate CSO water for three continuous day of average thunder storm so the water will be treated before leaving the site. The landscape serves as a park during ordinary days.
URBAN AREA
Feel the Bay in urban life: Introduce rain and gray water ponds with freshwater marsh plants, in-land vegetation, filtration sand bed and infiltration layers to reserve, treat and recycle rain water and gray water . The system also increase efficiency of current water treatment system, reduce storm damage and forms a net work of eco-passages in urban area. The system also serves as parks, plazas and parking spaces.
Gray Water
Gray water system is a series of unaccessible pounds of fresh water plants which also work as habitats in urban area
RELEASED INTO CHANNEL CLEAN DIRTY
Rain Water
The rain water system are ponds, infiltration layers, filtration sand beds and freshwater marshes which also work as parks, passages, parking spaces and plazas. Most of these units are under ground and have functions other than to gather, treat and recycle rain water.
T EC
LAND FILL BELT PARKWAY OYSTER REEFS MARSH PLANTS ELEVATED ROADS PARK ENTRANCE
AT E R G R AY W R R A IN WAT E
Function Programs
Eco-Restoration Projects
Morphology:
This diagram represents the shapes of this project. The water treatment eco-units: in-land, intertidal or underwater, are changing shapes from land to sea. The gray water units get larger when the water get cleaner. The rain water units, in order to fit themselves in the over developed urban situation, are rectangular in shape at first, and then change into more organic shapes. The morphology of these units, is an architectural representation of the city gradually blend into the bay ans different kinds of water gradually mixes with each other and goes into the sea.
gray water
rain water can be recycled without further treatment
black water
Evaporate
rain water
evaporate
recycle
rain water ponds serve as parks minimum water level over flow within rain water system infiltration layers serve as passages or parking spaces
marsh plants
gray water ponds unaccessible to public over flow within gray water system
filtration
oyster reefs
The rain water and gray water system has many different functions in the urban area. It create green public spaces, utilize parking spaces as underground reservoirs, and create habitats for small creatures. Through the rain and gray water system, people in the urban area can feel the bay even without seeing it, and, have more concern about our eco system.
visitor center
administration
At the estuary, the outflows of rain water system goes into a large recreational park. Right next to this park is the place where the treated gray water and the WWTP out flow being released into the channel. This water park is a working landscape where people can have fun with the treated rain water, and watch the marsh plants treating the rest of their waste water.
marsh bed freshwater marsh CSO & WWTP outflow gray water ponds filtration layer rain water ponds park & playground elevated street
C SE
TI
ON
Accessibility:
Accessibility of the parks and the ponds differs from cleanness of the water in order to avoid citizens from exposed to contaminated ponds. Basically, rain water ponds are always accessible, while gray water ponds are not.
always accessible unaccessible only during severe storms accessibility varies with daily water quality monitering
passage
1 2 3
Normally, out-flows from gray water system and WWTP goes through pond 1~4 and get cleaner and cleaner before released into the channel. Pond 1~4 have a combined capacity 2 times larger then daily WWTP out-flow (maximum depth 1.5~2 m). During the storm days, pond A and underground reservoir B will be used to help keeping the CSO water in site so that no untreated water will go into the bay. Pons 1~4 and A, B have a capacity to withstand three continuous days of average thunder storm without letting untreated water into the channel.
Bay Area:
In the bay area are oyster reefs restoration project that helps forming wetlands. Considering the constant lost of wet lands in the Bay, I basically developed a U shape artificial oyster reefs to slow down the outgoing flows. By the method the oysters and the marsh will have more time to clean the water, and, the suspended particles caught by the reefs are helpful in our course to restore the losing wet lands within the Bay.
surface current going out the Bay waterfront platform for big events water quality monitoring facility artificial oyster reefs ferry channel newly formed wetland marina
T he
in r ow
re g di
he of t tion
ree
CURRENT(OUT)
The Screen
Academic project in GSAPP Columbia Studio Critic: Frederic Levrat Site Location: Amman, Jordan
The Screen
Academic project in GSAPP Columbia Studio Critic: Frederic Levrat Site Location: Amman, Jordan
This project is an MOVING, INTERACTIVE SCREEN that works as a REAL-WORLD DIGITAL AGORA and a shaded park. Also, this project is designed to host the annual JORDAN SHORT FILM FESTIVAL and accommodate permanent structures such as office and projection rooms for the film festival. Inspired by the ARAB SPRING movement, this project discusses the relationship between public spaces, social network and interactive media. Also, to explore the possibility of having a truly interactive structure that brings the issue of information sharing into another scale, and, how that possible future may have its impact to our cities The Screen is: An agora and a public space A real-world cyber space A social network at a specific location A film festival curated by the audience And, it is about: Form, space and screen Social networks and physical background Events, hosts and participants Images, audiences and points of views Public spaces, urban contexts and landscape Augmented Reality
Hours 24-7
Content Digital
Subjects Miscellaneous
The screen
Mostly locals
Daily
All
Local/not censored
Some
By issues
Traditional media
Authority
Scheduled
Digital
Censored
Huge
Huge
Public spaces
Unknown
Vocal Physical
Local
A little
By issues
Locals
Internet
Flood of irresponsible information Addictive Pleasure of being noticed Pleasure of being anonymous
The screen Censorship, fixed time table Difficult to find specific information Very limited sources Unpredictable times and contents
Traditional media
Public spaces
This Diagram shows the differences between existing daily information sources of ours. The Screen is trying to combine the advantages of a public space and the internet to create a new type of media the belongs to neither governments nor major companies, which runs as a public spaces of information, images and sounds.
The use of Hyper Sonic Speakers can avoid different sound tracks from interfere with each other.
This is a space recognizes events, hosts and scales of events using cameras. This space responds to events and give additional support such as larger space, images or sounds. Authorized hosts can move freely in this space and their spatial setting shall follow them.
The space will also recognize different gestures to better understand the flow, the direction and condition of the crowd.
In more complicated settings, the physical scape can even suggest the center points, the flow and the viewing angles of events.
In Jordan Short Film Festival, the screen can create a now type of viewing experiences of a self-curated outdoor IMAX, Curators as Event Hosts ; Audiences as Participants.
Through some setting, the events can be arranged in orderly fashions such as multi-centered events or deformed events.
Using half-transparent screens can bring in the possibility of augmented reality, also, by having the possibility of projecting outward it creates a whole new dialog between events inside the screen and the rest of the city. And, by lowering the default position of the screen, it is possible to create unaccessible boundaries for events.
The Site
The site is located in the historical center of downtown Amman, right next to the first circle. With a little help from the hilly topography of Amman, this is a spot that can be seen by most parts of downtown Amman. The site is basically a slope as steep as 25~45 degrees -a good shape of outdoor theaters, and, with a rich urban context. The religious center of nearby area, an important mosque, is located right below the site. Surrounding the mosque is a very busy street and a market. Also, the most famous tourist spots, the citadel and a roman theater, are also within walking distance.
The Screen
A moving tent structure supported by 20 mega-columns. The screen displays digital contents, interact with its viewers and provide suitable physical forms for all issues(events) on display.
The Landscape
Inside the small pockets between the landscape and the audience are some permanent structures such as the office, a indoor projection room and some service spaces.
Viewing Angles
The Landscape
At some points, the default height is lower than 1 meter so that the I can create unaccessible(private) boxes by programing the screen shape.
Minimum Heights
Default Position
Because the screen changes its shape by being pulled up by cables, there will be a lowest position for every points on the screen. In order to determine that default position, the diagram at the right color coded the minimum heights required by each area on the audience. By that height study, we have the default position (the lowest position) of the screen. Default Position
Sensing area:
The heart of the digital agora, in which all people will be recognized by cameras and activate the screen.
01 02
03
01 02
03
Section Rendering
Ways to do Vibrancy
Academic project in GSAPP Columbia Studio Critic: Markus Dochantschi Site Location: Istanbul, Turkey Collaborated with Tin-Yu Kao
Ways to do Vibrancy
Academic project in GSAPP Columbia Collaborated with Tin-Yu Kao Studio Critic: Markus Dochantschi Site Location: Istanbul, Turkey
This project is an experimental method trying to integrate the entire workflow from URBAN PLANNING to ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN in order to create true, well-programed vibrancy in STREETS and PUBLIC SPACES. Ways to do Vibrancy is a project which is unique in its street-oriented planning method and its experimental zoning-on-the-facades technique. The combination of these two methods creates STREETS and BUILDINGS unlike any existing city, something totally new and never be seen before.
A_R
A_R_Start A_Road A_R_End A_Joint
Residences Sense of Beloning Street Lives
B_R
B_R_Start B_Road B_R_End B_Joint
C_R
C_R_Start C_Road C_R_End C_Joint
Types
Site Boundry
A_R_S A_R_E
B_R_S B_R_E
C_R_S C_R_E
B Class Roads
Descriptions
A Class Roads
Transportation Accessibility Public / Regional
*VT= Net width used for vehicles or transportation *Maximum distance: Maximum distance without any joints or intersections
100m
200m 400m
400M
After having the types of streets, we started to research for the right distances to help build our grid system. Our site, is an abandoned navy ship yard located in an industrial district near on the other bank of Istanbuls historical center. Looking into average distances between public TRANSPORTATION stops and community MOSQUES, we came up with two numbers: 400M for public transportation and 200M for community forming.
Example #01-1
Following #01-1's descriptions of street TYPES, CONNECTIONS and Distances, there the streets should form a network as shown as the right. #01-1 does not control the form or shape of the street system, therefore, there can be geometric forms or organic forms, but, these street system will still have the characters, the hierarchy system and the similar density as described before.
SITE
Access Points
#01-1: Free
Topo
#01-5: Topography:
Having more efficiency in transportation and arranging building sites.
Urban Fabric
Twisted Grid
Government
Get investment on building streets Get help on maintaining and managing streets Rent income
Users / Visitors
Use the streets
Developers / Owners
Have a chance to control the quality of streets Have a chance to own the streets
Street Programs:
After studying the programs and their portions of the streets in Istanbul, we identified 6 different groups of street programs as listed.
Street Programs
Streets in Istanbul
Transportation
Pedestrian
Green
Mixed Pedestrian
Mixed Green
Transit
Testing #02-1
And, we drew a series of streets, vertical streets and intersections to test our design guidelines, and, to find a way to ZONE THE STREETS efficiently. We came up with Guide line #02-2: All streets should be zoned in 4 different characters: TYPE of street, WIDTH, percentage of MIX-USED programs and percentage of GREEN area.
Connections, 100m~150m
B-Streets: Flexible
We use the B-street to mediate between A and C to allow some flexibility of design and planning.
Connections, 150m~200m
Forming the eco-connection between land and waterfront These streets, as studied in Test #01-1, have a considerable degree of sun exposure, fresh air and view of the river, and, are more suitable for recreational uses and green areas.
Guideline #03-1: How to Guide the Zoning of the Buildings According to the Street Zoning
Street TYPES Percentage of GREEN Percentage of MIXED-USE determines determines determines Building Heights Set-backs / Programs on the Top Programs on the Street Level
And, the rest of the buildings are zoned as PROPORTION MIDDLE, which designed to accommodate required residences and offices.
Proportion: Middle
Street Types Determines the Buildings Heights:
Types of the streets (the A, B and C types in #01-1) refers to accessibility and transportation. Generally, A-streets are capable to serve a greater population and with their advantage of conveniences in transportation, they are more likely to become business of commercial streets and have greater density of buildings. A Roads generate 30m-high faades along them B Roads generate 20m-high facades alone them C Roads generate 10m-hifh facades alone them The heights at the corner are combined number with all roads intersect at that corner, therefore, an intersection of two A roads generate a 50mhigh faade, etc.
Proportion: Above
HOURS OF VIBRANCY WEEK DAYS EVENINGS RESTAURANTS RETAILS DAILY SERVICES ENTERTAINMENT PROFESSIONAL SERVICES OFFICE RESIDENTTIAL OFFICE STUDIOS SMALL UNITS HOLIDAYS NO EFFECT
The GREEN Zoning Determines the Set-backs and Programs on Top of Buildings:
The GREEN zoning is more about physical environment, sun, wind, air, water, view and is about out-door, healthy, eco-friendly, recreational atmospheres. Therefore THE GREEN ZONING is a perfect guide of building set-back. The skyline of a city is, another chance we have to create green area for the environments sake, for recreational use or for delightful city scape. In this project, we also use the GREEN ZONING of the streets to guide our upper part of city, for we find its quite relevant. G + MG on Street 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 40% What in here is a specific mixture of programs we called THE PROPORTION ABOVE, which is a certain proportion of mixtures of different programs designed to have more open space, better air circulation, better lighting condition and less dense. Such as larger 50% residential units, open spaces, recreational and cultural uses along with small units of restaurants, retails and service. 40% Set-back Angles +30 degrees +20 degrees +10 degrees +-0 degrees -10 degrees Programs on Top 50% of total height 40% 30% 20% 10%
COMMERCIAL
Proportion: Middle
Residential: 50% Open Spaces / Void: 40% Office: 11%
LARGE UNITS
MID-SIZE UNITS
PUBLIC/OPEN
Proportion: Above
Commercial: 5% Residential: 30% Open Spaces / Void: 60% Office: 5%
Group 01,
School, Hospital and Cultural Center Facilities need to be located somewhere
SCHOOL WATER FRONT A Joints At least *1
Schools:
Schools dont need to be at the water front because the waterfront, is supposed to be a vibrant and noisy place by setting. And, a schools should br next to at least an A-joint so that itll have public transportation. And, the school should be next to a B-street whichs MIX-USED ZONING is less then 30%, therefore, the school will have a street quiet enough to place its classrooms. Schools should not next to C-streets because C-streets do not have enough capacity to handle the traffic in rush hours.
Hospital
School
Group 02:
Public Services, Bus Routes and Tronsportation
*PUBLIC SERVICES here refers to police, post offices, fire service and so on.... PUBLIC SERVICES BUS ROUTES Transportation Come with Bus Stops A Joints
Relationship with each other What kind of streets do they need What density do they need
At least*13 ( of all) At least*16 (2/3 of all)
B Streets At least *1 MP <30% C Streets HOSPITAL WATER FRONT A Joints At least *1 MP <30%
Hospitals
Hospital need quiet A-streets for emergency reasons
Stop at all PUBLIC SERVICE STATIONS A Joints Come with Bus Stops A Joints
A Streets At least *2 MP <30% C Streets CULTURAL CENTER WATER FRONT A Joints At least *1 MP >30% G+MG >30%
Cultural Center:
Cultural center need vibrancy, therefore, the water front is quite suitable. A-STREETS with more than 30% of both MIX-USED ZONING and GREEN ZONING can support Cultural Centers quite well in terms of traffic, vibrancy and high quality open spaces. Transportation / Public Service Park
Group 03:
Parks and Emergency
PARKS LARGE A Streets or B Streets C Streets MID-SIZE SMALL EMERGENCY B Joints C Joints C Joints At least*2 ( of all) At least*4 ( of all) All of them 1
What kind of streets do they need What density do they need Additional Requirements
MP >30% G+MG >30%
Emergency:
EMERGENCY here refers to operation spaces of fire trucks and ambulances, which should be located at all C-Joints because a C-joint means a dead end of a C-street so, there will be an EMERGENCY space at all C-joints which connected to a nearest A-street. Transportation
Cultural Center
The width of wetlands and soft edges are guided by the GREEN ZONING on the river-side street.
Proportion: Above
HOURS OF VIBRANCY COMMERCIAL WEEK DAYS EVENINGS RESTAURANTS RETAILS DAILY SERVICES ENTERTAINMEN PROFESSIONAL SERVICES OFFICE RESIDENTTIAL OFFICE STUDIOS SMALL UNITS MID-SIZE LARGE UNITS PUBLIC/OPEN GREEN EVENTS CULTURAL HOLIDAYS NO EFFECT
Proportion: Middle
Residential: 50% Open Spaces / Void: 40% Office: 11%
GROUP 01: VIBRANT ALL-TIME GROUP 02: EVENING/HOLIDAYS GROUP 03: NO EFFECT GROUP 04: DEAD AT NIGHT
Explainations
At least (1,2,3...) sides of this unit should connect to the streets Cant have residential units above this unit in a certain height Exceptions of the no-housing regulation At least (1,2,3...) sides of this unit should face the streets At least (1,2,3...) sides of this unit should face green or void areas Residentical, Large Residential, Small
Office Commercial
Vibrancy Chart
The red areas marked in these renderings represent programs that generate vibrancy in the buildings or on the streets. For example, the MP, MG in Guideline #02 and commercials in Guideline #05 Besides the red colors, we managed to estimate vibrancy at particular locations such as every corners. EVENTS INFRASTRUCTURE OPEN SPACE BUILDING PROGRAM STREET PROGRAM TRANSPORTATION DENSITY
Green Areas
The green color in these drawings show programs that provide green areas to the city, public or private. These programs include the G and MG in guideline #02, Parks and Emergencies in Guideline #04, Large Residential units in Guideline #05
Programs
And in some drawings, we color coded all interior or exterior programs to understand how our buildings and public spaces work. SCHOOL GREEN PUBLIC SERVICE CULTURAL CENTER MIXED/COMMERCIAL TRANSIT BUS ROUTE
A STREET TYPE 40% GREEN AREA 50% MIXED AREA A STREET TYPE 40% GREEN AREA 30% MIXED AREA A STREET TYPE 40% GREEN AREA 40% MIXED AREA
EVENTS INFRASTRUCTURE OPEN SPACE BUILDING PROGRAM STREET PROGRAM TRANSPORTATION FLOW DENSITY
Origami
An academic project in GSAPP Columbia Exploring the possibility of Revit as parametric modeler Simulating the pattern of a folding paper
Origami
Origami is a project try to represent the pattern of a folding paper. Using Revit as primary tool, the project explores the way to materialize origami pattern into building facade while exploring the possibility of using Revit for parametric design. The digital model we develop not only represents the origami pattern convincingly, it also respond to changes such as size and shape. The family unit and the whole model was developed in Revit with parameters (formulas) represent the pattern of a folding paper. The project model built by Revit, has parameters that fit the origami pattern into all free form surfaces. The physical model was made by a 3D printed frame and a real folding paper.
The Family
The family shows the smallest unit of this Origami Facade. To represent the folding pattern, this family model contents a series of formulas that control the over all thickness of the folded surface. There are 4 highest points located on the 4 edges of the unit, the height of these points are controlled by the length of the edge, therefore, when the unit get smaller, these points get higher, just like the folded papers. The rest of this family will form a space truss.
The Project
After applying the family model we developed onto any surface, that surface will become a representation of the origami paper. By controlling the shape of the surface and the ways that surface being divided, we can have all kinds of our Origami facade. The elevation at the left shows how the individual units change their shapes when the over-all facade changes.
Acupuncture
A Collaborated Work with Richard Phan / Prathyusha Viddam Academic project, GSAPP Columbia 1:1 mockup using stainless steal
4PM 10AM Image: Lighting Test on a 1/4 Scale Prototype, Noon Panel
Stretch Shelf
A Collaborated Work with: Fei Hu / YooJin Jang / Xiaoming Zhan Academic project in GSAPP Columbia .
Modeling
Changing Shapes:
The Stretch Shelf changes its shape according to the ways in which it is deployed or loaded.
Residential area The market place that is actually a cliff The residential area that is too steep to be developed The roads which cant be built The school that was canceled
SITE
My position in this project: Project Leader What I did: Schematic design / Design development / Architecture permit application / Green building code evaluation / Detail design / Design drawings / Working drawings,... etc.,
After two years of struggle, We came to an > agreement with a 11 stories apartment. Height limit from secondary road, municipal law, Taipei Preserved area for sidewalk, local urban plan <Our proposal to the committee of control of urban design: to loosen the 21m height limit in the regional codes of urban design, so we can build a 14 stories apartment with much better physical environment
A Giant House:
To mix in to the landscape of green hills and suburban residences, we decided that all features of high rise buildings must be neutralized. Therefore, we came up with the idea of the giant house. Through carefully adjusted geometric proportion, the apartment looks more like a huge house.
A
A
Section A A
Bali Apartment
A 26 stories apartment, Bail Township, Taipei County, Taiwan, 2007 ~ still in progress Award Winning Project (Chinese Golden Stone Award for Architecture -for out standing design and planning, 2008, Taiwan) My position in the project: Project Leader, Mar-May 2007 My contribution in this project: Development of the plan and types of units
A government funded research project that went to the 2nd International Architectural Biennale Rotterdam in year 2005, A publication and an interactive installation. Guest Curator: J.M. Lin Architect. My contribution of the project: I led the student research team and wrote the first Chinese version of all essays in this project.
To observe and document the coastline of Taiwan, we took a set of photos every 3km on the coastline and gathered a data base of photos and thereby start our research and analysis
A government funded research project that went to the 2nd International Architectural Biennale Rotterdam in year 2005, A publication and an interactive installation. Guest Curator: J.M. Lin Architect. My contribution of the project: I led the student research team and wrote the first Chinese version of all essays in this project.
The Ocean of TW is a research project trying to give a full diagnose of disrespectfully treated coastal spaces around Taiwan and the possible spiritual/cultural background behind the strange phenomena. It is really weird that Taiwanese residents treat their coast line that way: Beaches are isolated from towns and full of garbage; Fishing ports are empty with neither boats nor fishes; Nuclear reactors, incinerators, high-ways, military stations, dams and highly polluting factories are all around Taiwanese coast line despite the fact that Taiwan is an island highly dependant on the ocean. unlike other Islanders around the world, Taiwanese treats their ocean like it is ugly and no one wants to go there. To inquiry into the details of these bizarre phenomena and their cultural cause, we designed a research process begins from both spacial and spiritual aspects . After these two subjects were independently developed and came to their own conclusion, we emerged the result and thereby formed our opinion toward the coastal spaces of Taiwan.
A diagram as our conclusion of the Taiwanese attitudes toward the ocean that caused the problems of our coastal spaces.
A Key Word helped us to fucus: the Mazu goddess
Four Taiwanese characteristics Information about hundreds of Induce about the ocean Search from the internet different subjects Three Taiwanese attitudes toward ocean documenting in the field Images of about 200 different locations on the coast line organization built the possible relations between places identify special phenomena
13 full stories to explain our point of view some on-going projects which may make difference about our current problems
In order to document the spatial characters of Taiwanese coastline, the phenomenon of detached, isolated, misused, deserted or unrespectfully treated waterfront, and find out, the cultural and social reasons behind thes e scenes, we designed the structure shown at the right: A research starts from both the field (spatial quality) and the internet (social and cultural back ground).
Exhibition Site
A Key Word helped us to fucus: the Mazu goddess Four Taiwanese characteristics about the ocean Three Taiwanese attitudes toward ocean
The future
During our research, we read/analyzed a huge amount of data about Mazu and came up with several facts:
1.Thr worship of Mazu has a hidden cultural signification. The majority of Taiwanese were Chinese immigrants, and, as old descriptions of the casualties of migration from China to Taiwan: seven arrive, two die and one returns among ten, the ocean was dreadful to our ancestors, as a result, Mazu, who was originally a fishermans daughter who saved her own family and many others from shipwrecks, became the most important idol among the migrants. The fears of the sea passed down through generations and so did the worship of Mazu. 2. Successive political regimes attitudes towards Mazu cult and manners of dealing with it have mostly been respectful, which can, grab the people and take advantage of the social structure and human resources already set up by the cult. These regimes viewed Taiwan mostly as their colony, refuge or outpost and have the correct knowledge about how unwilling Taiwanese people would be to change their lifestyle. Centuries of uncertainty in politics evoked unique desire of stability among people, and, eventually, cultivated a relatively conservative society. Unlike most islanders around the world, our ancestors had less interest in voyaging, trading and exploring. 3. Several times in the history, Taiwan experienced different levels of blockage policies intended to keep the people from the ocean. Even till mid 20th century, the Taiwanese government still keep most of its coast line under strict military regulations in order to prevent possible attacks from China. 4. The belief of Mazu expended across Taiwan in an interesting pattern -the temples are related with each others as mothers and daughters. Ttracing the family trees of Mazu temples we managed to understand the pattern in which early immigrants developed their communities. Instead of growing alone the sea like other cultures might prefer, almost all Chinese immigrants went directly into land. Apparently, villages at the water front were just temporary stops rather than destinations to them. These people were farmers, the wanted land far more then sea. 5. Mazus transformation from goddess for going out to sea to Goddess for crossing the ocean to main deity and even on to goddess for protecting the realms, goddess of agriculture, goddess of getting into school reflects the reality of social changes and different needs of people. People slowly freed themselves from the primal fears and began the search of further stability.
continental character
over-sea immigration
Four main Taiwanese characteristics and three attitudes toward the sea:
After inducing the facts that were mentioned above(and many other information that werent shown here),we came up with a conclusion of four main characteristics: 1.Original alienation from the ocean 2.Inclination of Searching for temporary stability 3.Discontent with the status quo (the desire of expansion toward the sea but still view it as a substitute of land) 4.A continental oceanic character is our best description of present Taiwanese attitude toward sea Other these four characteristics, Taiwanese also have three unique attitudes about ocean: 1.The policies of obstruction toward the sea. 2.Agricultural use of the sea 3.Diverse crossing over the lines of obstruction, which, is the most important spacial phenomenon at the coast line. (See the next page for further explanation.)
The diagram at the right is our diagnose of Taiwanese continental oceanic character and how this character evolved through time.
A Key Word helped us to fucus: the Mazu goddess Four Taiwanese characteristics about the ocean Three Taiwanese attitudes toward ocean
Tourism:
Taiwanese people have a interesting thought about tourism: to use it as a promotion of local industry, to make their products sold better, or to bring fortune to local people. Most of these tourism are poorly planed and ends up fail because the tourist attractions are hardly attractive and the scenes are not delightful at all. The attitude of treating the sea as nowhere for decades has seriously damaged the possibilities for these spots to develop into a tourist site. continental character A continental oceanic character Diverse crossing over the lines of obstruction
over-sea immigration
Images of about 200 different locations on the coast line organization built the possible relations between places identify special phenomena Our conclusion of Taiwanese spacial phenomena at the coast :
Aquaculture
Fish port :
We have a lot fish ports and many of them are empty. politics liked to build fish ports as their achievement of their career, so.....
Industrial
Tourism/aqua culture
03 This area was full of salt pans and people are kept away from shore by inconvenience. After the salt pans are no longer required, they tried to introduce salt-industrial tourism into the area. Facilities were built. The business of tourism is not quite successful but people from near-by finally start doing low budget recreations here.
Induatrial
01
01
Tourism
01 0203 02 The island of wastes 02 03 03 This area is a massive lagoon once used as a military airport of hydroplanes that no civilians were allowed to go near. After the airport was abandoned, the locals found that its a perfect place of aquaculture - a massive lagoon with nobody around. The aquaculture here was so prosper that it seriously pollute the area and even formed a island of wastes. Now even the aquaculture business was gone. The government tried to change the lagoon into a tourist attraction for both the original beauty of the lagoon and the unique scene of the island of wastes. The visitors are few. 02
Aquaculture
01
03 02,03: The government set up fences and wires to keep people from the shore, but a surfing club ignores the fences, cut the wire and is running business of surfing lessons
Images of about 200 different locations on the coast line organization built the possible relations between places identify special phenomena
23N 120E
Industrial zone of No.6 Naphtha Plant: The government sold the 9km coastline for 25,000,000,000NT$/per year Industrial park Fishing port Industrial zone No.6 NCP. reclaimed land from sea. For the inhabitants, 001 9km of coast, where they used to fish along, was gone, and, for the 002 government, tax revenue increases NTD 25 billion every year. Local fishermen protested hard against the industrial zone, and, the NCP Temporary Temporary promised to build tourism facilities to increase income for local fishermen, fishing fishing however, no visitor ever came. Eventually, the fishermen have to find port port somewhere else to make there living. Tourism ?? 003 004
Industrial Zone
Bamboo rafts
Fighting for water against the earth Dong-shi township excessively pumped the groundwater for aquaculture and caused ground subsidence. In the yearly typhoon season, the sea water flowed back ward and washed away great amount of soil. The water break needed to be heighten every year.001 The inhabitants sit in their sinking homes and keep pumping water as their only way to make their living. The problem is not yet solved. The diagrams at the right shows how land subsidence got worse 004 by marking the areas in red circles.
002
003
Materials shown at the site of 2nd IABR, 2005 The contour of Taiwan defined Industrial profits and natural resources:
After our research, we found explanations of the strange phenomena around Taiwan such as the diverse crossing over the line of obstruction, agricultural use of the sea, special ideas of tourism, empty fish ports, and so on. Also, we studied the cultural background of Taiwanese attitudes toward ocean and concluded that it is a continental oceanic character At the end of our research, we came up with a full diagnose of Taiwanese coastal spaces, sorted the issues into 5 different types according to the most evident conflict that caused most the problems -the conflict between profit and natural environment. Hopefully, we wish this diagram can simplify our problems in Taiwan and help us to fix our coastal spaces in the future. C CD
005
006
DB
BA
AE
ED
DC
CD
+ Profit of transportation
+ Profit of tourism
+ Profit of industries
+ Natural resources -
LanYang River,YiLan
KaoShiung harbor
TungShih, ChiaYi
TaiChung harbor
KuanTu, Taipei
Taipei
Erchung floodway
Taipei juice:
Brain storming:
To bring up bold, unprecedented and experimental design to Shezi Isle, I asked my two team members for unusual ideas: anything about water, without any boundary, as long as it is wild. Here are 11 of these ideas.
When you have apples in water, it could be just apples in water, or apple juice. When you have Taipei in water, it could be just Taipei in water, or Taipei juice.
Use water as an important element in our architecture. Protect our safety by high rise buildings, waterproof cubes and pipes.
Use porous underwater structures to keep everything safe and pleasant above the surface.
City River
Pump the flood to higher ground and we will have plenty supply of all water we need.
Build the entire city a few meters above the ground using mega-structures.
We can surrender our city to flood whenever it comes. All we need are emergency exits.
Simply keep the flood out of our waterproof buildings. We may also have lovely lake views that way.
Simple(Earlier)
2
0.Drawing the family tree of ideas
Complicated(Later)
Issues:
Make people close to water Solve the problem of water supply
Create more space in which people may have fun with water Keep water resource within the city instead of in distant reservoirs
Something we MIXED with water Create more space for both river and people Something for SAFETY
Secure our supply and traffic system Share cubage in a 3D manner with river. Secure supply and traffic systems in waterproof pipes
Waters Position
Citizens Position
2. Outlining important feathers of our future design 3 . Tracing down the family treefor proper concept for our design. 4 .Identifying key elements and transforming them into architectural thoughts
Cubes: We can build our city with different kinds of cubes: waterproof boxes, permeable and semi-permeable structures, floating decks and others. Thereby, we can create interesting spaces interacting with water.
objects uncontrollable by men but affected by water objects operated by men that help controlling water floating deck open space waterproof hyaloid box waterproof box permeable solid
Pipes: Pipes ensure the safety of the traffic and supplying systems, protect
important buildings and any other things cant be secured by waterproof boxes.
3.
Towers, landscapes and main streets
High rise buildings stand out from surface, huge pipes connect to other areas of the city, Living spaces at lower levels mix with water.
4.
5. Our basic proposal of Shezi Isle
waterproof pipes
permeable
saturated
solid
30m
10m 0m
wet
dry
5.
pipes
Cubes
Drawn form the previous page: Create more space in which people may have fun with water. Keep water resource within the city instead of in distant reservoirs. Share cubage in a 3D manner with river. Secure supply and traffic systems in waterproof pipes. Drawn from facts mentioned above: Control the water level of Taipei City during floods. C ollect and connect the snippets into a complete experience of water.
Reserving water recourse: The reservoir Fei-Tsui has a capacity of 327,000,000(m3), support 3,280,000(m3)/day of water to Taipei. Our project can produce 250,000 (m3)/day Controlling flood The total area of the rivers in Taipei is 45,662,600(m2); The alarm height of water level is 6.7(m). Total amount of the flood is 305,939,420(m3) After our project built, it is going to contain up to 19,804,085(m3) of flood, lower Taipeis water level up to 0.4~1(m) during the flood. Create a water community for inhabitation, commercial use and recreation. Water and People live here happily forever after
Commercial: We are doing water as a fashion in the site. It encourage people consume for the Water-style and support the town financially. Town center: To create amazing land marks, new and fresh impression divided from old Water-cities like Venice Parking: We recommend visitors to park here and walk through the town and perhaps to try Boating . Water sports: Water sport is something you can hardly found in north Taiwan.
Programs
Residential Area:
This is how we picture the inhabitation area outside the town center. By the water, open to the water, and changes when the tides go up and down.
Recreational
At the outer area of the site, the pipes will be reconstructed with the remains of old Shezi embarkment and form a new kind of landscape. Most of the open spaces will be preserved as everglades, only minimum activities allowed.
Pipe system:
Drive ways, metro systems, walking passages, parking spaces and boats can be arranged in the pipe system.
The Site:
I chose to remodel the CKS Memorial Hall in Taipei City for its current layout and building style is a perfect example of a combination of Confucianism and Legalists Thoughts. The building complex of CKS memorial hall is relatively boring, however, it has this huge piazza at the center of Taipei where all kinds of debates and protests take place. Its the perfect site for this practice.
layouts:
Before doing the individual buildings, Ill have to start with a proper layout to coordinate all ten thoughts within one site. To do that, I tried to do layouts of different thoughts.
Mohists layout: Mohists are strict socialists, ascetics and rationalists. The are against all hierarchy in the society, and, they also hate music, social protocols and rituals. In Mohists layout, they eliminate the axis pointing to presidential palace and turn the building to face Taipei main station -the true center of Taipei. Also the CKS Memorial Hall will be gone for sure along with the opera house and the concert hall -Mohists dont need those. They might remodel them into more pragmatic uses.
Confucianism
Agriculturists
Legalists layout: Legalists are people developing efficient ways for emperors to control their people and strengthen the their empires. They managed three was to control people: 1.laws and punishments / 2.techniques of using political power / 3. threatening prestige. These are perfect monument builders. Basically, they would agree with Confucianists monument because the hierarchy behind the orders and forms of confucianists monuments remind people the political power of the government.
Legalists
Feng-Shui
Philosophic Taoism
Strategists
Mohists
Naturalists
How ever, there are other ways to control the huge piazza around a threatening monuments such as 1.colonnades (like those in Vatican,) / 2.patterns in strict orders, / 3.messive towers at corners and entrances, / 4.sunken squares. Legalists like all proper layouts as long as they have the affect legalists want on the public, and, big is good, huge is better.
Opera House
Current layout: It is a classic layout of Chinese palaces combining Confucinism and Legalists. It has an axis pointing to the presidential palace; on the far side of the axis lies the major building. Other buildings are put symmetrically on both sides of the axis when buildings nearer to the main hall and buildings at the left (viewing from the main hall) be considered as more important. Confucinism and Legalists have a hierarchy for not only people, but also buildings and the specific form they are allowed to use,
Confucianism: At the left is the classic layout of She-Ji, the place emperors offer sacrifices to ancestors, and the order of buildings. The perfect number of Chinese cities and palaces is 3, 9 and the squares or multiplications of these numbers. The diagram of an ideal city of Confucianism is shown bellow.
Taoism: (Philosophic Taoism, not Religious Taoism) People believe in Taoism observe and follow Tao, the way in which the universe create and run itself. Taoists will never like the idea of massive memorial buildings, although they wont fight hard against them. The only right way to do Taoism memorial is to do nothing at all and let the city grow in its own reasonable way. And, the alternative ways are: 1.patch works of city context. / 2.something subtle implies the existence of Tao.
The Art of War: These are people who study military strategies hoping to end the war. Their thoughts have been proved useful at all kinds of wars: military, business, international issues, ...etc.. Although it is not about architecture, I derived a concept of use as little volume as possible to control the site and effect the surrounding as well. In my thought, the most important spot of the site is the traffic circle at the left -it controls the road from presidential palace and train station. Having control of that ring first and two other traffic rings next to it equal to have control of the heart of Taipei. After that, secure the traffic within these rings and build a outpost to support these spots, and, thereby control the whole site and the heart of Taipei as well.
All together:
All together, and, it will look like this. to coordinate, I parallel the layouts of different thoughts to the ancient relationship of the philosophers whenever to solve the conflict: 1. Confucianism never yielded to Taoism 2. Confucianists and Moists never compromised to each other. 3. Confucianists worked with Legalists 4. Confucianism never yielded to military strategies. 5. Taoism never bothered arguing with anybody. 6. All philosophers respect (or learn from) Taoism. 7. Moists never yielded to Legalists. 8. Moists fought at battle fields against military commanders. 9. Legalists respect and learn from the art of war. 10 Military commanders took advantage from all philosophers. 11.Dialecticians caused no effect on anybody. 12.Agriculturists worked with Moists. 13.Stratagists observed and used anything available. 14.Stratagists tried hard to get notice. After adjusting the layouts by above mentioned principals, I did the master plane of all ten thoughts as shown in previous page.
Moists:
After the over all lay-out, I looked into spatial precedents in the history and start to discuss and develop different forms of individual buildings that represent each philosophy.
Confucianism: To represent Confucianism in architectural design, I applied two of the most important features in traditional architecture in Confucianism: 1. the perfect form in Confucianism. / 2.the hierarchy of spaces. 1. The perfect form: In Confucianism, the perfect form is circle, which, can only used in honoring the heaven itself. Even gods and emperors cant use round shaped buildings. Instead of circles, The lower left are classical planes of Ming-Tang, the main hall in which emperors met their ministers and generals. These planes suggest the second-best form should be a square with 4 smaller squares at its corners. The CKS Memorial Hall is also using the same shape.
Since Mohists are strict socialists, ascetics and rationalists. Who are interested in technologies, mechanics and all useful knowledge, I made an assumption that their buildings might be produced in mass production in factories using recycled materials and can easily be disassembled, and relocated.
Confucianism
Agriculturists
Legalists
Feng-Shui
Philosophic Taoism
In temples of Confucius there are usually walls blocking the main gate which imply the world will have to cross a huge obstacle to reach Confuciuss wisdom. Although this is not necessary in other Confucianism buildings, I still decided to have this wall here in honor of Confucius.
Strategists
Mohists
Naturalists
The hierarchy system: In Chinese palaces they verified the sizes of gates and the depth/height of scenes behind the gates according to the hierarchy system of Confucianism. The visitors can feel the importance of particular buildings by sense of scale without further information.
Opera House
The Cave
The Island
Taoism: The Valley Spirit never dies. It is called the mystic female. The door of the mystic female is the root of heaven and earth. Being interminable and seeming to endure, It can be used with toil There is a thing formed in chaos existing before Heaven and Earth. Silent and solitary, it stands alone, unchanging. It goes around without peril. It may be the Mother of the world. Not knowing its name, I can only style it Tao. With reluctance, I would call it Great. Great means out-going. Out-going means farreaching. Far-reaching means returning. Therefore, Tao is great. Heaven is great. Earth is great. Mankind is great. There are four greats in the universe and men are one of them. Man abides by earth, earth abides by heaven, heaven abides by Tao, and, Tao goes as its nature. -Lao Tzu. To represent the Taoism observation of our universe and the concept of Tao, I started with the places considered by Taoism priests as the best place to observe Tao: caves and islands. In the famous icon of Yin-Yang, there is black spot at the center of white and a white spot at the center of black. This is where the concept of caves and islands came from -a tiny piece of Yin within Yang, and a tiny piece of Yang within Yin. As a representation of the shape of Tao, my design have to be also representing Island and cave within a mixture of a mystic form.
The island
The interior To speculate the shape of Tao, I first studied the Taoism model of universe :
The Gate of the Mystic Female World Mountain (Kun-Lun) Finally, the world we live in Then, the Earth The Cave
The Island
The Taoism model of universe came from ancient folk religions in China, which, were religions based on the worship of the North Star. In general belief, there is a world mountain surrounded by sea which is located directly under the North Star -at the axis of universe. The world in which we live itself is an Island. Considering the obvious preference about depth, profundity, vacancy and circulation, the true spirit of Taoism should lies in the vacancy instead solidity. The cave under the world mountain is the holy place of Taoism. Therefore, I decided that the shape represent the way in which Tao runs itself is somehow like a torus or a bagel as demonstrated at the left.
Confucianism
Agriculturists
Legalists
Feng-Shui
Philosophic Taoism
Strategists
Mohists
Naturalists
Opera House
The different viewing angle produced by different height and the shape of the interface.
The Legalists: My design of the Legalists buildings is a combination of representation of: 1.laws, regulations and orders / 2.techniques of using political power / 3. threatening prestige. At the ground level of the main hall, I tried to create fearsome space with scale, lighting and stairs. At the upper part of the building, I designed a crooked passage to demonstrate the crooked sides in the use of political power. At the colonnade, I used the triangular columns to create difference angles of sight so that the people inside can see a wilder range than those from out side. At other areas I experimented the effects of differences height levels, viewing angles, scales and lightings.
Confucianism
Agriculturists
The agriculturists: Since the agriculturists worked with Moists and share same views about art and architecture, I designed the agriculturists building the same way of Moists.
Legalists
Feng-Shui
Philosophic Taoism
The Art of War : (The military commanders) The Art of War was basically Taoism practice on battle field, which, eventually developed its own theories such as its unique explanation about regular strategies and odd strategies. The odd and regular relates to each other like both sides on a Mobius Strip: one comes to existence when the other goes beyond its reach. I designed the building of Military Commanders by rapidly changing shapes and blur the boundary between its interior and exterior. The Strategists: The strategists were people selling strategies to political powers. They basically worked like the military commanders. I designed the Strategists building the same style as Military Commanders. Only at the most noticeable spot in site.
Strategists
Mohists
Naturalists
Opera House
The Naturalists The Naturalists were originated from Taoism and are believed as teachers of many important military commanders and strategists. The knowledge of Naturalists are broad and here I only chose to represent the famous theory of five basic elements that formed the universe: metal, wood, water, fire and earth.