Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 1 of 44
Desc
4 WINTHROP COUCHOT
PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
5 660 Newport Center Drive, Fourth Floor Newport Beach, CA 92660
6 Telephone: (949) 720-4100
Facsimile: (949) 720-4111
Eve A. Marsella, Esq. (CA Bar No. 165797) 10 CLARKSON, GORE & MARSELLA, APLC
3424 Carson Street, Suite 350
12 Facsimile: 310/214-7254
Email: sclarkson@lawcgm.com
13
In re:
19
Chaptcr 11 Proceeding
20
21
Debtor and
Debtor- i n- Possession.
22
23
DEBTOR'S AND COMMITTEE'S JOINT MOTION FOR ORDER APPROVING NONMATERIAL MODIFICATIONS TO DEBTOR'S AND COMMITTEE'S JOINT THIRD AMENDED CHAPTER 11 PLAN; MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES AND DECLARATION OF ROBERT E. OPERA IN SUPPORT THEREOF
(11 U.S.c. 1127(a); Fed. R. Bank. P. 3019(a)J
24
25
26 27
28
Courtroom 5A
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 2 of 44
Desc
3 MTI Technology Corporation, the debtor and debtor-in-possession ("Debtor"), and the
4 Official Committee of
5 Proponents") hereby jointly move the Court for an order granting to them the following relief:
6
7
8
1.
Debtor's and Committee's Joint Third Amended Chapter 11 Plan ("Third Amended Plan"), which modifications have been incorporated into the Plan Proponents' proposed Joint Fourth Amended Chapter 11 PIan (the "Fourth Amended Plan"), filed concurrently
herewith by the PIan Proponents;
2.
9 10
11
Finding that such modifications to the Third Amended Plan do not affect
the Claim of any Creditor or the Interest of any Interest Holder
12
13
14
15
Ordering that the modifications to the Third Amended Plan are deemed
accepted by all Creditors who already have accepted the Third Amended Plan; and
4.
16
Such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper.
17 This Motion is made pursuant to section 1127(a) ofthe Bankrptcy Code and Rule 3019(a)
18 of the Federal Rules of
20 Amended Plan filed concurrently herewith, all pleadings, papers, and documents on fie in this
21 III
22
23
24
25
26
27
i Unless otherwise defined herein, the definitions of
28
the capitalized term set forth herein are as set forth in the Fourth
Amended Plan.
-2MAINDOCS-li
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 3 of 44
Desc
1 case, and upon any such other evidence, both oral and documentary, as may be presented to the
WINTHROP COUCHOT
4
5
BY:~~
PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION
Robert E. Opera Richard H. Golubow
Counsel for the Official Committee of
6 7 8 9
Unsecured
Creditors
10
11
12 13
14
15
16 17 18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26 27 28
-3MAINDOCS-#149892-v I-MTI_ MtiiReApprovalNonMalerialModToPlan.DOC
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 4 of 44
Desc
2 BACKGROUND I. 3
4 A. The Debtor's Case.
5 When the Debtor operated, the Debtor was a global provider of end-to-end information
6 infrastructure solutions and had strategic technology and service relationships with industry
7 leaders, including EMC Corporation ("EMC"), Microsoft, VMWare, Symantec and Cisco. The
8 Debtor's revenues for its fiscal year 2006 exceeded $135.0 million.
9 In 2007, the Debtor experienced substantial cash flow difficulties which made its
10 continued business operations impossible. The Debtor was compelled to file, on October 15,
12 Since the Petition Date, the Debtor has liquidated its operating assets for the benefit of
13 Creditors. The Debtor sold its interests in its European subsidiaries for an aggregate amount of
14 $7,275,000, permitting it to satisfy its obligations to its primary secured creditors. The Debtor
15 also sold various assets located in the United States, including the following: the assets
16 associated with the Debtor's "Collective" information technology services division, formerly
17 located in Austin, Texas; excess furniture, fixtures and equipment; and certain assets associated
18 with the Debtor's "Legacy Hardware." Moreover, the Debtor has acted diligently to collect its
19 accounts receivable.
20 In addition to the Debtor's liquidation of
23 $120,000 that was paid to Wells Fargo as a penalty demanded by Wells Fargo for an
24 early termination of
26 Canopy Group, Tnc_ ("Canopy"), the Committee was able to recover for the benefit of
27 Creditors approximately $3,500,000 against which Canopy had asserted a secured claim.
28
-4MAINDOC S-L i 49892-v
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 5 of 44
Desc
litigation that the Debtor had filed against EMC pursuant to which
3 settlement EMC paid to the Debtor $1,900,000 cash, and EMC waived and released its
4 Administrative Claim against the Debtor, asserted to be in an amount of approximately
5 $578,649, and EMC waived and released its General Unsecured Claims against the
6 Debtor, asserted to be in an aggregate amount of
approximately $4,464,523.
the Estate
8 preference litigation. The Debtor also has pursued preference litigation. The Committee
9 and the Debtor have recovered to date approximately $90,000 for the estate and
12 which the Debtor anticipates will result in a significant recovery by the estate.
13 6. Pencom Parties. On October 14,2009, the Committee filed a complaint
14 against Pencom Systems, Inc., Edgar Saadi, Wade Saadi and Edward Ateyeh
18 reached a preliminary settlement of such litigation and are in the process of documenting
19 such settlement.
20 In addition to the efforts that the Debtor and the Committee have made and are making
21 to recover value for the benefit of Creditors, in order to reduce the amount of claims against the
22 estate, the Debtor has filed objections to Disputed Claims. The Debtor estimates that, by such
23 claims objections, the Debtor has been able to have disallowed in excess of $15.0 millon in
24 Disputed Claims, exclusive ofEMC's Administrative Claim and General Unsecured Claims
25 disallowed pursuant to the Debtor's settlement with EMC and any Disputed Claims disallowed
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 6 of 44
Desc
5 On June 10,2010, the Court entered the Disclosure Statement Order, approving the Disclosure
6 Statement as containing "adequate information" in accordance with the provisions of
7 section 1125 of
the Bankruptcy Code, and authorizing the Plan Proponents to solicit votes with
10 approximately 97% of
the Third
13 Amended Plan_
17 States Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") fied its Objection of U.S. Securities
18 Exchange Commission to Confirmation of
19 Chapter 11 Plan ("SEC Plan Objection"). The Plan Proponents now have been able to resolve
22 amendments to the Third Amended Plan in order to clarify the treatment of the Canopy
23 Claim pursuant to the Plan (Class 4 under the Plan). These amendments to the Third
24 Amended Plan merely acknowledge Canopy's rights pursuant to the Canopy Agreement
25 (Exhibit "I" to the Third Amended Plan), do not change in any manner the treatment of
26 Canopy's rights or interests under the Canopy Agreement or under the Third Amended
27 Plan, are not substantive in nature and do not affect the rights and interests of any other
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 7 of 44
Desc
i 2. SEC. By the SEC Plan Objection, the SEC raised two primary concerns
2 with respect to the confirmation of the Third Amended Plan -- the provisions of the Third
3 Amended Plan providing for the possibility of a Merger Transaction could be contrary to
4 public policy, and certain exculpatory provisions provided in the Third Amended Plan
5 for the benefit of
the Debtor, the Committee, their successors under the Third Amended
6 Plan, and their Representatives and Professionals are overly broad. The Plan Proponents
7 worked with the SEC to resolve the SEC Plan Objection, and agreed to amend the Third
8 Amended Plan in order to address the SEC's concerns. By reason ofthe amendments
9 that the Plan Proponents have made to the Third Amended Plan, incorporated into the
10 Fourth Amended Plan, the SEC has agreed to withdraw the SEC Plan Objection.
11 By reason ofthe foregoing, subject to the Court's approval of
15 In order to effectuate the settlements reached with Canopy and with the SEC, the Plan
16 Proponents hereby request that this Court authorize them to modify the Third Amended Plan in
17 order to incorporate the agreed-upon clarifications of the treatment of
18 make the amendments to the Third Amended Plan requested by the SEC. The Plan Proponents
19 hereby also request that this Court authorize them to modify the Third Amended Plan in order to
20 make certain other non-substantive modifications to the Third Amended Plan for the purpose of
21 clarifying the provisions ofthe Third Amended Plan. The Fourth Amended Plan, incorporating
22 such proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan, is filed concurrently herewith, and a
23 "redlined" version of
the Fourth Amended Plan, reflecting the modifications made to the Third
27 Plan do not affect adversely the interests of Creditors pursuant to the Third Amended Plan.
28
-7MAINDOCS-#149892-vl-MTI_ MtnReApprovalNonMateria lMoToPlan.DOC
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 8 of 44
Desc
The proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan will resolve the objection to the
Third Amended Plan asserted by Canopy and by the SEC. Approval of
2
3
eliminate the objections asscrted with respect to thc Third Amended Plan, and, accordingly, will
facilitate the confirmation of the Fourth Amended Plan, for the benefit of
4
5
Creditors.
Subject to the Court's granting this Motion, there wil be !! objections to the
6
7 8 9
Moreover, the Fourth Amended Plan wil have been accepted by each Class of Claims that
has cast a vote with respect to the Third Amended Plan. The votes cast with respect to the
confirmation of the Third Amended Plan are overwhelmingly in support of the
10
11
confirmation of the Third Amended Plan. All of the major Creditor constituents in the
Debtor's Case support the confirmation ofthe Fourth Amended Plan.2
Confirmation of
12
13
Fourth Amended Plan provides that Allowed Administrative Claims, Allowed Priority Tax
Claims and Allowed Priority Non- Tax Claims will be paid in fulL. Confirmation ofthe Fourth
14
15
Amended Plan wil produce for holders of Allowed General Unsecured Claims the most
favorable recovery on their Allowed Claims as is possible under the circumstances of
16 17 18 19
this Case,
and the Fourth Amended Plan is supported by the Committee and has been approved
overwhelmingly by the holders of Allowed General Unsecured Claims.
II.
20
21
22 23
24
25
2 The Class ofInterests established by the Third Amended Plan (Class 6) very likely will neither receive nor retain any
26 27
28
value under the Third Amended Plan. Therefore, in accordance with the provisions of section II 29(g) of the Bankptcy Code, the Class of Interests established by the Third Amended Plan is deemed to have rejected the Third Amended Plan. As is demonstrated by that Commttee's and Debtor's Brief in Support of Confirmation of Joint Fourth Amended Chapter 11 Plan filed concurrently herewith by the Plan Proponents, the Fourth Amended Plan meets
all of the requirements for confirmation under section I 129(a) of
because the Class ofInterests is deemed to have rejected the Fourth Amended Plan, and the Fourth Amended Plan satisfies all of the requirements for "cram down" under section I 1 29(b) of the Bankmptcy Code with respect to the Class of Interests.
-8MA1NDOCS-# 149892-vl-MTI_ MtnReApprovalNonMaterialModToPlan DOC
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 9 of 44
Desc
2
3
(a) The proponcnt of a plan may modify such plan at any time before confirmation, but may not modify such plan so that such plan as modified fails to meet the requirements of sections 1122 and 1123 ofthis title. After the proponent of a plan fies a modification of such plan with the court, the plan as modified
becomes the plan.
* * *
4
5
6
7
8
(d) Any holder of a claim or interest that has accepted or rejected a plan is deemed to have accepted or rejected, as the case may be, such plan as modified, unless, within the time fixed by the court, such holder changes such holder's previous acceptance or rejection.
11 U.S.C. 1127(a) and (d).
Rule 3019 of the Federal Rules of
In a chapter 9 or chapter 11 case, after a plan has been accepted and before
10
11
its confirmation, the proponent may fie a modification of the plan. If
the court
finds after hearing on notice to the trustee, any committee appointed under the Code, and any other entity designated by the court that the proposed modifcation
12
13
does not adversely change the treatment of the claim of any creditor or the
interest of any equity security holder who has not accepted in writing the modification, it shall be deemed accepted by all creditors and equity security holders who have previously accepted the plan.
Rule 3019(a)(emphasis added).
14
15
17
proposed modifications to a plan may be approved without any need for revoting on the plan;
18
notice and an opportunity to revote on the plan are applicable only as to any creditor for whom the
19
proposed modifications of the plan "adversely change the treatment of
20
21
proposed modifications to the plan are not adverse as to a creditor, then any prior acceptance of
the plan by that creditor is a deemed acceptance of the plan, as modified. As stated in Norton
22
24
25
(IJfthe court, after hearing on notice to the trustee and appointed committees, if any, and others designated by the court, concludes that a proposed modification does not "adversely change thc treatment of the claim of any creditor
or the interest of any equity security holder," there is no need for setting a time
26
27
28
within which to reject or give any notice thereof. Instead, this finding under the Bankruptcy Rules results in a "deemed acceptance" ofthe plan as
modified by the creditors and equity security holders who previously
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 10 of 44
Desc
2
3
(ei ourts do not require notice of a modification if the modifcation does not adversely change a claimant's treatment. To enforce a literal interpretation of the Code and require formalistic notice when the modifcations are not substantial would needlessly delay confirmation and
heighten the risk of a plan's failure.
4
5
By this Motion, the Plan Proponents seek from this Court an order authorizing them to
6 7
8
modify the Third Amended Plan in order to incorporate the modifications to the Third Amended
Plan upon which the Plan Proponents and Canopy have agreed and to incorporate the
modifications to the Third Amended Plan upon which the Plan Proponents and the SEC have
agreed, and to make certain other non-substantive modifications to the Third Amended Plan in
9
10
11
order to clarify the provisions of the Third Amended Plan. All of such proposed modifications to
the Third Amended Plan either enhance the interests of Creditors, or do not affect adversely the
12
13
interests of Creditors pursuant to the Third Amended Plan. Similarly, all of such proposed
modifications of the Third Amended Plan do not affect adversely the Interests of Interest Holders
pursuant to the Third Amended Plan.
14
15
A discussion of each of the modifications proposed to be made to the Third Amended Plan,
and the effect of each such modification on the interests of Creditors, follows immediately below.
16 17 18
PROPOSED MODIFICATION
TO THE THIRD
AMENDED PLAN
1. Section 2.1.62 - Clarifies that the Canopy Claim is not a General
19
20
21
Unsecured Claim.
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 11 of 44
Desc
2
3
OF PROPOSED MODIFICATION
EFFECT
4
5
6.6.2 and 6.8.3 -- Clarfy that the Plan Assets will be revested in the
Reorganized Debtor, but wil be
6 7
8
administered by the Plan Agent in accordance with the terms and conditions of the Plan.
9
3. Scctions 2.1.82 and 6.8.1 -
10
11
Clarify that any Distribution to be made under the Plan on account of the Canopy Claim wil be paid from
the Plan Fund.
12
13
14
15
16 17
18
the United States Trustee Fees will be paid from the Plan Fund.
19
20
21
5. Sections 6.6, 6.8.2, 6.11, 6.13,
6.14,9.1, 9.2 - Clarify
the Third
22
23
24
25
26
6. Section 6.16 - Adds Canopy as
27
28
Canopy merely is added as a party that is entitled to post-confirmation matters in the Case as a "Post-Effective Date Notice Party."
-11MAINDOCS-# 149892-vl-MTl_:vtneApprovaINonMateria lModToPlan.DOC
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 12 of 44
Desc
2
3
OF PROPOSED MODIFICATION
EFFECT
4
5
6
7 8 9
6.18.7.1,6.18.7.2 - Adds language to address the SEC's concerns about any Merger Transaction after the Effective Date of the Third Amended Plan.
10
11
12
13
Proponents' agreement with the SEC, the Plan Proponents propose to modify Section 6.18.4 as follows: (i) to provide expressly that the Plan Agent must give to the SEC notice of any proposed Merger Transaction; and (ii) to provide that the Plan Agent will have the burden of demonstrating to the Court that any such Merger Transaction is in the best interests of holders of Allowed General Unsecured Claims and that any such Merger Transaction is in compliance with thc laws, rules and regulations with respect to the issuance
of securities, as set forth in Section 6.18.7 of
the Fourth
14
15
Amended Plan.
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
A new Section 6.18.7 has been added to the Fourth Amended Plan, setting forth restrictions on the effectuation of any proposed Merger Transaction. Section 6.18.7 provides that the Reorganizcd Debtor will not issue any securities pursuant to the Plan unless: any such issuance of securities complies with the requirements of section 1145 of the Bankruptcy Code; or any such issuance of securities is either exempt from the registration requirements of the Securities Act, or is registered in accordance with the applicable rcquircments of the Securities Act. Section 6.18.7 provides further that the Reorganized Debtor will not consummate any Merger Transaction with a private
company unless: the Reorganized Debtor is current in
24
25
the consummation
26 27
28
of any such Merger Transaction; and any such Merger Transaction is consummated by the Reorganized Debtor in accordance with the requirements of the Securities Act, the Exchange Act, and all applicable rules and regulations promulgated by the SEC.
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 13 of 44
Desc
PROPOSED MODIFICATION
TO THE THIRD
EFFECT
OF
PROPOSED MODIFICATION
The proposed modifications to Section 6.18.4 of the
Third Amended Plan and the addition of
2 3
AMENDED PLAN
Section 6.18.7
4
5
6 7
8
to the Fourth Amended Plan do not affect adversely the interests of any Creditors. In essence, these proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan reflect only an agreement that any Court approval of any proposed Merger Transaction will be sought only after notice to the SEC, and that no Merger Transaction will be effectuated unless it is in compliance with applicable law, rules and regulations.
8. Sections 7.2.5 and 12.3 - Limit exculpatory provisions contained in the Third Amended Plan.
9
10
11
These proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan wil enhance the interests of Creditors, or wil have no effect on the interests of
Creditors. In accordance with the Plan Proponents'
12
13
agreement with the SEC, the Plan Proponents propose to modify the limitation ofliability provisions contained in Sections 7.2.5 and 12.3 of the Third Amended Plan to limit the scope of such provisions.
14 Thus, it is clear that the proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan either enhance
15 the interests of Creditors, or wil have no adverse effect on the treatment of Creditors under
16 the Third Amended Plan. Moreover, these proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan
17 will have no effect of any nature on the treatment ofthe Interests ofInterest Holders under the
18 Third Amended Plan_
19 Approval of
this Motion will eliminate the risks and costs associated with any protracted
20 confirmation dispute, will effectuate the agreements reached with the SEC and with Caropy, and
21 will facilitate greatly the confimiation of
~ CONCLUSION ~ 25
23 Debtor's Creditors.
27 or even at, a hearing on the confirmation of 28 of creditors. In fact, this is an integral part of
26 It is common for a debtor to make reasonable modifications to a Chapter 11 plan prior to,
the plan, in order to address and resolve the objections
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 14 of 44
Desc
1 Proponents propose to make modest, non-material modifications to the Third Amended Plan in
2 order to eliminate objections to the Third Amended Plan asserted by Canopy and by the SEC and
3 thereby obtain a fully consensual plan. The proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan
4 either enhance the interests of Creditors, or do not affect adversely the interests of Creditors, and
5 the proposed modifications have the support of the Debtor and the Committee. The Plan
6 Proponents respectfully submit that the relief sought herein is fair and is wholly appropriate and
7 should be authorized by this Court.
BY~'c9~
Creditors
12
13
o ert E. Opera Richard H. Golubow Counsel for the Official Committee ofUnsecuied
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-14MAl NDOCS-# 149892-v I-MTI _ MtnReApprovalNoiiMaterialModToPlan. DOC
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 15 of 44
Desc
4 counsel for the Official Committee of U nsecUfed Creditors in the Chapter 11 case of MTI
5 Technology Corporation ("Debtor"). The matters set forth herein are within my own personal
6 knowledge, and, if called upon as a witness, I could and would competently testify thereto.
7
2.
8 Motion for Order Approving Non-Material Modifications to Debtor's and Committee's Joint
9 Third Amended Chapter 11 Plan ("Plan Modification Motion")?
10 3.
No objections to the confirmation of
12 United States Securities and Exchange Commission ("SEC") filed its Objection of
4.
Canopy requested that the Plan Proponents make certain amendments to the Third
16 Amended Plan in order to clarify the treatment of the Canopy Claim pursuant to the Plan (Class 4
17 under the Plan). The Plan Proponents now have made amendments to the Third Amended Plan in
18 order to address Canopy's concerns, and such amendments to the Third Amended Plan have been
19 incorporated into the Fourth Amended Plan. Canopy's counsel has confirmed that, with such
20 amendments to the Third Amended Plan, as incorporated into the Fourth Amended Plan, Canopy
21 has no objection to the confirmation of
22
5.
By the SEC Plan Objection, the SEC raised two primary concerns with respect to
the Third Amended Plan -- the provisions of
23 the confirmation of
24 providing for the possibility of a Merger Transaction could be contrary to public policy, and
25 certain exculpatory provisions provided in the Third Amended Plan for the benefit of
the Debtor,
26 the Committee, their successors under the Third Amended Plan, and their Representatives and
27
3 Unless otherwise defined herein, the definitions of
28
the capitalized terms contained herein are as set forth in the Plan
Modification Motion.
-15MAOCS-l149892-v I-MTI _ MtnReApprovalNonMaterialModToPlanDOC
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 16 of 44
Desc
1 Professionals are overly broad. The Plan Proponents worked with the SEC to resolve the SEC
2 Plan Objection, and agreed to amend the Third Amended Plan in order to address the SEC's
3 concerns. By reason of
the amendments that the Plan Proponents have madc to the Third
4 Amended Plan, incorporated into the Fourth Amended Plan, the SEC has agreed to withdraw the
the Plan
7 Modification Motion, there will be at the Confirmation Hearing no pending objections to the
8 confirmation of
10 modifications to the Third Amended Plan, is filed concurrently herewith. A "redlined" version of
11 the Fourh Amended Plan, reflecting the proposed modifications to the Third Amended Plan, is
12 attached as Exhibit "A" hereto and is incorporated herein by this reference.
13
8.
Approval of
14
15
with the SEC and with Canopy to resolve their concerns regarding the Third Amended Plan and
thereby wil eliminate the risks and costs associated with any protracted confirmation dispute.
Accordingly, approval of the Plan Modification Motion wil facilitate the confirmation of
16 17 18 19
the
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
Executed this 5th day of August 2010, at Newport Beach, California.
20
21
r. .
/~~
Robert E. Opera
-16-
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 17 of 44
Desc
EXHIBIT "A"
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 18 of 44
Desc
2
3
Scott C. Clarkson, Esq. (CA Bar No. 143271) Eve A. Marsella, Esq. (CA Bar No. 165797) Clarkson, Gore & Marsella, APLC
3424 Carson Street, Suite 350
4
5
6 7
8
10
u .. Do
-i
'" '" "' '" 0: '" :E
11
.,
12
13
~
"' 0:
c.
c
~
'"
14
15
z"
" '"
16
17
18
In re
19
20
21
Debtor
22 23
Courroom 5A
24
25
Judge:
26 27
28
Exhibit A, Page 17
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 19 of 44
Desc
2
3
propose jointly this Joint Second Fourth Amended Chapter 11 Plan and request confirmation hereof
4
5
i.
INTRODUCTION
This Plan is proposed jointly by the Debtor and by the Committee for the resolution of the
Claims against the Estate.
6 7
8
Debtor. Pursuant to this Plan, the Allowed Claims of Creditors wil be paid in accordance with the
terms and conditions of
9
10 u .. ""
..
. .. ..
Sent to you in the same envelope as this Plan is the Debtor's Disclosure Statement. The
11
Disclosure Statement has been approved by the Bankptcy Court, and is being provided along
with this Plan in order to help you to understand this Plan and to evaluate the merits of this Plan.
The Disclosure Statement discusses, among other things, the Debtor's business, the results of
12
13
:;
Od "' '"
~ '" ~
the
l?
0
'" '" '"
14
15
Debtor's operations, the Debtor's assets and liabilities and the material terms of this Plan.
Creditors are encouraged to read the Disclosure Statement.
z 0
.. u
~
16 17
18
The objective of this Plan is to liquidate the Debtor's Assets for the benefit of Creditors and
make Distributions to the holders of Allowed Claims. By this Plan, the Reorganized Debtor will
continue in existence as appropriate to effectuate a Merger Transaction prior to the Merger Consummation Date, with any value obtained from any such Merger Transaction distributed to
holders of Allowed General Unsecured Claims in accordance with the terms and conditions of
19
20
21
this
Plan.
22
23
This Plan divides Creditors and Interest Holders into Classes based upon their respective legal rights and interests, and provides for the satisfaction of Allowed Claims in accordance with
the terms and conditions ofthis Plan. Interest Holders wil not receive or retain any value on
account of
24
25
their Interests, except as provided expressly to the contrary in Section 5.6 hereof.
26 27
28
2
i The definitions of the capitalized terms contained herein are set forth in Article II of
this Plan.
Exhibit A, Page 18
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 20 of 44
Desc
4
5
6 7
8
10 u ..
'"
11
..
.: ..
..
, 3
12
13
;; "
~ ~
~ j
, z
'" "
ti "
o ~
14
15
z
'" '"
;;
.. u
-(
16 17
18
CONSULT WITH ITS OWN LEGAL COUNSEL PRIOR TO VOTING ON THIS PLAN IN
ORDER TO ENSURE A COMPLETE UNDERSTANDING OF THE TERMS OF THIS
PLAN.
19
II.
20
21
22
23
terms), when used in this Plan, have the meanings set forth below.
2.1.1 "Administrative Claim" means a Claim for costs or expenses that are
allowable under sections 503(b) or 507(b) of
24
25
These costs or expenses may include: (a) actual, necessary costs and expenses of preserving
the Estate after the Petition Date; (b) Ordinary Course Administrative Claims; (c) Pre-Effective Date Professional Fee Claims; (d) Administrative Tax Claims; and
(e) United States Trustee Fees.
3
26 27
28
Exhibit A, Page 19
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 21 of 44
Desc
2.1.2 "Administrative Claims Bar Date" has the meaning set forth in
2
3
4
5
6 7
8
Claim, that a governental unit asserts against the Debtor for any tax period that, in whole
or in part, falls within the period commencing on the Petition Date and ending on the
Effective Date.
2.1.5 "Allowed Administrative Claim" means an Administrative Claim that is
9 10 u o0.
11
~ -:~ .. ..
;;
'"
12
13
based upon or arising from an entity's payment to the Debtor or Reorganized Debtor of a
:;
OI "' '"
-:
claim asserted against the entity pursuant to an Avoidance Action. Any Allowed Avoidance
Action Payment Claim shall be treated hereunder as a Class 3 Claim.
a
ui
a
..
'"
14
15
2.1.7 "Allowed Claim" means a Claim (a) that is listed in the Bankptcy
.. u
-:
16 17
18
Schedules filed with the Banptcy Court by the Debtor and not listed as disputed,
contingent, unliquidated or unkown as to amount and as to which no timely objection has
been filed; or (b) with respect to which a Proof of Claim has been fied by the Bar Date, and
as to which no objection is filed within the time period fixed by the Bankruptcy Code, the
19
20
21
Banptcy Rules, this Plan or by order of the Bankrptcy Court, or as to which any such
objection has been determined by a Final Order. The amount of an Allowed Claim shall be
as follows: (i) if thc Creditor did not fie a Proof of Claim with the Banptcy Court on or
22
23
before the Bar Datc, the amount of the Creditor's Claim as listed in the Bankptcy
Schedules as neither disputed, contingent, unliquidated or unkown; or (ii) if the Creditor
24
25
filed a Proof of Claim with the Bankptcy Cour on or before the Bar Date, (I) the amount
stated in such Proof of Claim if no objection to such Proof of Claim is filed within the time
26 27
28
period fixed by the Bankruptcy Code, the Bankptcy Rules, this Plan or by order of the
Bankuptcy Court, or (2) the amount thereof fixed by a Final Order of
4th_Amended_Ch_ll_PlanDOC
Exhibit A, Page 20
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 22 of 44
Desc
if an objection to such Proof of Claim is filed within the time period fixed by the
2
3
Banptcy Code, the Bankptcy Rules, this Plan or by order of the Banptcy Court.
Any Claim that is not filed by the Bar Date and that is listed in the Banptcy Schedules as
4
5
disputed, unliquidated, contingent or unkown, or that is not allowed under the terms of this
Plan, shall be disallowed, and no Distribution shall be made on account of such Claim. No
default interest or late charges or comparable fees, charges or penalties shall be included as
part of an Allowed Claim.
2.1.8 "Allowed Class '**' Claim" means an Allowed Claim classified in the
6
7
8
9 10 u ,. 0.
"' '" '" '"
specified Class.
2.1.9 "Allowed Deficiency Claim" means that portion of an Allowed Claim
11
that is in excess of the value of any Collateral which is security for the repayment of such
Claim, calculated in accordance with the provisions of section 506 of the Banptcy Code.
2.1.10 "Allowed General Unsecured Claim" means an unsecured Allowed
.. .. ..
12
13
::
d "' '"
:i 0
'" '" '"
14
15
Claim against the Debtor, however arising, not entitled to priority under section 507(a) of
the Bankruptcy Code, including, without limitation, an Allowed Deficiency Claim, an
Allowed Rejection Claim or an Allowed Avoidance Action Payment Claim.
-' u
.;
16
17
18
2.1.11 "Allowed Interest" means an Interest to the extent, and only to the extent,
of the amount of such Interest allowed by this Plan or by Final Order of the Banptcy
Court.
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
the Banruptcy
Code.
2.1.14 "Allowed Priority Tax Claim" means an Allowed Claim entitled to
priority under section 507(a)(8) of
26 27
28
Exhibit A, Page 21
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 23 of 44
Desc
2
3
Claim based upon or arising from the rejection of an executory contract or unexpired lease
pursuant to a Final Order of the Banptcy Court or pursuant to this Plan. Any Allowed
Rejection Claim shall be treated hereunder as a Class 3 Claim.
2.1.16
4
5
6 7
8 9
and unavoidable Lien against property in which the Estate has an interest, or which is
subject to setoff under section 553 of
the
holder of such Allowed Claim in the Estate's interest in such property, or to the extent of
10 u ..
11
the amount subject to any setoff, as the case may be. Unpaid principal and any accrued
interest allowable under section 506 of the Bankruptcy Code with respect to an Allowed
Secured Claim shall be computed as of
0-
.i .l oJ
oJ
12
13
-: :g
"
~ "' " 0
,.
14
15
~
oJ u
subordinated to Allowed Class 3 Claims to the extent provided by the Bankruptcy Code or a
Final Order.
2.1.18 "Assets" means all assets and properties of
" -:
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
proceeding, lawsuit or other action or proceeding arising under, or relating to, any similar
state law or federal law, and any other similar action or proceeding filed to recover property
for or on behalf of
26 27
28
Exhibit A, Page 22
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 24 of 44
Desc
2
3
arising from an entity's payment to the Debtor or Reorganized Debtor of a claim asserted
against the entity pursuant to an A voidance Action.
4
5
2.1.21 "Bankruptcy Code" means the United States Bankptcy Code, as set
forth in 11 U.S.C. 101-1532, as now in effect and as may be hereafter amended.
6 7
8
2.1.22 "Bankruptcy Court" means the United States Bankptcy Court for the
Central District of California, Santa Ana Division.
9
10
u .. '" ..
.,-
11
Financial Affairs filed by the Debtor in the Case, as they may have been
.. .. ;:
'"
12
13
::
oM "' '"
."
2.1.25 "Bar Date" means the last date for Creditors and Interest Holders whose
Claims or Interests, respectively, are not scheduled, or whose Claims or Interests are
" '"
."
14
15
0 OJ
.. u
16 17
18
2.1.26 "Business Day" means any day other than a Saturday, Sunday or a legal
holiday (as defined in Rule 9006(a) of
19
20
21
22
23
commenced by the Debtor on the Petition Date and bearng Case Number 8:07-13347-ES.
2.1.30 "Case Closing Date" means the date on which the Banptcy Court
enters a Final Decree closing the Case, in accordance with section 350 of
24
25
the Bankptcy
26 27
28
Code.
2.1.31 "Cash" means cash or cash equivalents including, but not limited to, ban
deposits, checks or other similar forms of payment or exchange.
7
Exhibit A, Page 23
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 25 of 44
Desc
2.1.32 "Causes of Action" means any and all claims, demands, rights, actions,
causes of action and suits of
2
3
known or unkown, suspected or unsuspected, whcther arising prior to, on or after the
Petition Date, in contract or in tort, at law or in equity or under any other theory of law, that
4
5
the Debtor or the Debtor's Estate has or asserts, or may have or assert, against third paries,
whether or not brought as of the Effective Date, and which have not been settled or
otherwise resolved by Final Order as of the Effective Date, including but not limited to
6 7
8
(a) rights of seton: counterclaim or recoupment, (b) claims on contracts or for breaches of
duties imposed by law, (c) rights to object to Claims or Interests, (d) such claims and
defenses as fraud, mistake, duress or usury, (e) Avoidance Actions, (f) claims for tax
9 10
u .. ~
,.
11
refunds, (g) claims to recover accounts receivable, and (h) any other claims which may be
asserted against third paries.
.i ~ ,.
::
o:
"' '"
'" '"
12
13
;;
2.1.33 "Claim" means a "claim" against the Debtor, as such term is defined in
section 101(5) of
0 0 OJ
14 15 16 17
18
z
,.
specific Claim, the ninetieth (90th) day after a Proof of Claim with respect to such Claim is
filed by a Creditor; (c) with respect to a Claim that is not listed in the Bankptcy
Schedules, the ninetieth (90th) day after the Plan Agent learns of the existence of such
Claim; or (d) such greater period of limitation as may be fixed or extended by the
19
20
21
Banptcy Cour or by agreement between the Plan Agent and the Creditor.
2.1.35 "Class" means a group of Claims or Interests as classified in Article IV of
22
23
this Plan.
2.1.36 "Collateral" means any property or interest in property of
24
25
the Estate
subject to a Lien of a Secured Creditor that is not subject to avoidance under the Bankptcy Code or otherwise invalid under the Bankptcy Code or applicable federal or state law.
26 27 28
Exhibit A, Page 24
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 26 of 44
Desc
2
3
Banptcy Court.
2.1.39 "Confirmation Date" means the date on which the Bankruptcy Cour
4
5
6 7
8
the Bankptcy
9 10 u -'
-.
~
11
~
-:" .. ..
12
13
" -: ::
o:
"'
this Plan.
"
14
15
2.1.45 "Cure Claims Schedule" has the meaning set forth in Section 10.5 of
this
i 0
g
Plan.
.. u
" -:
16
17 18
2.1.46 "Debtor" means MTI Technology Corporation, the debtor and debtor-inpossession in the Case. For the purpose of
19
2.1.47 "Deficiency Claim" means that portion of a Claim that is in excess of the
value of the Collateral which is security for the repayment of such Claim, calculated in
accordance with the provisions of section 506 of the Bankruptcy Code.
20
21
22
23
2.1.48 "De Minimis Distribution" has the meaning set forth in Section 7.2.3 of
this Plan.
24
25
2.1.49 "Disbursing Agent" means the entity charged with making Distributions
under this Plan. The Plan Agent shall serve as Disbursing Agent under this Plan.
2.1.50 "Disclosure Statement" means the Joint Third Amended Disclosure
26 27
28
Statement relating to this Plan, including, without limitation, all exhibits and schedules
thereto, as approved by the Bankruptcy Court pursuant to section 1125 of the Banruptcy
9
Exhibit A, Page 25
DOC
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 27 of 44
Desc
Code, as may be amended, modified or supplemented from time to time in accordance with
the provisions of the Bankruptcy Code and Banptcy Rules.
2.1.51
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
has been filed and the dollar amount of such Claim is not specified in a fixed amount; (b) a
Proof of Claim has been fied, to the extent to which the stated amount of such Claim
exceeds the amount of such Claim listed in the Banuptcy Schedules; (c) a Proof of Claim
9
10 u ,. 0.
~
'"
J
OJ ","
has been filed and such Claim is not listed in the Banuptcy Schedules; (d) a Proof of
Claim has been filed, or is deemed filed under Rule 3003(b)(1) of
11
.. ..
12
13
unkown as to amount; or (e) an objection, or request for estimation, has been filed by the
Claims Objection Deadline and such objection or request for estimation has neither been
withdrawn nor been denied by a Final Order.
2.1.53
~
""
;s
'"
Z ~
.. u
'" '" ""
14
15 16 17 18 19
"Disputed Claims Reserve" has the meaning set forth in Section 8.4.3 of
this Plan.
2.1.54
this
20
21
2.1.56
"Effective Date" means the eleventh (II th) day following the waiver or
this Plan.
22
23
2.1.57 "Estate" means the estate created in the Case under section 541 of the
Bankptcy Code.
24
25
2.1.58 2.1.59
this Plan.
26 27
28
Banptcy
"Final Decree" has the meaning set forth in Section 6. i 7 of this Plan.
10
Exhibit A, Page 26
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 28 of 44
Desc
2.1.61
2
3
other applicable court, as entered on the applicable docket, that has not been reversed,
stayed, modified or amended, and as to which the time to appeal, petition for certiorari, or
4
5
move for reargument or rehearing has expired and as to which no appeal, petition for
certiorari, or other proceedings for reargument or to obtain a rehearing shall then be pending
or as to which any right to appeal, petition for certiorari, reargue, or obtain a rehearing shall
6
7
8
have been waived in writing in form and substance satisfactory to the Plan Proponents prior
to the Effective Date, or to the Plan Agent after the Effective Date, as applicable, or, in the
event that an appeal, wrt of certiorari, or proceeding for reargument or rehearing of such
order or judgment has been sought, such order or judgment shall have been affirmed by the
highest court to which such order or judgment was appealed, or certiorari has been denied, or from which reargument or rehearing was sought, and the time to take any further appeal, petition for certiorari or move for reargument or rehearing shall have expired.
2.1.62
10
u ,. 0.
11
----
.
OJ '" '"
12
13
;;
0:
OJ '"
..
~
'" '"
14
15
~
-u
Administrative Claim, a Priority Tax Claim, a Priority Non-Tax Claim, a Secured Claim",
..
16
17
18
"Initial Distribution Date" has the meaning set forth in Section 7.2.8 of
19
this Plan.
2.1.64
20
21
defined in section 101 (16) of the Bankrptcy Code, no matter how held, including, without
limitation, issued and outstanding shares ofMTI Stock, and all rights and interests arising
thereunder, and all rights to acquire equity securities in the Debtor, including, without
22
23
24
25
26 27
28
Exhibit A, Page 27
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 29 of 44
Desc
2
3
2.1.68
4
5
2.1.69 "Loan Documents" has the meaning set forth in Section 13.21 of
this
6 7
8
Plan.
2.1. 70 "Local Bankruptcy Rules" means the Local Bankrptcy Rules applicable
to cases pending before the Banruptcy Court, as now in effect and as may be hereafter
amended.
2.1.71
9
10
c.
..
'"
11
~
...
,.
,.
12
13
this
~ ~
'" '
.. ..
~ z
~ ~ ~ ~
;;
:
o ~
'" "
14
15
2.1.73 "MTI Stock" means the issued and outstanding shares of common stock
and preferred stock of the Debtor as of the Effective Date.
2.1. 74 "Ordinary Course Administrative Claim" means an Administrative
Claim allowable under section 503(b) of
.. ,. c.
'" '"
16 17
18
ordinary course of the Debtor's operations or the Case, or the payment of which is provided for by an order of the Bankruptcy Court, exclusive of any Pre-Effective Date Professional
Fee Claims, Administrative Tax Claims and United States Trustee Fees.
19
20
21
2.1.75 "Penalty Claim" means any Claim for any fine, penalty, or forfeiture, or
for multiple, exemplary, or punitive damages, arising before the Petition Date, to the extent that such fine, penalty, forfeiture, or damages are not compensation for actual pecuniary
22
23
24
25
loss suffered by the holder of such Claim, as set forth in section 726(a)( 4) of the Banuptcy
Code.
2.1.76 "Petition Date" means October 15, 2007, the date on which the Debtor
26
27 28
12
Exhibit A, Page 28
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 30 of 44
Desc
2.1.77
2
3
including, without limitation, all exhibits, supplements, appendices, and schedules hereto, either in its present form or as it may be altered, amended, or modified from time to time.
2.1.78
4
5
"Plan Agent" means the entity appointed by this Plan to administer this
Plan and to make the Distributions provided by this Plan, in accordance with the provisions
of Section 6.6.1 of this Plan.
2.1.79
6
7
8
"Plan Agent Certifcation" has the meaning set forth in Section 6.16 of
this Plan.
2.1.80
"Plan Agent Disclosure" has the meaning set forth in Section 6.8.4 of
10
u .. ~
11
this Plan.
2.1.81
Effective Date of
0(
.. .. ..
W en '"
12
13
-:
Plan Agent~ on the Effective Date of this Plan, free and clear of any Liens that otherwise
:E
ol
0 " z
~
'" '"
OJ '"
14
15
-:
..
16 17
18
19
be made on or about the Effective Date, and all Cash received by the Reorganized Debtor
20
21
after the Effective Date. The Plan Fund Proceeds shall be made available for making Distributions to the following Creditors: the holders of Allowed General Unsecured
22
23
Claims: Canopy on account of any Canopy Claim: anany Allowed Subordinated Claims~
and for paying the Post-Effective Date Plan Expenses.
2.1.83
24
25
"Plan Fund Proceeds" means the Cash available in the Plan Fund for
making Distributions on account of Allowed General Unsecured Claims, the Canopy Claim, and any Allowed Subordinated Claims and for paying the Post-Effective Date Plan
Expenses.
26 27
28
13
Exhibit A, Page 29
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 31 of 44
Desc
2.1.84 "Plan Proponents" mcans, together, the Debtor and the Committee, the
2
3
4
5
2.1.86 "Post-Effcctivc Datc Committee Disclosure" has the meaning set forth
in Section 6.9.1 of
6
7
8
this Plan.
2.1.87 "Post-Effective Datc Noticc Partics" has the meaning set forth in
9 10
u .. Po ..
~ ,.
,.
"' '" '" '" 1 1
12
13
(collectively, "Expenses") incurred after the Effective Date related to the implementation of
""
this Plan, including, but not limited to: (a) the Expenses associated with administering this
Plan, including any taxes assessed against the Assets; (b) all United States Trustee Fees;
0 (j
'" '" '"
"' '"
14
15
0 ui
,. u
(c) the Expenses associated with making the Distributions required by this Plan; (d) any
16 17 18
Expenses associated with preparing and fiing tax returns and paying taxes; (e) any
reasonable Expenses incurred by a member of
excluding the attorneys' fees or other professional fees, if any, incured by it, except for any
such fees to which it is entitled by indemnification; (f) the Expenses of
19
independent
20
21
contractors and Professionals providing services to the Plan Agent or the Post-Effective
Date Committee; (g) the Expenses associated with the Plan Agent's indemnity obligations,
22
23
the purchase of errors and omissions insurance andlor other forms of indemnification; and
(h) the fees of
the Plan Agent, and the reimbursement of expenses, to which the Plan Agent
24
25
26
27 28
of
Exhibit A, Page 30
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 32 of 44
Desc
2.1.90
2
3
Claim from and after the Petition Date, in accordance with the provisions of
Sections 5.3.1.3 and 5.5.1.3 of
4
5
2.1.91
6
7
8
prior to the Effective Date pursuant to an order of the Bankptcy Cour in accordance with
sections 327 or 1103 of
9 10
u .. Po ..
-;-
11
rendered or expenses incurred prior to the Effective Date on behalf of thc Estate; or
12
13
:;
o:
"' " 0
" '"
the
14
15
Bankptcy Code.
z 0
ui '"
.. u
" '"
16 17 18 19
20
21
22
23
2.1.96 "Proof of Claim" means a statement under oath filed in the Case by a
Creditor in which the Creditor sets forth the amount claimed to be owed to it and detail
sufficient to identify the basis for the Claim, in accordance with Rule 3001 of
24
25
the Federal
Bankptcy Rules.
2.1.97 "Pro Rata" means proportionately so that the ratio of (a) the amount of
consideration distributed on account of an Allowed Claim to (b) the amount of the Allowed Claim is the same as the ratio of (x) the amount of consideration available for distribution
15
26 27 28
Exhibit A, Page 31
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 33 of 44
Desc
on account of all Claims in the Class in which that Allowed Claim is included to (y) the
amount of all Claims in that Class.
2
3
4
5
(x)
Claims ofthat
Class
(y)
6
7
(b)
made under this Plan, the Plan Agent, as Disbursing Agent under this Plan, shall establish
9
Reserves, on account of Disputed Claims, in accordance with the provisions of
Section 8.4.3
10
of this Plan.
u .. ~
..
'"
11
2.1.98 "Rejection Claim" means any General Unsecured Claim based upon or
. -i -i
12
arising from the rejection of an executory contract or unexpired lease pursuant to a Final
13
::
;
"' '"
-.
lJ
z'
0 0
..
2.1.99 "Reorganized Debtor" means the Debtor, as its financial affairs are
15
reorganized from and after the Effective Date. For the purpose of
ui '" '"
-i u
16
this Plan.
18
Unclaimed Property Reserve, and other reserves that the Plan Agent, as Disbursing Agent
20
23
the Bankptcy Code. A Claim is a Secured Claim only to the extent of
24
determined under section 506(a) ofthe Bankptcy Code, of
25
in the Collateral securing the Claim or to the extent of
26
whichever is applicable.
27
Exhibit A, Page 32
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 34 of 44
Desc
2
3
this Plan.
4
5
2.1.106 "Tax" means any tax, charge, fee, levy, or other assessment by any
federal, state, local or foreign taxing authority, including, without limitation, income,
6 7
8
excise, property, sales, transfer, employment, payroll, franchise, profits, license, use, ad
valorem, estimated, severance, stamp, occupation and withholding tax. "Tax" shall include
any interest, penalties or additions attributable to, or imposed on or with respect to, such
assessments.
9 10 u .. 0.
11
-i
. .. ..
12
13
;;
;;
tJ
'" '" '"
'" -0
this
01 "' '"
14
15
Plan.
z 0
..
16
17 18
this Plan.
19
2.1.111 "United States Trustee Fees" means all fees and chargcs assessed against
the Debtor or the Reorganized Debtor by the United States Trustee and due pursuant to
section 1930 of title 28 of the United States Code.
2.2 Rules of Interpretation. For the purpose of
20
21
22
23
this Plan, (a) the rules of construction set forth in section 102 ofthe Bankptcy Code apply to this
Plan; (b) Rule 9006(a) of
24
25
the Federal Bankptcy Rules applies when computing any time period
under this Plan; (c) a term that is used in this Plan and that is not defined in this Plan has the
26 27
28
meaning attributed to that term, if any, in the Bankrptcy Code or in the Bankptcy Rules; (d) the
definition given to any term or provision in this Plan supersedes any different meaning that may be
given to that term or provision in the Disclosure Statement; (e) whenever it is appropriate from the
17
Exhibit A, Page 33
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 35 of 44
Desc
context, each term, whether stated in the singular or the plural, includes both the singular and the
plural; (f) each pronoun stated in the masculine, feminine or neuter includes each of
2
3
the masculine,
feminine and neuter; (g) any reference to an exhibit, schedule, instruent or other document means
such exhibit, schedule, instrument or other document as it has been, or may be, amended, modified,
4
5
restated or supplemented as of the Confirmation Date, and any such exhibit, schedule, instrment or
other document shall be deemed to be included in this Plan, regardless of when it is filed; (h) the
6 7
8
phrases "under this Plan," "hereof," "hereto," "hereunder," and similar words or phrases, refer to
this Plan in its entirety rather than to only a portion of this Plan; (i) unless otherwise indicated, all
references in this Plan to sections, aricles or exhibits are references to sections, aricles or exhibits
9 10 u .. 0..
.
in this Plan; G) section captions and headings are used for convenience only and do not affect the
meaning of
11
this Plan; and (k) any reference to the holder ofa Claim or Interest includes that entity's
.. ..
'"
12
13
:;
..
:E
2.3 Exhibits. All exhibits to this Plan are incorporated into and are a par of this Plan as
if set forth in full herein.
ot
OJ
'"
Z ~
'" '"
14
15
III.
UNCLASSIFIED CLAIMS
As required by the Bankruptcy Code, this Plan places Claims and Interests into various
Classes according to their respective legal rights and interests, including their respective rights to
priority. However, in accordance with the provisions of section 1123(a)(l) of
.. u
-(
16 17
18 19
20
21
Administrative Claims and Priority Tax Claims are deemed "unclassified." These Claims are not
considered impaired under section 1124 of the Banptcy Code, and the holders of
these Claims
22
23
do not vote on this Plan, because these Claims are automatically entitled to specific treatment
provided for them in the Banptcy Code. Accordingly, the Plan Proponents have not placed
24
25
Administrative Claims and Priority Tax Claims in a Class. The treatment ofthese unclassified
Claims is as provided below.
26 27
28
3.1 Allowed Administrative Claims. Administrative Claims generally are Claims for
the expenses of administering the Debtor's Case that are allowed under section 503(b) of the
Bankptcy Code. Administrative Claims also include Claims provided for by section 503(b )(9) of
18
Exhibit A, Page 34
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 36 of 44
Desc
the Banruptcy Code. The Banruptcy Code requires that all Administrative Claims be paid on the
2
3
Effective Date of this Plan, unless a paricular Creditor agrees to a different treatment of its Claim.
The treatment of Administrative Claims under this Plan is as described below.
3.1.1 Payment. Except to the extent that the holder of an Allowed Administrative
4
5
Claim agrees to a less favorable treatment of its Allowed Administrative Claim, and, subject to the Administrative Claims Bar Date set forth in Section 3.1.2 hereof, each holder of an Allowed Administrative Claim shall receive, in full satisfaction, discharge, exchange and release of its Allowed Administrative Claim, Cash in an amount equal to such Allowed Administrative Claim, on the latest of (i) the Effective Date, (ii) the fifteenth (15th) Business
Day after the date upon which such Administrative Claim becomes an Allowed
6 7
8
9 10 u .. ..
-.
..
..
00" on " 00
11
Administrative Claim, or (iii) the date upon which such Allowed Administrative Claim
becomes due according to its terms; provided, however, that an Ordinary Course Administrative Claim shall be paid in full in accordance with the terms and conditions of the
agrecmcnts giving rise to such Ordinary Course Administrative Claim.
12
13
;,
:E
;,
c:
" 0
14
15
i :;
.. u
" " 00
16 17
18
for payment of Administrative Claims shall be filed with the Banptcy Court and served no
19
later than thirty (30) days after the Effective Date (the "Administrative Claims Bar Datc"). Any holder of an Administrative Claim that is required to file a request for payment of its
Administrative Claim by the Administrative Claims Bar Date and that does not file by the Administrative Claims Bar Date such a request for payment of its Administrative Claim shall be forever barred from asserting such Administrative Claim against the Debtor, the
Reorganized Debtor, the Estate or any of the property or assets of
20
21
22
23
24
25
Reorganized Debtor.
3.1.3 Deadline for Objections. All objections to allowance of Administrative
26
27
28
Claims that are subject to the Administrative Claims Bar Date must be fied by the Plan
Agent no later than forty-five (45) days after the Administrative Claims Bar Date (the
19
Exhibit A, Page 35
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 37 of 44
Desc
2
3
Deadline may be extended for a one-time thirty (30) day period by the Plan Agent by filing a
notice of the extended Administrative Claims Objection Deadline with the Bankptcy
Court. Thereafter, the Administrative Claims Objection Deadline may be furher extended
only by an order of the Banptcy Court. If the Plan Agent fails to file, by the
4
5
6 7
8
must be filed, and is filed, by the Administrative Claims Bar Date, such Administrative
Claim shall be deemed allowed as of the Administrative Claims Objection Deadline.
3.1.4 United States Trustee Fees. United States Trustee Fees shall be paid prior to
9
10
the Effective Date by the Debtor, and, after the Effective Date by the Plan Agent from the Plan Fund, in each case, when due in accordance with applicable law until the entry of a
Final Decree.
3.1.5 Pre-Effective Date Professional Fee Claims. Each Pre-Effective Date
u ,.
'"
11
~
-(.
.. ..
'"
12
13
:;
:;
J '" '"
-(
c.
14
15
Professional seeking from the Banptcy Court an award with respect to a Pre-Effective
i ;;
,.
'"
Date Professional Fee Claim shall file its final application for allowance of compensation for
services rendered and reimbursement of expenses incurred through the Effective Date by no
.. u
-(
16 17
18
later than the forty-fifth (45th) day after the EtIective Date or such later date as may be fixed
by the Banptcy Court. Such Pre-Effective Date Professional shall receive, in full
satisfaction, discharge, exchange and release of its Pre-Effective Date Professional Fee
Claim, Cash in such amounts as are allowed by the Bankptcy Court. All objections to
allowance of
19
20
21
Pre-Effective Date Professional Fee Claims must be filed and served timely in
22
23
3.2 Allowed Priority Tax Claims. Except to the extent that a holder of an Allowed
Priority Tax Claim agrees to a less favorable treatment of its Allowed Priority Tax Claim, each
24
25
holder of an Allowed Priority Tax Claim shall receive, in full satisfaction, discharge, exchange and
release of its Allowed Priority Tax Claim, Cash in an amount equal to such Allowed Priority Tax
Claim, on the later of (i) the Effective Date or (ii) the fifteenth (15th) Business Day after such
Priority Tax Claim becomes an Allowed Priority Tax Claim.
20
26 27
28
Exhibit A, Page 36
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 38 of 44
Desc
iv.
2
3
4.1 Overview. As required by the Banruptcy Code, this Plan places Claims and
Interests into Classes according to their respective legal rights and interests, including their
4
5
respective rights to priority. In Section 4.2 hereof, the Plan Proponents list each Class of Claims
and Interests established under this Plan and state whether each Class is impaired or is unimpaired
by this Plan. A Class is "unimpaired" by this Plan if
7
8
and contractual rights to which the holders of Claims or Interests in the Class are entitled, as
provided in section 1124 of the Bankptcy Code. Aricle V of
9
10
u .. 0. ..
-'
11
Pursuant to this Plan, a Claim shall be deemed classified in a paricular Class only to the
extent that the Claim qualifies within the description of that Class and shall be deemed classified in
another Class or Classes to the extent that any remainder of the Claim qualifies within the
., -'
:,
on '"
12
13
;: ~
:,
'"
.,
0 ..
;;
'" '"
14
15
description of such other Class or Classes. A Claim is classified in a paricular Class only to the
extent that the Claim is an Allowed Claim in that Class and has not been paid, released or otherwise
satisfied prior to the Effective Date.
.. u
.,
16 17 18 19
4.2 Designation of Classes. This Plan designates the following Classes of Claims and
Interests:
4.2.1 Allowed Claims.
4.2.1.1 Class 1: Any Allowed Secured Claims. This Class is unimpaired
20
21
by this Plan.
4.2.1.2 Class 2: Allowed Priority Non-Tax Claims. This Class is
22
23
24
25
26 27 28
21
Exhibit A, Page 37
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 39 of 44
Desc
2
3
4.2.2 Interests.
4.2.2.1 Class 6: Tnterests of
4
5
by this Plan.
6 7
8
4.3 Summary of Classification. The following table summarizes the Classes of Claims
and Interests established by this Plan:
CLASS
Class I
Class 2
DESCRIPTION
Allowed Secured Claims
9
10
u ,. Po
~
,," -'
; ~'
IMPAIRED! UNIMPAIRED
Unimpaired Unimpaired
Impaired
VOTING STATUS
Deemed to Accept Plan Deemed to Accept Plan Entitled to Vote on Plan
Deemed to Accept Plan
Entitled to Vote on Plan
Deemed to Reject the Plan
11
12
13
Class 3
:: ~ '" "
c:
:
"
Class 4
Class 5
Unimpaired
Impaired
Impaired
14
15
~
'"
Class 6
16 17
18
As set forth above, Classes 1, 2 and 4 are unimpaired by this Plan; holders of Claims in
these Classes are conclusively presumed to have accepted this Plan and, hence, are not entitled to
19
vote with respect to this Plan. Classes 3 and 5 are impaired by this Plan, and holders of Claims in
these Classes are entitled to vote to accept or reject this Plan. Interests in Class 6 are impaired; the
Plan Proponents believe that it is very likely that Interest Holders will not receive or retain under
this Plan any value on account of
20
21
22
23
24
25
26 27
28
against the Debtor or its property. This treatment supersedes and replaces any agreements or fights
which those entities have in or against the Debtor or its property. NO DISTRIBUTIONS SHALL
22
Exhibit A, Page 38
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 40 of 44
Desc
2
3
v.
TREATMENT OF CLASSES UNDER THIS PLAN
The following sets forth the treatment of Classes established by this Plan.
5.1 Class 1 -- Any Allowed Secured Claims. Class 1 consists of any Allowed Secured
4
5
6 7
8 9
Claims. Class 1 is unimpaired by this Plan. In the event that there is more than one holder of an
Allowed Class 1 Claim, the Allowed Secured Claim of each such Secured Creditor shall be deemed to be classified in a separate sub-class of Class 1, and each such sub-class of Class 1 shall be
deemed to be a separate Class under this Plan.
5.1.1 Treatment of Allowed Secured Claims. Within fifteen (15) Business Days
10 u ..
-.
.. ..
11
0.
,,"
'" en '"
12
13
after the Effective Date, each Secured Creditor holding an Allowed Class 1 Claim shall
"
'" '"
receive, at the election ofthe Plan Agent, made in the exercise of its sole and absolute
discretion, one of
;a ol
c:
14
15
~
'" '"
.. u
"
16 17
18
19
20
21
receive
22
23
any proceeds actually received by the Debtor or Reorganized Debtor (as applicable)
from the sale or other disposition of the Collateral in which that Secured Creditor
24
25
Claim should make an election under section 1111 (b) of the Banptcy Code, its
Allowed Deficiency Claim shall be treated hereunder as a Class 3 Allowed General
Unsecured Claim
26 27 28
23
Exhibit A, Page 39
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 41 of 44
Desc
2
3
4
5
6 7
8
1 Claim because an Allowed Secured Claim, to elect which treatment set fort under this
Section 5.1.1 to provide to the Secured Creditor holding such Allowed Class 1 Claim.
9 10 u ..
'"
5.2 Class 2 -- Allowed Priority Non-Tax Claims. Class 2 consists of all Allowed
11
-.
-:" .. .. :;
12
13
5.2.1 Treatment of Allowed Non-Tax Priority Claims. Except to the extent that
a holder of an Allowed Priority Non-Tax Claim agrees to a less favorable treatment of its
'"
~
"' '"
::
0
-:
14
15
Allowed Priority Non-Tax Claim, each holder of an Allowed Priority Non-Tax Claim shall receive, in full satisfaction, discharge, exchange and release of its Allowed Priority
Non-Tax Claim, Cash in the full amount of
-:
" 0
o: 0:
.. u
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Unsecured Claim agrees to a less favorable treatment of its Allowed General Unsecured Claim, the holder of an Allowed General Unsecured Claim shall receive,
in full and complete satisfaction, discharge, exchange and release of its Allowed
26 27
28
24
Exhibit A, Page 40
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 42 of 44
Desc
2
3
4
5
Class 3 Claims from the Plan Fund Proceeds. All holders of Allowed Class 3
Claims shall receive an initial Distribution of their Pro Rata share of
6
7
8
Proceeds within 180 days following the Effective Date, or on such later date as the Plan Agent determines to be practicable, in the exercise of its sole and absolute discretion, and shall receive thereafter during the Case Distributions of their Pro
Rata share of Plan Fund Proceeds on each I 80th-day anniversar of
9
10
u .. '"
.J
the Effective
Date, or on such later date as the Plan Agent determines to be practicable in the
11
exercise of its sole and absolute discretion. Holders of Allowed Class 3 Claims
shall receive any final Distribution of their Pro Rata share of
~
.J
."
..
'" co '"
12
13
within ten (10) days after the filing of the Plan Agent Certification, or as soon
.I
"' '" C!
14
15 16 17 18 19
thereafter as is practicable. Upon payment of the amount owed to the holder of any
Allowed Class 3 Claim under this Plan, such Allowed Class 3 Claim shall be
deemed to be fully and completely satisfied, discharge and released.
5.3.1.3 In accordance with section 726(a)(5) of
z'
~
'" '"
.J u
."
Allowed General Unsecured Claim shall not include Postpetition Interest on account
of such Allowed General Unsecured Claim, except to the extent that all of
the
20
21
following are satisfied and paid in full: (a) all Allowed Administrative Claims;
(b) all Allowed Priority Tax Claims; (c) all Allowed Priority Non-Tax Claims; (d) all Allowed Secured Claims (subject to the elections provided pursuant to Section 5.1.1 hereof); (e) all Allowed General Unsecured Claims; (f) the Canopy Claim; (g) all Late-Filed Claims; (h) all Post-Effective Date Plan Expenses; and
22
23
24
25
(i) all Allowed Penalty Claims. Any Postpetition Interest that may be payable on an
Allowed General Unsecured Claim shall be calculated from the Petition Date
through the date on which such Allowed General Unsecured Claim is paid in fulL.
26 27
28
25
Exhibit A, Page 41
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 43 of 44
Desc
2
3
this Plan, no Cash Distribution shall be made on account of any Allowed General
Unsecured Claim until each of
4
5
Claims are paid; (b) all Allowed Priority Tax Claims are paid; (c) all Allowed
Priority Non-Tax Claims are paid; (d) all Allowed Secured Claims are paid (subject
to the elections provided pursuant to Section 5.1. i hereof); (e) the Disputed Claims
6 7
8
this Section 5.3.1.4; and (f) all outstanding Post-Effective Date Plan
9 10 u .. 0.
'" '" "' '"
Expenses have been paid in full and an adequate Reserve is established by the Plan
Agent providing for full payment of
ii
12
13
Plan Expenses through the Case Closing Date, in an amount to be determined by the
Plan Agent in the exercise of its sole and absolute discretion.
5.3.1.5 Each holder of an Allowed General Unsecured Claim shall be
-. . .. ..
;g
'" "'
~
ti
z"
; '" "' '"
14
15
allocated its Pro Rata number of shares of Post -Effective Date Stock, to be held in
trust for such Creditor by the Plan Agent in contemplation of a potential Merger
16 17
i8
19
Date Stock, in connection with any Merger Transaction; provided, however, that the holder of an Allowed General Unsecured Claim shall have the right to elect not to
receive any Distribution of
20
21
22
23
24
25
26 27
28
Post-
26
Exhibit A, Page 42
Case 8:07-bk-13347-ES
Doc 1264 Filed 08/05/10 Entered 08/05/10 16:36:39 Main Document Page 44 of 44
Desc
2
3
4
5
6 7
8
modification, any and all amounts to which Canopy is entitled pursuant to paragraphs 2 and 3 of that Settlement Agreement and Mutual Release of Claims ("Canopy Agreement"),
approved by an order of
complete copy of
10
u ..
'"
11
~
.( .. ..
~ '" ..
12
13
:;
d1 "' '"
0 " 0
14
15
z'
this Plan, except to the extent that the holder of any Allowed
~ '" .. ..
16
17 18
Claim, in the event that all Allowed General Unsecured Claims are paid in full as set
forth in Section 5.3.1 of this Plan, the holder of an Allowed Subordinated Claim
19
shall receive, in full and complete satisfaction, discharge, exchange and release of
its Allowed Subordinated Claim, solely from the Plan Fund Proceeds, a Pro Rata
Distribution of any remaining Plan Fund Proceeds.
5.5.1.2 The Plan Agent shall make Distributions to the holders of
20
21
22
23
Allowed Class 5 Claims, from any Plan Fund Proceeds available for distribution to
24
25
holders of Allowed Class 5 Claims. All holders of Allowed Class 5 Claims shall
receive an initial Distribution of their Pro Rata share of any Plan Fund Proceeds
available for distribution to holders of Allowed Class 5 Claims on such date as the Plan Agent determines to be practicable, in the exercise of its sole and absolute
discretion, and thereafter shall receive Distributions of any such Plan Fund Proceeds
27
26 27 28
Exhibit A, Page 43