Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Density, lbs/ft3
Decorative Moldings
Insulation
60
70
80
Shore A
Shore D
Understanding Polyurethanes
Roy McClellan
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies DETOUR
CRITICAL ISSUE:
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
What is the problem?
Blowing Agents
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
A sister product, CFC-12 (dichlorodifluoromethane) was used for Both products were in large commercial production, had very
reasonable prices and contributed excellent insulating values (k and R factors) to the rigid urethane foams. used extensively to produce flexible, rigid and microcellular urethane foams with an integral skin, formed in place during the molding process.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
Global Production Phase-out* of CFC-11, 12 & HCFC 141b Latest Schedule Agreed to by all Parties of the Montreal Protocol 6/1989 1/1994 1/1996 6/1999 Freeze Production of all CFCs world wide. Reduce Production levels by 75% from 1986 levels. Total phase out of CFCs except for essential uses. Freeze HCFCs at 89 levels + 2.8% of 89 CFC consumption. Reduce CFCs to 95-97 avg. levels or 300 gms/capita (lowest amt.)
*Halon and other non-urethane related agents have been omitted. SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
Global Production Phase-out* of CFC-11, 12 & HCFC 141b Latest Schedule Agreed to by all Parties of the Montreal Protocol (cont) 1/2004 1/2005 1/2007 1/2015 1/2016 1/2040 Reduce HCFCs by 35% below base levels Reduce CFCs by 50% from 95-97 levels (essential users) Reduce CFCs by 85% from 95-97 levels (essential users) Reduce HCFCs by 90% Freeze HCFCs at base line 2015 average levels HCFCs completely phased out
*Halon and other non-urethane related agents have been omitted. SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
USA HCFC Situation
This will severely hamper the manufacture of polyurethane and other There are some new developmental materials and techniques that
may mitigate this situation to some degree. These are discussed in the following slides.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
Europe:
(hydrocarbons) such as, isopentane and cyclopentane for refrigeration, insulating board and panels.
The above may be used with water (CO2) as co-blowing There seems to be a trend in Europe toward PIR foams to
reduce need for halogenated flame retardants
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
CRITICAL ISSUE :
USA:
All SNAP (Significant New Alternatives Program) alternatives plus HCs and
water (CO2) co-blow are under investigation
HCs not popular due to fire potential in plant and insurance cost
implications, but some blends give excellent properties
combinations with water and/or HCs parallels European activities with HFC 365mfc (pentafluorobutane) panel products while 245fa seems to be favored for spray foam using some water co-blowing ruling could be initiated to delay implementation.
One of the preceding approaches will probably be used in the laminate and Always the outside possibility that Industry litigation against the EPA
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
While the replacement of CFC 11 by HCFC 141 b caused some technical difficulties, the use of the new generation(s) of blowing agents will cause major technical and economic challenges.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Base
Base
Base
Base
Base
Goal
Goal
nearly equal
Goal
better
Goal
Goal
poorer
chemical reaction during the polyurethane polymerization. Critical to their function is:
Boiling range Solubility and efficiency as a solvent in the raw materials and the developing polymer matrix during the foaming process Solubility and diffusion of the blowing agent gas or liquid through the polymer matrix out of the cell during aging
these functions, and, in some cases, can result in collapsed foams or foams with severe shrinkage or dimensional instability over both the short and long terms.
SynUthane International Inc.
For example, shrinkage has always been an issue in rigid foams, but
has been exacerbated recently with the use of R 141b blowing agent due to its fugitive nature and the creation of low cell pressure. Some of the foams made with HC materials and perhaps others will need monitoring of medium to long term cell pressure behavior. polymerization causing large voids and gas pockets.
In some cases, blowing agents become more insoluble during The safest method is to formulate with a balanced, compatible
system, using surfactants and solubilizers where required to prevent uncontrolled volatilization and separation of blowing agents during the polymerization. have focused on the need to strive for maximum cell strength. This property depends in large part on cell isotropicity
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Cell Geometry (Cont)
Note the ratio of strength of the cells parallel and perpendicular to the
rise direction of the foam and the gel point for each.
Cell Isotropicity Cell Anisotropicity Parallel, Strength~ 2X Parallel Strength, 1X Perpendicular Strength ~ 0.3-0.5X
Perpendicular Strength, 1X
Gel Point
RISE
Gel Point
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Cell Geometry (Cont) Premature gellation is caused by elastic polymer formation prior to completion of blowing process It may be addressed by:
Reducing the functionality of the polyol or NCO Increasing the NCO index Adding water to the formulation Use pre-expansion (froth) technique Reduce the level of polymerization catalyst In general, increase the MW per crosslink
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
The new blowing agent candidates under the most scrutiny seem to
be the HCs, HFCs and water. The HC materials are flammable, have high k factors (poorer insulators) but are very economical The HFC materials are non-flammable, have fairly good k factors, but are quite expensive CO2 is non-flammable, has a poor k factor, but is very economical when added directly as a gas, and higher when added through the isocyanate (water reaction)
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
0.25
0.2
BTU-in/hr. ft2 0F
0.15
0.1
0.05
0 HCFC-141b
BRITISH UNITS Series1
HFC365mfc 0.073
n-pentane 0.109
CO2 0.250
0.066
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
HFC365mfc 10.5
n-pentane 15.8
CO2 36.1
9.5
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
The HC materials are less soluble than the HFCs and both
They also have different boiling ranges. These different properties make formulating systems which
need to shipped in trucks, IBCs or drums a problem because of the different container pressures which develop due to solubility differences. and additives to mitigate these differences and keep the blowing agent in the polyol side during transport and storage.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
The actual mole gas content is quite low, and much of the blowing
agent migrates from the exposed foam surface relatively quickly.
reduce the consumption of the HCs for these applications as well as water to further reduce HC levels. met with strong resistance in the US due to worries about extraordinarily high insurance premiums
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Applications
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Insulation for Domestic Refrigerators and Commercial Cold Stores
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Pour-in Place for Refrigerators, Freezers, Cool Containers
High or low pressure equipment may be used. 2 -5 minute cycles Pre-expansion (froth) technique sometimes employed to assist
with reacting polymer flow in the tool and prevent cell stretching (anisotropicity)
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Polymer characteristics
Highly crosslinked, 500-600 mw/x-link 3-5 OH functional polyols used with TDI or 2.5-3.0 NCO
functional polymeric MDI
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Typical PUR Formula for Refrigerator Foam Sucrose/Glycerine/PO or TDA/PO Polyol OH# 400 Water Silicone Surfactant Amine Catalyst(s) R-141b + Compatibilizer Polymeric MDI @ 1.10 Index
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Pour-in-Place for Refrigerators, Freezers, Cool Containers
and CFC-12, using 141b. Must achieve complete non-ODS by 2003 Increased use of water blowing and alternate zero ODS blowing agents under development Increasing use of pentane/isomers in Europe, despite flammability concerns Direct injection of CO2 being evaluated
Improved adhesion of foam to various plastic liners Eliminate residual amine catalyst odors Higher insulating value foams (lower k-factor); reduced cell size
and/or new blowing technology
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Polymer characteristics
Highly crosslinked, 400-500 mw/x-link 3-5 OH functional polyols used with 2.5-3 NCO functional
polymeric MDI for urethane types 2-2.5 OH functional aromatic ester polyols used for polyisocyanurate (PIR) foams
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
125-175
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Most of this industry, now phased out of CFC 11, 12, mainly
using 141b Must achieve complete non-ODS by 2003 Increased use of water (CO2) blowing and alternate zero ODS materials under development Flammability:
of UL E-84 tests for flame spread and smoke generation European producers, faced with emerging halogen standards, are now converting to PIR after many years of using heavily flame retarded polyurethane to meet local fire and smoke standards
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Pour-in-Place for Insulating Panels (discontinuous)
Improve adhesion of foam to panel facers Minimize/eliminate shrinkage when converting to co-blown
chemistry at low density (141b + water) Continuing need for better insulating foam (lower K factor); reduced cell size, and/or new blowing agent materials Continuing need for improved flammability and smoke values
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Continuous Lamination of Insulating Panels
Foam density/configuration
Very large, automated lines Liquid foam components dispensed from high pressure metering
machines,between continuously moving substrates (skins) Panels are 36-48 wide (.9-1.2m) wide The panels are foamed in a heated pressure conveyor section and subsequently cut into desired lengths Line speeds vary from 75 to 300 ft/min (25 to 100 m/min.) Both flexible (aluminum foil) and rigid (steel) facing materials are used
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Polymer characteristics
Highly crosslinked, 300-500 mw/x-link PIR types Uses 2-2.3 OH functional aromatic polyester polyols and 2.7-3.3
NCO functional polymeric MDI
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
175-240
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Blowing agents: Most of this industry, now phased out of CFC 11,
mainly using 141b Must achieve complete non-ODS by 2003 Increased use of water (CO2) blowing and alternate zero ODS materials under development
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Continuous Lamination of Insulating Panels
Improve adhesion of foam to panel facers Minimize/eliminate shrinkage when converting to co-blown
chemistry at low density (141b + water)
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Pour-in-Place General Systems for Packaging, Shock Protection Foam density, configuration
Box is lined with PE film as is the item to be packaged Foam completely surrounds object and fills the box Pouring equipment is generally small, high pressure units (piston pumps) In other applications, foam is molded to shape in a mold and items are placed into the foam structure for shipping
Polymer characteristics
Foams are water blown and are usually grossly under-indexed Polymers are essentially open-celled polyurea materials Based on 2.2-2.4 NCO functional polymeric MDI with some high
MW polyol diol or triol used to provide ductility, lower friability
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Pour-in-Place General Systems for Packaging, Shock Protection
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Eliminate friability (dustiness) Reduce resilience, improve high impact absorbing qualities Minimize/eliminate residual amine catalyst odor
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Decorative Wood Imitation Polyurethane
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Structural foam: 25-40PCF (400-650 kg/m3), variable Wood imitation: 3-35 PCF (48-560 kg/m3), variable
Process/equipment
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Structural foam:
Moderately crosslinked, 800-1000 mw/x-link 2-3 hydroxyl functionality polyether and/or polyester polyols plus low
MW crosslinkers/chain extenders are used 2.1-2.3 NCO functional modified polymeric MDI is also used Fast reaction rates, compatible with RIM processing are used to afford short demolding cycles
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Typical Formula for Structural Foam Adipate Polyester, 110 Oh#, 2.3 Amine Based PO triol OH 560 Water Silicone Surfactant Amine Catalyst(s) Flame Retardant (s) R-141b Polymeric MDI @ 1.07 Index 60.0 40.0 1.5 0.5 0.5 10-20 2-10 98.0
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Typical Formula for Wood Imitation Sucrose/Glycerine/PO or TDA/PO or Amine based Polyol OH# 400 Water Silicone Surfactant Amine Catalyst(s) Flame Retardant (s) R-141b Polymeric MDI @ 1.10 Index
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Blowing agents, structural foam: HCFC 141b has replaced CFC-11 in this application and some co
blowing with water is commonplace Blowing levels are quite low and it is generally felt 141b can be replaced by a non ODS by 2003
Blowing agents, wood imitation: HCFC 141b is also used in this application but in larger amounts Co-blowing with water is practiced and attempts are being made to
find alternates to 141b to maintain high surface density (Integral skin)
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology Pour-in-Place General Systems for Structural Foam, Wood Imitation
Flammability: structural foam: Compliance with UL V-O testing is usually required for structural
foam cabinets used for electrical components
Flammability: wood imitation: The foams are usually flame retarded but are seldom affected by flammability regulations
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Structural foam & wood imitation: improved surface quality eliminate large cells/blisters improve strength, lower density, better impact
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Spray Foam for Industrial, Commercial and Residential Roofing, Tanks, Pipes and Equipment
Process/equipment
simple The chemicals (usually 1:1or 1:2 by volume ratio) are metered by piston pumps at high pressure through heated hoses to a small impingement mixing chamber After mixing, the foam is spray-applied similarly to airless paint. The foam rises and hardens rapidly so that additional layers can be applied quickly Often the exposed foam is coated with silicone, acrylic or aliphatic urethane topcoat for weather, UV and traffic protection
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Spray Foam for Industrial, Commercial and Residential Roofing, Tanks, Pipes and Equipment
Polymer characteristics
Reactive Mannich base polyols are also popular PIR formulations based on 2.0-2.3 OH functional aromatic
polyester polyols
2.6-2.8 NCO functional polymeric MDI used for both PUR and PIR Very reactive chemistry, foam is completely reacted in 10-15 sec
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Spray Foam for Industrial, Commercial and Residential Roofing, Tanks, Pipes and Equipment
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Spray Foam for Industrial, Commercial and Residential Roofing, Tanks, Pipes and Equipment
266
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Spray Foam for Industrial, Commercial and Residential Roofing, Tanks, Pipes and Equipment
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
Spray Foam for Industrial, Commercial and Residential Roofing, Tanks, Pipes and Equipment
Elimination of foam blistering after aging Smooth surface Improved adhesion of foam to substrate and foam itself Lower K factor, lower density Improvement in flammability/smoke properties
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Bun (Block) Foam for Fabrication into Low Density Pipe or Sheet Insulation
Foam density, configuration
1.6-3.0 PCF (26-48 kg/m3), 48w x 32h, (1.2m x 0.8m) for conventional
insulation products
Process/equipment
Foam mix is dispensed by low or high pressure open pour machine into
a paper lined, continuous conveyor belt with moving sides High dispensing output capacity is required for continuous, low density production lines Foam can be cut into lengths after a reaction time of 6-10 minutes Blocks should be aged for 7 days before cutting into desired configuration Discontinuous blocks can also be made by timed machine pours or in mechanically mixed batches High exotherm can scorch (and char) interior of the blocks or buns
SynUthane International Inc.
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Bun (Block) Foam for fabrication into low density pipe or sheet insulation
Polymer characteristics
Highly crosslinked, 350-500 mw/x-link 3-5 OH functional polyether polyols used for PUR foams 2-2.3 OH functional aromatic polyester polyols used for PIR
foams Controlled reactivity important for generation and maintenance of rectangular bun shape and cell isotropicity 2.7-3.2 NCO functional polymeric MDI used for both PUR and PIR foams
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technology
Bun (Block) Foam for fabrication into low density pipe or sheet insulation
266
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies Bun (Block) Foam for fabrication into low density pipe or sheet insulation
Blowing agents: Producers using 141b and some water co-blowing Alternate zero ODS materials being researched Flammability: End use applications will dictate which fire and smoke
tests must be passed Most existing bun/block foams are either UL E-84 class I or class II
Understanding Polyurethanes
Rigid Foam Application Technologies
This has been an overview of polyurethane rigid foam technology We hope you have found it interesting and informative
Questions?