Leveson Report

The
Leveson
Inquiry
culture, practices and
ethics of the press
AN INQUIRY INTO THE CULTURE,

PRACTICES AND ETHICS OF THE
PRESS
REPORT
The Right Honourable Lord Justice Leveson

November 2012
4 volumes not to be sold separately
Volume I
AN INQUIRY INTO THE CULTURE,

PRACTICES AND ETHICS OF THE PRESS
The Right Honourable Lord Justice Leveson
November 2012
Volume I
Presented to Parliament pursuant to Section 26 of the Inquiries Act 2005

Ordered by the House of Commons to be printed on 29 November 2012
HC 780-I
London: The Stationery Office
250.00
4 volumes not to be sold separately
Crown copyright 2012

You may re-use this information (excluding logos) free of charge in any format or
medium, under the terms of the Open Government Licence. To view this licence,
visit http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/doc/open-government-licence/ or
e-mail: psi@nationalarchives.gsi.gov.uk.
Where we have identified any third party copyright information you will need to
obtain permission from the copyright holders concerned.
Any enquiries regarding this publication should be sent to us at
generalenquiries@levesoninquiry.org.uk
This publication is available for download at www.official-documents.gov.uk
ISBN: 9780102981063
Printed in the UK by The Stationery Office Limited
on behalf of the Controller of Her Majestys Stationery Office
ID P002525215 11/12
22930
19585
Printed on paper containing 75% recycled fibre content minimum.
The
Leveson
Inquiry
culture, practices and
ethics of the press
CONTENTS
Volume I

Page
PART A: THE INQUIRY
Chapter 1: The Announcement

2
/
Role of the Assessors
s
Chapter 2: The approach
10

^
d

K
^

Chapter 3: Further issues of law
38

Z/Z
Z/Z
d
Chapter 4: The Report
49

^
W
d
PART B: THE PRESS AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST
53
/
Chapter 2: The freedom of the press and democracy
56

h<
d
d
W
d

&
W
K
i
The Leveson Inquiry
d

W

W
PART C: THE PRESS
91
Chapter 1: Context
93

/

d

/
E
E>
E^D'>
dD
ddD'
d'D'
d/'
d&d
d
D

/

dttt

^
K

W
Chapter 4: Plurality
180

t

dh<
,
ii
Contents
PART D: STANDARDS
193
d

/
dZW
dZz
dZ
dZ^Y
dZ^Y
dWt

^

/
dW

W&

PART E: CROSSING LEGAL BOUNDARIES:

d,Z/D/E>E/s/>>t
d
W

KZ
K'
KD

/
dKD
d
WKD
WWZ

WK

/
d
d
d
^
W
iii
The Leveson Inquiry

dEt
:d'
^dEzd
d'
d
W^

W/Ktd
dD^
Volume II
PART F: THE CULTURE, PRACTICES AND ETHICS OF THE PRESS:
THE PRESS AND THE PUBLIC
/

K
DKdZ
DK/
dW&Z
'

dh<
^

K
d
d
Êt

/
/Et

/
/

Chapter 5: Some case studies
539

/
d
<'D
:
Contents

dZ,'DW
,'
^
ZZ

/
>
h

,
/
d
Z
/
&
d

/
W
d
d/
WZd'd,WZ^Êd,WK>/d,Z>d/KE^,/W
W

/
d
d
d,Z

DW^
K
W
WW

/
d

d
d

The Leveson Inquiry

d
/W/W
,D/t&&
&DW
WKWK
d

/
d
/
K
>
'
D

Volume III
WZd,d,WZ^ÊdWZKdd/KE
/

d/K
KD

4
d
d/K
dW
What Price Privacy?d
What Price Privacy?dW
K

d

KD
Chapter 4: The ICO and the press today

1054
/
W
&KD
Contents

&
W/K
/

d/K
d/K

d
d
/
W/K
^Z
PART I: THE PRESS AND POLITICIANS
1115
/
d

WDd
WDD
E>

d
d
WD
WD
W
d

/
D>K
WD
Z
Chapter 5: Media policy: examples from recent history

Wddd^d
Z^Y
,Z
W

Dd^

1233
/
d
The Leveson Inquiry

: dZ,sDW
/^

:dZ,:,
D^
EZ,^D^W
&

/
dWDZ,EDW
d>KZ,DDW
d&D^Z,^D^W
dZ,<YDW
dZ,D'DW
dZ,'KDW
Z

/
d
d

Z
Chapter 9: Plurality and media ownership: conclusions

/
^
D
>
t
t
Volume IV
PART J : ASPECTS OF REGULATION: THE LAW AND THE
WZ^^KDW>/Ed^KDD/^^/KE
/
Chapter 2: The criminal law
1480

/
d
d/

W
Contents

W
W
W
d
d

/

>
d

dW

/
tW
/
d
dW
^W
/

PART K: REGULATORY MODELS FOR THE FUTURE
1581

/

&
/
W

dWW&

/
d
'

^
W
&
d
The Leveson Inquiry

d/&
/
WW&

/

&
/
W

ZWW&
^
K/

/

&
^
/
^
^
d

Z
^

d

W
W
/

dW/WK
K
ZE
d

/
Z
Z
Contents

/
K

s

'
^
d

d
d
t
t
,
d
D
Z

/
Z
PART L: SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS
1801
APPENDICES
1819
//d
^
t/
>

W/

PART A

THE INQUIRY
CHAPTER 1
THE ANNOUNCEMENT
/
1.1
On, 13 July 2011, the Prime Minister made a statement to the House of Commons in these
terms:1
/
t,

t
Z

/
>WD/>K
/D^,
: &
/
E /
^

/ / ,
/ ^ W ^ ,
/

/
^/,,

d
d

>'>,
/
t
t

&
^
t
^
HC Hansard, 13 July 2011, vol 531, col 311-312
PART A | The Inquiry

/,
> : > , , ^
^^D^d
/

^ > : >

,

'
,
d

d
Et
d

>:>/
>E

1.2
The Terms of Reference were then the subject of further discussion both with the devolved
^tE/d
WD:
,2
t t

D
t

t

1.3
ddZ/
Part 1
d
HC Hansard, 20 July 2011, vol 531, col 919
Chapter 1 | The Announcement

d

'

W'

Part 2
dE/

d
E/
DW

d

d
E /

E/
/

1.4
:3D/Z
,:,DW^^D^
D^,K/
K
W D D
/
>:>Z
d^4^5>6'7
':^W^>9
1.5
&
',
KD:KWDZ
Z^/<
d ^ ^ / :
:KZD^
/^,
Zt
'/
1.6
/td^/
Z:Y/
W,>D

1.7
Z
/
Z/

dZ/
'W
2. Role of the Assessors

2.1
&
/
,
them by name,10 the Prime Minister said of them
,
2.2
//

/ contrary vi/
/

10
,,:
5
2.3
/K11/
/
/W
these terms:12
/

hearing

or
W/

W/

W
/
2.4
//
WW
/
//

Wd

13
d

///
d

/d/
/
/
/

h /
d/
/
/

2.5
dW
d
/
11
ZW&<
WK
13
ZW&<
12

/

/

/
d < < D<

d

/
2.6
dK/14
/WD
/
/

E/

d
/
2.7
E/
/

d ,

//
d
/

2.8
/ W D /

d > K / indeed the
WD/
WD
2.9
& /
s/t
/
:YE>

15 /
14
ZW&<
15
Ibid
/
/
2.10 d
/
/
/
/
E
//
dZ
W/
^Z
3. Visits
3.1
//
/
/
/
/ /
^Ê>d
Dd^DdDdDd^Dd
WE/>d^ddd^d/

3.2
d / W
/
/

//
CHAPTER 2
THE APPROACH
^
1.1
d/d
/h
d

/

t/

d

1.2

/
/

/

/
d1
1.3
d /
D W ^ DW^ d K
tK

K d d
/

/
/
Zd/
W
K

1.4
d
/

/

/
10
d
1.5
d&

^

d/

/

2d

1.6
/WdZ/

t

^
1.7
d /

Kd'Dd

d K /
/

^:^dZ/
1.8
W
/
d

/

WZWZW

d

EW&<
11
1.9
d/
/
&

/

/
d
1.10 d
d
/
WD
Et
Edt

1.11 /

W
D
/

1.12 d
/
/
/
/

/
/
/ /

K

/
/Z/

/
12
d
1.13 d /
dZ
//
/
/d

Z
/
/
/

1.14 //
/
/dZ
WWWWW
W&d
/
/
dWW

Dd
ZD:DZ

DD

/
/
1.15 &&
&/
/

///
/

dD&
Z

1.16 /dZ/

,
13
3

1.17 / /
/d

d

WW

/

/d
/ /

^
1.18 d

d

/
d

these remain available on the website and can all be accessed on the website both to watch
4
1.19 ddKdW
W/:/^
'':
W,
Edt , D d D

ZW^
ddZ
Z W Z
'dd
<
d^Wd/^
W : < h , K

3
dZ
ZW&<
4
14
d

1.20 dtKd
^ Z d
> ^ W

^W
/t&WE>
W t D & &
d
>'&d
^ ^ , K
&d&^
dD
1.21 /^>
W ^ W
h t Y
5WZW>>^
&
: < /
W:W'h>
D Z < D<
d^Dd^
D'E
1.22 /
d
/
t

1.23 t/D
/

W

d
DdD/
^
W
15
/
6
1.24 d/
//
d
W

/

,

/
W
/
1.25 //
/7//

//
Z:Y
/d

1.26 d
/
/K/

/
/K/
/

/

/

6
Dt/W
^
ZWK^Wh>Z^^D/EZ
^W,d:/
///Ez

^W
7
16
d
1.27 ///

Ê

1.28 t/
/
/
:
/
d
/
/,/

/
/

d

1.29 Z/
/
/

/
W
1.30 Z
W
//
W /
W
/

dZ//
17
/
Z/Z
d
1.31 d/
/

/

WW/
D
9&/
/

1.32 d
/
KD^t
K
'DKt,
dZ
W
d//
/
d//
/

/
10d

DW
d
KW&<&Z
WED
d,: and
&W&D
&ZWD
and &Z
W'DD
ZWDD
WD
ED>:^:t,DDZ>:
<W:KD:^:dWY^:
KK
9
EW&<
10
dZ
/Z
Z/Z
d

W

1.33 //
//dd:,
d
'
EdD,
E
ddD
/K

dd,

1.34
^

d
Z

/

d
Module One
2.1
/

//dZ
11
/
DK

11
d'd^D
s:
DWK
19
1213
E/

WW/W
d

2.2
^//

&
/

/

/
/^
/:

'
/
W
2.3
/ /

/14/
as follows:
d/
t

z
d /

12
^,:<
dD^'^
Eh:
W
/
tZW&< and
Ed
Wd
d>:^^::Z
E>dZ,>:>>/t,
Z:K:
d
&
14
<Y
13
20
d
^

d /

^
W
K
d/

t

dd

d
d/

K E d
: d/

Standards

d

d/

/

d

Public interest
d/
d/
21

t

d

/
d /

interest, and on what basis.
/
2.4
//

/
/
/&

/
2.5
d
/DE
Z : Y
WtDE
DK&

/ D K
/ d
/
/
2.6
tD
W

/

d

Z
d
/ ,
, , t s , K:d : ,
ED>st,dt
& & ^ D
22
d

2.7
^

15
/
Y
dZ

2.8
//
/
W
/ /
/
d / /
Zt/
/
or to be accorded a lesser status to the evidence that was adduced orally: it has all been
d
/

/
2.9
//
/
because they were not relevant to the Terms of Reference but, rather, because they were both
d

K
2.10 /DD^>
d
:Z

DZ
Edt/
DD/
D Z
15
tW^d^
&DK&W'&&,>W
Z/>/dD:t/:E
':E'>D>DD:tD
Z&DZD/EdE
WZZWZd^^
^^DDEd/h<h<W
h>tdZh<DZ
:^tzD
23
W
t
/
/ /
//DZ
/16
Module Two
2.11 d D d & d

DKK
17
d/

d/
t
z
/
/

d/
d/

d/
W ^

d /
d /

d
d/

W^

d/
W ^

16
KWd
ZD
17
<YD
24
d
d/W^

d / W ^

d/

d/

/
d/

d/

d
/

d/

Professional Standards
d /

d/

d/

W^
25
d/

W^

2.12 Dd&
K
Z ,
K t d d
W
W''
D^
DW^

DW^
W
d

W K
&/^K
DW^&
DW^ D K W
d/

2.13 /
d Z D : D
EE
/dD
DdD
Module Three
2.14 DdD
d
WDWD
>K&D^
d

W
'E
^>ZD

/
d W Y
^ ^ K D ^
26
d
/ / W
Y,
:,DW19d:
:
2.15
20

/
d/
t
z
/
/
d/
t
,t
,
D:d
'

d/

t t
,
/

d/

tt
,

/
,

K
d/

,/
d
,D
19
K,D,
D/

/

20
<YD
27
d/
'

'
/

/
,
t
/
/
d /

,

tt
Module Four
2.16 D & : / d
/
W&W&W
D

/
d
/ Z Z21
d
d
//
d

d
d
d

d/
/

d
/
d/
21
Z^
d
Z^

/

/

/

/

&^
d
d

d

/

/
W

W
d

d
d

d
29
Cost
d

2.17 YD&

/
d
22

/ d
follows:
Z
,
, d

/

d/

in areas such as

,
Z

t

/
22
<YD
30
d

/
or obligatory.
W
t

/
td
d /

t
t

dW

t

W

10. What other changes would you consider desirable in order to encourage or
z

3.1
>/

t

d

/
31
d

3.2
d/
K
W/
/
dW/
dZ
d/>:D
W
,t,
d /

3.3
dW

&
W
/dZ/Z
2006 is in these terms:
^

t

t

who has given oral evidence.
d

t

3.4
^/
//
32
d
W/

23 That was, in fact, the
/
W

/
/
/

^/W

/
/
3.5
d
/dZ
E
&
3.6

//
/Y
, / /
/
,

d

24
3.7
&/d
W
DK

E
^>/
D/
23
24
dW
^tK
D&WdZ/

Z/Z
KD:,
KDE>:,
Z&:
33
d
'd/

/

dW
dZ/
3.8
d
/

dZ/K
3.9
W d ^ > W
'>W
W&

t Z D
^W
DZ,'DWD

25D
DDt
d/
d26,
^
3.10 //
/d
/
/
/
/

DD

DDD
d
d

3.11 /
/
/d/

DDdZ
25
dD,

26
dD,
:
34
d
KD
'd^
/27
3.12 //
K

dZ
/dZ

d
K
4.1
d/
/
/

//
d
/

/
/^
/&/
raised concerns about factual accuracy, /
/
4.2
s /
/
//
/
/
4.3
d/
/W

/d

/d
27
&/
DW&

dD
,:
35
^
5.1
//WD
K29 There were submissions at
the start of Module Two from Mr Jay, and also on behalf of the Commissioner of Police for the
DDWDKW
30DdD:31
5.2
/ / W
/
K
W

32^
Z / Z
/ ^

5.3
& /
/
d
/
d
Z
/ZdZ
W

5.4
/

:

Wd
29
dD,
E, d
,Ed
D,E
d,E
d,E
d,E
30
W
31
dD,D
32
ZZW^
ZK/
^K later amended
^K
/
ZW^/^D
&//
/
36
d
/

/
/

6.1
Z
/
/
6.2
//
d
d

/
t

/

/

6.3
K
///

/
37
CHAPTER 3
FURTHER ISSUES OF LAW
Z/Z
1.1
WZ
/Z
/
Z1/
K
/t
//

/

E

d
Z d / ^
Z

^

^Z^s>YZ

d
^ >: Z W W >
DZD
>>:
Dd/Y
d
/

d

/
/
E
>//^Z^/D
^://d

Z/Z
&/>
d /
&
/
^

/
/

t

d Z
/ZZt
>dZ
d

d
d

1.2
/ / / /
/
Z/

/

/

2
1.3
/DYdD

//
/
Z
/Z
39
/
/

/
/

1.4
Z/
d
/ W
d
/
1.5
/ Z
/
//

d
/
1.6
, / Z

Z//

tt
t

t

,/
//

W
1.7
d
/Zd/

//

/
,/
//
/ /
/
1.8
/Dd
DW^
40
&/>
3 On the other hand,

/ DW^
W///
ZDW^4
/Z
/
1.9
D d &

/d
Z
KdZ

/
/

dD
d/
/
1.10 ^ h<

W D
&
/ Z ^
/

1.11 d /

E
^ > / /
DW
5/

:/
/

/

3
/^W
DW:

4
Z/Z
DW^D
5
d
,D
41
1.12 /D&/Z
/
> W &
>,tW/
/
/

/

1.13 />/

>
//

//

Z
Z/Z
2.1
dZ/Z&
d

Ed

/
2.2
d

Z/Z6dZ

/

//
//
2.3
d
Z7

DZ
d/
//Z
7
d//Z
Z/Z
42
&/>
2.4
/
/

/

2.5
Z
//
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
Z/
d
3.1
d
/
9d
dZW/
/

D
E t

'

W

tK^
/EdDW^Z,WW/s
&^diatribe
loading a gun,

/

9
/
43
3.2
WE
td'

D /
//d
Z
d

'

W'

3.3
These issues are to be contrasted with those set out in Part 2 of the Terms of Reference,

E/

E//W
/W
/
W
E/
K
W
WdZ

44
&/>
3.4

/
10&/

11^
/
dD

d

3.5
d
&

/

/

E
/

3.6
E

d /

/
Edtd

t/W

3.7
//
d /

^
10
/
/
11
45

& /

d

3.8
d/

E/

//d

3.9
d /

/

3.10
//

d

//
analysis of Z,D^^W12
ZED,ZdEZ13 and Z14

the more careful the analysis of the facts will have to be not least because of the reduced
15
3.11 /Z/Z/
/

16 / D
/dZ,^t'/
12
Z,D^^W>E
Y
14
t>Z
15
^Z>d
Z^
W^W,Z
16
Z
/Z
13
46
&/>

,
17
3.12 /

/
Edt
/
Edt'
W
3.13 d
/

D/

/

3.14 D:YE>

/

3.15 /

d
/
d
/Z
/
/

3.16 ^
DdDd/

/

17

WZ
/Z
47
3.17 / /

d
d
Y

K

CHAPTER 4
THE REPORT
^
1.1
d/h</dZ
'h<Ê/t
/

/Z

h<D
/Z
Ê/t/

/

h< / /

W
2.1
dZ&/d
/
/

/
&
/

W /
Z
2.2

/
d
/

/

/

49
d
/

2.3
dZ
dZ/
d
Z
Z/
2.4
d Z /
dZ
&

//

/d
Z/
2.5
/Z
/Z

'//
/d
d
3.1
/WD
Z
d
dZD

d

3.2
/E
Z:
'
/
/Z
//
Z

50
dZ
3.3
D/

W

h/
W
d/

d
3.4
Z//
Z

d
Z1

/
Z,/
Z
d//
51
PART B

THE PRESS AND THE
PUBLIC INTEREST
53
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1
This Part of the Report alludes to some of the fundamental principles which must provide
h</

1.2
d
W
h<W

/
d
/
1.3
t
WZ
/
/
/
1.4
/WZ
/

d
and important concepts; commensurate clarity and care is needed in their deployment in the
Zd

1.5

/dZ^

d

d
1.6
d/

1//
//
//

/
/
dD,:
55
CHAPTER 2
THE FREEDOM OF THE PRESS AND
DEMOCRACY
1. Context
A free press is the unsleeping guardian of every other right that free men prize;
it is the most dangerous foe of tyranny Under dictatorship the press is bound to

&
1
Winston Churchill
d
&
elsewhere, have recognised the cardinal importance of press freedom and the need

>
1.1
d>
h< t
d
>

K>

1.2
DW
1.3
/R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Simms

>^
&
/
&
^,::^D

Abrams v USh^,:d
d
/
^
Z>'h<,>
Chapter 2 | The Freedom of the Press and Democracy
/
/
^
^^d>
/d

d

1.4
d>EReynolds v Times
E>
d

d W
to make an informed choice, regarding individuals as well as policies, and those
>

t
1.5
d , Z
^ / ^ ,,Z
^

^
^^d^

,Z
^

&
/

1.6
The fundamental importance of the freedom of the press was a very familiar theme of the
/ / /
d/

d
PART B | The Press and the Public Interest
/
dZ

2. A brief history of press freedom in the United

Kingdom
2.1
d
/
/
2.2
&
'
^
,s///
W^d
^
2.3
d^,
W
/d:D
the free press in d^>hW
d
>

/'

2.4
D
>
,

2.5

d
/W
W /
^d

2.6
/
W
WDW:t
d >
58

E
2.7
d,

d

&
2.8
^ t t '
ZZZ,
^
Z'
&
2.9
/ '
Z
' K

t

d'
d

2.10
'
ZW
W

W

/
d
'W5
to safeguard the freedom of the press; to encourage the growth of a sense of public

d&W&
^h

'ZWZ
5
/
2.11
ZW

of newspapers, magazines and other periodicals in the United Kingdom, including

television; to consider whether these factors tend to diminish diversity of ownership

/

/'d
W'
2.12 E
dZ
W
d
and editorial standards of newspapers and periodicals and the public freedom of

d W it is

The Press Council rejected

2.13 /'^Y
dZ
WWdW
W ^
Wd
8
2.14 t

, Z
,Z

/,Z
/
there can be no democracy

'ZWZ

8
W

K'h<,ZZ

^Z>^/
2.15

d

d,Z

11
2.16 ^
,Z,Z/
^

2.17 d
&
^&

2.18 ^
'

d
,

2.19
/
d

WKKE

/
d
d
3.1
t
W
11
>E
WKKE
d,:
d
13

a liberal public sphere, one in which every member, everyone in the community, can
/
but its also a good in itself that we all have the status of being able to take part in
W

3.2
/
ZZ15

/
/
>/
arguments over climate change and helping the public to evaluate where the truth
3.3
/
&
d

d:^DK>
d

/ an
argument for free speech for the powerless will not make a case for free speech for a powerful
3.4
d
d

/

d
13
WKKE
WKE

ZdD
,:
15
ZdK
Z

WKKEt
^WKE

Z

18
d

3.5
d
d

when some elements of the press are more powerful communicators than other papers and
/
3.6
d
D

its collision with error
,

dthere is

t
3.7
d

/

4. The importance of a free press: public debate and

holding power to account
4.1
d
d/
Zd
D,:
18
WKKEt
^WKE

t^W
D

tÊD

d
freedom from interference with the form and content of what it says, but also the

understanding

^
important /

The public interest in a free press lies largely in the character of our society as a
/
insofar as such a press serves as a necessary bulwark against government duplicity

d

d
/

d
to inform
and
wider public

public interest by its and
4.2
&
d
/

t^Z
ZdD
,:

t^W^
D

t^W
D

tÊD
4.3
d
d

&
4.4
d
s
D
by his modern counterparts at The Daily Telegraph resulted in the exposure of widespread
D W >

4.5
d

/
5. Press freedom within the rule of law and the role of

statute
5.1
d ,

5.2

5.3
>

/
5.4
/
Z

Z

d&

ddZ>

5.5
d

/

Z
^

,
5.6
d

d
5.7
Z

d

d
K/

d /

5.8
&

/

^
5.9
d
/
5.10 d
/

d/

/
5.11 The other reason to clarify that a free press within a mature democracy operates within the
/

d
5.12 dW

//

5.13

K
K
E

h

5.14 d / >
,
W
d
d/31K
/ W

5.15 dD
doubt possible of how the freedoms of the press should best be held in balance with other
W
/
W

W:
>,d
,:
31
dD

,ZW
d
the press
6.1
/

d
/

6.2
WE

d W W

&

>t:33
d

6.3
&
journalists a form of protected status
Reynoldsd

W ^

33
,D'E>Z
W
CHAPTER 3
COMPETING PUBLIC INTERESTS
1. Context
1.1
d

d

d

1.2
dE
/

/'

1.3
d
K

d
^

1
There are more components of the public interest than those that are served by a

^
1.4
D
d

d

Dovershadowed by his rhetoric

/

absolutely against faith or manners that no law can possibly permit that intends not
t^W
D
1.5
^
&
& h ^
t
h^^

1.6
,
/ h ^ ^

& d

d^

h<3
1.7
,Z
d

1.8
d/

/
/
interest would freedom of expression, or freedom of the press, have to be balanced
d/

the rule of law, the proper independence and accountability of law

enforcement of private interests, for example

,
Z
personal data,

property rights, and
&^nd
ibid

<YD
3
W/
individual freedom of expression and rights to receive and impart

t/
2. Freedom of expression
2.1

d
has value for individuals
5
&

2.2
d>
//
in this way
&

d
2.3
d
,
d
D

think that individuals need to be able to express their views in order to develop fully
as human beings, it does not follow that extensive freedom should be extended to
d
put the point starkly, those who aim to communicate must aspire to standards which
2.4
d
/

tÊD
t^Z

t^W^D
2.5
/
/
/

d

E >
/8
d

harmed by free speech the opportunity to exercise their right of reply, not all have the
/

2.6
^
&

d
E
2.7
t
/

Z
d
W
freedom of expression is put under pressure by the free speech of others in ways which are
2.8
d
d

11d
d

d
/
Ê
>&Z

^ZZ,h&:,

WWKW,
11
W&
W/
W
3.1
d
D

d
h<
/habeas corpus

3.2
Personal autonomy means that individuals must have a sphere in which they can exercise
d
personal sphere has been described in Western liberal philosophy in terms of the public
&
d

/
3.3
/

,Z
d
> ,
in D'E >

/
> E
3.4
d /

s
d
d

3.5
d
^

3.6
t

&^sW>

s
d

B
3.7
t
13D
d necessarily imply that other

3.8
d/15

,
/
E
does it follow that he has made some kind of tacit contractual agreement, where he

d

doing so, but it does not follow from this that everyone that the public might have
an interest in should have their private lives placed at risk of intrusive and invasive
3.9
d

3.10 /

d

3.11

13
^D

d,:
tÊD

d
W
15
tÊD

ibid
W/
,d

W

3.12 /
WD
:

d

3.13 d
,Z d

d,Z
d

18
4. Other public goods

4.1
d
K

d
K

4.2

d

d
t^W
D
18

D^^&t/
'ED>h<^
CHAPTER 4
THE RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE PRESS
1. Context
1.1
d
,Z
/

/

D the

that power to the
2. Press power and the impact on society

2.1
/
K

D
D
D
2.2
/

/d
/

K

d

Similarly, the there is a public interest in learning of dangers and risks, even where

2.3
d
3
tÊD
ibid
3
ibid
dZW

DK

/

&<
d
strictly speaking, one has an opportunity to express ones views, one is not free to
E

2.4

5
t

d

/

2.5
K
t
&
2.6
The tendency of views expressed in the press to prevail can be also be explained by a
d
/
/
ibid
t^W
D

W:d
dD,:

W:,
dD,:
5

/
d
DDZ
D
B
2.7
d

11
/
race or about gender, it isnt simply that there will be a wider audience for that but
also that the opinion comes with a greater degree of with an imprimatur, or seems
d

2.8
d

K

that individuals remarks are typically limited in their impact But this megaphone
/

13
/
/

3.1
d
d

W,d
D,:

Wdd
D,:

tÊD
11
W^D
dD,:

W:,
dD,:
13
W:d
dD,:

W,d
D,:
dZW
d

3.2

/

/

3.3
d t
t^
ds

d
3.4
E/
t
t

t
t

3.5
t&
d

Et

t
t
E

d
3.6
t

/ d
ds

'

3.7

^
/d

the newspaper;
WZ

3.8
/

WKKE
/

D
t
3.9
d

/
Those who aim to communicate must aspire to standards which are inapplicable for
15
d

/
that communicates other sorts of content eg music and art, puzzles and stories
E

'
d
15
t^W^
D

t^W
KE
dZW

/d
d

18
One aspect of the public interest is the public interest in truthfulness Here there
dnot being
deceived or misled
/

^
E intermediaries d
d
d
d
Knowing the source

K

t

appropriate procedures and mechanisms need to be in place to ensure that what is

4. Press ethics and the role of a code of ethics

4.1
W/dZ

d
WKKE
d,:
18
d,
:ibid

tÊD

ibid

ibid

ibid

ibid
81

4.2
d

4.3
d

d
4.4
/

/
t
/

/

/

/

//
/

&

W
will therefore be especially mindful of the need to ensure that the individuals it deals

itself to secure
d
EDd
,:
dZW

/
d/
d
^

/
also need to pursue its work with accuracy and rigour, to be concerned for the truth,

&
^

The strategy here has been to focus on the valuable ends that a free press is meant
not
that a free press can even stand as an obstacle
This is not to argue in favour of censorship but to point out ways in which a free press
can fail

/

K
a necessary
d

W^D
dD,:

t^W
D

WD
dD,:

tÊD

t^W
D
83
t

W

d

public sphere that gives appropriate status and respect to individual people, and on

31
d

d
33
&W

in and telling the press what they may or may not say with respect to output, but they

/E/
4.5
d

The fact that freedom of expression is in the public interest and it clearly is it
35
/
be the primary public interest the public has in the press, and then that can then seem
^
and one values being allowed to write what one thinks is important, theres a kind
/
4.6
/
standards are not inconsistent with a free press but necessary for it fully to realise the value

t^W
KE
31
t^Z

ibid
33
EDd
,:

WD
dD,:
35
Zd
D,:

WD
dD,:
dZW

has choices which it can exercise in ways which undermine the premises of its freedom and

4.7
t
t
4.8
d

4.9
d
/

whatever sells newspapers must ipso facto
d

d
/
d
not entail a right

There is no ethical duty at all to provide audiences with whatever they want, even if
38
d

d
&what^
/
stop

//
t
tÊD
ibid

ibid

ibid
38
85
4.10 d

D

4.11 d
d

They also include

4.12 d/
/E

4.13 d
W D

/
K

,
/
D

d

/

&
d

understood and endorsed by its owners and editors, and these people need to live
WKE
d,:
dZW
d

^

^

4.14

/
/

/
/
//

/

/
//

//
4.15 The /

/W
EDt^
ED

W^Dd
D,:
KE

4.16 /

/
K/
framework, while driven by a range of diverse goals that are not necessarily ethical

the liberal public sphere A free press within an ethical media industry in this sense

respect for the truth, respect for those about whom the press writes, respect
for readers;

/
communicate in ways that enable intended audiences to understand and to

dd

WKE
d,:
t^WKE

WKEt
^WKE

t^Z

t^W
KE
88
dZW
d

^

d

d

d

W
introduce governance reports which press/media would produce annually,
d

to avoid either being overburdensome or being a mere ritual in order to be

/ it has to be, not only coherent

4.17 //d
DW/

/
K

//
//
/ d
t

E/
t^W
D

tÊD

WdK
ZWK^Wh>Z^^D/EZ^W,
PART C

THE PRESS
CHAPTER 1
CONTEXT
/
1.1
d/

dWZ
d
1.2

d

d
d

/d
1.3
d

1.4
&

2. Commercial pressures on the press

2.1
/
d
h<

2.2
d

t

2.3
d
93
PART C | The Press
E
2.4
d^Y
W
dh<
ds/ds
K

Zd
2.5
E
^Z
dh<

ds
2.6
dd

sh<ds
d

2.7
Kh<3

h<

E

2.8

d^
/ K

and the
, that
,
t

^z

h<^
3

WW^K

'

WW^K

Chapter 1 | Context
2.9
d^^
^
dE
Title
d^
D
^
Z
D
d
d
Times
FT
Guardian
Independent
^
2002
Et
^^
^D
People
^^
^D
D^
^
^d
^d
K
/^
^
2012
% change

^9
E
2.10 E
/

9

^

PART C | The Press

2.11
dKh<
/
D

K
2.12 d

Z&

d^tE/

2.13 ,

2.14 d
Wt
^d
,:

t^^&
t^D'
t^:D>
t^:Z

^&D':D>:Z
dD,:
Chapter 1 | Context
dE
Publisher newspaper division
E
E/E
D'd
dD
&d'W
dD'
'ED'D'
EE^
Regional newspapers
:W
dD
ED'd
E'
FY 2010
Revenues (m)
2005-10 change
in revenues (%)

E
h
E/E'E>dE>
&d'/
dD'D'ZD
E
^
2.15

/
h<
DK'

2.16 d

/^Wd
,

2.17 d/

t^s
s
PART C | The Press
/
2.18 d/
/

2.19
d
/
2.20 K

2.21 d
&dD

2.22

dh<&
dd

2.23 dWh<
ZtdD,
:

Ztd
D,:

ZWd
D,E

^d
,:

^&D':D>:Z
dD,:WD
D'EWEd
,:
CHAPTER 2
THE PRESS: HISTORY, GOVERNANCE
STRUCTURES AND FINANCES
/
1.1
/ /
/E
/E/hÊ1 This
EtEdt
/ZD
Edt
/

E
Group history and context
2.1
EEDD
E > E >
h<h^2DD
E3

E^
E
>EE^Y
^
2.2
E
/ /
' , <
Group governance
2.3
EEzdE
5 The Board sets the
E
dE6 In
dddE>E'E>d

2
Page, B, The Murdoch Archipelago
3

ibid
5
6
ibid
99
PART C | The Press
:E
Z
D
2.4
dD
DDWd^
Ê<,
E
dD^
2.5
ED^D^
Edt
E/8
2.6
dDÊE/9/
/
W
2.7
dD^
E/d^ddd^d/E/

2.8
D^
E/
dDÊ/
11
2.9
dD^:<sWE
Corp,12'^sW
''E
EWsE
13dD^
&
2.10 E15/
/
16 / E

D^
9
ibid

ibid
11
ibid
12
ibid
13
D^

W
15
16
ibid

ibid
8
Chapter 2 | The Press: History, Governance Structures and Finances
2.11 E
/E
18 E
19/E

2.12 dEdt:
Wd

2.13 / E
D
d
E
d D ,
/W
2.14 dED
,W
>d According to that

^ZD'
^dW'^:D
/W^W21
E/
2.15 E h< E/22
dE,>dE,>E
' E > E'E d E > dE> d
dd^ddE,>E'Ed^
d^Êdt23
2.16 /E/d
,
/E
2.17 / ^ E/ d > W d
h<d>W
>
/^
>D>>^
18
ibid
21
ibid
22
23
t^d
D
19
PART C | The Press
2.18 d^DD
d^^^
family orientatedethical//
d^Dd^
force for good,25
d
^
to its readers26,,
2.19 DDEdt28

^D/
/
:DEdt29

2.20 E/dd
ddd^d
d^d/d

D/<Wd
&/&
E/E'
2.21 EdtZD:d^
/W/WDD
Kd
Edt:d^

31td^

Dh<
/^tE
25
Dd
,:
26
ibid

Dibid
28
ZDd
D,
29
:Dd
D,
31
^Zd'hd
2.22 DD
E/d^
Edtd
Edt<W
/
E/32d<
DD
33
2.23 The ^DD/

Wd

d ^
^>>
2.24 D D
dÊdt

E h : Eh:

2.25 E/ t
'/E/

d t

&
2.26 /
' 35 /
DD
E/&^

2.27 dÊ/
^
36
d^
/d^
2.28 dÊdt>W
E>'E/
32
Page, B, The Murdoch Archipelago

ibid

WThe Murdoch Archipelago
35
^Zd'hd
36
ibid

W/
33
PART C | The Press
/DD
d38/^'
>Wd^
Wd
D D
W/
2.29 d^h<
d39Edt
:
^
2.30 dd^^
Edt
E/dE,>
2.31 dE,>ddd
d^dddh<
/

2.32 &
dKE/
dh^&
d^
^d&^^

DDDD
2.33 ddK
ddDd^dDd^
^:W

DD
d d ,

&
^
dE,>
38
&
39

:

&

,,:s

,,:sibid
d

&

&

^
has delegated authority.
^

2.34 dd,>

2.35 d^^d>DW:^
^^
d K ' argued that
dE/
' d W D
^ ^ Z D &
'ZDW
/Z,'
WDd/d
d^/
/
2.36
dE/
^
2.37 dd

/ddd^d
D d d > W
d^dW

2.38 /&dd
d
d^
,,:sibid
,,:sibid
PART C | The Press
d&d
^^d
d^d
^^
2.39 h d ^ d d d ^ d
d h< d d
h<D
d'
D

E/
2.40 dE/d/
KE
^/DD
:E''EE/
dD/E/E
/
E/
E/'>

2.41 DD/E/:
,51

D

2.42 d/ddd^dd
Ê/
52E
E/Edt
&

t^d
D

&t^d
D
51
dD
dD,:
52
t^d
D
2.43 dE

E/E/inter
aliah<E/
53
2.44 d dE,>
^^dddE,>
/E
/E
E/ddE,>
ddd^d
55d/
d d dE,>
56d^ds There
dEE'EE/d
58
E/
2.45 E/E59d
^
E'E

2.46 By contrast, The dd^d
61,dE,>
dE,>

62
2.47 E'EE/
D
d >
W^
2.48 K E/ ,
E/
63
53
ibid
ibid
55
t^:t
56
t^:
,

t^:t
58
t^d
D
59

61
62
63
ibid
PART C | The Press
E/
2.49 dE/ddd^
d
DDE'E
dÊdt,/
/Et/

65/d^66

^
E/
2.50 dE
/
^D^
EW68dE/E'EdE,>z69 On account
hÊ/
^K
2.51 d&
Zd&dE/
dd
2.52
& Payments to

Edt
W
&K
d

ZDd
D,
65
ZDibid
66
ZDibid

t^d
D
68
t^^
W
69
ibid

ibid

ibid

t^d
D

ibid

t^^
W

ibid

ibid
In

E/
2.53
dD

2.54 d d
d^d
81d^
82
E/
2.55 EE/^
'WZZ
W83 / E/ E/
WWWW
W/WW
W & Edt
tW85WW86

tWE/
E'88
2.56 / E/ K
89 and
Kd
E/
ibid
t^
D

t^^
W

t^:
,
81
t^:
t
82
t^
Dt^
'^
83
t^d
D

ibid
85
ibid
86
ibid

ibid
88
ibid
89
ibid

ibid
PART C | The Press
2.57
W
91/
ddd^dd^W
92 d ^ d
W93
2.58 hE/E

d^d

the managing editor,9596
,Edt

98
E/
2.59 d
E/dE/DdE/
K
K 99
2.60 dd
d

:
d
2.61 d^dE

d
E
91
ibid
t^:,
t^:
t
93
t^:t

t^d
D
95
t^:t
96
t^W^

t^D
D
98
p5, para 19, ibid
99
t^d
D

ibid

t^:,

t^:t
92
2.62 d^
d d ^

E/
2.63 ^d^
Edt

E/
2.64 dd
z
d^d

^
2.65 dE^
^,/
Eh<
2.66 E/^d>
^d
W
h<^
> h<
h<hh<
2.67 d / / ^
^^^^
^
Dd

D This meant
h<

t^
D

t^'^

t^D
D

t^:,

ibid

t^:t

^W/

//
111
PART C | The Press
2.68 / W
d

^^
2.69
111/
E/^
^d

2.70 /EZ
^^
d , K E

E^
^
//
h/
/^^

are contrary to the public interestd/
112
2.71 h ^ /
d/

/113d
^

2.72 &^
h<d
^

d

K/ds
^^
^^

/
111
,>,Ks
112
,>,Es
113
,,Es
112
2.73 Ê
^<z/^
^ dd ^<z &Kyd>
EÊ
&^

^W>Ê
^
^115
^
2.74 d ^ d & K
d
EE/116
2.75 : D K ^
,
E / /
^
/
^/

,^
Ê
2.76 dÊ
Ê

118>Ê

2.77 KÊK

119KÊ
This
/ds121Ê
/K
122
&
&&
115
116
118
K&KD
119
ibid

ibid
121
ibid
122
ibid
113
PART C | The Press
2.78 d /
^ E d : Z , E ^ E D Z
/
'dÊ
123
2.79 DZÊ

2.80 DZ^
E

125
3. Associated Newspapers Ltd

,
3.1
dD,,d
D'dD'd>
, s E
DKddd^d
,D'd
,,stsZdds
sZDd,
D'd

3.2
s Z D'd /
DE'sZ
/126,
D'd
DsZ
/D
/
/E
D128
D/
d
t

123
:Zd
D,

:Zibid
125
:Zibid
126
sZd
D,D

sZibid
128
3.3
d DK

DsZDK
global footprint.129
3.4
d D W
t /
WD
131
dD'
3.5
D'd

/ D'd
D'd
D'd
EDED
Eh<
3.6
E/
132/
E
d E
h<
3.7
EDh<

ÊD
Z
3.8
E D D ^ D
DK d D
d^
&133dD
h</
d D ^ & 135
&Et^
^^&
d&D^
^
129
sZd
D,D
131
Wd
,&
132
ZEDE
133
&
135
&
115
PART C | The Press
3.9
d
DKdDKh<
d
h<h^136d
DKDD^,
DK
h^
Governance structures
3.10 E > D D ^ D
DKE>EDD'd
h<^138KED
EEDED
E
3.11 d D'd d
EDE
D'ddD'dZ

139 / / ^
E
3.12 dD'd
d E
D'd d
ED'd
d
DK
DE
3.13 D
//
z
136
t^D

Wtd
D,:
138
139
t^W
t^<

t^<

t^Wt

Dd
,D

Wd
,&
116
3.14 D
D'D'd
,/
/ d d d d K /
D /

3.15 d D D
E/D
/>'
/ , /
>'
DD
E
3.16 E
Ed

d
E

3.17 /
d

3.18 W

t

E
3.19 W
E
E>E>
W W
d
151
t^W
Wd
,&

t^W

ibid

ibid

p2, para 5, ibid

p6, para 18, ibid
151
p5, para 15, ibid
PART C | The Press

3.20 D /
/
D152
/

E>WW153

3.21 W

W
155d/E>

E>
156
3.22 /E>
W

/158
3.23 ^ E>
159E>:/
E> E>

d
E>

W161
152
p6, para 19, ibid

p8, para 25, ibid

p6, para 19, ibid
155
ibid
156
ibid

ibid
158
ibid
t^Wt
159
t^W

p13, para 39, ibid
161
ibid
153
118
3.24 W

162
3.25 Etd
W',/

163
E
3.26 EZ

/

165^166
d

3.27 dDKD/

168
3.28 /

W

169d/D

W
W
162
ibid
ibid

ibidt
^Wt
165
t^W
t^W
t
166
t^W
t^Wt

t^W
t^W
t
168
Dd
,D
169
t^
W

p6, para 19, ibid

ibid
163
119
PART C | The Press
E
3.29 d E>
D'd
D/
4. Northern and Shell Media Group Ltd

4.1
E^Z
d'DE/
/E^
greatest newspaper,

/

4.2
WD/
'
'
,t/
4.3
d W
>WZ
W
dW,/

//
>W

ibidt^
Wtt^
>,

t^W

t^Z

Zd
,:

,td
D,:

W,d
,:
,
4.4
d W /
D>
/&181
it will be for his role as a pioneer of newspapers and for his ability to form public

4.5
h
h</182,
>
d,/d,
^ E D / d ,
&,
hE/E
^^
E^Z
4.6
dE^D'Z
183d
d
EE:dE^
D'^
^ ^ ^ K< E ^
d
zs
185
4.7
/E^D'
186'
d&

d
d^DD
^d
^
E^'/&
^^^

^
181
183
Zd
,:
185
186
E^

&
182
121
PART C | The Press
E^
4.8
d '
188
dE^
4.9
dE
^/:E
WW189
E^
4.10 d/E^
ED
/

,191

4.11 d W ,
W
D,,
192
/D
DWD
W

4.12 D
D,
WDd,193
W,
188
t^W

189
t^Z

Wd
,:
t^Z
191
t^Z

192
W,d
,:
193
Zd
,:
122
E^
4.13 ' E ^
&
E E ^
E
dD

195

E^
4.14 E
196dW
'D
^^/
W
198dE^
/

199
4.15 E ^ W
WZ

WE^
'

4.16
E^

4.17 d The

t^Z
^
195
t^W
196
t^D

DD^
198
t^'
D
199
DD^

tÊ
W

tÊ
t^D
d

t^Z
^

t^Z
^
123
PART C | The Press
E/E
W,>E/
/
/
4.18 E^/
E
^ D
E
DE
^d

WE^

4.19 D t /
, D E ^
within the
/^^
DD/
E : D
D/
D

4.20 d/E
/DE/
^
^ /
t/
EWd
D,:

Ed
D,:

Eibid

Eibid

t^,
t

t^'
D

Ed
D,:
E^
4.21 d E ^
211 :
212d
213DW
/
//

/,

4.22
215 d /
216^

5. Trinity Mirror plc

5.1
dDD

218
^D>
219ZtD
>

5.2
>DW
DW221

211
tÊ
W
212
tÊ
213
t^,t

EWd
D,:
215
t^Z

216
t^,
t

tÊ
W
218
219

Ztd
D,:
221
t^>
125
PART C | The Press
DWd
222
5.3
D'>D
W/D
/
D223D
W/
D//
/
//

/
5.4
ddD
225 The
W
226d^D

Other campaigns
D , W
Awards228Dt/D
ordinary people229
,
5.5
d D , s E
d ,
s s E D
/

/:D

5.6
/D'/
W/W/D',
dÊ/
//WZ/>/W
222
ibid
>d
,:

>ibid
225
t^
dt
226
t^>

t^dt
228
t^Z
t
229
p6, para 18, ibid
223
126
,ZDDZ
D'DDd
>d
d D
'dDh<231
5.7
5.8
dDh<

/dD232 The Group
h<
d'ZEdE
dD
Z

dDDZ
^^DW^D
Z/&D233
dZ
D'
d^DW^
D&
^D'
^
^
5.9
dD>^
dD
5.10 d
d &
^235ZZ

236d/
Z

DEZ238
231
dDWD&/E>
233
&

&
235
236
t^^

p15, para 59, ibid
238
ibid
232
PART C | The Press
5.11 t d D
/

239d
DEZ

dD
5.12 d D ^ D W
dDd

dD
dD
5.13 &
E
dDdD
d&WdD

Trinity
D

/

5.14 D'E
Payments under the

d

251
239
t^dt
t^Z
t

t^^

p23, para 85, ibid

t^s
s

ibid

dD&Wd/

t^s
s

ibid

ibid

ibid

ibid
251
ibid
128
dD
5.15 dD^252
d253
dWWdD
255
256dDtW

5.16 dD'
258dD

W259
D
5.17 ddD'
d
d
,
D

5.18 d
d D d
' 261 262
:D
W263Dt/

D d

252
ibid
t^Ws

t^^

255
ibid
256
t^W
s

ibid
258
t^s
st^
Zt
259
Ztd
D,:
t^dt

^d
,:
261
t^>
t^d
t
262
t^D
D'
263
Ztd
D,:

Ztibid
253
129
PART C | The Press
265d

dD
5.19 d D
dD
266
D'Z
5.20 dD'D'^
/D'ZW
W268 d
/DEDE
'D'
269dDE

6. The Telegraph Media Group

6.1
d d
d d D ' d

campaigning newspaperD
DW

6.2
ddd'/
d,
W
265
t^d
t
266
t^>

t^D
D'
268
ibid
269
p5, para 26, ibid

ibid

p11, para 55, ibid

t^

ibid

ibid

t^d
'
6.3
ddtD
/
t d
'
,
6.4
dd^
:D>>
ds

> , h > d
' , / > , /
/^&^
,/d '
6.5
/&d
dd
h</
The ^d
^^dh<
^
6.6
d d D ' ^
^ & & ^ /
/
d ' d ^ d
d
d
6.7
d d D '
& ,
ZDWWD^>d
281
t^

&

t^d
'

:Z&zdD'>
D

t^D
D>
281
t^D
D>
131
PART C | The Press
d
6.8
d
282d
dD'
dD'283D'/
dD'

d
6.9
d

285

&286dD'/

6.10 dD'

&>288
KdD'
289

d
6.11 dD'
W291 d

292DdD'

293
282
t^d'
t^
/D'
283
ibid

d'd
,:
285
t^&
Z
286
t^d
'

t^&
Z
288
ibid
289
ibid

ibid
291
t^d
'
292
ibid
293
ibid
132
6.12 dD'
dD'

295dD'
/
296
d
6.13 dKdD'DD>
,
td
d
,d298
6.14 ddD'd
>>299t
t
W>

6.15 D'/d
dd

storiesD'

t^&
Z
295
ibid
296
t^/
D't^
d'

DD>
d,:
t^DD>
298
t^d
'
299
t^

t^t

t
^

d'd
,:

d'ibid
133
PART C | The Press
d
6.16 dD'
d

dD'
7. The Guardian Media Group

7.1
d'd

&^d'^
d
dd'

7.2
The Guardian d /

'Z
/
^ d

/>

t'>W>
W^W>W
,
7.3
d D ' ' : d
WdW^
' in ^
^dW^
'dd

t^
t^
d't
^/D'

t^
&

Zd
,:
7.4
dd
'd^d
'D'd'D'
'ED'D'Z'D'W
dD'
7.5
/'D'
' E D ' K
/'W'ED
/&d'
h<
d K &
^^
311
7.6
' E D 'D' 'D' ^

d'312d^d

Kd
d313 This is to ensure the independence
'
'
7.7
d ^ d /
'Z'D'
E/d
'D'315
7.8
d'D''
'D' ^ 'D'
&K'D''D'Zd
/316d^d
'D'd
'D'Z

'D'Z
311
&
312
313
d
,:

t^
&
315
316
ibid

t^
&
135
PART C | The Press
'ED
318
7.9
d K 'D'
'ED'D'
319
'
7.10
^dd'D'

d
^d
E
321
'
7.11 d''D'

322'ED
323d

7.12 W
& W

325^

326/
318
t^D
319
p3, para 6, ibid

t^
Z
321
t^
&
322
t^^
323
t^
Z

t^^
325
ibid
326
ibid

ibid
136
'
7.13 d'328
dW'
329 d 'ED
W
W
/'ED
KW
d
d
d

7.14 d'

331W:
'D''ED
d'D'332
'
7.15 ^d
/d'D'
K,'D''ED
'D'
' K333 d
'ED'D'K,'D'
d 335
328
t^
Z
329
ibid

p15, para 21, ibid
331
^^Z
332
^^
333
t^
Z

t^D

335
dD'ED'D'K:
PART C | The Press
7.16 K'K
d
336d
'
7.17 W > ^ ' W

'ED
d>^'ED
d

338
'
7.18 'Kd'
^d
d339dK
d
^WW
KEKd

7.19 'd

Kd'
Z

7.20 K

dD
/

d/d/
//
,
336
t^
Z

ibid
338
t^'W
339
d
,:

t^Z

t^:
D

d,:

ibid
138

7.21 dK
d
' d K
Z
dK

t

7.22 //DK
maybe one or two a yea
8. The Independent Group

8.1
d//W
> Z >
d^>>
:>/

,

8.2
D>>^
>
td/
D>

8.3
d d / D >
d/D/
/,
d/Dserious
,
ibid
ibid

ibid

>d
,

t^>

>d
,

t^

139
PART C | The Press
8.4
d/
>/
>>
,
8.5
d/t^^
'ÊWd
t/
/
8.6
d/

/ / E D /ED /
D'EEW
/ED
d
/
E,
E
8.7
/ : >
^ E d D'd
^351/D>
d/>352
/

/
d
//
8.8
K
W
d/
8.9
/ & d / /

h<d/^
&h<^
351
Dd
D,:
352
8.10 /W>/W>>&
d>^>353
d/
8.11 d/W>K/W>E
d^&
8.12 d/W>

355 d & ^ /W>

356
8.13 d/W>^>/W>
d/W>
/W>358
d/
8.14 d359d

D

8.15 ,D
/
361DD

D D
353
t^
D

ibid
355
ibidt
^DD
356
DDd
D,:

t^
D
358
D
dD,:
t^D
359
ibid

Dd
D,:
361

dD,:
PART C | The Press

362
8.16 D / d /
free from
363 / / D >

,
/365
/

d/
8.17 d/
366DD/W>&
^^>/

8.18 h,
&^D368

&
d & ^ D

D d
&E
h<369
362
Dd
D,:
363

dD,:

t^>
365
>d
,
366
t^D
D

DDd
D,:
368
t^D
D
369
ibid
8.19 DD/
/W>/

d/
8.20 /W>
D/
d/
E d
d/W>&
^W

/
8.21 d,

/W>
W/W>/W>
d/W>
8.22 /W>

/W> d
/D
:,d/D,
t
DDd
D,:

DDibid

dD,:

DDd
D,:

t^
D

p6, para 22, ibid

t^D
D
PART C | The Press
8.23 ^
W&381

8.24 K
D
d/D
,
//382
z
d
d/
8.25 Dd/d
^
383
8.26 >
Dd/

8.27 d

D/385
/

//t//

t/
8.28 &,
386
t^

t^D
D
381
p9, para 38, ibid
382

dD,:
383
ibid

ibid
385
ibid
386
t^

9. The Financial Times

9.1
d&d
> & d /

h<
9.2
d & d&d / &

Ed&dWW

W
W

&d'&d
9.3
d&d'&d
&d '
d &d ' h<388 In
& &d h<
h<ddd&d
h<389
9.4
&d>W'
W'W
h^h<d&d
W'
K&dd
&dD391/
W d &d W
392
9.5
d &d d &d &d

&d393
d &d
&dd&d
&d
,WKhd&d
WZ
389
&

t^^
,
391
t^>
392
t^:Z
393

'&d
388
PART C | The Press
&d
9.6
d&d&d
&d
,Zd395 The Board is
&d396
&d
9.7
d&d
&d
9.8
W W> W
&d
W
398
W
9.9
d&dW
399&d
W

&d/&d
d/
W
&d
9.10 D&d
Wd
/

W & d

395
t^:Z

p3, para 12, ibid
398
t^>
t^>
D>t^
:Z
399
p3, para 13, ibid

t^>D>

t^:Z

t^>D>

>d
D,:
396
9.11 d
&dD&d
/
9.12 W
W,D
/&d
WKW
D
D
&d
,/
,Z&
d
9.13 /D/
/&d

/Z

9.14 d&d
t
&d

9.15 d&d
/

'
d The FT states that it does

9.16 t
WW
^
>ibid
t^:Z

>d
D,:

>ibid

>ibid

t^:Z

t^^
,

t^>D>

t^^
,

t^>
D>

t^d
PART C | The Press
&d
9.17 d&dD
&d/
d&d
9.18 /
The
/ Z

&dt
9.19 &
d
10. The regional press

10.1 d h<
^
:
d
d
10.2 Zh<
^
/

10.3 dK

d
,
^
ibid
t^>D>

ibid

t^:Z

t^>

ibid

ibid

WW^K


d

10.4 dW

d

d
Rank
weekly
Group Name
Rank
E
Titles
Weekly

dD
:W
ED'
ED>
91
E>
^>
Archant
66
d>
15
1,588,395
dDE>
dE>
11
/ED
39
12
<D'
19
322,269
13
/ED
15
EtED>
15
D>
13
16
E'>
13
361,695
/E>
261,882
18
W'
19
dE>
&W>
12
13
Total Top 20 publishers
951
44,609,342
Total all publishers (87)
1,101
46,034,273
Ê^:
WW^Kibid
WW^Kibid

WW^Kibid

dW:
PART C | The Press
10.5 K
d
d

d

10.6 d
dD
E
E:W

10.7

^dD
//K
/ :
Dd
D

^ The
d
D
DdD

10.8 d/
DD'dDZDE
/
D E

/

WW^K

WW^Kibid

WW^Kibid

WW^Kibid

^d
,:

îbid

îbid

îbid

Zd
D,:Z
d,:

Zibid
10.9 K
d

d
D
/
10.10 d

^
d
d
K & d K&d

d

/K&d

d

merger.
dK&d
dK&dK
h<
10.11 dK
<D'
E D > K > D

dK&d
K
/
K&d

dK&d
d
K&d K
tK&dE
DE<'
Zd
D,:

^d
,:

151
PART C | The Press
10.12 ///
'
/

,
/
//
/

d
/
Z
11. Magazines and periodicals

11.1 dh<dh<
d

ABC monitors some 515 consumer

d

K
ds
E d D K
^ Z^W

D

/
11.2 d
d

11.3 WWWW

t

11.4 D

WWEZDD
D^

WW^K

152
A
WW

d
,K<,D/

11.5 d/
, K< , D /

W

11.6 ,Dd
d
,D
K< D
K<D
11.7 E^K<
h<
dK<D
>K<D

^ ^

11.8 D//
^K<D

.
WW^Kibid

>ZE>
dD,:

>ibid

ZEibid

>ibid

t^Z

>dD
,:

>ibid
153
PART C | The Press
11.9 d K< D

D/
d
either
^ /

D
11.10 dK<D
EK<DW,D/
W^
K<D
W
D
K<D
,D
11.11 ,DD>h<
'W,D'd
,D
>,d
D,D

ds
11.12 / W ,
D'W'D
/D
, D W
d '
W'
11.13 D /
ad hoc
dWZD
>ibid
t^>

ibid

t^>

t^>

>dD
,:
,D
11.14 , D ^ ,K> ^>
::,D
d

11.15 Z E , D
D E ,
D
WDE/
/

11.16 ,Dd

WZ^
,D

11.17 :,DWW
,DE/
Wd
DE/
d

,D
,K>^>K
t^ZE
ZEdD
,:

t^Z
E

ZEd
D,:

t^Z
E

ibid

p13, para 33, ibid
155
CHAPTER 3
ALTERNATIVE NEWS PROVIDERS
/
C
1.1
For centuries the printed press was the only medium that brought news to the people.
d

d

2. Broadcasters
2.1
dh<

groups).1
h<

2.2
h<ds3ds4

5t
d

K
K
d
2.3
dZ6
::&
Agreement.dZ There also

3
h<^
4

t^Dd

Ddd
D,:
t^>W
156
EW
& ^ ^
D^
2.4
dd
/11>W
dd

dd

2.5

^d

and discussed.13d^

D14
2.6
d'Dd/
,
15Dd
16

d
/
/
/

2.7
d Z
d

Corporate Governance
2.8
d '

d'
t^>W
Ddd
D,:
t^>W

t^>W
13
t^D
d
14
ibid
15
ibid
16
Ddd
D,:

Z
11
PART C | The Press
. d d
'/'
K including the
d
'
/'
W'
d

C
2.9

&&D/h
KK&KW
/ h t K
& d K d
h
dh

h
Z
2.10 dddd
>W
/
/Dd
/
'

2.11 ,>Wd
'dd

Zd
Ddd
D,:

^'
t
^ZW
tÊZ

^

t^D
dt^>
W

>Wd
D,:

t^>W
EW
d
dd

2.12 K
dZ&
d dK
K

K ^
&dK:^'
, d
Wsdd
K
dK

d
2.13 K
tK

& K

'
K
31
2.14 d/
d
' The scandal around
33

d
dZEDE
d
d
t^
>W

t^Dd

^'

ibid

ibid

ibid
31
^'

t^>
W
33
Ddd
D,:
PART C | The Press
Academy.34//
h
2.15 /KZ:Z
^35/
D
which had led to the programme being broadcast.36 d
d^
Z d ^
Kdd

2.16 ^D
d/

/

2.17 d:Ê

E
/ /

E/ds
W

Complaints system
2.18 d Z &

dd

34
Ddibid
t^>W
35
t^>W
36
Dd
dD,:

t^>W

Ddd
D,:

EW
2.19 dd
dWd
41 This is to
ddd

d/
^
2.20

K

K43K>W
/K
44^

KK45
2.21 >W

^

D
'46d
d
2.22 d
>W'
too
,/
whose role would be to ensure that
d ' Z

>W/
K
K K
' Z
Ddd
D,:
41
t^>W

t^D
d
43
ibid
44
t^>
W
45
ibid
46
t^D
d>W
dD,:

>Wd
D,:

>Wibid
161
PART C | The Press

2.23 /^
/Dd/
d

t/

/dE
2.24 /dE
/ds/dEE
/dEd/dED
K:,
/dsEE51D
/
/dED/dE,^D
K
2.25 /dE,:53D
D:dD
out
/dE
54d/dE
/dE
2.26 /dE D

Edt:'E/
D as part of the
/ / /dE

D 55D56
Ddd
D,:

t^:
51
t^D

ibid
53
t^d
t^''
54
t^:
55
:'d
,:
56
:d
,:
EW
/
/d

/
/d
E
2.27 D ' E

E/dEDD'
D , /dE K D ' / E
K which are

.
2.28 D'E
,
/dE
D,/E
D
'61
t

/dEE
2.29 D/dE
K
/ds
2.30 d E /dE
D
/dE
D'/
^
KE
t^''
Z'ED
W

:'d
,:

t^:'
61
:'d
,:

:'ibid
163
PART C | The Press
63D'E
64

dd
/
d
2.31 KED'
/K
E,65
/dE
/dE/
d/

/

Complaints system
2.32 /D//dE
K,
66
ED'E
d
,
D'
him.,K
D'
E
K
.
3. The World Wide Web

3.1
dh<
/
/

Ed
63
:'ibid
:'ibid
65
:'ibid
66
:'ibid

:'ibid

:'ibid
64
164
EW
/
/

3.2
/h<
D
3.3
d/
h<
D
h<d

engines.
3.4
/
t
d
/
/
/

d

no role in the newsgathering process.
3.5

'/'
material only through online news content.,
''
3.6
/

K

d
Z/
3.7
/ / /

t/
h<

WW^K

:
dD,:

:ibid
165
PART C | The Press
and what might be published by websites hosted abroad.t

W ,

/d^W,
/
3.8
d
/,
//

/
3.9
d/d

/E
E/EEh<'
3.10 /h<
K /
d
td
/
W
/W<
3.11 /

W
D ^ Z
D ^ Z d
dsKddsK
Kd

3.12 /dsKh</
^W
/
/^W
d/t&/t&
d /t& /^W
h<

3.13 d
h< ,
/^W
t^
D

W&
166
EW

country.
3.14 ddh<

Z/Dd

/>d

3.15 dd'
/
/ This should be

'
copyright.
3.16 t/

/
K These
/KW
WZWZ
WZ
W
E/K
3.17 d

'

3.18 d/'
:sW
'W'
^Z,sD^/
W/dKZthK

D^,D'

:d
D,:
PART C | The Press

the internet.D
'

/'
:

4. Blogs and other web-based commentary

4.1
d /
4.2
d,W

K'&
W the :<
Popbitcht
Popbitch/Popbitch was to create
W

4.3
d
tPopbitch
'
&W^
'&'&
4.4
d
&D^/'& site
,
D^
:ibid
:ibid

:ibid

'd
D,

td
,:

W^dD
,&

Wîbid
EW
Popbitch
,D

4.5
4.6
/
'
>//

d

d

,

/
be considered as such.
W
4.7
DtPopbitch^

Dt

This she

&
4.8
Dt

t/
4.9
h
Dt
Dt
W^d
D,&

::W/Y
W/:W/tt

td
,:

tibid

tibid

tibid

tibid
PART C | The Press
//

4.10 DtPopbitch

Popbitch to consider.
4.11 DPopbitch
'&
D^

/

d

d
4.12 /, D^

,
d
4.13 D ^
,

z
t
d
/
/
4.14 D^
'&/
D^K

4.15 D ^ /

As such '&
tibid
W^d
D,&

Wîbid

W^d
D,&

Wîbid

Wîbid
EW
'&

4.16 D^d
^<D
'&
it was gossipy or humorous in nature.
4.17 D'&
D t Popbitch is
, D
t^
Dt
d
not yet happened.
4.18 d/,W
UK/Popbitch'&,Wh<is not a blog built

W
W The
,Wh<

4.19 D,Wh<
d
made around training and editorial guidelines./
,D

rule. A similar emphasis on trust is placed on those news sites that the ,Wh<
Z
4.20 d,Wh<
W/
^DW
, W h<
W,

^,Wh<
Wîbid
Wîbid

td
,:

tibid

ibid

ibid

ibid

ibid
PART C | The Press
W
4.21 Dt/W
PopbitchW/
/Popbitch

tDt
Popbitch would consider
Dt
Popbitch.
4.22 t
,Wh< to hosted and other user generated content on its site are broadly typical
d,Wh<
/D111
t

4.23 D
d
113
4.24 D
^

system.114
4.25 '
/ ^ '
dd
115 /
, W h<. All content hosted through
'
116/
'<
'
ibid
td
,:

tibid
111
d
D,&

ibid
113
ibid
114
ibid
115
<d
D,:
116
:
dD,:
EW

Funding models
4.26 Dd
Popbitch and '
&

/
reach readers.
5. Social networking sites

5.1

D
/
D&d>/
'
5.2
/

/
/
dd
&
&
d d
&
W/
d

,'Wd/^d
5.3
/

,

/^W
<d
D,:

d
D,&

ibid
PART C | The Press
&
d^&
d
5.4

/

/
not need to be repeated here.
5.5
/d/

d and

,d/

5.6
/ d D
hW

t
5.7
D
d

print media.
5.8
/
Z

5.9
d
h^
,//

d
&

^d
,:

d
D,&

ibid

ibid

ibid
EW

5.10 d / D t Popbitch is
h< d
D t
/Popbitch sought

/D
t
/
//W

t

5.11 DtPopbitch than
/s
Popbitch were the
,
Dt
//
/

5.12 D^

D ^
,'&h^d
''D^
' D
^
/
&
5.13 d'
D ^ h<
t131&
D^
D^
h<
td
,:

tibid

tibid

tibid

W^d
D,&

Wîbid
131
ibid

Wîbid
PART C | The Press
5.14 , D >
EZ
133D^

Z134
5.15 d D ^

/D,Wh<
D , W h< h< h
,Wh<
h

135,,Wh< was not

/136D
,Wh<

D
6. Other providers
6.1
D
dd
/d
'D
'D<
'
''

or not.D<
^/

6.2
,D
d d
d141D
133
Wîbid
Wîbid
135
d
D,&
136
ibid

ibid

d
D,&

<d
D,:

<ibid
141
d
D,&
134
EW
'
,'

D'h<
/K143
D<
h<144
6.3
D<

'/

D <

145D<
''
'
h<146'
7. Enforcement
7.1

h<h<
/
d

7.2
/^Wh<
d

d/^W
t
/^W

7.3
D

//DD
'dh<
:d
D,:
143
:ibid
144
<d
D,:
145
<ibid
146
<ibid

<ibid
PART C | The Press
h</d

7.4
D<'

,D<
h<'
d

D<
151 /d
'
hZ>
7.5
h<
h<
h^

d
> h
//^W
d
D'
153
&
/
/
/

zd
^/

t

7.6
D ^
154
d
D,&

ibid

<d
D,:
151
<ibid

:
dD,:
153
:ibid
154
W^d
D,&
EW
//

z/
8. Press photographers
8.1
W d
Z /
W W
WW
h< K

155
8.2
d
W / /

W156 Those who

8.3
D
,
d

harassment or distress.
8.4
dWt in an accident that occurred while the car in which

^h<W
d
W
the newspaper concerned.
8.5
d
h<
h<ZW,
Z The

155
^dWW
W&

W&

W

W&
156
CHAPTER 4
PLURALITY
/
/D

1
t
1.1
There is a generally held view that the media is of central importance for a healthy, well-
informed democracy and therefore control of the media should not be concentrated in too
few hands. This is based on a concern that a small number of media owners could have too
W

1.2
d
d

h<d
d
/

h<
t/
plurality in the media.
1.3
K4
diversity of viewpoints

(emphasis added)
1.4
W D W / h
>
5
d
D,:

4
^KD
DW
5
t^W
D
180
Chapter 4 | Plurality

^
,

d

/

^

1.5
d
generally accepted. Robin Foster, an independent adviser on regulatory policy and strategic

W ^ h t

1.6
d
,
K

8 There are arguments for broadening the scope, which are considered
later in this Report.9,
2. Approaches to securing plurality

2.1
&

d
D^D^
d
Z&d
,:

p1, para 1, ^W^

8
^KD
DW
9
W/
181
PART C | The Press
10

way which suits their own purposes.
2.2
^

television channel or a local newspaper and a local television channel. These rules and how
2.3
dK

,

/

z

d'

2.4
d
Z11 The result
^^
2.5
d
d
/
D
2.6
D
'
of plurality and the needs of the wider economy, and to ensure that media ownership rules

dD^DKZ
E
d
/ t
10
DÊ
ownership.pdf
11
W/

DÊ
ownership.pdf


,
3. The history of media ownership rules in the UK from

the 1990s
>
3.1
D^DKZh<

/14&Z/
3.2
dh<

15d//
/
/
/ds / > Z
/ d /
powers to preview programmes and approve schedules in advance of transmission. The issue
ds
/
3.3
d/
/dZd

3.4
(a)
The previous contract-based regulatory system was replaced by a licensing system, with
>/dZ

/d
&
/d
W
d
/ Z
18d
14

dEd:

DÊ
media-ownership.pdf

18
Z
15
PART C | The Press

19
3.5
d
E
/ds'
ZhdsE
^
Provision of broadcast news
3.6
^
d/d
Z
/
Z
Zd
Z
3.7
d
d

Z
licence holders to select the same nominated news provider, from providers nominated for
/d
/'

Z
provider.
Digital TV services
3.8
dds

d
its overall deregulatory approach, so there are now no explicit ownership rules in respect of
ds
19
p5, paras 8-9, DÊ

media-ownership.pdf
D
D^

DÊ
media-ownership.pdf

184
Satellite and cable TV services

3.9
dd
well have been because these services were not subject to the same spectrum constraints
d
^h<h<E
^/
^^
^
to support two satellite broadcasters.
3.10 d ^
Ê^
,
^d'
^
^d

Radio

3.11 d
/
h< d
d

t
were removed (subject to the local cross media ownership rule designed to ensure that there
&K
DKZDK

3.12 d
d

3.13 h

&

this mirrored the provisions of the analogue regime by placing a limit on digital radio licences
of 55% of the points available in an area.

185
PART C | The Press
^
3.14 d
,
K

radio licence. d
d

d

d
3.15 d
d

E
/'
/
event, in circumstances fully described later in the Report,

Cross media ownership

3.16 d
Eds
Within each category they could hold up
d

^
>
ds
E ds
d
dsEZ
licence).

p15, para 40,

p15, para 41,

W,

D^
E

pp18-19, para 48,

DKd'WD
3.17 d
Z
/dsd

Z
^
d
ds

Review of ownership rules
3.18 dK
K^
^d
recommended no change./E Ofcom concluded that

K

3.19 K:^^K
K :
40/

'W,

DÊ
media-ownership.pdf

40
>D&
pdf
PART C | The Press
^^
DKZDK41
3.20 d '

d

D
3.21 The process by which the media plurality public interest test was inserted into the
Z
d ^ ^ K

plurality, diversity or standards.44
3.22 /^^

and
(c)
a genuine commitment to Ofcoms standards code.
3.23 d '
W/D

applied.45
3.24 dK^^
.

^^

3.25 d
41
DÊ
media-ownership.pdf

W/
44
DÊ
media-ownership.pdf
45

^
188

h<
h<
h<
h<
h<

d

Wd/
K

standards (including under self-regulatory regimes).48
3.26 49 but where

company is a newspaper enterprise.50
3.27 tK^
^

/^^

51
3.28 d^^
K
h<
h<

3.29 d ^ '
^/dsh<K

48
t^
Richards.pdf
49

50
^
^^
h<h<^
51
t^Z
pdf

189
PART C | The Press
K&d

54 d ^ ^
d
^^^
d
d
55
3.30 dE^

4. History of the newspaper ownership regime

4.1
D^/
4.2
^d
D D Z
ZW^^

d&d&d
subjected most newspaper mergers to a stricter system of control than other mergers. The
&d

^^
4.3
W^^d/

d ^ ^

^
^

&d

concerned was not economic as a going concern and that it was not intended to
&d
54

t^Z
pdf

dW/

DÊ
ownership.pdf
55
190

&d

4.4
d&d

h
^^
d

4.5
t
^^

h<
4.6
d^^
d

4.7

h<h<
t
d
^ ^ ,
^^K
,

^^

4.8
The interim K&d

a review of the local and regional media merger regime. The conclusions of this review were
d K&d

of small changes would be advantageous. This included amending OFT guidance to ensure
K&d
K > D >D
dK&d:
WD'
191
PART C | The Press
4.9
K > D
<D'<D'E
DK>DK&d^K

and investment, and provide a sounder commercial base from which to address long-term
structural change, for example by expanding the availability of online and other digital local
/
K&d
KK&d
<D'

<D' d
58
58
PART D

STANDARDS
CHAPTER 1
THE HISTORICAL BACKGROUND
/
1.1
1.2
/
dZ
ZW^
ttzZW^
Yd

period.
/ Z
^
/
/
/

/D^d
/1
d

Z
W
^
1.3
Z

/
/

1.4
&/

&
/
^D^d
195
Part D | Standards

1.5

/
d
d

d

d
K
1.6
/
/

'
/
ZW
/d

2. The Royal Commission into the Press 1947

2.1
^ > ' D E h
: Eh:

d Eh:

dEh:

W

W

2.2
d ,
W

DDdKD^
196
Chapter 1 | The Historical Background
3d
DWK/4
d
W
W
, Z

W
2.3
/Eh:W

'
d

d

5
2.4
,

' W W WW
6
WWW
d
d
d
2.5
d'

d'
t
t
t
tW

'ZWZ
5
KDd^ZW
6
WWZW

W
W

4
Part D | Standards

2.6
,
t Z /

d
'
Wd
/9

D
2.7
dZ'W
W

/Z

^Z

2.8
dZZ
'&
W

d Z
^tZ
d

/W

11
/
W W

2.9
/Z
W

KDd^K

11
'K
/ Z ' W

d

2.10 W
/

13
2.11 ddZ
Z ' d

dEh:
h
14
2.12 d

ZE>DW:^
^ W
Dd W d

'
15
2.13 t'W
'
Z/

W
^
W
&W

K

16
2.14 dD^d/
:^W
W
'K
^Zd'hd
14
KDd^K p56
15

16

KDd^K
13
199
Part D | Standards
d W
/

3. The Royal Commission of 1962 and the Younger

3.1
d ' W Z
&
/

Z/
Z

h<
3.2
>^>'Wd
Z
>^
,
h<W
E
3.3
dZ

/

d

h<
3.4
d

^

K
'W
19/
>^
Z
'ZWZ
KDd^K

'ZWZ
19
3.5
d ^ ^ d
'W
Z
d

3.6
d^
'
W,
Z/

'W
/

'
W
Z>^
/W

3.7

Z
Zd'W
W & d
W

dW
.d
W

3.8
dY
W
d
W
^ <
D &
W
DDW
W
Z

KDd^K

Part D | Standards
W
[rather] .
3.9
d W D t
'
dz
3.10 d W ^ < z
W
^<z
>W,KD
' W ^ <

3.11 W:z
W
dW
d
W

K z
W
d z

dz

3.12 /
,
^<

intrusion.
3.13 d W :
z Z /

>W

W>W
zZ
W
Z'WW/Wp13
&:Z

'dZWp13

KDd^K

^ZK

3.14 & z Z W
>W
31
'

W/W
'
^<zZW

W
D
4. The Royal Commission of 1974
4.1
d d Z W D
W K > D'

tKDW

4.2
dD'
z Z
W
W

d D'
33

4.3
tD'
d
/

34

W
/
W
4.4
d W
Z
KDd^K

'ZW&Z
33

34

31
Part D | Standards
>D'Z
z
W
/W

d35

4.5
dD'
W
/W

dD'
36
d

d

4.6
d

d
d

d
/^ZD'
W
W
dWD'
d

W
35

^ZK

36
4.7
/ z Z D'

39
4.8
DD'Z
^
W d W
D'

/
D'W

&

D^d41

ZzZ
4.9
KD'W

4.10 z
t
W D'

W/

D'

d^Y
5.1
/D'

W
Z

/
Z
W
^
39
'K

41
d
d

KDd^K
Part D | Standards
dz
ZW^d^:

Z ,
>,^

d
WW43
5.2
d
/

d
>W
dWD
/

44d

DdWD
W',t
:
W
>W
5.3
d>WWd
W & W
&W&
W>
W&
dW&
W
5.4
^W&
/Wt
W&ZZW
'ZdZZ
W
5.5
d
/ W
Z W

45dZZW
,
43
>^d
>WdWD
45
KDd^K
44

W / W
W&
&/
46
5.6
Z
W
/ ^ > Y W

mistreatment.,
/ ^ > /
W

5.7
d W
/

W

Eh:
W
5.8
W
W D W d

d
,DW:,

ddt>
DWdWd
/ W D t

5.9
d W D W
W
^
&49
/:>DW&

/
,
46
Z
d^^>
Y

&^^>
Y
49
KDd^K
Part D | Standards
/ : DW d d '

/ : DW >
d > DW
D
/
d
,>>W>>d
h Z Z Z > DW
ZWDW
5.10 d'
W
^Y
^

5.11 ^WZD:/

51 The
W
d

5.12 ,^

ZW
WWd
53

,W
t
W
d
/

t
^
,KZWKD

53

51
d
W
5.13 d
/
Z
Z
d
W
54/^

...[or]...
55 then
56
5.14 ^W

/

5.15 ^

^W
/^

W
5.16 /^
W
Zd
W
d

5.17 Z
dW
h<EW
E^WWÊ
W ^ E ^
W^&W&
WdW:

>D',
54
K
,KK
56
,KK

K
55
Part D | Standards
>D'Z
d^Y
6.1
W

/
W demonstrated
WZ^<z
59D^
W K
&
W
not independent.
6.2
d

/>DW^W
D & Z Wd
/W
>^WD
^61
6.3
& d ^
Wt:'Wt
^ ^ E , D Y DW
:d^
,DD

W
6.4
/:^^Ê,
:d
DDD
/

63d^
W:^,
^ZW&Z
^D
^d

K
61
^>^
,

DYDW
d,:
63
Wd,
:
59
WW
d,64
dW
/
/
/

6.5
^
,
W
d65
/W
W
Z/

'
/
W

6.6
/^W
d

d

66
6.7
dW^d
dW
/^
,W
>t
69
6.8
^ W d
K
64
YZW^5
pxi
66

t^^

^ZK
69
>^d
,D>t
dD,D
65
Part D | Standards
/ W
^

6.9
/W
W
W & d

^
6.10 d
>^^
E,:^,
^DWt
>D'W^D

W>

>
//
DE
W

DW
D^D^D
^DW

6.11 d'^Z
^Ê,sDW

>td/
' ^ : D
/'
'
,'
h<
ZDt^^:
W
>dD
,D

^:Dd
D,:

'W

6.12 ^:>
,/
^>

' d
>

6.13 ^^Ê,::

,,
'
'.,
W>t
^

6.14 E > t
>^

/

/
^:D>t

/>
D
Wdt
^
W

t^>

>dD
,D

t^>

^d
D,D

>td
D,D

^:Dd
D,:
Part D | Standards
6.15 ,>t/

W > t

/
/
/W
/
6.16 tW>t
W

^W
'

6.17 d W '
^ :
D
///
W d
/
WW^
^
:t
/
7. The death of Diana, Princess of Wales

7.1
dWt

7.2

W/
W
7.3
E
>^

W
>td
D,D

^:Dd
D,:
W
.
7.4
>^/'

W>^

.
7.5
,>^>t
Z

W>^

/
>^>t
/

7.6
> t
91

/
/
7.7
>^
,W
d

,Zh<
7.8
&W
:
>^93
/

>^d
,D

91

>^d
,D
93
Part D | Standards
7.9
>^W>t
W.94
/95
/t

/
7.10 Z
^
d
/
>t
96
7.11 /^DW
ZW:
d
/
8. Conclusions
8.1
/
h<'W

the press.
8.2
/
^ttd

d Z

Z
^
/d
8.3

d
d
94
>^d
,D
95
>^d
,D
96
>td
D,D

'
8.4
D/
/>

,

/W
D/
Z^tZ

DWD^
WD
Z
,99
/ / D
Dt
ZZ
^
8.5
>

d Z > z
WD
8.6
d /
W<h,/

,

/Z/
W
Wa
W:

99

W
dD,

Part D | Standards

d
,K
8.7
^ D ^ d
/ D D
Z

&
D

8.8
dDtd
Z^
>D'
,
Dd

8.9
d
d
,d
^D^d

t^D
D

Z

d

CHAPTER 2
^>&Z'h>d/KEK&d,WZ^^
/
1.1
This Chapter of the Report will look at the Press Complaints Commission (PCC) as the
,
W
^Y:
WW^&
W

W
W
1.2
dW

1.3
dWZW

:^
W

KDKd

ZW1
dW
2.1
2 W
^Y
2.2
d^
W
W
2.3
^:
Z
W
W

dW

W:
W
219
Part D | Standards
2.4
h<E
W E ^ W W
ÊWÊ^
W^&W&
WdW:
2.5
dW

/

^

^
W
2.6
/Wd

dW
W&
d&
W

2.7
, W

Z
, K D D Y DW
/:
^DD
W:/
:^W
Wd
2.8
ZW
^,W

&'
^W
Purpose of the PCC

2.9
dW

d
WW
W
ibid
^W
W&
treatment by newspapers, periodicals or magazines and unwarranted infringements

2.10 dW
/W6
/
does so primarily by dealing with complaints, framed within the terms of the Editors
W

2.11 /W
d
7

3.1
^:Wd>
D'>t^D
>,KWZ
W:K
DW
3.2
DW
W
W
/E^
:^

Ed^
W
3.3
/
W ^ W
EWE^
WWÊ^
dW
3.4
dWW
d
t^^

7
W:

^^
6
221
Part D | Standards
W
d
9
W/
WD
WDWd
W
Appointment of members
3.5
d W W& /
W&
d

not be engaged in or connected with or interested in the business of publishing newspapers,

3.6
/ W
& ^
DW^^:DW
D > ,
>^
&K^
3.7
//
d
>,W
d
W11
3.8
d/
& > '
^DW

3.9
d W D W D W
W D W D
d
WWD
^WW
WD
Z
t^
^îbidW
11
>,d
,:
222
^W

3.10 /
WDE
d'Z

3.11 dEW
WD/EW/t
EsWD
d E

EW&
d E / Z
Z
3.12 WDW&12
&W
3.13 dW^/
W,

W

3.14 / W

/W
The complaints process assessment
3.15 KW
W/
W ,
W
W/W

12
t^
^

ibid

ibid

Part D | Standards
tW
3.16 dW

16dW

3.17 t W
17t
Wprima facie

/
3.18 /prima facieW
KKW
19tW
d
dW
K

3.19 d W d
Wd
W
/W

editorsdW
21d
W

3.20 t W
W / ' Z
W
22
3.21 K W

d
WW

16
t^^

17
t^^

ibid
19
ibid

^,
21
22
^&
^W
W
3.22 KW
tW

:dW

W
3.23 ,Wt

26 The
W
^W
27Wd

,

>W
3.24 dW
d
W
W
h<

h<W

dW-
t^^
ED

ibid

ibid
26
ibid
27
ibid
Part D | Standards
W
3.25 dW&W
d W
W
W
3.26 D D W
'/
W 29 /
D^^W

real impact d W

3.27 ^ D /

^

W
/
W
,
W
^

3.28 D&d
W ^
/
,
et seqt^^

29
d
D,&

d
D,&

^Dd
,:

d
D,&

ibid

ibid
226
^W
W
W
3.29 /
W

/
W
d
WZ
&
3.30
Z
K
3.31 d
Wd/

WK
W
,W

3.32 d
W^
D d

3.33 d^,
^ D t / Z d /
Z W Z W W D W
d
WZ
d
W
W
ibid
ibid

t^^

W:

&tW
^:

W

ibid
227
Part D | Standards

3.34 /W

,
d
/Z
WW
3.35 dW'E
^
^

3.36 dWZ
/ W
Y
W&
4.1
W&W
W&
Wd
W&
W& E
E^WW
Ê^d
>
W
4.2
dW&^
,
WW&
Wd
/WW&
W

/'Z
4.3
d/>^
W&W,
/W&W
t^^
K:W
^<

t^>

ibid

^ZK

W:
^W

WW&>

W/
W
W&d
W
W
4.4
> W W

>W&
E E
dEW

4.5
dEW

EW
W&W&
d
W&
ZW&W
4.6
W&W
>

W>t
4.7
>^D
d

&
W
>dD
,&

>ibid

>dD
,&t
^>

>ibid

>ibid

>ibid

> ibid

> ibid

> ibi

> ibid

> ibid

> ibid

>ibid
229
Part D | Standards

,W
>,
4.8
d>,&
W
<&tD were

d
4.9
W& d

W&d

W&
^
dW&
4.10 d/
61>
>,
62//>

&/E

4.11 >Z:Y
PCC Chair was a de facto
>>D'W
>W,
66>/
>,WW
67
d
4.12 d W d

Wd

4.13 d W
EdW
>ibid
> ibid
62
> ibid

> ibid

>ibid

> ibid
66
>ibid
67
> ibid
61
^W
W

4.14 >
W/

69,

,>

71
4.15 ,>
W&,
/W&WW&

W72,

/
W
4.16 />W
W&W/
W / W
W

4.17 tW

^
/
d>,

76
4.18 ,
>'
K
t^^

69
>dD
,&

>ibid
71
>ibid
72
> ibid

>

>ibid

>ibid
76
>,d
,:
Part D | Standards
77 ,

4.19 K
WW
79 K ^ / ^
W
d D ^
^K
D:YW/
dW
4.20 dW
WdW

/W
W

4.21
//

W
Z'
4.22 dWW
/

so narrowly as to compromise its

interest
4.23 >Wit is the responsibility of editors and publishers to apply the
d

77
>'d
,:

>'ibid
79
t^^

^D

^D

>dD
,&

^W

4.24 dW

d
Wt
4.25 d W
^
d
,ZW
h< ^
where there is a

4.26 &
W
d

d

4.27

d

91
4.28 d

92
4.29 /

dD^d

t^^
91
92

^D^d
Part D | Standards
/W

4.30 dW>

,

4.31 / /
>

96,
97
4.32 >

,

99
4.33 / >
,
W

W
4.34 > /
W&
,
W
W&
,

>dD
,&

>ibid
96
>ibid
97
>ibid

passim,> ibid
99
>ibid

>ibid

>ibid

>ibid

>ibid
^W

5.1
tW
dh<
W

/

5.2
d > '

:ZZKdd
K
>'
W
5.3
>,

/

5.4
> / > ,

/>,
^
5.5
/

^
5.6
//
W^

W
^

111
>'d
,:

>'ibid

>,d
,:

>,ibid

d
D,&

ibid

ibid
111
ibid
Part D | Standards
5.7
> , /

/

W112>,
>,

W

D
6.1
d W
^

6.2
//^W

d W
Wd

/
6.3
d

W
6.4
W
W

D/
d
6.5
dW
dW
dW

dW
d
112
>,d,
:

>,ibid

^d
,:

t^
^
^W
W/
D
116
6.6
/D
,W
,W
/W

d
dh<117
6.7
dW
/
D
d
6.8
,119
d
d
d
6.9
dW
D
d

116
t^^

117
t^
^

ibid
119
ibid

ibid
Part D | Standards
ddEE
D
EWE
:
&
D
11
D
:
:
^
K
E

:
&
D
12
D
12
:
11
:
16
^
K
E
11

:
&
12
D
11
17
D
:
th
6 (up to 27 :
dKd>
255
dW
WW
6.10 W:
d/

6.11 /
W
/dW
^W

6.12 d'
^W&
t : D ^

^ W
121
6.13 //DDDd
WW/
Wt/
DDD
W
DDD122
KWW

6.14 DDDW
/ W

/
WD :
t E d t E
DW
W
6.15 /Wt
DDD
dW

/WW:
t^Z'
/dW

-
6.16 /W/DW
d
EÊ,DDD
121
'^d
,D
122
DDD/

DDD/
Part D | Standards
/W

6.17 d
W

W/

d

The PCC website
d
repeated approaches:
'
d
^ W
/
d

z/
/

^

^
friend or neighbour who is not as closely associated with the story to deal with press
d

/
W
6.18 , W
/

W

W126

/
W
DD
DD
126
DD
^W
6.19 >

d

W

127

7.1
/W

7.2

&
W /
W K
K d W
Kd

/
, W h<
7.3
//
W d
W
/W
K K
129
7.4
/
W^

/
W

d>
7.5
/ W
127
DD
d

WZ
129
W^D^d
W^
Part D | Standards
W>,
W,
,
//

7.6
/
W
dDtd

W
7.7
W/

^D
'

7.8
dW
d
,/D^d

WdD^d

WdD^d

dD^dW

WdW

t
7.9
dW
h<
/W
t^^

:D^'W^h^Dtd

ibid

^Dd
,:

DDd
D,&
^W
dW
h<
t
Z

7.10 dW
d
W
Z
h
&
&
d
W
7.11 DWnormally accept complaints

/
W
W& d
^

7.12 >,W

,
&W
dD
W d

WtW

^t^
^
Part D | Standards
7.13 , W

/ W

7.14 /^'D
^:D
W / W
D'/
W
W
d
7.15 d W
d W

d
W

W

Z

7.16 d , W

Z

/

7.17 ^/
^

/ W : D

/
ibid
E/K

t^^

^W
d

7.18 tD&&

/
/&&
^

WÊ''
7.19 dW
K

W
/ZW
/Z
WdW
W/
d
/
W

dW

dE
2012
h
^
2011
2010
2009
1744
91.7
4.1
3.0
1.3
Year
7.20

d
d

tDdD
,&

^^&&

ibid

/d
,:

D

^d
,:d
Part D | Standards

h
WZdZ

7.21 /W
W
W
K
WD

^//

7.22 /DW

^D

W
161
>d
D,&

^d
,:

îbid
161
^Dd
,:
PART E

CROSSING LEGAL
BOUNDARIES:
THE CRIMINAL AND
CIVIL LAW
CHAPTER 1
THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK
1.1
/

/

/

,Z

,Z&&,Zd
h<
,Z
1.2
d/

Wt
dZK
ZE

/
1.3
d

EdDD
D:a clear threat
to the women involved that unless they cooperated (albeit in exchange for some money)

something which would not, in itself, be unlawful.
d
1.4
/

d

1.5
d
/
d
,Z
Z
Mosley v. News Group Newspapers Ltd t,Y
249
PART E | Crossing Legal Boundaries: The Criminal and Civil Law

1.6

d
/

'dZthe extent to which the current policy

/
2
1.7
WZ

/
/
1.8
/
WW

K
Et
W
'Ezd
W

'
'D
E
/WW
dWZ

/KD
/ d
K
W,
CHAPTER 2
POLICE INVESTIGATIONS START
KZ
1.1
/ W
W
E

W E
WE/

1.2
/
D

d
1.3
1.4
d:KZd^/K
^D
//d

W^W
d
h<

2/
W

t
Wd
/
t^dZD
/DdD
,D
2
1.5
d
d

d
d

1.6
d

dDW^DW^
E^
1.7
d^
Z>Z
/
KD

s>d
KD/
/K/&
/KDW^K'
&KZK
'KD
1.8
^ D W^ W

d

Z>W
1.9
K K
,,:d

not that serious
WEd

1.10 KK,
,

WE

t^dZ
D
W/^
1.11 /
W^t

/^D
W^

4/
K
' /
W^

1.12 /^DK
Z,
I think I need to make clear that they werent out of scope. The whole inquiry right
from the outset was extremely open, an open-minded approach as to what we would
d

/

each and every occasion, open-minded as to who those customers would be, and we

1.13 /^D
d

1.14 /
^D
/

t
intelligence and evidence. The CPS were working alongside us, as were the Police
t
,
K'
2.1
K'

>:>d
D,D

/Dibid

t^dZ
D

/Dibid,

DW^

2.2
KDW
WDd
WE ^ t
/

ZKZK

W
Z>alter
egoD:
Dt
2.3
dZ>DW^
d
K'/D
^/K/'
/'/K
2.4
/'

,
9
t

didnt present any fear. There wasnt any fear involved at all. But we did recognise

that would obviously shape how we approached that, but it certainly wouldnt have

2.5
,
2.6
/ '

,
2.7
dK'
d D
d
D :
W
/'dD
,D

/'ibid

/'ibid

/'ibid
9
W/^
^tdD
WE ZK :
dD
tWEZK

W^

2.8
/
//
'
2.9
dDDK'
<
DDDDtd
KED<
2.10 DDt

D<
:/'

2.11 d/'

D<,
dD
what is it that I was hoping to achieve and what I wanted to achieve was to interview
/

/t<
/<

2.12 ,

W /
'K

,

/'ibid
/'ibid
2.13 : :

Dt
/'

ZKZK/'
Dt

,
D t
/'

d
2.14 dW^
2.15 dW^DD<t
W^

/'W^
d/

W^t

2.16 D D <
W
Dtd

2.17 /
/'
/ D W^
:

/'
d
/'ibid
&
ZK
d/
W^
d/
CHAPTER 3
OPERATION MOTORMAN
/
1.1
d K Z K /
/K^tD
K/K
KZD
td
DK

d

1.2
h/K
W
tWWtWWEd

WWd

d

KD
dKD
2.1
KEZ
>KZDKs
ZDsZD
2dsZD
DK
s>s>sZDs>
s>
D K
s> In the
DKs>
4 &
sZD

KZW

Kd
,E
4
t^
K

ibid
2
2.2
d d /K K D

d D W ^
DW^ K '
2.3
KZDK
sZDprotected number,
^DK

dDW^DKDt
::^
D K ^ t
d/KDt

^D/KDt
^W9
d
3.1
D t
d
Z'
zdDt
Dt
d

/

DK

3.2
D K /K / Z W

DtK
/KtWW
K'W

t^
K
9
Kd
,E

/KtWW

Kd
,E
t^K

t^
K
KD
EDK//
/KDt
3.3
d

^
/K
//
W/
d
W/
W/
Dprima facie
W//
W/
D
3.4
DK/Dt

d
sDt
3.5
DK
d
D
/K Z d /

d
K
Dt

Z

KD
E>:E>

prima facied

Kd
D,

K
d,E

Kd
D,

^t^
ZdZdZ:d

d

3.6
/
d

,
D t

dWZtWWE
D
Dd
D/
^
3.7
d D
t
D t

Kd
KDtD:d

d/E
KDt
dmodus operandi DK
D:
^
3.8
d

22//DK
KD
/KtWW
^t^Z
d

/KtWW

Kd
D,
22
/KtWW
KD
/ D, '

E
3.9
d
WEsZD

24/

3.10 DK
/
d
DK

W:

3.11 d
D
3.12 t
d
s>sZD
WE
DKtheres no way you can get
somebodys list of family and friends lawfully, unless you actually know them and whats on
dd,
Dd
WE
29
3.13 ^s>

ds>
ds>
Kd
,E
24
/KtWW

Kd
D,

ibid

Kd
,E

ibid
29
Zdd
D,

d

d

/

/
s>
3.14 WsZD
/
Dt
3.15 /
&
^

,tWW,

Dd

3.16 E / D d

,Dt

&

3.17 d
Dt
d
W
3.18 /Dd

/

ZZsZ>Z
Zdd
D,

Zdd
,
KD
DZY
E/But I have to say yet again, that was not typical, nothing
like typical of the cases that we were seeing. And although you made the point that the
majority of the cases were, in your language, only addresses or phone numbers, I would also

/ Dd
K D
, / / /
d/

3.19 '/KKD
/
,/W

/
/

Dd

W
3.20 /

/
W/
D
3.21 dDt

/K

3.22 /d

dprima facie

Zdibid
Zdibid
E
//
W/

WKD
4.1
d/
KD
Dt
,/K
DW^
W^
4.2
dDW^
WEW^
^ t : < W D
ZK
WEd
K
WDtD
W
4.3
K,,:^Y
,,:^Ythe vice of the primary conspiracy was to

and was bound at its lowest to cause immense embarrassment to members of the public
,
&WD

DD

^

4.4
^ W /K D
t,
W^d
tWW
/K
/K
&t^
Zd

ZdZ:d

ibid

^t^
Zd
KD
'
WWZ
5.1
/ / D d W
d
tWWd
D t W W E

tWW
5.2
d W Z D

tWWd'd^
ddd^:

/Z
d , ^
D^
improper and intrusive gathering of data
depressing catalogue of
42
5.3
d W
d

5.4
^tWW/K
ddocuments seized
KD/K
clear picture of how the market in unlawful personal data operates. Case details provided

t
44
5.5
dDt
d
D t
d
/KtWW
dWZd
dD,

/KtWW
42
ibid; D^^&ZWD
/,:

/KtWW
44
ibid

5.6
/

s>

5.7
d

Z ,
d

Dt
&

5.8

d

/

5.9
d K
D49d
5.10 //K

K

d
to those who request the disclosure of personal data and those who supply it, including
d
ibid
ibid

ibid

ibid
49
^t^Z
d

/KtWW

ibid
KD
5.11 d/KW
d /K
W,Z
tWWE
5.12 dWZtWWE

5.13 d&/
DtWW

5.14 d
d
W
D
^W
D
D^
Et
^D
D
^
dK
^
dW

tDD
^
d^
D
^^
Ed
29
24
22
E:

4
4
ED^
Ê
Z
^
^DD
ZD
/KtWWE, p9
W
Ed
E:

tK
d^d
DD
D/
^
dd
D
WD
^t
5.15 d
K D

5.16 //t
WWE

//Dd

,Dd

5.17 d &

D t &
D
d ^ d
^

t

6.1
&>&/
/K
K D d
D t d
Zdd
D,

Zdibid
KD
/K
K/K
K D W D

/K

WE
6.2

d/K
W

W^

dWZ
6.3
KW

&//K
t
/K
KD

Dt
&t^Z
d

Zdd
D,Dd

Zdibid

Zdd
D,

p2, para 9, &t^Z
d
CHAPTER 4
PHONE HACKING: THE EXPANDING IMPACT
OF OPERATION CARYATID
/
1.1
d /
E t Edt
D
,

DW^DW^'D
Edt
dD
d'Edt
E

EdtDW^

1.2
/dZW/

d

W
1.3
dZ
K

'
E/E/

E/

W^W^
270
W,d/K
1.4
K
E/
W W D ^
, , d W

1.5
'K
/DW^

d/
DW^
E/ / D
/ZDW^/
/
KD

td'Ezd
/

/
/
1.6
/ /
DW^W^'
/

/ Z

/t/

d
1.7
/Z,ZW
DW^:>W
,Wt,
/
'ZEdt
1.8
d , Z W >
^KW
DW^^K'
Z&
D ^K
Z/
ZDW^D
PART E | Crossing Legal Boundaries: the Criminal and Civil Law
2D
,

^K
1.9
'KD
,
^K,D,

, D 7 d
^ W ^
d>

8>
Z&
1.10 d ^ / K ^/K ^ W t
^ ^ t
D
K^tD
^dt:DD
D>
1.11 &/K/K/<^
^^,
^^D^/K
^td^D
//K
Z'^/D
t^W

t^
,

7
WdD
,D
8
t^>

K
&Z

Z

t^W

<^d
,&

t^W

Kd
272
W,d/K
^/K/K

1.12 ^t^^
/

WÊD,D
D
D

1.13 /Z
/
d
d
/
d
d
2.1
D K
Z,

2.2
d^t
D >W D
sK

20/
2.3
d^t/<^
^^s
/

DDd
,&

t^W

t^^W
t
20
t^^W
tt^^
<^

^
Es

t^Ê
22 d

d
2.4
:s
D>
WK
D'27
2.5
^t

28/

2.6
^t
Z,

2.7
dD'
2.8
KDD^t^
t / W ' /
D>W
D ' D '

Z,
22
t^^W
t

t^^<
^

t^^W
tshsEK
EZ

27
t^^W
tt^^
<^
28
t^^W
t

<^d
,&

ZD
W,d/K
2.9
K ^ t ,
D'
Z,d
D'D
>WZ,
/^tW^
D'
2.10 d
DD
d
Z/
WZ/W
^Z/W
h<

2.11 ^tZ/W

d/

,
'

h<
2.12 d ^ t
,
^K
d^t
^Kd

Z &
^K
2.13 Z,^
t
d Z & ^ t
Wtd
D,&Z

t^^Wt

^DDW^

2.14
^t
DD^t

/

2.15 D
^K ^ t
^t
D

2.16 ^t

,
DW^
/

/

2.17 /^t
Z&

/
Z,
Z&
/^t

Wtd
D,&

t^^Wt

^^^/D

t^^Wt
W,d/K
2.18 K^t^^,
^W^D
^
t^^Z/W^
^d

2.19 K D ^
Z/W D
Z/WD
^
^Z/W/
,

h

2.20 D
Z&&
D
>

2.21 dD
Z/WE//
d
Z/W
,
DW^
d^t

/^t
d
W^

//
t^^<
^

t^^Wt
t^^
<^

>Dd
D,

t^^Wt
277
/

2.22 d

/D
^t/

Z/W

W^D

W^
2.23 ^,
EtEdt&
Edt
D'
D
'Y
DW^
E///
/

2.24 dD^th
Wt
DD/K
WtK
,
K
KWtD

2.25 /^t
K
K
Z ,

K,

E'YdD
,:

E

t^^<^
278
W,d/K
/

d '

d/

2.26 ^t^
t>
^K/W^

^ t

D
:D>W
D
2.27 t^tD:^^

D>WD
t

2.28 W

/
ss

/Ds
s
/
,
s/
D

2.29 ts
d

t^^Wt
<^d
,&

t^/DD

Wtd
D,&

DDd
,&


d
2.30
D'dD'

2.31 KDK
d
D,:<d
Z,
D '
EdtD'Z,

Z,
2.32 KDD
WWWW<DY>
DYZ''d
Z&/D

'
hsD
/
hsD

>DY,

2.33 KD^^
D WW
D>WD
DD^^DDW
tdD,:<
<^d
,&

/
^,:<

t^^<^

t^^<^

E

t^>
DY

Kh
280
W,d/K
Z,
W

2.34 D
D

/
/

d
&

d

2.35 Dd

/

2.36 D
D^^
70,

^K,
/
d

^/
2.37 / ^ ^
Z ,
72
D'DD
t^^<^
t^W

70
Wd
D,D

72

^^
,
Z&
/

2.38 K : ^ t ,
ss

D '
D D77 ,
78 ^ t
^K
K

//
/

^KK

d

d
d
K
^

^Kd d

2.39 D
80dK:
^^
D ' D D
/

t^^<^

Kht:

77
t^^Wt

78
Wtd
D,&

Kht:
80
t^^<^

:
282
W,d/K

2.40 K:W^82d
W^
: D '
D>WD
&DE/
D
DDD
D >W D
DDD'
2.41 K:W^D
WW'>
DZ/W
,DD'
DDZ/WD

2.42 K:D^D
'DDZ,

^87
t/
DZ/W
,/

2.43 /
W^>
D

88
82
E
E

>DYd
D,

WY>

Wtd
D,&>
87
t^>D
Y>
88
>DYd
D,

2.44 :^t
, /
D
s/W/

,

/ ^K

2.45 ^tK
Z , D ' D D

^t

,K

K

2.46 /:^t
^K,
Z,
^K
^K

^/K

Khd:
W,d/K
2.47 ^tD
, ^ ^
:DD
d:^^
Z
EKtZ
^Z
D
t^^

2.48 K D W Y D
W

2.49 DWDDD
'D
Z/WZ/W
DW
WW

2.50 dD
KZ/WD

t
DZ/W
/
,

Z/W/
2.51 D/^^
^ ^

t^^Wt
:

<^d
,&

d

WYd
D,

<^d
,&
/
E
2.52 W

DWÊ/d
E/ Edt

D t
E/
D
E/
dEt
DEdt::,Z
d

D
ZD
2.53 dDD,
E/
D,

DE/D

2.54 dD,
DdD,D

D,DD
D , D
D,
K
D,
/D

2.55 DD,
D,
DD,
t^W

,d
,D

WdD
,D
W,d/K
D,D'
D D
/D,

D
2.56 D/

/
Z,

E/

2.57
^t^^D

D'DD

d^
t

^

//
d
2.58 K''D

E/t
W^D
'd
Edt^^
d E
' ' D
EKdt
^t

Wtd
D,&

<^d
,&

t^^<^
287
/EKdt
/
EKdtd
'

EKdt
W
2.59 /D
DD

2.60 /
^Ê/
d E /
d/E
/E/t
''
d D
E/

E/
d
W
d
dK
d
^d/

2.61 K ^ ^
D'
d

2.62 E ^ ^
/
//,E/
d
W

t^/DD
<^d
,&

t^^<^

<^d
,&

dW:
288
W,d/K
2.63 dDD
d
DD

/D'
'

2.64 t
Ed:
Z,EdtDDdEt
:d
,
dE/

Z
dZE^Z/Wd&KZEs/>>tE^z:hE
d
'dddZE^Z/Wd&KZEs/>>
2.65 /DD

dDDEdt
D D

2.66 & Edt
D D ^
/

2.67 KDW^
Z , /
Z,
E
d
h

t^^<^

E

E

t^>Z
2.68 & E/ > ^

,
D

/ /

d
2.69 K D D D '

DD

2.70 DD
dZ&
DD
'
/dd
:DW
D/W/EZD
sD
/Eh/>
t
d:
//
dE
/
,
d:
2.71 '
>W
t^d
Dd
D,

d

d>W
z:
WtdD,
&
W,d/K
: W d
:,z
Ds
/Et,
:W
2.72 KDD'

Kt
W/E/
K
d
dE
t
/
Et/
/
d

,

2.73 '
/
:/
d:/

2.74 ZDDE/
D''
/
E/
D'
2.75 KD'DD

KK/

t^t
t^^Wt

KK
dd

2.76 d
/,K>D^,K>D
^/^t^
^ ^ t ,K>D^
^^
2.77 /^^
K
K ^ ^ ^

/ d

2.78 /^^
D
DDD

,

Z , D W ^ D W
d

/ Z
DE
/E/
d

/

E
/
Wtd
D,&

t^^Wt

t^^<^

<^d
,&

d,
&

t^^<^
W,d/K

2.79 t^^

d

K
/
/

/

&

^

tE/

d
2.80 ^ ^
W^
d
WYZ/W

Z/W^^,

2.81 d^^^
/
/Dd

d
DD

2.82 ^ ^ DD

'
'Dd

h<
<^d
,&

t^^<^

t^/DD

t^^<^

<^d
,&
d
Edt

2.83 K > D
/EdtD
DE
D '
DD
KD'

d
E/''Dd
d

E
3.1
K
D W^
^tDWDD
d/
^tDWDD
/

/

Z,
d

d
d
^^
Wtd
D,&

t^WY

t^^<^

t^WY
t^^<
^

WYd
D,t
^^Wt

<^d
,&
W,d/K
3.2
&

/:DW
DD
t
E t 'D
tt
DE
t
3.3
E
DW
///
/
//
3.4
DW

,

///
/
3.5
Z D W

//
3.6
DW

/DW
t/
/ /

:z:Dz
WYd
D,

3.7
^ t
Edtt
^t

/
/
3.8
/ ^ t D
W^^/DD
W
^ t

WE/
3.9
t^tif

^t
DDt
tt

3.10 :^tW^
/

<^Y
^t
/

WK
K Ed&/h DW^ > > D

EKdt
Wtd
D,&

Wtd
D,&

<^Y
dD,E

<^Y>DWWE

W,d/K

d
3.11 D^^t^
D D D W

D
'DDDW

DD
3.12 /^t
/^t
D'

^t

^t
/

D'DD
3.13 &W^

DD
D
3.14 /
Z/W

/

t^WY

WYd
D,

d

d
d
DD
E/
W/W/^/d

dDW
/
/
/
DD/>t
/

3.15 ^
Z/WDDD
W

&DWs
WDW/

/DW

3.16 t^t/
^ t
/

/^t

^t

3.17 ZDW

E
&
W^
WYd
D,dDW:

dDW/

WYdD,
dDW

ZEd>'>/t,

WYd
D,

t^^Wt
W,d/K
/
Z/W
D

3.18 dW
t

d

DD,E/
DD
D W
DW
DD
DW
/

3.19 DW
EtDW
:
D'DDDW

K
D'd/
DW

/DW
E
sZ,
3.20 &
^
^d:
/
^

t^^Wt

WYd
D,

/DD

WYd
D,/

WYd
D,

E

t^^<^
D :
^
///
/
d//
/
//

///
/
D
//
/
/
''D//
//

/
3.21 ddZ/
D : / ^
^/
E/

3.22 /
s/D
D'
DD
On
/DK
^,,
s
KKK
/D
3.23 /
Z ,

' D '
d
>
d:d
D,D

t^/DD

E
W,d/K
DDd
D^'d^,
D
3.24 /
^t
^ Z d ^

^
dD
K
D

DW^&d
Zt

E/
3.25 /
^t
/D

/D

d
^td
t
3.26 dDD
/ ^ t
^

3.27 & E/
DW^d^>D
&t

/
>
D,Dd
:z:Dz
Wtd
D,&

^,d
D,&

^Wt
dD,&

KD,
E t d

d
3.28 / E/ W^
d
E/

d

3.29 /E/

3.30 dEdt

Z,/Ds
Edt200D
/D
d
E/

3.31 ^^/DEdt
DD
D'
DD202
3.32 K/D
d

KEE>/

^ W
^^W
t^W

<^d
,&d^^
D'
200
DDd
,&

202
t^^<^

t^/DD

:z:Dz
W,d/K
W
3.33 / W
DD

'DE>Eh<>
E/E
E'D:
E / W E
>

W
d ^ d

dE
>
d

3.34 /D
^207/208d

D '
D'
/'

ZDDED'
Z
3.35 /D
>

207
t^/DD
208
:z:Dz

>
d
d

3.36 K^/D

D'E/

d
//

D

D
D ' D ' D D W
t E
E/
3.37 ^ /
D^/
E E
t
W
/
/DDE
>D'd

EE
d
E>EKdt

EDDD
DDD
dd
EE

E E
Kd

W,d/K

3.38 /

E//
Edt

^t^^
/D
//D

3.39 ^
h E/ DW^ d DW^

E/
3.40 /E/:DW^
K t
d
tE/

/

E/

3.41 ZDD'
>,E/E/
/E/ZD
t
/

E/ZDd
//
t^/DD
<^d
,&Wt
dD,&

DDd
,&

ZDt^
<ZD

ZDd
D,

/ZD
d

ZDd
D,
3.42 d E/
E&ZD
E/
E
Ê/
DE/

d

tEdt

d,dh
3.43 K E ^ ^ , d h
W ^ DW^

220d
D

D : D
^:''Z':,h
::>^&DWDKW
3.44 d

d

DDDDD

3.45 ^^/D
222t/
D
d^K
Wd
D,D

E
220
t^/DD

222
<^d
,&

t^/DD
W,d/K
D

3.46 d,dh/
W
E/Ws

DW^ /
^

d/
K
d
d
4.1
dDDD'

>
,
Z/W
:
>WZ/W
W
,Z/W
D D D
^ ' d ^ , D
Z/W
4.2
DW

4.3
KEWD
D ' D D
<^d
,&

Wd
D,D

WYd
D,

Z/WK:D:'
D'DD
4.4
DD
E/
,d
D'/227
4.5

D '
Z
ZzDD
D:'
,'
E/228
4.6
DW

DD
/DW

d

DDDD
4.7
D:'D'

& E/

'
DEdt
^
5.1
K
K
/
DW^
E/
^
227
^D:'Z'D'
,^D:'Z'D'

WYd
D,

t^WY

^D:'Z'D'
228
W,d/K
5.2
/
Kd

d
5.3
WK

D^K

/
D
d
^h<
/

dh<
/
/
h<
d
h<
d
K
>KZ

h^h<

d
h<
/:h<>
d
h<
/

KK
K d
d
h<h^
K K
/
t^W
d
d^K
d

E
DW^
d
&
K
DW^/

>'D
d^K
d

K
E
5.4

Yd
K K
Z K : :
K
>>D
:
:
D,
5.5
>Z

,
^
,
5.6
dD

D'DDZ
Wd
D,D

Wd
D,D

,d
,D

t^>Z

>Zd
,D
W,d/K
d
5.7
Ê/
EdtD'
d^t

d
5.8
dDD

5.9
d
DDDD
E
Z,
5.10 dEdt
Z,
5.11 dDD
DD
D'
5.12 dE/
t
E/
E/D'
5.13 d

5.14 ^t

D
D,
DD

Wtd
D,&

<^/D
Edtt

d,&

DD

Wtd
D,&

5.15 ^t
&
DD/
y/^t

d^t
5.16 ^t

'^t

/
,
D
^t

D
5.17 ^ / D
EdtWe
t

5.18 /

/

d
D

d
5.19 /^t
DD,
/

Wtd
,&

DDd
,&

Wtd
D,&
W,d/K
d/
/
/

5.20 ^^

DD&

^K,

5.21 d

d
d
dK

5.22 ^ t ^ ^ D
D^t^t
E/
^^

^Kd
D

D'
5.23 D

,K>D^
Z/W
D
t^^
<^

<^d
,&

^Z^Wt,

t
E/D

WdD,
D

t^^<
^

5.24 K
D,^
:
/
'D
tt
t
t
/
/
5.25 D
&

/
/

^

d

',KK

5.26 ,

5.27 D
^t^t
^
t/
d
D^t
D^t^^

/
t^
W

Wd
D,D

D^t
W,d/K
^KD
5.28 dD
D
,

/
//

/

5.29 D

^
/

5.30 ,^

/
D
/t//
/
/

5.31 /D

D

/
d
d
5.32 D

&^^
^t^

Wd
D,D


D
/>

5.33 / ^/K D
^t
D/,
//
/t

/
5.34 ^^

,
D
,
,//
t//
d
/
/W
//
d
/

5.35 ED,>D,
D

D

5.36 >KK
K

Wt
dD,&

t^^<
^

<^d
,&

,d
,D

W,d/K

/270>

,

5.37 > D
272DD
,

>
///
W/

5.38 t D
D
,,
/
D

5.39 d D

/

E//
D
Z
5.40 DD^
tK^/K
270
>dD
,D

t^>

272
>dD
,D

dD
E/
Wd
D,D

D
^277^t^
K278
5.41 D

^/K^tD
/
D
E

: z K 280 /

DW^
5.42 //D

5.43 ^W^/,282

/

^/
K
5.44 d
DD

278
dD,
&

Wd
D,D
280
d^

Wd
D,D
282
^W^d
D,D
277
W,d/K
,

d

5.45 dEdt
/Dd

D ' D D /
D
t
E/

/
5.46 ^t
D

/
D'
5.47 ^t
d

//
/
/
/
5.48 ^^
t
EKdt
d
Dd
Wd
D,D

Wtd
D,&

Wtd
,&

t^^
<^
5.49 /D287
d/
/
DDd/

Ett
5.50 /
D

5.51 ^tEdt
^ t

288
d / d
/
/E
/
/
5.52 ,
d/
/

5.53 t/
/
^t
D
5.54 d^^

^^
/
Z/W

,
287
DDd
,&
288
Wtd
D,&

<^d
,&

W,d/K

5.55 ^ ^
,

Kss
/

Z/W

Z/W

5.56 ^ ^

,

,/

^^
^t

E/
5.57 dD^t^^
D
/
D,
t /

/
5.58 D
,
/
/
//
5.59 ,

5.60 /

Wd
D,D

t d Z

DW^ E/ d /

E/
5.61 /^t

,
/
t/
/
t/

d

5.62 ^t

/

W^

5.63 /
^t
Z

/
^t
5.64 &
E/
/
D'DD/^t

D D
Wtd
D,&

W,d/K
,
D'
DD
/E/
5.65 /^t
W^Dz

E/
/
^t

5.66 //&
^ t

dD
^t
/

5.67 ^^t/^t
W^

5.68 ^/
E/

/D
^D
D
K
5.69 '

''D/

DW^
E/

d^t^
t:zd
5.70 ^^/

/E//
//

5.71
,

^/
//
d/
5.72 K D
/E/
/
E/D,
//

/

^/K/

^/K

5.73
//
Y
WYW^

W ^

W^
<^d
,&

Wd
D,D

,d
,D

WYd
D,
W,d/K
/
/
W
d
6.1
/

^tD^t
D
D
,

6.2
D

D
zD

KK
6.3
^ t
/ W s ' D

d
DK

D
t&
t^W
Wd
D,D

t^W

Wd
D,D

t^W

t^^W
t
d
hsED't
h<hsE

d
KK
h

d
d
/
hsEd

/
/^K

&

hsE
d

K
/
'

DWZ,WD

d
D hsE

/
W,d/K
d

W

ZK
K
/
/DW^
d
d

WDWZ
6.4
^t
/
/

/
d

6.5
,
:z

,this

d
W

6.6
/
DWZ,W
D
/
D'DD
t^^Wt
t^^Wt

Wtd
D,&
^
t
DW
Z ,
/
Dd

6.7
/

,
6.8
d
^ ^ W

/
/

d
D
D

D'DDd^
tD'
d

6.9
^t,
^
tZ/Wd
Z/W
Dd

<^

dDDDD

dD,&

dD
D

dD
,&
W,d/K
//
d

^
^
//

d ^ t

6.10 t^^

^^
/ /

/E
/DW
>>
/
6.11 /

d
/
W

6.12 h
d

d

6.13 ^t
t//

/^^
DWZ,^K

<^d
,&

t^^W
t
/
/

6.14 ^t
^t

d

6.15 ^ ^
DWZ,
,
dD

/
d

K
D

t/
/
d/

:t>K

d

&

6.16 /
/
&

<^d
,&

t^^
<^

dK
W,d/K

/K

/
DW^
DW^
dDW^
6.17 Dz^t^^
/:
/

6.18 t/DW^
d
KtdDW^

^K

6.19 ^^D
,

/
D

6.20 /

d
D

D

/
: z
/
^sK
:z:Dz

dDW^
/

^<^Z

t^W

/

6.21 d

DW^K

E/dDW^

6.22 D
,^
/
6.23 ^t
d&

6.24 ^t

^t
///
/
//
/
/

6.25 />W

>W

//D
s
ddW
Wd
D,D

t^^W
t

Wtd
D,&

d>W

W,d/K
&K/DK
KKJoan
,^t>
W,
/ /
t /

D

6.26 /^t
>W
W
DK/
>Wd
/

/
/

^^
d
/ d
d

^
:

6.27 &WD
D'DD
,
/:Z,^
' D d
K
K,
K
'D

Wtd
D,&

<^d
,&

t^^W
t

t^W

6.28 >Z
D
,
/D
D
:

6.29 d ^
D>Z

^ /
'D

///
D/
6.30 >Z
>WDD

6.31 E/
/

&//

DWÊ/
^K

6.32 /
&DK^
^D^
/
W > W ^ , W
DW^
,dhDD/,
dh
d
D D D W
t^>Z

>Zd
,D

W,d/K
/DW
&Z,^,DW
D D

EdtD'
6.33 /

d

,

''//

dE/
6.34 d
E/ D ' d
,

/
'D'
6.35 'D

EdtE/

EdtDD

/
E/

d
E/

6.36 dE/Edt
D'&
E/ D '
D
WD:'

t^^
,DW
/

6.37 ^Ê/
,

d
6.38 d^t,
////

/

/

6.39 ,
//

d/

/
/
//
///
/

d
6.40 ^ t E/

K

6.41 dDWÊ/

E/dDWÊ/
<^d
,&

<^

Wtd
D,&

W,d/K

dDWÊ/
E/DW^

DWÊ/

Edt/

E/
6.42 dDW^
KtE/
t

DD
/
Edt

6.43 dDW^
E/
/
K
E/
t
d

E//E/
dDW^
K
6.44 &DW^DWÊ/
^t
D
dDW^

D
dEt

7.1
d Edt
DD
<^d
,&
D
DD,
/>,///

7.2
D
E/
K D
d
E/D
7.3
Z D D D
DDDD
D,
DDDD

/ZD
>,DD

dDD
'D
/^/

/&

7.4
DD
////
//
/d

7.5
dDD
,DD
d
,D

ZDd
D,

ZDKD
ZDEdt

ZDE

Dd
,

Dd
D,
W,d/K
D
DD

^
/

d
The PCC
7.6
D d d W W
W

Edt

&DdDD
D'DD
/DDW

Et
7.7
DDW

,
Et
7.8
DDD'd
7.9
DD
d
E/

dWW
t^dd

WD

WD

WD

WD
7.10 dW
E
DDD,
D'DWW
dDD'
D
E
tD'D
,

W
7.11 KD>,E/D^
,D^
s
D,
,D'
d
Edt
D ' D D
'
7.12 /D'Edt
/
d

dE/WW

E
/

7.13 /D'
,D'
d E/
Edt
Edt
tD
WDW>^/E^Zd,zWZ>/E<
YD^^Z
^Y

E/WW

>'E/D/
W,d/K
D'D
D
'

EtE

7.14 /D,&D,
D'd
/
Et/

/
z &

7.15 d
D'KDD'
,ZE/
,
Edt
Edt

7.16 KDD'E/
d
KD:>
E/ , >
D'D
>,>

/

D'
7.17 /
d
D'
dd
,

>>,'&/

'/>
dD,

7.18 K D D D
d
t
/
''
DEt

7.19 >D
'D

7.20 D
/t

/
7.21 d
/
'

7.22 / , >
E/

D'DD
d
7.23 D , D^
Edt
D '
,>
D'DDD
D ' D
D
D '
s

/
E/

Dd
D,
W,d/K
7.24 D
,DDD
D'/

D
D
7.25 D

D
'DD,
E/D

D
ZD'
tE/

//

7.26 D

D
DD

EtDD
D'

D'
Et
d'D
7.27 /:E/D'
&
D'dD'
D
d
:
dD,

dd
,

d

d

d

d

Dd
D,

:d
D,

:
7.28 dD'

d
D'

dEt

d

7.29 Z E/ D '
E/DD
/DDE/
E/
:d
DDD

t/
D D
/&
D D D
DD
D'
7.30 dD'
D D
D
D
d'd
7.31 d'd
DDDD
Et

D'DD
7.32 d E'E D D
t D d
E'E
,Dd

DDEtDD
:d
,

:

:

W&
W,d/K
DdE
DdD
DZ
DE'E&Dd

7.33 /
D>
Dd
DD^YE'E
dD^:D
D^
E'E

7.34 ,
/D^
E
t
/
E'E
7.35 ::W&DdE'E
,E'E

DWDdD>:D
> D d
dDWD
d
hE'EDd
t
7.36 /D

:W:W^
:W

:W

:W:W^

:W:W^

:Wd
D,

:W:W^

:W:W^

DK^Z:Y
dD,E
D'd
DDD
'
':D
D
DD
dDD

7.37 /DDD
'
DD
Dd
D
7.38 d : D d
D D : D
,DW
DDDDD
DW:D
d/D'

:D
D D D W : D
D D
:DD
D
EtD'
7.39 dD^
dDDD
D^

E'E : D
D^

E'E D ' t
:
dD,

Dd
D,

:W:W^

:Dd
D,

:D

dd
D,:W
d,

Dd
D,

:Dd
D,
W,d/K
D^
/

7.40 K:DD:D
Dd
dDD
: ' d W &
hd:W&
d/
d/d
7.41 :D
Dd^
,DD
d
:Dd

7.42 K : D D D : D
DdDD
^
E
:D
ED
E:D
D'DD
DD

7.43 :D
DdEdt
, D D
D

7.44 :D

,
EEdtD
d
Edt,
:Dd
D,

:D

dd
D,

d

d

:Dd
D,
D^D^

D'
7.45 'Z
DZD
Dd,

,:D
Dd
EdtE'EDd,
:D

7.46 ZDE/

7.47 ,
/
D:
7.48 DD D
EdtD

d
DD
/ /

7.49 t:
EdtE/Ed
Edt
/

d

:D
:D

ZDd
D,

ZD

ZD

dd
,

dd
D,

Dd
D,
W,d/K

Edt
/:ZD

Edt
E/
7.50 ,/:D

DDD
d
:
/
:
7.51 /:D

E/ /
:D
DDD

7.52 E
/ZD

DD
D,/E
ZD
/E
ZD

E/
7.53 //D
:
:DdDD
D^

KDd
7.54 & D D D
:D
^:E
DD
K/
DDD

: D

7.55 //dZ
W/
&/

/
/
&
:
7.56 /

dDD

D'

K
d

Etd
D
:d'
/
8.1
Edt K
''D

'
t'
EzdWW
d
W/
8.2
D /
DW^
DW^
/
DWÊ/
DWÊ/
W,d/K
8.3
d:
DW^:z

K

d'
8.4
K : ' E'E

d

DWd
'd
d'
E'D
Et^
8.5
8.6
d Z
D
DW^
WÊ'
W
dE/D'D
D
D'd
, D '
' E '

dDW
:Wd:
8.7
dDd
DW^D'
:z:Dz
d^zE
'Dd
Et
EtD

8.8
dE/
Dd/
d^zEt
'D
d
E/

d ' ^ z
d E '
'D
8.9
d'D
'/
'
8.10 d
E/d:D
Edt
Dd,

d

8.11 ,
d
8.12 K : '
DW
^W^WK/

^W
DW^,
/
:Dd
D,

^W^
dD,D
t^^W^
W,d/K
:zDz
,^K
8.13 ^WDz^WDzD
zK
Dz
dd

Z
E

d:

8.14 Dz
E t d
'
EdtE
DtEdt

Dz
8.15 W

t D z
Dt/

DW^

8.16 /
DtDz

Dt,
d:
^D'
d/

^W^d
D,D

t^:z

W'
DzEdt

:zd
,D
/

8.17 >
Dz/
Dt
'
K
Dz

D'
DD&Dz
Dt
t

E///
:t

:
//

/
8.18 Dz
/ :
/ E

/
/
8.19 /Dz
,

D t
K
&

Dt

8.20 D z
Et
/

W,d/K
'

8.21 Dz
D t ,
D z
^^
Dzt
Dz
Dt

8.22 Dz

E//
'
/Dz
K

d

8.23 /
d'^W^
Edt/
/
,

8.24 ^WDz

//

/Dz

8.25 /&DZY
E/Dz ^ t
'
Z

/

Dt

^W^d
D,D^WDW^

8.26 /^WDzDt
^W
t
Dz
//
/ /
/
/Dt/
8.27 /^W
Dt'^W

, D z /

/
Dz
/

/
t/
/

8.28 ^W
,
t/
/
8.29 d t

d
/
d
/
^W
^W^d
D,D

/^KW
W,d/K
d
8.30 /Dz

:
8.31 D z
''
Dz
^t^^^^
^tDz
dDz

8.32 d d
^t
Dz

Dz
^t
8.33 Dz^t

/Dz
d

d

8.34 d ' ' D z
dt

d
&
tDzd
hZ
E/^t
D z
:zd
,D/^^

Wtd
,&

Wtd
,&

:z:Dz
''

8.35 >K

Dz
D '
/
K^t
/^t:

K
/
Dz
8.36 /^t

'
^t
8.37 t^^t

:dd
/

D '
D

K

W
8.38 dd
^t

/Dz
D
^
D'DD

8.39 / DW^

D ' D D
t^^Wt
W,d/K

//

8.40 dDW^

Dz^t
Dz:
DDz/

/

8.41 ^t

,Dz
/Dz

D

d
Dz

^/:
Dz
K
'

8.42 dDz
D z

/''Dz
t
DW^
,D
Dt

D'DD
tDDW/E

t
E't
/^t/
K
D'/
D

law
/

8.43 D z :
WK
,^

d
,Dz

W^
,

8.44 /Dz^
t D z
D z
W^
' W^

'

8.45 /Dz
D
'^tDz

'/
^tDz

Dz
:/

8.46 /DW^

/^tDz
,Dz
^t
'
'Dz^t
D'

:zd
,D

:z:Dz

:zd
,D

W,d/K
/D
Dz
'

8.47 &Dz
d
'':
dDz

Dz
K
Dz'
8.48 d:d
''
Dz
^ t ' d
WDz
E ^ z ^ t
^^
't
DW^

8.49 d''

DW^
>
&//

8.50 d'Dz

D'DD
/Dz
d
/W^
d

8.51 d/W^

/DD
>dD
,D

:z:Dz

W^W

8.52 Dz^t
'
^t

E
/
8.53 ^t^^
^t
W^
t

8.54 t

D^t

D z

8.55 D z

d
/

8.56 'K
d

D
:z:Dz
W,d/K
Dz

d/
////

8.57 d''Dz

K

d
dZ

t

8.58 ^t
,/
/
Z/W

8.59 /^t
Z/W
^t^^
^t
W^
d^t

^^
8.60 / ^ t D z

^t

8.61 /&Dz

:zd
,D

:z:Dz

Wtd
,&

d


8.62 d
D z
'
^tDz
'

DzE/
DWÊ/
8.63 /Dz
d
d
d
Dz

d
/
^/

^
//

/
8.64 &'
Dz
KD'
/
t:
/
D

d
8.65 t D z

Dz

/
t^
:z

:zd
,D

W,d/K

^ W d '
'

8.66 Z D z ^ W ^
/D
/

/
D
/
D//
ddD

t

/

/

8.67 dDW^/
>
//
/ ^W ^
W

8.68 /
Dz
8.69 dDz

D
d

/
^W^
dD,D
^t
/
/
DZY/
/
E/Et
8.70 /Dz
'dK
/
/
^W^
Dz
&,^Z,:DW
WK:^W^
/Dz
/
DW^
8.71 d^W^
^t^t
'

/
/Dz
8.72 ^ t

/ /

/

/
' ^ t
Dz

8.73 / /^t D
zd^t/
/^
tDz
Wtd
,&

W,d/K

^t
E///
/
/ / /
/
//
///^/K
//
/
h^/K/
//

8.74 d ^ t

/

d

d Z / /
^t/
Dz
E/
8.75 Z '
Dz^t
,
'

^/
/
//
8.76 D z '
d'
tDz
'
/^
t
Dz
/
/
/

:zd
,D

/d
/

8.77 Dz

&

8.78 /Dz
:
^

,
/ d < ^

/z
:
8.79 Dz

tE

WW
d
8.80 ,
dd
/

8.81 DzDt,Y
/
/
/

Edt,,
//

W,d/K
8.82 Dz
^ t K
D'
Dz

/

8.83 Dz
,

/
/
Edt

8.84 Dz
Edt
'
K
'
d

8.85 //
&Dz

d/

Dz
8.86 &/Dz:
dWD
dWD
:Wd:
W
8.87 d
>WZ,:WDW>W
^W^'
DW^
Dz
t^:z
:z:Dz
>W
/
Dz>W
''^t
> W
^t
/
ACTIONWt
8.88 d Dz>W
^t
>W
d
^t
^t
8.89 ^tDz:
^d
WD:WWt<^
DW
dDW
8.90 /
D z > W
^t
^ ^ D z

d^t^^D
z
Z/W/

D
8.91 d^tDz
>W^t
Dz

DDD
DDD
:W:,
:z:Dz
:z:Dz
W,d/K
Et
/Ds

ddW
K/DK
KK
:,
8.92 ^t>W
K

8.93 WDz^t
Zd
>W

E/
8.94 dD
zDW^

d
dW^
8.95 < ^ Y > D WW
'
Edt,

W^
,
^WW
,^
'

8.96 /DzD^'

d

8.97 D^Dz
d/
^t^<
^Y

<^d
D,
/
D z
>:D^

/

/
/
W^/

'

d/
/
/
8.98 DzD^
8.99 /D^

W^
dE

8.100 d

&WW
W^
dD
^
DW^W^
d
D'
DD
8.101 hD
W^D^>D
Dd
^,^
D^

:z:Dz

^t^<
^Y

W,d/K
W^
DW^dW^

DD:d
W
t,h
8.102 :
D^D^^W^

:
8.103 d:Dz''
d^^d

d K '
D
d DW^ E t

/DDEt
d
d
W^

W
Z d

/ DW^
/

^^Ê/W

d
8.104 dDz

dDzE/
dDz
Dz
E
:z:Dz

:z:Dz

:z

/

8.105 dDz

/

,:
,
8.106 ^^:

,Dz,D
/ ,D/ ^ t
^ ^
Dz,D/

8.107 ^^Dz
//
:
^ t
^^
Dz&D
z^^
:

8.108 /:
,dd/D,

d
D,

&
:zd
,D

^<^/

^Wt/
W,d/K
D,

8.109 / D ,
/ E/

,
K

/
&
D,dd
E/
E/
8.110 : ^ t ^ ^
D z ^ t
:
/
K/:/
^t^^

/D
/

E W/E
K

/

DD
'd

DE
tD/

DEKdt'd

8.111 /
Et
, d
,D

:z:Dz

Wtd
,&

:z:Dz
E

8.112 d^t
Dz

Dz
d

DD
/
D'
/
^^
8.113 / D z
/

DDDz
D z
t
/

d

DD

/ t
/
8.114 Dz^t:^^

DD
DD
/

Edt

/
/
DzDz

d

:zd
,D

W,d/K
8.115 d^t^^

Z/W
/

d

d

8.116 d
^Z/WD
d

8.117 d^t
Z/WD
&^t^^

/

,

8.118 h^t
Dz

/ ^
^^^

t/
E/
8.119 ^ W ^ D z
' D z

d
^W,
Dz

:z:Dz
t^^W
^

^W^d
D,D
8.120 Dz'':d^t
DD,W^^,d
DW^

'd

&W:z'
d
/'
h
W
'
8.121 DDz

DD,Dz
t
8.122 d''DW^^t
^^KY
D
z''
8.123 K:E'
D^,
E D D
'd
8.124 :WY>D
d
t
E t 'D
tt
DE
t
^,Dz''
',^/KKs

:z:Dz

E

:z:Dz

/E
DW^W^'::
W^

:z:Dz
W,d/K
8.125 d
D^

8.126 Dz
D ^ D z
&

Dz
DD

8.127 t
DD
Dz
d/
W/
/

t/
W/
W/
/
8.128 t D z

8.129 K : ,
D^^W^
DW^,

' D z
,
DDEdt

8.130 :^tW^
D,
^t^
<^Y

d,
D

:z:Dz

E
WWW^W

/ ' D
EK
d,
/ ^
W

8.131 d D , ^ ^
/^^

8.132 K : D , WW
/W^
D'DD/
W^
,W^
/
W^/
W^
/
'D

8.133 : ^ t t

D

/

/

/ d
d

E
:z:Dz

E
W,d/K
d

/
8.134 ^tDz

//
Dzd

8.135 ^t
EKdt
DD/

2. Data//
K
^ '
d:

s /
'
/

Wd//

8.136 /^t

8.137 >:WWE
WWEdtE
dW^
8.138 K : D z ' '
EdD
z,DWE
^t
d
E
^t^<
^Y

:z:Dz
^tEdt

8.139 : D z
^ t
E,

,
/

EKdt
W d d
E /

&
E
/d
8.140 &:WÊ

DW^W^D^
DD^^,D
'
D ^
/d
/
D^

8.141 :D^WYd

, D ^
Dz

DzD^
DzD:
&
DWD^Dz
ED
:z:Dz
^t^<
^Y

<^d
,
W,d/K
^
&D^
WW
8.142 KD:Dz^t
DW^/
D^DW
E ^ t
d

<^>d^

8.143 D^
8.144 D^Dz

hD^
DW

Dzd
D^DW
^t
8.145 ^^tW^

W^h^t
Z/W,
E
Edt
D'&
E

/
DzD^
8.146 D^DW
/WW
DW
<^d
,

E

<^Yd
,

:z:Dz

^t^<
^Y

WÊ
:

ZE
:
ZE
8.147 DW
Z
D^DW
^t,

DW^ W^
dW^:
DW
^
t D
W

Z / W

8.148 DWW^
, : E
,
^t

8.149 DW
'
/
W^
8.150 tD^
DW
d
WW D W

E
/KDDDW
:
DDWY
dD,

/DW

W,d/K

Z/W,
^t

8.151 / D W
D^

DW

8.152 dWWD^:
DWD^
D'DD

8.153 K ^ t
D^/

^/WW^^

^^

8.154 W D^ ^ t
^
EKdt
WW^
W

'D

EKdt

8.155 ^t

dEKdt
'D
t
WYd
D,

:z:Dz'

:z:Dz

^tDzD^^

8.156 KEWWD^,
DW
Z/W
KDzD^
,
,It is not

8.157
Dz//

KDz
//:///
/z

8.158 dDz^t
/
/ D z /
/
,
//

//

8.159 >
/:zE/
E//
/
8.160 ^W^Dz,I
/
:z:Dz
:z:Dz

Wtd
,&

>dD
,D

^W^d
D,D
W,d/K
E/E/,

8.161 /Dz
D t E/
d '
/E/
EtE/
8.162 /
Edt
/D'Y/
/Dz

t/Dz
/
d
8.163 ,:
:Dz

8.164 /:^t^^Dz

dDz

/Dz
E'':Dz
^t^^
,^^
/
Dz

8.165 ^^

/^^

^t:/
D z :

:

:z:Dz

:z:Dz
/^
^

8.166 /:

d
KWt

:z
t

Wt
:z Wt

Z

W
8.167 /^t
d

8.168 K:/DK
K
d
K
KK&^d
D d
d
K

^

8.169 s K d

^
Dz
s K
E/Dz
:z:Dz
E

E
W,d/K
^t^^
8.170 K:KYDz
D ' D D >d/ >d/
/d
,K>D^
dDW^

Dz
d
/DW^

8.171 Dz
/

^/K,

Dz
/:/
/
,K>D^z/
/
,K>D^
E
/
/
^ / D
/
/
//
E

8.172 KEE
K/D
t

t
Wt

t^/D
D

:z:Dz

E

:zd
,D

/D
/ > ^/K
^ / K

8.173 K
h
t

8.174 d
8.175 K:/DKK
^t
W

/D

K

t
/Wt
t
&

d
t

K
8.176 dK

8.177 K E
K

8.178 K:/Ds^/D
E
8.179 K & DW^ E &
/

E

E

E
W,d/K
8.180 K & D z D^

^
,
^/

d
/d

DW^d
d

t
'D
DW^

8.181 d

8.182 ^ t K
/DW^
&/
D^t/D

DD

d
K
WD

:z:Dz
:z:Dz

:z:Dz
//
:z

/

/
d

/

,

t
&
dE&K/

K
t:t

/
d

dE&K/

K
tK
/

d
8.183 /

Dz:/
d
W,d/K

/

8.184 /''^^t
^
/

d^
t:z
8.185 / K E
dDW^

/
K
Ks
d''K
^tDz

^t
DW^d/
DW^

8.186 /^tK
K s

,
,
DW^/
^t

8.187 K E K K
DW^
KdDd
K
DW^K
K
d
DW^
:z:Dz
:z:Dz

:z:Dz

:z:Dz
8.188 KEK
/K

8.189 &Es
/

^ W s t
s
d

/s

8.190 dW/E

8.191
Dz
D z

,/d

d

8.192 /

/ DW^ D z ^ t ^
^ E

d
Ks
d
d
K

E/

:zd
,D

t^:z
W,d/K
8.193 / > W

>^DW^DD
:W,
DE/^>
^KWdyd^KW
dydh,

D D D z
,K>D^
///
: W
//
/
8.194 d/Dz
>W

,
/ /
DW/

,
/WD
//

8.195 ^tDz
,K>D^
Dz
dd&/
Dz

Dz
WD
dW
8.196 Z
WK:
ZDWWWDt,
:zd
,D

d^t>W

>W

d W

/
W'/

8.197 d W

/
Edt'/K
8.198 K : W D D
'

8.199 / D D
' In

KEt
'
' d
'd
:'
d'D
d
t'd

^:

Et
d

8.200 D D
'
WEK
^s

WEK
W,d/K
,
DD
/
/
/
'
8.201 d W
DD
KD'/

d
'
8.202 /DD:
E
W
D '
,
t E
/^/:/

/^^/
W
^
8.203 ///
DD^
W
KW

8.204 /DDW
E '
DDD',

D
E
t'
8.205 d/
E/

Dd
D,

WEK


DD
8.206 W
t E d
D'W
dW

'DE
t'D/
W
dD^
8.207 dD^'
E/
E
Edt d
' W /
DWÊ//
WWD>'ddE/
dD^<>,
d'D'EdZ
Dd
d

8.208 /E/D'
D,
d
'
8.209 / D D D
'
D,

8.210 D

,
t'
//
//
W
DW^D^
^WW>Z

YD^ZW^W>

Y

Y
W,d/K
/
/
tD

zK
d/
td

8.211 D/

8.212 KDD
D

tD
/
D

t/
D

d
D

8.213

/D
8.214 d&
E
t't

8.215 d
W/
Et/
Y
Y

Y

Y

DW^D
^^WW>Z

Et

8.216 dE/
D^
WEdt

/Edt
Êdt
Kt
8.217 d DW^ K ^ D z
^tD^Dz
Z/W

,
K

WW

/
8.218 Dz:
/
/

/
/
/
/ '
/

//
/

8.219 ,'

'DW^
d
'
YDW^D
^^

Y
W,d/K
8.220
E
DW^
/ D W
' D
'DEt
WÊ
d
d
dDW

8.221 W
tW
''Dd'
:W
Et
dW
E/
^dEzd
9.1
KÊzdd,
Zd
Edt
DW^d

d
^z/

d D

W/E^zD

^z

D ' t

9.2
dDW^
Edt
DW^D
^^WW>Z

:z:Dz
/Edt

Edtd

d
d DD
Edt
dDWÊdtd
E t
dDW^
E/
d DW^ W^
DW^

DW^ Edt
9.3
KÊzd^,
Z,
,
9.4
' E
z d D , D z

KK
,^t
^^
D'DD

/
:
/
Dz

Ez
d
9.5
K^Dz
dEzdDW^K
t
t^,
t
:z:Dz
W,d/K
^,Z
W^
9.6
Dz>W

^
>Wd
D'd
9.7
K^Dz''E^t^
^d''
dWKDW^
dEE
t ^ , ^ D Z
,DWDDE
d^
:z

d^,
^K^K
9.8
^,^/K
W^
^D
d D z
WW > ^ D
zW^W>
DzD^
Dz
Ezd
^,W^
9.9
K^^,W^DW^
/
^
/
/
9.10 K^Dz''
^,
d
Ks

:z:Dz
:z:Dz

E

:z:Dz

E
d^

Et
9.11 ''^
Ezd
K s ^ , E z d
9.12 ^ , ,K>D^

,K>D^>WDD
/^
:WDD
WZd:>WW/E:>W

:>W,
>W/>
W
D
9.13 ZWÊzd
D^D^
tWY>D/

Z/WDWY
D^/
W^
DWÊ
zd
9.14 /D^

Z/W
DD,Y
9.15 dWWDW^,
DW

Z/W
DD,
DW
Z/W
Z/W

9.16 h D ^

:z:Dz
:z:Dz

^t^<
^Y

E
W,d/K
D^DW
E
K^DW
Z/W
^t,
E
9.17 K^WWD,/
D,
Z/W
& W
D,

9.18 / W ^ D ^
Z/W
W^
Z/W
9.19 KK^,^
,W^^,
Ks
9.20 KKdddd,
Edt
&^,D

&EDDK

/
, / /
/ E t :

^//

9.21 ,
ddDW^^,
DK In
^,

E
E

:z:Dz

:z:Dz

:z:Dz

/E&
/ /
/

9.22 DW^D^
DK
DÊD^

/ / /
D
/
//
/^

//
9.23 K E ^ , W^

EKs

K,
D'
DD,

9.24 dEzd
d/
d^,
d^D
d W DD Edt

dD
d Z , E
Edt
d
9.25 ^,

<^d
,

W,d/K
9.26 D'DD
EdDd
E
,
'D,
D D
D,Edt
,

d
Edt
d
9.27 Wd
dd/DW^K

,

/

DW^
9.28 d DW^ ' d /
EdtDW^
E
9.29 & Edt

E
9.30 ^,
, DW^

dEt
/
d

/
W^
DW^W^/

9.31 KDKsW^,

W
,
'

:z:Dz
W^
D
/ ^ ,
D

9.32 dWWD
9.33 KsDzEzd
W^/tDz

Ezd

t'
Ezd
DDEdtd
DW^d
K
d'
10.1 K'
^DE'EDD
d W E t
WDD
Z,
Et
'
10.2 dW
DW^,d'
DD
DD
:>d

d'

D

t^:z
W,d/K
d ^ z

d

/ : E t '
D

,

10.3 d

10.4 K:'W^
W^
DDD^
W^
, D ^

W^
,
t/
^D/
Ed
E
^D//

/d'/
/

10.5 /&:D^
DzD^

W^
d D z

d
,Ks'Dd

:z
<^Yd
,

E
WW'Dd

10.6 /
D^
//

/dDz
/
//
/
10.7 D^Dz
D
^DzDW^
dDz
WWD^W>
D>Y
10.8 dDz

,
/:
WW
d>Y

10.9 /Dz

10.10 dDzWW

t
d
cases
/
d

<^Yd
,

^t^<
^Y

t^:z

:z:Dz'
W,d/K
10.11 :W^DW^
10.12 K : E/ DW^
Edt
E/E/
D'd
DW^
EdtDz

10.13 K E/
/

10.14 d : ' Edt

DK:
Edt
YW

10.15 K:
^W^:D
z
10.16 K:,h
d
Dz
Dz

D D
/

/

DD

t^:z

dW'

:z:Dz

DW^,
,
d
ds:
11.1 d /
/

E'EDW^
11.2 s:DW^
^
d D D D
D D
D D D
DDE'E
D
E'EDD
dDDD
DW^D
11.3 K:DDD
D
Edt

11.4 :,':<
DW^
DD
Edt
11.5 >W
:
KE'E
DD
E t
/
DD

Ê'E>t,

E'E

W,d/K

/
DDdEt
E'E
DD
E t
t
11.6 :E'E
E'E

DD
dDW^
11.7 d:'
&DW
Z DW >W
DW^
11.8 D
D
&

,
DW^

11.9 D W
,
DW^

11.10 > W D z

d

11.11 ^DD

,
h
DD
11.12 d^>W
Ed
DW^K

ZDWWWDt,
11.13 K&>^DW^>W
E/
DD
W/E>
W
11.14 KDDDD

11.15 KDDW
d

d
DDDW
11.16 KD
D : &
DDW>
Wh
DW^d

/,Z

d
d
d
& ' D
'

^

11.17 d ' >: / : '

W

ZDWWWDt,
W,d/K
W^

d
12.1 /K

/W

E/d

12.2 &/
K
'

''D
/

12.3 d^W

/

E/Edt
12.4 d ,
'

/
K

h

12.5 & /
/
d

D'/

12.6 ^

/

&

'D
W/E
12.7 /
DW^ Edt

/
/
E//

DWÊ/
12.8 d
Edt E/

/
Edt
tE/Edt

DW^

dE/
Et
12.9 E/
D '
D
' D D D

d D D
Edt

12.10
D E/
D'd
W,d/K
was
Z

12.11 D ^ Y

Z : D
/
E/
DDD
tEdt'

/
Edt

d

E

E/
12.12 E/D'
W
WDÊ/
EdtD
'dE/
DD
D^
W
Edt
/Edt
Êdt
Kt
W
12.13 ::K

d
/ D z
d

DW^
W^
d
Z/W
d
^

'
d
^
^K

E'
Ezd
W
12.14 /DW^'
:&Dz

,^WWW
Wt/Dz
Dt
DW^

Edt
/

12.15 dDz'
,^t

E
&

D'
d

12.16 d :

K
sEzdd

Ezd
Edt

:DzWW
DW^W^h

Dz
E/:
W,d/K
12.17 d^t,
Z
^t

'
d

12.18 , / / ^ t
Dz

&

Dz'

12.19 //^t
Edt

E

,Dz

^t/^t
12.20 d DW^

/

E/DW^
DW^ W
D,d
:,
E/E//

The CPS
12.21 d W^ '
'D/

Edt
D
d/

12.22 : : WW
Y
' :
' W^
W^
'W^
WW
W^d
DW^
/
12.23 /WW
' D
/
W^,
E:
D^DW/
DW

/

12.24 dEzdWW
'W^
Ks/:
^DD^

12.25 /D'

d
/

/
d'd
,D
CHAPTER 5
A NEW APPROACH TO THE ALLEGATIONS
W/Kt
Tuleta
/
1.1
Kt:/
DW^DWÊ/E/DW^

E t Edt 1 /
d
^^DW^
K^
^
Kd
1.2
K:DWÊ/

Edt2^
K
1.3
Kd:
Edt
Kd4/
1.4
/&:
K
KK
^
dZ
t^^

^t^^

ibid

dt^^

&t^^
421
Kt
1.5
&K
t
Kt

D8K9
^Kt
/DW^
E/11
K K t
E/
/12
weve rebuilt experts have rebuilt material that we thought had been lost, and
that was completed towards the end of November last year. So were now going
through that material.
1.6
dKt
^

K
Edt

^K

14
1.7
/Kt
/
1.8

K^^

dD,
&

:
t^^

t^^passim

ibid

ibid

dD,
&

&t^^

, ibid

, ibid
422
E
K
1.9
/&K
DW^d
E/
K
K
d^D ^D;
^ ^ d K
W

W
18
KW^
19
1.10 /

2122
Kd
1.11 Kd
/,EdtK
Kd

24d

1.12 /Kd
D^D^
^D^

^t^
^

dt^
^&t
^^

dt^^

&t^
^

KE

dt^
^

ibid

t^/,

&t^
^

dt^
^

ibid

dD
,:
it seems that on occasions weve found that material has been downloaded from
E /
/
dated around late 2010, that one of the mobile phones has been examined with a
view to breaking its code, its security code, so that the contents can be downloaded
by experts.
1.13 K K d

E//
D^28
1.14 K D
K
d29dd
KdD

W^
1.15 Kt
Edt
dD^
2.1

EdtW''D

s

:'
WE
zd
2.2
/DW^
E/
EEE/
dD^
D^:Eh<
>'Y
2.3
>'
E/DW^
ibid
&t^
^

&t^
^
424
E
Edt K > '

'^sW''E
::
< ' h ^ '
EWs
EE'
'
2.4
/:E/t>d
D''DE/^'
, E/
D^dDÊ
':WD^
2.5
dDÊ/E
dD^
E d D^
E/ t > E/
d D^
EdtE/
d
2.6
dDÊ
EdtE/^D^

EdtE/
E//d

E/d
Y h ^
&Wh^
EE/
h^/h<E/
Eh<
h^ZD
/ED^
h^:
2.7
dh<
DW^K
/W

dK

D^

t^d
D

t^<Z
D
/WdDW^h<E/D^
h^h<
DÊ/h<dD^
E
E/d^ddd^d/
Edt.
2.8
D^
E/
D^
E/d
d^ddd^d
41 d /
D^
2.9
/D^
E/^
Edt
E/d^
E/
E ' E E'E E/
Edt42dÊ
K
Edt
^^',:
^
E'E
44
2.10 E/^

d^

d^
Kt
^
E'E
DW^
^
t^:&
t^'

D^

D^

D^

E

2.11 dD^D^

E//DW^
Kt/Wd

W
D ^ ^ / Z ^
D^W
48
D^

2.12 ^/
DW^D^/
D^

DW^ D^
DW^
K D^ d ^49 /
D^
d ^ d d d ^ d
DW^
2.13 dDW^D^

/W
WDW^
/DW^^

E/
and thats what were doing. So its voluntary disclosure as opposed to applying for a
W
2.14 d D^
K

^
ZE/W,s//

ZE/W,s/

^d
D,&

îbid
d ^ : & d
E/
d ^
&
d^d<

d^
2.15 / D

^
d^
^^
d
d
existence of The Sun. To this end there has been liaison with the MSC to take account
d^d^
^

d^^
2.16 /D^
DW^&:&
D^
t

forthcoming.
2.17 dDW^
D^D^
D^
D^DW^/
DW^
D^D^
^d
D,:

d^d<t
^W/
/

^t^
^/
K

^t^
^

^d
D,:

^d
D,:
428
E
2.18 DD
D^DW^^
/D^
DW^

then these were other lawyers, Burton Copeland. Then Mr Lewis and Mr Greenberg

D D^

on a more formal basis with lawyers only.
2.19 D^

d
D^:
DW^>'D^^
E/

2.20 d
D^ DW^
D^DW^
&D^t>
^'

/D^DW^

2.21 ^:
D^ DW^ /
/
//
îbid
dt
^^

^d
D,:

îbid
dt^^

^d
D,:
dt^^

^d
D,:
dt^^

^d
D,:
dt^^

^
dD,:
dt^^
429
dD^
2.22 DD^DW^
d D^ E/
t

D^

2.23 d
/

K,
DW^
D^
2.24 /D:
D^^

^Kd
d

KtD

2.25 D D^
K
Edt
d^d
/

There also appears to have been a culture at the Sun of illegal payments, and

d
openly referred to within the Sun, in which case the source is not named, but rather

2.26 dD^
d

E///:DDW^
^
^t^
^

dt^
^

dDif downloaded in the form of a kind of
/
d
D,:

^

dt^^

E

dD'dD'E'dDW^
D^D
^ ^ ^
dD'
Kd

2.27 D^dD'
DW^
^dD'DW^W

D^
D
D^
2.28 D^ E/ E
/ W
DW^D^
d E
D^DWD^
E
DW^
2.29 D W
, D^ DW^

WD^
d^DW
d^
weve had around the Sun newspaper she never asked for. Its been volunteered by
t ^
aware of?
,D^
DW^
dt^
^

ibid

^d
D,:

W
t^
W

W

Wibid

Wibid
E/

/

2.30 DWDW^
,
DW^
DW^
D W

DW^DWDW^
,

,/
some people may not be convinced by the current arrangements and it may

/^
integrity, nor the head of the MSC
2.31 dDW

DW^DW
DW^,
WKD
Wt/
/
2.32 DWDW^
E/^DW^
DÊ/
,81
D W
E/
how it might be in the interests of Rupert Murdoch or News Corp and in the interests
DW
2.33 DWDWÊ/
/
DWÊ'YDW
DW^
82D'
Wibid
Wibid

Wibid

Wibid
E
K
/WDW

DW
,/W
2.34 D W
DW^
D^^DÊ/
84

d
DÊ//

2.35 D^
K
K
Kt
Kd
2.36 //
/
>'
t&/
K
DW
D^DW^

2.37 dDÊ/

/
EE//
EE/D^
2.38 //DW
/
E/DW^&
/

DW^
Wibid
^
^t^
^

^
dD,:
2.39 DW^D^/

D^/

&D^
2.40 KDDÊ/
d d d ^ d d ^ Z D
E/dd
d^d
no evidence of illegal conduct other than a single incident reported months ago.
d d
2.41 E
d ^ E D^ DW^
d^88
the MSC would say the result of the review was the material that they had disclosed
to us, but we havent received or -- I understand there is no formal report as a result
of their review.
E/
D^/

2.42 /D^
E/d
d'

E/89d/D^
dDKE//K

it is appropriate that compliance within NI be strengthened immediately. I have
therefore not waited for the output of the reviews... I have implemented, or am in the

2.43 &DÊ/h<
E&'Z&^D

^d
D,:

E/'>Z&^:

t^d
D
E
E/^
DÊ/d
:91/
E/'>Z&^:
Published by TSO (The Stationery Office) and available from:

Online
www.tsoshop.co.uk
Mail, Telephone, Fax & E-mail
TSO
PO Box 29, Norwich, NR3 1GN
Telephone orders/General enquiries: 0870 600 5522
Order through the Parliamentary Hotline Lo-Call 0845 7 023474
Fax orders: 0870 600 5533
E-mail: customer.services@tso.co.uk
Textphone: 0870 240 3701
The Houses of Parliament Shop
12 Bridge Street, Parliament Square
London SW1A 2JX
Telephone orders: 020 7219 3890/General enquiries: 020 7219 3890
Fax orders: 020 7219 3866
Email: shop@parliament.uk
Internet: http://www.shop.parliament.uk
TSO@Blackwell and other Accredited Agents

Leveson Report

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Leveson Report

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

The

AN INQUIRY INTO THE CULTURE,

The Right Honourable Lord Justice Leveson

AN INQUIRY INTO THE CULTURE,

Presented to Parliament pursuant to Section 26 of the Inquiries Act 2005

London: The Stationery Office

Crown copyright 2012

Printed on paper containing 75% recycled fibre content minimum.

PART A: THE INQUIRY

Chapter 1: The Announcement

Chapter 2: The approach

Chapter 3: Further issues of law

Chapter 4: The Report

PART B: THE PRESS AND THE PUBLIC INTEREST

The Leveson Inquiry

PART C: THE PRESS

PART E: CROSSING LEGAL BOUNDARIES:

The Leveson Inquiry

Chapter 5: Some case studies

The Leveson Inquiry

Chapter 4: The ICO and the press today

PART I: THE PRESS AND POLITICIANS

Chapter 5: Media policy: examples from recent history

The Leveson Inquiry

Chapter 9: Plurality and media ownership: conclusions

PART K: REGULATORY MODELS FOR THE FUTURE

The Leveson Inquiry

PART L: SUMMARY OF RECOMMENDATIONS

HC Hansard, 13 July 2011, vol 531, col 311-312

PART A | The Inquiry

HC Hansard, 20 July 2011, vol 531, col 919

Chapter 1 | The Announcement

PART A | The Inquiry

2. Role of the Assessors

Chapter 1 | The Announcement

PART A | The Inquiry

Chapter 1 | The Announcement

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

3 On the other hand,

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

PART A | The Inquiry

/R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Simms

Chapter 2 | The Freedom of the Press and Democracy

PART B | The Press and the Public Interest

2. A brief history of press freedom in the United

Chapter 2 | The Freedom of the Press and Democracy

PART B | The Press and the Public Interest

/R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Simms