Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MaintenanceLevel Description
1 Shoviece IaciIily
2 Comrehensive Slevardshi
3 Managed Care
4 Reaclive Mainlenance
5 Crisis Resonse
Formostfacilities,theminimumacceptablemaintenancelevelcorresponds
toAPPAsLevel2(ComprehensiveStewardship). AIIA dehnes lhis IeveI of
mainlenance as foIIovs:
Mainlenance aclivilies aear organized vilh direclion. Lqui-
menl and buiIding comonenls are usuaIIy funclionaI and in oeraling
condilion. Service and mainlenance caIIs are resonded lo in a limeIy
manner. uiIdings and equimenl are reguIarIy ugraded, keeing lhem
currenl vilh modern slandards and usage.
bviousIy, lhis IeveI of mainlenance recognizes lhal each faciIily is
an assel lhal musl be mainlained in order lo achieve maximum relurn on
inveslmenl. This text, then, is based on providing APPAs Level 2 main-
tenance for all facilities.
Ior mainlenance slafhng and budgeling uroses, faciIilies can be
divided inlo calegories based on lheir comIexily:
Tye 1 faciIilies incIude K-12 schooIs, ofhce buiIdings, relaiI buiId-
ings, holeIs, nursing homes, medicaI cIinics, elc. lhal are generaIIy reIa-
6 Effective Building Maintenance
liveIy basic buiIdings designed for a reIaliveIy shorl lo medium Iife (3O
years or Iess). Sland-aIone buiIdings in lhis calegory generaIIy viII make
use of conlracled mainlenance services. Hovever, if considered in aggre-
galea schooI syslem, a chain of slores, a muIli-buiIding ofhce camus
lhe need for an in-house mainlenance slaff viII normaIIy arise, even
lhough some mainlenance needs may sliII be mel on a conlracl basis.
Tye 2 faciIilies incIude inslilulionaI faciIilies (such as higher edu-
calion cIassroom and adminislralive buiIdings, governmenl ofhces, elc.)
and basic induslriaI buiIdings. These buiIdings are designed for Ionger
Iife (4O-5O years), have more comIex syslems and comonenls, and re-
resenl higher assel vaIue lo lhe user.
Tye 3 faciIilies incIude hosilaIs, research Iaboralories, dala cen-
lers, and high lechnoIogy manufacluring. These buiIdings have very
comIex syslems and comonenls and require much higher IeveIs of reIi-
abiIily lhan eilher Tye 1 or Tye 2 faciIilies.
Generally, only an in-house maintenance program will provide the level
of programmed maintenance typically required for larger, and especially more
complex,facilities. Hovever, even for Iarger faciIilies, seciaI area mainle-
nance may be rovided by oulside conlraclors for eIevalors, hre srinkIer
syslems, Iaboralory fume hoods, securily syslems, HVAC conlroIs, elc.
simIy because onIy lhe very Iargesl faciIilies can afford mainlain fuII-
lime seciaIisl mainlenance lechnicians lo meel lhe mainlenance require-
menls of lhese comonenls. This aroach can be incororaled inlo any
mainlenance dearlmenl organizalion and slafhng Ian.
To achieve AIIA LeveI 2 mainlenance, aroriale budgeling and
funding for mainlenance musl be eslabIished. There are lvo aroaches
lo lhis:
1. The NalionaI Research CounciI (NRC) sludied lhe mainlenance of
IederaI faciIilies in lhe Iale 199Os (lhe resuIls of vhich vere ub-
Iished in 1998 as Stewardship of Federal Facilities). This sludy found
lhal for an accelabIe IeveI of mainlenance, lhe revenlalive main-
lenance budgel vas 2-4/ of lhe faciIilys currenl reIacemenl cosl.
This amounl does nol incIude lhe cosls of erforming mainlenance
deferred from rior years.
Ior smaIIer faciIilies vilh Iimiled Ianning and budgeling re-
Facilities as Assets 7
sources, use of lhe NRC aroach for mainlenance budgeling may
be an good iniliaI aroach and lhe recommended IeveI of mainle-
nance can be execled lo require annuaI funding of 3.5-4/ of cur-
renl reIacemenl cosl.
2. A beller aroach is lo use zero-based budgeling vhereby lhe
acluaI annuaI cosls of each required mainlenance eIemenl are de-
lermined. This aroach has lhe benehl of dehning nol onIy cosls,
bul il rovides exceIIenl guidance as lo lhe slafhng needs for imIe-
menling lhese rocedures.
There are numerous annuaI surveys of mainlenance exendilures
by faciIilies ubIished by Whileslone, uiIding vners and Managers
Associalion (MA), AIIA, elc. lhal dehne vhal lhe olher guys are
doing. WhiIe inleresling, lhese dala are for aII raclicaI uroses
vorlhIess since lhere are no corresonding dala as lo lhe effecliveness of
lhese exendilures. (Hovever, lhey may rovide some basis for |uslifying
mainlenance budgels lo uer managemenl!)
STAIIING THL MAINTLNANCL DLIARTMLNT
Wilh lhe excelion of lhe AIIA ubIicalion discussed above (and
some individuaI slale recommendalions for K-12 schooIs), lhere are no
generaI mainlenance slafhng slandards in Iace in lhe Iniled Slales. To
dehne slafhng needs, each faciIily, lhe comonenls of lhal faciIily, and re-
quired comonenl mainlenance rocedures musl be carefuIIy evaIualed.
Any mainlenance dearlmenl (and nole lhal ve are excIuding cus-
lodiaI and grounds services from lhis discussion) can be organized gener-
aIIy aIong lhe slafhng IeveIs shovn in TabIe 1-2.
asic |ob descrilions for each of lhese slaff osilions are rovided
al lhe end of lhis chaler.
The number of each lye of slaff member required al any faciIily
viII vary based on lhe size and comIexily of lhe faciIily and lhe IeveI
of conlracled mainlenance services uliIized by lhe faciIily. The reIalion-
shi belveen lhe size (gross area) of a faciIily and lhe lyes of buiIdings
and olher eIemenls (comIexily) making u lhe faciIily viII delermine
lhe hnaI mix of lyes and number of slaff osilions. ul, in generaI, lhe
foIIoving guideIines can be aIied:
8 Effective Building Maintenance
1. Lvery mainlenance dearlmenl musl have a manager. Since lhe
maximum number of eoIe lhal can be effecliveIy managed by one
individuaI is 1O, assislanl mainlenance managers and1or crafl su-
ervisors musl be added as lhe size of lhe dearlmenl increases.
2. Assislanl mainlenance managers are required vhen lhe dearlmenl
musl be organized on a funclionaI basis. Ior examIe, on assislanl
manager may be resonsibIe for mainlenance Ianning, anolher for
mainlenance rocedures, a lhird for slaff deveIomenl and lraining,
elc. TyicaIIy, onIy lhe Iarger faciIilies require assislanl managers.
Table 1-2
Facilities as Assets 9
3. A crafl suervisor is lyicaIIy required vhen lhe number of lechni-
cians in a given crafl area exceeds 5-6. (nce lhere are more lhan 3
lechnicians in a crafl area, one LeveI III lechnician may be aoinled
foreman.)
4. The foIIoving labIe reecls lhe slafhng IeveI for crafl lechnicians
lhal is lyicaIIy required er 1OO,OOO gsf of each lye of faciIily.
Hovever, lhese IeveIs may be increased or decreased due lo many
faclors, incIuding slaff quaIihcalions and roduclivily, lhe quaIily of
lhe faciIily conslruclion, revious deferred or avoided mainlenance,
elc.
Table 1-3. Typical Maintenance Staffng Levels
Craft Supervisor
Second or lhird lier managemenl IeveI in a mainlenance dearlmenl,
resonsibIe for direcling and suervising lhe daiIy oeralions1aclivilies
of lechnicians vilh a secihc crafl area (generaI faciIily, HVAC, IIumbing,
or LIeclricaI). IIans, suervises, direcls and revievs lhe vork of skiIIed
and semi-skiIIed and suorl slaff erforming |ourney-IeveI inslaIIalion,
reair, and mainlenance.
Facilities as Assets 23
Minimum GeneraI asic skiII vilh hand looIs and over looIs normaIIy
SkiII Sel uliIized in a secihc crafl area.
KnovIedge of conslruclion drafling and abiIily lo read
and undersland bIuerinls.
Working knovIedge of vorkIace safely ruIes and
rocedures.
Crafl SkiII Sel AIy carenlry lechniques and using carenlry looIs lo
conslrucl, aIler, reair, and1or inslaII vaIIs, slairs, oors,
ceiIing, vindovs, doors, roofs, gullers, Iock, elc.
Ierform slrucluraI reair, aIleralions, or imrovemenl
vork such as rearing surfaces for Iasler or cemenl
vork, sludding, and Iaslering vaIIs.
InslaII gIass in doors and vindovs.
Facilities as Assets 25
HVAC Technician Level I
Lnlry or arenlice IeveI mainlenance vorker vho erforms onIy
under lhe direcl and conlinuous suervision of a higher IeveI lechnician.
Minimum GeneraI asic skiII vilh hand looIs and over looIs normaIIy
SkiII Sel uliIized in a secihc crafl area.
asic knovIedge of sho malh, mechanicaI draving,
aIied hysics and chemislry, eIeclronics, bIuerinl
reading, and comuler aIicalions.
Some knovIedge of Iumbing and eIeclricaI vork aIso is
heIfuI.
A basic underslanding of eIeclronics is required
Working knovIedge of vorkIace safely ruIes and
rocedures.
Facilities as Assets 27
HVAC Technician Level III
SkiIIed or |ourneyman IeveI mainlenance vorker.
Crafl SkiII Sel Reviev bIuerinls and buiIding codes and secihcalions
lo delermine vork delaiIs and rocedures.
Sludy buiIding Ians and insecl slruclures lo assess
maleriaI and equimenl needs, lo eslabIish lhe sequence
of ie inslaIIalions, and lo Ian inslaIIalion around
obslruclions such as eIeclricaI viring.
Facilities as Assets 29
AssembIe ie seclions, lubing and hllings, using
couIings, cIams, screvs, boIls, cemenl, Iaslic soIvenl,
cauIking, or soIdering, brazing and veIding equimenl.
IiII ies or Iumbing hxlures vilh valer or air and
observe ressure gauges lo delecl and Iocale Ieaks.
Locale and mark lhe osilion of ie inslaIIalions,
conneclions, assage hoIes, and hxlures in slruclures,
using measuring inslrumenls such as ruIers and IeveIs.
Measure, cul, lhread, and bend ie lo required angIe,
using hand and over looIs or machines such as ie
cullers, ie-lhreading machines, and ie-bending
machines.
Tesl, reair, and reIace Iumbing hxlures, ums,
lanks, elc.
InslaII ie assembIies, hllings, vaIves, aIiances such
as dishvashers and valer healers, and hxlures such as
sinks and loiIels, using hand and over looIs.
SkiII Sel
CaabIe of erformance of basic revenlalive
mainlenance rocedures vilhin one or more crafl areas
vilh no suervision.
CaabIe of erforming inseclion, anaIysis, and
evaIualion of faciIily comonenls vilhin one or more
crafl areas.
CaabIe of direcling and suervising LeveI I and II
lechnicians.
Minimum GeneraI asic skiII vilh hand looIs and over looIs normaIIy
SkiII Sel uliIized in a secihc crafl area.
KnovIedge of conslruclion drafling and abiIily lo read
and undersland bIuerinls.
Working knovIedge of crafl and vorkIace safely ruIes
and rocedures, arlicuIarIy NIIA Standard70E.
Crafl SkiII Sel AIy ainls, varnish, and1or slains lo aII lyes of
surfaces (e.g. vood, melaI, Iasler, elc.) In order lo
rolecl and beaulify such surfaces using aroriale
ulensiIs and equimenl such as ainl sraying
machines.
Ireare surfaces for ainling using aroriale looIs,
equimenl, and lechniques.
SeIecl lhe lyes and coIors of ainls, varnish or slain
and mixes, bIends and reares lhe same for roer
coIor malch.
Ireare surfaces for Iasler or cemenl vork by laing
|oinls on sheelrock, cauIking and valerroohng vaIIs
and cracks in oors, elc. by using aroriale looIs and
equimenl.
Ierforms reIaled dulies such as removing and reIacing
gIass, driIIing hoIes in signs, rinling Iellers and signs,
and moving ofhce furnilure.
ased on assignmenl, may oerale road-Iine ainling
machines and sand bIasling equimenl.
Facilities as Assets 35
Minimum 6 or more years vorking in conslruclion or buiIding
Lxerience mainlenance.
Locksmith
Crafl SkiII Sel InslaII Iock devices in doors, desks, ofhce equimenl
and olher unils.
Reair and1or overhauI Iocking devices such as morlise,
rim, key-in-lhe knob Iocks, dead boIl, ofhce equimenl,
adIocks and emergency exil Iocks by reairing for
reIacing vorn lumbIers, srings or olher arls of
Iocking devices, by making aIleralions lo Iocking
mechanisms and unils, and1or by reIacing esculcheons
and face Iales on doors lo change lhe size of exisling
hoIes.
InslaII Iocks conlaining duaI Iocking caabiIilies
by revorking Iocking devices designed lo vork in
con|unclion vilh olher comonenls and equimenl lo
form a comIele securily of surveiIIance syslems.
Changes Iock combinalion by inserling nev or reaired
lumbIers inlo Iocks in order.
Masonry/Tile Technician
Crafl SkiII Sel Lay brick, slone, and CMI and olher masonry unils
using a variely of hand and over looIs such as brick
or naing hammer, brick or shiII sav, ick, chiseI
and hammer lo buiId, aIler, reair and1or mainlain
brick and1or concrele surfaces and slruclures such as
sidevaIks, arlilions, oors, chimneys, elc.
Reair or inslaII ceramic lime, slone, or brick ooring.
Ierform reIaled dulies such as cauIking and
valerroohng cracks in masonry vaIIs and oors and
coring hoIes lhrough concrele or masonry vaIIs or
oors.
Crafl SkiII Sel Mainlain, reair, and reIace aII lyes of roohng
maleriaIs using looIs and equimenl of lhe lrade.
Reairs Ieaks in melaI roof, vaIIs, and ceiIings by
soIdering, criming, riveling, and veIding seams in
sheel melaI and inslaIIing ashing and valerroof feIl
using aroriale hand and over looIs lo reduce valer
damage and reslore valer-lighl inlegrily.
Iabricale misceIIaneous melaI arls such as gaveI
guards, gullers, souls, ies, by culling, driIIing,
laing and soIdering melaI lo meel roohng
requiremenls.
Crafl SkiII Sel Working knovIedge and signihcanl exerience vilh one
or more seciaI eIeclricaI syslems, incIuding hre aIarm,
securily, communicalions, informalion lechnoIogy, elc.
41
Chapter 2
Planned Replacement or
Major Renovation
Theconceptofentropyisthatnaturetendsfromordertodisorderin
isolatedsystemstherefore,componentfailureisinevitable.
IILDING CMINLNT LIIL
Lvery buiIding is assembIed from a greal many individuaI com-
onenlsmaleriaIs, syslems, sub-syslems, devices, equimenl, elc. ul,
every one of lhese buiIding comonenls viII uIlimaleIy faiI and musl be
reIaced or renovaled vhen il does. HisloricaIIy, lhe Iife-cycIe of buiIding
comonenls has been reresenled by lhe balhlub curve of Iigure 2-1.
Hovever, lhe balhlub curve does nol dehne lhe oinl al vhich
normaI aging faiIures hnaIIy require lhal lhe comonenl be reIaced or
renovaled.
Maximum erformance Iife of a buiIding comonenl is lhe lime
over vhich lhe comonenl serves ils anlicialed funclion over lhe range
from 1OO/ (vhen inslaIIed or iniliaIIy Iaced in service) lo O/ (vhen
il faiIs and lhe onIy olion is lo reIace il). Hovever, once lhe IeveI of
erformance faIIs beIov some minimum (|usl hov many roof Ieaks are
accelabIe`) and lhe cosl of conlinuing lo mainlain a faiIing comonenl
lhrealens lo exceed lhe cosl of reIacemenl, lhen lhe comonenl has
reached lhe end of ils design service Iife (oflen referred lo as ils eco-
nomic Iife).
Iigure 2-2, an enhancemenl of lhe balhlub curve, ignores infanl
morlaIily faiIures associaled vilh nev conslruclion and shovs a more
dehnilive reIalionshi belveen comonenl erformance and lime. ver
any comonenls erformance Iife, funclion degrades sIovIy, even vilh
adequale mainlenance, unliI a liing oinl is reached vhere funclion
begins lo degrade al an acceIeraling rale unliI faiIure occurs.
42 Effective Building Maintenance
The cosl of mainlenance foIIovs an inverse reIalionshi, as shovn
in Iigure 2-3. WhiIe rouline and revenlalive mainlenance is a reIaliveIy
smaII (bul conslanl) requiremenl from day one, as lhe liing oinl is a-
roached, mainlenance robIems and cosls begin lo acceIerale dramali-
caIIy unliI hnaI faiIure occurs and conlinued use and mainlenance of lhe
comonenl is no Ionger an olion.
However,ifreplacementisdelayeduntilfnalfailureoccurs,thetotalcost
of maintenance will inevitably exceed the cost of replacement that would have
beenincurredasthetippingpointwasreachedattheendofthedesignservicelife.
Design service Iife does nol imIy lhal lhere is no erformance Iife Iefl in
lhe comonenl, bul il does imIy lhal lhe cosl of oblaining lhal remaining
erformance viII exceed lhe cosl of reIacemenl al lhal oinl.
The besl currenl eslimales for lhe reference or median service
Iife of buiIding comonenls are resenled in Component Life Manual,
Housing Associalion Iroerly MuluaI Lld. (HAIM), London, IK
(IubIished by L. & I.N. Son, Andover, Hanls, IK.), 1999. Hovever,
lhe dala conlained in lhis ubIicalion are generaIIy Iimiled lo maleriaIs
commonIy aIied lo housing and Iighl commerciaI conslruclion in lhe
Iniled Kingdom and are somevhal incomIele vhen comared lo con-
Figure 2-1. Component Failure as a Function of Time (Source: NASA)
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 43
Figure 2-2. Component Performance as a Function of Time
Figure 2-3. Maintenance/Replacement Cost as a Function of Time
44 Effective Building Maintenance
slruclion maleriaIs and melhods used in lhe Iniled Slales. lher dala
are avaiIabIe from various rofessionaI organizalions and some com-
merciaI hrms (Whilehead, Means, elc.), bul aImosl aII of lhese dala are
anecdolaI in origin, nol based on any reaI scienlihc sludy.
TabIe 2-1 is a masler Iisl of buiIding comonenls lyicaIIy found
in commerciaI and inslilulionaI faciIilies. Thislistisnotall-inclusiveand,
overtime,shouldbemodifedbyeachuserbasedonexperiencewithotherma-
terials,equipment,andsystems. The comonenls are Iisled in accordance
vilh ASTM Slandard L1557, Iniformal II, vhich dehnes a slandard
cIassihcalion for buiIding comonenls and reIaled sile vork. TabIe 2-1
rovides reference economic or service Iife vaIues based on evaIualion
of lhe dala from numerous sources (eseciaIIy lhe HAIM) and lhese
vaIues are based on lhe buiIding and ils comonenls being mainlained
lo al Ieasl a slevardshi IeveI.
Some condilions lhal can reduce lhe reference service Iife have
been idenlihed and are Iisled in TabIe 2-1 as service Iife issues, as foI-
Iovs:
2.1 Reduce lo 1O years if lrealed vood is nol used for exosed or dam
Iocalions, incIuding mud siIIs, vaII bollom Iales on concrele
sIabs, lhe hrsl rov of exlerior shealhing, elc.
2.2 AcryIic cauIking is average (8-12 years). ulyI and bilumen rubber
cauIks have a Iife of 5 years. IoIysuIhide and oIyurelhane have
an execled Iife of 15-2O years. acker rods shouId be reIaced
vilh recauIking. Sublracl 5 years for second and subsequenl cauIk-
ing aIicalions.
2.3 Reduce lo 5 years for dark coIors facing soulh or soulhvesl.
2.4 Reduce Iife by 5O/ if sIoe exceeds 3112.
2.5 Slorms and hurricanes can damage roof coverings enough lo sig-
nihcanlIy shorlen lheir Iife. Sublracl 2 years for each year vilh
above average slorm aclivily.
3.1 Sublracl 3 years for use in corridors or olher high lrafhc areas. Sub-
lracl 5 years if vilhin 2O feel of exlerior door.
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 45
3.2 High humidily IeveIs, roof Ieaks, or olher moislure evenls viII re-
quire ceiIing reIacemenl.
3.3 VinyI vaII covering inslaIIed on an exlerior vaII lhal has no oul-
board vaor relarder can creale a moId infeslalion condilion, re-
quiring immediale removaI of lhe vaII covering.
3.4 Lxcess buiIding movemenl due lo lhermaI exansion1conlraclion,
vind, or differenliaI sellIemenl can cause seaIanls lo searale, re-
quiring immediale reIacemenl.
3.5 IhysicaI damage by carls, cIeaning oeralions, elc. can reduce Iife
by as much as 5O/.
4.1 Reduce Iife by 4O/ for ouldoor aIicalion. uldoor inslaIIalion
requires a second, vealherroof covering lo rolecl lhe insuIalion.
4.2 In coaslaI areas, condenser hns and unil casing musl have eoxy or
henoIic coaling lo rolecl aIuminum from raid oxidalion. Wilh-
oul lhis coaling, Iife is reduced by 7O/.
4.3 IIumbing hxlures in middIe schooIs suffer grealer vandaIism. Re-
duce Iife by 2O/ in middIe schooIs.
6.1 Reduce Iife by 3 years each lime lhe cIassroom is reIocaled.
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life
46 Effective Building Maintenance
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 47
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
48 Effective Building Maintenance
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 49
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
50 Effective Building Maintenance
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 51
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
52 Effective Building Maintenance
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 53
Table 2-1. Typical Component Service Life (Continued)
IINDLD DLIRLCIATIN AND IDGLTING
IR RLILACLMLNT1RLNVATIN
IIanned reIacemenl or renovalion of a buiIding comonenl
vhen il faiIs is a ma|or arl of any effeclive rogrammed mainlenance
efforl.
Ior many buiIding ovners, lhe aroach lo funding needed re-
Iacemenl or renovalion is lo budgel funds as cailaI inveslmenls lo
address lhe need, bul onIy afler lhe need arises. The imacl of lhese
sudden, signihcanl cailaI needs on annuaI budgels is lyicaIIy so greal,
lhal onIy lhe mosl veII-heeIed ovner can make funds avaiIabIe vhen
needed. Mosl ovners alleml lo defer lhe cosl as Iong as ossibIe resuIl-
ing in deferred mainlenance and, uIlimaleIy, even grealer cosl (see Life
CycIe Cosl AnaIysis al ReIacemenl1Renovalion Time, beIov).
54 Effective Building Maintenance
Sohislicaled buiIding ovners incororale a funding Ian as arl
of Ianned reIacemenl or renovalion of buiIding comonenls. This
Ian, in accounling Ianguage, is referred lo as funded derecialion,
bul a more accurale lerm is reinveslmenl or recailaIizalion. Inder
lhis scheme, funds are sel aside each year, usuaIIy in safe, inleresl-
bearing accounls, so lhal vhen a comonenl reaches lhe end of ils
service Iife, lhe cailaI required for ils reIacemenl or renovalion is
aIready aIIocaled and avaiIabIe.
The hrsl sle in lhis rocess is lo eslabIish each comonenls service
Iife.
Ior iniliaI Ianning for reIacemenl1renovalion of comonenls in
exisling faciIilies, lhe referenced service Iife from TabIe 2-1 can be used as
lhe slarling oinl lo delermine lhe anlicialed remaining design service
Iife for each comonenl. Longer service Iife can generaIIy be oblained
from beller maleriaIs, designers having exercised beller quaIily conlroI,
beller conslruclion quaIily, and more comrehensive mainlenance. Like-
vise, oorer efforls in lhese areas, aIong vilh more severe environmenlaI
condilions, heavy vear-and-lear usage, and1or oor mainlenance viII
cerlainIy shorlen service Iife. vners musl ad|usl lhe service Iife used for
anaIysis for lhese various faclors.
Tvo lechnicaI slandards exisl lhal dehne melhodoIogies for evaIual-
ing lhe service Iife of buiIdings or buiIding comonenls:
IS Slandard 15686-1, Building and Construction Assets Service Life
Planning:GeneralPrinciples
Canadian Slandards Associalion (CSA) S478-95 (R2OO7), Guideline
onDurabilityinBuildings
olh slandards are based on lhe foIIoving aroach for dehning
faclors lhal inuence remaining design service Iife of buiIding como-
nenls:
RDSL = RSL A C D L I
Where
RDSL = eslimaled (or anlicialed) remaining design service Iife
RSL = reference service Iife rovided in TabIe 2-1
A = quaIily of maleriaIs faclor (oor, fair, good, beller, besl)
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 55
= design quaIily conlroI faclor (oor, fair, good, beller, besl)
C = conslruclion quaIily conlroI faclor (oor, fair, good, beller,
besl)
D = environmenlaI condilions faclor (non-lyicaI environmen-
laI condilions such as a harsh coaslaI cIimale or one vilh
Iong coId vinlers, soIar radialion, hol-humid cIimales, ur-
ban environmenls, oIIulanls, elc.)
L = in-use condilions faclor (high IeveI of vear-and-lear, such
as K12 schooIs, buiIding ubIic areas, and arking areas or
abuse, such as correclionaI faciIilies)
I = mainlenance IeveI faclor
Lach of faclors A lhrough I musl be evaIualed and an iniliaI vaIue
belveen O.8 and 1.2 assigned lo each.
As part of the preventative maintenance program detailed in Chapter 3,
each building component must be inspected and evaluated on a periodic, rou-
tinebasis. ased on lhese evaIualions, lhe RDSL for each comonenl musl
lhen be ad|usled, al Ieasl annuaIIy. (Nole lhal lhe RDSL can be a negalive
number if needed reIacemenl or ma|or renovalion has been osloned
or deferred.)
This rocess, lhen, is a syslemalic aroach lo ansvering lhe reair
or reIace queslion for aging buiIding comonenls. During lhis rocess,
lhe ansvers lo lhe foIIoving queslions are being delermined:
1. Whal is lhe age of lhe comonenl reIalive lo ils design service Iife`
If lhe age is veII vilhin lhe design service Iife, lhen lhe lendency
vouId be lo consider reair. If lhe RDSL is Iov, lhen lhe lendency
vouId be lo reIace.
2. Whal is lhe currenl condilion indicaled by condilion araisaIs
made during revenlalive mainlenance rocedures` Look al
condilion lrendscondilion degradalion and increased reairs may
indicale lhal reIacemenl lime has come.
3. Are sare arls sliII avaiIabIe` In areas of raid lechnoIogicaI
change, such as buiIding DDC syslems, hre aIarm syslems, elc.,
reair is nol feasibIe if sare arls are nol avaiIabIe. This may diclale
reIacemenl even vhen lhe condilion of lhe comonenl is sliII good.
56 Effective Building Maintenance
4. WouId reIacemenl reduce mainlenance cosls, reduce energy cosls,
and1or reduce valer cosls lo an exlenl lhal an accelabIe ayback
eriod can be achieved` If so, lhe cosl of reIacemenl may be |uslihed.
The besl aroach lo budgeling for reIacemenl1renovalion main-
lenance is lo aIy lhe concel of fundeddepreciation lo each buiIding com-
onenl. This concel is oflen caIIed re-cailaIizalion or reinveslmenl
(lhough ils knovn hisloricaIIy as a sinking fund) and il requires buiId-
ing ovners lo sel aside funds each year, usuaIIy Iaced in an inleresl-
bearing inveslmenl, lhal viII be avaiIabIe in lhe fulure lo ay lo lhe cosl
of ma|or reIacemenl or renovalion of a buiIding comonenl vhen lhal
comonenl reaches lhe end of ils RDSL. This aroach, adoled by many
induslriaI hrms and even some slale governmenls (such as Minnesola),
uIlimaleIy eIiminales lhe need for borroved funds (Ioans or bonds) and
corresonding debl service obIigalions. And, as shovn by lhe foIIoving
discussion, thisconcepteliminatesdeferredmaintenanceandlowersthecostsof
replacement/renovationmaintenance.
Ising lhis concel, lhe currenl cosl of reIacemenl or renovalion of
each comonenl, y, is delermined, aIong vilh an eslimale of ils RDSL. Di-
viding lhe reIacemenl1renovalion cosl by lhe number of years of RDSL
yieIds lhe budgel amounl lhal musl be aIIocaled each year belveen nov
and lhe lime of lhe reIacemenl1renovalion.
Iulure reIacemenl or renovalions cosls viII be higher lhan currenl
cosls due lo inalion and, lhus, a cost escalation factor (CEF) musl be in-
cororaled inlo lhe caIcuIalion. Inalion has a signihcanl affecl on fulure
cosls and under eslimaling lhe imacl of inalion is lhe kiss of dealh
for adequale funded derecialion.
Conslruclion cosl inalion is aImosl aIvays grealer lhan lhe generaI
inalion rale, as iIIuslraled by lhe dala in TabIe 2-2 comaring generaI in-
alion and conslruclion cosl inalion rale in lhe Iniled Slales over each
decade since 197O.
Thus, it is good planning to assume that construction cost infation will
be 30-50% higher than the general infation rate, a condition that has existed
forthelast(almost)40years. lhervise, lhe funds avaiIabIe al lhe end of
lhe comonenls service Iife lo ay for reIacemenl1renovalion couId be
voefuIIy inadequale.
Ior schooI boards and counly commissioners, lhe slicker shock
associaled vilh needed reIacemenls or renovalions is a key cause of de-
ferred mainlenancea roof reIacemenl lhal vouId cosl $1,OOO,OOO loday
Planned Replacement or Major Renovation 57
viII cosl $2,OOO,OOO+ in 14 years (vhen lhe need for reIacemenl arrives)
vilh a 5/ conslruclion cosl inalion rale!
Since annuaI budgeled funds are nol senl unliI lhe end of lhe com-
onenls service Iife, lhese funds can be Iaced in inleresl-bearing invesl-
menls and, lhus, an inleresl rale faclor (IRI) musl be incororaled inlo
lhe caIcuIalion. Thus, lhe annuaI budgeled funding, x, required lo yieId
lhe required funds for lhe reIacemenl or renovalion of a comonenl al
lhe end some n years in lhe fulure, lhe RDSL, can be delermined by lhe
foIIoving reIalionshi:
x = y (1+CLI)
n
1(1+IRI) |(1+IRI)
n
- 1j1n
Ising lhis equalion, lhe annuaI budgeled amounl required for a
roof reIacemenl having a currenl cosl of $1OO,OOO and a remaining ser-
vice Iife of eighl years is comuled as foIIovs:
Variable Value
y = $1OO,OOO
n = 8 (years)
CLI = O.O9 (9/ annuaI cosl escaIalion)
IRI = O.O5 (5/ inveslmenl inleresl rale)
Avg.Annual Avg.Annual
GeneralInfation ConstructionCost
Decade Rate(%) InfationRate(%)*
65
Chapter 3
Preventative Maintenance
Theallocationofadequateresourcestomaintenance
isrequiredforthemaintenancetobeeffective.
ASIC RLQIIRLMLNTS IR
GLNLRAL CNSTRICTIN MAINTLNANCL
The requiremenls for eslabIishing a generaI conslruclion mainle-
nance rogram vary videIy based on lhe size and comIexily of lhe faciI-
ily. Hovever, lhe foIIoving basic eIemenls are common lo aII faciIilies:
Have a vorking knovIedge of generaI conslruclion maleriaIs,
means, and melhods.
blain lhe originaI design dala (as buiIl dravings and secihca-
lions). This is lhe informalion lhal dehnes buiIding comonenls and
delaiIs of conslruclion.
blain &M manuaIs rovided by conlraclor(s), incIuding origi-
naI vendor submillaIs. These manuaIs shouId rovide basic mainle-
nance requiremenls for seciaI buiIding comonenls.
ASIC RLQIIRLMLNTS IR SLRVICL SYSTLMS MAINTLNANCL
Plumbing
The requiremenls for eslabIishing a Iumbing mainlenance and sys-
lems lroubIeshooling rogram are reIaliveIy simIe:
Indersland Iumbing basic rinciIes and erformance require-
menls for each Iumbing syslem and ils individuaI eIemenls
ums, iing, heal exchangers, hxlures, brass, elc.
66 Effective Building Maintenance
blain lhe originaI design dala (as buiIl dravings and secihca-
lions). This is lhe informalion lhal dehnes Iumbing syslems and
comonenl erformance requiremenls.
blain &M manuaIs rovided by conlraclor(s), incIuding origi-
naI vendor submillaIs on each iece of equimenl (eseciaIIy um
curves) and hxlure. These manuaIs shouId rovide lhe basic main-
lenance requiremenls for Iumbing syslem comonenls.
DeveIo and aIy rouline mainlenance and lroubIeshooling check-
Iisls and rocedures, incIuding erformance lesls. These revenla-
live mainlenance measures kee lhe syslems and comonenls o-
eraling roerIy, reduce energy and valer vasle, and mainlain lheir
design service Iife.
If lhe Iumbing syslems are exlensive, eslabIish sare arls slorage
for comonenls lhal have more frequenl faiIure.
Heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning (HVAC)
The requiremenls for eslabIishing an HVAC mainlenance and sys-
lems lroubIeshooling rogram are slraighl forvard:
Indersland HVAC basic rinciIes and erformance requiremenls
for each HVAC syslem and ils individuaI eIemenls.
blain lhe originaI design dala (as buiIl dravings and secihca-
lions). This is lhe informalion lhal dehnes HVAC syslems and com-
onenl erformance requiremenls.
blain &M manuaIs rovided by conlraclor(s), incIuding origi-
naI vendor submillaIs on each iece of equimenl (eseciaIIy fan
and um curves). These manuaIs shouId rovide lhe basic mainle-
nance requiremenls for HVAC syslem comonenls.
blain as buiIl conlroI dravings, incIuding vaIve and damer
scheduIes, lhal dehne lhe conlroI modes and Iogic for lhe HVAC
syslem. Wilhoul good documenlalion of lhe HVAC syslem conlroIs,
lhe oeralion of lhese syslems is based soIeIy on assumlions (vhich
may be vrong) and1or guesses (vhich may be equaIIy vrong).
Preventive Maintenance 67
blain minimum lesl inslrumenls, as Iisled beIov. Wilhoul lesl in-
slrumenls, il is imossibIe lo delermine vhal is acluaIIy haening
in each HVAC syslem. Wilhoul lhis informalion, reair or addilion-
aI mainlenance requiremenls cannol be idenlihed.
Table 3-1. Minimum Required HVAC Maintenance Instruments
QuantitytobeEvaluated Instrument(s)Required
QuantitytobeEvaluated Instrument(s)Required
Typical
Type TypicalCondensing Compressor
OfCondensing Temperature(F) kW/Ton
CombustionEffciency(%)atFlueGasTemperatureLess
Excess(%) CombustionAirTemperature(F)
AdditionalInsulationThickness(in.)
ExistingInsulation atFluidTemperature(F)
Thickness(in.) 200orless 201-350 351+
or Iess 1 1 2
1 1 1 2
1 1 1
2 1
NetWater
RatioofShortto Consumption
TypeofBuilding LongFlushes (GPF)
GPM/Ton %
Cycles Evaporation Blowdown Make-up Make-up
Illuminance
Category SpaceTypes (Footcandles)
Group 1 Tasks
A IubIic saces 3
Group 2 Tasks
Group 3 Tasks
To Max.NoiseLevelandDuration
Avoid
dBA Hrs
Annoyance 5O-55 16
Dislurbance of communicalion1Iack
of seech inleIIigibiIily 35 AII
SIee dislurbance 3O 8
Object MinimumDistance(ft)
*Laboralory fume hood exhausl air oulIels shaII be in comIiance vilh NIIA 45 and ANSI1
AIHA Z9.5.
**This dislance shouId be a greal as ossibIe lo reduce LegioneIIa conlaminalion olenliaI.
IiIlers are aIied in air-handIing syslems lo remove arlicuIale
conlaminanls and oIIulanls such as dusl, oIIen, moId, bacleria, smoke,
and elc. from lhe air. ASHRAL Slandard 52.2-2OO7 dehnes lhe melhod-
oIogy of raling and aIying hIlers in HVAC syslems by eslabIishing
minimum effciency ratingvalues (MERV) for hIlers and a lesl melhod for
delermining lhe MLRV. TabIe 4-1O summarizes lhe aIicalion guideIines
for each lye of hIler and eslabIishes a range of recommended MLRVs.
This labIe can be used lo seIecl air cIeaner erformance required for mosl
HVAC aIicalions.
LIeclroslalic hIlers, assive residenliaI grade hIlers, are ranked al
Special Maintenance Considerations 117
lhe Iov end of lhe MLRV scaIe, desile cIaims by lhe manufaclurers lhal
lhis lye of hIler is bolh effeclive and reIiabIe. The slandard recognizes
lhal lhese cIaims are, al besl, exaggeraled and lhe hIlers do nol erform
veII or reIiabIy in HVAC syslems.
Aclive eIeclroslalic or eIeclronic hIlers are very efhcienl, vilh
an MLRV of 12-15, when they are properly operated and maintained.
Table 4-10. Filter Application GuideIines
(Adaled from ASHRAL Slandard 52.2-2OO7)
118 Effective Building Maintenance
Hovever, lhe reguIar mainlenance required lo ensure roer hIler er-
formance is seIdom rovided. InlernaI hIler faiIures (eIeclricaI breaks,
elc.) and simIy arlicuIale Ioading on lhe allraclor Iales reduce hIler
erformance and, since lhere is no obvious indicalion of lhese faiIures,
oor erformance can occur over Iong eriods of lime. Therefore,unlessthe
ownerisawareofandcommittedtotherequiredmaintenance,thistypeofflter
shouldnotbeused.
ASHRAL Slandard 62.1-2OO7 requires a hIler MLRV of nol be Iess
lhan 6 (and lhal hIlers be inslaIIed uslream of lhe cooIing coiIs, vhich
conicls vilh lhe hnaI hIler requiremenls for some hosilaI and Iabora-
lory aIicalions). ul, in generaI, toreduceparticulatestoacceptablelevels,
analysis by Lawrence Berkley Laboratories, along with other studies indicates
thatflterswithanMERVof8-9aretheminimumrequired.Thissameanalysis
indicatesthat,forcomfortair-conditioningapplications,flterswithanMERV
greaterthan13provideonlyminorimprovementinindoorairqualityunlessthe
MERVisincreasedtoatleast16. Higher MLRV IeveIs may be required by
reguIalory bodies for seciaI aIicalions such as some hosilaI areas,
research faciIilies, cIean rooms, elc.
Since indoor air quaIily is deendenl on ouldoor air quaIily, lhe oul-
door air musl be cIean and accelabIe for diIulion venliIalion. Hov-
ever, in some Iocalions, during al Ieasl arl of lhe year (usuaIIy summer),
ambienl air condilions are seriousIy degraded by vehicIes, over Ianls,
and1or adverse almosheric ressure condilions. Ior induslriaI buiId-
ings, or buiIdings Iocaled in induslriaI areas, lhe ambienl ouldoor air may
be conlaminaled vilh arlicuIales and1or gaseous oIIulanls lhal musl
be removed by air hIlralion and cIeaning. This condilion can exisl even
oulside of induslriaI areas if buiIdings are Iocaled cIose lo vehicIe lraf-
hc, have Ioading docks, or even use combuslion engine overed Iavn
equimenlaII of vhich roduce a vide range of oIIulanls lhal can be
sucked in lhrough ouldoor air inlakes.
To remove exlernaIIy inlroduced VCs and olher oIIulanl gases or
vaors, gaseous hIlralion is required, vhich invoIves chemicaI reaclion
belveen lhe hIler media and lhe oIIulanl gas via sorption. Sorlion is
a rocess based on lhe eIeclron forces vilhin lhe oIIulanl moIecuIe be-
ing allracled by simiIar forces on lhe surface of hIler media beds. These
forces creale overfuI chemicaI bonds by vhich lhe oIIulanl moIecuIes
are allached lo lhe surface of lhe media, a rocess caIIed adsorlion. To
increase efhciency and caacily, lhe sorlion media viII be highIy orous,
roducing surface areas oflen raled in lhousands of square feel er ounce
Special Maintenance Considerations 119
of media.
Gaseous air cIeaning can aIso be accomIished by lhe rocess of
absorlion vhere lhe oIIulanl moIecuIes (aIong vilh valer vaor
moIecuIes) merge inlo lhe hIler media, simiIar lo Iiquid hase mixlures.
The absorlion rocess roduces ionizalion, enabIing chemicaI reaclion
lo occur. To enhance lhis rocess, sorbenls can be imregnaled vilh se-
cihc reagenls lo enhance lheir abiIily lo chemicaIIy reacl vilh secihc gas-
eous oIIulanls.
There are no universaI lesl melhods of raling and seIecling chemicaI
hIlers. Hovever, lhe foIIoving generaI guideIines can be aIied:
Carbon is besl aIied againsl conlaminanls lhal are higher in con-
cenlralion, heavier in moIecuIar veighl, and nonoIar and lhal have
a higher moIecuIar carbon conlenl. This incIudes mosl VCs and
Iong moIecuIar chain hydrocarbons. Il aIso vorks besl al Iover lem-
eralure and humidily condilions.
Potassium Permanganate (KMnO
4
) erforms besl againsl Iover
moIecuIar veighl comounds, oIar comounds such as formaIde-
hyde, and reaclive inorganic comounds such as hydrogen suIhde
and suIfur dioxide.
Zeolite is arlicuIarIy effeclive as a calion exchange media. This
makes il erform veII againsl conlaminanls such as ammonia and
olher nilrogen bearing comounds. Il aIso has a higher surface area
lhan aIumina comounds.
CO
2
and Odor Control
Dilutionventilation is a rocess by vhich some ercenlage of dirly
indoor air is conlinuousIy reIaced by cIean ouldoor air. When evaIual-
ing indoor air quaIily, lhe Iilmus lesl is hov cIose lo ouldoor ambienl air
slandards il comes.
LslabIishing crileria and melhods of conlroIIing minimum venliIa-
lion airov in HVAC syslems is becoming more and more comIex. In
Norlh CaroIina, lhere are numerous codes and1or slandards lhal aIy
lo eslabIishing and conlroIIing venliIalion rales:
ASHRAL Slandard 62.1-2OO7
ASHRAL1ILSNA Slandard 9O.1-2OO7
120 Effective Building Maintenance
Slale and LocaI uiIding Codes
ASTM Slandard D6245-98, Standard Guide for Using Indoor Carbon
DioxideConcentrationstoEvaluateIndoorAirQualityandVentilation
The venliIalion rales eslabIished in lhese slandards and codes are
based on normaI buiIding occuancy lhal conlain lhe secihed occuanl
densily and aclivilies lhal can normaIIy be execled lo lake Iace. When-
ever buiIding maleriaIs, cIeaning and mainlenance maleriaIs, or seciaI-
ized human aclivilies inlroduce Iarge quanlilies of secihc conlaminanls
inlo lhe buiIding almoshere, lhere may be occuanl comIainls and se-
ciaI venliIalion measures shouId be considered lo aIIeviale lhem.
Routinemaintenanceisrequiredtoensurethatproperlevelsofventilation
aremaintainedinthefacility.
MISTIRL INTRISIN AND MLD INILSTATIN
Inanybuilding,thekeytopreventingmoldinthebuildingboilsdownto
keepingwateroutandoperatingandmaintainingHVACsystemstodealwith
anywatervaporthatdoesmigrateinward. Il is u lo lhe ovner lo raidIy
resond lo and correcl any valer inlrusion robIem lhal may arise, in-
cIuding cIeaning and drying any buiIding maleriaIs lhal have become
vel (or reIacing lhem if lhey cannol be dried). Water-damaged materi-
alsmustbedriedorreplacedwithin24-48hourstopreventgerminationand
subsequentmoldgrowth! nce moId grovlh is eslabIished, mosl buiIding
conslruclion maleriaIs cannol be cIeaned and reIacemenl is lhe onIy
olion.
Irevenling moId grovlh in buiIdings is a rime examIe of lhe oId
adage lhal an ounce of revenlion is vorlh a ound of cure. Irevenling
moId from becoming a robIem is fairIy simIe and chea, vhiIe remedi-
aling a buiIding vhere moId has become eslabIished is bolh comIex and
exensive.
MoIds are fungi, vhich are singIe-ceIIed or muIli-ceIIed non-moliIe
organisms lhal cannol make lheir ovn food. They reIy on olher organ-
isms or lheir environmenls for nulrienls. They viII coIonize any carbon-
based maleriaI lhal suIies aroriale nulrienls and moislure.
In generaI, fungi acliveIy groving indoors can exisl as yeasls or
moIds. Yeasls are singIe-ceIIed organisms lhal reroduce by budding or
simIe milosis. MoIds are more comIex, deveIoing Iarge coIonies (mals
Special Maintenance Considerations 121
or baIIs) of muIli-ceIIuIar hIamenls caIIed hyae. Some hyae enelrale
lhe maleriaI lhal is being used for food, making removaI very difhcuIl.
lhers Iie on lhe surface and deveIo reroduclive slruclures vhen
lemeralure and moislure condilions are aroriale. Iungi are ubiqui-
lous, occurring in soiI, in and on Ianls and animaIs, and in lhe ambienl
air bolh indoors and ouldoors. Lven in buiIdings vilhoul aclive fungaI
grovlh, lolaI fungi sore concenlralions of 3,OOO-1O,OOO sores er cubic
meler of air are common.
In any buiIding, any Iocalion roviding high enough moislure con-
lenl and a olenliaI food source viII suorl fungi grovlh.
MoId viII grov on mosl surfaces if lhe reIalive humid ily al lhe sur-
face is above a crilicaI vaIue and lhe surface lemera lure is conducive lo
grovlh. The Ionger lhe reIalive humidily remains above lhe crilicaI vaIue,
lhe more IikeIy is visibIe moId grovlh, and lhe higher lhe humidily or
lemeralure, lhe shorler is lhe lime needed for germinalion. The surface
reIalive humidily is a comIex funclion of maleriaI moislure conlenl, ma-
leriaI roerlies, and IocaI lemeralure and humidily condilions. In addi-
lion, moId grovlh deends on lhe lye of surface.
IuIIy recognizing lhe com Iexily of lhe issue, lhe InlernalionaI Ln-
ergy Agency Annex 14 (199O) neverlheIess eslabIished a surface humidily
crilerion for design uroses: The monlhIy average surface reIalive hu-
midily shouId remain beIov 8O/. lhers have roosed more slringenl
crileria, lhe mosl slringenl requiring lhal surface reIalive humidily re-
main beIov 7O/ al alltimes. AIlhough lhere sliII is no agreemenl on vhich
Figure 4-3. Indoor Mold Infestation
122 Effective Building Maintenance
crilerion is mosl aroriale, moldmildewcanusuallybeavoidedbylimiting
surfacemoistureconditionsover80%toshorttimeperiodsand70%forlonger
periods (even though some molds will begin to grow at a relative humidity as
lowas60%). These crileria shouId onIy be reIaxed for nono rous surfaces
lhal are reguIarIy cIeaned. Mosl moIds grov al lemeralures above a-
roximaleIy 4OI. Moislure accumuIalion beIov 4OI may nol cause moId
and miIdev if lhe maleriaI is aIIoved lo dry beIov lhe crilicaI moislure
conlenl before lhe lemeralure rises above 4OI.
IolenliaI subslrales for moId grovlh incIude vood, aer, and lex-
liIes, vhich are common in buiIdings. Some moIds viII even grovn on
subslrales lhal rovide no nulrienls, such as sleeI or hbergIass, as Iong as
nulrienls and valer are resenl in lhe air or in dusl sellIing on lhe moIds.
The most important risk factor for mold growth indoors is excess liquid
waterinbuildingmaterialsduetowaterintrusionduringconstructionorwater
intrusion from rain and/or water leaks after the building is occupied. In hot,
humidclimates(whichincludesmostofthesoutheastUnitedStates),thesecond
mostimportantriskfactorishighhumidity,eitherintheairorinthesubstrate
materialduetoinfltrationofhumidoutdoorairandexacerbatedbyimproperly
designedoroperatedHVACsystems.
The besl vay lo revenl moId grovlh is lo revenl moislure inlru-
sion robIems and lhis rocess slarls vilh lhe roof.
Lvery faciIily musl deveIo and imIemenl an aggressive roof-
mainlenance rogram as oulIined in lhis lexl. This rogram vouId in-
cIude eriodic inseclion of every roof lo idenlify dehciencies. Il is besl
lo erform lhese inseclions in each sring and faII. Inseclions shouId
be erformed by individuaIs caabIe of delermining nol onIy aarenl
immediale robIems, bul aIso condilions lhal couId become robIems in
lhe fulure. The inseclions shouId concenlrale on high-risk areas such
as around roof halches, drains, mechanicaI equimenl, and high-lrafhc
areas. As arl of lhese inseclions, aIso incIude roof ashings and drains,
Iumbing venls, elc.
In addilion lo semi-annuaI inseclions, erform inseclions afler
severe slorms, reair or aIleralions lo rooflo equimenl, or re-roohng
ro|ecls in ad|acenl roof areas. Ierform reairs in a limeIy manner, once
inseclors have idenlihed dehciencies, a quaIihed roohng mechanic musl
make lhe reairs immedialeIy.
Aside from lhe roof, foundalions and vaIIs are oflen lhe source of
valer inlrusion robIems. Groundvaler can be kel oul a buiIding if lhe
surrounding grade roerIy sIoes avay from lhe vaII and adequale sile
Special Maintenance Considerations 123
drainage is rovided. Hovever, over lime, lhe residue from Ianlings,
ground cover (ine slrav, muIch, elc.), elc. can buiId u lo bIock lhe vee
hoIes lhal drain masonry vaIIs or even creale a reverse ov condilion so
lhal valer is lraed againsl lhe vaII (onding). The faciIily mainlenance
Ian musl incIude reguIar inseclion and correclive aclion, as needed,
lo revenl lhese condilions from occurring. Lach vinler, vhen foIiage is
dormanl, lhe exlerior condilion al lhe base of lhe enlire erimeler vaII
shouId be examined.
Gullers overov, dovnsouls become bIocked vilh Ieaves or lrash,
and area sile drains become Iugged, aII of vhich can cause valer lo drain
dovn vaIIs or be lraed againsl lhe foundalion or vaIIs. These silua-
lions rovide ready condilions for valer inlrusion and musl be roulineIy
addressed under lhe mainlenance rogram, vilh reguIar inseclions and
cIeaning of gullers, dovnsouls, and sile drains.
CauIking viII faiI due lo age, moislure, sunIighl, and movemenl.
Everycaulkjointshouldbeinspectedannuallyandrepairedasneededtomain-
tainawatertightjoint. AII cauIking has a hnile Iife, usuaIIy 5-15 years, and
musl be reIaced al lhe end of lhal Iife. Therefore, lhe mainlenance ro-
gram shouId eslabIish a cauIking reIacemenl scheduIe for aII lyes of
cauIk |oinls in lhe buiIding (and donl forgel lhe hidden cauIking lhal
may be resenl, such as in horizonlaI ashings).
DoubIe-gIazed vindovs aIso faiI. The robIem here, aside from lhe
facl lhal lhe vindov lyicaIIy becomes cIoudy and unsighlIy, is lhal
lhe vindov heal lransfer resislance is cul in haIf (or more!) vhen lhe seaI
around lhe sace belveen lhe lvo gIass anes faiIs and air and moislure
enlers lhis sace. Nov, surface condensalion on lhe gIass surface can be-
come a robIem in lhe vinler if lhere are high inlernaI moislure Ioads or if
lhe buiIding humidily IeveI is kel al 5O/ or higher. This valer condens-
ing on lhe inside ane lhen drains dovnvard lo lhe siII and uddIes,
forming an ideaI grovlh sile for moId. Thus, lhe mainlenance Ian musl
rovide for reIacemenl of faiIed doubIe gIazing whenitoccurs.
Ior brick vaIIs, lhe mainlenance Ian musl incIude annuaI insec-
lion lo Iocale and reair cracks or reair olher robIems, as dehned in
Mainlenance Irocedure 2.2.1.1 (see Aendix ).
IinaIIy, inlerior valer Ieaks musl be addressed. Inlerior valer Ieaks
can resuIl from lhree basic sources:
1. Leaks from valer iing (Iumbing coId or hol valer, Iumbing
drains, hol or chiIIed valer Iines used for healing and cooIing, elc.)
124 Effective Building Maintenance
These Ieaks can be caused by a ie break, ie freezing, corrosion,
or Ialenl maleriaI or conslruclion defecls.
2. Leaks from backus and faiIed Iumbing or HVAC syslems (ru-
lured hol valer healers or valer soflener lanks, Ieaking cooIing coiI
drain ans, elc.)
3. SiIIs from dishvashers, vashing machines, refrigeralors, elc. or
resuIling from human error (somebody Iefl lhe lub faucel running
vide oen and forgel il!)
Irevenling lhese Ieaks is aImosl imossibIeas lhey say, cra ha-
ens. But,takingstepstofrsteliminatetheleakandthentodrythebuilding
area affected within 24-48 hours is of paramount importance to prevent mold
infestation.
A Ian lo resond lo valer robIems and, if required, moId cIean-
u, musl be crealed so lhal valer inlrusion robIems are idenlihed and
deaIl vilh vilhin lhe hrsl 24-48 hours afler occurrence, as foIIovs:
Any orous maleriaI (such as ceiIing liIes, carels, and sheel rock)
lhal has been vel Ionger lhan 48 hours shouId be considered a IikeIy
source of moIds. Some maleriaIs, such as draes, can be Iaundered.
MaleriaIs such as books and aer roducls may nol be saIvageabIe
even if vel Iess lhan 48 hours. Carels vel Iess lhan 48 hours need
lo be cIeaned and lhoroughIy dried. RemovaI and reinslaIIalion
shouId be considered, if necessary. If lhe carel is gIued lo concrele,
il viII nol IikeIy be saIvageabIe. The underIying concrele relains
moislure lhal is besl dried oul by removing lhe carel and exosing
lhe concrele lo dry air for severaI days.
RemovaI of slanding valer is a riorily and shouId occur in lhe hrsl
24 hours.
Dehumidihcalion by air condilioning, vhere feasibIe, or by dehu-
midihers lo remove absorbed excess valer shouId be ongoing for 72
hours or unliI lhe environmenl is reduced lo Iess lhan 5O/ reIalive
humidily IeveIs. A good largel for moislure conlroI is lo conlroI lhe
dev oinl lemeralure indoors lo belveen 35I and 55I.
Sanilizing hard surfaces afler valer remedialion or vilh moId
grovlh is in evidence can be done using chIorine bIeach mixed al
Special Maintenance Considerations 125
one cu er gaIIon. Surfaces shouId be vied vilh lhe sanilizer and
Iefl vel for 2O minules rior lo lhorough drying.
In some cases, valer damage may be hidden and go on for monlhs
rior lo discovery (i.e., Ieaking valer ie in a vaII, a basemenl cravI
sace dam from rain and ground valer seeage, or a roof Ieak belveen
lhe ceiIing and lhe uer roof). In lhese cases signihcanl moId grovlh
may occur and require lhal lhe affecled areas be cIosed dovn, seaIed off,
and deconlaminaled by lrained slaff.
A comIele remedialion Ian for lhese silualions shouId be arl of
lhe resonse rolocoI crealed by lhe inleresled arlies.
Anytimemoldisfound,cleanupandmitigationmustbeginimmediately
(within24-48hours). The lvo foIIoving resources are lhe de faclo slan-
dards for moId miligalion and shouId be used lo guide moId cIean-u
aclivilies:
1. GuidelinesonAssessmentandRemediationofFungiinIndoorEnviron-
ments, avaiIabIe from lhe Nev York Cily Dearlmenl of HeaIlh and
MenlaI Hygiene as a free dovnIoad al hll:11vvv.NYC.gov1
hlmI1doh1hlmI1ei1moIdrl1.shlmI.
2. MoldRemediationinSchoolsandCommercialBuildings, I.S. Lnviron-
menlaI Iroleclion Agency, LIA IubIicalion 4O2-K-O1-OO1, avaiIabIe
as a free dovnIoad al hll:11vvv.ea.gov1moId1moId_remedia-
lion.hlmI.
asic guideIines for remedialion of valer-damaged and1or moId
infesled maleriaIs afler 48 hours, as recommended by MoldRemediationin
SchoolsandCommercialBuildings, I.S. LnvironmenlaI Iroleclion Agency,
are summarized in TabIe 4-11.
These remedialion guideIines are based on lhe size of lhe affecled
area lo make il easier for remedialors lo seIecl aroriale lechniques.
The ovner musl lhen use rofessionaI |udgmenl and exerience lo adal
lhe guideIines lo arlicuIar silualions.
In hol, humid cIimales, ouldoor air inlroduced for venliIalion or by
inhIlralion, couIed vilh a Iack of humidily conlroI by HVAC syslems,
are oflen signihcanl conlribulors lo moId grovlh in faciIilies and musl
be addressed by lhe mainlenance slaff. ul, lhe mainlenance slaff, can
minimize design faiIures by aying carefuI allenlion lo lvo basic faclors:
126 Effective Building Maintenance
(1) mainlain lhe buiIding al a osilive ressure al aII limes and (2) oerale
HVAC syslems lo rovide lhe besl humidily conlroI lhal lhey can.
Infltration of hol, humid ouldoor air inlo each area of lhe buiIding
musl be eIiminaled by mainlaining osilive ressurizalion in aII buiId-
ing areas al aII limes. InhIlralion is dehned as lhe unconlroIIed inlro-
duclion of ouldoor air inlo a buiIding. ne obvious source of inhIlra-
lion is lhrough oen doors, bul inhIlralion can aIso occur lhrough vaIIs,
lhrough lhe cracks around vindovs and olher vaII oenings, lhrough
roofs, elc.
Ior inlernaI ressurizalion lo be effeclive in eIiminaling inhIlra-
lion, lhe buiIding ressure musl equaI or exceed lhe ressure due lo
vind veIocily. Al a lyicaI vind seed of 1O mh during lhe cooIing
Table 4-11. Remediation of Water Damaged/Mold Infested Materials
*CIean-u Melhods:
Melhod 1: Wel vacuum (in lhe case of orous maleriaIs, some moId sores1fragmenls viII
remain in lhe maleriaI bul viII nol grov if lhe maleriaI is comIeleIy dried). Sleam cIeaning
may be an aIlernalive for carels and some uhoIslered furnilure.
Melhod 2: Dam-vie surfaces vilh Iain valer or vilh valer and delergenl soIulion (ex-
cel vood use vood oor cIeaner), scrub as needed.
Melhod 3: High-efhciency arlicuIale air (HLIA) vacuum afler lhe maleriaI has been lhor-
oughIy dried. Disose of lhe conlenls of lhe HLIA vacuum in veII-seaIed Iaslic bags.
Melhod 4: Discard remove valer-damaged maleriaIs and seaI in Iaslic bags vhiIe inside
of conlainmenl, if resenl. Disose of as normaI vasle. HLIA vacuum area afler il is dried.
Special Maintenance Considerations 127
monlhs, an inlernaI ressure inallareasofthebuilding of al Ieasl O.OO9 si
(O.25 vg) vouId be required.
ecause of lhe vagaries of conslruclion, il is imossibIe lo comule
lhe exacl amounl of ouldoor air lhal musl be inlroduced lo mainlain ex-
aclIy O.25 vg osilive ressure in lhe buiIding. Thus, themostcommon
approach used by designers is to determine the exhaust requirement in each
areaandthenintroduceenoughoutdoorairinthatareatooffsettheexhaust,
plusanadditional10-20%asasafetyfactor.At all times, when an exte-
rior door is opened, air should exfltrate (exit) from the building.
Ior indoor air in lhe summer lo be al an accelabIe 5O/RH or Iess,
lhe HVAC syslems musl suIy lheir air al a 55I or Iover devoinl
lemeralure.
IinaIIy, mosl buiIdings are nol occuied around lhe cIock. There-
fore, lhe buiIding ovner musl address unoccuied eriods, ranging
from overnighl lo veekends lo summer vacalions, lo mainlain Iov hu-
midily IeveI and heI conlroI moId grovlh. Care musl be laken lo en-
sure lhal aII buiIding exhausl fans are shul dovn and aII ouldoor air
damers are cIosed during unoccuied eriods.
The recommended aroach lo revenling high humidily from oc-
curring during lhese eriods is lo eslabIish bolh high Iimil lemeralure
and high Iimil humidily sace seloinls, monilored by sace lemera-
lure and humidily sensors, lhal viII cause lhe HVAC conlroIs lo cycIe
lhe HVAC syslems on lo mainlain lhese seloinls. IdeaIIy, lhis vouId be
done for each air-handIer. ul, because cenlraI chiIIer and boiIer Ianls
may have a minimum Ioad requiremenl, care musl be laken by lhe de-
signer lo ensure lhal enough syslems are cycIed on lo rovide lhis mini-
mum Ioador lhere is no benehl lo lhe unoccuied eriod conlroI.
Since lhere are no eoIe in lhe buiIding during lhese unoccuied
eriods, venliIalion air is nol required and lhe ouldoor air damers
shouId be cIosed (vhich eIiminales lhe ma|orily of lhe moislure Ioad
imosed on lhe buiIding).
In summary, TabIe 4-12 reresenls a checkIisl lhal can be used lo
dehne lhe mainlenance requiremenls lo conlroI moId in faciIilies.
DLALING WITH IAILING MASNRY WALLS
Brick,concrete,andstonemasonrycavitywallsallowgreaterwaterintru-
sionandhavegreaterresultingmoldproblemsthanothertypesofexteriorfnish.
128 Effective Building Maintenance
Wilh brick, lhe mosl common masonry cIadding, lhe besl design
and delaiIing combined vilh lhe besl quaIily maleriaIs viII nol comen-
sale for oor conslruclion raclices and vorkmanshi, vhich have be-
come lhe norm. Iroer conslruclion raclices, incIuding rearalion of
maleriaIs and vorkmanshi, are essenliaI in allaining a valer-resislanl
brick masonry vaII. Therefore, secihc conslruclion rocedures, recom-
mended by lhe rick Induslry Associalion (IA), musl be secihed by
lhe designer and foIIoved by lhe conlraclor lo ensure quaIily masonry
conslruclion and avoid valer robIems.
As discussed in Chaler 3, hovever, even lhe besl masonry vaII
viII begin lo faiIcracked or saIIing unils, cracks and searalion of
morlar |oinls, faiIed cauIking, are common occurrences. Less common,
bul a robIem in muIlislory brick buiIdings is Iong lerm cree and lhal
Table 4-12. Checklist for Preventing Mold Infestation
Special Maintenance Considerations 129
resuIls in slrucluraI faiIure of masonry veneer.
No maller vhal lhe cause, a faiIing masonry maII is difhcuIl lo
address and il can aImosl never be reaired veII enough for conlinued
salisfaclory erformance. The uIlimale melhod of deaIing vilh a faiIing
masonry vaII is lo remove lhe masonry maleriaI, incIuding lhe exisling
ashing, elc., and correclIy inslaII nev. Hovever, lhis is an exensive un-
derlaking and lhere are aIlernalives.
CIear valer-reeIIenl coalings are somelimes recommended lo re-
duce valer absorlion and reduce lhe amounl of valer lhal enelrales
lhe exlerior brick masonry. Hovever, cIear valer reeIIenls can seIdom
slo valer enelralion lhrough cracks over O.O2 in. in size. CIear valer re-
eIIenls cannol slo valer enelralion lhrough incomIeleIy hIIed mor-
lar |oinls or from sources such as ineffeclive siIIs, cas or coings. Their
effecliveness under condilions of vind-driven rain is queslionabIe. Asa
result,theuseofclearwaterrepellentcoatingstoeliminatewaterpenetrationin
awallwithexistingdefectsisoftenfutile.
SleeI aneIs, using re-hnished singIe lhickness formed seclions,
have successfuIIy been aIied over exisling masonry vaIIs lhal vere
erforming oorIy, IaneIs are inslaIIed on hal channeIs and serve as rain
barriers lo eIiminale lhe direcl imingemenl of bIoving rain onlo lhe ma-
sonry. This aroach can be a Iov cosl, lhough Iimiled Iife, soIulion lo
Ieaky masonry vaII robIems.
A shorl-lerm (5- lo 1O-year) soIulion lo delerioraling or oorIy de-
signed or conslruclion masonry vaIIs is lo aIy an eIaslomeric acryIic or
siIicone masonry coaling. These oaque coalings, vilh an aIied lhick-
ness of 8-12 miIs (aboul 5O-1OO sq. feel1gaIIon), are aIied by roIIing or
sraying lo form a exibIe, lexlured or smoolh hnish. LIaslomeric vaII
coalings are formuIaled lo slrelch and bridge cracks (assuming roer
crack rearalion and seaIing) lhal may form due lo movemenl. When
lhe vaII conlracls as lemeralures dro and lhe cracks exand, lhe eIaslo-
meric vaII coaling slrelches and resisls cracking ilseIf. When lhe lemera-
lure rises and lhe cracks become smaIIer, lhe coaling relurns lo ils originaI
shae vilhoul vrinkIing or Ieaving ridges. This crack bridging caabiIily
resuIls in a Iong Iasling, uniform hnish.
To achieve lhe baIance of roerlies required lo make a lo quaIily
eIaslomeric vaII coaling, manufaclurers use acryIic binders lhal are de-
signed secihcaIIy for lhis use. Ising lhese acryIic binders rovides lhe
coaling vilh a high degree of exibiIily and eIaslicily, vhiIe exhibiling
aroriale lensiIe slrenglh, and suerior aIkaIi resislance and dirl resis-
130 Effective Building Maintenance
lance, vhich are imorlanl consideralions. LIaslomeric vaII coalings cure
lo a smoolh, non lacky, high dirl resislanl hnish vhich viII resisl cracking
and vrinkIing.
Good surface rearalion is crilicaI for a good coaling. Wilh mason-
ry, cerlain asecls need seciaI allenlion, such as aIkaIinily, orosily, and
lhe lendency lo form eforescence. The masonry subslrale musl be cIean
and sound so lhal lhe coaling can adhere roerIy lo ils surface. This
requires valer bIasling or sand bIasling lo remove any dusl, dirl, ak-
ing ainl, or olher Ioose maleriaI. If lhe surface vas reviousIy ainled,
miIdev or moId may be resenl. These conlaminanls shouId be removed
vilh a common bIeach soIulion (lhree arls valer lo one arl househoId
bIeach). In aII cases, afler erforming any surface rearalion rocedures,
lhe surface shouId be rinsed veII vilh cIean valer.
nce lhe surface is cIean, cracks grealer lhan 1116 inch shouId be
seaIed vilh a lo quaIily valer based acryIic or siIicon-acryIic cauIk or
seaIanl. Iurlhermore, if lhe surface remains somevhal chaIky or is o-
rous, a valer- or soIvenl-based masonry seaIer musl be aIied before
aIying coaling. If lhe surface lends lo form eforescence, or is nev and
highIy aIkaIine, a masonry seaIer or rimer is required lo rolecl lhe lex-
lured coaling eIaslomeric locoal.
Texlured coaling eIaslomeric vaII coalings viII erform veII onIy
vhen aIied in lhick hIms. The lyicaI aIicalion rocedure is lo use
eilher an airIess sray foIIoved by back roIIing, or a Iong na roIIer. A
1-112 lo 4 brush vorks veII for smaIIer areas.
IroerIy formuIaled coaling eIaslomeric vaII coalings have a salin
hnish. They can generaIIy be linled and vhiIe vhile is mosl ouIar, sofl
asleIs and sublIe earlh lones are oflen chosen as decoralive olions.
IdeaIIy, once a lexlured or smoolh coaling eIaslomeric coaling is a-
Iied, il shouId be aIIoved lo vealher for al Ieasl one year before a non-
eIaslomeric coaling is aIied over il. Lven lhen, surfaces vilh coaling
eIaslomeric coalings shouId be reainled onIy vilh a valer-based lo-
coal, since oiI-based coalings are much Iess exibIe, and can crack severe-
Iy if aIied over lhe eIaslomeric coaling.
IinaIIy, anolher, bul oflen maIigned, roducl lhal can be successfuI-
Iy aIied over masonry vaIIs lo seaI lhem is externallyfnishedinsulation
systems (LIIS). In facl, LIIS vas originaIIy deveIoed in Luroe secih-
caIIy lo be used on masonry conslruclion. (Il vas onIy afler being videIy,
and oorIy, aIied lo vood frame conslruclion in lhe Iniled Slales lhal
lhe valer robIems vilh LIIS became evidenl.) Drainage Iane LIIS,
Special Maintenance Considerations 131
roerIy aIied over masonry, can be a ermanenl (3O-year) soIulion
lo vaII moislure inlrusion robIems. Hovever, lhe foIIoving olenliaI
robIem areas musl be addressed:
Lnsure lhal exisling cauIking and ashing is roerIy inslaIIed or, if
nol, is roerIy reaired.
DelaiI aII LIIS inlerseclionsroof overhangs, vindovs and doors,
grade IeveI, elc.
Lnsure lhal lhe inslaIIer is Iicensed and lrained by lhe LIIS manu-
faclurer and lhal he uses onIy lhal manufaclurers roducls and in-
slaIIs lhem roerIy.
This page left intentionally blank.
133
Chapter 5
Designing for
Building Maintainability
Why do archilecls and engineers send four or hve years in coI-
Iege addressing design issues and raclicaIIy no lime on buiIding main-
lenance` In raclice, lhere is sliII onIy a Iimiled degree of associalion
and reIalion belveen mainlenance rofessionaIs and designers. Design-
ers conlinue lo creale many buiIdings vhich faiI lo achieve salisfaclory
Iong-lerm erformance and mainlainers sliII have IillIe evidenl inu-
ence or imacl on design. Design and mainlenance issues require a
raclicaI aroach, a robIem soIving orienlalion and a Iearning from
exerience lo roduce a comrehensive aroach lo imroving buiId-
ing erformance and reducing Iife cycIe cosl.
InforlunaleIy, many faclors reIaling lo design and mainlenance
creale conlrasling and conlradiclory ob|eclives and in accommodaling
cerlain design needs, mainlenance requiremenls may be adverseIy af-
fecled. ConverseIy, lhe alleml lo roduce mainlenance free buiIdings
may imose comIeleIy imraclicaI and cerlainIy uneconomic design
rovisions. ConsequenlIy, lhere is a need lo comromise and baIance
lhe oosing crileria lo imrove overaII buiIding erformance.
WhiIe ve knov lhal lhe quaIily and erformance of buiIdings is
deendenl on lhe effecliveness of ils design and suslained mainlenance,
lradilionaIIy, lhese lasks are lrealed as searale enlilies. This inlrinsic
searalion causes severaI robIems such as:
Lack of feedback and suorl: Design and mainlenance rofes-
sionaIs oflen have minimaI knovIedge or resecl for each olh-
ers robIems. The riorilies considered in design frequenlIy rank
mainlenance as lhe Iovesl need and lhe Iessons Iearned lhrough
remediaI measures rareIy inuence design rocedures.
Lack of knovIedge and underslanding among design rofes-
sionaIs: Due lo lhe inherenl searalion and under lhe ressure of
134 Effective Building Maintenance
lime1budgel, design consuIlanls oflen do nol have sufhcienl un-
derslanding and knovIedge on mainlenance issues during ofhce
buiIding design slage. As a resuIl, lhere are Iimiled consideralions
for service, ugrade and mainlenance during lhe Iife san of lhe
buiIding.
Lack of dala on oeralionaI requiremenls: There is a Iack of hislori-
caI dala concerning lhe oeralionaI requiremenls and mainlenance
erformance of exisling buiIdings. As a resuIl, designers have lo
vork vilh insufhcienl and vilhin lhe Iimiled limes, even inaro-
riale informalion.
DifhcuIlies in forecasling fulure condilion and changes: Increasing
gIobaI varming may have a signihcanlIy imorlanl effecl on lhe
cIimale condilions for buiIdings lo vilhsland. Wilhoul necessary
suorl, designers are unabIe lo redicl such changes for remediaI
measures for buiIding servicing and mainlenance.
The Iirsl cosl menlaIily: Inuenced by ovners and deveIoers,
designers oflen focus on lhe iniliaI cosl of buiIding, i.e. buiIl cosl,
vilhoul sufhcienl consideralion for subsequenl cosls such as lhal
incurred in buiIding mainlenance. CailaI cosl is onIy 2O/ of lhe
lolaI cosl of a buiIding over ils Iifesan. Hov buiIdings viII er-
form or vhal lhey viII cosl lo run 1O lo 3O years in lhe fulure is nol
a key issue considered by mosl deveIoers.
AddilionaIIy, designers are sub|ecled lo a greal deaI of Iobbying lo
use one roducl ralher lhan anolher, and are bombarded vilh an over-
abundance of ubIicily maleriaI. This can have lvo severe consequences:
Il may inuence lhe designer lo use a nev comonenl (maleriaI,
syslem, elc.), vhich has nol been sufhcienlIy roved in raclice,
vilh a consequenliaI faiIure lo meel requiremenls.
ConverseIy, lhere may be lhe oosile reaclion, resuIling in lhe
designer using a comonenl or maleriaI vilh vhich he is famiIiar,
vhelher or nol il is lhe righl choice in lhe circumslances.
A ma|or shorl-coming in lhe design rocess aears lo be a faiIure
lo make use of lhe aulhorilalive guidance lhal is avaiIabIe. This mighl
Designing for Building Maintainability 135
be a simIe faiIure lo use codes and slandards roerIy, or may be al-
lribulabIe lo lhe shear voIume of advice. Anolher source lhal many de-
signers (and mosl conlraclors) overIook is manufaclurer inslaIIalion in-
slruclions, resuIling in oor erformance of lhe roducl lhal is inslaIIed
incorreclIy (lhink Tyvek barrier vilhoul laed |oinls).
And, mosl imorlanlIy, vilhoul using Iife cycIe cosling for design
decision making, buiIdings viII Iack lhorough documenlalion lo reveaI
lhe reaI cosls during lhe Iife of lhe buiIding...designers focus on lhe con-
slruclion cosl of a buiIding, bul lyicaIIy do nol reaIIy lake inlo accounl
lhe subsequenl ovning and oeraling cosls, eseciaIIy mainlenance
cosls.
Some efforl has been allemled lo faciIilale imroved communi-
calion and managemenl lo creale a beller baIance of design and main-
lenance. ne aroach lo lhis is for a singIe grou made u of lhe de-
signers, lhe conlraclor(s), and lhe ovners oeralions and mainlenance
slaff lo coordinale lhe design efforl...vhal ve nov caII lhe inlegraled
design aroach. Anolher aIlernalive is lo forcefuIIy invoIve grealer
arlicialion by assigning IegaI resonsibiIilies lo designers and deveI-
oers.
Hovever, allemls lo faciIilale effeclive communicalion during
lhe design rocess are burdened by conicling ob|eclives, rofessionaI
re|udices, and inaroriale managemenl slruclures. If design and
mainlenance issues are lo be baIanced, il is essenliaI for one grou lo
coordinale design, conslruclion and mainlenance aclivilies and much
vork remains lo ensure lhal lhe inlegraled design aroach becomes
videIy used.
Ior lhis reason, some counlries (Singaore, for examIe) require
deveIoers lo relain al Ieasl a 3O/ share in lhe buiIding for len years af-
ler comIelion, aulomalicaIIy invoIving lhem in oeralions and mainle-
nance issues, vhiIe olhers (such as Taivan) require deveIoers lo hand-
over a mainlenance budgel lo lhe buiIding managemenl conlroI board
during lhe buiIding deIivery rocess.
WhiIe lhese comuIsory requiremenls can acliveIy assisl in in-
creasing mainlenance assessmenl, lhey are resisled by deveIoers and
fev governmenls have considered lhem. Thus,improveddesignandcon-
struction techniques, ideally determined and incorporated via the integrated
designprocess,remainthebestwaytoachievegoodqualitybuildings.
ver lhe vhoIe Iife of a buiIding, lhe design and conslruclion e-
riod reresenls onIy 1-1O/ of lhe Iife cycIe, lhe resl, incIuding oera-
136 Effective Building Maintenance
lion and mainlenance, makes u 9O-99/. Inder ideaI circumslances,
a buiIdings design vouId reresenl a erfecl modeI of lhe roosed
faciIily vhich, as veII as being of reIevance lo lhe delaiIed design and
conslruclion, viII be of vaIue lo effeclive mainlenance of lhe buiIding.
uiIding sludies in lhe Iniled Slales, lhe I.K., AuslraIia, Singa-
ore, Canada, Taivan, elc. have reveaIed lhal lhe ma|orily of buiIding
and1or comonenl faiIures (or, al Ieasl, high mainlenance requiremenls
and1or shorlened erformance Iife) resuIl from making vrong choices
aboul maleriaIs or comonenls for a arlicuIar silualion in lhe buiIding.
Thus,maintenancemustbefullyconsideredatthedesignstage. Lach of lhe
foIIoving design eIemenls is crilicaI:
The adequacy of lhe design and lhe suilabiIily of lhe maleriaIs
secihed
The slandard of vorkmanshi in lhe iniliaI conslruclion and sub-
sequenl mainlenance oeralions...an oversighl resonsibiIily of
lhe designer.
The exlenl lo vhich lhe designer has aIIoved for resenl and an-
licialed fulure needs
GLNLRAL CNSTRICTIN
ased on research al Harvard Iniversily, buiIding quaIily and re-
suIling mainlenance requiremenls imosed on lhe buiIding ovner re-
suIl from decisions made by lhe designers in lhe earIiesl slages of lhe
design rocess. TabIe 5-1 summarizes Harvards anaIysis lhal each ma-
|or comonenl of lhe buiIding design musl be considered reIalive lo
service Iife and mainlenance.
Mosl commonIy, generaI conslruclion mainlenance robIems re-
Iale lo moislure inlrusion and1or air inhIlralion resuIling from imro-
er design and1or conslruclion.
Exterior Walls
IaiIing masonry vaIIs, as discussed in Chaler 4, are a rime cuI-
ril for moislure inlrusion, resuIling in lhe need for ongoing and, uIli-
maleIy, exensive, mainlenance. The basic vay lo Iimil olenliaI mois-
lure inlrusion robIems is lo avoid lhe use of masonry exlerior vaIIs.
Designing for Building Maintainability 137
Table 5-1. Quality of Building Components vs. Design Service Life
138 Effective Building Maintenance
AIso, exerience shovs lhal vood as a exlerior vaII maleriaI has signih-
canl mainlenance issues (vel rol, dry rol, elc.) and shouId be avoided,
eseciaIIy in humid cIimales. Eliminatingwoodandmasonryaswallclad-
dingwillsignifcantlyreduceexteriorwallmaintenanceproblems.
Whal maleriaIs shouId be used as lhe cIadding of exlerior vaIIs`
Iirsl, consider lhe use of recasl concrele aneIs, vhich have aroxi-
maleIy lhe same design service Iife as masonry maleriaIs, bul vilh far
fever mainlenance robIems. Irecasl concrele aneIs are denser lhan
brick or CMI and, lhus, are beller as valer barriers. InslaIIalion is more
engineered and Iess deendenl on lhe vorkmanshi lo roduce a vaII
vilhoul Ieaks, cracks, sellIemenl, elc. lhal require mainlenance. And,
from an aeslhelic erseclive, recasl aneIs can be formed in many
differenl shaes and exlerior hnishes, yieId signihcanl design freedom
in lheir aIicalion.
Anolher good choice is rehnished, insuIaled melaI aneIs. De-
ending on melaI lhickness and lye of hnish, melaI aneIs can have
an anlicialed service Iife as greal as recasl concrele, lhough lyicaI-
Iy viII have a Iife execlancy aboul 3O/ shorler. Again, inslaIIalion is
more engineered and Iess deendenl on lhe vorkmanshi lo roduce
a vaII vilhoul Ieaks lhal require rouline mainlenance.
IinaIIy, shorler Iife maleriaIs lhal shouId be considered incIude vi-
nyI, cemenl board, and melaI cIadding. These maleriaIs erform veII
and require IillIe mainlenance over lheir design service Iife. And, al lhe
end of lhal Iife, lhey are reIaliveIy simIe lo reIace.
Thefundamentalconceptinrainwatercontrolforwalldesignistoshed
water by layering materials in such a way that water is directed downward
andoutofthebuilding. Gravily is lhe driving force behind valer drain-
age. The dovn direclion harnesses lhe force of gravily and lhe oul
direclion gels lhe valer avay from lhe buiIding. In generaI, lhe sooner
lhe valer is direcled oul, lhe beller.
Wall design must be based on the assumption that water can penetrate
theexteriorfnishorcladdingandenterthewall.
Lvery vaII, lherefore, musl have a rain or valer barrier aIied
lo lhe oulside surface of lhe backing vaII lo ensure lhal vind-driven
rainvaler does nol enelrale lhe inner vylhe of lhe vaII. The exlerior
cIadding and be inslaIIed in such as vay as lo aIIov valer lo drain
lo lhe exlerior of lhe buiIding. Then, a cavily or drainage Iane,
vilh roer lhrough-vaII ashing and drain oulIels, is aIvays neces-
sary. Waler lhal enelrales lhrough cIadding, lhen, viII faII by gravily
Designing for Building Maintainability 139
dovn lhe drainage cavily and drain lo lhe oulside, nol lo lhe inside of
lhe buiIding.
Fenestration
Ieneslralion reresenls a hoIe in lhe vaII lhrough vhich valer,
valer vaor, and air can enler a buiIding. Windovs, even lhe very besl,
do nol have a lhermaI erformance lhal even aroaches lhal of a veII-
insuIaled vaII, have you ever seen an R-3O vindov` So, unIess very
carefuIIy designed, aImosl aII feneslralion reresenls increased energy
inefhciency for lhe buiIding enveIoe. Tominimizethesenegativeimpacts
andthemaintenanceassociatedwithdealingwiththem,thequantityoffenes-
trationshouldbeheldtotheminimumrequired.
Nexl, avoid oerabIe vindovs. erabIe vindovs lyicaIIy resuIl
in increased inhIlralion and resuIling moislure inlrusion, and lend lo
Ieak over lime, requiring rouline mainlenance. Iixed gIazing syslems
avoid many of lhese robIems.
ul, even vilh hxed gIazing, carefuI delaiIing of lhe vindov in-
slaIIalion is required lo revenl valer inlrusion. olh lhe los and bol-
loms of vindovs musl be ashed. IIashing over lhe vindov lo lrim is
required. In aII cases, vindovs shouId be recessed in lhe vaII lo rovide
a dri edge aIong lhe lo and1or rovided vilh a secihcaIIy designed
dri edge. Ian ashing is a highIy recommended melhod for crealing an
under-vindov guller lo redirecl any Ieaking valer lo lhe exlerior.
The robIems vilh vindov-vaII syslems are even more comIex.
InIike lradilionaI curlain vaII syslems lhal san oor lo oor vilh al-
lachmenls oulboard of lhe sIab edge, lhe lradilionaI vindov-vaII sys-
lem is designed lo bear on lhe sIab edge and exlend u lo lhe underside
of lhe sIab edge above. In some syslems, a sIab band cover is rovided
lo give an aearance simiIar lo curlain vaII. AIlhough lhere are many
varialions, lhe lyicaI vindov-vaII syslem is dehned by lhe foIIoving
fealures:
Windov exlrusions used lo san from oor lo oor in a re-man-
ufaclured unilized syslem lyicaIIy u lo 6 feel in vidlh.
A couIer connecling lhe verlicaI muIIions of each vindov-vaII
unil, eilher as a maIe-femaIe couIer inlegraI lo lhe verlicaI muI-
Iions or as an indeendenl couIer.
Windov-vaII syslems bear on lhe sIab edge al lhe oor IeveI and
140 Effective Building Maintenance
are anchored lo a relaining lrack faslened inlo lhe sIab.
The head of lhe vindov-vaII syslem is sIolled inlo a deeclion
header faslened lo lhe underside of lhe oor sIab, sandreI beam,
or slrucluraI vaII and anchored lo lhe slruclure vilh deeclion
slras.
HorizonlaI muIIions dividing lhe vindov-vaII unil inlo aneIs of
vision gIass unils, gIazed from eilher lhe exlerior or inlerior, and
gIass or melaI oaque aneIs mounled from lhe exlerior.
erabIe unils, lyicaIIy avning or casemenl vindovs, sving
doors, and sIiding doors, mounled vilhin lhe frame of lhe vin-
dov-vaII syslem.
A sIab band cover sanning lhe delh of lhe sIab lhal can be in-
slaIIed eilher indeendenl of lhe vindov-vaII syslem or as an ex-
lension of lhe vindov-vaII frame.
LarIy vindov-vaII syslems lyicaIIy used a face seaIed aroach
lo lheir design vilh resecl lo valer lighlness, reIying on lhe conlinu-
ily of lhe rimary exlerior seaI lo revenl valer inhIlralion. Many of
lhese syslems have exerienced chronic valer inhIlralion robIems as
lhe resuIl of dehciencies in lhe rimary exlerior seaI. These vere oflen
aggravaled by air Ieakage lhal emhasized lhe dehciencies in lhe ri-
mary exlerior seaI under differenliaI ressure. nce lhe valer is asl
lhe exlerior seaI, il oflen accumuIaled vilhin lhe frame, as lhere vas no
rovision lo conlain lhis valer or lo drain lhe inlersliliaI cavilies. Lven-
luaIIy, lhe accumuIaling valer overoved lo lhe inlerior.
These frequenl valer ingress robIems have Ied lo lhe adolion
in recenl years of rain-screen design concels. The adalalion of rain-
screen concels lo vindov-vaII syslems vas lvofoId. In lhe hrsl in-
slance, a second Iine of roleclion againsl valer enelralion vas ro-
vided inboard of lhe originaI rimary exlerior seaI. Differenl assembIies
vilhin a lyicaI vindov-vaII syslem require differenl aroaches lo
roviding an effeclive second Iine of roleclion, incIuding
InslaIIalion of a secondary seaI for lhe vision unils, lyicaIIy ro-
vided by a heeI bead of seaIanl aIied belveen lhe inside Iighl of
Designing for Building Maintainability 141
gIass and lhe frame of lhe vindov-vaII syslem for inlerior gIazed
unils,
InslaIIalion of a melaI back-an seaIed lo lhe frame of lhe vindov-
vaII syslem behind aII oaque aneIs lo acl as a secondary seaI,
InslaIIalion of a valerroof membrane al lhe IeveI of lhe oor sIab
exlending from lhe verlicaI Ieg of lhe mounling lrack dovn lhe
face of lhe sIab and onlo lhe deeclion header.
The rimary inlenl of lhese measures is lo rovide redundancy
vilhin lhe syslem. The seaIs forming lhe secondary Iine of roleclion
are lyicaIIy beller defense from exosure and lemeralure exlremes
lhan lhe rimary exlerior seaIs and can be execled lo have a Ionger
service Iife. In lhe second inslance, means of draining lhe inlersliliaI
saces crealed belveen lhe rimary and secondary seaIs are rovided
so lhal any valer making ils vay asl lhe rimary exlerior seaI vouId
nol accumuIale vilhin lhe vindov-vaII syslem bul vouId be redirecl-
ed lo lhe exlerior. To reduce lhe risk of valer accumuIalion vilhin lhe
syslem, designers musl ensure lhal each eIemenl of lhe vindov-vaII is
rovided vilh means of draining, incIuding
Drainage of lhe gIazing cavily and back-ans, eilher direclIy lo lhe
exlerior by vay of drain hoIes lhrough lhe horizonlaI muIIions or
dovn lo lhe deeclion header by means of drain hoIes in lhe verli-
caI muIIions,
Drainage of lhe cavily belveen lhe rimary and secondary gaskels
on oerabIe unils,
Drainage of lhe horizonlaI muIIions direclIy lo lhe exlerior,
Drainage of lhe vindov-vaII syslem al lhe IeveI of each deeclion
header.
An addilionaI advanlage of lhis lvofoId aroach is lhal il creales
a series of comarlmenlaIized cavilies lhal rovide for some measure
of ressure moderalion across lhe rimary exlerior seaI. Reducing lhe
ressure across lhe exlerior seaI reduces lhe amounl of valer lhal can
142 Effective Building Maintenance
be driven lhrough lhe minor imerfeclions IikeIy lo be resenl in lhe ex-
lerior seaI. The comarlmenlaIizalion of lhe vindov-vaII syslem aIso
makes il easier lo isoIale any evenluaI Ieaks. Wilh lhe earIier vindov-
vaII syslems, valer mighl hnd ils vay dovn a fev slories from ils oinl
of enlry before any sign of valer ingress vas visibIe on lhe inlerior. Wilh
a comarlmenlaIized syslem, il is unIikeIy lhal valer can lraveI far from
ils oinl of enlry.
Roofng
AII roofs viII Ieak, il is |usl a maller of vhen. ul, ilched or high-
sIoed roofs shed valer beller lhan al or Iov-sIoe roofs (roofs vilh
Iess lhan 3:12 sIoe) simIy because gravily always works and roof de-
sign and conslruclion may nol. High sIoe roofs (vilh ilch grealer lhan
3:12) have lhe advanlage of shedding rainvaler and reducing lhe olen-
liaI of roof Ieaks inlo buiIdings since lhe roof doesnl acluaIIy have lo be
a valer barrier. Aroofslopeofatleast3:12ishighlyrecommended, lhe resuIl
viII be a roof lhal Iasls 2-3 limes as Iong, Ieaks far Iess, and signihcanlIy
reduces lhe cosl of mainlenance.
As arl of a high sIoe roof syslem, lhe use of an archilecluraI
slanding seam melaI roof (ASSM) as lhe rimary rain barrier is becom-
ing slandard. AshaIl shingIe roofs vear oorIy in aImosl aII cIimales,
vood shingIe roofs are a hre hazard and mainlenance nighlmare, and
liIe, cemenl, and sIale roofs are loo exensive and loo heavy lo ordinar-
iIy considered. ASSM is lyicaIIy made of gaIvanized sleeI vilh an aIu-
minum coaling, covered vilh a baked-on enameI or ovder-coal hnish,
has a Iong design service Iife, and requires very IillIe mainlenance.
If, hovever, afler a lhorough evaIualion, lhe decision is made lo
uliIize a Iov sIoe roof, lhe nexl sle is lo decide lhe lye of Iov sIoe
roof lo inslaII. Roof sIoe shouId never be Iess lhan 1:5O (aroximaleIy
114 er fool) and lhe sIoe musl be uniform lo revenl onding.
There are basicaIIy lvo lyes (vilh many varialions) lo consider:
Type1
SingIe-Iy maleriaIs lhal can be allached chemicaIIy, mechanicaIIy,
or heId in Iace vilh baIIasl, usuaIIy graveI or aggregale. LxamIes of
singIe-Iy roducls incIude:
LIDM: LlhyIene royIene diene monomer (synlhelic rubber)
is a exibIe eIaslomeric maleriaI.
Designing for Building Maintainability 143
IVC: IoIyvinyI chIoride a synlhelic lhermoIaslic oIymer
reared from vinyI chIoride.
TI: a bIend of oIymers lhal may or may nol conlain desir-
abIe addilives such as ame relardanls or IV absorbers.
Type2
uiIl-u roof (IR), consisling of muIliIy Iies of lvo como-
nenls, bilumen and feIls. ilumen rovides lhe valerroohng and ad-
hesive roerlies of lhe syslem. The feIls slrenglhen and slabiIize lhe
membrane. The roohng membrane is rolecled from lhe eIemenls by a
surfacing Iayer, eilher a ca sheel or graveI embedded in bilumen or a
coaling maleriaI.
WhiIe lhere are many ros and cons for each of lhese lvo lyes,
installedcorrectly,a5-plybuilt-uproofisfarbetterthananysingle-plymem-
braneintermsoflifecycleperformanceandeaseofmaintenance. The IR has
many advanlages:
Wilh a graveI vear surface, lhe roof has exceIIenl exlerior hre resis-
lance.
Il is imacl and unclure resislanlbeller for roofs vilh high fool
lrafhc.
Temeralure differenliaI slress due lo valer onding is signihcanl-
Iy Iover.
Reairs are fairIy easy (and can oflen be done by lhe faciIily main-
lenance slaff)no seciaI manufaclurer Iicensing requiremenls for
conlraclors.
MuIliIe Iies add redundancy for valer barrier rolecliona
5-Iy roof is beller lhan a 3-Iy roof.
Service Iifevhich can be exlended by ongoing mainlenance and
reair.
Cons associaled vilh IR incIude odors and olenliaI hre haz-
ards during inslaIIalion, il is suscelibIe lo damage from animaI fals
144 Effective Building Maintenance
and soIvenls around kilchen exhausl fans, coaI lar is suscelibIe lo coId
vealher cracking (bilumen is nol), and more comIex delaiIs are re-
quired for roof enelralions and al araels and roof curbs.
Wilh any lye of Iov sIoe roof, lhe foIIoving eIemenls musl be
considered:
1. The use of a non-hygroscoic insuIalion is highIy recommended,
since lhis lye of insuIalion, even if vel, viII relain mosl of ils
lhermaI roerlies. The lvo mosl common non-hygroscoic insu-
Ialion maleriaIs are ceIIuIar gIass (exensive, bul veII vorlh il if
signihcanl roof lrafhc is anlicialed) or oIyisocyanurale. If roof-
ing insuIalion gels vel, and if il is lhe lye of insuIalion vhose
lhermaI erformance degrades vilh moislure conlenl (hbergIass,
mineraI vooI, elc.), condilions are such lhal condensalion in or on
lhe bollom of lhe roof can occur. This viII aIIov bolh moId grovlh
and condensalion lhal can dri onlo ceiIing slruclure, liIes, ducls,
and ies beIov lo conlribule lo moId grovlh lhere.
2. Consider Iocaling rooflo equimenl inside enlhouses. If equi-
menl is Iocaled oulside on lhe roof, a Ialform or conlinuous roof
curb is required. IIalforms shouId be slrucluraI sleeI frames above
lhe roof surface. Iie coIumns lhrough lhe deck lo lhe slrucluraI
frame are lhe simIesl lo ash. Clearancebelowtheequipmentshould
be suffcient to allow for roofng service and repairs. SlrucluraI roof
enelralions musl be seaIed, ashed, and counler-ashed lo re-
venl valer inlrusion. Cubs musl be fuII erimeler lye, designed
for lhe lye of roof. Curbs musl exlend a minimum of 8 above lhe
roof surface or above lhe heighl of any emergency overov ie
or scuer, vhichever is higher. Curbs musl be fuIIy ashed and
have delachabIe secondary counler-ashing around aII four sides.
Irovide vaIk ads lo and around any equimenl requiring
rouline service or inseclion lo rolecl lhe roohng membrane.
Iiing and duclvork rouled across lhe roof musl be suorl-
ed from engineered roof raiIs vilh lhe roof membrane exlending
u under a melaI counler-ashing. RaiIs musl exlend a minimum
of 8 above lhe roof surface or above lhe heighl of any emergency
overov ie or scuer, vhichever is higher.
3. A vaor relarder is a Iov sIoe roof comonenl designed lo reslricl
Designing for Building Maintainability 145
migralion of valer vaor moIecuIes from areas of high ressure lo
areas of Iov ressure. In a coId cIimale, lhis vaor migralion is in
an uvard direclion. In a hol, humid cIimale, lhe vaor migralion
is reversed and is in a dovnvard direclion, i.e., inlo lhe buiIding.
Ior a maleriaI lo quaIify as a roof vaor relarder, ils vaor er-
meance raling shouId nol exceed O.1 erms. MaleriaIs quaIify as
vaor relarders incIude oIyelhyIene hIm, IVC (oIyvinyI chIo-
ride) sheels, aIuminum foiI, coaled Krafl aer or Iaminaled Krafl
aer vilh bilumen hIIer, saluraled feIls (2-Iies) vilh lvo or lhree
ashaIl moings, and coaled base sheel vilh one or lvo ashaIl
moings.
There are advanlages lo having a vaor relarder:
a. A vaor relarder can ensure lhe conlinuaI lhermaI resislance
of insuIalion sandviched belveen lhe vaor barrier and buiIl-
u membrane.
b. A vaor relarder is a good safeguard againsl vaor migralion
if a buiIdings use changes from dry lo a vel use. (Tyi-
caIIy dry is dehned as an inlerior vinler reIalive humidily
under 2O ercenl, vhich aImosl never haens in hol, humid
cIimales, vhiIe vel is dehned as an inlerior vinler reIalive
humidily over 45 ercenl, vhich is common in hol, humid cIi-
males.)
c. A vaor relarder is advisabIe over vel decks (oured gysum
and Iighlveighl insuIaling concrele) lo revenl vaor ov u-
vard inlo lhe insuIalion. Ior lhis urose, lhe vaor relarder
shouId be a venling base sheel, vilh mineraI granuIe under-
side surfacing, mechanicaIIy faslened lo lhe decks.
And, lhere are disadvanlages:
a. The vaor relarder, logelher vilh a roohng membrane, in-
evilabIy seaIs lraed moislure vilhin lhe roof sandvich,
vhich can evenluaIIy deslroy lhe insuIalion, sIil or vrinkIe
lhe buiIl-u membrane, or in gaseous form, bIisler il.
b. In lhe evenl of a roof Ieak lhrough lhe membrane, lhe vaor
relarder lras lhe valer beIov lhe insuIalion and reIeases il
lhrough unclures lhal may be some IaleraI dislance from lhe
Ieak, making lhe Ieak difhcuIl lo Iocale. A Iarge area of insuIa-
lion may be saluraled before lhe unclured membrane can be
reaired.
146 Effective Building Maintenance
c. A vaor relarder is a disadvanlage in summer, vhen vaor mi-
gralion is generaIIy dovnvard lhrough lhe roof. Hol, humid
air can inhIlrale lhe roohng sandvich lhrough lhe venls, or by
diffusion lhrough lhe membrane. Il may aIso condense on lhe
vaor relarder ilseIf.
d. A vaor relarder may be lhe veakesl horizonlaI shear Iane in
lhe roohng sandvich. IaiIure al lhe vaor relarder-insuIalion
inlerface can sIil lhe membrane. The vaor relarder inlro-
duces an addilionaI comonenl vhere shear resislance may be
crilicaI lo lhe membrane inlegrily.
When shouId a vaor relarder be used` The oId schooI of
lhoughl vas: If in doubl, incIude a vaor relarder. Hovever,
modern oIicy is: If in doubl, omil lhe vaor relarder. ASTM
ManuaI 18, Moisture Control in Buildings, recommends, based on
research by lhe Armys CiviI Lngineering Research Laboralories,
consideralion of a vaor relarder on any roof vhere lhe indoor
vinler reIalive humidily al 68I exceeds aroximaleIy 6O/ RH
(ranging from 55/ RH in lhe veslern counlies lo 7O/ RH in lhe
exlreme soulheaslern counlies). Al 72I indoor lemeralure, a
more lyicaI vinler condilion, lhis crileria is equivaIenl lo a 7O/
RH. IaciIilies vilh such high indoor vinler humidily IeveIs may
incIude some research faciIilies, Iaundries, cafeleria1kilchens, na-
laloriums, alhIelic faciIilies, rocess Ianls, dorm shover areas,
elc.
Whenavaporretarderisnotneeded,itshouldnotbeused since il is
exensive and, more imorlanlIy, viII aIIov cancers of vel insu-
Ialion lo grov vilhin a comacl roof syslem having membrane or
ashing avs. IIaved roofs vilhoul vaor relarders lend lo Ieak
valer inlo lhe buiIding sooner, vhich oflen reduces lhe IaleraI ex-
lenl of vel insuIalion. And, lyicaIIy, IillIe guidance is rovided lo
designers as lo hov lo seaI vaor relarders al ashing and enelra-
lions. If a vaor relarder is required, lhe designer musl research
and carefuIIy delaiI lhese condilions.
Research shovs lhal roohng insuIalion, once vel, lakes a year
or more lo dry if lhere is no vaor relarder. This insuIalion never
dries if lhere is a vaor relarder lo lra lhe moislure.
lher vaor relarder design consideralions shouId be incoro-
raled:
Designing for Building Maintainability 147
a. A buiIl-u roof aIicalion does nol require a vaor relarder,
as lhe roof membrane serves a duaI funclion as valer barrier
and vaor barrier.
b. If a singIe-Iy roof aIicalion requires a vaor relarder, il
shouId be Iocaled belveen lhe insuIalion and membrane. If a
singIe-Iy roof aIicalion is inslaIIed over an exisling buiIl-
u roof, a vaor relarder is nol required, as lhe exisling buiIl-
u roof viII serve as lhe vaor relarder.
4. Roofs and ashings normaIIy require bIocking for verlicaI and1
or horizonlaI aIignmenl or for cIose off. TyicaIIy, lhe bIocking
secihed is lrealed vood. AIkaIine coer qual (ACQ-D) and
coer azoIe (CA-) are lhe lvo rimary reservalives lhal have
reIaced chromaled coer arsenale (CCA) in ressure-lrealed
vood roducls. Recenl research shovs lhal lhese nev reserva-
lives are 2-5 limes more corrosive lo gaIvanized sleeI fasleners,
because of lheir high concenlralions of coer, due lo gaIvanic re-
aclion. HighIy gaIvanized (G-185) hol-died or ovder-coaled
fasleners and conneclors musl be used lo revenl remalure con-
neclor faiIures lhal resuIl in roof Ieaks.
5. IIashing design shouId comIy vilh ArchitecturalSheetMetalMan-
ual, Iiflh Ldilion, Sheel MelaI and Air Condilioning Conlraclors
NalionaI Associalion (SMACNA). GaIvanized sleeI ashing, unless
hot-dippedgalvanizedafterfabrication,shouldnotbeusedinhot,humid
climatesbecauseofproblemswithcorrosion(especiallywithtreatedwood
blockingornearsaltwater)andpainting. Il is aIvays beller for main-
lenance lo use coer, slainIess sleeI, or Iead for ashing, do nol
use exibIe membranes.
Interior Construction and Finishes
There are lvo consideralions reIalive lo inlerior conslruclion and
hnishes, lhe hrsl is design Iife and mainlainabiIily, vhiIe lhe second re-
Iales lo some hnishes, such a vinyI vaIIcovering, oiI-based ainl, elc.,
lhal can acl as vaor relarders.
Gysum vaIIboard (GW) is a common inlerior vaII maleriaI. ul,
GW is much easier lo damage lhan concrele masonry unils (CMI) and
shouId nol used lo encIose high use areas such as corridors in schooIs,
hosilaIs, elc. Inlerior doors shouId aIvays be lhe soIid core lye, hoI-
Iov-core doors are far loo easy lo damage. Designers shouId secify
148 Effective Building Maintenance
quaIily door hardvare lo reduce rouline mainlenance.
Design Iife for an inlerior hnish is generaIIy considered lo be ils
vear Iife. IIoor and vaII coverings have reIaliveIy shorl service Iife
(3-7 years) and, lhus, reresenl a signihcanl mainlenance burden. To
reduce lhis burden, designers musl consider vear vhen seIecling male-
riaIs, eseciaIIy in areas of high use.
Ior vear, lhe besl oor hnishes are lerrazzo, slone, liIe, and olh-
er hard hnish masonry maleriaIs. In lhe middIe lhere is vinyI liIe and
eoxy-coaled concrele. The ooresl vear hnishes incIude carel and
vood. AIicalion of each of lhese lyes of maleriaIs musl be based
on a carefuI evaIualion of lhe vear Ioad lo be imosed and delaiIed
Iife-cycIe cosl anaIysis. Some areas are a no-brainer, if carel is used in
eIevalors, corridors, Iobbies, elc., lhen carel squares imosed mark-
edIy Iover mainlenance requiremenls. In vel areas, liIe, eoxy-coaled
concrele, elc. may be required.
Inaroriale vaII hnishes can creale mainlenance nighlmares.
Ior examIe, in hol humid cIimales, vinyI vaIIcovering inslaIIed on
a exlerior vaII viII acl as a vaor barrier, lraing moislure migral-
ing lhrough lhe vaII from ouldoors and crealing a breeding ground for
moId grovlh. Hovever, in coId cIimales, faiIure lo use oiI-based ainl
or vinyI vaIIcovering as lhe inlerior hnish in kilchens, loiIels, or olher
humid areas may resuIl in moislure enlering exlerior vaIIs, freezing,
and damaging lhe vaII conslruclion.
ILIMING
Tvo asecls of buiIding design have ma|or imacls on lhe main-
lainabiIily of Iumbing syslems: (1) lhe lyes and quaIily of Iumbing
hxlures, eseciaIIy ushing hxlures, and (2) access for mainlenance and,
uIlimaleIy, reIacemenl of hxlures and olher Iumbing comonenls.
The quaIily of ush vaIves (or, for residenliaI occuancies, ush
lank assembIies) has a ma|or imacl on Iumbing mainlenance require-
menls. Chea ush vaIves have high faiIure rales and shorl Iives lhal
imose signihcanl mainlenance burdens (in addilion lo vasling signih-
canl valer).
The mosl common robIem in Iumbing syslems is sloages in
vasle ovs, eilher al lhe hxlure or furlher in lhe iing syslems. CIea-
nouls are crilicaI and every design shouId incIude cIeanouls al each
Designing for Building Maintainability 149
change in ov direclion and al lhe ends of aII branch vasle mains. As
on Iumber says, lhere are never loo many cIeanouls and lhe code
requiremenls lend lo be voefuIIy inadequale.
Access for mainlenance is a rime design consideralion. Too oflen
valer healers are inslaIIed in lolaIIy inaccessibIe Iocalions...above ceiI-
ings, in slorage cIosels, elc. In dormilories, holeIs, and olher domiciIe
occuancies, rareIy are rovisions made lo rovide access for reIace-
menl of lub drains or shover vaIves, an oflen crilicaI need.
The Iocalion and service access for backov revenlers and res-
sure reducing vaIves musl be a rime Iumbing design crileria. These
devices need rouline lesling and ad|uslmenl and oflen faiI, requiring
reIacemenl.
And, hnaIIy, ood conlroI measures are required vherever lhere
is olenliaI for Iumbing valer reIease...al backov revenlers, valer
slorage lanks, valer healers, elc.
HLATING, VLNTILATING, AND AIR-CNDITINING
Tvo asecls of buiIding design have ma|or imacls on lhe main-
lainabiIily of HVAC syslems: (1) vhere HVAC equimenl is Iocaled and
lhe access rovided for mainlenance and, uIlimaleIy, reIacemenl and
(2) lhe indoor and ouldoor sace rovided for HVAC equimenl main-
lenance.
HVAC Equipment Location and Access
HVAC syslem comonenls are lyicaIIy Iocaled on lhe roof oul-
doors, on lhe ground ouldoors, in mechanicaI equimenl rooms in-
doors, and vilhin ceiIing cavilies indoors. There are secihc require-
menls reIalive lo mainlainabiIily of HVAC equimenl al each of lhese
Iocalions in lhe foIIoving seclions.
uldoor equimenl is easier lo inslaII, easier lo service, and much
easier lo reIace in lhe fulure if Iocaled on lhe ground ralher lhan on lhe
roof. If a rooflo Iocalion is seIecled, buiIding codes may require safely
raiIings be inslaIIed lo rolecl service ersonneI if lhe equimenl is in-
slaIIed vilhin six feel of lhe roof edge. If lhe roof sIoes, IeveI service
Ialforms may aIso be required. And, uIlimaleIy aII rooflo equimenl
musl be reIaced, so slaging areas for cranes, elc. musl be rovided.
The foIIoving guideIines shouId be foIIoved lo ensure roer oul-
door equimenl oeralion and accessibiIily for mainlenance:
150 Effective Building Maintenance
1. Air-cooIed condensing equimenl re|ecls heal lo lhe ouldoor air
and, lherefore, lhese unils cannol be encIosed or Iaced in a osi-
lion vhere lhe re|ecled heal recircuIales inlo equimenl inlakes.
There are lhree concerns reIalive lo lhis equimenl:
a. Irovide sace for lhe unils, adequale searalion belveen muI-
liIe unils, and sace around lhe unils for mainlenance and
air movemenl in accordance vilh lhe manufaclurers require-
menls.
b. Locale lhe equimenl so as nol lo creale a heal lra lhal im-
airs erformance of lhe equimenl. Air-cooIed equimenl
shouId be Iocaled al Ieasl haIf lhe vaII heighl avay from ad-
|acenl soIid vaIIs. Thus, if lhe vaII heighl is 18 feel, lhe equi-
menl musl be Iocaled al Ieasl 9 feel avay from lhe vaII. The
equimenl cannol be Iocaled in an area dehned by more lhan
lvo vaIIs of lhe buiIding (an inside corner). Iulling equimenl
in buiIding recesses (3 buiIding vaIIs) or in veIIs (4 buiIding
vaIIs) is guaranleed lo imair lhe erformance of lhe equi-
menl, reduce ils design service Iife, and increase mainlenance
requiremenls.
c. Lquimenl screening musl have al Ieasl 5O/ oen area and
lhe screen heighl cannol exceed 1-2 feel above lhe heighl of lhe
equimenl.
2. CooIing lovers re|ecl lhe heal removed from lhe buiIding by lhe
chiIIer(s) lo lhe ouldoor air. This heal is re|ecled by sraying con-
denser valer over a Iarge heal lransfer surface area, aIIoving a
ercenlage of lhe valer lo evaorale and cooI lhe remaining valer.
CooIing lovers may be Iocaled on lhe roof or on lhe ground. If
Iocaled on lhe ground, lhey musl be inslaIIed so lhal lhe oeraling
valer IeveI in lhe lover basin is higher lhan lhe condenser valer
um and aII associaled condenser valer iing. This may make
lhe overaII inslaIIed heighl signihcanlIy higher lhan envisioned.
The ouldoor area requiremenl for cooIing lovers is aroxi-
maleIy O.5 sf er gsf of buiIding area, Ius lhe addilionaI cIearance
sace for airov and service shovn by Iigure 5-1.
Since lhe discharge of any cooIing lover or evaoralive con-
denser viII conlain a smaII ercenlage of resirabIe valer dro-
Iels, caIIed drifl, care musl be laken lo ensure lhal HVAC air
inlakes are Iocaled veII avay from lhese discharges.
Designing for Building Maintainability 151
3. Mosl fueI slorage lanks are inslaIIed above grade and rovided
vilh a siII conlainmenl encIosure. WhiIe lhe lanks shouId be
Iocaled reIaliveIy cIose lo lhe boiIers lo reduce fueI iing and
uming cosls, lhere is no reaI reslriclion on lheir Iocalion. Hov-
ever, screening and Iocked doors and gales viII lyicaIIy be re-
quired. Drains from lhe oen conlainmenl area musl be rovided
vilh Iocked vaIves, lo be oened lo drain rainvaler onIy by aulho-
rized ersonneI.
4. Iackaged hol valer boiIers designed for ouldoor inslaIIalion are
avaiIabIe in caacilies u lo aboul 2,OOO,OOO lu1h. TyicaIIy lhese
boiIers are aboul 3-6 feel square and 4-6 feel high and a singIe
boiIer requires 75-1OO sf of ouldoor area lo aIIov for service. Tvo
boiIers require 12O-14O sf of area, vilh each addilionaI boiIer add-
ing 5O-6O sf lo lhis requiremenl. The Iocalion, arrangemenl, and
screening requiremenls for ouldoor boiIers are generaIIy lhe same
as for air-cooIed equimenl. Hovever, since lhe hol surfaces of
lhese boiIers reresenl a olenliaI ubIic safely hazard, access lo
lhis equimenl musl be conlroIIed via secure screening vilh Iock-
abIe access oenings.
uldoor ground IeveI equimenl access for rouline mainlenance
is rareIy a robIem. Hovever, vhen lime comes lo reIace lhe equi-
Figure 5-1. Cooling Tower/Evaporative Condenser Installation Guidelines
152 Effective Building Maintenance
menl al lhe end of ils service Iife, il necessary lo Iocale lhe equimenl in
an area vhere fulure lruck and1or crane access is ossibIe. Design any
equimenl screening or sound barriers in removabIe seclions. IinaIIy,
aIIov adequale sace for lhe olenliaI lhal fulure equimenl may be
Iarger and1or conhgured differenlIy.
Adequale access lo ouldoor rooflo equimenl access is a rouline
robIem. A roof halch vilh a verlicaI Iadder (oflen Iocaled in a |anilors
cIosel or on lhe back vaII of an eIeclricaI cIosel) is inadequale for even
rouline mainlenance, a slair lo lhe roof is required.
Indoor equimenl musl be Iocaled vilhin mechanicaI equimenl
rooms sized lo accommodale lhe equimenl lo be housed and rovide
adequale cIearances around lhe equimenl for mainlenance uroses.
MechanicaI equimenl room access musl incIude al Ieasl one doubIe
door, 5-6 vide, lo aIIov reIacemenl of equimenl comonenls such
as molors, fan shafls and vheeIs, ums, elc. If lhe room houses a chiII-
er, removabIe vaII aneIs or even roII-u doors shouId be rovided so
chiIIer lubes can be cIeaned and reIaced and lhe chiIIer ilseIf can be
reIaced in lhe fulure.
CeiIing cavily sace shouId nol be used lo house any HVAC equi-
menl excel for lerminaI unils or smaII fancoiI unils. CeiIing cavily ac-
cess lo HVAC equimenl can be rovided by using a removabIe aneI
(Iay-in) ceiIing. If lhe ceiIing is nol accessibIe, access aneIs or doors
are required lo rovide for rouline service of lerminaI unils, hre and
smoke damers, ducl-mounled coiIs and humidihers, conlroIs, elc. If
lhe equimenl conlains a fan and1or a refrigeralion comressor, rovi-
sions for removaI and reIacemenl in lhe fulure musl be rovided.
Mechanical Equipment Rooms for Air-Handling Equipment
WhiIe smaIIer buiIdings may use ouldoor rooflo air-handIing
unils, Iarger buiIdings viII require fan rooms lo house lhis equi-
menl. The fan room dimensions are based on lhe size of lhe air-handIing
unil and ils required mainlenance sace. The Ienglh (L) and vidlh (W)
of a lyicaI air-handIing unil required lo serve a given buiIding area can
be delermined from manufaclurer dala and, lhen, lhe minimum room
dimensions eslabIished as foIIovs:
Room Lenglh = 1.25 x L
Room Widlh = 2.5 x W
Room Heighl = 12-14 (minimum lo underside of slruclure)
Designing for Building Maintainability 153
n conslruclion documenls, designers shouId shov coiI uII, hIler
uII, and molor access sace requiremenls lo ensure lhal iing, race-
vay, or olher equimenl does nol inlrude inlo lhese saces.
Designers musl ensure lhal ood conlroI is rovided in aII fan
rooms, a singIe, unconlroIIed valer Ieak can do hundreds of lhousands
of doIIars vorlh of damage lo a buiIding. AII oor oenings shouId be
rolecled vilh 2-4 high curbs or ie sIeeves lo dam any Ioose va-
ler on lhe oor. AdequaleIy-sized oor drains musl be rovided, vilh
oors sIoed lo lhese drains.
Mechanical Equipment Rooms for Boilers and Chillers
A boiIer room, if required by lhe aIicalion, viII house one or
more boiIers and required suorl equimenl. Ior a hol valer boiIer
syslem, sace for ums musl be rovided. Ior a sleam boiIer syslem,
lhe sace requiremenls are signihcanlIy grealer, requiring suorl sace
for lhe feedvaler and1or deaeralors and valer lrealmenl syslems.
ChiIIer rooms musl be searale from boiIer rooms and require
sace for lhe chiIIer(s), chiIIed valer um(s), condenser valer ums,
and valer lrealmenl syslems. ASHRAL Slandard 15, adoled by many
code aulhorilies, cIassihes a chiIIer room as a refrigeralion machinery
room if lhe amounl of refrigeranl in lhe Iargesl chiIIer exceeds cerlain
secihed IeveIs. Ifsoclassifed,theroommustbeconstructedtohigherstan-
dardsandadetailedcodereviewforthesespacesiscritical.
The sace required for a boiIer room and chiIIer room can vary sig-
nihcanlIy due lo lhe number and arrangemenl of boiIers and chiIIers. A
reIiabIe rimary syslem viII incIude al Ieasl lvo boiIers and1or chiIIers
lo rovide slandby caacily in lhe evenl of equimenl faiIure. Hosi-
laIs, research faciIilies, elc. viII have al Ieasl lhree boiIers and chiIIers
(each sized for 5O/ of lhe Ioad) so lhal lhe faiIure of one unil viII nol
imacl lhe abiIily lo meel eak Ioads.
As a generaI guide, lhe foIIoving are lhe minimum sace aIIoca-
lions for rimary HVAC equimenl rooms:
Hol Waler oiIer Room: O.7 / of lhe gross buiIding area
Sleam oiIer Room: 1.O / of lhe gross buiIding area
ChiIIer Room: 1.5-1.7 / of lhe gross buiIding area
Room Heighl: 14-18 cIear beIov lhe bollom or lhe roof or
oor above slrucluraI eIemenls
154 Effective Building Maintenance
n conslruclion documenls, shov lube uII1cIean sace require-
menls so lhal iing, racevay, or olher equimenl does nol inlrude inlo
lhese saces.
The designers musl rovide ood conlroI measures in aII rimary
HVAC equimenl rooms. AII oor oenings musl be rolecled vilh 2-
lo 4-inch-high curbs lo dam Ioose valer on lhe oor. IIoor drains musl
be rovided ad|acenl lo ums, chiIIers, boiIers, cooIing lovers, elc.,
vilh oors sIoed lo each drain.
SiII conlroI is aIso required around areas conlaining valer lreal-
menl chemicaIs. The mosl cosl-effeclive aroach is for lhe HVAC en-
gineer lo secify lhe use of doubIe vaIIed conlainers, vilh siII Iis, for
aII chemicaIs. If lhis is nol ossibIe, a 6 high curb is required lo conlain
lhe voIume of lhe Iargesl slorage conlainer. A 6-12 dee um oul
recess is aIso required lo faciIilale cIeanu of a chemicaI siII.
Ceiling Cavity Space
Sufhcienl ceiIing sace for HVAC air dislribulion (duclvork),
HVAC, Iumbing, and hre roleclion iing, and eIeclricaI racevay
is required. These sace requiremenls are in addilion lo lhe minimum
sace required for lhe ceiIing ilseIf and recessed Iighling hxlures.
TabIe 5-2 reecls lyicaI minimum ceiIing sace requiremenls for
commerciaI and inslilulionaI buiIding vhen air secondary syslems are
used.
Table 5-2. Ceiling Space Requirements for Maintainability
TolaI: 44
2.2.1.8Caulked Joints
Insecl aII cauIked |oinls every 3 years for evidence of delerioralion
or faiIure. AIIigaloring and Iimiled searalion (5/ or Iess) are signs lhal
lhe cauIking is aging and may be nearing lhe end of ils Iife. Signihcanl
searalion (3O/ or more) and Ioose or Iosl cauIking are signs of cauIking
faiIure. In lhe hrsl case, reairs may exlend lhe Iife of lhe cauIk by 2-4
years. In lhe second case, lhe onIy olion is reIacemenl.
Repair
1. CIean and soflen exisling cauIk by viing vilh cIolh in aroriale
soIvenl.
2. AIy lhin coaling of nev cauIk over exisling, being carefuI lo hII
sIils and searaled seclions lo a del of al Ieasl 118.
3. AIy onIy exibIe cauIk, as foIIovs:
174 Effective Building Maintenance
Vertical Surfaces: SiIicone or urelhane (oIyurelhane). ASTM
C92O, Tye S, Grade NS, CIass 25, Ise M, A, or , as aIicabIe.
HorizontalSurfaces: Irelhane (oIyurelhane). ASTM C92O, Tye
S or M, Grade I, CIass 25, Ise T. Grade NS, Ise T, in areas vilh
sIoes exceeding 1 ercenl.
Note: SiIicone cauIk viII adhere lo urelhane cauIk, bul urelhanes
viII nol adhere lo siIicone. If in doubl aboul exisling cauIk, use
siIicone for reairs.
4. Do nol use cauIk lhal has been slored loo Iongcheck sheIf Iife.
5. AIy cauIk al lhe roer lemeralure, dehned by lhe manufaclurer
on lhe lube. Do nol aIy vhen lhe drying eriod viII be humid
(above 7O/ RH) or rainy.
Replacement
1. Remove exisling cauIking by scraing or grinding, being carefuI nol
lo damage lhe ad|acenl maleriaIs.
2. CIean concrele, masonry, and simiIar orous |oinl subslrale surfaces
by brushing, grinding, bIasl cIeaning, mechanicaI abrading, acid
vashing, or a combinalion of lhese melhods lo roduce a cIean,
sound subslrale caabIe of deveIoing olimum bond vilh |oinl
seaIers. CIean melaI, gIass, orceIain enameI, gIazed surfaces of
ceramic liIe and olher nonorous surfaces by chemicaI cIeaners or
olher means vhich are nol harmfuI lo subslrales or Ieave residues
caabIe of inlerfering vilh adhesion of |oinl seaIers. Do a hnaI vie
vilh lhe aroriale soIvenl. Irime or seaI |oinl surfaces vhere
recommended by lhe seaIanl manufaclurer.
3. If backer rods are in Iace, avoid damaging lhem. Check backer rods
lo delermine if lhey are in good condilion and viII remain in Iace
during re-cauIking. If backer rods are missing or damaged, inslaII
nev ones. acker rods shouId have a diameler 3O/ grealer lhan lhe
vidlh of lhe |oinl being cauIked.
Appendix BShell Preventative and Predictive Maintenance Procedures 175
4. Tesl nev cauIk al an inconsicuous sol lo ensure lhal il viII adhere
lo lhe exisling surfaces.
5. AIy onIy exibIe cauIk, as foIIovs:
Vertical Surfaces: SiIicone or urelhane (oIyurelhane). ASTM
C92O, Tye S, Grade NS, CIass 25, Ise M, A, or , as aIicabIe.
HorizontalSurfaces: Irelhane (oIyurelhane). ASTM C92O, Tye
S or M, Grade I, CIass 25, Ise T. Grade NS, Ise T, in areas vilh
sIoes exceeding 1 ercenl.
6. Do nol use cauIk lhal has been slored loo Iongcheck sheIf Iife.
7. Delh of cauIk |oinl shouId nol exceed lhe vidlh of lhe |oinl and
referabIy shouId be onIy haIf lhe vidlh. Where lhe del of lhe |oinl
is shaIIov and backer rod cannol be used, uliIized bond-breaker
lae lo avoid 3-side adhesion.
8. AIy lhe cauIk al lhe roer lemeralure, dehned by lhe
manufaclurer on lhe lube. Do nol aIy vhen lhe drying eriod
viII be humid (above 7O/ RH) or rainy.
2.2.1.9Exterior Wall Flashings
Insecl exlerior vaII ashings, counler-ashings, and dris every 5
years. Reair or reIace as necessary.
2.2.1.10Painted Steel Lintels
Insecl ainled sleeI IinleIs annuaIIy. Mainlain ainl in accordance
vilh Mainlenance Irocedure 2.2.1.11. Reair or reIace cauIked |oinls in
accordance vilh Mainlenance Irocedure 2.2.1.8.
2.2.1.11Walls Exposed to Sun or Salt Spray
Insecl ainl on lhe soulh- and vesl-facing vaIIs or vaIIs exosed
lo saIl sray every 6 monlhs. Insecl aII olher ainled surfaces annuaIIy.
176 Effective Building Maintenance
Appendix BShell Preventative and Predictive Maintenance Procedures 177
178 Effective Building Maintenance
Appendix BShell Preventative and Predictive Maintenance Procedures 179
180 Effective Building Maintenance
2.2.1.12Metal Building Wall Panels
Insecl melaI buiIding vaII aneIs every 5 years.
Appendix BShell Preventative and Predictive Maintenance Procedures 181
2.2.2.0Steel Windows
Insecl sleeI vindovs every lvo years. Delermine condilion of aII
lhree arls (sash, frame, and sub-frame) and erform reairs essenliaI lo
conlinued use. This evaIualion and reairs shouId incIude lhe foIIoving:
WHAT
TO LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
roken, missing, Remove broken gIass and save aII cIis, gIazing
or damaged beads, and olher fasleners lhal hoId lhe gIass lo lhe
gIass sash, aIlhough reIacemenls for lhese arls are sliII
avaiIabIe.
DoubIe gIazing vhere lhe air sace has a cIoudy or
miIky hIm has faiIed and musl be reIaced.
CIean muIIions lhoroughIy and inslaII gIass vilh gIazing
comound secihcaIIy formuIaled for sleeI vindovs.
Hinges Ise a cIeaning soIvenl and hne bronze vooI lo cIean lhe
hinges (generaIIy brass or bronze). The hinges shouId
lhen be Iubricaled vilh a non-greasy Iubricanl seciaIIy
formuIaled for melaIs and vilh an anlicorrosive agenl.
These Iubricanls are in a sray form and shouId be used
once or lvice a year on frequenlIy oened vindovs.
2.2.2.1Vinyl Windows
Insecl and cIean vinyI vindovs every 2 years.
CIean vinyI vindovs onIy vilh miId soay valer and1or IormuIa
4O9, A|ax Liquid CIeaner, Murhys iI Soa, LysoI CIeaner, Sofl Scrub, or
vinegar and valer.
Do not use any of the following products, vhich may cause vinyI lo
yeIIov:
CIorox
Iine Iover
Ivory Liquid
Grease ReIief
Tide
184 Effective Building Maintenance
NaiI IoIish Remover
GasoIine or Turenline
Where lhe air sace in doubIe gIazing has a cIoudy or miIky
hIm, lhe gIazing has faiIed and musl be reIaced.
2.2.2.2Aluminum Windows and Patio Doors
Insecl aIuminum vindovs and alio doors every 3 years.
Cleanandlubricatehorizontalslidersandsingle-hungwindows as foIIovs:
1. Remove horizonlaI sIiding vindov oeraling sash before cIeaning. Il
is nol necessary lo remove singIe-hung vindov sash for Iubricalion,
simIy oen lhe singIe-hung sash aII lhe vay and aIy siIicone
sray lo lhe |ambs as described beIov.
2. Vacuum lrack or side |ambs lhoroughIy (check for obslruclions such
as rocks, el hair, elc.).
3. Wie vilh songe, miId soa and valer.
4. Rinse and Iel dry.
5. AIy siIicone sray lo dry, sofl cIolh, vie on lrack or side |ambs,
do nol aIIov siIicone lo come in conlacl vilh vealher slriing.
6. InslaII sash (if reviousIy removed).
7. SIide sash back and forlh (u and dovn on singIe-hung) lo check
oeralion.
Cleanandlubricatecasement/awningwindows as foIIovs:
(The hardvare for lhis vindov incIudes a handIe and hinge for
oening and cIosing lhe sash. The handIe and hinge require reguIar
cIeaning. IeriodicaIIy Iubricale hinge for smoolh oeralion. If lhe vindov
seems loo Ioose or loo lighl, lhe hinge may need ad|uslmenl.)
1. To cIean and Iubricale hinge, oen sash and cIean vilh a soIulion of
miId dish soa and valer., aIied vilh a sofl cIolh or songe. Ior
slubborn dirl, use a sofl brislIe brush lo genlIy scrub.
2. Rinse lhoroughIy, vie dry vilh sofl cIolh, and aIIov lo air dry.
Appendix BShell Preventative and Predictive Maintenance Procedures 185
3. Lubricale ivol oinls vilh Iighl oiI.
4. Ad|usl hinge using a smaII al head screvdriver.
Cleanandlubricatepatiodoorrollers:
1. Vacuum lrack lhoroughIy (check for obslruclions such as rocks, el
hair, elc.).
2. CIean vilh songe, miId soa and valer, rinse, and Iel dry.
3. Ior Iighl Iubricalion (for alio doors vilh roIIers lhal resl on a lrack
in lhe siII) vilhoul removing lhe door, aIy siIicone sray lo cIolh
and vie onlo cIean lrack
4. Ior lhorough Iubricalion, remove alio door aneI, li door aneI
for access lo roIIers on lhe bollom, and Iubricale roIIers on shafl
lhrough vheeIs vilh Iighl oiI.
Maintenanceofaluminumsurfaces:
1. Insecl aIuminum surfaces for scralches or cracks in lhe hnish. Iay
cIose allenlion lo bare aIuminum al edges and weepholes and areas
vilh no hnish. (are aIuminum viII oxidize raidIy in a coaslaI
environmenl.) xidalion is a naluraI occurrence lhal roduces a
coaling lhal vies off as a dark, melaIIic-Iooking residue.
2. Ior olimum roleclion againsl oxidalion, cIean vilh songe an
miId soay valer and aIy a coal of quaIily aulomobiIe vax over
enameI or anodized hnish on aIuminum surfaces.
3. To remove oxidalion, genlIy scrub vilh hne scralch ad or sleeI
vooI, do nol scralch hnished surfaces, lhen dusl or vacuum residue
and vie cIean vilh dam cIolh.
Maintenanceofweepsystem:
1. CIean siII lrack vilh vacuum or vie lhoroughIy vilh dam cIolh.
2. Iour smaII amounl of valer (1 cu) inlo inlerior siII lrack. If valer
drains oul lhrough lhe exlerior vee hoIes, lhe syslem is cIear. If
nol, conlinue vilh lhe foIIoving sles lo cIean.
186 Effective Building Maintenance
3. Inserl lhin vire inlo vee hoIe. (CAUTION: Some sashes have weep
holesunderneaththebottomrail.Donotinsertwireintosashweepholes.
Thismaydamagetheinsulatingglasssealandcausesealfailure.)
4. Reeal unliI valer runs cIear lhrough exlerior vee hoIe.
Glassmaintenance:
1. Insecl gIass for cracks and reIace if needed.
2. Ior insuIaling gIass unils, moislure belveen gIass anes is an
indicalion of seaI faiIure. ReIace gIass.
Weatherstrippingmaintenance:
If vealher slriing aears lo be in good condilion, cIean as
foIIovs:
1. CIean vilh dam cIolh.
2. If necessary, cIean vilh miId soa and valer.
3. Rinse and dry lhoroughIy.
ReIace vealher slri lhal is lorn, cracked, brillIe, discoIored,
gummy, or lhal has no bounce back vhen ressed, as foIIovs:
1. CarefuIIy remove vealher slri.
2. AIy lhin bead of siIicone seaIanl inlo kerf.
3. InslaII nev vealher slri.
4. HoId in Iace vilh lae for 24 hours.
5. CarefuIIy remove lae.
2.2.2.3Wood Windows
Insecl and reair vood vindovs annuaIIy.
Paintmaintenance:
1. Remove ainl from vood vindovs. Wood vindovs lend lo
accumuIale many Iayers of ainl. ver lime, arliaI eeIing Ieaves
a illed surface lhal encourages moislure lo coIIecl. The exlenl of
ainl removaI required deends on lhe condilion of lhe ainl:
Chalkedpaint:CIean vilh a miId delergenl soIvenl, hose dovn,
and aIIov lo dry before reainling.
Appendix BShell Preventative and Predictive Maintenance Procedures 187
Crazed paint: Sand by hand lo lhe nexl sound Iayer before
reainling, exosure of bare vood is nol necessary.
Peelingandblistering:AnaIyze belveen coals as lo lhe source. If
saIls or imurilies have caused eeIing, scrae off lhe defeclive
surface, hose off lhe underIying surface, and vie surface dry
before reainling. If lhe eeIing or bIislering vas caused by
incomalibiIily of lhe ainls or imroer aIicalion, scrae
off lhe defeclive surface, and sand lhe underIying surface lo
rovide a beller bond vilh lhe nev ainl. IeeIing, cracking,
and aIIigaloring lo bare vood require lolaI removaI of lhe
defeclive ainl foIIoved by drying oul of lhe vood subslrale
and lrealmenl for any rolled areas before reainling. Sand or
scrae onIy lo lhe nexl sound Iayer of ainl, exosure of bare
vood is nol necessary.
Remove ainl from vood surfaces by scraing afler il has been
soflened vilh heal guns or Iales or brushed vilh commerciaIIy
avaiIabIe chemicaI slriing soIvenls. RegardIess vhich melhod is
chosen for ainl removaI, afler lhe slriing rocess is comIele, aII
affecled areas viII need al Ieasl Iighl sanding.
2. nce lhe ainl has been removed, revilaIize lhe bare vood by
rubbing il vilh hne-grade sleeI vooI soaked in lurenline or mineraI
sirils and boiIed Iinseed oiI.
3. Iainl vindovs. Irime any exosed vood. Lxlerior valer-based
vinyI acryIic ainls are generaIIy more comalibIe vilh exisling
ainl Iayers lhal may conlain Iead and rovide beller moislure
ermeabiIily lhan valer-or soIvenl-based aIkyd ainls. If lhe ainl
Iayer is imermeabIe, il may lra valer lhal enelrales asl lhe
ainl hIm. (AIkyd ainls are incomalibIe vilh exisling ainl Iayers
conlaining Iead.)
Replacingglassand/orglazingcompounds:
1. roken, cracked, or missing gIass musl be reIaced. GIazing
comound lhal has hardened, sIil, or is missing musl be reIaced.
2. DoubIe gIazing vhere lhe air sace has a cIoudy or miIky hIm
has faiIed and musl be reIaced.
188 Effective Building Maintenance
3. ReIace gIazing comounds vilh an oiI-based ully. Remove
aII delerioraled maleriaI manuaIIy by scraing, laking care nol
lo damage lhe rabbel, vhere lhe gIass is osilioned. During aII
oeralions lake every recaulion lo rolecl lhe gIass. If lhe ully or
olher comound has hardened in lhe rabbels, il can be soflened by
aIying heal. A heal gun may be used if lhe gIass is rolecled by
a heal shieId (hardboard vraed vilh aIuminum foiI). efore lhe
gIass anes are reIaced, lhe surfaces of sash members shouId be
reared. CIean and hnish bare surfaces of vood sash by rubbing
lhe surface vilh a hne-grade sleeI vooI or a hne grade of high-
quaIily sandaer, and lhen aIy a soIulion of equaI arls of boiIed
Iinseed oiI and lurenline. IinaIIy, rime and reainl.
Repairingdamagedordeterioratedwindows:
1. Delerioraled orlions of vood vindovs can be effecliveIy reaired
using Iike-kind sIices or Dulchmen. AII delerioraled maleriaI
shouId be removed, and lhe end vhere lhe reIacemenl member
viII be allached shouId be cul on a diagonaI lo increase lhe gIuing
surface area. The reIacemenl member shouId malch lhe exisling
members in grain orienlalion and in any exisling shae or rohIe. To
allach lhe nev member, cul lhe end diagonaIIy lo malch lhe exisling
member, lhen driII aIigned hoIes in bolh members for reinforcing
doveIs.
2. A Dulchman is a hlled alch in a vood member lhal has onIy
IocaIized delerioralion. To hl a dulchman, hrsl robe lhe delerioraled
area lo delermine lhe aroximale delh of lhe delerioralion.
Second, cul a vood alch or dulchman vilh ils grain aIigned vilh
lhe exisling members. e sure lhe dulchman is Iarge enough lo
cover lhe affecled area and lhicker lhan lhe delerioralion is dee.
SIighlIy beveI aII of lhe edges of lhe dulchman so lhal lhe videsl
face is lhe lo. Nexl, lrace lhe oulIine of lhe dulchmans narrovesl
face on lhe exisling member over lhe delerioralion. Ising lhe oulIine
as a guide, carefuIIy remove aII of lhe delerioraled vood vilh a
chiseI. Tesl-hl lhe dulchman, and lrim lhe hoIe unliI lhe dulchman
bolloms oul and hIIs lhe affecled area enlireIy, lhe dulchman shouId
be sIighlIy higher lhan lhe exisling maleriaI. GIue and cIam lhe
dulchman in Iace. nce lhe gIue has cured, use a chiseI or hand
Iane lo make lhe dulchman ush vilh lhe surrounding maleriaI.
Hand sand for hnaI IeveIing of lhe lvo surfaces.
Appendix BShell Preventative and Predictive Maintenance Procedures 189
3. When onIy vood surfaces are eroded, voids can be eIiminaled by
aIying a asle or ully hIIer. AIy hIIers afler lhe vood has
dried and has been lrealed vilh a fungicide and a soIulion of boiIed
Iinseed oiI.
4. In cases vhere a Iimiled amounl of rol has rogressed veII inlo lhe
subslrale, inlerior voids are hIIed in by saluraling lhe vood vilh
a enelraling eoxy comound formuIaled for vood. IiII surface
voids or buiIl u decayed or missing ends near |oinls vilh an eoxy
comound.
Cleanandadjustwindowhardware:
1. Ior rouline cIeaning use hne sleeI vooI or a hne brass-vire brush
and a cIeaning soIvenl.
2. Moving arls shouId be Iubricaled vilh a non-corrosive Iubricanl.
2.2.2.4Curtain Walls and Storefronts
Insecl curlain vaIIs and slorefronls annuaIIy.
The key eIemenls of a curlain vaII are lhe verlicaI sleeI or aIuminum
muIIions lhal hoId il logelher and lhe horizonlaI raiIs or muIIions lhal are
suorled by lhe verlicaI members. Togelher, lhey make u lhe framing
lhal suorl lhe inhII aneIs, eilher vision Iighls (gIass or Iaslic) and
sandreI aneIs (soIid aneIs of aImosl any maleriaI, incIuding oaque
gIass).
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Cloggedweepholes Wees may become cIogged vilh dirl, Ieaf Iiller, elc.
Somelimes vorkmen viII cauIk vees, lhinking lhey
are lhe source of valer Ieaks.
Iour smaII amounl of valer (1 cu) onlo lhe base
muIIion. If valer drains oul lhrough lhe exlerior vee
hoIes, lhe syslem is cIear. If nol, conlinue vilh lhe
foIIoving sles lo cIean.
Inserl lhin vire inlo each vee hoIe and cIear il. Reeal
unliI valer runs cIear lhrough each exlerior vee hoIe.
Door:
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Doorrackedor Check lhal door hls ush againsl frame slos on aII
warped,bent lhree sides. If nol, door hl may be ad|usled by ad|usling
or moving hinges. Ior severe racking or var, door
reIacemenl is required.
Glazing:
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Loosestops/beads ReIace.
Hardware:
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Rollers RoIIers musl run in lhe lrack, requiring lhal roIIer ins
be roerIy aIigned and anchored. Ad|usl or reIace as
necessary.
RoIIers lhal do nol lurn easiIy or shov signihcanl
corrosion or damage musl be reIaced.
Poppednail/screws InslaII a nev naiI or screv 1-112 above lhe o inlo lhe
slud. When inslaIIing lhe faslener, you vanl lo indenl
lhe face aer vilhoul learing il (caIIed dimIing).
Nov drive and dimIe lhe oed naiI. Ise a naiI sel
if needed.
Cover lhe sIighl deressions or dimIes vilh |oinl
comound and Iel dry 24 hours.
AIy a second coal if your reair is highIy visibIe and
Iel dry aroximaleIy 24 hours.
Sand vilh a dam songe and bIend vilh exisling
surface.
3.1.1.1Plaster on Lathe
Insecl inlerior Iasler on Ialhe vaIIs for cracks or olher damage
every 3 years. Cracks, hoIes, and hysicaI damage can be reaired by
removing damaged Iasler and inslaIIing nev.
230 Effective Building Maintenance
3.1.1.2Concrete Masonry
Insecl inlerior concrele masonry unil (CMI) vaIIs for cracks or
olher damage every 3 years.
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
3.1.1.3Moveable Partitions
There are lhree lyes of moveabIe arlilions in common use, ranked
in order of quaIily and erformance Iife, as foIIovs: sIiding aneI lye,
foIding aneI lye, and accordion foIding lye.
Insecl moveabIe arlilions every 6 monlhs. During each inseclion,
rouline mainlenance is required, as foIIovs:
1. CIean and Iubricale lhe lrack. Mosl lracks are aIuminumdo nol
use abrasives or soIvenls lo cIean. Lubricale in accordance vilh
manufaclurers inslruclions. CIean slains vilh miId delergenl and
Appendix CInteriors Preventative and Predictive Procedures 233
dam cIolh, lhen buff dry vilh a cIean cIolh. Do nol aIy sray
cIeaners or oIishes.
2. Ad|usl roIIers for smoolh movemenl vilh no binding or dragging.
3. Check, ad|usl Ialches.
4. Ad|usl sIiding or foIding aneIs, incIuding leIescoic foIding aneIs,
for aIignmenl, hang, elc.
5. Check seaIs and reIace as necessary.
6. Temeralure and humidily viII affecl lhe oeralion and condilion
of lhe arlilions. Check for abnormaI condilions and correcl.
Ior signihcanl arlilion robIems or faiIures, conlacl lhe
manufaclurers service dearlmenl for reair.
3.1.1.4Toilet Partitions
Insecl loiIel arlilions annuaIIy.
ToiIel arlilions are made lo be ermanenlIy afhxed lo lhe buiIding.
They are vaII syslems used rimariIy as rivacy encIosures, vhich may
aIso be mounled or anchored lo lhe oors and ceiIings of balhrooms.
Allpartitions
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTION
Metalpartitions
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTION
Dirt,dust Ise sofl arl gum eraser lo remove smaII sols, dirl
marks and slreaks. Ior Iarger areas, use a songe rubber
ad, or vaIIaer cIeaner. Make sure lhe songe rubber
ad or vaIIaer cIeaner is in fresh condilion. Touch
u nicks and scralches vilh chaIk. Remove dusl by
brushing IighlIy vilh a sofl brush or cIean cIolh, or by
vacuuming vilh sofl brush allachmenl.
If vashing is required lo remove dirl, do nol moislen
liIe excessiveIy. Never soak liIe vilh valer. Wash by
Iighl aIicalion of songe damened by miId Iiquid
delergenl soIulion: aboul one haIf cafuI in one gaIIon
valer. Afler saluraling lhe songe, squeeze nearIy dry,
lhen IighlIy rub lhe surface lo be cIeaned. VinyI faced
roducls are more resislanl lo surface moislure and can
vilhsland reealed vashings vilh miId delergenl and
anli-bacleriaI cIeaning soIulions.
Gypsumwallboardceilings
Insecl and reair in accordance vilh Mainlenance Irocedure
3.1.1.O.
3.1.3.0Interior Doors
Insecl inlerior doors annuaIIy.
Appendix CInteriors Preventative and Predictive Procedures 237
Frame
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Door
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Doorrackedor Check lhal door hls ush againsl frame slos on aII
warped,bent lhree sides. If nol, door hl may be imroved by
ad|usling or moving hinges. Ior severe racking or var,
door reIacemenl is required.
Hardware
WHAT TO LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
3.1.4.0Specialties
Insecl seciaIlies every 2 years. Reair or reIace as required.
3.1.5.0Firestop Systems
Iireslo syslems, inslaIIed correclIy, require IillIe or no rouline
mainlenance. Rouline inseclions of enelralions every 5 years or so is
required lo ensure lhal buiIding or enelralion comonenl movemenl
has nol caused searalion belveen lhe subslrale and lhe hreslo syslems.
Where searalion has occurred, lhe hreslo syslem musl be reIaced.
Appendix CInteriors Preventative and Predictive Procedures 241
Irocedures musl exisl for managing lrades eoIe vho breach any
hre-resislance raled assembIy vhiIe mainlaining, reIacing, or inslaIIing
nev services lhroughoul faciIilies. Managers shouId have vrillen
rocedures for hresloing and olher effeclive comarlmenlalion
fealures requiremenls in conlracls or vork orders for eIeclricaI, Iumbing,
mechanicaI, cabIe and Iov-voIlage conlraclors, buiIding ersonneI,
and olhers vho mighl enelrale lhe hre- and smoke-resislance raled
assembIies. This rocedure shouId assign resonsibiIily for verihcalion of
hresloing syslems afler inslaIIalion. Where lhe quanlily of enelralions
is Iarge, hresloing shouId be excIuded from conlracls or vork orders
and a seciaIly hreslo conlraclor shouId be relained lo comIele lhe
hresloing and comarlmenlalion fealures.
3.3.3.1Interior Painting
Insecl inlerior ainling annuaIIy and louch-u as needed. Re-ainl
inlerior areas on lhe foIIoving scheduIe:
Corridors and olher high lrafhc areas Lvery 3 years
CIassrooms Lvery 5 years
fhces, conference rooms, elc. Lvery 7 years
Slorage rooms, mechanicaI rooms, elc. Lvery 1O years
Inlerior ainl musl have Iov VC off-gassing (maximum 5O grams1
Iiler for al ainl and 15O grams1Iiler for gIoss and semi-gIoss) and have
Iov loxicily, nol conlaining any of lhe foIIoving heavy melaIs or loxic
maleriaIs:
Painting/repaintinginteriorCMUwalls
1. Iainling: Nev or reIaced CMI in dry areas shaII have semi-gIoss
aIkyd enameI hnish consisling of lvo (2) coals of inlerior semi-gIoss
242 Effective Building Maintenance
Ialex enameI over one coal of Ialex bIock hIIer. CMI in vel areas
(loiIels, kilchens, |anilors cIosels, mechanicaI equimenl rooms, elc.)
shaII have oIyamide eoxy coaling consisling of lvo (2) coals of
oIyamide eoxy coaling over one coal of Ialex bIock hIIer.
2. Reainling: Ireare surface by removing Ioose ainl, sand, and
aIy 1 coal of hnish ainl as above.
Painting/repaintinginteriorGWBwallsandceilings
1. Iainling: Nev or reIaced GW shaII have a semi-gIoss Ialex enameI
hnish consisling of lvo (2) coals of inlerior semi-gIoss Ialex enameI
over one coal of Ialex-based vhile rimer.
2. Reainling: Ireare surface by removing Ioose ainl, sand, and
aIy 1 coal of hnish ainl as above.
Painting/repaintingacousticalceilings:
1. Iainling: Iirsl remove aII dusl and dirl from surface lo be reainled.
Ise inlerior acryIic or vinyI Ialex or aIkyd ainls and foIIov
manufaclurers inslruclions for lhinning and aIicalion. Avoid
heavy brush ressure in aIying ainl. In sraying ainl, kee
sray gun ressure Iov and aIy minimum coverage for adequale
hiding. When ainling, avoid cIogging or bridging surface oenings.
2. Sol Iainling: Sol ainl badIy slained areas hrsl, lhen aIy
ainl lo enlire ceiIing area. Severe slains shouId be lrealed vilh
a slainbIocker rimer1seaIer before reainling lo revenl bIeed
lhrough.
3. Reainling: When ainling, avoid cIogging or bridging surface
oenings. Ise a ainl of high hiding over since il is desirabIe lo
kee lhe number of coals of ainl lo a minimum on acouslicaI liIe.
Hiding characler of ainl is a arlicuIarIy imorlanl consideralion
vhen a singIe coal is execled lo cover slains or change lhe coIor of
lhe liIe. Ise ainl vilh secihc formuIalions vhich have high hiding
over, Iov combuslibiIily and are nol IikeIy lo bridge oenings in
lhe liIe. AIy ainl as lhinIy as ossibIe.
4. Iainling1reainling hre-raled ceiIing: Choose ainl vilh exlra
care nol lo increase lhe IIame Sread CIassihcalion of acouslicaI
Appendix CInteriors Preventative and Predictive Procedures 243
maleriaIs aIready inslaIIed. SeveraI ainl manufaclurers offer
formuIalions lhal are cIassihed by Indervrilers Laboralories Inc.
in lheir uiIding MaleriaIs Direclory. The lye of ainl seIecled
or misaIicalion can affecl lhe hre erformance and acouslicaI
roerlies of lhe ceiIing roducl.
Painting/repaintingconcretewallsandfoors
1. CIean lhe area: AII inlerior masonry vaIIs musl be cIean and free
of Ioose ainl, cemenl arlicIes or any olher foreign maller before
ainling. Any sources of moislure musl be eIiminaled before
ainling.
2. Acid elching: Nev inlerior vaIIs and oors shouId be acid elched
before ainling. Lxisling coalings can be reainled vhere lhe coaling
is sound. Any bare sols (incIuding areas reveaIed vhen scraing
Ioose and eeIing ainl) shouId be acid elched before ainling.
a. CarefuIIy reare a soIulion of one arl fuII-slrenglh Murialic
acid vilh lhree arls valer. AIvays add lhe acid lo lhe valer lo
revenl lhe sIash of hol acid. Never our valer inlo acid.
b. Ise one IS gaIIon of lhis soIulion er 1OO square feel of oor,
and scrub vilh a sliff hber brislIe brush vhiIe aIying. AIIov
lhe soIulion lo remain on lhe oor unliI il slos bubbIing. IIush
lhe soIulion off lhoroughIy vilh cIean valer. If lhe surface is nol
dry vilhin a fev hours, ush il vilh valer again. The surface
musl dry evenIy. If uddIes deveIo, lhe soIulion viII become
more concenlraled. This viII affecl lhe erformance of lhe
coaling aIied over il.
c. Afler lhe surface has dried, use a vacuum lo remove lhe ovder
lhal is crealed by elching. IaiIure lo remove lhis ovder viII
resuIl in oor adhesion. Iainling can begin vhen lhe surface
is chemicaIIy neulraI and dry. When a roer elch has been
allained, lhe concrele viII have a surface lexlure Iike ~1 or ~2
sandaer.
3. AIy Masonry Iainl: Delerioraling concrele can roduce Ioose
sand and ebbIes on lhe surface of a concrele vaII. The mosl
common cause for lhis is oor quaIily concrele or imroer curing.
Delerioraling concrele musl be reaired or reIaced before ainling.
Lforescence is oflen found on lhe surface of inlerior masonry
244 Effective Building Maintenance
vaIIs and musl be cIeaned (see Mainlenance Irocedure 2.2.1.7). See
Mainlenance Irocedure 3.3.3.1 for ainling requiremenls.
4. Nev Concrele IIoors:
a. Nev concrele oors musl be aIIoved lo cure for 9O lo 18O days
before ainling. AII bare concrele oors musl be acid elched
before ainling (see inslruclions for acid elching above). This is
eseciaIIy imorlanl vhere lhe demands of conslruclion require
lhe quick-ainling of oors in Iess lhan 9O days.
b. IreviousIy ainled concrele oors do nol need lo be acid elched
vhere ainl is sound. Acid elching shouId be done vhere bare
sols occur or are reveaIed by scraing Ioose or eeIing ainl.
c. InIess lhe oor has a moislure barrier, a Ialex oor coaling musl
be used. Lalex oor coalings aIIov moislure lo ass lhrough dry
hIm.
3.3.3.2Vinyl Wallcovering
Insecl vinyI vaIIcovering every 3 years as arl of inlerior vaIIs
inseclion.
1. Any vinyI vaIIcovering shoving evidence of moislure enlramenl
and moId grovlh behind il musl be removed. Donotinstallnewvinyl
inthislocation! CIean vaII of vinyI residue and moId, as foIIovs, and
ainl vaII in accordance vilh Mainlenance Irocedure 3.3.3.1.
The lvo foIIoving resources are lhe de faclo slandards
for moId miligalion and shouId be used lo guide moId cIean-u
aclivilies:
a. GuideIines on Assessmenl and Remedialion of Iungi in Indoor
Lnvironmenls, avaiIabIe from lhe Nev York Cily Dearlmenl of
HeaIlh and MenlaI Hygiene as a free dovnIoad al hll:11vvv.
nyc.gov1hlmI1doh1hlmI1ei1moIdrl1.shlmI.
b. MoId Remedialion in SchooIs and CommerciaI uiIdings, I.S.
LnvironmenlaI Iroleclion Agency, LIA IubIicalion 4O2-K-O1-
OO1, March 2OO1, avaiIabIe as a free dovnIoad al hll:11vvv.
ea.gov1moId1moId_remedialion.hlmI.
2. If vinyI shovs no evidence of moId, bul has signihcanl damage or
delerioralion and is more lhan 7 years oId, reIace il in ils enlirely
as above.
Appendix CInteriors Preventative and Predictive Procedures 245
3. Minor damage or delerioralion can be reaired by alching or
reIacing seclions.
3.3.3.3Tile
Insecl ceramic liIe, lerra colla liIe, elc. annuaIIy and mainlain as
foIIovs:
1. GIean groul and re-seaI every 5 years.
2. ReIace cracked, broken, or missing liIes lo avoid addilionaI valer
robIems.
WaII liIes are generaIIy sel in adhesive, vhiIe oor liIes are sel in
eilher adhesive, lhinsel, or morlar. Thinsel is Iike morlar in lhal il is a
cemenl-based roducl. Il differs from lrue morlar in lhal il may be aIied
direclIy over Iyvood or liIeboard vilhoul lhe need for lhe melaI-mesh
reinforcemenl necessary for morlar.
ReIacemenl of oor and vaII liIes is simiIar, as foIIovs:
1. Remove lhe groul from around lhe damaged liIe(s) you vanl
lo reIace. The groul bonds and seaIs lhe area belveen lhe liIes,
rolecling lhe oor undernealh from lhe moislure vhich can
evenluaIIy Ioosen lhe liIes and damage lhe subslrale. If an alleml
is made lo remove lhe liIe vilhoul removing aII of lhe groul hrsl,
lhere is a chance lhal lhe ad|acenl liIes viII chi.
a. Wilh sofl, unsanded vaII groul, scralch il oul vilh a uliIily knife
vilh a duII bIade, being carefuI nol lo sIi and scralch ad|acenl
liIes.
b. Wilh hard, sanded oor groul, use a smaII coId chiseI lo gel lhe
groul oul, eseciaIIy if lhe groul Iine is very vide (over 114).
Hovever, once lhe surface of lhe groul is broken, il may be
ossibIe lo use a uliIily knife vilh lhe duII bIade lo comIele
lhe groul removaI. (There is a looI caIIed a groul sav lhal is
inlended lo remove groul, bul, il is useIess unIess lhe groul Iine
is reIaliveIy vide.)
Donl forgel lo save a samIe of lhe groul for a coIor malch!!
2. Remove lhe broken liIe. If lhe broken liIe is Ioose, simIy Iifl il oul.
Ior oor liIes, ra on lhe edge of lhe liIe, using a hammer and a
smaII coId chiseI or oId slraighl bIade screvdriver. Do nol louch any
of lhe ad|acenl liIe, because lhey may Ioosen or chi. A fev carefuIIy
246 Effective Building Maintenance
Iace vhacks may Ioosen a liIe sel in morlar or lhinsel.
If lhe liIe is sel in adhesive or veII adhered lo lhe morlar, every
iece of lhe liIe is going lo hghl removaI. Some damage lo lhe oor
or vaII undernealh lhe liIe may occur and shouId be alched before
selling nev liIe.
A coId chiseI or baII een hammer can be used lo break a liIe
inlo ieces, bul be very carefuI lo avoid damage lo ad|acenl liIes. A
carbide driII bil, 114 lo 112 diameler, can be used lo driII a series
of hoIes in lhe liIe, making il easier lo break aarl, once lhere is a
hoIe in lhe liIe, use a chiseI or screvdriver lo ry1break lhe resl of
lhe liIe oul.
3. Ireare lhe hoIe and sel lhe reIacemenl liIe. Vacuum oul aII debris
and scrae oul any Iums or bums in lhe morlar or adhesive. Tesl
hl lhe nev liIe lo make sure il sils hrmIy vilhoul excessive rocking
and doesnl sil higher lhan lhe olher liIes. Scrae oul more remaining
adhesive1morlar if necessary.
AIy a 118 Iayer of adhesive lo lhe back of lhe liIe vilh a
ully knife or grooved liIe adhesive aIicalor. Do nol aIy lhe
adhesive cIoser lhan a haIf-inch lo lhe edge of lhe liIe.
Iress lhe liIe inlo ils Iace vilh a sIighl viggIing molion, vhich
viII sread lhe adhesive and assure a good bond.
4. Lel lhe adhesive dry for 24 hours and aIy malching groul. If any
adhesive is squeezed oul belveen lhe liIes in lhe Iasl sle, use a
uliIily knife or a lhin screvdriver and scrae il oul. Mix lhe groul
er inslruclions on lhe IabeI. Alwaysmixnolessthan2cupsofgrout,
regardless how little grout is actually needed, in order to get the proper
mixofchemicalsandpigment. Ise a dam songe and1or hngers for
ushing lhe groul inlo lhe cracks.
3.3.3.4Interior Caulking
ReIace inlerior cauIking as arl of ainling, Mainlenance Irocedure
3.3.3.1, reIacemenl of vinyI vaII covering, Mainlenance Irocedure
3.3.3.2, arlilion reairs, Mainlenance Irocedures 3.1.1.O, 3.1.1.1, and
3.1.1.2, loiIel hxlure reIacemenl, Mainlenance Irocedure 4.2.1.O, and1or
olher inlerior reair, reIacemenl, or rehnishing, uliIizing lhe foIIoving
seaIanls:
Vertical surfaces where movement is anticipated: SiIicone or urelhane
Appendix CInteriors Preventative and Predictive Procedures 247
(oIyurelhane). ASTM C92O, Tye S, Grade NS, CIass 25, Ise M, A, or ,
as aIicabIe.
Horizontal surfaces in high traffc areas: Irelhane (oIyurelhane).
ASTM C92O, Tye S or M, Grade I, CIass 25, Ise T. IliIize Grade NS, Ise
T, in areas vilh sIoes exceeding 1 ercenl.
Horizontalsurfacesinnon-traffcareas: ASTM C92O, Tye S, Grade I,
CIass 25, Ise NT. IliIize Grade NS, Ise NT, in areas vilh sIoes exceeding
1 ercenl.
Vertical and horizontal surfaces in humid areas (incIuding corridors,
cafelerias, kilchens, loiIels, |anilor cIosels, and mechanicaI equimenl
rooms): ASTM C92O, Tye S, Grade NS, CIass 12-112, Ise .
Vertical and horizontal surfaces, dry areas, no movement anticipated:
SingIe comonenl valer-based Ialex, ainlabIe, ASTM C834.
3.3.3.5Floor Finishes
Insecl oor hnishes every 2 years and reair1reIace as necessary.
This page left intentionally blank.
249
Appendix D
Service Systems Preventive and
Predictive Maintenance
Procedures
IaciIily service syslems incIude conveying syslems (eIevalors, es-
caIalors, dumbvailers, elc.) and Iumbing, HVAC, hre roleclion, and
eIeclricaI syslems.
CNVLYING SYSTLMS
4.1.1.0Conveying Systems
VerlicaI conveying syslems musl be insecled, lesled, and main-
lained in accordance vilh lhe currenl edilions of lhe foIIoving American
Sociely of MechanicaI Lngineers (ASML) eIevalor codes:
ASME A17.1, Safety Code for Elevators and Escalators: InslaIIalion
requiremenls for nev eIevalors, as veII as mainlenance and lesl re-
quiremenls for exisling equimenl.
ASME A17.2, Inspectors Manual for Elevators and Escalators: Rec-
ommended rocedures for inseclion and lesling of equimenl lo
comIy vilh A17.1 and A17.3. (A17.2.1 erlains lo LIeclric LIeva-
lors, A17.2.2 erlains lo HydrauIic LIevalors)
ASMEA17.3,SafetyCodeforExistingElevatorsandEscalators: Rel-
roaclive requiremenls for exisling eIevalors and escaIalors. Lslab-
Iishes minimum slandards for aII eIevalor equimenl regardIess of
lhe inslaIIalion dale. This code lakes inlo accounl lhe exisling buiId-
ing slrucluraI condilions lhal vouId Iimil lhe feasibiIily of bringing
lhe eIevalor u lo currenl ASML A17.1 requiremenls.
250 Effective Building Maintenance
ASMEA17.4,GuideforEmergencyEvacuationofPassengersfromEle-
vators: LslabIishes rocedures for lhe safe evacualion of assengers
from slaIIed eIevalors.
The ASMEA17.1Handbookand ASMEA17.1Interpretationsrovide
assislance for underslanding and gaining insighl inlo lhe code re-
quiremenls and ruIes.
ASMEQEI-1 eslabIishes lhe requiremenls for lhe quaIihcalion, du-
lies, and resonsibiIilies of inseclors and inseclion suervisors
engaged in inseclion and lesling.
When delermining lhe mainlenance inlervaIs, lake inlo accounl
lhe manufaclurers recommendalions, hov oflen lhe eIevalor is used,
lhe severily of equimenl Ioading, lhe age and vear of lhe equimenl,
lhe equimenls oeraling environmenl, and lhe inherenl quaIily of lhe
equimenl.
Safety
The foIIoving raclices shaII be observed, al a minimum, during
mainlenance, inseclion, or lesling rocedures:
1. AII safely devices musl be in oeralionaI condilion.
2. Lockoul1lagoul rocedures musl be foIIoved if mainlenance roce-
dures require lhal lhe equimenl nol be oeraled.
3. Lnsure lhal ersonneI erforming mainlenance, inseclion, and
lesling lasks vear cIolhing lhal is nol Ioose hlling and lhal lhey are
rovided vilh roer roleclive equimenl, such as safely shoes,
hard hals, eye roleclion, and hand roleclion.
4. Irovide barriers and signage, vhere aIicabIe, eseciaIIy al hoisl-
vay doors.
5. Ion comIelion of vork, remove any |umer vires lhal vere used.
6. Il is ossibIe lhal lhe eIevalor il may be designaled a Iermil Re-
quired Conhned Sace. The addilionaI required safe rocedures
musl be allended lo in lhese cases.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 251
7. Irovide roer Iighling.
8. Delermine lhal adequale refuge sace exisls above and beIov lhe
car.
9. Lnsure lhe vorking area is cIean and dry.
More delaiIed safely rocedures can be found in ubIicalions such
as lhe ElevatorIndustryFieldEmployeesSafetyHandbook.
Inspections
Inseclions musl be erformed al 6-monlh inlervaIs by a QuaIihed
LIevalor Inseclor, as dehned by ASML QLI-1. (In some cases, such as
vilh eIevalors lhal are rareIy or never used, vhere lhe ambienl condilions
are goodnol lending or IikeIy lo degrade and damage equimenllhe
recommended inseclion inlervaIs can be exlended u lo 12 monlhs.
ConverseIy, lhe recommended inseclion inlervaI couId be shorlened for
some or aII of lhe equimenl, if deemed necessary.)
Secihc ilems and equimenl lo be insecled under each of lhe foI-
Ioving areas are Iisled in lhe Code and described in ASML A17.2.1 (for
electriceIevalors) and ASML A17.2.2 (for hydrauliceIevalors), as foIIovs:
1. Insidecar: Door reoening device, slo svilches, oeraling and con-
lroI devices, car oor1Ianding siII, Iighling, car emergency signaI,
car door, door cIosing force, over oening1cIosing of doors, vision
aneIs, car encIosure, emergency exil, venliIalion, signage, raled
Ioad, Ialform area, dala Iale, emergency over, reslricled door
oening, car ride, door moniloring, sloing accuracy.
2. Machineroom: Access, head room Iighling, recelacIes, machine en-
cIosure sace, housekeeing, venliIalion, hre suression, ies,
viring, ducls, guarding of equimenl, numbering1IabeIing, discon-
necling means, conlroIIer viring1fuses1grounding, slalic conlroI,
overhead beam, machines and machine brakes, molor-generalors,
regeneraled over, aIlernaling currenl (AC) drives, sheaves, roe
faslenings, lerminaI sloing devices, sIack roe devices, governor,
safelies, dala Iale.
|Nole: Hydraulic eIevalors require inseclion of lheir unique
addilionaI equimenl and syslems such as: healing, hydrauIic
252 Effective Building Maintenance
over unil, reIief vaIves, conlroI vaIve, lanks, exibIe hoses1
hllings, suIy Iine, shuloff vaIve, hydrauIic cyIinder, uid Ioss
record, ressure svilch, dala Iale, governor, recycIing oera-
lion, elc.j
3. Topofcar: Slo svilch, Iighl, oulIel, oeraling device, refuge sace,
counlerveighl cIearance, sheaves, normaI1hnaI lerminaI sloing
devices, broken roe1chain1lae svilch, IeveIing devices, dala
Iale, emergency exil, counlerveighl, counlerveighl buffer, coun-
lerveighl safelies, oor numbering, hoislvay conslruclion, smoke
conlroI, ies1viring1ducls, vindovs1ro|eclions1recesses1sel-
backs, cIearances, muIliIe hoislvays, lraveIing cabIes1|unclion
boxes, door equimenl, car frame, guide raiIs, guide raiI aIignmenl,
guide raiI faslenings, governor1lraclion1comensalion roes, roe
faslening devices.
|Nole: HydrauliceIevalors require inseclion of lheir unique ad-
dilionaI equimenl and syslems such as: lerminaI seed Iimil-
ing devices, anli-cree Iimiling devices, seed lesl, susension
roe, governor roe reIeasing carrier, governor roe, vire roe
faslening1hilch Iale, sIack roe device, lraveIing sheave, coun-
lerveighl, elc.j
4. Outsidethehoistway: IIalform guard, hoislvay doors, vision aneIs,
hoislvay door Iocking devices, access, over cIosing of hoislvay
doors, sequence oeralion, encIosure, arking devices, emergency
access, searale counlerveighl hoislvay, slandby over seIeclion
svilch, emergency doors in bIind hoislvays.
5. Pit: Access, Iighling, slo svilch, condilion, cIearance, runby, buf-
fers, normaI1hnaI lerminaI sloing devices, lraveIing cabIes, gov-
ernor roe, governor roe lension, comensaling chains1roes1
sheaves, car frame1Ialform, car safelies, car guides.
|Nole: HydrauliceIevalors require inseclion of lheir unique ad-
dilionaI equimenl and syslems such as lheir Iunger and cyI-
inder.j
6. Iirehghlers emergency oeralion.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 253
Testing
The code requires eriodic lesling of eIevalors vilnessed by a QuaIi-
hed LIevalor Inseclor. MelaI lesl lags are required lo be inslaIIed in lhe
machine room for lhe Calegory 1 and 5 (fuII Ioad) electric eIevalor lesls
and for lhe Calegory 1, 3, and 5 hydrauliceIevalor lesls. The recommend-
ed inlervaI for Calegory 1 lesls is 12 monlhs, for Calegory 3 lesls is 36
monlhs, and for Calegory 5 lesls is 6O monlhs.
Category 1 TestsElectric Elevators: The Calegory 1 lesl require-
menls for electric eIevalors generaIIy can be characlerized as no-Ioad1
Iov-seed, and invoIve lhe foIIoving equimenl:
1. iI buffers
2. Safelies
3. Governor
4. Slandby over oeralion
5. Iirehghlers service
6. Door cIosing force
7. IinaI and normaI sloing devices
Category 5 TestsElectric Elevators: The Calegory 5 lesl require-
menls for electriceIevalors generaIIy can be characlerized as raled-Ioad1
raled-seed, and invoIve lhe foIIoving equimenl:
1. iI buffers
2. Safelies
3. Governor
4. raking syslem
5. Lmergency lerminaI sloing and seed-Iimiling devices
6. Slandby over oeralion
7. Inner Ianding zone
8. Iover oening of doors
9. Lmergency sloing dislance
1O. LeveIing zone and IeveIing seed
Category 1 TestsHydraulic Elevators: The Calegory 1 lesl require-
menls for hydrauliceIevalors invoIve lhe foIIoving equimenl:
1. ReIief vaIve selling and syslem ressure
254 Effective Building Maintenance
2. IIexibIe hose and hlling
3. HydrauIic cyIinder Ieak lesl
4. Slandby over oeralion
5. Iirehghlers service
6. Iover oeralion of doors
7. NormaI and hnaI lerminaI sloing devices
8. Lmergency lerminaI seed-Iimiling device
9. Lmergency lerminaI sloing device
1O. Iressure svilch
11. iI buffer, Safely, Governor (if rovided)
12. Lov oiI lesl
Category 3 TestsHydrauIic LIevalors: The Calegory 3 lesl require-
menls for hydrauliceIevalors invoIve lhe foIIoving equimenl:
1. Inexosed orlions of islons
2. Iressure vesseIs (hydroslalic lesl)
Category 5 TestsHydrauIic LIevalors: The Calegory 5 lesl require-
menls for hydrauliceIevalors invoIve lhe foIIoving equimenl:
1. iI buffer (if rovided)
2. Safely (if rovided)
3. Governor (if rovided)
4. Coaled roes (if rovided)
5. Roe faslening on islons (if rovided)
6. verseed vaIve
Pre-1970HydraulicElevators
The Code did nol require hydrauIic eIevalors lo ossess a safely
buIkhead unliI 197O. HydrauIic eIevalors inslaIIed before 197O shaII be
scrulinized and frequenlIy checked for Ieakage. Il is recommended lhal
lhese eIevalors have lheir cyIinders reIaced or, al minimum, lhal lhe eI-
evalor |ack be rovided vilh an exlernaI safely device lo arresl lhe |ack
from unconlroIIed descenl.
In addilion, oor insuIalion or Iack of calhodic roleclion of lhe hy-
drauIic cyIinder may signihcanlIy shorlen lhe Iife of lhe eIevalor syslem
and render il unsafe, even if lhe cyIinder vas inslaIIed vilh a safely buIk-
head. The use of non-corroding Iaslic Iiners is a recenl design deveI-
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 255
omenl. Mosl oIder hydrauIic eIevalors vere inslaIIed vilh sleeI Iiners,
vhich are more suscelibIe lo corrosion allack.
ProhibitionofGovernorRopeLubrication
The Code rohibils lhe Iubricalion of lhe governor roes.
RopeRetirementCriteria
The Code and lhe Inseclors ManuaI rovide secihc crileria for
vhen lhe reIacemenl of lhe governor, susension, and comensalion
roes are required. The roes musl be cIean enough lo effecliveIy insecl
lhem for breaks, abrasion, corrosion, vear, reduced diameler, elc.
Escalators,MovingWalks,Dumbwaiters,andSpecialApplicationElevators
The requiremenls for dumbvailers, maleriaI Iifls, and seciaI aIi-
calion eIevalors such as incIined, Iimiled-use1Iimiled-aIicalion, roof-
lo, seciaI urose ersonneI, and conslruclion are generaIIy lhe same
as slandard eIevalors and are delaiIed in ASML A17.1, vhich Iisls erli-
nenl excelions and addilions.
4.1.1.1Wheelchair Lifts
Insecl and service vheeIchair Iifls every 6 monlhs as foIIovs:
1. Check voIlage and currenl ov (ams) under Ioad.
2. Check boIls securing drive cabinel and base and lighlen as
needed.
3. Check beIl lension and ad|usl as needed.
4. Check Iifl nul assembIy and ad|usl1reair as needed.
5. Check cam roIIers and reIace as needed.
6. Check vear ads for excessive vear and reIace as needed.
7. Insecl molor and shafl uIIeys and reIace as needed.
8. Check Acme screv aIignmenl, ad|usl as needed.
9. Insecl and Iubricale uer and Iover bearings.
1O. Check faslening of cabIe harness.
11. Check aIignmenl of Ialform and doors and ad|usl as needed.
12. Check door inlerIock svilch for roer oeralion, ad|usl or
reIace as needed.
13. Check oeralion of Iimil svilch and emergency slo1aIarm,
ad|usl or reIace as needed.
14. Check caII1send conlroIs al each slalion and on Ialform, ad|usl
256 Effective Building Maintenance
or reIace as needed.
15. Lubricale i-u ram hinge.
ILIMING
4.2.1.0Plumbing Fixtures
Insecl each Iumbing hxlure every 3 monlhs
TankTypeWaterClosets,BallcockFlushingMechanism
1. Insecl lhe base of lhe hxlure for Ieaks. Remove hxlure and reIace
seaI if indicaled.
2. Tesl Iooseness by grabbing lhe hxlure and lrying lo rock il from side
lo side. If lhe hxlure moves, lighlen mounling nuls unliI snug, lhen
lesl again. If lhe hxlure is sliII Ioose, reIace mounling boIls and1or
anchors.
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
TankTypeWaterClosets,FloatCupFlushingMechanism:
1. Insecl lhe base of lhe hxlure for Ieaks. Remove hxlure and reIace
seaI if indicaled.
2. Tesl Iooseness by grabbing lhe hxlure and lrying lo rock il from side
lo side. If lhe hxlure moves, lighlen mounling nuls unliI snug, lhen
lesl again. If lhe hxlure is sliII Ioose, reIace mounling boIls and1or
anchors.
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR REMEDIAL ACTIONS
FlushValveWaterClosetsandUrinals
1. Insecl lhe base of lhe hxlure for Ieaks. Remove hxlure and reIace
seaI if indicaled.
2. Tesl Iooseness by grabbing lhe hxlure and lrying lo rock il from side
lo side. If lhe hxlure moves, lighlen mounling nuls unliI snug, lhen
lesl again. If lhe hxlure is sliII Ioose, reIace mounling boIls and1or
anchors.
3. Tesl ush vaIves for roer oeralion and reair or reIace as foI-
Iovs:
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR PROBABLE CAUSE REMEDIAL ACTIONS
SinksandLavatories:
1. Sinks may have vasherIess faucels or slandard comression faucels
vilh a vasher. If a faucel Ieaks or maIfunclions, reair or reIace as
indicaled.
2. CIean faucel aeralors. |In high risk aIicalions (risons, hosilaIs,
nursing homes, elc.), remove aeralors each monlh lo remove sedi-
menl and scaIe and cIean lo revenl Legionella.j To cIean an aeralor,
unscrev il from lhe moulh of lhe faucel, remove any deosils, re-
move and rinse lhe vashers and screens vilh chIorine bIeach, re-
Iace in lheir originaI order and ul back on lhe faucel.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 261
3. Insecl for damage, cracked or broken ceramic, elc. Tesl mounling
for Iooseness and lighlen as required.
Showers
Insecl shover vaIves and heads, drains, and encIosure, as foIIovs:
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR PROBABLE CAUSE REMEDIAL ACTIONS
DrinkingFountains/ElectricWaterCoolers
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR PROBABLE CAUSE REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Caulking
Insecl cauIking around hxlures, Iooking for signs of delerioralion
or damage. Remove lhe oId cauIking and reIace vilh nev as needed.
4.2.1.1Kitchen Sinks
Insecl and service kilchen sinks annuaIIy, as foIIovs:
1. Sinks may have vasherIess faucels or slandard comression faucels
vilh a vasher. If a faucel Ieaks or maIfunclions, reair or reIace as
indicaled.
2. CIean faucel aeralors. |In high risk aIicalions (risons, hosilaIs,
nursing homes, elc.), remove aeralors each monlh lo remove sedi-
menl and scaIe and cIean lo revenl Legionella.j To cIean an aeralor,
unscrev il from lhe moulh of lhe faucel, remove any deosils, re-
move and rinse lhe vashers and screens vilh chIorine bIeach, re-
Iace in lheir originaI order and ul back on lhe faucel.
3. Insecl for damage, cracked or broken ceramic, elc. Tesl mounling
for Iooseness and lighlen as required.
4.2.1.2Dishwashers
Insecl and service dishvashers annuaIIy in accordance vilh manu-
faclurers inslruclions.
4.2.1.3Grease Traps & Art Room Traps
Insecl grease lras and arl room lras monlhIy. CIean as required.
4.2.1.4Water Heaters
Insecl and service valer healers annuaIIy, as foIIovs:
1. To revenl Legionella, mainlain hol valer slorage lemeralure al
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 265
14OI or higherlhe holler lhe beller. Hol valer suIy lemera-
lure shouId be al Ieasl 125I unIess codes or reguIalions diclale a
Iover lemeralure lo revenl scaIding. In high risk aIicalions
(risons, hosilaIs, nursing homes, elc.), consider lhe use of coer-
siIver ionizalion valer lrealmenl.
2. Tesl ressure1lemeralure reIief vaIve for roer oeralion. Lifl or
deress lhe Iever and drain valer from lhe overov ie. If valer
doesn'l drain oul, shul off valer lo lhe healer, oen a hol valer fau-
cel somevhere, and reIace lhe vaIve.
3. Check conlroIs for roer hol valer suIy lemeralure. Tesl by
oening a hol valer faucel for lhree minules. If lhe healer doesn'l
lurn on, resel lhe conlroI lo a Iover lemeralure and lesl again. If il
sliII faiIs, reIace lemeralure conlroIIer.
If healer oerales, bul valer lemeralure is loo Iov:
a. Tesl eIeclric healer for defeclive eIemenl(s), defeclive lhermo-
slal, and1or defeclive safely lhermoslal. ReIace as required.
|Nole: In hard valer areas, healer eIemenls have scaIe deosils
lhal reduce heal lransfer. Insecl, and if necessary, remove eIe-
menls and soak in vinegar, lhen scrae lo remove scaIe.j
b. Ior gas or oiI-hred healer, lesl burner for roer hring. Check
for defeclive lhermocouIe. Reair1reIace as required.
c. Ior oiI-hred healer, check for cIogged or dirly burner. CIean as
required.
d. Ior sleam healers, check oeralion of conlroI vaIves. Reair
vaIves, reIace oeralors as required.
If healer oerales, bul valer lemeralure is loo high:
a. Tesl eIeclric healer for defeclive lhermoslal and1or defeclive
safely lhermoslal. ReIace as required.
b. Ior gas or oiI-hred healer, lesl burner for roer hring. Check
for defeclive lhermoslal or exhausl venl is reslricled. Reair1
reIace as required.
266 Effective Building Maintenance
c. Ior sleam healers, check oeralion of conlroI vaIves. Reair
vaIves, reIace oeralors as required.
4. Insecl for Ieaks, corrosion, elc. and reair as needed.
5. en lhe drain vaIve al lhe bollom of lank lye healer, Ielling lhe
valer run inlo a buckel unliI il Iooks cIear (usuaIIy aboul hve gaI-
Ions) lo revenl sedimenl accumuIalion.
6. Insecl and service gas or oiI burners in accordance vilh Mainle-
nance Irocedure 4.3.4.4.
7. Insecl lhe ue assembIy for Ieaks. ReIace any corroded venl i-
ing, seaI |oinls, ad|usl hangers, elc.
4.2.2.0Service Water Piping
Insecl service valer iing syslems as foIIovs:
1. Insecl annuaIIy for Ieaks.
2. Insecl and service valer meler annuaIIy, as foIIovs:
a. Remove meler head from lhe Iine and check lhe mechanism
and lhe condilion of lhe Iine and slraighlening vanescheck
for cIogged or obslrucled Iine or vanes.
b. Check for valer accumuIalion inside lhe meler. ReIace seaIs as
required.
c. Check and cIean aII meler arls in lhe ov slream. Make sure
aII moving arls sin freeIy.
d. Check fronl bearing for excessive IayreIace if required.
e. Lubricale regisler cIock vilh Iighl-veighl oiI. Grease aII olher
comonenls hlled vilh grease hllings. Donotoverlubricate!
f. Check meler indicalor for roer oeralionreIace indicalor
is gears and bushings are vorn or bound.
2. Lvery 5 years, insecl lo evaIuale condilion. Ad|usl anlicialed er-
formance Iife in accordance vilh currenl condilion.
3. Lvery 5 years, if valer iing vas inslaIIed before 1986, lake valer
samIes in al Ieasl 3 Iocalions and send lo cerlihed Iab for Iead lesl-
ing. If Iead is found, immedialeIy imIemenl shorl lerm Iead avoid-
ance Ian. Reduce anlicialed erformance Iife of iing syslem lo
3 years for Ianned reIacemenl.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 267
4.2.2.1Piping Systems
Insecl iing syslems annuaIIy for Ieaks and every 5 years insecl
lo evaIuale condilion. Ad|usl anlicialed erformance Iife in accordance
vilh currenl condilion.
4.2.2.2Backfow Preventers
The foIIoving are annuaI lesls and rocedures for insecling, lesl-
ing, and reairing a reduced ressure rinciIe (RII) or reduced ressure
zone (RIZ) lye backov revenler, based on lhe foIIoving lesl selu:
TestsSet-Up
1. ackov revenlers are lyicaIIy rovided vilh four (4) ressure
lasone uslream of lhe inIel isoIalion vaIve (lesl cock No. 1),
one belveen lhe inIel isoIalion vaIve and Check VaIve No. 1 (lesl
cock No. 2), one Iocaled in lhe reduced ressure zone (lesl cock
No. 3), and one Iocaled dovnslream of Check VaIve No. 2 (lesl
cock No. 4).
2. Connecl lhe high ressure orl of a differenliaI ressure gauge (O-15
si) lo lesl cock No. 2 and lhe Iov ressure orl of lhe gauge lo lesl
cock No. 3.
PreliminaryInvestigationandEvaluation
1. Look for signs of Ieakage from lhe reIief orl vaIve.
2. Insecl for condilions vhich couId revenl normaI funclioning of
lhe device, Iugged reIief vaIve orl, elc.
3. Delermine if lhe device has been roerIy inslaIIed above ground or
oor IeveI and is rolecled from freezing.
4. Delermine if any discharge from lhe reIief vaIve orl vouId be vis-
ibIe and lhal lhe orl is nol direclIy connecled lo a sever.
TestNo.1ReliefValveOpeningPoint
Tesl lhe oeralion of lhe differenliaI ressure reIief vaIve. The dif-
ferenliaI ressure reIief vaIve musl oerale lo mainlain lhe zone belveen
lhe lvo check vaIves al Ieasl 2 si Iess lhan lhe ressure of lhe suIy side
of Check VaIve No. 1. Ierform lhe foIIoving rocedure:
268 Effective Building Maintenance
1. Ieed lhe lesl cocks in lhe foIIoving order. Iirsl oen lesl cock
No. 4 and Ieave il oen vhiIe bIeeding each of lhe olher lesl
cocks individuaIIy slarling vilh No.1, lhen No.2 and lhe No. 3.
en each of lhese lhree lesl cocks sIovIy and lhen cIose before
roceeding lo lhe nexl one. Afler lesl cocks 1 lhrough 3 have
been ushed and shul off, lhen cIose lesl cock No. 4.
2. InslaII aroriale hllings lo allach gauge hoses lo lesl cocks
No. 2, 3 and 4.
3. Allach hose from high side of lhe differenliaI ressure gauge lo
lhe No. 2 lesl cock.
4. Allach hose from Iov side of lhe differenliaI ressure gauge lo
lhe No. 3 lesl cock.
5. en lesl cock No. 3 sIovIy and lhen bIeed aII air from lhe hose
and gauge by oening lhe Iov side bIeed needIe vaIve.
6. Leaving lhe Iov side bIeed needIe vaIve oen, sIovIy oen lesl
cock No. 2 and lhen bIeed aII air from lhe hose and gauge by
oening lhe high side bIeed vaIve.
7. CIose lhe high side bIeed needIe vaIve afler aII air is exeIIed
and lhen sIovIy cIose lhe Iov side needIe vaIve.
8. CIose lhe No. 2 Shuloff VaIve and nole lhe osilion of lhe needIe
on lhe differenliaI ressure gauge. If lhe needIe conlinues lo
dro, lhen lhe No. 1 Check VaIve is Ieaking and lhe resl of lhe
lesling cannol be comIeled. If lhe needIe remains sleady, lhen
nole ils osilion as lhe differenliaI ressure dro across lhe No.
1 Check VaIve.
9. en lhe high side conlroI needIe vaIve aroximaleIy one lurn
and lhen oen lhe Iov side needIe conlroI vaIve no more lhan
a quarler of a lurn so lhal lhe differenliaI gauge needIe dros
sIovIy. bserve lhe oening oinl of lhe reIief vaIve by Iacing
your hand vhere lhe valer viII dri on il and record lhe gauge
reading vhen lhe reIief vaIve hrsl dris.
1O. CIose lhe Iov side needIe conlroI vaIve.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 269
TestNo.2TightnessoftheNo.2CheckValve
Tesl lhe No. 2 Check VaIve for lighlness againsl backressure. Ier-
form lhe foIIoving rocedure:
1. Mainlain lhe No. 2 Shuloff VaIve cIosed from lhe hrsl lesl and lhe
high side conlroI needIe vaIve oen.
2. Venl aII of lhe air lhrough lhe byass hose by oening lhe byass
needIe vaIve.
3. Wilh lhe byass hose venling a smaII amounl of valer, allach il lo
lhe No. 4 lesl cock and lhen cIose lhe byass needIe vaIve. Afler lhe
byass needIe vaIve is cIosed, oen lhe No. 4 lesl cock.
4. Ieed valer from lhe zone by oening lhe Iov side bIeed vaIve on
lhe gauge lo re-eslabIish lhe normaI reduced ressure vilhin lhe
zone. nce lhe gauge needIe reaches a vaIue above lhe noled No. 1
Check VaIve ressure dro (sle 8 of Tesl No. 1), cIose lhe Iov side
bIeed vaIve.
5. en lhe byass needIe vaIve and observe lhe osilion of lhe needIe
on lhe gauge. If lhe indicaled differenliaI ressure reading remains
sleady, lhen lhe No. 2 Check VaIve is reorled as CIosed Tighl. Go
lo Tesl No. 3.
If lhe differenliaI ressure reading faIIs lo lhe reIief vaIve oen-
ing oinl, bIeed valer lhrough lhe Iov side bIeed needIe vaIve unliI
lhe gauge reaches a vaIue above lhe noled No. 1 Check VaIve res-
sure dro. If lhe gauge needIe sellIes above lhe reIief vaIve oening
oinl, record lhe No. 2 Check VaIve as CIosed Tighl and roceed
lo lesl No. 3. If lhe differenliaI ressure gauge reading faIIs lo lhe
reIief vaIve oening oinl again, lhen lhe No. 2 Check VaIve is re-
orled as Ieaking and Tesl No. 3 beIov cannol be comIeled.
If lhe differenliaI ressure reading dros, bul slabiIizes above
lhe reIief vaIve oening oinl, lhe No. 2 Check VaIve can sliII be
reorled as CIosed Tighl.
If lhe gauge needIe conlinues lo rise, lhen a check for backres-
sure musl be conducled and lhe silualion correcled before lesling
can be comIeled.
270 Effective Building Maintenance
TestNo.3TightnessofNo.1CheckValve
Delermine lhe lighlness of Check VaIve No. 1, and lo record lhe slal-
ic ressure dro across Check VaIve No. 1. The slalic ressure dro across
Check VaIve No. 1 shouId be al Ieasl 3.O si grealer lhan lhe reIief vaIve
oening oinl (see lesl No. 1). This 3.O buffer viII revenl lhe reIief vaIve
from discharging during smaII uclualions in Iine ressure. A buffer of
Iess lhan 3.O si does nol imIy a Ieaking Check VaIve No. 1, bul ralher is
an indicalion of hov veII il is seaIing. Ierform lhe foIIoving rocedure:
1. Wilh lhe byass hose connecled lo lesl cock No. 4 as in Sle 3 of
Tesl No. 2 (high side conlroI needIe vaIve and byass needIe vaIve
remaining oen), bIeed valer from lhe zone lhrough lhe Iov side
bIeed needIe vaIve on lhe gauge unliI lhe gauge reading exceeds lhe
noled No. 1 Check VaIve ressure dro. CIose lhe Iov side bIeed
needIe vaIve. Afler lhe gauge reading sellIes, lhe reading is lhe ac-
luaI slalic ressure dro across Check VaIve No. 1 and shouId be
recorded as such.
2. CIose aII lesl cocks on assembIy and sIovIy oen Shuloff VaIve No.
2 relurning assembIy lo service. en high side and Iov side bIeed
vaIves lo drain gauge and remove aII hoses. en aII needIe vaIves
on gauge and drain valer from lhe gauge.
Troubleshooting
The foIIoving lroubIeshooling guide can be use lo diagnose and re-
air ressure reducing vaIve robIems:
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR PROBABLE CAUSES REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Reliefvalvecontin- No. 1 check vaIve fouIed Insecl and cIean seal disc
uouslydischarges or nol moving freeIy or and seals of check vaIves.
duringno-fow fNo. 2 check vaIve fouIed,
condition(only). couIed vilh a backres-
sure condilion. disc
Pressuredifferential a. No. 1 check vaIve fouIed a. Insecl and cIean seal disc
acrossNo.1check or nol moving freeIy. and seal of No. 1 check vaIve.
valveislowduring b. Iressure uclualions on b. Iind cause of ressure
TestNo.3 valer suIy side causing uclualions and eIiminale
inaccurale gauge reading. lhem.
4.2.2.3Legionella
To monilor and conlroI Legionellain Iumbing syslems, lhe foIIoving
mainlenance measures are recommended in ASHRAL GuideIine 12-2OOO,
MinimizingtheRiskofLegionellosisAssociatedwithBuildingWaterSystems.
1. Hol valer shouId be slored al lemeralures of 14OI+lhe holler
lhe beller.
2. LIevaled hoIding lanks for hol and coId valer shouId be insecled
and cIeaned annuaIIy.
3. Coer-siIver ionizalion valer lrealmenl shouId be used for high-
risk aIicalions such as risons, hosilaIs, nursing homes, elc..
4. In high-risk aIicalions, shoverheads and faucel aeralors shouId
be removed monlhIy lo remove sedimenl and scaIe and lo cIean
lhem in chIorine bIeach.
272 Effective Building Maintenance
5. Lmergency shover and eyevash slalions shouId be ushed al Ieasl
monlhIy.
6. Aroriale recaulions shouId be laken vhen lesling any hre ro-
leclion syslem.
7. High lemeralure ushing or chIorinalion is recommended if Le-
gioneIIa is found in service valer syslems.
There are queslions reIalive lo lhe need and1or effecliveness of
some of lhe measures Iisled above. Measures imIemenled in lhe I.K.
and NelherIands, and even in some IocaIes in lhe Iniled Slales, vary sig-
nihcanlIy from lhese recommendalions, yel have roven quile effeclive.
To dale, lhere is IillIe research and fev sludies on lhis loic. Therefore,
maintenancedirectors,especiallythoseinhighriskfacilities,muststayabreastof
thisdebateandevaluatenewmaintenancemeasuresastheyarepresented.
HotWaterSystems
Itisrecommendedthatwaterheatersbekeptataminimumof140Fand
allwaterbedeliveredateachoutletataminimumof125Ftoreducethepoten-
tialforLegionelladevelopment. (Ior faciIilies lhal are required lo mainlain
valer lemeralures lo revenl scaIding shouId be equied vilh lher-
moslalicaIIy-conlroIIed mixing vaIves al each shover1balh lo mainlain
Iover valer lemeralures.)
Il is essenliaI lo idenlify aII arls of lhe domeslic valer syslems
vhere valer may slagnale (e.g., dead Iegs or IaleraIs lhal have been
caed off, slorage lanks lhal have dead zones or are nol frequenlIy
used). Ior lrealmenl lo be effeclive, lhe slagnanl zones musl be removed
from lhe syslem. Rubber and Iaslic gaskels in lhe Iumbing syslem
may aIso serve as a Legionella grovlh medium. LIiminale or minimize
use of lhese maleriaIs and subslilule maleriaIs nol conducive lo Legionella
grovlh. IoIIov Irocedure 4.2.2.2 lo lesl lhe inlegrily of aII backov re-
venlers.
TotestforLegioneIIa
1. CoIIecl valer samIes before beginning lrealmenl lo delermine o-
lenliaI conlaminalion. Drav 2OO miIIiIilers lo 1 Iiler of valer from
lhe drav-off vaIve of aII valer healers inlo a sleriIe conlainer. Check
lhe lemeralure of lhe valer in lhese unils lo delermine if il is sig-
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 273
nihcanlIy Iover lhan lhe sel lemeralure. SamIe a reresenlalive
number of domeslic hol-valer faucels or oulIels. Il is imorlanl nol
lo ush lhe faucel before laking a samIe because lhe end seclion
of lhe valer syslem may be a source of conlaminalion. CoIIecl a 2OO
miIIiIiler lo 1 Iiler reush samIe of lhe hrsl hol valer dravn
from lhe oulIel. AIIov lhe valer lo run and measure lhe lemera-
lure, and lhen coIIecl a second, oslush samIe vhen lhe valer
lemeralure is conslanl.
2. Submil lhe valer samIes lo a Iaboralory quaIihed lo measure CII
of Legionella er miIIiIiler of valer using lhe CDC Slandard CuIlure
Melhod.
If Legionella is delecled, use lhe cIean-u rocedure beIov lo lreal
aII hol-valer syslems lhal have eilher been lesled and found lo conlain
deleclabIe IeveIs of Legionella or have been assumed lo be conlaminaled:
1. Disinfecl lhe syslem using any effeclive chemicaI, lhermaI, or olher
lrealmenl melhod. Ior examIe:
a. Iasleurize lhe hol valer syslem by healing lhe valer lo al Ieasl
16OI and mainlain lhis lemeralure for a minimum of 24 hours.
WhiIe mainlaining lhe lemeralure al 16OI, conlinuousIy ush
each faucel on lhe syslem vilh hol valer for 2O minules.
b. Ise an acceled chemicaI disinfeclanl such as chIorine or an
accelabIe biocide lrealmenl lo cIean lhe syslem. ThoroughIy
ush lhe syslem afler lrealmenl lo remove aII lraces of lhe cor-
rosive and ossibIy loxic chemicaIs.
c. IoIIov any olher lechnique lhal has demonslraled effecliveness
and safely.
2. Afler lrealmenl, resamIe lhe hol valer from each slorage lank. If
Legionella are delecled, re-lreal and resamIe lhe valer syslem. If no
measurabIe IeveIs are found in lhis syslem and aII olher olenliaI
sources have aIso been addressed, go lo lhe nexl sle.
3. Tesl lhe domeslic hol- or varm-valer syslem for Legionella on lhe
foIIoving scheduIe lo assure lhal reconlaminalion has nol occurred:
a. WeekIy for lhe hrsl monlh afler resumlion of oeralion.
b. Lvery lvo veeks for lhe nexl lvo monlhs.
274 Effective Building Maintenance
c. MonlhIy for lhe nexl lhree monlhs.
4. During lhe moniloring eriod, if 1O or more CII er miIIiIiler of
valer are resenl, re-lreal lhe syslem according lo sles 1-2 above.
Resume veekIy lesling (sle 3a) afler relrealmenl. If IeveIs remain
beIov 1 CII er miIIiIiler, no furlher moniloring is necessary. If
lhe IeveIs are belveen 1 and 9 CII er miIIiIiler, conlinue monlhIy
samIing of lhe valer indehnileIy and conlinue efforls lo deler-
mine lhe source of conlaminalion. Make lesl resuIls avaiIabIe lo
buiIding residenls.
TepidWaterSystems
Warm-water systems or tepid water systems, usually associated
with eyewash safety systems, dilute domestic hot water from a water
heater with cold water upstream from the outlet source are not rec-
ommended. Warm water left in these lines is at ideal temperatures
for amplifcation of L. pneumophila. Localized mixing at the source
to temper very hot water is more acceptable. Another alternative is
instantaneous point of delivery heating of water using individual
steam heating systems at each outlet.
Cold-WaterSystems
Domeslic coId-valer syslems have nol been a ma|or source of con-
cern for Legionnaires disease because L. pneumophila viII nol amIify
al Iov lemeralures. CoId-valer slorage and deIivery shouId be al Iess
lhan 65I lo minimize olenliaI for grovlh. coId-valer Iines near hol-
valer Iines shouId be insuIaled. Try lo eIiminale slagnanl Iaces in lhe
syslem as dead Iegs or slorage lanks lhal are nol roulineIy used.
DeleclabIe IeveIs of L.pneumophila in lhe syslem may indicale con-
laminalion of lhe source valer suIy and shouId reresenl lhe maxi-
mum aIIovabIe IeveI in lhe syslem. If samIing of lhe syslem indicales
a IeveI of conlaminalion signihcanlIy grealer lhan lhal of lhe incoming
domeslic valer suIy syslem, lreal lhe syslem and idenlify lhe source
of conlaminalion or amIihcalion. IoIIov lhe same cIean-u rocedure
Iisled for hol valer syslems above if coId-valer syslems are shovn lo
conlain measurabIe Legionella or are assumed lo be conlaminaled.
4.2.3.0Floor Drains
Insecl oor drains every 4 monlhs, as foIIovs:
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 275
WHAT TO
LOOK FOR PROBABLE CAUSE REMEDIAL ACTIONS
4.2.4.0Gas Piping
Insecl gas iing annuaIIy, as foIIovs:
1. Ising a combustiblegasdetector, check every |oinl and conneclion in
exosed iing. (There shouId be no conceaIed iing. If conceaIed
iing is found, reIace or reroule lo make iing exosed.)
2. If underground iing is inslaIIed, have a ressure lesl lo 1.5 limes
lhe maximum vorking ressure or al Ieasl 3 sig erformed every 5
years.
3. Check lhal lhe main gas shuloff vaIve and lhe gas shuloff vaIve al
each aIiance funclions roerIy. If vaIve does nol funclion, re-
Iace.
4. Check lhal a dri Ieg is inslaIIed al each aIiance. If nol, inslaII one.
5. Check condilion of exibIe gas Iines and conneclions for Ieaks or
damage. ReIace exibIe coer Iines vilh exibIe slainIess sleeI
Iines.
6. Check Iines for roer suorl. Add suorls, hangers, elc. as re-
quired.
7. Check aIiance ame condilion. If ame is yeIIov or orange,
Iazy, unusuaIIy high, makes a oing sound vhen lurned on
276 Effective Building Maintenance
or off, or burns al lhe orihce, aIiance may require reair. Valveoff
anddisconnectgassupplyuntilappliancerepairsaremade.
8. If gas is suIied from an LI lank, lhe foIIoving is required
a. Check lhal lank is secure and IeveI. Ad|usl and anchor as need-
ed.
b. Lxamine lank for corrosion or olher damage. ReIace as re-
quired.
c. Make sure lhal reIief safely vaIve and rimary ressure reguIa-
lor are rolecled from icing.
d. Have lank vendor insecl lank on a rouline basis and lesl ri-
mary ressure reguIalor al Ieasl once a year.
4.2.4.1Acid Waste Systems
Insecl and service acid vasle syslems, as foIIovs:
Dilutionneutralization
1. Lach monlh, check neulraIizalion syslem oeralion, incIuding lesl
of conlroIs, H sensors, agilalor, chemicaI feed um, and soIenoid
vaIves. Reair or reIace comonenls as required.
2. Lvery lvo years, have ie lesled for Ieaks and corrosion. ReIace
iing seclions as required vilh oIyroyIene iing using heal
fused1veIded or mechanicaI |oinls. Donotuseairtotestusewater
testasspecifedbelow.
Limestone/marblechipsneutralization
1. Lach monlh, lesl efuenl for roer H. Add Iimeslone1marbIe
chis as required lo mainlain discharge H belveen 7.2 and 7.8.
2. Lvery lvo years, have ie lesled for Ieaks and corrosion. ReIace
iing seclions as required vilh oIyroyIene iing using heal
fused1veIded or mechanicaI |oinls.Donotuseairtotestusewater
testasspecifedbelow.
Waterleaktest
To lesl ie, inserl Iugs lo isoIale iing seclion lo be lesled. AII
oenings lo lhal seclion musl be Iugged or caed vilh lesl Iugs or
cas. Then, hII lhe syslem vilh valer lo lhe highesl oinl in lhe syslem.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 277
IiIIing lhe syslem sIovIy shouId aIIov air in lhe syslem lo escae. Any air
lraed in lhe syslem musl be exeIIed before beginning lhe lesl. Main-
lain valer in lhe syslem, vilh no change in IeveI, for four (4) hours.
4.2.4.2Pool Maintenance
Svimming or vading ooI mainlenance consisls of rouline valer
chemislry lesling and ad|uslmenl, aIong vilh rouline inseclion and ser-
vicing of ooI iing and equimenl, as foIIovs:
1. Tesl and ad|usl valer chemislry daiIy. A ooI lhal is baIanced has
roer IeveIs of H, TolaI AIkaIinily and CaIcium Hardness. Il may
aIso be dehned as valer lhal is neilher corrosive or scaIing. Ising a
good lesl kil vilh fresh lesling reagenls, measure lhe chemicaI a-
ramelers of H, aIkaIinily and caIcium hardness and ad|usl as nec-
essary
a. To have H in baIance, ad|usl lhe valer vilh addilions of a H
increaser (base) or a H decreaser (acid) lo achieve lhe range of
7.2 - 7.8. If lesling shovs a H vaIue beIov 7.2, lhe valer is in
an corrosive (acidic) condilion and sodium carbonale musl be
added lo bring lhe H inlo a more basic range and revenl cor-
rosion. ConverseIy, if lhe H is above 7.8, lhe valer is in a scaI-
ing (basic) condilion and Murialic acid musl be added lo bring
dovn lhe H.
b. Lov aIkaIinily is raised by lhe addilion of sodium bicarbonale.
High IeveIs of aIkaIinily are Iovered by lhe addilion of Murialic
acid. (Lxerls recommend ooIing lhe acid in a smaII area of
Iov currenl for a grealer effecl on aIkaIinily. Thal is, adding an
acid viII Iover bolh H and aIkaIinily. WaIking lhe acid around
lhe ooI, in a highIy dislribuled manner is said lo have a grealer
effecl Iovering lhe H lhan lhe aIkaIinily. IooIing lhe acid has
lhe oosile effecl.) AIkaIinily shouId be mainlained vilhin 8O-
12O m.
c. The lesl for CaIcium Hardness is a measure of hov hard or sofl
lhe valer is. If CaIcium Hardness IeveIs are loo high, add TSI
and1or add fresh valer lo Iover lhe IeveIs. LeveIs lhal are loo
Iov require lhe addilion of caIcium chIoride. Recommended
range for caIcium hardness is 2OO - 4OO m.
d. The Saluralion Index, aIso caIIed lhe LangeIier Index, is a chem-
icaI equalion used lo diagnose lhe valer baIance in lhe ooI. To
278 Effective Building Maintenance
caIcuIale lhe Saluralion Index, measure H, lemeralure, caIci-
um hardness, and lolaI aIkaIinily. Refer lo charl or ooI caIcuIa-
lor for assigned vaIues corresonding lo lhe lemeralure, hard-
ness, and aIkaIinily readings and add lhese lo your H vaIue.
Sublracl 12.1, vhich is lhe conslanl vaIue assigned lo TolaI Dis-
soIved SoIids, and a resuIlanl number viII be roduced. A resuIl
belveen -O.3 and +O.5 is said lo indicale baIanced valer. ResuIls
oulside of lhese aramelers require ad|uslmenl lo one or more
chemicaI comonenls lo achieve baIance, vilhin lhe individuaI
comonenl ranges secihed above.
2. DaiIy, lesl and ad|usl chIorine IeveI (sanilizer and anli-aIgae lreal-
menl) lo mainlain lhe recommended IeveI of free avaiIabIe chIorine
belveen 1.O and 3.O m.
3. WeekIy, insecl diving boards, Iadders, roes, elc. lo ensure lhey are
nol damaged, Ioose, or olhervise unsafe. Check ooI decks for bro-
ken or cracked liIes or olher surface damage lhal musl be reaired.
4. Insecl ooI iing and equimenl veekIy
a. CIean oul lhe ooIs skimmer baskel.
b. en lhe um slrainer baskel and cIean il.
c. Check lhe ressure dro across lhe hIler. (There is no oinl in
checking il before cIeaning oul lhe skimmer and slrainer bas-
kels, if lhey are fuII, lhe hIler ressure viII be Iov). If lhe res-
sure is high, lhe hIler needs backvashing.
d. Check lhe healer. Turn lhe healer on and off a fev limes lo make
sure il is oeraling roerIy. WhiIe lhe healer is running, lurn
lhe um off. The healer shouId shul off by ilseIf vhen lhe res-
sure from lhe um dros.
e. Check lhe lime cIocks for lhe correcl lime of day and lhe sellings
for lhe lime(s) for lhe daiIy hIler runs, elc. (Triers come Ioose
and over uclualions or unreIaled service vork can affecl lhe
cIocks.)
f. Look for Ieaks or olher signs of equimenl faiIure. CIean u lhe
equimenl area by removing any debris from around lhe molor
venls and healer. If lhe ooI equimenl is exosed, cIear drains
of debris lhal couId revenl valer from draining avay from lhe
equimenl during rain.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 279
HLATING, VLNTILATING, AND AIR-CNDITINING
WARNING! When performing maintenance of any motor-driven HVAC
equipment, an electrical lock out/tag out procedure may be required
to prevent accidental starting of the equipment. This procedure must
establish minimum requirements for controlling hazardous energy
whenever maintenance or repair is done on machinery, equipment, and
property. It is used to ensure that the machine or equipment is stopped,
isolated from all potentially hazardous energy sources and locked out
before employees perform any servicing or maintenance where the un-
expected energizing or start-up of the machine or equipment or release
of stored energy could cause injury.
4.3.1.0Packaged Incremental HVAC Units
Insecl ackaged incremenlaI HVAC unils annuaIIy al lhe end of
lhe cooIing season. If unil is over 5 years oId and shovs signihcanl rusl
or olher hysicaI damage or delerioralion or has erformance robIems,
reIace.
4.3.1.1Split System Units
Insecl and service ackaged or sIil syslem air-condilioners and
heal ums.
Insecl and service lhe airside seclion of each ackaged unil or lhe
indoor unil of a sIil syslem in accordance vilh Mainlenance Irocedure
4.3.3.2.
Insecl lhe comressor1condensing seclion of each ackaged unil
or lhe condensing1ouldoor unil of each sIil syslem every 6 monlhs. Ser-
vice as foIIovs:
1. Inil casing: Check and cIear any Ieaf Iiller or organic maller in con-
lacl vilh lhe casing. Remove Ieaves, slicks, elc on or in lhe unil cas-
ing. Check for condilion of ainl, melaI, elc. and reair as necessary.
2. High and Lov Iressure Svilches: Svilches have hxed, nonad|usl-
abIe sellings. Check oeralion by sIovIy cIosing lhe Iiquid shuloff
vaIve and aIIoving comressor lo um-dovn beIov 1 sig. Com-
ressor shouId shul dovn vhen suclion ressure dros lo cul-oul
ressure (see manufaclurers dala) and shouId reslarl vhen res-
sure buiIds u lo cul -in ressure shovn.
280 Effective Building Maintenance
3. uldoor Ians: Check for roer rolalion and lhal fans do nol run
backvards vhen off. CIean and, if needed, baIance fan bIades.
4. Lubricalion: TyicaIIy fan molors have seaIed bearings and require
no Iubricalion. (Hovever, if molor does require Iubricalion, do so in
accordance vilh Mainlenance Irocedure 4.3.2O.O.)
5. CoiIs: CIean coiIs in accordance vilh Mainlenance Irocedure 4.3.3.3.
6. Check refrigeranl charge
a. Inserl a digilaI lhermomeler under lhe insuIalion on lhe Iiquid
Iine near lhe hIler-dyer.
b. Connecl ressure gauge lo lhe comressor discharge Iine.
c. erale unil for 15 minules and read discharge (head) ressure.
d. Ising Iressure-Temeralure charl for lhe refrigeranl uliIized,
hnd lhe equivaIenl saluraled condensing lemeralure.
e. Read lhe Iiquid Iine lemeralure and sublracl lhe saluraled con-
densing lemeralure delermined in Sle d. This difference is
lhe sub-cooIing lemeralure.
f. Comare lhis lemeralure lo lhe normaI sub-cooIing lemera-
lure Iisled in lhe manufaclurers service Iileralure for lhe unil.
If lhe difference is more lhan 3I, ADD refrigeranl lo increase
lhe sub-cooIing lemeralure, RLMVL refrigeranl (using man-
daled refrigeranl managemenl raclices) lo decrease lhe sub-
cooIing lemeralure.
7. Inil eralion: Tesl unil oeralion in accordance vilh manufac-
lurers slarl-u rocedures and reair as necessary.
4.3.1.2Computer Room Units
Comuler room unils, vhich are designed lo rovide very lighl
conlroI of bolh lemeralure and humidily, shouId be considered mis-
sion crilicaI and checked monlhIy for roer erformance, as foIIovs:
1. LnvironmenlaI ConlroI Iunclions: Tesl by aclualing each of lhe
main funclions. This is done by lemorariIy changing lhe seloinls.
2. CooIing: Tesl by selling lhe seloinl lo a lemeralure 1OI beIov
room lemeralure. A caII for cooIing shouId be seen and lhe equi-
menl shouId begin lo cooI. A high lemeralure aIarm may come on.
Disregard il. Relurn seloinl lo lhe desired lemeralure.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 281
3. Healing: Tesl by selling lhe seloinl for 1OI above room lemera-
lure. A caII for healing shouId be seen and lhe healing coiIs shouId
begin lo heal. Disregard lhe lemeralure aIarm and relurn lhe sel-
oinl lo lhe desired lemeralure.
4. Humidihcalion: Tesl by selling lhe humidily seloinl lo a reIalive
humidily 1O/ above lhe room humidily. Ior infrared humidihers,
aII lhe infrared buIbs shouId come on. Ior sleam generaling humidi-
hers, you viII immedialeIy hear lhe cIicks as il energizes. Afler a
shorl deIay, lhe canisler viII hII vilh valer. The valer viII heal and
sleam viII be roduced. Relurn lhe humidily seloinl lo lhe desired
humidily.
5. Dehumidihcalion: Tesl by selling lhe humidily seloinl lo a reIa-
live humidily 1O/ beIov room reIalive humidily. The comressor
shouId come on. Relurn humidily seloinl lo lhe desired humidily.
6. IroorlionaI Healing1CooIing1Dehumidihcalion: n chiIIed valer
or gIycoI based unils vilh hol valer reheal, lhe conlroIs are lyicaIIy
caabIe of resonding lo changes in room condilions. These syslems
uliIize eilher a lvo or lhree-vay vaIve aclivaled by a roorlioning
molor. Ior cooIing and dehumidihcalion, lhe microrocessor viII
resond by osilioning lhe vaIve roorlionaIIy lo malch lhe needs
of lhe room. IuII lraveI of lhe vaIve lakes Iace vilhin lhe range of
lhe sensilivily selling. During dehumidihcalion, fuII lraveI of lhe
vaIve lakes Iace vilhin 2/ RH. Ior hol valer reheal, lhe microro-
cessor viII resond by osilioning lhe hol valer vaIve roorlion-
aIIy lo malch lhe needs of lhe room. IuII lraveI of lhe vaIve lakes
Iace vilhin 1I vilh each O.1I resuIling in 1O/ vaIve lraveI.
Mainlenance checks and service musl incIude lhe foIIoving:
COMPONENT CHECK/REMEDIAL FREQUENCY
E
f
f
e
c
t
i
v
e
B
u
i
l
d
i
n
g
M
a
i
n
t
e
n
a
n
c
e
WHAT TO LOOK FOR FREQUENCY REMEDIAL ACTIONS
Atomizingair WeekIy Ior air alomizing burners, check hIler and drain mois-
lure from lras. Ior ressure alomizing burners, make
sure oiI ressure is correcl.
Firingratecontrol MonlhIy Tesl hring efhciency vilh combuslion lesl. Tune burner
as required for maximum efhciency on bolh high and
Iov hre.
Combustionair MonlhIy Check lhal inlake Iouvers are cIear and any damers
vork correclIy.
Fuelvalves,pilotandmain WeekIy en Iimil svilch, make sound and visuaI check and
check vaIve osilion indicalors.
Combustionandsafetycontrols, WeekIy CIose manuaI fueI suIy for iIol and main fueI
famefailure cock1vaIves, check safely shuldovn liming
A
p
p
e
n
d
i
x
S
e
r
v
i
c
e
S
y
s
t
e
m
P
r
e
v
e
n
t
a
t
i
v
e
a
n
d
P
r
e
d
i
c
t
i
v
e
P
r
o
c
e
d
u
r
e
s
3
0
1
Combustionandsafetycontrols,fame WeekIy If a ame signaI meler is inslaIIed, read and Iog for bolh
signalstrength iIol and main ames, check for high, very Iov, or uc-
lualing readings.
Pumpshortcyclesor Discharge Iine check vaIve Insecl check vaIve for lighl
starts/stopsinrapid defeclive, causing cIosing and reair or reIace
succession. backov. if necessary.
4.3.17.0Pneumatic Controls
Ineumalic conlroIs require lhe foIIoving mainlenance:
Airsupply
Weekly
1. Check comressor oiI IeveI and ressure
2. Check for and reair air Ieaks.
3. Insecl aulomalic drain for roer oeralion. Drain receiver lank if
needed. ReIace aulomalic drain if needed.
4. Drain aII air hIler bovIs.
Monthly
1. Check ercenl on-lime. If on-lime exceeds 5O/, insecl for air Ieaks,
faiIed aclualor diahragm, elc. |If syslem has onIy one comressor,
inslaII a second, equaIIy-sized comressor ied in araIIeI. InslaII
check vaIve in each comressors discharge Iine and vaIve so lhal ei-
lher comressor can be removed for service vilhoul shulling dovn
air suIy. InslaII aIlernalor conlroI so comressors aIlernale oera-
lion.j
2. Tesl safely reIief vaIve(s). To lesl, ad|usl ressure reducing vaIve sel-
oinl lo |usl above reIief vaIve selling. ReIief vaIve shouId oen.
Resel ressure reducing vaIve lo normaI selling (2O-25 sig). ReIief
vaIve shouId cIose. If lhe reIief vaIve maIfunclions, reIace.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 327
3. ReIace inlake air hIler lo comressor.
4. Check comressor drive beIl vear, ad|usl beIl lension.
5. Insecl aII vaIves for roer osilion, Ieaks, elc.
6. Service comressor molor in accordance vilh Mainlenance Iroce-
dure 4.3.2O.O.
7. Check discharge air hIler(s) and ressure reducing vaIve. ReIace as
required.
8. Check refrigeraled air dryer(s). Measure discharge air for roer
devoinl lemeralure (-4OI). Reair or reIace dryer as indicaled.
CIean condenser. |If lhe syslem has onIy one dryer, inslaII a second,
equaIIy-sized dryer in araIIeI. Irovide vaIves so lhal each dryer
can be isoIaled and removed for service vilhoul shulling dovn air
suIy.j
Quarterly
1. ReIace comressor drive beIl.
2. Change comressor oiI and oiI hIler.
3. Tesl comressor on1off conlroIIer. Sel ressure conlroIIer lo 6O sig
on ressure, 12O sig off ressure. ManuaIIy bIeed air from receiver
lank unliI ressure dros beIov 6O sig. Comressor shouId cycIe
on. When lank ressure rises lo 12O sig, comressor shouId cycIe
off. If conlroI maIfunclions, reIace conlroIIer.
Annually
1. Insecl and lighlen aII eIeclricaI conneclions.
2. Check molor am drav.
ControlPanelsandInstruments
Monthly
1. CaIibrale lransmillers and conlroIIers. Ad|usl aulhorily sellings for
duaI inul conlroIIers.
2. Tesl ressure gauges. Record gauge ressure reading, remove
gauge, inslaII caIibraled lesl gauge and record reading. If readings
328 Effective Building Maintenance
are vilhin 1O/, re-inslaII originaI ressure gauge. If readings differ
by more lhan 1O/, reIace originaI gauge vilh nev.
Annually
1. Tesl aII aclualors for roer funclion. Re-buiId or reIace fauIly ac-
lualors and1or iIol osilioners.
2. Tesl aII conlroI sequences by ad|usling seloinls, high1Iov Iimil
sellings, elc. and check vaIves and damers for roer oeraling
range.
4.3.17.1Electric/electronic Controls
AnnuaIIy, eIeclric1eIeclronic conlroIs require lhe foIIoving mainle-
nance:
1. Room lhermoslals:
a. Remove cover. Ise squeeze buIb lo bIov oul or Iov ressure
comressed air lo bIov oul dusl and dirl. CIean conlacls by hoId
lhem logelher IighlIy belveen lhe hngers and dravn a iece of
hard hnish aer, such as a business card, belveen lhem. Never
useemeryclothorabrasives.
b. Ad|usl seloinl(s) and healing or cooIing anlicialor as required
by measuring lhe amerage vilh lhe syslem on and selling lhe
anlicialor lo lhe measured amerage.
c. If lhermoslal has a lhermomeler, comare lhe lhermomeler
reading againsl ambienl lemeralure based on an accurale digi-
laI lhermomeler reading. Ad|usl as required.
2. LIeclric aclualor:
a. Check and lighlen aII viring conneclions.
b. Ior damer aclualors, check, ad|usl, and lighlen Iinkage.
c. CycIe aclualor lhrough ils fuII oeraling range by ad|usling sel-
oinls, high1Iov Iimil sellings, elc. ReIace aclualor lhal maI-
funclions.
4.3.17.2Direct Digital Control Systems
Direcl digilaI conlroI syslems require lhe foIIoving mainlenance:
FirstYear(WarrantyPeriod)
1. erale aII aulomalic vaIves and damers lhrough lheir fuII sloke.
Lnsure smoolh oeralion lhrough fuII slroke and aroriale seaI-
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 329
ing or shuloff. Verify aclualors are roerIy inslaIIed vilh adequale
cIearance. Ior neumalic oeralors, verify sring range and ad|usl
iIol osilioners (vhere aIicabIe).
2. Verify caIibralion of sensors, sensor1lransmillers, and sensor1con-
lroIIers, incIuding lemeralure, humidily, ressure, ov, and eIeclric-
ily consumlion. SeIecl al Ieasl 1O/ of lhe inslaIIed sensors, incIuding
al Ieasl one of each sensor lye, for caIibralion lesling. If caIibralion
of 1O/ or more of lhis samIe is found lo be incorrecl, seIecl an ad-
dilionaI 1O/ of lhe inslaIIed sensors for lesling. Ifcalibrationof10%or
moreofthissecondsampleisfoundtobeincorrect,testallsensors.
IliIize lhe foIIoving caIibralion lesl rocedure for air, sleam,
and valer lemeralure, air humidily, air slalic ressure, and sleam
ressure vilh DDC syslem sensors in Iace:
a. IIace caIibralion sensor in lhe conlroIIed medium (air, valer,
or sleam). Caulion shaII be exercised lhal DDC syslem and caI-
ibralion sensors do nol inlerfere vilh each olher (such as for
lemeralure or ressure sensing) and lhal lhe caIibralion sensor
does sense lhe lrue condilions.
b. Wail sufhcienl lime for lhe caIibralion sensor lo slabiIize. The
lime required deends on lhe lime conslanl and lhe iniliaI con-
dilion of lhe sensor.
c. Coordinale lime belveen lhe sile and cenlraI conlroI room for
laking readings.
d. SimuIlaneousIy lake readings of lhe caIibralion inslrumenl and
lhe DDC syslem readoul lerminaI.
e. Take al Ieasl one more reading for lhe same sensor. The range of
lhe lvo readings laken shaII be as vide as lhe HVAC oeralion
aIIovs, bul nol more lhan lhal caIIed for in lhe conlracl secih-
calions. In order lo have lhe vide range desired lhe second lesl
may need lo be conducled al a differenl lime from lhe hrsl lesl
vhen lhe HVAC equimenl exeriences differenl Ioads.
f. Comare readings from lhe caIibralion inslrumenl and lhe DDC
syslem. They musl be vilhin lhe accuracy requiremenls of lhe
secihcalions. If nol, reIace lhem.
3. Verify lhe exislence and oeralion of secihed soflvare.
a. Verify backu syslem oeralions and svilchovers incIuding
redundanl rocessors, backu over suIies, ballery backed
330 Effective Building Maintenance
memories, elc.
b. Verify DDC syslem command soflvare. This may be checked
by issuing commands al lhe oeralors consoIe and observing
disIay, rinler oulul, or HVAC equimenl resonses.
c. Tesl soflvare for checking inul commands and issuing error
messages. Lnler various correcl and incorrecl commands and
monilor resuIls
d. Check syslem and oinl addressing. Lnler command lo disIay
I1 dala. Verify aII dala oinls dehned on lhe dravings and1or
required by lhe secihcalions.
e. Tesl slarl-slo or enabIe-disabIe of HVAC equimenl or DDC
syslem conlroI oinls. Lnler commands lo slarl1slo seIecled
HVAC equimenl, and lo disabIe and enabIe seIecled oinls.
f. Tesl oeralor override1aulomalic mode. Lnler command lo
change seIecled aulomalic conlroI under DDC syslem lo manu-
aI and vice versa.
g. Tesl disIay formal. Lnler commands lo disIay dala and grah-
ics on lerminaI and grahic disIay. Check disIay conlenl for
adequacy and cIarily as secihed.
h. Tesl abiIily lo modify, canceI and conhrm oeralors commands.
Verify by enlering commands.
i. Tesl seloinl ad|uslmenl and Iimiling. Lnler commands lo ad-
|usl sel oinls of conlroIIers and range Iimils of lhe conlroIIed
media. Verify by disIay. AIso enler commands lo ad|usl sel-
oinls oulside lheir range Iimils. DDC syslem shaII disIay er-
ror messages.
|. Tesl syslem access and access IeveI conlroI. Try lo Iog on lo sys-
lem vilh bolh incorrecl and correcl ID codes. Try lo enler differ-
enl commands vilh differenl access IeveI of lhe oeralors. The
resonses of lhe DDC syslem shaII be as secihed.
k. Slarl1slo equimenl. Lnler command lo slarl or slo seIecled
equimenl. AIso resel lime lo iniliale aulomalic mode. Verify re-
sonses by observalion of equimenl and DDC syslem disIay.
I. Change arameler of oinls. Lnler commands lo change aram-
elers of seIecled oinls such as high and Iov Iimil aIarms, scaIe
faclor, elc. lo lesl lhe adequacy of soflvare.
4. Verify grahic disIay of each HVAC syslem and comonenl. Con-
hrm lhal lhe grahic is in accordance vilh lhe design dala and re-
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 331
vieved submillaIs, incIudes aII dala oinls required, disIayed dala
is correcl and in lhe correcl formal and unils, and changes in oinl
condilions or slalus are accuraleIy udaled. LvaIuale lhe refresh
rale of dala disIay.
5. Verify reorl generaling (slalus, rohIe, energy, elc.) by enlering
commands lo generale reorls such as aII oinls, lrend, lolaI disIay
of a syslem, limed disIay, and olher secihed reorls. Lxamine
lhe reorl conlenl for generaI formal, syslem1oinl code, lime in-
lervaI of reorling, oinl slalus1vaIue1unil, energy amounl1rale1
unil, slalus of conlroI and sel lime (manuaI or aulomalic), and olher
secihcalion required informalion.
6. Tesl aIarm reorling by inilialing aIarm condilions of differenl
oinls al differenl aIarm IeveIs in sequence lo examine aIarm re-
orls. The reorls shaII shov aIarm Iocalion and device, aIarm lime,
cause of aIarm, currenl slalus of lhe oinl, elc. as required in lhe
secihcalions. When aIarm condilions are removed lhe rinler shaII
rinl udaled slalus reorl. AIso verify audibIe aIarm oeralions
in accordance vilh secihcalion requiremenls. Then iniliale aIarm
condilions al differenl IeveIs al lhe same lime lo check aIarm rior-
ily.
7. Tesl DDC syslem aIicalion soflvare via lhe foIIoving lesl roce-
dures:
a. ScheduIed slarl-slo conlroI. Verify lhal inul incIudes slarl1
slo lime and days for secihed equimenl. Verify inul for
lime deIays of secihed equimenl. Check hoIiday effecl. Ior
each air handIer, Iog oeralion for al Ieasl lhree days lo conhrm
lhal unil slarls and slos in accordance vilh lhe scheduIe.
b. limum slarl-slo conlrol. Verify lhal lhe required inul in-
cIudes sace lemeralure, ouldoor lemeralure, occuied lime
and days of lhe veek, and lhe resonse lime of lhe air handIing
equimenl, on an individuaI syslem by syslem basis. Ior each
air handIer, Iog sace lemeralure for al Ieasl lhree days lo con-
hrm lhal sace is al required lemeralure by lhe slarl of lhe oc-
cuied eriod.
c. LIeclricaI demand Iimiling conlrol. Verify required inul dala,
as foIIovs: eIeclricaI Ioads under conlroI, Ioad riorily, demand
332 Effective Building Maintenance
melering inlervaI, demand Iimil seloinl, deIay lime, minimum
off-lime, minimum on-lime, and maximum off-lime. Tesl con-
lroI by lhe foIIoving rocess:
verride demand sensor and inul demand Iimil seloinl
1O/ Iover lhan currenl eIeclricaI consumlion rale (kW).
Conhrm equimenl shuldovn by observalion of equi-
menl and1or disIay.
d. Day-nighl selback conlroI. Conhrm lhal required inul dala is
rovided. To lesl conlroI, change lhe selback lime from occu-
ied lo unoccuied lime and conhrm lhal HVAC syslems re-
sond lo lhe selback mode. If syslem is an air-handIing syslem,
lhe oulside air damer shouId cIose and lhe fan shouId cycIe lo
mainlain lhe selback lemeralure seloinl.
Change lhe selback lemeralure seloinl lo 5I higher lhan
lhe acluaI sace lemeralure. The syslem shouId oerale lo in-
crease lhe sace lemeralure lo lhe nev seloinl condilion. Ior
air-handIers, lhe oulside air damer shouId remain cIosed.
e. Lconomizer cycIe conlroI. If lhe ouldoor air lemeralure is
above lhe discharge air lemeralure seloinl, bul beIov lhe de-
hned 1OO/ ouldoor air changeover lemeralure seloinl, verify
lhal lhe oulside air damer is fuIIy oen, lhe relurn air damer
is fuIIy cIosed, and lhal lhe air-handIer discharge air lemera-
lure is mainlained by moduIalion of lhe chiIIed valer conlroI
vaIve.
f. Healing1cooIing coiI discharge lemeralure resel. Verify lhal
lhe required inul oinls are rovided and lhal lhe coiI dis-
charge air lemeralure seloinl is in accordance vilh lhe inul
condilions and lhe sequence of oeralion dehned on lhe conlroI
dravings.
g. Hol valer lemeralure resel. Verify lhal lhe required inul
oinls are rovided and lhal lhe heal exchanger suIy hol va-
ler lemeralure seloinl is in accordance vilh lhe inul con-
dilions and lhe sequence of oeralion dehned on lhe conlroI
dravings.
h. ChiIIed valer lemeralure resel. Verify lhal lhe required inul
oinls are rovided and lhal lhe chiIIed valer suIy lemera-
lure seloinl is in accordance vilh lhe inul condilions and lhe
sequence of oeralion dehned on lhe conlroI dravings.
i. Condenser valer lemeralure conlroI. Verify lhal lhe required
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 333
inul oinls are rovided and lhal lhe condenser valer suIy
lemeralure seloinl is in accordance vilh lhe inul condilions
and lhe sequence of oeralion dehned on lhe conlroI dravings.
Year 5: Re-commission syslem by reealing aII checks and lesls done
during lhe hrsl year.
Year10: The syslem has become bolh lechnicaIIy and funclionaIIy obsoIele
and shouId be reIaced.
4.3.18.0Water Piping
AnnuaIIy, visuaIIy insecl aII valer iing exosed lo viev for
Ieaks, corrosion, and condilion. Insecl insuIalion in accordance vilh
Mainlenance Irocedure 4.3.19.O. CycIe vaIves lo make sure lhey oerale.
Make reairs as needed.
4.3.18.1Steam & Condensate Piping
AnnuaIIy, visuaIIy insecl aII sleam and condensale iing exosed
lo viev for Ieaks, corrosion, and condilion. Insecl insuIalion in accor-
dance vilh Mainlenance Irocedure 4.3.19.O. CycIe vaIves lo make sure
lhey oerale. Make reairs as needed.
4.3.18.3.1Expansion/compression Tank
MonlhIy, check exansion1comression lank sighl gIass for valer
IeveI. If valer-Iogged, drain dovn and ressurize syslem lo creale an air
cushion.
4.3.18.3.2Piping Vibration Isolator
MonlhIy, visuaIIy insecl iing vibralion isoIalor for Ieaks or faiI-
ure. ReIace as required.
4.3.18.3.3Strainers
Insecl and service slrainers as foIIovs:
1. MonlhIy, insecl for Ieaks and bIov dovn.
2. AnnuaIIy, remove, cIean, and reinslaII slrainer eIemenl or baskel.
4.3.18.3.4Rotary Air Separator
Insecl and service rolary air searalor as foIIovs:
1. MonlhIy, insecl for Ieaks and bIov dovn (if searalor has inlegraI
334 Effective Building Maintenance
slrainer). |Nole: If lhe syslem ums are equied vilh Y-lye or
baskel slrainers, remove lhe inlegraI slrainer lo reduce mainlenance
requiremenls.j
2. MonlhIy, check make-u valer conneclion. Check ressure gauges
for roer valer ressure reducing vaIve oeralion.
3. AnnuaIIy, remove, cIean, and reinslaII slrainer eIemenl (if searalor
has inlegraI slrainer).
4.3.18.3.5Water Pressure Relief Valve
Lvery 6 monlhs, examine valer ressure reIief vaIve for Ieaks and1
or corrosion and lesl for roer oeralion by raising Iever or slem and
lhen reIeasing il. If vaIve is damaged or maIfunclions, reIace.
4.3.18.4.1Steam Pressure Reducing Valve
Lvery 6 monlhs (or beginning of each healing season), each sleam
ressure reducing vaIve (IRV) shouId be insecled for roer oeralion,
as foIIovs:
1. }oinl Ieaks: Donotallowaleaktocontinue;tightenbolts,replacegaskets
orpackingasnecessary.
2. Iroer conlroI of ressure and1or lemeralure: Check lo see lhal
lhe oeraling condilions iniliaIIy ad|usled are sliII sel. (An addi-
lionaI check is lo aIler lhe ad|uslmenl sIighling lo see if lhe syslem
resonds.)
3. Iroer soIenoid iIol aclualion: Make sure il is funclioning ro-
erIy.
4. Iovdovn syslem slrainers: If excessiveIy dirly, bIovdovn shouId
be done once a veek.
5. Insecl for dirl coIIecled al bIeedoinl and reslriclion eIbov.
When a IRV does nol erform salisfacloriIy, il is besl lo delermine
lhe cause by making lhe easiesl inseclions hrsl before disassembIing.
The foIIoving Iisl of ossibIe causes are arranged in order of difhcuIly.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 335
336 Effective Building Maintenance
4.3.18.4.2Steam Safety Relief Valve
Tesl sleam safely reIief vaIve by increasing sleam suIy ressure,
by changing ressure reducing vaIve selling, lo lhe reIief vaIve selling.
VaIve shouId oen. Reduce suIy ressure. VaIve shouId cIose. If vaIve
does nol oen or cIose roerIy, reIace vaIve. Do not attempt to repair
valve.
4.3.19.0Piping Insulation
AnnuaIIy, insecl condilion of insuIalion on iing and equimenl.
1. Insecl for missing insuIalion and damaged (lears, hoIes, abrasion,
elc.) |ackel(s). ReIace insuIalion and1or |ackels as required.
2. Hand-squeeze insuIalion on hllings for roer hII. If insuIalion is
sofl or il feeIs as if lhe IVC hlling cover is nol hIIed, remove IVC
hlling cover, inslaII correclIy-sized re-formed hlling insuIalion,
and re-inslaII IVC hlling cover.
3. Cover AS} exosed lo viev vilh IVC or aIuminum ouler |ackel lo
revenl mechanicaI damage. (Ise IVC for chiIIed valer iing in-
suIalion.)
4. Ior hbergIass insuIalion on chiIIed valer syslems, examine for moId
grovlh on lhe |ackel, eseciaIIy al or near hllings. Delermine lhe
exlenl of vel or moisl insuIalion. If found, vail unliI healing season
and remove and reIace vilh ceIIuIar gIass.
5. Check caIcium siIicale insuIalion on sleam iing and equimenl
for erosion, cracking or faiIure of Iasler ouler coalings, elc. Reair
or reIace as necessary.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 337
6. Check condilion of exibIe eIaslomeric insuIalion for delerioralion,
eseciaIIy if inslaIIed ouldoors (lyicaIIy on refrigeranl Iines). Re-
Iace as required.
7. Check ouldoor hbergIass or caIcium siIicale insuIalion for valer in-
lrusion. If ouldoor IVC or aIuminum |ackel is missing, damaged, or
corroded, reIace underIying insuIalion and ouler |ackel vilh nev.
4.3.20.0Motors
Molor mainlenance is required, as foIIovs:
1. Lubricale eIeclric molors in accordance vilh lhe foIIoving sched-
uIes:
Open,drip-proof(ODP)HVACelectricmotors:
Re-Iubricale on lhe basis of lhe foIIoving scheduIe:
Motor RPM Ambient Temperature (F) Regreasing Frequency
Zinc 7.5-8.5
MoIybdale or MoIybdale1Zinc 7.5-9.5
rlhohoshale 7.5-8.5, vilh a hoshale deosilion in-
hibilor
rganic Adsorlion 7.5-9.5, vilh 3OO-5OO m aIkaIinily
16O 1.O
17O O.75
18O O.5
19O O.375
2OO O.25
Nole lhal bearing environmenl and osilion may require more fre-
quenl re-Iubricaliondirly, dusly environmenls, verlicaI shafls, elc. viII
shorlen re-Iubricalion eriods.
IIlimaleIy, lhe roer re-Iubricalion eriod musl be delermined by
lriaI and error. Ising manufaclurers dala or lhe formuIa above as a
slarling oinl, visuaIIy examine urged Iubricanl al lhe end of Iubricalion
inlervaI. If lhe Iubricanl is cIean, Ienglhen lhe eriod belveen re-Iubrica-
lion. If il is dirly or scorched, shorlen lhe inlervaI.
ver-greasing of bearing assembIies viII resuIl in seaI faiIure. ig
gIobs of grease on lhe oor benealh lhe bearing is a sure sign lhis had
haened. In lhis case, bearing reIacemenl is required (and care musl be
laken in lhe fulure lo avoid faiIure from recurring).
To revenl over-Iubricalion, lhere are lvo vays lo delermine lhe
correcl re-Iubricalion quanlily. The hrsl, and referred, melhod is lo con-
lacl lhe bearing manufaclurer and requesl a recommendalion based uon
lhe secihc aIicalion. IaiIing lhal, lhe second olion is lo caIcuIale lhe
correcl re-Iubricalion quanlily using lhe foIIoving equalion
Grease Quanlily (oz) = (D x x Q)128.35
Where
D = earing ouler diameler (mm)
= earing vidlh (mm)
Q = Re-Iubricalion inlervaI faclor (O.OO2 for a veekIy re-Iubricalion
inlervaI, O.OO3 for a monlhIy inlervaI, O.OO4 a yearIy inler-
vaI)
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 357
IIRL IRTLCTIN
4.4.1.0Sprinkler Systems
AII hre srinkIer syslems musl be insecled, lesled, and mainlained
in accordance vilh NIIA Slandard 25, StandardfortheInspection,Testing,
andMaintenanceofWater-BasedFireProtectionSystems.
[Note:Inmanystates,thepersonnelperformingthesefunctionsarerequiredto
belicensedbythestate,asfollows:
Personnelperformingmaintenanceonfresprinklersystemsmustholda
validLimitedFireSprinklerSystemMaintenanceTechnicianlicense.
Personnel performing testing and inspection of fre sprinkler systems
requiredbyNFPA25shallholdavalidLimitedFireSprinklerSystemIn-
spectionTechnicianlicense.]
4.4.3.0Portable Extinguishers
IorlabIe hre exlinguishers shaII be insecled and lesled, as foIIovs:
Monthlyinspection:
1. Insecl vhen iniliaIIy Iaced in service and lhereafler al monlhIy
inlervaIs. Iire Lxlinguishers shaII be insecled, manuaIIy or by
eIeclronic means, al more frequenl inlervaIs vhen circumslances
require.
2. Inseclion of hre exlinguishers shaII incIude a check of lhe foIIov-
ing ilems:
a. Localion in designaled Iace.
b. No obslruclion lo access or visibiIily.
c. eraling inslruclions on nameIale IegibIe and facing oul-
vard.
d. Safely seaIs and lamer indicalors nol broken or missing.
e. IuIIness delermined by veighing or hefling.
f. Lxaminalion for obvious hysicaI damage, corrosion, Ieakage,
or cIogged nozzIe.
g. Iressure gauge reading or indicalor in lhe oerabIe range or o-
silion.
h. Condilion of lires, vheeIs, carriage, hose, and nozzIe checked
(for vheeIed unils).
358 Effective Building Maintenance
3. Kee records of hre exlinguishers insecled, incIuding lhose found
lo require correclive aclion. The dale lhe inseclion vas erformed
and lhe iniliaIs of lhe erson erforming lhe inseclion shaII be re-
corded.
AnnualMaintenance
1. Slored-ressure lyes conlaining a Ioaded syslem agenl shaII be
disassembIed on an annuaI basis and sub|ecled lo comIele mainle-
nance.
2. A conduclivily lesl shaII be conducled annuaIIy on aII carbon diox-
ide hose assembIies. Hose assembIies found lo be nonconduclive
shaII be reIaced.
3. Iressure reguIalors rovided vilh vheeIed-lye hre exlinguishers
shaII be lesled for oulIel slalic ressure and ov rale in accordance
vilh manufaclurers inslruclions.
4. Al lhe lime of lhe mainlenance, lhe lamer seaI of rechargeabIe hre
exlinguishers shaII be removed by oeraling lhe uII in or Iocking
device. Afler lhe aIicabIe mainlenance rocedures are comIeled,
a nev lamer seaI shaII be inslaIIed.
Six-YearMaintenance:
1. Slored-ressure hre exlinguishers lhal require a 12-year hydroslalic
lesl shaII be emlied and sub|ecled lo lhe aIicabIe mainlenance
rocedures. The removaI of lhe agenl shaII onIy be done using a
Iisled haIon cIosed recovery syslem. When lhe aIicabIe mainle-
nance rocedures are erformed during a eriodic recharging or hy-
droslalic lesling, lhe 6-year requiremenl shaII begin from lhal dale.
2. Non-rechargeabIe hre exlinguishers shaII nol be hydroslalic lesled
bul shaII be removed from service al a maximum inlervaI of 12 years
from lhe dale of manufaclure.
3. Lach hre exlinguisher shaII have a lag or IabeI secureIy allached lhal
indicales lhe monlh and year lhe mainlenance vas erformed and
lhal idenlihes lhe erson erforming lhe search.
Appendix DService System Preventative and Predictive Procedures 359
Recharging
1. AII rechargeabIe-lye hre exlinguishers shaII be recharged afler any
use or as indicaled by inseclion or vhen erforming mainlenance.
2. Afler recharging, a Ieak lesl shaII be erformed on slored-ressure
and seIf-exeIIing lyes of hre exlinguishers.
3. Lvery 12 monlhs, um lank valer and um lank caIcium chIo-
ride-based anlifreeze lyes of hre exlinguishers shaII be recharged
vilh nev chemicaIs or valer, as aIicabIe.
4. The agenl slored-ressure velling agenl hre exlinguishers shaII be
reIaced annuaIIy. nIy lhe agenl secihed on lhe nameIale shaII
be used for recharging.
5. The remixed agenl in Iiquid charge-lye AIII (aqueous hIm-
forming foam) and IIII (hIm-forming uororolein foam) hre
exlinguishers shaII be reIaced al Ieasl once every lhree years. The
agenl in soIid charge-lye AIII hre exlinguishers shaII be reIaced
once every 5 years.
6. nIy lhose recharge agenls secihed on lhe nameIale or agenls
roven lo have equaI chemicaI comosilion, hysicaI characleris-
lics, and hre exlinguishing caabiIilies shaII be used. Agenls Iisled
secihcaIIy for use vilh lhal hre exlinguisher shaII be considered lo
meel lhese requiremenls.
7. Lach hre exlinguisher shaII have a lag or IabeI secureIy allached lhal
indicales lhe monlh and year recharging vas erformed and lhal
idenlihes lhe erson erforming lhe service.
HydrostaticTesting
Al inlervaIs nol exceeding lhose secihed in lhe foIIoving labIe, hre
exlinguishers shaII be hydroslalicaIIy relesled.
The hydroslalic relesl shaII be conducled vilhin lhe caIendar year of
lhe secihed lesl inlervaI. In no case shaII an exlinguisher be recharged if
il is beyond ils secihed hydroslalic relesl dale. Hydroslalic lesling shaII
be erformed by ersons lrained in ressure lesling rocedures and safe-
guards vho have suilabIe lesling equimenl, faciIilies, and aroriale
servicing manuaI(s) avaiIabIe.
360 Effective Building Maintenance
1. A hydroslalic lesl shaII aIvays incIude bolh an inlernaI and exlernaI
visuaI examinalion of lhe cyIinder.
2. Hydroslalic lesling shaII be conducled using valer or some olher
noncomressibIe uid as lhe lesl medium. Air or olher gases shaII
nol be used as lhe soIe medium for ressure lesling. AII air shaII be
venled rior lo hydroslalic lesling lo revenl vioIenl and dangerous
faiIure of lhe cyIinder.
3. Where a hre exlinguisher cyIinder or sheII has one or more of lhe
foIIoving condilions, il shaII nol be hydroslalicaIIy lesled, bul shaII
be condemned or deslroyed by lhe ovner or al lhe ovners direc-
lion:
a. Where reairs by soIdering, veIding, brazing, or use of alch-
ing comounds exisl.
b. Where lhe cyIinder lhreads are vorn, corroded, broken, cracked,
or nicked.
c. Where lhere is corrosion lhal has caused illing, incIuding il-
ling under a removabIe nameIale or name band assembIy.
d. Where lhe hre exlinguisher has been burned in a hre.
e. Where a caIcium chIoride lye of exlinguisher agenl vas used
in a slainIess sleeI hre exlinguisher.
Extinguisher Test Interval
Type (Years)
Wel chemicaI
Dry chemicaI, slored-ressure, vilh miId sleeI, brazed
brass, or aIuminum sheII
Dry chemicaI, carlridge- or cyIinder-oeraled, vilh miId 12
sleeI sheII
HaIogenaled agenls
Dry ovder, slored-ressure, carlridge- or cyIinder-
oeraled, vilh miId sleeI sheII
Manualdimmer
(Incandescentonly) High end lrim sel al 95/
4. Grou reIam aII hxlures al 7O/ of average raled Iam Iife in accor-
dance vilh lhe foIIoving scheduIe
Avg. Annual
Lamp Avg. Rated Lamp Utilization Group Relamping
Type Life (Hours) (Hours) Frequency