Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SPONSORS
SUPREME COURT OF OHIO | THE ATTORNEY GENERAL OF OHIO OHIO STATE BAR ASSOCIATION | ACLU OF OHIO FOUNDATION
The Ohio Supreme Court Offers a complete program of services for Ohioans to learn about the judicial system:
Watch the Supreme Court live at sc.ohio.gov. Watch archived oral arguments at ohiochannel.org. Get news updates on all Ohio courts at courtnewsohio.gov. Follow a justice who is a former teacher. Her blog offers educational material on the courts at justicejudy.blogspot.com. Plan a class tour of the Thomas J. Moyer Ohio Judicial Center at sc.ohio.gov/mjc.
IN THIS ISSUE
OCLREs 30th Anniversary ..........3 Mock Trial News ........................5 Students Roles on Election Day................................6 John Carroll University Students Make a Difference .......8
TEACHABLE MOMENT
Article 3 offers a great opportunity for students to read and offer their reactions to several provisions including a strong endorsement for education. Article 3 also addresses the treatment of Indians in the Northwest Territory. The Northwest Ordinance was the template for territorial expansion, democratic processes for statehood, trial by jury, protection of property, and freedom of religion; in essence, the document ensured that every state created would have a republican form of government. A more detailed account of the happenings in Philadelphia and New York can be found in Decision In Philadelphia: The Constitutional Convention of 1787 by Christopher Collier and James Lincoln Collier. A very good supplement on the Northwest Ordinance can be found at the Michigan Historical Society: The Mitten: The Northwest Ordinance Student Activities: Have students prepare a detailed timeline of important events between May 25 and September 17, 1787. From the timeline, students will have a better understanding of the interaction between the delegates at the Convention and the delegates in Congress. Have students rank the provisions of the Northwest Ordinance in the order of importance as they see them. Have them explain their reasoning in a class discussion.
clearly see what happened? Dont ask that question unless it is clearly stated in the witness statement. Well prepared witnesses will take the opportunity to undo the cross by discussing all the reasons why he or she could see what happened. Always be wary of asking one question too many and leave this ultimate point to the closer. Cross Examination Performance Be the Star: The goal of an attorney on cross is to make himself or herself the center of attention. If possible, take a position in the middle of the courtroom or as close to the witness box as possible. Use inflection, hand gestures or movement when appropriate. Get Your Answers: Cross examination is more than asking questions, its also getting answers to those questions. Anyone can simply read or memorize a list of questions. If a witness doesnt clearly answer the question, dont just move on to the next one. Ask another question until you get a yes or no. For example say can I take that as a no? or thank you for that answer but my original question was The ability to react to the witness testimony shows an ability to think on your feet that will score points with judges. Never End on an Objection: Its very important to leave a positive impression with the judges and sitting down on a lost objection makes that difficult. If the last question seems likely to elicit an objection, change the order of your questions or have a safer back-up question ready.
Portraying an Effective Witness on Cross Examination Maintain Character: If a witness is funny, emotional, or extremely professional on direct, this demeanor should carry over to cross. Many of the questions likely to be asked can be anticipated in advance so a witness can plan to make a joke or show emotion at a certain time. Abandoning the character played on direct is sure to result in a lower witness score. Avoid Yes or No Answers When Possible: The goal of an attorney on cross is to be the center of attention and elicit yes or no answers. As a witness, try to prevent this (Continued on page 5)
oclre.org. Teams will not be assigned to a competition site until OCLRE receives a roster. Withdraw Deadline: Teams that withdraw prior to January 7 will be assessed a $5 processing fee, the remaining balance will
be refunded. After January 7, no refunds or credits will be available. District Assignments: District Competition site assignments were released at www.oclre.org on January 11.
Connecting English/Common Core with the Social Studies Through Middle School Mock Trial
trial: read and analyze witness statements, form arguments to support each side of the case, prepare and ask witness questions, and deliver opening statements and closing arguments. The Center has developed cases based on eleven pieces of literature commonly read at the middle school level. This years state showcase is a trial based on the novel Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry by Mildred Taylor, a novel specifically listed in the English/Common Core standards illustrating the complexity, quality, and range of student reading for middle school students. The programs culminating activity, a state showcase at the Ohio Judicial Center in Columbus, gives students the opportunity to argue their case before judges and attorneys. Its an authentic, place-based, performance-based assessment thats just plain fun! Contact Tim Kalgreen at tkalgreen@oclre.org or 614-485-3515 for more information. 5
Middle school students love a good argument and teachers want them to read good literature. OCLREs Middle School Mock Trial program will pique students interests in civics, government, and the law, while integrating the common core curriculum. Middle School Mock Trial is an interdisciplinary program that engages students in the social studies components of learning the judicial and legal systems as well as the common core standards of reading, writing, speaking, and listening. Students participate in each step of a
(Continued from front page.) Since 2004, the Ohio Supreme Court has broadcast all of its proceedings live on cable television and over the Internet. Not only has our use of cameras not caused the types of problems our federal counterparts fear, but we believe it has clearly enhanced the publics general understanding of the judicial system. I hope our counterparts in the federal system progress to where weve come and open their doors for all the world to see. Without that access, misconceptions about what courts do will persist. A 2007 study by two political science professors examining previous research on the publics knowledge and perceptions of the courts concluded that the more the public knows about the courts, the more positive their perceptions are. People distrust what they dont understand, and we can hardly expect people to understand something they are not permitted to observe first hand.
By John Jackson, 13; We the People (5th grade classroom). Jackson is a senior at JCU, pursuing a degree in political science and a minor in entrepreneurship and economics:
By Alyssa Giannirakis, 14, Youth for Justice (8th grade classroom). Giannirakis is a junior double majoring in political scienc and communications:
By Kyle Hutnick, 13, Project Citizen (10th grade classroom). Hutnick is a senior pursuing a degree in sociology with concentration in criminology and political science:
JCU We the People tutors teach Cleveland area fifth graders the basics about the Constitution, citizenship, and United States History. Teams of three to four tutors teach an hour class on a weekly basis in urban schools. The year culminates with a Simulated Congressional Hearing on John Carrolls campus where local officials and other professionals, such as state senators, judges, and lawyers in the area assess the children on their knowledge of the material. We the People exposes Cleveland area students to John Carrolls campus and provides positive role models in both the tutors and the judges. Tutors see growth in content knowledge, public speaking skills, and overall confidence of the students. I continue to return to the program each year because of the relationships I have with the students, with the hope that I am making a difference in their lives.
Youth for Justice empowers students in ways I could not have imagined. Each week, John Carroll students take time out of their schedules to teach 8th graders that they do have a voice in their communities, and that together, their voices will be heard. By researching topics of injustice, and exploring the issues together, we are teaching students that they can be an important part of a solution. This program allows college students to build meaningful relationships and grow as individuals. In addition, the program provides students in Cleveland not only enriching material, but also dedicated role models and friends. The power of this program, for me, is to watch JCU tutors and 8th grade students become more civically engaged and witness the process of change together.
For the students participating in Project Citizen, there are few things quite so valuable as the moment of awakening when they realize that their voices were heard and their concerns were addressed. Last year, 10th graders were able to advocate for stricter gun laws, more vegetarian lunch options, and better bullying policies. Many high school students want to express their feelings to their superiors, but often have no outlet to do so. Project Citizen both teaches them and gives them access to the most effective ways to communicate with policy makers. The John Carroll tutors are the students biggest allies in the process. Along the way, our JCU students have a chance to put both coursework and social justice teachings into action. I am looking forward to seeing what difference we will make this year.
Middle School Mock Trial blends social studies learning about the law and the judicial system with important English/language arts skills including reading classic literature, writing, and public speaking. Middle School We the People meets the requirements of SB 165 and is an interactive way to teach historical documents, including the US Constitution, Bill of Rights, Declaration of Independence, and the Federalist Papers. If you have questions, need additional information, or to RSVP as the Centers guest, contact Tim Kalgreen at tkalgreen@ oclre.org or 614-485-3515.
Kindle, Google Play, or Barnes & Noble Nook. Visit http://new.civiced.org/resources/ publications/ebooks to order. The Center for Civic Education is also excited to announce the inaugural Middle School We the People National Finals, scheduled on May 3-7, 2013 on the campus of George Mason University in Fairfax, Virginia. For the first time, middle school students will have the opportunity to bring their knowledge of constitutional principles to Washington, D.C. and explore our nations capital. Additional information can be found at http://new.civiced.org/middle-schoolnational-finals-2013 or by contacting the Center for Civic Education at 818-591-9321. Space is limited to the first 50 teams nationally. If you are interested in sending your class to the first-ever Middle School We the People National Finals, please contact the Center for Civic Education and Tim Kalgreen at tkalgreen@ oclre.org or 614-485-3515.
10
11
Reporter
P.O. Box 16562 Columbus, Ohio 43216-6562 1700 Lake Shore Drive Columbus, Ohio 43204 614-485-3510 Toll free 877-485-3510 www.oclre.org
NON-PROFIT ORG. U.S. POSTAGE PAID COLUMBUS, OHIO PERMIT NO. 4247