Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Compromise of Interests?
FIDIC is International Federation of National Association of Independent Consulting Engineers FIDIC Forms of Contract are drafted by committees which represent a variety of interests, Owners, Engineers, Contractors and other construction professionals As such they generally represent a kind of compromise FIDIC written in English but intended to be used internationally used on 50% of projects Written primarily from a Common Law perspective but capable of adaptation for Civil Law jurisdictions Supplemented by Particular Conditions Choice of governing law extremely important
Role of Engineer
Traditional role of Engineer to make impartial determinations now modified to reflect current practice now represents the Employer Employers Representative introduced into the Silver and the Gold Books Issue instructions, monitors performance, acts as certifier In making decisions, reviewing documents, approving design, issuing instructions Engineer /Employers Representative to act fairly
Role of Engineer
In making any determination /decision under the Contract the Engineer /Employers Representative must
Consult with both parties Make a fair determination Take due regard to all relevant circumstances Act in accordance with the Contract
A failure to so act could place the Employer in breach of Contract and possibly expose the Engineer to a claim in negligence by the Contractor.
Common Features
Structure and clause numbering 20 main clauses Dispute resolution procedure Dispute Adjudication Board Temporarily binding followed by Amicable settlement attempt, followed by Arbitration Employer can terminate for convenience Notice provisions and procedural bars to claim:
Employer claims (including LADs) : Clause 2.5 Contractor claims : Clause 20
Design (where undertaken) to be fit for purpose Contractors liability under the Contract is limited Clause 17.6
Exclusion of indirect or consequential losses (save for termination losses /indemnities) Financial cap in Particular Conditions
Engineer acts for the Employer no longer stated to be impartial. Specified examples of Variations Particular entitlements to Extensions of Time
10
Silver Book
Engineer Procure Construct /Turnkey Contract Specifically introduced for Project Financed Works Employers Requirements usually a Performance (Output) Specification Almost Complete Risk transfer to the Contractor
Sufficiency of design Adequacy of Price (Lump Sum) with limited adjustments
No Independent Engineer, Employers Representative determines Testing procedures to demonstrate achievement of specified and result prove reliability and performance.
11
Some authorities use other FIDIC construction forms and add on O&M obligations.
12
Silver Book:
Contractor bears risk of errors /omissions in Employers Requirements and site data but some carve outs (Clause 5.1): Immutable or responsibility of Employer Definitions of intended purposes of Works Testing and performance criteria Cannot be verified by Contractor
Importance of full and proper due diligence by Contractor responsibility for Site data (Clause 4.10)
13
14
This makes it clear that if any instruction constitutes a Variation, Clause 13 [Variations and Adjustments] shall apply.
15
Employers Claims
Where Employer believes it is entitled to additional payment or to an extension to the Defects Notification Period
If the Employer considers himself to be entitled to any payment under any Clause of these Conditions or otherwise in connection with the Contract, and/or to any extension of the Defects Notification Period, the Employer or the Engineer shall give notice and particulars to the Contractor. However, notice is not required for payments due under Sub-Clause 4.19 [Electricity, Water and Gas], under Sub-Clause 4.20 [Employers Equipment and Free-Issue Material], or for other services requested by the Contractor.
Notice must be given "as soon as practicable after the Employer became aware of the event or circumstances giving rise to the claim." Engineer then proceeds to determine the claim in accordance with Clause 3.5 (except under the Silver book, where Employer determines his own claim).
16
Contractor's Claims
Red and Yellow Books contain approximately 30 sub-clauses specifying events entitling Contractor to claim, for example:
Clause 2.1: Late Access to Site Clause 4.12: Unforeseeable physical conditions Clause 8.5: Authority generated delays Clause 13.2: Variations Clause 16.1: Contractor's entitlement to suspend work Clause 17.4: Consequences of Employer's Risks
17
18
19
Employers Right to Vary (2): Procedure Clause 13.3 (Variations and Adjustments)
Three options:
Employer instruction Employer request for proposal Contractors value engineering proposal
21
Engineer /Employers Representative to consider and approve /disapprove /comment on the proposal as soon as practicable
22
Contractor bears the cost of preparing the proposal Under Red Book, Contractor obtains a 50% share in the savings Under Yellow, Silver and Gold Books, no express savings-sharing mechanism, but value engineering proposals must be taken into account when making any adjustment to the Contract Price as a result of any Variation
23
Valuation of Variations
Red Book:
Variations valued on a re-measurement basis under Clause 12
All to include an allowance for reasonable profit and take account of value engineering proposals Day works for minor Variations
24
25
26
Contractor liable for delay damages if Actual Completion occurs after the Agreed Completion Date [Sub-Clause 8.7] Sum stated in Appendix to Tender and only damages due from Contractor for such default other than in event of [Employer termination under 15.2] Contractor still has to complete and perform all other obligations UNLESS Delay is caused by a matter for which an EoT is available under the relevant FIDIC form
27
28
29
30
Naturally Contractor must comply with the law, but compensation for Changes:
In Laws of the Country where the Works are executed Laws include all national (or state) legislation, statutes, ordinances and other laws and regulations and by-laws of any legally constituted public authority; Extends to changes in judicial interpretation of such laws After Base Date Affecting Contractors performance of its obligations Contract price adjusted up or down to reflect increased or decreased Costs Cost includes overheads but not profit Adjustment determined by Engineer/Employer in accordance with Clause 3.5
31
32
Conclusions
FIDIC used on about 50% of International Projects It represents a reasonable balance of sometimes conflicting interests It is well understood in the market It is capable of being adapted for specific requirements Need to check local law for compliance
33
www.pinsentmasons.com
34
24003635