Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Best Practices for Driving Higher Quality Lending, Portfolio Management, and Investment Decisions
Overview
Contents
Introduction Best Practice #1 Best Practice #2 Best Practice #3 Best Practice #4 Best Practice #5 Conclusion Page 2 Page 3 Page 5 Page 6 Page 9 Page 10 Page 11
The local market factors impacting real estate lending, servicing, and investment decisions are growing in number and complexity. And given increased regulatory requirements and internal scrutiny, the need to incorporate a comprehensive view on how market conditions impact a property, its value, and the borrower is more important than ever. Unfortunately, given increased complexity, its also more difficult than ever to gain the necessary comprehensive view of market drivers. This guide addresses the key questions you must ask to understand the most important market drivers. More importantly, it details answers to these questions that leverage new, innovative tools to deliver the intelligence you need to make the right decisions.
www.dataquick.com
HPI
170 150 130 110 90 Nov 02 Nov 03 Nov 04 Nov 05 Nov 06 Nov 08 Nov 09 Nov 10 Nov 07 Nov 11
Unfortunately, its not that easy. When you dig deeper using a more granular HPI, and look at more localized price trends in Maricopa County (Figure 2) you can answer the question Yes, but you can also answer No and Maybe. Zip codes, like 85301 and 85029, where property values are still appreciating, appear to still be in a recovery mode. Property values here may still be underpriced. In zip codes, like 85007, where property values are decreasing, the recovery either hasnt started, is stalled, or perhaps even over. Zip codes, like 85837 and 85008, where property value trends are uneven would be put in the maybe bucket. Figure 2 Home Price Index: Select Zip Codes
210 190 170 150 130 110 90 70 50 Feb 10 Feb 12 Feb 02 Feb 03 Feb 04 Feb 05 Feb 06 Feb 07 Feb 08 Feb 09 Feb 11
HPI
www.dataquick.com
Figure 3 puts all of this into perspective. The wide distribution of zip-level price appreciation changes illustrates that Phoenixlike all major geographies is comprised of multiple local markets. Any market analysis must consider valuation trends (and any trend for that matter) at the local level to be meaningful. The spikes in the graph also suggest that while there are many local markets, you can cluster multiple zip codes into the same growth segments. Segmenting geographies like this allows greater flexibility when youre trying to establish a propertys value via comparisons to comparable properties. Your basis for comparison expands because you can make comparisons not only within a zip code but between two similarly behaving zip codes. Figure 3 Zip-level Price Appreciation Distribution - Phoenix
www.dataquick.com
In addition to YOY appreciation, the analysis also considers momentum. Momentum determines whether property appreciation has increased/decreased in the past 3 months relative to the increase/decrease recorded in the previous 12 months. Momentum ratios greater than 1.0 indicate that property valuation appreciation over the past 3 months is higher than what was seen in the previous 12 months. In other words, appreciation is accelerating the value of adding Momentum is to understand whats happening in the market now. Its great that all of the bands in Maricopa County have seen healthy appreciation in the last year, but the increases have clearly slowed considerably for some bands in the past three months, including <$75,000, $75,000-$124,999, and $450,000-$749,999. Much of the deceleration in property values can be traced to shifts in the underlying supply and demand dynamics of the Maricopa County market that will be addressed in the next section.
www.dataquick.com
How is the supply of available inventory impacting property values? What demand factors are having the greatest influence on market trends and property values?
This supply question used to be simple. Track listings over time to understand how the inventory of available properties was changing in relation to market forces, property values, and demand. But with the collapse of the market and subsequent proliferation of distressed properties, this became a much more complicated, multi-faceted problem. Figures 4-8 highlight the many components that must be considered before an educated answer can be delivered. The graphs very much present a good news/bad news scenario for Phoenix. The good news in Phoenix is monthly foreclosure filings and REO inventory have seen steep declines of 50% and 46% respectively since 1Q11 (Figure 4). In response to this good newsas well as the general rebound in property values reported earlierit shouldnt be a surprise to see the an 88% spike in all listings (not just distressed properties) since the beginning of 2012 reported in Figure 5. Heres where the bad news starts to creep in though. Figure 5 also shows that since the beginning of 2Q12, listings haveat beststayed level, indicating the possibility of saturation. Possibility turns to reality (certainly for the distressed properties) when you look at Figure 6 and see the steady increase in Months Supply of REO Listings since the middle of 2011. Its not quite a buyers market, but the significant increase in supply in Phoenix certainly goes a long way to explain the slowing in property valuation Momentum being reported for several segments reported in section 2 above. After establishing the baseline of supply-side issues in a market, the natural next step is to look at how demand-side variables are being impacted by supply and how they, too, are driving property values and general market trends. Figure 4 New Foreclosures and REO Inventory in Maricopa County
30,000 25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
Jun 10
www.dataquick.com
Jun 12
Jun 06
Jun 07
Jun 08
Jun 09
Jun 11
May 12
Feb 12
Apr 12
Jul 12
Mar 12
Aug 12
Jul 11
Jan 12
Aug 11
Nov 11
Dec 11
Jun 12
20
15
10
Jun 10
www.dataquick.com
Jun 12
Jun 06
Jun 07
Jun 08
Jun 09
Jun 11
Sep 12
Sep 11
Oct 11
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
Jun 10
13%
12%
15%
13%
Non-Distress
REO
Short Sale
Auction
Phoenix buyers had more choices over the last 12 months as supply surged. When you combine increased supply with a 41% drop in distressed discount property rates (Figure 7) and a the drop in REO inventory documented earlier (Figure 4), the significant change in the make-up of property sales in the County illustrated in Figure 8 isnt surprising. Specifically, non-distressed sales, which accounted for 39% of all sales in September 2011, jumped to 62% in Septemeber 2012. Buyers, when given the choice of a distressed or non-distressed property, are much more likely to opt for the non-distressed propertyespecially if they dont feel there are as many bargains to have in the distressed market. This analysis zeroed in on REO Inventory and Listings key indicators of market health. Other metrics that could have been factored into the analysis include local market statistics on foreclosure filings, negative equity, and shadow inventory.
8 www.dataquick.com
Copyright 2013 DataQuick Transforming Information into Intelligence
Jun 12
Jun 06
Jun 07
Jun 08
Jun 09
Jun 11
Average Single Family Residence (SFR) Value, 12/20091 Average SFR Value, 12/20121 Average Monthly Rent 4 BR SFR, 20092 Gross Rental Income (2009-2012) Net Rental Income (assumes 20% operating margin) Net Revenue from Property Sales w/o Rental Income Net Revenue from Property Sale w/Rental Income Overall Return w/o Rental Income Overall Return w/Rental Income Percent Return from Property Appreciation Percent Return from Rental Income
1 Source: DataQuick Automated Valuation Model 2 U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
$262,467 $308,029 $1,803 $67,539 $13,508 $45,562 $59,070 17% 23% 77% 23%
$241,258 $281,057 $1,567 $58,699 $11,740 $39,799 $51,539 16% 21% 77% 23%
$269,894 $285,935 $1,818 $68,101 $13,620 $16,041 $29,661 6% 11% 54% 46%
$309,267 $342,382 $2,385 $89,340 $17,868 $33,115 $50,983 11% 16% 65% 35%
The key assumptions used in this analysis: Holding period for the property is 3 years Rental operating return (rental income after operating expenses) is 20% Annual rental appreciation rate is 4% Two key insights flow from this analysis. The first, and most obvious, is that Miami-Dade, FL and Maricopa, AZ Counties provideby farthe most attractive returns of the 6 local markets evaluated. When you consider property appreciation and rental return (net of operating expenses) these two counties deliver nearly a 2x return in comparison to the other counties. Perhaps just as important though is what drives the largest returns. Specifically (and not surprisingly), high overall returns are driven much more by property appreciation than rental return. Using, Miami-Dade as an example, Table 2 shows that 77% of the overall return on the investment is the result of property appreciation during the holding period as opposed to just 23% for the rental return. The moral of this storywhich becomes increasingly more impactful as we move back to market conditions where steady property appreciation becomes the norm across most local marketsis that investors need to realize that while rental income can provide a boost to their expected gains, the lions share of the return will come from property appreciation. In todays and tomorrows market, its the first and most important factor to consider in making the investment.
9 www.dataquick.com
Copyright 2013 DataQuick Transforming Information into Intelligence
November 2011 Distressed Discount Rate November 2012 Distressed Discount Rate YOY Change
Source: DataQuick CMV-Distress
25% 27% 5%
10
www.dataquick.com
Conclusion
The need for a comprehensive view of local markets has never been greater, but so are the challenges. Lenders, Servicers, and Investors must determine the right sources for the required intelligence, how to analyze the intelligence once its acquired, and finally, how to integrate it into existing work flows to ensure every decision about a property can be made with the confidence that the unique dynamics of the local market have been accurately considered.
Our Mission
We deliver advanced information solutions powered by higher quality data, innovative analytics, and automated decisioning across a national footprint. We create customerfocused solutions that drive out time, cost, and risk.
Our Values
DataQuicks Associates are energized by the daily challenge of solving our clients unique business challenges. Three core values are at the center of how we manage our business:
Integrity
We deliver on the commitments we make to our Clients, Associates, and Investors.
Passion
We attack challenges and pursue opportunities with an intense sense of urgency.
Innovation
Our drive to deliver unique, high-value solutions is never-ending.