commons vs crisis

Rebel:
www.rebelnet.gr

Rebel: . Rebel
, .

700 , ,
2011. .
,
, .

www.rebelnet.gr
, e-mail: rebelnetgr@gmail.com


1. : Commons vs Crisis

. 4

2. Massimo De Angelis
,
: Commoning

. 25

3. Massimo de Angelis

. 64

4. Werner Bonefeld
:

. 73

5. Midnight Notes
:

. 96

6.

. 154

commons vs crisis

1. : Commons vs Crisis

,
: , , .
, - ,
,
(commons). , Midnight Notes Collective and Friends,
,

,

:

. ( )
.
.

(our common). ,
(Midnight Notes Collective and Friends, 2009).

: Commons vs Crisis

(commons)1 : (pooled resources), (community)

(commoning). (commoning)
(community)
(pooled resources) commoners2.
commoners ,
,
(, , , )
,
3
.
commoners ,
, (reclaim)
(common wealth) (commoning) .

De Angelis
:
. . ,

1. Common/Commons: / . .
2. Commoners: .
3. Enclosure/Enclosures/New Enclosures: / /
. .

commons vs crisis
,

. ,
.
-

to common ( ).

(De Angelis Stavrides 2009).
commoning
Peter Linebaugh 2008 The
Magna Carta Manifesto (Linebaugh 2008)

commoners
. , Linebaugh, commoning

(Linebaugh 2008). De Angelis The
Production of Commons and the Explosion of the Middle Class
commoning :
(common) (to common commoning)
.
, , ,
: commoning,
. () commoning - (De Angelis 2010). , De
Angelis
(commoning) : ,
. ,

: Commons vs Crisis

.
commoning ( )
(De Angelis Stavrides
2009). ,
- commoning- , -
, , , , , - , .
,
, De Angelis
commoners, , ,

(De Angelis Stavrides 2009).
( , ,
) , ,
,
:
.
commoning ( )
sharing ().

.




.
. (De Angelis

commons vs crisis
Stavrides 2009). , ,
,

(anticommons4).
, Federici, De Angelis

(commoning), ,
(commoning) ,
( ).

(Federici 2011),
: (gated
reality),
, ,
,
, , (Federici 2011).
Midnight Notes Collective and Friends
Promissory Notes from Crisis to Commons

(Midnight Notes Collective and Friends, 2009).
(
- ), ,
, ,

4. Anticommons: .
.

: Commons vs Crisis

,
commoners.
Harvey,
, (Harvey 2011). ,
, ..
, , ,
,
commoning,
. ,
commoning
,
De Angelis :

. ,
. ()
(
) (De Angelis 2009).
,
.
:
(enclosures)
(distorted commons).

5. Marx ,
, -

commons vs crisis
Marx ,
-
.5
, commoners, , , , ,
.6
19 20
, 7, -

,
, ,
( 1867: 757)
6. O Marx
.
24 ,
: , .
.
, :
, , : , , ,
. , ,
(Marx 1867:739).
7.
Luxembourg
(1913), .

10

: Commons vs Crisis

- .
( , , , ,
, ), 8.
, 20 ,
70
, ,
, ,

8. Lenin
(1899),
. Lenin,
, ,
(De Angelis 2001).
9. Midnight
Notes Collective 80. ,
, . , ,
,
, , , ,
(
) () ,
, -

11

commons vs crisis
. 9

80, , ,
, ,
,
(Caffentzis 2004).

, , ,

,

, , .
,
,
. ,
Marx,
:

, , (Marx 1867:739). ,
,
, ,
, -

, () :
(Midnight Notes Collective, 1990).

12

: Commons vs Crisis

. O
.
Werner Bonefeld,


: ,
.
,
. ,
.
. , , .
,

. ()
, ,
.

(Bonefeld 2009) .
,
.
, , ,


.
, .

13

commons vs crisis
, Chandra
Basu , , :

, , , .
,
, , )
)
( )
. ,
.
(Chandra Basu 2007). ,
,

,
.10

10 Midnight Notes Collective and Friends

: : , , . () ,

. ()
,
( , ,

14

: Commons vs Crisis

, ,
,
.
Federici, ,


(Federici 2011).
,


, , -

) , .
:
, ; ()
:
,
. ,
. Marx
,
,
.

(Midnight Notes Collective and Friends 2009).
11. , Federici
, , :

15

commons vs crisis
.11 ,

(commoning). De
Angelis,


. ,

. ,
.
,
,

(De Angelis, M. and Stavrides 2009).




(commoning).
commoning, -

.
(communal) ,

. ,
,
,
, .. internet (Federici 2011).

16

: Commons vs Crisis

,
, , ,
. , , , ,
,
. Marx Engels:
, ,
! (Man), , ,
(living Man), ,
,
,
. (Marx/
Engels, 1980: 98). , , ,
,
, .
Bonefeld,
, , . , ,

, ; .
. :

. .


(Bonefeld 2010).
, , -

17

commons vs crisis
, (commons)
(commoning),

,
. (distorted commons)
(commoning),
.
Federici,

, 1990,

.
,
,
,
,
- (Federici 2011).

Caffentzis
: Plan B ;,
1980 1990
, , ,
, , , . ,

18

: Commons vs Crisis

.

.
() , ,

( Hardin12
Coase13), ,
(Caffentzis 2010).
, De Angelis
(distorted)
,
-
, (De Angelis
2009). ,
, ,
.
De Angelis:

12. G.
Hardin (Hardin 1968), , (free ride)
- .
13. Coase,
, ,
(Coase 1988).

19

commons vs crisis
. ,
,
- . ,
- .
. ,
.
,

,
.

.
,
-
(- , ..).
, , , (De Angelis 2009).
,
,
, ,
.
,
. (De Angelis 2009).
, De Angelis,

20

: Commons vs Crisis

, ,
: ,

. , (). . ,


- .
:

( ) (De Angelis 2009).
, (commoning distorted commoning),

, De
Angelis :

, , ,

(De Angelis 2009). Negri

:
Marx
, , ,
. ()
(common wealth) (Negri 2008)

21

commons vs crisis
,
,
.
Negri,
, ,
(Negri 2008). De Angelis


,
, . De Angelis
, . ,
- - , .

, .()
.
.
commoners
, (De Angelis, M. and Stavrides 2009).
,
,
, , , , ,

, .
.

22

: Commons vs Crisis

Bonefeld, W., 2001. 2009. Primitive Accumulation and Capitalist Accumulation:

Economic Categories and Social Constitution,
- 2010. History and Human Emancipation: Struggle, Uncertainty and
Openness, Journal of Socialist Theory Volume 38, Issue 1.
Caffentzis, G 2004. A Tale of Two Conferences: Globalization, the Crisis of
Neoliberalism and Question of the Commons.
- 2010. The Future Of The Commons: Neoliberalisms Plan B Or The Original
Disaccumulation Of Capital? New Formations. is. 69 imperial ecologies, pp
23-41.
Chandra P., Basu D., 2007. Neoliberalism and Primitive Accumulation in India,
The need to go beyond capital.
Coase, R.H., 1988. The Problem of Social Cost. In The firm, the market and
the Law. Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press.
De Angelis, M., 2001. Marx and primitive accumulation: The continuous
character of capitals enclosures, Commoner n. 02.
- 2006. Enclosures, Commons and the Outside. Paper presented at the
annual meeting of the International Studies Association, Town & Country
Resort and Convention Center, San Diego, California, USA, Mar 22, 2006.
- 2009. The tragedy of the capitalist commons, turbulence 5, London:
turbulence.
- 2010 The Production of Commons and the Explosion of the Middle Class,
Antipode Vol. 42 No. 4 2010 pp 954977.
De Angelis, M. and Stavrides 2010. On the Commons, A Public Interview,
e-flux j. 17
Federici, S., 2011. Feminism And the Politics of the Commons, he
Commoner.
Hardin G. 1968. The tragedy of the commons, Science, 162: 1243-1248.
Harvey, D., 2011. The future of the commons, Radicale History Review issue
109.
Linebaugh, P., 2008. The Magna Carta Manifesto: Liberties and Commons for
All, University of California Press.
Luxemburg R., (1971) The Accumulation of Capital, London: Routledge and

23

commons vs crisis
Kegan Paul Ltd.
Marx K. [1867] 2009. , (. .), : .
- [1844] 1975, , (. . ), : .
Marx, K., Engels F. 1980. Die heilige Familie, MEW 2, Dietz, Berlin.
Midnight Notes Collective and Friends, 2009. Promissory Notes: From Crises
to Commons
Negri A 2008. commonwealth, (. .),
: .
Ostrom, E., [1990] 2002. , (.
.), : .

24

2. 1

: commoning . An Architektur
Massimo De Angelis .2
An Architektur: . ,
(land enclosure) . ,
1960 , , (file-sharing ),
.

;

1. : e-flux 16,
2010, http://www.e-flux.com/journal/view/150
2. An Architektur

,
Massimo de Angelis University
of East London, , 4
2009 .

25

commons vs crisis
Massimo De Angelis:

,
. .

.


.
, , ,
.
,
.
-
.
:
Massimo De Angelis:
,
, , .

;


;

26

;

;
, ,
. , , ,
.

- ,
. ,
.

- ,

.
, .
. :
,
commoners ( )
, .
: (pooled
resources), (community), (commoning).
Massimo De Angelis:
.
. ,
, .

27

commons vs crisis
,
. .

. ,
(pooled resources), ( ), (non-commodified)
. , (communities) - , , .
commoners (), ,
,

. , ,
,
. ,
. i
- to common (, ).
. Peter
Linebaugh, Magna
Carta , commoning ( ), commoners .

-
-
.
-

28

,
de facto .
,
.
An Architektur:
.

;

.
;
Massimo De Angelis:
. ,
. ,
commoners,


,
. 16 17
-
. ,
,
. ,
.
, , ,
. .

29

commons vs crisis


.
commoners, , .
. , ,
,
,
.
,
.
, , (precondition).
,
- :
. , ,
,
,
. 80 ,
. .
,
( ),
, , ,
, ,

, ,
,
projects,
.

30

Midnight Notes Collective .

, .
. ,

. ,

.


.
,
, - .
. ,
commoners,
, .
Narmada,
PueblaPanama.
, . ,
, , (commoning). -

31

commons vs crisis

,

. peer to peer

.

commoners. ,
. ,
,
,
.

An Architektur: - ,
, .

.

;
Massimo De Angelis:

Gerrit Hardin 1968. Hardin
,
,
-

32

. ,
.
, . :

. ,
, commoners . ,
commoning ( ).
(self-management) (self-government).

, , : (pooled
resources), (community)
(commoning). Hardin
,
(community), (commoning), ,
.
,
, . ,
. commoning (
) .
. , :
-

33

commons vs crisis
.

.

, ,

.
, .

An Architektur:
; , avant-garde ;
Massimo De Angelis: .
, , ,
,
.
,
commoning.
,
. ,
,
,
, . . ,
,

34

. ,
-
(
)
.

.
:
, comming (cyber-comming) peer-to-peer ()
,

, high-tech . ,
,
.

,
.
;
An Architektur: , ; Massimo ;
: , (community) (public). ,

35

commons vs crisis
,
.


.

. commoning (
) sharing ().


.


. .
commoners
, . ,
,

, .

.
,
. ;
;

;

36

(others) ; ,
,

.
:
An Architektur:
, ,

;
: ,
. ,
: .

,
.
,

. ,
, . ,
,
.

.
,
: ,

37

commons vs crisis
;
,
( -),
. ,
.
.

,
.
; , ,
;

, .

,
.

(commoning)
An Architektur: Massimo,
(commoning)
, .
;
; ,
,
.
Massimo De Angelis: -

38

:
- ,
-

.
- , , .
An Architektur: ;
Massimo De Angelis: , ,
, . , .
, copyright.
- (commodities), .
, (inputs)
.
. ,
, , . ,
, commoning. ,
. ,
, commoning, commoning
. ,
,
commoning (distorted commoning),

39

commons vs crisis

commoning
commoning,
, . ,
commoning. ,
. , commoning ,
,
.
commoning.


. ,
-
commoners
.
. ,
, ,

.
: - , Negri
Hardt. ,
-

40

,
, .
Negri Hardt

- :
,

.
,
, (in common - )
(produce commons).
, .
(enclosure acts)
internet,
. internet

commoning .
:
.
-
.
. .
Massimo De Angelis: ,
-

41

commons vs crisis

(co-optation). .

, , .
, ,
,

, .


,
,
. ,

.
O
An Architektur:
; , , ;
;
Massimo De Angelis:

.
1980 , ,
-

42

,
2001.

commoning, . , ,
. ,
. , ,
,
,
.
An Architektur:
commoning ;

; , ,
commoning; ;
; , ;
: ,
,
.
. , , ,
.

.
, .
,

43

commons vs crisis
.

,
,
.
, , . ,
,
. , , , .
, ,
.
, ,
.
,
,
. ,
, ,
, . , ,
, , ,
.

:
,
,
.
, -

44

,
,
.

,
.
. ,
.

, .
An Architektur: ; ;
: : . .

. , , .
,
,
,
,
, . ,
, , ,

.
,
, .

45

commons vs crisis
:
, .
Massimo De Angelis: , .
,
.
,
commoning.
,
.

.
, , .
, , , .
,
. ;.
,
. , ,
, ,
, , , , commoning
.
, , ,
. , .
,

46

. ,

.
: . , ,
.
, .
commoning, commoners. :
, ,
.


. , , ;
.
, ,

. .
.


.


,
. []
.

47

commons vs crisis
,
.
Massimo De Angelis: .
, ,

(commoning).

. , ,
commoning. , , ,
,
.
,
,
, .

commoning
.
.
.
, ,
.
,
commoning.
,
; .

48

:
- .
An Architektur:
;
: , commoning.
,
. , :
, , ,
. ,
.

.

.
, .
,
, .
, ,
,
,
. ;

; -

49

commons vs crisis

,
(mandar obedeciendo).

.
,

.
,
,
, .
, - ;
.

, ,
. , ,
,
,
.

Oaxaca, .
-,

. Oaxaca, - ,
, , .
.
.

50

. Oaxaca 600.000
.
, -

Oaxaca . ,
,
.
!
:
An Architektur: ,
.
;
:
. .
, . ,
,
, .

.
:
; ;
,
,
. ,
,
,
.

51

commons vs crisis
, , , .
, , . . ,
.
,
;


. ,
,
, . ,
,
.
. ,

, .
, ;
An Architektur: , ;

; ,
;

Massimo De Angelis: ,
:

52

. ,
. .

- homo economicus, - . , .
, .
, ,
. , , : ;
;

(- ) . .
,
, , ,
.
, ,
,
, .

. ; .
:
;
,
,
.

53

commons vs crisis


commoners.
,
,
commoners ,
.
, - -
.
: ,
.
.
,
,
; .
. ,
, ,
.
. , ,

,
.
! , ,
, , . ,

, . ,
,

54

. ,
. , . ,


.
, .
, .

(commoning) -
,
.

.


, .

.
, : ,
. ,
-
. , ,

. ,

55

commons vs crisis
,
.
.
,
.


, . , .

- .
Massimo De Angelis:
.
,

-commoning. ,
. , . , ,
, ,
.

Massimo De Angelis: ,
,
,

. commoning
. ,

56

.
,
,
, ,
.
commoning .

commoning, commoners,
. ,


, , . , -
, ,

commonig
.
,
,

commoning. .
commoning
,
(constituent movement)
.
An Architektur: ,

57

commons vs crisis
, Massimo; ;
:
. 50% !
. .
,


.

,
, ,
.
,
.
, ,
,
.
, ,
- .

,

70. ,
Christianias; ,
,
.

58

. : ,
- -, -
-. , - -
, , ,
,
.

An Architektur: , ,
;
,
. ; ;
:

. , .
.
.
banlieue.
, .
, ,
. ,
. ,
, ,

59

commons vs crisis

,
, . , . .
.
, ,

, , ,
,
.
.
, .
. ,
.
. . , .

.
. ,

,
,

. , ,

. -
- () -

60

.
:

An Architektur: , projects.

,
;
:
(space) .

. ,

- ,
. , ,

.
,
,
. , ,
.

61

commons vs crisis
, ,
,
,
, . .
,
,
.
,

.

. Walter Benjamin,
,
. , (flaneur), :
.
,

. ,
.
,
, , ()
.
Lefebvre

.

-
-

62

.
, , . Lefebvre,

. , ,

, , , .
,
.

63

commons vs crisis

3. 1

Massimo de Angelis
, - ,
Elinor Ostrom

, . Massimo De Angelis


.

,

-

(commons): -
.

1. , Turbulence 5,
2009: http://turbulence.org.uk/turbulence-5/capitalist-commons/

64

.
, ,
- .
.
. Joseph
Stiglitz, - ,
,
.
, ,
. Stiglitz, ,

.
,
: ,
, ,
. , Stiglitz
.
-
-

. , Stiglitz

,

65

commons vs crisis

.
:
,
.
,
,
.
, Stiglitz,
.
;
(commons) (common interests).
,
- .
,
.

(global sisterhood)
. ,
, .
, -

66

(
, , )
21 .
.
, , .

, , , .
Stiglitz .
Stiglitz
.
,
.
.

.
- (distorted commons), -
, .


. ,
. ..

,

67

commons vs crisis
.
, ,
,
.

(distorted commons),
.
,

,
. ,

.
.

.
, ,
, .
,
. ,
,

. ,
,
.
,
.
- (distorted

68

commons),
. ,
- (distorted commons).

. , , -
(non-commodified common spaces and
resources). , -
.

. ,
.
,


, .
.
, -
(- ,
..).
,
.

69

commons vs crisis
,
,

. ,
.
.
. , -,

- ,
-
.
.
. ,
:
,
. , :

- . ,
:
. , ,
- , -
(distorted)
. ,
, (, , , )- :
.

70

(reclaiming commons)2
, ;



. ,


. , :
. ,
, .

(.. ) .


,

2. reclaim
,

-
- (
-),
, .

71

commons vs crisis
. ,

, , .
;

,
;
- -
(distorted commons). ,


( ) .
,

. ,
, , . .
,
- .
:

( ) .

72

4. : 1

Werner Bonefeld2
3

, , .
.

(Caffentzis, 1999). ,
(Federici, 1997). - (Dalla Costa, 1995a,

1. : The
Commoner 2, 2001, http://www.commoner.org.
uk/02bonefeld.pdf, . , Athens
Indymedia (6 2005).
2. Werner Bonefeld York ,
Open Marxism
K (1991), What is to Be done (2002),
Subverting the Present, Imagine the Future (2010).
3. Massimo De Angelis
.

73

commons vs crisis
1995b). Marx


,
(Marx, 1983, p. 707),
.

. ,
, ,
. ,

. ,
. , ,
.
. ,
, ,
.

- .
.
.

, - .

74

, - ,
(clearing of the estates)-
: . , ,
-
.
,
.
,
Luxemburg (1963), (capitalism proper)
. Luxemburg, ,

, , ,

. , ,
(original accumulation)
, , :
. , , .
Luxemburg
, ,
.

75

commons vs crisis
Amin, 1970,
: - ,
. , , ,

(Amin, 1974, p. 3).4

, , ,
. Marx (1973, p. 515) ,
- - -
(propertylessness) .
.

Marx
[ ]
.5

4. de Angelis (1999). De Angelis . Bonefeld

(1988; 2001).
5. Marx (1966, Ch. 48).

76

.6 Marx, ,
, , , , []

(Marx, 1972, p. 508) , , (Marx, 1962, p. 90).7
,
, ,
(Marx, 1972, p. 515).
:
(Marx, 1966, p. 391). -
; -

(.., p. 818). , ,
,

. ,

. , Marx, [

6. Marx (1966, p. 880; 1972, p. 491).

7. verrckt form,
absurd form (Marx, 1983, p. 80). absurd. , verrckt : verrckt (mad/)
ver-rckt (displaced/). , perverted forms
mad displaced. perversion / perverted /
.

77

commons vs crisis
] [ ] (Marx, 1962, p. 95).
.8 :
,
,
,
,
,

(Marx, 1973, p. 489).


.
.
-
. , , ,
(Marx, 1972, p.
272).
(..).
Marx, .
...
( )

.

8.
.

78

(
)
(.., p. 89).
, , (Krahl, 1971,
p.223). ,

[] ...[]
(Marx, 1972, p. 272).
(Marx, 1972, p. 422)
[ ]
(..). , ,
, . ,
(Marx, 1966, p. 880).

(..).
,
,
,

(..). , (aufgehoben)
. , ,
. ,

-

79

commons vs crisis
, , -
, (Marx, 1973, p. 460). , -

. , ,

-
(Marx, 1983, p. 585).


,
.9 ,

- (wage-labouring commodity).
,
, ,
.
Marx:
.

,
.
,

9. : Negt Kluge (1981).

80

, , .
, , , ,
, (Marx, 1983, pp. 77-8).
, ,
: .

.
, , .
, ,
, , .
,
, (Marx, 1973, p. 162).



(.., pp. 163-64).
, , , , ,
.
,
,
.
(cf. Negri, 1984)

, , ,

81

commons vs crisis
(Marx, 1983, p.
555). . ,
,
.
, [ ]
,
(..).

,
,

.
(Marx, 1963, p.
408). ,


(Gambino, 1996, p. 55).


- ,

-
, , ,
(Marx, 1973, pp. 452-53). (Marx, 1972,
p. 422). , Marx,
(..).
, Marx
, , , ,

82

, . ,
, (.. 422).


(.. p. 271).
, , . , . Marx
, [bildet] [Begriff]
(Marx, 1966, p. 246). (Marx, 1978, p. 116) ,

(Marx, 1983, p. 85). , ,
,
.10 , , -
(pre-positing) .11
: - ,


. ,
-

10. Holloway (1995).

11. Psychopedis (1992).

83

commons vs crisis

(Clarke, 1982, p. 80).12
, ,
.

. , ,


.
, ,
, ,
(
) (Marx, 1966, p. 246).
, , .
,
,
, .
,
, , , , ,
, ,
, [] . -
-

12. , Bonefeld (1993).

84

, ,
, , , , [ ]
, ...,
, (Marx,
1972, pp. 475-76).
. .
,
.
, ,
[] .
, [] , [
] , ,

, ,
, , , ,
,

(Marx, 1972, pp. 507-8).
, ,
,
[Dasein] . ,
,
,

85

commons vs crisis
. ,
(Marx, 1973, p. 458).
, , . ,
(..).
,

,

.

() () .13
Horkheimer (1985, p. 246),
.
, ,
. ,

, .


(Negri, 1992, p. 70).
,


.14
, ,

13. , , Brenner (1998),

.
14. Bonefeld (1999) Lebowitz (1999).

86

. Marx
: . ,
, ! , ,
, ,
,
,
a person apart.

(Marx/Engels, 1980, p. 98). Marx
(unreflected) :
. ,
Marcuse ,
,
(1988, p. 151).
, , . , ,

,

(Jessop, 1991).

- ,
:

(Negri, 1992, p. 70).
:

87

commons vs crisis
(Marx, 1972, p. 492)
, ,
(Marx, 1983, p. 555).

(.., p. 568)
,
.
, , ,
[ ]:
,
,
[]
, . ,
, sine qua non (.., pp. 535-36).
, ,
.
Marx,
,
(Marx, 1972 p. 272, Marx,
1983, p. 688).
(Marx, 1973, p. 507).

, (objectless labour) (.., p. 508).

,

88

. ,
- (.., p. 555)

.

(Urquhart, Marx, 1983, p.
343), , ,
[Mensch] (cf. Marx, 1977, p. 155). ,
,
,
(Marx, 1983,
p. 317).

.

(Marx, 1973, p. 399).
. , -,
.

. , ,
.15 -

15. ,
,
, . ,
(actual) ...

89

commons vs crisis
,
, ,
, Marx
. , (Gewalt),
, ,
,
, ,
, , ,
, , ,
.
, , ,
- . ,
(value form)
. (cf. Marx, 1973, p. 105).
, , ,

[Mensch], ,
,
...
[] .
,
, , , ,

(Marx, 1966, p. 820). Wildcat Holloway (Wildcat, 1999).

90

,

. .
,
(Dalla Costa, 1995a,
p. 21). -.

,
, .

(Dalla Costa, 1995a,b, Caffentzis, 1995)
.
- . (cf. Agnoli, 2000)
(cf.
Godelier, 2000),
. Marx (1983, p. 447)
, ... ,
.
:
.
. . , .

91

commons vs crisis
, ,
forces propres


(Marx, 1964, p. 370). Marx
,

.
. (, ,
)
-

(Marx and Engels, 1962, p. 74).
Adorno (1975, p. 44),
. , ,
.


.
. , ,
,
,
, (dignities)
,

(cf. Marx, 1983,p.85). , .

92

, ,
, (Marx,
1983, p. 309). , ,
, , ,
,
, (cf.
Marx, 1975, p. 182). ,
(object-less labour). , ,
.

.

Adorno, T. (1975), Gesellschaftstheorie und Kulturkritik,

Suhrkamp, Frankfurt.
Agnoli, J. (2000), The Market, the State and the End of History,
in Bonefeld, W. and K. Psychopedis (eds) The Politics of Change,
Plagrave, London.
Amin, S. (1974), Accumulation on a World Scale. A critique of the
theory of Underdevelopment, Monthly Review Press, New York.
Bonefeld, W. (1988), Class Struggle and the Permanence of
Primitive Accumulation, Common Sense no. 8.
Bonefeld, W. (1993), Crisis of Theory, Capital & Class, no. 50.
Bonefeld, W. (1999), Notes on Competition, Capitalist Crises and
Class, Historical Materialism, no. 5.
Bonefeld, W. (2001), Labour, Capital and Primitive Accumulation:
Class and Constitution, forthcoming in Dinerstein, A. and M.
Neary (eds) The Labour Debate, Ashgate, Aldershot.
Brenner, R. (1998), The Economics of Global Turbulance, New
Left Review, no. 229.

93

commons vs crisis
Caffentzis, G. (1995), The Fundamental Implications of the Debt
Crisis for Social Reproduction in Africa, in Dalla Costa, M. and
G.F. Dalla Costa (eds) Paying the Price, Zed Books, London.
Caffentzis, G. (1999), The End of Work or the Rennzissance of
Slavery?, Common Sense, no. 24.
Dalla Costa, M. (1995a), Development and Reproduction,
Common Sense no. 17.
Dalla Costa, M. (1995b), Capitalism and Reproduction, in
Bonefeld, W. etal. (eds.) Open Marxism: Emancipating Marx,
Pluto, London.
de Angelis, M. (1999), Marxs Theory of Primitive Accumulation: a
Suggested Reinterpretation
Federici, S. (1997), Reproduction and Feminist Struggle in the
New International Division of Labour, in Dalla Costa, M. and
G.F. Dalla Costa (eds) Women, Development and Labour
Reproduction, African World Press, Lawrenceville.
Gambino, R. (1996), A Critique of the Fordism and the Regulation
School, Common Sense no. 19.
Godelier, M. (2000), The Disappearance of the Socialist System:
Failure or Confirmation of Marxs View on the Transition from
One Form of Production and Society to Another?, in Bonefeld,
W. and K. Psychopedis (eds), The Politics of Change, Palgrave,
London.
Holloway, J. (1995), Capital Moves, Capital & Class no. 57.
Horkheimer, M. (1985), Zur Kritik der instrumentellen Vernunft,
Fischer, Frankfurt.
Jessop, B. (1991), Polar Bears and Class Struggle, in Bonefeld, W.
and J. Holloway (eds) Post-Fordism and Social Form, Macmillan,
London.
Krahl, J. (1971), Konstitution und Klassenkampf, Verlag Neue
Kritik, Frankfurt, 4th ed. 1985.
Lebowitz, M (1999), In Brenner, Everything is Reversed, Historical
Materialism, no. 4.
Luxemburg, R. (1963), The Accumulation of Capital, Routldege,

94

London.
Marcuse, H. (1988), Philosophy and Critical Theory, in ibid.
Negations, Free Association Press, London.
Marx, K. (1962), Das Kapital, vol. I, MEW 23, Dietz Verlag, Berlin.
Marx, K. (1963), Theories of Surplus Value Part I, Lawrence &
Wishart, London.
Marx, K. (1964), Zur Judenfrage, in MEW 1, Dietz, Berlin.
Marx, K. (1966), Capital Vol. III, Lawrence & Wishart, London.
Marx, K. (1972), Theories of Surplus Value Part III, Lawrence &
Wishart, London.
Marx, K. (1973), Grundrisse, Penguin, Harmondsworth.
Marx, K. (1975), Contribution to Critique of Hegels Philosophy of
Law. Introduction, Collected Works, vol. 3, Lawrence & Wishart,
London.
Marx, K. (1977), Das Elend der Philosophy, MEW 4, Dietz, Berlin.
Marx, K. (1978), Capital, Vol. II, Penguin, Harmondsworth.
Marx, K. (1983), Capital, vol. I, Lawrence & Wishart, London.
Marx, K. and F. Engels (1962), Die deutsche Ideology, MEW 3,
Dietz, Berlin.
Marx, K. and F. Engels (1980), Die heilige Familie, MEW 2, Dietz,
Berlin.
Negri, A. (1984), Marx beyond Marx, Bergin & Garvey,
Massachusetts.
Negri, A. (1992), Interpretation of the Class Situation Today, in
Bonefeld, W. etal. (eds.) Open Marxism: Theory and Practice,
Pluto, London.
Negt, O. and A. Kluge (1981), Geschiche und Eigensinn, Verlag
2001, Frankfurt.
Psychopedis, K. (1992), Dialectical Theory, in Bonefeld, W. etal.
(eds.) Open Marxism: Dialectics and History, Pluto, London.
Wildcat and J. Holloway (1999), Wildcat (Germany) reads John
Holloway - A Debate on Marxism and the Politics of Dignity,
Common Sense, no. 24.

95

commons vs crisis

5. :
1

Midnight Notes2
.
.

,
, , .
:
2008 .

1. Promissory Notes: From Crisis to Commons,

Midnight Notes Collective 2009: http://www.midnightnotes.
org/Promissory%20Notes.pdf, -.
2. Midnight Notes Collective 1979
,
George Caffentzis, Silvia Federici, Ian Boal,
Peter Linebaugh, .., 3
, , , , , - ,
.
Midnight Notes Collective http://www.
midnightnotes.org/

96

: ,
, .

. , ,
.
. ,
, , , ,
.
,


, .
.
, .

, 2008 ( ).
.


;

,
.
,
. ,

97

commons vs crisis
,

[hedge-funds]
. , ,
,

.


.
21
19 ,
, ,
.
,
, . , .
(

).


. ,

: , , .
, , . 1930,

98

,
,
.

, . ,
. ,

. ,

. ...

, ( , ,
) ,
.
: ,

;
, , 19 :
. 1848:
...,
.
, ,
,
.

:

99

commons vs crisis
,
. ,
.

, ,
.
.
, .
:
1. .
2. .
3. .
4. (commoning).

.
5.
.
1. :

New Deal. ,

New Deal.
, .
, .

, . ,
-

100

,
. .

, , .
, ,
80 90.
,
. ,
, , ...
.
. ( ),
.

,
!
, [financialization] , ,
,
.
-

101

commons vs crisis
,
.
,
( )
,
New Deal.
. , . ,
/
: , .
.. (
,
.)
. ,
New Deal.
New Deal )
, )
)
. New Deal

, ,

,
.
. ,

30. (

102

..)
New Deal, ,
60 70
New Deal.
,
,
, . ,
,
. ,
( ) 70.
, 70
.
80
:
.
, .
30
,

.

, , .
, -

103

commons vs crisis

(
19 ). ,
: , ,
,
(. MN, 1997).
( )
,
( P.M, 1985) A-deal ( ),B-deal ( ) C-deal (
).

A-deal:
1981,
1985,
(
).
B-deal: ,
.
C-deal: ,

()
() .

104

, ,
.

,
.
.
,
90
sweatshops .
, 1997 .
,
.

.
,
. , hedgefunds .
,
. ,
( )
( ).


.
, .
-

105

commons vs crisis
( )
.
. , , : ,
; / / /
:
/ 100%.
,
50%. ;

,
.
. , ,

. ,
.
,
;
,
: )
)
( )
. ,

. , ,

106

.
, , ) ).
)
, ( , ),

. ,
.


. , ,
,
.
400% 1996-2006,
300% 1990-2005,
2000 2005.


.
.
1/10

100%.
1/5
. , ,
50%.
, ,
. -

107

commons vs crisis
, ,
1997, One
No and many Yeses (, 1997).
(
, )
.

.

, Gucci.


,
.
:
.
. ,
, ,
. , ,
,
.
) /
. ,

. ,

108

,
, ,
,
(GM),

.
, .

, ,
Monet.

. ,
.

,
.
, , ,
,
... ;
.



;
. ,
, -

109

commons vs crisis

.

,

.
,
, ,
.
, , , (
)
.
2. :
.
, ,

, :
. ,
, ;

.

30,
,
. , . ,

110

, .
, ,
, .

( )
, ,
(
, ...). ,
70, OPEC

.
()
1975

.

.
,
.
,
.

111

commons vs crisis

.

70 ,
,
,
.


. , :
1.
.
2.
/ .
3. (
).
4. (, , ).
5.

.
6. , ,
.
1.


, ,
.
GATT ( )

112

() 1994. ,


.
. , , ,
:
)
80, 1989, 1994.
)
,
, , G8.
)
(
) , , ,
.
.


. , Doha
,
.

1998-2008 (
, ).

, ,
,

113

commons vs crisis
,
.
2. 1999. ,

,
(, 2002). ,
. . , ,

, ,
:
(OPEC) . , , ,
.
( ). , ,

2011,
! ,
,

.

114

3.

1973.
,
70.
(.. ) .
, , ,
,
, . ,
,

.
,
, .
, .
, 1997 (. , 1997).
,

,
.
4.
,
.
, -

115

commons vs crisis
.

, . , - (common
land) (
), .

. , ,
(Movement for
the Emancipation of the Niger Delta, MEND).

, . ,
, .
Hubbert.
5.
,
. ,
, .
/ / /


; / -

116

/
;
, ,
, .

:
[subprime mortgages], ,
, 401(k). ,
,
. ,
. ,
( , ), . , ,
.
,
. ,
(, , ...)
.
,
.

.
.
,
.

117

commons vs crisis
,
.
,

/ /.
( )
.

.

,
. ,

, .
,
(
),
. ,


. ,
,
,
. ,
$1000 ,
. $1.000.000.000
, .
, 1.000.000

118

$1000 ,
!

.
, ,
. (

, )
. , ,
,
,
. , .
[intra-class], [omni-class],
[inter-class]
.
6.
(, ,
, )
, .
21 ,
,
. ,
, ,
; , , ,
, ,
-

119

commons vs crisis
.



21 .
.

,
(5) (6);
,

.
( ),

. ,

. 60
redlining . ,

. , ,
21 ;
. , ,
2008.
, , ,
, ,
, -

120

. (
) ,
, ,
.
3.

: )
, )

) ,
, ,
.
:
I. ;
,

.
,
.
.
(
)

( ,

121

commons vs crisis
, , offshore
!)
, ; ,
,
;
,
(
) multipurpose (Citygroup),
(AIG), (BearStearns)
.
GM Chrysler
AIG,

.

,
21 ,
: ) ,
(
,
) ) ,
.

122

, Bubble Act 1720
, ,
1720, Glass-Steagall Act
1929.

,
.

,
:
( )
,
, ,
. 21 ,
20 , (

);
, (
). . ,
(
)
.
, -

123

commons vs crisis
. ,
(
)
.


.
II.
, 19 ,
. 1860:
,
. ,
, .
. (

).

. ,
(
) , , , ,
.
,
,
.
, 19 .

124

,

. ,
.

,

. ,
19 ,

( ) .
, . .


(
30% ). ,
21 ,
[inter-class] ,
.
,
--,

. ,
. :
21
;

125

commons vs crisis

;

, , , , .
(
) ,
, ,
, . ,
,
,
,
.

.
.
, .

:
, ,
,
.
,
.
,
,
,

.

126

III. : .
.
, 80. ,

,
70 ,
, (
). 1979
,
, .
,
80, , ,

,

().
,
,
, .
,


.
1997,

127

commons vs crisis

1980 1990. , ,
, .

80 2000.

, ,

,
.
,
Chiapas . ,

21 , (,
).
, ,
, /
, ,
.. .
( )
, ,
.
, ,
(.

). , ,
,

128

. ,

. ,
G20
1
.

.

, . ( ),
,
. (
, , , jatropha )
, .
,
,

.
jatropha ( ).

.


,

129

commons vs crisis
, ( )
,
. ,
.
, ,

. .
,
!
3.


.
( ,
). Republic
Windows and Doors ,
.

: City Life
. IAF
. ,
Take Back the Land

. ACORN
San Francisco Bay

130

. ,

.
,
. ,
, .

, .

,
.
, ,
,

, .

:
, , ;
,
(, ) (, , ).
, ,
, .
,
, -

131

commons vs crisis
, , 15
, G20,
. ,
BBVA. , Lehman
Brothers, Robin-Bank
38 ,
.
,
,

.
,
70% ,
.
, ,

: .
:
. , ,
, ,
.
, , , , ,
, , .
4. :
.

132

. ,
, .
,
,
( )
.
,
(
) .

.
; , ,

.
Common Sense.
, , , , .
: . : !.
, ,

. ( )

, . .

133

commons vs crisis
(our common). ,
,
,

. , ,
,
,
. , ,

, .
,
,
,
.
.
,
, ,

. ,
,
.
, .

,

. ,
. ,
.
:

134

* 37 .
*
.
*

.
*
.
* 70
.
* .
. ,
.
, ,
, , .
( , ,
/ ),

(
, , , , )
( 13 14, Wagner Act,
Voting Rights Act ).
, , -

135

commons vs crisis
.

Rio Bravo.
, , ,
potencia (-) poder ().
(2005): ,

,
: , , , ,
, , , , , , , .
.
, ,
,
,
,
,
.
.

,
. ,
,
.
.
,
, .

136

: .
,
,
.
, 1970. .
,
hobo jungles
, , , ,
, .
:
,
.

.
.
, ,
(Tent Cities)
,
.
:
.

. , ,
,
, , ,

.

137

commons vs crisis
:

.
,
.
: ,
. ... !

,
,
, ,
business as usual.
:
.
15
;
,
, ;
: , ,
. ,

.
, . :
* :

138

( )
(
, ).
.
*
. ,
21 ,
, ,
,
,
, , , ,
( ,
, , ).
, , , .

, ,
,
.
*
, . . ,

( ),
.
*

139

commons vs crisis
, , .
* ,

.
,
. ,
.
* : ...
5. .
, , ,
.
...
(

).

( )
(
)
. ,
20 , .
/,

140

. ( ) -,
/ ,
. ,

.
. ,
/
.

, .
/ ,
.

, , , , ,
,
,
. , . ,
.
, ,
.
, , , .

141

commons vs crisis
(
. ) , (..
) . ,
, , ,

.
. MN
. Massimo de ngelis ,
, The beginning of History:
, , , ,
, , ,
,
, , (
). ,



,
,

. (DeAngelis, 2007: 227).
Chris Carlsson
Nautopia , :
,

142

, ,
, ,
, , (Carlsson, 2008:45).
,
,

.
, /
. ,
, . . ,
,

/
, ,
, .
, ,

,
, , , , .
2005,
, brador
PRD ( )
, ,
-

143

commons vs crisis
,
.
.
, . ,
, , , , ,
. ,
,

. , , , ,
, ,
.
, . ; ,
,
,
.

, ,
.

,
(..

144

).

, ,
,
.
1. , ,
, , ,

. ,
( ),
.
( ,
)
.
: , , , , , , (
) . (

, ).
/; ; ,

;
2.
, , . , ,
. .

145

commons vs crisis
, Kolya Abramsky Gathering Our
Dignified Rage:
,
, ,
; (Abramsky, 2008). ,

, Zerowork
70: ,


(MN, 1992: 112).
3. .
, ,
.

/, .
.
4. .
.

, , , . ,
, ;
, (
, ); ,
,

146

; ,
; ( ),
;

;
5. .
.

.
.

, ,
. . ,
,
, .
1960, ,
,
.
/
/
; (
,

). ,
;
; : -

147

commons vs crisis
urban gardening
,
,
.
, .,
,

( , ). , (
) , ,
. , ,
,
. ,
( , , , ) ,
,
,
;
6. .
, ,
. ,
,
.

;
; ,
;
7.

148

, , , ,
(, )

. :
( ) .
, .
; , ,
,
.

( , , ). ,
,
.
8. .
. , .
.
, . , ,
(bioengineering) , , , , ,
, .

,
.
9. . , -

149

commons vs crisis
. ,
.

.
.
. ( )
.
.

(
)
,
,
.
6. :

. ,

.
,

.

. ,
,
, -

150

. ,

, :
;
,
1989;
. , ( , , ,
),
.
, ,
.
( )

( ),

( ),

.

, , ,

. , 1990 (
)
( ).

151

commons vs crisis
, ,
,
,
(
).
. , ,
, . , ,
,
.

* Midnight Notes www.midnightnotes.org.

Abramsky, Kolya. 2008. A Gathering of Dignified Rage.

http://zapagringo.blogspot.com.
De Angelis, Massimo. 2007. The Beginning of History: Value
Struggles and Global Capital.
Boal, Iain, et al. 2006. Afflicted Powers: Capital and Spectacle in
a New Age of War.
Bonefeld, Werner (ed.). 2008. Subverting the Present, Imagining
the Future: Insurrection, Movement, Commons.
Carlsson, Chris. 2008, Nowtopia: How Pirate Programmers, Outlaw
Bicyclists, and Vacant-lot Gardeners Are Inventing the Future
Today!
Cleaver, Harry. 2000. Reading Capital Politically. Second edition.
Holloway, John. 2002. Change the World Without Taking Power:

152

The Meaning of Revolution Today. Holloway, J.

, .
Linebaugh, Peter. 2008. The Magna Carta Manifesto: Liberty and
Commons for All.
Midnight Notes. 1992. Midnight Oil: Work, Energy, War: 1973
1992.
Midnight Notes. 1997. One No, Many Yeses. ( www.
midnightnotes.org.)
Midnight Notes. 2001. Auroras of the Zapatistas: Global and Local
Struggles in the Fourth World War.
Midnight Notes. 2002. Respect Your EnemiesThe First Rule of
Peace: An Essay Addressed to the U. S. Anti-war Movement.
[ www.midnightnotes.org.]
P.M. 1985. Bolo-Bolo.
Shukaitis, Stevphen, David Graeber, with Erika Biddle. 2008.
Constituent Imagination: Militant Investigations Collective
Theorization.
(EZLN). 2005.
( VI:
).

153

commons vs crisis

6.

Common/Commons:

common/s communis,
comoenus ( ), com-,
manis ,
com-, unus /,
com- (e)meya
. , , communis
. communis
Communism, Communalis, Communa Commune Kommuna
Community (, ), common/commons,
, .. , , .
common/commons ,
(. , . , . )
. common/commons,
,
common pool resources ( , , , , , , , , ,
..)

154

- common pool resources communities

- commoning.
common/commons /,

, ,
commons - ,
. ,
commons ,
(
commodities), , ,
.
Commoner/Commoners:
,
(commoning), ,
, -
(reclaim commons)
(inventing commons). commoners
. Governing the Commons
Elinor Ostrom (Ostrom 2002)1, commoners 2.

1. Ostrom, E., [1990] 2002. , (. .), : .

2.
appropriate usurp arrogate commandeer misappropriate,
commoning,
,

155

commons vs crisis
commoners,
(pool resource),
,
. ,
-
- ( ),
, .

, , , (.. )
.
,
.

.

, ,
, , . , commoners
- (reclaim), -

reclaim
.

156

(commoning)
.

Marx - (realisation
- verwirklichung), . ,
commoners
- ,
,
( ) .

, commoners
,
commoning.
,
commoner, commoners .
Enclosure/ Enclosures/ New Enclosures: / / . enclosure enclosures inclosure
(15 ),
enclos enclore
,
incldere, incld, in- (
) claud clavis,
. , enclosure

157

commons vs crisis
. , , , ,
enclosure ,

. (anticommons). ,
enclosure ,
. ,
, ,
. , , ,

, ,
. , ,
70 ,

( , internet, , , , ),
,
( , ), (human
trafficking) ...
Anticommons: . (anticommons)

(commons). , -

158

, ..
(gated communities) ( ) (others) .

commoners. commoners
, ,

- . ,

enclosure, .

159

commons vs crisis

160