Professional Documents
Culture Documents
In Our Midst
A Final-Year Photojournalism project From The
Wee Kim Wee School of Communication & Information,
Nanyang Technological University By Wallace Woon
2 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
04 Myanmar:
Then & Now
Who Are
They? 12
30
Speaking With
Confidence
Away
Together 36
44
Away
On Duty
Burmese
Singaporean 52
54
Keeping The
Home Abroad
62
For Family
For the Future
4 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
Myanmar:
Then & Now
5
corruption and daily hardship, mass riots would pepper the 1970s, most,
if not all, meeting the same ruthless suppression from the authorities.
Under Ne Win’s rule, the country experienced policies that were
implemented on the advice of fortune tellers, which resulted in quirks
such as the production of 45 and 90-kyat banknotes as legal tender. The
systematic demonetization of existing 50 and 100 kyat notes meant that a
vast majority of the Burmese people had their savings evaporate into thin
air overnight. In 1987, the United Nations awarded Myanmar with the
dishonorable title of Least Developed Country.
The country would rise up a year later, following the brutal police
clamp downs on student protests which saw more than a hundred
students and civilians killed, in what is today known as the 8888 Uprising
– the date of 8th August 1988 considered auspicious by the Burmese.
Violence, anarchy and subsequently, martial law, swept the country, with
thousands perishing in confrontations with the police and military.
Dropping its colonial namesake Burma in 1989, the country adopted the
name Myanmar and continued the process of economic reform started by the
old regime. The landslide result won by the National League for Democracy
(NLD), led by the iconic Aung San Suu Kyi, during the multi-party elections
in 1990 was nullified by the military regime and many of the NLD’s members
were thrown into prison. Suu Kyi herself was put under house arrest and
10 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
would remain isolated in her own country just as Myanmar was to the world.
In response to a withdrawal of fuel subsidies, protests led by monks would
sweep the country again in 2007. The all too familiar ending of government
subjugation would replay itself and resulted in the much publicised and
criticised murder of Japanese photographer Kenji Nagai, as well as the
systematic round up and torture of the monks and protestors involved.
A series of changes, denounced by international observers to be
merely skin-deep, were undertaken but the first real breakthrough on the
international scene was to happen in 2010 when Aung San Suu Kyi was
finally released from house arrest and when the military government finally
made way for a civilian regime, albeit one formed of ex-generals.
President Barack Obama would become the first ever American head-
of-state to step on Burmese soil during his visit in 2012.
Finally allowed to participate in by-elections last April, the NLD won
41 out of the 44 seats on offer. Suu Kyi was, herself, elected to the House
of Representatives in Burmese parliament. Policy reforms tackling the
widespread corruption and the instability of the currency were implemented
and restrictions prohibiting foreign enterprise in the country were lifted. The
release of political prisoners was another step by the civilian government to
make amends with the population.
Businesses and tourists have already begun to flock towards the country.
With Myanmar looking to catch up with its prospering neighbours, the
world waits with “cautious optimism” as the country seeks to shed its
grisly and inglorious past.
11
ABOVE: Another of
Myanmar’s holy sites,
the Shwedagon Pagoda
is far from being just
a mere tourist sight.
The compounds of the
temple were a staging
ground for the monk-led
Saffron Protests of 2007.
12 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
13
Who AreThey?
14 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
First Footsteps
S
ome of the first Burmese to settle on Singapore soil during the
1960s and 1970s were doctors and lawyers. Their search for greater
economic and political freedom is something that still persists till
today and has expanded beyond those who come from the upper classes.
The following two decades – particularly after the violent
demonstrations in 1988 – saw an increased number of Burmese make
the decision to migrate to Singapore amongst other destinations, such
as the United States. The biggest community of Burmese living outside
of Myanmar today resides in neighboring Thailand numbering nearly
two million. Around half a million Burmese work in Malaysia and there
are sizable numbers in Japan, Pakistan (where about 200,000 Rohingya
Muslims have taken refuge), as well as countries in the European Union.
A Straits Times article dated 24th of September 1988, estimated that
around 400 families, or 2000 people, were living here at the time. The
article reported the reaction of the Burmese community in Singapore
to the 8888 Uprising and the brutal government crackdown. Official
reports in 2008 put the Burmese population in Singapore at 80,000
but individuals in the community claim that the numbers range from
150,000 to 200,000. These numbers include those holding tourist visas,
the various employment and social visit passes, permanent residents
and those who have since converted their citizenship.
The influx, which saw a near hundred-fold increment of the
population over twenty years, occurred during the 1990s and consisted
mostly of technically skilled workers, such as engineers and electricians,
in addition to the many students who came to pursue their studies. Due
to the academic focus on the sciences in Myanmar, the public perception
that science degrees had better job prospects and the lack of Singaporean
manpower to fill up “dirty jobs” such as ship repair, many Burmese with
15
ABOVE: Using a methodical often makes the journey back to Myanmar, Soe Myat’s daughter, Ms. Cynthia Soe,
approach and reasoning each trip lasting for a couple of months at 22, who was born and raised in Singapore,
with logic, Thihan helps
a time. says that she hopes to one day be able to set
students tackle questions
they might face in the Currently in her first year in the up a school in Myanmar to provide better
examinations. For his electronic and electrical engineering course opportunities for Burmese children. The
country, however, he hopes in NTU, Hnin Pwint Phyuson, 24, cites that communications undergraduate, currently
that both the rulers and her reason for staying is due to the wage and undergoing an internship program at
the Burmese people can job opportunities here being far beyond digital media agency Kult, says: “I feel
solve their issues through
those possible in Myanmar, but later adds very lucky to have grown up and studied
the same use of rational
thinking. that those are the only reasons. in Singapore and want to give back in
“If I could earn as much there (Myanmar) whatever way I can.”
as I could here, I would go back home to Echoing Cynthia’s sentiments is staff-
work,” she says. nurse Pyi Tha Tun, 58. Joining the Ren
Dr. Tin explains that the phenomenon is Ci nursing staff 18 years ago and having
fuelled mainly by “the feeling of nationalistic earlier spent 18 years at Yangon General
pride and the sense of community” inherent Hospital, Pyi Tha intends on retiring
in the Burmese. While many are keen to in his village utilizing the expertise he
pounce on the rapidly developing economic has gathered working in the healthcare
bandwagon that Myanmar is now known field. “I want to focus on education and
for, there are those who see more noble healthcare, to teach basic concepts of
reasons to return to the country. health to people in the village so they
27
don’t make ill-advised decisions when it Despite having grown up and spending intention of returning due to the fact that he
comes to their health,” he says. his adolescent years in Myanmar, he finds has gotten too used to living in Singapore.
While many are hopeful about the the procedural red tape and corruption that “My children are both studying here and
changes effected in Myanmar, and mars everyday routine unbearable. He cites I want the best for their future. I enjoy life
the possibility that they can directly an instance when he returned to visit his here and my income allows me to support
contribute to effect similar changes, there parents in Myanmar. my parents at home, so there is no reason
are those who have little, or no, intention “I was still holding a Burmese passport for me to go back,” he adds.
in returning to the country. at the time and upon arrival in Yangon There are also those who, having grown
Stepping onto foreign soil as a wide- International Airport, the authorities up abroad, feel little sense of attachment
eyed 19-year-old, Mr. Thi Han, 55, has proceeded to confiscate it.” He then to either their country of birth or the
since come to call Singapore home. elaborates on the established practice of country they were brought up in. Teacher
Despite having spent his formative years hiring “agents” who know exactly who Emiko Thein, 24, grew up following her
in Myanmar, Thi Han finds that he is more to bribe and how much (at each stage of parents around the world on ambassadorial
rooted to Singapore than to his country bureaucracy). “It was something like, one postings. “Although both my parents are
of birth. One of the key reasons being packet of cigarettes for the first fellow and a Burmese and I identify as Burmese, I don’t
Singapore’s often touted efficiency and bottle of Johnnie Walker for the next. After feel much attachment to Myanmar,” says
corruption-free processes. While many that I had my passport returned back to me Emiko. Born in Japan and having grown
Singaporeans take punctual train arrivals in no time.” up in Myanmar and Australia, Emiko,
and decisive action by the authorities for Quality executive at the Ren Ci who is currently working Singapore, feels
granted, there are those, like Thi Han, Community Hospital, Mr. Min Min more a citizen of the world than that of
who appreciate the full value of it. Aung, 36, similarly explains that he has no any single nation.
28 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
29
W
hile there can be little doubt that
Myanmar’s political and economic
revival has had an impact on the
Burmese community in Singapore, the question
for many of them is “Will I stay?”. Although
opportunities are newly abound in Myanmar,
many who have sunk their roots in Singapore feel
that their migration has become a permanent one.
Conversely, there are those, who despite having
spent many years living and working here, still feel
the yearning to return home - to retire in the less
stressful and quieter environment of Myanmar.
The new freedom experienced by Burmese at
home has led to a decline in the number of fresh
migrants opting to leave the country. Although the
generation of Burmese who have lived and worked
in Singapore for the majority of their lives are now
choosing to return to Myanmar, many are here to
stay and will continue to form an integral part of
our multi-ethnic society for years to come.
30 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
31
T
here is little that identifies Mr. Samuel Myat San,
31, as Burmese, not least his cleanly accented
English and his strong build. Only those familiar
with Burmese names might be able to pick him out as a
non-Chinese Singaporean.
The eldest son of a plastic surgeon and pediatrician,
Samuel moved to Singapore when he was 10, completing
his O and A levels at ACS(I) and ACJC. He went to
America to read International Relations at Harvard
University, writing his final thesis about sanctions in
Myanmar.
Speaking
After serving his PSC scholarship bond in various
government bodies, he left the civil service to become a
full-time speech and debate trainer and plies his trade in
his alma mater as well as other schools in Singapore.
With Confi dence During his days working in the civil service, he had
already begun to coach school debate teams, albeit on a
Two decades after he first came to pro-bono basis. He took the coaching job full time when
Singapore, Samuel has finally found he left the government service.
his feet living the Singapore dream. Samuel spends most of his time at schools where he
Despite this, he remains fiercely proud coaches debate teams and prepares them for tournaments.
of his heritage and spares no effort in
maintaining his cultural ties and traditions. As a student he juggled between two co-curricular
activities - track & field and the debate team. Samuel
stuck with the debate team as he found it to be more
intellectually challenging, chief of his complaints about
representing the school on the track were that “no matter
how hard you trained, genetics would only let you go so
far.”
He met his wife Stephanie in 2006 and tied the knot
in November 2012. They had two wedding ceremonies,
the customary church wedding as well as a traditional
Burmese wedding back in Yangon.Born to mixed Karen
and Bamar heritage, Samuel was baptized as a Christian.
His mother, at the time a practicing Buddhist, soon
followed suit.
As a student in junior college, he actively sought out other
students of Burmese ethnicity in a bid to practice the language.
While most had, like him, moved to Singapore at a tender age,
Communication, in the form of
there were those who had spent their formative years in
both concise articulation and
meticulous listening, is key to the Myanmar and as such he found some difficulty interacting
success of a debator. Mirroring with them, as they would often be on different wavelengths.
competition conditions, Samuel Despite spending more than two thirds of his life studying
indicates the time remaining in
order for his students to receive and living in Singapore, Samuel fondly retains his heritage.
the best training. “Without it”, he says “we have nothing to root ourselves to and
we lose our identity.”
32 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
“Without it, we
have nothing to RIGHT: A built-in library
stands as the showpiece
Accents
From
Myanmar
At his nuptials, Samuel and
his wife received numerous
wedding gifts, some bought
and some passed down.
Pieces such as the intricately
carved dish (right) hark
back to a more traditional
artform whereas the
Burmese chess set (bottom)
and the contemporary
paintings of Burmese daily
life (below) point towards
a country prepared to
embrace its forthcoming
development.
36 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
Away,
together
Alone in Singapore, immigrants like Win Naing Oo have to deal with
the financial burden of bills and monthly rental single-handedly, as
well as the feelings of isolation from the lack of close companions.
Joined now by childhood friends and his brother, he has come a
long way since arriving alone in Singapore fifteen years ago.
37
TOP: Although
Nan Thein (left), 33,
typically takes charge
of the cooking, having
guests over means
that the responsibility
of making dinner is
shared out amongst
everyone else in the
house.
Win enlists the help of his flatmates and his brother to carry an air cooler, amongst
other items in his luggage, from his home to the main road. The cost of electronic
appliances and other consumer goods are considerably cheaper in Singapore and
as such, individuals often fly home carrying a whole deluge of gifts for relatives and
friends back in Myanmar. Often too much for one person to handle alone, the bags
are stuffed with items such as instant coffee mix or the latest smartphones, in order
to bypass the import duties which are imposed.
43
44 MYANMAR
In Our Midst
45
Away
On Duty
In the wee hours of the morning when Singapore is fast sleep, the
lights of a hospital remain lit and nursing staff like San Lwin Oo
stay up and running. Instilled with a unwavering sense of duty,
the staff nurse at the Ren Ci Community Hospital undertakes his
tasks with utmost dedication and diligence.
BELOW: Doubling up as a
janitor, San often has to do
the dirty work that happens in
and around the ward although
his primary duties focus on
healthcare. Despite being in
charge of a team of nurses, he
is not excused from performing
clean-up work such as clearing
soiled bedsheets.
47
Burmese Singaporean
For Priscilla, her dual heritage is a source of frustration, early on in the friendship. where he oversees a community
whether from the questions she gets about her One would presume that of churches. He also runs a small
Singaporean citizenship, or the lingering connection repeated occurrences would parish that conducts Burmese
she feels with Myanmar . make an individual toughen up services in Singapore. Although
to these hurtful encounters, she the time he spends in Myanmar is
A
and protective of their identity. says, “I still get offended when often in excess of six months in a
lthough she was born
year, Priscilla and her sister have
and raised in Singapore, While foreigners are often people ask. I’m not lenient even
only visited the country on four
student Priscilla Kham, chastised for their effect on on those who are not close to
occasions, their most recent visit
22, often gets asked whether she the society and economy, new me.” in December last year. Raising
is Singaporean. citizens are equally prone to Having spent primary and his daughters in Singapore, he
“Even after I take out and receiving taunting remarks; secondary school days with finds no reason for the girls to
show them my pink IC, I still such is the extent of these some of her long-time friends, learn how converse in Burmese.
get skeptical looks from people”, xenophobic sentiments. it is not difficult to empathize As Singaporean as she might
she says. Currently interning as a with her frustration. be at heart, Priscilla says she
Queries like that may not journalist at The Straits Times, Born to Burmese and feels a connection to Myanmar,
seem out of place to most, many of the people whom Singaporean parents, Priscilla whether by way of her heritage
or because of her comparatively
given Singapore’s current social Priscilla meets at work and in has no doubts over where she
privileged upbringing.
climate. The heavy influx of her social life, some whom she chooses to call home. “My Of her inexplicable pining she
foreigners into the country, as later befriends, find the need to whole life is here, my friends says: “I definitely want to go back
well as the burgeoning ranks ask if she was born in Singapore. and family,” she explains. one day and do something in
of newly converted citizens, This is in spite of her accent, or Her father, Mr. Kenneth Myanmar, I don’t know what it
have led Singaporeans to lack thereof, and the fact that Kham, 63, often spends long is now, but I know I want to give
become fiercely nationalistic the question is rarely raised spells of time in Myanmar back in some way.”
53
“I definitely want to go back
one day and do something in
Myanmar, I don’t know what
it is now, but I know I want
BELOW: The Kham family’s trips
to Myanmar often see them put up
to give back in some way.”
in hotels or on the residence of the - Priscilla on acknowledging
church that Mr Kham runs in the her Burmese heritage.
country.
Abroad
Keeping the home Keeping the house and attending to two
young children earns San San the money
she needs to send her daughter to school
in Yangon, as well as to upkeep the home
she left four years ago for Singapore.
55
ForforFamily
their future
As a result of his resolute work ethic,
Nay Lin, 37, received personal assistance
from his boss,to help establish a family
and a home in Singapore.
63
LEFT: Pausing a
midday nap to tease his
son, Nay Lin explains
that the toy gun is
never loaded, the foam
bullets removed for the
safety of his two boys.
The author would like to thank the following organisations and individuals:
To Samuel, Win Naing, San Lwin, Priscilla, San San and Nay Lin. These are your stories, I hope that I have done justice to
them. Thank you for letting me into your lives and allowing me to learn about you, your country and your hardship. I am
eternally grateful for everything that you have so readily and generously given me.
Dr. Tin, Thihan, Ni Ni Long, Pyi Tha Tun, Phyuson(Snow), Ye Yint Aung, Vanessa and Emiko for the lovely conversations
about all things Myanmar and some things not.
Mum & Dad- for letting me chase whatever stories I think are worth telling and for burning countless litres of petrol.
Kay Chin - for believing that I’d somehow pull a rhinoceros out of a hat.
71
MYANMAR This work was produced as a Final-Year Project in
t h e S c h o o l o f C o m m u n i cat i o n a n d I n f o r m at i o n ,
In Our Midst N a n ya n g T e c h n o lo g i ca l U n i v e rs i t y , S i n g a p o r e