Professional Documents
Culture Documents
SUBMITTED BY
NAME: Rashid Khan MASTERS IN MANAGEMENT STUDIES. ROLL NO. 2011027 BATCH: YEAR 2011 - 2013
DECLARATION
I declare that the Project undergone by me, under the guidance of Prof. Amit Shrivastava, Internal Guide, Durgadevi Saraf Institute of Management Studies (DSIMS), Mumbai, and is an independent work. This report has not been submitted earlier to Mumbai University or to any other Institution. The report is towards the fulfillment of the requirement of the Master in Management Studies (MMS) course of Durgadevi Saraf Institute of Management Studies, Mumbai. The information submitted herin is true and original to the best of my knowledge.
PLACE
: MUMBAI
DATE
--------------------------------
(SIGNATURE)
Rashid Khan
ROLL NO: 2011049
Certificate
This is to certify that the project titled Future prospects of Broking firms in
This Project has been carried under the guidance of Prof. Amit Shrivastava.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I wish to thank all those who helped me and without whose support, I could not have completed this project successfully. First, I thank our Institute guide Amit shrivastava, who is the Professor of DSIMS whose help, stimulating suggestions and encouragement helped me in all the time in the writing of this project report. Without his patience, encouragement and constant guidance, I could not have completed this report. I would like to thank with immense gratitude Dr. RAKESH SINGH, the Director of Durgadevi Saraf Institute of Management Studies for allowing me to undertake this project. I wish to also acknowledge the contributions from officials of some of the stock broking firms & local people. I contacted for taking time out of their busy schedule to answer some pertinent questions concerning our work. Last, but not the least, I would like to thank our families and friends for their support and encouragement to pursue our interests. We would like to also express our gratitude to all those who have not been mentioned in this report work but gave us the possibility to complete this report.
INDEX
Sr.no 1 2 3 4 5 6 Particulars Introduction to International Financial market Introduction to stock market Evolution of Capital and Stock market in India Service provided by stock exchange/ stock broker in India Current Scenario of Stock Broking Firms in India Account opening & Charges, Customer service and Research of 4 unlisted broking firms in India 7 Account opening & Charges, Customer service and Research of 4 listed broking firms in India 8 9 10 11 12 Emergence of online and software based trading Online stock trading in India Net Sales of top 5 Stock broking company in India Conclusion References 19 23 24 27 28 18 Page.no 9 11 12 14 16 17
List of Abbreviations. 1] AMC Annual maintenance charges. 2] BSE - Bombay Stock Exchange. 3] NSE National Stock Exchange. 4] MCX Multi Commodity Exchange. 5] STT Securities Transaction Tax. 6] OTC Over the Counter. 7] NA Not applicable. 8] NCD Non-convertible debentures. 9] IPO Initial public offering. 10] MCA Ministry of corporate affairs. 11] SEBI Securities and Exchange Board of India. 12] RBI Reserve Bank of India. 13] NHB National Housing Banks. 14] IRDA - Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority. 15] M.Cap Market Capitalization. 16] FIIs Foreign Institutional Investors.
Research Methodology:
The research will utilize both quantitative and qualitative secondary data collection tools to achieve the objective of this project. The Data collection The secondary data will be collected from the following sources. 1] www.chittorgarh.com (comparison of charges and services of various brokers) 2] www.dnb.co.in 3] www.dnb.co.in 4] www.nseindia.com 5] www.sebi.gov.in
The financial market can be broadly classified into Money market and Capital market. A money market is a market were short term instrument are traded (less than 1 year) and the capital market is the market were long term securities or instrument are traded (more than 1 year). Money Market: Money market is a market for debt securities that pay off in the short term usually less than one year, for example the market for 90/180 days treasury bills. This market encompasses the trading and issuance of short term non equity debt instruments including treasury bills, commercial papers, bankers acceptance, certificates of deposits, etc. Capital Market: Capital market is a market for long-term debt and equity shares. In this market, the capital funds comprising of both equity and debt are issued and traded. This also includes private placement sources of debt and equity as well as organized markets like stock exchanges. Capital market includes financial instruments with more than one year maturity. A capital market is place were an Individuals and institutions trade securities. It includes 1] Equity shares. 2] Preference shares. 3] Corporate debts. 4] Government bonds. Need for investment in capital market: To earn return on your idle resources. To generate a specified sum of money for a specific goal in life. To make a provision for an uncertain future. The main objectives of capital market are: To mobilize resources for investments. To facilitate buying and selling of securities. To facilitate the process of efficient price discovery. To facilitate settlement of transactions in accordance with the predetermined time. A capital market can be classified into primary and secondary market. Primary market : It deals with new securities being issued for the first time. Eg: IPO, FPO, etc. Secondary Market : It is a market where existing share are traded with the help of stock exchanges.
10
11
Limited). NSE scored nearly 100% market share in the runaway success of equity derivatives trading, thus consigning BSE into clearly second place. Today, NSE has roughly 66% of equity spot turnover and roughly 100% of equity derivatives turnover. Sr. no 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Market participants FY 2010 27 9,772 1,705 1,459 75,378 17 164 5 243 2 FY 2011 (As on 30,Sep 2011) 27 10,248 2,240 2,083 79,797 19 192 3 248 2
Number of Stock Exchange Broker (cash segment) Broker (Equity derivatives) Broker (Currency derivatives) Sub- brokers Custodian Merchant Bankers Underwriters Portfolio Managers Depositories ( NSDL & CDSL)
13
they offer comes at a cost. There services charges, fees and brokerages are higher from discount brokers. They charges brokerage based on a certain % of the trade value. Most of the stock brokers in India are full-service brokers. Some popular names are Edelweiss financial services, ICICI Securities Pvt Ltd, HDFC Securities Ltd, Kotak Securities Ltd, etc. 2. Discount Broker (Discount Brokerage): An increasing popular discount broker's provides less number of services but at a much cheaper price. They offer no-frill services and specialized into few investment options. Discount brokers are good for 'do-it-yourself' kind of investors or well trained and experienced investors. While the services offered by them varies from broker to broker, many of the discount stock brokers do not provide services like stock research, investment in IPO's, Mutual Funds, FD's, Bonds and NCD's. They generally do not have their own research teams (not necessarily) and thus do not provide wealth management related services. Discount Brokerage is a new concept in India and its picking up very quickly. There are two sub categories of discount brokers in India by the way they charge the brokerage: A] Brokers charging Fixed Price per Trade: These are the brokers who charges 'fixed price brokerage per trade' irrespective to the size of trade. i.e. Zerodha, R K global, etc. B] Brokers charging Fixed Monthly Fees for unlimited Trades: These are the brokers who charge 'fixed monthly fees' and offers unlimited trading in selected segments and exchanges. R K Global Shares & Securities Ltd and RKSV Securities Ltd are two popular brokers who provide unlimited brokerage services based fixed monthly rates.
15
[Shailesh Menon, ET Bureau on Dec 11, 2012] Current taxes of securities and commodities at various exchanges: Sr. 1] 2] 3] 4] 5] 6] Taxes Transaction charges Stamp duty on Intraday Stamp duty on delivery STT on Trading STT on Delivery Service Tax {on brokerage} BSE 0.00335% 0.001% 0.010% 0.025% 0.125% 12.36% NSE 0.00335% 0.002% 0.010% 0.025% 0.125% 12.36% F&O 0.0020% 0.001% NA 0.017% NA 12.36% MCX 0.0025% 0.001% NA NA NA 12.36%
16
Account opening & Charges, Customer service and Research of 4 unlisted broking firms in India.
A/c opening and brokerage charges. A/c opening charges Annual maintenance charges Cash delivery Cash Intraday Future Options Minimum brokerage charges Customer services offered Email Support Phone Support Online Live Chat Toll Free Number Branches Ratings Research and Tips offered Daily Market Report Quarterly Result Analysis Free Tips News Alerts Ratings Investment option available Equity (stocks) Commodity Currency Initial Public Offers (IPO) Bond / NCD Debt Mutual Funds Ratings Kotak securities 750 600 0.49% 0.049% 0.049% Rs.100/lot Rs.4 paisa/share Sharekhan 750 400 0.50% 0.10% 0.10% Rs.100/lot Rs.10paisa/share Angel broking Nil 347 0.40% 0.04% 0.04% 0.04% Nil Ventura Nil 420 0.20% 0.03% Rs.50/lot Rs.50/lot Nil
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 5/5 Yes No Yes No 2/4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes 6/7
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 5/5 Yes Yes Yes Yes 4/4 Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes 7/7
Yes Yes Yes No Yes 4/5 Yes Yes Yes Yes 4/4 Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes 6/7
Yes Yes Yes No yes 4/5 No Yes No No 2/4 Yes Yes Yes No No Yes Yes 5/7
17
Account opening & Charges, Customer service and Research of 4 listed broking firms in India.
A/c opening and brokerage charges. A/c opening charges Annual maintenance charges Cash delivery Cash Intraday Future Options Indiabulls securities 950 450 0.40% 0.04% 0.04% 2.5% or Rs 100 per lot whichever is higher. Rs.4paisa/share India Infoline [IIFL] 750 300 0.50% 0.05% 0.05% 1% or Rs 100 per lot whichever is higher. Rs.5paisa/share Religare enterprises 500 300 0.25% 0.025% 0.05% 1% or Rs 50 per lot whichever is higher. Rs.1paisa/share Motilal Oswal Nil 441 0.50% 0.10% 0.10% Rs.100/lot
Minimum brokerage charges Customer services offered Email Support Phone Support Online Live Chat Toll Free Number Branches Ratings Research and Tips offered Daily Market Report Quarterly Result Analysis Free Tips News Alerts Ratings Investment option available Equity (stocks) Commodity Currency Initial Public Offers (IPO) Bond / NCD Debt Mutual Funds Ratings
Nil
No No No No 0/4
Customer service and Research of 4 unlisted broking firms in India in below diagrams [Assuming yes = 2 and No = 1].
2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Email Support Phone Support Online Live Chat Toll Free Number Branches Kotak securities Sharekhan Angel broking Ventura
In the segment of customer services, all five services are offered by all four brokers except toll free number for dial and trade are not provide by Angel broking and Ventura.
2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Kotak securities Sharekhan Angel broking Ventura
In the category of research and tips Sharekhan and Angel broking are providing all four kinds of research and tips i.e. daily market report, quarterly result analysis, free tips and news alert. While
19
kotak securities do not provide quarterly result analysis and news alert on the other hand Ventura provides only quarterly result analysis.
2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Kotak securities Sharekhan Angel broking Ventura
The equity, commodity, currency and mutual funds are provided by all four brokers. Investment options in IPO and Bonds are not provided by Ventura. Bonds/ NCD options are not provide by Angel broking and Debt options are not provided by Kotak securities.
20
Customer service and Research of 4 listed broking firms in India in below diagrams [Assuming yes = 2 and No = 1].
2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Email Support Phone Support Online Live Chat Toll Free Number Branches Indiabulls securities India Infoline [IIFL] Religare enterprises Motilal Oswal
In the segment of customer services, email support, phone support and branch trading are provided by all four listed broking firms. While, online live chart are not provided by any of the above four brokers and toll free number are provide only by Religare enterprise.
2 1.8 1.6 1.4 1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 Indiabulls securities India Infoline [IIFL] Religare enterprises Motilal Oswal
In the segment of research and tips, Indiabulls securities do not provide any research and tips. India Infoline provides all four research and tips i.e. daily market report, quarterly result analysis, free tips and news alert. Religare enterprises do not provide free tips, while Motilal Oswal does not provide free tips and news alerts.
21
The equity, commodity, IPO, debt and mutual funds are provided by above listed all four brokers. Motilal Oswal does not provide Currency and Bond options. India Infoline does not provide investment options in Bond/NCD.
22
Disadvantages of Online or Website based trading Platform: Sometime the website is too slow or not enough user friendly. Difficult for those who dont know much about computer and internet. You cannot trade if you are not on the computer where you have installed trading terminal software. It requires high speed internet connection. It becomes difficult when you are at job or on travel.
23
Unique draw tools including trend line customization and Fibonacci tools. Different chart type options such as Line, Bar and Candlestick.
REPORTS The reports comprise of Order Book, Trade Book, Net Positions, Margin, Exercise Book and Holdings. In any trading terminal, all these reports are dynamically updated without the need to refresh or pull information. From the Reports window you can Modify, Cancel, Square Off or Exercise. MARKET ANALYSER Market analyzer feature would provide top traded, top gainers and top losers with percentage change, value and total quantity. It would also provide the list of shares that have touched their 52 week High or 52 week low.
25
Revenue {Net sales} of top 5 Stock broking company in India {All the figure are in Crore} Sr Name 1 Religare entreprises 2 Edelweiss capital 3 India Infoline 4 JM financial 5 Motilal Oswal M.cap 4,565 2,364 1,780 1,221 1,115 2012 56.63 166.32 548.55 13.80 46.43 2011 126.66 448.74 698.95 43.72 49.53 2010 101.59 244.12 665.99 95.23 51.09 2009 12.55 191.39 542.27 24.46 55.71
The above historical or past result shows that the net sales of all top 5 five broking firms (in terms of market capitalization) has declined because various reasons such as increase in competition, decrease in volumes, etc. and because of the above reasons many stock broking firm are trying diversify their business and services.
26
Conclusion: Sr 1 2 3 4 5 Parameters Resource mobilization in primary market Market capitalization(BSE+NSE) All-India Equity market turnover All-India Equity Derivatives notional turnover* Net Investment by FIIs CAGR{2000-01 to 2010-11 27.18% 27.12% 17.99% 87.15% 30.88% (Source SEBI)
Note: All-India Equity Derivatives notional turnover is calculated from 2001-02 to 2010-11. The Indian equity market has made progress due to development of better and secured instruments and modern market mechanisms. The key strengths of the sector include fullyautomated trading system on all stock exchanges, a wide range of products, integrated platform for trading in both cash and derivatives. Stock markets in India have gone through tremendous improvements in recent time with the introduction of various norms. These norms are for greater transparency in operations and the international trading and investment process. Besides the market slowdown, stock brokers are facing multiple challenges in the form of structural changes that are sweeping the industry. A declining profits and reduced commission in financial products because of huge competition in Stock broking market in India. A number of Indian stock brokerages have entered into real estate broking as profits from their core equity broking business fall and commissions from the distribution of financial products shrinked. Mumbai-based IIFL (India Infoline) and Anand Rathi Financial Services have entered into commercial and residential real estate broking. Hyderabad-based Karvy stock broking [karvy group] has revamped its real estate broking business in the last few months. Many Stock broking firms have shown a major fall in net profit in 2011-12 compared with that in the previous year. The main reason for this is the fall in trading volume, and the overall volume is shifting from the cash market, which offers a decent brokerage, to the derivatives market, where the brokerage rates are very low. The competition from foreign players is increasing, especially in the institutional side which reduces the commission and other fees of Local and small broking firms. Hence, to sustain and grow in this competitive business environment the Indian stock broking firms needs to widen their customer base and increase their products and services to cater to all kinds of investors and provide advisory and consultancy services to corporate and Institutional investors.
27
Reference:
1] Foundation of Financial markets and institutions (3rd edition, Frank j. fabozzi, Franco Modigliani, Frank j. Jones and Michael G.ferri) 2] Introducing the Map of the Global Stock Market by Dariusz Wojcik 3] www.yeahindia.com/c-india1. 4] www.chittorgarh.com/newportal/online-stock-brokers-list.asp 5] Handbook on Basics of Financial Markets on www.nesindia.com 6] Article on Stock brokers slash charges as trading volumes nosedive/ Shailesh Menon, ET Bureau Dec 11, 2012. 7] www.sebi.gov.in/acts/contractact.pdf 8] http://vinodkothari.com/tutorials/Notes on Indian Financial Markets final 9] http://shodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/2027/7/07_chapter 2 10] http://www.stockmarketindian.com/online_stock_market_trading.html 11] http://www.sharemarketschool.com/understanding-the-online-trading-software/ 12] http://www.dnb.co.in/EquityBroking2011/overview.asp 13] http://www.nseindia.com/content/us/ismr2011ch1.pdf
28