Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Bill Leighty, Director The Leighty Foundation Juneau, AK wleighty@earthlink.net 907-586-1426 206-719-5554 cell
Pumped hydro (PHS) Compressed air (CAES) (large ans small scale) Natural gas - coupled (NGS) Flow batteries (FBES) Flywheel (FES) Superconducting magnetic (SMES) Supercapacitors
Energy Storage System Characteristics - A Storage capacity (Mwh, scf, nM3, Mt, gallons . ) Power (kW, MW, scfm, tpd, gpm .) In / out rate Costs Capital O&M Efficiency Response time Durability (cycling capacity, lifetime) Depth of discharge Self-discharge
Energy Storage System Characteristics - B Reliability Autonomy Adaptation to the generating source Mass and volume energy density Monitoring and control equipment Operational constraints Feasibility Environmental Safety
5
Must think long-term Benefits: aggregate; external Costs: aggregate; external Systems thinking tech, econ analysis
6
Pickens Plan
Bold, large-scale, motivates thinking GW scale: economies Underestimates Transmission cost, obstacles Grid integration, thermal gen plant abuse Firming storage needed Disregards Hydrogen demand Gulf Coast refineries Transport fuel Disregards Ammonia demand Fertilizer Fuel Attract new turbine manufacturers, designs ?7
State
North Dakota Texas Kansas South Dakota Montana Nebraska Wyoming Oklahoma Minnesota Iowa Colorado New Mexico
AEP, TWh
1,210 1,190 1,070 1,030 1,020 868 747 725 657 551 481 435
Wind Gen MW
(nameplate) (40% CF)
345,320 339,612 305,365 293,950 291,096 247,717 213,185 206,906 187,500 157,249 137,272 124,144
TOTALS
9,984
2,849,316
401
$ 401
890
$ 534
1.2
Seasonality Factor
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
Winter
Spring
Summer
Fall
11
Annual scale Firming Great Plains Wind Potential, 12 states, ~50% of land area:
10,000 TWh = 100 quads = entire USA energy, all sources, all uses 2,800,000 MW nameplate
Seasonality:
Summer minimum Spring Summer maximum storage Firming energy storage need per 1,000 MW wind = 450 GWh
12
Nurse tanks
Cost 1,000 gallon $ 6,321 Cost 1,450 gallon $ 9,502 Usually owned by Co-ops
13
Ammonia 620 kg H2
14
15
USDOE-EIA: Estimated 2050 energy use (All auto fleet using H2 from wind electrolysis)
Estimated Future U.S. Energy Requirements - 143.3 Quads)
Hydro 1.21 Bio/Geo 7.28
Bio/Geo 7.28
Projection Year 2050 From Year 2025 Efficiency Year 2025 Modified Energy Distribution Year 2025 Modified
17
How shall we bring the large, stranded, Great Plains renewables to market ?
18
19
Transmission:
Costly: $B Low capacity factor (CF) or curtailment NIMBY
Distributed or centralized ?
20
Largest highwaytransportable
21
,0 5
,0 0
,0 0
,0 0
,0 0
,0 0
,0 0
,0 0
45
14
18
30
30
40
60
90
11
,5 7
5, 86
30,000 Tons
$15M turnkey
-33 C 1 Atm
23
150 bar, 200,000 m3 physical $70 $30 per m3 physical Alton project, Nova Scotia: new, bedded, 5-15 caverns
NH3 tank
30,000 Mt optimal econimic size Atmospheric refrigerated
$ 60
$ ??
24
Personal Vehicle On-board Storage 300 mile range: estimated OEM cost per vehicle
Storage cost $ 100 $ 10,000 $ 300 $ 4,000 $ 3,000 $ 300 Hybrid drive train efficiency 25 % 90 % 25 % 35 % 60 % 45 % Storage capacity 10 gal ? kWh ? scf 5 kg 3 kg 15 gal
Gasoline, diesel Electricity: batteries CNG H2 (70 bar) ICEHV H2 (70 bar) FCHEV Ammonia (20 bar)
25
26
27
Analytical framework: Not all answers Long-term Benefits Costs Systems thinking tech, econ analysis
28
1: Adequate Renewables
Run the world; humanitys needs Distributed and Centralized Affordable, benign Diverse, synergistic Richest are stranded
Far from markets No transmission
29
30
Centralized:
Large, rich; lower cost than distributed ? But stranded (no transmission)
32
33
36
37
38
39
Flywheel: Electricity example Fast out, slow in Short-term: millisecond minute High volume energy density High cost / MWh
40
41
42
CAES
Compressed Air Energy Storage
Lowest-cost electricity storage Geology-dependent Requires generation fuel: NG Hours to days storage capacity; not seasonal renewables
43
CAES
McIntosh Unit 1, AL , began 91 Bremen, Germany, began 78 110 MW 290 MW
Iowa Energy Storage Park 268 MW Capital cost ~ $220M = engrg + construction (Nov 06 estimate) Construction cost @ 268 MW @ $800 / kW = $214M Mt. Simon site, Dallas Center; several others rejected DOE, via SNL = $2.9M, mostly geology Completion May 11 Energy storage capacity ??
44
Analytical framework: Not all answers Long-term Benefits Costs Systems thinking tech, econ analysis
Whence the hydrogen ? Conversion cost, loss ? Whence the ammonia ? Conversion cost, loss ?
46
Wind Generators
City gate
High-press Electrolyzers
Wind Generators
500 miles Hydrogen Gas Pipeline 20" diameter 1,500 -- 500 psi
Liquefy
Aircraft Fuel
47
1,000 miles Hydrogen Gas Pipeline 36" diameter, 1,500 - 500 psi Pipeline Storage = 240 GWh
AC grid W holesale
Storage
Liquefy
Aircraft Fuel
52 PB ESS
Wind Generators
AC grid Wholesale
N2
Electrolyzers
End users Retail Liquid Ammonia Transmission Pipeline Cars, Buses, Trucks, Trains
H2 H20
Wind Generators
Aircraft Fuel
53
Syngas
Electricity
CO 2
CT, ICE
Sequestration ?
H20 O2
Wind Generators
Air
Generator
Grid
Reactors
CO 2
N2
Electrolyzers
H2
Haber-Bosch Ammonia Synthesis
H20
Liquid Ammonia Transmission Pipeline Cars, Buses, Trucks, Trains
H2 H20
Wind Generators
Aircraft Fuel
54
Syngas
Electricity
CO 2
CT, ICE
Sequestration ?
H20
Air
Generator
Grid
Reactors
CO 2 H2
Water-shift Reaction
N2 O2
Electrolyzers
H2 H20
Wind Generators
H20
Liquid Ammonia Transmission Pipeline
Liquid Ammonia Tank Storage
Aircraft Fuel
55
SMR
H2 NH3
H-B
Electrolyzer
Wind Generators
AC grid Wholesale
N2
Electrolyzers
End users Retail Liquid Ammonia Transmission Pipeline Cars, Buses, Trucks, Trains
H2 H20
Wind Generators
Aircraft Fuel
58
ASU: Air Separation Unit Energy consumption 7,000 8,000 kWh per ton NH3
59
H-B $1.5 M per MWe input 2 tons / day output per MWe input O&M cost / ton: ?? SSAS $650 K per MWe input 3.2 tons / day output per MWe input O&M cost / ton: lower ?
60
Incremental Capital Cost Analysis: With and without Annual-scale Firming Storage
From Ammonia 06 presentation
Simple capital recovery factor (CRF) method Novel system: no experience Rough estimates of NH3 system components Many other cases to consider
61
Total annual costs $ 954 M Total cost per mt NH3 = $ 1,126 Total cost per kg NH3 = $ 1.13 1 Subsidies, value-adders: PTC, O sales, REC 2 2 Annual Energy Production @ $US 0.057 / kWh
64
Capital costs Wind generators, 1.5 MW @ $1,500 / kW Electrolyzers, 450 psi out @ $350 / kWe Electrolyzer power electronics saving H2 compressors NH3 synthesis plant Pipeline Pipeline pumping Pipeline infrastructure Tanks: 4 tanks @ $ 25 M Total, with firming storage
Case 4b: Annual costs, Firming storage tanks 2,000 MW Great Plains windplant
Elec GH2 NH3 Liquid Pipeline + tanks City gate
Capital costs @ 15% CRF @ $ 5,370 Conversion and transmission losses Electrolyzer conversion loss @ 20% AEP Compression NH3 synthesis plants (2) Pipeline pumping energy Pipeline misc O&M Tank in / out Total annual costs Total cost per Mt NH3 = $ 1,144 $ 805 M
$ 80 M $ 1M $ 80 M $ 2M $ 1M $ 0M $ 969 M
66
$ 1,030 M
67
System:
RE electricity source: Juneau hydro SSAS module ~ 10 kWe input NH3 storage tank NH3-fueled ICE genset ~ 50 kW: return to grid Village energy system prototype
68
69
Hydrogen Engine Center, Algona, IA 1,000 hours, ICE, 6 cyl, 100 hp 75% ammonia, 25% propane
70
Budget:
SSAS R&D from AEL&P to NThree, LLC Build 5-50 kW RE-NH3 system for AEL&P Build identical system for co-applicant Management + system integration + contingency Total $ 500K $ 100K $ 100K $ 200K $ 900K
71
72
Energy Storage with Anhydrous Ammonia: Comparison with other Energy Storage
74