You are on page 1of 44

ACQUISITION OF ATHEROS COMMUNICATIONS BY QUALCOMM

DEB SAHOO, MBA, ROSS SCHOOL OF BUSINESS, UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN, ANN ARBOR
April 25, 2011

INDUSTRY NEWS

Industry Buzz

Target Overview

Financial Statements of Buyer

Financial Statements of Target

11

Discounted Cash Flow Valuation of Target

15

Comparable Company Valuation of Target

18

Precedent Transactions Valuation of Target

22

Valuation Summary

24

Financial Projections of Buyer and Target

26

Transaction Analysis

29

EPS Accretion/Dilution Analysis

35

Profitability Contribution Analysis

40

Deal Fact

42

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Executive Summary

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Company: Qualcomm Inc.


Headquarter: San Diego, CA
CEO: Paul E. Jacobs
Number of Employees: 17,500
Engaged in the development, design, manufacture, and
marketing of digital wireless telecommunications products and
services based on code division multiple access technology
Develops and supplies CDMA based integrated circuits and
system software for wireless voice and data communications,
multimedia functions and global positioning system products for
wireless device and infrastructure manufacturers

Target Overview

Company: Atheros Communications Inc.


Headquarter: Santa Clara, California
CEO: Willy C. Shih, PhD
Number of Employees: 1,778
Developer of semiconductor system solutions for wired and
wireless communications products
Combines its wireless systems expertise with high performance
radio frequency (RF), mixed signal and digital semiconductor
designs and provides highly integrated but low cost chipsets

Key Financials of Buyer and Target

Valuation

Buyer

Total deal value: $3,654 MM


Total Enterprise Value/ 2011P EBITDA: 18.7x
Total Enterprise Value/ 2011P Revenue: 3.15x
FY 2011P P/E: 28.9x
Offer Price per Share: $45.0
Cash Consideration: 40%
Premium: 30.4%
EPS Accretion without synergy: +1.4%
EPS Accretion with synergy: +2.5%
% Shares owned by Qualcomm shareholders: 98%

Ticker: QCOM
Stock Price: $56.82
5 Year avg. Sales Growth: 15.0%
Market Cap: $95.55B
Number of Basic Shares: 1,617.7MM
2010 EBITDA: $3,949 MM
Total Enterprise Value: $78.54B

Ticker: ATHR
Stock Price: $34.50
5 Year avg. Sales Growth: 40.3%
Market Cap: $3.27 B
Number of Basic Shares: 73 MM
2010 EBITDA: $147 MM
Total Enterprise Value: $2,686B

Target

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Buyer Overview

TARGET OVERVIEW

Develops semiconductor system solutions for communication products


that include solutions for wireless local area network (WLAN), mobile
WLAN, Ethernet, Bluetooth, global positioning system (GPS), and power
line communications
Offers reference designs used in designing networking cards and
routers, broadband gateways, mobile devices, and handsets and
provides single and multi-chip WLAN products, including wireless
networking products for personal computers (PCs) and small
office/home office (SOHO) markets; and wireless infrastructure systemson-chip with network management capabilities for the enterprise
networking market
Atheros wireless system solutions are used in various applications in the
PCs, enterprise access, broadband gateway, SOHO networking,
consumer electronics, and mobile communications markets and Its
radio-on-chips for mobile solutions are used for WLAN in mobile devices,
such as smart phones and mobile consumer products
Its ETHOS products comprise access points, routers, gateways,
Ethernet physical layer, transceivers, and switches for personal computer
customers
Also provides Bluetooth solutions for PCs; GPS system solutions for
signal acquisition, tracking, data extraction, and GPS navigation

Industry Comparables

Products and Services


WLAN
ETHERNET
BLUETOOTH
HYBRID
GPS
PLC
PON

Stock Performance

Stock Price: $34.50


52 Week High: $44.88
52 Week Low: $22.77
Stock Beta: 1.82
FY 2010 EPS: $0.73

TARGET OVERVIEW

Company Overview

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF BUYER

30-Sep-10

30-Sep-09

30-Sep-08

28-Sep-07

29-Sep-06

10,991.0

10,416.0

11,142.0

8,871.0

7,526.0

Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) incl. D&A

3,517.0

3,181.0

3,414.0

2,681.0

2,182.0

COGS excluding D&A

2,851.0

2,546.0

2,958.0

2,298.0

1,910.0

666.0

635.0

456.0

383.0

272.0

Depreciation

437.0

428.0

372.0

317.0

239.0

Amortization of Intangibles

229.0

207.0

84.0

66.0

33.0

Gross Income

7,474.0

7,235.0

7,728.0

6,190.0

5,344.0

SG&A Expense

4,191.0

3,996.0

3,998.0

3,351.0

2,654.0

Research & Development

2,549.0

2,440.0

2,281.0

1,829.0

1,538.0

Other SG&A

1,642.0

1,556.0

1,717.0

1,522.0

1,116.0

0.0

230.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

3,283.0

3,009.0

3,730.0

2,839.0

2,690.0

935.0

653.0

646.0

826.0

523.0

58.0

24.0

22.0

11.0

4.0

122.0

1,545.0

529.0

27.0

24.0

4,038.0

2,093.0

3,825.0

3,627.0

3,185.0

787.0

484.0

666.0

323.0

686.0

1,557.0

182.0

465.0

229.0

387.0

389.0

291.0

245.0

185.0

156.0

-1,152.0

30.0

-36.0

-90.0

142.0

-7.0

-19.0

-8.0

-1.0

1.0

After-tax Adjustments - Net

-4.0

-17.0

1.0

-1.0

-29.0

Equity in Earnings of Affiliates

-4.0

-17.0

1.0

-1.0

-29.0

Consolidated Net Income

3,247.0

1,592.0

3,160.0

3,303.0

2,470.0

M inority Interest Expense

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

3,247.0

1,592.0

3,160.0

3,303.0

2,470.0

All figures in millions of U.S. Dollar, except per share items


Sales/Revenue

Depreciation & Amortization Expense

Other Operating Expense


EBIT (Operating Income)
Nonoperating Income (Expense) - Net
Interest Expense
Unusual Expense (Income) - Net
Pretax Income
Income Taxes
Income Taxes - Current Domestic
Income Taxes - Current Foreign
Income Taxes - Deferred Domestic
Income Taxes - Deferred Foreign

Net Income

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF BUYER

5 Year Income Statement of Qualcomm Inc.

30-Sep-10

30-Sep-09

30-Sep-08

28-Sep-07

29-Sep-06

10,279.0

11,069.0

6,411.0

6,581.0

5,721.0

Total Accounts Receivable

730.0

729.0

4,038.0

715.0

700.0

Inventories

528.0

453.0

521.0

469.0

250.0

Other Current Assets

596.0

319.0

753.0

1,056.0

378.0

Total Current Assets

12,133.0

12,570.0

11,723.0

8,821.0

7,049.0

Net Property, Plant & Equipment

2,373.0

2,387.0

2,162.0

1,788.0

1,482.0

Total Investments and Advances

8,123.0

6,673.0

4,858.0

5,234.0

4,228.0

--

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

Intangible Assets

4,510.0

4,557.0

4,621.0

1,989.0

1,707.0

Other Assets

1,511.0

415.0

369.0

345.0

230.0

Total Assets

28,650.0

26,602.0

23,733.0

18,177.0

14,696.0

1,086.0

2.0

1.0

0.0

0.0

764.0

636.0

570.0

635.0

420.0

Income Tax Payable

1,443.0

0.0

20.0

119.0

137.0

Other Current Liabilities

2,175.0

2,175.0

1,700.0

1,504.0

865.0

Total Current Liabilities

5,468.0

2,813.0

2,291.0

2,258.0

1,422.0

0.0

187.0

142.0

91.0

58.0

--

47.0

--

--

--

Deferred Taxes

-1,922.0

-840.0

-829.0

-313.0

-512.0

Other Liabilities

4,246.0

4,079.0

4,185.0

306.0

322.0

Total Liabilities

7,792.0

6,286.0

5,789.0

2,342.0

1,290.0

Common Equity

20,858.0

20,316.0

17,944.0

15,835.0

13,406.0

Total Shareholders' Equity

20,858.0

20,316.0

17,944.0

15,835.0

13,406.0

Liabilities & Shareholders' Equity

28,650.0

26,602.0

23,733.0

18,177.0

14,696.0

All figures in millions of U.S. Dollar, except per share items


Assets
Cash & ST Investments

Long-Term Note Receivable

Liabilities & Shareholders' Equity


ST Debt & Curr. Portion LT Debt
Accounts Payable

Long-Term Debt
Provision for Risks & Charges

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF BUYER

5 Year Balance Sheet of Qualcomm Inc.

30-Sep-10

30-Sep-09

30-Sep-08

28-Sep-07

29-Sep-06

3,247.0

1,592.0

3,160.0

3,303.0

2,470.0

Depreciation, Depletion & Amortization

666.0

635.0

456.0

383.0

272.0

Deferred Taxes & Investment Tax Credit

116.0

-33.0

306.0

91.0

514.0

All figures in millions of U.S. Dollar, except per share items


Operating Activities
Net Income before Extraordinaries

Other Funds

93.0

985.0

344.0

10.0

10.0

4,122.0

3,179.0

4,266.0

3,787.0

3,266.0

-46.0

3,993.0

-708.0

24.0

-13.0

Receivables

-18.0

3,083.0

-653.0

-16.0

-133.0

Inventories

-80.0

69.0

-47.0

-234.0

-71.0

Accounts Payable

148.0

57.0

-63.0

209.0

51.0

--

--

--

139.0

--

Other Assets/Liabilities

-96.0

784.0

55.0

-74.0

140.0

Net Operating Cash Flow

4,076.0

7,172.0

3,558.0

3,811.0

3,253.0

426.0

761.0

1,397.0

818.0

685.0

Funds from Operations


Changes in Working Capital

Other Accruals

Investing Activities
Capital Expenditures
Net Assets from Acquisitions

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

617.0

-5,223.0

-991.0

-494.0

-1,534.0

-1,030.0

527.0

-431.0

-586.0

-404.0

-839.0

-5,457.0

-2,819.0

-1,898.0

-2,623.0

Cash Dividends Paid

-1,177.0

-1,093.0

-982.0

-862.0

-698.0

Change in Capital Stock

-2,327.0

357.0

-486.0

-909.0

-797.0

1,064.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

35.0

-97.0

161.0

660.0

403.0

-2,405.0

-833.0

-1,307.0

-1,111.0

-1,092.0

Exchange Rate Effect

-2.0

-5.0

-3.0

2.0

-1.0

M iscellaneous Funds

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

830.0

877.0

-571.0

804.0

-463.0

Purchase/Sale of Investments
Other Funds
Net Investing Cash Flow
Financing Activities

Issuance/Reduction of Debt, Net


Other Funds
Net Financing Cash Flow

Net Change in Cash

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF BUYER

5 Year Cash Flow Statement of Qualcomm Inc.

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF TARGET

All figures in millions of U.S. Dollar, except per share items


Sales/Revenue

31-Dec-10

31-Dec-09

31-Dec-08

31-Dec-07

29-Dec-06

926.8

542.5

472.4

417.0

301.7

Cost of Goods Sold (COGS) incl. D&A

507.7

290.4

248.7

217.0

159.4

COGS excluding D&A

459.0

272.0

229.9

204.6

156.1

48.7

18.5

18.8

12.4

3.3

8.7

6.9

6.5

5.0

1.8

40.0

11.6

12.2

7.4

1.5

Gross Income

419.1

252.0

223.7

200.0

142.3

SG&A Expense

320.7

219.3

197.8

160.1

113.6

Research & Development

189.7

130.6

121.6

100.9

71.1

Other SG&A

131.0

88.7

76.3

59.2

42.5

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

98.4

32.7

25.9

39.8

28.7

Nonoperating Income (Expense) - Net

4.3

6.0

8.9

11.5

8.7

Interest Expense

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

36.8

12.6

15.5

7.2

10.8

--

2.0

15.5

2.3

--

33.7

--

--

--

--

3.1

10.5

0.0

4.9

10.8

Pretax Income

66.0

26.2

19.3

44.2

26.5

Income Taxes

11.6

-20.2

0.4

4.2

7.8

-4.8

7.5

6.4

8.8

6.5

3.8

-20.4

1.2

0.9

0.1

12.3

-7.1

-6.4

-4.7

1.5

Depreciation & Amortization Expense


Depreciation
Amortization of Intangibles

Other Operating Expense


EBIT (Operating Income)

Unusual Expense (Income) - Net


Financial Assets Impairment
Legal Claim Expense
Other Unusual Expense

Income Taxes - Current Domestic


Income Taxes - Current Foreign
Income Taxes - Deferred Domestic

0.3

-0.2

-0.8

-0.8

-0.2

Consolidated Net Income

Income Taxes - Deferred Foreign

54.4

46.4

18.9

40.0

18.7

Net Income

54.4

46.4

18.9

40.0

18.7

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF TARGET

5 Year Income Statement of Atheros Communications Inc.

31-Dec-10

31-Dec-09

31-Dec-08

31-Dec-07

29-Dec-06

Cash & ST Investments

515.8

402.2

293.8

219.5

185.9

Total Accounts Receivable

103.1

58.0

58.4

58.0

46.0

Inventories

95.7

70.4

69.8

35.5

25.9

Other Current Assets

20.1

27.0

15.9

16.1

10.6

Total Current Assets

734.8

557.6

437.8

329.1

268.4

Net Property, Plant & Equipment

22.1

15.0

14.8

13.5

9.0

Total Investments and Advances

12.8

15.5

17.0

30.5

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

375.3

324.2

125.0

136.1

81.7

Other Assets

9.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

Total Assets

1,154.0

912.3

594.6

509.2

359.2

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

51.8

59.9

30.5

29.6

17.1

Other Current Liabilities

118.5

81.2

65.5

47.3

46.9

Total Current Liabilities

170.2

141.1

96.0

76.8

64.0

Long-Term Debt

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

Deferred Taxes

17.8

39.4

27.1

30.9

-4.9

Other Liabilities

71.3

-0.0

0.0

0.0

18.6

Total Liabilities

259.3

180.5

123.1

107.7

77.7

Common Equity

894.8

731.9

471.5

401.5

280.9

894.8

731.9

471.5

401.5

280.9

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.5

894.8

731.9

471.5

401.5

281.5

1,154.0

912.3

594.6

509.2

359.2

All figures in millions of U.S. Dollar, except per share items


Assets

Long-Term Note Receivable


Intangible Assets

Liabilities & Shareholders' Equity


ST Debt & Curr. Portion LT Debt
Accounts Payable

Total Shareholders' Equity


Accumulated M inority Interest
Total Equity

Liabilities & Shareholders' Equity

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF TARGET

5 Year Balance Sheet of Atheros Communications Inc.

31-Dec-10

31-Dec-09

31-Dec-08

31-Dec-07

29-Dec-06

Net Income before Extraordinaries

54.4

46.4

18.9

40.0

18.7

Depreciation, Depletion & Amortization

48.7

18.5

18.8

5.0

3.3

Deferred Taxes & Investment Tax Credit

9.6

-23.0

-2.0

1.6

1.4

57.8

50.8

46.8

36.9

19.6

170.5

92.7

82.4

83.4

43.0

-24.3

50.1

-19.0

-11.9

6.5

Receivables

-44.3

11.6

-0.4

-10.7

-12.5

Inventories

-25.8

7.6

-35.0

-7.7

-1.4

Accounts Payable

-9.7

20.2

0.6

11.9

-1.0

Other Accruals

55.6

13.5

17.8

-4.0

24.3

Other Assets/Liabilities

-0.1

-2.8

-1.9

-1.3

-3.0

Net Operating Cash Flow

146.2

142.8

63.4

71.5

49.4

14.0

3.9

7.4

9.7

5.9

-70.6

-70.7

-0.5

-23.7

-52.1

0.0

0.0

0.7

2.3

0.0

-131.0

-57.9

-133.6

9.8

11.1

-1.2

0.2

-2.5

-0.3

0.0

-216.8

-132.2

-143.3

-21.6

-46.9

53.0

22.6

18.6

23.1

14.1

Issuance/Reduction of Debt, Net

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

Other Funds

0.0

0.7

1.5

2.9

6.3

53.0

23.2

20.1

26.0

20.4

0.0

0.0

-0.0

0.0

-0.0

-17.7

33.8

-59.7

75.9

23.0

All figures in millions of U.S. Dollar, except per share items


Operating Activities

Other Funds
Funds from Operations
Changes in Working Capital

Investing Activities
Capital Expenditures
Net Assets from Acquisitions
Sale of Fixed Assets & Businesses
Purchase/Sale of Investments
Other Funds
Net Investing Cash Flow
Financing Activities
Change in Capital Stock

Net Financing Cash Flow


M iscellaneous Funds
Net Change in Cash

FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF TARGET

5 Year Cash Flow Statement of Atheros Communications Inc.

DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW VALUATION OF TARGET

Free Cash Flow Projection

FY Ending December 30
2009

2010

2011

$542.5

$926.8
70.8%

EBITDA
% Margin
Less: Depreciation
EBITA
Tax Rate

Revenue
% Growth

Unlevered Net Income


Plus: Depreciation
Less: Capital Expenditures
Less: Change in Working Capital
Free Cash Flow
Net Debt
FDSO
TEV/EBITDA

2012

2013

2014

2015

$986.6
6.5%

$1,129.3
14.5%

$1,210.0
7.1%

$1,222.1
1.0%

$1,234.3
1.0%

5.8%

147.1
15.9%

166.4
16.9%

248.3
22.0%

297.0
24.5%

300.0
24.5%

303.0
24.5%

16.2%

(8.7)
138.4
20.0%

(7.0)
159.4
20.0%

(8.2)
240.1
20.0%

(8.5)
288.5
20.0%

(8.6)
291.4
20.0%

(8.7)
294.3
20.0%

$110.7
8.7
(12.5)
288.2
$395.1

($490.4)
75.629
14.4x

CAGR

$127.5
7.0
(15.6)
44.9
$163.8

$192.1
8.2
(17.7)
107.0
$289.6

$230.8
8.5
(18.1)
60.5
$281.7

$233.1
8.6
(23.2)
9.1
$227.5

$235.4

2011-2015

16.6%
16.6%

8.7
(23.5)
9.2
$229.8

8.8%

DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW VALUATION OF TARGET

Free Cash Flow Projection

DCF Valuation (2011-2015): EBITDA Multiple Method

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Total Enterprise Value


Terminal EBITDA Multiple
14.0x
15.0x
16.0x
$2,899.8
$3,050.4
$3,201.1
$2,791.5
$2,935.7
$3,080.0
$2,688.3
$2,826.5
$2,964.7

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Implied Perpetuity Growth Rate


Terminal EBITDA Multiple
14.0x
15.0x
16.0x
9.1%
9.5%
9.8%
10.0%
10.4%
10.7%
11.0%
11.4%
11.7%

(1)

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Total Equity Value


Terminal EBITDA Multiple
14.0x
15.0x
16.0x
$3,390.2
$3,540.8
$3,691.5
$3,281.9
$3,426.1
$3,570.4
$3,178.7
$3,316.9
$3,455.1
(2)

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Price Per Share


Terminal EBITDA Multiple
14.0x
15.0x
$44.8
$46.8
$43.4
$45.3
$42.0
$43.9

16.0x
$48.8
$47.2
$45.7

DCF Valuation (2011-2015): Perpetuity Growth Method

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Total Enterprise Value


Terminal Perpetuity Growth Rate
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
$1,771.8
$1,871.3
$1,990.8
$1,638.9
$1,720.3
$1,816.5
$1,524.9
$1,592.3
$1,670.9

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Implied Terminal EBITDA Multiple


Terminal Perpetuity Growth Rate
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
6.5x
7.2x
8.0x
6.0x
6.6x
7.2x
5.6x
6.1x
6.6x

(1)

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Total Equity Value


Terminal Perpetuity Growth Rate
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
$2,262.2
$2,361.7
$2,481.2
$2,129.3
$2,210.7
$2,306.9
$2,015.3
$2,082.7
$2,161.3

15.0%
16.0%
17.0%

Price Per Share


Terminal Perpetuity Growth Rate
3.0%
4.0%
5.0%
$29.91
$31.23
$32.81
$28.16
$29.23
$30.50
$26.65
$27.54
$28.58

(2)

Discount
Rate
(WACC)

DISCOUNTED CASH FLOW VALUATION OF TARGET

Valuation Sensitivity Analysis

COMPARABLE COMPANY VALUATION OF TARGET

COMPARABLE COMPANY VALUATION OF TARGET

Industry Comparables

Capitalization Analysis
LTM as of 21-Apr-2011

Company Name
Broadcom Corp.
Intel Corp.
Marvell Technology
RF Micro Devices
Intersil Corp.

Ticker

Price
(21-Apr-2011)

Market
Value

Diluted
Shares
Outstanding

Equity
Value

Enterprise
Value

Cash
and ST
Investments

Total
Debt

Preferred
Equity

Minority
Interest

Total
Assets

Long
Term
Debt

D/
D+E

BRCM
INTC
MRVL
RFMD
ISIL

40.16
21.94
15.83
6.17
14.54

19,504.4
118,150.4
10,026.7
1,703.7
1,815.1

544.6
5,696.0
676.9
284.2
124.6

21,871.6
124,970.2
10,715.0
1,753.2
1,811.7

17,543.7
98,380.4
7,097.2
1,611.5
1,730.6

2,657.7
21,885.0
2,930.0
304.7
383.0

697.0
2,115.0
0.5
212.5
298.5

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

7,944.3
62,897.0
6,310.5
1,053.4
1,578.6

697.0
2,077.0
0.0
207.4
275.0

0.11x
0.04x
0.00x
0.24x
0.22x

19.7
15.8

30,240.1
10,026.7

5,632.1
2,657.7

664.7
298.5

651.3
275.0

0.1
0.1

Mean
Median

1,465.2
544.6

32,224.3
10,715.0

25,272.7
7,097.2

15,956.7
6,310.5

Margin Analysis
LTM as of 21-Apr-2011
Company Name
Broadcom Corp.
Intel Corp.
Marvell Technology
RF Micro Devices
Intersil Corp.

Ticker
BRCM
INTC
MRVL
RFMD
ISIL

Mean
Median

Gross Margin (%)


FY-1
FY0

LTM

FY-1

50.4
55.6
52.5
24.5
52.7

51.4
65.2
57.0
36.0
54.8

4.5
16.9
11.9
(98.1)
8.8

47.1
52.5

51.4
65.2
57.0
36.3
54.8
52.9
54.8

52.9
54.8

(11.2)
8.8

EBIT Margin (%)


FY0
16.9
35.6
25.0
11.2
15.8
20.9
16.9

LTM

EBITDA Margin (%)


FY-1
FY0

LTM

FY-1

16.9
35.6
25.0
14.9
15.8

6.8
31.3
18.8
14.3

18.9
46.2
29.8
23.0
21.7

1.5
12.4
12.6
(100.2)
6.3

21.6
16.9

17.8
16.6

18.9
46.2
29.8
20.5
21.7
27.4
21.7

27.9
23.0

(13.5)
6.3

Net Margin (%)


FY0
15.9
26.3
25.0
7.3
3.2
15.5
15.9

LTM
15.9
26.3
25.0
11.5
3.2
16.4
15.9

Valuation Analysis
LTM as of 21-Apr-2011

Company Name
Broadcom Corp.
Intel Corp.
Marvell Technology
RF Micro Devices
Intersil Corp.
Mean
Median
Low
High

Ticker

Market
Value

Enterprise
Value

Sales

EBITDA

BRCM
INTC
MRVL
RFMD
ISIL

19,504.4
118,150.4
10,026.7
1,703.7
1,815.1

17,543.7
98,380.4
7,097.2
1,611.5
1,730.6

6,818.3
43,623.0
3,611.9
1,099.3
822.4

1,291.0
20,148.0
1,077.1
252.9
178.6

30,240.1
10,026.7
1,703.7
118,150.4

25,272.7
7,097.2
1,611.5
98,380.4

11,195.0
3,611.9
822.4
43,623.0

4,589.5
1,077.1
178.6
20,148.0

LTM

Price / EPS
FY1

FY2

20.18
10.92
11.81
13.41
69.24

14.38
9.74
10.66
10.06
14.57

13.13
9.09
9.52
11.16
11.39

2.6x
2.3x
2.0x
1.5x
2.1x

15.2x
6.3x
7.8x
9.8x
13.3x

25.1
13.4
10.9
69.2

11.9
10.7
9.7
14.6

10.9
11.2
9.1
13.1

2.1x
2.1x
1.5x
2.6x

10.5x
9.8x
6.3x
15.2x

Price to
Book
Value

Price
to
Sales

13.6x
4.9x
6.6x
6.4x
9.7x

3.7x
2.4x
1.9x
2.6x
1.7x

3.2x
2.9x
3.0x
1.6x
2.2x

8.2x
6.6x
4.9x
13.6x

2.5x
2.4x
1.7x
3.7x

2.6x
2.9x
1.6x
3.2x

Enterprise Value /
Sales
EBIT
EBITDA

COMPARABLE COMPANY VALUATION OF TARGET

Comparable Company Key Financial Statistics

Atheros Inc. Key Financial Metrics


Net Debt
FDSO
Book Value of Share
EPS (FY1)
EPS(FY2)
Sales
EBIT
EBITDA

$
$
$
$
$
$

($490.4)
75.629
11.8
1.6
1.9
926.8
98.4
147.1

Implied Total Enterprise Value


Mean

Median

Low

2,213.1
1,399.9
1,555.4
1,921.0
1,034.5
1,209.8

2,188.3
1,255.9
1,599.1
1,950.3
968.6
969.3

1,551.5
1,147.3
1,302.3
1,358.7
624.2
718.3

Implied Price per Share


High

Mean

Median

Low

3,321.9
1,716.5
1,880.4
2,384.7
1,496.4
1,999.0

29.3
18.5
20.6
31.9
20.2
22.5

28.9
16.6
21.1
32.3
19.3
19.3

20.5
15.2
17.2
24.4
14.7
16.0

High
-

43.9
22.7
24.9
38.0
26.3
32.9

COMPARABLE COMPANY VALUATION OF TARGET

Comparable Company Valuation Range

PRECEDENT TRANSACTIONS VALUATION OF TARGET

Precedent Transactions

Deal

Buyer

Target

Deal Details

Year

Name

Industry

Ticker

Name

Industry

Ticker

2009
2009
2009
2009
2009

Cisco Systems
Cisco Systems
EMC Corp.
Hewlett Packaard
Dell Inc.

Hardware
Hardware
Hardware
Hardware
Hardware

CSCO
CSCO
EMC
HPQ
DELL

Tandberg
Starent
Data Domain
3Com
Perot Systems

Hardware
Hardware
Hardware
Hardware
IT Services

TAA
STAR
DDUP
COMS
PER

Mean
Median
Low
High

Enterprise Value

EV/Revenue

EV/EBITDA

Premium

$3,000.0
$2,400.0
$2,100.0
$2,700.0
$3,900.0

3.5x
5.4x
5.5x
2.5x
2.4x

15.1x
22.1x
20.0x
19.3x
12.9x

11%
20%
30%
39%
67%

$2,820.0
$2,700.0
$2,100.0
$3,900.0

3.9x
3.5x
2.4x
5.5x

17.9x
19.3x
12.9x
22.1x

33%
30%
11%
67%

Atheros Inc. Key Financial Metrics


Net Debt
FDSO
Revenue
EBITDA

$
$

($490.4)
75.629
926.8
147.1

Implied Total Enterprise Value

Implied Price per Share

Mean

Median

Low

High

Mean

Median

Low

High

3,577.4
2,630.1

3,243.8
2,839.0

2,224.3
1,897.6

5,097.4
3,250.9

53.8
41.3

49.4
44.0

35.9
31.6

73.9
49.5

PRECEDENT TRANSACTION VALUATION OF TARGET

Precedent Transactions Analysis

VALUATION SUMMARY

DCF Analysis
Low
Range
High

15% -17% WACC


$2,826.5
$223.9
$3,050.4

14x -16x Exit Multiple


$2,791.5
$288.5
$3,080.0

Precedent Transactions
2.4x -5.5x Revenue
$2,224.3
$2,873.1
$5,097.4

12.9x -22.1x EBITDA


$1,897.6
$1,353.3
$3,250.9

Comparable Companies
1.5x - 2.4x Revenue
$1,358.7
$865.6
$2,224.3

4.88x - 9.7x EBITDA


$718.3
$707.0
$1,425.3

VALUATION SUMMARY

Target Valuation Summary

FINANCIAL PROJECTIONS OF BUYER AND TARGET

FY Ended December 30

FY Ending December 30

CAGR

2008A

2009A

2010A

2011P

2012P

2013P

2014E

2015E

$11,142.0
NA

$10,416.0
(6.5%)

$10,991.0
5.5%

$14,263.0
29.8%

$15,996.2
12.2%

$17,581.0
9.9%

$19,322.8
9.9%

$21,237.2
9.9%

2,958.0
26.5%
$8,184.0
73.5%

2,546.0
24.4%
$7,870.0
75.6%

2,851.0
25.9%
$8,140.0
74.1%

4,017.4
28.2%
$10,245.6
71.8%

4,403.6
27.5%
$11,592.6
72.5%

4,964.4
28.2%
$12,616.6
71.8%

5,456.2
28.2%
$13,866.6
71.8%

5,996.8
28.2%
$15,240.4
71.8%

SG&A
% of Sales

3,998.0
35.9%

3,996.0
38.4%

4,191.0
38.1%

4,221.5
29.6%

4,554.6
28.5%

5,059.8
28.8%

5,561.1
28.8%

6,112.0
28.8%

EBITDA
% Margin

$4,186.0
37.6%

$3,874.0
37.2%

$3,949.0
35.9%

$6,024.1
42.2%

$7,038.0
44.0%

$7,556.8
43.0%

$8,305.5
43.0%

$9,128.3
43.0%

372.0
3.3%
84.0
0.8%
$456.0
4.1%

428.0
4.1%
207.0
2.0%
$635.0
6.1%

437.0
4.0%
229.0
2.1%
$666.0
6.1%

362.6
2.5%
100.0
0.7%
$462.6
3.2%

600.0
3.8%
93.3
0.6%
$693.3
4.3%

800.0
4.6%
83.1
0.5%
$883.1
5.0%

879.3
4.6%
83.1
0.4%
$962.4
5.0%

966.4
4.6%
83.1
0.4%
$1,049.5
4.9%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

EBIT
% Margin

$3,730.0
33.5%

$3,239.0
31.1%

$3,283.0
29.9%

$5,561.5
39.0%

$6,344.7
39.7%

$6,673.7
38.0%

$7,343.1
38.0%

$8,078.9
38.0%

9.8%

EBITA
% Margin

$3,814.0
34.2%

$3,446.0
33.1%

$3,512.0
32.0%

$5,661.5
39.7%

$6,438.0
40.2%

$6,756.8
38.4%

$7,426.2
38.4%

$8,162.0
38.4%

9.6%

Interest Income
Interest Expense
Equity Income
Minority Interest
Other Income
Other Expense
Income Before Taxes

646.0
22.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
529.0
$3,825.0

653.0
24.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
1,545.0
$2,323.0

935.0
58.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
122.0
$4,038.0

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$5,561.5

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$6,344.7

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$6,673.7

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$7,343.1

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$8,078.9

666.0
17.4%

484.0
20.8%

787.0
19.5%

671.2
12.1%

1,160.3
18.3%

813.8
12.2%

895.4
12.2%

985.1
12.2%

$3,159.0
28.4%

$1,839.0
17.7%

$3,251.0
29.6%

$4,890.3
34.3%

$5,184.4
32.4%

$5,859.9
33.3%

$6,447.7
33.4%

$7,093.7
33.4%

9.7%
11.5%

Total Revenue
% Growth
COGS - ex D&A
% of Sales
Gross Profit
% Margin

Depreciation
% of Sales
Amortization
% of Sales
Total D&A
% of Sales
Stock-Based Comp
% of Sales

Income tax
% Tax Rate
Net Income
% Margin
Diluted EPS

2011-2015
10.5%

10.4%

10.9%

9.8%

$1.90

$1.10

$1.96

$2.63

$2.83

$3.55

$3.72

$4.07

1,663.158

1,675.789

1,656.633

1,856.916

1,832.791

1,648.788

1,734.815

1,742.123

$69.4
0.0
0.0

$163.9
0.0
0.0

$184.4
0.0
0.0

$87.9
0.0
0.0

$76.2
0.0
0.0

$73.0
0.0
0.0

$73.0
0.0
0.0

$73.0
0.0
0.0

Net Income - GAAP


% Margin

$3,089.6
27.7%

$1,675.1
16.1%

$3,066.6
27.9%

$4,802.4
33.7%

$5,108.2
31.9%

$5,786.9
32.9%

$6,374.7
33.0%

$7,020.7
33.1%

10.0%

Diluted EPS - GAAP

$1.86

$1.00

$1.85

$2.59

$2.79

$3.51

$3.67

$4.03

11.7%

$1,397.0
12.5%

$761.0
7.3%

$426.0
3.9%

$466.3
3.3%

$672.4
4.2%

$899.9
5.1%

$966.1
5.0%

$1,061.9
5.0%

Diluted Shares Out


Cash to GAAP Reconciliation
Amortization
Stock-Based Comp
One-Time Charges

Capex
% of Sales

FINANCIAL PROJECTIONS OF BUYER AND TARGET

Income Statement Projection of Qualcomm Inc.

FY Ended December 30
2008A

2009A

FY Ending December 30

2010A

2011P

CAGR

2012P

2013P

2014E

2015E

2011-2015

Total Revenue
% Growth

$472.4
NA

$542.5
14.8%

$926.8
70.8%

$986.6
6.5%

$1,129.3
14.5%

$1,210.0
7.1%

$1,222.1
1.0%

$1,234.3
1.0%

COGS - ex D&A
% of Sales
Gross Profit
% Margin

229.9
48.7%
$242.5
51.3%

272.0
50.1%
$270.5
49.9%

459.0
49.5%
$467.8
50.5%

532.0
53.9%
$454.6
46.1%

555.3
49.2%
$574.0
50.8%

578.0
47.8%
$632.0
52.2%

583.8
47.8%
$638.3
52.2%

589.6
47.8%
$644.7
52.2%

SG&A
% of Sales

197.8
41.9%

219.3
40.4%

320.7
34.6%

288.2
29.2%

325.7
28.8%

335.0
27.7%

338.4
27.7%

341.7
27.7%

EBITDA
% Margin

$44.7
9.5%

$51.2
9.4%

$147.1
15.9%

$166.4
16.9%

$248.3
22.0%

$297.0
24.5%

$300.0
24.5%

$303.0
24.5%

6.5
1.4%
12.2
2.6%
$18.7
4.0%

6.9
1.3%
11.6
2.1%
$18.5
3.4%

8.7
0.9%
40.0
4.3%
$48.7
5.3%

7.0
0.7%
14.0
1.4%
$21.0
2.1%

8.2
0.7%
14.5
1.3%
$22.7
2.0%

8.5
0.7%
15.2
1.3%
$23.7
2.0%

8.6
0.7%
15.2
1.2%
$23.8
1.9%

8.7
0.7%
15.2
1.2%
$23.9
1.9%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

EBIT
% Margin

$26.0
5.5%

$32.7
6.0%

$98.4
10.6%

$145.4
14.7%

$225.6
20.0%

$273.3
22.6%

$276.2
22.6%

$279.1
22.6%

17.7%

EBITA
% Margin

$38.2
8.1%

$44.3
8.2%

$138.4
14.9%

$159.4
16.2%

$240.1
21.3%

$288.5
23.8%

$291.4
23.8%

$294.3
23.8%

16.6%

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
8.9
15.5

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
6.0
12.6

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
4.3
36.8

0.0
2.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

0.0
4.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

Income Before Taxes

$19.4

$26.1

$65.9

$143.4

$221.6

$273.3

$276.2

$279.1

Provision for Tax


% Tax Rate

3.4
17.4%

5.4
20.8%

12.8
19.5%

17.3
12.1%

40.5
18.3%

33.3
12.2%

33.7
12.2%

34.0
12.2%

$16.0
3.4%

$20.7
3.8%

$53.1
5.7%

$126.1
12.8%

$181.1
16.0%

$240.0
19.8%

$242.5
19.8%

$245.1
19.9%

18.1%
12.5%

Depreciation
% of Sales
Amortization
% of Sales
Total D&A
% of Sales
Stock-Based Comp
% of Sales

Interest Income
Interest Expense
Equity Income
Minority Interest
Other Income
Other Expense

Net Income
% Margin
Diluted EPS

5.8%

9.1%

16.2%

18.1%

$0.25

$0.33

$0.73

$1.56

$1.89

$2.48

$2.48

$2.50

62.910

63.570

72.500

80.940

95.610

96.650

97.770

98.200

$10.1
0.0
0.0

$9.2
0.0
0.0

$32.2
0.0
0.0

$12.3
0.0
0.0

$11.8
0.0
0.0

$13.3
0.0
0.0

$13.3
0.0
0.0

$13.3
0.0
0.0

Net Income - GAAP


% Margin

$5.9
1.3%

$11.5
2.1%

$20.9
2.2%

$113.8
11.5%

$169.2
15.0%

$226.6
18.7%

$229.2
18.8%

$231.7
18.8%

19.5%

Diluted EPS - GAAP

$0.09

$0.18

$0.29

$1.41

$1.77

$2.34

$2.34

$2.36

13.8%

$7.4
1.6%

$3.9
0.7%

$12.5
1.3%

$15.6
1.6%

$17.7
1.6%

$18.1
1.6%

$23.2
1.9%

$23.5
1.9%

Diluted Shares Out


Cash to GAAP Reconciliation
Amortization
Stock-Based Comp
One-Time Charges

Capex
% of Sales

FINANCIAL PROJECTIONS OF BUYER AND TARGET

Income Statement Projection of Atheros Communications Inc.

TRANSACTION ANALYSIS

Current
Price

Transaction Prices Per Atheros Inc. Share

$34.50

$44.00

$45.00

$46.00

$47.00

$48.00

$49.00

$50.00

Uses
Atheros Inc. Common Consideration
Atheros Inc. Options Consideration
Atheros Inc. Preferred Consideration
Total Equity Consideration

$2,779.0
0.0
0.0
$2,779.0

$3,544.2
0.0
0.0
$3,544.2

$3,624.8
0.0
0.0
$3,624.8

$3,705.3
0.0
0.0
$3,705.3

$3,785.9
0.0
0.0
$3,785.9

$3,866.4
0.0
0.0
$3,866.4

$3,947.0
0.0
0.0
$3,947.0

$4,027.5
0.0
0.0
$4,027.5

Atheros Inc. Revolver Refinanced


Atheros Inc. Convertible Debt Assumed
Atheros Inc. Convertible Debt Refinanced/Retired
Atheros Inc. Non-Convertible LT Debt Assumed
Atheros Inc. Non-Convertible LT Debt Refinanced/Retired
Total Levered Consideration

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$2,779.0

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,544.2

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,624.8

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,705.3

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,785.9

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,866.4

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,947.0

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$4,027.5

Acquirer Refinanced Debt


Financing Fees
Advisory Fees
Total Uses

0.0
0.0
30.0
$2,809.0

0.0
0.0
30.0
$3,574.2

0.0
0.0
30.0
$3,654.8

0.0
0.0
30.0
$3,735.3

0.0
0.0
30.0
$3,815.9

0.0
0.0
30.0
$3,896.4

0.0
0.0
30.0
$3,977.0

0.0
0.0
30.0
$4,057.5

Sources
Qualcomm Inc. Common Consideration
Qualcomm Inc. Options Consideration
Qualcomm Inc. Preferred Consideration
Cash Consideration
Qualcomm Inc. Revolver
Acquisition Debt
Atheros Inc. LT Debt Assumed

$1,667.4
0.0
0.0
1,141.6
0.0
0.0
0.0

$2,126.5
0.0
0.0
1,447.7
0.0
0.0
0.0

$2,174.9
0.0
0.0
1,479.9
0.0
0.0
0.0

$2,223.2
0.0
0.0
1,512.1
0.0
0.0
0.0

$2,271.5
0.0
0.0
1,544.3
0.0
0.0
0.0

$2,319.8
0.0
0.0
1,576.6
0.0
0.0
0.0

$2,368.2
0.0
0.0
1,608.8
0.0
0.0
0.0

$2,416.5
0.0
0.0
1,641.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

Total Sources

$2,809.0

$3,574.2

$3,654.8

$3,735.3

$3,815.9

$3,896.4

$3,977.0

$4,057.5

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

0.000

Sources & Uses

Check
Cash Schedule
Cash Available
Qualcomm Inc. Existing Cash
Atheros Inc. Existing Cash
Minimum Cash Balance
Total Cash Available
Cash Needed
Cash Paid to Atheros Inc. Shareholders
Financing Fees
Advisory Fees
Qualcomm Inc. Debt Retired
Atheros Inc. Debt Retired
Cash Needed Before Revolver
Optional Paydown of Atheros Inc. Revolver
Optional Paydown of Qualcomm Inc. Revolver
Total Cash Needed

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$10,279.0
515.8
(100.0)
$10,694.8

$1,111.6
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,141.6
0.0
0.0
$1,141.6

$1,417.7
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,447.7
0.0
0.0
$1,447.7

$1,449.9
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,479.9
0.0
0.0
$1,479.9

$1,482.1
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,512.1
0.0
0.0
$1,512.1

$1,514.3
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,544.3
0.0
0.0
$1,544.3

$1,546.6
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,576.6
0.0
0.0
$1,576.6

$1,578.8
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,608.8
0.0
0.0
$1,608.8

$1,611.0
0.0
30.0
0.0
0.0
$1,641.0
0.0
0.0
$1,641.0

TRANSACTION ANALYSIS

Sources and Uses of Funds

Transaction Value Per Share

$45.00

Assets
Current Assets
Cash and Equivalents
Accounts Receivable
Inventory
Deferred Income Taxes
Other Current Assets
Total Current Assets

Qualcomm Inc.

Atheros Inc.

25-04-11

25-04-11

Adjustments
Write-Up

Pro Forma

Financing

$10,279.0
730.0
528.0
0.0
596.0
$12,133.0

$515.8
103.1
95.7
0.0
20.1
$734.7

$2,373.0
1,488.0
3,022.0
8,123.0
0.0
0.0
1,511.0

$22.1
222.0
153.4
12.8
0.0
0.0
9.0

$28,650.0

$1,154.0

$31,164.0

Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity


Current Liabilities
Accounts Payable
Accrued Expenses
Income Taxes Payable
Deferred Revenue
Other Current Liabilities
Current Portion of Long-Term Debt
Total Current Liabilities

$764.0
0.0
1,443.0
0.0
2,175.0
1,086.0
$5,468.0

$51.8
0.0
0.0
0.0
118.5
0.0
$170.3

$815.8
0.0
1,443.0
0.0
2,293.5
1,086.0
$5,638.3

Revolver
Non-Convertible Debt
Convertible Debt
Deferred Income Taxes
Other Long-Term Liabilities
Total Liabilities

$0.0
0.0
0.0
(1,922.0)
4,246.0
$7,792.0

$0.0
0.0
0.0
17.8
71.3
$259.4

$0.0
0.0
6,856.0
0.0
(88.0)
785.0
13,305.0

$0.0
773.7
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
120.9

Net PP&E
Goodwill
Intangibles
Investments/Restricted Cash
Unearned Compensation
Deferred Financing Fees
Other Assets
Total Assets

Preferred Stock, par value


Common Stock, par value
APIC / Capital Surplus
Treasury Stock
Accum. & Other Comp. Income (Loss)
Unrealized Gain/Loss Marketable Securities
Retained Earnings

($1,479.9)

25-04-11

15.0
2,142.4
682.5
0.0
0.0

127.6

$9,314.9
833.1
623.7
0.0
616.1
$11,387.8
$2,410.1
3,852.4
3,857.9
8,135.8
0.0
0.0
1,520.0

$0.0
0.0
0.0
(17.8)

$0.0
0.0
0.0
(1,794.4)
4,317.3
$8,161.2

$0.0
1,401.2
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(150.9)

$0.0
2,174.9
6,856.0
0.0
(88.0)
785.0
13,275.0

Total Stockholders' Equity

$20,858.0

$894.6

$23,002.9

Total Liabilities and Stockholders' Equity

$28,650.0

$1,154.0

$31,164.0

0.000

0.000

0.000

Check

TRANSACTION ANALYSIS

Pro Forma Balance Sheet

FY Ended December 30
2008A
Total Revenue
% Growth

2009A

FY Ending December 30

CAGR

2010A

2011E

2012E

2013E

2014E

2015E

2011-2015

$11,614.4
NA

$10,958.5
(5.6%)

$11,917.8
8.8%

$15,249.6
28.0%

$17,125.5
12.3%

$18,791.0
9.7%

$20,544.9
9.7%

$22,471.5
9.7%

COGS
COGS Synergies
% of Sales
Gross Profit
% Margin

3,187.9
0.0
27.4%
$8,426.5
72.6%

2,818.0
0.0
25.7%
$8,140.5
74.3%

3,310.0
0.0
27.8%
$8,607.8
72.2%

4,549.4
0.0
29.8%
$10,700.2
70.2%

4,958.9
(25.0)
28.8%
$12,191.6
71.2%

5,542.4
(25.0)
29.4%
$13,273.6
70.6%

6,040.0
(25.0)
29.3%
$14,529.9
70.7%

6,586.4
(25.0)
29.2%
$15,910.1
70.8%

SG&A
SG&A Synergies
% of Sales

4,195.8
0.0
36.1%

4,215.3
0.0
38.5%

4,511.7
0.0
37.9%

4,509.7
0.0
29.6%

4,880.3
(50.0)
28.2%

5,394.8
(50.0)
28.4%

5,899.4
(50.0)
28.5%

6,453.8
(50.0)
28.5%

$4,230.7
36.4%

$3,925.2
35.8%

$4,096.1
34.4%

$6,190.5
40.6%

$7,361.3
43.0%

$7,928.8
42.2%

$8,680.4
42.3%

$9,506.3
42.3%

378.5
0.0
3.3%
96.2
0.0
0.8%
474.7
4.1%

434.9
0.0
4.0%
218.6
0.0
2.0%
653.5
6.0%

445.7
0.0
3.7%
269.0
0.0
2.3%
714.7
6.0%

369.6
1.5
2.4%
114.0
136.5
1.6%
621.6
4.1%

608.2
1.5
3.6%
107.8
136.5
1.4%
854.0
5.0%

808.5
1.5
4.3%
98.3
136.5
1.2%
1,044.8
5.6%

887.8
1.5
4.3%
98.3
136.5
1.1%
1,124.2
5.5%

975.0
1.5
4.3%
98.3
136.5
1.0%
1,211.3
5.4%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

0.0
0.0%

EBIT
% Margin

$3,756.0
32.3%

$3,271.7
29.9%

$3,381.4
28.4%

$5,568.9
36.5%

$6,507.3
38.0%

$6,884.0
36.6%

$7,556.3
36.8%

$8,295.0
36.9%

10.5%

EBITA
% Margin

$3,852.2
33.2%

$3,490.3
31.9%

$3,650.4
30.6%

$5,819.4
38.2%

$6,751.6
39.4%

$7,118.8
37.9%

$7,791.1
37.9%

$8,529.8
38.0%

10.0%

0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0

29.6
0.0
0.0
0.0

29.6
0.0
0.0
0.0

29.6
0.0
0.0
0.0

29.6
0.0
0.0
0.0

EBITDA
% Margin
Existing Depreciation
New Depreciation
% of Sales
Existing Amortization
New Amortization
% of Sales
Total D&A
% of Sales
Stock-Based Comp
% of Sales

Interest (Income) / Expense


Equity (Income)
Minority Interest
Other (Income) / Expense
Other Transaction Adjustments
Income Before Taxes
Income Tax
% Tax Rate
Pro Forma Net Income
% Margin
Pro Forma Diluted EPS
Diluted Shares Out

10.2%

10.4%

11.3%

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

0.0

$5,819.4

$6,722.0

$7,089.2

$7,761.5

$8,500.2

1,064.2
18.3%

1,229.3
18.3%

1,296.5
18.3%

1,419.4
18.3%

1,554.5
18.3%

$4,755.2
31.2%

$5,492.7
32.1%

$5,792.7
30.8%

$6,342.1
30.9%

$6,945.7
30.9%

9.9%
11.7%

$2.51

$2.94

$3.43

$3.58

$3.90

1,895.192

1,871.068

1,687.064

1,773.091

1,780.400

Accredition/Dulition
Qualcomm Inc. Standalone Diluted EPS
$ Accretion / (Dilution)
% Accretion / (Dilution)
Incremental Pre-Tax Synergies to Breakeven

$2.63
($0.12)
(4.7%)
$288.7

$2.83
$0.11
3.8%
($244.8)

$3.55
($0.12)
(3.4%)
$248.7

$3.72
($0.14)
(3.8%)
$303.3

Capex
% of Sales

$481.9
3.2%

$690.1
4.0%

$918.0
4.9%

$989.4
4.8%

$4.07
($0.17)
(4.2%)
$371.9
$1,085.3
4.8%

9.9%

TRANSACTION ANALYSIS

Pro Forma Income Statement

Current
Price
$34.50

Transaction Prices Per Atheros Inc. Share


$44.00

$45.00

$46.00

$47.00

$48.00

$49.00

$50.00

Fair Value of Options Issued by Acquirer


Unvested Options
Weighted Average Strike
Weighted Average Remaining Term (yrs)
Black Scholes Value Per Option
Options Outstanding
Fair Value of Unvested Options

$14.60
4.0
$24.51
0.000
$0.0

$14.60
4.0
$33.44
0.000
$0.0

$14.60
4.0
$34.39
0.000
$0.0

$14.60
4.0
$35.35
0.000
$0.0

$14.60
4.0
$36.30
0.000
$0.0

$14.60
4.0
$37.26
0.000
$0.0

$14.60
4.0
$38.22
0.000
$0.0

$14.60
4.0
$39.18
0.000
$0.0

Vested Options
Weighted Average Strike
Weighted Average Remaining Term (yrs)
Black Scholes Value Per Option
Options Outstanding
Fair Value of Vested Options

$29.49
2.7
$15.91
0.000
$0.0

$29.49
2.7
$23.64
0.000
$0.0

$29.49
2.7
$24.48
0.000
$0.0

$29.49
2.7
$25.33
0.000
$0.0

$29.49
2.7
$26.19
0.000
$0.0

$29.49
2.7
$27.05
0.000
$0.0

$29.49
2.7
$27.92
0.000
$0.0

$29.49
2.7
$28.79
0.000
$0.0

Common Equity Consideration


Fair Value of Unvested Options
Fair Value of Vested Options
Fair Value of Preferred Stock
Total Purchase Price

$2,779.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$2,779.0

$3,544.2
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,544.2

$3,624.8
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,624.8

$3,705.3
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,705.3

$3,785.9
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,785.9

$3,866.4
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,866.4

$3,947.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
$3,947.0

$4,027.5
0.0
0.0
0.0
$4,027.5

Unearned Compensation
Adjusted Purchase Price

$0.0
$2,779.0

$0.0
$3,544.2

$0.0
$3,624.8

$0.0
$3,705.3

$0.0
$3,785.9

$0.0
$3,866.4

$0.0
$3,947.0

$0.0
$4,027.5

$2,779.0
(894.6)
$1,884.4

$3,544.2
(894.6)
$2,649.6

$3,624.8
(894.6)
$2,730.2

$3,705.3
(894.6)
$2,810.7

$3,785.9
(894.6)
$2,891.3

$3,866.4
(894.6)
$2,971.8

$3,947.0
(894.6)
$3,052.4

$4,027.5
(894.6)
$3,132.9

$15.0
471.1
(222.0)
17.8

$15.0
662.4
(222.0)
17.8

$15.0
682.5
(222.0)
17.8

$15.0
702.7
(222.0)
17.8

$15.0
722.8
(222.0)
17.8

$15.0
743.0
(222.0)
17.8

$15.0
763.1
(222.0)
17.8

$15.0
783.2
(222.0)
17.8

Purchase Price Calculation

Purchase Price Allocation


Adjusted Purchase Price
Less: Target Book Value of Net Assets
Excess Purchase Price to Allocate
Write-Up of Tangible Assets
Write-Up of Identifiable Intangible Assets
Write-Off of Target's Existing Goodwill
Write-Off of Target's Existing DTL
Allocation to Goodwill (Before DTL Allocation)

$1,602.5

$2,176.4

$2,236.8

$2,297.2

$2,357.6

$2,418.1

$2,478.5

$2,538.9

($88.9)
0.0
$1,691.4

($123.9)
0.0
$2,300.3

($127.6)
0.0
$2,364.4

($131.2)
0.0
$2,428.5

($134.9)
0.0
$2,492.6

($138.6)
0.0
$2,556.7

($142.3)
0.0
$2,620.8

($146.0)
0.0
$2,684.9

$1,884.4
25.0%
$471.1
5.0
$94.2

$2,649.6
25.0%
$662.4
5.0
$132.5

$2,730.2
25.0%
$682.5
5.0
$136.5

$2,810.7
25.0%
$702.7
5.0
$140.5

$2,891.3
25.0%
$722.8
5.0
$144.6

$2,971.8
25.0%
$743.0
5.0
$148.6

$3,052.4
25.0%
$763.1
5.0
$152.6

$3,132.9
25.0%
$783.2
5.0
$156.6

18.3%
$77.0

18.3%
$108.3

18.3%
$111.5

18.3%
$114.8

18.3%
$118.1

18.3%
$121.4

18.3%
$124.7

18.3%
$128.0

Write-Up of Tangible Assets


Depreciation Period (yrs)
Annual Incremental Depreciation Expense

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

$15.0
10.0
$1.5

Marginal Tax Rate


After-Tax Annual Depreciation Expense

18.3%
$1.2

18.3%
$1.2

18.3%
$1.2

18.3%
$1.2

18.3%
$1.2

18.3%
$1.2

18.3%
$1.2

18.3%
$1.2

DTL From Write-Up of Assets


DTL From Deferred Compensation
Total Goodwill Created
Amortization of Identifiable Intangibles
Excess of Purchase Price Over Book Value
% Allocated to Identifiable Intangibles
Write-Up of Intangible Assets
Amortization Period (yrs)
Annual Incremental Amortization Expense
Marginal Tax Rate
After-Tax Annual Amortization Expense
Depreciation of Fixed Asset Write-Up

TRANSACTION ANALYSIS

Purchase Price Allocation and Accounting Adjustments

Atheros Inc.

Transaction Prices Per Atheros Inc. Share

$34.50
Common Stock
Stock Options
ITM Convertible Securities
Total Diluted Equity Value
Net Debt
Total Enterprise Value
Premiums Analysis
Current Price
52-Week High
52-Week Low
1 Week Trading Average
1 Month Trading Average
3 Months Trading Average
6 Months Trading Average

$2,519.3
259.6
0.0
$2,779.0
(515.8)
$2,263.2

$45.00

$46.00

$47.00

$48.00

$49.00

$50.00

$3,213.1
331.1
0.0
$3,544.2
(515.8)
$3,028.4

$3,286.1
338.7
0.0
$3,624.8
(515.8)
$3,109.0

$3,359.1
346.2
0.0
$3,705.3
(515.8)
$3,189.5

$3,432.1
353.7
0.0
$3,785.9
(515.8)
$3,270.1

$3,505.2
361.2
0.0
$3,866.4
(515.8)
$3,350.6

$3,578.2
368.8
0.0
$3,947.0
(515.8)
$3,431.2

$3,651.2
376.3
0.0
$4,027.5
(515.8)
$3,511.7

Atheros Inc.

$56.82
$91,918.5
12,213.9
0.0
$104,132.4
(17,316.0)
$86,816.4

Transaction Premium Per Atheros Inc. Share

$34.50
44.88
22.77
41.60
41.70
41.70
63.50

0.0%
(23.1%)
51.5%
(17.1%)
(17.3%)
(17.3%)
(45.7%)

27.5%
(2.0%)
93.2%
5.8%
5.5%
5.5%
(30.7%)

30.4%
0.3%
97.6%
8.2%
7.9%
7.9%
(29.1%)

FY 2011P Revenue
FY 2012P Revenue
FY 2013P Revenue

$986.6
1,129.3
1,210.0

2.29x
2.00x
1.87x

3.07x
2.68x
2.50x

3.15x
2.75x
2.57x

3.23x
2.82x
2.64x

3.31x
2.90x
2.70x

3.40x
2.97x
2.77x

FY 2011P EBITDA
FY 2012P EBITDA
FY 2013P EBITDA

$166.4
248.3
297.0

13.6x
9.1x
7.6x

18.2x
12.2x
10.2x

18.7x
12.5x
10.5x

19.2x
12.8x
10.7x

19.7x
13.2x
11.0x

FY 2011P EBITA
FY 2012P EBITA
FY 2013P EBITA

$159.4
240.1
288.5

14.2x
9.4x
7.8x

19.0x
12.6x
10.5x

19.5x
12.9x
10.8x

20.0x
13.3x
11.1x

$1.56
1.89
2.48

22.1x
18.2x
13.9x

28.2x
23.2x
17.7x

28.9x
23.8x
18.1x

29.5x
24.3x
18.5x

Multiples Analysis

FY 2011P Cash P/E


FY 2012P Cash P/E
FY 2013P Cash P/E

Qualcomm Inc.

$44.00

33.3%
2.5%
102.0%
10.6%
10.3%
10.3%
(27.6%)

36.2%
4.7%
106.4%
13.0%
12.7%
12.7%
(26.0%)

39.1%
7.0%
110.8%
15.4%
15.1%
15.1%
(24.4%)

Qualcomm Inc.
42.0%
9.2%
115.2%
17.8%
17.5%
17.5%
(22.8%)

$56.82
59.84
31.63
60.60
61.20
62.70
72.80

44.9%
11.4%
119.6%
20.2%
19.9%
19.9%
(21.3%)

0.0%
(5.0%)
79.6%
(6.2%)
(7.2%)
(9.4%)
(22.0%)

3.48x
3.04x
2.84x

3.56x
3.11x
2.90x

6.09x
5.43x
4.94x

$14,263.0
15,996.2
17,581.0

20.1x
13.5x
11.3x

20.6x
13.8x
11.6x

21.1x
14.1x
11.8x

14.4x
12.3x
11.5x

$6,024.1
7,038.0
7,556.8

20.5x
13.6x
11.3x

21.0x
14.0x
11.6x

21.5x
14.3x
11.9x

22.0x
14.6x
12.2x

15.3x
13.5x
12.8x

$5,661.5
6,438.0
6,756.8

30.2x
24.8x
18.9x

30.8x
25.3x
19.3x

31.5x
25.9x
19.7x

32.1x
26.4x
20.1x

21.6x
20.1x
16.0x

$2.63
2.83
3.55

Transaction Muliple Analysis of Atheros Inc. Acquisition

TRANSACTION ANALYSIS

Transaction Premium and Multiple Analysis

EPS ACCRETION/DILUTION ANALYSIS

Standalone
Qualcomm Inc.
Transaction Value Per Share
Equity Purchase Price

$95,854.3

Transaction Multiples Analysis


FY 2011P Revenue
FY 2012P Revenue

All Stock
$44.00
$3,544.2

$45.00
$3,624.8

$46.00
$3,705.3

$47.00
$3,785.9

$48.00
$3,866.4

$49.00
$3,947.0

$50.00
$4,027.5

6.09x
5.43x

3.07x
2.68x

3.15x
2.75x

3.23x
2.82x

3.31x
2.90x

3.40x
2.97x

3.48x
3.04x

3.56x
3.11x

FY 2011P EBITDA
FY 2012P EBITDA

14.4x
12.3x

18.2x
12.2x

18.7x
12.5x

19.2x
12.8x

19.7x
13.2x

20.1x
13.5x

20.6x
13.8x

21.1x
14.1x

FY 2011P Cash P/E


FY 2012P Cash P/E

21.6x
20.1x

28.2x
23.2x

28.9x
23.8x

29.5x
24.3x

30.2x
24.8x

30.8x
25.3x

31.5x
25.9x

32.1x
26.4x

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

Qualcomm Inc. Standalone EPS


FY 2012P Cash Net Income
FY 2012P Shares Outstanding
FY 2012P Cash EPS
After-Tax Acquisition Adjustments
Atheros Inc. FY 2012P Cash Net Income
Interest Lost on Cash Used
Incremental Interest on New Debt
Interest Gained on Conversion of Convert(s)
Deferred Stock-Based Compensation
Amortization of Indentifiable Intangibles
Depreciation of Acquired Tangible Assets
Write-Down of Deferred Revenue

$181.1
(0.5)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

Pro Forma Cash Net Income Without Synergies


After-Tax Synergies
Pro Forma Cash Net Income With Synergies
Diluted Shares - Treasury Method
Qualcomm Inc. FY 2012P Shares Outstanding
Shares Issued for Atheros Inc. Basic Shares
Total Shares Post-Transaction
Accretion/Dilution Summary
FY 2012P Cash EPS Without Synergies
$ Accretion / Dilution
% Accretion / Dilution
Pre-Tax Synergies to Breakeven
% of Combined Opex (Excl. Syngergies)
FY 2012P Cash EPS With Synergies
$ Accretion / Dilution
% Accretion / Dilution
Pre-Tax Synergies to Breakeven
% of Combined Opex (Excl. Syngergies)

Ownership Structure Post Transaction


% Shares Owned by Qualcomm Inc. Shareholders Post-Transaction
% Shares Owned by Atheros Inc. Post-Transaction
Total %

$181.1
(0.5)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(0.5)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(0.5)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(0.5)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(0.5)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(0.5)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$5,363.8
61.3
$5,425.0

$5,363.8
61.3
$5,425.0

$5,363.8
61.3
$5,425.0

$5,363.8
61.3
$5,425.0

$5,363.8
61.3
$5,425.0

$5,363.8
61.3
$5,425.0

$5,363.8
61.3
$5,425.0

1,832.791
62.376
1,895.167

1,832.791
63.794
1,896.585

1,832.791
65.211
1,898.003

1,832.791
66.629
1,899.420

1,832.791
68.046
1,900.838

1,832.791
69.464
1,902.255

1,832.791
70.882
1,903.673

$2.83

$2.83
$0.00
0.1%
($3.6)
(0.0%)

$2.83
($0.00)
(0.0%)
$1.3
0.0%

$2.83
($0.00)
(0.1%)
$6.2
0.1%

$2.82
($0.00)
(0.2%)
$11.2
0.1%

$2.82
($0.01)
(0.2%)
$16.1
0.2%

$2.82
($0.01)
(0.3%)
$21.0
0.2%

$2.82
($0.01)
(0.4%)
$25.9
0.2%

$2.83

$2.86
$0.03
1.2%
($78.6)
(0.7%)

$2.86
$0.03
1.1%
($73.7)
(0.7%)

$2.86
$0.03
1.0%
($68.8)
(0.6%)

$2.86
$0.03
1.0%
($63.8)
(0.6%)

$2.85
$0.03
0.9%
($58.9)
(0.6%)

$2.85
$0.02
0.8%
($54.0)
(0.5%)

$2.85
$0.02
0.7%
($49.1)
(0.5%)

96.7%
3.3%
100.0%

96.6%
3.4%
100.0%

96.6%
3.4%
100.0%

96.5%
3.5%
100.0%

96.4%
3.6%
100.0%

96.3%
3.7%
100.0%

96.3%
3.7%
100.0%

EPS ACCRETION/DILUTION ANALYSIS

EPS Accretion/Dilution All Stock Deal

Standalone
Qualcomm Inc.
Transaction Value Per Share
Equity Purchase Price

$95,854.3

Transaction Multiples Analysis


FY 2011P Revenue
FY 2012P Revenue

60.0% Stock / 40.0% Cash


$44.00
$3,544.2

$45.00
$3,624.8

$46.00
$3,705.3

$47.00
$3,785.9

$48.00
$3,866.4

$49.00
$3,947.0

$50.00
$4,027.5

6.09x
5.43x

3.07x
2.68x

3.15x
2.75x

3.23x
2.82x

3.31x
2.90x

3.40x
2.97x

3.48x
3.04x

3.56x
3.11x

FY 2011P EBITDA
FY 2012P EBITDA

14.4x
12.3x

18.2x
12.2x

18.7x
12.5x

19.2x
12.8x

19.7x
13.2x

20.1x
13.5x

20.6x
13.8x

21.1x
14.1x

FY 2011P Cash P/E


FY 2012P Cash P/E

21.6x
20.1x

28.2x
23.2x

28.9x
23.8x

29.5x
24.3x

30.2x
24.8x

30.8x
25.3x

31.5x
25.9x

32.1x
26.4x

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

Qualcomm Inc. Standalone EPS


FY 2012P Cash Net Income
FY 2012P Shares Outstanding
FY 2012P Cash EPS
After-Tax Acquisition Adjustments
Atheros Inc. FY 2012P Cash Net Income
Interest Lost on Cash Used
Incremental Interest on New Debt
Interest Gained on Conversion of Convert(s)
Deferred Stock-Based Compensation
Amortization of Indentifiable Intangibles
Depreciation of Acquired Tangible Assets
Write-Down of Deferred Revenue

$181.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

Pro Forma Cash Net Income Without Synergies


After-Tax Synergies
Pro Forma Cash Net Income With Synergies
Diluted Shares - Treasury Method
Qualcomm Inc. FY 2012P Shares Outstanding
Shares Issued for Atheros Inc. Basic Shares
Total Shares Post-Transaction
Accretion/Dilution Summary
FY 2012P Cash EPS Without Synergies
$ Accretion / Dilution
% Accretion / Dilution
Pre-Tax Synergies to Breakeven
% of Combined Opex (Excl. Syngergies)
FY 2012P Cash EPS With Synergies
$ Accretion / Dilution
% Accretion / Dilution
Pre-Tax Synergies to Breakeven
% of Combined Opex (Excl. Syngergies)

Ownership Structure Post Transaction


% Shares Owned by Qualcomm Inc. Shareholders Post-Transaction
% Shares Owned by Atheros Inc. Post-Transaction
Total %

$181.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$5,364.2
61.3
$5,425.5

$5,364.2
61.3
$5,425.5

$5,364.2
61.3
$5,425.5

$5,364.2
61.3
$5,425.5

$5,364.2
61.3
$5,425.5

$5,364.2
61.3
$5,425.5

$5,364.2
61.3
$5,425.5

1,832.791
37.426
1,870.217

1,832.791
38.276
1,871.068

1,832.791
39.127
1,871.918

1,832.791
39.977
1,872.769

1,832.791
40.828
1,873.619

1,832.791
41.678
1,874.470

1,832.791
42.529
1,875.320

$2.83

$2.87
$0.04
1.4%
($90.5)
(0.8%)

$2.87
$0.04
1.4%
($87.6)
(0.8%)

$2.87
$0.04
1.3%
($84.7)
(0.8%)

$2.86
$0.04
1.3%
($81.7)
(0.8%)

$2.86
$0.03
1.2%
($78.8)
(0.7%)

$2.86
$0.03
1.2%
($75.8)
(0.7%)

$2.86
$0.03
1.1%
($72.9)
(0.7%)

$2.83

$2.90
$0.07
2.6%
($165.5)
(1.5%)

$2.90
$0.07
2.5%
($162.6)
(1.5%)

$2.90
$0.07
2.5%
($159.7)
(1.5%)

$2.90
$0.07
2.4%
($156.7)
(1.5%)

$2.90
$0.07
2.4%
($153.8)
(1.4%)

$2.89
$0.07
2.3%
($150.8)
(1.4%)

$2.89
$0.06
2.3%
($147.9)
(1.4%)

98.0%
2.0%
100.0%

98.0%
2.0%
100.0%

97.9%
2.1%
100.0%

97.9%
2.1%
100.0%

97.8%
2.2%
100.0%

97.8%
2.2%
100.0%

97.7%
2.3%
100.0%

EPS ACCRETION/DILUTION ANALYSIS

EPS Accretion/Dilution 60% Stock + 40% Cash Deal

Standalone
Qualcomm Inc.
Transaction Value Per Share
Equity Purchase Price

$95,854.3

Transaction Multiples Analysis


FY 2011P Revenue
FY 2012P Revenue

All Cash
$44.00
$3,544.2

$45.00
$3,624.8

$46.00
$3,705.3

$47.00
$3,785.9

$48.00
$3,866.4

$49.00
$3,947.0

$50.00
$4,027.5

6.09x
5.43x

3.07x
2.68x

3.15x
2.75x

3.23x
2.82x

3.31x
2.90x

3.40x
2.97x

3.48x
3.04x

3.56x
3.11x

FY 2011P EBITDA
FY 2012P EBITDA

14.4x
12.3x

18.2x
12.2x

18.7x
12.5x

19.2x
12.8x

19.7x
13.2x

20.1x
13.5x

20.6x
13.8x

21.1x
14.1x

FY 2011P Cash P/E


FY 2012P Cash P/E

21.6x
20.1x

28.2x
23.2x

28.9x
23.8x

29.5x
24.3x

30.2x
24.8x

30.8x
25.3x

31.5x
25.9x

32.1x
26.4x

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

$5,184.4
1,832.791
$2.83

Qualcomm Inc. Standalone EPS


FY 2012P Cash Net Income
FY 2012P Shares Outstanding
FY 2012P Cash EPS
After-Tax Acquisition Adjustments
Atheros Inc. FY 2012P Cash Net Income
Interest Lost on Cash Used
Incremental Interest on New Debt
Interest Gained on Conversion of Convert(s)
Deferred Stock-Based Compensation
Amortization of Indentifiable Intangibles
Depreciation of Acquired Tangible Assets
Write-Down of Deferred Revenue

$181.1
(58.4)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

Pro Forma Cash Net Income Without Synergies


After-Tax Synergies
Pro Forma Cash Net Income With Synergies
Diluted Shares - Treasury Method
Qualcomm Inc. FY 2012P Shares Outstanding
Shares Issued for Atheros Inc. Basic Shares
Total Shares Post-Transaction
Accretion/Dilution Summary
FY 2012P Cash EPS Without Synergies
$ Accretion / Dilution
% Accretion / Dilution
Pre-Tax Synergies to Breakeven
% of Combined Opex (Excl. Syngergies)
FY 2012P Cash EPS With Synergies
$ Accretion / Dilution
% Accretion / Dilution
Pre-Tax Synergies to Breakeven
% of Combined Opex (Excl. Syngergies)

Ownership Structure Post Transaction


% Shares Owned by Qualcomm Inc. Shareholders Post-Transaction
% Shares Owned by Atheros Inc. Post-Transaction
Total %

$181.1
(59.7)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(61.0)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(62.4)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(63.7)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(65.0)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$181.1
(66.3)
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
(1.2)
0.0

$5,305.8
61.3
$5,367.1

$5,304.5
61.3
$5,365.8

$5,303.2
61.3
$5,364.5

$5,301.9
61.3
$5,363.2

$5,300.6
61.3
$5,361.9

$5,299.3
61.3
$5,360.5

$5,297.9
61.3
$5,359.2

1,832.791
0.0
1,832.791

1,832.791
0.0
1,832.791

1,832.791
0.0
1,832.791

1,832.791
0.0
1,832.791

1,832.791
0.0
1,832.791

1,832.791
0.0
1,832.791

1,832.791
0.0
1,832.791

$2.83

$2.89
$0.07
2.3%
($148.6)
(1.4%)

$2.89
$0.07
2.3%
($147.0)
(1.4%)

$2.89
$0.06
2.3%
($145.4)
(1.4%)

$2.89
$0.06
2.3%
($143.8)
(1.3%)

$2.89
$0.06
2.2%
($142.2)
(1.3%)

$2.89
$0.06
2.2%
($140.6)
(1.3%)

$2.89
$0.06
2.2%
($139.0)
(1.3%)

$2.83

$2.93
$0.10
3.5%
($223.6)
(2.1%)

$2.93
$0.10
3.5%
($222.0)
(2.1%)

$2.93
$0.10
3.5%
($220.4)
(2.1%)

$2.93
$0.10
3.4%
($218.8)
(2.0%)

$2.93
$0.10
3.4%
($217.2)
(2.0%)

$2.92
$0.10
3.4%
($215.6)
(2.0%)

$2.92
$0.10
3.4%
($214.0)
(2.0%)

100.0%
0.0%
100.0%

100.0%
0.0%
100.0%

100.0%
0.0%
100.0%

100.0%
0.0%
100.0%

100.0%
0.0%
100.0%

100.0%
0.0%
100.0%

100.0%
0.0%
100.0%

EPS ACCRETION/DILUTION ANALYSIS

EPS Accretion/Dilution All Cash Deal

Accretion/Dilution without Synergy

Cash
%

1.4% $ 43.00
30%
1.1%
35%
1.3%
40%
1.4%
45%
1.6%
50%
1.8%

$ 44.00
1.1%
1.2%
1.4%
1.6%
1.7%

Accretion/Dilution with Synergy

Offer Price
$ 45.00 $ 46.00
1.0%
1.0%
1.2%
1.1%
1.4%
1.3%
1.5%
1.5%
1.7%
1.7%

$ 47.00
0.9%
Cash
1.1%
1.3%
%
1.4%
1.6%

Pre Tax Synergy Required to Breakeven

-8759.7% $ 43.00
Cash
%

30%
35%
40%
45%
50%

($72.4)
($82.9)
($93.5)
($104.0)
($114.6)

$ 44.00
($68.9)
($79.7)
($90.5)
($101.3)
($112.1)

$ 44.00
2.2%
2.4%
2.6%
2.7%
2.9%

Offer Price
$ 45.00 $ 46.00
2.2%
2.1%
2.3%
2.3%
2.5%
2.5%
2.7%
2.6%
2.9%
2.8%

$ 47.00
2.1%
2.2%
2.4%
2.6%
2.8%

% Share Owned by Microsoft Post Transaction

Offer Price
$ 45.00 $
($65.5)
($76.6)
($87.6)
($98.6)
($109.7)

2.5% $ 43.00
30%
2.3%
35%
2.4%
40%
2.6%
45%
2.8%
50%
2.9%

46.00

$ 47.00

($62.1)
($73.4)
($84.7)
($95.9)
($107.2)

($58.6)
($70.2)
($81.7)
($93.2)
($104.8)

Cash
%

98.0% $ 43.00
30%
97.7%
35%
97.9%
40%
98.0%
45%
98.2%
50%

98.4%

$ 44.00
97.7%
97.8%
98.0%
98.2%
98.3%

Offer Price
$ 45.00 $ 46.00
97.6%
97.6%
97.8%
97.7%
98.0%
97.9%
98.1%
98.1%
98.3%

98.3%

$ 47.00
97.5%
97.7%
97.9%
98.0%
98.2%

EPS ACCRETION/DILUTION ANALYSIS

EPS Accretion/Dilution Sensitivity Analysis

PROFITABILITY CONTRIBUTION ANALYSIS

Qualcomm Inc.
FY11

FY12

Revenue
% Growth

$14,263.0
29.8%

$15,996.2
12.2%

EBITDA
% Margin

$6,024.1
42.2%

GAAP Net Income


% Margin
Cash Net Income
% Margin
Contribution
Revenue
EBITDA
GAAP Net Income
Cash Net Income

Combined

Atheros Inc.
FY11

(1)

Pro Forma

Synergies

FY12

FY11

FY12

FY11

$986.6
6.5%

$1,129.3
14.5%

$15,249.6
28.0%

$17,125.5
12.3%

$0.0

$7,038.0
44.0%

$166.4
16.9%

$248.3
22.0%

$6,190.5
40.6%

$7,286.3
42.5%

$4,802.4
33.7%

$5,108.2
31.9%

$113.8
11.5%

$169.2
15.0%

$4,916.2
32.2%

$4,890.3
34.3%

$5,184.4
32.4%

$126.1
12.8%

$181.1
16.0%

93.5%
97.3%
97.7%
97.5%

93.4%
96.6%
96.8%
96.6%

6.5%
2.7%
2.3%
2.5%

6.6%
3.4%
3.2%
3.4%

FY12

(2)

FY11

FY12

$0.0

$15,249.6
28.0%

$17,125.5
12.3%

$0.0

$75.0

$6,190.5
40.6%

$7,361.3
43.0%

$5,277.4
30.8%

$0.0

$61.3

$4,977.4
32.6%

$5,338.7
31.2%

$5,016.4
32.9%

$5,365.5
31.3%

$0.0

$61.3

$5,077.7
33.3%

$5,426.8
31.7%

100.0%
100.0%
100.0%
100.0%

100.0%
100.0%
100.0%
100.0%

PROFITABILITY CONTRIBUTION ANALYSIS

Profitability Contribution by Buyer and Target

DEAL FACT

Prepared
by
Deb Sahoo
MBA, Ross School of Business
University of Michigan, Ann Arbor

You might also like