Professional Documents
Culture Documents
WHAT IS DEVIANCE?
WHO IS DEVIANT?
We perceive and understand the physical and social world based on a shared sense of order
(predictability): the meanings we attach to people, things, and actions. "Otherness" (differentness)
challenges our assumptions, our taken-for-granted sense of normalcy and naturalness
• At a basic "gut" level it calls into question our basic beliefs and ideas: It threatens us.
• At a social level it challenges the social order: the existing web of relationships, values,
reality and meaning
• Internal/socialization.
• External: a system of norms, sanctions and enforcement.
Deviance is problematic, yet essential and intrinsic to any conception of Social Order. It is
problematic because it disrupts; it is essential because it defines the confines of our shared
reality; and it is intrinsic to a conception of order in that defining what is real and expected,
defining what is acceptable, and defining who we are- always is done in opposition to what is
unreal, unexpected, unacceptable, and who we are not ("We defines They"). If we can accept the
reality of change, then designations of deviance are crucial in locating the shifting boundaries of
our socially structured reality.
And, when we define someone or some group as deviant- we strengthen our own position and
simplify our response to the "other": ignore, expunge, destroy, or rehabilitate them. We convince
ourselves of our own normalcy by condemning and controlling those who disagree. Deviance is a
phenomenon situated in power: Winners are the good and the normal; Losers are the sick, the
crazy, the evil (and they often accept the "label").
Deviance, therefore, exists in opposition to those who attempt to control it-- to those who have:
Power.
Winners: Organize social life
Losers: Are controlled (executed, shamed, jailed, hospitalized, cared for). They are just not treated
as NORMAL. They are STIGMATIZED.
Deviance is not a matter of the cost or consequences of a particular behavior, or the behavior
itself. Deviance is a label (PROCESS) used to maintain the power, control, and position of a
dominant group.
Deviance is a negotiated order. Deviance violates some groups assumptions about reality (social
order). It violates expectations. The definition of deviance defines the threat and allows for
containment and control of the threat. The definition of deviance preserves, protects, and defines
group interests and in doing so maintains a sense of normalcy. Deviance is a product of Social
Interaction.
Crusading Reformers
Rule Enforcers
• Once a new rule (law): Then institutionalization- an Agency (police, FBN, etc)
• Agency's interest and motives? Detachment- not concerned with the content of the rule, but
with enforcement: The rule is a JOB.
• Need to continue to maintain justification for the existence of the JOB: Crime is increasing at
a decreasing rate.
• Day to day reality: Need for maintenance of position on the street. Respect.
• Official deviance often becomes, not rule breaking, but lack of respect for rule enforcer.
o Demeanor
o Discretion
o The "Fix": 'Amateurs get caught'
o Enforcers have little stake in the content of the rule, they often develop their own
evaluation of the importance of the rule in light of the contingencies of their daily
activities.
Enforcers and Creators: Often at odds==> Leads to a new crusade. Deviance "re-
loaded."
• Escalation:
1. Increase frequency, seriousness (high speed chase, runaway->probation->new violation->delinquent)
2. new categories(carjacking)
3. increases skill level of 'criminal'
4. violations linked to enforcement ("buy money," 'scared straight,' "the usual suspects")
• Non-Enforcement
• Covert Facilitation
• 1 and 2: force the blind to recognize their 'differentness' and creates a social identity that is
either accepted or rejected by the blind (in either case they are forced into responding to the
stigma, and "becoming" a "Self" based on their response. This imposes uniform behavioral
patterns on the blind, which in turn feed the stereotypes........
• 3, 4, and 5: Provide further evidence of 'differentness,' deny feedback, and relegates the
blind to a subordinate position.
• Changes in:
1. The social image of children.
2. Assumptions that formed the basis of our understanding of the "causes" of deviance.
3. The organization of Social Control
• The social organization of the medical profession:
1. ER doctors were unaware, unwilling (perhaps) and restrained by confidentiality and
fear of loss of control.
2. Pediatric Radiology and Psychodynamic Psychiatry were removed from the
immediacy of the situation and stood to gain in professional status: The most
idealized mission of the profession: "To label as illness what was not previously
labeled at all, or labeled in some other fashion."
• Once "medicalized" the idea spreads: Interests of social workers, lobbying efforts of the
medical profession, and the role of the media.
• Resistance was weak: Labelers==> Middle class, 'removed' from abusers. Abusers==> Lower
class; no power.
• With continued acceptance==> further spread and continued medicalization. Definition of
abuse has broadened, and need for treatment has become a preventive reality.
• 1993: 50,000 calls in the State of Missouri.
• 2003: 108,685 calls
URL: http://www.umsl.edu/~keelr/200/intrdev.html
Owner: Robert O. Keel rok@umsl.edu
References and Credits for this Page of Notes
Last Updated: Monday, January 29, 2007 1:22 PM