Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • When Securities Firms Fail - Rebuilding Success Spring 09 AN

    Uploaded by

    anackan
    27 views2 pages
    Nrms saw fee revenues fall as a result of reduced trading activity. Investors have become worried about the safety of their investments. Insolvency and restructuring professionals can gain insight into the full extent of Canada's investor protection laws.

    Original Description:

    Original Title

    When Securities Firms Fail_Rebuilding Success Spring 09 AN

    Copyright

    © Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    Nrms saw fee revenues fall as a result of reduced trading activity. Investors have become worried about the safety of their investments. Insolvency and restructuring professionals can gain insight into the full extent of Canada's investor protection laws.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    27 views2 pages

    When Securities Firms Fail - Rebuilding Success Spring 09 AN

    Uploaded by

    anackan
    Nrms saw fee revenues fall as a result of reduced trading activity. Investors have become worried about the safety of their investments. Insolvency and restructuring professionals can gain insight into the full extent of Canada's investor protection laws.

    Copyright:

    Attribution Non-Commercial (BY-NC)
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 2

    When Securities

    Firms Fail:
    An Inside Look
    at the Marlow Group
    Bankruptcy
    Pour visionner la traduction française de cet article, visitez le
    http://www.cairp.ca/french/communications_advo/spring_2009_fr.asp

    By Allan Nackan,
    #!s#)20 #)20

    F PMMPXJOH UIF 64 ëOBODJBM


    NFMUEPXOUIBUCFHBOJO4FQUFNCFS
      TUPDL NBSLFUT BSPVOE UIF
    XPSME IBWF FYQFSJFODFE VOQSFDFEFOUFE
    /PUBCMZ  IPXFWFS  UIF +BOVBSZ  DBTF
    of Ashley v. Marlow Group Private Portfolio
    Management Inc. (Marlow) BEESFTTFETPNF
    PGUIFTFJTTVFT#ZSFWJFXJOHUIFPVUDPNFT
    Mr. Nackan is a partner with
    Toronto-based A. Farber & Partners
    Inc., which for almost 30 years has
    provided broad-based services and
    advice in the areas of insolvency
    WPMBUJMJUZ 8IJMF UIF JNQBDU PG UIF DSJTJT PG UIBU DBTF  JOTPMWFODZ BOE SFTUSVDUVSJOH and restructuring.
    SFWFSCFSBUFEJONBOZTFDUPST UIFëOBODJBM QSPGFTTJPOBMT DBO HBJO JNQPSUBOU JOTJHIU
    TFSWJDFT JOEVTUSZ XBT QBSUJDVMBSMZ IBSE JOUP UIF GVMM FYUFOU PG $BOBEBT JOWFTUPS
    IJU#SPLFSBHFëSNTTBXGFFSFWFOVFTGBMM QSPUFDUJPOMBXT"UUIFTBNFUJNF ZPVDBO
    BT B SFTVMU PG SFEVDFE USBEJOH BDUJWJUZ CFHJOUPCFUUFSVOEFSTUBOEUIFSPMFPG1BSU .FBOXIJMF  BT UIPTF DMBJNT JODIFE
    %FDMJOJOHNBSHJOMPBOTBMTPQVUBTRVFF[F 9** PG UIF Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act UISPVHIUIFDPVSUT UIF3FDFJWFSPSUSVTUFF
    POJOUFSFTUSFWFOVFT (BIA)JOTFDVSJUJFTëSNCBOLSVQUDJFT XPVME IBWF JO JUT QPTTFTTJPO WPMBUJMF
    *O BEEJUJPO UP TIBUUFSJOH JOWFTUPS DPOë TFDVSJUJFT XIPTFWBMVFTDPVMEQPUFOUJBMMZ
    5PBQQSFDJBUFUIFJNQPSUBODFPG1BSU9**PG
    EFODF UIFDSFEJUDSVODIDBMMFEJOWFTUNFOU EJNJOJTI XIJMF UIF WBSJPVT DVTUPNFST
    the BIA JUIFMQTUPVOEFSTUBOEUIFMFHJTMBUJWF
    ëSN QSBDUJDFT JOUP RVFTUJPO 8JUI NFEJB CBUUMFEUPIBWFUIFJSTFDVSJUJFTSFUVSOFE
    TUBUF PG BêBJST QSJPS UP JUT FOBDUNFOU JO
    IFBEMJOFT QSFEJDUJOH UIF GBJMVSF PG TFDVSJ
    6OUJMUIBUUJNF UIFBENJOJTUSBUJPO 8JUI UIF JOUSPEVDUJPO PG 1BSU 9** PG
    UJFTëSNTBOEPUIFSNBSLFUJOUFSNFEJBSJFT 
    JOWFTUPST IBWF CFDPNF XPSSJFE BCPVU UIF
    PGTFDVSJUJFTëSNJOTPMWFODJFTXBTFYUSFNFMZ the BIA JO   1BSMJBNFOU TPVHIU UP
    TBGFUZPGUIFJSJOWFTUNFOUT UJNFDPOTVNJOHBOEVODFSUBJO PVTU BMM USVTU DMBJNT GSPN TFDVSJUJFT ëSN
    CBOLSVQUDJFTBOEBMMPXGPSUIFSFUVSOPG
    8IBUIBQQFOTXIFOBTFDVSJUJFTëSNHPFT *O BO FêPSU UP SFDPWFS UIFJS TIBSFT 
    POMZiDVTUPNFSOBNFTFDVSJUJFTw
    CBOLSVQU )PXDBOJOWFTUPSTQSPUFDUUIFJS DVTUPNFST PG CBOLSVQU TFDVSJUJFT ëSNT
    NPOFZ  *G ZPV IBWF FWFS BENJOJTUFSFE JOWBSJBCMZ SBJTFE USVTU DMBJNT  JOWPLJOH ɨF HPBM PG UIJT SVMF XBT UP QSPNPUF B
    UIF CBOLSVQUDZ PG B TFDVSJUJFT ëSN  DFOUVSJFTPME iUSBDJOHw DPODFQUT "T POF TJNQMJëFE BOEIPQFGVMMZNPSFFRVJUBCMF 
    PS SFQSFTFOUFE BOYJPVT JOWFTUPST  ZPV 64 DPVSU MBNFOUFE JO Slattery & Co.
     EJTUSJCVUJPOQSPDFTT4JODFJUDBOCFEJïDVMU
    LOPXUIFSFBSFOPFBTZBOTXFSTUPUIFTF iQSPCBCMZ OP CSBODI PG CBOLSVQUDZ UP USBDF UIF PXOFSTIJQ PG JOEJWJEVBM
    RVFTUJPOT 6OSBWFMMJOH UIF BêBJST PG B BENJOJTUSBUJPOQSFTFOUTNPSFUSPVCMFTPNF TFDVSJUJFT  1BSU 9** NBOEBUFT UIBU POMZ
    GBJMFETFDVSJUJFTëSN BOEEJTUSJCVUJOHJUT RVFTUJPOT PG MBX BOE BENJOJTUSBUJPO UIBO UIPTF TFDVSJUJFT SFHJTUFSFE JO DVTUPNFST
    SFNBJOJOHBTTFUT JTGSBVHIUXJUIMFHBMBOE EPFTUIFJOTPMWFODZPGBTUPDLCSPLFSBHFPS OBNFTXJMMCFSFUVSOFEUPDVTUPNFST"MM
    QSBDUJDBMDPNQMFYJUJFT JOWFTUNFOUDPODFSOw PUIFS TFDVSJUJFT BOE DBTI XPVME CF QVU

    34 Rebuilding Success Spring 2009


    JOUP B HFOFSBM iDVTUPNFS QPPMw  UP CF NFNCFS PG BO FYDIBOHF  BT QSJODJQBM PS ɨJTSBJTFTJOUFSFTUJOHRVFTUJPOTSFHBSEJOH
    EJTUSJCVUFEQSPSBUBUPDVTUPNFST BHFOUw ɨF .BSMPX DBTF BDUT BT DMFBS UIFQSPUFDUJPOPGJOWFTUPSTNPOFZ-FHBM
    KVEJDJBM BïSNBUJPO UIBU TFDVSJUJFT ëSN BOE BDDPVOUJOH QSPGFTTJPOBMT TIPVME
    &OUFS UIF .BSMPX DBTF *O .BSDI   CBOLSVQUDJFT TIPVME CF BENJOJTUFSFE QBZQBSUJDVMBSIFFE5PQSFWFOUJOWFTUPS
    UIF.BSMPX(SPVQPGDPNQBOJFT XIJDI VOEFS1BSU9** TFDVSJUJFT GSPN GBMMJOH JOUP B HFOFSBM
    PQFSBUFEBTTFDVSJUJFTEFBMFST JOWFTUNFOU
    DVTUPNFSQPPMGPSEJTUSJCVUJPO BEWJTPST
    EFBMFST BOE JOWFTUNFOU BEWJTPST  XBT ɨF$PVSUBMTPDPOTJEFSFEUIFEFëOJUJPO
    TIPVME USZ UP IBWF TFDVSJUJFT SFHJTUFSFE
    QMBDFE JOUP SFDFJWFSTIJQ "QQBSFOUMZ  PG XIBU DPOTUJUVUFT B iDVTUPNFS OBNF
    JOUIFJSDVTUPNFSTOBNFTBTTPPOBTUIF
    NPSFUIBONJMMJPOIBEWBOJTIFEGSPN TFDVSJUZw *UT ëOEJOH XBT UIBU  VOMFTT
    TFDVSJUJFTBSFQVSDIBTFE
    DMJFOUTUSVTUBDDPVOUT DBVTJOHUIF0OUBSJP TFDVSJUJFTBSFSFHJTUFSFEJOUIFOBNFPGUIF
    4FDVSJUJFT $PNNJTTJPO UP TVTQFOE DVTUPNFS  PS BSF JO UIF QSPDFTT PG CFJOH ɨFSF BSF BMTP PUIFS TUFQT UIBU BEWJTPST
    UIF DPNQBOZT BêBJST 8IJMF JOWFTUPST SFHJTUFSFE  UIFZ BSF OPU iDVTUPNFS OBNF TIPVME UBLF JO MJHIU PG UIF $PVSUT
    TDSBNCMFEUPMPDBUFUIFJSNJTTJOHNPOFZ  TFDVSJUJFTw"TTVDI UIFZEPOPUOFFEUPCF EFDJTJPO 'PS JOTUBODF  UP SFEVDF UIF
    UIF0OUBSJP$PVSUBQQPJOUFEPVSëSNBT SJTL PG GSBVE PS NJTBQQSPQSJBUJPO 
    3FDFJWFS 0VS NBOEBUF XBT UP JEFOUJGZ JOWFTUPST TIPVME BJN UP EFBM XJUI POMZ
    BOE TFDVSF UIF .BSMPX (SPVQT BTTFUT  DSFEJCMF JOTUJUVUJPOT -BSHF CBOLT BOE
    RVBOUJGZ UIF MPTTFT BOE EFUFSNJOF UIF JOWFTUNFOU EFBMFST BSF TUSJDUMZ SFHVMBUFE
    NPTUTVJUBCMFCBTJTPOXIJDIUPEJTUSJCVUF To prevent investor BOE NBZ CF NPSF MJLFMZ UP IBWF CFUUFS
    UIFSFNBJOJOHGVOET DPOUSPMT PWFS USVTU GVOET "ENJUUFEMZ 
    securities from UIF GBJMVSF PG NBKPS 64 JOWFTUNFOU
    %FTQJUF UIF GBDU UIBU UIF .BSMPX DBTF
    ëSNTMJLF-FINBO#SPUIFSTBOE.FSSJMM
    TFFNFE B QFSGFDU ëU GPS 1BSU 9** PG UIF falling into a -ZODI DBO OFHBUF UIJT BSHVNFOU
    BIA  TPNF JOWFTUPS HSPVQT DIBMMFOHFE
    )PXFWFS  $BOBEJBO JOWFTUNFOU ëSNT
    JUT BQQMJDBUJPO 0OF HSPVQ DMBJNFE UIBU general customer UFOE UP CF NPSF DMPTFMZ SFHVMBUFE UIBO
    DFSUBJOTFDVSJUJFT BMUIPVHIOPUSFHJTUFSFE
    UIFJS"NFSJDBODPVOUFSQBSUT XIJDIDBO
    JOJUTDVTUPNFSTOBNFT XFSFCFJOHIFMEJO pool for distribution, QSPWJEF EPNFTUJD JOWFTUPST XJUI NPSF
    USVTU BOE TIPVME  UIFSFGPSF  CF SFUVSOFE
    FêFDUJWFQSPUFDUJPO
    "OPUIFS HSPVQ  DMBJNJOH .BSMPX XBTOU advisors should try
    ZFU UFDIOJDBMMZ CBOLSVQU  USJFE UP PCUBJO 4JNJMBSMZ  UIF $BOBEJBO *OWFTUPS
    MBTUNJOVUF OBNF SFHJTUSBUJPO PG JUT to have securities 1SPUFDUJPO 'VOE $*1'
     BMTP QSPUFDUT
    TFDVSJUJFT:FUBOPUIFSBSHVFEUIBU.BSMPX TPNFPGUIFDBTIBOETFDVSJUJFTPGFMJHJCMF
    XBTOPUBTFDVSJUJFTëSNBUBMM CVUNFSFMZ registered in DVTUPNFSTPGJOWFTUNFOUEFBMFSTUIBUBSF
    BO JOWFTUNFOU BEWJTPS  BOE UIBU CVZJOH NFNCFST PG UIF *OWFTUNFOU *OEVTUSZ
    BOETFMMJOHTFDVSJUJFTGPSJUTDVTUPNFSTXBT their customers’ 3FHVMBUPSZ0SHBOJ[BUJPOPG$BOBEBɨJT
    OPUJUTQSJNBSZCVTJOFTTBDUJWJUZ XBTPGMJUUMFWBMVF IPXFWFS JOUIF.BSMPX
    5P HJWF UIFTF QBSUJFT UIF PQQPSUVOJUZ UP
    names as soon as DBTF0OMZPOFPGUIF.BSMPXDPSQPSBUF
    FOUJUJFTXBTB$*1'EFBMFSNFNCFS8IJMF
    IBWF UIFJS QPTJUJPOT IFBSE  UIF 3FDFJWFS
    CSPVHIU B NPUJPO GPS EJSFDUJPOT CFGPSF
    the securities are UIF JOWFTUPST PG UIBU DPNQBOZ TVêFSFE
    NJOJNBM MPTTFT  JOWFTUPST PG UIF OPO
    UIF $PVSU UP EFUFSNJOF XIFUIFS UIF
    .BSMPX(SPVQTIPVMECFDPNFCBOLSVQU
    purchased. JOTVSFE FOUJUJFT XFSF OPU BT GPSUVOBUF
    'SPNBOJOWFTUPSQSPUFDUJPOTUBOEQPJOU 
    BOE XIFUIFS JUT CBOLSVQUDZ TIPVME CF
    UIFO JUTJNQPSUBOUGPSBEWJTPSTUPFOTVSF
    BENJOJTUFSFEJOBDDPSEBODFXJUI1BSU9**
    UIBU TFDVSJUJFT ëSNT BSF SFHJTUFSFE XJUI
    ɨFWBSJPVTQBSUJFTCSPVHIUDSPTTNPUJPOT 
    UIF $*1' JO BEWBODF PG NBLJOH DMJFOU
    TFUUJOHPVUUIFJSSFTQFDUJWFQPTJUJPOT SFUVSOFE UP DVTUPNFST /PUBCMZ  DVSSFOU investments.
    *OUIFFOE UIPVHI UIF$PVSUIFMEUIBU QSBDUJDFJTHFOFSBMMZOPUUPSFHJTUFSTFDVSJ
    0UIFS QSPUFDUJPO TUSBUFHJFT JODMVEF
    UIF.BSMPX(SPVQPGDPNQBOJFTXBTUP UJFT JO DVTUPNFST OBNFT BT BO FMFDUSPOJD
    XPSLJOH XJUI NPSF UIBO POF
    CF BTTJHOFE JOUP CBOLSVQUDZ ɨF $PVSU TZTUFNPGSFHJTUSBUJPOPGTFDVSJUZJOUFSFTUT TFDVSJUJFT ëSN UP EJWFSTJGZ UIF SJTLT PG
    BMTPBïSNFEUIBUUIFCBOLSVQUDZPGUIPTF JTFNQMPZFE*O.BSMPX NPTUJOWFTUNFOUT NJTNBOBHFNFOUBOENPWJOHRVJDLMZUP
    DPNQBOJFTUIBUXFSFTFDVSJUJFTëSNTXBT XFSFQVSDIBTFEBOEIFMEJOUIFOBNFPGB QSPUFDUBTTFUTBUUIFëSTUTJHOPGUSPVCMF
    UP CF BENJOJTUFSFE JO BDDPSEBODF XJUI .BSMPXFOUJUZBOETIBSFTXFSFOPUJPOBMMZ 4BEMZ CZUIFUJNFBUSVTUFFJOCBOLSVQUDZ
    1BSU9***OGBDU UIF+VEHFXFOUUPHSFBU PS3FDFJWFSFOUFSTUIFQJDUVSF‰BGUFSUIF
    BMMPDBUFE UP JOEJWJEVBM JOWFTUPST ɨVT 
    MFOHUIT UP DPOTJEFS XIBU DPNQSJTFT B 0OUBSJP4FDVSJUJFT$PNNJTTJPOJOTUJUVUFT
    FWFOUIPVHI.BSMPXIFMENPSFTIBSFTPG
    iTFDVSJUJFT ëSNw BOE TP GBMMT VOEFS 1BSU QSPDFFEJOHT‰JUTPGUFOUPPMBUF
    9** &TTFOUJBMMZ  UIF EFëOJUJPO JODMVEFT B QBSUJDVMBS JOWFTUNFOU UIBO UIFSF XFSF
    iB QFSTPO XIP DBSSJFE PO CVTJOFTT PG DMBJNT BHBJOTU UIPTF TIBSFT  UIFZ BMM GFMM .BSMPX JOWFTUPST SFDPWFSFE NPSF
    CVZJOH BOE TFMMJOH TFDVSJUJFT UP  GSPN JOUPUIFDVTUPNFSQPPMGVOEGPSQSPSBUB UIBO  PO UIF EPMMBS *O UPP NBOZ
    PS GPS B DVTUPNFS  XIFUIFS PS OPU BT B EJTUSJCVUJPOUPBMMDVTUPNFST JOTUBODFT MPTTFTDVUNVDIEFFQFS RS

    Volume 8 Issue 1 Rebuilding Success 35

    You might also like