: ,

,

,
? : ,
, 3 : ,

:
:
: 2500 27 105 ( 200437)

, ,

?
? ,
? ,

,


:

,
,
, ,

,

( liberal instit utionalism) ,

( special international agencies )

( supernational aut hori2
,
,1992 , 111

27

ties)
(interest groups)

( t ransgovernmental policy network)

( t ransnational actors)

( neoliberal instit utiona2

lism) , ( inter2
national instit utions)

:
, ,


,
,

,

( Robert Lieber)

:

, ,
,
, ,

( Richard Nedlebow) ,

,


( Robert Powell)
,

,
,
,

,
, ,

, ,

, ,

( ) ,
:
,
,
,
,

:
,
,
Josep h M. Grieco
: Anarchy and t he Lim2
its of Cooperation : a Realist Critique of t he Newest
Liberal Institutionalism, International Organization
Vol. 42 ,No. 3 ,Summer 1989 ,P. 494.

, 104
Robert J . Lieber : Existential Realism ,
Washington Quaterly ,Vol. 16 ,No. 1 , Winter 1993 ,
P. 1561
Richard Ned Lebow : The Long Peace ,
t he End of t he Cold War , and t he Failure of Rea2
lism , International Organization , Vol. 48 , No. 2 ,
Spring 1994.
Robert Powell :Anarchy in International
Relations Theory :t he Neorealist2neoliberal Dedate,
International Organization , Vol. 48 , No. 2 , Spring
1994 ,P. 331.

28

, , (
)
, ?
,
,
, , ,
? ,
,

,
1648
,
, ,

:
, ;
;

1997 4

( Nicholas Onuf )
:
,
( Alexander Wendt )
4 :
( 1)
,

( 2 )

,

,
, ,
( 3) ,

, ,

( 4 )

,

3
,
?
,

, ,
,

, ,

: ,
, ,
,

,
( con2
st ructionism)

, ,
,

Robert Powell :Anarchy in International

Relations Theory :t he Neorealist2neoliberal Dedate,
International Organization , Vol. 48 , No. 2 , Spring
1994 ,P. 332.
, 107 - 108
Jonat han Mercer :Anarchy and Identi2
t y, International Organization , Vol. 49 , No. 2 ,
Spring 1995 ,P. 232.
,P. 235.
Jonat han Mercer :Anarchy and Identi2
t y, International Organization , Vol. 49 , No. 2 ,
Spring 1995 ,P. 235.

29

,
(Jonat han Mercer)
,
,
, ,

: ,
;
,
, ,

,

4
?

,
; , ,

,

, , ,

, ,

, ;
( relative gains)
,
,
:1
,

3 : 1

;2

( ab2
solute gains) , :
,
;

, ,

, ,

,
,
,

,

(Josep h M. Grieco )
,

, ,

, ,
;2
;3

:
Jonat han Mercer :Anarchy and Identi2
t y, International Organization , Vol. 49 , No. 2 ,
Spring 1995 ,P. 234.

, 124
,P. 235
Robert Keohane : After Hegemony
( Princeton : Princeton University Press , 1984 ) , P.
66.

Josep h M. Grieco
: Anarchy and Coopera2
tion , International Organization Vol. 42 , No. 3 ,
Summer 1988 ,P. 487.

30
( )

,


( Hendrik
Spruryt ) :

1997 4

, ,
,

,

: ,
(
)

,
,

,
; ,

,
; ,

, ,
, ,
,

,
,
,

,

,

,
,

,
,

,
( )
,

,
, ,
, ,
,
,

,
,

,
,

,
,
,
, ,

31

,
,


4
,

,


,

,
,

,

: ,


,
,

70 ,

( )
,
, :
1

, ,

,
; ( ) ,

, ,

, ,
;
,

( : )

; ,

3

,
,
,

Robert G. Gilpin : The Richness of t he

Tradition of Political Realismin Robert O. Keo2
hane ed.Neorealism and Its Critics, New York ,
Columbia University Press ,1986 ,P. 304.