!

"#$%&'($$%&')$ '$
!"#$%!&'(")*

Please read the instructions in each part carefully before proceeding. There is no
right or wrong answer. All we ask is that you answer each question as honestly as
possible so that you can learn more about yourself. You will be given 20 minutes to
complete the survey. Please take your time and answer all the questions. If you
need any clarification, please raise your hand and wait for us to acknowledge and
approach you.

Please begin by giving us some background information about yourself by putting
an X in the appropriate boxes.

Age
School:
Grade / Year Level:
Favorite Subject(s): Name at
least one, at most three.


elow are cases ihvolvihg lhe cohlraslihg views ol lwo licliohal characlers. Jose ahd
Pablo. Read lhe cases ahd lhe quesliohs lollowihg lhen. For every ilen, choose lhe
respohse lhal besl expresses your respohse lo lhe queslioh by pullihg ah X ih lhe
appropriale box. Please hole lhal lhere is ho righl or wrohg ahswer.


17
Xavier School
H4H
Social Science
!"#$%&'($$%&')$ %$

1. Jose believes lhal
RQHPDWKHPDWLFLDQV
prool ol lhe nalh
lornula is righl.

Pablo believes lhal
aholher
PDWKHPDWLFLDQV
prool ol lhe nalh
lornula is righl.


Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.

!
2. Jose believes lhal
lhe uhiverse was
crealed by a
superhalural beihg or
power.

Pablo believes lhal
lhe uhiverse was
crealed oul ol a
purely halural
process.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
X
X
X
!"#$%&'($$%&')$ ($
!
3. Jose lhihks lhe lirsl
piece ol nusic lhey
lislehed lo is beller.

Pablo lhihks lhe
secohd piece ol
nusic lhey lislehed
lo is beller.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
!
4. Jose has ohe view
ol why crinihals keep
goihg back lo crine.

Pablo has a dillerehl
view ol why crinihals
keep goihg back lo
crine.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
!
5. Jose accepls ohe
ERRNVH[SODQDWLRQRI
how lhe braih works.

Pablo believes
DQRWKHUERRNV
explahalioh ol how
lhe braih works.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
X
X
X
X
X
!"#$%&'($$%&')$ )$
!
6. Jose lhihks lyihg is
wrohg.

Pablo lhihks lyihg is
pernissible ih cerlaih
silualiohs.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!

7. Jose lhihks lhe lirsl
book lhey bolh read
is beller.

Pablo lhihks lhe
secohd book lhey
bolh read is beller.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
X
X
!"#$%&'($$%&')$ *$
!
8. Jose agrees wilh
RQHERRNV
explahalioh ol how
childreh learh
lahguage.

Pablo agrees wilh
DQRWKHUERRNV
explahalioh ol how
childreh learh
lahguage.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
!
9. Jose lhihks people
should lake
respohsibilily lor
lhenselves.

Pablo lhihks people
should work logelher
lo lake care ol each
olher.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
X
X
X
X
!"#$%&'($$%&')$ +$
!
10. Jose lhihks lhe
lirsl paihlihg lhey
looked al is beaulilul.

Pablo lhihks lhe
secohd paihlihg lhey
looked al is beaulilul.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
!
11. Jose lhihks lhe
goverhnehl should
linil lhe hunber ol
childreh lanilies are
allowed lo have lo
keep lhe populalioh
lron gellihg loo big.

Pablo lhihks lanilies
should have as nahy
childreh as lhey
choose.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
X
X
X
!"#$%&'($$%&')$ ,$
!
12. Jose lhihks ohe
ERRNVH[SODQDWLRQRI
why World War ll
begah is righl.

Pablo lhihks aholher
ERRNVH[SODQDWLRQRI
why World War ll
begah is righl.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
!
13. Jose has a
parlicular beliel
aboul whal happehs
aller dealh.

Pablo subscribes lo a
dillerehl beliel aboul
lhe allerlile.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
X
X
X
!"#$%&'($$%&')$ -$
!
14. Jose believes ohe
ERRNVH[SODQDWLRQRI
whal alons are nade
up ol.

Pablo believes
DQRWKHUERRNV
explahalioh ol whal
alons are nade up
ol.
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!
!
15. Jose has a
specilic beliel aboul
Cod.

Pablo cohlorns lo a
beliel dillerehl ahd
eveh cohlrary lo
-RVHVEHOLHI.
!
!
!
Can only one of their views be right, or could both have some rightness?

(A) ONLY ONE OF THE VIEWS IS RIGHT
(B) BOTH VIEWS CAN BE RIGHT TO SOME DEGREE

If your answer is (B): Can one view be better or more right than the other?

(A) YES, one view CAN be more right than the other.
(B) NO, one view CANNOT be more right than the other.
!

What did you think of the survey? Was it hard/easy to answer?

X
X
X
X
East to answer.