Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Self-Motivated Agents TM
Kim A. Cooper
URL’s
Agent00
Self-Motivated Agents
Kim A Cooper
To schedule a live online demo
2
Copyright © 2004, 2009 by Exceed III, LLC
ISBN: 0-9771722-1-X
Cooper, Kim A
Creating and sustaining self motivated agents
maximizes company profits and ROI—while replacing
complacency among agents with self esteem.
/ Kim A Cooper.
First Edition
3
Introduction
In this rich and valuable practical guide, Kim
Cooper has distilled the lessons and insights he has learned
over the past 25 years while serving in senior leadership
roles for WordPerfect Corporation, Novell, Inc., TechTeam
Global, Inc., and Sento Corporation’s worldwide technical
service programs, and through his participation as a friend
and advisor to esteemed global contact centers executives
like Dave Garner CEO of Sitel, Jeffrey Tarter CEO of the
Association of Support Professionals, John Sykes CEO of
Sykes Enterprises, Amy McCarty VP of ACS, Ron Schultz
President/COO of Convergys, Richard Munn Chairman and
Founder of ITSMA, Chris Brown VP of IBM Global
Services; and as a Board member of Sun/JavaSoft,
Information Technology Services Marketing Association
(ITSMA), and The Association for Services Management
International (AFSMI).
4
Acknowledgements
gents are wonderful individuals. I learned this
7
Chapter One
11
Chapter O - The Missing Link
1 Exceed III, LLC owns 26 patents, and has 9 additional pending, on Agent00 in the
US and Internationally, including but not limited to: i) pay for performance labor
management, ii) real time individual balanced scorecard, iii) real time individual
behavior-conditioning scorecard, iv) real time customer surveying, v) real time analytical
integration of performance and conditioning data, vi) real time, sensory-based data
presentment to a human, vii) SOA/SaaS/BI2.0 architecture for rapid deployment and
modification, viii) a complex performance optimization process.
13
Chapter O - The Missing Link
14
Chapter O - The Missing Link
through the turns and the traffic and then let them run
unrestrained at the right times—a pattern the two develop
together with repetition. I’ve started this book with this
principle because the energy that can be found within the
heart, internal drive and self-motivation of an agent is the
crown jewel of a contact center –much more so than its
efficiency tools. Once a contact center has learned how to
cultivate and harness this energy of the heart within its
agents, the rest falls into place and performance
optimization steadily and predictably rises to new heights.
1 Based upon recent production pilot results. See, Appendix: Proven Results page 120.
15
Chapter O - The Missing Link
16
Chapter O - The Missing Link
17
Chapter Two
you find those with heart, hire them, direct them –and then
open the gate and let them run. (*Hold this thought* I’ll
come back to it later.)
19
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
20
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
• Instruction
• Pre-set Goals
• PICs
• NICs
22
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
1. Instruction:
23
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
1
An “element” is a specific task within Agent00 that has further description
and definition hotlinked to it for agent training and instructional purposes.
24
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
2. Pre-Set Goals:
Volume:
1
A “dashboard” is the layout user interface of Agent00 and is made up of goals and
rewards. Dashboards are flexible and can be modified.
2 “Goals” are the focused tasks of an agent and are made up of elements.
25
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
26
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
27
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
a female agent, and this is her volume gauge thus far
through her day.
Agent00 analyzes
28
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
needs to know about volume –some unique to her; others
more big picture.
Her thoughts:
I gotta’ get out of alert 10:00 am
almost there …
29
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
I hafta’ keep pushing
1:00 pm
3:00 pm
4:00 pm
YEAH BABY!
one more
take another
I love it!
do another
30
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
This gives her a perfect understanding of how her
performance today and every day drives her own prosperity
–and the company’s prosperity and stability. This level of
awareness and company connection is a CEO’s dream.
31
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
This is the power of incorporating PICs into her
day. 100 years of behavioral science has proven that she
will reach for them everyday. This is how Agent00 helps
contact centers condition optimized behavior in their
agents.
32
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Customer satisfaction:
1 TIP: The number of questions asked, and the clarity of answers sought for can vary
as desired, according to response rate. Agent00 can be simplified or expanded as desired.
35
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Quality:
Expertise
A few years ago a relatively new Novell sales rep
picked me up at Logan International airport in Boston to
drive me out to a meeting with the CEO of a multibillion
dollar corporation. The new rep missed the proper exit off
the I-90 turnpike heading west. We went the wrong way for
thirty minutes before we were able to turn around. It was a
costly mistake. I missed my appointment with the CEO.
38
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Schedule:
Scheduling is a very important function in contact
centers. It is usually a complex process to do well because
of the hundreds or thousands of agents that need to cycle
seamlessly through three eight hour shifts every day,
assigned to different teams, with cross-trained skill sets.
Scheduling is like a tapestry made up of many intricate
threads.
1 A contact center should make computer based training programs available to agents
24/7 over the web.
39
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
40
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Peer Ratings
Agents most often work in teams. As such, team
mates are uniquely positioned to give daily appraisals of
one another’s level of performance quality on a daily basis.
The four questions an agent can be asked to answer about a
fellow teammate are as follows:
41
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
42
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Money
Respect
Awards
43
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Money
45
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
46
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
47
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
2008 Position after 20 years of status quo Trending in the next 2 years with
exceeds exceeds
margin margin
goals goals
underperforms underperforms
margin margin
goals goals
48
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
When she makes her quota and begins earning the company
its margin dollars, the company cup is right side up and full
of gold.
50
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
51
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Agent00’s
Daily Individual Agent Goals
$ 250.00
$ 200.00
margin for this $12/hr agent begins at
$ 150.00
$ 100.00
$ 50.00
$ 0.00
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40
Number of Calls
52
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
Awards
54
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
56
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
57
Chapter Two - Winning With “Heart”
58
Chapter Three
Is It Real? Is It Possible?
Is It Worth It?
60
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
61
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
62
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
Scientific solution
63
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
64
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
Is It Real?
1
“Over the past few years, software companies have struggled to keep the cost of
telephone-based tech support under control. Thousands of hours of consulting time,
conferences, and operations research have been spent on finding ways to deliver support
more efficiently, without cutting service quality to a level that might send customers to
the competition. So what has all this effort accomplished? Sadly, not much. Although
individual companies have fine tuned their phone-based support operations, overall
industry benchmarks for tech support performance have shown almost no
improvement.” --The Association of Support Professionals, Watertown, MA.
65
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
Is It Possible?
66
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
Is It Worth It?
67
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
COST % OF
DESCRIPTION
CATEGORY TOTAL
All agents and management
Labor & Benefits team members, benefits and 75%
training
All rent, utilities, maintenance,
Facility Costs property taxes and building 6%
services
Telecommunications Phone/data usage, including
5%
Costs monthly service fees
Transactional support from the
following areas: human
Support Costs resources, training, quality 5%
assurance, IT, telecom
and finance
Other Operating
Office supplies, postage, printing 1%
Costs
Monthly expense for assets, and
Depreciation &
cost of capital (interest) charges 8%
Interest
for purchased equipment
68
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
• Informed Agents
• Reduced Expenses
• Increased Revenues
69
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
70
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
72
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
2. Reduced expenses
Assumptions
73
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
1
The US Contact Center Operational Review: 2nd edition – 2008
http://www.contactbabel-downloads.com/USOR2008.pdf; “This year’s mean annual
attrition rate is an eye-watering 42%.”
74
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
The average
Group: Customer Relationship Management Strategies.
cost of recruiting and training a call center
representative is between $ 5,000 and $ 18,000.
BenchmarkPortal.com. For purposes herein, I will use a
common median estimate of $8,000 in the model.
75
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
45,000,000
44,500,000
44,000,000
43,500,000
DOLLARS
42,500,000
42,000,000
41,500,000
41,000,000
1 2 3 4 5
Labor $ w/o A00 44,614,920 44,614,920 44,614,920 44,614,920 44,614,920
Labor $ w/ A00 44,753,142 43,714,292 42,359,692 43,559,692 42,280,086
YEARS
77
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
60
50
40
NUMBER OF
Managers without
Managers w/A00
30
Team Leaders without
Team Leaders w/A00
20
10
-
1 2 3 4 5
Managers without 5 5 5 5 5
Managers w/A00 5 3 2 2 2
Team Leaders without 50 50 50 50 50
Team Leaders w/A00 50 33 22 20 20
YEAR
78
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
79
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
700
600
500
Senior Agents without
NUMBER OF
100
-
1 2 3 4 5
Senior Agents without 200 200 200 200 200
Senior Agents w/A00 200 225 300 275 275
Agent 2s without 500 500 500 500 500
Agent 2s w/A00 500 525 525 575 575
Agent 1s without 300 300 300 300 300
Agent 1s w/A00 300 250 175 150 150
YEAR
82
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
3. Increased Revenues
83
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
Added Assumptions…
• Senior Agents 24
• Agent 2s 22
• Agent 1s 18.
84
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
# of calls
tenure
agent
Agent 1s 18 x 1.22 = 22
Agent 2s 22 x 1.11 = 24
Sr. Agents 24
1 University of Calgary survey quoted in Meta Group Research Report entitled "Agent
Training Automation: More than One Queue" by Elizabeth Ussher. See also: High-
performing employees in operations roles are 40 percent more productive than their
average counterparts. McKinsey & Company "War for Talent, Part Two."
85
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
INCREASED NUMBER OF CALLS TAKEN
5,750,000
5,700,000
5,650,000
5,600,000
CALLS
5,500,000
5,450,000
5,400,000
1 2 3 4 5
Total Calls Taken w/o A00 5,514,000 5,514,000 5,514,000 5,514,000 5,514,000
Total Calls Taken w/ A00 5,546,550 5,670,150 5,709,300 5,709,300 5,709,300
YEAR
86
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
5,900,000
5,800,000
5,700,000
CALLS
5,500,000
5,400,000
5,300,000
1 2 3 4 5
Total calls taken w/o A00 5,514,000 5,514,000 5,514,000 5,514,000 5,514,000
Total calls taken w/ A00 +bc 5,605,059 5,754,663 5,819,817 5,845,821 5,871,825
YEAR
87
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
INCREASED REVENUES
91,000,000
90,000,000
89,000,000
88,000,000
DOLLARS
87,000,000
Total Call Revnue w/o A00
Total Call Revenue w/ A00
86,000,000
85,000,000
84,000,000
83,000,000
82,000,000
1 2 3 4 5
Total Call Revnue w/o A00 84,805,320 84,805,320 84,805,320 84,805,320 84,805,320
Total Call Revenue w/ A00 86,205,807 88,506,717 89,508,785 89,908,727 90,308,669
YEAR
88
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
89
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
1 Revenue increase is a result of i) more capacity per agent because of a more veteran
mix of agents and ii) bonus calls taken above margin goals.
90
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
91
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
93
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
1 Telemanagement Search and F.A.C./Equities both report that there are in excess of
7,000,000 contact center agents in the U.S. alone – growing at a CAGR of 20% per year.
Ovum reports there are nearly 14,000,000 contact center seats worldwide.
2 Next Generation Web Metrics, Claes Fornell and Larry Freed
94
Chapter Three – Is It Real? Is It Possible? Is It Worth It?
Objective Performance
Evaluations
97
Chapter Four - Objective Performance Evaluations
99
Chapter Four - Objective Performance Evaluations
PRODUCTIVITY LOSS
100,000,000
90,000,000
80,000,000
70,000,000
60,000,000
DOLLARS
Total Revenue
50,000,000 Impaired Ttl Rev 2-wks / 33% agents
Ttl Rev Loss at 12% / 2-wks / 33% agents
40,000,000
30,000,000
20,000,000
10,000,000
-
1 2 3 4 5
Total Revenue 86,205,807 88,506,717 89,508,785 89,908,727 90,308,669
Impaired Ttl Rev 2-wks / 33% 85,773,777 87,916,672 88,912,060 89,309,335 89,706,611
agents
Ttl Rev Loss at 12% / 2-wks / 432,030 590,045 596,725 599,392 602,058
33% agents
YEAR
100
Chapter Four - Objective Performance Evaluations
1 18 hours per quarter per agent multiplied by 1,000 agents amounts to 18,000 hours per
quarter spent on performance evaluations by team leaders or managers. Translated into
man-hours per team leader (18k ÷ 2080 hours per FTE), traditional subjective
performance evaluations require nine team leaders to conduct. This is equal to about
$660k per year based on the ASP salary survey, or $3.3M over five years.
2 Seven Secrets of Minimizing Agent Turnover, BenchmarkPortal.com
3 Jim Hatch, a partner at PricewaterhouseCoopers and co-author of Delivering on the
Promise: How to Attract, Manage, and Retain Human Capital.
101
Chapter Four - Objective Performance Evaluations
102
Chapter Four - Objective Performance Evaluations
“If you have the right [agents], you don't need to worry
about motivating them. The right [agents] are self-
motivated: Nothing beats being a part of a team that is
expected to produce great results … the single biggest
constraint on the success of my organization is the ability
to get and to hang on to enough of the right [agents].” 1
1 Jim Collins, Good to Great: Why Some Companies Make the Leap... and Others
Don't (inserts added –“employees” changed to “agents” for purposes herein)
103
Chapter Five
1 "C.P. Snow's Two Cultures: Hardware and Software, Discovery and Creation" by
MIT research scientist Dan Dewey (July 1999). The American Heritage Dictionary;
Usage Note: The application of the term culture to the collective attitudes and behavior
of corporations arose in business jargon during the late 1980s and early 1990s. Over 80
percent of Usage Panelists accept the sentence The new management style is a reversal of
GE's traditional corporate culture, in which virtually everything the company does is
measured in some form and filed away somewhere.
2 Impact Learning Systems International, 2004
108
Chapter Five - High Morale Culture
109
Chapter Five - High Morale Culture
1 Southwest is the only airline that has made money every year since 1973, with stock
value up more than 500% since 1990. An investment of $1000 in Southwest stock in
1973 would be worth over $1.8 million today. Southwest's stock trades at about 20 times
on earnings, double the industry standard, and Wall Street Investor Peter Lynch says
"Southwest's (stock) performance has yet to be outdone." Its net profit margins averaged
over 5%, the highest in the industry, since 1991. Foundation for Enterprise Development
/ Beyster Institute, Washington D.C. 20006
110
Chapter Five - High Morale Culture
111
Chapter Five - High Morale Culture
1
Bandura, 1969
112
Chapter Six
A SaaS/BI2.0 Application
114
Chapter Six - A SaaS/BI Application
-E x a m p l e d a t a s o u r c e s i n a c o n t a c t c e n t e r -
115
Chapter Six - A SaaS/BI Application
117
Chapter Six - A SaaS/BI Application
Epilogue
118
Chapter Six - A SaaS/BI Application
119
Appendix
Value Table
Agent00 does more than just save money and
increase revenues, but clearly these are key elements
of a thriving contact center. So, for your convenience,
I have created this easy index table to provide you with
a consolidated look at the productivity gains outlined
in this book, associated with the 1,000-agent case
study.
Proven Results
Beginning in Q1 2006 Agent00 was installed in
its first production operation within a global manufac-
turing company’s centralized helpdesk operation.
Thereafter, Agent00 has been used in various contact
centers.
121