1

Under the Optic of a Bourgeois Revolution:

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%


)

/ .
?
Benedict Anderson
()

The Notion of Bourgeois Revolution Perry Anderson . New Left Review
English Questions (1992)

..
()
( )

(
)
vs.
- vs. -


%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Perry Anderson
Perry
:
- /
.. , , , , ,
/
-
( , , ,
)

-
, ,

-
(, ) (populism

)
(


.....)
- vs.

,



:
=
() =

-


/
.. ( ...
among others)
Hugh Trevor-Roper Christopher Hill,
Alfred Cobban, Francois Furet, Denis Richet Albert Soboul

)
( vs.
) (, )
Perry Anderson
()

:
)
(
)

(
) -
(the overdetermination of bourgeois revolution from above)

vs.

vs.

- (the overdetermination of
bourgeois revolution from below)
)


)
) )



- (the
overdetermination of bourgeois revolution from within)
)


-
(the overdetermination of bourgeois revolution from without)
) )
)
)

()

)
..
(
)

) (
)
) ..
/ (model)
)
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

(judicial rule)


/

()

Perry Anderson The Notion of Bourgeois Revolution (

.. )



Perry
()

) -
(
) :-
-
-

)

(
) : -

-

,
, -

- (Rvolution den haut
Rvolution den bas)
(i.e.
)
(, )

- ,
-

10

:
- ()
?
-
?
- ()
?