Professional Documents
Culture Documents
17
REPORT FORMAT FOR WEIGHT CONTROL OF OFFSHORE STRUCTURES by Stein Bjrhovde BAS Engineering AS / ShipWeight
For Presentation at the 71st Annual Conference of Society of Allied Weight Engineers, Inc. Bad Ggging and Manching Bavaria, Germany 05-10, May, 2012
Permission to publish this paper, in full or in part, with credit to the author and the Society may be obtained, by request, to: Society of Allied Weight Engineers, Inc. P.O. Box 60024, Terminal Annex Los Angeles, CA 90060
The Society is not responsible for statements or opinions in papers or discussions at the meeting. This paper meets all regulations for public information disclosure under ITAR and EAR
PAPER No : 3483
Table of Contents
Table of Contents.......................................................................................................................................................... ii Table of Figures ........................................................................................................................................................... iii Abstract..........................................................................................................................................................................1 Background....................................................................................................................................................................2 The goal of this Paper ....................................................................................................................................................2 ISO 19901-5: Weight control during engineering and construction ..............................................................................2 Statoil requirement TR2352: Weight control requirements for topsides and substructures ..........................................2 Identification (key) and description fields .................................................................................................................3 Unique identification of items ............................................................................................................................... 3 Topics for further discussion and consideration ....................................................................................................3 Quantity, weight and co-ordinate fields .....................................................................................................................3 Net weight vs. gross weight ...................................................................................................................................4 Content and co-ordinates .......................................................................................................................................4 Local coordinates ...................................................................................................................................................4 Topics for further discussion and consideration ....................................................................................................4 Information fields ...................................................................................................................................................... 4 Additional fields needed to comply to ISO standard ............................................................................................. 5 Topics for further discussion and consideration ....................................................................................................5 Weight report content ....................................................................................................................................................6 Layout of printouts and tables ...................................................................................................................................7 1. Introduction ....................................................................................................................................................... 7 1.1 Major assemblies..........................................................................................................................................7 1.2 Cut-off date ...................................................................................................................................................... 7 1.3 Weight information provided by others ...........................................................................................................7 1.4 List of reported loading conditions ..................................................................................................................8 2.1 Main summary .................................................................................................................................................9 2.2 Weight and load budget (WLB) ..................................................................................................................... 10 2.3 Global CoG plot................................................................................................................................................. 10 2.4 Main variations from the previous report .......................................................................................................... 11 2.5 Weight forecast .................................................................................................................................................. 12 2.5.1 General............................................................................................................................................................ 12 2.5.2 Main trend graphs ........................................................................................................................................... 13 2.6 Main weight printout summaries by area and discipline ................................................................................... 14 2.7 As built / weighing data ..................................................................................................................................... 15 3.1 Variation from last report by area and discipline ............................................................................................... 16 3.2 Trend graphs by area ......................................................................................................................................... 17 3.3 CoG plots ........................................................................................................................................................... 18
PAPER No : 3483
3.4 Area weight printouts ........................................................................................................................................ 19 5.1 Assumptions ...................................................................................................................................................... 20 5.1.1 General assumptions ....................................................................................................................................... 20 5.1.2 Discipline assumptions ................................................................................................................................... 20 5.2.1 Global origin ................................................................................................................................................... 21 5.2.2 Area designations............................................................................................................................................ 22 5.3 Weight allowance and contingency ................................................................................................................... 23 5.4 Report codes ...................................................................................................................................................... 23 5.4.1 Weight installation codes ................................................................................................................................ 23 5.4.2 Weight phase codes ........................................................................................................................................ 24 5.4.3 Weight status codes ........................................................................................................................................ 24 5.4.4 Area codes ...................................................................................................................................................... 24 Automatic generated weight reports ............................................................................................................................ 25 Background .............................................................................................................................................................. 25 Requirements ........................................................................................................................................................... 25 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................................... 25 Terms and definitions .................................................................................................................................................. 26 Appendix 1: Examples of Main Summary tables from various Weight Reports. ........................................................ 27 Example 1: Jacket topside ....................................................................................................................................... 27 Example 2: FPSO topside ........................................................................................................................................ 28 Example 3: Jacket topside ....................................................................................................................................... 28 Example 4: Semi-submersible total platform .......................................................................................................... 29 Example 5: FPSO topside and vessel ...................................................................................................................... 30 Appendix 2: Example of chapter mapping between ISO standard chapters and weight reports from past projects .... 31
Table of Figures
Figure 1: Major Assemblies printout ............................................................................................................................. 7 Figure 2: Loading Conditions printout .......................................................................................................................... 8 Figure 3: Main Summary printout .................................................................................................................................9 Figure 4: Weight and Load Budget printout ................................................................................................................ 10 Figure 5: Global CoG printout ..................................................................................................................................... 10 Figure 6: Main Variations printout .............................................................................................................................. 11 Figure 7: Weight Forecast printout .............................................................................................................................. 12 Figure 8: Main Trend Graphs printout ......................................................................................................................... 13 Figure 9: Area & Discipline Summary printout .......................................................................................................... 14 Figure 10: As-built / Weighing Data printout .............................................................................................................. 15
PAPER No : 3483
Figure 11: Variation from Last Report by Area & Discipline printout ........................................................................ 16 Figure 12: Trend Graphs by Area printout .................................................................................................................. 17 Figure 13: CoG Plots printout...................................................................................................................................... 18 Figure 14: Area Weight printout .................................................................................................................................. 19 Figure 15: Discipline Assumptions printout ................................................................................................................ 20 Figure 16: Global Origin printout ................................................................................................................................ 21 Figure 17: Area Designations printout......................................................................................................................... 22 Figure 18: Weight Allowance and Contingency printout ............................................................................................ 23 Figure 19: Weight Installation Codes printout............................................................................................................. 23 Figure 20: Weight Phase Codes printout ..................................................................................................................... 24 Figure 21: Weight Status Codes printout ..................................................................................................................... 24 Figure 22: Area Codes printout ................................................................................................................................... 24
PAPER No : 3483
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to suggest standard layouts for printouts to be included in the weight report for engineering and construction of offshore structures. The proposals are based on a systematic review of weight reports for existing oil platforms built for the North Sea and Gulf of Mexico during the last 10 year. The content of these weight reports are systemized according to the ISO standard for weight control, as well as the Statoil requirement for weight control. Requirements for weight control of offshore structures are described in the ISO standard 19901-5 Petroleum and natural gas industries Specific requirements for offshore structures Part 5: Weight control during engineering and construction. This document includes definitions, weight control classes, weight- and load budgets, weight reporting, requirements for suppliers, requirements for weighing in addition to various appendixes. In this paper we will focus on chapter 6.3 Requirements to the weight report. The content of existing weight reports are systemized and mapped to the defined chapters (printouts/tables) that are required according to the ISO standard. The Norwegian energy company Statoil has a technical requirement for weight control titled TR2352 Weight control requirements for topside and substructures. This document specifies among others which data fields the weight database should include as a minimum. One of the results of this paper is an overview of which data fields are included in the various weight report chapters required by the ISO standard. This paper can serve as a specification of the data fields and printouts that should be included in a weight control system for offshore structures to fulfill the requirements of the ISO-19901-5. The layouts of the printouts are in focus. In this paper it is also discussed whether its realistic to desig n a weight control system that automatically or semi-automatically produces the weight reports. Stein Bjrhovde is one of the founders and head of development of BAS Engineering. Mr. Bjrhovde has a Master of Science Degree in Ship Design, and has been developing the weight engineering software ShipWeight since 1993. He has also been involved in development of other weight control software, in addition to being a consultant doing weight estimation and monitoring in the offshore industry. He has more than 15 years experience in weight estimation of new ship designs for several Norwegian and international ship designers and yards.
PAPER No : 3483
Background
A weight report for offshore structures is typically released every second month during the engineering and construction period. A large offshore project can take years to complete and the numbers of revision of the weight report can be significant. The amount of work put in to preparing these weight reports is therefore also quit significant, and it might be that more standardization can reduce time consumption and increase quality both when it comes to reliability of the figures, but also in terms of readability. In the Norwegian offshore industry the content of a weight report has been quite standardized due to Norwegian Standards (NS 2128 NS2131 from 1994) that have been around for a long time, and oil companies having similar requirements. But even though the overall content has been standardized, the order and format of the figures, tables and text can differ quit a lot. And when the industry has become more internationalized over the years, the demand of standardization is even higher. A key document when it comes to standardization is the ISO standard for weight control for offshore structures during engineering and construction from 2003. In addition to this standard the oil companies will have separate requirements when it comes to weight control and reporting. A standardized format for a weight control report must be based on these two requirement sources.
Statoil requirement TR2352: Weight control requirements for topsides and substructures
The Norwegian energy company Statoil has a technical requirement for weight control titled TR2352 Weight control requirements for topside and substructures. This requirement document cover new building projects in the engineering and construction phase. The technical requirement TR1244 Technical requirements for cost estimate classes offshore projects with appendixes A1-4 covers Pre-Feed and modification projects. The TR1244 document refers to the ISO standard 19901-5 both in general and when it comes to more specific topics. TR1244 requires that weight control is performed according to class A.
PAPER No : 3483
The TR2352 document specifies among others which data fields the weight database should include as a minimum for each weight record. These fields are described and discussed in the following chapters.
Equipment
For equipment items both drawing and piece numbers must be identical to the tag number for the weight carrying item (skid). But the use of both drawing number and piece number it not logical to identify equipment items because the tag number is unique by itself and the res not necessarily one specific drawing describing an equipment skid.
PAPER No : 3483
Co-ordinates: The co-ordinates in the platform north direction, the platform east direction and Elevation.
Local coordinates
Local co-ordinates for equipment skids are specified by the supplier on a weight datasheet. The global coordinate for the skid will refer to the origin of the item, often located in the southwest corner of the support structure. If there are only one set of co-ordinates in the item database, these will refer to total co-ordinates which are global- plus local co-ordinates. But if the equipment arrangement is relocated, orientation is changed or local coordinates are updated on new revisions of weight datasheet (e.g. du to weighing), it will be difficult to enter new total co-ordinates without referring backup information. It should therefore be considered whether the weight record should contain fields for both local and global co-ordinates and whether total co-ordinates also should be stored.
Information fields
Originator code: The originator code according to the Engineering Numbering System (ENS) of the organization or contractor who have calculated or revised the weight data for a piece number. Discipline code: The discipline code according to the ENS. System code: The system code according to the ENS. Area code: The area code according to the ENS. Drawing revision: The revision of the drawing from which the weight has been identified or calculated.
PAPER No : 3483
Weight status code: A coding to identify the level of accuracy of the weight data of each piece number. See sub-section 2.4.2 of this document. Weight installation code: A coding to identify whether a piece is installed or not on a module/installation. The Physical Breakdown Structure (PBS): A hierarchical structure which defines the physical/functional component of a project. For all projects at the Norwegian Continental Shelf (NCS) the PBS shall be used at level four in accordance with NORSOK Z-014. For other projects the NORSOK Z-014 is a recommended guideline. Code of Resources (COR): A hierarchical structure which defines project resources. For all projects at the Norwegian Continental Shelf (NCS) the COR shall be used at level three in accordance with NORSOK Z-014. For other projects the NORSOK Z-014 is a recommended guideline. Package number: The procurement package number. Compensation code: Contract Appendix B compensation cost item code at lowest level (for modification projects).
Lift code
One of the chapters that are considered optional according to the ISO standard is lifting reports. A field for Lifting code is not listed in TR2352 and should therefore be considered. Especially because Statoil in chapter 5.1 of TR 2352 list lift report as one of the minimum required topics included in weight reports. Lift code is neither included in specifications for Master Equipment list or Material Take-off list in Statoil requirement TR1244 covering weight reporting for modification and early phase projects.
Displacement code
For floaters it is required to report lightship weight (ref. ISO 19901-5, ch. 6.3.2.1). Lightship is normally complete dry weight included content from some systems. It will therefore be necessary to identify all items included in the lightship weight (LW) with a specific code. All other items should be either deadweight or temporary. This is also an argument for keeping content in separate records, ref. previous discussion.
PAPER No : 3483
2.
3.
4.
5.
A systematic review of a number of weight report from North Sea and Gulf of Mexico for the last 10-15 years has given us a good overview of how the content of these report comply with the topics specified in
PAPER No : 3483
the ISO standard. An overview of mapping between ISO standard chapters and chapter numbering in weight reports from some past offshore projects can be seen in Appendix 2. In general terms it can be said that the content of the weight reports corresponds good with what the ISO standard describes as necessary content for a weight report, but the order of how this content appears in the reports and the actual layouts and formats varies a lot. The ISO standard forms a template of how the chapters of a weight report can be organized.
1. Introduction
All weight reports shall have an introduction giving information necessary to understand the content of and background to the report. ISO 19901-5: 2003
PAPER No : 3483
Title Description Transport to offshore field Weight of lifting slings and spreader bars etc. are included Lift at offshore field Weight of lifting slings and spreader bars etc. are NOT included. Offshore dry installed Future operating installed (max load)
PAPER No : 3483
LC50 - Transport to offshore field WEIGHT Last month Variation This month Budget Margin CoG East Last month Variation This month C00 - Deckbox 10 250 30 10 280 10400 120 C00 - Deckbox 331,600 0,400 332,000 L00 - Living quarter 1 315 5 1 320 1400 80 L00 - Living quarter 277,200 -0,200 277,000 U00 - Utility modules 4 270 -20 4 250 4400 150 U00 - Utility modules 303,800 0,200 304,000 P00 - Process modules 1 720 30 1 750 1900 150 P00 - Process modules 328,100 -0,100 328,000 D00 - Drilling modules 6 450 0 6 450 6250 -200 D00 - Drilling modules 372,200 -0,200 372,000 F00 - Flare 235 5 240 250 10 F00 - Flare 390,700 0,300 391,000 T00 - Topside 24 240 50 24 290 24600 310 T00 - Topside 334,880 0,149 335,028 COMMENTS: CoG North Last month Variation This month This report shows an increase in the reported dry weight of 50 tonnes since last C00 - Deckbox 119,600 -0,100 119,500 report. The margins are 310 tonnes. L00 - Living quarter 120,300 0,100 120,400 U00 - Utility modules 121,100 0,100 121,200 The margins for CoG East are negative by 2,417 meters. P00 - Process modules 119,000 -0,500 118,500 D00 - Drilling modules 121,400 -0,200 121,200 The margins for CoG North are negative by 0,233 meters. F00 - Flare 120,500 -0,300 120,200 T00 - Topside 120,347 -0,115 120,233 CoG Elev. Last month Variation This month C00 - Deckbox 508,300 0,200 508,500 L00 - Living quarter 535,600 -0,100 535,500 U00 - Utility modules 528,200 0,800 529,000 P00 - Process modules 530,200 1,300 531,500 D00 - Drilling modules 527,000 1,200 528,200 F00 - Flare 528,800 -0,300 528,500 T00 - Topside 520,015 0,625 520,640 LC60 - Lift at offshore field WEIGHT Last month Variation This month Budget Margin CoG East Last month Variation This month C00 - Deckbox 10 100 30 10 130 10250 120 C00 - Deckbox 331,600 0,400 332,000 L00 - Living quarter 965 5 970 1050 80 L00 - Living quarter 277,200 -0,200 277,000 U00 - Utility modules 4 170 -20 4 150 4300 150 U00 - Utility modules 303,800 0,200 304,000 P00 - Process modules 1 670 30 1 700 1850 150 P00 - Process modules 328,100 -0,100 328,000 D00 - Drilling modules 6 300 0 6 300 6100 -200 D00 - Drilling modules 372,200 -0,200 372,000 F00 - Flare 185 5 190 200 10 F00 - Flare 390,700 0,300 391,000 T00 - Topside 23 390 50 23 440 23750 310 T00 - Topside 335,552 0,153 335,706 COMMENTS: CoG North Last month Variation This month This report shows an increase in the reported dry weight of 50 tonnes since last C00 - Deckbox 119,600 -0,100 119,500 report. The margins are 310 tonnes. L00 - Living quarter 120,300 0,100 120,400 U00 - Utility modules 121,100 0,100 121,200 The margins for CoG East are negative by 2,527 meters. P00 - Process modules 119,000 -0,500 118,500 D00 - Drilling modules 121,400 -0,200 121,200 The margins for CoG North are negative by 0,228 meters. F00 - Flare 120,500 -0,300 120,200 T00 - Topside 120,345 -0,117 120,228 CoG Elev. Last month Variation This month C00 - Deckbox 508,300 0,200 508,500 L00 - Living quarter 535,600 -0,100 535,500 U00 - Utility modules 528,200 0,800 529,000 P00 - Process modules 530,200 1,300 531,500 D00 - Drilling modules 527,000 1,200 528,200 F00 - Flare 528,800 -0,300 528,500 T00 - Topside 519,737 0,635 520,372
Budget 330,000 280,000 300,000 330,000 370,000 395,000 332,612 Budget 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 Budget 510,000 540,000 527,000 530,000 527,000 530,000 520,815
Margin -2,000 3,000 -4,000 2,000 -2,000 4,000 -2,417 Margin 0,500 -0,400 -1,200 1,500 -1,200 -0,200 -0,233 Margin 1,500 4,500 -2,000 -1,500 -1,200 1,500 0,175
Budget 330,000 280,000 300,000 330,000 370,000 395,000 333,179 Budget 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 120,000 Budget 510,000 540,000 527,000 530,000 527,000 530,000 520,497
Margin -2,000 3,000 -4,000 2,000 -2,000 4,000 -2,527 Margin 0,500 -0,400 -1,200 1,500 -1,200 -0,200 -0,228 Margin 1,500 4,500 -2,000 -1,500 -1,200 1,500 0,125
PAPER No : 3483
LC70 - Offshore dry installed Area C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 Description Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside Rep.dry wgt. 9 880 920 3 850 1 650 6 200 190 22 690 Budget Margin 10 000 120 1 000 80 4 000 150 1 800 150 6 000 -200 200 10 23 000 310 Change Order 65 5 35 5 75 0 185 Inital Company Budget Reserves 9 935 199 995 20 3 965 79 1 795 36 5 925 119 200 4 22 815 456 Future 2 866 -15 956 969 1 957 -4 6 729 Not to Exceed 13 000 1 000 5 000 2 800 8 000 200 30 000
Horizontal envelope
North
120,5 521,0 Budget
Vertical envelope
Envelope
Budget
01F East
120,0 333,0 02F
520,0
01F
02F
334,0
335,0
336,0
337,0
03F 04F
05F
519,0
East
03F 04F
05F
06F 119,5
518,0 333,0
334,0
335,0
336,0
337,0
06F
CoG East CoG North CoG Elev. 333,609 120,000 520,435 333,500 119,800 518,200 333,800 120,100 518,900 334,500 120,200 519,200 335,600 120,300 519,450 336,000 120,342 519,661 336,152 120,223 520,296
PAPER No : 3483
LC70 - Offshore dry installed Area Type Discipline C00 Equipment Bulk Electrical Safety Instrument Architect Piping Surface protection Structural Outfitting structure Total D00 Equipment See drilling wgt.rep. Bulk See drilling wgt.rep. Structural See drilling wgt.rep.
Change Temp containers and equipment Cables updated Passive fireprotection components and cables Coating and insulation Pipe support updated New takeoff on paint Outfitting updated from As built drawings, temp located hookup material
Rep.wgt. 5 6 2 1 2 6 1 7 30 0 0 0 0
Total F00 Equipment Bulk Structural No changes Minor adjustements Minor adjustements
Total L00 Equipment Bulk Telecom Structural No changes Temporares for hookup phase Reinforcement due to transport
0 2 3 5 0 -2 7 5 5 -40 5 10 -20 5 10 5 10 30 50
Total U00 Equipment Bulk Piping Surface protection Structural Temp. containers and equipment Temporaires for hookup phase New take-off Temp. located hookup material
Total P00 Equipment Bulk Piping Surface protection Structural New weight certificate Pipe support updated New take-off Temp. located hookup material
PAPER No : 3483
LC70 - Offshore dry installed VOR status APP PEN Company reserve Wgt. impact impact 15 15 45 27 1 3 91 54 14 68 45
Area C00
Type Discipline Equipment Bulk Electrical Safety Instrument Architect Piping Surface protection Structural Outfitting structure
Description Frequency control HVAC motors Upgraded MOB boat system New walls New walls MOB boat system
PEN
Total D00 Equipment Bulk Structural Replacement of crane arrangement Replacement of crane arrangement
3 63
0 0 2 2 15 3 1 2 21 86
Helideck surface
PEN
4 4
Total P00 Equipment Bulk Piping Instrument Structural Outfitting structure Increased size of test separator Test separator Test separator Test separator PEN PEN PEN PEN
15 3 1 2 21 184
PAPER No : 3483
30 000
28 000
Not to exceed
Rep. wgt.
26 000
Company budget
Contractor budget Rep.dry.wgt
24 000
22 000
20 000
Revision Date Not to exceed Future Company budget Company reserves Change Order Contractor budget Margin Rep.dry.wgt
01F 02F 03F 04F 05F 06F 01.07.2011 01.09.2011 01.11.2011 01.01.2012 01.03.2012 01.05.2012 30 000 30 000 30 000 30 000 30 000 30 000 6 729 6 729 6 729 6 729 6 729 6 729 23 271 23 271 23 271 23 271 23 271 23 271 271 221 191 126 86 86 0 50 80 145 185 185 23 000 23 050 23 080 23 145 23 185 23 185 1 500 1 315 1 035 930 725 495 21 500 21 735 22 045 22 215 22 460 22 690
PAPER No : 3483
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside 335,028 120,233 520,640
33 15 60 30 55 0 193 3,1 %
365 1 25 40 55 0 486
80 5 35 15 60 1 196 3,1 %
10 20 15 5 0 0 50 0,8 %
EQUIP.
Total Electrical Safety HVAC Inst.
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside 335,028 120,233 520,640
30 10 55 30 50 0 175 2,9 %
350 1 25 40 50 0 466
80 4 30 15 60 1 190 3,1 %
10 15 15 5 0 0 45 0,7 %
EQUIP.
Total Electrical Safety HVAC Inst.
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside 335,028 120,233 520,640
30 10 50 30 50 0 170 2,9 %
340 1 20 40 50 0 451
80 4 30 15 60 1 190 3,3 %
10 14 10 5 0 0 39 0,7 %
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside 335,028 120,233 520,640
30 10 60 30 50 0 180 2,7 %
430 1 25 40 50 0 546
80 4 30 15 60 1 190 2,9 %
10 14 15 5 0 0 44 0,7 %
PAPER No : 3483
Comment
Implemented in database
515,345
540,812
528,800
508.3
PAPER No : 3483
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside 0,149 -0,115 0,625
5 5 5
1 -2
15 50,0 % Eq./Tot.
6 -50,0 %
2 -16,7 %
0 0,0 %
1 -8,3 %
-2 16,7 %
7 7 10 3
17
7 7 10 3 0 0 27
30 5 -25 18 0 2 30
EQUIP.
Total Electrical Safety HVAC Inst.
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside 0,153 -0,117 0,635
5 5 5
1 -2
15 50,0 % Eq./Tot.
6 -50,0 %
2 -16,7 %
0 0,0 %
1 -8,3 %
-2 16,7 %
7 7 10 3
17
7 7 10 3 0 0 27
30 5 -25 18 0 2 30
EQUIP.
Total Electrical Safety HVAC Inst.
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside -2,543 -0,119 -0,636
5 5 5
1 -2
15 50,0 % Eq./Tot.
6 -50,0 %
2 -16,7 %
0 0,0 %
1 -8,3 %
-2 16,7 %
7 7 10 3
17
7 7 10 3 0 0 27
30 5 -25 18 0 2 30
BULK
Architect. Piping Surf.prot. Telecom Total Primary struct.
STRUCTURAL
Second. struct. Outf. struc. Total
TOTAL
Rep. wgt.
C00 L00 U00 P00 D00 F00 T00 CoG East CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside 0,145 -0,128 0,658
5 5 5
1 -2
15 50,0 % Eq./Tot.
6 -50,0 %
2 -16,7 %
0 0,0 %
1 -8,3 %
-2 16,7 %
7 7 10 3
17
7 7 10 3 0 0 27
30 5 -25 18 0 2 30
Figure 11: Variation from Last Report by Area & Discipline printout
PAPER No : 3483
C00 - Deckbox
13 500
13 000 12 500 12 000
Rep. wgt.
Not to exceed
11 500
11 000 10 500 10 000
Company budget
9 500
9 000
Revision Date Not to exceed Future Company budget Company reserves Change Order Contractor budget Margin Rep.dry.wgt
01F 02F 03F 04F 05F 06F 01.07.2011 01.09.2011 01.11.2011 01.01.2012 01.03.2012 01.05.2012 13 000 13 000 13 000 13 000 13 000 13 000 2 734 2 734 2 734 2 734 2 734 2 734 10 266 10 266 10 266 10 266 10 266 10 266 331 319 308 285 266 201 0 12 23 46 65 65 9 935 9 947 9 958 9 981 10 000 10 000 435 317 148 196 150 120 9 500 9 630 9 810 9 785 9 850 9 880
PAPER No : 3483
C00 - Deckbox
LC70 - Offshore dry installed
120,5
511,0 Budget
510,0
Envelope
Horizontal envelope
North
Vertical envelope
Budget
01F
120,0
01F
02F
119,5 East 03F 04F
509,0
508,0 East
02F 03F
04F
05F
06F
05F
06F
119,0 329,0
330,0
331,0
332,0
333,0
507,0 329,0
330,0
331,0
332,0
333,0
CoG East CoG North CoG Elev. 330,000 120,000 510,000 329,600 119,500 508,050 329,600 119,900 508,140 330,450 120,320 508,420 330,830 119,830 508,380 331,600 119,600 508,300 332,000 119,500 508,500
PAPER No : 3483
THIS PERIOD
Allowance/ Contingency
LAST PERIOD
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dry wgt. Rep. dev.
BUDGET
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dev. CoG East
COORDINATES
CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside
30 5 -20 30 0 5 50
THIS PERIOD
Allowance/ Contingency
LAST PERIOD
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dry wgt. Rep. dev.
BUDGET
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dev. CoG East
COORDINATES
CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside
30 5 -20 30 0 5 50
THIS PERIOD
Allowance/ Contingency
LAST PERIOD
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dry wgt. Rep. dev.
BUDGET
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dev. CoG East
COORDINATES
CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside
30 5 -20 30 0 5 50
LC90 - Future operation installed (max load) Area Description THIS PERIOD
Net.dry. wgt.
Allowance/ Contingency
LAST PERIOD
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dry wgt. Rep. dev.
BUDGET
Rep.dry wgt. Rep.dev. CoG East
COORDINATES
CoG North CoG Elev.
Deckbox Living quarter Utility modules Process modules Drilling modules Flare Topside
30 5 -20 30 0 5 50
PAPER No : 3483
5.1 Assumptions
The assumptions for the report shall be split into two main sections, one for general assumptions and one for discipline asssumptions. ISO 19901-5: 2003
PAPER No : 3483
OIL COMPANY XX-XX-XX-XXX-XXXXX Weight Control Report GLOBAL ORIGIN & MAIN AREA CODES
PAPER No : 3483
PAPER No : 3483
OIL COMPANY XX-XX-XX-XXX-XXXXX Weight Control Report WEIGHT ALLOWANCES AND CONTINGENCIES
BULK (B)
B2 B3 B4 B5 E0 E1
EQUIPMENT (E)
E2 E3 E4 E5
E F H I L M O P R SA SB SC T X
Electrical Safety HVAC Instrument Architect Mechanical Marine Piping Surf. prot. Piping Struct.primary Struct.second. Struct.outfitting Multi disc.
0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0
10,0 10,0 10,0 10,0 10,0 10,0 10,0 10,0 10,0 10,0 7,0 10,0 10,0 10,0
5,0 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,0 5,0 4,0 5,0 5,0 5,0
3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 3,0 2,0 3,0 3,0 3,0
2,0 2,0 2,0 2,0 2,0 2,0 2,0 2,0 2,0 2,0 1,0 2,0 2,0 2,0
0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0
0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 0,0 -
0,0
PAPER No : 3483
Description Estimate based upon historical data from other projects. Weight take-off from drawings and 3D-models issued in Front end engineering design (FEED). Weight take-off from drawings and 3D-models issued in the Project execution Weight take-off from drawings and 3D-models issued in the Project execution period after inter discipline check (IDC). Weight take-off from drawings approved for construction and as-built. Weighed weights. Estimate based upon historical data from other projects. Estimate based upon concept specific preliminary process data. Estimate based upon information from equipment data sheets. Weight data as supplied by vendor. Confirmed weight data from vendor based on fabrication drawings and catalogue data for standard equipment. Weighed weights.
PAPER No : 3483
Requirements
Automatic generated weight reports can only be possible if all necessary information is present in the weight database. One of the goals of this paper was to get an overview of how much of the information of weight reports that can be presented as printouts / tables from the system and how much must be produced manually. Until now we have not found any information that cannot be systemized and stored in the weight database. On the contrary, systemizing all information of a weight report would be of great benefit because that makes it possible to quickly search up all related information from previous projects. But there is no doubt that it would be significant amount of work to define all the queries and formats thats necessary to produce weight reports with proper layout. It is therefore of vital importance that the content and layout of the weight report are standardized.
Conclusion
There is good correlation between the ISO standard for weight control, ISO 19901-5, and the Statoil weight control requirement, TR2352, when it comes to weight reporting. The Statoil requirement document focus on which data fields should be included in the database, while the ISO standard is specific when it comes to what information should be included in the various sessions of a weight report. While most reviewed past weight reports includes all the information required by the ISO standard, the order of this information is presented in the reports, and the formatting of printouts and tables are varying a lot. It should be considered to extend the ISO standard 19901-5 with an appendix specifying contents and formats for printouts and tables due to the requirements specified in chapter 6.3 of the standard. A report format specification would also make it possible to automatic generate weight reports from the weight control system. But without this standard specification, it will probably be too much work implementing different format templates customized to the oil companies different requirements and practice.
PAPER No : 3483
PAPER No : 3483
PAPER No : 3483
PAPER No : 3483
PAPER No : 3483
PAPER No : 3483
Appendix 2: Example of chapter mapping between ISO standard chapters and weight reports from past projects
ISO ch. 6.3.1 6.3.1a 6.3.1b 6.3.1c 6.3.1d 6.3.1e 6.3.2 6.3.2.1 6.3.2.2 6.3.2.3 6.3.2.4 6.3.2.5 6.3.2.5.1 6.3.2.5.1a 6.3.2.5.1b 6.3.2.5.1c 6.3.2.5.2 6.3.2.6 6.3.2.7 6.3.3 6.3.3.1 6.3.3.2 6.3.3.3 6.3.3.4 6.3.4 6.3.4.1 6.3.4.2 6.3.4.3 6.3.5 6.3.5.1 6.3.5.1a 6.3.5.1b 6.3.5.2 6.3.5.3 6.3.5.4 6.3.5.4a 6.3.5.4b 6.3.5.4c 6.3.5.4d 6.3.5.5 6.3.5.6 Chapter 1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 2 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5 2.5.1 2.5.1.1 2.5.1.2 2.5.1.3 2.5.2 2.6 2.7 3 3.1 3.2 3.3 3.4 4 4.1 4.2 4.3 5 5.1 5.1.1 5.1.2 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.4.1 5.4.2 5.4.3 5.4.4 5.5 5.6 Description Introduction Major assemblies Cut-off date Weight information provided by others List of reported loading conditions Discrepancies Summary and conclusions to the report Main summary Weight and load budget (WLB) Global CoG plot Main variations from the previous report Weight forecast General Approved design changes not included Proposed design changes Possible weight changes Main-trend graphs Main weight printout summaries by area and discipline As built / weighing data Area / module reports Variation from last report by area and discipline Trend graphs by area CoG plots Area weight printouts Special reports (optinal) System reports Sub-area report or sub-assemblies report Secondary lift report Annexes to the report Assumptions General assumptions Discipline assumptions Area designations and global origin Weight allowance and contingency Report codes Weight installation codes Weight phase codes Weight status codes Area codes References Other descriptions (incl. VO) SemiModule/ Jacket Topside Jacket Topside Jacket Topside submersible modification 1 1 1 1 1 2 5 9 10 7 NA NA NA 8 2.1 7.1 Missing 8 9.2+9.3 5 Missing A.1 A.2-A.8 1 1 1 1 1 2.2.3 2.2 7.8-7.9 2.3 8.6 NA NA NA 8.7 9.2 Missing 8.2 7.7 7.8-7.9 6.1 Missing 6.1 7 1.2 1.2 1.1 1.1 1.1 2.3.1-4+2.4 2.3.1-4+2.4 Missing 2.3.1-4+2.4 3.1 NA NA NA 6.6 4.2 4.1.1 6.5 6.6 Missing 7.3+8.3 Missing Missing 5.4 1 1 Missing 1 1 2.1 3 6.5 3 4 5.2 5.2 5.2 5.2 8.18.2 7.2 7.1.1+10.2 7.3 Missing Missing 9.1-9.6 Missing 1 1 1 5.6 1 3.1 Missing 4.2.3 2.2 2.2 2.2 2.2 2.2 4.1.1 3.1 Missing Missing 4.1.1 4.2.1-3 NA Missing NA NA
10.4
5.3
10.1