Professional Documents
Culture Documents
fQ ]uY\]Z]Yaf
y
Yz]Yty ZYzY
Zvz-
YzcZ.Yu
yZ
Z vvYu
vYzkYsZ.Yu
|q
0HFK(QJ'HS
W
.KDMHK1DVLU8QLYRI 7HFK
$%675$&7
$$(VPDLOL DQG01LNNKDK%DKUDPL
0HFK(QJ*URXS
7HKUDQ8QLY
,Q WKLV ZRUN DQ REVHUYHUEDFNVWHSSLQJ DSSURDFK KDV EHHQSURSRVHG IRU WKH IHHGEDFNFRQWURO RI DQ DLUFUDIW
ORQJLWXGLQDO FRQWURO %DFNVWHSSLQJFRQWUROOHU LV XVHG WR VWDELOL]H DOO VWDWH YDULDEOHV VLPXOWDQHRXVO\ EDVHG RQ
/\DSXQRYWKHRU\7KHFRQWUROREMHFWLYH LV WUDFNLQJWKH IOLJKWSDWKDQJOHUHIHUHQFHVLJQDO7KHFRQWUROOHUXVHV
WZRLQWHUQDOO\JHQHUDWHGSLWFKUDWHDQGDQJOHRIDWWDFNVLJQDOV GHULYHGIURPEDFNVWHSSLQJDOJRULWKP 7KHIDFW
WKDW WKHUH LV QR PHDVXUHPHQWIRU WKH DQJOHRI DWWDFN PDNHVWKLV ZRUN GLIIHUHQWIURP SUHYLRXVRQHV LQ WKLV
DUHD$QREVHUYHULVLPSOHPHQWHGRQ WKHV\VWHPWRHVWLPDWHWKHDQJOHRIDWWDFN,QRUGHUWRFRPSHQVDWHIRUWKH
HUURUVWKHREVHUYHUV LQWURGXFHGDQGLPSRVHVRQWR WKHEDFNVWHSSLQJDOJRULWKPWKHGHVLJQLVPRGLILHGXWLOL]LQJ
QRQOLQHDUGDPSLQJ 7KHO\DSXQRYVWDELOLW\DQDO\VLV DVZHOODVVLPXODWLRQUHVXOWV VKRZKLJKSHUIRUPDQFHRI
WKHSURSRVHGFRQWUROOHU 8QFHUWDLQWLHVDQGGLVWXUEDQFHVLQ WKH DHURG\QDPLFFRHIILFLHQWVDQGVDWXUDWLRQOLPLWV
LQDFWXDWRUVDQGVWDWHYDULDEOHVDUHH[DPLQHGDQGWKH HIIHFWLYHQHVV RI WKH SURSRVHGDSSURDFKLQWKH SUHVHQFH
RIWKHVHHIIHFWVLVGHPRQVWUDWHG E\VLPXODWLRQUHVXOWV
.H\ZRUGV1RQOLQHDU&RQWURO/\DSXQRY6WDELOLW\ 7KHRU\5HFXUVLYH'HVLJQ%DFNVWHSSLQJ
&RQWUROOHU)OLJKW&RQWURO1RQ OLQHDU
JKDIIDUL#NQWXDFLU yZYu
.tZvDOLDHVPDLOL#JPDLOFRP vyYZyZlYu
uZdY
Zuz-yZ] v\zcYz]^Z^
Zy ] yu bYdz-yYz fp]uy}
ys~ {Zs{YzzdyudyyZ]sz
vYdYuYyuz]yZ zc zc]}v
szys~ z-yZ] Z]]v{Zsyyu
xovzdZzdyz]szYzgPc
aYzc vM bu] sd]od
ZcyY bz yuzczgYyu)vzkZu
yuu ZpyYyu |vM0uk] {Yz
yZ ] {Yz Yz Yz]uzzzdld
bY{ys~{ZsZYYz] >@uy
|ZMaZdZdszYmYz
ZuyuZMzgPc ] .d] YkyuZcbY
yuZ] PzcY vZ]>ZYyuyYud
ZyZd- Zz uv Yz{bY{Yzzd
Y ]]ZduYz] vd}zduyu>Zu
u|YuZYyZ zYyvZZs]Zyu
WYyYys~ {Zszzd]YyZszzd
>@ vuz
Yc ZMyu) vyYuuk|0zd)/Zy
0oYzvuaZY]{Zv]Yyzzd)Y
Yz] |.Zk\]Z-zdoYzy uz)
Yxoyu Y|YMyu)bYys ~ {Zs
z-Y uyYv ukzdZyudsz
YyuvvyYvZay] szZ
odyu bYvzd^k{Yay
d{ZZfZ]zYY vZvYsZ]d]
Yz]zdzdc] vvZZsz]Yz]yu
] Z- y uyYu{Zd]yYv0zd)dyYvZ
"dzvZ] ZZpcz] 0d^Yy\
ZvyuYyMZuz]yZ uzz >@ YyZ
yczd)/Yz]YyyYZM vuYuZsz
yuuZ{ aZpczsYZv#yu >@ vuz]yZ)]bk
yu Yy] szzzdyu\]Z-{
YyZ yZ bYvZYsYy] {Yzzd
)HHGEDFN/LQHDUL]DWLRQ
%DFNVWHSSLQJ
Wd
NJ
PV
PV
UDGVHF
UDG
P
1P
P
P
P
J
vzbz 97
Z-YY{bz 4
vzzk
]wZk[Zd
Z-Y{
oY{
oY{tc
oY{tcZs
^Zk |Y{
{YzzY{
{YzzY{ZzZ.
YZ]Y{
zzd[Z]Y{
v]] ypZcYzyYuz]Z
ZuyZ
Z^nboZ
Z^ZuzM
.
D D R
D
U
/
G F G FR
]73
|
v 0oYzd]yYvzdouYuYsZ
vZ]^ZlyYvZ
Xe
{YYduYz]d-{Z]oYzy\]Z-y
kz}ZYz]t]Yyu bYzdZd
Zd yz]Yy\]Z-y >@
$ uz uZZMyz]YyyYYc
bZozdMyuz.dy \]Z-{YZh
uYuZYz] zYybYvz-{YvY
zdZ FOIZZzd]ZcuzYvy
z-0 zyuYyz{d
[ I [ J [ [
[ D [ [ E [ [ X
X 5 bZoZzd [ 5 [ 5 Q Myu
[ {YYtuzxd]YcE D J I zduy
yuYd z{zduyY]Yy [ vd[
[ZtdYp] YyM[yYv z- z
9 [ [ I [ J [ [ GHV [ [ z
a
ZYy [ [ [ GHV [ vZvvkzdZo
Zzd \o z] d z vu
u dz{ay]vvk
&RQWURO/\DSXQRY)XQFWLRQ
*OREDO$V\PSWRWLFDOO\6WDEOH
9LUWXDO&RQWURO/DZ
97
' 7 FRV D FRV E PJ
P
T 4
4
/ 7 VLQ D PJ FRV J
P9 7 FRV E
/ 7 VLQ D PJ FRV J
P9 7 FRV E
D 4
J
0 7] 73
,\
T6& '
T6& /
T6F& 0
ZzdZ^cyYp vzbzoZ
[
I [ J [ [ [ GHV [
[ D [ [ [ GHV [ E [ [ [ GHV [ X
w[ GHV [
I [ J [ [ [ GHV [
w[
u|YZ]ZZzd)]Zc dYz]
a
z{ay]v Yz^kYy [ vZ]zayZ^
u c
9 [ [ 9 [ [
yYu]ZcYZ{dYz]
9 9 [ I J [ GHV [ 9 [ J
D EX
w[ GHV
I J [ [ GHV
w[
w[ GHV
I J [ [ GHV 9 [ J D N [
E w[
9 9 [ I T [ GHV N [ d
ZY {YzZuszvt]Yyu
yu {Yz zY{]Zuyzzdv uWYyY
YyudyyZ] v bY bzo
bYyYdYvzZuZz]pc
z{ay] dZuauZvYyu >@
vd
D D DF
4 4 4F
ZzZ.u]zxd 0.dPc y]
u0 y^u^czzd( {YYy M J U
auZYz]Z] Z0 JF J F Yyzd/Z0kzs
v {Z]z{ay]
J
Z{]f Q{Y / /
D D
D
T 6& /D
D
P97 FRV E
bYp] J U ZzZ.\czdv
Yz]Z] vZ]yYvZ4 Z-/YY{bz . oY{
auZ\]Z-zdyZYYz]
]YyuYuyYz Z] vz-yYzuZdYuy
bYuYsauZYyu
J
T6& /
IJ
P9 7 FRV E
D 4
4
T6& /
ID
P9 7 FRV E
T6F& 0
I4
,\
IJ
ID
I4
. DG
7 VLQ D PJ FRV J
P9 7 FRV E
7 VLQ D PJ FRV J
P9 7 FRV E
7] 73
,\
T6
P9 7 FRV E
D \zbu]z.dyZyYvZz
oY{Z]Zuz M\YzaYzc
z.dyZ]d]yYvdY^kYz-Zu
ZcuZ{}ZZ]zzdyZdsZ
ZcZ{}ZY]YcYyzzd)
zdYz] . z zd Yz# bz-zyu
/ YzdbZyu . zdYz]4 zczzd
uyyZ]4 zdYz]
Yyx- ZrZ\] Z- y\czc Y ]
{ZYvk] Yz]Z] dz-zyuYyzZzd
oYzvMzyuz{Zz uyYv{ZZ{}Z
vuZdYpc
zxd 4F D F J F ZZ. z
vd 4 D J J ZMaZd
F
vY I D I J I 4 ]Yc z
z-zyuYy Zudz{YY]
o Ja 0{YzY{]ZuyZs{ZyYvZYz]
ZaZY|Zave\]Z/
zcuZ|Yy D vvkZZ
9 J D
. DG & / D
J
D
G
bYz{ay]MZ{d
9 9 . DG & / D D
G
N J J
d . DG & / D JD
. DG & / D D
G
a
J ]zZZ]Zc Ja uZc
9 Z{d Ja Zu|.ZkZ] z
uz)^ZpYc0Yy
Yy 9
wDF
wD
. DG & /R & /D D JU F JU
wJ
wJU
u [ZtdYp]vZ].F \]Z-y^
v xo szYZ]]YyyuuYuyYz Z]
Zszc ukZ]ZYvZ] 9 ld
YoY{z-{YvYukvu] D tc
u] vYtv \]Z-uyYvZdYayyuzY
bpcvYc ZsYvd-vyuyZ
fZ]Z-vZyZsYYz
[ZdkYYz] uuvpyYzZ{yudyYvZZ
u|Y D zcyu 6 Ja szYzzYY{Y
F
9
DF
u
&
P9 7 FRV E
/R
N J 6 J JF
& /D
T6& /D
9 yuM|.Zk Da D D F ZszcZ]
bYuYs
9
N J J J6 J . DG & /D JD
. DG & /D JD
z{]Yy]aZ^ZpZ] 6 Ja
9
9 u[ZtdYyvZ] 4F b
z{ay]Yy 4F vZ]yYvZ Ja Da Zu u]
[ZtdY
N J J G J
. DG & /D JD
. DG & /D JD
G
N J J
d . DG & / D JD
GJa [ZtdYZ]
y
. DG & /D
G
. DG & / D JD
G
9 d N J J N D D N 4 4
. DG & /D D
G G
T6
& /R & /D D J
P9 W FRV E
wDF
T6
& /R & /D D JU
wJ P9 W FRV E
G D
wDF
wD
D F . DG & /D D
wJ
wJ
d N J N D
4
. DG & /D D 4D
G
. DG & /D D
G G
yYu 4 ]ZuyZsZuYz]
T6F
& 0R & 04 4 & 0 G G I 4 4F
, \\
a
9 4 z ] ]zZZ]Zc
uzc ]Yy MZ{dYz] u
[ZtdY 9
9 9 44
F T6F
9 4
& 0R & 04 4 & 0 G G 4F
, \\
9 u [ZtdYY-]z{ay]| G F
vZ]
GF
&0 G
6LPXOLQN
9 d N J N D
. DG & /D D
G
Z ^lZf
wDF wDF
JU
wJU
wJ
0Z- qz ]ZuyZszd|.Zk Z]
a
vvYsyYzz]z{ZZ 9 ayZ^yu 4 4 4
Z Z^scyuZ J F ZzZ. u
yuyu .F 4F Z Z. bYvd
v ]ZuyYyv vczzd
N D G D
4F
& 0R & 04 4
, \\
T6F& 0 G
N 4 D 4F
JDP DF
[F
[GRWF
[FI
JDP DFI
)LOWHU
.
JDP D
.
.
*DLQ
$GG
[F
[GRWF
DOSKDGRW
[FI
)LOWHU
JDP DW
&
&RQVWDQW
.
DOSKDK
[F
.
$GG
.
*DLQ
[GRWF
[FI
)LOWHU
/R
GHOWDF
&RQVWDQW
GHOWD
.
4
.
.
.
$GG
*DLQ
*DLQ
GHOWDF
0R
&RQVWDQW
DOSKDW
6,08/,1. yu\]Z-zzdv
J U
q kzZ.Yz]Zv]dZrZ
J U
J U
q kzZ.Z]]ZuyZZs
q kzZ.Yz]Zv]dZrZ
vo ] G F zdZzZ. vyy
vd ^Z>Z vo yuZ$ZrZZ^Y
yuukZZ aYzgPc Z
Z yYvuYz]YyZuzM\Yz
Z uYrZ]zkc]Zd vu
bY\]Z-ybsMu bY
] yuvYc d szZzc
u vu ZyuY vZ]vyYvZ
cZoYYc ZrZyu. yZcuZlYYz]
uz^]z]-&Y{YuzuZlYzdYzyu
)OLJKW3DWK$QJOH
G >GHJ@
7LPH >VHF@
3LWFKUDWH
7LPH >VHF@
D
DR
D >GHJ@
$QJOHRI$WWDFN
4>GHJVHF@
GRF
5HTXLUHGWDLOGHIOHFWLRQ
JU
JF
J >GHJ@
b ] bz Z]ZsZZ.u vZ
vZ] ]yZ]kyudrZ dyz
Yz] Zg {YzdvoyuzZrZy
Z] ZaZ]y vbYvZvZZd
. ZY ] ]zdtv]kc
yZ] yYvZg Z{b]Zg{YzYzYz] bY
J U
7LPH >VHF@
7LPH >VHF@
q
)OLJKW3DWK$QJOH
JU
JF
7LPH >VHF@
3LWFKUDWH
D >GHJ@
4>GHJVHF@
$QJOHRI$WWDFN
D
DR
7LPH >VHF@
7LPH >VHF@
\zcsyay]ZzdYyZ^cdy.Y,
yu v |.Zk\]Z-dy.Yyu vu{
\Z^cdy.YtcZs z.dy yo
uYz.dZmY\]Z-dy.YZ]Z|
Zs Z-v$vZ]zx ZYyYvZpc
cZpc{Yyuv]Z-vYc uyYuYyus
vZ]
7LPH >VHF@
J U
GRF
G >GHJ@
J >GHJ@
5HTXLUHGWDLOGHIOHFWLRQ
mY
nf
bzovyz]\]Z-yZYyu
yubZoZzdZcdZoYz]vz
{Z^jZd bYvyz] WYyYvZ^}zdu
z.dyYz]\]Z-yZYvuZ
ZzdyYvZcz]d]vu|Y
ldYy]yZ]uzYyx-bZorZyubZo
Zzd Zz.yuZ^Yuk$ vu
pc]ZZ]yZ]voZcdz]Z0ZzgPc
vPcYy0zd)du]ZZ{Z^ u]
v
zcvYc #z-YZuzM\YzZYyu
Z {YZ]>Zd^vyu vzZYv
aYzcuy yuZY uz ZpZMyuYc|Yy
{Yt]\MvZkyZsYzgYyu\Yz Z-Z
}ZoY\Yz sy\zc]{Z/{Yz
{YuZdYZ] uz-kdyYvZZ{YZcu
2QOLQH$SSUR[LPDWLRQ
%DFNVWHSSLQJ )OLJKW &RQWURO 8VLQJ 2Q
/LQH )XQFWLRQ $SSUR[LPDWLRQ $,$$
*XLGDQFH 1DYLJDWLRQ DQG &RQWURO &RQI
$,$$
/HH 7 DQG .LP < 1RQOLQHDU $GDSWLYH
)OLJKW &RQWURO 8VLQJ %DFNVWHSSLQJ DQG
1HXUDO 1HWZRUNV &RQWUROOHU -RXUQDO RI
*XLGDQFH&RQWURODQG'\QDPLFV9RO
1R
6LQJK 61 DQG 6WHLQEHUJ 0 $GDSWLYH
&RQWURO RI )HHGEDFN /LQHDUL]DEOH
1RQOLQHDU 6\VWHPV ZLWK $SSOLFDWLRQ WR
)OLJKW &RQWURO $,$$ - *XLGDQFH
&RQWURODQG'\QDPLFV9RO1RSS