Professional Documents
Culture Documents
On
ADVANCES MANAGEMENT
Indian Overseas bank
Gaurav Manchanda
DECLARATION FORM
I hereby declare that the Project work entitled ADVANCES submitted by me for the Summer Internship during the Post Graduate Program to IILM Institute for Higher Education is my own original work and has not been submitted earlier either to IILM or to any other Institution for the fulfillment of the requirement for any course of study. I also declare that no chapter of this manuscript in whole or in part is lifted and incorporated in this report from any earlier / other work done by me or others.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to express my gratitude to all those who gave me opportunity and help to complete this project report. I would like to thank Indian Overseas Bank for providing me opportunity to work with them and giving guidance in completing the project to the best of my abilities. I would like to extend my special gratitude to Miss Rashmi Agarwal, Assistant Manager, Advances Department, Indian Overseas Bank, for being my company guide and providing me an insight into various issues pertaining to the case mentioned in the report. Her professional advice given throughout the completion of this project will not be forgotten. I would also like to thank my team members Miss. Kritika Gupta and Mr. Anand Kumar for their assistance, motivation and being a continual source of encouragement and guiding me to complete this project successfully. I am highly indebted to Prof. Rajkishan Nair for his mentorship and valuable suggestions that gave immense confidence and encouragement that helped me to put in my best. I am also thankful to my parents because of whom I am capable of pursuing pgdm. Last but not the least I would like to thank my friends and classmates who gave me a positive feedback and a competitive frame of mind while making this report.
TABLE OF CONTENTS S.No Name of the Topic Executive Summary Objectives Company Profile Introduction Corporate Social Responsibility Socio- Economic responsibilities Page no. 6 8 9 11 11 Remarks
Chapter- 2 Introduction to the Project 2.1 General concepts of loans and Advances 2.2 Basel- II Accord A measure of Risk Adequacy 2.3 Lending and Advances 2.4 Types of Advances 2.5 Financial Analysis of Lending 2.6 Methods of Credit Rating 2.7 Methods of Assigning Credit Limits and Drawing Power 2.8 Securities used against Lending 2.9 Modes of Charging Securities 2.10 Credit Appraisal 2.11 Credit Appraisal Process Chapter - 3 3.1 3.2 3.3 Working Capital Finance Introduction Operating cycle Working capital financing by banks 3.4 Form of assistance
12 13 15 16 18 23 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30 30
Chapter - 4 Working Methodology 4.1 Procedure of Credit Appraisal Chapter - 5 Analysis 5.1 Working Capital Analysis 5.2 Ratio Analysis
32
41 45
Chapter - 6 Case Study XYZ Media Ltd. Recommendations Limitations Conclusion References
46 57 58 59 60
Executive Summary
Bank lending is an art as well as a science. There are several techniques, tools, methods and principles which are mechanical and can work as guide to action or aid to perfection with some of them have an inherent property that they are not static and are drawn from experiences primarily used for appraising a credit proposal. Every lender should remember and follow the basic principles of lending i.e. Safety, Security, Suitability, Profitability, Integrity, Adequacy of Finance and Diversion of Risk. While considering and sanctioning loans, banks usually investigate the prospective borrower effectively and efficiently. Effective investigation means the collection and interpretation of all the required data and efficient investigation will ensure that time and money are not wasted in the process. The prime focus of this report is to enlighten the purpose and process of credit investigation and subsequently how credit proposals are made. Different types of advances, method of assigning credit limit and drawing power to individuals and business units has also been a part of study during the internship period. The main purpose of the credit investigation is to determine the business reputation, credibility and responsibility of the individuals involved with particular reference to their experience in the line of activity, dealings with customers trading or dealing with them, management capability, professional reputation with their bankers, history of payment record and fulfillment of financial obligations, honesty and integrity, willingness to repay the debt. A thorough credit investigation should take into account the economic and business environment in which the prospective borrower is placed .The process of credit investigation involves study of both financial and non-financial aspects of the proposed borrower. Credit investigation includes ascertaining the creditworthiness of the guarantors also. Analysis of financial statements forms an integral part of a proposal and it is an important tool for decision making. Key financial indicators assist a banker in taking qualitative credit decisions. Normal credit risk is inherent in any advance. Analysis helps a banker in careful evaluation of risks to arrive at a decision on calculated risk. The basic aspects of analyzing financial statements include analysis of financial data of an organization in two statements i.e. balance sheet and profit and loss account. While the balance sheet reflects the financial position as on a particular date, the relative profit and loss account discloses the working results of the enterprise during the preceding twelve months. The major aim of analyzing the balance sheet is to examine the position of liquidity of the enterprise. The other important attachments of the balance sheet are the Auditors report and Directors report. The Auditors report is the end product of every audit which implies that the auditor has examined the relevant records, in accordance with generally accepted auditing practices and is expressing an opinion on whether or not the financial statements reflect a true and fair view of the state of affairs and the working results of an enterprise. Then the ratio analysis is one of the most important aspect which should be taken into consideration, this includes Tangible Net worth (TNW), Total outside liabilities (TOL)/Tangible Net Worth, Funded Debt to Equity Ratio, Current Ratio, Net Working Capital. Appraisal of Term Loan, Working Capital, Non-Fund based facilities, the credit rating methods applied by the bank to rate the credibility of the
prospective clients, risk management processes and Credit monitoring discussed in the report.
Later, the report includes the conversion of accounts into standard or bad debts. The treatment of those Non-performing assets and the recovery of the same along with the legal procedure followed by the bank are discussed in great detail. A model credit proposal of a company (with changed personal details) is also given in the report which was witnessed during the summer internship program. Finally, conclusion and recommendation as per the analysis during the training period winds up the report.
Objectives
The objective of this report is to understand the entire process involved in successful lending by the bank as per the norms of the Reserve Bank of India and the authority that governs the functioning of Indian Overseas Bank which involves principles of lending, Credit investigation i.e. the assessment of the credit worthiness of the borrowers and estimation of the net worth of the assets owned by him. The whole process of financial analysis involving assessment of the balance sheets, P & L account, ratio analysis, then the purpose and detailed analysis of the appraisal of term loan have also been a potential objective of this report. Working capital, Non-Fund based facilities, rating of borrower accounts, Credit Risk Management Policies, Credit Monitoring, Non Performing Assets (NPAs) and the recovery policies are also some of the vital castles of this report and one of the major objective of this report is to present detailed conceptualization which would prove to be valuable in comprehension and formation of credit proposal and Credit Monitoring Arrangement (CMA). The project is likely to help organization understand the various issues related to the advances, giving it certain solutions to reduce the loses due to non recovery of loans and maintain a healthy trend line of decreasing net NPA thereby helping it to maintain a balance between its deposits and advances and an increase in its percentage yield.
Policy and Planning Department from Det Norske Veritas (DNV), Netherlands in September 1999. IOB started its STAR services in December of the year 1999 for speedy realisation of outstation cheques. Now the Banks has 14 STARS centres and one Controlling Centre for providing this service and in the same year started tapping the potential of Internet by enabling ABB cardholders in Delhi to pay their telephone bills by just logging on to MTNL web site and by authorising the Bank to debit towards the telephone bills. The Bank made a successful debut in raising capital from the public during the financial year 2000-01, despite a subdued capital market. IOB bagged the NABARD's award for credit linking the highest number of Self Help Groups for 2000-2001 among the Banks in Tamil Nadu. Mobile banking under SMS technology was implemented in Ahmadabad and Baroda. Pilot run of Phase I of the Internet Banking commenced covering 34 branches in 5 Metropolitan centers. IOB was one among the first to join Reserve Bank of India's negotiated dealing system for security dialing online. The Bank has finalized an e-commerce strategy and has developed the necessary Internet banking modules in-house. For the first time a Total Branch Automation package developed in-house has been customized in one of the Overseas Branches of the Bank. Most software developed in-house. During the year 2002-03, a new credit scheme Shubh Yatra' was introduced to provide loans to those who undertake foreign travel for tourism, employment and medical treatment. During the year 2004, the Government OF India selected IOB for channelizing government credit to other countries, which runs into billions of dollars. And also in the same year the bank made tie up with Times Online Money to launch an Internet-based remittance product, e-Cash Home, targeted at NRIs in the US wishing to transfer money to India. IOB made pact with Chola for MF products. During the year 2005, the bank joined hands with Visa to offer debit cards to its esteemed customers. In the year 2006, IOB inked MoU with CRI Pumps. In September 2006, Indian Overseas Bank (IOB) has finally taken control of Bharat Overseas Bank (BhOB), an unlisted private bank. This is the first instance of a public sector bank taking over a strong private sector bank without resorting to the moratorium route. During May of the year 2007, Indian rating agency ICRA assigned an 'A1+' rating to the proposed 20 bln rupee certificates of deposit programme of Indian Overseas Bank, citing the bank's consistent and measured growth, the improvement in its asset quality through effective monitoring and collection systems, and improving core profitability. During June of the year 2008, IOB launched two new products namely IOB Gold' and IOB Silver' in savings account and IOB Classic' and IOB Super' under current account. IOB have a network of more than one thousand eight hundred branches all over India located in various metropolitan cities, urban, suburban and rural areas. IOB plans to set up banking operations in Malaysia in a joint venture with two other India-based banks Bank of Baroda and Andhra Bank with a minimum capital investment of RM320 million (US$100 million).
10
11
12
Suitability Banker should concentrate his lending on purposes, which are desirable from the stand point of economic health of the nation and economic imperatives of the country. Profitability An advance must be guaranteed at a rate of interest considered satisfactory in relation to the risk entailed and keeping in view the amount of work and expenses the amount will cause to the bank. Liquidity A bank would remain liquid if its advances are also liquid. In order to meet the demands of the depositors, it is essential for the banker to ensure that borrower would be in a position to repay the loan either on demand or within a reasonable period thereafter. Integrity No advance should be made to a borrower of doubtful integrity. A banker should be concerned about the business integrity of the borrower. Adequacy of finance A prudent banker would not lend a sum, which is inadequate to finance a given project. If he does, not only he kills the project but sinks the advance as well because, a partly completed project cannot generate money to pay for the investment. Timeliness Not only that adequate finance be made available to the borrower, it is also important that it is given in time. It is better not to give the finance at all rather than giving it after a considerable lapse of time. Many opportunities might have been last due to delay or many crises could have been averted but for the delay. Diversification of Risk Banker should be ensured that the advances are diversified in a good number of customers. 2.2 BASEL II ACCORD: A measure of risk adequacy For the purpose of regulations about how much capital banks should put aside to guard against various types of financial and operational risk , bank supervisors and central bankers from the 13 countries which forms the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision(BCBS) recommended Basel II or The New Accord (correct full name is the International
13
Convergence of Capital Measurement and Capital Standards A Revised Framework) which is the second Basel published in June 2004.Its a kind of recommendations on banking laws and regulations. THE ACCORD IN OPERATION: Minimum Capital Requirement Supervisory review Market Discipline 1
BASEL II
SUPERVISORY REVIEW
MARKET DISCIPLINE
To avoid strategic, reputational risks and to practice best risk practices, creation of Supervision framework.
It requires banks to disclose capital structures, capital adequacy and risk exposures.
BASEL II
1. MINIMUM CAPITAL REQUIREMENTS Capital charges Stipulation for the improvement of risk management
14
2. SUPERVISORY REVIEW PROCESS To avoid strategic, reputational risks and to practice best risk practices, creation of Supervision framework. 3. ENHANCEMENT OF MARKET DISCIPLINE It requires banks to disclose capital structures, capital adequacy and risk exposures.
15
Borrower comes to the bank with a loan proposal, colleateral security and appropriate financial details. Now bank verifies the purpose, credit worthiness and repayment capacity of the borrower. Than bank make a credit proposal of the borrower and send this credit proposal to the Regional Office . Now Regional Office verifies the proposal and then, either approve or reject the loan. Banks provide to kinds of loan facilities:
TYPES OF ADVANCES
FUND BASED ADVANCES Includes term loans, demand loans, cash credit, overdraft, bill discounted etc.
i.
Fund Based Facilities (Fund Based Advances) Fund based Facilities includes term loans, demand loans, cash credit, overdraft, bill discounted etc.
ii.
Non-Fund Based Facilities (Non Fund Based Advances) Non-Fund Based Facilities includes letters of credit and bank guarantee.
.Indian Overseas Bank offers a wide range of services in the loans and advances segment some of which are indexed here: i. Personal loan ii. Educational loans iii. Loans on bank term deposits iv. Loans against National Saving Certificates (NSC) v. Loans against Insurance Policies vi. Loans against Gold jewels
16
vii. viii.
Loans against Collateral Security, Stocks and debtors Loans against shares.
Term Term of the loan can be defined as the length of the time in which borrower have to repay the loan or debt. Debt financing can be either long-term or short- term: i. Long Term Loan For the purpose of purchasing, improving or expanding fixed assets such as pant, facilities, major equipments and real estate one can seek bank for long term financing. If someone is buying some asset and seeking loan from bank he or she has to repay the amount within the useful life of the asset. In todays lending environment the rate of interest is more in long term debt financing because of the risk carry by the of the extending period of time. Long term debt financing also needs more substantial collateral. Short Term loan Cyclic needs, inventory needs, accounts payable and working capital are the prime mottos behind short term loans.
ii.
17
Letter of Credit
With near cash characteristics i.e. no fluctuation with market conditions and can be cashed in when presented to the issuing bank, Letter of Credit has been considered as a valuable widely used collateral for many years in securities lending industry. Letter of Credit is a kind of bank guarantee which bank issues whenever there is a contract between two parties, according to which bank guarantees to pay the agreed amount on behalf of its client. Letter of credit is operationally efficient collateral which carries very low settlement risk. Usually used in international transactions, where two nations find it difficult to understand each other personally due to different legal systems .
Bank Guarantee
Bank guarantee is a kind of guarantee provided by a lending institution which depicts that if the debtor fails to repay a debt, bank will cover it . This kind of guarantee helps the debtor to expand the business by acquire goods, buy equipment or draw down loans. Bank guarantee is usually used in cases like when a buyer buys goods from seller. And it runs into cash flow difficulties and cant pay to the seller. Similarly if the supplier was unable to provide goods, the bank will pay from supplier side to buyer. Its a kind of safety measure for the supposing party in the transaction.
3. Liquidity Companys ability of covering immediate obligations and to maintain a healthy positive cash flow. 4. Stability The firms stability can be assessed by looking at its ability to sustain in the business for long term without incurring too much loss and these attributes can be assessed by balance sheet, P and L A/c and other non-financial indicators.
Step 2: includes a quick scanning of some important terms from one year to the next year. The prime aim of doing this exercise is to find out any significant fluctuations and if found then to subsequently conduct a relevant research to find out the reason so that any suspicion can be removed. Step 3: This step consist of a crude assessment of balance sheet for the purpose of scrutinizing large changes in the various components of balance sheet. i.e. companys assets and liabilities of equity e.g. if the amount for fixed assets have grown rapidly because of new facilities or acquisitions, one should also taken into consideration that whether the debt has also increased rapidly. Step 4: This step includes assessment of income statement which includes preparation of graphs and growths of the Revenue (sales) and Net Income (profit and earnings), and then there will be trend assessment over time. Each expense component of the income is calculated in terms of the percentage of sales of that year. Then there will be high lightening of the favorable and unfavorable components. Step 5: this step involves the assessment of the cash flow statement. This assessment gives clear picture about cash inflows and outflows. This statement shows that how the borrower is generating cash and how it is utilizing the same, which shows management efficiencies also what an investor is searching for.
19
Bank uses following ratios for the purpose of analysis: Liquidity Ratio Degree of financial leverage of debt Profitability Efficiency Value
a) Analyzing Liquidity
Cash convertible assets are called as liquid assets. For the purpose of analysis of liquidity we should calculate two important ratios. These ratios are Current Ratio and Quick Ratio. We can calculate them as: 1. Current Ratio = Total Current Assets / Total Current liabilities 2. Quick Ratio = (Total Current Assets Inventories ) / Total Current Liabilities The benchmarks or rule of thumb or acceptable values are Current Ratio (2:1), Quick Ratio (1:1). The higher values of these two ratios indicate a greater liquidity and lower risk for short term lenders.
b) Analyzing Debt
Debt ratios show that how much a company depends on debt to finance its investments and operations and how much it is capable of repaying its debt obligation. Inability of the company to repay its debt obligation can take it into bankruptcy and the other face of the scenario says that debt is very useful because company can avail tax benefits on this as well. These ratios are: 1. Leverage Ratios 1a. Debt to Equity Ratio = Total Debt / Total Equity Here Total debt has both the debts i.e. i. ii. Short Term Debt = bank advances + the current portion of long- term debt Long Term Debt = bonds, leases, notes payable
20
Debt to equity ratio shows firms degree of leverage or how much it depends upon external debt for financing purpose. 1b. Debt to Assets Ratio = Total Debt / Total Assets. Lowering of any of the above two ratios indicates the conservative nature of the company. However, no one can reject this fact that if a company does not use debt, it may loose investment and growth opportunities.
3. Return on Equity ( ROE) =Profit after taxes / shareholders Equity (book value) 4. Earnings per Common Share (EPS) = ( Profits after taxes Preferred Dividend / Number of common shares outstanding
5. Payout Ratio = Cash Dividends / Net Income. As far as decision making is concerned, present value of the future profits is the main consideration in the mind of lender (bank). For the purpose of ascertaining future profits, bank analyzes past or current profits and this can be done by identifying historical and forecasted trends of profits and sales.
21
d) Analyzing Efficiency
These ratios depicts that how efficiently firm has managed its assets. These ratios are as follow: 1. Inventory Turnover = Cost of Goods Sold / Average Inventory Inventory turnover indicates that how quickly the inventory got sold to produce sales. Higher ratio signifies that the firm manages inventories efficientlt by minimizing the investment in inventories.
2. Total Assets Turnover = Sales / Average Total Assets Total Assets Turnover shows that how much sales a firm is producing for every dollar of investment in assets. Higher ratio signifies better performance. 3. Accounts Receivable Turnover = Annual Credit Sales / Average Receivables 4. Average Collection Period = Average Accounts Receivable / (Total Sales / 365) Ratios like Accounts Receivable Turnover and Average Collection Period depicts that how much efficient the firm is in collecting cash from its sales credit. One can comprehend from lowering of this ratio that the firm is very strict in its credit policy which may repel customers but at the same time lowering of these ratios is also good. 5. Days in Inventory = Days in a year / Inventory turnover Days in inventory shows that how fastly the manufactures product is sold off the Shelf. It is also called as Shelf Life. e) Value Ratios These ratios indicate embedded value in stock. These ratios are: 1. Price to Earnings Ratio (P/E) = Current Market Price per Share / After-tax Earnings per Share 2. Dividend Yield = Annual Dividends per Share / Current Market Price per Share
22
f) Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) Net Profit after tax* + Depreciation + Interest on T/L and other long term debts DSCR = -----------------------------------------------------------------Installment of T/L and other long term debts + Interest on T/L and other Long term debts
*(but before appropriation of dividends) This ratio is calculated on yearly basis from the year of commercial production to the last year of proposed repayment. DSCR of 2:1 or above is considered as an ideal ratio which indicates that for every rupee of debt to be repaid in one year, the cash profit available is rupees two , which indirectly shows a very comfortable and safe debt servicing capability. For large industries, an average DSCR of 1.5 with a minimum of 1.2 in one year and in case of SME units located in backward areas, a minimum DSCR of 1.5:1 is accepted.
23
Cash Credit Facility for business Concern Bank usually assesses all the particulars of the customer who is looking for Cash Credit facility for business concern. The documents, a customer must submit to the bank for this purpose are as follows: Balance sheets for the past three years Recent Stock Statement which should consist of paid up stock, bank dont take stock on credit into consideration. Record of debtors showing book debts up to 90 days. Pan Card details Sales Turnover of past three years. If the sales turnover exceeds Rs 40 lacs, a certification from chartered accountant is also required. Assets and Liability statements of both the borrower and guarantor are required. Projected sales and balance sheets of two years is also required. On quarterly basis the customer is suppose to submit the stocks, debtors and sales statement for the purpose of review of his credit limit from time to time.
Drawing Power
Drawing power can be calculated as: Drawing Power = 75 % of stock + 50 % of debtors (both the stocks and debtors can be calculated as per the details furnished in the documents)
Collateral securities are the securities that are accepted by the bank and can be legally liquefied if the borrower defaults on repayment. The securities which are accepted by the bank as collaterals are as follows: Policies Endowment policy is accepted by the bank e.g Life Insurance Policy of LIC. Banks usually sanction the loan up to 80-90% of the surrender value of the policy. Loans against policies are not common but they are offered against saving policies and this is one of the cheapest methods. National Savings Certificate (NSC) and Kendriya Vikas Patra (KVP) NSCs and KVPs can be transferred to the banks name by the borrower and can certainly be treated as bank security. Banks generally mark lien on the documents and inform the same to the issuing authority.
24
Fixed Deposit Receipts (FDR) Bank usually take Fixed deposit Receipts (FDRs) as security against loans while keeping 10 % as margin. House Property In case of house loans, bank usually takes house property as security or insurance for the repayment of the loan. One can avail up to 80 % of the cost of the property. Other Assets Any appropriate possession like machinery, equipment or business property can be consider as securities and bank usually accepts them as collateral. In such cases the asset remains with the borrower unless there is default, in which case the asset goes to the bank. Generally banks dont provide credit facilities against equipments and machinery.
1.
2.
3.
4.
25
2.10
Credit Appraisals
Credit appraisal is an important activity carried out by the loans and advances department of the bank to determine whether to accept or reject the proposal for financing its project. The project deals in credit facilities such as working capital methods of assessment, compilation of credit reports. The methods that are used by the banks in order to calculate the loan limits are Turnover method, MBPF system and Cash budget system. The financial viability of the borrower and its firm is analysed through firms CMA data or through its proposed financial statements like audited and provisional balance sheet and P/L account of previous years, current financial year and assessment year. The firms financial performance is analyzed through ratio analyses. Financial requirements for project finance and working capital purposes are taken care of at the credit department. Companies that intend to seek credit facilities approach the bank. Primarily, credit is required for following purposes: 1. Working capital finance 2. Term loan for projects
26
Receipt of documents (Audited, Provisional or Projected Balance sheets, Valuation reports of properties, Legal Opinion, ROC documents, Guarantors Statement, Debtors & Stock statements for 120 days)
Verification of legal procedures (Check for RBI defaulters list, Wilful defaulters list, CIBIL Report, ECGC specific approval list, check for watchoutinvestors website etc.) Property and unit /stock inspection
Proposal preparation
27
28
Payments to creditors
30
31
Primary Data: Observation, Discussion with the company guide at the bank. The company profile, its guidelines and principles. Secondary Data: Secondary data relating to the procedure of assessment of working capital finance, old sanction proposals, and RBI guidelines etc., financial statements have been sourced from the branch and referenced books.
32
33
1. PRE SANCTION PROCESS: When a customer required any credit facility or working capital loan he is required to complete application form and submit the same to the bank.Also the borrower has to submit the required information along with the application form. Pre sanction process requires following documents and information which are analysed prior to raising the credit proposal Audited balance sheets and profit and loss accounts for the previous three year Estimated balance sheet for current year. Projected balance sheet for next year Profile for promoters/directors, senior management personnel of the company Obtain Guarantors statement Examine for preliminary appraisal RBI guidelines and Policies Prudential exposure norms and bank lending policy Industry exposure restriction and related risk factors. Obtain RAM rating ,CRISIL rating Compliance regarding transfer of borrowers accounts from one bank to another bank Government regulation / legislation impact on the industry Acceptability of the promoter and applicant status with regards to other unit to industries. Credit report of accounts running with other banks Arrive at the preliminary decision. Evaluation of prime and collateral security Examine/analysis /assessment Financial ratio & Dividend policy. Depreciation method Revaluation of fixed assets. Records of defaults (Tax, dues etc.) Pending suits having financial implication (Customs, excise etc.) Check for RBI defaulter list, Willful defaulter list, ECGC specific approval list,CIBIL report. Qualifications to balance sheet auditors remarks etc. Trend in sales and profitability and estimates /projection of sales. Production capacities and utilization: past & projected production efficiency and cost. Estimated working capital gap W.R.T acceptable build-up of inventory/receivables/other current assets and bank borrowing patterns. Assess MPBF determine facilities required Companys structure and system Profitability factor, Inventory/Receivable level, Capacity utilization
34
2. Preparation of CMA data Credit Monitoring Arrangement (CMA) data is a very important area in the process of credit appraisals. It is a critical analysis of current & projected financial statements of a loan applicant by the banker. CMA data is a systematic analysis of working capital management of a borrower and objective of this statement is to ensure the usage of long term and short term fund have been used for the given purpose.CMA data is also beneficial for analysing financial indicators .CMA data at Indian Overseas Bank is prepared in main 3 components statements. Balance sheet - Balance sheet analysis for the current & projected financial years is the first statement in CMA data. This statement gives the detailed analysis of Current & noncurrent assets, fixed assets, cash & bank position, current & noncurrent liabilities of the borrower. Also this statement indicates the net worth position of the borrower for the projected years. Balance sheet analysis gives a complete financial position of the borrower and cash generating capacity during the projected years. Below is the snapshot of CMA data of XYZ Media Ltd. Co. prepared at IOB as a part of the project.
SNAPSHOT - 1
Type of Financials Year ended 1.ASSETS 1.1CURRENT ASSETS I. Inventories Raw Materials Stock in process Finished Goods Consumable Spares Audited 2011 BALANCE SHEET Audited 2012 Provisional 2013 Projected 2014
TOTAL INVENTORIES II. Trade Debtors Domestic Debtors over six months Domestic Debtors less than six months Export Debtors over six months Export Debtors less than six months TOTAL DEBTORS III. Other Current Assets Cash and Bank Balance Prepaid Expenses Advance Tax Deposits with Excise and Sales Tax Loans and Advances Others/Dep margin with Bank/cenvat input
198.59
240.45
160.00
110.00
35
Total Other Current Assets SUB- TOTAL (a) 1.2 FIXED ASSETS I. Land & Buildings II. Plant & Machinery III. Sundries Gross Fixed Assets Less: Depreciation to date Net Fixed Assets (b) Capital Work in Progress
762.07 1,662.55
851.95 2,082.50
919.97 2,079.97
875.67 2,085.67
0.00
136.51
91.00
91.00
II. Others Non Current Assets Investment in other companies Loans and Advances Overdue debitors security and other deposits Non-Moving Inventories Others
56.51 Total Other Non Current Assets SUB-TOTAL (c) Deferred Tax Asset (d) 1.4 INTANGIBLE ASSETS (e) TOTAL ASSETS (a+b+c+d+e) 56.51 0.00 0.00 2,027.52 2011 31-Mar-11
Year ended 2. LIABILITIES 2.1.CURRENT LIABILITIES I. Borrowings from IOB From other Banks Commercial Paper sub- total II. Creditors for Purchases III. Other Current Liabilities Creditiors for Expenses Provision TL due within one year Outstanding Expenses Others/Advances taken
312.35 0.00 0.00 312.35 3.35 0.00 14.50 42.70 0.00 91.61
439.76 0.00 0.00 439.76 9.31 0.00 26.00 16.67 0.00 67.37
440.00 0.00 0.00 440.00 10.00 0.00 23.00 29.00 0.00 72.25
500.00 0.00 0.00 500.00 12.00 0.00 28.00 66.00 0.00 65.30
36
SUB-TOTAL (e) 2.2.DEFERRED LIABILITIES I. Term Loan from IOB II. Term Loan from institutions III. Other Long Term Liabilities Preference Shares Long-term loans from other banks Foreign currency loans NCD borrowings Others Other Long term liability which have been taken as Quasi Equity Total Other Long Term Liabilities SUB-TOTAL (f) 2.3.CAPITAL AND SURPLUS I. Paid up Capital II. Reserves and Surplus III. Revaluation Reserves Share Application Money SUB-TOTAL (g) Deferred Tax Liability (h) TOTAL LIABILITIES (e+f+g+h) Off Balance Sheet Debt Current Portion of Long Term Debt
97.51 84.16
65.00 100.00
56.00 80.00
0.00 70.00
51.94 1,141.30 0.00 29.00 0.00 1,222.24 0.00 2,027.77 0.00 42.70
65.96 1,297.82 0.00 5.00 0.00 1,368.78 0.00 2,714.03 0.00 16.67
66.56 1,348.16 0.00 6.00 0.00 1,420.72 0.00 2,730.97 0.00 29.00
72.56 1,411.81 0.00 6.00 0.00 1,490.37 0.00 2,781.67 0.00 66.00
Profit and loss P &L is the second component of CMA data of a company and shows the company's revenues and expenses during a particular period. It indicates net sales, gross profit, operating profit, profit before tax (PBT), and net profit after tax (NPAT). SNAPSHOT -2
Year ended PROFIT AND LOSS 1.NET SALES I.Domestic Sales - Cash II.Domestic Sales - Credit iii. Exports Less Excise Duty Total Net Sales 31-Mar-11 31-Mar-12 31-Mar-13 31-Mar-14
37
2. COST OF SALES Opening stock finished goods Opening stock WIP Opening stock RM - Indigenous Opening stock RM - Imported Add Purchases RM - Indigenous Add Purchases RM - Imported Stores consumed Manufacturing Expenses Depreciation Add:Purchases Finished Goods Less Closing stock finished goods Less closing stock WIP Less closing stock RM - Indigenous Less closing stock RM -- Imported Cost of Sales Cost of Production 3. GROSS PROFIT(+)/LOSS(-) (1-2) 4. SELLING & ADM. EXP. 5. INTEREST & FIN.CHARGES
0.00 0.00 774.15 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 51.99 45.31 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 871.45 871.45 599.13 498.37 63.83
0.00 0.00 997.87 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 56.91 46.34 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,101.12 1,101.12 875.30 735.02 81.02
0.00 0.00 1,260.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 95.20 55.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,410.20 1,410.20 989.80 845.40 87.00
0.00 0.00 1,325.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 105.10 60.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1,490.10 1,490.10 1,109.90 954.25 97.00
Total (4+5) 6.OPERATING PROFIT/LOSS 7.I.OTHER INCOME Sale of Scrap Interest Received Profit on Sale of FA / INV Others
562.20 36.93
816.04 59.26
932.40 57.40
1,051.25 58.65
Total Other Income 7 II.LESS OTHER EXPENSES Loss on Sale of FA / INV Loss on Currency Fluctuation Misc. Exp written off Others
Total Other Expenses Other Income Net of Expenses 8.PROFIT BEFORE TAX/LOSS 9.INCOME-TAX PROVISION 10.NET PROFIT AFTER TAX/LOSS 11.N.P.BEFORE DEP.&TAX 12.N.P.BEFORE DEP.TAX&INT. 13. CASH GENERATION 14.DIVIDEND
38
Analytical and comparative Ratios- Ratio Analysis is a form of Financial Statement Analysis that is used to obtain a quick indication of a firm's financial performance in several key areas. The computation of ratios facilitates the comparison of firms which differ in size. Ratios can be used to compare a firm's financial performance with industry averages. In addition, ratios can be used in a form of trend analysis to identify areas where performance has improved or deteriorated over time. SNAPSHOT - 3
Year ended ANALYTICAL AND COMPARATIVE RATIOS I.FINANCIAL INDICATORS 1.TANGIBLE NETWORTH 2.TOTAL OUTSIDE LIAB.TO TNW (TOL-USL)/(TNW+USL) 3.FUNDED DEBT TO TNW 4.NET WORKING CAPITAL 5.CURRENT RATIO 6.STOCK HOLDINGS 6.1.RAW MATERIALS R.M. HOLDING (IN MTHS) 6.2.STOCK IN PROCESS SIP HOLDING (IN MTHS) 6.3.FINISHED GOODS FG HOLDING (IN MTHS) 6.4.CONSUMABLE SPARES CON.SPARE CONSUMED CON.SPARE HOLD(MTHS) 7.SUNDRY DEBTORS (DOMESTIC) SUNDRY DEBTORS (EXPORT) GROSS SALES (DOMESTIC) GROSS SALES (EXPORT) RECEIVABLES HOLD(MTHS) (DOMESTIC) RECEIVABLES HOLD(MTHS) (EXPORT) 8. CREDITORS FOR PURCHASES PURCHASES CREDIT AVAIL (MONTHS) II. PROFITABILITY RATIOS 31-Mar-11 31-Mar-12 31-Mar-13 31-Mar-14
1,222.24 0.66 0.30 0.28 1,198.04 3.58 0.00 198.59 3.08 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 #DIV/0! 701.89 0.00 1,470.58 0.00 5.73 #DIV/0! 3.35 0.00 #DIV/0!
1,368.78 0.98 0.26 0.57 1,523.39 3.72 0.00 240.45 2.89 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 #DIV/0! 990.10 0.00 1,976.42 0.00 6.01 #DIV/0! 9.31 0.00 #DIV/0!
1,420.72 0.92 0.27 0.52 1,505.72 3.62 0.00 160.00 1.52 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 #DIV/0! 1,000.00 0.00 2,400.00 0.00 5.00 #DIV/0! 10.00 0.00 #DIV/0!
1,490.37 0.87 0.32 0.42 1,414.37 3.11 0.00 110.00 1.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 #DIV/0! 1,100.00 0.00 2,600.00 0.00 5.08 #DIV/0! 12.00 0.00 #DIV/0!
39
9. NET SALES INCREASE/DECR.SALES 10.PERCENT.INCR. SALES 11.GROSS PROFIT TO SALES 12.OP.PROFIT TO SALES 13.N.P.BEFORE TAX TO SALES 14.N.P.AFTER TAX TO TNW 15. TOTAL BANK BORROWINGS 16. NPAT/Sales
3. Assessment of working capital limits - A unit needs working capital funds mainly to carry current assets required for its operations. Proper assessment of funds required for working capital is essential not only in the interest of the concerned unit but also in the national interest to use the scare credit according to production requirements. When a borrower demands for a credit facility from the bank, the bank has to assess the limits of working capital to be sanctioned. Proper assessment of working capital requirement may be done as underi. TURNOVER METHOD (Nayak Committee Recommendations) a. Mainly used for SMEs (Small and Medium Enterprises). b. Not appropriate for manufacturing and big trading companies. ii. CASH BUDGET SYSTEM a. Mainly used for service sector companies b. Cash inflow Cash outflow = Bank finance in form of WC TONDON COMMITTEE RECOMMENDATIONS a. It has three methods of lending. b. Out of 3 methods recommended, method II also known as Maximum Permissible Bank Finance (MPBF) is mainly used by the banks for assessment of WC finance
iii.
4. Appraisal and Recommendation This is the last step of appraising the credit proposal. All lending made or proposed by the branches must be in conformity with banks lending policy and within the budget allocations made from time to time. In this connection officers are expected to be thorough with the Loan Policy Document. Managers should strictly adhere to all the instructions and guidelines issued by the Central Office from time to time. It is primarily the responsibility of the Branch Managers to ensure the safety of all the advances of their branches. It is the basic duty of the Branch Managers and the other officials to protect the banks interest in all the transactions of the bank handled by them including advances. When the entire assessment is done ,the proposal is sent to discretionary powers to appraise the credit proposal
40
Chapter 5 ANALYSIS
The project involves the following tools for analysing the given project proposal: Working capital analysis Ratio analysis
41
1. DRAWING POWER OF THE BORROWER The drawing power that a borrower enjoys at any one point depends on each components of working capital. The bank for each component, which the borrower must hold as his contribution to finance working capital, prescribes margins. The drawing power of the borrower can be best explained with the following illustration Illustration: Suppose a borrower has Rs 100.00 lacs as working capital limit sanctioned to him by a bank. The security provided by the borrower to the bank is the hypothecation of inventory. Suppose, the borrower needs to hold an inventory level of say 130 lacs in order to enjoy Rs 100 lacs as his working capital limit. The actual level of inventory with the borrower at a point is say 110 lacs.The inventory margin prescribed by the bank is say 25 % Therefore with this inventory level, the borrower enjoys only Rs 82.5 lacs as his working capital limit as against Rs 100 lacs. 2. SECURITY Banks provide credit on the basis of the following modes of security from the borrowers. Hypothecation: the banks provide credit to borrowers against the security of movable property, usually inventory of goods. Mortgage: It is the transfer f a legal / equitable interest in specific immovable property for securing the payment of debt. Pledge: The goods which are offered as security, are transferred to the physical possession of the lender.
42
First method of lending Banks can work out the working capital gap, i.e. total current assets less current liabilities other than bank borrowings (called Maximum Permissible Bank Finance or MPBF) and finance a maximum of 75 per cent of the gap; the balance to come out of long-term funds, i.e., owned funds and term borrowings. This approach was considered suitable only for very small borrowers i.e. where the requirements of credit were less than Rs.10 lacs Second method of lending This is the most commonly used methods by banks. Under this method, it was thought that the borrower should provide for a minimum of 25% of total current assets out of long-term funds i.e., owned funds plus term borrowings. A certain level of credit for purchases and other current liabilities will be available to fund the build up of current assets and the bank will provide the balance (MPBF). Consequently, total current liabilities inclusive of bank borrowings could not exceed 75% of current assets. RBI stipulated that the working capital needs of all borrowers enjoying fund based credit facilities of more than Rs. 10 lacs should be appraised (calculated) under this method. Third methods of lending Under this method, the borrower's contribution from long term funds will be to the extent of the entire CORE CURRENT ASSETS, which has been defined by the Study Group as representing the absolute minimum level of raw materials, process stock, finished goods and stores which are in the pipeline to ensure continuity of production and a minimum of 25% of the balance current assets should be financed out of the long term funds plus term borrowings. But This method was not accepted for implementation.
44
The level of credit limits to be assessed by turnover method ' has since been increased to Rs. 2.00 crores for all categories of borrowers and further to Rs. 5.00 crores for SSI units. The banks have further been given discretion to apply this method upto any level of limits not below the limits specified by Reserve Bank of India and frame a suitable policy in this regard.
Detailed ratio analysis for the case study of XYZ Media Ltd. Has been mentioned in the next section.
45
102.69 31.01.13 He has experience of more than a decade in the field of advertising. Has rich experience in the field of real estate, hospitality & timber imports. 25.55 31.01.13 More than four years of experience in advertising field.
Mr. Y
Director
27
Mr. Z
Director
45
34.60 31.01.13 Worked as director in MNC. He is associated with advertising field for more than 9 years.
46
REQUIREMENT OF: Enhancement in cash credit limits & LG limit to Rs.5.00crs & Rs.2.60crs respectively with projected sales of Rs 26 crores for the year 2013-14 To raise term loan of 6.60 crores PURPOSE: In 2010, company acquired two major tenders for a term of five years from DMRC. For the same purpose we issued a bank Guarantee of Rs 216.00lacs on behalf of the subject company in favour of DMRC. Company requires term loan to erect 42 super structures at Gwalior for advertising
Security
Prime Security -Stocks- Rs 160.00 lacs -Book Debts- Rs 1000.00 lacs -Fixed Assets- Rs 420.00 lacs (As per ABS- 31.03.13) Rs.1580 lacs
Total value:
Collateral security
Total value:
Forced Sales Value of property (FSV) Agra- 35.00 lacs Faridabad- 156.00 lacs IP Extn. Delhi- 115.00 lacs Gujarat-60.00 lacs Fixed Deposit- 57.00 lacs Collateral Coverage: 51% Rs. 423 lacs
Banking Arrangement: Subject is presently enjoying CC limit of Rs 330.00lacs, Term loan of Rs 175.00lacs and LG of Rs 230.00lacs, from IOB, Vanasthali branch. Limits are utilized judiciously and operations in the account are reported to be satisfactory. Past Performance: Sales of the company are increasing continuously over the last 3 years. It achieved sales of Rs 910.74lacs in 2009-10 compared to Rs 884.70lacs in 2008-09, which translated in increase of 2.94% over previous year. In FY2010-11 they achieved sales of Rs 1470.58lacs i.e. 73.53% of their projections (`2000.00lacs). In FY 2011-12, company has estimated sales of Rs 2200.00lacs
47
(audited) (Provisional) (Projections) 1,976.42 59.26 50.18 96.52 1,523.39 3.72 1,368.78 0.98 0.26 2,400.00 57.40 34.60 105.60 1,505.72 3.62 1,420.72 0.92 0.27 2,600.00 58.65 52.65 112.65 1,414.37 3.11 1,490.37 0.87 0.32
(audited) (Provisional) (Projections) 1,368.78 786.14 559.11 2,714.03 374.88 0.00 2,082.50 0.00 2,714.02 1,420.72 736.00 574.25 2,730.97 420.00 0.00 2,079.97 0.00 2,730.97 1,490.37 620.00 671.30 2,781.67 460.00 0.00 2,085.67 0.00 2,781.67
48
The TNW increased from Rs 1222.24 lacs in 2010-11 to Rs 1368.78 lacs in FY 2011-12 by retention of profits of Rs 50.18 and balance by induction of capital by Rs 96.36 lacs. Further in 2012-13 the TNW of the company increased to Rs 1420.72 lacs by retaining profits of Rs 34.60 lacs and balance by induction of fresh capital of Rs 17.34 lacs.The company further projected to achieve the TNW of Rs 1490.37 lacs in FY 2013-14 by retention of profits of Rs 52.65 lacs and balance by induction of fresh capital of Rs 17.00 lacs. The subjects projected TNW of Rs 1581.32 lacs for the FY 2014-15 by retention of Rs 72.95 lacs and balance by increasing the capital by Rs 18.00 lacs, which is acceptable.
GRAPH -1
TNW(in lacs)
1600 1400 1200 1000 800 600 400 1222.24 1368.78 1420.72 1490.37
200
0 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15
49
GRAPH 2
TOL/TNW
1.2 1 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.66 0.98 0.92 0.87
0.2
0 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15
GRAPH - 3
0.28
2011-12
2012-13
2013-14
2014-15
50
GRAPH-4
400
200 0
2011-12
2012-13
2013-14
2014-15
Current ratio
It helps to measure liquidity and financial strength, indication of availability of current assets to pay current liabilities. The higher the ratio betters the liquidity position. Generally it should be at least 1.33. Current ratio for the company is at a comfortable level from last 4 years Current ratio for the company is at a comfortable level from last 4 years. CR for the company as on 31.03.2011 was 3.58, which is well above the benchmark level of 1.25:1(for SME units). For FY 2011-12, it is at 3.72 & estimated at 3.62 as on 31.03.13. The projected CR is 3.11 & 3.20 as on 31.03.14 & 31.03.15 respectively, which may be accepted. However debtor needs to be realized on a faster pace to improve liquidity
51
GRAPH -5
Current Ratio
3.8 3.6 3.4 3.2 3 2.8 2011-12 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 3.11 3.58 3.72 3.62
GRAPH- 6
52
GRAPH-7
40.74
GRAPH-8
53
NPBT to Sales
5 4 3 2 1 3.13 2.4 3.85 3.1
0
2011-2 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15
NPAT to TNW
4 3.5 3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 3.67 2.58 2.44
3.53
2011-2
2012-13
2013-14
2014-15
54
NPAT to Sales
3 2.5 2 1.5 1 0.5 0 2011-2 2012-13 2013-14 2014-15 2.14 2.54 2.03
1.44
Particulars
31.03.2011 (Audited)
Stock The average inventory period for raw material is reducing over the years. It has reduced from 3.08 months as on 31.03.11 to 2.89 months as on 31.03.12. It is further reducing to 1.52 months & 1 month as on 31.03.13 & 31.03.14 respectively. The subjects further projected to reduce the stovk holding to 0.87 months which is acceptable.
55
Sundry Debtors The holding level for Debtors is 5 months of sale. In view of the activity and past trend the said holding level is acceptable. However branch to arrive at DP on Debtors upto 120 days old debtors only.
Sundry Creditors The holding level of creditors has increased from 0.05 months to 0.11 months as on 31.03.2012. It has reduced to 0.10 months as on 31.03.2013. the projected holding level as on 31.03.2013 &b 31.03.2014 is 0.11 months & 0.13 months respectively which is acceptable
56
RECOMMENDATIONS
1. All the documents required to appraise the project should be asked at the time of application only rather than later by the bank 2. The bank must bring more transparency in appraisal of the project, there should be explanation for a appraisal of the project that was sanctioned by higher authority. 3. The bank must not rely on software or information provided by the client the bank should dig in for other sources in order to draw a real picture for the company. 4. Credit scoring allows lenders to determine whether or not you fill the profile of the type of customers they are looking for. 5. Banks should not rely on the documents provided by the client,they must inspect each and every element of credit document. 6. Banks concerned should continuously monitor loans to identify accounts that have potential to become non-performing. 7. At the time of projections due to lack of documents, the projections are done. 8. Indian Overseas Bank uses only ratio analysis tool for assessment, it should also bring Capital Budgeting Techniques for assessment of working capital. 9. Bank provide loan on the basis of only re-payment capacity of the borrower and hence it is suggested to adopt some modern methods to appraise the loan to the business to check the feasibility of the project for appraising such high amount of loan. 10. Bank must extend working capital finance through non-fund based facilities. 11. Another ideal method would be to use LC as the primary source of extending, working capital clubbed with bill discounting. This would ensure that the credit isput to the right use by the borrower and repayment is guaranteed to the bank. 12. The bank must further secure themselves by holding a second charge on all the fixed assets of the borrower.
57
LIMITATIONS
1. As far as the illustration and analysis of the case study is concerned, the project is limited to Indian Overseas Bank, Regional office , Rajendra place 2. Matters related to Banks asset classification / income recognition procedures, investment are not given by the bank. 3. The project involves a case study of a firm for which the entire assessment has been done but the personal details and the companys name are intentionally kept hidden. 4. The project uses only ratio analysis tool for working capital assessment and it does not involve various other financial tool like capital budgeting technique. 5. The study of the project is limited to the types of advances funded by the bank i.e.IOB and not all types of advances.
58
CONCLUSION
Credit appraisal is done to check the commercial, financial & technical viability of the project proposed its funding pattern & further checks the primary or collateral security cover available for the recovery of such funds Following points has been taken out of the project as the main crux of the study which Bank considers while sanctioning the working capital limit to the concern: 1. Turnover size of the concern: The bank normally gives working capital limit upto 2025 % of the turnover estimated (for the year under review) by the concern. 2. Current ratio should be 1.33: 1. Hence all the CR ratio level must above the benchmark level of 1.33; only then the proposal would be accepted. 3. Total Outside Liability/ Net worth Ratio should lie in the limit of 4:1. 4. As a measure to incentive to export sector while calculating the margin i.e. 25% of current assets, export receivables are excluded from current assets. 5. Additional credit needs of exporters arising out of firm order/ confirmed letter of credit (which are not taken into account while fixing regular credit limits of borrowers) are to be met in full even if sanction of such additional credit limit exceeds MPBF 6. Credit limits of the borrowing concern in the sugar industry may be determined on the basis of a current ratio of 1:1. 7. Sick/weak units under rehabilitations will be exempted from the application of 2nd method of lending. 8. Term loan Instalments payable within the next twelve months time are excluded from current liabilities while calculating MPBF but included while calculating Current Ratio. From the above discussion we can say that bank credit occupies an important place in financing working capital requirements of industries. Working capital financing is a specialized line of business and largely dominated by commercial banks. Generally, the bank finance for meeting working capital needs is easily available to firms. But it has been always difficult to determine the norms for an adequate quantum of bank credit required by an industry for working capital purpose. Various committees have been set up for examining the working capital financing by banks and to recommend norms for and to regulate bank credit. Besides this from time to time, Reserve Bank of India has been issuing guidelines and directives to the banks to strengthen the procedures and norms for working capital financing.
59
REFERENCES
1. Real Estate Advances-Guidelines.ADV (2009),ADV/422/2010-11 ,BOI Advances General Instructions ,volume 2. 2. RBI. Management of advances(2012).RBI recommendations,Annexture 1,para 2.7 3. Bhalla, V. K., (2003), Working Capital Management, New Delhi, Anmol Publications Private Limited, 5th Edition. 4. Srinivasa, S., (1999), Cash and Working Capital Management, New Delhi, Vikas Publishing House Private Limited. 5. Tandon, Chore, Kannan and Certain Other Committees Recommendation,Retrived from http://www.rushabhinfosoft.com/webpages/BHTML/CH-16.htm 6. Credit facilities,Retrived from www.iob.in 7. Tondon committee and Nayak Committee Recommendations, Retrived from www.docstoc.com 8. RBI. Master Circular- Loans and Advances Statutory and Other Restrictions(201112), RBI/2011-12/59,Retrived from http://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/BS_ViewMasCirculardetails.aspx?id=6514 9. Market portfolio,Retrived from http://www.indiainfoline.com. 10. Pamela Peterson Drake( 2012),study on Financial Ratio Analysis
60