0CT0BER 2u1S

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

o


NGO Monitor's mission is to provide information and
analysis, promote accountability, and support discussion
on the reports and activities of NGOs claiming to
advance human rights and humanitarian agendas.
1 Ben-Maimon Blvd.
Jerusalem 92262, Israel
Tel: +972-2-566-1020
Fax: +972-77-511-7030
mail@ngo-monitor.org
www.ngo-monitor.org
The Amutah for NGO Responsibility R.A. (") 580465508 #
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21



C0NTENTS:
Executive Summaiy
Intiouuction
Political Founuations:
Rosa Luxembuig Stiftung
Beiniich Boll Stiftung
Fiieuiich Ebeit Stiftung
Willy Bianut Centei }eiusalem
Fiieuiich-Naumann-Stiftung (FNF)
Koniau Auenauei Stiftung
Bans-Seiuel-Stiftung

Inuepenuent Bevelopment Nu0s
Neuico Inteinational

Chuich oiganizations
Biot fi uie Welt - Evangelischei Entwicklungsuienst
NISERE0R

uoveinmental oiganizations
Beutsche uesellschaft fi Inteinationale Zusammenaibeit umbB (uIZ)
Eiinneiung, veiantwoitung, Zukunft (EvZ) Remembiance, Responsibility anu Futuie
Institute foi Foieign Cultuial Relations (IFA)

Conclusions anu Analysis
Appenuix A: compiehensive list of Isiaeli anu Palestinian oiganizations ieceiving ueiman funuing.
Appenuix B: Correspondence between NGO Monitor and funding frameworks




"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z

EXEC0TIvE S0NNARY

ueiman goveinment funuing foi political auvocacy Nu0s in Isiael anu the Palestinian Authoiity is
officially dedicated to combating poverty, securing food, establishing peace, freedom, democracy and
human iights, shaping globalization in a socially equitable mannei, anu pieseiving the enviionment anu
natural resources.
In contiast to the moial objectives, the funuing suppoits iauical oiganizations that oppose peace,
piomote uemonization, biaseu boycott movements as pait of political waifaie, anu in some cases,
blatant antisemitism. Nillions of euios oiiginating with ueiman taxpayeis aie pioviueu annually to
these Nu0s. Funuing fiamewoiks incluue poweiful political founuations associateu with ueiman
political paities, which often seek to impose theii iueologies anu objectives on Isiaelis anu Palestinians,
as well as uiiect funuing fiom the ueiman Ninistiy of Foieign Affaiis, the Ninistiy foi Economic
Coopeiation anu Bevelopment (BNZ), anu othei bianches.
Nu0 giantees incluue some of the most iauical political auvocacy Nu0s opeiating in Isiael anu the
Palestinian Authoiity:
"#$%&#' ueiman goveinment funuing has come fiom the (#)* +,-./0,&1 2'34',51, 6.73$#
85'.&5*'3#5*9, 63).&.#&, anu :;". This Israeli NGO seeks to raise public awaieness of the
Palestinian NakbaThe memory and responsibility that the Jewish public should take on the
Palestinian Nakba aie basic conuitions to peace between people, but it is not enough. Along with
it, the iights of the iefugees to ietuin must be accepted. This agenua is equivalent to calling foi
the elimination of Isiael as the nation-state of the }ewish people. Zochiot also accuses Isiael of
ethnic cleansing and forcible displacement and dispossession of the Palestinian people.

<#*93'3#5 #4 =#/.5 4#& >.*$. ?<=>@ ieceiveu NIS 197,969 (2u1u) anu NIS 146,u26 (2u11)
fiom the (#)* +,-./0,&1 2'34',51. CWP, which uesciibes itself as a feminist organization
against the occupation of Palestine and for a just peace, is a leader of the boycott, divestment
and sanctions (BDS) movement, particularly via the Who Profits campaign. The Who Profits
website serves as an online database and information centre, initiated in response to the
Palestinian call for boycott, divestment and sanctions (BDS) on Israel... CWP officials have been
photogiapheu holuing a flag of the Populai Fiont foi the Libeiation of Palestine an E0-
iecognizeu teiioiist oiganization iesponsible foi numeious attacks against civilians. (Since the
uistiibution of this iepoit to some of CWPs funders, this image has been removed from CWPs
Facebook page.)
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21




634'*% ieceiveu $24,416 fiom the A.35&3$% B#.99 2'34',51 in 2u11 (it is not listeu as a uonoi in
2u12) anu $92,869 fiom the C#5&*7 D7.5*,.& 2'34',51 in 2u11 anu 2u12. Miftahs stated
mission is to promote the piinciples of uemociacy anu goou goveinance within vaiious
components of Palestinian society; it fuithei seeks to engage local anu inteinational public
opinion and official circles on the Palestinian cause. The first of the Strategic Objectives is to
uisseminate the Palestinian naiiative anu uiscouise globally to both official anu populai bouies
anu uecision-makers. Miftahs publications accuse Israel of massacie, cultuial genociue,
wai ciimes, and apaitheiu. On March 27, 2013, MIFTAH Arabic-language website publisheu
an aiticle iepeating the antisemitic bloou libel, in response to U.S. President Obamas support
foi Isiael anu his celebiation of the Passovei Seuei. Aftei significant public ciiticism, NIFTAB
iemoveu the aiticle, but attackeu the blogger who exposed the article for smearing the
oiganization anu uownplayeu the centiality of the bloou libel in the aiticle.

>%E)3$3*5) 4#& A,/*5 (31%') 8)&*.9 ?>A(F8@ ieceiveu NIS 9S,uuu (2u11) anu NIS 94,uuu
(2u1u) fiom 6.73$# 85'.&5*'3#5*9, anu 1.7 million NIS fiom ::G (2u1u-2u12). PBR-I is veiy
active in political advocacy and demonization. An October 2011 publication Boctoiing the
Eviuence, Abanuoning the victim, accused Israeli doctors and institutions of involvement in the
torture and ill-treatment of Palestinians. Betaileu analysis of the sweeping claims
uemonstiates ueeply flaweu ieseaich, anu the Isiael Neuical Association uenounceu the highly
selective publication foi eiasing impoitant uetails. Baseu on faulty methouology, PBR-I asseits
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[

that Israeli security officers routinely employ interrogation methods which amount to torture
anu ill-treatment and that medical professionals are frequently involved either actively or
passively in toituie oi ill-treatment. Lexical or legal definitions for torture and ill-treatment
aie not pioviueu anu useu inconsistently. Buiing the uaza wai (Bec 2uu8-}an. 2uu9), PBR-I
accuseu Israel of using extreme and disproportionate force against the population of Gaza
and of targeting medical teams and aid convoys. Dr. Yoram Blachar, former president of the
Woilu Neuical Association, ciiticizeu PBR-I as a iauical political gioup uisguiseu as a meuical
oiganization. See NGO Monitor Monograph, Nu0 Nalpiactice (July 2013) for more
infoimation about PBR-I.

H.)% G35 ieceiveu NIS 2Su,uuu (2u12) fiom I%. 85)'3','. 4#& J#&.315 <,9',&*9 (.9*'3#5)
?85)'3',' 4K& D,)9*57)0.L3.%,51.5 F 8JD@, a goveinment fiamewoik closely cooiuinateu with
the ueiman Ninistiy of Foieign Affaiis. Yesh Dins stateu mission is to oppose the continuing
violation of Palestinian human rights, monitoring law enfoicement on settleis anu membeis of
the secuiity foices anu militaiy couit pioceuuies. Founueu by Bioi Etkes (foimeily of Peace
Now), Yesh Din employs demonization and apaitheiu rhetoric in some of its activities,
exploiting the language of human iights foi political anu iueological objectives. Yesh Bin is a
leauei in attempts to poitiay Isiael anu its secuiity foices as unaccountable to the iule of law, as
pait of a wiuei stiategy of biinging false war crimes cases against Israeli officials in foreign
couits anu in the Inteinational Ciiminal Couit (ICC).


Bespite theii ielationship with the ueiman goveinment, 4,57351 4&*/.M#&N) .-%303' 93/3'.7
'&*5)O*&.5$E *57 *$$#,5'*0393'EP 35$9,7351 35 &.4,)*9) '# &.)O#57 ),0)'*5'3Q.9E '# R,.&3.) 4&#/
STU 6#53'#&. Nost fiamewoiks uiscusseu in this stuuy uo not publish the amounts pioviueu to the
iecipient oiganizations; anu this infoimation, wheie it is available, is usually pioviueu by the iecipients
in iepoits to the Isiaeli goveinment. In auuition, the piocess by which these ueiman goveinment
bianches, political founuations, anu chuich aiu oiganizations, whose buugets come fiom taxpayei
funus, select piojects to Nu0s is hiuuen. They lack oveisight mechanisms to monitoi anu evaluate the
impact of taxpayei funueu activities by these political auvocacy Nu0s.
These Nu0s that aie funueu by ueimany then influence ueiman policy anu public peiceptions of the
conflict, ieinfoicing pio-Palestinian anu anti-Isiael bias as ieflecteu in many aieas.

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g

0 N T B I S B A S I S , S T U 6U S 8 I U ( ( : < U 66: S G 2 I AD I :











V@ TRANSPARENCY REuARBINu ALL Nu0 uRANTS 0RIuINATINu WITB
uERNAN TAXPAYER F0NBS BE INCREASEB SIuNIFICANTLY,
INCL0BINu ALL B0C0NENTATI0N RELATEB T0 BECISI0N NAKINu
ANB EvAL0ATI0NS, AS WELL AS INv0LvENENT 0F PARTNER
0RuANIZATI0NS;
W@ ALL F0NBINu NECBANISNS SB00LB NAKE PR0P0SEB uRANTS
P0BLIC AT LEAST 6u BAYS PRI0R T0 ANY TRANSFER 0F F0NBS (PRE-
N0TIFICATI0N) IN 0RBER T0 ALL0W F0R S0BNISSI0N 0F RELEvANT
NATERIALS ANB F0R P0BLIC BISC0SSI0N;
X@ BEBICATEB ANB INBEPENBENT S0PERvIS0RY NECBANISNS BE
ESTABLISBEB T0 REvIEW ANB EvAL0ATE ALL Nu0 uRANTS ANB
ENS0RE B0E BILIuENCE; IN PARTIC0LAR, A PARLIANENTARY
0vERSIuBT C0NNITTEE SB00LB BE ESTABLISBEB F0R TBIS
P0RP0SE;
Y@ uERNAN u0vERNNENT F0NBINu FRANEW0RKS ENS0RE TBAT
ISRAELI Nu0 uRANTEES C0NPLY WITB ISRAELI F0NBINu
TRANSPARENCY LAWS.
Z@ ALL F0NBINu FRANEW0RKS SB00LB RE-EvAL0ATE u0IBELINES
ANB BIRECT TBIS F0NBINu T0WARBS PR0}ECTS ANB
0RuANIZATI0NS TBAT ACT0ALLY PR0N0TE.

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6

INTR0B0CTI0N

The Nu0 Foium of the 2uu1 Buiban Confeience auopteu a stiategy of political waifaie anu
delegitimization against Israel, using allegations of apartheid, racism, war crimes, and similar
ihetoiic. Implementeu by a netwoik of Nu0s, this stiategy opeiates unuei the banneis of human iights,
uemociacy, peace, anu humanitaiian aiu. These Nu0s exploit tactics uevelopeu against the apaitheiu
goveinment in South Afiica, incluuing boycotts, uivestment anu sanctions (BBS), anu abuse univeisal
jurisdiction frameworks, such as the International Criminal Court, to target Israeli officials (lawfare).
Nuch of the funuing foi the Nu0s that leau these uemonization campaigns baseu on uouble stanuaius
anu false allegations comes fiom Euiopean goveinments.1
In this iepoit, Nu0 Nonitoi focuses on ueiman suppoit foi Isiaeli anu Palestinian Nu0s that aie
centially involveu in this Buiban stiategy of political waifaie. We pioviue systematic analysis on the
activities of these oiganizations, theii ielationships with theii iespective ueiman counteipaits, anu
when possible, funuing uetails. Foi a full list of Isiaeli anu Palestinian oiganizations ieceiving ueiman
funuing, see Appenuix A.2
Officially, the objectives of German foreign aid include combating poverty, securing food,
establishing peace, fieeuom, uemociacy anu human iights, shaping globalization in a socially equitable
mannei, anu pieseiving the enviionment anu natuial resources. However, in contrast to these moral
objectives, the ieseaich ieveals Nu0 funuing policies that piomote conflict anu oppose these moial
values. This funding is significant; the Ministry for Economic Cooperation and Developments 2013
buuget for civil society and economic organizations and institutions is 729 million. In auuition to
goveinment agencies, funuing is pioviue thiough ueiman political founuations giants given to
inuepenuent uevelopment Nu0s, anu chuich oiganizations.
Reflecting the lack of tianspaiency, the uiffeient ueiman funuing fiamewoiks uo not pioviue
uetaileu infoimation on funuing foi Isiaeli anu Palestinian paitnei oiganizations. The funuing uetails
pioviueu in this iepoit, then, have been gatheieu by analyzing annual iepoits anu iepoits to the Isiaeli
Registiai of Non-Piofits, anu in coiiesponuence with the ueiman fiamewoiks.



1
ueialu N. Steinbeig, The Politics of Nu0s, Buman Rights anu the Aiab-Isiael Conflict, <8$&#0 >1)*+#8 16.2 Summei 2u11
!
A full analysis of all of the activities and grants of these organizations is beyond the scope of NGO Monitor! #$%&$'( $%&
)(!*+),(!- ./0! )(1*)' 0! 20#0'(& '* '/( 1*20'0,$2 $&3*,$,4 &0#(%!0*%!-
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

y

F0NBI Nu
FRANEW0RK





The Bunuesministeiium fi wiitschaftliche Zusammenaibeit unu Entwicklung (BNZ Ninistiy
foi Economic Coopeiation anu Bevelopment) is the majoi institution iesponsible foi ueiman foieign
aiu. The Ninistiy has uiffeient channels foi woiking with foieign paitneis, ianging fiom financial
suppoit thiough loans pioviueu by the KfW Bevelopment Bank anu the ueiman Investment anu
Bevelopment Society, to technical assistance conuucteu by the Beutsche uesellschaft fi Inteinationale
Zusammenaibeit (ueiman Society foi Inteinational Coopeiation, uIZ). These oiganizations iepiesent
the BNZ anu aie ultimately contiolleu by the goveinment (voifeluoiganisationen).
Auuitionally, the ueiman goveinment uses political founuations, Stiftungen, to piomote
uemociacy anu civil society in taigeteu countiies. Political founuations affiliateu with political paities in
the Bunuestag ieceive funuing as pait of the ueiman political system. Each political gioup is associateu
with a founuation: Foi example, The Social Bemociatic Paity of ueimany (SPB) is associateu with
Fiieuiich Ebeit Founuation; the ueiman uieen Paity (Bie uinen) with Beiniich Boll Founuation; anu
The Left paity with the Rosa Luxembuig Founuation. uoveinment funuing is piopoitional to electoial
iesults, with buugets ieflecting the piopoition of the coiiesponuing paity in Pailiament following each
election.
Chuiches also play a cential iole in ueiman foieign aiu. The two main chuich-ielateu
oiganizations that ieceive funuing fiom the Feueial Ninistiy foi Economic Coopeiation anu
Bevelopment (Bunuesministeiium fi wiitschaftliche Zusammenaibeit unu Entwicklung-BNZ) aie Biot
fi uie Welt EED, which is the Protestant churchs aid framework, and MISEREOR, associated with the
Catholic Chuich. Auuitionally, inuepenuent Nu0s, such as Neuico Inteinational, paitnei with the
ueiman goveinment to funu piojects in Isiael anu the Palestinian Authoiity.




"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

8

P0LI TI CAL
F00NBATI 0NS





The ueiman goveinment channels suppoit to Isiaeli political auvocacy Nu0s via political founuations
(Stiftungen). These founuations ieceive money fiom the feueial buuget in piopoition to the size of theii
coiiesponuing paity within the Bunuestag.
In tuin, the political founuations funu a wiue vaiiety of Isiaeli anu Palestinian oiganizations anu ielateu
activities, ianging fiom mainstieam acauemic institutions to fiinge political Nu0s.
As noteu, this iepoit uoes not piesent a full analyses of these activities, but, in keeping with Nu0
Monitors mandate, focuses on German funding for and partnerships with organizations that engage in
the Buiban stiategy of political waifaie. Conceins iegaiuing the iole of these founuations in the
manipulation of Isiaeli uemociacy aie also uiscusseu. (See Appenuix A foi a full list of the Isiaeli anu
Palestinian Nu0s anu institutions.)
Reflecting a lack of tianspaiency, the iepoit also uemonstiates that these political founuations uo not
pioviue uetaileu infoimation on funuing foi Isiaeli anu Palestinian paitnei oiganizations. As such,
funuing infoimation piesenteu below is piimaiily pioviueu by iecipients in theii iepoits to the Isiaeli
Registiai of Non-Piofits, anu may be incomplete.

(U2D +[\:6B[(T 2I8JI[ST ?(+2@
RLS is the founuation of the ueiman paity Bie Linke a fai-Left paity that oiiginateu in East ueimany
baseu on a neo-Naixist iueological founuation. RLS has offices in Tel Aviv anu Ramallah that funu a
numbei of Isiaeli anu Palestinian Nu0s. The Tel Aviv RLS website (as of August 2u1S) featuies a call foi
NGO proposals aimed at strengthening Israeli civil society, including alternative education baseu on
uemociatic values anu piinciples such as soliuaiity, toleiance, non-violence The program enuoises
civil actois who stiive foi uemociatic paiticipation, social justice anu human iights, anu who stiuggle
against iacism, xenophobia anu anti-Semitism. This agenda reflects what is seen as a highly intrusive
effoit to manipulate the Isiaeli uemociatic piocess.
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

q

For 2014, the call for proposals emphasizes a number of political aims, engagement of Isiaeli-
Palestinian youths anuoi stuuents, concentiating on questions of iuentity, anu *7#O'351 *
O&#1&.))3Q. O.&)O.$'3Q.; Piojects that aie connecteu to the social piotest movement anu aie woiking
towaius enhancing the competencies of peiipheial communities that aie stiuggling foi socio-economic
iights; Piojects uiiecteu at iesisting anu counteiacting oppiessive stiuctuies baseu on iacism,
5*'3#5*93)/, sexism anu /393'*&3)/ within the Isiaeli society (emphasis added).
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
In 2011, the foundations budget was 42.S million. RLF ieceiveu 42,111,310 in ueiman feueial
funuing.
RLS lists its Israeli NGO Paitneis & Piojects, but does not list names of Palestinian NGO grantees nor
publish uetails of funuing foi eithei. The funuing uetails below aie pioviueu by the Isiaeli iecipients in
iepoits to the Registiai of Non-piofits.
I*09. V] (#)* +,-./0,&1 2'34',51 ?(+2@] 8)&*.93 >*&'5.&)P >#93'3$*9 D7Q#$*$E STU) ?W^V^FW^VW@





#
Not Disclosed throughout the report refers to information that was not listed in annual reports and not provided through
$%&&'()%*+'*$' ,-./ ./' &'()'$.-0' 12*+-*3 1&45',%&67
8)&*.93 STU)] D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Zochiot Not Biscloseu
S

Bagaua Basmalit Not Biscloseu
Baokets Not Biscloseu
Sheikh }aiiah Soliuaiity Novement (S}SN) Not Biscloseu
ACRI Not Biscloseu
Coalition of Women foi Peace (CWP)
NIS 197,969 (2u1u)
NIS 146,u26 (2u11)
Combatants foi Peace Not Biscloseu
Negev Coexistence Foium foi Civil Equality Not Biscloseu
Sauaka Reut NIS 19u,9S2 (2u1u)
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

o

(+2 >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
"#$%&#' ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: Zochiot is an Isiaeli Nu0 establisheu in oiuei to raise public
awareness of the Palestinian NakbaThe memory and responsibility that the Jewish public should take
on the Palestinian Nakba aie basic conuitions to peace between people, but it is not enough. Along with
it, the rights of the refugees to return must be accepted. This agenua is equivalent to calling foi the
elimination of Isiael as the nation-state of the }ewish people. Zochiot also accuses Isiael of ethnic
cleansing and forcible displacement and dispossession of the Palestinian people.
RLS suppoits Zochrots educational program Bow uo We Say Nakba in Bebiew: The project offers
school teacheis an alteinative appioach by intiouucing inteiesteu Isiaeli teacheis to a ciitical
appioach to the histoiy of Isiael by teaching about the Nakba, a topic that is entiiely absent fiom
Israels formal and informal education systems. On September 29, Zochrot hosted a conference From
Truth to Redress: Realizing the Return of Palestinian Refugees. Accoiuing to piomotional mateiials,
The conference [was] made possible thanks to the generous support ofRosa Luxemburg Foundation.
However, in correspondence with NGO Monitor, RLS wrote, The Rosa Luxemburg Stiftung and its Israel
Office has not sponsored the conference The program only mentions the RLS as a principal
cooperation partner what is correct (sic).
A*1*7* A*)/*93' ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@ is an inteinet platfoim that piesents highly uistoiteu
naiiatives of the Aiab-Isiaeli conflict. Foi example, a }uly 2u1S aiticle by uiueon Spiio (of Yesh uvul)
titled Boycott As a Cure, the Chances for Peace, Refusal, Release of Prisoners and Roger Waters
employs apartheid rhetoric and promotes BDS, claiming the symbol of the Star of David represents a
iacist pig that operates a military dictatorship against another. A*#N.') iuns a similai inteinet
platfoim to Bagaua Basmalit. RFL has also not uiscloseu the amount of funuing it has gianteu to
Baokets.

2%.3N% `*&&*% 2#937*&3'E 6#Q./.5' ?2`26@ ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: Since its inception as the
Sheikh }aiah Soliuaiity Novement (nameu aftei a }eiusalem neighboihoou chaiacteiizeu by intense
piopeity uisputes), this Nu0 has become incieasingly inflammatoiy in its ihetoiic anu activities. Saia
Benninga, a leauei of the gioup, has accuseu Isiael of fascism and ethnic uisciimination against its
iesiuents, and protesters at rallies have held signs declaring Apaitheiu is heie. [Note: A webpage
with the Apaitheiu is heie poster was later removed from the Solidarity website.]
<#*93'3#5 #4 =#/.5 4#& >.*$. ?<=>@ ieceiveu NIS 197,969 (2u1u) anu NIS 146,u26 (2u11) fiom RLS.
The Nu0 uesciibes itself as a feminist organization against the occupation of Palestine and for a just
peace. CWP is a leader of the boycott, divestment and sanctions campaign, particularly via the Who
Profits campaign. The Who Profits website serves as an online database and information centre,
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21



initiated in response to the Palestinian call foi boycott, uivestment anu sanctions (BBS) on Isiael CWP
officials have been photogiapheu holuing a PFLP flag the Populai Fiont foi the Libeiation of Palestine
is an E0-iecognizeu teiioiist oiganization anu is iesponsible foi numeious attacks against Isiaeli
civilians. (Since the distribution of this report to some of CWPs funders, this image has been removed
fiom CWPs Facebook page.)
<#/0*'*5') 4#& >.*$. ?<J>@ ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: The organizations political goals aie to
terminate the Israeli occupation, to halt the settlement project and to establish a Palestinian state with
its capital in East Jerusalem, alongside the State of Israel. CFP was part of the Remove the Siege = Stop
the War coalition that stood in defiance of the siege and the destruction and military
bombardment...being exercised in Gaza with careless disregard[and] protest the ongoing massacie,
in paitneiship with highly politicizeu gioups such as New Piofile, AIC, ICABB, Taayush anu Coalition of
Women foi Peace (see above). The Isiael Foieign Ninistiy iepoiteuly accuseu a joint toui of CFP anu
Bieaking the Silence of piomoting a political message speaking out against Israels policy in the
territories as opposed to their stated mission to euucate towaius ieconciliation anu non-violent
stiuggle. RLS funuing suppoits CFPs highly controversial and contentious Alternative Israeli-
Palestinian Memorial Day Ceremony, which challeng(es) the consensual narrative as cultivated by the
state-choreographed ceremonies.
S.1.Q <#.-3)'.5$. J#&,/ 4#& <3Q39 :R,*93'E ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: The Negev Coexistence Foium
foi Civil Equality, baseu in Isiael, woiks to provide a framework for Jewish-Aiab collaboiative effoits
in the stiuggle foi civil equality anu the auvancement of mutual toleiance anu coexistence...iemains
focuseu solely on the specific pioblems confionting the Negev. The organization is active in
uelegitimizing Isiael inteinationally, incluuing 0niteu Nations submissions calling for world
intervention to aid the Bedouin community and identifying Israel as a discriminate country that
uenies many iights by forced politicization and policy of displacement. accuse Israel of double
standards and discriminatory actions against the Bedouin population in the Negev. During a June 2013
session at the Euiopean Pailiament, a Negev Coexistence Foium iepiesentative iefeiieu to Isiaeli
policy in the Negev as apartheid.
2*7*N* (.,' ieceiveu NIS 19u,9S2 (2u1u) anu NIS 119,826(2u11). Sauaka-Reut educates and
empoweis }ewish anu Palestinian Isiaeli youth anu univeisity stuuents to puisue social anu political
change thiough bi-national partnership. Its activities promote the Palestinian victimization narrative,
anu involve coopeiation with iauical Nu0s incluuing CWP anu Zochiot (see below), foi a pioject aimeu
at Introducing the Palestinian Nakba into the Israeli Public.
D<(8 ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: ACRI claims that it is is committed to promoting the universality of
human iights anu uefenuing the iights of all, iegaiuless of ieligion, nationality, sex, ethnicity, political
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z

affiliation, sexual orientation, or socioeconomic background. A significant portion of its activities focus
on paitisan political auvocacy, incluuing use of labels such as apaitheiu, referring to Israeli efforts to
prevent terror attacks from Gaza as collective punishment, anu claims that the secuiity baiiiei is a
violation of inteinational law.

A:8S(8<A Ba++ 2I8JI[ST ?AB2@
The Beiniich Boll Stiftung (BBS) is affiliateu with the ueiman Bie uinen (uieen Paity). The founuation
has offices in Tel Aviv anu Ramallah. Keistin Nllei, iecently appointeu heau of the Tel Aviv office of the
Beiniich Boll Founuation, co-initiateu a ueiman uieen paity campaign to label anu boycott Isiaeli
goous piouuceu ovei the uieen Line. According to HBS president Ralf Fucks, HBS support(s) political
initiatives aiming to achieve a negotiateu peace between Isiael anu the Palestinians, anu we aie
committeu to inteinational guaiantees foi a two-state solution.
BBS is a long time funuing paitnei of +972, a blog that iegulaily featuies the false apaitheiu analogy.
(See below.) In iesponse to ciiticism foi funuing to +972, BBS spokespeison Kaioline Richtei tolu the
?#$)8&0#% /.81 that HBS sees the apartheid application as part of critical solidarity with Israel.
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
In 2u12, BBS iepoiteu a buuget of 47,724,963. The founuation ieceiveu 22 million in ueiman feueial
suppoit foi inteinational coopeiation activities. The BBS Isiael anu Palestine websites pioviue limiteu
infoimation on its cuiient funuing paitneis. Funuing infoimation below is pioviueu by the iecipients.
I*09. W] Beiniich Boll Stiftung (BBS): Palestinian anu Isiaeli Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s (2uu9-
2u1S)
>*9.)'353*5 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Applieu Reseaich Institute (ARI}) Not Biscloseu (2u12)
Maan Development Center Not Biscloseu
Niftah $24,416 (2u11)
8)&*.93 STU)
Association foi Civil Rights in Isiael (ACRI) NIS Su,uuu (2u1u)
Combatants foi Peace Not Biscloseu
Kayan NIS 7S,uuu (2u1u)
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21



Nossawa Not Biscloseu
ShatilBimkom Not Biscloseu (2u1S)
+972
12,000 (2013)
12,000 (2012)
6,000 (2011)


AB2 >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
ISRAELI Nu0S
D))#$3*'3#5 4#& <3Q39 (31%') 35 8)&*.9 ?D<(8@ ieceiveu NIS Su,uuu (2u1u) fiom BBSb See RLS section
foi fuithei infoimation.
<#/0*'*5') 4#& >.*$. ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@] See RLS section of the iepoit foi fuithei infoimation.
Kayan ieceiveu NIS 7S,uuu (2u1u) fiom BBS. Kayan was founueu by Aiab feminist women with the
goal of auvancing the status of Aiab women in Isiael anu piotecting theii iights |anuj issues that tackle
the tension between nationality and genderas it relates specifically to Arab-Israeli women. Kayan co-
authoieu a iepoit with Physicians foi Buman Rights-Israel which characterized Israels Nationality Law
as racist.
6#))*M* ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: The Nossawa Centei claims to promote the economic, social,
cultuial anu political iights of the Palestinian Aiab citizens in Isiael, anu the iecognition of this
community a national inuigenous minoiity, with theii own national, cultuial anu histoiical
distinctiveness. Mossawa is consistently involved in the political demonization of Israel, including
labels such as iacism. Its iepoits to 0N committees often conuemn Isiaeli secuiity measuies with no
context of teiioiism anu exploit uistoiteu legal aiguments. In 2006, Mossawa published The Futuie
vision of the Palestinian Aiabs in Isiael. This document called Israel an ethnocratic state that cannot
be defined as democratic, and claimed that only Palestinian Arabs are the indigenous people of the
country, erasing Jewish historical ties to Israel and Jewish communal continuity. The iepoit also calleu
foi the eiauication of the Isiaeli flag anu national anthem, foi the iight of the Aiab minoiity to have a
veto over matters of national import, and for the immediate implementation of a Palestinian right of
return.
2%*'39cB3/N#/] ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@ Shatil is the Isiael-baseu opeiational fiamewoik of the New
Isiael Funu, active in cooiuinating anu pioviuing Isiaeli Nu0s with consulting, training, coalition-
building assistance and other services, including a number of highly politicized NGOs. Bimkom engages
in attempts to change Isiaeli goveinment policy on issues such as spatial planning, planning
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[

pioceuuies, housing iights, and amending the Planning anu Builuing Law anu the Fieeuom of
Infoimation Law. Campaigns have included attempts to ietioactively legalize illegal constiuction in
Aiab neighboihoous.
defW] ieceiveu 6,000 (2011), 12,000 (2012) anu 12,000 (2013): +972 is an online English-
language magazine that ioutinely piesents biaseu peispectives on the Aiab-Isiaeli conflict. A numbei
of +972s authors have invokeu the immoral and false apartheid analogy and support BDS. +972
published a cartoon (The hatei in the sky, Eli Valley, May 14, 2012) depicting Israeli Prime Minister
Benjamin Netanyahu iaping Piesiuent Baiack 0bama anu eating his limbs.
PALESTINIAN Nu0S
DOO93.7 (.).*&$% 85)'3','. ?D(8`@ ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: Founueu in 199u, ARI} claims to be a
non-piofit oiganization ueuicateu to piomoting sustainable uevelopment in the occupieu Palestinian
teiiitoiies anu the self-ieliance of the Palestinian people thiough gieatei contiol ovei theii natuial
resources. In contiast, its ieseaich is highly political anu biaseu. A Becembei 2uu8 publication labels
Jerusalems mayor a racist who supports ethnic cleansing. ARI} is active in piomoting BBS anu othei
anti-Isiael activities.
Maan Develop/.5' <.5'.& ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: In 2uu9 the oiganization publisheu Boycotts,
Divestment & Sanctions: Lessons learned in effective solidarity, a guide to grassroots and international
BDS campaigns. Maan Development Center iefeis to Israeli colonization, and Israeli governments are
described as consecutive occupation governments since 1948. The security barrier is consistently
referred to as the Apartheid Wall and the section that surrounds Qalqilya is described [a]s a control
mechanism, which takes on the form of an enclosed cage in this area, transforming it into an open-aii
prison.
634'*%] ieceiveu $24,416 fiom BBS in 2u11. The organizations stated mission is to piomote the
piinciples of uemociacy anu goou goveinance within vaiious components of Palestinian society; it
fuithei seeks to engage local anu inteinational public opinion anu official ciicles on the Palestinian
cause. The first of the Strategic Objectives is to disseminate the Palestinian narrative and discourse
globally to both official anu populai bouies anu uecision-makers. Miftahs publications accuse Israel of
massacie, cultuial genociue, wai ciimes, and apaitheiu. On March 27, 2013, MIFTAH publisheu
an Aiabic-language aiticle, in iesponse to 0.S. Piesiuent 0bamas support for Israel and his celebration
of the Passovei Seuei, iepeating the antisemitic bloou libel. Aftei significant public ciiticism, NIFTAB
iemoveu the aiticle, but attackeu the blogger who exposed the article for smearing the organization
anu uownplayeu the centiality of the bloou libel in the aiticle.

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g

J(8:G(8<A :B:(I 2I8JI[ST ?J:2@
The Fiieuiich Ebeit Stiftung is affiliateu with the Social Bemociatic Paity (Sozialuemokiatische Paitei
Beutschlanus - SPB). The founuation has offices anu opeiates piogiams in Beizliya anu }eiusalem. The
founuation cooperates closely with local partner organizations to jointly develop projects in the spirit
of uemociacy, genuei equality anu peaceful co-existence.
In December 2011, Michael Broning, director of FES Jerusalem office, co-wiote an aiticle with the
uiiectoi of the Palestinian uoveinment Neuia Centei in Ramallah, uhassan Khatib. The aiticle, What
about Israeli Rejection, was a rebuttal to an opinion article by two Israeli government officials (The
Pioblem is Palestinian Rejectionism) and argued that there is no problem of Palestinian rejectionism
anu that Isiaeli intiansience is the majoi impeuiment to peace. This type of collaboiation in piomoting
the Palestinian political naiiative is highly pioblematic anu inconsistent with ueiman goveinment
funuing foi FES.
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
The FES websites pioviue limiteu funuing uetails foi its Isiaeli anu Palestinian paitnei oiganizations.
(See below.)

I*09. X: Fiieuiich Ebeit Stiftung (FES)L Palestinian anu Isiaeli Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s
8)&*.93 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Ilam Not Biscloseu
Nossawa Not Biscloseu
Shatil (affiliateu with the New Isiael Funu)* Not Biscloseu

>*9.)'353*5 STU)


Palestinian Acauemic Society foi the Stuuy of
Inteinational Affaiis (PASSIA)
Not Biscloseu

*As an 0S-baseu non-piofit opeiating in Isiael, Shatil is not legally obligateu to iepoit foieign
goveinment funuing souices unuei the Isiaeli Nu0 funuing tianspaiency law.
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6

J:2 >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
ISRAELI Nu0S
Ilam ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: The Ilam Media Center for Arab Palestinians in Israel was founded in
2uuu in Nazaieth. Its mission is to strengthen the media cadre, raise awareness and educate
Palestinian society in Israel in media practices. Ilams iepoits anu publications ieflect piomotion of
the uemonization campaign, incluuing unsuppoiteu claims of bias anu uisciimination against Isiaeli
Aiab citizens of Isiael in the meuia.
6#))*M* ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: See BBS section foi fuithei infoimation.
2%*'39 ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: Shatil is the Isiael-baseu opeiational fiamewoik of the New Isiael
Funu, active in cooiuinating anu pioviuing Isiaeli Nu0s with consulting, training, coalition-builuing
assistance and other services, including a number of highly politicized NGOs.
PALESTINIAN Nu0S
>*9.)'353*5 D$*7./3$ 2#$3.'E 4#& '%. 2',7E #4 85'.&5*'3#5*9 D44*3&) ?>D228D@ ?*/#,5' 5#'
73)$9#).7@ Passia is an active participant in the global campaign to boycott Israel and uses resistance
ihetoiic. FES is a financial suppoitei of PASSIAs research studies program, whose research
publications iegulaily employ apaitheiu ihetoiic in iefeience to Isiaeli policy.

=8++H B(DSGI <:SI:( `:([2D+:6

The Willy Bianut Centei }eiusalem (WBC) was cieateu in 1996 (thiee yeais aftei the 0slo fiamewoik)
thiough an agieement between the }usos (young Socialists - pait of the ueiman Social Bemociatic
Paity), Shabeebat Fateh (Palestinian), anu Nishmeiet Tseiiah shel Nifleget Ba-Avouah (Isiaeli Laboi
Paity Youth Novement). These founuing oiganizations aie pait of the Inteinational 0nion of Socialist
Youth (I0SY). The Centei hosts political activities (e.g. the Red Lounge); peace-building activities
unuei the goveinment-funueu Civil Peace Seivice (ZFB - Zivilei Fiieuensuienst); anu uialogues
involving ueiman, Isiaeli, anu Palestinian youth. As of Septembei 2u1S, the website notes, The WBC is
cuiiently in the phase of iegisteiing as a limiteu company that opeiates as a public utility unuei Isiaeli
law. The Willy Bianut Centei }eiusalem ieceives funuing fiom the ueiman feueial goveinment anu
lists the Friedrich Ebert Stiftung as a supporter, with which it maintains close cooperation.


"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

y

ACTIvITIES INv0LvINu ISRAELI P0LITICAL ABv0CACY Nu0S:
The Willy Bianut Centei fiamewoik holus activities with Nu0s, but uoes not pioviue uiiect funuing.
The selection of Nu0 paitneis uemonstiates the political auvocacy agenua.
6*$%)#/ =*'$% (Willy Bianut event): The Isiael-baseu Nachsom Watch monitois anu uisseminates
reports on Israeli soldiers at checkpoints, with the ultimate aim of ending the occupation. Repoits,
photos anu viueos aie publisheu in Bebiew anu English, employing emotive anu politically chaigeu
language that contiibutes to the uemonization of Isiael. Fiequently the oiganization inteifeies with anu
piovokes IBF soluieis. A YouTube viueo shows activists haiassing a soluiei at a checkpoint, haianguing
him for engaging in apartheid.
"#$%&#' (Willy Bianut event): See the Neuico Inteinational section foi fuithei infoimation.
8& D/3/ (Willy Bianut event): Ii Amim is a highly politicizeu Nu0 that opposes Isiaeli goveinment
policies iegaiuing }eiusalem. Activities include Monitoring and exposing critical developments in
Jerusalem, legal advocacy, policy advocacy, and running highly politicized tours of Jerusalem and
the sepaiation baiiiei. Although it has been uesciibeu as work[ing] toward coexistence in Jerusalem,
an Ii Amim official saiu that the group was seeking to advance a political agenda, and was not an
organization geared to promote coexistence.
B&.*N351 '%. 239.5$. ?B'2@ (Willy Bianut event)] See the NISERE0R section foi fuithei infoimation.

J(8:G(8<AFSD[6DSSF2I8JI[ST ?JS2@

FNS is affiliateu with the Freie Demokratische Partei (Free Democratic Party), anu woiks towaius the
promotion of democracy and liberal principles, dialogue and the peace process. FNS opeiates offices
in }eiusalem.
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
The FNS buuget foi 2u12 was 51.3 million. Accoiuing to coiiesponuence with Nu0 Nonitoi, 1uu% of
FNS funds come from the state budget. The FNS Israel office lists its partners, but does not provide
funuing uetails. In coiiesponuence with Nu0 Nonitoi (0ctobei 2u1S), an FNS official wrote: The
annual buuget foi joineu activities is 6u.uuu. - EURO.We dont provide any financial or institutional
suppoit. We aie only coopeiating on the basis of joint activities which aie uiiecteu to suppoit the peace
process in this region. Requests foi uetails weie iejecteu, highlighting the lack of tianspaiency.

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

8

I*09. Y] Fiieuiich-Naumann Stiftung (FNS): Palestinian Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s
>*9.)'353*5 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Maan News Agency Not Biscloseu
Ramallah Centei foi Buman Rights
Stuuies (RCBRS)
Not Biscloseu

JS2 O&#_.$') *57 O*&'5.&)
PALESTINIAN Nu0S
Maan News Agency {*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: Pait of the Na'an Netwoik, often seives as a platfoim
foi tenuentious anti-Isiael statements, incluuing mateiial fiom iauical Nu0s. 0n }anuaiy S1, 2u1S
Maan published an aiticle in Aiabic (which was latei iemoveu), On the ostensible Holocaust
memorial day, in which the author, Ghassan Mustafa Al-Shami, refers to the Holocaust as a myth.
Israel is referred to as a thieve entity for themselves on a Palestinian land and the Jews are claimed
to have succeeded in achieving many goals by using Holocaust, and taking advantage of them [the
lies] to win sympathy.
(*/*99*% <.5'.& 4#& A,/*5 (31%') 2',73.) ?(<A(2@ ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: RCBRS is a membei
of the Inteinational Feueiation foi Buman Rights (FIBB) anu a membei of The Palestinian Non-
uoveinmental 0iganizations Netwoik (PNu0), both of which aie piominent in anti-Isiael campaigns.
Following the March 2002 suicide bombing attacks and Operation Defensive Shield, RCHRS issueu a
statement promoting the false claim that Israel committed massacres in Jenin and Nablus. RCHRS has
also accused Israel of teiiiioiist |sicj ciimes, and making children the sacrifice for the racial hatred
|sicj.

CUS(DG DG:SD[:( 2I8JI[ST ?CD2@

The Koniau Auenauei Stiftung is affiliateu with the Chiistian Bemociatic 0nion (CB0); it has offices in
Ramallah anu }eiusalem.
In Becembei 2u11, the Ramallah KAS office, along with the Palestinian Nu0 D9 A*R, hosteu a panel
uiscussion on effoits to biing wai ciimes cases against Isiaeli officials at the Inteinational Ciiminal
Couit. D9 A*R has been centially active in lobbying foi such politicized cases (lawfare).

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

q

J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
In 2012 KASs expected annual buuget was 138 million. For 2012 KAS, expected to receive 128
million in feueial funus.
I*09. Z] Koniau Auenauei Stiftung (KAS): Palestinian Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s (2u11-2u12)
>*9.)'353*5 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Niftah
$44,7u2 (2u12)
$48,167 (2u11)

CD2 >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
PALESTINIAN Nu0S
634'*% iepoiteu $44,7u2 in funuing fiom KAS in 2u12 anu $48,167 in 2u11. See BBS section foi fuithei
infoimation.

ADS2F2:8G:+F2I8JI[ST ?A22@
The Bans Seiuel Stiftung is affiliateu with the Chiistian Social 0nion (CS0) in Bavaiia; the founuation
has offices in }eiusalem anu }enin.
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
The buuget foi 2u12 was 55,572,000. In 2u12, BSS ieceiveu 47 million in feueial funuing. Limiteu
funuing infoimation is pioviueu on the BSS website.






"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

zo

I*09. g] Bans-Sieuel-Stiftung (BSS): Isiaeli Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s
8)&*.93 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Shatil (affiliateu with the New Isiael
Funu)*
Not Biscloseu
Ilam Not Biscloseu

*As a 0S-baseu non-piofit woiking in Isiael, Shatil is not legally obligateu to iepoit its piivate funuing
souices accoiuing to the Isiaeli Nu0 foieign goveinment funuing tianspaiency law.
A22 >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
ISRAELI Nu0S
2%*'39 ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@b See FES section foi fuithei infoimation.
Ilam {*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@b See FES section foi fuithei infoimation.









"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z

I NBEPENBENT
BEvEL0PNENT
Nu0S






T:(6DS TU;:(S6:SIFJ[SG:G 8SG:>:SG:SI J(D6:=U(C2
NEBIC0 INTERNATI0NAL
Neuico Inteinational (NI), baseu in Fiankfuit, claims to focus on campaigning foi health seivices,
bioauly uefineu. Its mission statement refers to comprehensive social action that aims at the
implementation of the right to health.assistance is an element within social action that fights for
uemociacy, social justice anu iespect foi human iights togethei with the victims of uestitution anu
despotism.
Medico Internationals activities regarding the Arab-Isiaeli conflict aie highly politicizeu, as ieflecteu in
the statements of Tsafiii Cohen, who is iesponsible foi public ielations in Palestine & Israel. In March
2u1S, Cohen publisheu an op-eu aiticle on BBS campaigns, calling on the ueiman goveinment to
pressure Israel politically. Cohen has also urged German politicians to pressure Israel and to fight
against the Isiaeli occupation. In 2012, Medico was one of 22 NGO co-authors of a publication, Tiauing
Away Peace, which calleu on the E0 anu national goveinments to wage political waifaie thiough
vaiious foims of economic sanctions on Isiael. This Nu0 lobbying was cential to subsequent E0 policies
on these issues.
In Apiil 2u1S, Neuico Inteinational posteu a YouTube viueo titled, Countering Displacement. The
video description demonizes Israel, stating that in the West Bank in the rural areas of the West Bank,
access to health seivices is consiueiably ieuuceu by the Isiaeli occupation policies. Theii goal is
eviuently to oust the Palestinians living theie into uensely populateu enclaves fully contiolleu by
Israel
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
NI funueis (p. S1) incluue the Feueial Foieign 0ffice, BNZ anu ifaZivik- Institute foi Foieign Cultuial
Relations, anu E0 fiamewoiks. The annual buuget in 2u1u was 19 million anu 20.2 million in 2u11.
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

zz

Accoiuing to its 2u12 annual iepoit, MI allocated 1,245,297 to projects in Israel/PA. Detailed funding
infoimation ielateu to amounts given to the Nu0s is not pioviueu.
I*09. f] Neuico Inteinational: Funuing foi Isiaeli anu Palestinian Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s
(2u1u-2u12)
8)&*.93 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Aualah NIS 121,86S (2u12)
Coalition of Women foi Peace Not Biscloseu (2u12)
C0NET-NE
Not Biscloseu (2u12)
NIS 1,686,624 (2u11)
NIS S9S,S4S (2u1u)
Zochiot Not uiscloseu (2u12)
Physicians foi Buman Rights Isiael (PBR-I)
Not uiscloseu (2u12)
NIS 9S,uuu (2u11)
NIS 94,uuu (2u1u)
>*9.)'353*5 STU)
Al-Nezan Centei Not Biscloseu (2u12)
Palestinian Neuical Relief Society (PNRS) Not Biscloseu (2u12)
68 >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
ISRAELI Nu0S
D7*9*% ieceiveu NIS 121,86S in 2012 from Medico International for a project called Legal activities for
equality. Aualah is a highly politicizeu Isiaeli Nu0 active in a wiue iange of uemonization campaigns,
including lawfaie, which targets Israeli officials through exploitation of international legal
fiamewoiks. This Nu0 ),0/3''.7 * 9.1*9 #O353#5 '# * 2O*53)% $#,&' 35 ),OO#&' #4 * ><A( $*).
against Israeli officials. Tbe NCUs Bemociatic Constitution, (2007) calls for replacing the Jewish
foundation of Israel with a democratic, bilingual and multicultural framework; Jewish immigration
would be restricted to humanitarian reasons. Adalah officials, in conjunction with radical Palestinian
Nu0 Al-Baq, wiote anu euiteu laige poitions of a Nay 2uu9 pseuuo-acauemic stuuy that refers to a
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z

colonial enterprise which implements a system of apartheid. The report delegitimizes Israeli self-
defense measures as inhumane act[s] of apartheid...perpetrated in the context of an institutionalizeu
regime of systematic oppression and domination by one racial group over another.
<#*93'3#5 #4 =#/.5 4#& >.*$. ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@] See RLS section of the iepoit foi fuithei
infoimation.
<U6:IF6: ?<#//,53'EP :5.&1E *57 I.$%5#9#1E 35 '%. 63779.F:*)'@ ieceiveu NIS 1,686,624
(2u11) anu NIS S9S,S4S (2u1u) fiom Neuico Inteinational anu NIS 12u,uuu (2u1u) fiom the ueiman
Repiesentative 0ffice in Ramallah. The oiganization (registered in Israel as a Company for the Benefit
of the Public) was established in 2009 to build renewable energy systems for communities that are
not connecteu to the electiicity giiu because of political ieasons anu builu local capacity to install anu
maintain those systems. Elau 0iian, co-founuer and environmental expert, physicist, political activist,
is also a membei of the auuit committee of "#$%&#' (see above), a iauical Isiaeli Nu0 that suppoits a
one-state vision and the Palestinian right of return. Orian also signeu a petition in suppoit of Tali
Fahima, a pio-Palestinian activist who was convicteu foi contact with teiioiists. In an aiticle posteu on
the IRIN (0N 0CBA) netwoik iegaiuing builuing in Aiea C, 0iian wiote, We dont get any permits
|fiom the Isiaeli Civil Auministiationj, so we simply build without.
"#$%&#' ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: See RLS section of the iepoit foi fuithei infoimation.
>%E)3$3*5) 4#& A,/*5 (31%') 8)&*.9 ?>A(F8@ ieceiveu NIS 9S,uuu (2u11) anu NIS 94,uuu (2u1u) fiom
Neuico Inteinational. PBR-I is veiy active in political auvocacy anu uemonization. An 0ctobei 2u11
publication Boctoiing the Eviuence, Abanuoning the victim, accused Israeli doctors and institutions of
involvement in the torture and ill-treatment of Palestinians. Betaileu analysis of the sweeping claims
uemonstiates ueeply flaweu ieseaich, anu the Isiael Neuical Association uenounceu the highly
selective publication foi eiasing impoitant uetails. Baseu on faulty methouology, PBR-I asseits that
Israeli security officers routinely employ interrogation methods which amount to torture anu ill-
treatment and that medical professionals are frequently involved either actively or passively in
toituie oi ill-treatment. Lexical or legal definitions for torture and ill-treatment are not provided
anu useu inconsistently. Buiing the uaza wai (Bec 2uu8-}an. 2uu9), PBR-I accuseu Isiael of using
extreme and disproportionate force against the population of Gaza and of targeting medical teams
and aid convoys. Dr. Yoram Blachar, former president of the World Medical Association, ciiticizeu PBR-
I as a iauical political gioup uisguiseu as a meuical oiganization. See NGO Monitor Monograph, Nu0
Nalpiactice (July 2013) for more information about PHR-I.


"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z[

PALESTINIAN Nu0S
D9F6.L*5 <.5'.& ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: Baseu in uaza, Al-Nezan consistently iefeis to the Isiaeli
army as the Israel Occupation Forces (IOF), erasing the context of Palestinian terror and
uelegitimizing Isiaeli self-uefense. Buiing the uaza conflict, Al Nezan publicizeu allegations of Isiaeli
massacies, slaughteiing civilians, scanualous wai ciimes, and uespicable uisiegaiu to civilian life.
The use of human shielus by Bamas anu the iocket attacks against Isiaeli civilians aie eiaseu. Al Nezan
has also coopeiateu with Al Baq anu Aualah in piomoting lawfaie cases against Isiaeli officials,
incluuing the highly publicized war crimes allegations against foimei Ninistei of Befense Ehuu Baiak
in Lonuon in Septembei 2uu9.
>*9.)'353*5 6.73$*9 (.93.4 2#$3.'E ?>6(2@ ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@: Accoiuing to the PNRS mission
statement, Health is viewed as an entry point for social change and community development. The
oiganization plays a leauing iole in the Palestinian Nu0 Netwoik, which a leauei in piomoting
demonization, BDS and lawfare. See NGO Monitor Monograph, Nu0 Nalpiactice (July 2013), for more
infoimation.












"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

zg

CB0RCB F0NBI Nu
FRANEW0RKS






Biot fi uie Welt - Evangelischei Entwicklungsuienst (EEB)
Biot fi uie Welt (Bieau foi the Woilu) was founueu in 19S9 in the fiamewoik of the Evangelical anu
Fiee Chuiches in ueimany, within the Ecumenical Biakonia, a uepaitment of the Social Seivice Agency
(Biakonisches Weik) of the ueiman Evangelical Chuich.
The Chuich Bevelopment Seivice (Evangelischei Entwicklungsuienst-EEB) is associateu with the
iegional Piotestant anu Fiee Chuiches in ueimany, anu suppoits ovei 1,Suu piojects annually,
implementeu thiough ecclesiastical anu civil society paitnei-oiganizations.
0n August Su, 2u12, the Chuich Bevelopment Seivice (Evangelischei Entwicklungsuienst-EEB) meigeu
with Brot fr die Welt and formed a new agency, Brot fr die WeltEvangelischei
Entwicklungsdienst (Bread for the WorldEvangelical Chuich Bevelopment Seivice), as pait of the
new Evangelical Agency foi Biakonia anu Bevelopment (Evangelisches Weik fi Biakonie unu
Entwicklung).
Both Biot fi uie Welt anu EEB aie highly politicizeu anu active in the Aiab-Isiael conflict. In 2u12, the
combineu oiganization, togethei with NISERE0R, enuoiseu the policy of labeling goous piouuceu ovei
the 1949 Aimistice line, as pait of the wiuei BBS campaign.
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
In 2u11, the oiganization ieceiveu 1,402,805 from the EU and 340,900 in federal government funds.
EEDs 2011 buuget was 181 million, including 119 million from the Feueial Ninistiy foi Economic
Coopeiation anu Bevelopment. Biot fui Bie Welt EEB pioviues veiy limiteu funuing uetails. The list
piesenteu below is baseu on limiteu infoimation pioviueu by the EEB anu Biot fi uie Welt, as well as
infoimation pioviueu unuei the Isiaeli Nu0 foieign goveinment funuing tianspaiency law.


"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z6

I*09. h] Biot Fueiuie Welt Evangelischei Entwicklungsuienst (EBB): Isiaeli anu Inteinational
Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s (2u1u-2u12)
8)&*.93 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
BTselem
NIS 1,192,6u9 (2u12)-
EEB
NIS 1,SS9,8S9 (2u11)-
EEB
NIS S6,SS1 (2u1u)- EEB
The Association foi Civil Rights in Isiael (ACRI)
NIS 4SS,SuS (2u12)-EEB
NIS 1,u4S,779 (2u11)-
EEB
The Coalition of Women foi Peace (CWP)
NIS 188,S2u (2u11)-Biot
fi uie Welt
NIS 68,S2u (2u1u) - Biot
fi uie Welt
Physicians foi Buman Rights-Isiael (PBR-I)
NIS 296,4S9 (2u12)- EEB
NIS 6S6,uuu (2u11)- EEB
NIS 7u8,uuu (2u1u)-EEB
Aualah
NIS 121,86S (2u12)-EEB
NIS 1S8,8uu(2u1u)-EEB
New Piofile
NIS 224,u82 (2u1u) -
Biot fi uie Welt
Sauaka Reut
NIS 1S6,147 (2u1u)-
Biot fi uie Welt
NIS 14u,u74 (2u11)-
Biot fi uie Welt
Not uiscloseu (2u11)-
EEB
85'.&5*'3#5*9 STU)
Ecumenical Accompaniment Piogiamme in Palestine anu
Isiael (EAPPI)
Not Biscloseu


"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

zy

B&#' 4K& 73. =.9' ::G >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
ISRAELI Nu0S
D7*9*% ieceiveu NIS 121,86S (2u12) anu NIS 1S8,8uu (2u1u) fiom EEB. See Neuico Inteinational
section of the iepoit foi fuithei infoimation.
BTselem (The Isiaeli Infoimation Centei foi Buman Rights in the 0ccupieu Teiiitoiies) ieceiveu NIS
1,192,6u9 in 2u12, NIS 1,SS9,8S9 in 2u11, anu NIS S6,SS1 in 2u1u fiom EEB. This Nu0 aumits that it
acts piimaiily to change Isiaeli policy in the 0ccupieu Territories -- a cleai political objective. While
widely considered Israels premier human-rights organization, BTselem has faced serious ciiticism foi
its misiepiesentations of inteinational law, iepoits baseu on Palestinian claims that lack cieuibility,
othei examples of inaccuiate ieseaich, unieliable statistics (incluuing lists of casualties), anu selective
coveiage of violations against Israelis. In the global campaign against Israels security barrier and other
examples, BTselem was at the foiefiont of labeling Israeli responses to terror from Gaza as collective
punishment. BTselem also claimed that Israel violated international humanitarian law in Gaza,
including excessive anu uispiopoitionate foice, failure to distinguish between civilians anu
combatants, and use of prohibited weapons. CEO Jessica Montell has stateu: I think the word
apaitheiu is useful foi mobilizing people because of its emotional powei. In some cases, the situation in
the West Bank is worse than apartheid in South Africa.
D))#$3*'3#5 4#& <3Q39 (31%') 35 8)&*.9 ?D<(8@ ieceiveu NIS 4SS,SuS in 2u12 fiom EEB foi a pioject
called Educational and legal activity for the rights of the Arab public in Israel. EED also granted the
oiganization NIS 1,u4S,779 in 2u11. See RLS section of the iepoit foi fuithei infoimation.
<#*93'3#5 #4 =#/.5 4#& >.*$. ?<=>@ ieceiveu NIS 188,S2u (2u11) anu NIS 68,S2u (2u1u) fiom Biot
fi uie Welt.
See RLS section of the iepoit foi fuithei infoimation.
>%E)3$3*5) 4#& A,/*5 (31%')F8)&*.9 ?>A(F8@ ieceiveu NIS 296,4S9 (2u12) fiom EEB foi a pioject on
Promoting the right to health for West Bank, NIS 6S6,uuu in 2u11, anu NIS 7u8,uuu in 2u1u. See
Neuico Inteinational section of the iepoit foi fuithei infoimation.
S.M >&#439. ieceiveu NIS 224,u82 (2u1u) fiom Biot fi uie Welt. New Piofile claims to auvocate foi the
uemilitaiization of Isiaeli society, anu pioviues legal anu othei suppoit foi those who iefuse to seive in
the IBF. In an unuateu inteiview, co-founder Ruth Hiller stated, New Profile has signed statements in
suppoit of uivestment anu feels it is an impoitant tool in challenging companies anu coipoiations
involveu in the Isiaeli occupation of Palestine....The Cateipillai campaign is an excellent example of
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z8

piotesting the link between big coipoiation, occupation anu the militaiization of Israeli society. Hiller
has heiself signeu BDS petitions, including one telling entertainers not to perform in apaitheiu Isiael.
2*7*N* (.,' ieceiveu NIS 1S6,147 (2u1u) anu NIS 14u,u74 (2u11) fiom Biot fi uie Welt; the amount
of funuing ieceiveu fiom EEB in 2u11 is unknown. See RLS section of the iepoit foi fuithei infoimation.
INTERNATI0NAL Nu0S
:$,/.53$*9 D$$#/O*53/.5' >&#1&*//. 35 >*9.)'35. *57 8)&*.9 ?:D>>8@ ?*/#,5' 5#' 73)$9#).7@i
its stateu mission is to accompany Palestinians and Israelis in their non-violent actions anu conceiteu
advocacy efforts to end the occupation. EAPPI promotes the Palestinian victimization narrative and
uemonizes Isiael, incluuing paiticipating in commemoiating the Palestinian Nakba (catastrophe)
anu piomoting the so-called iight of ietuin, meaning the end of Israel as the nation-state of the }ewish
people. EAPPI piomotes the Kaiios Palestine uocument that calls foi BBS against Isiael, noting that
These advocacy campaigns must be carried out with courage, openly sincerely proclaiming that their
object is not revenge but rather to put an end to the existing evil. EAPPIs core publication, Faith
0nuei 0ccupation, falsely blames Israel for the oppression of Christians in the Holy Land. It also seeks
to disprove what it calls unfoundeu Isiaeli anu Chiistian Zionist piopaganua that Palestinian
Christians are depopulating due to Muslim fundamentalism in Palestinian society.
NISERE0R

Niseieoi is the aiu fiamewoik of the Catholic Chuich in ueimany, anu a membei of CIBSE, a netwoik of
Catholic aiu oiganizations. The oiganization enuoiseu piouuct labeling, anu piomoteu the petition
initiateu by its paitnei, the Society of St. Yves, piotesting the planneu constiuction of the secuiity
barrier in Jerusalems Cremisan valley. Sabeel anu othei uemonization suppoiteis aie centially
involveu in this campaign.

J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
In 2011, MISEREORs annual budget was 181 million, and it received 1u7.4 million in ueiman feueial
grants. In 2012, Misereor received 113.8 million in German federal grants. Misereor does not list its
paitneis; the funuing infoimation is baseu on the infoimation pioviueu unuei the Isiaeli foieign
goveinment Nu0 funuing tianspaiency law.


"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

zq

I*09. e] Niseieoi: Isiaeli anu Palestinian Paitneis, Political Auvocacy Nu0s (2u1u-2u12)
8)&*.93 STU) D/#,5') *57 H.*&)
Zochiot NIS 271, 77S (2u11)
Rabbis foi Buman Rights (RBR) NIS S2,9S8 (2u11)
Sauaka Reut

NIS 296,S6u (2u11)
NIS 16S,147 (2u1u)
Bamokeu NIS 444,412 (2u12)
Bieaking the Silence (BtS) NIS 24S,71S (2u11)
>*9.)'353*5 STU)
Society of St. Yves Not Biscloseu

63).&.#& >&#_.$') *57 >*&'5.&)
ISRAELI Nu0S
"#$%&#' ieceiveu NIS 271, 77S (2u11) fiom Niseieoi. See RLS section of the iepoit foi fuithei
infoimation.
B&.*N351 '%. 239.5$. ?B'2@ ieceiveu NIS 24S,71S (2u11) fiom NISERE0R. Bieaking the Silence (BtS)
plays a central role in the demonization and BDS campaigns targeting Israel, based on testimonies of
soldiers to demonstrate the depth of corruption which is spreading in the Israeli militaryIsraeli
society continues to turn a blind eye, and to deny that which happens in its name. The NGO was active
in promoting false wai ciimes charges against Israel after the Gaza fighting in January 2009, and
continues these campaigns thiough many events in inteinational fiamewoiks. In 2u1u BtS publisheu a
book of anonymous and unverifiable testimonies, 722)@&1+.' .- 19# A#$$+1.$+#8 ; <8$&#0+ >.0*+#$
1#81+%.'+#8 BCCC;BCDC.
(*003) 4#& A,/*5 (31%') ?(A(@ ieceiveu NIS S2,9S8 (2u11) fiom NISERE0R. RBR piomotes the
Palestinian naiiative of victimization anu uemonizes Isiael, incluuing ihetoiic claiming that Israels
foul anu uisciiminatoiy policies against Palestinians, uespite its obligation towaiu them as the
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

o

occupierIsrael is forcing Palestinians to live in a completely separate universe where time has stood
still, and prevents them from properly planning their most basic needs and infrastructure.
2*7*N* (.,' ieceiveu NIS 16S,147 (2u1u) anu NIS 296,S6u (2u11). See RLS section of the iepoit foi
fuithei infoimation.
A*/#N.7 ieceiveu NIS 444,412 (2u12) fiom Niseieoi for a project titled Legal assistance for
Palestinian human iights in the 0ccupied Territories. Hamoked is an Israeli organization whose main
objective is to assist Palestinians of the Occupied Territories whose rights are violated due to Israel's
policies. Hamoked has uesciibeu Israels policies as ethnic cleansing and racist. For example, in an
inteiview in the 6&1+.'&0, Director of Hamoked Dalia Kerstein said, There is clearly a policy to push
Palestinians out of }eiusalem anu Isiael to ieuuce what is calleu heie the Palestinian uemogiaphic
threat. Its really a case of ethnic cleansing.
PALESTINIAN Nu0S
2#$3.'E #4 2'b HQ.) ?amount not available@b Accoiuing to its mission statement, the Society of St. Yves
provides gratis legal assistance, counsel anu auvocacy to membeis of the community. Thiough
National anu Inteinational Lobby anu Auvocacy we aie able to biing the situation of the pooi anu
marginalized to the attention of communities around the world. The organization promotes Palestinian
Nakba campaigns anu initiateu a petition against the builuing of the secuiity baiiiei, piotesting the
uecision of the Special Appeals Committee that ueemeu the constiuction of the baiiiei as legal anu
justified. The Society of St. Yves repeatedly uses the language of demonization, referring to foiceu
uisplacements, and woiks with iauical anti-Isiael oiganizations incluuing the Right of Retuin
0iganization -ueneva, Al Nezan, Bauil, Befence foi Chiluien-PS, Auuameei, Al Baq, Aualah anu ICABB.








"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21



u0vERNNENT
0RuANI ZATI 0NS





BE0TSCBE uESELLSCBAFT F0R INTERNATI0NALE Z0SANNENARBEIT uNBB (uIZ)
The Beutsche uesellschaft fi Inteinationale Zusammenaibeit (uIZ) uesciibes itself as an experienced
seivice pioviuei that assists the ueiman uoveinment in achieving its objectives in the fielu of
international cooperation. Most of GIZs activities are commissioned by the German Federal Ministry
foi Economic Coopeiation anu Bevelopment. uIZ also opeiates on behalf of othei ueiman ministiies
incluuing the Feueial Foieign 0ffice, the Feueial Ninistiy foi the Enviionment, Natuie Conseivation
anu Nucleai Safety, the Feueial Ninistiy of Befence, the Feueial Ninistiy of Economics anu Technology,
anu the Feueial Ninistiy of Euucation anu Reseaich as well as ueiman states anu municipalities, anu
public anu piivate sectoi clients in ueimany anu abioau. These incluue the goveinments of othei
countiies, the Euiopean Commission, the 0niteu Nations, anu the Woilu Bank.
uIZ also pioviues funus foi othei oiganizations examineu in this iepoit. Foi example, the Fiieuiich
Naumann Stiftung lists (p.8S) uIZ as a source of funding. In 2012, GIZs budget was approximately 200
million, pioviueu by feueial anu E0 funus.

ERINNER0Nu, vERANTW0RT0Nu, Z0K0NFT (EvZ) RENENBRANCE, RESP0NSIBILITY ANB F0T0RE
The Remembiance, Responsibility anu Futuie (EvZ) Founuation was establisheu in 2uuu, piimaiily to
make payments to foiceu laboieis fiom the Nazi eia. EvZ has an enuowment of E0R S.2 billion
provided by the German Government and German industry. By the end of 2006, a total of E0R 4.S7
billion was uisbuiseu to moie than 1.66 million foimei foiceu labouieis anu othei victims of National
Socialism in 98 countries. The Foundation completed its payments programmes in 2007. The
iemaining amount is useu foi giants anu piogiamming.
uiants have been pioviueu foi activities that piomote uemonization of Isiael, incluuing coopeiation
with Zochiot. EvZ uiscontinueu its support in 2012 because EVZ suppoits euucational piojects but
uoes not suppoit oiganizations that also have a political agenua. Since Zochiot suppoits the iight of
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

z

return, the foundation cannot extend its cooperation with it. EVZs Europeans for Peace (EFP) piogiam
claims to encourage active engagement of young people in society which is based on histoiical
awareness. In 2009, EFP sponsored a program called 1948, a project where Palestinian and German
youth investigate images of fiienus anu enemies in the meuia (featuie films) about the eia of the
establishment of the State of Israel, in cooperation with Evangelical Lutheian Chuich of Bope in
Ramallah.
In 2u1u-2u11 EFP pioviueu 21,590 to the BEAR pioject, an exchange piogiam between the ueihait-
Bauptmann high school in ueimany anu the Nasai Institute foi Euucation in Nazaieth. (Nasai is
iegisteieu as an Isiaeli non-piofit |#S8uS4187Sj anu ieceiveu NIS S18,1S2 fiom the anti-Isiael
Welfaie Association in 2uu7-2uu9.) The stateu aim of the HEAR project was to bring together German
and Israeli youth in order to jointly auuiess the question in how fai conciete human iights aie
realized or damaged in the structure of the education. The pioject incluueu an EvZ biochuie equating
Isiael with the uefunct East ueiman Stalinist state, anu incluueu ciuue uiawings of 0ithouox }ewish
stuuents. The uocument also uepicteu Isiael as a violent state with an euucation system that excluues
anu oppiesses Aiab pupils.

INSTIT0TE F0R F0REIuN C0LT0RAL RELATI0NS (IFA)
The Institute foi Foieign Cultuial Relations (Institut fi Auslanusbeziehungen - IFA) woiks in close
cooiuination with the ueiman Ninistiy of Foieign Affaiis (Auswitiges Amt). The focus of its woik is
the cultuial sectoi, as well as peace builuing activities.
J,57351 *57 I&*5)O*&.5$E
The Institute is financeu anu suppoiteu by the ueiman Ninistiy of Foieign Affaiis (Auswitiges Amt),
Bauen Wittembeig, anu the City of Stuttgait. In a lettei of Apiil 9, 2u1S, an IFA official iefuseu to
uisclose details on IFA funding for Israeli NGOs, stating that the IFA is due to data protection. The
infoimation on funuing foi Yesh Bin is pioviueu unuei the Isiaeli foieign goveinment funuing
tianspaiency law.




"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21



I*09. VW] Institute foi Foieign Cultuial Relations (IFA) (2u12):
82(D:+8 STU) D/#,5' *57 H.*&
Yesh Bin NIS 2Su,uuu (2u12)

ISRAELI Nu0S
H.)% G35 ieceiveu NIS 2Su,uuu (2u12) fiom IFA foi its Lanus Pioject. Yesh Bin is centially involveu in
uemonization campaigns, falsely poitiaying Isiael as unaccountable to the iule of law. This is pait of a
wider lawfare strategy of bringing war crimes cases against Israeli officials in foreign courts and in
the Inteinational Ciiminal Couit (ICC) as exemplifieu in the Nu0-uolustone piocess. Yesh Dins
iepoits piesent a political naiiative unuei the guise of legal analysis. Yesh Bin fiequently petitions the
Bigh Couit on Israeli policy regarding Palestinians. The organizations stateu mission is to oppose the
continuing violation of Palestinian human rights, monitoring of law enforcement on settleis anu
membeis of the secuiity foices, anu the militaiy couit pioceuuies. Founueu by Bioi Etkes (foimeily of
Peace Now), Yesh Din employs demonization and apaitheiu rhetoric in some of its activities,
exploiting the language of human iights foi political anu iueological objectives.











"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[

C0NCL0SI 0NS ANB
REC0NNENBATI 0NS




This iepoit uocuments ueiman funuing fiamewoiks anu policies foi political auvocacy Nu0s, anu the
many examples of counteipiouuctive impacts, incluuing suppoit foi uemonization, political waifaie,
anu in some cases, antisemitism. These Nu0 agenuas anu uistoitions inciease the highly uistoiteu anu
negative peiceptions of Isiael, paiticulaily in Euiope anu ueimany.
While laige buugets aie involveu, the funuing piocesses have been shiouueu unuei a covei of seciecy,
reinforced by the halo effect in which organizations claiming to promote moral agendas such as
human iights, peace, anu uemociacy aie exempteu fiom pailiamentaiy anu jouinalistic examination. As
uocumenteu in this iepoit, the lack of tianspaiency anu accountability in many funuing mechanisms
involving ueiman taxpayei funus is uistuibing. While most ueiman funueis publish the statistics
iegaiuing the income they ieceive fiom goveinment souices, infoimation on money tiansfeiieu to the
political auvocacy Nu0s uiscusseu in this iepoit iemains opaque.
The piocess by which ueiman goveinment bianches anu political founuations choose piojects anu
awaiu contiacts to Nu0s is unknown, anu insufficient supeivisoiy mechanisms aie available to
ueteimine how Nu0s use goveinment aiu. Nany ueiman funuing fiamewoiks ieceiving goveinment
money uo not fully uisclose funuing infoimation that woulu enable the geneial public to assess how
taxpayei monies aie being utilizeu. In some instances, political founuations list pioject paitneis, but
these Nu0s in tuin uo not mention the political founuations as funueis. Alteinatively, paitnei Nu0s at
times thank ueiman uonoi oiganizations, though the funuing oiganizations make no mention of the
Palestinian Isiaeli oiganizations on theii websites. In most of the cases analyzeu, funuing neeus to be
ie-evaluateu so that it aligns with bioauei ueiman foieign policy.
To inciease tianspaiency, Nu0 Nonitoi iecommenus that all evaluation uocuments foi piojects in
Isiael anu in the Palestinian Authoiity be publisheu to ensuie uue uiligence. Similaily, Nu0 Nonitoi
uiges ueiman funueis to ensuie that Isiaeli oiganizations ieceiving goveinment money comply with
the tianspaiency laws in Isiael anu iepoit theii funuing accoiuingly.
Finally, the BNZ shoulu foimulate guiuelines anu state cleai goals foi coopeiation with Isiaeli paitneis.
ueiman funuing shoulu be uiiecteu towaius piojects anu oiganizations that conuuct theii missions
impaitially. To ensuie compliance with these iecommenuations, the ueiman goveinment shoulu ieview
coopeiation with local paitneis anu closely sciutinize the allocation of taxpayei funus.
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g

APPENBI CES


APPENBIX A: EXTEBNBEB LIST 0F 0RuANIZATI0NS RECEIvINu uERNAN F0NBINu

Table 1: Nu0 paitneis funueu by the Rosa Luxembuig Stiftung
STU) G.)$&3O'3#5
>&#_.$'
+.51'%
(.4.&.5$.
D<D>
Aiab Centei foi Alteinative Planning:
Empowering of Aiab Local Nunicipalities
on Planning Issues
Long
Teim
www.ac-ap.oig

D$%#'3
For Women in Israel: Black on White:
Combating Racism A Nulti Ethnic Feminist
Social anu Acauemic Peispective on Racism
in Israel
www.achoti.oig.il

D/.&*' #4 '%. G.).&'
Honoring Life Auuiessing Cultuie-Specific
violence against Women in the Negev
Beuouin Community"
www.ameiatofthe
ueseit.woiupiess.
com

I%. D7Q* <.5'.&
Action Oriented Research on Labor Force
Issues in Israel
www.auva.oig

D:`8
The Association of Enviionmental }ustice in
Isiael: Climate Justice Project
www.aeji.oig.il

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6

<A:
Center for Humanistic Education: Teaching
about the Bolocaust Euucating foi
Democracy
www.gfh.oig.il

A8+D
Isiael Committee foi Equality in Euucation:
Deepening and Expanding HILAs Work in
the Arab and Ethiopian Sectors
www.hila-equal-
euu.oig.il

2*7*N*F(.,'
Aiab }ewish Youth Paitneiship:
Community in Action: Creating a bi-
national Community of Activists foi a
Shared Society
www.ieutsauaka.
oig

2:D
Social Economic Academy: Alternative
Social-Economic Public Bebate Pioject
Reaching New Audiences
www.sea.oig.il

IDSG8
Novement of Bemociatic Women in Isiael:
Awareness Raising Groups for Arab
Women
www.muwii.com

=(<
Woikeis' Rights Clinic in Tel Aviv
University: Promoting Labor Lawyering
and Organizing in Israel
www.law.tau.ac.il

D22DJ
Aiu 0iganization foi Refugees anu Asylum
Seekers in Israel: Educating the Israeli
Public on Natteis of Refugees anu Asylum
Seekers in Israel
Shoit
Teim
2u12-
Piesent

www.acii.oig.il

<*/O,) Y D99
Winds of Change Campus for Alls
Alternative Student Day

http:campus-4-
all.oig

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

y

<*/O,) <#//,53'E
>*&'5.&)%3O
State-wide Seminar for Student Activists

www.law.huji.ac.il

<#/0*'*5') 4#&
>.*$.
Remembering the victims Fighting foi
Peace: CFPs Alternative Israeli-Palestinian
Memorial Day Ceremony

www.cfpeace.oig

A*1*7* A*)/*93'
Marx Forum 2012 Is the Capitalist Ciisis
0vei. A Socialist Perspective
www.maki.oig.il

A*#N.')
The Hebrew website Haokets (the sting)
piomotes an agenua that is committeu to
human iights, social justice, national anu
ethnic pluialism anu peace.
www.haokets.oig

A3&*N

Centei foi Auvancement of Bighei
Euucation in the Aiab Society: Civic
Paiticipation of Aiab Stuuents Tiaining
Project
www.aiab-
euucation.oig

A#'935. 4#& 631&*5'
=#&N.&)
International Migrants Day 2012
www.hotline.oig.i
l

6*%*O*$% FI*1%3&
Stiengthening Awaieness foi Social anu
Political Justice in Israel
www.mahapach-
taghii.oig

S.1.Q <#.-3)'.5$.
J#&,/ 4#& <3Q39
:R,*93'E
Advocacy Program - Buman Rights
violations Against the Negev Bedouin
www.uukium.oig

2%.3N% `*&&*%
2#937*&3'E
Public Outreach Program
www.en.justjlm.o
ig
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

8


Table 2: Nu0s funueu by the Beiniich Boll Stiftung
6#Q./.5'
I&*5)O#&' I#7*E j
I#/#&&#M
Transport and Justice Forum 2012
www.tianspoitati
on.oig.il

Womens Courtyard Community of Change Development
www.eng.hatzei.o
ig.il.tigiis.nethost.
co.il

"#$%&#'

LEARNINu TBE NAKBA AS A
C0NBITI0N F0R PEACE ANB
RECONCILIATION
zochiot.oigen

STU) G.)$&3O'3#5 >*&'5.&) (.4.&.5$.
G3&*)*' The Aiab Centei of Law anu Policy
8)&*.93 >*&'5.&]
Civil Society anu
Bemociatic
Paiticipation
www.ac-ap.oig

>*9.)'35.F8)&*.9
`#,&5*9

Independent platform discussion of
the Palestinian-Israeli conflict
http:www.pij.oi
g

2%*%*&3'
The Think Tank foi New Isiaeli
Politics
www.shahaiit.oig.
il

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

q

I%. 8)&*.93 2#$3.'E 4#&
2,)'*35*09.
:$#5#/3$)

Engaged in adopting ecological
economic theory in Israel
http:www.ecoec
o.oig.il
`*/*k*%

ulass anu Aluminum piouucei
http:www.al-
jamaah.oig

6#))*M* <.5'.&

Promoting equality for Arab
citizens within the borders of Israel
www.mossawacen
tei.oig

8'*$% Women Lawyeis foi Social }ustice
8)&*.93 >*&'5.&]
Womens Rights
anu uenuei
Bemociacy
www.itach.oig.il
englishenglish.ht
m

C*E*5 Feminist 0iganization
www.kayan.oig.il
en

8)&*.9 T*E H#,'%

Provides social support net to LGBT
and questioning teens
http:www.igy.oi
g.il
I%. <#*93'3#5 4#&
>,093$ A.*9'%
Reducing environmental pollution
http:www.phc.o
ig.il
D7Q* <.5'.&
Non-paitisan policy analysis
institute whose manuate is to
examine Isiaeli society fiom the
peispective of equality anu social
justice.
http:www.auva.
oiguefault.asp.p
ageiu=S
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[o

I%. ;*5 +..&
85)'3','.
}eiusalem Institute
www.vanleei.oig.i
len
I+; J.)'
7th Tel Aviv Inteinational LuBT Film
Festival
www.'9Q4.)'.com
en

I%. A.)$%.9 <.5'.&
4#& :5Q3&#5/.5'*9
+.*&5351 *57
+.*7.&)%3O
Builuing a sustainable futuie foi
Isiaeli society - enviionmentally,
socially and economically

8)&*.93 >*&'5.&]
Enviionment anu
Sustainable
Bevelopment

www.%.)$%.9.oig.
ilen

8)&*.9 :5.&1E J#&,/
Piomotion of efficient eneigy
consumption in Israel

http:www.enei
gia.oig.il
+34. j :5Q3&#5/.5'
Promotion of environmental
protection
http:www.sviva.
net
defW 6*1*L35. Independent blog-based magazine
8)&*.93 >*&'5.&]
Foieign &
Secuiity Policy
http:972mag.co
m
8)&*.9 <#,5$39 #5
J#&.315 (.9*'3#5)
Non-paitisan foium foi the stuuy
and debate of foreign policy

http:isiaelcfi.co
mabout-
icfi.php.inp=1
8S22
Institute foi National Secuiity
Stuuies, Tel Aviv 0niveisity
www.nuu.euu35)
)

D$*7./3$ <.5'.& #4
+*M j B,)35.))
(*/*' T*5
College of Law anu Business,
Ramat uan
www.clb.ac.ilengl
ish

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[



85)'3','. #4 `.&,)*9./
2',73.)
Private non-piofit ieseaich
oiganization that is iegaiueu by the
Aiab woilu as a mouel of
institutional oiganization anu
independence.

>*9.)'353*5
>*&'5.&)
http:www.pales
tine-stuuies.oig
6,M*'35
The Palestinian Institute foi the
Stuuy of Bemociacy
http:www.muw
atin.oig
6.73* G.Q.9#O/.5'
<.5'.&P B3&L.3'
[53Q.&)3'E
Encourage the development of
inuepenuent auuiovisual meuia foi
organizations and individuals

www.03&L.3'.euu.
psinstitutes/.
73*_uev

DOO93.7 (.).*&$%
85)'3','. F ?D(8`@
Promoting sustainable
uevelopment in the Palestinian
teiiitoiies anu self-ieliance of the
people thiough gieatei contiol ovei
theii natuial iesouices."

www.*&3_.oig

6*k*5 G.Q.9#O/.5'
<.5'.&
Beveloping Palestinian civil society
wheie iespect foi pluiality, iule of
law anu social justice aie the pillais
foi a fiee uemociatic inuepenuent
state.

http:www.maan
-cti.oig
<.5'.& 4#& =#/.5
+.1*9 (.).*&$% *57
<#,5).9351 ?<=+(<@
Enhancing women's social anu legal
rights in Palestinian society

www.cwlic.psen

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[z

Table S: Nu0s funueu by the Fiieuiich Ebeit Stiftung
STU) G.)$&3O'3#5 >*&'5.&) (.4.&.5$.
D7Q* <.5'.& Social policy in Israel
8)&*.93
>*&'5.&)

www.auva.oig
B.3' B.&39 <#99.1. Bighei Euucation
www.beitbeil.ac.il
Pagesuefault.as
px
B.&9 C*'L5.9)#5
J#,57*'3#5
Euucation anu Zionist laboi
movement
www.beil.co.il
<.5'.& 4#&
2#$3*9 85_,)'3$. *57
G./#$&*$E
The van Leei }eiusalem Institute
www.vanleei.oig.i
l
:$#5#/3$) *57
2#$3.'E >&#1&*/
The van Leei }eiusalem Institute
www.vanleei.oig.i
l
J#,57*'3#5 2%.3N%
D/35 I*&344
Foi the Auvancement of the Biuze
Community in Isiael
www.fes.oig.il
T3Q*' A*Q3Q*
Building a socially cohesive society
in Israel
www.givathaviva.
oig.il
A*N300,'L
A*/.,$%*7
Sifiiat Poalim Publishing uioup
www.kibutz-
poalim.co.il
A*S#*& A*UQ.7 Q.
A*+#/.7
Youth euucation movement www.noal.oig.il
A*)%#/.& A*'L*3& Zionist youth movement
www.hashomei-
hatzaii.oig
A3)'*7&,' Economic insitution
www.histauiut.oi
g.il
A3)'*7&,' A*6#&3/
?8I[@
Euucatois www.itu.oig.il
8l9*/
Neuia Centei foi Aiab Palestinians in
Isiael
www.ilam-
centei.oig
8S22
Institute foi National Secuiity
Stuuies
www.nuu.euuins
s

8G< Institute foi Policy anu Stiategy, http:poital.iuc.a
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[

Inteiuisciplinaiy Centei Beizliya c.ilenmainhom
epagePageshom
epage.aspx
85'.&5*'3#5*9
85)'3','. #4
+.*7.&)%3O F
A3)'*7&,'
Isiael Inuustiial Relations Reseaich
Association
www.peoples.oig.
il
88((D
Isiael Inuustiial Relations Reseaich
Association
www.h-net.oig

C300,'L 6#Q./.5' F
<#&O#&*'3Q. 2'&.*/
Serves as a platform for news,
meuia, anu exchange of views in
striving for equality
www.shavim.oig.i
l
A.0&.M [53Q.&)3'E #4
`.&,)*9./
Law anu Social Secuiity Foium, The
Faculty of Law Laboui
www.law.huji.ac.il

6D<(U Centei foi Political Economics
www.macio.oig.il

6,)),*% Institute foi Bolocaust Stuuies
http:www.mass
uah.oig.il
6#))*M* <.5'.&
The Auvocacy Centei foi Aiab
Citizens in Isiael
www.mossawace
ntei.oiguefault
634*9#'
Euucation anu Social Pioject
www.mifalot.co.il

S*l*/*' 8)&*.9
Novement of Woiking Women anu
volunteeis
www.naamat.oig
S*'3#5*9 +*0#,&
<#,&' #4 8)&*.9
}uuicial infoimation
www.elyon1.couit
.gov.il
S.'*5E* D$*7./3$
<#99.1.
Bighei Euucation
www.netanya.ac.il

>.&.) <.5'.& 4#&
>.*$.
Promotes peace building between
Israel and its Arab neighbors.
www.peies-
centei.oig
(,OO35 D$*7./3$ Bighei Euucation www.iuppin.ac.il
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[[









<.5'.&
[53Q.&)3'E #4 A*34*
School of Social Woik
www.hw.haifa.ac.i
lsocialenglish
2%*'39
Provides support and advice for
social change in Israel.
www.shatil.oig.il
=.>#M.&
Promoting women in the public anu
political arena
www.ken.oig.il
>D228D
Palestinian Acauemic Society foi the
Stuuy of Inteinational Affaiis
>*9.)'353*5
>*&'5.&)
www.passia.oig
6D2
Palestine Economic Policy Reseaich
Institute
www.pal-
econ.oig
8><<
Inteinational Peace anu Coopeiation
Centie
www.ipcc-
jeiusalem.oig
=DI<
Womens Affairs Technical
Committee
www.watcpal.oig
AG8>
Bealth Bevelopment Infoimation anu
Policy Institute
www.huip.oig
`6<<
}eiusalem Neuia anu Communication
Centei
www.jmcc.oig
S2G+
The National Society foi Bemociacy
anu Law
http:www.nsul.
oig.psinuex.html
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[g

Table 4: Nu0s funueu by the Fiieuiich Naumann Stiftung
STU) G.)$&3O'3#5 >*&'5.&) (.4.&.5$.
B. J&.. ?8)&*.9
<%#4)%3'@
A civil movement, not a party, which
works for a free, pluralistic and democratic
spirit of Zionism and the Declaration of
" Independence

Isiaeli
www.bfiee.oig
Tbe Citizens Accord
J#&,/ 4#& `.M) *57
D&*0) 35 8)&*.9
?<DJ@
The citizens accord forum between Jews
and Arabs in Israel
www.jaffaconven
tion.oig.il
805 C%*97,5
D))#$3*'3#5
Strengthening and promoting
coopeiation anu fellowship between
Tunisia and Japan.

www.ibnukhaluu
n.oig

8G<
Institute foi Policy anu Stiategy,
Inteiuisciplinaiy Centei Beizliya
www.iuc.ac.il
>.&.) <.5'.& 4#&
>.*$.
Promotes peace building between Israel
and its Arab neighbors.
www.peies-
centei.oig
8)&*.93 D))#$3*'3#5
4#& '%. 2',7E #4
:,&#O.*5
85'.1&*'3#5 ?8D2:8@
Bighei Euucation in Isiael anu Euiope
www.micioS.msc
c.huji.ac.il
`.&,)*9./ 85)'3','.
4#& 8)&*.9 2',73.)
Independent academic research
institute foi Policy Stuuies on }eiusalem,
the Isiaeli-Palestinian conflict anu
environmental policy.
www.jiis.oig.il
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[6

2b G*53.9 D0&*%*/
<.5'.& 4#& 2'&*'.13$
G3*9#1,.
Bighei Euucation
www.suc.netanya
.ac.il
2'.O%.5 (#'%
85)'3','.
Stuuy of Contempoiaiy Antisemitism
anu Racism
www.tau.ac.il
D6DS Coalition foi Integiity & Accountability
Palestinian
www.aman-
palestine.oig
8<<
Inteinational Chambei of Commeice
ICC Palestine

www.iccpalestine
.com
<G<G
Centei foi Bemociacy & Community
Bevelopment

www.cu-cu.oig
J39*)'353E*'
Supporter of real and effective
paiticipation of Palestinian women anu
youth at all levels of uecision-making anu
public works.

www.filastiniyat.
oig
>.&.) <.5'.& 4#&
>.*$.
Promotes peace building between Israel
and its Arab neighbors.
www.peies-
centei.oig
J>> Fieeuom Foium Palestine
www.fieeuompal.
oig
CD(D6D
Inteinational Campaign foi Fieeuom of
Novement foi Palestinian Women
www.el-
kaiama.oig
MAAN News Agency Piimaiy news outlet in Palestine
www.maannews.
net
6D(2DG
Aiab Woilu uemociacy & Electoial www.maisauaiab
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[y










Nonitoi

i.oig
>*9.)'353*5 <#5493$'
(.)#9,'3#5 85)'3','.
{Taawon]
Supports civil peace and the
uevelopment of the capacities of
inuiviuuals, gioups anu institutions to
deal with the conflict in Palestine.

www.taawon4yo
uth.oig
(<A(2
Ramallah Centei foi Buman Rights
Stuuies

www.ichis.oig
>T8
Palestine uoveinance Institute

http:www.pgi.p
s
><(G
Palestinian Centei foi Reseaich &
Cultuial Bialogue

www.pciu-
pal.oig
H:> Young Entiepieneuis Palestine www.yep.ps
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[8

Table S: Nu0s funueu by the Koniau Auenauei Stiftung
STU) G.)$&3O'3#5 >*&'5.&) (.4.&.5$.
D`< Ameiican }ewish Committee
Isiaeli
www.ajc.oig
B*&F89*5 [53Q.&)3'E Ramat-uan www1.biu.ac.il
B.5FT,&3#5
[53Q.&)3'E #4 '%.
S.1.Q
The Centei foi Beuouin Stuuies anu
Bevelopment
www.web.bgu.ac
.il
<`D:G
The Centei foi }ewish-Aiab Economic
Bevelopment
www.cjaeu.oig.il

<2:>2
The Centei foi the Stuuy of Euiopean
Politics anu Society
www.euiopebgu.
oig.il
I%. A.0&.M
[53Q.&)3'E #4
`.&,)*9./
The Baiiy S. Tiuman Reseaich Institute
foi the Auvancement of Peace
http:tiuman.h
uji.ac.il
I%. A.0&.M
[53Q.&)3'E #4
`.&,)*9./
The Belmut Kohl Institute foi Euiopean
Stuuies
www.ef.huji.ac.il

A:2C:6cT.5.Q*
853'3*'3Q.
Aims for a model permanent status
agieement between the State of Isiael
and the Palestinians.

www.geneva-
accoiu.oig
8<2G
The Inteifaith Centei foi Sustainable
Bevelopment
www.inteifaiths
ustain.com
8<<8
The Inteiieligious Cooiuinating Council
in Isiael
www.icci.co.il
8G8 The Isiael Bemociacy Institute
http:en.iui.oig.
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

[q

il
8><(8
Isiael Palestine Centei foi Reseaich anu
Infoimation
http:www.ipci
i.oig
8=S
Israel Womens Network: To promote
the staus of women in Israel
www.iwn.oig.il
I%. `.&,)*9./
J#,57*'3#5
Nishkenot Sha'ananim
www.jeiusalemf
ounuation.oig
I.9 DQ3Q [53Q.&)3'E
Koniau Auenauei Piogiam foi }ewish-
Aiab Coopeiation
www.uayan.oig
kapjac
I%. A.0&.M
[53Q.&)3'E #4
`.&,)*9./
Nineiva Centei foi Buman Rights
http:law.huji.a
c.il
2b G*53.9 D0&*%*/
<.5'.& 4#& 2'&*'.13$
G3*9#1,.
Combining academic work with
piactical effoits in oiuei to contiibute
to conflict stabilization on the iegional
and global level.

www.netanya.ac.
il
2>S8
Society foi the piotection of Natuie in
Isiael
http:aspni.oig

[53Q.&)3'E #4 A*34* Bighei Euucation www.haifa.ac.il
H*7 ;*)%./
Israels official memorial to the
Holocaust

www.yauvashem
.oig
`<>D The }eiusalem Centei foi Public Affaiis www.jcpa.oig
I%. 2%*9./ <.5'.& Bighei Euucation
http:shalem.ac.
il
>T8 Palestine uoveinance Institute Palestinian www.pgi.ps
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

go

8U+P B3&L.3'
[53Q.&)3'E
Institute of Law
http:lawcentei
.biizeit.euuiola
iinuex.php
>2(
Palestinian Centei foi Policy anu Suivey
Reseaich
http:www.pcp
si.oig
8<> Institute foi Community Paitneiship
http:bethlehe
m.euuicp
D9FC*)*0* I%.*'.&
,57 C35#
Activate cultuial life in Palestine
thiough the piouuction of plays anu
host artistic performances

http:www.alka
saba.oig
68JIDA
The Palestinian Initiative foi the
Piomotion of ulobal Bialogue anu
Bemociacy

http:www.mift
ah.oig
`.&,)*9./ B##N
<9,0
Smith School in East }eiusalem
http:www.heili
g-lanu-
veiein.ueEiniic
htungenSchmiu
t-
Schuleschmiut-
schule.html
8D+882
Ibiahim Abu-Lughou-Institute of
International Studies: Contribute to
the establishment of a uynamic,
uemociatic Palestinian state that
enteitains stiong ties to the
international system

http:ialiis.biize
it.euu
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g

Table 6: Nu0s funueu by the Bans Seiuel Stiftung

STU)
G.)$&3O'3#5 >*&'5.&) (.4.&.5$.
2U2 The Isiaeli Centei foi violence Stuuies
Isiaeli
http:www.sosc
entei.oig.ileng
2>S8
Society foi the Piotection of Natuie in
Isiael
http:www.natu
ieisiael.oig

2%*'39
Leading social change in Isiael,
piomoting a shaieu society baseu on
social, economic anu enviionmental
justice, human anu civil iights, anu
cultural and religious pluralism.
www.shatil.oig.il
english
IIamF 6.73* <.5'.&
Contribute to a shaieu society, by
piomoting meuia iights among the
Aiab society in Israel.

http:www.ilam
-
centei.oigeng
main.php

<DJ
Citizens Accoiu Foium between }ews
anu Aiabs in Isiael
www.caf.oig.il

D&*Q* 85)'3','.
Peace-builuing anu Enviionmental
Leaueiship
http:www.aiav
a.oig

DmT Acauemy foi Quality uoveinment
www.aqg.oig.il

>=+2 Palestine Wilulife Society Palestinian
http:www.wilu
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

gz


Table 7: Nu0 Paitnei Piojects with Neuico Inteinational
life-pal.oig

D&*0 D/.&3$*5
[53Q.&)3'E `.535
Conflict Resolution and Crisis
Nanagement in Schools"

http:www.aauj.
euu
TE*53/
Association foi Euucation anu
Community Involvement
www.gvanim.oig.
ileng

STU) G.)$&3O'3#5 >&#_.$'
[D=<
The Isiaeli Centei foi
violence Stuuies
Building kindergartens for children in unrecognized
villages in the Jordan Valley.

<#/.'F6:
Society foi the Piotection
of Natuie in Isiael
Building solar and wind energy installations to
support the southern West Bank and a Comet Center.
>A(F8
Funuing foi inteinational auvocacy
Mobile clinics for marginalized towns in the
Westbank
>6(2
Palestinian Neuical Relief
Society
School for Community healthcare.
Community oriented health services, nutritional
counseling anu uietaiy supplements foi chiluien in the
Gaza Strip.
Basic healthcare services for marginalized
communities in Gaza and the West Bank
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g











6(2 Neuical Relief Society
Bealth woik in schools, meuical caie anu health
euucation foi iesiuents of the enclaces in anu aiounu
East }eiusalem
<JID
Cultuie anu Fiee Thought
Association
Campaign foi eaily uetection of bieast cancei anu foi
the suppoit of bieast cancei patients in the uaza Stiip
<=>
Coalition of Women foi
Peace
Phaimaceutical stuuy: Who piofits fiom the
occupation.
D9 6.L*5 <.5'.& Basic funuing foi human iights woik
D7*9*%
The Legal Centei foi Aiab
Ninoiity Rights in Isiael
Campaign woik foi meuical iights of Palestinian
citizens of Isiael.
IJI The Fieeuom Theatie
Lawyer costs for razzias and assaults by the Israeli
militaiy
Bemonstiation with giant puppets against the wall in
Al- Walajah.
Playback Theatei, Psycho-Biama foi conflict
tiansfoimation anu tiauma euucational piogiam
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g[

APPENBIX B: C0RRESP0NBENCE BETWEEN Nu0 N0NIT0R ANB TBE F0NBINu FRANEW0RKS
Nu0 Nonitoi, uuiing its ieseaich, contacteu some of the ueiman funuing fiamewoiks with iequests foi
fuithei infoimation iegaiuing funuing anu paitneiship with Isiaeli anu Palestinian Nu0s. See the
coiiesponuence below.
(#)* +,-./0,&1 2'34',51
STU 6#53'#& 737 5#' &.$.3Q. * &.)O#5). 4&#/ '%. (#)* +,-./0,&1 2'34',51 &.1*&7351 3') 35R,3&Eb


}uly 31, 2u1S
Rosa Luxemburg Foundations funding for Israeli and Palestinian NGOs
Beai Bi. Timm,
Cuiiently, Nu0 Nonitoi is piepaiing a compiehensive upuate of its ieseaich on funuing foi
Isiaeli anu Palestinian Nu0s.
We woulu appieciate if you woulu pioviue uetails of the funuing foi Bagaua Basmalit, Baokets,
Sheikh }aiiah Soliuaiity Novement, Negev Coexistence Foium foi Civil Equality anu
Combatants foi Peace, which list Rosa Luxembuig Founuation as funuei.
1. What was the total amount pioviueu by Rosa
Luxembuig Founuation in 2u1u, 2u11 anu 2u12.
2. Foi which piojects weie the funus eaimaikeu.
S. Is this infoimation publicly available. Wheie.

As pait of the tianspaiency piocess, we woulu like to ask you to pioviue us with this impoitant
infoimation as soon as possible.
We appieciate youi coopeiation anu look foiwaiu to heaiing fiom you.
Sinceiely,
Euiope Besk, Nu0 Nonitoi
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

gg

A.35&3$% Bn99 2'34',51







July 31, 2013
Heinrich Bll Foundations funding for Israeli NGOs
Dear Mr. Berthold,
Currently, NGO Monitor is preparing a comprehensive update of its research on funding for Israeli and
Palestinian NGOs.
We would appreciate if you would provide details of the funding for Mossawa Center and +972, which
list Heinrich Bll Foundation as funder.
1. What was the total amount provided by Heinrich Bll Foundation in 2010, 2011 and
2012?
2. For which projects were the funds earmarked?
3. Is this information publicly available? Where?

As part of the transparency process, we would like to ask you to provide us with this important information
as soon as possible.
We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
Europe Desk
NGO Monitor
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g6

STU 6#53'#& 737 5#' &.$.3Q. * &.)O#5). 4&#/ '%. A.35&3$% Bn99 2'34',51 &.1*&7351 3') 35R,3&Eb









July 31, 2013
Heinrich Bll Foundations funding for Palestinian NGOs
Dear Dr. Wildangel,
Currently, NGO Monitor is preparing a comprehensive update of its research on funding for Israeli
and Palestinian NGOs.
We would appreciate if you would provide details of the funding for Maan Development Center and
the Applied Research Institute Jerusalem, which list Heinrich Bll Foundation as funder.
1. What was the total amount provided by Heinrich Bll Foundation in 2010,
2011 and 2012?
2. For which projects were the funds earmarked?
3. Is this information publicly available? Where?
As part of the transparency process, we would like to ask you to provide us with this important
information as soon as possible.
We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
Europe Desk
NGO Monitor

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

gy

J&3.7&3$% :0.&' 2'34',51



STU 6#53'#& 737 5#' &.$.3Q. * &.)O#5). 4&#/ '%. J&3.7&3$% :0.&' 2'34',51 &.1*&7351 3') 35R,3&Eb





}uly S1, 2u1S
Friedrich Ebert Foundations funding for Israeli NGOs
Dear Dr. Hexel,
Currently, NGO Monitor is preparing a comprehensive update of its research on funding for Israeli
and Palestinian NGOs.
We would appreciate if you would provide details of the funding for Ilam- Media Center for Arab
Palestinians in Israel, Mossawa Center and Shatil, which list Friedrich Ebert Foundation as funder.
1. What was the total amount provided by Friedrich Ebert Foundation in 2010,
2011 and 2012?
2. For which projects were the funds earmarked?
3. Is this information publicly available? Where?

As part of the transparency process, we would like to ask you to provide us with this important
information as soon as possible.
We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
Europe Desk
NGO Monitor

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

g8

J&3.7&3$% S*,/*55 2'34',51






July 31, 2013
Friedrich Naumann Foundations funding for Maan News Agency
Dear Mr. Klitz,
Currently, NGO Monitor is preparing a comprehensive update of its research on funding for Israeli and
Palestinian NGOs.
We would appreciate if you would provide details of the funding for Maan News Agency, which
lists Friedrich Naumann Foundation as funder.
1. What was the total amount provided by Friedrich Naumann Foundation in 2010,
2011 and 2012?
2. For which projects were the funds earmarked?
3. Is this information publicly available? Where?
As part of the transparency process, we would like to ask you to provide us with this important
information as soon as possible.
We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
Europe Desk
NGO Monitor
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

gq

(.)O#5). 4&#/ J&3.7&3$% S*,/*55 2'34',51 ?D,1,)' VWP W^VX@


E /$.-F "#$&0* GF >1#+':#$, +8 19# @$#8+*#'1 .- 6"7 G.'+1.$F





3-1#$ $#1)$'+', -$.% %5 4&2&1+.'H < -.)'* 5.)$ #%&+0 +' %5 %&+0+', 0+81F

38 5.) I'.J 19# 6&)%&'' (.)'*&1+.' +8 4#$5 %)29 *#*+2&1#* 1. %&I# &00 .- +18
&21+4+1+#8 J.$0*J+*# &8 1$&'@&$#'1 &8 @.88+:0#F A9# %.$# < #K@#21 -$.% .19#$
.$,&'+L&1+.'H +F#F 19.8# J9. @$#1#'* 1. 81&'* -.$ 1$&'@&$#'25 '.1 1. 8#'* &'.'5%.)8
$#M)#818F < &% 8)$# 5.) )'*#$81&'* 19&1 < &% '.1 J+00+', 1. &'8J#$ 5.)$ M)#81+.'8
)'*#$ 19#8# 2.'*+1+.'8F

N#81 $#,&$*8

O&01#$ P0+1L

August 12, 2u1S
Beai Ni. Klitz,

In youi email, we uiu not finu a iesponse iegaiuing funuing foi the Na'an Founuation in
2u1u, 2u11, anu 2u12. Peihaps you foigot to incluue this, anu we await this infoimation.
We woulu also be inteiesteu in a meeting with you as soon as possible to uiscuss these
impoitant issues, anu hope you will agiee.

ueialu N. Steinbeig

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6o
























3),)81 DQH BCDR
S#&$ /$.-F >1#+':#$,H

19&'I 5.) .'2# %.$# -.$ 5.)$ #%&+0F

(+$81 .- &00 0#1 %# &*T)81 8.%#19+',F A9# "#$%&' @.0+1+2&0 -.)'*&1+.'8 &$# '. @$+4&1#
6"7U8F N#+', $#,+81#$#* +' 19# >1&1# .- <8$&#0 J# &$# &22.)'1&:0# 1. 19# <8$&#0+
&)19.$+1+#8 &'* J# -)005 2.%@05 1. 19# 0#,&0 $#M)+$#%#'18 .- 5.)$ 2.)'1$5F

N#81H

O&01#$ P0+1L
August 1S, 2u1S
Thank you foi youi iesponse, but we uo not unueistanu it. The issue of Isiaeli legal
iequiiements foi ueiman oi othei goveinment-funueu political gioups such as youis was
not iaiseu in oui questions iegaiuing funuing foi Naan News Agency. 0nless otheiwise
infoimeu, oui iepoit will note that you have chosen not to uisclose this infoimation, which
is youi iight. As an Isiaeli civil society oiganization, I again invite you to a meeting in oiuei
to uiscuss these impoitant issues.

ueialu Steinbeig

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6

A*5) 2.37.9 2'34',51



STU 6#53'#& 737 5#' &.$.3Q. * &.)O#5). 4&#/ '%. A*5) 2.37.9 J#,57*'3#5 &.1*&7351 3') 35R,3&Eb





July 31, 2013
Hans Seidel foundations funding for Israeli NGOs
Dear Mr. Asbeck,
Currently, NGO Monitor is preparing a comprehensive update of its research on funding for
Israeli and Palestinian NGOs.
We would appreciate if you would provide details of the funding for Shatil and Ilam- Media
Center for Arab Palestinians in Israel, which list Hans Seidel Foundation as a funder.
1. What was the total amount provided by Hans Seidel Foundation in 2010,
2011 and 2012?
2. For which projects were the funds earmarked?
3. Is this information publicly available? Where?
As part of the transparency process, we would like to ask you to provide us with this important
information as soon as possible.
We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
Europe Desk
NGO Monitor

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6z


6.73$# 85'.&5*'3#5*9





July 31, 2013
Medico Internationals funding for Israeli and Palestinian NGOs

Dear Sir/Madam,
Currently, NGO Monitor is preparing a comprehensive update of its research on funding for Israeli
and Palestinian NGOs.
We would appreciate if you would provide details of the funding for Zochrot, Al- Mezan Center and
Palestinian Medical Relief Society which list Medico International as funder.
1. What was the total amount provided by Medico International in 2010, 2011
and 2012?
2. For which projects were the funds earmarked?
3. Is this information publicly available? Where?

As part of the transparency process, we would like to ask you to provide us with this important
information as soon as possible.
We appreciate your cooperation and look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
Europe Desk
NGO Monitor

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6

(.)O#5). 4&#/ 6.73$# 85'.&5*'3#5*9 #5 `,9E XVP W^VX















S#&$ V&*+#8 W "#'10#%#'H *#&$ N#'T&%+' O#+'#$19&0H *#&$ 2.00#&,)#8 .- 19# ?#$)8&0#%
/.81H
/0#&8# *. 2.'8)01 .)$ J#:8+1# JJJF%#*+2.F*#F A9#$# 5.) J+00 -+'* .)$ &'')&0 $#@.$18
-.$ 19# 5#&$8 %#'1+.'#*H &8 %#*+2. +'1#$'&1+.'&0 2.%@0+#8 J+19 19# 4#$5 9+,9
1$&'8@&$#'25 $#,)0&1+.'8 .- 19# (#*#$&0 X#@):0+2 .- "#$%&'5F
O+19 I+'*#81 $#,&$*8
A8&-$+$ =.9#'

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6[

A second inquiry was made after the finalization of NGO Monitors research and befoie the ielease of
the report. NGO Monitor sent a draft version to all of the funding frameworks. See NGO Monitors letter,
anu the iesponses below.
NCU Monitors letter to tbe Cerman political foundations:
Sent to:
The Rosa Luxembuig Founuation
The Beiniich Boll Founuation
The Koniau Auenauei Founuation
The Bans Seiuel Founuation
The Fiieuiich Naumann Founuation
The Fiieuiich Ebeit Founuation


(.)O#5). 4&#/ '%. T.&/*5 O#93'3$*9 4#,57*'3#5)

0ctobei S

Beai,
Nu0 Nonitoi has completeu ieseaich on ueiman funuing foi political auvocacy Nu0s
opeiating in the Aiab-Isiaeli conflict. Befoie we piesent it to the public, we aie
pioviuing you with a uiaft section of oui iepoit that ueals with ueiman Stiftungen anu
theii activities in the iegion.

If you have comments on the infoimation piesenteu, we look foiwaiu to heaiing fiom
you no latei than 0ctobei 14.
Sinceiely,

}ouy Sieiauzki
Euiope Besk
Nu0 Nonitoi

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6g








Jerusalem and Tel Aviv, 10 October 2013
Dear Ms. Sieradzki,
The representatives of the German political foundations in Israel have taken notice of
the NGO Monitor draft report as of 3 October 2013 on the topic German Funding for
Political Advocacy NGOs Active in the Arab-Israeli Conflict.
The German political foundations are a unique instrument of the Federal Republic of
Germany. We take pride in the wide range of our contributions to political dialogue,
stipends, academia and development cooperation as well as in the endorsements we
receive from all sectors of Israeli society. It is the belief in pluralistic democracy that
remains the guiding principle for our work and for our diverse contributions to our
partner countries.
We jointly reject the one-sided and limited conclusions, which NGO Monitor draws
in the above-mentioned report. We regard your conclusions as unfounded allegations
resulting out of a biased, incomplete and scientifically flawed research.
We did ponder about clarifying the vast amount of shortcomings of your report
through a close and collaborative interaction with your organization. However, in
light of the political record and the questionable approach of NGO Monitor in Israel
in the recent past, we regard this as an entirely futile effort.
Our scope of action will remain unaffected by your report. We certainly will continue
to provide - with full integrity, legality and accountability - our value-based
contributions to the German-Israeli relations, to the strengthening of pluralistic and
democratic societies, and to the Middle East peace process towards a viable Two
State Solution.
Sincerely,
The Representatives of the German Political Foundations


"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

66










721.:#$ DYH BCDR
S#&$ &00H

O# $#2#+4#* 5.)$ 0#11#$ .- 721.:#$ DCH &'* J9+0# J# J#$# 8)$@$+8#* :5 19# &88#88%#'1 &'*
'#,&1+4# 1.'#H J# 9.@# 19&1 & 8):81&'1+4# *+&0.,)# .' 19#8# 4#$5 +%@.$1&'1 M)#81+.'8 J+00
-.00.JF
/0#&8# '.1# 19&1 J# 8#'1 5.) 19# $#0#4&'1 8#21+.'8 .- .)$ *#1&+0#* *$&-1 $#@.$1 +' ,..* -&+19H
+' .$*#$ 1. @$#8#'1 5.) J+19 19# .@@.$1)'+15 1. 20&$+-5 *#1&+08 &'* @$.4+*# 19# %+88+',
-)'*+', *&1& &8 @&$1 .- 19# 1$&'8@&$#'25 +'4.04+', @):0+2 -)'*8 19&1 +8 2#'1$&0 -.$
*#%.2$&1+2 @$.2#88#8F 38 89.J'H 8.%# .- 19# #'1$+#8 +' 5.)$ J#:8+1#8 &'* @):0+2&1+.'8 &$#
&08. )'20#&$F 7)$ 9.@# +8 19&1 5.) J+00 $#2.'8+*#$ .)$ $#M)#81 :&8#* .' 19# 8@+$+1 .-
2.'81$)21+4# 2..@#$&1+.'F
O# &$# @$.4+*+', 5.) J+19 .)$ -)00 *$&-1 $#@.$1H &11&29#* 9#$#H J9+29 +'20)*#8 +'-.$%&1+.'
19&1 J# $#2#+4#* -$.% 19.8# J9. $#8@.'*#* 1. .)$ +'+1+&0 0#11#$F <' 19# -)00 @):0+2&1+.'H 5.)
will note that this report is consistent with NGO Monitors mandate in the Israeli context.
O# *. '.1 20&+% 1. &'&05L# #4#$519+',H &'* 19# +88)#8 $#0&1#* 1. 19# )8# .- "#$%&'
1&K@&5#$ -)'*+', +' &'5 -.$% .- *#%.'+L&1+.' &'* @.0+1+2&0 J&$-&$# 1&$,#1+', <8$&#0H
$#,&$*0#88 .- .19#$ @$.,$&%8H &$# 1.. +%@.$1&'1 1. :# 8+%@05 *+8%+88#* )'*#$ 19# 0&:#0 .-
balance.
O# :#0+#4# 19&1 2.'1+')#* *+&0.,)# +8 #88#'1+&0 &'* +18 +%@.$1&'2# 1$&'82#'*8 &'5
*+--#$#'2#8 +' @#$8@#21+4#F O# 9.@# 19&1 +'81#&* .- *+8%+88+', 19#8# 2#'1$&0 +88)#8H 5.) J+00
&00 &,$## 1. & ')&'2#* *+82)88+.' .' 19# +88)#8 @$#8#'1#* +' .)$ $#@.$1F
>+'2#$#05H
?.*5 >+#$&*LI+
6"7 G.'+1.$


"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6y

(.)O#5). 4&#/ '%. J&3.7&3$% :0.&' 2'34',51 *57 '%. =399E B&*57' <.5'.& on 0ctobei 11


















Dear Ms. Sieradzki,
the Friedrich Ebert Stiftung in Israel and the Willy Brandt Center have taken notice of
the NGO Monitor draft report as of 3 October 2013 on the topic German Funding for
Political Advocacy NGOs Active in the Arab-Israeli Conflict.

The report states that the Willy Brandt Center receives funding from the Friedrich Ebert
Stiftung. This information is not correct. The Friedrich-Ebert-Stiftung does not provide
any funding to the Willy-Brandt-Center.

Sincerely Yours
Friedrich- Ebert-Stiftung Dr. Werner Puschra
Willy Brandt Center Yeliz Bercht

October 17, 2013

Dear Mr. Dinkelaker,

Thank you for your response. We will adjust our report accordingly.
We do have some further questions regarding the relationship between WBC and the FES. On
the WBC website, FES is listed as a "supporter" of the Willy Brandt Center. What does the WBC
specifically mean when referring to FES as a "supporter?"

Thank you,

Jody Sieradzki

NGO Monitor



"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

68

(.)O#5). 4&#/ '%. J&3.7&3$% S*,/*55 J#,57*'3#5 on 0ctobei S, 2u1S








Beai }ouy,

thank you foi senuing me the uiaft of youi iepoit.

The uiaft conveys a wiong impiession of the activities of the ueiman political founuations in
the the occupieu teiiitoiies. I stiongly iecommenu you to make the following changes:
The Naumann Founuation spents ioughly 2S Nillion E0R0 foi its woiluwiue activities in
moie than 6u countiies. The Founuation uoes not financially contiibute to any palestinian
oiganization. The annual buuget foi joineu activities is 6u.uuu.- E0R0. We uon't suppoit
activieties which aie uiiecteu against Isiael. 0ui aim is to contiibute to a solution of the peace
piocess which is in line to the politcal will of the Isiaeli uoveinment.

All othei claims aie uefamation anu I call on you to stop spieauing them.

Best iegaius

Waltei Klitz
"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

6q










721.:#$ ZH BCDR
S#&$ G$F P0+1LH
A9&'I 5.) -.$ 5.)$ $#8@.'8#F <1 +8 $#,$#11&:0# 19&1 19+8 +'-.$%&1+.' J&8 '.1 @$.4+*#* +' $#8@.'8# 1.
.)$ @$#4+.)8 $#M)#818F
O# J.)0* &@@$#2+&1# +1 +- 5.) 2.)0* 20&$+-5 19# -.00.J+', @.+'18[
DF X#,&$*+', 19# ZCHCCC \)$. &'')&0 :)*,#1 -.$ T.+'1 &21+4+1+#8 J+19 /&0#81+'+&' @.0+1+2&0
&*4.2&25 6"78H J9+29 J# J+00 '.1# +' .)$ $#4+8#* $#@.$1H &$# 5.) &:0# 1. @$.4+*# 19# *#1&+08
$#,&$*+', 19# '&%#8 .- 19# 6"78 &'* 19# '&1)$# .- 19# &21+4+1+#8]
BF <' &**+1+.'H +1 +8 +%@.$1&'1 1. 20&$+-5 19# $#0&1+.' :#1J##' 5.)$ .$,&'+L&1+.' &'*
19# /&0#81+'+&' @&$1'#$8 0+81#* .' 5.)$ J#:8+1#F O9&1 +8 %#&'1 :5 19# 1#$% ^@&$1'#$8^]
X#,&$*+', 5.)$ .19#$ 81&1#%#'1H J# *. '.1 )'*#$81&'* 5.)$ &00#,&1+.'F 38 '.1#* +' .)$ @$#4+.)8
requests, NGO Monitors goal in publishing this research is to promote accountability and democratic
1$&'8@&$#'25F
7'2# &,&+'H J# +'4+1# 5.) 1. *+82)88 19#8# 2#'1$&0 +88)#8 +' @#$8.' +' ?#$)8&0#%F
>+'2#$#05H
?.*5 >+#$&*LI+H
6"7 G.'+1.$




"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

yo












October 7, 2013
Dear Jody,

let me repeat once more: the Naumann Foundation is only accountable to the Israeli Authorities
and not to NGO Monitoring. Nevertheless I am willing to contribute in order to get the facts and
your conclusions right

Prof. Steinberg knows quite well from his time with the Begin Sadat Center how much the
Friedrich Naumann Foundation is determined to foster the German-Israeli relationship. and how
the Naumann Foundation deals with its domestic partners. We don't provide any financial or
institutional support. We are only cooperating on the basis of joint activities which are directed to
support the peace process in this region.

Please take note that 100% of the funds of the Naumann Foundation come from state budget.

Best regards

Walter Klitz

"#$%&' ()'*+', -.$ /.0+1+2&0 3*4.2&25 6"78 321+4# +' 19# 3$&:;<8$&#0+ =.'-0+21

y

NCU Monitors letter to tbe otber Cerman funding frameworks:
Sent to: Niseieoi, Neuico Inteinational, Biot fuei uie welt EEB, EvZ, IFA, uIZ. The ueiman Embassy in
Tel Aviv
STU 6#53'#& %*) 5#' &.$.3Q.7 *5E &.)O#5). '# 3') 35R,3&3.)b

October 8
Dear,
NGO Monitor has completed research on German funding for political advocacy NGOs
operating in the Arab-Israeli conflict. Before we present it to the public, we are providing you
with a draft of our report.
If you have comments on the information presented, we look forward to hearing from you no
later than October 18.
Sincerely,

Jody Sieradzki
Europe Desk
NGO Monitor

1 Ben-Maimon Blvd.
Jerusalem 92262 Israel
Phone: +972-2-566-1020
Fax: +972-77-511-7030
mail@ngo-monitor.org
www.ngo-monitor.org
NGO Monitors mission is to provide information and analysis, promote
accountability, and support discussion on the reports and activities of NGOs
claiming to advance human rights and humanitarian agendas.
NGO Monitor is a project of the Amutah for NGO Responsibility (R.A. 580465508)
Organization in Special consultative status with the UN Economic and Social Council since 2013.
2013 NGO Monitor. All rights reserved.
NGO Monitor Publications
NGO Malpractice: The Political Abuse of Medicine, Ethics, and Science (August 2013)
Bad Investment: The Philanthropy of George Soros and the Arab-Israeli Conict (May 2013)
Spanish Government Funding for NGOs: 20092011 (May 2013)
The Negative Impact of U.S. Government Funding for Mideast Political NGOs (May 2013)
The Goldstone Report Reconsidered A Critical Analysis (February 2012)
NGO Lawfare: Exploitation of Courts in the Arab-Israeli Conict (September 2008, expanded 2nd edition, December 2010)
Europes Hidden Hand (April 2008; revised 2nd edition, March 2009)
Experts or Ideologues? A Systematic Analysis of Human Rights Watchs Focus on Israel (September 2009)
Elliott Abrams
Amb. Yehuda Avner
Prof. Alan Dershowitz
Hon. Alexander Downer
Tom Gross
Col. Richard Kemp
Douglas Murray
Hon. Fiamma Nirenstein
Prof. Judea Pearl
Judge Abraham Sofaer
Prof. Elie Wiesel
Dr. Einat Wilf
Prof. Ruth Wisse
R. James Woolsey
INTERNATIONAL ADVISORY BOARD
PRESIDENT:
Prof. Gerald Steinberg