IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

DATA CARRIERS, LLC, Plaintiff, v. FRONTIER AIRLINES HOLDINGS, INC., Defendant. C.A. No. _________ JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

COMPLAINT FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT Plaintiff Data Carrier , LLC !"Plaintiff#$ alle%e t&e follo'in% for it (o)*laint a%ain t Defendant Frontier Airline Holdin% , In(. !"Defendant#$. THE PARTIES 1. +- ine Plaintiff i a Dela'are li)ited lia+ilit, (o)*an, &avin% a *rin(i*al *la(e of

at ./01 2ennett Pi3e, S-ite 411, 5il)in%ton, Dela'are 167/890/17. 0. Defendant i a (or*oration or%ani:ed -nder t&e la' of t&e State of Dela'are 'it&

a *rin(i*al offi(e at 76/6 P-rd-e Road, S-ite 1//, Indiana*oli , Indiana .;0;7. Defendant )a, +e erved 'it& *ro(e via it re%i tered a%ent Cor*oration Servi(e Co)*an,, 0811 Centerville

Road, S-ite .//, 5il)in%ton, Dela'are 167/7. JURISDICTION AND VENUE 1. T&i i a *atent infrin%e)ent a(tion. T&e Co-rt &a -+<e(t )atter <-ri di(tion

*-r -ant to 07 =.S.C. >>1111 and 1117. .. +- ine T&e Co-rt &a *er onal <-ri di(tion over Defendant, +e(a- e Defendant (ond-(t in t&i <-ri di(tion, in(l-din% +, offerin% and *ro)otin% ervi(e for ale via t&e

internet, '&i(& i a((e i+le to and a((e ed +, re ident of t&i Di tri(t. T&e Co-rt al o &a *er onal <-ri di(tion over Defendant, +e(a- e it i a Dela'are (or*oration. 4. ?en-e i *ro*er in t&i Di tri(t *-r -ant to 07 =.S.C. >>1161!+$9!($ and >1.//!+$,

+e(a- e Defendant re ide in t&i di tri(t and -+ tantial a(t of infrin%e)ent &ave o((-rred in t&i Di tri(t. COUNT ONE INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. PATENT NO. 5,388,198 ;. Plaintiff i t&e o'ner +, a i%n)ent of =nited State Patent No. 4,177,167 !t&e

"@167 *atent#$, entitled "Proa(tive Pre entation of A-to)atin% Feat-re to a Co)*-ter = er.# T&e a**li(ation for t&e @167 *atent 'a filed on A*ril 1;, 1660. T&e *atent i -ed on Fe+r-ar, 8, 1664 and 'a ori%inall, a i%ned to S,)ante( Cor*oration. A tr-e and (orre(t (o*, of t&e @167 Patent i atta(&ed a EA&i+it A &ereto. 8. Plaintiff &old t&e eA(l- ive ri%&t to ta3e all a(tion , in(l-din% t&e filin% of t&i

*atent infrin%e)ent la' -it, ne(e ar, to enfor(e it ri%&t to t&e @167 Patent. Plaintiff al o &a t&e ri%&t to re(over all da)a%e for *a t, *re ent, and f-t-re infrin%e)ent of t&e @167 Patent and to ee3 in<-n(tive relief a a**ro*riate -nder t&e la'. 7. Defendant &a dire(tl, infrin%ed, eit&er literall, or +, eB-ivalent , one or )ore

(lai) of t&e @167 Patent, in(l-din% at lea t Clai) 4, +, - in% t&e (lai)ed )et&od in o*eratin% t&e 'e+ ite '''.fl,frontier.(o) in a 'a, t&at a-to)ati(all, intervene in a (- to)er or *otential (- to)er@ - e of t&e 'e+ ite to -%%e t or *re ent feat-re +a ed on infor)ation on t&e - e of t&e , te), in(l-din% +-t not li)ited to a-to(o)*lete feat-re . 5&ile a - er i a((e in% t&e 'e+ ite, Defendant (ontin-o- l, )onitor and (o)*are - er )ani*-lation and *ro%ra) (onteAt 'it& feat-re te)*late fo-nd. 0 tored in )e)or, and *re ent a-to)atin% feat-re if a )at(& i

6.

Defendant@ o*eration of it 'e+ ite in t&e a+ove9de (ri+ed )anner in t&e =nited

State i 'it&o-t t&e *er)i ion of Plaintiff and (on tit-te infrin%e)ent -nder 14 =.S.C. >081 for '&i(& Defendant i lia+le. 1/. A a re -lt of Defendant@ infrin%e)ent, Plaintiff &a +een da)a%ed )onetaril, t&an a rea ona+le ro,alt, *-r -ant to 14

and i entitled to adeB-ate (o)*en ation of no le =.S.C. > 07..

JURY DEMAND Plaintiff reB-e t a <-r, on all i -e o tria+le. PRAYER 5HEREFORE, Plaintiff re *e(tf-ll, reB-e t t&at t&e Co-rtC A. @167 PatentD E. A'ard Plaintiff da)a%e for Defendant@ infrin%e)ent in an a)o-nt to +e Enter <-d%)ent t&at Defendant &a infrin%ed, eit&er literall, or +, eB-ivalent , t&e

deter)ined at trial, in(l-din% en&an(ed da)a%e , (o t , and *re and *o t9<-d%)ent intere tD and C. A'ard an, ot&er relief dee)ed <- t and *ro*er. EAGARD, P.A. I I Ste*&en E. Era-er)an ! +.640$ Ri(&ard D. 2ir3 !r3/600$ Ste*&en E. Era-er)an ! +.640$ ?ane a R. Tiradente !vt4167$ Sara E. E- iere ! +4804$ 000 Dela'are Aven-e, S-ite 6// 5il)in%ton, DE 167/1 !1/0$ ;4494/// r3ir3H+a,ardla'.(o) +ra-er)anH+a,ardla'.(o) vtiradente H+a,ardla'.(o) +- iereH+a,ardla'.(o) Attorneys for Plaintiff Data Carriers, LLC

Nove)+er 14, 0/11 OF CO=NSELC Pa-l ?. Stor) Sara& F. PaA on GARDERE 5GNNE SE5ELL LLP 1;/1 El) Street, S-ite 1/// Dalla , TeAa 840/1 !01.$ 66691/// *v tor)H%ardere.(o) *aA onH%ardere.(o)