Professional Documents
Culture Documents
HtsroRY (PRE-REGIONALIATION)
LONGTERMCONTROLPLAN
REGIONALI7IATION ALLOWS FOR EFFICIENCY COLLECTION SYSTEM IMPROVEMENTS
UNIQUE IDEAS
HARTFORD,
YORKCITY
COTdfVECTICUT
M ffi#6##ffiM*ffiffiv#ffiM W*/#ffierd" $r&wvsdrdlrd #ffimffiffi ffirudl d/-e#M/s P ffi#Jtr#ru*/Fsfru r ffitr ffitd" tr#'fl##ffi ffiM
#ffi#xr&ffi
Mffi
ffiffiffiryffiru
ffi
ESTABLISHED CONNECTION
sysf,ffi#d FEES
h-
i,i,ir
BUDGET MAINTENANCE
IMPROVED INSPECTIONS INFLOW REDUCTION MAXIMIZING USE OF THE CT DEEP CWF LOAN PROGRAM
ffiffiffiffiffisffiMffimMffi,,,
r*cr $frp
;sJ -!l
FORMERLY HAD LOOKED TO AN INFRASTRUCTURE INTENSIVE APPROACH TO CSO PLANNING $580M+ PROGRAM PROMPTED PROACTIVE RETHINKING OF THE CSO APPROACH
C AN D
TH
REG U
LAT
RS
W
tr$d4[d sdhr \[hL'(i liib{nlrrn
DEVELOPED STRATEGYTOMEETCSOGOALS
pd.,4tr &sMr#'&4rs --r#,&#$fftrffi ffip pffi#J#"trrs {/ffi{,frrrMffi #Mers M/ffitrtr ffiffi##"ffi svs?trM
r ltr i. *}rJipjl rf,r.:i rsl^M. \ :.++ .iii{ri{{ill ,i ----lq l;lii;;;-' tr n,r, Er-.. rfi .i .n ,i :1n .,r":ri:: .r.:(rr ir fi rfr !.: -i:.:.r:.'.
i r" ,.
,j ,rt
Irii5
l::l:: 1l':ii::.r
cS i.r,:
in ii...r, .n ,$ .n .$ rn : .,r d "r: .l il iig ,.. rri l,C ifl .:. .nt ;)h
ljS ire ra '!a iis :\,:i,i
i36 ig .r li{
:E tn liF irn
' .a'
;,r.i;..r".1.:
\Pa
r
;lr;-..r.1
1Pa.r l Atu
.:r@./El
rrd
I *E
I re@
,sPht
Mffitrvf,ffiffi
MMER TAPS
ltlg$ililletb[dlR{t Gaf;lnsfrmHroh.
u$$
sil.
,S
FOR
f;trffidd."s d
@ lB'
ptr&MA-LrrufrR
sosK
nt
t @.
r0
*rc
mDffi.affia
PLUENC
J#S$-6trff&ypffi{
ffifffffiffigru#ssdstr{/s*
rkns *F:--
wF"
""|dtu
the
,_ .,'': GREEAI S TRU CT URE
ieliminationorreductionofstormwaterinto16gMffiry
Authority' s combined sewer
Separate wherever possi ble, make developers build infras if a separated system is within reasonable distance to the site.
IAIFRA
system.
R*quire the developer to install infil systems and/or facilities to detain the Z-year 6-hour post development peak flow rate.
ffiffi
f#ffiS
Sffiffi fffiff$
18 PERMITTED CSOs
14 ACTTVE
E 24 CSO REGULATORS
19 ACTIVE
4 CLOSED
5 CLOSED
ffiSffi ffids#
ffiffiffiMd"/ffi d.#ffi
Y#'ffitrS
usl
ry
SsVSd&WtrffiM
#sffi
ffi* ffi
e-M
sd#&d#rffi-ryfffiffi
krrlra.
pffi#ffiffiMs$
E INITIATED JUNE 2012 E 32 FLOW METERS IN SERVICE E TYPICAL YEAR ESTIMATES
300 CSO events 150 MG of CSO volume
#Eryr
n.pirrio6 ,ltariring l
l
wehlir*ing xi*rirbnr
Hllirg
sfflPfisg
ffie##'& ffi#mffi
w#a ffip&s#"ru
r p&#-p##r's
& Houses
of worship
church renovations
ffiffis'trM ffi#ffi#
pffi mJtr#r
& 30 & 50
individual projects
acres of combined sewer area separated
s Technologies employed to detain the 2 year 6 hour design storm (2.05 inches of rain)
Rain water storage
GNHWP.A2.YR6'H.URSToRMEVENT
wells
features
,, ,i
'-*-*-*----'*'
i\
"'
I ,.\\
,I
\-"-$
10
&truaf#e"
Idfit,!/
11
ffi$# ffi##{/#rcsfw trtrsffd"ffitrffi trffis&f 6ffi##M tr##tr w#d" #pMtrtr r ptr #J#'rfr $
redevelopment projects
300 CSO events
150 MG
YALE SCHOOL OF MANAGEI\,,IENT GI IN CONSTRUCTION
ffs# M#ffiM#ffi#pd,ess*/d. ffiMffi flMssd 6tr*#tr tr#"mffi w#d. #peftrtr r p$tr #J##rs
I,
N
\t
t
ii,
.t$.
n,
12
The 2001 LTCP Hydraulic Model uses Area Reduction Factors (ARFs)to
:,
An ARF of 75% is used in combined sewer areas An ARF of 25% is used in separated sewer areas where public sources only have been disconnected An ARF of 10% is used in separated sewer areas where public and private sources are disconnected
TECHNICAL ASSUMPTIONS
a one acre site would be reduced to 0.35 acres in the hydraulic model to represent the change in runoff response resulting from construction of green infrastructure
13
si0{"t*
ffftr6 ftrfid.0[,r/ tr##d/trry6M FeO&s Seff',tr trr*}st/s'r sp&$trtrr pffi sJ#rrs rs tr##r {.ff 4 #g&
DTSCfiNNEtrTTON
ln the preceding example, a one, acre site was "effectively reduced" to 0.35 acres via green redevelopment
It would require disconnection of 35 homes with roof leaders to achieve the same 0.65 acre reduction in the hydraulic model based on the assumptions on the next slide
MffiJ
f({rd
?"M# ftrFd.6l,r[/ trf&{rfru#rY FtrCIM #tr#'flY ,ryr#f rs{, Sp&f#'trr Pffi OJrf r.s r# #OSr I &X srtr
dlfs##sfw#rffi#tr
TECHNICAL ASSUMPTIONS
{& Effective area reduction is
(ARF 25% to 10%)
&
1/8th
ie I
& &
$25,000.
* BASED ON A PAPER PRESENTED AT NEWEA ANNUAL CONFERENCE IN JANUARY 2013
14
EQUATIN INFLOW REDUCTTON FROM GREEN REfrEVELOPMENT PROJECTS TO ROOF LEADER DISONNECTTON
E HARTFORD
'
50 acres of combined sewer area have been separated via green redevelopment projects in New Haven equates to disconnection of 1700 homes with roof leaders (35 homes/acre X 50 acres= 1700 homes)
* fhis
r,
Assuming a cost of $25,000 per home, this equates to a total cost of $ 42.5 million
TQUATTNG THE COST Or RE$N REDEVELOqMENT PROSECTS TO SEWER SEPAfrATION OT PUSLTC INnLOW
s,o{/frcrs'
& lt would require separation of 1.3 acres to achieve the same 0.65 acre reduction in the hydraulic model based on a reduction in ARF from7l%to25%
15
rf,trs rrrF rss'r- sfl 6,&rrtr &trp,f vtrd" #pMe'/vr p#S.?trff$ fS S'#'M/F# }YO# #F,e#,#d.ff ftrf*#p$/
60{/14
ctl! twi"EC
^$,fPd,{C
E NEW HAVEN
50 acres of combined sewer area have been separated via green redevelopment projects This equates to sewer separation of 65 acres (1.3 acres/acre X 50 acres = 65 acres)
Assuming a cost of $250,000 per acre* this equates to a total cost of $16.3 million
#'w*/,e ffi?1d#
rfftr fpsr #r 6m#'Frv ffi##ryst #rsMfitrr PeoJ#'trrs rm $4/ffd rs ffi9rtr6 ffisMsgffi ffin&/r& #s# tr#MM{/tr#ffitrs
E PHILADELPHIA
$2,4 B 25 year green infrastructure program
Use green infrastructure to recover 9,654
"green acres" A "green acre" is 1 inch of rain over an acre Cost estimate $250,000 per "green acre"*
Ratio acres based on 2.05" vs. 1" of rain
&t
16
EQAATTN TfrE COST 0r GffEE/v fr.EPffVELaPW*NT PRO}YCTS TO WNAT'S SETNG SmffrJ& #ruf#'e CS0 CO{*{M{lltlfffiFS
Manage the first inch of rain from at least 10% of impervious surfaces in CSO areas with green infrastructure elements - 5 year program Cost estimate $450,000 per acre* (managing > 100/0 of impervious area)
'
I{ECHANTSM fiO
Since 2008, the GNHWPCA has approved 30 green redevelopment projects which have separated 50 acres of combined sewer area These green redevelopment projects have reduced CSO events by 7 per year and CSO volume by 3.3 MG per year
re#*vmlmpmsmf Sr$#r#rm ls fu*i*g rm':pl*remmf*# *f NO CO$I fm mrur rafe Bxyers
Tfo*
6r***
17
ffiMSf e,{rPO4'5
#RffrY
Rf'P#'Mg{. OprryffSf
ffi
t i
r"l
mffi
Ir
Disconnecting 1700 homes with roof leaders in Hartford at a cost of $42.5 million
WryYX{t Separating 65 acres of combined sewer area in ffi#"fto# ::ii:rx" U New Haven at a cost of $16.3 million "f
liili!F+#{f
ffi
ffi
Using green infrastructure to recover 102.5 "green acres" in Philadelphia at a cost of $25.6 million Using green infrastructure to manage runoff from 102.5 acres in NYC at a cost of $46.1 million
$tr#ffiM &#'##'&/#t OP$dfrWf fS,4 Jt, CCI.S,frrT #'d?3M#Mr#pf,4&ffs$d m Rr{}ucF rsos sff rurffir#dd vrtr
1B