Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Technical Report
Effective December 6, 2006, this report has been made publicly available in accordance with Section 734.3(b)(3) and published in accordance with Section 734.7 of the U.S. Export Administration Regulations. As a result of this publication, this report is subject to only copyright protection and does not require any license agreement from EPRI. This notice supersedes the export control restrictions and any proprietary licensed material notices embedded in the document prior to publication.
Effects of Cold Work and Heat Treatment on the ElevatedTemperature Rupture Properties of Grade 91 Material
1011352
EPRI 3412 Hillview Avenue, Palo Alto, California 94304 PO Box 10412, Palo Alto, California 94303 USA 800.313.3774 650.855.2121 askepri@epri.com www.epri.com
ORDERING INFORMATION
Requests for copies of this report should be directed to EPRI Orders and Conferences, 1355 Willow Way, Suite 278, Concord, CA 94520, (800) 313-3774, press 2 or internally x5379, (925) 609-9169, (925) 609-1310 (fax). Electric Power Research Institute and EPRI are registered service marks of the Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. EPRI. ELECTRIFY THE WORLD is a service mark of the Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. Copyright 2005 Electric Power Research Institute, Inc. All rights reserved.
CITATIONS
This report was prepared by Alstom Power, Inc. Materials Technology Center 1119 Riverfront Parkway Chattanooga, TN 37402 Principal Investigator J. Henry This report describes research sponsored by EPRI. The report is a corporate document that should be cited in the literature in the following manner: Effects of Cold Work and Heat Treatment on the Elevated-Temperature Rupture Properties of Grade 91 Material, EPRI, Palo Alto, CA: 2005. 1011352.
iii
PRODUCT DESCRIPTION
For many years it has been understood that straining austenitic materials reduces their hightemperature properties. Recognizing this, ASME added a section (PG-19) to the Boiler Code, SC-I, which requires heat treatment after the forming of austenitic materials. The industry has experienced failures of newer creep-enhanced ferritic materials like Grade 91 that indicate these materials suffer from the same type of degradation mechanism as austenitic materials. Boiler manufacturers have implemented guidelines for heat treating these alloys, but there is no consensus among manufacturers as to the proper heat treatments for different strain levels. The goal of the project described in this report is to develop a technical basis for rules that will be added to PG-19 for Grade 91 material. Results and Findings Large test coupons were marked with grids to make measurements of strain possible, then the coupons were bent to induce strain. Rupture coupons were removed from locations within the block where the material had experienced specific strain levels. These coupons were then tested to determine the amount of degradation resulting from each level of strain. Subsequent samples received heat treatments to determine the appropriate levels of heat treatment needed to restore rupture properties. Challenges and Objectives The goal of this project is to provide technical justification and rules for heat treatment of Grade 91 materials after forming. Methods to develop a specific strain level throughout the entire test specimen were developed. This required having a large block of Grade 91 material forged into 6-in. x 6-in. x 30-in. (152-mm x 152-mm x 762-mm) pieces that could be strained. A method of measuring strain using grid markings on the blocks was developed. With the correlation between strain level and required heat-treatment temperatures that was developed by this project, premature failures resulting from strain-induced material degradation will be minimized. Applications, Value, and Use Many new creep-strength-enhanced ferritic alloys are currently under development or have recently started to be used in fossil boiler applications. These include T23, T24, P91, and P92. Methods developed by this project to test the effect of strain-induced degradation of these materials can be used to develop guidelines for post-strain heat treatment. The elimination of premature failures caused by strain will allow utilities to realize the full benefit from upgrades and retrofits on new construction using these alloys.
EPRI Perspective EPRI has been at the forefront of new alloy development for high-temperature boiler applications. Because these alloys are much stronger than the low-alloy ferritic materials (P11 and P22) commonly used for boiler pressure parts, thinner components can be used. This results in initial material savings and improvements in component life. Thinner components are also more resistant to thermal fatigue damage, allowing utilities more flexibility in dispatching units. Higher operating pressures and temperatures are possible with these materials, thereby resulting in more-efficient power plants. Approach This program first developed a method to test the effect of strain on the high-temperature performance of materials. Next, an alloy that is being widely used for replacement and new fabrication was tested to see what level of degradation resulted in degraded material properties. Finally, heat treatments were evaluated to determine if properties could be restored through a subcritical or normalization heat treatment. Keywords P91 Fabrication Advanced materials Headers Piping Heat treatment
vi
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
EPRI acknowledges the contribution of J. C. Hitchcock, Alstoms principal manufactory engineer, for his assistance in the preparation and production of the cold-bent test blocks.
vii
CONTENTS
1 BACKGROUND AND INTRODUCTION ................................................................................1-1 2 STRAIN DEVELOPED DURING THE COLD-BENDING OF GRADE 91 TUBING AS A FUNCTION OF R/D RATIOS .................................................................................................2-1 2.1 Deformation/Strain Determination Using the Grid Method ..............................................2-1 2.2 Deformation/Strain Determination Using the Wall Thickness Method.............................2-7 2.3 The Effect of Heat Treatment on Cold-Worked Grade 91 Microstructure .....................2-13 3 REVIEW OF CREEP RUPTURE TEST RESULTS USING COLD-ROLLED GRADE 91 STRIPS .................................................................................................................................3-1 4 EVALUATION OF COLD-WORK AND HEAT TREATMENT ON THE ELEVATEDTEMPERATURE CREEP RUPTURE PROPERTIES OF GRADE 91 MATERIAL USING COLD-BENT BLOCKS..............................................................................................................4-1 4.1 Material Preparation for Creep Rupture Testing .............................................................4-1 4.2 Scale Model Study of the Bending Procedure for Preparation of Test Coupons ............4-3 4.3 Bending the 6" x 6" x 30" Test Coupons .........................................................................4-5 4.4 Determination of Local Strain and Strain Distribution for Preparation of Creep Rupture Test Specimens.......................................................................................................4-9 4.5 Creep Rupture Testing ..................................................................................................4-10 4.5.1 Creep Rupture Behavior of Unstrained Grade 91 Material....................................4-11 4.5.2 The Effect of Cold-Work on Creep Rupture Behavior of Grade 91 Material..........4-13 4.5.3 The Effect of Heat Treatment on Creep Rupture Behavior of Cold-Worked Grade 91 Material...........................................................................................................4-15 4.5.4 The Relationship Between Cold-Work-Induced Hardness Increase and Creep Life Reduction......................................................................................................4-17 5 CONCLUSIONS .....................................................................................................................5-1 6 RECOMMENDATIONS ..........................................................................................................6-1 7 FUTURE WORK .....................................................................................................................7-1
ix
8 REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................8-1 A MEASURED AND CALCULATED STRAINS FOR BENT TUBES USED IN THE STUDY...................................................................................................................................... A-1
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 2-1 Locations of Measured and Calculated Strains Using the Grid Method ...................2-3 Figure 2-2 Calculated Strain Levels at Seven Locations Around the Tube Bend for Nominal 33% Level (Based on Grid Method L/Li) ............................................................2-4 Figure 2-3 Calculated Strain Levels at Seven Locations Around the Tube Bend for Nominal 25% Level (Based on Grid Method L/Li) ............................................................2-5 Figure 2-4 Calculated Strain Levels at Seven Locations Around the Tube Bend for Nominal 20% Level (Based on Grid Method L/Li) ............................................................2-6 Figure 2-5 Calculated Strain Levels at Seven Locations Around the Tube Bend for Nominal 15% Level (Based on Grid Method L/Li) ............................................................2-7 Figure 2-6 Locations of Measured and Calculated Strains Using the Wall Thickness Method ...............................................................................................................................2-8 Figure 2-7 Calculated Strain Levels at the 90 Location of the Tube Bend at Eight Locations Around the Circumference, for the Nominal 33% Strain Level (Based on Wall Thickness Method t/ti) ..............................................................................................2-9 Figure 2-8 Calculated Strain Levels at the 90 Location of the Tube Bend at Eight Locations Around the Circumference, for the Nominal 25% Strain Level (Based on Wall Thickness Method t/ti) ............................................................................................2-10 Figure 2-9 Calculated Strain Levels at the 90 Location of the Tube Bend at Eight Locations Around the Circumference, for the Nominal 20% Strain Level (Based on Wall Thickness Method t/ti) ............................................................................................2-11 Figure 2-10 Calculated Strain Levels at the 90 Location of the Tube Bend at Eight Locations Around the Circumference, for the Nominal 15% Strain Level (Based on Wall Thickness Method t/ti) ............................................................................................2-12 Figure 2-11 Example of the Effect of Heat Treatment on the Microstructure of ColdFormed Tubing.................................................................................................................2-14 Figure 3-1 Summarized Creep Rupture Test Results Using Cold-Rolled Grade 91 Strips at Test Temperatures of 600C and 650C and at Various Stress Levels in the Range of 81190 MPa .......................................................................................................3-3 Figure 3-2 Summarized Creep Rupture Test Results as a Function of Cold-Work Levels ........3-4 Figure 4-1 Sketch Showing the Center Thermocouple Location ...............................................4-2 Figure 4-2 Typical Microstructural Condition of the Grade 91 Material in the Re-Heat Treated Condition...............................................................................................................4-3 Figure 4-3 Typical Results of Single-Step 3-Point Bending and Multiple-Step 3-Point Bending ..............................................................................................................................4-4
xi
Figure 4-4 Example of the 6" x 6" x 30" Test Blocks and the Grids Inscribed on the Surface of the Blocks Prior to Bending ..............................................................................4-6 Figure 4-5 Bending Status After Completion of the First Stage in the Bending Process ...........4-7 Figure 4-6 Bending Status After Completion of the Second and Third Stages of the Bending Process ................................................................................................................4-8 Figure 4-7 Final Condition of the Bent Test Coupons, with the Inscribed Grid Patterns Shown in the Bend Zone....................................................................................................4-9 Figure 4-8 Photo Showing Orientation of Test Specimens ......................................................4-10 Figure 4-9 Documentation of the Creep Rupture Behavior of the Unstrained Grade 91 Test Material as Compared to the Imputed Mean and Minimum Properties for Grade 91 Material ............................................................................................................4-12 Figure 4-10 Documentation of the Effect of Cold-Work on the Creep Rupture Behavior of the Grade 91 Test Material, Based on Comparison with the Behavior of the Unstrained Base Metal .....................................................................................................4-14 Figure 4-11 The Effect of a Post-Forming Subcritical Heat Treatment on the Creep Rupture Behavior of the Cold-Worked Grade 91 Test Material Compared with the Behavior of the Unstrained Base Metal and the Cold-Worked Material with No PostForming Heat Treatment ..................................................................................................4-16 Figure 4-12 Creep Life Reduction as a Function of Hardness Increase Induced by ColdWorking ............................................................................................................................4-19
xii
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1-1 Chemical Composition of Wrought Modified 9Cr and Standard 9Cr-1Mo Steels ......1-2 Table 2-1 Chemistry for Two Heats Used in the Deformation Study .........................................2-1 Table 2-2 Tube Identification .....................................................................................................2-2 Table 2-3 The Ratio t / L ........................................................................................................2-12 Table 2-4 Hardness Values of Specimens...............................................................................2-15 Table 3-1 Chemical Composition for the Two Heats Used for Simulated Creep Rupture Testing ...............................................................................................................................3-1 Table 3-2 Material Hardness Values as a Function of the Level of Cold-Work .........................3-2 Table 4-1 Chemical Composition of the Grade 91 Heat for the Test Program ..........................4-1 Table 4-2 Mechanical Composition of the Grade 91 Heat for the Test Program .......................4-2 Table 4-3 Hardness Measurements from the Surface to the Center of the Block .....................4-3 Table 4-4 Cold-Work-Induced Hardness Increase and Creep Life Reduction.........................4-18
xiii
The efficiency of fossil power plants is a direct function of both the temperature and the pressure of the product steam. Strategies for improving overall power plant efficiency have received attention worldwide since the first of the energy crises in the 1970s, and an inevitable focus of that attention has been an increase in the operating parameters (steam pressure and temperature). Of course, such an increase requires the selection of materials for critical pressure part components that can operate reliably under the more rigorous operating conditions. One group of materials that has shown substantial promise for operation in the intermediate temperature regimes of advanced-cycle steam generators has been the creep-strength-enhanced ferritic alloys, among which the modified 9Cr alloy (Grade 91) has seen the most extensive use in existing plants. The Grade 91 alloy was developed by the then Combustion Engineerings (CEs) Metallurgical and Materials Laboratory under U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) sponsorship from 1969 to 1977. Beginning in 1969, a series of proposals for the development of a super 9Cr alloy for use in the liquid metal fast breeder reactor (LMFBR) was submitted to DOE (and to its predecessor organizations, AED and ERDA) by CE. Approval was granted to begin the hardware development work at CE in early 1975 under the administration of Oak Ridge National Laboratorys (ORNLs) Metals and Ceramics Division. The alloy composition and favorable mechanical properties, including high creep rupture strength coupled with satisfactory fracture toughness at temperatures below ambient, had been established by the year 1977. Subsequently, ORNL participated actively in the commercialization and ASME Code approval of what today is known as Grade 91. It should be recognized that the composition and properties of Grade 91 were optimized for the LMFBR application, particularly for the steam tubing and other structural material for the sodium-steam generator components. This alloy was not optimized for fossil boiler or petrochemical applications [16]. With the loss of funding support for the LMFBR program that occurred in the late 1970s, the program sponsors looked toward other possible applications of the alloy, and fossil-fired steam generators were identified as potential users. Grade 91 gained its initial acceptance as boiler tubing suitable for use in ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code Section I construction in Code Case 1943 in 1983. The ensuing years have seen widespread usage of the material, largely in the power and petrochemical industries. In addition, there have been further developments in the advanced 9-12Cr ferritic steels, leading to new alloys with service temperature advantages over Grade 91. Among these new alloys are Grade 92 (Code Case 2179), Grade 122 (Code Case 2180), and Grade 911 (Code Case 2327). Included among the new boiler steels has been an enhanced version of the standard 2-1/4Cr-1Mo alloy, known as Grade 23 in Code Case 2199.
1-1
The modified 9Cr alloy represents a reengineering of the standard 9Cr-1Mo alloy, which is identified as T9 in the ASME SA-213 tubing specification. The principal modification consists of controlled additions of vanadium, niobium, and nitrogen, which substantially increase the creep strength of the alloy through the precipitation of M23C6 carbides and MX (Nb, V) carbonitrides, in addition to the lesser solution strengthening effects. Like its lower-strength predecessor, the modified 9Cr alloy exhibits superior hardenability and, within the specified chemical composition range, will transform to 100% martensite upon air cooling, even in thick sections. Table 1-1 compares the specified chemical compositions for the standard 9Cr-1Mo alloy and the modified 9Cr material [7].
Table 1-1 Chemical Composition of Wrought Modified 9Cr and Standard 9Cr-1Mo Steels Element
Standard 9Cr-1Mo Modified 9Cr
C
0.15 max. 0.08 0.12
Mn
0.30 0.60 0.30 0.60
P
0.025 max. 0.020 max.
S
0.025 max. 0.010 max.
Si
0.25 1.00 0.20 0.50
Cr
8.00 10.00 8.00 9.50
Mo
0.90 1.10 0.85 1.05
Ni
0.40 max.
V
0.18 0.25
Nb
0.06 0.10
N
0.030 0.070
Al
0.04 max.
From the standpoint of designing pressure part components for operation at elevated temperatures in boilers, creep is one of the primary damage mechanisms that must be considered in determining the serviceability of those components. In common engineering practice, the effect of creep is simply taken into account through the allowable stresses, which are established by Subcommittee II of the ASME Code based on the tested creep properties of the material. The data from which the allowable stresses are derived are typically based on the testing of fully heat-treated base material samples using uniaxial test specimens. The effects of fabrication processes, such as welding and forming, on the creep behavior of the materials, as that behavior compares to the unprocessed material (base metal), are generally not considered. That these processes may adversely affect the properties of the material is well known, as the premature failures of high-energy piping at longitudinal seam welds have demonstrated. There is no doubt, therefore, that an understanding of the possible effects of fabrication on the creep properties of materials is essential to predicting the serviceability of the components fabricated from these materials. With regard to the creep-strength-enhanced ferritic steels, the critical dependence of these materials on the ability of the carbonitride particles precipitated during tempering to stabilize the disordered martensitic structure suggests that they may be particularly vulnerable to processing effects. Certainly the well-known susceptibility of these materials to the Type IV effect is evidence of this vulnerability. Because of their strong microstructural dependence, the modified 9Cr alloys typically have fabrication requirements that are more stringent than those of the standard boiler alloys. Material vendors, regulatory groups, and construction companies have established these requirements in attempts to address the unique characteristics of the modified 9Cr alloy and thereby ensure optimum serviceability of the components. However, long-term service experience with the material is limited, so all effects of processing are not known at this time. As a result, the requirements imposed by various organizations are not consistent, and in some cases are contradictory. Fabrication difficulties and recent service failures have indicated that the requirements associated with cold-forming of modified 9Cr material should be better understood. 1-2
For example, concerns have arisen that some forming requirements are too conservative with regard to the application of heat treatment, that some post-forming heat treatment is actually deleterious, and that forming limits are inconsistent. A few preliminary studies have been conducted to investigate the effects of cold-working on the creep properties of Grade 91 by ORNL, Sumitomo, and Stork Boiler/TNO Research Institute in the Netherlands [810]. From these studies it appears certain that there is a significant reduction in the creep rupture strength of Grade 91 material when strained beyond certain limits. However, there are not sufficient data to establish what the limits are and whether the degree of reduction is a direct function of the amount of working, or whether there exists some threshold level of strain below which there are no significant effects. Since modified 9Cr steel is being used more extensively by boiler manufacturers due to its excellent elevated-temperature properties, it is essential that the effects of cold-forming and subsequent heat treatment on the creep properties of modified 9Cr steel be quantified to the extent possible. In order to provide a more sound technical basis for assessing the effects of cold-forming and subsequent heat treatment on the creep properties of modified 9Cr steel, a program of testing has been initiated by Alstom Powers Materials Technology Center under the sponsorship of EPRI. This program has been designed to address the issues outlined above by providing additional data that will make it possible to devise technically defensible cold-forming requirements. The objective of this program is to more accurately characterize the magnitude of the effect of coldworking on the elevated-temperature properties of Grade 91, recognizing that not all possible combinations of composition, heat treatment, strain, and operating conditions can be evaluated. Should effects be uncovered during this program that have not been anticipated, then supplementary efforts may be advisable. The first stage of the program involved more accurately determining the deformation/strain patterns that develop in boiler tubing during bending. Accurate strain measurements were made on etched bend samples in both the circumferential and longitudinal directions, with special attention given to the extrados and intrados of the bends. Common sizes of Grade 91 tubing were purchased, and the tubes were cold-formed into bends using R/D ratios commonly used for boiler tubing. The cold-forming procedures used to bend the tubing mirrored the standard procedures used at Alstoms Chattanooga tubular production site for many years. Once the deformation/strain data obtained from the T91 tube bends were evaluated, test coupons representing several different deformation/strain levels were produced using cold-bent Grade 91 wrought plate (6" [152 mm] thick). Creep rupture specimens were extracted from the tension side of the bent coupons to simulate the extrados condition of cold-formed tubing. In order to provide baseline data, creep rupture specimens also were prepared from the as-received base material. For the program, four simulated cold-bent coupons (6" x 6" x 30" [152 mm x 152 mm x 762 mm]) of Grade 91 material were produced. The strain pattern developed in each of the test coupons during cold-bending was based on the evaluation of a matrix consisting of 0.25" x 0.25" (6.35 mm x 6.25 mm) cells inscribed into the surface of each coupon prior to bending. Over 1200 measurements were made and the appropriate calculations performed to define the strain pattern. The creep rupture test specimens were then removed from the test coupons to represent specific strain levels. Creep rupture test conditions were designed based on the imputed creep rupture 1-3
properties of unstrained Grade 91 material calculated from ASME SCI allowable stresses for sections above and below 3" (76 mm) in thickness, along with test data from ORNL, V&M Tubing, EPRI, MPC, and Mitsubishi Heavy Industries (MHI) The test stress levels for the program ranged from 8.7 ksi (60 MPa) to 20.3 ksi (140 MPa); this range spans the design stress levels for most applications in boilers. Test temperatures were selected to yield rupture times for the unstrained base metal between 300 and 10,000 hours. In this report, the results of the program are reviewed and the implications of the results to the more general issue of coldforming of Grade 91 material are discussed in detail.
1-4
STRAIN DEVELOPED DURING THE COLD-BENDING OF GRADE 91 TUBING AS A FUNCTION OF R/D RATIOS
The purpose of this portion of the study was to more accurately determine the cold-working strains developed in the process of tube bending when using bending techniques that represent standard practice in the industry. As part of this evaluation, the strains estimated by standard design formulas were compared to the actual strains developed in a tube during bending in both the longitudinal and transverse directions. Obviously, the ability to accurately quantify the level of strain developed in a cold-bent tube is essential in establishing the relationship between coldworking effects and creep rupture life. Grade 91 tubing was purchased for use in sizes commonly adopted for superheater or reheater applications, and tube bends were cold-formed to several different R/D ratios typically used in the production of superheater or reheater bends. The bending practice reflected common shop procedures, such as those that have been used at Alstoms Chattanooga tubular production site for many years. The deformation/strain pattern along the length of the cold-formed T91 tubing was determined in both the circumferential and longitudinal directions, with the focus of attention being the extrados and intrados of the bends, where the maximum strain was expected to occur. A grid pattern was inscribed on the outer diameter surface of each tube along the length of tubing to be bent. The etching was applied around the full circumference of the tube for a length of 20" (508 mm). The grid pattern itself consisted of a 0.25" (6.35 mm) square with four circles 0.1" (2.54 mm) in diameter inside the square. A deep etching pattern was used to ensure survival of the pattern during the bending operation.
Heat B 9832-01 .094 .39 .023 .001 .39 .08 8.28 .99 .21 .077 .002 .009 .02 .013 <.001 <.01 <.001 .003 <.001 .040 Heat B 9833-01 .094 .39 .024 .001 .39 .08 8.34 .98 .21 .077 .002 .01 .02 .013 <.001 <.01 <.001 .003 <.001 .044
2-1
Strain Developed During the Cold-Bending of Grade 91 Tubing as a Function of R/D Ratios
A total of 23 tubes were included in this portion of the study. As previously mentioned, a grid pattern was first etched onto the outer diameter surface of the tube in the area to be bent, the grid consisting of 0.25" (6.35-mm) squares, with each square containing four 0.1" (2.54-mm) diameter circles. All 23 tubes were then bent to one of four estimated strain levels, 15%, 20%, 25%, and 33%. The bend radius was determined using the formula for strain, D/2R, with D being the original tube outer diameter (D = 2.125" [53.975 mm]) and R being the nominal bend radius. To evaluate possible effects of heat treatment on the cold-worked microstructures, eight tubes, two from each estimated strain level and one from each heat, were stress relieved at 1350F (732C) for 30 minutes. In addition, eight tubes, two from each estimated strain level and one from each heat, were stress relieved at 1425F (774C) for 60 minutes. Table 2-2 lists the tube identifications, nominal bending strains, and post-bending stress relief conditions.
Table 2-2 Tube Identification Tube # 11A 11B 12A 12B 13A 13B 15A 15B 16A 16B 17A 17B 19A 19B 20A 20B 21A 21B 24A 24B 25A 25B 26A Heat # B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 B 9833-01 B 9832-01 Estimated Strain Level 33% 33% 33% 33% 33% 33% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 15% 15% 15% 15% 15% Heat Treatment As Bent As Bent 1350F 30 minutes 1350F 30 minutes 1425F 60 minutes 1425F 60 minutes As Bent As Bent 1350F 30 minutes 1350F 30 minutes 1425F 60 minutes 1425F 60 minutes As Bent As Bent 1350F 30 minutes 1350F 30 minutes 1425F 60 minutes 1425F 60 minutes 1350F 30 minutes 1350F 30 minutes 1425F 60 minutes 1425F 60 minutes As Bent
2-2
Strain Developed During the Cold-Bending of Grade 91 Tubing as a Function of R/D Ratios
After the tubes were bent, the grid pattern on each tube was measured at seven locations around the bend, as indicated in Figure 2-1. Each square etched onto the tube surface was originally 0.25" (6.35 mm), and the L was calculated by subtracting 0.25" from the measured length. Actual strain was defined as L = L/Li. These calculated strain values then were compared with the nominal strain. The data are represented in graphical form in Figures 2-2 through 2-5, and individual values are presented in Appendix A. As shown in Figures 2-2 through 2-5, the measured axial strain was in all cases somewhat higher than the strain estimated by the D/2R formula. At all four strain levels, certain locations on the bend extrados exceeded the estimated strain. The magnitude of the difference depended on the applied strain and the location within the bend. For a nominal strain of 33%, the measured strain was up to 1.2 times higher than the nominal value. In fact, the maximum strain measured at all strain levels was between 1.2 and 1.3 times the nominal strain value. However, the location within the bend where the maximum strain occurred varied to a small extent, although the variations appeared to be within the normal scatter of the data. In general, as can be seen in Figures 2-2 through 2-5, at each of the four strain levels for both heats of material the measured strains were very consistent.
Figure 2-1 Locations of Measured and Calculated Strains Using the Grid Method
2-3
Strain Developed During the Cold-Bending of Grade 91 Tubing as a Function of R/D Ratios