Professional Documents
Culture Documents
COURSE WORK
MARKETING MANAGEMENT
COURSE : MBA
SEMESTER: 2
Developed by the Boston Consulting Group (BCG), the BCG Growth Share Matrix is a
popular approach to product portfolio planning. The matrix is defined by two factors:
relative market share (the company's market share relative to the competition) and market
growth. To use the matrix, place each individual product in your company's portfolio into
one of the four quadrants and then do the same for your competitors' products. The result
has implications for brand positioning and market share.
• Stars. A star is a product in a high growth market that controls a sizeable share of that
market. Stars tend to generate strong revenues. Over time, as growth slows, stars
become cash cows if they hold their market share and dogs if they don't.
• Cash cows. A cash cow commands a large share of a slow growth market. The more
the company invests in cash cows, the greater the return. Cash cows tend to pay the
dividends, the interest on debt and cover the corporate overhead.
• Dogs. A dog has a low share of a slow growth market. Dogs often report a profit even
though they are net cash users. They are essentially cash traps.
• Question marks (sometimes called wildcats). A question mark is a product with a low
share of a high growth market. Their cash needs are great because of their growth, but
generate little in return because their market share is low. Question marks are difficult
to turn into stars because the cost of acquiring market share compounds the cash needs.
They may be big winners if backed to the limit, but most often, they fail to develop a
leading market position before growth slows and become dogs.
The purpose of this tool is to help you balance your product portfolio. Ideally, you would
eliminate any dogs, while keeping the others in a kind of dynamic equilibrium. The cash
generated by cash cows can then be used to turn question marks into stars, which, in turn,
may become cash cows. As noted above, many of the question marks will become dogs,
which mean you'll need to compensate for these failures by improving margins on the
stars and cash cows.
GE/McKinsey Matrix
Industry attractiveness and SBU strength are calculated by first identifying the criteria for
each, determining the value of each parameter in the criteria, and multiplying that value
by a weighting factor. The result is a quantitative measure of industry attractiveness and
the SBU’s relative performance in that industry. The industry attractiveness index is made
up of such factors as market size, market growth, industry profit margin, amount of
competition, the degree of seasonal and cyclical fluctuations in demand, and industry cost
structure. The industry attractiveness index consists of factors like relative market share,
price, competitiveness, product quality, customer and market knowledge, sales
effectiveness, and geographic advantages.
Each SBU can be portrayed as a circle plotted on the matrix, with the information
conveyed as follows:
The sample diagram shows the relative position of an SBU with a market share of 65%.
The arrow in the upward right position indicates that the SBU is expected to lose strength
relative to competitors, and that the business unit is in an industry that is projected to
become increasingly less attractive. The tip of the arrow indicates the future position of
the center point of the circle.
Both axes are divided into three segments, yielding nine cells. The nine cells are grouped
into three zones:
• The Green Zone consists of the three cells in the upper left corner. If the SBU
falls in this zone, it’s in a favorable position with relatively attractive growth
opportunities. This position indicates a "green light" to invest and grow this SBU.
• The Yellow Zone consists of the three diagonal cells from the lower left to the
upper right. A position in the yellow zone is viewed as having medium
attractiveness. Management must therefore exercise caution when making
additional investments in this SBU. The suggested strategy is to protect or allocate
resources on a selective basis rather than growing or reducing share.
• The Red Zone consists of the three cells in the lower right corner. A harvest
strategy should be used in the two cells just below the three-cell diagonal. These
SBUs shouldn’t receive substantial new resources. The SBUs in the lower right
cell shouldn’t receive any resources and should probably be divested or
eliminated from a firm’s portfolio.
There are strategy variations within these three groups. For example, within the Red
Zone, a firm would be inclined to quickly divest itself of a weak business in an
unattractive industry, whereas it might perform a phased harvest of an average SBU in
the same industry.
While the GE/McKinsey Matrix represents an improvement over the relatively simplistic
BCG Growth-Share Matrix, it still encompasses a limited view of the competitive
landscape. The matrix doesn’t take into account interactions among SBUs or the core
competencies that lead to value creation. For these and other reasons, some believe the
matrix is better suited for providing an overview of the current market rather than serving
as a resource allocation tool.
The matrix presents four main strategic choices, ranging from an incremental strategy in
which current products are sold to existing customers to a revolutionary strategy in which
new products are sold to new customers.
• Diversification. This quadrant entails the greatest risk; here, the company markets new
products to new customers. There are two types of diversification: related and
unrelated. In related diversification, the company enters a related market or industry. In
unrelated diversification, the company enters a market or industry in which it has no
relevant experience.
These quadrants represent varying degrees of risk. Assuming that the more a business
knows about its market, the more likely it will be to succeed; the market penetration
strategy entails the least risk, while the diversification strategy entails the most.
QN.2. Discuss the Macro environment of a pharmaceutical company
ANS:
There are many factors in the macro-environment that will effect the decisions of the
managers of any pharmaceutical company. Tax changes, new laws, trade barriers,
demographic change and government policy changes are all examples of macro change.
To help analyze these factors, managers can categorize them using the criteria below;
Economic environment. This includes interest rates, taxation changes, economic growth,
inflation and exchange rates. Economic changes have a major impact on a firm's
behavior. For example: higher interest rates may deter investment because it costs more
to borrow, a strong currency may make exporting more difficult because it may raise the
price in terms of foreign currency, inflation may provoke higher wage demands from
employees and raise costs, higher national income growth may boost demand for the
health industry's products.
Social and cultural environment. Changes in social trends can impact on the demand for a
firm's products and the availability and willingness of individuals to work. In the
developed world, for example, the population has been ageing. This has increased the
costs for firms who are committed to pension payments for their employees because their
staff are living longer. It also means some firms such have started to recruit older
employees to tap into this growing labor pool. The ageing population also has impact on
demand: for example, demand for medicines increases.
Technological environment: new technologies create new products and new processes.
This will influence the kind of technology to be employed by companies in this industry.
This may make the industry over rely on automated systems for production. Technology
can reduce costs, improve quality and lead to innovation. These developments can benefit
consumers as well as the organizations providing the products.
Natural environment: environmental factors include the weather and climate change.
Changes in temperature can impact on many industries including health and insurance.
With major climate changes occurring due to global warming and with greater
environmental awareness this external factor is becoming a significant issue for firms to
consider. The growing desire to protect the environment may have an impact on the
pharmaceutical industry, for example, more taxes may be imposed and this general move
towards more environmentally friendly production processes will affect demand patterns
and business opportunities.
Legal factors: these are related to the legal environment in which firms operate. Legal
changes can affect a firm's costs (e.g. if new systems and procedures have to be
developed) and demand (e.g. if the law affects the likelihood of customers buying the
good or using the service). Different categories of law include; consumer laws; these are
designed to protect customers against unfair practices such as misleading descriptions of
the product, competition laws; these are aimed at protecting small firms against bullying
by larger firms and ensuring customers are not exploited by firms with monopoly power,
employment laws; these cover areas such as redundancy, dismissal, working hours and
minimum wages. They aim to protect employees against the abuse of power by managers,
health and safety legislation; these laws are aimed at ensuring the workplace is as safe as
is reasonably practical. They cover issues such as training, reporting accidents and the
appropriate provision of safety equipment.
3. Explain the components of MIS.
ANS:
An internal records system is one of the major components. This consist information on
the; order to payment cycle and the sales information system.
The order to payment cycle, records the timing and size of orders placed by consumers,
the payment cycle followed by consumers and the time taken to fulfill the orders.
Customers place orders through sales agents and companies dispatch the goods and
receive payments directly or through the bank.
A sales information system on the other hand records everything in the sales department,
starting from sales call reports to prospects history to sales territory and quota
information for better sales planning and forecasting purpose.
Complex buying behavior. Here customers are highly involved in the purchase of the
product or service. The process is complex as the difference between brands is very high.
Here the customer wants to know every detail of the product he is to purchase and also
know what the difference means in terms of satisfaction. For example, when buying a
specific brand of a DVD, he will compare all the functions and would want to know what
the difference means. Therefore, the marketer has the obligation to clarify all the details
to a customer with such buying behavior.
Dissonance reducing buying behavior is the other. This behavior is exhibited when there
is high involvement by the customer in purchasing goods where a few differences exist.
For example, a customer who wants to buy CTV will not find many differences between
the brands but the price of the product and its technicality makes a customer involve
more. The customer here will show post purchase dissonance which may be difficult for
the marketer control.
Variety – seeking buying behavior also arises. In this behavior, the customer will not
involve more while purchasing, but goods significantly differ. For example a customer
buying juice products, there are many varieties in the market available, like; sun sip,
quencher, qungwa. The customer who purchased quencher at one time may try sun sip
another time just to explore. The marketer is therefore advised to encourage the customer
buy repeatedly in case of a market leader, make the product visible, and where the
product is new, encourage customers through promotions.
Assael also identifies the habitual buying behavior. Under this behavior, the customer has
a low involvement between the brands and few differences between the brands exist
which leads to a habitual buying behavior. For example mineral water companies, a few
differences exist between the products and there fore the customer does not search
information to purchase a particular brand. Here marketers are expected to use price and
sales promotions to stimulate product trial, use more visual aspects of advertisement, and
use classical conditioning theory to create advertisements.
The above four aspects cover the different buying behaviors as espoused by Henry
Assael, as well as what the marketer is expected to do if any of these behaviors is
observed in a prospective customer.
5. Discuss the segmentation strategy of a cement company.
ANS:
Identify and name the broad market-which for this case will be the construction industry.
If your company is already on a market, this can be a starting point; more options are
available for a new business but resources would normally be a little limited. The biggest
challenge is to find the right balance for your business: use your experience, knowledge
and common sense to estimate if the market you have just identified earlier is not too
narrow or too broad compared to the production capacity of the company.
Identify and make an inventory of potential customers' needs. This step pushes the
creativity challenge even farther, since it can be compared to a brainstorming session.
What you have to figure out is what needs the consumers from the broad market
identified earlier might have. The more possible needs you can come up with, the better.
Got your self stuck in this stage of segmentation? Try to put yourself into the shoes of
your potential customers: why would they buy your product, what could possibly trigger
a buying decision? Answering these questions can help you list most needs of potential
customers on a given product market.
Identify the determining dimensions. Carefully review the list resulting form the previous
step. You should have by now a list of need dimensions for each market segment: try to
identify those that carry a determining power. Reviewing the needs and attitudes of those
you included within each market segment can help you figure out the determining
dimensions.
Name possible segment markets. You have identified the determining dimensions of your
market segments, now review them one by one and give them an appropriate name. A
good way of naming these markets is to rely on the most important determining
dimension.
Evaluate the behavior of market segments. Once you are done naming each market
segment, allow time to consider what other aspects you know about them. It is important
for a marketer to understand market behavior and what triggers it. You might notice that,
while most segments have similar needs, they're still different needs: understanding the
difference and acting upon it is the key to achieve success using competitive offerings.
Estimate the size of each market segment. Each segment identified, named and studied
during the previous stages should finally be given an estimate size, even if, for lack of
data, it is only a rough estimate. Estimates of market segments will come in handy later,
by offering a support for sales forecasts and help plan the Marketing mix: the more data
we can gather at this moment, the easier further planning and strategy will be.
These are the steps to segment a market, briefly presented. If performed correctly and
thoroughly, you should now be able to have a glimpse of how to build Marketing mixes
for each market segment.
6. a) Do you think ticket based pricing will provide continuous revenue to Infosys in
the long term? Comment
ANS:
I think ticket pricing will not provide continuous revenue to Infosys in the long run.
This is mainly because software applications become stable after some time. Therefore,
this would mean that the company will lose most revenues as the applications continue to
stabilize.
For business continuity, I think it is better for Infosys to adopt the ticket pricing as a
penetrating strategy to attract customers. But as it stabilizes, it would be much better to
adopt fixed pricing in order to ensure continuous earnings in the long run.
6.b). Compare three pricing strategies discussed here and choose any one as your
choice.
ANS:
Ticket – based pricing is more flexible and cost friendly to the customer. This is based on
the fact that the customer only pays for what he wants and when he wants it. This is a
very attractive pricing strategy for new entrants especially in a competitive industry.
Fixed pricing is also particularly important for companies especially if they have a high
market penetration. This helps a company to ensure steady inflow of funds as the
company will receive maintenance fee even where there has been no work done.
However, a few companies will accept dealing with a company that deals with this
pricing strategy especially as the struggle to cut costs.
Time and material – based pricing is based on the number of man hours spent on the
project. This may also be a cost effective strategy as the price is based on the cost
incurred in terms of resources and man power.
After closely looking at the three pricing strategies, I would opt for the time and material
– based pricing. This is because it focuses more on the cost incurred other than the
demand which will ultimately lead to better calculation of profits. It is also fairer to the
buyer and the seller. Where all the companies in the industry use similar pricing strategy,
it may lead to price stability.