You are on page 1of 185

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 1

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

CASE NO. 13-4429 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT TARA KING, ED.D., individually and on behalf of her patients, RONALD NEWMAN, PH.D., individually and on behalf of his patients, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR RESEARCH AND THERAPY OF HOMOSEXUALITY (NARTH), and AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF CHRISTIAN COUNSELORS (AACC), Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. CHRISTOPHER J. CHRISTIE, Governor of the State of New Jersey, in his official capacity, ERIC T. KANEFSKY, Director of the New Jersey Department of Law and Public Safety: Division of Consumer Affairs, in his official capacity, MILAGROS COLLAZO, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Marriage and Family Therapy Examiners, in her official capacity, J. MICHAEL WALKER, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Psychological Examiners, in his official capacity; and PAUL JORDAN, President of the New Jersey State Board of Medical Examiners, in his official capacity, Defendants/Appellees, And GARDEN STATE EQUALITY, Intervenor-Defendant/Appellee. APPENDIX OF PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS VOL III.A (000277-000414) Mathew D. Staver (Lead Counsel) Anita L. Staver LIBERTY COUNSEL 1055 Maitland Ctr. Cmmns 2d Floor Maitland, FL 32751-7214 Tel. (800) 671-1776 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants Stephen M. Crampton Mary E. McAlister Daniel J. Schmid LIBERTY COUNSEL P.O. Box 11108 Lynchburg, VA 24506 Tel. (434) 592-7000 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 2

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME I (000001-000070) Plaintiffs Notice of Appeal.............000001 Memorandum Opinion ...........000003 Order ...000069 VOLUME II (000071-000276) District Court Docket Sheet.....000071 Complaint........000085 Complaint Exhibit A ...000131 Complaint Exhibit B ...000137 Application for Temporary Restraining Order and/or Preliminary Injunction...000141 Declaration of Dr. Tara King...000167 Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman....000174 Declaration of David Pruden...000181 Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik..000187 Declaration of Dr. Joseph Nicolosi..000231 Declaration of Dr. Eric Scalise000249 Garden State Equalitys Notice of Motion to Intervene as Party Defendant ...000257 Certification of Troy Stevenson .000259

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 3

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

Defendants Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56...000272 Proposed Intervenor-Defendant Garden State Equalitys Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment .............000274 VOLUME III (000277-000449) Exhibit C, Declaration of Gregory Herek, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation ................................................................................000277 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik ..................000415 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman.....000441 VOLUME IV (000450-000665) Declaration of Dr. Judith Reisman .....000450 Declaration of John Doe, Minor Child ...000537 Declaration of Jane Doe, Mother of Minor Child ......000542 Declaration of Jack Doe, Father of Minor Child.000549 Plaintiffs Motion Objecting to Courts Dispensing with Plaintiffs Supporting Declarations and Evidence, Dispensing with Evidentiary Motions, and Motion to Deem Certain Factual Allegations Admitted by the State 000554 Transcript of Motions Hearing000588

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 4

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

CASE NO. 13-4429 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT TARA KING, ED.D., individually and on behalf of her patients, RONALD NEWMAN, PH.D., individually and on behalf of his patients, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR RESEARCH AND THERAPY OF HOMOSEXUALITY (NARTH), and AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF CHRISTIAN COUNSELORS (AACC), Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. CHRISTOPHER J. CHRISTIE, Governor of the State of New Jersey, in his official capacity, ERIC T. KANEFSKY, Director of the New Jersey Department of Law and Public Safety: Division of Consumer Affairs, in his official capacity, MILAGROS COLLAZO, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Marriage and Family Therapy Examiners, in her official capacity, J. MICHAEL WALKER, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Psychological Examiners, in his official capacity; and PAUL JORDAN, President of the New Jersey State Board of Medical Examiners, in his official capacity, Defendants/Appellees, And GARDEN STATE EQUALITY, Intervenor-Defendant/Appellee. APPENDIX OF PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS VOL III (000277-000449) Mathew D. Staver (Lead Counsel) Anita L. Staver LIBERTY COUNSEL 1055 Maitland Ctr. Cmmns 2d Floor Maitland, FL 32751-7214 Tel. (800) 671-1776 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants Stephen M. Crampton Mary E. McAlister Daniel J. Schmid LIBERTY COUNSEL P.O. Box 11108 Lynchburg, VA 24506 Tel. (434) 592-7000 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 5

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME I (000001-000070) Plaintiffs Notice of Appeal.............000001 Memorandum Opinion ...........000003 Order ...000069 VOLUME II (000071-000276) District Court Docket Sheet.....000071 Complaint........000085 Complaint Exhibit A ...000131 Complaint Exhibit B ...000137 Application for Temporary Restraining Order and/or Preliminary Injunction...000141 Declaration of Dr. Tara King...000167 Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman....000174 Declaration of David Pruden...000181 Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik..000187 Declaration of Dr. Joseph Nicolosi..000231 Declaration of Dr. Eric Scalise000249 Garden State Equalitys Notice of Motion to Intervene as Party Defendant ...000257 Certification of Troy Stevenson .000259

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 6

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

Defendants Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56...000272 Proposed Intervenor-Defendant Garden State Equalitys Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment .............000274 VOLUME III (000277-000449) Exhibit C, Declaration of Gregory Herek, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation ................................................................................000277 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik ..................000415 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman.....000441 VOLUME IV (000450-000665) Declaration of Dr. Judith Reisman .....000450 Declaration of John Doe, Minor Child ...000537 Declaration of Jane Doe, Mother of Minor Child ......000542 Declaration of Jack Doe, Father of Minor Child.000549 Plaintiffs Motion Objecting to Courts Dispensing with Plaintiffs Supporting Declarations and Evidence, Dispensing with Evidentiary Motions, and Motion to Deem Certain Factual Allegations Admitted by the State 000554 Transcript of Motions Hearing000588

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 7

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

CASE NO. 13-4429 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT TARA KING, ED.D., individually and on behalf of her patients, RONALD NEWMAN, PH.D., individually and on behalf of his patients, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR RESEARCH AND THERAPY OF HOMOSEXUALITY (NARTH), and AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF CHRISTIAN COUNSELORS (AACC), Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. CHRISTOPHER J. CHRISTIE, Governor of the State of New Jersey, in his official capacity, ERIC T. KANEFSKY, Director of the New Jersey Department of Law and Public Safety: Division of Consumer Affairs, in his official capacity, MILAGROS COLLAZO, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Marriage and Family Therapy Examiners, in her official capacity, J. MICHAEL WALKER, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Psychological Examiners, in his official capacity; and PAUL JORDAN, President of the New Jersey State Board of Medical Examiners, in his official capacity, Defendants/Appellees, And GARDEN STATE EQUALITY, Intervenor-Defendant/Appellee. APPENDIX OF PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS VOL III (000277-000449) Mathew D. Staver (Lead Counsel) Anita L. Staver LIBERTY COUNSEL 1055 Maitland Ctr. Cmmns 2d Floor Maitland, FL 32751-7214 Tel. (800) 671-1776 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants Stephen M. Crampton Mary E. McAlister Daniel J. Schmid LIBERTY COUNSEL P.O. Box 11108 Lynchburg, VA 24506 Tel. (434) 592-7000 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 8

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME I (000001-000070) Plaintiffs Notice of Appeal.............000001 Memorandum Opinion ...........000003 Order ...000069 VOLUME II (000071-000276) District Court Docket Sheet.....000071 Complaint........000085 Complaint Exhibit A ...000131 Complaint Exhibit B ...000137 Application for Temporary Restraining Order and/or Preliminary Injunction...000141 Declaration of Dr. Tara King...000167 Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman....000174 Declaration of David Pruden...000181 Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik..000187 Declaration of Dr. Joseph Nicolosi..000231 Declaration of Dr. Eric Scalise000249 Garden State Equalitys Notice of Motion to Intervene as Party Defendant ...000257 Certification of Troy Stevenson .000259

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504693

Page: 9

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

Defendants Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56...000272 Proposed Intervenor-Defendant Garden State Equalitys Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment .............000274 VOLUME III (000277-000449) Exhibit C, Declaration of Gregory Herek, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation ................................................................................000277 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik ..................000415 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman.....000441 VOLUME IV (000450-000665) Declaration of Dr. Judith Reisman .....000450 Declaration of John Doe, Minor Child ...000537 Declaration of Jane Doe, Mother of Minor Child ......000542 Declaration of Jack Doe, Father of Minor Child.000549 Plaintiffs Motion Objecting to Courts Dispensing with Plaintiffs Supporting Declarations and Evidence, Dispensing with Evidentiary Motions, and Motion to Deem Certain Factual Allegations Admitted by the State 000554 Transcript of Motions Hearing000588

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 10 Date Page Filed: 1 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 761

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000277

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 11 Date Page Filed: 2 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 762

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000278

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 12 Date Page Filed: 3 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 763

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000279

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 13 Date Page Filed: 4 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 764

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000280

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 14 Date Page Filed: 5 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 765

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000281

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 15 Date Page Filed: 6 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 766

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000282

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 16 Date Page Filed: 7 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 767

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000283

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 17 Date Page Filed: 8 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 768

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000284

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 18 Date Page Filed: 9 of 01/10/2014 84 PageID: 769

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000285

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 19 Date Page Filed: 10 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 770

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000286

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 20 Date Page Filed: 11 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 771

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000287

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 21 Date Page Filed: 12 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 772

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000288

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 22 Date Page Filed: 13 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 773

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000289

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 23 Date Page Filed: 14 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 774

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000290

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 24 Date Page Filed: 15 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 775

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000291

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 25 Date Page Filed: 16 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 776

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000292

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 26 Date Page Filed: 17 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 777

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000293

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 27 Date Page Filed: 18 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 778

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000294

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 28 Date Page Filed: 19 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 779

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000295

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 29 Date Page Filed: 20 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 780

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000296

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 30 Date Page Filed: 21 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 781

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000297

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 31 Date Page Filed: 22 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 782

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000298

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 32 Date Page Filed: 23 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 783

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000299

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 33 Date Page Filed: 24 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 784

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000300

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 34 Date Page Filed: 25 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 785

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000301

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 35 Date Page Filed: 26 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 786

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000302

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 36 Date Page Filed: 27 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 787

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000303

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 37 Date Page Filed: 28 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 788

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000304

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 38 Date Page Filed: 29 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 789

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000305

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 39 Date Page Filed: 30 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 790

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000306

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 40 Date Page Filed: 31 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 791

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000307

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 41 Date Page Filed: 32 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 792

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000308

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 42 Date Page Filed: 33 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 793

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000309

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 43 Date Page Filed: 34 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 794

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000310

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 44 Date Page Filed: 35 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 795

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000311

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 45 Date Page Filed: 36 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 796

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000312

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 46 Date Page Filed: 37 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 797

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000313

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 47 Date Page Filed: 38 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 798

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000314

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 48 Date Page Filed: 39 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 799

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000315

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 49 Date Page Filed: 40 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 800

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000316

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 50 Date Page Filed: 41 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 801

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000317

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 51 Date Page Filed: 42 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 802

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000318

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 52 Date Page Filed: 43 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 803

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000319

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 53 Date Page Filed: 44 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 804

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000320

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 54 Date Page Filed: 45 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 805

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000321

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 55 Date Page Filed: 46 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 806

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000322

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 56 Date Page Filed: 47 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 807

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000323

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 57 Date Page Filed: 48 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 808

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000324

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 58 Date Page Filed: 49 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 809

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000325

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 59 Date Page Filed: 50 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 810

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000326

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 60 Date Page Filed: 51 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 811

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000327

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 61 Date Page Filed: 52 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 812

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000328

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 62 Date Page Filed: 53 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 813

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000329

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 63 Date Page Filed: 54 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 814

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000330

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 64 Date Page Filed: 55 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 815

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000331

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 65 Date Page Filed: 56 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 816

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000332

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 66 Date Page Filed: 57 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 817

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000333

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 67 Date Page Filed: 58 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 818

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000334

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 68 Date Page Filed: 59 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 819

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000335

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 69 Date Page Filed: 60 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 820

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000336

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 70 Date Page Filed: 61 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 821

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000337

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 71 Date Page Filed: 62 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 822

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000338

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 72 Date Page Filed: 63 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 823

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000339

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 73 Date Page Filed: 64 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 824

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000340

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 74 Date Page Filed: 65 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 825

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000341

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 75 Date Page Filed: 66 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 826

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000342

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 76 Date Page Filed: 67 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 827

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000343

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 77 Date Page Filed: 68 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 828

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000344

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 78 Date Page Filed: 69 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 829

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000345

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 79 Date Page Filed: 70 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 830

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000346

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 80 Date Page Filed: 71 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 831

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000347

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 81 Date Page Filed: 72 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 832

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000348

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 82 Date Page Filed: 73 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 833

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000349

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 83 Date Page Filed: 74 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 834

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000350

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 84 Date Page Filed: 75 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 835

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000351

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 85 Date Page Filed: 76 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 836

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000352

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 86 Date Page Filed: 77 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 837

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000353

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 87 Date Page Filed: 78 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 838

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000354

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 88 Date Page Filed: 79 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 839

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000355

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 89 Date Page Filed: 80 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 840

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000356

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 90 Date Page Filed: 81 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 841

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000357

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 91 Date Page Filed: 82 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 842

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000358

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 92 Date Page Filed: 83 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 843

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000359

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-6 Filed Page: 09/13/13 93 Date Page Filed: 84 of01/10/2014 84 PageID: 844

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000360

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 94 Date Page Filed: 1 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 845

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000361

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 95 Date Page Filed: 2 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 846

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000362

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 96 Date Page Filed: 3 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 847

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000363

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 97 Date Page Filed: 4 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 848

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000364

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 98 Date Page Filed: 5 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 849

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000365

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 99 Date Page Filed: 6 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 850

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000366

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 100 Date Page Filed: 7 of 54 01/10/2014 PageID: 851

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000367

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 101 Date Page Filed: 8 of 54 01/10/2014 PageID: 852

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000368

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 102 Date Page Filed: 9 of 54 01/10/2014 PageID: 853

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000369

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 103 Date PageFiled: 10 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 854

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000370

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 104 Date PageFiled: 11 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 855

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000371

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 105 Date PageFiled: 12 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 856

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000372

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 106 Date PageFiled: 13 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 857

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000373

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 107 Date PageFiled: 14 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 858

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000374

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 108 Date PageFiled: 15 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 859

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000375

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 109 Date PageFiled: 16 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 860

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000376

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 110 Date PageFiled: 17 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 861

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000377

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 111 Date PageFiled: 18 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 862

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000378

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 112 Date PageFiled: 19 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 863

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000379

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 113 Date PageFiled: 20 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 864

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000380

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 114 Date PageFiled: 21 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 865

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000381

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 115 Date PageFiled: 22 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 866

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000382

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 116 Date PageFiled: 23 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 867

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000383

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 117 Date PageFiled: 24 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 868

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000384

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 118 Date PageFiled: 25 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 869

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000385

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 119 Date PageFiled: 26 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 870

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000386

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 120 Date PageFiled: 27 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 871

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000387

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 121 Date PageFiled: 28 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 872

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000388

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 122 Date PageFiled: 29 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 873

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000389

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 123 Date PageFiled: 30 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 874

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000390

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 124 Date PageFiled: 31 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 875

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000391

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 125 Date PageFiled: 32 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 876

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000392

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 126 Date PageFiled: 33 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 877

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000393

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 127 Date PageFiled: 34 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 878

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000394

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 128 Date PageFiled: 35 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 879

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000395

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 129 Date PageFiled: 36 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 880

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000396

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 130 Date PageFiled: 37 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 881

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000397

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 131 Date PageFiled: 38 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 882

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000398

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 132 Date PageFiled: 39 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 883

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000399

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 133 Date PageFiled: 40 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 884

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000400

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 134 Date PageFiled: 41 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 885

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000401

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 135 Date PageFiled: 42 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 886

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000402

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 136 Date PageFiled: 43 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 887

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000403

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 137 Date PageFiled: 44 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 888

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000404

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 138 Date PageFiled: 45 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 889

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000405

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 139 Date PageFiled: 46 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 890

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000406

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 140 Date PageFiled: 47 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 891

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000407

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 141 Date PageFiled: 48 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 892

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000408

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 142 Date PageFiled: 49 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 893

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000409

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 143 Date PageFiled: 50 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 894

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000410

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 144 Date PageFiled: 51 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 895

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000411

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 145 Date PageFiled: 52 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 896

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000412

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 146 Date PageFiled: 53 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 897

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000413

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504693 30-7 Filed Page: 09/13/13 147 Date PageFiled: 54 of 01/10/2014 54 PageID: 898

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000414

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504694

Page: 1

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

CASE NO. 13-4429 UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT TARA KING, ED.D., individually and on behalf of her patients, RONALD NEWMAN, PH.D., individually and on behalf of his patients, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR RESEARCH AND THERAPY OF HOMOSEXUALITY (NARTH), and AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF CHRISTIAN COUNSELORS (AACC), Plaintiffs/Appellants, v. CHRISTOPHER J. CHRISTIE, Governor of the State of New Jersey, in his official capacity, ERIC T. KANEFSKY, Director of the New Jersey Department of Law and Public Safety: Division of Consumer Affairs, in his official capacity, MILAGROS COLLAZO, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Marriage and Family Therapy Examiners, in her official capacity, J. MICHAEL WALKER, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Psychological Examiners, in his official capacity; and PAUL JORDAN, President of the New Jersey State Board of Medical Examiners, in his official capacity, Defendants/Appellees, And GARDEN STATE EQUALITY, Intervenor-Defendant/Appellee. APPENDIX OF PLAINTIFFS-APPELLANTS VOL III.B (000415-000449) Mathew D. Staver (Lead Counsel) Anita L. Staver LIBERTY COUNSEL 1055 Maitland Ctr. Cmmns 2d Floor Maitland, FL 32751-7214 Tel. (800) 671-1776 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants Stephen M. Crampton Mary E. McAlister Daniel J. Schmid LIBERTY COUNSEL P.O. Box 11108 Lynchburg, VA 24506 Tel. (434) 592-7000 Email court@lc.org Attorneys for Appellants

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504694

Page: 2

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

TABLE OF CONTENTS VOLUME I (000001-000070) Plaintiffs Notice of Appeal.............000001 Memorandum Opinion ...........000003 Order ...000069 VOLUME II (000071-000276) District Court Docket Sheet.....000071 Complaint........000085 Complaint Exhibit A ...000131 Complaint Exhibit B ...000137 Application for Temporary Restraining Order and/or Preliminary Injunction...000141 Declaration of Dr. Tara King...000167 Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman....000174 Declaration of David Pruden...000181 Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik..000187 Declaration of Dr. Joseph Nicolosi..000231 Declaration of Dr. Eric Scalise000249 Garden State Equalitys Notice of Motion to Intervene as Party Defendant ...000257 Certification of Troy Stevenson .000259

Case: 13-4429

Document: 003111504694

Page: 3

Date Filed: 01/10/2014

Defendants Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment Pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 56...000272 Proposed Intervenor-Defendant Garden State Equalitys Notice of Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment .............000274 VOLUME III (000277-000449) Exhibit C, Declaration of Gregory Herek, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation ................................................................................000277 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Christopher Rosik ..................000415 Rebuttal Declaration of Dr. Ronald Newman.....000441 VOLUME IV (000450-000665) Declaration of Dr. Judith Reisman .....000450 Declaration of John Doe, Minor Child ...000537 Declaration of Jane Doe, Mother of Minor Child ......000542 Declaration of Jack Doe, Father of Minor Child.000549 Plaintiffs Motion Objecting to Courts Dispensing with Plaintiffs Supporting Declarations and Evidence, Dispensing with Evidentiary Motions, and Motion to Deem Certain Factual Allegations Admitted by the State 000554 Transcript of Motions Hearing000588

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 4 Date Page Filed: 1 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1046

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000415

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 5 Date Page Filed: 2 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1047

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000416

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 6 Date Page Filed: 3 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1048

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000417

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 7 Date Page Filed: 4 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1049

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000418

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 8 Date Page Filed: 5 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1050

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000419

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 9 Date Page Filed: 6 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1051

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000420

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 10 Date Page Filed: 7 of 26 01/10/2014 PageID: 1052

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000421

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 11 Date Page Filed: 8 of 26 01/10/2014 PageID: 1053

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000422

CaseCase: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 12 Date Page Filed: 9 of 26 01/10/2014 PageID: 1054

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000423

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 13 Date PageFiled: 10 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1055

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000424

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 14 Date PageFiled: 11 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1056

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000425

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 15 Date PageFiled: 12 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1057

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000426

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 16 Date PageFiled: 13 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1058

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000427

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 17 Date PageFiled: 14 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1059

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000428

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 18 Date PageFiled: 15 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1060

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000429

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 19 Date PageFiled: 16 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1061

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000430

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 20 Date PageFiled: 17 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1062

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000431

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 21 Date PageFiled: 18 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1063

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000432

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 22 Date PageFiled: 19 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1064

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000433

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 23 Date PageFiled: 20 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1065

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000434

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 24 Date PageFiled: 21 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1066

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000435

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 25 Date PageFiled: 22 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1067

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000436

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 26 Date PageFiled: 23 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1068

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000437

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 27 Date PageFiled: 24 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1069

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000438

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 28 Date PageFiled: 25 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1070

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000439

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document: Document 003111504694 33-1 Filed Page: 09/20/13 29 Date PageFiled: 26 of 01/10/2014 26 PageID: 1071

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000440

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 30 Date Page Filed: 1 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1072

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY TRENTON DIVISION

TARA KING, ED.D, individually and on behalf of her patients, RONALD NEWMAN, PH.D., individually and on behalf of his patients, NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR RESEARCH AND THERAPY OF HOMOSEXUALITY (NARTH), AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF CHRISTIAN COUNSELORS (AACC), Plaintiffs, Case No. 13-cv-5038 v. CHRISTOPHER J. CHRISTIE, Governor of the State of New Jersey, in his official capacity, ERIC T. KANEFSKY, Director of the New Jersey Department of Law and Public Safety: Division of Consumer Affairs, in his official capacity, MILAGROS COLLAZO, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Marriage and Family Therapy Examiners, in her official capacity, J. MICHAEL WALKER, Executive Director of the New Jersey Board of Psychological Examiners, in his official capacity; PAUL JORDAN, President of the New Jersey State Board of Medical Examiners, in his official capacity, Defendants.

REBUTTAL DECLARATION OF DR. RONALD NEWMAN I, Dr. Ron Newman, hereby declare as follows:

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 1

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000441

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 31 Date Page Filed: 2 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1073

1.

I am over the age of 18 and am one of the Plaintiffs in this action. The statements in this

Declaration are true and correct and if called upon to testify to them I would and could do so competently. 2. I am submitting this Declaration in support of Plaintiffs Converted Motion for Summary

Judgment and in Response to the State of New Jerseys and Garden State Equalitys Cross Motion for Summary Judgment. 3. I received a Doctor of Philosophy degree in Psychoeducational Processes from Temple

University in 1990. I received a Master of Arts degree in Counseling Psychology from Trinity International University in 1980, a Bachelors Degree in Psychology from West Virginia University in 1976, and an Associates of Arts degree in Practical Theology from Christ for the Nations Institute in 1978. I have 33 years of experience as a mental health professional and have been a Licensed Clinical Psychologist (LCP) in the State of New Jersey, since 1995. I am a Board Certified Professional Christian Counselor through the American Association of Christian Counselors. I am the Founder of the Christian Counseling Consortium of South Jersey (CCC), which is a group of approximately 50 licensed and unlicensed mental health professionals, counselors, and pastors committed to engaging in counseling from a Christian perspective founded on the truths inherent in Scripture and with approximately 200 people who have expressed interest and are on our mailing list. 4. Despite the States contention to the contrary, the fact that homosexuality is not a

disease is irrelevant, since there are countless issues that are not a disease and become a matter of therapeutic concern (e.g., family conflicts, a wide range of stressors both externally and internally in peoples lives, etc.). In my practice of Sexual Orientation Change Efforts (SOCE) (which is only with those who have unwanted same sex attractions, not those who self-

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 2

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000442

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 32 Date Page Filed: 3 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1074

identify as gay), there have always been other diagnoses that are a matter of clinical concern (e.g., PTSD, OCD, depression, anxiety, etc.) which bring the client in for therapy, and the SOCE is secondary. 5. A3371 infringes on the ethical obligation to allow the client the right of self-

determination, and hinders ethical psychologists (which most are) from giving treatment options that are not strictly gay affirming. 6. Our country and our mental health professions have been founded on acceptance of

diversity of beliefs and philosophical positions. We claim to look to evidence to make our clinical decisions, but inaccuracies abound based on a variety of cognitive distortions, including emotional reasoning. Scientific and anecdotal evidence of the fluidity of the sexuality of many people is ignored in A3371 and by its advocates in favor of a presupposition that people can be born gay and that the science is settled on that matter. It is not. 7. While it purports to be protecting minors, the central issue of this law is not to protect

minors from unethical and harmful professionals. The real central issue is a direct attack on the worldview and belief systems of most major conservative religious organizations and what they consider to be their Holy books (The Torah, the Bible, the Koran, the Book of Mormon, etc.). This is evidenced by Defendants experts who say counselors should focus on changing those religious beliefs that oppose homosexuality. Section 1(j) of A3371 states, As with any societal prejudice, bias against individuals based on actual or perceived sexual orientation, gender identity or gender expression negatively affects mental health, contributing to an enduring sense of stigma and pervasive self-criticism through the internalization of such prejudice. The societal prejudice referenced has to do with conservative interpretations of various historical Sacred writings which present a worldview that is contrary to the belief that a

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 3

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000443

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 33 Date Page Filed: 4 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1075

person is born gay and has no choice regarding their sexual behavior patterns . (The conservative religious position has scientific support, in spite of the political positions of various professional associations on this issue.) 8. The religious organizations teach that people have the right of self-determination and the

responsibility to control their behavior within the boundaries established by their teachings. Most religions have a holy book, such as the Torah or Bible, which conservative believers look to for their belief system and how to live their lives. The freedom to believe a diversity of things about God, morality, etc., is part of what defines us as a nation. This freedom is now being severely challenged by this law. A3371 attacks the right of parents to practice their religious faith and teach their children the boundaries they understand to be healthy for them. 9. A3371 also denies the rights of individuals to choose therapy with someone who

understands the tenants of their faith and can counsel in a manner that is culturally sensitive to their faith subculture. It also hinders my ability to practice my faith and work with clients who desire assistance in applying the most effective therapeutic tools to help them align their behavior with their deeply held religious belief systems. 10. The purported harmful effects of SOCE are based on inadequate science with no serious

objective scientific support, far less than the evidence supporting the effectiveness and benefit of SOCE, proving the bias of the sub-groups of the APA who put out the report against SOCE. The issue of protecting minors is false, particularly since the ethics of the profession already protect minors against the type of harmful counseling characterized in the law and licensed professionals are sensitive to the clients right to self-determination of therapeutic goals. 11. Informed consent is part of my practice, and I respect my clients right to self-

determination. I believe that respectful dialogue is possible and that those pushing for this law

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 4

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000444

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 34 Date Page Filed: 5 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1076

demonstrate their intolerance toward those who disagree with them, primarily those with a conservative religious belief system. Some within the gay community who are pushing for this law want this belief system to be silenced or eliminated in order to prevent depression, anxiety, self-destructive behavior and suicide, while my experience is that the polarization needs to be eliminated to the benefit of everyone. My educational and work experiences in a diversity of settings throughout the past 40 years have taught me this important lesson. 12. The law will actually do more harm to the public, as it will cause those with unwanted

same-sex attraction to lose hope that change is possible, since they cannot access those licensed professionals who are best equipped to help people change their unwanted behaviors. Research indicates there are an equal number of people with unwanted same sex attraction as those who embrace a gay identity. The inner conflicts of those with unwanted same sex attractions potentially will lead to even more depression, anxiety, self-destructive behavior and suicide due to the lack of access to appropriate mental health services to help them process and resolve their struggles. 13. In my 33 years of clinical practice, I have helped many minors and adults work

through anxieties and depressions related to their unwanted same-sex attractions. While under this law, I will not even be able to refer potential clients to a non-licensed (religious) counselor, as it can be perceived as a sexual orientation change effort. Parents will still seek and send clients to non-licensed counselors who are often not as adequately equipped, nor ethically trained, to address their children in the most appropriate therapeutic manner (which could include helping the parent to not force SOCE on their children, if the child has embraced a deeply held gay identity).

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 5

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000445

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 35 Date Page Filed: 6 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1077

14.

In other words, this law will increase the practices and harm that they are seeking to

eliminate! It should also be noted that no one is denying that some people who receive counseling for a variety of reasons, can get worse as a result due to stirring up and exploring past issues of rejection, hurt and emotional pain in their lives. This is a part of the informed consent that many psychologists give to their clients prior to beginning any treatment. SOCE treatment is no different in that regard. 15. Free speech is hindered, as the law is too broad and thus public speeches and seminars by

licensed professionals, psychoeducational materials for clients and their parents, including books, journal articles, websites, etc., can all be viewed as an effort to change a persons sexual orientation or behavior, or to reduce or eliminate sexual or romantic attractions or feelings toward a person of the same gender. I have been involved in all of the above, and my inability to speak or teach on this issue will actually be a set-back to the gay community, as I teach concepts of love and tolerance and a gracious attitude toward anyone with whom we disagree in any matter of theology or behavior. 16. Social prejudice and intolerance will only increase under a climate of increased

polarization, which this law encourages. The First Amendments protections are ignored by this law. It hinders me from speaking, teaching, or writing on this issue, since these can be construed as seeking to influence others sexual behavior. As a licensed psychologist, I am at risk for sharing my religious convictions and psychological opinion. For the supporters of this law, diversity seems to translate to anything but conservative religious beliefs. 17. Research on SOCE has been hampered by the political power of some in the gay

community who censor this option. Supporting documents for the law, including primarily the APA Task Force Report claim that more research needs to be done on SOCE, yet the law

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 6

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000446

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 36 Date Page Filed: 7 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1078

prohibits it. Research on SOCE can never be expected to occur under the current political climate, as is self-evident even through the proposal of this law. The Spitzer study (Spitzer, R. L. (2003). Can some gay men and lesbians change their sexual orientation? (200 participants reporting a change from homosexual to heterosexual orientation.) Archives of Sexual Behavior, 32(5), 403-417) demonstrating the efficacy of SOCE, in spite of his retraction, was a step in the right direction and demonstrated change in sexual behavior and even orientation is possible. A client of mine was a part of that historic study. 18. This law will impact nearly all of the work I do with minors, as the definitions of

SOCE are so broad that I fear discussing sexuality at all will put me at risk for violation of the law. Anyone who does therapy with adolescents knows that it is a time of identity formation, which for many includes exploring and consideration of their sexual identity. Experimentation is common, and with our current cultural climate, including the internet and easy access to gay pornography (it cannot be blocked from smart phones, and many parents do not monitor their childrens internet activity), consideration of homosexual behavior is increasingly frequent in those I counsel. 19. A female client who may kiss a girlfriend out of curiosity does not mean she regards

herself as gay, but may want to process that experience therapeutically. Neutrality of counseling, as pretended in this law, is a myth. Only gay affirmative counseling is really permitted. Thus, even exploring and affirming clients heterosexual interests can, in the future, be construed as influencing their behavior in a way that puts me at risk of violation of this law. 20. Helping a male client process his experience of molestation by another male, including

his temptations toward a repetition of that same-sex behavior, can be construed as violation of this law if his heterosexual interests are affirmed and homosexual behavior is discouraged. Or,

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 7

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000447

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 37 Date Page Filed: 8 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1079

helping a male client who questions in his diary, Am I gay? cannot be objectively counseled without future risk, unless the (non)-therapeutic response is to answer in the affirmative. The risks of homosexual behavior, documented by scientific studies (Centers for Disease Control (2011). HIV and AIDS among Gay and Bisexual Men. Retrived from

http://www.cdc.gov/nchhstp/newsroom/docs/2012/CDC-MSM-0612-508.pdf), cannot even be discussed due to this laws prohibition on influencing sexual behavior in any way other than what is gay affirmative. 21. Since the majority of my clients come to me because they are seeking counseling that

integrates a Christian worldview, my psychology practice would suffer irreparable harm if I were no longer able to counsel in a manner consistent with a conservative Christian faith. No parent would refer a minor child if they believed I could only address issues of sexuality in a gay affirming manner without regard to their belief system. 22. My refusal to bring my minor clients into this case is due to my desire to protect them.

They are conscious of this law and the restrictions on my current therapeutic options under this law. Neither has chosen to embrace a gay identity, even though this question was addressed during the course of therapy in the past. Neither of these clients wants others to even know they are in therapy, and it is my clinical judgment that they would suffer significant anxiety and harm if they were influenced to testify in this case. 23. My private psychology practice for over fifteen years, as well as the practices of other

faith-based licensed professionals, have been built on referrals from the clergy and a wide range of Christian sources, and would be irreparably harmed if referrals from those sources were to cease. The fact that clergy are excluded from this law is irrelevant, since they refer to

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 8

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000448

Case Case: 3:13-cv-05038-FLW-LHG 13-4429 Document:Document 003111504694 33-2 Filed Page: 09/20/13 38 Date Page Filed: 9 of 01/10/2014 9 PageID: 1080

professionals in more difficult cases or where expertise is needed, such as with unwanted samesex attraction.

I declare under penalty of perjury of the laws of the United States and New Jersey that the foregoing statements are true and accurate.

Executed this 20th day of September, 2013.

Declaration of Ron Newman, Ph.D. - 9

APPENDIX (VOL. III) - PAGE 000449

You might also like