Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Measurement of xylem sap amino acid concentrations in conjunction with whole tree transpiration estimates spring N remobilization by cherry (Prunus avium L.) trees
G. GRASSI1, P. MILLARD2, R. WENDLER2, G. MINOTTA3 & M. TAGLIAVINI1
Dipartimento di Colture Arboree, Universit di Bologna, Via Fanin 46, 40127 Bologna, Italy, 2Macaulay Institute, Craigiebuckler, Aberdeen AB15 8QH, UK and 3Dipartimento AGROSELVITER, Universit di Torino, Italy
ABSTRACT
Prunus avium trees were grown in sand culture for one vegetative season with contrasting N supplies, in order to precondition their N storage capacities. During the spring of the second year a constant amount of 15N was supplied to all the trees, and the recovery of unlabelled N in the new biomass production was used as a direct measure of N remobilization. Destructive harvests were taken during spring to determine the pattern of N remobilization and uptake. Measurements of both xylem sap amino acid proles and whole tree transpiration rates were taken, to determine whether specic amino acids are translocated as a consequence of N remobilization and if remobilization can be quantied by calculating the ux of these amino acids in the xylem. Whereas remobilization started immediately after bud burst, N derived from uptake by root appeared in the leaves only 3 weeks later. The tree internal N status affected both the amount of N remobilization and its dynamics. The concentration of xylem sap amino acids peaked shortly after bud burst, concurrently with the period of fastest remobilization. Few amino acids and amides (Gln, Asn and Asp) were responsible for most of N translocated through the xylem; however, their relative concentration varied over spring, demonstrating that the transport of remobilized N occurred mainly with Gln whereas transport of N taken up from roots occurred mainly with Asn. Coupling measurements of amino acid N in the xylem sap with transpiration values was well correlated with the recovery of unlabelled N in the new biomass production. These results are discussed in relation to the possibility of measuring the spring remobilization of N in eld-grown trees by calculating the ux of N translocation in the xylem. Key-words: asparagine; cherry; glutamine; N remobilization; 15N; transpiration; xylem sap.
INTRODUCTION
Remobilization of stored nitrogen is used by many trees to augment the supply of nutrients from the soil (Millard
Correspondence: Giacomo Grassi. Fax: +39 0512096401; e-mail: grassi@agrsci.unibo.it 2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd
1996). This source of N is often the rst, and sometimes the only N-source used for growth in the spring and can provide the majority of nitrogen used for growth each year (e.g. Millard & Proe 1991; Neilsen et al. 1997; Weinbaum & van Kessel 1998; Dyckmans & Flessa 2001). However, measurement of the nitrogen storage capacity of a tree is difcult. Studies have often used either 15N enriched (e.g. Millard 1996) or depleted tracers (e.g. Weinbaum et al. 1984; Weinbaum & van Kessel 1998), involving making destructive budgets of tree N. Such studies are either restricted to the use of sand culture for growing small trees, or can be imprecise if N budgets are constructed for large, eld-grown trees. An alternative method to quantify the N storage capacity of a tree might be to measure remobilization of N, because the amount of N remobilized depends upon the amount in store and is unaffected by the current N supply (Millard 1996). Furthermore, storage pools of N can disappear completely by the summer (Coleman et al. 1993; Sauter & van Cleve 1994). Several studies have shown a peak in the concentration of N in the xylem sap during bud burst and leaf growth which was attributed to N remobilization (Ferguson, Eiseman & Leonard 1983; Glavac & Jockheim 1993; Schneider et al. 1994). Using 15N to label storage pools, Millard et al. (1998) showed that remobilization by Betula pendula trees led to a more than 10-fold increase in the concentration of citrulline and glutamine in the xylem sap. The subsequent decrease in concentration of N in the xylem sap was not solely due to dilution, caused as a consequence of higher transpiration rates, but to the end of remobilization (Millard et al. 1998). A similar pattern of amino acid translocation has been measured in the xylem of Malus domestica trees during remobilization (Malaguti et al. 2001). Coupling measurements of the concentration of the amino acids translocated during remobilization with either sap velocity or whole tree transpiration might allow the ux of N to be calculated. Such an approach has already been used to quantify mineral uxes via xylem sap ow in Picea abies trees (Dambrine et al. 1995). This approach could potentially give a non-destructive method to measure N remobilization, and so indirectly the storage capacity of the tree, which does not depend upon the use of tracers. To determine the feasibility of such an approach we grew 1689
1690 G. Grassi et al. Prunus avium trees in sand culture with contrasting N supplies, in order to precondition their N storage capacities. During the spring of the second year we supplied a constant amount of 15N to all the trees and used the recovery of unlabelled N in the new biomass production as a measure of N remobilization. In addition, we measured both xylem sap amino acid proles and whole tree transpiration rates, in order to determine if: (1) there are specic amino acids translocated by P. avium as a consequence of N remobilization, and (2) remobilization can be quantied by calculating the ux of these amino acids in the xylem. The use of trees pre-conditioned to have contrasting amounts of N available for remobilization was to test how robust such a technique could be. between each. One tree from each treatment within each block (four replicates per treatment) was randomly assigned to each harvest. At harvest the trees were destructively sampled, and xylem sap collected as described below. The trees designated for the next harvest then had their transpiration rate measured (as described below) until they in turn were sampled.
Sap collection
Xylem sap collection was carried out just before harvesting the trees, between 1130 and 1430 h. A portion of the stem,
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
Xylem sap amino acid translocation and N remobilization 1691 between 20 and 50 cm above the collar, was collected from the trees. A few centimetres of bark were removed from the higher cut end of the stem to avoid phloem contamination. The stem portion was immediately placed in a Scholander pressure chamber so that the section of wood with bark removed protruded. The pressure in the chamber was slowly increased to a maximum of 02 MPa, and xylem sap exuded was collected with micro-capillary tubes. Initial tests (as described by Malaguti et al. 2001) indicated that pressures up to 02 MPa did not cause any contamination by cellular components. Sap samples were stored at -70 C until analysis of the concentration and 15N enrichment of their individual amino acids by gas chromatography linked to mass spectrometry (GCMS). measured for an individual amino acid had to be greater than the precision value for the corresponding standard before the sample was considered to be enriched.
Data analysis
For the four replicates per treatment, data for leaf area, total new biomass production (leaves and axes), recovery of unlabelled and labelled N, xylem sap amino acid proles and whole tree transpiration were related to the stage of development by using the number of days from bud burst as a measure of time. Data for leaf area, total new biomass production, recovery of unlabelled and labelled N in the new biomass production and transpiration were tted against time using sigmoid functions of Table Curve 2d software (SPSS Inc., Chicago. IL. USA). These functions were chosen because they provided a good and biologically meaningful description of the phenomenon. Data for leaf area, total new biomass production, recovery of unlabelled and labelled N in the new biomass production collected after the 95% of the maximum value was reached (calculated using the functions described above) were subjected to analysis of variance to determine the signicance of the difference between the treatments. Data of amino acid N in xylem sap during and after the period of N remobilization were processed by analysis of variance for the effects of N treatments, time and their interaction using the SPSS for Windows (version 61.3; SPSS Inc.) statistical package. The effect of tree N status on the comparison of the two methods for measuring N remobilization was determined by a comparison of the slope of linear regressions between the amount of labelled N recovered in leaves and the ux of amino acid and amide N in the xylem, as described by Gomez & Gomez (1984).
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
LN Leaf N before leaf senescence (% DW) Stem height (cm) Stem diameter at the base of the tree (cm) Number of buds 21 01 151 4 15 002 31 1
HN 26 01 155 3 15 003 34 1
The concentrations of the three predominant amino acids and amides in the xylem sap were followed during time, and their 15N labelling was used to determine the amount of each translocated as a consequence of N remobilization. Gln and to a lesser extent Asn and Asp were translocated as a consequence of N remobilization, with tree N status having no effect on the form of N translocated during remobilization (Fig. 3a & b). In LN plants some Gln and Asn were also translocated as a consequence of direct
High-nitrogen (HN) and low-nitrogen (LN) treatments refer to the amount of nitrogen received in 1999. Number of replicates: six for leaf N, and 40 for stem height, stem diameter and bud number. Levels of signicance: NS, not signicant, *P 005, **P 001.
1 .2
(a)
0 .9
Remobilization of N started straight after bud burst in both treatments, reaching 95% of maximum value 62 and 40 d after bud burst for HN and LN plants, respectively (Fig. 2a). These dates were designated as the time when remobilization nished and were used in subsequent calculations. After these dates, the difference between treatments in the amount of N remobilized was signicant at P < 0001 (489 26 mg tree-1 for HN and 237 16 mg tree-1 for LN). At the end of the experiment, the fraction of total N in the new biomass production that came from remobilization was 26% for HN and 14% for LN plants. Recovery of N taken up by roots occurred after remobilization of N had started, reaching the 5% of maximum value at 22 and 20 d after bud burst for HN and LN plants, respectively (Fig. 2b). In the new biomass a slightly higher content of N deriving from root uptake was found in LN in comparison with HN plants; however, after the 95% of maximum value was reached no statistical differences between treatments were recorded (1388 37 mg tree-1 for HN and 1469 62 mg tree-1 for LN).
-1
0 .6
80
(b)
60
-1
40
Figure 1. Pattern of (a) leaf area and (b) total new biomass production (leaves + axes) during 2000 in Prunus avium trees, in relation to days from bud burst. High-nitrogen (HN) and lownitrogen (LN) treatments refer to the amount of nitrogen received in 1999. Data points in (a) are tted with sigmoid curves with the following equations: y = -004 + 088/(1 + exp((x - 306)/101)) for LN plants (r2 = 094, P < 0001); y = 0018 + 090/(1 + exp((x 304)/966)) for HN plants (r2 = 093, P < 0001). Data points in (b) are tted with sigmoid curves with the following equations: y = -298 + 692/(1 + exp((x - 425)/129)) for LN plants (r2 = 097, P < 0001); y = -253 + 758/(1 + exp((x - 427)/129)) for HN plants (r2 = 098, P < 0001).
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS
* *** *** *** *** *** NS *** *** *** *** *** *** *** *** ***
NS NS NS * NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS NS
Values are given as g amino acid N g xylem sap1 and are mean SE of four replicates. Mean daily transpiration (g tree1 d1) SE of the selected plants is also shown. Levels of signicance: NS, not signicant, *P 005, ***P 0001.
individual plants in a sampling period was added to the mean value of N remobilization of the previous period, in order to calculate the cumulative N remobilized. This procedure was then repeated until the end of the period of N remobilization for each treatment (62 and 40 d from bud burst for HN and LN trees, respectively). Figure 5 shows the amount of N remobilized by HN and LN trees during the remobilization period, as measured by the recovery of unlabelled N in their new biomass production (Fig. 2a), compared with the amount calculated by the ux of amino acid in their xylem. The comparison showed a good agreement between the two methods, and the slopes of the linear regressions for the two N treatments (084 for the LN trees and 109 for the HN trees) were not signicantly different. During the calculation of N ux through the xylem we assumed that the concentration of N in the xylem sap which was taken at the end of the sampling period was representative of the mean concentration of the whole period. This assumption involves two possible errors. First, marked diurnal variations in xylem sap N concentration, possibly due to variation in transpiration rates, would mean that at the time of sap collection the concentration of xylem N was signicantly different from other periods of the day. A separate study on P. avium trees indicated that in spring xylem sap N concentration during the night was signicantly higher (60% more, P < 001) than during the day. However, if we consider that in the trees used in our experiment transpiration during the night period (19000700 h) was negligible in comparison with
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
1694 G. Grassi et al. separate set of 20 trees, 30 ( 2) days after bud burst; sap samples were collected from 3 or 4 replicate trees per treatment in three different periods: 07001100, 11001500 and 15001900 h. The concentration of N in Gln, Asn and Asp showed a relatively small, and statistically insignicant, decline during the central part of the day (Table 3); furthermore, because of the higher transpiration rates, the total ux of N through the xylem was higher during the middle of the day, the period when saps were collected from the main experiment. Therefore, we concluded that any errors associated with a diurnal variation in sap composition were negligible. The second possible error could be due to marked variations in amino acid concentrations during the sampling period. This occurred during the rst 3 weeks following bud burst, when a peak in concentration was evident (Fig. 3). This may have led to an overestimation of remobilization of N if the saps were collected during the ascending part of the peak and to an underestimation if they were collected as the peak declined. However, these two errors would partly compensate for each other, and so the overall error was considered probably to be negligible.
800
(a)
Unlabelled N (mg tree )
-1 15
600
400
2000
(b)
Labelled N (mg tree )
-1
15
LN HN
that occurring during the light period (07001900 h) (typically less than 2% of total daily transpiration, see Fig. 4b), we concluded that the resulting ux of N during the night was also negligible. We thus concentrated our attention to the light period, in order to check if concomitant variations in xylem sap N concentration and transpiration between 0700 and 1900 h could have produced errors in our calculations. The pattern of N in Gln, Asn and Asp during the light period was checked, by collecting xylem saps from a
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
1200
(c) HN plants
900
600
600
300
300
Unlabelled N (m gN g sap)
0 0 20 40 60 80 Days from bud burst (d) LN plants 900 Aspartic Asparagine Glutamine 100
-1
1200
600 300
600
300
Figure 3. Concentration of (a and b) unlabelled N and (c and d) labelled 15N in aspartic acid, asparagine and glutamine in the xylem sap
of Prunus avium trees in relation to days from bud burst. High-nitrogen (HN) and low-nitrogen (LN) treatments refer to the amount of nitrogen received in 1999.
remobilization period. In this period, Gln accounted for nearly half of the total amino acid N in the xylem sap followed by Asn and Asp, whereas only negligible concentrations of other amino acids were found. Therefore, P. avium was predominantly an amide translocator, as has been reported for a range of other tree species. For example, Gln has been reported to be the predominant form of organic N in xylem saps of Prunus spp. (Andersen et al. 1995 ), Populus and Salix spp. (Sauter 1981; Sauter & van Cleve 1994; Schneider et al. 1994), Eucalyptus spp. (Adams, Attiwell & Wang-Liang 1995), Actinidia deliciosa (Clark & Smith 1991), Vitis vinifera (Peuke 2000), Pinus spp. (Barnes 1963; Plassard, Bonafos & Touraine 2000) and Picea abies (Weber et al. 1998). Asparagine was the predominant amino acid in Prunus dulcis (Yousse, Brown & Weinbaum 2000), Malus domestica (Tromp & Ovaa 1985; Malaguti et al. 2001) and Sorbus aucuparia (Prima Putra & Botton 1998). Increases in the Gln concentration in xylem saps of Populus canadensis in the spring have been correlated with the turnover of ray parenchyma storage protein vesicles (Sauter & van Cleve 1994). These authors suggested that as Gln was a minor component of the storage protein but the
predominant form of N in the sap during remobilization, protein turnover must result in Gln synthesis before release into the xylem. Tree N status had no statistically signicant effect upon the amino acid concentration or composition of the xylem saps. In contrast, Yousse et al. (2000) found that fertilization of P. dulcis increased both tree N status and xylem sap amino acid concentrations. However, in our study HN plants had an earlier leaf area development and consequently higher initial transpiration rates compared to LN trees, so the results may be at least in part the consequence of a different dilution of the saps between treatments. The peak in concentration of amino acids found in xylem sap shortly after bud burst was predominantly due to remobilization of N. The subsequent decrease in xylem sap amino acid and amide N concentration was caused only in part by dilution, as a consequence of higher transpiration as leaves grew. Whereas the sap N concentration showed a 12-fold decrease between day 10 and 20 from bud burst, transpiration increased by only six times; subsequently, N concentration remained constant despite a large increase in transpiration. Furthermore, qualitative differences in sap
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
1696 G. Grassi et al. (Malaguti et al. 2001), suggesting that these changes are species-specic.
500
(a)
Transpiration (g tree d )
-1
-1
40 HN LN 30
(b)
Sap flux (g h )
-1
20
10
0 1 2 4 5 7 9 10 12 13 15 17 18 20 22 Hour
Figure 4. (a) Daily mean transpiration rates by Prunus avium
trees in relation to days from bud burst. Data points are tted with sigmoid curves with the following equations: y = -096 + 2948/ (1 + exp((x - 263)/490)) for LN plants (r2 = 091, P < 0001) and y = -127 + 3176/(1 + exp((x - 235)/703)) for HN plants (r2 = 092, P < 0001). (b) Daily courses of sap ux measured 30 2 d from bud burst (averages of four trees per treatment).
800
600
400
composition during and after remobilization were evident. The proportion of the total sap N recovered in Gln showed a 10-fold decrease following remobilization, whereas the proportion of total N found in Asn doubled. This demonstrated that the changes in xylem sap composition during spring reect a shift in N sources from remobilization of internal reserves to uptake by root and therefore that remobilization of N occurred through specic amino acids, partially different from those used for transport of N taken up from roots. Similar qualitative changes in xylem sap composition during spring were also observed in Betula pendula (Millard et al. 1998), but not in Malus domestica
800
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
Transpiration (g) HN 396 27 1078 15 447 98 1921 12 LN 350 28 1003 16 353 34 1706 12 NS *** NS
Flux of N in the xylem (mg N tree-1) HN 115 08 190 57 87 19 392 26 LN 110 13 187 54 115 05 412 23 NS NS NS
Values are mean SE. Levels of signicance: NS, not signicant; ***P 0001.
(Glavac et al. 1989; Smith & Shortle 2001), as well as spatial variations in sap ux density (Loustau, Domec & Bosc 1998; Lu, Muller & Chacko 2000). If a signicant exchange of N compounds occurs between the xylem sap and surrounding tissues as the sap ascends the tree, then measuring sap velocity and composition at only one point might not reect the ux of remobilized N reaching the buds and new biomass production. The processes of N remobilization and uptake in spring showed markedly different dynamics. During the rst 3 weeks after bud burst, when about 60% of N remobilization had already occurred in both treatments, practically no root N uptake had occurred. The temporal separation of these processes varies between species. For example, N uptake and remobilization are concurrent in Betula pendula (Millard et al. 1998), whereas in Acer pseudoplatanus (Millard and Proe 1991), Pyrus communis (Tagliavini, Quartieri & Millard 1997) and Prunus persica (Rufat & DeJong 2001) the majority of N recovered in the new biomass production during the rst 2530 d following bud burst is supplied by remobilization. In contrast, there is almost no N uptake by Sorbus aucuparia before remobilization is complete (Millard et al. 2001). The temporal separation of uptake by root from remobilization would make estimating the ux of remobilized N in the xylem easier, and avoid the need to use isotopes. In the current study, translocation of some Gln, Asn and Asp as a consequence of uptake by root was measured during the period of remobilization by LN trees. This demonstrated that when trees had a low N status and were provided with abundant N in the spring, they were capable of translocating N from uptake by root in the same form as that from remobilization. For species exhibiting concurrent uptake and remobilization of N, this could cause a considerable error in estimating the ux of remobilized N in the xylem sap, unless isotopic tracers were used. Millard et al. (1998) raised the possibility of measuring the spring remobilization of N in eld-grown trees by calculating the ux of N translocation in the xylem during
spring, without the use of tracers. Data from this study suggest that, given that the amount of transpiration can be measured precisely, such an approach could be feasible for eld-grown P. avium trees. However, such an approach would probably not work for species exhibiting concurrent N uptake and remobilization in the spring. Furthermore, it would be necessary to know which amino acids were translocated as a consequence of remobilization. If these were the same as those resulting from uptake by root and assimilation of N (e.g. Malus domestica, Malaguti et al. 2001) then such an approach would probably not be feasible.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Dip. Colture Arborce Univ. Bologna, publication no. 1768. P.M. thanks Manaaki Whenua Landcare Research, New Zealand for funding a Senior Research Fellowship which enabled him to nd the time to contribute to the writing of the paper, and David Whitehead for all his support and encouragement while in New Zealand. The authors also like to thank P. Gioacchini and R. Croce for technical help and A. Peressotti (University of Udine) for providing the heat balance stem gauges. The research was funded in part by Italian Ministry of University and Research (MURST, projects ex 40% and ex 60%) and by SEERAD through their grant-in-aid to the Macaulay Institute.
REFERENCES
Adams M.A., Attiwell P.M. & Wang-Liang M. (1995) Effects of phosphorus supply on growth and nitrogen fractions in xylem sap and foliage of Eucalyptus regnans (F. Muell.), E. nitens (Maiden) and E. globulus (Labill.) seedlings: implications for herbivory. Trees 9, 324331. Andersen P.C., Brodbeck B.V. & Mizel R.F. III (1995) Diurnal variations in tension, osmolarity and the composition of nitrogen and carbon assimilated in xylem uid of Prunus persica, Vitis
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699
2002 Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Plant, Cell and Environment, 25, 16891699