Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page1of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Contents
Introduction
Definitionsofterms
7
7
9
9 9 10 11 14
15
15 15
16 18
Section3 Principlesofpsychosocialprogramming
Keylearningpoints Childrensrighttolife,survival,anddevelopment(CRCArticle6) Donoharm Nonviolenceinallitsforms Participation Workingwithfamiliesandcommunities Accesstoavailableresourcesandcapacities Contextualapproach Multilayered,integratedpsychosocialsupport Trainingmaterialforthissection
18
19
19 19 19 20 20 21 22 23 24 26
Section4 Implementationstrategies
Keylearningpoints Level1Basicservicesandsecurity Level2Communityandfamilysupports Psychosocialsupportactivitieswithchildren Psychosocialsupportactivitieswithfamiliesandothercaregivers Level3Focusednonspecialisedsupports
27
27 27 28 29 31 32
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page2of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport Contents
Level4Specialisedservices
21 Whatshouldbeavoidedinpsychosocialprogrammesinemergencies
33 34
35
35 35 37 38 38 39 40
Endnotes Furtherreading
44 46
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page3of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport Contents
Trainingmaterialforthismodule
Exercisesandhandoutsarealsolistedattheendofeachsection. Whenreferredtointhetext,exercisesandhandoutsarealwaysfromthelistof trainingmaterialattheendofthesectionwherethereferenceappears,unlessthe referencespecificallypointstoothersections.
9
14 14 14 14 14 14
15
18 18
Section3 Principlesofpsychosocialprogramming
Exercise1 Exercise2 Exercise3 Handout1 Handout2 Handout3 Handout4 Handout5 Psychosocialwellbeing:everybodysresponsibility Psychosocialinterventionpyramid Communityandfamilysupport Scenario Roleplayidentities Scenario TheIASCpsychosocialsupportpyramidmodel Scenario
19
26 26 26 26 26 26 26 26
27 35
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page4of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport Contents
ThismoduleisoneofthefollowingseriesofARCresourcepackmodules. Foundationmodules 1 Understandingchildhoods 2 Childrightsbasedapproaches 3 Programmedesign 4 Participationandinclusion 5 Advocacy 6 Communitymobilisation 7 Psychosocialsupport Criticalissuemodules 1 Abuseandexploitation 2 Education 3 Childrenwithdisabilities 4 Sexualandreproductivehealth 5 Landmineawareness 6 Separatedchildren 7 Childrenassociatedwitharmedforcesorarmedgroups Allmodulesinclude:
ThefollowingdocumentsarealsoincludedintheARCresourcepackCDROMto ensureyoucanmakethemostofthesemodules.
ViviStavrou UNICEF
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page5of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport Contents
TerredesHommes
Coverphotograph UNICEFNYHQ20070797/NicoleToutounji.Barrachit,Lebanon.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page6of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Introduction
Thismoduleprovidespracticalinformation,guidelines,examplesandtoolstosupport organisationsandkeyactorstoundertakepsychosocialsupporttobringaboutpositive changeforchildreninhumanitariancontexts.Usefulguidanceisprovidedtoanalyse whattypeofsupportbestsuitsaparticularcontextaswellasidentifyingtargetsand appropriatemessagesanddevelopingsupportstrategies. Psychosocialsupportinemergencieshasspecificchallengesandrisks,butalsohasthe potentialtodrawattentiontoneglectedemergenciesandmakearealchangeinthe fulfilmentofchildrensrights.Itcanleadtoshorttermchangesbutcanalsoaddress underlyingcauses,makingitanessentialpartofarightsbasedapproach. Thisfoundationmoduleisorganisedintofivesections,followingthelogicthatcouldbe usedinaworkshoptointroducetraineestoarightsbasedapproachtoARC.The materialinthismoduleiscomplementedbymoredetailedapplicationinother methodologyorCriticalissuemodulesandsoaimatestablishingbaseprinciplesand conceptsthroughgenericexercises. Section1Whatispsychosocialsupportandwhyisitimportantin emergencies? Explainstheconceptofpsychosocialsupportandhowitcanincrease theresiliencyofchildrenwhilecreatinganintegrateddevelopmentalapproachto promotingpsychosocialwellbeing. Section2Arightsbasedapproach:principlesandapproaches Illustrateswhy childrightsareessentialtopsychosocialsupportandtheneedtoaddresspsychosocial issuesnotjustonanindividuallevel,butalsoholisticallywithincommunities. Section3Principlesofpsychosocialprogramming Explainswhypsychosocial supportshouldberightsbased,childfriendly,genderandageresponsive,and culturallysensitiveandsustainable,andhowthismaybeaccomplished. Section4Implementationstrategies Outlinesdifferenttypesofsupportthatmay berequiredfollowingemergencies. Section5Monitoringandlearninginpsychosocialprogrammes Tellsofthe importanceofclearandmeasurableobjectivesandindicatorsthatareestablishedat theinitialstagesoftheintervention,aswellasseekingtheparticipationofchildren, familyandcommunitymembersindevelopingsupportprogrammes. Definitionsofterms
Psychosocial referstothecloseconnectionbetweenpsychologicalaspectsofhuman experienceandthewidersocialexperience. Psychosocialsupport isascaleofcareandsupportwhichinfluencesboththe individualandthesocialenvironmentinwhichpeopleliveandrangesfromcareand supportofferedbycaregivers,familymembers,friends,neighbours,teachers,health workers,andcommunitymembersonadailybasisbutalsoextendstocareand supportofferedbyspecialisedpsychologicalandsocialservices.Toreflectthisbroad rangeoftypesofsupport,theInterAgencyStandingCommittee(IASC)Guidelines usethecompositetermMentalHealthandPsychosocialSupport(MHPSS).Thismodule willmakeusofthetermpsychosocial.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page7of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport Introduction
Cognitive pertainstothementalprocessesofperception,memory,judgment,and reasoning. Affective referstoexpressingemotionorfeelingemotional. Socialeffects concernrelationships,familyandcommunitynetworks,cultural traditionsandeconomicstatus,includinglifetaskssuchasschoolorwork. Mainstreaming ensureschildrenspsychosocialwellbeingisapriorityinallaspects ofprogramming,policydevelopmentandorganisationaldevelopment.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page8of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Psychosocialreferstothechildsinnerworldandtherelationshipwithhisorher environment. Psychosocialsupportisimportantinordertomaintainacontinuumoffamilyand communitybasedcareandsupportduringandafterhumanitariancrisesandto preventimmediateorlongtermmentalhealthdisorders. Accesstohumanitarianassistanceandsafetyandsecurityforthepopulationisthe cornerstoneofpsychosocialsupportduringhumanitarianemergencies. Animportantshifthastakenplaceinpsychosocialinterventionsfromanindividualised approachtoacommunitybasedapproachfocusedonenhancingtheresiliencyof childrenandfamilies. Theaimofpsychosocialinterventionsistoaddresschildrensissuesandneedsina holisticmannerandtoplacepsychosocialinterventionsinsidewiderdevelopmental contextssuchaseducationorhealthcare.Thiswillcreateanintegrateddevelopmental approachtopromotingpsychosocialwellbeing. Whatdoespsychosocialmean?andwhatispsychosocialwellbeing? Thetermpsychosocialisusedtoemphasisethecloseconnectionbetween psychologicalaspectsofthehumanexperienceandthewidersocialexperience. Psychologicaleffectsarethosethataffectdifferentlevelsoffunctioningincluding cognitive(perceptionandmemoryasabasisforthoughtsandlearning),affective (emotions),andbehavioural.Socialeffectsconcernrelationships,familyand communitynetworks,culturaltraditionsandeconomicstatus,includinglifetaskssuch 1 asschoolorwork. Theuseofthetermpsychosocialisbasedontheideathatacombinationoffactorsare responsibleforthepsychosocialwellbeingofpeople,andthatthesebiological, emotional,spiritual,cultural,social,mentalandmaterialaspectsofexperiencecannot necessarilybeseparatedfromoneanother.Thetermdirectsattentiontowardsthe totalityofpeoplesexperienceratherthanfocusingexclusivelyonthephysicalor psychologicalaspectsofhealthandwellbeing,andemphasisestheneedtoviewthese issueswithintheinterpersonalcontextsofwiderfamilyandcommunitynetworksin whichtheyarelocated(seediagramDefinitionofpsychosocial). Thesetwoaspectsarecloselyintertwinedinthecontextofcomplexemergencies wherebytheprovisionofpsychosocialsupportispartofthehumanitarianreliefand earlyrecoveryefforts.Oneofthefoundationsofpsychosocialwellbeingisaccessto basicneeds(food,shelter,livelihood,healthcare,educationservices)togetherwitha senseofsecuritythatcomesfromlivinginasafeandsupportiveenvironment.The benefitsofpsychosocialsupportinterventionsshouldresultinapositiveimpacton childrenswellbeing,andaddressthebasicpsychologicalneedsofcompetenceand relatedness.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page9of47
Definitionofpsychosocial
Definitionsofpsychosocialsupportandpsychosocialinterventions Psychosocialsupport:
isabouthelpingchildren,familiesandcommunitiestoimprovetheirpsychosocial 3 wellbeing isaboutencouragingbetterconnectionsbetweenpeople,andbuildingabettersense ofselfandcommunity isexpressedthroughcaringandrespectfulrelationshipsthatcommunicate understanding,toleranceandacceptance isaboutpromotingeverydayconsistentcareandsupportinthefamilyandcommunity. Psychosocialsupportisacontinuumofcareandsupportwhichinfluencesboththe individualandthesocialenvironmentinwhichpeoplelive.Thiscontinuumrangesfrom careandsupportofferedbycaregivers,familymembers,friends,neighbours, teachers,healthworkers,andcommunitymembersonadailybasis,ie.ongoing nurturingrelationshipsthatcommunicateunderstanding,unconditionallove,tolerance andacceptance,andextendstocareandsupportofferedbyspecialisedpsychological andsocialservices.Experiencehasshownthatemergencydriveninterventionsare bestaccomplishedviagroupexperiencesincommunitysettings,wherethemost individualscanbehelpedinthequickestmannerthroughcollectivesupportofthe group.Inthelongertermaftermathofacrisis,inadditiontocontinuedpsychosocial support,asmallminorityofchildrenmayrequireprofessionalpsychological interventions.Thislevelofcareisbeyondthescopeofpsychosocialsupport,although thereisalotofcrossoverwithcommunitybasedmentalhealthcare,especiallywhen familymembersengagewithmentalhealthworkerstoprovidesupport(seediagram TheIASCpsychosocialsupportpyramidmodel). Undernormalconditions,forhealthydevelopment,mostchildrendonotrequire additionalpsychosocialsupportaboveandbeyondthecareandsupportofferedby theirfamiliesandhouseholds.Wherethisfirstcircleofsupportisrupturedorbroken, othercommunitymembersmighthavetostepin.Itiswhereandwhenthissecond circleofsupportisbrokenorrupturedthatexternalagencieshavearoletoplayby 4 offeringprogrammaticpsychosocialsupportorinterventionsaimedat:
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page10of47
strengtheningthecapacityofcaregivers,friends,teacherstoprovideeveryday psychosocialcareandsupporttoallchildren strengtheningthecapacityofspeciallypositionedcommunitymembersand paraprofessionalstoprovidespecialisedpsychosocialsupporttosubgroupsofchildren atriskand/orchildrendirectlyaffectedbyHIVandAIDS,povertyandconflictwho haveexperiencedseverelossesortrauma. Complexemergenciestendtoweakenthetraditionalsocialandsecuritysafetynetsfor children.Organisedcareandsupporthasbeenrelativelyquickinrespondingtothe material,physicalandeducationalneedswhichhavemoretangibleoutputs.However, beyondthis,holisticchilddevelopmentdemandsmore.Thekeyunderlyingideato psychosocialinterventionsaddressingposthumanitarianemergencyrecoveryis thatparticipationinsuchactivitiesassistschildrenandtheirfamilieswhohave experiencedseverestresstorestoretheirsocialandpsychologicalhealthandprevent morelongtermsocialandmentalhealthproblems.Theprimaryfocusofsuch psychosocialinterventionsisonsupportingthenaturalhealingandrecoveryprocess byrestoringasquicklyaspossibleresilienceinthefaceofchallengingcircumstances 5 andthestabilityofanentireaffectedcommunity. Whypsychosocialsupportisimportant Experiencingdifficultordisturbingeventscansignificantlyimpactthesocialand emotionalwellbeingofachild.Exposuretoviolenceordisaster,lossof,orseparation fromfamilymembersandfriends,deteriorationinlivingconditionsandlackofaccess toservicescanallhaveimmediate,aswellaslongtermconsequencesforchildren, familiesandcommunitiesbalance,developmentandfulfilment. Recentyearshaveseenadramaticgrowthinprogrammesdesignedtoprovide psychologicalandcommunitybasedsupporttochildrenandfamiliesrecoveringfrom distressingevents.Throughoutthe80sand90smanyagenciesappliedwestern, individualisedapproachestocounsellingandtherapytoculturesinwhichtheydonot readilyapply.Anumberofstudieshaveshownthattheconsequencescanbenotonly wastefulbutalsopotentiallydamagingtochildrenastheymaynotrecogniseand valuewhatalreadyexistswithintheculture,withinfamiliesandwithineachchild, potentiallyunderminingexistingpracticesandtraditionswhichmaybeofgreat importanceinfacilitatingchildrensrecovery. Thetermpsychosocialinterventionaroseintheearly1990sasareactionagainstthe overlymedicalandoftendecontextualisedposttraumaticstressdisorder(PTSD) modelofresponsetochildrenaffectedbyconflict.Thepsychosocialapproachshiftsthe emphasisfromchildrensvulnerabilitiestoaviewofchildrenasactiveagentsinthe faceofadversityandadoptsamodelofservicedeliverywhichrecognisesand 6 strengthensresilienceandlocalcapacities. Thisresiliencebuildingapproachto psychosocialwellbeingandchildprotectionwasdevelopedinanattempttoadvancea moresustainableandholisticapproachtoworkingwithchildrenaffectedbyconflict, HIVandAIDS,naturaldisastersandotherverydifficultanddangeroussituations. Psychosocialinterventionsdonotarisefromaninitialpremiseofneed,illnessor deficiencyofindividualchildren,butbuilduponachildsnaturalresilienceandfamily andcommunitysupportmechanisms,examinepossibleriskandprotectivefactorsand attempttoprovideadditionalexperiencesthatwillpromotecopingandpositive
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page11of47
Psychosocialdomains
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page12of47
Psychosocialindicatorsfromaparticipatoryevaluationstudyofsports,play andstructuredrecreationactivitiesdoneincampsforinternallydisplaced people,northernUganda Thequalitativeresultsindicatethatalthoughthereviewcannotclaimadirectcausal relationshipbetweentheperceivedchangesandthesportsanddevelopment,right toplayprogrammes,theoverallbenefitsindicateapositiveimpactonchildrens wellbeingandaddressthebasicpsychologicalneedsofcompetenceandrelatedness. Emotionalwellbeing Themostcommonlycitedchangeinthisdomainbythechildrenwasanincreased senseofsecurityandconfidenceasindicatedbyreachingoutandmaking friends,oratleastparticipatinginsocialactivities(prosocialbehaviour).Thisis anespeciallyimportantstepforformerlyabductedchildren. Themostcommonlycitedchangeinthisdomainbytheadultswasincreasedself controlandprosocialbehaviour(reducedaggression,reducedratesofconflict andfightingamongstthechildrenandincreasedcooperation).Citedinfluences beingpositivepeerpressure,principlesoffairplay,positivecoachingand facilitationexperiences,improvedselfcontrolandproblemsolvingfrom participationinregular,organisedactivity. Parentsreportthattheirchildrensandtheirownparticipationintheactivitieshas broughtaboutachangeinthemasparents,resultinginagreaterawarenessof thespecificneedsofdifferentagegroups(unlikeinthepastwhenparentsjust didwhatevertheylikedfortheirchildren)agreaterawarenessoftheirown childrensindividualstrengthsandneeds,andmoreintergenerationaldialogue. Thehappierthechildren,thehappierandmoreproudweare.Alsoacquisitionof skillsandknowledgeareanotherpositivesideeffect. Socialwellbeing Themainchangehereisrelatedtotheimprovedabilitytoassumesocially appropriateroles,whichappearstobelinkedtoagreatersenseofthechild beingappreciatedbythefamilyandbelongingtotheircommunity.Thechilds participationintheresumptionofculturalactivitiesandtraditionsisakey indicatorinthisdomain. Bothadultsandchildrenplacedthegreatestvalueonsocialskill,socialresponsibility andsocialconformityasevidencedbypositivesocialfunctioningbehaviour. Socialcompetenceisprimarilyindicatedthroughimprovedgoodvaluesasshown bythewillingandrespectfulparticipationinappropriatehousehold responsibilities,livelihoodsupportandfilialobligations.Fulfillingchildrelated developmentaltasks,suchasschoolworkandplay,issecondarytotraditional obligationsandtasksthatsupportfamilycohesionandsurvival.Contributingto thefamilyandlivinguptofamilyexpectationsaremajorindicatorstofamily membersthattheyouthisdoingwell.Similarfindingsfromresearchdonein northernUgandashowsthatfamilyconnectednessandsocialsupportappearto bethemainprotectivefactorsforthepsychosocialwellbeingofchildren. Thereis,however,lessevidenceonthebenefitsrelatedtogreaterandsustained socialinclusion,ofimprovednetworkingandsocialcohesionbetweenthe
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page13of47
participatingchildrenandchildrenoutsideoftheproject. Skillsandknowledge Themainchangesinthisdomainarerelatedtotheacquisitionofskillsand knowledgerelatedtoprojectactivitieslikefootballandnetball,dances,games, playingmusicandsongs,drama,debates,discussionsandtrainingsrelatedto childrights,healthinformation,safebehaviour,sessionsonthequalitiesof friendlybehaviour,conflictresolution,peaceandforgiveness. Thereappearstobeaboostingofchildrenscognitivedevelopmentrelatedto learningandcreativity. Parentsreportanincreaseintheirchildrensknowledgeasevidencedbythechildren returningandinformingthefamilymembersofhealth,hygieneandchildrights messagesteachingsiblingsandneighbouringchildrenthegamestheylearnt participatingintheprogramme. Parents,teachers,coachesandfacilitatorsreportthatchildrenwhogothroughthe structuredgrouporsportsprogrammesbecomemorecreativeandexploremore. Teachersreportthattheparticipatingchildrendrawmorepicturesandtheir drawingsaremoreskilledthanbefore.Theparticipatingchildrenplaymore,and theyplaybetterorganisedgamesintheplayground.Theyhaveintroducednew activitiesanddomoreactivitiesthantheotherchildren. Physicalwellbeing Therelevanceofphysicalhealthandwellbeingtothechildrenisanimportant indicatoroftheiroverallwellbeing.Thechildrenemphasisetheimportanceof physicalhealthandcleanlinesstotheirphysicalandpsychologicalwellbeingmore thantheadultsdo.Beinghealthy,cleanandstrongandhavingenoughfoodto eatisoneofthemainthingsthatmakethechildrenfeelhappyandproud. StayingaliveisahugeachievementintheIDPcampsofnorthernUganda.The abilitytokeepthemselvesclean,wellgroomedandhealthyisasignofself efficacyaswellasindicatingeconomicsecurityandfamilyconcern.Being hungry,gettingsickand/orlosingtheirparentsfromillnessisoneofthemost commonlycitedworriesandfearsthatthechildrenreport. ReviewofUNICEFsupportedRighttoplayinterventionsinrespondingtothe psychosocialneedsofchildrenaffectedbyconflictinnorthernandeasternUganda StavrouV,UNICEF,UgandaSeptember2007
Trainingmaterialforthissection Exercise1 Exercise2 Handout1 Handout2 Handout3 Handout4 Effectsoffrighteningexperiencesandseparation Theimportanceofsocioculturalunderstanding Casestudy Reactionsandfactorsalteringoutcomes Scenario Socioculturalnorms
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page14of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Section2 Arightsbasedapproach:principlesandapproaches
Keylearningpoints
Guidingprincipleswhenprovidingpsychosocialsupporthelptoreducetheriskofharm andpromotecommunitybasedintervention. Psychosocialsupportandchildrights Psychosocialsupportanddevelopmentprogrammesareacriticalelementinthe protectionofchildrensrights.TheinterventionsshouldbebasedupontheUN Conventionontherightsofthechild(CRC),ensuringthatallgroupsaregiventhe opportunitytoparticipateandallinterventionsareculturallyrelevant.Inlinewiththe CRC,childrenshouldhaveanactiveroleindesigningandimplementingprogrammes. BelowaresomeoftherelevantstandardsfromtheCRCthatapplytopsychosocial supportandchildren'srighttoit.
1 Article29.1.a Psychosocialsupportcanprovidetheopportunityforchildrento bedevelopedtotheirfullestpotential. 2 Article5andArticles12to17 Psychosocialsupportempowerschildrenand youthbyprovidingopportunitiestoparticipateinsociallife,beselfreliant,develop selfconfidenceandempowermentwithdueregardtothematurityandevolving capacityofthechild,andrespectingtherightsandresponsibilitiesofadults. 3 Article2 Psychosocialsupportcombatsdiscriminationbyfacilitatingthe integrationofgroupssufferingfromdiscrimination,suchasgirls,childrenbelonging tominoritygroups,childrenlivinginpovertyandchildrenwithdisabilities. 4 Articles20,22,23and31 Psychosocialsupportadvocatesforandprovidesan opportunityforallgroupsofchildreninneedofspecialprotection tobeprovidedequalaccesstodifferenttypesofsupport(includingeducation,social protection,sports,play,music,danceanddrama),suchaschildrenwithdisabilities, childrenlivinginsocialandotherinstitutions,childrenlivingindetentioncentres,child refugees,childreninrehabilitativecareandworkingchildren. 5 Articles19and29 Psychosocialsupportpromotesnonviolence byprovidingopportunitiesforsocialintegration,encouragingfairplayandchannelling energyawayfrompotentialdestructivebehaviour.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page15of47
6 Article39 Psychosocialsupportisarehabilitationandreintegrationtoolto supportthephysicalandpsychologicalrehabilitationandsocialreintegrationof childrenandfamiliesimpacteduponbyconflictandotherhumanitarianemergencies. Thechilddevelopmentandthechildrightsapproachestochildrenaffectedby humanitarianemergencies Thetwodominantapproachestounderstandingthesituationofchildreninemergency situationsandprovidingassistancetothemhavebeenorientedaroundchild developmentandchildrights.Thesetwoapproachescomplementeachotherevenas 9 theyplacedifferentemphasisonvariousaspectsofchildrenssituations.
Thechilddevelopmentapproach Ageandstagerelateddevelopmentalneeds, vulnerabilities,andcapacitiesthatmustbe addressedforhealthyandholistic developmentinchildren. Aimistominimiserisksandpreventfurther harmwhilereinforcingprotectivefactorsthat facilitatechildrensphysicalandpsychosocial wellbeing. Culturalinfluencesandcontextualfactors suchaspatternsofsocialisation,education, andcarecanhaveaprofoundinfluenceona childsdevelopingattitudes,values,and beliefs,andshouldbeconsideredwhen adoptingadevelopmentalapproach. Participatinginculturalandsocialactivitiesis alsoadevelopmentalneedofchildren,and thewayinwhichthishappenswillbediverse. Themainaimistoallowchildrentoreach theirfullestpotentialinaholisticmanner. Bothchilddevelopmentandchildrightsapproachesplaceprimaryimportanceonthe protectionofchildrenfromviolations,maltreatment,injury,andexploitation.Bothapproaches alsoemphasisetheprovisionofservicestochildren,forinstancetherighttofoodand healthcare,therighttoeducation,andtherighttoenjoysecurity.Therightsapproachplaces additionalimportanceontherighttoparticipation. Therightsbasedapproach Childrenhavenotonlyneeds,butalsothe righttohavetheseneedsmet,aswellas otherrightssuchassurvivalrights,protection rights,andparticipationrights. TheCRC,whichwaslaunchedin1989and widelyratifiedbygovernmentsaroundthe world,andtheAfricancharterontherights andwelfareofthechild(1990),set internationalnormsfortherecognitionand observanceofchildrensrights. ThethreekeyprinciplesoftheCRCare: thebestinterestsofthechildmustbe observed nondiscriminationistoassurethatall childrenhavetherighttobetreated equally childrenmusthavetherighttoparticipation
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page16of47
Interventionsandprojectsaredesignedusingaparticipatoryframework.Thisincludes usingparticipatoryactionresearch,collectingsystematicinformationthatisthenused toconstructevidencedriveninterventions. Takinganecologicalapproachthatidentifiestheproblematthedifferentindividual, familyandcommunitylevels.Thuscollectingsystemicinformationnecessarytoguide theinterventionatmultiplelevels,andattemptingaholisticresponsetothesituation. Identifyingtheexistingknowledgeandskillsoftheparticipants,drawinglessonsfrom theirresilienceandcopingstrategiesandseekingtoidentifybarriersthathamper accesstosupportandservices,andtoaddressthegapsthatexistregardingsupport andserviceprovision. Informationissoughtfrom,andassistanceprovidedimpartiallyto,allparticipants regardlessofpoliticalorsocialaffiliationorlocation. Participatingpartnersareaccountabletotheparticipantsandbeneficiariesandensure fulltransparencyduringtheplanning,implementationandmonitoringofprojectsand anysubsequentfollowup. Mechanismstoadvocateforchildrensrightsneedtobeincludedinthedesignand followupplans. Interventionsarehighlysupportiveandconstructedinamannerthatprotectsallthe participants.Thisiscriticalsincetheresearchandinterventionprocessitselfcan increasevulnerability.Informedconsentneedstobesoughtfromallparticipants. Likewise,humanitarianstaffneedstobemonitoredonaregularbasis,ensuringthat ethicalissuesarerespectedandethicalnormsappropriatelyapplied. Inaddition,workingwithchildrenandfamiliesinemergencycontextscanbe dangerousandextremelystressfulforprojectworkers,andincludesthepossibilityof vicarioustraumatisation.Supportanddebriefingneedstobemadeavailabletostaff workinginthesesituations. Emergencyrightsbasedpsychosocialsupportprogramming:
Guidingprinciplesoftherightsbasedapproachwithinthecontextofpsychosocial supportforprogramminginhumanitarianemergenciesareincludedinSection3.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page17of47
Sportfordevelopmentandpeace TheUNHCRhaslongusedsportinitsprogrammestofosterrefugeereintegration. In2005,UNHCRexpandeditsactivities,developingmorepartnershipswithsports orienteddonorstoenableittoexpanditssportsprogrammesfurther.UNHCRhas foundthatsportsprogrammesinrefugeecampsprovideaneffectivetoolfor empoweringgirls,giventhattheyareoftenexcludedfromparticipatingand enjoyingthephysicalandpsychosocialbenefitsofferedbysport.Bydirectly challenginganddispellingmisperceptionsaboutwomenscapabilities,integrated sportsprogrammeshelptoreducediscriminationandwidentherolesprescribedto womenandgirls. Playingforpeace Intimesofconflict,postconflictandemergencies,sport,recreationandplaycan providechildrenandadolescentswithasenseofhopeandnormalcy.Theyhelp traumatisedchildrenlearntointegratetheexperienceofpain,fearandloss.They helphealemotionalscars,creatingasafeenvironmentthatenableschildrenand adolescentstoexpresstheirfeelingsandbuildtheirselfesteem,selfconfidenceand trust.Sport,especiallyparticipatinginateamoraclub,canprovide[children formerlyassociatedwitharmedforcesorarmedgroups]acriticalsenseof belonging,necessaryfortheirreintegrationintothecommunity.Childrenwhoplay sportsseethatinteractionispossiblewithoutcoercionorexploitation.Players cooperatewithinaframeworkofrulesarefereeadjudicatesonthejustnessof activityduringagame.Penaltiesexisttosanctiontransgressionsandenable reconciliationbetweensportingadversaries. Sportfordevelopmentandpeace:towardsachievingthemillenniumdevelopment goalsUnitedNationsInteragencyTaskForce,2003
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page18of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Section3 Principlesofpsychosocialprogramming
Keylearningpoints
Differentbutcomplementaryinterventionsarerequiredinemergencies. Accesstobasicservicesandsecurityisthefirststeptoensurethepsychosocial wellbeingofchildren. Promotingcommunitybasedpsychosocialinterventionshelpsamajorityofchildren willbeabletoregainasenseofnormalcyfollowinganemergency. Asmallergroupofchildren,suchasthoseatriskorvictimsofexploitationandabuse, willbenefitfromfocused,nonspecialisedsupportbysocialworkersorpsychologists. PsychosocialprogrammesandinterventionsshouldbebasedontheCRCandpromote thefollowingprinciplesandvalues. Childrensrighttolife,survival,anddevelopment(CRCArticle6) Theoverallobjectiveofpsychosocialinterventionsistoreestablishastateof wellbeingthatisnecessaryforandpromotesthehealthydevelopmentofthechild. Thisalsomeansthatwherechildrenfacelifethreateningsituations,psychosocial interventionsshouldconsiderwhatpracticalstepscanbetakentoprotectchildren fromfurtherharmandexposuretoviolence. Donoharm Workonpsychosocialsupporthasthepotentialtocauseharmbecauseitdealswith highlysensitiveissues.Humanitarianactorsmayreducetheriskofharminvarious ways.
Informedconsent Priortoundertakingpsychosocialinterventions,consentshould beobtainedfromchildrenandtheirfamilywithfullknowledgeofwhatwillhappenand theprobableeffectsonthechild. Confidentiality Psychosocialassessmentsandinterventionsshouldrespect confidentiality,includingwhentheinterventionsareundertakeningroups psychosocialinstitutionsshouldprotectthisconfidentialityandensureanonymitywhen communicatingabouttheirinterventions. Honestyandobjectivity Psychosocialworkersmustnotmisleadthebeneficiaries, andmusttellthemthetruthinanageappropriatemannerandtothedegreetowhich itcontributestotheirlongtermdevelopment.Institutionsandindividualsshouldalso behonestandrecognisetheirownlimitsandbeabletorefercasesbeyondtheirarea ofcompetency. Responsibility Intervenersmusttakeresponsibilityfortheimpactoftheir interventions.Thismeanstheymustmakeanaccurateassessmentoftheriskinvolved andchoosetheappropriatemethodologyforoptimumbenefitsandminimalrisksfor thebeneficiaries.Theyareresponsibleforcloselymonitoringtheimplementationand impactoftheintervention.Tothedegreethatisfeasible,theyarealsoresponsiblefor providingassistance,includingfollowuporreferral,foranybeneficiarieswhocannot beadequatelyassistedthroughtheintervention.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page19of47
Participatingincoordinationgroupstolearnfromothersandtominimise duplicationandgapsinresponse(seemultilayeredsupportbelow). Designinginterventionsonthebasisofsufficientinformation(seeContextual approachbelow). Committingtoevaluation,opennesstoscrutinyandexternalreview. Developingculturalsensitivityandcompetenceintheareasinwhichtheyintervene andwork. Developinganunderstandingof,andconsistentlyreflectingupon,universalhuman rights,powerrelationsbetweenoutsidersandemergencyaffectedpeople,andthe valueofparticipatoryapproaches.
Nonviolenceinallitsforms Childrenshouldbeprotectedfromallformsofviolencebytheirfamilyandcommunity, includingpoliticalviolence,violenceatschool,familyviolence,violenceamongpeers, andrepresentationsofviolence,includinginthemedia.Psychosocialinterventions shouldbefreefromallformsofviolenceagainstorinthepresenceofchildren.Where itisabsolutelynecessarytoencourageorallowthechildtoexpresshisorher experienceofviolenceaspartofahealingprocess,thisshouldbedoneusingthe safestformofexpression,forexample,drawingratherthanacting,andshouldhappen inaconfidential,supportivesettinginvolvingonlythosewhodirectlyexperiencedthe violence.Itshouldoccurassoonaspossibleaftertheoccurrenceoftheeventaspart ofacontinuumofinterventionsthathelpthechildtodeveloppositiveandconstructive behaviour. Participation InlinewiththeCRC,childrenshouldhaveanactiveroleinthedesignand implementationofprogrammes.Achildhastherighttofreelyexpressanopinionin allmattersaffectingherorhimandtohavethatopiniontakenintoaccount.Every childhaspersonalandsocialresourceswhichheorsheemploysatdifferentmoments inhisorherlife.Interventionsfocusontheidentificationofinternalandexternal resourcesinorderforthechildtodevelopprotectionmechanismsforherorhisown wellbeing.Psychosocialinterventionsworktoenablechildrentobecomeactiveagents inbuildingcommunitiesandplanningtheirfutures. Respectfortheviewsofthechild Psychosocialinterventionsmustensurethatchildrensviewsareacknowledgedand respectedsothattheyparticipateintheirownhealinganddevelopment,andsothat theirdignityispreserved. Bestinterestsofthechild Inalldecisionsaffectingthepsychologicalandsocialwellbeingofthechild,primary considerationshouldbegiventothechildshealthydevelopment.Eachchildsviews aretheirreality,andthismustbeweighedagainstthebestinterestsofthechildwhen anydecisionsaretaken.Psychosocialprogrammesandtheiroutcomesshouldnotbe usedforanypurposeotherthanthepsychosocialdevelopmentofchildren,in particular,suchactivitiesshouldnotbeusedforpolitical,media,economicorsocial gainfortheimplementingorganisationorindividual.Thelongtermdevelopmentof thechildandtheindirectconsequencesofanyshortterminterventionshouldbetaken intoaccountwhenimplementingprogrammes.Shortterminterventionsthat
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page20of47
underminethetrustbetweenthechildrenandtheircaregiversorthatmakechildren moreawareoftheirproblemswithouthelpingthemtofindsolutionsforthese problemscanbeharmfulforthechildren. Nondiscriminationofanykind Includingonthebasisofsex,age,religion,socioeconomicstatus,ethnicity,and disabilitystatus,particularlyregardingavailabilityandappropriatenessofservices. Psychosocialworkersshouldalsominimisethepositiveornegativestereotypingof childrenwhohaveexperiencedpsychologicalorsocialdistressorbeenexposedtoor involvedinviolence. Usingagendersensitiveapproach Takesintoaccountthesituation,dynamicsandneedsofeachmemberofthe community,women,men,girlsandboys,inordertobetterachieveprogramme objectivesintheinitialstageofselectingtargetgroupsandthemostappropriateway toinfluencechange. Inclusionofadolescents Adolescentsareusuallyoverlookedinprogramming,asresourcesaredirectedtowards 13 youngerchildrenwhoareperhapsperceivedasmoreworthyrecipientsofaid. Not onlyaretheneedsofadolescentsoverlooked,buttheirstrengthsandtheirpotentialas constructivecontributorstosocietiesalsoremainunrecognised.Adolescentsare affectedbyarmedconflictinparticularwaysthatexposethemtoincreasedriskssuch asrecruitmentintoarmedgroups,sexualabuse,thecontractionofsexually transmitteddiseases,andeconomicexploitation.Theymayassumeadult responsibilitiessuchasheadinghouseholds,yetarefrequentlynotaccordeddecision makingpowersincommunities.Adolescentsmaythusbefacedwithparticular problemsandmayhavespecificpsychosocialissuesthattheywanttoaddress.Ina 14 participatoryresearchstudywithyoungpeopleinKosovo, adolescentsidentified psychosocialproblemsastheirsecondmostimportantconcern,supersededonlyby securityconcerns.Thelossoffamilyandfriendsanduncertainlyaboutthefutureand feelingsofhopelessnesswerementionedasissueswithwhichtheyneededhelp. Workingwithfamiliesandcommunities Thepsychosocialwellbeingofadults,particularlyparentsandcaregivershasadirect impactonthatofchildren,andshouldthusbeaddressedthroughconcurrentparent focusedinterventions.Psychosocialinterventionsshouldbedirectedatenabling connectednesstoanadultinthechildslifeandsocialinclusionintothelarger communitynetwork,psychosocialinterventionsneedtomaintainafocuson strengtheningcommunities,familiesandothersocialinstitutionsasresponsiveand protectivespacesforchildren. Inaddition,therightsbasedapproachdemandsthatpsychosocialworkersdevelopan understandingof,andconsistentlyreflectupon,universalhumanrights,power relationsbetweenoutsidersandemergencyaffectedpeople,andthevalueof participatoryapproaches.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page21of47
AnapproachrootedinthecultureofrefugeesfromsouthSudan InaremotepartofnorthernKenyaisalargerefugeecampinwhichthereisan extraordinarilylargeconcentrationofunaccompaniedchildren,mainlyboys. TheexactcircumstancesoftheirflightfromSudanandtheirseparationfromtheir familiesarenotentirelyclear.Whatisclearisthatintheprocessofflight,initially intoEthiopia,andlaterbecauseofthreatstotheirsafetythere,thelongwalk throughsouthSudanandintoKenyawasfraughtwithdangers,fromsoldiers,from wildanimalsandfromthethreatofstarvation,dehydrationanddisease.Ifany groupofrefugeechildrenwouldbeexpectedtobedeeplyaffectedbytheir experiencesofwar,separation,multipledisplacementandhardship,itwouldbethis group. Fromthebeginning,SavetheChildrenSwedensawtheneedtoconstructa compositeprogrammebasedcarefullyandsensitivelyaroundtheculturaltraditions andpracticesoftherefugees.Carearrangementswerebasedonthetraditionof grouplivingincattlecampsandtheacceptabilityofcareprovidedbyunrelated families.Arangeofactivitiesfacilitatedthechildren'srecoveryfromtraumatic experiencesinawaywhichrespectedcultureandtraditiontheseincluded storytelling,composingpoems,recountinganddiscussingdreams,traditional singinganddancingandanartformbasedonthetraditionalimportanceofknowing thecoloursofeachboysbull.Theinvolvementofthewholecommunitywas significantinemphasisingtheimportanceofcollectivelycopingwithshared experiences.Despitetherepeatedexperiencesofdanger,fearandflight,andthe factofseparationfromtheirfamilies,thepsychosocialhealthofthesechildren remainedremarkablygood:onlyatinypercentagewerefunctionallyimpaired,as evidencedbytheirbehaviourpatterns,thequalityofinterpersonalrelationships andtheirperformanceinschool.Aninvestigationoftheirpsychologicalhealth revealedremarkablyfewchildrenreportingsymptomsofstressanditwasclear that,ingeneral,thesechildrenwerecopingremarkablywell. Workingwithchildrenmodule,ARCtrainingpackage2002
Accesstoavailableresourcesandcapacities Buildingonavailableresourcesandcapacities Allaffectedgroupshaveassetsorresourcesthatsupporttheirmentalhealthand psychosocialwellbeing.Akeyprinciple,evenintheearlystagesofanemergency,is buildinglocalcapacities,supportingselfhelpandstrengtheningtheresourcesalready present.Externallydrivenandimplementedprogrammesoftenleadtoinappropriate mentalhealthandpsychosocialsupportandfrequentlyhavelimitedsustainability. Wherepossible,itisimportanttobuildbothgovernmentandcivilsocietycapacities. Universalaccesstoessentialservicesforchildren Therightsbasedapproachispredicatedonthecentralprincipleofidentifyingbarriers toaccessingresources,andadvocatingforuniversalaccesstoessentialservicesand Stateprotectionforchildren.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page22of47
Intermsofpsychosocialprogramming,achievementinthepsychosocialdomains outlinedaboveistargetedonthebasisthatthiswillsupportlongertermimpacts onthelivesofchildren.Itisclearthattheresponsesareframedbytheprevailing culturalpracticesandtoalesserextentthesocioeconomicconditions,andthusthe identificationofoutcomesandindicatorsneedstobemadewithinthiscontext. Anapproachthatonlyemphasisesindividualbehaviourslikeincreasedself esteemascriticalindicatorsofimprovedpsychosocialwellbeing,neglectingmore prosocialbehaviourslikeachangeintheperformanceofdailytasks,changeinthe proportionofthetargetgroupshowinglocallydefinedprosocialbehaviours,orthe resumptionofculturalactivitiesandtraditions,willresultinunattainableoutcomes anddiscriminateagainstchildrenandtheirfamilies. Definingspecificoutcomesandindicatorsthatarerelevanttothechildrensand theircaregiverslivesinalocalcontext,andassessingsuchimpactsisacrucialtask inthepsychosocialfieldbecausetheevidencebaseforthelongertermvalueof suchprogrammingiscurrentlyweak.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page23of47
Inemergencies,peopleareaffectedindifferentwaysandrequiredifferentkindsof support.Akeytoorganisingpsychosocialsupportistodevelopalayeredsystemof complementarysupportthatmeetstheneedsofdifferentgroups.Itiscriticalthat duringandafteranemergency,plannersandprovidersofpsychosocialinterventions participateincoordinationgroupstolearnfromothersandtominimiseduplicationand gapsinresponse.Thisgoessomewaytoensuringthatinterventionsaredesignedon thebasisofsufficientinformation,andcommittingtoevaluation,opennesstoscrutiny andexternalreview.TheIASCpyramid(seefollowingdiagram)demonstratesthat psychosocialsupportcanbeprovidedinmanydifferentforms,andwhiletimingand contextiscritical,onelayerisnotmeanttobeprioritisedoveranotheralllayersof thepyramidareimportantandshouldideallybeimplementedconcurrently. Ifpsychosocialinterventionsremainstandalone,withoutlinkstofamilyand communityinteractions,andtootherprogrammaticareas,theyhavelimitedpotential toeffectivelycontributetothepsychosocialwellbeingoftheindividualandthegroup. Forexample,manyinterventionsthatarenotplannedorconceivedaspsychosocial interventionshavebeenrecognisedashavingsignificantpsychosocialimpact,like welfaregrantsandnutritionalsupport,theprovisionoffoodandwaterandthe constructionofshelter.Byremovingothersignificantstressors,likehunger,general wellbeing,includingpsychosocialwellbeing,islikelytoimprove.Whatisalsoimportant ishowthenutritionalsupportisofferedandthatpsychosocialissuesarenotignored. AsseenintheIASCpyramidofmultilayeredpsychosocialsupport,psychosocial interventionsmakeuponlyasmallpercentageofwhatconstitutespsychosocial support.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page24of47
TheIASCpsychosocialsupportpyramidmodel
Descriptionofsupport 1 Advocacyforpyschosocialsupportandaccesstobasicservices (food,shelter,water,hygiene,functioninggovernance systems,healthcare)intowhichpsychosocialsupportneedsto bemainstreamed,andtheassuranceofsecurityinorderto reestablishwellbeingandmitigatefurtherpsychosocialharm. Aimtoreachmanychildrenandsupportwaysofcoping. 2 Careandsupportprovidedbycaregivers,friendsand communitymembers.Childrenwhohaveexperiencedtheloss offamilyandcommunitylevelsupports,throughdeath, separationandlossoflivelihoodopportunitieswillrequire specificsupporttorestoretheprotectivefactorsthatthese systemsprovideeg.familyreunion,healingritualsfor reconciliation,vocationaltraining. 3 Asmallerpercentageofthepopulation,withparticularly stressfulreactions,willrequiremorefocusedandspecialised supportinterventionswithattentiontotheindividual,familyor group(eg.psychosocialfirstaidbyhealthworkers). 4 Childrenexperiencingsignificantdistressthatdisruptstheir abilitytofunctiononadaytodaybasiswillrequirespecialised mentalhealthandpsychosocialsupport(tobeprovidedby trainedprofessionalsincludingspecialisedtraditionalhealers).
Childprotectionofficersor socialworkers
Psychologist
Psychiatristormental healthspecialist
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page25of47
IntheIASCpyramid,achildwithinacommunitywhohasrecentlylostbothparents and/orhasexperiencedviolenceortraumamightthen:
benefitfromindividualcounsellingwithasocialworkerorpsychologist(mentalhealth interventionofferedtoaverysmallpercentageofthechildreninthecommunity) laterjoinasmallgroupofotherdirectlyaffectedchildrenwithinagroupstructured approachinterventiondesignedtoprovideopportunitiesforgrievingandnormalisation (specialisedpsychosocialsupport)offeredtoasmallpercentageofthechildreninthe community makeaherobookwithalltheotherchildreninhisorherclassorschool,and/or participatewithasignificantnumberofotherchildreninthecommunityaspartofa youthorganisation(everydaypsychosocialcareandsupport) Psychosocialprogrammingexistsgenerallywithintherealmofeveryday psychosocialcareandsupport,andtoalesserextenttherealmofspecialised psychosocialsupport. Trainingmaterialforthissection Exercise1 Exercise2 Exercise3 Handout1 Handout2 Handout3 Handout4 Handout5 Psychosocialwellbeing:everybodysresponsibility Psychosocialinterventionpyramid Communityandfamilysupport Scenario Roleplayidentities Scenario TheIASCpsychosocialsupportpyramidmodel Scenario
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page26of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Section4 Implementationstrategies
Keylearningpoints
Theimmediatereestablishmentofsecurity,adequategovernanceandservicesis crucialinanyemergencysituationinordertohelpprotectthewellbeingofchildren. Oneofthemostimportantaspectsinpromotingpsychosocialwellbeingistofacilitate conditionsforcommunitymobilisation,ownershipandcontroloftheemergency response. Childrenwhoarestrugglingtocopewithintheirexistingcarenetwork,whoarenot progressingintermsoftheirdevelopment,orareunabletofunctionaswellastheir peersmayrequireactivitieswhichaddresstheirpsychosocialneedsmoredirectlyand areimplementedbyspecialisedstaff. Level1Basicservicesandsecurity
19 Ineachemergency thewellbeingofallpeopleshouldbeprotectedthroughthe reestablishmentofsecurity,adequategovernanceandservicesthataddressbasic physicalneeds(food,shelter,water,basichealthcare,controlofcommunicable disease)soitisimportanttoidentifywhichaspectsoftheenvironmentarehavingthe greatestimpactonthepsychosocialwellbeingofchildrenaslackingofbasicservices thisshouldhavebeendoneaspartoftheinitialassessmentandtheongoing programmeimplementationandmonitoringthroughdialoguewiththeaffected population(Foundationmodule3Programmedesign).Belowarelistedavarietyof issuesthathavebeenfoundtohaveacrucialimpactonpsychosocialwellbeingof childreninvarioussituationsanduponwhichapsychosocialprogrammemaychoose toconductadvocacy.Giventhatsomeoftheseactivitiesrequirespecialised knowledge,normallyaspecialisedsectorororganisationwillberesponsiblefor implementingprogrammestoaddresstheseissues.
Establishmentofsecuritymeasures. Protectionofchildren(andtheircaregivers)fromviolence,abuseandexploitation. Accesstobasicneeds:shelter,food,healthcare,waterandsanitation. Accesstoanyspecialservicesparticularlythoseneededbyatriskchildren. Promotionoffamilyunity(seeCriticalissuemodule6Separatedchildren)through preventionofseparation,immediateidentificationofseparatedchildren,and appropriatecareandprotectionforseparatedchildren. Promotionofthecontinuationofbreastfeeding. Promotionoffamilyselfsufficiencythroughincomegenerationandaccesstoeconomic supportactivities. Reestablishingformalandinformaleducationopportunitiesforallchildren. Disseminatingessentialinformationofexistingservices.Suchinformationcanreach childrenatchildfriendlyspaces,clinics,feedingcentres,distributionsites,water collectionpoints.Otherwaysofdisseminatinginformationincludeannouncements,
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page27of47
meetings,posters,homevisits,largeandsmallgroupdiscussions,communityradios, localnewspapers.
Theneedforculturalsensitivityinprogramming InAlbania,followingtheexodusofhundredsofthousandsofKosovarsinApril1999 intorefugeecamps,manyorganisationsgavefoodtoKosovars.Inonecamp,the elderssaidtheyfeltdemeanedbybeingfedAlbanianfoodandtreatedasiftheir ownculturedidnotmatter.Thefoodhandoutswereunintentionallyhavinga negativeimpact.TheywantedtoeatKosovarfood,notAlbanianfood.Accordingly, theygavenongovernmentalorganisationsalistoftheingredientstheywanted. Havingtakenoverabuildingforakitchen,theybegancookingandservingtheir ownmealsandworking12hourseachday.Youthinthecamphelpedtoorganise peopleinshiftsinordertoavoidlonglines.Boththecooksandtherecipients reportedthattheyfeltmuchbetteraboutthefood,feltmoreincontrolovertheir circumstances,andexperiencedprideinwhattheyhadaccomplished.Throughtheir demandformorecontrolovertheircircumstances,whathadbeenastraightforward fooddistributionprojectintegratedapsychosocialcomponenttoaddresssocialand emotionalwellbeing. Childrenincrisis,goodpracticesinevaluatingpsychosocialprogramming DuncanJ,Ph.D.andArntsonL,Ph.D.MPH,fortheInternationalPsychosocial EvaluationCommitteeandSavetheChildrenFederation,Inc.withsupportfromthe AndrewW.MellonFoundation
Level2Communityandfamilysupports Oneofthemostimportantaspectsinpromotingpsychosocialwellbeingistofacilitate conditionsforcommunitymobilisation,ownershipandcontroloftheemergency response.Oftenafteradisaster,socialstructuresaredisruptedpeopleareunder extremestressandneedtomeetbasicneedssuchasshelter,foodandhealthcare. Communitymobilisationisaconceptthatincludestheuseofcommunityresources (humanandmaterial)andstrengths(existingmechanisms),andtakesinto considerationthewishesofacommunityanditsfeedbackinordertodevelopa project.Inthisway,families,teachers,communityandreligiousleaders,aswellas governmentandnongovernmentalrepresentatives,allworktogethertosupportthe reestablishmentofexistingornewcopingmechanismswithinacommunity.Inorder toachievetheseobjectives,specificcommunitymembersmaybeinvolvedatdifferent
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page28of47
timesduringtheproject,suchastheassessment,planning,implementation,or evaluation(seeFoundationmodule6Communitymobilisation). Themainobjectiveofimplementingcommunitybasedpsychosocialprogrammesisto buildandenhancethecapacityofthecommunitytobeabletoprovidecareand responsetochildrenspsychosocialneeds.Thisisaccomplishedbyinvolvingthemin eachstepoftheprogrammeandlearninghowtodesignfurtherinterventionsbasedon theirownresources.Thesewillbemoresustainableinterventions,assuredbyan assessmentwithchildren,parentsandothercommunitymembersthattheirneedsare prioritisedintheactivitiesandtheirparticipationissoughtintheimplementation.One exampleistheinvolvementofcommunitymembersasanimatorsinchildfriendly spaces,whichcanhelpinrestoringasenseofnormalitybecausethesecommunity membersarecaringforthemagainastheydidintheiroriginalhomeareas.Thiscan makethemfeelsecureandopentosharetheirconcernsandfears,astheparentsand communityfeltthesamewhendiscussingtheirchildrenspsychosocialconcerns. Additionally,theanimatorsworkasmessengersforraisingcommunityawareness.
Psychosocialsupportactivitieswithchildren Resilience(seeFoundationmodule1Understandingchildhoods)meanstheabilityto recoverfrom(ortoresistbeingaffectedby)ashockordisturbance.Inpsychology, resilienceisatermusedtodescribethecapacityofpeopletocopewithstressand catastrophe.Toberesilient,apersonneedstodrawuponalloftheresourcesathisor herdisposal,bothpsychologicalandenvironmental.Resilienceisbuiltthroughthe existenceandstrengtheningofprotectivefactorsintheenvironmentandrelationships, familyandsocietal,aswellasinnerresourcesandstrengths. Theabilitytoreestablishregularactivitiesisacrucialstepinfeelingsecureand confidentthatrecoveryispossible.Itsupportschildrensdevelopmentandcoping,and itenablesfamiliestomaintainsocialnetworksandrestoreincomegeneration.Itis importantforachildtobecomeinvolvedinaroutine,andactivitieswithchildrencan supportthis.Whenconductingactivitieswithchildren,thepriorityshouldbeto mobilisethechildsexistingsupportsystem,includingfamily,friends,teachers,social workers,communityandreligiousleaders.Usingthisapproach,activitiescanbe determinedandimplementedinpartnershipwithchildren,familiesandcommunities, andwithunderstandingofwhatlifewaslikebeforethecrisis.Themostcommontypes ofrequiredactivitiesarelistedbelow.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page29of47
Childfriendlyspacesandenvironments Childrenneedtoplayitistheirwayoflearningandassimilatingtheireveryday experiences.Thismaybeparticularlyhelpfulincampenvironmentswherethereare feweropportunitiesforchildrentoplaysafely.Achildfriendlyspacemaybeina mosqueortemple,communitycentre,designatedareawithinacamporinpeoples houses.Itisasafelocationwherechildrencanspendafewhoursaday,wherethey canfeelsecureandcomfortableandwheretheycantakepartinvariouspsychosocial, educationandotherchildprotectionactivities.Theyalsoserveaswaysforchildrento accessotherservices(suchashealthandnutrition),eitherthroughreferringchildren totheotherservices,orhavingbuiltuponhemintegratedinthechildfriendlyspace. Childrenshouldbeinvolvedineverystepofsettingupandorganisingthechild friendlyspaces.
Itisimportantthatthisspacebuildsuponthetraditionsandpracticesinthe communityregardingwhen,whereandhowchildrengather.Whenestablishinga childfriendlyspace,itisimportanttofirstidentifywhethertherearesomeexisting practicesthatcouldbebuiltupon. Insomesituationsitisappropriatetohaveacentralhuborphysicalspace,for example,inIDPcamps,whereasinothersitismoreappropriatetohavemultiple activitiesindifferentlocations,forexample,whereemergencyaffectedpopulations arestilllivingintheirvillages. Childfriendlyspacesprovidechildrenopportunitiestomeetwithotherchildrenand socialise,aswellastobefriendtheadultschargedwiththeircare.Thespacesalso makeiteasiertodetectchildrenwithparticularproblemsandprovideassistanceto themandtheirfamilies. Childfriendlyspacesprovideanenvironmentforengagementandsupportof parentsandfamiliestobegincommunitymobilisationbasedontheneedsoftheir children. Someactivitiesthatcanbeeasilyimplementedinsuchenvironmentsincludeplay, artandsportingactivities.Differentagegroupsrequiredifferenttypesofactivities, forexampleyoungchildrenwillfocusmoreonplay,whileolderchildrenusually preferartsortheatre.Ifconditionspermit,activitygroupsshouldbeorganised roughlyaccordingtochildrensageandstageofdevelopment(0to18months,18 monthstothreeyears,threetosixyears,sixto12years,12to18years). Differentactivitiesmaybeappropriateforboysorgirls,dependingontheculture, age,interestandskillsofthechildren.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page30of47
emergencyandtheirroleinit.Opportunitiesforadolescentstobeconstructively involvedinrespondingtotheemergencycanprovidethemwitharenewedsenseof purpose,strengthentheirsenseofselfworth,expandsocialnetworks,anddevelop theirsenseofcompetence. Psychosocialsupportactivitieswithfamiliesandothercaregivers Thepeoplewhocareforandareincontactwithchildrenonadailybasisareinthe bestpositiontohelpthem.Thefirstthingistoassesswhomchildreninteractwith, whomtheytrustandwhocaninfluencethem.Strengtheningtheabilityofthese peopletounderstandandsupportchildrenandtodealwiththeirownproblemsis essential.Belowaresomeexamplesofactivitieswithfamiliesandcaregivers. Supportcaregiversandfamilymemberstodealwiththeirowndifficulties Helpingparents,grandparentsorothercaregiverstodealwiththeirowndistressand reestablishtheircapacityforgoodparentingisvitalfortheirownpsychological healingandthatoftheirchildren.Makingavailableculturallyappropriateinformation onconstructivecopingmethods,awarenessofharmfulpractices,andenabling traditionalgrievingceremoniesareallusefulstepsinhealing.Providingasafegroup settingtosharefeelingswithotherswithsimilarexperienceshasproveneffective.Itis preferableforthesegroupstohaveaccesstoprofessionalsupport.Thetypeof awarenessandsupportactivitieschosenshouldbeculturallyspecific,anddetermined intandemwiththecommunity.Examplesincludeindividualcasework,groupwork, informationviathemedia,orfundingforcommunityledinitiatives.Trainingsessions, mediaactivities,parentsupportgroups,andoutreachprogrammesarewaysparents canbereached. Supportandfacilitatecaregivercommitteesand/orchildprotection committees Theymaybeinformalgatheringsororganisedeventsthatserveasaforumtodiscuss childrensreactionstoemergencies,whattodoandhowtoreferwhenneeded.They mayalsoprovideanopportunityforcaregiverstoparticipateanddecideuponissues affectingthem.Childprotectioncommitteescanidentifychildrenatrisk,monitorrisks, intervenewhenpossibleandrefercasestoprotectionauthoritiesorcommunity serviceswhenappropriate. Carryoutregularfamilyvisitsforcaregiversinneedofadditionalsupport Thesevisitsareanopportunitytodiscussproblemsandissuesinanopenandhonest mannerandtopreventfamilybreakdown.Thisisvitalforfamilieswhohavebeen reunited,orwheretheremaybeissuesofstigmaordiscrimination.Forexample:girl mothers,childrenformerlyassociatedwitharmedforces,childrenlivingwithunfamiliar relativesornewcarers,grandparentheadedhouseholdsandchildheadedhouseholds. Supportfamilyaccesstobasicservices Helpingfamiliestoaccessappropriatesocial,health,legal,economicandhousing supportisalsoimportant.Thiscanbedonethroughreferraltoappropriateservices and/ormobilisingthecommunitytohelpfamiliesinneed. Promotefamilyselfsufficiency Emergenciescancausedestitutioninmillionsoffamilies,eitherbythetotallossofall oftheireconomicassets(suchashome,land,livestockandbelongings)and/orthe lossofthecashearningmember(s)ofthefamily(throughdeath,recruitment,mental distressandinjuryordesertion).Destitutionleadstonumerousdistressingsituations
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page31of47
forchildrenandtheirfamilies.Providingincomegeneratingopportunitieshelpsfamily membersgaincontrolovertheirlivesanddevelopasenseofselfworth.(Income generationisacomplexfieldandrequiresspecialexpertiseandunderstandingoflocal marketmechanismsbeforeinitiatingthistypeofhelp)Inaddition,legalaidshouldbe provided.Legalaccesstolandforwidowedwomenandorphanedchildrenisoftenan issuetobeaddressed. Level3Focusednonspecialisedsupports Formostchildren,theprovisionofbasicservicesandsecurity(Level1activities), combinedwithgeneralactivitiestorestoreroutine,socialnetworks,andasenseof purpose(Level2activities),areenoughtorestoreormaintainpsychosocialwellbeing. Therewillbeasmallerproportionofchildrenwhowillrequiremorefocusedsupport. Childrenwhoarestrugglingtocopewithintheirexistingcarenetwork,whoarenot progressingintermsoftheirdevelopment,orareunabletofunctionaswellastheir peersmayrequireactivitieswhichaddresstheirpsychosocialneedsmoredirectly.This sectionsuggeststypesofactivitiesthatcanhelpthoseinneedofmorespecific psychosocialsupports. Itisimportanttonotethatthislevelofsupportrequiresspecialisedstaffoftenthese activitiesarecarriedoutbysocialworkers.Fieldworkers(animators,community mobilisersorprotectionofficers)playacrucialroleinidentifyingandreferringchildren inneedoffocusedsupport. Ensureindividualfollowup Addressingindividualprotectionneedscanbecomeparticularlycomplicatedwithina programme.Efficientandaccountablemanagementsystemsarenecessarybutmust beflexibletoallowforindividualdifferences.Themainstepsforprovidingsocial assistanceareto:
identifychildreninneedofimmediatecare developaninformationmanagementsystem setupareferralmechanism establishasystematicprocesstoassistchildrenandtheirfamilies establishaclearactionplanforeverychildthatincludesexitstrategies. Setuphotlinesandothercommunitybasedreportingmechanisms Followinganemergency,hotlinesorothercommunitybasedreportingmechanisms maybesetupinordertoreportcasesofabuse,exploitationorotherprotectionissues andtoconnectindividualswithappropriateresourcesandsupportnetworks.Reporting mechanismsshouldbechildfriendly,freeandconfidential.Hotlinesandother reportingmechanismsshouldalwaysbeoperatedincoordinationwithgovernmental institutionsinordertoensurethattheycomplementexistingstructuresandare sustainable. Provideculturallyappropriatecounselling Althoughmostchildrenwillnotneedoneononecounselling,paraprofessionals: teachers,socialworkers,psychologists,canofferanalyticalandproblemsolvingskills tomoreseverelyaffectedchildrenoradults.Counselling,onlycarriedoutbytrained staff,maybeconductedinindividual,grouporfamilysettings.Theseactivitiescan takeplacewhereotherpsychosocialsupportactivitiesoccur,inordertobeincontact
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page32of47
withthechildrenandadults,andalsotoidentifyotherchildreninneedofindividual followup. Level4Specialisedservices TheWorldHealthOrganisationhasprojectedthatinemergencies,onaverage,the percentageofpeoplewithaseverementaldisorder(psychosisandseverelydisabling presentationsofmoodandanxietydisorders)increasesbyonepercent,abovean estimatedbaselineoftwotothreepercent.Inaddition,thepercentageofpeoplewith mildormoderatementaldisorders,includingmostpresentationsofmoodandanxiety disorders(suchasposttraumaticstressdisorder,orPTSD),mayincreasebyfiveto 10%aboveanestimatedbaselineof10%.Despitecommunityworkorgeneral childrensactivities,somechildrenwillnotbeabletofunctionaswellastheirpeers. Examplesofdisturbancesincludethefollowing.
Prolongedseverereactionstoacrisis.Intheaftermathofadisasteralmosteveryone willshowinitialanxietyandbehaviouralchanges.Thesewouldnotbeconsidereda disorderunlessitwentonforalongtime,worsenedovertimeorinterferedwith normalactivitiessuchasgoingtoschoolorworking.Childreninparticularmay experienceseparationanxietyafteradisasterordeath,andwillwanttostaycloseto caregivers,thisisexpectedforaperiodofmonths.Prolongedreactionsshouldnotbe consideredPTSDunlessdiagnosedbyapsychiatrist. Addictiontodrugsoralcohol. Disabilityorbecomingmute(thatis,notspeaking). Excessiveaggression,thatis,dangeroustothemselvesorothers. Socialexclusionrelatingtopastorpresentcircumstances.Somechildrenmaybe excludedfromparticipatinginsocietyasaresultofculturalbeliefs.Forexample,agirl whohasbeenrapedmaybeviewedasuncleanandunmarriageableorachildwho haskilledwhenforcedintoanarmedforceorgroupmayberejectedashaving offendedthespiritworld. Mentalhealthproblems,forexample:
Depression Childrenoftendemonstratedepressionthroughirritability,or boredom.Theywillnotknowthattheyaredepressed,anditcanbedifficultto distinguishdepressionfromothertransientconditions.Severelydepressedchildren willdemonstrateoneormoreofthefollowingbehavioursforanumberofweeks: feelssadallofthetimeandmaycryalotdoesnoteatandisgettingthinnerand thinnerisfrequentlytiredanddoesnotfeellikedoinganythingisunabletosleep atnightseemstohavelostinterestinmostofthethingsinwhichtheyusedto takepleasure. Suicide isaveryrealriskinadolescents,andshouldbetakenseriously.Ifthereis anydoubt,theyshouldbeaskeddirectly.Thereisnoriskthatthiswillputinto theirheadtheideaofsuicideiftheyhavenotbeenthinkingaboutit.Although rare,childrenbelowtheageof10havebeenknowntoconsidersuicideandtohave carrieditout.Anychildoradolescentwhotalksaboutnotwantingtoliveshouldbe referredtoaprofessionalandshouldnotbeleftalone. Psychosis Itisunusual,butnotimpossibleforchildrentodemonstratethatthey havelosttouchwithreality.Losingtouchwithrealitymeansthattheycantseem
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page33of47
Counsellingorotherinterventionsthatfocusonsingleeventsortypesofreactions,for example,posttraumaticstresssymptoms,shouldbeavoidedintheacuteandmedium termphaseoftheemergency,becauseasdescribedabove,peoplehavemultiple causesofdistressandvariousreactions.Anymentalhealthorpsychosocial intervention,includingcounselling,shouldrespondtothevarioussourcesandformsof distressfromwhichpeoplearesuffering.Theonlyexceptiontotheaboveisthe provisionofcognitivebehaviouraltherapybyfullytrainedclinicianswhohavehad extensivetrainingandsupervisioninthisadvancedformofpsychotherapy. Allprogrammesandstaffshouldbecarefulnottoelicitemotionalmaterialtooearly, beforepeopleareinasafeenvironmentwheretheirbasicneedsaremetandwithout guaranteeoffollowup.Suchpracticesareusuallyineffectiveandcancausemore distressandharmtotheperson. Donothaveuntrainedand/orunsupervisedstaffperformdiagnosticassessment and/orcounselling. Avoidinappropriateexplorationsofthestressfulexperiences.However,ifthesurvivor wishestospeak,donotstophimorherfromtellingtheirstory. Donotpathologisewhatarelikelytobenormalreactionstoextremelydistressing events. Supportpeoplewiththemostseverementalhealthproblemsreferthemtohealth servicesorcommunityhealthcentresifotherwaysofsupportingthemarenot effective. Donotdiscourageorencouragepeoplefromusingtraditionaland/orfaithbased copingmechanisms,itisuptotheindividual.Inotheremergenciesthroughoutthe world,disastersurvivorshaveoftenfoundsuchsupportshelpful. Avoidculturallyinappropriateinvestigationandmisuseofdiagnostictools. Donotscreenpeopleforproblemswithoutbeingabletoreferthepersontoaservice whichcanprovideeffectivesupport. Donotcarryoutanyinterventionsthatriskfurtherisolationorstigmatisationof particularvulnerablegroupsamongtheaffectedpopulation.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page34of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Section5 Monitoringandlearninginpsychosocialprogrammes
Keylearningpoints
Itisimportanttohaveclearandmeasurableobjectivesandindicatorsthatare establishedattheinitialstagesofapsychosocialsupportintervention. Children,theirfamiliesandkeymembersoftheircommunitiesmustparticipatein planning,monitoringandevaluatingpsychosocialinterventions,especiallybyassisting indevelopingprojectobjectivesandprovidinglocalunderstandingsofwellbeing. Methodsformonitoringandlearningincludequantitativeandqualitativetools. Psychosocialinterventionswithintheprogrammecycle Designing,monitoringandevaluatingpsychosocialprogrammesisnotaneasytask. Evaluationsofmostpsychosocialinterventionsandprogrammestendtobelargely descriptiveandanecdotal,andremainattheoutputlevelratherthanmeasuring changeattheoutcomeandeventheimpactlevels.Thesecircumstancesaredueto therelativenewnessofthisfieldofprogrammingwithinhumanitarianand developmentaid,aswellastothefactthattheseprogrammesoftenmeasurea subjectivestateofmind,areculturallybound,andtheinterventionsmayonlyhavean effectoveralongerperiodoftime.Forexample,measuringprojectsrelatedto physicalhealthtendtobeeasierbecauseinternationalstandardsforobjective, measurableandshorttermobjectivesandindicatorshavebeenestablished. Forexample1000childrensufferingfrompoliohavereceivedtreatmentoverasix monthperiod. Itisimportantthatthestatedobjectivesofpsychosocialprojectsshouldprovidethe clearestdefinitionofwhattheinterventionsareseekingtoachieve.Muchtime,energy andmoneyisspentontheseprojects,thusprogrammersmustensurethattherewill beanactualpositivechangeforchildrenandtheirfamiliesand/orcommunitieswithin 22 thecorepsychosocialdomains.
Psychosocialdomain Skillsandknowledge Forexample:lifeskills,using culturallyappropriatecoping mechanisms,vocationalskills, conflictmanagement Emotionalwellbeing Forexample:feelingsafe,trust inothers,selfworth,hopeful forthefuture Socialwellbeing Forexample:attachmentwith caregivers,relationshipswith peers,senseofbelongingtoa community,accesstosocially appropriateroles,resuming culturalactivitiesandtraditions Somemeasureofimproved socialfunctioning Somemeasureofimproved emotionaladjustment Coreindicator Somemeasureofacquisition ofskills
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page35of47
1 Oncethesituationanalysishasbeencarriedout(seeFoundationmodule3 Programmedesign)itisimportanttotakeastepbackandevaluatethegeneral concern:whyisthisprogrammebeingestablished?Example:alargenumberof childrendisplayhighlyaggressivebehaviours.Followingthisreflection,staffcan determinethegoal:whataretheobjectivesandwhatshouldbeactedon? Example:therateofaggressivebehaviouramongchildreninPalestineisreduced. Projectimpactistheoverallchangeinthelivesofchildren(andtheirfamiliesand communities)thatresultsfromaproject. 2 Oncetheimpacthasbeenexplicitlydefined,staffcandecidewhatwillbethefocusof theprojectandhowtocontribute.Thiswillbecalledtheoutcome.Inpsychosocial programmingtherearegenerallythreetypesofoutcomes,allindicatingpositive change.
Projectoutcomesaretheeffectsthatcomeaboutduringthecourseofaprojectas aresultoftheoutputsachieved. 3 Thenextstepwillbetodiscusswhatneedstobedoneinordertoreachthisoutcome. Thisistheoutput.Iftheoutcomeoftheprojectisthatchildrenarelessstressed,the outputcanbe:900childrenparticipatedinrecreationalactivitiesonceamonth(and thereforeshouldbelessstressed).Iftheoutcomeisthatchildrensolvetheirproblems peacefully,theoutputcanbe:900childrenparticipatedinclassroombased interventionsessionsreinforcingtheircooperationskills. Projectoutputsaretheplannedachievementsputoutbyimplementingaproject (suchasnewlytrainedstaff,improvedservicesorfacilities)whichsignalsthatworkis ontrack. 4 Inordertoachievetheoutput,theprojectdefinesactivitieswithspecificdetailson forexample,participants,frequency,numberofchildren.Example:conductsix sessionsofrecreationalactivitieswith120childreneachtimeconduct10sessionsof classroombasedinterventionsin25schoolswith25studentspergrouprecruitand trainstaffandvolunteersonclassroombasedinterventionandrecreationalactivities.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page36of47
Projectinputsarethemoney,materials,equipment,staffandotherresourcesputin toprojectactivities. 5 Thenextstepistoestablishindicatorsthatwillmeasuretheeffectivenessofthe interventionsandtheactualchangethathasoccurredwiththechildren(andtheir caregivers,theplannedtargetgroup)asaresultofthepsychosocialintervention. Changecanbemeasuredbydevelopingindicatorsattheplanning(situationanalysis, baselineresearch),output,outcomeandimpactlevelsoftheproject.Indicatorsare establishedattheplanningstage,monitoredthroughouttheprogramme(output)and measuredbothattheendoftheprogramme(outcomes)andifpossiblesometime aftertheinterventionhasendedinordertomeasureimpact.
23 Examplesofpsychosocialindicators
Indicator Impact
Socialwellbeing Reductioninnumberof conflictsbetweenIDPs andhostcommunities (measuredby communityinterviews andbyreductionin policereportsofsocial disturbancesinvolving IDPs)
Outcome
Output
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page37of47
Reflectingandevaluating Providefeedbackondraftresultsandtheimplicationsfortheircommunityandfuture similarprojects.Forexample:childrenandparentshelpdefineobjectivesand indicators. Levelsofparticipation Therearedifferentlevelsofparticipation(seeFoundationmodule4Participation 24 andinclusion).TheladderofparticipationbyRogerHart isoftenusedtorepresent levelsofchildrensparticipation(however,itisnotalwaysappropriatetoconsider movinguptheladderasalineardevelopmentwhatismeaningfulandgoodpractice willdependonthesituation,contextandcapacitiesandresourcesofthoseinvolved). Thiscanprovideausefulprompttounderstandingthewaychildrenmightbe involved.Theladderhaseightrungsspanningparticipation,withmanipulationat oneendandchildinitiatedshareddecisionmakingattheother.Keyquestionsto askincludethefollowing.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page38of47
Maytriggerstrongemotions,whichneedsto beanticipatedandadequatesupportputin placetosupportchildrenindistress.This shouldreflecttheprincipleofdonoharmand useoftheethicalguidelinesdiscussedearlier. Examples Childfriendlykeyinformantinterviews. Focusgroupdiscussionsincludingnonverbal methodsofenquiry. Creativeselfexpression.Forexample: evaluationsong,evaluationbodies. Participatoryactionresearch.Forexample: journeyoflifetimelines,socialmapexercise (whodoIvisit?),spiderdiagrams,daily diaries,riskandresourcemaps,bodymaps. Casestudies.Forexample:mostsignificant changetechnique,lifehistoryandindividual casestudy,communitystudies,socialgroup studies,studiesoforganisationsand institutions,studiesofevents,rolesand responsibilities. Observation.Forexample:develop observationchecklist. Documentreview.Forexample:ofprimary andsecondarymaterial.
Typeofdesign PosttestonlydesignXO
Questionsthatcanbeanswered Howwellaretheparticipantsdoing
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page39of47
Forexample: postsurveyonly Attheendoftheprogramme,askingparentsor teachersWhatwerethethreebiggestproblemsyour childfacedsixmonthsago?Whataretheseproblems now?andAresleepingproblemslessofanissue? PretestandposttestdesignOXO Forexample: preandpostsurveys Collectthesameinformationbeforeandafterthe programmeandseewhethertherewasapositive change.Thiscanbequantitativeinformation (forinstance,75%oftheparentsdeclarethattheir childrensleptbadlybeforetheproject,andonly20% attheend),orqualitative(forinstance,duringfocus groups,badsleepingwasalwaysmentionedby parentsatthebeginningoftheprogramme,thenitis nolongermentionedattheend).
25 Keyevaluationcriteriaforpsychosocialprogrammes
Evaluationcriteria Relevance concernstheextenttowhich programmeshaveaddressedimportant needs,andhavedonethisaccordingto currentpolicyguidance.Thismeansthe extenttowhichaninterventionhasaddressed thepsychosocialdomainsofskillsand knowledge,emotionalwellbeingandsocial wellbeingforchildren,theirfamiliesand communities. Efficiency isgenerallythenumberofpeople aprogrammehasreachedinrelationtothe resourcesexpended.Itcanbeseenasa measureofhowwelloutputshavebeen achieved,giventheinputsmade.
Evaluationquestions Didtheprogrammearticulateobjectives relatedtochangesinchildrenswellbeingand lives,andthatoftheirfamilyandcommunity? Wereclearneedsdefinedwithrespectto requiredlevelsofpsychosocialsupport? Werepotentialbeneficiariesinvolvedin developingprogramming? Isprogrammeresponserelevanttoidentified needs? Haveactivitiesbeendeliveredcost effectively? Hasprogrammingreachedanappropriate numberofbeneficiaries,givenprogramme costs? Wastheprogrammeimplementedinatimely manner?
Hasthecentralgoaloftheproject,theneeds thatprovidedtherationaleforintervention,
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page40of47
thelivesofchildrenandtheircommunities.
Inpsychosocialwork,coverage meansthe proportionofaffectedchildren(and communities)thathavebeenreachedbyan intervention,focusingbothongeographical coverageandtheinterventionreachingsub groupsofapopulationwhomaybe particularlyvulnerable,forexample,children withdisabilities,adolescents. Coordination usuallymeansthe effectivenessofcollaborationand communicationamongstagenciesdelivering psychosocialsupportandotherservicestoa community.Thisincludesensuringthatthe workofoneagencyneitherdisruptsnor duplicatestheworkofanother,establishing commonprogrammingguidelinesand strategies,coordinatinggeographical distributionofprogrammes,establishing referralmechanismsandsharingofresources andinformation. Coherence meansthatworkhasbeen consistentwiththeapproachandprinciples setdownincurrentpolicy.Inemergencies, thismeansthatpsychosocialprogramming shouldbeconsistentwiththeIASCGuidelines onmentalhealthandpsychosocialsupportin emergencysituations. Intermsofprotectiontheissuefor psychosocialprogrammingiswhether activitieshaveworkedtostrengthenthe protectiveenvironmentsupporting children.
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page41of47
TheAngolanprovincebasedwartraumateam Thisprojectwasdesignedtoaddresstheeffectsofcivilwaronchildrenandfamilies. InAngola,warhascontinuedfornearly40years,andbothchildren,whocomprise nearlyhalfthepopulation,andcaregivershavebeenaffectedbypoverty,hunger, displacement,homelessness,deathoflovedones,landmines,andviolenceat multiplelevels.From1995to1998theprojectsoughttosupporttheLusakaPeace Processthroughcommunitybasedhealingaimedatalleviatingsufferingand breakingcyclesofviolence(includingtheintergenerationalcyclesassociatedwith violence). SeeProjectlogicmodelchartbelow. GoodpracticesinevaluatingpsychosocialprogrammingDuncanJ,Ph.D.and ArntsonL,Ph.D.MPH,forTheInternationalPsychosocialEvaluationCommitteeand SavetheChildrenFederation,Inc.withsupportfromtheAndrewW.Mellon Foundation
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page42of47
Angolanprojectlogicmodelchart
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page43of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Endnotes
1 AdaptedfromPsychosocialinterventionincomplexemergencies:aframeworkfor practiceThePsychosocialWorkingGroup 2 IASCguidelinesonmentalhealthandpsychosocialsupportinemergencysettings InteragencyStandingCommittee(IASC),Geneva2007 3 Programmingforpsychosocialsupport,frequentlyaskedquestionsUNICEF, 18August2005 4 Wheretheheartis,meetingthepsychosocialneedsofyoungchildreninthecontextof HIVandAIDSRichterL,FosterGandSherL,2006 5 StavrouP 6 Aguidetotheevaluationofpsychosocialprogramminginemergencies BoothbyN,AgerAandAgerW,UNICEF,2007 7 Aguidetotheevaluationofpsychosocialprogramminginemergencies BoothbyN,AgerAandAgerW,UNICEF,2007. ThesedomainsdrawonPsychosocialinterventionincomplexemergencies:a frameworkforpracticeThePsychosocialWorkingGroup www.forcedmigration.org/psychsocialA%Framework%20for%20Practice.pdf 8 ReviewofUNICEFsupportedrighttoplayinterventionsRespondingtothe psychosocialneedsofchildrenaffectedbyconflictinnorthernandeasternUganda StavrouV,UNICEF,UgandaSeptember2007 9 EyberC 10 Workingwithchildreninunstablesituations,guidingmanualforpsychosocialsupport UniversityofOxfordandUNICEF,2002 11AdaptedbyStavrouV,fromChildprotectioninemergenciesinteragencytrainingand resourceCD:foundationmoduleUNICEF 12AdaptedfromProgrammingforpsychosocialsupport:frequentlyaskedquestions UNICEF18August2005andThePalestiniancharterforpsychosocialwork committeecomprisedof:NPASecretariatforChildren,SCF/US,CIDA,UNRWA andUNICEF,10July2001 13UntappedpotentialWomenscommissionforrefugeewomenandchildren 14Lowicki2001http://www.womenscommission.org/pdf/yu_adol.pdf 15AreviewofUNICEFpoliciesandstrategiesonchildprotectionUnitedNationsEconomic andSecurityCouncil,UNICEFexecutiveboardannualsessionJune1996(Item E/ICRF/1995/13,item(b)) 16SeeFoundationmodule3Programmedesign 17GlossaryofkeyandrelatedpsychosocialtermsREPSSIregionalpsychosocialsupport initiative,2008 18Guidelinesonmentalhealthandpsychosocialsupportinemergencysettings InteragencyStandingCommittee(IASC) 19Ibid
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page44of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport Endnotes
20ChildtochildTrustbasedattheUniversityofLondon'sInstituteofEducation 21InteragencystatementonmentalhealthandpsychosocialsupportinGasain2009: principlesandresponse 22Aguidetotheevaluationofpsychosocialprogramminginemergencies BoothbyN,AgerAandAgerW,UNICEF,2007 ThesedomainsdrawonPsychosocialinterventionincomplexemergencies:a frameworkforpracticePsychosocialworkinggroup www.forcedmigration.org/psychsocialA%Framework%20for%20Practice.pdf 23Aguidetotheevaluationofpsychosocialprogramminginemergencies BoothbyN,AgerAandAgerW,UNICEF,2007 24Childrensparticipation: fromtokenismtocitizenshipHartR,UNICEF,1992 25Monitoring&evaluationquickreference:extractsfromtheprogrammepolicyand proceduremanualrevisedUNICEF,May2005 www.unicef.org/
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page45of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport
Furtherreading
AguidetotheevaluationofpsychosocialprogramminginemergenciesBoothbyN, AgerAandAgerW,UNICEF,2007 AladderofcitizenparticipationJournaloftheAmericanplanningassociation,vol.35, No.4ArnsteinS,July1969pp216to224 AreviewofUNICEFpoliciesandstrategiesonchildprotectionUnitedNationsEconomic andSecurityCouncil,UNICEFexecutiveboardannualsessionJune1996(Item E/ICRF/1995/13,item(b)) AtoolkitonpositivedisciplinewithparticularemphasisonSouthandCentralAsia SavetheChildren,2007 http://sca.savethechildren.se/sca/Publications/Childrenandviolence/ CommunitybasedpsychosocialsupporttrainingmanualIFRC Childrenincrisis:goodpracticesinevaluatingpsychosocialprogramming DuncanJandArntsonL,SavetheChildrenUS,2004 EastTimorassessmentofthesituationofseparatedchildrenandorphansinEast TimorIRCandUNICEF,2002 Emergenciesandpsychosocialcareandprotectionofaffectedchildren SavetheChildrenSweden,2005 GlossaryofkeyandrelatedpsychosocialtermsREPSSIregionalpsychosocialsupport initiative,2008 IASCGuidelinesonmentalhealthandpsychosocialsupportinemergencysettings InteragencyStandingCommittee(IASC),Geneva2007 InteragencystatementonmentalhealthandpsychosocialsupportinGazain2009: principlesandresponse Monitoringandevaluationquickreference:extractsfromtheprogrammepolicyand proceduremanualrevisedUNICEF,May2005 www.unicef.org/ Programmingforpsychosocialsupport:frequentlyaskedquestionsUNICEF, 18August2005 Promotingpsychosocialwellbeingamongchildrenaffectedbyarmedconflictand displacement:principlesandapproachesSavetheChildrenUK,1996 Psychosocialcareandprotectionofchildreninemergenciesafieldguide SavetheChildren,2004 Psychosocialcareandprotectionoftsunamiaffectedchildren:guidingprinciples IRC,SCUK,UNHCR,UNICEFandWVI.,2005 Psychosocialinterventionincomplexemergencies:aframeworkforpractice ThePsychosocialWorkingGroup www.forcedmigration.org/psychsocialA%Framework%20for%20Practice.pdf PsychosocialinterventionstrainingmanualSavetheChildren,2001Therefugee experiencepsychosocialtrainingmoduleRefugeeStudyCentre,OxfordUniversity, 2001
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page46of47
Foundationmodule7Psychosocialsupport Furtherreading
ReviewofUNICEFsupportedrighttoplayinterventionsRespondingtothe psychosocialneedsofchildrenaffectedbyconflictinnorthernandeasternUganda StavrouV,UNICEF,UgandaSeptember2007 Sportfordevelopmentandpeace:towardsachievingthemillenniumdevelopmentgoal UnitedNationsInteragencyTaskForce,2003 TheConventionoftherightsofthechild(adoptedbytheGeneralAssemblyofthe UnitedNationson20November1989) ThePalestiniancharterforpsychosocialwork,committeecomprisedof:NPA SecretariatforChildren,SCF/US,CIDA,UNRWAandUNICEF,10July2001 UNICEFprogrammingforpsychosocialsupport,frequentlyaskedquestions August182005 UntappedpotentialLowickiJ,Womenscommissionforrefugeewomenandchildren http://www.womenscommission.org/pdf/yu_adol.pdf Wheretheheartis,meetingthepsychosocialneedsofyoungchildreninthecontextof HIVandAIDSRichterL,FosterGandSherL,2006 Workingwithchildreninunstablesituations,guidingmanualforpsychosocialsupport UniversityofOxfordandUNICEF,2002 Workingwithchildreninunstablesituationsprinciplesandconceptstoguide psychosocialresponsesUNICEF,2003
ARCresourcepack2009 http://www.arconline.org
ARCModF7StudyMaterial2009 Page47of47