Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Table of Contents I. II. III. IV. V. VI. VII. IX. X. Introduction Logic Model Microfinance Overview Market Analysis Competition Market Strategy Loan Services Risk Assessments Team Profiles 3 4 5 6 9 12 15 18 19 20
I. Introduction
The Madison Fund, Inc. (TMF) is a non-profit micro lender based in Madison, Wisconsin. TMF was organized in order to improve the economic and financial conditions of small businesses and low-income entrepreneurs in the Madison, Wisconsin area and to provide these business owners with safe and affordable capital for their business activities. These loans are aimed at borrowers with little or no collateral, credit, income and resources. TMF also aims to fund and enable businesses that have a larger sustainable and green impact in the community. The Madison Fund was founded by University of Wisconsin-Madison students and incorporated in September of 2010. At the time of the composition of this Social Venture Plan, TMF is in its earliest stages of development and has not engaged in activities other than organization. In the future, TMF will accomplish the aforementioned goals by offering affordable micro-loans to small business owners, motivated entrepreneurs and low-income residents in Madison. Borrowers will be those who are unable to secure loans from traditional sources because of poor credit, insufficiently large borrowing demands, or fear of receiving loans from a bank. Because of TMFs loans, these people will not have to resort to seeking loan sharks, credit cards, or loans from friends and family members and will be helped by TMFs staff along the way. The Madison Funds primary activities will include raising funds (donations will be tax-deductible once the 501(c)3 Application is approved by the IRS or upon partnership with a fiscal sponsor) to add to TMFs primary loan pool, and lending these funds to borrowers in the Madison area. The business model that TMF strives to use will be as cost effective as possible. It is our ambition to keep all expenses as low as possible. Ideally, the organization will be maintained and managed by students motivated by social development and the relevant internship and volunteer experience and not by a salary. As of now, TMF does not pay anyone a salary or fee for services of any type, and it has no plans to pay anyone a salary or service fee in the future. Other than necessary costs to keep the business afloat; utility bills, office space, costs of transportation etc., our aim is to have close to zero expenses so that as close to 100% as possible of the loan pool will be available for loan packaging, and as close to 100% as possible of the loan returns will be reinvested in the loan pool. In this way, the fund will be able to grow at a much quicker rate than it would normally and at a faster rate than its competitors and similar funds.
Activities
In order for TMF to carry out its vision, we will accomplish the following activities
Outputs
When these activities are accomplished, we expect to observe these results
Long-term Outcomes
When we accomplish our activities we expect to observe these changes in 2-4 years
Impacts
We expect that if we accomplish these activities we will observe these changes in our organization and community in 7-10 years
-Networking with professors and other non-profits; advisory panel Model for application process, loan origination, and repayment Postings on BuckyNet, social networking
Create a loan program outcome success measurement Obtain diverse volunteer staff
More experienced and professional advisory; broaden community outreach and increase community-based referrals Default rate less than 10%, client satisfaction 100% Broader range of ideas and opportunities for volunteers
Reduce costs of administration transitions, legal/financial guidance to keep TMF expenses as near $0 as possible A majority of net operating capital put in loan pool for new loan origination Highly qualified volunteers contributing skills and knowledge to TMF, keeping costs as near $0 as possible Established community ties lead to more trusting and safe borrower/lender relationship, and ultimately growth An established and sustainable community micro-lender, help create 100 local jobs annually TMF seen as expert guide on microfinance industry and market in Wisconsin A fully operational nonprofit micro-lender will boost employment and strengthen the community
Broader knowledge and skill base, ability to choose staff more selectively Increased loan pool by $20,000 within a year, larger base of potential borrowers Increased number and dollar amount of loans distributed, increased direction of TMF Increase borrowers by 50% each year 10 loans funded
Local awareness and support of TMF; access to potential borrowers Increased funds for lending; increased awareness More focus on how to best direct TMF efforts Additional credibility for TMF, increased attractiveness for donors Financial stability, allows analysis of TMF performance benchmarks Connect more borrowers to TMF services
Completed research on available grants, completed business plan TMF loan statistics, more staff Complete and submit 501c3 documents Volunteer Staff
Application of grants
Design and implement microloan demand and impact research IRS 501c3 Status
Students committed for all or majority of their college career, Reduce costs of administration transition Increase borrowers by 50% each year, 15 positive reviews or articles in popular media Raise at least $100,000 through grants, have established grant programs to apply for each year Create loan packages tailored specifically to Madison area In-flow of at least $20,000 in private donations a year
Hire a CFO
Build relationships with similar organizations, establish TMF as most prominent community micro-lender
Market Demographics: 1. Recent research estimates that approximately 4.3% of Wisconsins population is
under-banked. This equates to nearly 250,000 people across the state.2
3. The Small Business Administration Office (SBA) research indicates that the
immigrant population constitutes a larger proportion of those who start their own businesses. This suggests the pronounced need for microfinance among immigrants.4
Market Demand:
1. The U.S. Small Business Administration Office (SBA) states that the recent collapse of financial markets, especially the credit freeze in short-term funding, has had a devastating impact on small businesses. The SBA research concludes that despite the Federal Open Market Committees extraordinary efforts to ease monetary policy, there is an inadequate supply of credit to small firms.5
1 2 3 4 5
FDIC: National Survey of Un-banked and Under-banked Households, pg. 11-12, 2009 U.S. Census Bureau, Data for Dane County, 2009 Ibid (FDIC) SBA, The Small Business Economy, pg 11, 2008 Ibid
2. The demand for credit can be indirectly observed by size of the payday loan industry, which annually contributes around $10 billion to national GDP. There are approximately 30 payday loan store locations in the immediate Madison area. 3. Tougher bank lending rules are driving more small businesses and startups towards micro loans. The Small Business Administrations (SBA) loan volume declined 36% in 2009, as the economic recession prompted traditional banks to tighten their credit policies.6 4. Recent innovations in microfinance business models are increasing the selfsufficiency and profitability of the industry. The FDIC conducted a pilot SmallDollar Loan Program that ended in 2009. Over the course of the program, 28 participating banks made 34,400 micro loans, totaling to 40.2 million dollars. Participating lenders noted the small loans increased long-term profitability, as well as customer relations.7 5. Alex Counts of the Grameen Foundation has recently noted that with additional capital provided by foundations, donors, and government agencies, there is significant room for growth in the U.S. microfinance industry.8
6 7
<http://www.oregonlive.com/business/index.ssf/2009/02/micro_loans_on_rise_in_portlan.html> FDIC Quarterly, 2010, Volume 4, No. 2: The FDICs Small-Dollar Loan Pilot Program 8 <http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29258701/>
Furthermore, TMF will provide assistance and support throughout the lifespan of the loan to make the payment process as fluent as possible. TMF will also network its borrowers with other borrowers and business owners in the area in hopes that they will be able to share experience, knowledge and expertise with one another.
V. Competition
The Banking Industry
Traditional lending sources will not compete with The Madison Fund. Such institutions are not usually willing to lend the small dollar amounts that TMF specializes in. In our research, we look at the ratio of micro-loans to total business loans (SSBL/TBL) at one hundred of the U.S.s leading lending institutions.9 We find that 74% of these lenders have a SSBL/TBL ratio ranging from 0.00 to 0.05. This means that, at most, only 5% of their loans are aiding small business. Since the start of the 2000s, the small business loan share of banks loan and asset portfolios has steadily declined, especially in the smallest loan size category.10 Thus, TMF views itself as separate from traditional lending sources.
10
Data was taken from the SBA: Small Business and Micro Business Lending in the U.S., table 1B, pg. 26, 2008 SBA: Small Business in Focus: Finance, pg. 14, 2009
3) Microfinance Leadership Initiative, a UW-Madison student organization that aims to increase knowledge of microfinance, for its establishment on campus. TMF will benchmark itself against these competitors in the United States: 1) The Capital Good Fund, a Rhode Island nonprofit, for its rapid growth and innovative microfinance model geared specifically for U.S. markets. 2) Grameen America, a national nonprofit, for its rapid expansion in the U.S. and its role a leading policy advocate for microfinance in the U.S. 3) The Elmseed Enterprise Fund, a nonprofit in New Haven, Connecticut, for its small interest loans and social media marketing In our Competitive Analysis we conclude that many of these benchmark organizations provide models for TMF to imitate. Adapting proven techniques to our market and community will strengthen the TMF model. We conclude that there are opportunities for partnership, as the nonprofit sector is collaborative in nature.
10
Microfinance Organizations
Competitor
Envest
Strengths
-Established community presence, many partners -International presence Well financed
Weakness
-Does not lend in Madison
Threats
-Environmental focus could push into TMFs Energy Efficiency Loan None at present
Opportunities
-Cooperation in the future could lead to expansion of TMFs geographic coverage -Cooperation could lead WCCN to direct more funds locally, boosting TMFs loan pool -Cooperation could lead to expanded TMF staff
Key Insights
-Reliance on private donors is not necessarily most effective way to raise capital -TMF can focus on local markets with low risk of competition -Student population is a key resource
WCCN
-Innovative microfinance model developed for U.S. -Financial stability -Yunus as spokesperson -Extremely well financed, and stable
-Focused on loans to Latin America and women -Have more activities than just microfinance -Does not actively operate as a microlender -Focuses only on increasing awareness of microfinance -Have many expenses, less in loan pool than possible -Group loan model does not translate well in the United States -Have not introduced innovations to microfinance model
-Partnership could allow TMF to utilize well tested business models -Their push for microfinance policy in the U.S. government strengthens all micro-lenders None at present
Grameen America
-Rapidly Expanding
-Efficient loan application process -Model geared towards U.S. urban area -Impact of policy
Elmseed
None at present
11
Obstacles to Success
The need for microfinance in the United States is greater than ever. Although the un-banked and under-banked continue to demand capital for their projects and ideas, it is estimated that only 2% of the potential market is being served11 . Many microfinance organizations experience slow growth and have trouble entering local capital markets. The Madison Fund identifies four major obstacles to success: high service costs, poor modeling, lack of funding, and lack of borrowers. The Madison Fund strives to keep costs as near zero as possible. TMF relies on volunteer staff for operations, and pays out no salaries. TMF has no plans of paying out salaries in the future. TMF strives to put every cent received in donations, grants, and loan repayment directly back into our loan pool. In this way, TMF avoids the burden of slow growth due to high service costs. While classic microfinance models, such as group borrowing, have been successful in third world countries, entrance in a U.S. market requires adaptation. In order to succeed, TMF will focus on using and developing innovative micro-lending models geared specifically for the U.S. The Capital Good Fund (CGF), a nonprofit microlender based in Rhode Island, has demonstrated the effectiveness of altering the classic microfinance model to better fit the local market. CGFs innovative DoubleGreen! Loan
11
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/11/09/magazine/09nix-t.html?scp=1&sq=check%20casher&st=cse
12
and grassroots marketing campaigns have made them one of the leading micro-lenders in the United States, bolstering Rhode Island employment and preventing 4 tons of carbon dioxide emissions12 . TMF will adapt models from innovators such as CGF to fit the Madison area market, as well as develop region-specific programs to target organic farmers and other small businesses. An insufficient capital stock can result in slow growth of microfinance institutions. Without the proper funding, MFIs must wait for outstanding loan repayment in order to replenish their loan pool. Invaluable time is lost and business expansion is impossible. The Madison Fund ambitiously seeks out private donations and grants to assure that its capital reserve is ample enough to avoid this problem. Kiva.org has demonstrated the importance of raising individual donations online. Through an inventive online lending channel, Kiva.org has helped fund nearly 300,000 loans around the world, totaling $222,286,225 in value13 . TMF has constructed its website to ensure that the donation process is as hassle-free for the donor as possible. TMF will avoid failing to obtain sufficient capital reserves by making use of technological advances and proper grassroots marketing campaigns. MFIs may find it difficult to connect with clients. This is due to lack of borrower knowledge of the benefits of credit, financial literacy, and sustainable practices. Borrowers may also find it difficult to connect with MFIs due to a lack of technology, education, and health/family issues. The Madison Fund relies on grassroots organization and marketing to overcome these challenges.
Customer Acquisition
TMF utilizes four important competitive advantages in positioning in the Madison area and obtaining borrowers: nonprofit status in the community, grassroots organization, local partnerships, and a green focus. TMF drives awareness of its activities by utilizing a grassroots and word of mouth marketing strategy. Making connections with local community centers, such as churches and small business development centers, allows TMF to expand its cliental. Wherever it is appropriate to do so, TMF places flyers and brochures expounding the benefits of microfinance services and loans. In the future, TMF will strive to utilize radio ads, which have proven effective with other nonprofit micro-lenders such as the Capital Good Fund. TMF will also take advantage of local outdoor markets and set up information stands, so that the community may put a face with the organization. Online social media and networking is a key tool utilized by TMF. Internet forums, such as Facebook and Twitter, are an essential way to reach into the community. These forums allow TMF to advertise its services, as well as foster conversations about
12 13
http://www.capitalgoodfund.org/ourimpact/bythenumbers http://www.kiva.org/about/stats
13
microfinances role in aiding community growth. TMF will launch a PR campaign to gain press in leading national microfinance blogs and forums. TMF has invested a large portion of its expense into an accessible, easy-to-navigate, and resourceful website. TMFs website utilizes search engine optimization (SEO) strategies to ensure potential borrowers are directed quickly to the site. This investment will allow TMF to launch an online marketing campaign that reaches into the community for borrowers and donors. TMF takes advantage of its university and community connections for its word of mouth campaign. The UW-Madison Small Business Development Center is a key resource for referrals. TMF is partnered with local nonprofit Nehemiah, which aids community development through tested training programs. Partnerships such as this allow TMF to extend further into the community and reach out to borrowers. TMF uses its green focus to gain community support. UW-Madisons We Conserve sustainability initiative is a key indicator of the communitys environmental stance. TMF hones in on this attitude, offering an energy efficient loan package, to expand its market to organic farmers and other sustainable small businesses.
14
15
potential borrowers do not have these documents, TMF will gladly assist potential borrowers in obtaining them. Borrowers who meet these criteria are considered most reliable and well prepared to take on the loan liability, and will thus be considered for one of TMFs loan packages. Finally, if a borrower obtains a loan, he/she must decide on a meeting schedule with a loan officer to update on progress. Borrowers and loan officers should constantly be in touch, and TMF believes that these update meetings will foster a strong and trusting relationship between the loan officer and the borrower. No borrower may take out another loan to repay an existing one.
Entrepreneurial Loans
The Entrepreneurial Loan package is designed for those who have either limited or no history of business practice. These entrepreneurs possess the ideas, skills, talents, or plans for operations, but are finding it difficult to begin business. Entrepreneurs come to TMF in the need for start-up seed capital for their business plans. If entrepreneurs also find themselves struggling with their financial organization or management, TMF will be readily available with all the assistance it can provide, including (if necessary) referral to a more expert source such as the Wisconsin Small Business Development Center. These loans will be relatively similar to the Small Business Loan Package except the target borrowers are entrepreneurs rather than business owners. The amounts of these loans will range from $500-$5,000. Again, the nature of the business is not of primary concern, though these borrowers must have a business plan coupled with a clear purpose and detailed outline for the funds that they will receive. Borrowers receiving this loan
16
package must open a business banking account if they do not have one already, and TMF can assist them in that process.
Citizenship Loans
The Citizenship Loan is designed for those submitting or planning to submit an Application for Naturalization with the US Citizenship and Immigration Services Bureau. These borrowers are Madisons future citizens, and are an essential part of creating a unified, more inclusive city. With this loan package, applicants will obtain both guidance and financial support to lessen the unexpected burden of the application process and fee. The Citizenship Loan Package will provide the borrower with $675the fee that the US Bureau of Citizenship and Immigration Services charges for submission of an Application for Naturalization.
17
Formula
Purpose
Return on Assets
Asset Management
Loan-Loss Provision Ratio Loan-Loss Provision/Average Performing Assets Amount Written Off/Average Loans Outstanding Balance of Past Due Loans/Value of Loans Outstanding Capital/Total Performing Assets Total Liabilities/Total Performing Assets Indicator of provisioning requirements on current loan portfolio A rough indicator of TMFs overall portfolio quality, a tool for combating default risk Measures amount of default in current portfolio
Loan-Loss Ratio
Portfolio in Arrears
Capital Adequacy
Capital to Assets Ratio Debt to Asset Ratio Measure of general capital sufficiency Indicator of how much of TMFs assets are financed through debt
Liquidity
Current Ratio Current Assets/Current Liabilities Number of Active Borrowers/Number of Personnel Operating Expense/Average Gross Loan Portfolio Operating Expense/Average Number of Active Borrowers Indicates TMFs ability to meet shortterm credit obligations Measures the overall productivity of TMF staff Overall measure of TMF efficiency
Team Efficiency
Personnel Productivity
18
Capitalization Risk
TMF faces the risk of not being able to fundraise sufficient operating capital. TMF will focus on increasing operational self-sufficiency on a yearly basis, aiming for a rate of 95%. Expansion of TMF operations will occur at a slow rate, so as to ensure our capital is used wisely and efficiently. TMF has been structured in order to ensure that incoming revenue from donations, grants, and loan payments is sufficient enough each year to keep TMF operational and to grow or at least sustain the current levels of the loan pool.
19
X. Our Team
Alexander K Rosenthal Executive Director University of Wisconsin-Madison Class of 2013 Departments of Chinese, Economics and Mathematics alex.rosenthal@madisonfund.org | (800) 294-7517 Andrew Tapper Executive Director University of Wisconsin-Madison Class of 2013 Departments of Economics and Mathematics andrew.tapper@madisonfund.org | (847) 513-3005 Ben Landau - Managing Director University of Wisconsin-Madison Class of 2013 Department of Economics, School of Business ben.landau@madisonfund.org | (800) 294-7517 Tony RudeenMarketing University of Wisconsin-Madison Class of 2013 Department of Economics, School of Business tony.rudeen@madisonfund.org | (800) 294-7517 Arielle DanieliLoan Services University of WisconsinMadison Class of 2013 Department of Accounting, School of Business arielle.danieli@madisonfund.org | (847) 293-5522
20
21