11/2/2014

BURMESE VERSION | BLOG | VIDEO |

Burmas Ethnic Minorities Decry Census, Jostle for Advantage

Insert Email to Subscribe Newsletter

HOME

BURMA

ASIA

BUSINESS

OPINION

FEATURE

INTERVIEW

CARTOON

SPORTS

MULTIMEDIA

ARCHIVES

BURMA

Search...

Burmas Ethnic Minorities Decry Census, Jostle for Advantage

By Y EN SNA ING / T HE IRRA W A DDY | 2 Mon da y , Febr u a r y 1 0 , 2 0 1 4 |

MO RE A RTIC L ES IN THIS SEC TIO N

In Maungdaw Village, Residents Fret Over Missing Family Members Marching Villagers Call for Burma Minister to Be Sacked Over Comments Burmas Government to Appoint a Second Woman Minister Burmas NLD and 88 Generation Team Up to Push for Charter Reform Security on the Agenda at Upcoming Arakanese Conference Wa Rebels to Send Fighters to China for Pilot Training: Reports Photoshopped Thein Sein Prompts Media Ethics Discussion Burmas Former Political Prisoners Offer Counseling for Trauma

Bu r m a s Min ist er of Im m ig r a t ion a n d Popu la t ion Kh in Y i poin t s t o a g r a ph a s h e spea k s a t a n ew s con fer en ce a bou t t h e u pcom in g cen su s in Ra n g oon on Sept . 1 5 , 2 0 1 3 . (Ph ot o: Reu t er s / Soe Zey a T u n )

RANGOON Members of Burmas largest ethnic minority groups and smaller ethnic subgroups are voicing concerns over a census due to be conducted late next month, with the surveys system of classification criticized as inaccurate by some, and unnecessarily divisive by others. Major ethnic groups like the Karen, Chin and Kachin have complained that they are being robbed of some subgroups, claiming they owe lineage to the larger respective ethnic identities but have been incorrectly placed elsewhere under the current categorization scheme. Other voices from among the ranks of Burmas biggest ethnic minorities have called for categorizing the scores of ethnic subgroups under the primary ethnic groups rather than giving an individual code number to each. That recommendation has not won the endorsement of some of Burmas ethnic subgroups and tribes, however. The Palaung, also known as Taang, as well as ethnic Zomi, Pathi and Rohingya, have all expressed a desire to maintain a distinct ethnic classification with their own designated code number on the upcoming census. The Palaung State Liberation Front (PSLF) last week issued a statement rejecting the censuss categorization of the Taang people as being one of 33 Shan subgroups. The Taang are of Mon-Khmer ancestryMon, Khmer and Palaung [Taang] belong to this group. We are not derived from Shan. We migrated to the Shan region for various reasons, among them climate and war, said Mann Aik Kyaw, a communications officer for the Taang National Liberation Army (TNLA), the PSLFs armed wing. The PSLF statement said: The Palaung State Liberation Front objects to the fact that eight main ethnic groups have been specified by the Burmese government led by President Thein Sein in the collection of nationwide census data, placing the Taang under one of the main ethnic groups 33 subgroups. Similarly, ethnic Zomi peoples are officially listed as a subgroup of the Chin, but Zomi representatives say they cannot accept the governments decision to group them among the 53 designated Chin subgroups. The UN Population Fund (UNFPA) and a handful of foreign governments are assisting Burma in the lead up to the census, which will be the first to be conducted in the country in more than three decades. In a letter to parliamentary Speaker Shwe Mann, 23 Kachin civil society groups have called for postponement of the census, to allow for a discussion of its system of categorization. Absent a resolution to the various groups concerns over classification, the letter urges census administrators

http://www.irrawaddy.org/burma/burmas-ethnic-minorities-decry-census-jostle-advantage.html

1/3

11/2/2014

Burmas Ethnic Minorities Decry Census, Jostle for Advantage

to drop Question 8, which asks for ethnic or tribal identification. The problem is the promulgation of 135 ethnicities in 1983 by Gen. Ne Win under one-party rule. [It was] the grouping of ethnics without consulting any ethnics at the time. That system has been reapplied now, under the democratic system, which creates problems, Thet Ko from Minority Affair told The Irrawaddy. The respective ethnic groups have questioned this, said Thet Ko, the director of Minority Affair, a civil society group that conducts research on Burmas ethnic minority groups. The list of ethnics should be compiled again after consulting with ethnic groups through a democratic procedure. The Nationalities Brotherhood Federation (NBF), an alliance of 20 registered ethnic political parties, has also called for a review of the census classification system in negotiation with ethnic groups. The NBF fears that requiring Burmese nationals to identify as one of the 135 listed ethnic groups could lead to disunity among ethnic groups, the coalition said in a statement released on Feb. 2. Thet Ko said the government had never adequately explained the basis for its accounting of Burmas ethnic groups, which officially listed 144 different ethnic groups in 1973. Ten years later, the nations ethnic composition was announced to have been reduced to 135 ethnic groups. They have never explained the reason why they repealed the nine ethnic groups, he said. Some, like Myint Swe of the Peace Cultivation Network, have speculated thatas is believed to have guided other policy decisions by the superstitious Ne Winthe change in the ethnic tally was the product of yadaya, the practice of following an astrologers advice on what one must do to avert an impending event, or realize ones desires. We were no longer on the official ethnic list after Ne Win removed us as koe-na-win, Myint Swe said, referring to the practice of acting on the number nine, widely believed by Buddhists to be auspicious. Many of Burmas Muslims are also organizing to try to secure favorable representation in the census. A support committee for followers of the Islamic faith has issued an announcement encouraging Muslims who trace roots to the ethnic Pathi to identify themselves as such in the census. Kyaw Khin, of the United National Congress Party, says Pathi Muslims want a separate code number for their identity. Failing that, Kyaw Khin and others are instructing people who identify as Pathi to mark themselves under the censuss Other designation, where they can write in Pathi. Myint Thein, also with the Peace Cultivation Network, says self-identifying Pathi will continue to push for official recognition, which they were given in the governments 1973 reckoning, but was rescinded in the 1983 tally. Khin Yi, the Union minister of immigration and population, told us that the 135 ethnics might not be the same after the census. It might be fewer and new ethnic groups might appear too, he said, adding that the minister had advised them to submit the issue to Parliament.

Related Posts :

Wa Rebels to Send Fighters to China for Pilot Training: Reports

Burma Govt Should Be Tolerant of M edia: Human Rights Watch

Ethnic Leaders Demand Thein Sein: Constitution Burmas Ethnic Armed Spot on Burma Election M ust Reflect Deals With Groups Share Ceasefire Commission Ethnic Groups Draft With Govt Negotiator

Find us on Facebook

Irrawaddynews
Like

166,609 people like Irraw addynew s.

Facebook social plugin

WSJ LIVE VIDEO:

3 Responses to Burmas Ethnic Minorities Decry Census, Jostle for Advantage

http://www.irrawaddy.org/burma/burmas-ethnic-minorities-decry-census-jostle-advantage.html

2/3

11/2/2014
Cakei
Tu esday , Febru ary 11, 2014 - 12:02 am

Burmas Ethnic Minorities Decry Census, Jostle for Advantage

USDP regim e is handling nothing rightly . The ethnics know about them m uch better than USDP regim e. I am a Chin. Our Naga brothers and sisters insist that they are not the Chin ethnic. The Naga people are Naga, not Chin. If USDP regim e categorizes the Naga people as one tribe under the Chin, the Naga will lose countless benefits in the future. So, USDP regim e m ust better stop doing this census if it does not know what and how to handle it. We the Chin people lov e the Naga people. But the Naga are not one of the Chin tribes.
Reply

Chin Lay
Tu esday , Febru ary 11, 2014 - 10:50 am

Som e Chin people do not accept the nam e Chin. I am a Chin but we call ourselv es as Laim i. My anm ar People call them selv es as My anm ar but I call them Kawl. Kawl in Chin m eans Looking for. I do not know what Chin m eans to the My anm ars who are believ ed to call us first Chin. Many people com e up with different roots and definitions of the nam e Chin. Any way , I am proud to be called as Chin by others. It is becom ing our legal nam e. Zom i, Laim i, Zophei, Zotung, Khum i so on. We all are under a beautiful nam e, CHIN.
Reply

Lay Lwin
Tu esday , Febru ary 11, 2014 - 11:22 am

Khin Yi the Pim p is leading one of the m inistries. Hahahahaha. I hope the census will rev eal all his concubines and m istresses.
Reply

Leave a Reply
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
Nam e *

Em ail *

Website

Com m ent

You m ay use these HTML tags and attributes: <a h r ef="" t it le=""> <a bbr t it le=""> <a cr on y m t it le=""> <b>
<block qu ot e cit e=""> <cit e> <code> <del da t et im e=""> <em > <i> <q cit e=""> <st r ik e> <st r on g >

Post Comment

Code of Et h ic

Pr iv a cy

Copy r ig h t

RSS

Fa cebook

T w it t er

Con t a ct Us

A bou t Us

W or k for Us

Ma g a zin e Su bscr ipt ion

Ph ot o St or e

Don a t ion

Copy r ig h t (c) 2 0 1 3 Ir r a w a ddy Pu blish in g Gr ou p. A ll Rig h t s Reser v ed

http://www.irrawaddy.org/burma/burmas-ethnic-minorities-decry-census-jostle-advantage.html

3/3