You are on page 1of 47

E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

In the Iowa District Court in and for SAC County Case No: 02811 LACV019374 Title: BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH

NOTICE REGARDING ELECTRONIC FILING


This case has been converted to an electronic case by Order of the Court.

New rules apply to electronically filed cases.

Because your case has been converted to an electronic case, it is now governed by Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management System.

What is required of you? You must register to use the Electronic Document Management System (EDMS).
If you haven't already registered, please log on to the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website at https://www.iowacourts.state.ia.us/EFile to register.

You are required to have a current e-mail account for use with EDMS. Registration requires you to understand and agree to comply with the rules that govern electronic filing, contained the Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the use of the Electronic Document Management System, available on the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website. Your registration constitutes your request for, and consent to, electronic service of court-generated documents and documents filed electronically by other parties. When you have completed your registration, you can begin filing and viewing documents on your case and receiving notifications of filings, and events. EXCEPTIONS: For good cause, the court may authorize you to submit a document in paper. Upon showing of exceptional circumstances, the chief judge of the district in which a case is pending may grant you an exemption from registering and filing electronically.

You must protect private information when using EDMS.

Division VI of Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management System specifies personal information that is now considered protected by the court, as well as what you must do to keep protected personal information out of the public documents you eFile.

Training and technical support are available for EDMS.

Technical support for the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website is available at 1-877-369-8324. If you have questions about court procedures related to electronic filing, contact your county clerk of court office.

We look forward to your comments and suggestions as we implement electronic filings in the Iowa Courts

E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

In The Iowa District Court for the Second Judicial District In re the conversion of paper files to electric documents Administrative Order

Iowa Court Rule 16.102 authorizes a chief judge to order the conversion of paper court files to an electronic file of any case not subject to the Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management System (EDMS). It is in the best interest of all for the Court to have access via EDMS to pending files that exist at the time a county clerk of court office implements EDMS. Accordingly: It is so Ordered that: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Each Clerk of Court may take action to convert paper case files that are pending and will likely appear on a future court schedule as soon as implementation of EDMS begins in their respective counties. The Clerk shall work with the local Court to identify specific documents that are to be scanned in each case type. Upon implementation of electronic filing in the County, the security level of these electronic records shall be as identified by the EDMS Business Advisory Committee. The Clerk shall send the Notice Regarding Electronic Filing to the attorneys and parties appearing pro se. Once notified, counsel of record or parties appearing pro se shall apply the rules pertaining to protection of personal privacy (Iowa Ct.R.16.602 through 16.607) to all future filings in that case. After being notified of commencement of the electronic filing in that County, attorneys, parties appearing pro se and all other shall file all future filings on that case electronically.

It is so Ordered: Dated 3rd day of November, 2010 /s/ Kurt L. Wilke Kurt L. Wilke, Chief Judge of the Second Judicial District of Iowa

Recipient List Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH Event Cd : E-FILED NOOT 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT DAVID POWELL JENNETT filed

E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

In the Iowa District Court in and for SAC County Case No: 02811 LACV019374 Title: BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH

NOTICE REGARDING ELECTRONIC FILING


This case has been converted to an electronic case by Order of the Court.

New rules apply to electronically filed cases.

Because your case has been converted to an electronic case, it is now governed by Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management System.

What is required of you? You must register to use the Electronic Document Management System (EDMS).
If you haven't already registered, please log on to the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website at https://www.iowacourts.state.ia.us/EFile to register.

You are required to have a current e-mail account for use with EDMS. Registration requires you to understand and agree to comply with the rules that govern electronic filing, contained the Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the use of the Electronic Document Management System, available on the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website. Your registration constitutes your request for, and consent to, electronic service of court-generated documents and documents filed electronically by other parties. When you have completed your registration, you can begin filing and viewing documents on your case and receiving notifications of filings, and events. EXCEPTIONS: For good cause, the court may authorize you to submit a document in paper. Upon showing of exceptional circumstances, the chief judge of the district in which a case is pending may grant you an exemption from registering and filing electronically.

You must protect private information when using EDMS.

Division VI of Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management System specifies personal information that is now considered protected by the court, as well as what you must do to keep protected personal information out of the public documents you eFile.

Training and technical support are available for EDMS.

Technical support for the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website is available at 1-877-369-8324. If you have questions about court procedures related to electronic filing, contact your county clerk of court office.

We look forward to your comments and suggestions as we implement electronic filings in the Iowa Courts

E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

In The Iowa District Court for the Second Judicial District In re the conversion of paper files to electric documents Administrative Order

Iowa Court Rule 16.102 authorizes a chief judge to order the conversion of paper court files to an electronic file of any case not subject to the Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management System (EDMS). It is in the best interest of all for the Court to have access via EDMS to pending files that exist at the time a county clerk of court office implements EDMS. Accordingly: It is so Ordered that: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Each Clerk of Court may take action to convert paper case files that are pending and will likely appear on a future court schedule as soon as implementation of EDMS begins in their respective counties. The Clerk shall work with the local Court to identify specific documents that are to be scanned in each case type. Upon implementation of electronic filing in the County, the security level of these electronic records shall be as identified by the EDMS Business Advisory Committee. The Clerk shall send the Notice Regarding Electronic Filing to the attorneys and parties appearing pro se. Once notified, counsel of record or parties appearing pro se shall apply the rules pertaining to protection of personal privacy (Iowa Ct.R.16.602 through 16.607) to all future filings in that case. After being notified of commencement of the electronic filing in that County, attorneys, parties appearing pro se and all other shall file all future filings on that case electronically.

It is so Ordered: Dated 3rd day of November, 2010 /s/ Kurt L. Wilke Kurt L. Wilke, Chief Judge of the Second Judicial District of Iowa

Recipient List Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH Event Cd : E-FILED NOOT 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT DAVID POWELL JENNETT filed

E-FILED 2013 JUN 03 10:35 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 JUN 03 10:35 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 JUN 05 9:30 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 JUN 05 9:30 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 JUN 08 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 JUN 08 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 JUN 08 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

E-FILED 2013 JUN 13 3:42 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

IN THE IOWA DISTRICT COURT IN AND FOR SAC COUNTY

BROCO, LLC., Plaintiff, vs. TRENT MC ONO!"#, efen$ant Case No. LACV019374 ORDER CONTINUING HEARING

T%is &atte' is set fo' %ea'in( on )*ne 13t%, +013 at 9,00 a.&. in -a. Co*nt/, 0o1a. Atto'ne/ fo' t%e Plaintiff &a/ not 2e a2le to atten$ 2e.a*se of %is &ot%e'3s .on$ition. !n$e' t%e .i'.*&stan.es, t%is &atte' is %e'e2/ .ontin*e$ to a $ate to 2e $ete'&ine$ 2/ t%e Co*'t an$ atto'ne/s.

E-FILED 2013 JUN 13 3:42 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

State of Iowa Courts Type: Case Number LACV019374 ORDER FOR CONTINUANCE Case Title BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH So Ordered

Electronically signed on 2013-06-13 15:42:55

page 2 of 2

E-FILED 2013 JUN 17 9:27 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

Notice Id: 2CA004

IN THE IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

BROCO LLC, Plaintiff / Petitioner, vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH , Defendant / Respondent. Notice of Civil Trial Setting Conference Case No: 02811 LACV019374

A scheduling conference will be held on 06/25/13 at 11:00 AM with Kellie Orres, as District Court Designee, pursuant to I.R.C.P 1.602. This conference shall be conducted by telephone conference call initiated by plaintiff's counsel. Kellie Orres may be contacted via telephone at: (515) 574-3752. 1. PARTICIPATION: All attorneys appearing in the case shall participate in this conference. A party who is not represented by counsel shall contact the Court Administrator's office (at the above phone number) prior to the date and time of the conference call. 2. TRIAL SCHEDULING: A firm trial date shall be established in accordance with the Supreme Court's time standards as provided by Chapter 23, Iowa Court Rules. NO CONTINUANCES SHALL BE GRANTED EXCEPT BY COURT ORDER, UPON GOOD CAUSE SHOWN. 3. SANCTIONS: If a party or attorney fails to participate in the scheduling conference or is substantially unprepared to participate in the conference, the Court may impose appropriate sanctions, including reasonable expenses and attorney fees. (I.R.C.P 1.602(5)).

/s/ Kellie Orres --------------------------------------Designee of the Court Clerk to provide copies or notice of document to attorneys of record and parties appearing

E-FILED 2013 JUN 17 9:27 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

pro se.

Recipient List Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH Event Cd : E-FILED OFTN 2013 JUN 17 9:27 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT DAVID POWELL JENNETT JOSEPH JOHN HEIDENREICH filed filed

E-FILED 2013 JUL 02 11:52 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

Notice Id: 2CA101

IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

BROCO LLC, Plaintiff / Petitioner, vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH , Defendant / Respondent. Case No: 02811 LACV019374 Trial Notice

The above entitled matter is hereby scheduled for non-jury trial on 10/24/13 at 09:00 AM . 1 Day Damages Issue Discovery Due 60 days prior to trial

/s/ Kellie Orres ----------------------------------Designee of the Court

Clerk to provide copies or notice of this document to attorneys of record, parties appearing pro se and judge if assigned

Docket Code = OSTR

Recipient List Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH Event Cd : E-FILED OSTR 2013 JUL 02 11:52 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT DAVID POWELL JENNETT JOSEPH JOHN HEIDENREICH filed filed

E-FILED 2013 OCT 23 11:33 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

BROCO LLC, Plaintiff,


vs.

02811 LACV019374 ORDER OF CONTINUANCE

TRENT MCDONOUGH , Defendant.

Trial in the captioned matter has been set for October 24, 2013. The Court is unavailable on that date and finds that the trial should be continued. Counsel have no objection to the continuance.

This matter is continued, Non Jury Trial is scheduled on 10/30/2013 at 1:00 PM at the DISTRICT COURT - CIVIL.

Copies to: Plaintiff / Plaintiff's Attorney Defendant / Defendant's Attorney

1 of 2

E-FILED 2013 OCT 23 11:33 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

State of Iowa Courts Case Number LACV019374 Type: Case Title BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH ORDER FOR CONTINUANCE So Ordered

Electronically signed on 2013-10-23 11:33:43

2 of 2

E-FILED 2013 OCT 31 9:22 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

BROCO LLC, Plaintiff, vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH ,

Case No: 02811 LACV019374 EXHIBIT LIST Trial to the Court October 30, 2013 Presiding Judge: William C. Ostlund

Defendant.

The following exhibits were offered and admitted by the Court at the hearing as shown above: Plaintiff's 1. Photos 2. Rental Agreement 3. Bills for repairs 4. Rent payments 5. Wall Lake Lumber 6. Punch list 7. Diapers (not offered) 8. Damages

Defendant's 101. 102. check 103. Laursen Construction

1 of 2

E-FILED 2013 OCT 31 9:22 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

State of Iowa Courts Case Number LACV019374 Type: Case Title BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH EXHIBIT LIST So Ordered

Electronically signed on 2013-10-31 09:22:15

2 of 2

E-FILED 2013 OCT 31 9:24 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

2RCV12 IN THE IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY BROCO LLC, Plaintiff, vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH , Defendant. COURT REPORTER MEMORANDUM AND CERTIFICATE Case No. 02811 LACV019374

COURT REPORTER MEMORANDUM (The court reporter shall file this memorandum with the district court clerk.) Appearances: For Plaintiff/Petitioner: Joseph Heidenreich For Defendant/Respondent: David Jennett Other: Information required by Iowa Rule of Civil Procedure 1.903(3): I, Nancy A. Timmons, am providing the following information as required by Iowa Rule of Civil Procedure 1.903(3): 1. The type of proceeding that was reported: trial to the Court 2. The date(s) on which the proceeding occurred: October 30, 2013 3. The name of the court reporter who reported the proceeding: Nancy A. Timmons 4. The name of the judge who presided over the proceeding: William C. Ostlund 5. The reporting fee for the proceeding: $40.00 6. We, the undersigned judge before whom the above-entitled case was tried, and the official court reporter who, by order of the Court, reported the same, do hereby certify that the above and foregoing is the report of the whole proceedings upon the trial and/or hearing of the above-entitled cause made and taken pursuant to the order and direction of the Court, in accordance with Iowa Code Section 624.10. /s/Nancy A. Timmons _________________________________________
1 of 2

E-FILED 2013 OCT 31 9:24 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

State of Iowa Courts Case Number LACV019374 Type: Case Title BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH COURT REPORTER MEMORANDUM AND CERTIFICATE So Ordered

Electronically signed on 2013-10-31 09:23:42

2 of 2

E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY BROCO, LLC, Plaintiff, #$. TR*NT +'DONOU,-, D.f.n%ant. ) ) ) No. LACV019 !" ) ) Fin%in&$ of Fa't, ) Con'l($ion$ of La) an% R(lin& ) ) )

T/i$ 'ont.$t.% 0att.1 )a$ t1i.% to t/. Co(1t on O'to2.1 0, 301 . T/. a(t/o1i4.% a&.nt of t/. Plaintiff )a$ 51.$.nt alon& )it/ t/.i1 atto1n.6 7o$.5/ -.i%.n1.i'/. 7.nn.tt. T/. D.f.n%ant )a$ 51.$.nt 1.51.$.nt.% 26 /i$ atto1n.6 Da#i% T/. Co(1t /a$ 'on$i%.1.% t/. t.$ti0on6, t/. .#i%.n'. off.1.% an%

1.a'/.$ t/. follo)in& fin%in&$ of fa't, 'on'l($ion$ of la) an% 1(lin&. Findings of Fact C/('8 B1ot/.1ton t.$tifi.% a$ t/. a(t/o1i4.% 1.51.$.ntati#. of B1o'o. -. i$ al$o t/. C*O of Wall La8. L(02.1 Co05an6 an% o)n$ a n(02.1 of ot/.1 l(02.1 'o05ani.$. T/. 'o15o1ation o)n$ t/. 51o5.1t6 in 9(.$tion lo'at.% in Sa' Cit6, Io)a. It i$ a %(5l.: 'ontainin& a 8it'/.n, li#in& 1oo0, t)o 2.%1oo0$, a 2at/1oo0, an% &a1a&.. T/i$ 51o5.1t6 )a$ 2(ilt in 199; an% /a$ /a% t)o t.nant$. T/. t.nant 51.#io($ to t/. D.f.n%ant li#.% t/.1. fo1 .l.#.n 6.a1$. T/. D.f.n%ant /a$ li#.% t/.1. fo1 t)o 6.a1$, .:.1'i$in& a 1.ntal l.a$. 'o00.n'in& t/. 1$t %a6 of A(&($t, 3010, an% 1.$i%in& in t/. 51o5.1t6 (ntil /. l.ft a551o:i0at.l6 A51il 1, 3013. T/. 1.nt )a$ in t/. a0o(nt of <=>0. T/. l.a$. f(1t/.1 51o#i%.% t/at ?an6 noti'., fo1 )/i'/ 51o#i$ion i$ 0a%. in t/i$ 1.ntal a&1..0.nt, $/all 2. in )1itin& an% 0a6 2. &i#.n 26 .it/.1 5a1t6 to t/. ot/.1 in a%%ition to an6 ot/.1 0ann.1 51o#i%.% 26 la) . . .@ +1. B1ot/.1ton $tat.% t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 /a% 2..n ).ll 0aintain.% an% /a% 2..n 'l.an.% 51io1 to t/. l.a$. a&1..0.nt )it/ t/. D.f.n%ant an% )a$ 'l.an.% follo)in& /i$ .:it. S.1#i'.$ ).1. 51o#i%.% to t/. Plaintiff 26 t/. 'l.anin& 'o05an6 8no)n a$ t/. ?Co(nt16 Co($in$.@ It i$ t/. 'ont.ntion of t/. Plaintiff t/at t/. D.f.n%ant %i% not &i#. 51o5.1 noti'. of /i$ t.10ination of t/. l.a$. an% o).% on. 0ont/A$ 1.nt. In a%%ition, t/. Plaintiff

E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

a1&(.$ t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 )a$ l.ft in a $tat. of t.11i2l. 'l.anlin.$$ an% 5.10an.nt %a0a&. /a% 2..n %on. to t/. 51o5.1t6 )/i'/ 1.9(i1.% $(2$tantial 'l.anin& an% 1.5la'.0.nt. T/($, t/. la)$(it )a$ fil.% an% t/. o1i&inal 'o05laint all.&.% %a0a&.$ o).% in .:'.$$ of <!,000. An it.0i4ation of t/. .:5.n$.$ i$ 'ontain.% in an .:/i2it off.1.% to t/. Co(1t, )/i'/ t/. Co(1t /a$ ($.% a$ an o(tlin. fo1 it$ 1.'a5it(lation. T/.1. a1. a n(02.1 of it.0$ t/at )o(l% 2. 'on$i%.1.% $tan%a1% it.0$, 2(t al$o a%%itional .:5.n$.$ 1.lat.% to .:t1ao1%ina16 'l.anin&, 'l.anB(5 0at.1ial$ an% (n5ai% (tilit6 2ill$. -o).#.1, t/. a55a1.nt fi&/tin& i$$(. i$ t/. 1.5la'.0.nt of 'a15.t )it/in t/. 1.ntal 51o5.1t6. Plaintiff $tat.$ t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 )a$ 2.6on% 'l.anin& an% 1.5la'.0.nt )a$ 1.9(i1.%. S($an F1an8, )/o )a$ on. of t/. ?Co(nt16 Co($in$,@ t.$tifi.% t/at on A51il 13, 3013, $/. )a$ /i1.% to 'l.an t/. a5a1t0.nt. S/. al$o $tat.% t/at $/. 'l.an.% 2.fo1. t/. D.f.n%ant 0o#.% in. S/. $tat.% t/at t/. 'on%ition of t/. a5a1t0.nt 51io1 to D.f.n%ant )a$ &oo%, in'l(%in& t/. 'a15.tin&. S/. t.$tifi.% t/at aft.1 t/. D.f.n%ant /a% l.ft, t/. 51o5.1t6 )a$ ?51.tt6 na$t6.@ S/. $tat.% t/at t/. )all$ an% '.ilin&$ ).1. 2la'8 an% t/at t/. 'a15.t )a$ 2.6on% 2.in& 'l.an.%. T/. a55lian'.$ ).1. filt/6 an% in /.1 .$ti0ation, &1o$$. S/. $tat.% t/at t/. 'on%ition$ ).1. )o1$. t/an no10al. S/. $tat.% t/at &a12a&. /a% 2..n l.ft an% t/at it )a$ /.1 o5inion t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 /a% not 2..n 51o5.1l6 ta8.n 'a1. of. T/($, $/. $tat.% t/at t/. 2ill )a$ 0o1. t/an t/. o1%ina16 2(t )a$ 1.9(i1.% to 'l.an t/. 51o5.1t6 to a $(ita2l. 'on%ition. A n(02.1 of .:/i2it$ ).1. off.1.%, in'l(%in& *:/i2it 1, )/i'/ ).1. 5i't(1.$ ta8.n $(2$.9(.nt to t/. D.f.n%antA$ l.a#in&. T/.6 ).1. off.1.% to $(2$tantiat. t/. %i1t6 'on%ition t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 )a$ in follo)in& /i$ %.5a1t(1.. Ra'/.l B1ot/.1ton, )/o i$ 0a11i.% to C1ai& Ct/. &1an%$on of C/('8 B1ot/.1ton), t.$tifi.% a$ t/. 5/oto&1a5/.1 of t/. 5i't(1.$ i%.ntifi.% a$ *:/i2it 1. S/. 0.1.l6 $tat.% t/at $/. )o(l% not /a#. li#.% t/.1., %.$'1i2in& t/. 'on%ition$ a$ nonBli#a2l.. T/. Plaintiff a1&(.$ t/at on. 0ont/A$ 1.nt )a$ %(. a$ /. %i% not 1.'.i#. an6 noti'. of t/. D.f.n%antA$ l.a#in& o1 int.ntion to l.a#.. T/. D.f.n%ant t.$tifi.% t/at /. /a% li#.% t/.1. fo1 a 0.1. t)o 6.a1$, alon& )it/ /i$ $on. In fa't, /. $tat.% t/at t/. 1.$i%.n'. )a$ ($.% 0ainl6 a$ a $to5Bo#.1 2.'a($. /. t1a#.l.% .:t.n$i#.l6 an% %i% littl. .nt.1tainin& an% 'oo8in& 2

E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

on t/. 51o5.1t6. -. $tat.% t/at t/.1. )a$ .#i%.n'. of a2($. of t/. 51o5.1t6 )/.n /. 0o#.% in an% $tat.% t/at 0an6 of t/. 0a18$ on t/. floo1 ).1. t/. 1.$(lt of t/. t.nan'6 of t/. 51.#io($ .l.#.n 6.a1$. T/. D.f.n%antA$ $i$t.1 an% 0ot/.1 t.$tifi.% t/at t/.6 ).1. 'all.% (5on to /.l5 'l.an (5 t/. 51o5.1t6 )/.n T1.nt 0o#.% in. It )a$ t/.i1 o2$.1#ation t/at it )a$ %i1t6 an% t/at t/. 5la'. ?1..8.%@ of $0o8.. T/. D.f.n%ant .#.n $tat.% t/at /. /a% ($.% $i: o%o1 2o02$ to 'o(nt.1a't t/. $0.ll )/.n /. 0o#.% in. T/. D.f.n%ant $tat.% t/at /. )a$ t/. o)n.1 of nin. 1.ntal 51o5.1ti.$ an% )a$ fa0ilia1 )it/ t/. lan%lo1%A$ %(ti.$ an% o2li&ation$. T/. D.f.n%ant $tat.% t/at /. /a% tol% 7i0 +a$on Ct/. (noffi'ial 51o5.1t6 0ana&.1) of /i$ int.ntion$ to 0o#. an% 'on$i%.1.% t/at $(ffi'i.nt noti'. to t/. Plaintiff. In $/o1t, /. f.lt t/at /. )a$ not o2li&at.% fo1 t/. a%%itional 0ont/A$ 1.nt. Conclusions of Law and Ruling T/i$ la)$(it i$ %.'i%.% in la1&. 5a1t 2a$.% (5on t/. Co(1tA$ 5.1'.5tion of t/. '1.%i2ilit6 of t/. 5a1ti.$ in 'onD(n'tion )it/ t/. .:/i2it$. *:/i2it 1 'l.a1l6 .$ta2li$/.$ t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 )a$ in 5oo1 $/a5. )/.n t/. D.f.n%ant l.ft t/. 51o5.1t6. T/. t.$ti0on6 of S($an F1an8 )a$ #.16 $t1ai&/tfo1)a1% an% 'on'i$.. T/. Co(1t %.t.10in.$ t/at /.1 '1.%i2ilit6 $ li8.l6 (n9(.$tion.% an% /.1 %.$'1i5tion of t/. 51o5.1t6 a$ ?&1o$$@ an% ?51.tt6 na$t6@ i$ a''.5t.%. T/. Co(1t i$ l.$$ in'lin.% to 2.li.#. t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 1.9(i1.% $(2$tantial 'l.anin& 26 t/. D.f.n%ant o1 /i$ 0ot/.1 o1 $i$t.1 51io1 to /i$ 'o00.n'.0.nt of t/. l.a$.. On'. a&ain, t/. 5i't(1.$ .$ta2li$/ t/. %i$a11a6 of t/. 51o5.1t6 51io1 to it$ la$t 'l.anin&. T/. i$$(. of t/. 'a15.t i$ of 51i0a16 'on'.1n a$ t/. 'o$t of 'a15.tin& an% la2o1 total$ al0o$t < ,000. T/. Co(1t not.$ t/at t/. 51o5.1t6 )a$ 2(ilt in 199; an% t/. 'a15.t /a$ 2..n t/.1. fo1 fift..n 6.a1$. #al(. of a551o:i0at.l6 t).nt6 6.a1$. Of t/i$ ti0., it )a$ in/a2it.% fo1 at l.a$t 1 6.a1$. In 0o$t in$tan'.$, 'a15.tin& /a$ a %.51.'iation T/($, t/. Co(1t %.t.10in.$ t/at it i$ (n1.a$ona2l. fo1 t/. Plaintiff to .:5.'t t/. D.f.n%ant to 2.a1 t/. .nti1. 'o$t of 'a15.tin& )/i'/ 0o$t li8.l6 )o(l% 2. 1.5la'.% )it/in a 1.a$ona2l. a0o(nt of ti0.. U$in& t/at fo10(la, t/. Co(1t %.t.10in.$ t/at E of t/. lif. of t/. 'a15.t /a% 2..n ($.% an% t/. %a0a&. %on. 26 t/. D.f.n%ant 1.51.$.nt$ F of t/. #al(.. Finall6, t/. Co(1t %.t.10in.$ t/at t/. a%%ition 0ont/A$ 1.nt i$ in%..% %(.. T/. 3

E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

D.f.n%ant 'annot ($. i&no1an'. o1 la'8 of /i$ (n%.1$tan%in& of o2li&ation$ in #i.) of t/. fa't t/at /. /a$ a n(02.1 of 1.ntal 51o5.1ti.$ /i0$.lf. Noti'. in t/. fo10 of a 'on#.1$ation to an6on. 2(t t/. Plaintiff )o(l% 2. 'on$i%.1.% in$(ffi'i.nt an% t/($ t/. 1.nt i$ %(.. In 'on'l($ion, t/. Co(1t )o(l% %i1.'t t/. 5a1ti.$A att.ntion to Co(1t *:/i2it A )/i'/ i$ t/. 1.'a5it(lation of %a0a&.$ o).% 26 t/. D.f.n%ant to t/. Plaintiff. 7(%&0.nt i$ .nt.1.% in fa#o1 of t/. Plaintiff in t/. a0o(nt of < ,1"=.0! 5l($ 'o(1t 'o$t$.

Cl.18 to fo1)a1% 'o5i.$ toG 7o$.5/ -.i%.n1.i'/ Da#i% 7.nn.tt

E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

COURT *H-IBIT A Bo6intonA$ -a1%)a1. C'l.anB(5 0at.1ial$) ,a1a&. Doo1 S(55l6 Co(nt16 Co($in$ C'l.anin& la%i.$) +i%BA0.1i'an La5.l La)n S.1#i'. C1.5ai1 )o18 on 6a1%) Wat.1I$.).1 Ca15.t an% la2o1 C<=;= J 331") : 3>K R.nt Cin'l(%in& int.1.$t) < = .9; 1>.=0 1," !.>0 ".3> 130.00 "1.!" !!>.00 !0;.00 LLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL < ,1"=.0!

E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

State of Iowa Courts Type: Case Number LACV019374 OTHER ORDER Case Title BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH So Ordered

Electronically signed on 2013-11-20 13:38:27

page 6 of 6

You might also like