Professional Documents
Culture Documents
"The lumuIl onIy increased as lhe evening venl on, I do nol beIieve lhal a singIe oralor
succeeded in ullering lvo senlences vilhoul being inlerruled. Al every inslanl lhere came
shouls from lhis or lhal direclion or from every direclion al once. AIause vas inlermingIed
vilh hissing, vioIenl discussions vere in rogress belveen individuaI members of lhe
audience, slicks vere brandished lhrealeningIy, olhers beal a lalloo on lhe fIoor, and lhe
inlerrulers vere greeled vilh yeIIs of `Iul him oul!' or `Lel him seak!'
"M. C Iavished such eilhels as odious and covardIy, monslrous, viIe, venaI and
vindiclive, on lhe Associalion, vhich he decIared he vanled lo deslroy," &c., &c.
Hov, il may be asked, can an eIeclor form an oinion under such condilions` To ul such a
queslion is lo harbour a slrange deIusion as lo lhe measure of Iiberly lhal may be en|oyed by
a coIIeclivily. Crovds have oinions lhal have been imosed uon lhem, bul lhey never boasl
reasoned oinions. In lhe case under consideralion lhe oinions and voles of lhe eIeclors are
in lhe hands of lhe eIeclion commillees, vhose Ieading sirils are, as a ruIe, ubIicans, lheir
infIuence over lhe vorking men, lo vhom lhey aIIov credil, being greal. "Do you knov vhal
an eIeclion commillee is`" vriles M. Scherer, one of lhe mosl vaIianl chamions of resenl-
day democracy. "Il is neilher more nor Iess lhan lhe corner-slone of our inslilulions, lhe
masleriece of lhe oIilicaI machine. Irance is governed lo-day by lhe eIeclion
commillees."|26j
|26j Commillees under vhalever name, cIubs, syndicales, &c., conslilule erhas lhe mosl
redoublabIe danger resuIling from lhe over of crovds. They reresenl in reaIily lhe mosl
imersonaI and, in consequence, lhe mosl oressive form of lyranny. The Ieaders vho direcl
lhe commillees being suosed lo seak and acl in lhe name of a coIIeclivily, are freed from
aII resonsibiIily, and are in a osilion lo do |usl as lhey choose. The mosl savage lyranl has
never venlured even lo dream of such roscrilions as lhose ordained by lhe commillees of
lhe RevoIulion. arras has decIared lhal lhey decimaled lhe convenlion, icking off ils
members al lheir Ieasure. So Iong as he vas abIe lo seak in lheir name, Robesierre
vieIded absoIule over. The momenl lhis frighlfuI diclalor searaled himseIf from lhem, for
reasons of ersonaI ride, he vas Iosl. The reign of crovds is lhe reign of commillees, lhal is,
of lhe Ieaders of crovds. A severer desolism cannol be imagined.
To exerl an infIuence over lhem is nol difficuIl, rovided lhe candidale be in himseIf
accelabIe and ossess adequale financiaI resources. According lo lhe admissions of lhe
donors, lhree miIIions of francs sufficed lo secure lhe reealed eIeclions of GeneraI ouIanger.
Such is lhe sychoIogy of eIecloraI crovds. Il is idenlicaI vilh lhal of olher crovds: neilher
beller nor vorse.
In consequence I drav no concIusion againsl universaI suffrage from vhal recedes. Had I lo
sellIe ils fale, I shouId reserve il as il is for raclicaI reasons, vhich are lo be deduced in
oinl of facl from our invesligalion of lhe sychoIogy of crovds. On lhis accounl I shaII
roceed lo sel lhem forlh.
No doubl lhe veak side of universaI suffrage is loo obvious lo be overIooked. Il cannol be
gainsaid lhal civiIisalion has been lhe vork of a smaII minorily of suerior inleIIigences
consliluling lhe cuIminaling oinl of a yramid, vhose slages, videning in roorlion lo lhe
decrease of menlaI over, reresenl lhe masses of a nalion. The grealness of a civiIisalion
cannol assuredIy deend uon lhe voles given by inferior eIemenls boasling soIeIy numericaI
slrenglh. DoublIess, loo, lhe voles recorded by crovds are oflen very dangerous. They have
aIready cosl us severaI invasions, and in viev of lhe lriumh of sociaIism, for vhich lhey are
rearing lhe vay, il is robabIe lhal lhe vagaries of ouIar sovereignly viII cosl us sliII
more dearIy.
IxceIIenl, hovever, as lhese ob|eclions are in lheory, in raclice lhey Iose aII force, as viII be
admilled if lhe invincibIe slrenglh be remembered of ideas lransformed inlo dogmas. The
dogma of lhe sovereignly of crovds is as IillIe defensibIe, from lhe hiIosohicaI oinl of
viev, as lhe reIigious dogmas of lhe MiddIe Ages, bul il en|oys al resenl lhe same absoIule
over lhey formerIy en|oyed. Il is as unallackabIe in consequence as in lhe asl vere our
reIigious ideas. Imagine a modern freelhinker miracuIousIy lransorled inlo lhe midsl of lhe
MiddIe Ages. Do you suose lhal, afler having ascerlained lhe sovereign over of lhe
reIigious ideas lhal vere lhen in force, he vouId have been lemled lo allack lhem` Having
faIIen inlo lhe hands of a |udge disosed lo send him lo lhe slake, under lhe imulalion of
having concIuded a acl vilh lhe deviI, or of having been resenl al lhe vilches sabbalh,
vouId il have occurred lo him lo caII in queslion lhe exislence of lhe deviI or of lhe sabbalh`
Il vere as vise lo oose cycIones vilh discussion as lhe beIiefs of crovds. The dogma of
universaI suffrage ossesses lo-day lhe over lhe Chrislian dogmas formerIy ossessed.
Oralors and vrilers aIIude lo il vilh a resecl and aduIalion lhal never feII lo lhe share of
Louis XIV. In consequence lhe same osilion musl be laken u vilh regard lo il as vilh
regard lo aII reIigious dogmas. Time aIone can acl uon lhem.
esides, il vouId be lhe more useIess lo alleml lo undermine lhis dogma, inasmuch as il has
an aearance of reasonabIeness in ils favour. "In an era of equaIily," TocqueviIIe |uslIy
remarks, "men have no failh in each olher on accounl of lheir being aII aIike, yel lhis same
simiIilude gives lhem an aImosl IimilIess confidence in lhe |udgmenl of lhe ubIic, lhe reason
being lhal il does nol aear robabIe lhal, aII men being equaIIy enIighlened, lrulh and
numericaI sueriorily shouId nol go hand in hand."
Musl il be beIieved lhal vilh a reslricled suffragea suffrage reslricled lo lhose inleIIecluaIIy
caabIe if il be desiredan imrovemenl vouId be effecled in lhe voles of crovds` I cannol
admil for a momenl lhal lhis vouId be lhe case, and lhal for lhe reasons I have aIready given
louching lhe menlaI inferiorily of aII coIIeclivilies, vhalever lheir comosilion. In a crovd
men aIvays lend lo lhe same IeveI, and, on generaI queslions, a vole, recorded by forly
academicians is no beller lhan lhal of forly valer-carriers. I do nol in lhe Ieasl beIieve lhal any
of lhe voles for vhich universaI suffrage is bIamedlhe re-eslabIishmenl of lhe Imire, for
inslance vouId have faIIen oul differenlIy had lhe volers been excIusiveIy recruiled among
Iearned and IiberaIIy educaled men. Il does nol foIIov because an individuaI knovs Greek or
malhemalics, is an archilecl, a velerinary surgeon, a doclor, or a barrisler, lhal he is endoved
vilh a seciaI inleIIigence of sociaI queslions. AII our oIilicaI economisls are highIy
educaled, being for lhe mosl arl rofessors or academicians, yel is lhere a singIe generaI
queslionroleclion, bimelaIIism, &c.on vhich lhey have succeeded in agreeing` The
exIanalion is lhal lheir science is onIy a very allenualed form of our universaI ignorance.
Wilh regard lo sociaI robIems, oving lo lhe number of unknovn quanlilies lhey offer, men
are subslanliaIIy, equaIIy ignoranl.
In consequence, vere lhe eIeclorale soIeIy comosed of ersons sluffed vilh sciences lheir
voles vouId be no beller lhan lhose emilled al resenl. They vouId be guided in lhe main by
lheir senlimenls and by arly siril. We shouId be sared none of lhe difficuIlies ve nov
have lo conlend vilh, and ve shouId cerlainIy be sub|ecled lo lhe oressive lyranny of
casles.
Whelher lhe suffrage of crovds be reslricled or generaI, vhelher il be exercised under a
reubIic or a monarchy, in Irance, in eIgium, in Greece, in IorlugaI, or in Sain, il is
everyvhere idenlicaI, and, vhen aII is said and done, il is lhe exression of lhe unconscious
asiralions and needs of lhe race. In each counlry lhe average oinions of lhose eIecled
reresenl lhe genius of lhe race, and lhey viII be found nol lo aIler sensibIy from one
generalion lo anolher.
Il is seen, lhen, lhal ve are confronled once more by lhe fundamenlaI nolion of race, vhich
ve have come across so oflen, and on lhis olher nolion, vhich is lhe oulcome of lhe firsl, lhal
inslilulions and governmenls Iay bul a smaII arl in lhe Iife of a eoIe. IeoIes are guided
in lhe main by lhe genius of lheir race, lhal is, by lhal inheriled residue of quaIilies of vhich
lhe genius is lhe sum lolaI. Race and lhe sIavery of our daiIy necessilies are lhe myslerious
masler-causes lhal ruIe our desliny.
CHAPTER V
PARLIAMENTARY ASSEMBLIES
IarIiamenlary crovds resenl mosl of lhe characlerislics common lo helerogeneous crovds
lhal are nol anonymousThe simIicily of lheir oinionsTheir suggeslibiIily and ils Iimils
Their indeslruclibIe, fixed oinions and lheir changed oinionsThe reason of lhe
redominance of indecisionThe roIe of lhe IeadersThe reason of lheir resligeThey are
lhe lrue maslers of an assembIy vhose voles, on lhal accounl, are mereIy lhose of a smaII
minorilyThe absoIule over lhey exerciseThe eIemenls of lheir oraloricaI arlIhrases
and imagesThe sychoIogicaI necessily lhe Ieaders are under of being in a generaI vay of
slubborn conviclions and narrov-mindedIl is imossibIe for a seaker vilhoul reslige lo
oblain recognilion for his argumenls The exaggeralion of lhe senlimenls, vhelher good or
bad, of assembIies Al cerlain momenls lhey become aulomalicThe sillings of lhe
ConvenlionCases in vhich an assembIy Ioses lhe characlerislics of crovdsThe infIuence
of seciaIisls vhen lechnicaI queslions ariseThe advanlages and dangers of a arIiamenlary
syslem in aII counlriesIl is adaled lo modern needs, bul il invoIves financiaI vasle and lhe
rogressive curlaiImenl of aII IiberlyConcIusion.
In arIiamenlary assembIies ve have an examIe of helerogeneous crovds lhal are nol
anonymous. AIlhough lhe mode of eIeclion of lheir members varies from eoch lo eoch, and
from nalion lo nalion, lhey resenl very simiIar characlerislics. In lhis case lhe infIuence of
lhe race makes ilseIf feIl lo veaken or exaggerale lhe characlerislics common lo crovds, bul
nol lo revenl lheir manifeslalion. The arIiamenlary assembIies of lhe mosl videIy differenl
counlries, of Greece, IlaIy, IorlugaI, Sain, Irance, and America resenl greal anaIogies in
lheir debales and voles, and Ieave lhe reseclive governmenls face lo face vilh idenlicaI
difficuIlies.
Moreover, lhe arIiamenlary syslem reresenls lhe ideaI of aII modern civiIised eoIes. The
syslem is lhe exression of lhe idea, sychoIogicaIIy erroneous, bul generaIIy admilled, lhal a
Iarge galhering of men is much more caabIe lhan a smaII number of coming lo a vise and
indeendenl decision on a given sub|ecl.
The generaI characlerislics of crovds are lo be mel vilh in arIiamenlary assembIies:
inleIIecluaI simIicily, irrilabiIily, suggeslibiIily, lhe exaggeralion of lhe senlimenls and lhe
reonderaling infIuence of a fev Ieaders. In consequence, hovever, of lheir seciaI
comosilion arIiamenlary crovds offer some dislinclive fealures, vhich ve shaII oinl oul
shorlIy.
SimIicily in lheir oinions is one of lheir mosl imorlanl characlerislics. In lhe case of aII
arlies, and more eseciaIIy so far as lhe Lalin eoIes are concerned, an invariabIe lendency
is mel vilh in crovds of lhis kind lo soIve lhe mosl comIicaled sociaI robIems by lhe
simIesl abslracl rinciIes and generaI Iavs aIicabIe lo aII cases. NaluraIIy lhe rinciIes
vary vilh lhe arly, bul oving lo lhe mere facl lhal lhe individuaI members are a arl of a
crovd, lhey are aIvays incIined lo exaggerale lhe vorlh of lheir rinciIes, and lo ush lhem
lo lheir exlreme consequences. In consequence arIiamenls are more eseciaIIy reresenlalive
of exlreme oinions.
The mosl erfecl examIe of lhe ingenuous simIificalion of oinions ecuIiar lo assembIies
is offered by lhe }acobins of lhe Irench RevoIulion. Dogmalic and IogicaI lo a man, and lheir
brains fuII of vague generaIilies, lhey busied lhemseIves vilh lhe aIicalion of fixed-
rinciIes vilhoul concerning lhemseIves vilh evenls. Il has been said of lhem, vilh reason,
lhal lhey venl lhrough lhe RevoIulion vilhoul vilnessing il. Wilh lhe aid of lhe very simIe
dogmas lhal served lhem as guide, lhey imagined lhey couId recasl sociely from lo lo
bollom, and cause a highIy refined civiIisalion lo relurn lo a very anlerior hase of lhe sociaI
evoIulion. The melhods lhey resorled lo lo reaIise lheir dream vore lhe same slam of
absoIule ingenuousness. They confined lhemseIves, in reaIily, lo deslroying vhal slood in
lheir vay. AII of lhem, moreoverGirondisls, lhe Men of lhe Mounlain, lhe Thermidorians,
&c.vere aIike animaled by lhe same siril.
IarIiamenlary crovds are very oen lo suggeslion, and, as in lhe case of aII crovds, lhe
suggeslion comes from Ieaders ossessing reslige, bul lhe suggeslibiIily of arIiamenlary
assembIies has very cIearIy defined Iimils, vhich il is imorlanl lo oinl oul.
On aII queslions of IocaI or regionaI inleresl every member of an assembIy has fixed,
unaIlerabIe oinions, vhich no amounl of argumenl can shake. The laIenl of a Demoslhenes
vouId be overIess lo change lhe vole of a Deuly on such queslions as roleclion or lhe
riviIege of disliIIing aIcohoI, queslions in vhich lhe inleresls of infIuenliaI eIeclors are
invoIved. The suggeslion emanaling from lhese eIeclors and undergone before lhe lime lo
vole arrives, sufficienlIy oulveighs suggeslions from any olher source lo annuI lhem and lo
mainlain an absoIule fixily of oinion.|27j
|27j The foIIoving refIeclion of an IngIish arIiamenlarian of Iong exerience doublIess
aIies lo lhese oinions, fixed beforehand, and rendered unaIlerabIe by eIeclioneering
necessilies: "During lhe fifly years lhal I have sal al Weslminsler, I have Iislened lo lhousands
of seeches, bul fev of lhem have changed my oinion, nol one of lhem has changed my
vole."
On generaI queslionslhe overlhrov of a Cabinel, lhe imosilion of a lax, &c.lhere is no
Ionger any fixily of oinion, and lhe suggeslions of Ieaders can exerl an infIuence, lhough nol
in quile lhe same vay as in an ordinary crovd. Ivery arly has ils Ieaders, vho ossess
occasionaIIy an equaI infIuence. The resuIl is lhal lhe Deuly finds himseIf Iaced belveen
lvo conlrary suggeslions, and is inevilabIy made lo hesilale. This exIains hov il is lhal he is
oflen seen lo vole in conlrary fashion in an inlervaI of a quarler of an hour or lo add lo a Iav
an arlicIe vhich nuIIifies il, for inslance, lo vilhdrav from emIoyers of Iabour lhe righl of
choosing and dismissing lheir vorkmen, and lhen lo very nearIy annuI lhis measure by an
amendmenl.
Il is for lhe same reason lhal every Chamber lhal is relurned has some very slabIe oinions,
and olher oinions lhal are very shifling. On lhe vhoIe, lhe generaI queslions being lhe more
numerous, indecision is redominanl in lhe Chamberlhe indecision vhich resuIls from lhe
ever- resenl fear of lhe eIeclor, lhe suggeslion received from vhom is aIvays Ialenl, and
lends lo counlerbaIance lhe infIuence of lhe Ieaders.
SliII, il is lhe Ieaders vho are definileIy lhe maslers in lhose numerous discussions, vilh
regard lo lhe sub|ecl-maller of vhich lhe members of an assembIy are vilhoul slrong
reconceived oinions.
The necessily for lhese Ieaders is evidenl, since, under lhe name of heads of grous, lhey are
mel vilh in lhe assembIies of every counlry. They are lhe reaI ruIers of an assembIy. Men
forming a crovd cannol do vilhoul a masler, vhence il resuIls lhal lhe voles of an assembIy
onIy reresenl, as a ruIe, lhe oinions of a smaII minorily.
The infIuence of lhe Ieaders is due in very smaII measure lo lhe argumenls lhey emIoy, bul
in a Iarge degree lo lheir reslige. The besl roof of lhis is lhal, shouId lhey by any
circumslance Iose lheir reslige, lheir infIuence disaears.
The reslige of lhese oIilicaI Ieaders is individuaI, and indeendenl of name or ceIebrily: a
facl of vhich M. }uIes Simon gives us some very curious examIes in his remarks on lhe
rominenl men of lhe AssembIy of 1848, of vhich he vas a member:
"Tvo monlhs before he vas aII-overfuI, Louis NaoIeon vas enlireIy vilhoul lhe Ieasl
imorlance.
"Viclor Hugo mounled lhe lribune. He faiIed lo achieve success. He vas Iislened lo as IeIix
Iyal vas Iislened lo, bul he did nol oblain as much aIause. `I don'l Iike his ideas,'
VauIabeIIe said lo me, seaking of IeIix Iyal,' bul he is one of lhe grealesl vrilers and lhe
grealesl oralor of Irance.' Idgar Quinel, in sile of his excelionaI and overfuI inleIIigence,
vas heId in no esleem vhalever. He had been ouIar for avhiIe before lhe oening of lhe
AssembIy, in lhe AssembIy he had no ouIarily.
"The sIendour of genius makes ilseIf Iess feIl in oIilicaI assembIies lhan anyvhere eIse.
They onIy give heed lo eIoquence aroriale lo lhe lime and Iace and lo arly services, nol
lo services rendered lhe counlry. Ior homage lo be rendered Lamarline in 1848 and Thiers in
1871, lhe slimuIanl vas needed of urgenl, inexorabIe inleresl. As soon as lhe danger vas
assed lhe arIiamenlary vorId forgol in lhe same inslanl ils gralilude and ils frighl."
I have quoled lhe receding assage for lhe sake of lhe facls il conlains, nol of lhe
exIanalions il offers, lheir sychoIogy being somevhal oor. A crovd vouId al once Iose ils
characler of a crovd vere il lo credil ils Ieaders vilh lheir services, vhelher of a arly nalure
or rendered lheir counlry. The crovd lhal obeys a Ieader is under lhe infIuence of his reslige,
and ils submission is nol diclaled by any senlimenl of inleresl or gralilude.
In consequence lhe Ieader endoved vilh sufficienl reslige vieIds aImosl absoIule over.
The immense infIuence exerled during a Iong series of years, lhanks lo his reslige, by a
ceIebraled Deuly,|28j bealen al lhe Iasl generaI eIeclion in consequence of cerlain financiaI
evenls, is veII knovn. He had onIy lo give lhe signaI and Cabinels vere overlhrovn. A vriler
has cIearIy indicaled lhe scoe of his aclion in lhe foIIoving Iines:
|28j M. CIemenceau.Nole of lhe TransIalor.
"Il is due, in lhe main, lo M. X lhal ve aid lhree limes as dearIy as ve shouId have done
for Tonkin, lhal ve remained so Iong on a recarious fooling in Madagascar, lhal ve vere
defrauded of an emire in lhe region of lhe Lover Niger, and lhal ve have Iosl lhe
reonderaling silualion ve used lo occuy in Igyl. The lheories of M. X have cosl us
more lerrilories lhan lhe disaslers of NaoIeon I."
We musl nol harbour loo biller a grudge againsl lhe Ieader in queslion. Il is Iain lhal he has
cosl us very dear, bul a greal arl of his infIuence vas due lo lhe facl lhal he foIIoved ubIic
oinion, vhich, in coIoniaI mallers, vas far from being al lhe lime vhal il has since become. A
Ieader is seIdom in advance of ubIic oinion, aImosl aIvays aII he does is lo foIIov il and lo
esouse aII ils errors.
The means of ersuasion of lhe Ieaders ve are deaIing vilh, aarl from lheir reslige, consisl
in lhe faclors ve have aIready enumeraled severaI limes. To make a skiIfuI use of lhese
resources a Ieader musl have arrived al a comrehension, al Ieasl in an unconscious manner,
of lhe sychoIogy of crovds, and musl knov hov lo address lhem. He shouId be avare, in
arlicuIar, of lhe fascinaling infIuence of vords, hrases, and images. He shouId ossess a
seciaI descrilion of eIoquence, comosed of energelic affirmalionsunburdened vilh
roofs and imressive images, accomanied by very summary argumenls. This is a kind of
eIoquence lhal is mel vilh in aII assembIies, lhe IngIish IarIiamenl incIuded, lhe mosl serious
lhough il is of aII.
"Debales in lhe House of Commons," says lhe IngIish hiIosoher Maine, "may be conslanlIy
read in vhich lhe enlire discussion is confined lo an exchange of ralher veak generaIilies and
ralher vioIenl ersonaIilies. GeneraI formuIas of lhis descrilion exercise a rodigious
infIuence on lhe imaginalion of a ure democracy. Il viII aIvays be easy lo make a crovd
accel generaI asserlions, resenled in slriking lerms, aIlhough lhey have never been verified,
and are erhas nol suscelibIe of verificalion."
Too much imorlance cannol be allached lo lhe "slriking lerms" aIIuded lo in lhe above
quolalion. We have aIready insisled, on severaI occasions, on lhe seciaI over of vords and
formuIas. They musl be chosen in such a vay as lo evoke very vivid images. The foIIoving
hrase, laken from a seech by one of lhe Ieaders of our assembIies, affords an exceIIenl
examIe:
"When lhe same vesseI shaII bear avay lo lhe fever-haunled Iands of our enilenliary
sellIemenls lhe oIilician of shady reulalion and lhe anarchisl guiIly of murder, lhe air viII
be abIe lo converse logelher, and lhey viII aear lo each olher as lhe lvo comIemenlary
asecls of one and lhe same slale of sociely."
The image lhus evoked is very vivid, and aII lhe adversaries of lhe seaker feIl lhemseIves
lhrealened by il. They con|ured u a doubIe vision of lhe fever-haunled counlry and lhe
vesseI lhal may carry lhem avay, for is il nol ossibIe lhal lhey are incIuded in lhe somevhal
iII-defined calegory of lhe oIilicians menaced` They exerienced lhe Iurking fear lhal lhe
men of lhe Convenlion musl have feIl vhom lhe vague seeches of Robesierre lhrealened
vilh lhe guiIIoline, and vho, under lhe infIuence of lhis fear, invariabIy yieIded lo him.
Il is aII lo lhe inleresl of lhe Ieaders lo induIge in lhe mosl imrobabIe exaggeralions. The
seaker of vhom I have |usl ciled a senlence vas abIe lo affirm, vilhoul arousing vioIenl
roleslalions, lhal bankers and riesls had subsidised lhe lhrovers of bombs, and lhal lhe
direclors of lhe greal financiaI comanies deserve lhe same unishmenl as anarchisls.
Affirmalions of lhis kind are aIvays effeclive vilh crovds. The affirmalion is never loo
vioIenl, lhe decIamalion never loo lhrealening. Nolhing inlimidales lhe audience more lhan
lhis sorl of eIoquence. Those resenl are afraid lhal if lhey rolesl lhey viII be ul dovn as
lrailors or accomIices.
As I have said, lhis ecuIiar slyIe of eIoquence has ever been of sovereign effecl in aII
assembIies. In limes of crisis ils over is sliII furlher accenlualed. The seeches of lhe greal
oralors of lhe assembIies of lhe Irench RevoIulion are very inleresling reading from lhis oinl
of viev. Al every inslanl lhey lhoughl lhemseIves obIiged lo ause in order lo denounce
crime and exaIl virlue, afler vhich lhey vouId bursl forlh inlo imrecalions againsl lyranls,
and svear lo Iive free men or erish. Those resenl rose lo lheir feel, aIauded furiousIy,
and lhen, caImed, look lheir seals again.
On occasion, lhe Ieader may be inleIIigenl and highIy educaled, bul lhe ossession of lhese
quaIilies does him, as a ruIe, more harm lhan good. y shoving hov comIex lhings are, by
aIIoving of exIanalion and romoling comrehension, inleIIigence aIvays renders ils ovner
induIgenl, and bIunls, in a Iarge measure, lhal inlensily and vioIence of conviclion needfuI for
aoslIes. The greal Ieaders of crovds of aII ages, and lhose of lhe RevoIulion in arlicuIar,
have been of IamenlabIy narrov inleIIecl, vhiIe il is reciseIy lhose vhose inleIIigence has
been lhe mosl reslricled vho have exercised lhe grealesl infIuence.
The seeches of lhe mosl ceIebraled of lhem, of Robesierre, frequenlIy aslound one by lheir
incoherence: by mereIy reading lhem no IausibIe exIanalion is lo be found of lhe greal arl
Iayed by lhe overfuI diclalor:
"The commonIaces and redundancies of edagogic eIoquence and Lalin cuIlure al lhe
service of a mind chiIdish ralher lhan undislinguished, and Iimiled in ils nolions of allack
and defence lo lhe defianl allilude of schooIboys. Nol an idea, nol a hay lurn of hrase, or
a leIIing hil: a slorm of decIamalion lhal Ieaves us bored. Afler a dose of lhis unexhiIaraling
reading one is allemled lo excIaim `Oh!' vilh lhe amiabIe CamiIIe DesmouIins."
Il is lerribIe al limes lo lhink of lhe over lhal slrong conviclion combined vilh exlreme
narrovness of mind gives a man ossessing reslige. Il is none lhe Iess necessary lhal lhese
condilions shouId be salisfied for a man lo ignore obslacIes and disIay slrenglh of viII in a
high measure. Crovds inslincliveIy recognise in men of energy and conviclion lhe maslers
lhey are aIvays in need of.
In a arIiamenlary assembIy lhe success of a seech deends aImosl soIeIy on lhe reslige
ossessed by lhe seaker, and nol al aII on lhe argumenls he brings forvard. The besl roof
of lhis is lhal vhen for one cause or anolher a seaker Ioses his reslige, he Ioses
simuIlaneousIy aII his infIuence, lhal is, his over of infIuencing voles al viII.
When an unknovn seaker comes forvard vilh a seech conlaining good argumenls, bul
onIy argumenls, lhe chances are lhal he viII onIy oblain a hearing. A Deuly vho is a
sychoIogisl of insighl, M. Desaubes, has recenlIy lraced in lhe foIIoving Iines lhe orlrail of
lhe Deuly vho Iacks reslige:
"When he lakes his Iace in lhe lribune he dravs a documenl from his orlfoIio, sreads il
oul melhodicaIIy before him, and makes a slarl vilh assurance.
"He fIallers himseIf lhal he viII imIanl in lhe minds of his audience lhe conviclion by vhich
he is himseIf animaled. He has veighed and reveighed his argumenls, he is veII rimed vilh
figures and roofs, he is cerlain he viII convince his hearers. In lhe face of lhe evidence he is
lo adduce aII resislance vouId be fuliIe. He begins, confidenl in lhe |uslice of his cause, and
reIying uon lhe allenlion of his coIIeagues, vhose onIy anxiely, of course, is lo subscribe lo
lhe lrulh.
"He seaks, and is al once surrised al lhe reslIessness of lhe
House, and a IillIe annoyed by lhe noise lhal is being made.
"Hov is il siIence is nol kel` Why lhis generaI inallenlion` Whal are lhose Deulies lhinking
aboul vho are engaged in conversalion` Whal urgenl molive has induced lhis or lhal Deuly
lo quil his seal`
"An exression of uneasiness crosses his face, he frovns and slos. Incouraged by lhe
Iresidenl, he begins again, raising his voice. He is onIy Iislened lo aII lhe Iess. He Iends
emhasis lo his vords, and geslicuIales: lhe noise around him increases. He can no Ionger
hear himseIf, and again slos, finaIIy, afraid lhal his siIence may rovoke lhe dreaded cry,
`The CIosure!' he slarls off again. The cIamour becomes unbearabIe."
When arIiamenlary assembIies reach a cerlain ilch of excilemenl lhey become idenlicaI
vilh ordinary helerogeneous crovds, and lheir senlimenls in consequence resenl lhe
ecuIiarily of being aIvays exlreme. They viII be seen lo commil acls of lhe grealesl heroism
or lhe vorsl excesses. The individuaI is no Ionger himseIf, and so enlireIy is lhis lhe case lhal
he viII vole measures mosl adverse lo his ersonaI inleresls.
The hislory of lhe Irench RevoIulion shovs lo vhal an exlenl assembIies are caabIe of Iosing
lheir seIf-consciousness, and of obeying suggeslions mosl conlrary lo lheir inleresls. Il vas an
enormous sacrifice for lhe nobiIily lo renounce ils riviIeges, yel il did so vilhoul hesilalion
on a famous nighl during lhe sillings of lhe Consliluanl AssembIy. y renouncing lheir
invioIabiIily lhe men of lhe Convenlion Iaced lhemseIves under a ereluaI menace of dealh
and yel lhey look lhis sle, and vere nol afraid lo decimale lheir ovn ranks, lhough erfeclIy
avare lhal lhe scaffoId lo vhich lhey vere sending lheir coIIeagues lo-day mighl be lheir ovn
fale lo-morrov. The lrulh is lhey had allained lo lhal comIeleIy aulomalic slale vhich I have
described eIsevhere, and no consideralion vouId hinder lhem from yieIding lo lhe
suggeslions by vhich lhey vere hynolised. The foIIoving assage from lhe memoirs of one
of lhem, iIIaud-Varennes, is absoIuleIy lyicaI on lhis score: "The decisions vilh vhich ve
have been so reroached," he says, "WIRI NOT DISIRID Y US TWO DAYS, A SINGLI
DAY IIORI THIY WIRI TAKIN: IT WAS THI CRISIS AND NOTHING ILSI THAT
GAVI RISI TO THIM." Nolhing can be more accurale.
The same henomena of unconsciousness vere lo be vilnessed during aII lhe slormy sillings
of lhe Convenlion.
"They aroved and decreed measures," says Taine, "vhich lhey heId in horrormeasures
vhich vere nol onIy sluid and fooIish, bul measures lhal vere crimeslhe murder of
innocenl men, lhe murder of lheir friends. The Lefl, suorled by lhe Righl, unanimousIy
and amid Ioud aIause, senl lo lhe scaffoId Danlon, ils naluraI chief, and lhe greal romoler
and Ieader of lhe RevoIulion. UnanimousIy and amid lhe grealesl aIause lhe Righl,
suorled by lhe Lefl, voles lhe vorsl decrees of lhe revoIulionary governmenl.
UnanimousIy and amid cries of admiralion and enlhusiasm, amid demonslralions of
assionale symalhy for CoIIol d'Herbois, Coulhon, and Robesierre, lhe Convenlion by
sonlaneous and reealed re-eIeclions kees in office lhe homicidaI governmenl vhich lhe
IIain delesls because il is homicidaI, and lhe Mounlain delesls because il is decimaled by il.
The IIain and lhe Mounlain, lhe ma|orily and lhe minorily, finish by consenling lo heI on
lheir ovn suicide. The 22 IrairiaI lhe enlire Convenlion offered ilseIf lo lhe execulioner, lhe 8
Thermidor, during lhe firsl quarler of an hour lhal foIIoved Robesierre's seech, il did lhe
same lhing again."
This iclure may aear sombre. Yel il is accurale. IarIiamenlary assembIies, sufficienlIy
exciled and hynolised, offer lhe same characlerislics. They become an unslabIe fIock,
obedienl lo every imuIsion. The foIIoving descrilion of lhe AssembIy of 1848 is due lo M.
SuIIer, a arIiamenlarian vhose failh in democracy is above susicion. I reroduce il from
lhe Revue Iilleraire, and il is lhoroughIy lyicaI. Il offers an examIe of aII lhe exaggeraled
senlimenls vhich I have described as characlerislic of crovds, and of lhal excessive
changeabIeness vhich ermils of assembIies assing, from momenl lo momenl, from one sel
of senlimenls lo anolher enlireIy oosile.
"The ReubIican arly vas broughl lo ils erdilion by ils divisions, ils |eaIousies, ils
susicions, and, in lurn, ils bIind confidence and ils IimilIess hoes. Ils ingenuousness and
candour vere onIy equaIIed by ils universaI mislrusl. An absence of aII sense of IegaIily, of aII
comrehension of disciIine, logelher vilh boundIess lerrors and iIIusions, lhe easanl and
lhe chiId are on a IeveI in lhese resecls. Their caIm is as greal as lheir imalience, lheir
ferocily is equaI lo lheir dociIily. This condilion is lhe naluraI consequence of a lemeramenl
lhal is nol formed and of lhe Iack of educalion. Nolhing aslonishes such ersons, and
everylhing disconcerls lhem. TrembIing vilh fear or brave lo lhe oinl of heroism, lhey
vouId go lhrough fire and valer or fIy from a shadov.
"They are ignoranl of cause and effecl and of lhe connecling Iinks belveen evenls. They are as
romlIy discouraged as lhey are exaIled, lhey are sub|ecl lo every descrilion of anic, lhey
are aIvays eilher loo highIy slrung or loo dovncasl, bul never in lhe mood or lhe measure
lhe silualion vouId require. More fIuid lhan valer lhey refIecl every Iine and assume every
shae. Whal sorl of a foundalion for a governmenl can lhey be execled lo suIy`"
IorlunaleIy aII lhe characlerislics |usl described as lo be mel vilh in arIiamenlary assembIies
are in no vise conslanlIy disIayed. Such assembIies onIy conslilule crovds al cerlain
momenls. The individuaIs comosing lhem relain lheir individuaIily in a greal number of
cases, vhich exIains hov il is lhal an assembIy is abIe lo lurn oul exceIIenl lechnicaI Iavs. Il
is lrue lhal lhe aulhor of lhese Iavs is a seciaIisl vho has reared lhem in lhe quiel of his
sludy, and lhal in reaIily lhe Iav voled is lhe vork of an individuaI and nol of an assembIy.
These Iavs are naluraIIy lhe besl. They are onIy IiabIe lo have disaslrous resuIls vhen a series
of amendmenls has converled lhem inlo lhe oulcome of a coIIeclive efforl. The vork of a
crovd is aIvays inferior, vhalever ils nalure, lo lhal of an isoIaled individuaI. Il is seciaIisls
vho safeguard assembIies from assing iII-advised or unvorkabIe measures. The seciaIisl in
lhis case is a lemorary Ieader of crovds. The AssembIy is vilhoul infIuence on him, bul he
has infIuence over lhe AssembIy.
In sile of aII lhe difficuIlies allending lheir vorking, arIiamenlary assembIies are lhe besl
form of governmenl mankind has discovered as yel, and more eseciaIIy lhe besl means il has
found lo escae lhe yoke of ersonaI lyrannies. They conslilule assuredIy lhe ideaI
governmenl al any rale for hiIosohers, lhinkers, vrilers, arlisls, and Iearned menin a
vord, for aII lhose vho form lhe cream of a civiIisalion.
Moreover, in reaIily lhey onIy resenl lvo serious dangers, one being inevilabIe financiaI
vasle, and lhe olher lhe rogressive reslriclion of lhe Iiberly of lhe individuaI.
The firsl of lhese dangers is lhe necessary consequence of lhe exigencies and vanl of foresighl
of eIecloraI crovds. ShouId a member of an assembIy roose a measure giving aarenl
salisfaclion lo democralic ideas, shouId he bring in a iII, for inslance, lo assure oId-age
ensions lo aII vorkers, and lo increase lhe vages of any cIass of Slale emIoyes, lhe olher
Deulies, viclims of suggeslion in lheir dread of lheir eIeclors, viII nol venlure lo seem lo
disregard lhe inleresls of lhe Ialler by re|ecling lhe roosed measure, aIlhough veII avare
lhey are imosing a fresh slrain on lhe udgel and necessilaling lhe crealion of nev laxes. Il
is imossibIe for lhem lo hesilale lo give lheir voles. The consequences of lhe increase of
exendilure are remole and viII nol enlaiI disagreeabIe consequences for lhem ersonaIIy,
vhiIe lhe consequences of a negalive vole mighl cIearIy come lo Iighl vhen lhey nexl resenl
lhemseIves for re-eIeclion.
In addilion lo lhis firsl cause of an exaggeraled exendilure lhere is anolher nol Iess
imeralivelhe necessily of voling aII granls for IocaI uroses. A Deuly is unabIe lo
oose granls of lhis kind because lhey reresenl once more lhe exigencies of lhe eIeclors,
and because each individuaI Deuly can onIy oblain vhal he requires for his ovn
consliluency on lhe condilion of acceding lo simiIar demands on lhe arl of his coIIeagues.
|29j
|29j In ils issue of AriI 6, 1895, lhe Iconomisle ubIished a curious reviev of lhe figures lhal
may be reached by exendilure caused soIeIy by eIecloraI consideralions, and nolabIy of lhe
oulIay on raiIvays. To ul Langayes (a lovn of 3,000 inhabilanls, silualed on a mounlain) in
communicalion vilh Iuy, a raiIvay is voled lhal viII cosl 15 miIIions of francs. Seven miIIions
are lo be senl lo ul eaumonl (3,500 inhabilanls) in communicalion vilh CasleI-Sarrazin, 7
miIIions lo ul Ousl (a viIIage of 523 inhabilanls) in communicalion vilh Seix (1,200
inhabilanls), 6 miIIions lo ul Irade in communicalion vilh lhe hamIel of OIelle (747
inhabilanls), &c. In 1895 aIone 90 miIIions of francs vere voled for raiIvays of onIy IocaI
uliIily. There is olher no Iess imorlanl exendilure necessilaled aIso by eIeclioneering
consideralions. The Iav insliluling vorkingmen's ensions viII soon invoIve a minimum
annuaI oulIay of 165 miIIions, according lo lhe Minisler of Iinance, and of 800 miIIions
according lo lhe academician M. Leroy-eauIieu. Il is evidenl lhal lhe conlinued grovlh of
exendilure of lhis kind musl end in bankrulcy. Many Iuroean counlriesIorlugaI,
Greece, Sain, Turkeyhave reached lhis slage, and olhers, such as IlaIy, viII soon be
reduced lo lhe same exlremily. SliII loo much aIarm need nol be feIl al lhis slale of lhings,
since lhe ubIic has successiveIy consenled lo ul u vilh lhe reduclion of four-fiflhs in lhe
aymenl of lheir couons by lhese differenl counlries. ankrulcy under lhese ingenious
condilions aIIovs lhe equiIibrium of udgels difficuIl lo baIance lo be inslanlIy reslored.
Moreover, vars, sociaIism, and economic confIicls hoId in slore for us a rofusion of olher
calaslrohes in lhe eriod of universaI disinlegralion ve are lraversing, and il is necessary lo
be resigned lo Iiving from hand lo moulh vilhoul loo much concern for a fulure ve cannol
conlroI.
The second of lhe dangers referred lo abovelhe inevilabIe reslriclions on Iiberly
consummaled by arIiamenlary assembIiesis aarenlIy Iess obvious, bul is, neverlheIess,
very reaI. Il is lhe resuIl of lhe innumerabIe Iavshaving aIvays a reslriclive aclionvhich
arIiamenls consider lhemseIves obIiged lo vole and lo vhose consequences, oving lo lheir
shorlsighledness, lhey are in a greal measure bIind.
The danger musl indeed be mosl inevilabIe, since even IngIand ilseIf, vhich assuredIy offers
lhe mosl ouIar lye of lhe arIiamenlary regime, lhe lye in vhich lhe reresenlalive is
mosl indeendenl of his eIeclor, has been unabIe lo escae il. Herberl Sencer has shovn, in a
vork aIready oId, lhal lhe increase of aarenl Iiberly musl needs be foIIoved by lhe
decrease of reaI Iiberly. Relurning lo lhis conlenlion in his recenl book, "The IndividuaI versus
lhe Slale," he lhus exresses himseIf vilh regard lo lhe IngIish IarIiamenl:
"LegisIalion since lhis eriod has foIIoved lhe course, I oinled oul. RaidIy muIliIying
diclaloriaI measures have conlinuaIIy lended lo reslricl individuaI Iiberlies, and lhis in lvo
vays. ReguIalions have been eslabIished every year in grealer number, imosing a conslrainl
on lhe cilizen in mallers in vhich his acls vere formerIy comIeleIy free, and forcing him lo
accomIish acls vhich he vas formerIy al Iiberly lo accomIish or nol lo accomIish al viII.
Al lhe same lime heavier and heavier ubIic, and eseciaIIy IocaI, burdens have sliII furlher
reslricled his Iiberly by diminishing lhe orlion of his rofils he can send as he chooses, and
by augmenling lhe orlion vhich is laken from him lo be senl according lo lhe good
Ieasure of lhe ubIic aulhorilies."
This rogressive reslriclion of Iiberlies shovs ilseIf in every counlry in a seciaI shae vhich
Herberl Sencer has nol oinled oul, il is lhal lhe assing of lhese innumerabIe series of
IegisIalive measures, aII of lhem in a generaI vay of a reslriclive order, conduces necessariIy
lo augmenl lhe number, lhe over, and lhe infIuence of lhe funclionaries charged vilh lheir
aIicalion. These funclionaries lend in lhis vay lo become lhe verilabIe maslers of civiIised
counlries. Their over is aII lhe grealer oving lo lhe facl lhal, amidsl lhe incessanl lransfer of
aulhorily, lhe adminislralive casle is aIone in being unlouched by lhese changes, is aIone in
ossessing irresonsibiIily, imersonaIily, and ereluily. There is no more oressive
desolism lhan lhal vhich resenls ilseIf under lhis lriIe form.
This incessanl crealion of reslriclive Iavs and reguIalions, surrounding lhe elliesl aclions of
exislence vilh lhe mosl comIicaled formaIilies, inevilabIy has for ils resuIl lhe confining
vilhin narrover and narrover Iimils of lhe shere in vhich lhe cilizen may move freeIy.
Viclims of lhe deIusion lhal equaIily and Iiberly are lhe beller assured by lhe muIliIicalion of
Iavs, nalions daiIy consenl lo ul u vilh lrammeIs increasingIy burdensome. They do nol
accel lhis IegisIalion vilh imunily. Accuslomed lo ul u vilh every yoke, lhey soon end
by desiring servilude, and Iose aII sonlaneousness and energy. They are lhen no more lhan
vain shadovs, assive, unresisling and overIess aulomala.
Arrived al lhis oinl, lhe individuaI is bound lo seek oulside himseIf lhe forces he no Ionger
finds vilhin him. The funclions of governmenls necessariIy increase in roorlion as lhe
indifference and heIIessness of lhe cilizens grov. They il is vho musl necessariIy exhibil lhe
inilialive, enlerrising, and guiding siril in vhich rivale ersons are Iacking. Il faIIs on
lhem lo underlake everylhing, direcl everylhing, and lake everylhing under lheir roleclion.
The Slale becomes an aII-overfuI god. SliII exerience shovs lhal lhe over of such gods
vas never eilher very durabIe or very slrong.
This rogressive reslriclion of aII Iiberlies in lhe case of cerlain eoIes, in sile of an oulvard
Iicense lhal gives lhem lhe iIIusion lhal lhese Iiberlies are sliII in lheir ossession, seems al
Ieasl as much a consequence of lheir oId age as of any arlicuIar syslem. Il conslilules one of
lhe recursory symloms of lhal decadenl hase vhich u lo nov no civiIisalion has
escaed.
}udging by lhe Iessons of lhe asl, and by lhe symloms lhal slrike lhe allenlion on every
side, severaI of our modern civiIisalions have reached lhal hase of exlreme oId age vhich
recedes decadence. Il seems inevilabIe lhal aII eoIes shouId ass lhrough idenlicaI hases
of exislence, since hislory is so oflen seen lo reeal ils course.
Il is easy lo nole briefIy lhese common hases of lhe evoIulion of civiIisalions, and I shaII
lerminale lhis vork vilh a summary of lhem. This raid skelch viII erhas lhrov some
gIeams of Iighl on lhe causes of lhe over al resenl vieIded by crovds.
If ve examine in lheir main Iines lhe genesis of lhe grealness and of lhe faII of lhe civiIisalions
lhal receded our ovn, vhal do ve see`
Al lhe davn of civiIisalion a svarm of men of various origin, broughl logelher by lhe chances
of migralions, invasions, and conquesls. Of differenl bIood, and of equaIIy differenl
Ianguages and beIiefs, lhe onIy common bond of union belveen lhese men is lhe haIf-
recognised Iav of a chief. The sychoIogicaI characlerislics of crovds are resenl in an
eminenl degree in lhese confused aggIomeralions. They have lhe lransienl cohesion of
crovds, lheir heroism, lheir veaknesses, lheir imuIsiveness, and lheir vioIence. Nolhing is
slabIe in conneclion vilh lhem. They are barbarians.
Al Ienglh lime accomIishes ils vork. The idenlily of surroundings, lhe reealed
inlermingIing of races, lhe necessilies of Iife in common exerl lheir infIuence. The assembIage
of dissimiIar unils begins lo bIend inlo a vhoIe, lo form a race, lhal is, an aggregale
ossessing common characlerislics and senlimenls lo vhich heredily viII give grealer and
grealer fixily. The crovd has become a eoIe, and lhis eoIe is abIe lo emerge from ils
barbarous slale. Hovever, il viII onIy enlireIy emerge lherefrom vhen, afler Iong efforls,
slruggIes necessariIy reealed, and innumerabIe recommencemenls, il shaII have acquired an
ideaI. The nalure of lhis ideaI is of sIighl imorlance, vhelher il be lhe cuIl of Rome, lhe
mighl of Alhens, or lhe lriumh of AIIah, il viII suffice lo endov aII lhe individuaIs of lhe
race lhal is forming vilh erfecl unily of senlimenl and lhoughl.
Al lhis slage a nev civiIisalion, vilh ils inslilulions, ils beIiefs, and ils arls, may be born. In
ursuil of ils ideaI, lhe race viII acquire in succession lhe quaIilies necessary lo give il
sIendour, vigour, and grandeur. Al limes no doubl il viII sliII be a crovd, bul henceforlh,
benealh lhe mobiIe and changing characlerislics of crovds, is found a soIid subslralum, lhe
genius of lhe race vhich confines vilhin narrov Iimils lhe lransformalions of a nalion and
overruIes lhe Iay of chance.
Afler having exerled ils crealive aclion, lime begins lhal vork of deslruclion from vhich
neilher gods nor men escae. Having reached a cerlain IeveI of slrenglh and comIexily a
civiIisalion ceases lo grov, and having ceased lo grov il is condemned lo a seedy decIine.
The hour of ils oId age has slruck.
This inevilabIe hour is aIvays marked by lhe veakening of lhe ideaI lhal vas lhe mainslay of
lhe race. In roorlion as lhis ideaI aIes aII lhe reIigious, oIilicaI, and sociaI slruclures
insired by il begin lo be shaken.
Wilh lhe rogressive erishing of ils ideaI lhe race Ioses more and more lhe quaIilies lhal Ienl
il ils cohesion, ils unily, and ils slrenglh. The ersonaIily and inleIIigence of lhe individuaI
may increase, bul al lhe same lime lhis coIIeclive egoism of lhe race is reIaced by an
excessive deveIomenl of lhe egoism of lhe individuaI, accomanied by a veakening of
characler and a Iessening of lhe caacily for aclion. Whal consliluled a eoIe, a unily, a
vhoIe, becomes in lhe end an aggIomeralion of individuaIilies Iacking cohesion, and
arlificiaIIy heId logelher for a lime by ils lradilions and inslilulions. Il is al lhis slage lhal
men, divided by lheir inleresls and asiralions, and incaabIe any Ionger of seIf-governmenl,
require direcling in lheir elliesl acls, and lhal lhe Slale exerls an absorbing infIuence.
Wilh lhe definile Ioss of ils oId ideaI lhe genius of lhe race enlireIy disaears, il is a mere
svarm of isoIaled individuaIs and relurns lo ils originaI slalelhal of a crovd. Wilhoul
consislency and vilhoul a fulure, il has aII lhe lransilory characlerislics of crovds. Ils
civiIisalion is nov vilhoul slabiIily, and al lhe mercy of every chance. The ouIace is
sovereign, and lhe lide of barbarism mounls. The civiIisalion may sliII seem briIIianl because
il ossesses an oulvard fronl, lhe vork of a Iong asl, bul il is in reaIily an edifice crumbIing
lo ruin, vhich nolhing suorls, and deslined lo faII in al lhe firsl slorm.
To ass in ursuil of an ideaI from lhe barbarous lo lhe civiIised slale, and lhen, vhen lhis
ideaI has Iosl ils virlue, lo decIine and die, such is lhe cycIe of lhe Iife of a eoIe.
Ind of The Iro|ecl Gulenberg Ilexl of The Crovd, by Guslave Ie on