Professional Documents
Culture Documents
6.
You have been tasked to look at options for routing a new coastal road across a river estuary. A small sea-side village is situated next to the estuary. There appear to be three main options: a) A small ferry to carry vehicles across the estuary across the river at an annualised cost (to the government) of R10 million. This will result in considerable inconvenience to the through-traffic (travelling along the coast) and disruption to the villagers (additional traffic) but will cause minimum damage to the environment (shortest distance, no major capital works) and will make it easier to access the village. A detour upstream to a point where the river can easily be crossed by a small bridge at an annualised cost (to the government) of R20 million. The road will completely by-pass the village. This option will lead to increased damage to the environment (longer road distance) and some inconvenience to the through traffic (longer route). A long bridge across the estuary and through the village at an annualised cost (to the government) of R50 million. This will result in considerable damage to the environment (impact on the estuary) and disruption to the villagers (additional traffic), however the village will be directly connected to the road and inconvenience to the through traffic will be eliminated.
b)
c)
Describe how you would perform a Utility-Cost analysis taking into account: Damage to environment Disruption to the villagers Ease of access to the village Inconvenience to the through traffic
Illustrate your answer by performing the appropriate calculations using values of your own choosing where necessary. [40]