Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Legal medicine (AKA forensic medicine) branch of medicine that deals with application of knowledge to legal problems and proceedings Medical jurisprudence - branch of law that deals with application of law to medicine or conversely medical science to legal problems Forensics application of scientific knowledge to legal problems and proceedings - Used in the p rs it of ! stice in co rt proceedings and in the protection of the p blic from environmental ha"ards Pathology branch of medicine that deals with diagnosis of disease and ca ses of death by means of laboratory e#ams of body fl ids$ cell samples and tiss es from the body% if alive & biopsy if dead & a topsy' systematic e#ternal and internal e#amination of the dead a s bspecialty is forensic pathology( a forensic pathologist e#amines persons who died s ddenly$ ne#pectedly$ violently or a medically nattended death$ an e#pert in determining the ca se and manner of death$ involved in crime investigation$ case coordinator for the medical$ forensic and scientific assessment of a given death )may be the lead investigator)$ e#pert in interpreting the scene of death$ assessing the consistency of witnesses and interpretation of pattern in! ries Medico-Legal officer physician who is involved in medico-legal d ties *+,% -. ,ode of *anitation( Any medical officer )M/0$ 1/0$ 2istrict /ealth 0fficer)$ medical offices from law enforcement agencies$ ,/1 and members of the medical staff of accredited hospitals% Medico-legal cases( deaths or in! ries involving persons who have no means of being identified$ those who are prono nced dead on arrival on +1s$ deaths nder the following circ mstances 3death occ rred within 45 ho rs of admission$ clinical ca se of death is nknown$ ne#pected s dden death especially when the person was of apparent good health$ d6t nat ral disease b t associated with physical evidence of fo l play$ death as a res lt of violence$ s icide or poisoning$ death d6t negligence of a 7 rd person$ incl ding cases of child ab se$ physical and se# al ab se$ rape$ dr g addiction and iatrogenic ca ses of in! ry$ disease or death )one ca sed by the medical professional s ch as the doctor6n rse)$ etc8
Child protection specialist - new kind of specialist in the field of pediatrics' deals with medico-legal cases of children who were allegedly ab sed N0 formal training on how one becomes a Medico-legal officer% Doctor as a witness: ,an either be a professional witness or an ordinary6 fact witness or both 9ive fact al medical evidence$ cannot give comments or opinions :U; an e#pert witness can give an opinion abo t medical facts +#pert witness has special knowledge as well as c rrent knowledge or skill gained by ed cation$ training$ or e#perience in the field of e#pertise +#plain scientific matters that may or may not be nderstood by ! dges Medical e#pert testimony co ld either be for the prosec tion or for the defense Medical testimony m st be ob!ective and acc rate Law does not make a < alification of an e#pert physician based on a medical specialist )so look into their < alifications$ their formal training etc)
,hild =rotection has set < alifications of a doctor who can provide care for the se# ally ab sed child and these are doctors who can also give e#pert testimony in co rt% >% 4% 7% 5% .% pediatrician$ gynecologist$ pediatric gynecologist$ family medicine )important that there?s e#pos re to children) formal training pdated with research st dies e#perience reg lar conference$ cons lt one another here and abroad etc =age 1 of !
Medical and legal stat s of death( o Medical 2octor proclaims or prono nces a person dead% o Legal +#tinction of the person?s identity$ etc% ;he ascertainment of death is a chemical problem% @t?s the doctor who will determine when a person has died% 'tages of Death: >% ,linical or somatic death 4% :rain death 7% :iological death 5% ,ell lar death Clinical or somatic death: ;he respiratory and circ latory f nctions have ceased% : t beca se of an advancement in medicine$ the circ latory and respiratory f nctions may be restored thro gh res scitating meas res% Co may end p as a person who?s wide awake$ contin o sly breathing$ heart still beating% 0r yo may end p as a person who?s awake$ heart beating$ b t yo ?re not breathing on yo r own% 0r yo may end p as a person who?s ! st o t% Co are nconscio s and cannot comm nicate with yo r environment% Co ?re breathing$ either on yo r own with yo r heart beating on yo r own$ or yo r respiration is being assisted$ with yo r heart beating on its own% @f there?s irreversible nconscio sness$ with spontaneo s respiration and heart beat$ it cannot be accepted as tr e death% ;he person is still breathing on his own% /e?s nconscio s b t he?s breathing on his own$ his heart beating% (rain death: =age of !
o o
Ahen everybody dies changes can happen% /ow do we estimate the time of deathH #$2L3 C&$4.#' %&$% &$PP#4 $F%#2 D#$%&: >% 1igor Mortis 4% ,adaveric1igidity 7% =ost Mortem /ypostasis 5% ,ooling of the body after death or Algor Mortis Ahen the heart stops and the breathing stops event ally there?s a falling blood press re$ there?s no more o#ygen and the cell method will stop working and beca se of that yo r nerve cells will die and there?s going to be no more ne rological activity% Ahen blood press re falls down and there?s no more circ lation$ yo wo ld become pale% ;here wo ld be pallor personae$ there will be eye changes$ refle# is gone$ the p pils will not dilate and will not constrict if it?s shown light$ the blood vessels in the f nd s that yo see that are act ally retina% Co won?t see any p lsation and if yo to ch the eye$ it?s very soft% M scles will become flaccid% As soon as there is a loss of the m scle tone it becomes flaccid and this is termed the primary flaccidity and this may retain any activity and may respond to other forms of stim li that?s why yo might see some twitching of the toes or some m scle twitching that?s reacting to the stim li% @t?s not act ally dictated by higher senses% ;here will also be loss of m scle tone so yo r anal sphincter will ! st come o t% Co r rinary sphincter$ yo r rine will ! st come o t% 0r some semen might ! st be emitted b t that doesn?t mean that he had ! st had se# before he died% ;here will be revegitate of the gastric contents beca se there is a sphincter in the esophag s and in the stomach% ;hat will also be rela#ed so when the person falls on his back or even head down stomach opening rela#es$ gastric sphincter will flow backwards this can be conf sed as if the person died beca se of asphy#iation )gastric contents going into the airway)% ;he only way we can say that a person died beca se of asphy#iation from aspirating food is from eyewitnesses? acco nt% @f food debris can be fo nd down to the smallest part of the l ng and then we can say he asphyrated and that is the ca se of his death% 2igor mortis5 ;he temperat re dependent physico-chemical changes or chemical reactions occ r within motor cells as a res lt of lack of o#ygen% 2ifference between a normal metabolic pathway and the ano#ic )no o#ygen pathway)% A normal metabolic pathway happens within yo r body$ within yo r system% An important reprod ction of energy in yo r body$ yo r A;= sing o#ygen% *o if there is no more o#ygen it?s ! st gl cose that is being sed to prod ce A;= b t then witho t o#ygen it will not go thro gh this process of o#idity PPPP lactic acid pathway and will prod ce a lot of lactic acid in the body% Aith the lack of o#ygen$ very little A;= or energy$ more of lactic acid what happens isPPPCo r m scles are made p of fibers of cells-acti enmycin fibers% ;hey bind together and they form a gel and that makes the m scles stiff% @t?s that lactic acid =age 6 of !
2+A;/ @NF+*;@9A;@0N%% @t involves police investigation and the application of forensic science% Kinds of death that re< ire investigation in the =hilippines$ nderstand the principles of death investigation incl ding the a topsy% Learn and nderstand the contents of a medico legal a topsy report and how the medico legal findings become sef l to the legal system% =age ! of !
Co need the help of e#perts or forensic people like forensic pathologist$ orthodontologist$ anthropologist when the dead bodies are severely in! red or severely m tilated$ decomposed or skeleti"ed% ;he identity of a person is established by comparing or matching the parameters that can be meas red with the parameters of another person which is s spected to belong to the body being meas red% ;he best feat re on how to identify a person is his specific feat res that are matched to one that is known to a certain person% M+;/02* 0L @2+N;@L@,A;@0N( Morphological characteristics5 ;his is a method of identifying criminals thr height$ weight$ general physi< e$ hair color and length$ presence of beard and m stache$ skin pigmentation and other facial appearances$ eye color$ shape of the lips$ and chin% ;hese can differentiate one person from another )e%g% race)% Picture: get the frontal and the side view shot )more often than not$ yo r left profile is different from the right profile) ;o determine the age( white thing around the eye$ teeth only p to age 4. and a range is given$ *-ray )o#ification centers$ bone growth) Clothing and jewelry5 %attoos5 =age 11 of !
Fingerprints %hree main patterns: loops$ whirls and arches or a combination of any of these three% Used to ascertain a positive @2 of a person No two persons have the same fingerprint even twins ,annot be altered by time or in! ry ,an be e#tracted in any s rface they come into contact with% %hree %ypes Patent prints -left when a foreign s bstance on the skin of a finger comes in contact with the smooth s rface of another ob!ect Plastic prints -left when a finger to ches a soft malleable s rface Latent prints - impressions secreted in a s rface or an ob!ect that is invisible to the eye$ the res lt from perspiration from the sweat pores fo nd on the ridges of sweat pores -invisible to the eye -visible prints -no need for enhancements -visible prints - no need for enhancements - needs d sting) enhancement )e%g%
No less than >B points of similarity before declaring prints to be identical ;he investigating agency m st already have a file of fingerprints for comparison For decomposed or damaged -odies: se e#pert' can be obtained from despomated shedding the strat m corne m )the fisrt s bmersion' sing the s rface below the strat speciali"ed techni< e from a fingerprint skin of the nderlying epidermis after layer) when it comes to prolonged m corneum =age 1 of !
Principles o o no two persons have the same 2NA pattern e#cept for identical twins or clones each part of yo r body contains the same 2NA
@f the 2NA pattern left at the scene of the crime does not match the s spect?s 2NA pattern$ the s spect was never in that scene% @f it matches the s spect?s 2NA pattern$ it p ts the s spect in the vicinity of the scene of the crime b t does not necessarily mean that he is g ilty of the crime% ;he 2NA molec le consists of two strands of s gar and phosphate molec les that link to one another to form a do ble heli#% ;en percent of the molec le is sed for genetic coding and the rest are silent% ;hese silent "ones repeat themselves$ meaning$ there is only >J percent of the billions of molec les in the body and only a few percent is specific to yo alone b t the distrib tion is ni< e for each one of s$ the se< encing is different% ;he 2NA is fo nd in the n cle s and it is a do ble heli#% @t is very stable b t the specimen that contains the 2NA that is to be analy"ed can easily be contaminated by the collector% 2NA typing is a well-established means of identifying h man remains and is a powerf l tool resorted to when traditional methods of identification are not helpf l% 2NA fingerprinting is the last resort in identifying people% @t?s sed for healthcare$ pharmace tical research$ evol tion and forensic% ;here are 7 ways of determining 2NA se< ences% ;ypes of samples needed for 2NA analysis( it m st have n cle s )white blood cells$ hair root$ spermato"oa)% =age 1) of !
(lood groups can only be sed for e#cl sion in paternity or maternity testing' not acc rate like that of 2NA analysis% @f the child?s blood type is 0 and the mother?s blood type is 0$ the father?s co ld be A or :% *amples for 2NA testing( mother$ child and probable father% @n paternity e#cl sion$ if there?s none matching profiles in at least two 2NA locations it can constit te concl sive proof that the alleged father is not the biological father% @n child se# al ab se cases$ it does not necessarily e#onerate the s spect from the ab se charges' it ! st means that the ab se did not impregnate the child% @n paternity incl sion$ complete matches in the 2NA profiles of the child and the alleged father will not necessarily establish paternity% ;he strength of the matches is determined statistically%
@2+N;@L@,A;@0N 0L L@F@N9 AN2 2+A2 Use of 2NA evidence in co rts( @mportant to se 2NA- allowable for @2 and testing of parentage *, said 2NA can be sed as corroborative evidence together with other evidences Lind o t how sample collected$ handled$ possibility of contaminating samples$ standard proced re followed in analysis$ proper standards followed in cond cting tests and < alifications of the analysts who cond cted the 2NA tests )< estions that sho ld be answered when yo present evidence in co rt) :y itself 2NA cannot establish the g ilt of an individ al )powerf l corroborative evidence) only 2NA e#perts can say that the 2NA samples belong to the s spect 2NA e#perts are the most appropriate persons to answer < estions regarding 2NA forensic process% Lind o t his professional < alifications$ how reliable is their 2NA testing process and the laboratory itself% +#pert witness will interpret the 2NA res lts and will e#plain the match or e#cl de a s spect as a possible so rce of the 2NA%
2NA report contains( what were the samples tested the controls sed 2NA profile of sample consistent with that of the s spect?s *tatistics of the probability that the evidence sample came from the s spect ,oncl sion based on the res lts of their test
/ow are these interpretedH @ndependent 2NA profiles of the victim )se# ally assa lted kid) and the reference samples are compared% ;he res lts are either inconcl sive or there?s an e#cl sion or an incl sion%
>% 8nconclusi,e - 2NA testing did not prod ce info that wo ld incl de or e#cl de the s spect% May res lt from =age 10 of !
Contusions$ br ises )ecchymosis$ hematoma) breakage or r pt re of blood vessels ca se escape of blood from blood vessels to the dermis res lting to discoloration +#ternal br ising and internal br ising )br ises on internal organs) ;he greater the force the greater the br ising the site of br ising does not necessarily reveal the site of tra ma beca se blood is not static$ can move by gravity initially reddish 6 p rplish to yellowish or brown )d6t breakdown of hemoglobin) =age 11 of !
Lacerations res lt of bl nt force overstretching the skin and there will be a split of the f ll thickness of the skin deep and will bleed important to look for bridging fibers )remain intact in lacerations and will not be c t) skin can be compressed within the applied force and the nderlying bone rare in soft fleshy areas of the body margins are always ragged if ca sed by thin sharp ob!ect$ the wo nd is sharply defined and may be mistaken for incision b t nder the microscope there co ld be abrasions and cont sions on the edges and bridging fibers in the laceration
'harp force injuries: >% @ncised wo nds also ca sed by ob!ects with sharp and c tting edge and disting ished from a stabbed wo nd by being longer than deep - +dges will give indication of the sharpness of the ob!ect sed% Fery sharp ob!ects will not leave br ising on the edges$ no bridging fibers% - rarely life threatening nless it c ts deep into a tiss e like yo r ! g lar artery 4% *tab wo nds wo nds that are deeper than they are longer 2epth of the in! ry will make it fatal beca se of the bleeding Any ob!ect with a point or a tip can ca se it$ edge need not be sharp% =ressed into the skin with eno gh force to overcome the nat ral elasticity of the skin Appearance does not necessarily mimic the cross-sectional shape of the ob!ect sed% ,ontraction of the elastic fibers of the skin will distort a slit like wo nd after removing the weapon *hape of the wo nd can tell yo if it was a single edged weapon or do ble edged knife = shing the edges of the wo nd together is not an effective way of meas ring the si"e of the wo nd and determining the si"e of the weapon *i"e of the wo nd will depend on the shape of the blade and how it was inserted% Movement of the knife in the wo nd will change the shape and can enlarge the wo nd opening @f knife f lly inserted br ising might res lt d6t the hilt of the weapon or by the hand of the assailant -
=age 16 of !
$'P&3B8$5 Absence of p lse% @t describes a range of conditions for which the lack of o#ygen is considered the ca se% Mechanism: obstr ctive or non-obstr ctive ;he obstr ctive type is medico-legally significant% Classical Features: @t is not diagnostic% Not definite signs of asphy#ia like( facial congestion$ facial edema$ facial cyanosis$ petechial hemorrhages in the skin and in the eye$ star dose spots Conditions=causes >% * ffocation Lack of o#ygen in the inspired air +#ample( = tting plastic bags on the head of prisoners ;here is < ick death and minimal signs of asphy#ia e#cept for pallor in the face Not str ggling to breath' there is low e#ternal press re 4% *mothering ;he victim str ggles May e#perience cyanosis and congestion :r ises and abrasions on the face$ on the lips$ or inside the mo th Non-str ggling victims( may not see any of the signs' diffic lt to diagnose 7% ,hoking or gagging @nternal obstr ction of the pper airway passages by an ob!ect or s bstance impacted in the pharyn# or laryn# M c s membranes swell or congest if yo breathe thr yo r nose ;here will be respiratory distress$ can become cyanosis and congested face and neck p 5% *trang lation or hanging ;hree forms of prime forensic importance Man al strang lation Ligat re strang lation se of band aro nd the circ mference of the neck /anging press re of the ligat re on the neck prod ced by the weight of the body ,an res lt into two effects( classical asphy#ia signs the person died a slow death' no asphy#ia signs there was s dden cardiac arrest ;he effects and events depends on the method sed$ si"e of the press re$ and the force with which the press re is applied =age of !
O g lar veins drain veno s blood ) n-o#ygenated blood) from the head% @f there is obstr ction$ the blood will remain in the head% ;he person will swell$ congest or become cyanotic% ;he arterial veins will r pt re ca sing petechial hemorrhages nderneath the skin% 0bstr ction in the carotid artery )carries o#ygenated blood) ca ses cerebral skemia and the person will collapse beca se of lack of o#ygen in the brain% *tim lation of the barrow nerve endings in the neck will bring abo t the slowing of the heart% +#ternal signs( abrasions and br ises in the neck area$ laryngeal damage$ .% ;ra matic asphy#ia )restricting the movement of the chest) +#ternal press re is p t on the chest thereby restricting respiration ,lassic signs( very congested from face and neck p$ person becomes very bl e or red$ e#tensive petechia :lood from above the chest cannot ret rn to the heart$ it?s ! st like obstr cting the ! g lar veins B% =ostrial asphy#ia 2isabled or nconscio s person lies with the pper half of the body lower than the rest of the body ;here is press re in the abdomen that does not allow the diaphragm to move' it?s like tra matic asphy#ia where there is restriction of chest movement ,ommonly seen on persons arrested$ they are p shed to the gro nd /emoglobin carries o#ygen b t it prefers carbon mono#ide% Lail re of o#ygen tili"ation will paraly"e the chest m scle% &3P+B8$5 =artial lack of o#ygen% $4+B8$5 ,omplete lack of o#ygen% %2$4'P+2% 84A/28#'@ D2+"484.@ $LC+&+L ) .2+/P' +F ;8C%8M' =edestrian$ passengers$ cyclists or motorcyclists %2$4'P+2% 84A/28#':
Primary injuries from the direct contact of the vehicle =rimary in! ries are recogni"able and may take the pattern of the b mper for e%g%% Aherever the in! ry is that?s the point where the pedestrian was hit% ,l es as to the speed on the car( T 4J km6hr thrown off the hood either forward or sideways 4J-BJ km6hr victim may fall on the hood and head may strike windshield BJ->JJ km6hr victim may fly p in the air and he can fall on the car or beyond the car% 'econdary injuries from the contact of other ob!ects or the gro nd after contact with the vehicle 0ften more serio s and potentially lethal than primary in! ries )e%g% head and spinal in! ries)
Car occupant ;he in! ries s ffered will depend on the kind of impact =age ) of !
Motorcyle injuries d e to falls from the machine yo can have abrasions$ in! ries in the head bicycles more milder forms since lower speeds b t the problem is when they are hit by other vehicles wear appropriate safety gears
8MM#2'8+4 $4D D2+"484. 2ifferent things :odies recovered from water co ld have died from nat ral ca ses before entering the water% 2etermine A0N victim died of nat ral ca ses before entering the water or while in the water having entered it either vol ntarily or accidentally% 2id he die of nnat ral ca ses before entering the waterH 2id he die from e#pos re or hypothermia while in the waterH 2ied of in! ries after entering waterH 2id he die of s bmersion or drowningH 'u-mersion ! st act ally being in the water% A person who drowns can have signs of being s bmerged b t a person who was s bmerged in water does not necessarily mean he drowned% @f yo died before yo were placed in the water yo are s bmerged% '='* of 'u-mersion: >% 4% 7% 5% washerwoman?s fingers6hand macerations and skin will peel off after weeks of immersion decomposition +vent ally yo r body will float% ;he only time body won?t float is when yo ?re s bmerged in very cold water%
/ow do we know if these in! ries are post-mortem or ante-mortemH @n! ries m st be seen nder the microscope and if there?s inflammatory reaction seen then yo know in! ries are before death since there are no inflammatory reactions if yo got in! red after yo died% D2+"484. yo die of s ffocation beca se of water within yo r l ngs and yo have to be immersed in water +ffect depends whether yo drowned in fresh or sea water% Lresh water is absorbed into o r circ latory system res lting to vol me overload and hemodil tion$ event ally leading to cardiac arrest% *ea water more concentrated than blood$ so fl id in o r blood will go o t into o r l ngs and there?s p lmonary edema or congestion res lting to hypo#ia$ respiratory arrest$ cardiac fail re and cardiac arrest =ost mortem findings variable and ca se of death hard to prove . stages a% Co str ggle$ yo may find br ises in yo r chest and sho lders b% Co get tired and yo sink c% Co don?t want to breathe in water so yo stop breathing% :eca se we hold o r breath carbon dio#ide goes p so respiratory centers in o r body say breathe so we breathe in water d% ,o gh vomit$ loss of conscio sness% ,onv lsions% @nvol ntary respiratory movements and we keep inhaling water% e% 1espiratory arrest and cardiac arrest% =age 0 of ! -
$LC+&+L Alcohol ab se s ally enco ntered in child ab se and rape cases% @t?s a dr g and addictive% Makes one prone to accidents and an homicide% '='* of alcohol into*ication: >% +#citement - lack of inhibition or self-control$ feelings of well-being 4% @ncoordination and ,onf sion loss of nervo s control of yo r body$ bl nting of perceptions$ no m sc lar corrdination$ na sea$ vomiting$ cardiac and respiratory symptoms 7% Narcossis or ,oma deep sleep$ slow breathing$ paralysis of cardiac and respiratory centers which can lead to death Males cannot say that they co ld not have raped a girl beca se they were dr nk beca se erection can happen in the e#citement stage% 0n the other hand$ they take advantage of girls when the girls get into the incoordination and conf sion stage )2r g facilitated se# al ab se) /ow do we diagnose dr nkennessH >% 4% 7% 5% .% B% D% E% alcoholic smell of breath or vomit s dry tong e e#cessive salivation irreg lar behavior bloodshot eyes thickness of speech tremors$ error of coordination and orientation :est tests( blood alcohol content ):A,)$ rine test for alcohol and breath analy"er test =age 1 of ! nderlying ca se of misdemeanor$ assa lt and
/nderstanding the Child Child de,elopment: - ,ontin o s process that starts from birth to mat rity$ and goes to define stages and phases% :efore yo can go to the ne#t phase$ the child m st master first the previo s stage% - Now the skills and the comple#ities as he grows older centers all in the physical$ mental$ social$ and emotional f nction of that person% @t affects cognitive development$ emotional development$ and social development% 85 First ) to 0 years of -a-y: - Ne rons start to connect with one another% And the only way these ne rons get connected with one another is if the baby is stim lated at the time when he is born% - +#perience leads to ne ral changes in the brain% - Fis al stim lation sho ld happen in the first B months for the necessary ne ral pathway to develop% - Co are now developing comm nication with the baby% @f yo meet the needs of the child$ that child will learn to tr st yo and will develop an attachment to yo as a caregiver% - @f yo need the baby to master a certain task$ he m st be stim lated at the right time$ given the right e#perience% +#ample$ a B-month-old baby$ yo can?t teach that baby to walk$ since he has not developed the m scles to s pport his own body to walk or stand on his own or balance himself% - ;hey learn to recogni"e their father and mother% Ahen looking at ob!ects and yo hide it right away$ they will think the ob!ect is no longer e#isting% ;hey don?t know the ob!ect is there and event ally as they grow older$ peek-a-boo is an important game for babies$ beca se they will learn yo are still there act ally% - ;o ching is very important for children% Lor children who are not to ched at all$ when they grow p they don?t want to be to ched$ since it?s strange for them to be to ched% - ;hese babies are learning to be a tonomo s$ they are learning how to toilet train and how to be independent and if yo don?t allow them to toilet train themselves$ learn new skills$ they will not develop self-esteem% - ;hey now have the ability to symboli"e% @n the beginning$ they know the mental image of what an apple is% :y the time they are > or 7 years old$ now they can say this is an apple% - *o they are ready to play with other people% ;hey will only do things for the approval of a parent$ they will do things not to be p nished% ;hat?s all what they care abo t for the first 7 years of life% - ;he se# al behavior at this stage is more on to ching and looking% ;hese are ! st learning% *e# al behavior at this age is merely knowing abo t the difference between the vagina and penis% - As early as two years of age$ they already learn the concept of right and wrong% @t has nothing to do abo t pleasing the parents or they are being p nished% Moral control is internali"ed by age B thro gh consistent parental =age 6 of !
=age ! of !