Professional Documents
Culture Documents
issue
Mutual UFO ~ e t w o r k
Calendar, p. 19.
UFO Marketplace, p.
23.
Columns
Director's Message 2
Filer's Files 15
Ted Phillips 17 One of the best series of UFO photos ever taken (ranking up there with
Stan Friedman 20 McMinnville) was the series shot along a California highway by the late Rex Heflin.
McLeod's Night Sky 24 Veteran dol lo gist Ann Drlrffel looks at Heflin and the latest research on his photos,
beginning on page 3.
January 2006 Number 453
MUFON Amateur Radio Net: Postmaster: Send form 3579 to advlse change of address to MUFON UFO Journal. P.0. Box 369. Morrlson,
40 meters - 7.237 MHz
CO 80465.0369
I
i
H
owling is fundamentally a
form of communication be Ms. Woodward worked with the Na- ported to have run off howling just be-
tional Investigations Committee on fore they and the UFO arrived in the
tween dogs, particularly be- Aerial Phenomena (NICAP) in the
tween animals at some distance from area. The relationship between the
1960's, assisting with the original UFO dog's behavior and the UFO is ques-
one another. E v i d e n c e (1964). She returned to
Some dogs, as an instinctive re- ufology in 1996 as a field investigator tionable.
sponse, will howl when they hear cer- for MUFON and the Fund for UFO Re- AR91 presents a pure and reason-
tain sounds, such as musical instru- search after retiring from the U.S. Geo- able howling reaction, and is one of
ments or sirens. logical Survey as a research technician. multiple sightings involving red lights
She assisted Richard Hall in devel- that occurred in the local area that night.
When howling, the dogs are nor- oping an index of James E. McDonald's
mally relaxed, In this case, as a cigar-shaped ob-
correspondence in the Donald E. Keyhoe ject with red lights and a "dynamo"
and their howls Archives. and worked on data compi-
humming sound moved slowly through
are a social re- lation for Hall's Alien Invasion o r Hu-
sponse, not a ttratr Fontasv? his area. the witness reported that the
Ms. Woodward later took over the dogs were howling as they did when
response to
discomfort. animal reactions section of Francis they heard a siren or passing train.
Ridge's special evidence section of the The description of what would nor-
They are not NlCAP web site. She also has exten- mally cause these dogs to howl is of
howling be- sive experience with both domestic and great value and adds enormous clarity
cause a siren wild animals.
to the event.
hurts their
AR49. like the Everglades sighting,
ears. Howling UFO made a very high pitched sound involves changing behavior with dis-
would be ex- like a transformer hum, and flew by low tance. This sighting occurred in 1977
pected to occur Joan Woodward four times. in Uruguay, where a glowing disc
in response to a AR77 is a similar sighting, but with moved about a - barnyard, eventually
sound or to elicit a response from an- less detail. A dog barked and howled hovering about 20 feet high.
other animal. and was described as fearful as an oval A watchdog ran aggressively toward
Fully 73 percent of the sightings with disc generated wind, moving trees the object, barking. When 15 feet from
howling dogs reported sound from the about. The only sound heard by humans it, he stopped, sat, and began howling
UFO. Only two sounds are reported as was a wind sound from the UFO. as he looked up at the UFO. This is a
high-pitched, and both were associated In AR 12, the Flynn sighting in the more typical description of normal
with fearful dogs that howled. Most of Everglades previously discussed, the howling behavior.
the sightings involving howling dogs are crated dog tried to escape its crate while The dog is not running or moving,
also in other behavior sections. howling (really odd behavior). The but is still, and its head is up as it howls.
Of the 11 sightings, five of them re- sound reported from the UFO 600 feet The disc was reported to make a noise,
port dogs' alert-alarm barking and away was loud and high pitched. but, unfortunately, the sound is not de-
howling. In three of these, witnesses One might expect a dog under these scribed.
report sound associated with the UFO conditions of trying to escape to whine EM effects, electrical shock, and
(hum, loud hum, air conditioner-wash- or yelp or even scream, but not howl.
ing machine). In these three sightings, it is possible
The fact that some dogs barked and the howling response was an involun- Editor's Note
some howled is reasonable, due to the tary reaction by a dog faced with an This article, Part Four in a se-
variability of the individual responses. overwhelming stimulus. ries, is abridged from Ms.
Three sightings report dogs that are Three sightings concern only howl- Woodward's full presentation, in-
fearful and howling. This is not an ex- ing. The least interesting is AR39, a cluding charts, case descriptions,
pected combination of behaviors as a bothersome sighting in that many of the and other material, which is in-
howling dog is normally relaxed with details were not clear when focusing cluded in the MUFON booklet Ani-
its head raised. on the animal reaction aspect. mal Reactions to UFOs. The full
In AR07 dogs were running and A UFO was initially encountered report is also included in the 2005
howling (odd behavior combination) in while witnesses were in a car with their MUFON Symposium Proceedings.
the yard, and when let into the house, dog, which was seemingly unaware of
they shook, whimpered, and hid. The the UFO. As they arrived home and
MUFON UFO Journal January 2006
heat were reported by the witness. If
the dog felt electrical shock and heat,
the last thing one would expect would
be for it to sit and howl.
Some of these howling reports may
be imprecise language on the part of
the witnesses. AR9 1 is a very good ex-
ample of a sighting with the dogs clearly
howling.
In AR12, a dog trying to escape its
crate while howling suggests that the
stimulus causing the howling was over-
whelming.
Electrical effects and EM effects
McCampbell (1976) suggests dog
reactions may be responses to micro-
waves associated with the UFO. and
thinks that an artificial state of fear may
be produced by this radiation.
He also thinks there is an associa-
tion between physiological effects, elec- In the famous 1971 Delphos, KS, case investigated by Ted Phillips, both
trical shock feeling, and EM type reac- Ronald Johnson and his outdoor dog Snowball were present when the ob-
tions on engines. ject "took off Ronald was temporarily blinded. Snowball seemed to show
"
Rasmussen (1980) refers to a study only moderate reaction to the event at the time, but did look up into the sky
indicating that, under certain experi- as the object lefi. Lnter; however; Snowball zrncharacteristically tried to get
mental circumstances;electromagnetic
waves can be detected by the central into the house, was frightened by high-pitched sounds, avoided the area
nervous system. where the UFO had sat, and ran into fences as if he did not see them. See
Ackerman (1989) suggests an elec- the book Delphos, A CloseEncounter of the Second Kind, available from
tromagnetic propulsion system with a MUFON.
side effect generating an electric field
in the area of the UFO. did not report sound in either case. . sitting next to one another, both look-
One would intuitively expect that AR99 is a 2000 North Carolina ing up into the air.
dogs would be reactiveto at least some sighting. The witness called the Fund Lee followed their gaze, but saw
of these effects. Thus far there is little for UFO Research, who called me. nothing. He called and tried to get their
support for this theory, as the percent- I talked to the witness, Lee, at length attention. One dog ignored him, con-
age of sightings with these effects is a number of times, and also corre- tinuing to look upward, and the other
low-with the exception of a possible sponded by mail and arranged for glanced at him and then returned its
relationship between howling dogs and MUFON to send a field investigator to gaze upward.
EM effects. interview the witness in person. As Lee left the area, walking his
These effects, like most secondary This sighting should not be included usual circuit, the dogs remained in place
effects, are scattered among sightings in this study as it does not meet the cri- gazing upward. When Lee came out
without any clear correlation with be- teria in that the dog behavior and UFO about two hours later, the dogs were
haviors. sighting were not simultaneous. How- normally loud and aggressive, and have
About half of the sightings in the ever, I am malung an exception. remained so without fail ever since.
electric effect-EM compilation have Lee was a security guard, and But as Lee patrolled the grounds on
various sounds reported as well. Al- walked an outdoor route regularly his 9 PM circuit, he had a sighting of a
though sightings with howling dogs also around the fenced perimeter of the plant perfectly straight row of 15-20 lights
have a somewhat higher percentage of where he worked. in a variety of colors that he thought to
EM effects, far more sightings are Two boxer-pit bull type dogs lived be about 500 feet from him.
needed to determine the reality of this nearby, their yard adjacent to the plant's As he watched, the lights faded one
relationship. fence. Without exception, the two dogs by one in a very systematic manner
Mesmerized dogs? charged and barked and behaved ag- from the end lights inward. He heard
The dog reactions in two totally in- gressively when Lee walked his circuit. no sound. He was convinced there was
dependent UFO events were amazingly This night, at 7 PM, Lee started to a relationshipbetween the dogs' behav-
similar, involving totally atypical behav- walk his circuit, and did not see or hear ior and the UFO.
ior for the dogs. There is no similarity the dogs. He was so surprised that he Compare the North Carolina dogs'
in the UFO descriptions, and witnesses went to look for them. He found them behavior to the dogs of AR98, a sight-
January 2006 MUFON UFO Journal 11
ing in 1997 from Georgia reported by Ob j tot /
Tom Sheets (2002). This sighting in-
volved three outdoor dogs described as
frisky and aggressive.
A couple arrived home about 10 PM
to find their three dogs sitting in a small
circle under a red glowing ball that was T o o l box
( n o t to
5-7 feet high in the air. ~e cale
-
I Phvsical Traces
I By Ted Phillips
Levitation cases "Then my younger daughter cold wind stopped, and the two women
Last month I noted some of the more screamed 'Its coming down! Its corn- and their dog dropped to the ground.
interesting levitation cases-people, mi- ing down! Let's go!'- and I said, 'No, The mother and Marileide landed in a
mal, and objects somehow lifted into it's not coming down.' squatting position facing the house, but
the air by UFOs-up to August, 1983. "But I was wrong. It WAS coming neither was able to stand up or say any-
Since I specialize in physical traces- down, and very quickly. It was a very thing.
which include residue, animalhuman intense white light shaped like a big tub. Shocked and trembling with fright,
effects, and physical effects-these types It looked like a fishing net. The light lit they began crawling toward the house.
of levitation cases interest me the most. up the ground all around us." The dog crawled alongside them with
There are, of The younger daughter, Maria his belly scraping the ground, his ears
course. numer- DaGuia, was closer to the house than bent down, and his tail between his legs.
ous levitation the others and was able to run inside. Once inside the house, neither the
cases that do not But her mother and sister and the dog mother nor Marileide could speak for
involve physical were "captured" by the light coming a half hour. The mother called the "net"
traces. from the object. and they found them- a tarrafa, which is a circular net cast in
Following are selves pulled into the air. shallow waters.
additional levita- "I felt this cold wind all around me, This was not the only case in Brazil
tion events in- pulling us up." the mother said. "I in which victims described a "net" in
volving physical couldn't touch the ground. I was off the conjunction with an encounter.
traces and hu- ground. When I tried to lift my leg. I It was five months before the mother
manlanimal ef- L - .
!:
felt a cold wind like when someone got up enough courage to go outside at
fects. Ted Phillips opens a refrigerator. We were about a night. Marileide recovered more
Anyone hav- meter off the ground. I was wearing a quickly than her mother. The dog ap-
ing additional details on these or other very large skirt, and the wind filled it parently suffered no ill effects, but was
cases of this type are asked to share with air, blowing it up around me." hit by a car several years later. (Thanks
their information. The mother and daughter were both to Bob Pratt)
O8/00/83 2200 Velhas, Brazil- screaming, but the dog, almost para- 10/15/83 2030 Bellwood, PA-A
Male witness, man levitated, human lyzed with fright, made no sound, not woman was driving when an object
effects. even a whimper. approached car. The object was some
08/07/83 Winifreda, Argentina- "I was yelling for them to run," said 24 feet in diameter and hovered above
Farmer levitated, human effects. - the mother, "but they couldn't run. I had the vehicle, which was levitated 2-3 feet
08/15/83 2200 Born Jesus, Brazil- one hand on Marileide's arm and the off the pavement. There were human
Maria Dos Dores Lopes was 47 at the dog's leash wrapped around the other. effects. (MUFON UFO Journal No-
time of the event. He was close to me. I tried to push vember, 1983)
"It was right here, out in front of the Marileide away toward the house, but 11/01/83 2200 Valley of the Old
house," she explains. "My two daugh- I couldn't. Women, Brazil-Geraldo Gomes and
ters and I went outside one night to take "At the same time I was trying to his wife Angela were walking down a
our dog for a walk before putting him run, but my feet weren't touching any- hill 300 yards from their home when
in the kennel for the night. It was about thing. I was running in the air. Marileide "suddenly a big light lit up everything
ten o'clock." couldn't run either, and she was cry- behind us," explains Geraldo.
The daughters are Marileide, then ing. The dog was cowering. "I looked over my shoulder and saw
15, and Maria Da Guia, 13. Their dog "I wasn't able to do anything. I tried a bright light 300 meters away. It was
was a large, black mongrel called to look up at the thing, and could see it bluish-white, and bright enough we
Doggie. was spinning, but I was very afraid. The could see where we were walking. The
"We were out in the front yard, about wind was like a hurricane, going in light was coming out of a hole in some-
15 meters [46 feet] from the house, and circles.'' thing dark, but I couldn't tell the shape
I saw what I thought was a light in the It ended as quickly as it began. "The or color of the object itself because the
sky. I was watching it, and I thought it fishing net suddenly went straight up light was so bright.
was very beautiful. It was like a rain- into the sky," said the mother. "All I saw was a dark form. We con-
bow. As the light moved silently away, the tinued walking, and I looked back
January 2006 MUFON UFO Journal
again, and the object was suddenly very nothing touching him. After falling on a courtyard, was approached by an ob-
close, only 20 meters away. It got to us the ground he saw nothing more. ject. She saw a net falling toward her,
in no time. It was the size of a minibus. His eyes were swollen, and he and in the center of the net was a bright,
I heard a sound like a refrigerator mo- couldn't see correctly. He had to crawl white point. She tried to push it back
tor. home. For three days he stayed in his and felt an eletric shock.
"Then it was right on top of us. I was room and kept the door locked. He When she screamed, her voice be-
hot. I felt like I was near a fire. It made couldn't stand any kind of light. came shrill and sharp as if acoustic
me sweat, and my clothes were wet. 08/06/87 2300 Cimolais, Italy- waves had been distorted by the atmo-
The light went out, and I felt something Male witness, red light beam from ob- sphere around her. Her family rushed
soft touching my shoulder, but I ject, car levitated 40km, traces. out of the house and saw her in the air,
couldn't see what it was. 1 reached 01/20/88 0430 M u n d r a b i l l a , with a flying disk hovering less than 50
back, and it felt like a soft towel, and Australia-Mrs. Knowles, her sons feet away.
suddenly my feet were suspended Sean, 21, Patrick, 24, and Wayne, 18, The disk vanished, and she found
above the ground. were driving east from Perth when they herself back on the ground. She was
"I tried to push the thing away, but I had to swerve to miss a large bright paralyzed for a while. "It was as if
was lifted up about 70 cm ljust over glowing object on the road. something had tried to pull the skin
two feet] above the ground and carried It was "bright and white with a yel- from my fingers," she said. The tips of
for about ten meters. Angela saw I was low center, shaped like an egg and her fingers were enlarged." (Thanks to
being taken away. She panicked and about 1 meter wide," she said. They Vallee)
grabbed me and pulled me back down." observed the object as it chased a truck 12/03/90 2320 Jozsa, Hungary-
Angela said, "It looked like he was and a car before it turned and caught Male witness, car EM, humanoid, car
dancing in the air. I was very afraid." up with the Knowles vehicle. levitated and turned around.
She grabbed her husband and pulled "It landed on the roof and lifted the 05/19/91 1800 Campo Redondo,
him back down, and the object irnme- car from the road," said Mrs. Knowles. Brazil-Moises Vasco Campelo, 39, re-
diately moved back in the direction it She had reached out her window and ports, "I was walking home passing an
had come from. A few seconds later felt the base of the object, which she imbu tree and all of a sudden there was
the light came on again about a hun- described as "like a rubber suction a big headlight focused on me. This
dred yards away and hovered motion- pad." light covered me. It was all around me,
less above some dense bushes. Suitcases packed on the roof were and I felt a tremendous heat.
"Angela was screaming her head off gone. The car became covered with a "I felt as if I was being sucked up.
and then fainted," said Geraldo. "I black ash-like substance and it came When it was happening, I wasn't afraid,
picked her up and carried her down the into the car like smoke. The dogs in the but afterwards I got really scared. I was
hill. She quickly revived and we both car were going crazy. raised about one and a half meters off
began running. The car was levitated, except for the the ground. This lasted about three min-
"When we got to the bottom of the front tire which blew out. At that point utes, and then they let me down very
hill the object came back close to us the car was dropped heavily back on gently.
again. We were both screaming, and my the road. 'Then it moved off a ways, but I still
relatives saw it. My father-in-law came The family jumped from the car and saw this bright light. Then they came
out of the house with a light to help us, hid in the brush until the object left 30 back and got me again. This time I felt
and then the object went away for minutes later. They contacted police very cold, and I was paralyzed. I
good." when they reached the next town. The couldn't talk. I couldn't move. This
08/00/87 Ismeraldas, Brazil- car had dents on the roof. Truck driv- lasted 15 minutes.
Joao de Jesus, coming home on a very ers also saw the object. "During the time I was paralyzed,
dark night, saw a light coming toward 09/16/89 0000 Nicolayev, Russia- the thing was above me, going around
him. It went out, and within seconds A young woman who worked at a meat and around and around. It finally left,
he saw a silhouette in front of him. packing plant had left her job early to and I was blind in one eye. My eye
It was a spherical object with two catch the tramway home. She was alone swelled so much I couldn't see. Fifteen
landing legs six meters away. In order as she approached the tramway and minutes after I got home it was still vis-
to see better, he tried to turn on a flash- suddenly realized she was being levi- ible near the church."
light, but it wouldn't work. tated to a height of 160 feet. 08/00/911900 Lajes, Brazil-Maria
He tried to light a match, but when The whole crew leaving the plant Natividade Cavalcanter, 56, went to get
he was about to strike the match, he saw her floating in the air, alongside an water in a drum under an agarobe tree.
was pushed and lifted off the ground to unknown object. The crew started yell- As she returned, she was covered by a
his rear. He estimated he was moved ing and screaming, and eventually she light of many colors. She could feel it
about 10 meters quickly, but not vio- was returned to the ground. (Thanks to pulling on her, and she squatted down.
lently. Vallee) As it pulled, she felt heat on her body,
When he was pushed and levitated 10/11/89 1800 Nalchik, Russia-A but was very cold inside. She was
he couldn't feel anything-no pressure, 16-year-old girl, Natasha Barinova, in numb. She was in shock and couldn't
Susan Clancy and abductions cal hypnosis to help numerous shell- hadn't been hypnotized.
I hadn't had high hopes for the book shocked war veterans regain horrifying She does admit her preconceptions
A b d i ~ t e d :How people Come to Be- memories and work through them, had that people thinking they had been ab-
lieve They Have been Kidnapped by even told Dr. James McDonald that the ducted played Dungeons and Dragons
Aliens by Dr. Susan A. Clancy intensity of emotion in the Betty and as a kid, were a computer programmer
(Harvard University Press, 2005, 179 Barney Hill sessions was sometimes or a sci-fi buff, and had attended Star
pages). more intense than any he had found in Trek conventions.
After all, the segment about abduc- the military cases he had treated. What is really crazy here to me as a
tions which featured her on Peter She goes on to say, "Even better, scientist is that normally one expects
Jennings' grossly-misleading "docu- alien abductees were people who had somebody beginning research in a new
mentary" on Feb. 24 was definitely un- developed area to do a literature search first. She
scientific. memories of couldn't be bothered.
The focus was on sleep paralysis. a traumatic However, she insists. "I believe I
with no recognition being given to mul- event that I have read every account of alien abduc-
tiple persons being abducted at once. could be tion ever published. and just about ev-
that most abductions take place other fairly certain erything that social psychologists, psy-
than when the abductee was sleeping had never choanalysts, post modernists, journal-
in bed. or that many people recalled the occurred. A ists. physicists, biologists and ex-mili-
details without the use of hypnosis. major prob- tary personal (sic) have to say about
This despite the fact that all of these lem with my them ...I've watched nearly every
had been discussed by Budd Hopkins research on American movie and TV show ever
during his PJ interview, but never made false mem- made about aliens."
the program. Stan Friedman ory creation by If she did, she must have been sleep-
Still I was shocked by how much victims of al- walking, as she seems to get almost ev-
bias and prejudice she shows in the leged sexual abuse was that it was al- erything wrong.
book. She should have been flunked for most impossible to determine whether Here is a typical example of her
her gross inaccuracy in her accounts, they had in fact, been abused. gross inaccuracy. Speaking of a meet-
brief though they were, of various cases "I needed to repeat the study with a ing with a number of abductees she
about which I am well informed. population that I could be sure had 're- says, "Highlight of Saturday evening
Remember that her so-called re- covered' false memories. Alien abduc- was a conversation with two brothers
search was conducted at Harvard Uni- tion seemed to fit the bill." from Manchester, NH. These men were
versity using government research She notes how she would use the relatively well known abductees who
grants, and the book was published by same techniques with the abductees as had written a book about their experi-
Harvard University Press. I guess they with the sexual abuse people, and ad- ences.
couldn't afford a fact checker. dressed the "corroboration issue since "One night in the late 1960s they had
She describes how she got into ab- it was certain the event hadn't hap- been canoeing on a lake in Maine and
duction research because she had been pened." had seen some weird lights across the
working on the false memory syndrome It is hard to imagine so called re- water. A few years later one had fallen
with regard to sexual abuse of children. search starting out with such strong down an elevator shaft at work; he'd
There was always the problem of de- bias. Is this what passes for research at suffered brain damage, developed epi-
termining whether any abuse had ever Harvard University? lepsy and became severely depressed." -
taken place. Dr. Clancy describes how she got her The simple fact of the matter is that
Abductions would be much easier, study population. She advertised in there were four people involved, not
she says, because "Here was a group newspapers seeking subjects, asking, two, and the event took place in Au-
that had 'repressed memories,' but the "Have you been abducted by aliens?" gust, 1976, not in the 1960s.
memories would be much less painful She dumped any she thought were The book, The Allagash Abductions,
to hear about than memories of child- psychotic, for which, I suppose, we was written by an experienced investi-
hood sexual abuse." should be grateful. It isn't clear that she gator, engineer Raymond Fowler, not
No basis is given for this silly proc- accepted any subjects who claimed that by the brothers. It was based on data
lamation. Dr. Benjamin Simon, an out- they had been abducted with somebody obtained independently from each of the
standing psychiatrist who used medi- else and not out of their beds and who four.
20 MUFON UFO Journal January 2006
The book is, of course, not refer- John Fuller's files are at Boston from Air Force disinformation expert
enced although she has 14 pages of University, not far from Harvard. Col. Weaver that Jesse Marcel's story
noted references, including 146 items. Clancy obviously hadn't been there ei- first came out in the National Enquirer
Her own "research" papers were each ther. I have done all these things. in 1978, even though it was 1980, and
cited several times. Demonstrating both her bias and ig- after Bill Moore and I had spoken with
Clancy not only seems to consider norance she claims Betty and Barney 62 people about the case.
herself a truly knowledgeable Hill became famous in abduction his- I gave the late Bob Pratt, who wrote
abductionist, but also an expert on tory in the 1960s because, in the words the article, Jesse's contact information.
UFOs in general: "So far as we know of Seth Shostak, an astronomer associ- She has all wrong the date rancher Mac
there is no evidence that aliens exist. ated with the SETI Institute, "they were Braze1 found the wreckage, the date he
You can't disprove alien abductions. All more or less Mr. and Mrs. Front came into town, and the date Jesse went
.. you can do is argue that they're improb- Porch." out, as well as other details.
able." An interracial couple i n New En- Clancy says that The Roswell Inci-
Obviously she didn't intend this next gland in 1961 were hardly Mr. and Mrs. dent claimed that "pieces of aliens had
comment to be referring to herself: Front Porch, whatever that is supposed been among the debris. This was at-
'The confirmatory bias-the tendency to to mean. Surely no reasonable person tested to by more than70 witnesses who
seek or interpret evidence favorable to could consider Seth Shostak an expert had some knowledge of the event."
existing belief or reinterpret unfavor- on any aspect of ufology, much less ab- This is totally false; no such claim is
able evidence is ubiquitous, even ductions. made in the book to which I was a ma-
among scientists." Clancy and Shostak certainly share jor contributor.
Amen, and she provides many ex- an affinity for "Don't bother me with She says "the evidence for a crashed
amples of her own tendency: "We don't the facts, my mind is made up," and spaceship and dead extraterrestrials
accept the alien abduction explanation "What the public doesn't know, I won't was entirely anecdotal, consisting of
because there is no external evidence tell them," and do your research by first hand reports from people who
to support it." proclamation; investigation is too much 'wished to remain anonymous' and
Isn't it amazing that she never dis- trouble." even more tenuous second and third
cusses physical trace cases, at least Clancy doesn't discuss the UFO evi- hand reports (so and so told what's-his-
16% of which involve reports of strange dence either. She almost gets into the name who told me that such-and-such
beings. She doesn't mention the many Condon Report with this strange com- really happened 30 years ago."
cases in which abductees separately ment, "In 1969 the National Academy This nonsense comes from a woman
c o n f m that missing time. of Sciences sponsored a study of all the claiming to have read everything about
She never mentions Marjorie Fish's available evidence on UFOs. The con- UFOs and aliens.
star map work connected with the Betty clusion, 'On the basis of present knowl- I am a physicist who has written
and Barney Hill case, though she does edge, the least likely explanation of more than 80 UFO articles and two
mention the case. As might be expected unidentified flying objects is the hypoth- books relating to Roswell, and was a
her comments are seriously in error. esis of extraterrestrial visitations by in- major contributor to The Roswell Inci-
She says "Betty had spotted a bright telligent beings."' dent. I am not referenced at all.
star that seemed to be pursuing them. The fact is that this is from a brief There are lots of real people named
Nervous, they had turned off the main summary by the NAS at the beginning by me, Don Berliner, Kevin Randle,
highway onto narrow mountain roads of the 965-page Condon report. The Don Schmitt (none referenced), and
arriving home two hours later than ex- NAS didn't sponsor the study. The Air other serious researchers as opposed to
pected." And she claims to have read Force did. It was certainly not a study Clancy's pseudoscientific claims.
The Interrupted Journey??? of all available evidence. The NAS re- The video "Recollections of
Sounds to me like she read a Parade view committee did no investigation~ Roswell" has first-hand testimony from
Magazine piece by Carl Sagan which itself.. . not one single case. 27 witnesses-all named.
makes the same false claim. It would Clancy misrepresents the Travis One could write a lot more about the
be interesting to know just where Walton case, speaking disdainfully of trash in this book and the self-serving
Clancy's misinformation comes from his books claiming he was abducted nonsense about being objective. Not
besides her fertile imagination, as she two weeks after the Hill case movie and surprisingly there is a blurb on the back
gets virtually everything wrong. described his experience on national from Dr. Elizabeth Loftus, one of the
She certainly hadn't read the book TV. leaders of the False Memory Syndrome
carefully or Terence Dickinson's "The No mention, of course, of his being cult-like group: "Abducted is an enor-
Zeta Reticuli Lncident," or watched the gone for 5 days and the initial zapping mously brave, smart, original book."
"UFO Incident" on NBC, or spoken being observed by five other people, I suppose that is true once one rec-
with Betty or Barney or Dr. Simon or and all the rest of the investigative work ognizes that most of it is fiction mas-
John Fuller or even Betty's niece Kathy done by APRO and others.. querading as truth.
Marden, very familiar with the case and As might be expected, Clancy gets www.stantonfriedman.com
possessor of Betty's files. Roswell all wrong. She repeats garbage fsphys@rogers.com
January 2006 MUFON UFO Journal
Director's Message
(Continued from page 2) $3.50 p&h in the U.S. The total price ceedings and also on page- 17 of the
to provide financial support as well. outside the U.S. is $32.50. It may also 2005 MUFON symposium proceed-
Leslie made a special box-a sort of be purchased via the Internet at ings. We are extremely grateful for this
a piggy bank-that she called "Pandora's www.mufon.com using PayPal. vote of confidence and outstandmg level
Box." She brought the box to every of support to MUFON.
meeting of Colorado MUFON and New Lifetime Member
called on meeting attendees to donate It is a pleasure to announce that Gail MUFON E-News
to support the Pandora work. Barton of Lakewood, CO, is now a MUFON publishes a free E-News-
At their December meeting she pre- MUFON Lifetime Member. Gail letter on the Internet. Anyone may join
sented the box containing $156.86 to serves MUFON is a number of ways, the free newsletter distribution list on
MUFON Headquarters, saying, "Use including taking responsibility for the the MUFON website at
this money for the Pandora work." art displays at the annual MUFON In- www.mufon.com.
Leslie said they will be starting a new ternational UFO Symposium, provid- All that is required is listing your
box in January, 2006, and issued a chal- ing artwork in support of UFO field name and email address. The email
lenge to other state directors to do the investigations, and providing artwork address list is handled by ListBot and
same thing. Their heartfelt support is for MUFON publications. is not used for any other purpose. You
appreciated. Her work was featured on the cover may withdraw from the list at anytime
of the 2003 MUFON symposium pro- by clicking on "unsubscribe."
Position Announcements
Kevin Green of Blountville, TN, has
accepted the position of State Director
for Eastern Tennessee. Kevin replaces
Kim Shaffer in this role. Kim is still
active in the field, but was unable to
MUFON Forum
continue as State Director at this time. Physical traces (Trancas case ) passed through Trancas at 3 PM, and
Preston Mattke of Spicer, MN, has I want to add some comments to the the sighting occurred at 7 PM, so the
accepted the position of Research Spe- Villa Trancas case (Oct. 21, 1963, lights over the railroad could not have
cialist in Industrial Technology. Tucuman, Argentina), commented on been a train. The military maneuvers
, Monte McDonald of Las Vegas, by Ted Phillips in the October MUFON were some days later, and in daylight
NV, has accepted the position of Re- UFO Journal. hours. There was found no trace of mili-
search Specialist in Education. The three sisters of the Moreno fam- tary vehicles.
Robert Newel1 of Pharr, TX, has ily saw two intense lights where human With respect to the calcium carbon-
accepted the position of Research Spe- forms moved over the railroad. ated balls found in the area, Galindez
cialist in Education. Calcium carbonated balls were stated that it could not be due to anti-
found the next day in the place where aircraft reflectors, because these do not
New Field Investigators the circular object was seen. expel that amount, and the calcium car-
Kathleen Marden, Director of However, in the late 1980s Argen- bonated residue is deposited in the re-
Field Investigator Training, has an- tina ufologist Roberto Banch, a skep- flectors trays.
nounced that Carl Barlow of Sierra tic, determined that in those days there -Claudio Del Rosario, MUFON
Vista, AZ; Lisa A. Shiel of Lake Lin- were military maneuvers in Cabeza de Field Investigator.
den, MI; and Kim McKelvey & Buey ( Salta Province ) which stopped .
Address: Carbonari 1474 B 1882
Sylvia McKelvey of San Jose, CA; in the de Morenos Family field, and EFD .Emeleta. Buenos Aires, Argen-
have passed the MUFON Field which used anti-aircraft reflectors of tina. dlauhiodelrosario@tutopia.c6m
Investigator's Exam and are now great power that confused the witnesses
MUFON Field Investigators. with a UFO.
All Field Investigator Trainees are That's how he explained the calcium Estate planning
urged to self-study the MUFON Field carbonated ball, originated by those Planned giving can be beneficial
Investigator's Manzrnl and take the reflectors. to both MUFON and to your own
exam. State Directors, Assistant State Years later, ufologist Oscar Galindez tax and estate situation.
Directors, State Section Directors, and FSR investigator in the 60's, investi- If you wish to have more infor-
State Chief Investigators are good gated the case and stated that the hy- mation on various options and ben-
sources of help and training. pothesis of Roberto Banch didn't have efits, please contact MUFON
The manual is available from consistency.. Headquarters.
MUFON Headquarters for $25 plus The last train, Galindez commented,
MUFON UFO Journal January 2006
World's Best UFO Cases
MUFON 2005 INTERNATIONAL UFO By Dwight Connelly
SYMPOSIUM PROCEEDINGS Editor, MUFON UFO Journal
"Unconventional Flying Objects: the Body of Tech- This is a collection of the very best cases of the past 50
nological Evidence, Pt. 2" Includes papers by Phyllis years, investigated by the very best researchers. Essentially,
Budinger, Richard Dolan, Alan Holt, Elaine Douglass, it is "the best of the MUFON UFO Journal."
Stanton Friedman, Paola Harris, Roger Leir, Edgar Included are contributions by Stanton Friedman (Hill star
Mitchell, Scott Ramsey, Esen Sekerkarar, R. Leo map), John Schuessler (Cash-Landrum encounter), Ray Fowler
Sprinkle, Claude Swanson. and Joan Woodward. i"
, .. . .
-. (Allagash abductions). John Carpenter
Available from MUFON Headquarters in hard copy , . ,.., . - (video-taped abduction). Bill Chalker
or CD-ROM. Price: $32.50 in U.S. and $36.50 Out- fiYzr ,.ll.o ( sb,,.:'' (alien DNA case). Don Burleson (deci-
side the U.S. phering Ramey message), David Rudiak
(evaluating Ramey message), Nancy
Talbott (science of crop circles). Ted
ANIMAL REACTIONS TO UFOs: A Bloecher (New Berlin repair case). Dr.
PRELIMINARY INVESTIGATION FROM Roger Leir (implants). Stan Gordon
THE ANIMAL'S PERSPECTIVE (Bigfoot). Phyllis Budinger (analysis of
By Joan Woodward Delphos soil: analysis of Betty Hill
The FULL report. including charts. of the series cur- dress): Walter Webb (Buff Ledge abduc-
rently running in the MUFON U F O Journal. tions). Kathleen Marden (Betty & Barney
Available from MUFON Headquarters for $14 in Hill), and Len Stringfield (three Kentucky women abducted).
the U.S. and $16 outside the U.S. Other cases covered include the Hickson-Parker abduc-
tions at Pascagoula, Betty & Barney Hill, Travis Walton,
UFO AWARENESS T-SHIRTS with logo on left Australia's Kelly Cahill multiple witness encounter (prob-
ably the world's best currently-known case-illustrated on the
front and "others talk - we investigate" on the back. book's cover), McMinnville photos, Father Gill's close sight-
Available from MUFON Headquarters in s, m, lg, xlg ing, animal abductions/mutilations, historic UFO art, and the
and 2x sizes. White with black letters are $15 in the ongoing Romanek case (which will likely be the best case
U.S. and $19 outside the U.S. Black with white let- ever).
ters are $18 in U.S. and $22 outside the U.S. The compiling, writing, and editing of this 240-page soft
cover book is by Dwight Connelly, MUFON Journal editor.
BACK ISSUES OF THE MUFON UFO JOUR- Order from the MLFON.com website, or from the author
NALS (all years) are available from MUFON Head- at 14026 Ridgelawn Road, Martinsville, IL 62442. $9.95 plus
auarters on word searchable CD-ROMs. Price Der $2.00 shipping (single or multiple copies). Signedhnscribed
ct
year is $22.95 in U.S. and $24.95 outside U.S. ?he
complete collection from 1967 - 2004 is also avail-
able on DVD at a special price.
-
I
Send for our
c:'
-FREE-UFO
'
& LUMBER
HARDWARE COMPANY : Products Catalog-
SUPPORTS THE
0 Hundreds of UFO
MUTUAL UFO NETWORK documentaiies on DVD
PO. BOX10 109 W. Jefferson St Boston. Georgia 3 I626 and VHS -
Office: 229-498-6371 Fax: 229-498-4807
I -(b
Vintage UFO radio shows
F
I
-- . . ,
8 ' ,
541.523.2630
theUFOstore
i
1930 Ash Street. Suite 9M
I- - zmail: saIes@theUFOstore.com Baker City, Oregon 97814, USA
- schuesslrtr@mho.net.
-
303-948-6223
- A