Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Argus
M O N T H LY
Petroleum Coke
www.energyargus.com/coke.html Wednesday January 8, 2003 Report No. 03S-001 DECEMBER COKE INDEX
40 HGI 25.50 / 26.50 23.00 / 24.00 45 HGI 31.00 / 32.00 26.00 / 27.00 40 HGI 37.05 / 38.05 34.55/ 35.55 45 HGI 42.00 / 43.00 37.00 / 38.00 70HGI 26.00 /27.00 24.00 /25.00
IN THIS ISSUE... Venezuela strikes at heart of the coke market ..........2 Trading stalls or goes underground ....................3
70HGI 37.55 / 38.55 35.55 / 36.55
$/mt
$/mt
ExxonMobil replaces Koch with ConocoPhillips..........5 Venezuelan crisis slashes coke production ..............8 Oil market faces fight on two fronts ........................8 Saudis want Opec output increase ..........................9 US coal prices leap higher ............................11 A market report from the publishers of
$/mt
Note:Delivered prices are calculated using fob prices plus Panamax freight
COAL INDEX
Next Month Delivery 12/30/02 December Avg 29.50 28.58 ------------Next Quarter Delivery 12/30/02 December Avg 30.50 29.42 35.35 34.79 27.50 27.00 25.25 24.28 30.75 29.89 cif ARA cif Japan 105.78% 98.59% 142.19% $/mmBtu 1.58 1.43 1.20 1.12 1.18 0.97 Btu % Coal
fob US Gulf Coast 88.38% 79.88% Spot 39.00 35.35 37.55 35.05 36.80 34.30
EUROPEAN BTU COMPARISON Coal Delivered Spanish Med Coal Delivered Northwest Europe Hard 4.5% Coke Delivered Spanish Med Hard 6.5% Coke Delivered Spanish Med Hard 4.5% Coke Delivered NW Europe Hard 6.5% Coke Delivered NW Europe
&
SO2 INDEX
12/30/02 135.00 December Average 132.15
PETROLEUM ARGUS
$/bl Maya US Gulf Coast ANS US West Coast WTI/Maya spread Brent/Dubai spread 1pc Fuel Oil New York Asphalt, Western Gulf Coast, $/st
Page 1
$/t
30 25 20 15 10 5 Sep
Dec
Mar 4.50%
Jun 6.50%
Sep
Dec
The supply-side crisis has seized the market and European prices appear to have already crossed the point where coal is a better burn value than coke. Our subscribers should not be surprised. Argus warned in its March 5, 2002, issue that "one wild card remains hanging over the market, one that many have chosen to ignore at their peril, is Hugo Chavez." Our overview went on to say that "the coke industry in its short life has had experience with political risk in the form of regulation, but not in the form of unpredictable and unstable governments. Up until a few years ago, the overwhelming majority of cokers were located in the relatively stable economy of the United States. Now that balance is shifting with Venezuela taking a greater share."
3.5 3.0 2.5 2.0 1.5 1.0 0.5 0.0 Jun Jul
$/t
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
Dec
$/t
38 34 30 26 22 18 14 Aug
At March of last year, coke prices were at their weakest values in over two years. Few could take seriously the threat of a supply crisis when low sulphur hard coke was at $9.50 and coal in Europe was at $34. But today that same coke is at $26 and coal in Europe is at $35. European buyers of coke usually balk when the price of coke exceeds 65% of the price of coal on a Btu basis. In December, coke was valued at between 77% and 82% of coal on a Btu basis delivered into Northwest Europe. And it was between 71% and 76% of coal in the Mediterranean. This will be disconcerting to those with flexible demand, at least as disconcerting as a commodity price rise of 275% in ten months. What looked like an opportunity to the cement and industrial buyer last spring now looks much more like a liability.
Defaults spread
Sep Oct Nov ARA Coal Dec USGC Coke Nymex Spec Coal
One US utility, that utilizes coke sourced from Venezuela, said in December that force majeure letters were falling out of the sky. PdV declared force majeure on all crude and products exports shortly after the strike began, which includes the three new crude upgrading projects. The loss of coke may force the utility to solicit for additional coal, after already securing what it thought was ample coal for this year. Some market sources say that the high price of coke will prompt US end users to switch to coal, or at least to a higher percentage of coal usage. Even prior to this month's surge in prices, some end users like the City Public Service Board of San Antonio (Texas) had grown disenchanted with coke prices and opted not to use coke this year. Other utilities that burn only a small portion of coke in their fuel mix, such as Owensboro Municipal Utilities (OMU) in Kentucky, could easily switch away from coke altogether.
$/mt
12 11 10 9 8
7 Apr-02
Jun-02
Aug-02
Oct-02
Dec-02
Source: Clarksons
Page 2
$/bl
16 15 14 13 12 11 10 9 8 2-Dec
USWC USGC
Another US utility says the strike could end up costing it one or two cargoes, but that the primary impact of the strike has been the delay in vessels loading at PdV/Amerada Hess Hovensa refinery at St Croix, Virgin Islands.
9-Dec
16-Dec
23-Dec
$/t
220 200 180 160 140 120 100 80 A M
$tl
30.00 29.50 29.00 28.50 28.00 27.50 27.00 26.50 26.00 25.50 25.00 10/1
Bullish stories in the coke market in 2002, such as the surprise entrance of China as a buyer into the market, take on even more impact given the current supply situation. China, in the first 11 months of 2002, purchased almost 1.3mn tons of coke, or 112,000 tons per month. In November, Premcor closed its Hartford, Illinois, refinery, with its 325,000 t/yr high sulphur, hard coke output. Last spring, JEA brought the first of two, coke-fired circulating fluidized bed (CFB) boilers online, with the second just behind it. The utility faced challenges finding the right coke and coal mix, but still utilized up to 500,000 tons of coke in 2002. When the units begin to use 100% coke, they will combine for up to 1.6mn t/yr of consumption.
10/22
11/12
12/3
12/24
$/st
32.00 31.50 31.00 30.50 30.00 29.50 29.00 28.50 28.00 27.50 27.00 26.50 1st Month
2nd Month
1st Q 1-Dec
2nd Q 1-Jan
3rd Q
Page 3
% 20 18 16
60%
14 12
30%
10 8 6
Jul Aug Sep 4.5% 40 Oct 6.5% 40 Nov Dec
0%
4 2 0
mt
250,000
-2 -4 1/97 6/97 1/98 6/98 1/99 6/99 1/00 6/00 1/01 6/01 1/02 6/02
200,000
Calcined Uncalcined
150,000
mt
100,000
50,000
4.0 3.8
Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov
3.6
,000 t
600,000 500,000 400,000 300,000 200,000 100,000 0 Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct
3.4
Jul
Spain
ENERGY ARGUS
As of December 30, 2002 New York Diesel New York 0.3% Fuel Oil* New York 1% Fuel Oil Transco Zone 6 Gas Nymex spec Coal Gulf Coast 4.5% 40 HGI Coke Gulf Coast 6.5% 40 HGI Coke PJM Power
BTU COMPARISONS
Heat Value in Spark Spread $/mmBtu in $/MWH 6.27 -21.58 6.12 -20.03 4.44 -3.32 5.35 -12.36 1.38 27.29 1.28 28.36 1.39 27.24 41.13
000 t
1,700 1,500 1,300 1,100 900 700 500 May
CLARKSONS
60,000 mt (Panamax) $/mt US Gulf Coast to European Continent to Spanish Mediterranean to Black Sea US West Coast to European Continent to Spanish Mediterranean to Japan
Jun Europe
Jul Asia
Aug
Sep
Oct
Latin America
Page 4
Report No. 03S-00-01 - Wednesday January 8, 2003 (EAPC, February 5, p6). In the spring of 2002, Power Park also awarded 250,000 tons of coke to trader Capex, and 50,000 tons to TCP for 2002 delivery. St Johns is in a comfortable position with regard to inventories, as it has up to four months worth of coke supplies on the ground. Last year, the utility consumed 650,000 tons of petroleum coke, up 50,000 tons from a year earlier. And the same amount is projected to be burned this year. St Johns, which is permitted to utilize coke in up to 20% of its fuel mix at any given time, increased its annual coke usage from 15.5% to 17% in 2002 (EAPC, September 3, 2001, p6). But the utility will pursue using more coke in the future, which will require re-permitting and making boiler modifications, a company official says. With regard to the strike in Venezuela, St Johns has not been significantly impacted. The strike could result in up to two cargoes being delayed or cancelled, but that has not happed yet. The biggest impact so far is that vessels are taking longer to load at Hovensas St Croix refinery in the Caribbean, which typically processes Venezuelan crude. JEA, which witnessed the ups and downs of bringing two new boilers utilizing circulating fluidized bed (CFB) technology on line back-to-back in 2002 at its Northside 1 and 2 units, is being adversely affected by the Venezuelan strike. The utility has reportedly received several force majeure letters, and says it may have to put out a solicitation for coal if the situation is not resolved soon. But JEA said nothing was known at the time with regard to what it will decide to do. The utility last month said it will solicit for 2003 coke supplies this month or next (EAPC, December 5, 2002, p5). JEA has some coke supply contracts that extend into this year, but exact details are unavailable. In March 2002, JEA awarded up to 1.3mn tons of coke to Koch Carbon, TCP and SSM, and prior to that time awarded a supply contract to Aimcor for an unspecified volume of coke (EAPC, November 5, 2001, p6). JEAs 2002 coke burn was estimated between 400,000 and 500,000 tons, but once the two 300MW Northside units are utilizing 100% coke, they will combine for an annual burn of up to 1.6mn tons (EAPC, September 3, 2001, p6). JEA has yet to discover why it is having problems burning 100% coke at the units, and continues to run them on a 70:30 blend of coke and coal. But it is still the utilitys intention to run Units 1 and 2 on 100% coke as soon as they are able to do so. JEA, which conducted planned, two-week outages on its coke and coal burning Northside Units 1 and 2 in Jacksonville, Florida, last October and November, has announced additional maintenance for this spring (EAPC, December 6, 2002, p5). While last autumns outages prepared the units for the winter, JEA is planning to take both units down in March and April, for two to three weeks each, to make improvements for the summer run. The utility will do the work during the low load period, and will make engineering improvements and other various fixes, including limestone feed problems. Northside Units 1 and 2 will continue to burn a mixture of coke and coal
Page 5
Energy Argus Petroleum Coke this year, but JEAs goal is to have both units consuming 100% coke in 2004. Taiwan's Formosa Petrochemical has pushed ahead with its Mailiao refinery's new power plant despite persisting problems with the petroleum coke unit, using coal as a blend to make up for the shortfall on coke supply (EAPC, December 6, 2002, p5). The coker is designed to produce around 1mn t/yr, all of which is intended for consumption by the power plant at the 450,000 b/d refinery. But technical problems have prevented the coker getting up to full speed, although the situation does appear to be improving. Testing on the unit began way back in June. "We still have some time to go to get it running smoothly," a source at the privately owned refinery said. "But the power units are running." The source would not say exactly how much petroleum coke is currently being produced, but indicated that the situation has recently improved. A test run at 50% capacity in November could only be sustained for a few days. Electricity from the two new 150MW circulating fluidized bed (CFB) boilers at the plant is to be sold to Taiwan's national grid as well as supplying the Mailiao refinery itself. Formosa has enough coke of its own to blend with coal to run the power plants, the source said. No purchases of petroleum coke are being contemplated. The 540,000 b/d Reliance refinery at Jamnagar, on Indias northwest coast, is reportedly back to normal, and is producing close to 8,000mt/day of petroleum coke, a company official says. Industry sources in late 2002 suspected that Reliance had raised coke output from early year levels of 6,800mt/day, but the figures were never confirmed until now (EAPC, December 6, 2002, p7). Technical problems that surfaced at the refinery late last summer interrupted some output, and the problems have only now been corrected. With the additional coke production, Reliance has increased domestic sales, primarily into the cement industry. The Indian producer will export any surplus coke that is not utilized in the domestic market, but cannot commit any material in the near term, an official says. Venezuelan crisis slashes over 500,000 tons of production Venezuelas political crisis is showing no sign of resolution, over five weeks into a national strike aimed at removing President Hugo Chavez from power. The operations of stateowned PdV remain paralyzed, and prospects for a quick recovery from the crisis appear more remote with every passing day. Global crude and products have been impacted, and prices have shot higherincluding petroleum coke. Shortly after the strike began, PdV was forced to declare force majeure on all exports. Industry sources agree that close to 15,000 t/d of Venezuelan coke production is being lost due to the strike, and an additional 5,000 t/d at affected US Gulf coast and Caribbean
Report No. 03S-00-01 - Wednesday January 8, 2003 refineries. The strike started December 2, but not all refineries or upgraders were closed down that day. Closings came at different times, and some, such as Sincor, the PdV/TotalFinaElf/Statoil joint venture upgrader in Jose, Venezuela, came down as late as December 13. As a result, the industry estimates that over 500,000 tons of coke has been lost since the inception of the strike, at a time when the global coke market was already tight on supply. Some have put that figure closer to 1mn tons, and are quick to point out that even if the strike ended today, it would take another two to four weeks for refineries to ramp up after being shut down cold. Reports have emerged claiming serious damage to oil fields, refineries and other infrastructure that could delay a return to production when the current stalemate is resolved. One coke market participant called the Venezuelan situation a ticking time bomb, and said most people have yet to fully understand all the implications of the prolonged strike. In Venezuela alone, the three upgrading projects plus PdVs two coke-making refineries produce a combined 6.2mn tons of coke per year. PdVs coke output at the Cardon/Judibana refinery is 1.2mn t/yr, and another 800,000 tons is produced at the Amuay refinery. And the Cerro Negro, Sincor and Petrozuata upgraders account for the remainder of the coke production. Additionally, subsidiaries of PdV and Amerada Hess own the Hovensa refinery in St Croix, which has a capacity of 1.3mn t/yr. The exact status of US refiner Citgo, a wholly-owned subsidiary of PdV, is unknown, but most agree that it has avoided force majeure, but is scrambling to replace 650,000 b/d of Venezuelan crude. It has so far avoided deep run cuts at its Lake Charles, Louisiana and Corpus Christi, Texas, refineries. But the 260,000 b/d Citgo Lyondell Chemical refinery in Houston, which is 42pc owned by Citgo, has cut runs by roughly 50pc. Citgo produces 2.91mn t/yr of coke at its three refineries. Several US Gulf coast refineries have been directly affected by the strike. Murphys Meraux, Louisiana, plant, was running 15,000 b/d below capacity, while Lyondell-Citgo in Houston, Texas, slashed runs by half as of late December. ConocoPhillips in Sweeney, Texas, was about 40,000 b/d below capacity. Hovensa was reportedly well below capacity in December. With regard to coke production, Hovensa is operating anywhere from 60% to 100% of normal levels on a daily basis, industry sources say. The refiner is buying spot crudes, some of which are actually better quality than Venezuelan crude. Overall, Hovensa coke production has fallen one quarter since the beginning of the strike, sources say. But the producer has not had to cancel any coke deliveries due to the lower production. Many end users are reluctant to say how the Venezuelan strike is affecting them. One of the major cement producers says the strike has impacted them, but due to the complicated force
Page 6
Energy Argus Petroleum Coke majeure situation it cannot comment on anything. The producer said the strike impacts all buyers of coke, and hopes the matter is solved as soon as possible. Another cement producer in the Asia Pacific region does not know how the strike is affecting them at this time. Some lifters of Venezuelan coke say that the true implications of the strike could depend on how contracts with PdV are set up. The force majeure complicates the issue, and some contracts may end up being cancelled due to the strike. At least one US utility, JEA in Jacksonville, Florida, has hinted that it might be forced to put out a tender for coal, as its coke suppliers rely heavily on Venezuelan material. The utility previously fulfilled its 2003 coal requirements, but may need extra supplies now. Coke prices at the US Gulf coast have jumped about 20pc since the beginning of December due to the strike. The global coke market is very tight on supply, and most producers do not have any excess material to sell. The lingering question is how long will the strike last. But even if the strike ends today, the effects of the strike will persist throughout the year. Western Kentucky Energy (WKE ) has announced that it will receive spot bids on January 24 and term bids on February 7 for either coal or petroleum coke. The utility has not set any certain volumes for the solicitations, primarily given current market conditions. But the minimum monthly bid is for 5,000 t from any bidder or supplier. WKE has not been active in the coke market recently due to the current pricing of coke versus coal. The utility says it would be surprised to see many bids for petroleum coke given current market conditions.
Page 7
Report No. 03S-00-01 - Wednesday January 8, 2003 after hurricanes shut in offshore production. The shortfall in the Gulf coast will soon spread inland to the high-consuming midcontinent region, where crude stocks have been close to historic lows for several months. There is now a strong argument for Washington to release some of the 600mn bl Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR). But it is unlikely to do so, even if consumers are hit by high prices, because SPR oil is seen an insurance policy against supply disruptions during an attack on Iraq. With no end to the political stand-off in sight, crude prices look set to rise further. And higher product prices will follow swiftly if US demand remains close to the current 20mn b/d. Colder than average temperatures on the US Atlantic coast have boosted distillate deliveries to their highest level in two years. And robust gasoline demand is keeping pressure on refiners to rebuild inventories before the start of the next driving season. A shortage of crude now could mean tight gasoline supplies and high pump prices in the spring.
Page 8
Energy Argus Petroleum Coke the Venezuelan crisis, indicating that output may be raised if the upper $28/bl limit is breached for 20 days. The Opec promise temporarily stemmed the rise in prices. But extra supplies from the Middle East will be of little immediate help to Gulf coast refiners. There is no ready substitute for short-haul Venezuelan supply. And strong demand from Asia has already cut the volume of long-haul oil moving west this month. Political debate in the US has focused on the countrys dependence on Middle East oil. But the loss of a major source of supply just a few days away by sea is potentially much more serious. Any disruption to Iraqi output could be more easily managed, as western refiners would be cushioned by the six-week voyage. Losses of short-haul supply give little time to find alternative supplies and this is precisely why stocks need to be maintained at reasonable levels. Yet in the past four years Opec has drained the industry of stocks in order to push up prices. Crude stocks held by US refiners are close to historical lows, and there is now a compelling case for Washington to release oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR). But Washington has its own agenda. It has been building up stocks in the SPR ahead of the expected assault on Iraq, and now refuses to release oil to cover the crisis in Venezuela. How quickly the oil market has flipped from feast to famine faster, perhaps, than policy makers can think or respond. Two months ago, after a $5/bl slide in prices, Opec ministers were worried about oversupply. Now prices are at a two-year high, Venezuela has stopped exporting and war looms in the Middle East. But there has been minimal political reaction to the changed circumstances, either from the US or Opec. Politicians did not foresee the change. The industry will have to cope alone. No country plans to fight two wars simultaneously, and the industry does not plan for two oil crises. This year it may have to find a way to do just that.
Report No. 03S-00-01 - Wednesday January 8, 2003 The parties have committed to significantly increase both the refining and smelting capacities at Pingguo over the next few years. The current alumina expansion should be completed in the middle of this year, at with time the capacity of the alumina plant will be 850,000 t/yr. There are also plans to expand the 130,000mt/yr aluminum smelter at Pingguo by 250,000mt/yr, bring total capacity to 380,000mt/yr by 2006. Both parties expect to finalize the necessary arrangements and obtain government approvals by the second half of this year. No US regulatory approvals are required. Chalco is the sole alumina producer and the largest producer of primary aluminum in China, and was ranked 2nd in terms of alumina production volume in 2001 in the world. Its mining, refining and smelting operations are the largest in the Chinese aluminum industry. Alcoa is the worlds leading producer of primary aluminum, fabricated aluminum and alumina, and is active in all major aspects of the industry.
Page 9
Energy Argus Petroleum Coke an Opec delegate told Argus. Opec ministers are holding consultations over the telephone to decide the exact amount of the increase, which would use the new 23mn b/d January output target for Opec s 10 participating members as a baseline, said the Opec delegate. An extraordinary Opec meeting is being convened in Vienna on 12 January to discuss an increase in production, indicating that some of the group's members disagree with the proposal to officially hike output by up to 2mn b/d. Kuwait's acting oil minister Sheikh Ahmad al-Fahd alSabah said his country favors a 1mn b/d increase, while others appear to favor sticking to the 500,000 b/d increase called for by the mechanism. One of the issues under discussion is how to allocate the increase on a pro-rata basis, given that the level of Venezuela s output will remain unknown. Asked if Opec s nine members excluding Iraq and Venezuela have enough spare capacity to offset a possible simultaneous export halt by these two countries, the first Opec delegate said: "We are not going to deal with ifs." If a US-led war on Iraq coincides with a continued curtailment in Venezuelan exports, some 4mn5mn b/d would be lost, straining Opec's spare capacity to the limit. Momentum for an output rise has been building within Opec since last weekend.
Report No. 03S-00-01 - Wednesday January 8, 2003 stand around 4.5mn t, of which 1.8mnt is iron ore. Market sources say that while there were fewer vessels than expected during December, activity is forecast to increase at the port over the next few days. The EMO terminal handled 20mn t of coal last year, while the smaller port of EBS processed 3mn t. EMO's maximum coal-unloading capacity is roughly 175,000 t/d. The EBS terminal, in Rotterdam's Botlek area, offers facilities for efficiently discharging ships up to 70,000 tons. But EBS offers board-board facilities for longer vessels in the Beneluxhaven (Europoort).
Page 10
Coal Markets
European physical coal prices have leapt up around $1/t during the past four weeks, following a spate of buying by a number of Scandinavian utilities and concerns over the further tightening of South African supply. Scandinavian buyers have been seen in the market purchasing coal for prompt delivery at higher levels after lower hydro output helped to boost coal burn. Physical coal prices in Europe (cif Rotterdam) currently stand at $35.65/t, while South African fob prices are reported at $27.71/t. Driven by the onset of winter temperatures in the US and increased buying activity from utilities, eastern US spot coal prices strengthened noticeably during the past month. Prices for most coal specifications have increased by at least $1/ton since the beginning of December, and may strengthen further, especially if utilities continue to increase their coal burns. A substantial amount of coal remains available among eastern coal producers, but many utilities may be forced to enter the market at the same time in the coming months, resulting in a much-anticipated price spike. Many utilities are working with smaller stockpiles than normal during the winter season. Although there were alternative sources of coal being offered into the ARA region, strengthening freight rates were helping to keep these products off the market. Towards the end of the month the route 4 freight rate reached $10.70/t.
Crude Markets
Crude prices were driven sharply higher in December as a strike by employees at Venezuela's PdV erased over 2mn b/d of supply from the market. Since much of the country's output is higher-sulphur crude, the loss was felt most sharply among prices for alternatives like US domestic Mars and Ecuador's Oriente. The cash price for US benchmark WTI hit its highest level since November of 2000 at more than $32/bl, even as liquidity in the Americas crude markets dried up alongside falling supply. Worsening jitters over a possible war in Iraq also supported crude prices as the month wore on, and the premium for prompt oil over forward oil soared. Yet US purchases of Iraqi crude accelerated as refiners scrambled to replace lost Venezuelan supply. Availabilities of even light sweet crude from the North Sea and west Africa were quickly snapped up in the US at everincreasing premiums to WTI. And in a testament to the bad timing inherent in trying to manage a commodity as complex as oil, Opec met mid-month to ratify a cut to real output of up to 1.7mn b/d. Only weeks later it was reconsidering that decision as prices stayed above the organisation's price band. Traders watched closely to see if the US Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) could be tempted to release some of its stocks, which finished the month nearing the 600mn bl mark. But reserve officials instead agreed only to allow deferrals of deliveries scheduled for December and January.
SO2 Markets
The SO2 emissions market stayed within its post-Enron range between $125 and $135. The market finished up at $131. The bulk of SO2 volume for last week took place on just two days where 29,000t and 15,000t traded respectively. Trading of SO2 forwards and future vintages in December was extremely light, due to the major decline of speculative trading, another result of the Enron collapse.
Asphalt Markets
Higher feedstock costs forced US asphalt producing refiners to raise their asphalt winter-fill prices. The higher quotes have come at a time when US buyers typically expect to see the lowest wholesale prices of the season. Surging prices for highdensity fuel oil in northwest Europe and the Mediterranean failed to have an impact on bitumen prices. Many marketers expect pressure on bitumen prices of up to Euros 25/t in January, the result of rising feedstock costs. Southeast Asian asphalt prices found support on strengthening fuel oil and crude, but demand for prompt supplies petered out ahead of the year-end holidays. North Asian asphalt demand slowed in the winter season as refiners switched to fuel oil production.
Page 11
Coal forward curve: Represents the level of contango or backwardation in the coal markets by charting the price for forward delivery on the day quoted. BTU Comparison: Compares the relative values of different fuels on a BTU basis. Conversions for mmBtu per unit are: Diesel 5.79/bl, 0.3pc fuel oil 6.258/bl, 1pc fuel oil 6.384/bl, Coal 24/short ton (12,000 btu), Coke 30.86/metric ton (14,000 btu). New York 0.3% fuel oil is high pour and includes New York taxes. Coal and coke values include cost of sulphur allowances. Spark Spread: Indicates the relative profitability of burning various fuels in a northeastern US power plant. The spark spread is the difference between the spot power price and the cost of generating output from a given fuel based on a heat rate of 10,000. Coal and coke adjusted for SO2 allowances: A comparison of the true cost of coal and coke at a US electric generating plant after sulphur allowances are included. The spot price of coal and coke is adjusted for the cost of sulphur dioxide emissions, assuming the plant applies sulfur dioxide allowances at the current market price for those allowances. The SO2 index price is listed on page 1 of the report. Light/Heavy Product Spread A measure of the profitability of coking. For the Gulf coast, the spread is the average of prompt 87 octane conventional gasoline and prompt diesel in Houston, less the price of 3pc sulphur fuel oil fob US Gulf coast. For the West coast, the spread is the average of prompt 87 octane CARB gasoline and prompt CARB diesel in Los Angeles, less the price of 380 CST fuel oil in Los Angeles. US Exports of Non-Calcined Coke Source: United States International Trade Commission, http://dataweb.usitc.gov/. Clarkson's Freight Rates Rates are assessments for day quoted and assume a 65,000 metric ton dry bulk vessel, with a 45 foot draft at load port and no other restrictions.
Page 12