Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PROBLEM:
Probiotic yogurt as a
Functional Food
ARE PROBIOTICS IN YOGURT BENEFICIAL FOR HEALTH, REALLY?
STUDENTS:
-
SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES:
-
FRAMEWORK:
PROBIOTICS
Probiotics are described as live microorganisms which, when administered in adequate
amounts, confer a health benefit on the host.
Although there is a long history of health claims concerning living microorganisms in food,
the term probiotic appeared only in the 1960s, and since then a number of definitions have
appeared in the literature. The term probiotic, which comes from the Greek meaning for
life, was originally used by Lilly and Stillwell in 1965 to describe substances secreted by
one microorganism that stimulate the growth of another. It was later described by Parker in
1974 as animal feed supplements that have a beneficial effect on the host animal by
affecting its gut flora. Fuller found this definition unsatisfactory as it did not exclude
antibiotics, and redefined a probiotic as a live microbial feed supplement that beneficially
affects the host animal by improving its intestinal microbial balance.Fullers definition was
expanded to state that a probiotic is a mono- or mixed culture of live microorganisms that,
when applied to animal or man, affects the host beneficially by improving the properties of
the indigenous microflora.This definition stresses the importance of live microorganisms
that occur in the mouth, gastrointestinal tract (GIT), upper respiratory or urogenital tracts
and improve the health status of both man and animal.
In 1998, Guarner and Schaafsma introduced the concept of consuming adequate numbers
of probiotics to reach target sites in the body, and described them as living organisms
that, upon ingestion in certain numbers, exert health effects beyond inherent general
nutrition.
The health benefits of probiotics are derived from specific bacterial strains that have
demonstrated clinical efficacy; products may not be considered a probiotic unless they
confer a proven health benefit.
Combining more than one probiotic strain in a single product does not necessarily
enhance the benefits of each strain, and may in fact interfere with the activity already
proven. Further studies are needed to determine the efficacy of combinations of strains.
The most used microorganisms like probiotics are showed in this table.
colonization. Other examples of the influence of LAB on the respiratory system were
shown in two different randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies by Hatakka
and de Vrese. The former group showed that there was a reduction in the number of
children afflicted with respiratory tract infections in the group that received milk with Lb.
GG, compared to those who drank milk without Lb. GG.
Michael De Vrese studied the effects of three LAB strains (Lb. gasseri, B. longum SP, and
B. bifidum MF) on the common cold. They found that daily consumption of these LAB
strains for 3 months reduced the severity and duration, but not incidence, of common cold
episodes in 479 healthy adults. One of the most widely touted benefits of yogurt
consumption is said to be the enhancement of the immune system. It has been proposed
that LAB and fermented milk modulate certain parameters of both the nonspecific and
specific immune responses. The link between these benefits and the immune system,
however, has not been identified, and the mechanisms involved are still unknown.
Yoghurt and other fermented milks are foods that have achieved great popularity for
various reasons , a greater awareness by consumers of the relationship between food and
health , the importance of preventing disease, widespread search for a healthier old age
and , of course, more scientific evidence of the effectiveness of these products .
SIDE EFFECTS
Digestive problems
Side effects of probiotics rarely occur, but the most common side effect is gastrointestinal
upset. When large dose of probiotics is consumed, they adjust the balance of flora in the
digestive tract or possibly gases resulting in abdominal discomfort. These side effects are
usually temporary and ultimately benign. Generally, probiotics have the opposite effect:
The probiotic supplements are useful in the treatment of gastrointestinal disorders such as
bacterial retrovirus and irritable bowel syndrome. The process of biological adaptation, no
probiotic supplements in itself is probably the cause of stomach problems.
Infection
It is theoretically possible that the live bacteria in probiotic supplements may colonize on
the intestines, causing infection. Although no case reports of this complication occurs, it
may be a risk to infants, the elderly and people with severely compromised immune
systems. Treatment for this type of infection may require antibiotics. Because of this
potential risk, people who are immune compromised should use caution when taking very
large doses of probiotics. However, it should be noted that the risk of such side effects is
minimal. Probiotics are normally consumed in foods and nutritional supplements for people
of all ages and conditions, and has not been known that infection-related complications
occurred.
Overstimulation
Overstimulation of the immune system is another complication that is theoretically
possible, but has not been recorded so far. If the body is "wrong" with probiotics believing
they are foreign invaders and infection can lead to a similar response to infection. This can
cause a high white count, fever, fatigue and possibly even blood cells. Probiotics have not
been well studied in people with autoimmune diseases. Although it may be beneficial for
people with autoimmune disorders, people of this group may be at greater risk for this rare
and unknown complication. Anyone with an autoimmune disorder or an extraordinarily
aggressive immune system should use caution when taking large doses of probiotics.
Metabolic changes
Probiotics may slightly alter the function of the colon, resulting in unusual changes in
metabolism. Some people may experience more frequent to take probiotics while others
may experience a slowdown in bowel habits bowel movements. Metabolic changes can
cause weight gain, weight loss or absorption problems. For most people using probiotics,
adjustments in body metabolism will be positive and desired. However, if these changes
are uncomfortable or injurious to health for the person taking probiotics, you should adjust
your dose or stop taking the supplements.
Yoghurt
Yogurt is produced using active cultures of bacteria to ferment cream or milk. Yogurt that
is produced in the United States is made with two specific live and active cultures of lactic
acid bacteria (LAB)Lactobacillus bulgaricus (Lb. bulgaricus) and Streptococcus
thermophilus (S. thermophilus). These bacteria metabolize some of the milk sugar
(lactose) in the milk into lactic acid. This action helps change the consistency of liquid milk
into yogurt. The production of fermented milk, or yogurt, requires that the milk is first
concentrated by the addition of dairy solids, evaporated, or membrane filtered. The mixture
is then heated to destroy undesirable organisms, and cooled. Then, the starter cultures are
added. Yogurt products may also have added ingredients such as sugar, sweeteners,
fruits or vegetables, flavoring compounds, sodium chloride, coloring stabilizers, and
preservatives. In the United States, Lb. bulgaricus and S. thermophilus are required by
U.S.
The fermentation process involves the inoculation of pasteurized milk that has been
enriched in milk protein with concentrated cultures of bacteria, which is then incubated at
4044C for 45 h. During fermentation, lactic acid is produced from lactose by the yogurt
bacteria, the population of which increases 100- to 10,000-fold to a final concentration of
approximately 109/mL. The reduction in pH, due to the production of lactic acid, causes a
destabilization of the micellar casein at a pH of 5.1 to 5.2, with complete coagulation
occurring around pH 4.6. At the desired final pH, the coagulated milk is cooled quickly to
410C to slow down the fermentation process.
Fermentation of milk with LAB leads to specific organoleptic characteristics (taste, aroma)
of the final product. The metabolism of LAB and the interactions between the selected
strains are responsible for the production of lactic acid, the coagulation of milk proteins,
and the production of various compounds. Variables such as temperature, pH, the
presence of oxygen, and the composition of the milk further contribute to the particular
features of a specific product. Fermented milks exhibit a wide variety of textures ranging
from liquid drinks such as kefir, koumiss, and acidophilus milk to semisolid or firm products
including yogurt, filmjolk, villi, dahi, and leben.
Certain strains of S. thermophilus, Lb. bulgaricus, and other LAB, such as Lactococcus
cremoris and some species of Leuconostoc, produce exocellular polysaccharides that
modify the texture of a fermented milk product i.e., by increasing the viscosity or creating a
ropy texture. Lactic acid is also responsible for the slightly tart taste of the fermented milk
product, whereas the other characteristic flavors and aromas are additional results of LAB
metabolism. For example, acetaldehyde provides the characteristic aroma of yogurt,
whereas diacetyl, produced by Lc. Diacetylactis and Leuconostoc cremoris, impart a
buttery taste to some fermented milks. Acetoin, acetone, lactones, and volatile acids are
other important flavor components that may be present in certain fermented milks as byproducts of bacterial metabolism.
There is a symbiotic relationship, also known as protocooperation, between S.
thermophilus and Lb. bulgaricus, in which each species of bacteria stimulates the growth
of the other. Lb. bulgaricus stimulates the growth of S. thermophilus by liberating amino
acids and peptides from milk proteins; which enable S. thermophiles to grow faster in the
early part of incubation. S. thermophilus in turn produces formic acid, which stimulates the
growth of Lb. bulgaricus, resulting in a shortened fermentation time and a product with
characteristics different than that of milk fermented with a single species.
SECOND PART
CHAPTER 1: PROBIOTICS
Probiotics
Probiotics are described as live microorganisms which, when administered in adequate
amounts, confer a health benefit on the host.
Generally probiotics are described as live microorganisms which, when administered in
adequate amounts, confer a health benefit on the host. Examples of health benefits
associated with the consumption of probiotics include a decrease in rotavirus shedding in
infants, reductions in antibiotic-associated diarrhea, reduction in the incidence of childhood
atopic eczema, and management of inflammatory bowel diseases such as Crohns
disease. Foods containing probiotics, such as fermented milks, yogurts, and cheese, fall
within the functional food category, which includes any fresh or processed food claimed to
have health-promoting and/or disease-preventing properties beyond the basic nutritional
function of supplying nutrients. The area of probiotics, prebiotics, and synbiotics represent
the largest segment of the functional food market in Europe, Japan, and Australia.
Lactobacillus casei
In order to exert health benefits on the host, probiotics must be able to grow in the human
intestine, and, therefore, should possess the capability to survive passage hrough the
gastrointestinal tract (GIT), which involves exposure to hydrochloric acid in the stomach
and bile in the small intestine. Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium species are ideal probiotic
candidates for incorporation into foods for human consumption. These microorganisms are
known inhabitants of the gastrointestinal tract (GIT) and share a number of common traits
such as acid and bile tolerance, the ability to adhere to intestinal cells, and GRAS status
(generally regarded as safe).
A major challenge associated with the application of probiotic cultures in the development
of functional foods is the retention of viability during processing. Given that probiotics are
generally of intestinal origin, many such strains of bacteria are unsuitable for growth in
dairy-based media, and are inactivated upon exposure to high temperatures, acid, or
oxygen during dairy and food processing. The survival of bifidobacteria during processing
can be particularly challenging, as these are strictly anaerobic microorganisms with
Classification
The classification of probiotics can be compared to that of people. That is, genus
corresponds to family name, species to given name, and strain to fingerprints.
The health benefits of probiotics are derived from specific bacterial strains that have
demonstrated clinical efficacy; products may not be considered a probiotic unless they
confer a proven health benefit.
Combining more than one probiotic strain in a single product does not necessarily
enhance the benefits of each strain, and may in fact interfere with the activity already
proven. Further studies are needed to determine the efficacy of combinations of strains.
Probiotics are classed by group (e.g., lactic acid bacteria), genus (e.g., Bifidobacterium,
Lactobacillus), species (e.g., casei, plantarum, bulgaricus, johnsonii) and strain (e.g., DN173 010, DN-114 001, GG).
With many people having the same first or last name, identification can be difficult but
fingerprints are unique, allowing accurate identification of an individual.
Probiotics work in much the same way: if we dont know their strain, we cant know which
specific role they play in the body.
In order to better communicate with consumers, the names of certain strains have been
modified by manufacturers. As an example, while the precise scientific name of the
probiotic in DanActive yogourt isLactobacillus casei DN-114 001, what appears on the
packaging is L. casei Defensis. This practice is common, with the intention being to help
consumers understand the benefit or remember the probiotic more easily. That being said,
a legitimate company will always specify the exact scientific name of the strain, and this is
what consumers should be encouraged to look for.
Distinguishing between the different types of probiotics is important, since each strain
plays a specific role. In fact, it is the strain that determines a probiotics role, and not just
the genus.
The differences in properties between strains do not indicate with certainty that all their
effects on the host would be different; however, this possibility must be considered, at
least until proved otherwise. It is not impossible that the presence of a well identified active
substance in a probiotic may be shown to be sufficient to permit a reliable prediction that
an effect will be obtained. However, this is unlikely in the near future and will require solid
verification. It is therefore generally accepted that the effects of one strain cannot be
extrapolated to another. In other words, clinical studies on the strain itself are required
before any claim can be made.
Producers can use this characteristic to protect the specificities of their products.
Advertising or claims referring to similar strains must not be used in scientific or
promotional dossiers or brochures, neither in their evaluations.
The most used microorganisms like probiotics are showed in this table.
2. - Prebiotics:
Prebiotics are non-digestible food ingredients that stimulate the growth and/or activity of
bacteria in the digestive system in ways claimed to be beneficial to health. They were first
identified and named by Marcel Roberfroid in 1995.
A prebiotic effect occurs when there is an increase in the activity of healthy bacteria in the
human
intestine.
The
prebiotics
stimulate
the
growth
of
healthy such
as bifidobacteria and lactobacilli in the gut and increase resistance to invading pathogens.
This effect is induced by consuming functional foods that contain prebiotics. These foods
induce metabolic activity, leading to health improvements. Healthy bacteria in the intestine
can combat unwanted bacteria, providing a number of health benefits.
Prebiotics are non-digestible but fermentable oligosaccharides that are specifically
designed to change the composition and activity of the intestinal microbiota or microflora
with prospect to promote the health of the host.
Synbiotics:
prebiotics.
Salmonella, Listeria, and Campylobacter without disturbing the normal microbiota. They
also found in this study that the Lb. gasseri that strongly attached to the intestinal Caco-2
cells inhibited the attachment of Escherichia coli 0111 under the condition of exclusion.
Ability to survive passage through the GIT is a requirement in order to confer health
benefits to the host. Acid tolerance, tolerance to human gastric juice, and bile tolerance
should all be established by using in vitro methods.
Probiotic microorganisms should also be technologically suitable for incorporation into food
products, such that they retain both viability and efficacy in that food product (to a
commercial scale) prior to and following consumption. Probiotics should be capable of
surviving industrial applications (e.g., common dairy processing methods using
pharmaceutical manufacturing protocols), of thriving in the product to the end of shelf life,
and of having an acceptable taste throughout the storage time. Above all, probiotic food
products must demonstrate efficacy in controlled and validated clinical trials to prove that
the probiotic characteristics were not altered or lost during manufacturing.
CONCLUSIONS
Probiotic research has expanded rapidly over the past few years. One of the many
reasons for this is the heightened awareness of their clinically proven healthpromoting effects in humans, and hence the growing interest in the incorporation of
probiotic microorganisms into food products.
The mechanisms by which functional microbes and ingredients affect human gut
health are still largely unknown. The knowledge acquired by genomics on the
genetics and physiology of a probiotic strain can be used for strain improvement.
The great challenge of growing probiotic cultures at a manufacturing plant can only
be tackled by using a holistic approach and having qualified personnel and
sophisticated quality control laboratories.
Many species in such fermented foods have the potential to be probiotic, health
attributes can only be expected if strains having documented clinical effects are
used.
A higher number of strains is not proof of greater efficacy.
The effect of one strain cannot be extrapolated to another.
Some strains are not recommended for human use. Species from bacterial genera
like Bacillus cereus and Enterococcus have also been used as probiotics, but
because these species contain strains known to be pathogenic (this is particularly
true of Enterococcus), there are concerns for their safe use. The onus must be on
producers to prove that their strains are not pathogenic.
RECOMMENDATION
Foods or supplements containing probiotics would list the following information on their
labels:
Description of genus, species and strain.
The minimum viable numbers of each probiotic strain at the end of the products
shelf life.
A suggested serving size, which must deliver an effective dose of probiotics
relative to the health claim.
The health claim.
Proper storage conditions.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
EDWARD R. FARNWORTH, Handbook of Fermented Functional Food. Second
Edition. Ed. CRC Press, 2008. Pages 1 25, 129 165, 513 537.
CLYDESDALE, F., Functional foods: opportunities and challenges, Full report at:
www.ift.org, IFT Expert Reports, 2005. Pages 58 35.