You are on page 1of 7

Earn

4.0 Contact
Hours

Late-Onset Posttraumatic
Stress Disorder
Abstract
Posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is derrecognized and undertreated disorder
a complex psychological response to a that can result in psychosocial disability,
perceived life-threatening trauma that in- substance use, and other negative health
© 2008/Comstock, JupiterImages Corporation

cludes re-experiencing the trauma, avoid- outcomes. This article examines the range
ance, intrusive thoughts, hyperarousal, and of symptoms related to PTSD in older adults
dissociation. Exposure to trauma in early and expands on health care provider sensi-
adulthood increases the potential for fur- tivity to the interrelationship of mental and
ther psychological threats throughout life. physical health when addressing the needs
In older adult populations, PTSD is an un- of older adults with this disorder.

Marsha Snyder, PhD, PMHCNS, BC

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing • Vol. 46, No. 11, 2008 39


W
ithin the last cen- 2005). In the case of older adults, l Subjective sense of numb-

tury, the average life research surrounding trauma and ing or detachment.
span has increased responses to trauma has been pri- l Reduced awareness of sur-

by 37%, with many people liv- marily inclusive of male veteran roundings.
ing well into their 80s and 90s. It populations. However, several l Derealization, depersonal-

is estimated that by 2030, more studies do address trauma-related ization, or dissociative amnesia.
than 15 million older adults will issues for civilian older adult fe- These symptoms block processing
experience a mental illness. The male populations. An area of re- of traumatic memories and adap-
aging of the Baby Boomer cohort cent interest is the reoccurrence tation. Interestingly, individuals
and greater longevity is responsi- of trauma-related stress symp- who develop PTSD do not always
ble for this statistic (U.S. Depart- toms in later life. report Cluster B symptoms (Bry-
ment of Health and Human Ser- ant, 2003). It is proposed that
vices [USDHHS], Office of the Acute Stress Disorder both individuals who experience
Surgeon General, 1999). The es- The majority of individuals all symptoms and those who ex-
timated prevalence rate for anxi- exposed to an acute stress epi- perience all but Cluster B symp-
ety disorders in adults age 55 and sode will recover in the months toms can be at risk for developing
older is approximately 11%. This following the traumatic event PTSD (Bryant, 2003). Symptoms
percentage is greater than that of and will not require formal inter- can abate and resurface over
any other disorder associated with vention. These individuals fall months or years and can reoccur
older adults (USDHHS, Office of within the diagnostic categories in full force if the person is retrau-
the Surgeon General, 1999). In outlined in the Diagnostic and matized. While survivor symp-
particular, posttraumatic stress Statistical Manual of Mental Dis- toms can persist as an individual
disorder (PTSD) in older adults orders, fourth edition, text revi- ages into older adulthood, how
is an underrecognized and under- sion (American Psychiatric As- these symptoms are expressed is
treated disorder that can result in sociation, 2000) for acute stress very individual and may depend
psychosocial disability, substance disorder (ASD) (Bryant, 2003). on genetic and epigenetic fac-
use, and other negative health Symptoms related to ASD occur tors, premorbid personality traits,
outcomes. For this reason, the within a month of a traumatic early life experiences, and social
purpose of this article is to exam- event. Symptoms are categorized support (Weintraub & Ruskin,
ine this disorder as it relates to into six areas: 1999). Consistent findings report
older adults and increase health l Cluster A—fearful re- that delayed onset of PTSD is rare
care provider sensitivity to the sponse after a traumatic event. when no prior exposure to trauma
interrelationship of mental and l Cluster B—three dissocia- has occurred (Andrews, Brewin,
physical health when addressing tive symptoms. Philpott, & Stewart, 2007).
the needs of older adults with l Cluster C—re-experienc-
this disorder. ing symptoms. Predictive Factors
l Cluster D—marked avoid- for PTSD
Differential Diagnosis ance. Age can offer a protective
of PTSD l Cluster E—marked anxiety. shield against the effects of a trau-
As Americans live longer, l Cluster F—evidence of sig- matic event through the passage
the psychological stressors some nificant distress or impairment in of time and successful life expe-
individuals sustained at earlier everyday task completion. riences. Factors that seem to be
life stages can become deterrents associated with resilience against
to successful aging (USDHHS, PTSD the development of PTSD in-
Office of the Surgeon General, Disturbance in all six areas clude marriage, social support,
1999). This is especially true identified for ASD must last a increased socioeconomic sta-
for individuals who are exposed minimum of 2 days and a maxi- tus, and religion (Weintraub &
to trauma related to combat, mum of 4 weeks before the diag- Ruskin, 1999). Across studies, no
ravages of war, sexual abuse, or nosis of PTSD can be assigned. agreement has been reached on
events a person conceptualizes as Three Cluster B symptoms of dis- the symptom combination that is
catastrophic, and when available sociation need to be present for a predictive of PTSD, and for this
coping mechanisms fail (Murray, diagnosis of ASD: reason, increased attention has

40 JPNonline.com
been directed toward biological ened declarative memory sug- tive responses are demonstrated
indicators (Bryant, 2003). gestive of hippocampal involve- through persistent negative ap-
ment; impairment in working praisal of the traumatic event
Biological Indicators memory suggestive of prefrontal, and subsequent events through
The connection between the cingulated, temporal, and pari- disturbance in memory that is
basal ganglia, limbic system, and etal cortexes; and neurotransmit- characterized by “poor elabo-
prefrontal cortex brain structures ter systems associated with dopa- ration and contextualization,
are well supported in the litera- mine and serotonin (Grossman strong associative memory, and
ture. This connection seems to et al., 2006). strong perceptual priming” (Bry-
include processing of both so- Increases in these measures ant, 2003, p. 792).
cial and emotional information seem to reflect a preexisting vul- As the traumatic event is pro-
(Flannelly, Koenig, Galek, & El- nerability trait that heightens cessed, understanding and mean-
lison, 2007). The basal ganglia, the risk for developing PTSD fol- ing are attributed to the event
although primitive, provides an lowing a traumatic event. Func- within the contexts of social and
autonomic system for threat as- tional brain images for patients cultural environments. Studies
sessment. The basal ganglia and who have had PTSD reflect sig- indicate the level of psychologi-
the limbic system operate in pre- nificant activation in the ventral cal impact of the trauma experi-
consciousness for both language frontoparietal network and left ence on the individual depends
and emotional arousal. For this hippocampal area, which are heavily on pretrauma function-
reason, in the case of PTSD, as-
sessment of threat is excessive and
sometimes in error, as the person
perceives a threat when there is
Opportunity exists for primary care and
none. All three brain components psychiatric nurses to come together and shape a
(basal ganglia, limbic system, and
prefrontal cortex) rely on sensory system of care that is responsive to patient needs.
input from the prefrontal cortex
and amygdala for their assessment
information regarding a threat, connected with visual attention ing. Preexisting depression and
as well as past experience and and memory (Bryant, 2003). As anxiety and multiple trauma
memories. Judgments regarding a result, even slight traumatic exposures seem to increase an
threat potential seem to be routed stimuli can initiate flashbacks individual’s vulnerability to the
primarily through emotional pro- in the presence of poor concen- stressors related to trauma, with
cessing rather than through cog- tration and attention. It seems the highest rates of PTSD as-
nitive reasoning and, as a result, this traumatic stimulus becomes sociated with violent or sexual
are unconscious, rapid, and auto- associated with arousal and sub- trauma (Nakell, 2007).
matic, with the response outcome sequent development of fear
not necessarily within a person’s conditioning that can trigger fur- POPULATIONs at risk
conscious awareness (Flannelly et ther conditioning. Mechanisms Veteran Survivors
al., 2007). for this sensitization are unclear, Veterans who meet criteria
Another area of biological but it does seem evident that re- for PTSD also report symptoms
investigation is research that ad- petitive activation of traumatic of major depression, generalized
dresses the relationship between memories increases sensitivity anxiety disorder, panic disorder,
increased glucocorticoid levels within the limbic system (Bry- and alcohol abuse. Older vet-
and PTSD symptoms. On the ba- ant, 2003). erans seen in primary care who
sis of peripheral and neuroendo- reported depression and symp-
crine studies of individuals with Psychological Indicators toms of PTSD also reported more
PTSD symptoms, Grossman et Development and continued suicidal ideation, smoking, and
al. (2006) reported greater sensi- experience of acute and chronic negative perceptions of their
tivity in the central brain to glu- symptoms of PTSD are mediated health than did those who did
cocorticoids. This phenomenon by cognitive responses to the not report these symptoms. These
was expressed through height- traumatic event. These cogni- symptoms contributed to difficul-

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing • Vol. 46, No. 11, 2008 41


ty concentrating, worry, feelings years. As levels of activity shift not a coward, or fear of having
of worthlessness, and depressed from productivity to introspec- a serious physical or mental dis-
mood (Rauch, Morales, Zubritsky, tion—in combination with losses order (Murray, 2005). Initially,
Knott, & Oslin, 2006). Although in daily structure and routine, self- avoidance behaviors serve to in-
intrusive thoughts, hyperarousal, esteem, status, and social interac- sulate the individual from trigger
avoidance, and dissociation are tion—usual coping mechanisms situations, but when the ability
associated with PTSD, veterans are threatened and challenged to meet everyday needs is inter-
reported that over time they ex- (Weintraub & Ruskin, 1999). rupted because of the inability
perienced a decline in intrusive to focus on anything other than
thoughts and survivor guilt. How- Older Female Survivors the triggers, older adults may be
ever, these survivors reported that Older women are at higher risk motivated to seek help (Murray,
avoidance symptoms and estrange- for PTSD than are older men due 2005). When older adults even-
ment from others were symptoms to higher rates of sexual and do- tually do seek help, it is because
that lingered into advanced age mestic physical abuse experienced they feel unsafe or have physical
(Nakell, 2007). The relationship by women. Although they are at symptoms. Seeking psychiatric
between PTSD and alcohol abuse higher risk, older women are un- help for their difficulties is gener-
is reflected inconsistently in data derdiagnosed for PTSD and are ally not a serious consideration.
(Rauch et al., 2006). given diagnoses related to depres-
War veterans seem to be at sion, anxiety, or poor health. As a Primary Care and Older
increased risk for reactivation of result, women may seek help more Adults
PTSD symptoms in later life. In frequently, but they do not always Due to feelings of stigma asso-
an extensive review of case stud- receive appropriate intervention ciated with seeking mental health
ies and group studies literature, or treatment (Franco, 2007). Old- treatment, older adults will most
Andrews et al. (2007) suggested er women who sustained repeated likely seek help within primary
the delay in onset of PTSD symp- physical assault at an early age care. Primary care settings offer
toms is likely due to reactivation report more negative emotional the option of community-based
of prior symptoms rather than responses to the event than do services that are convenient and
delay in onset of the disorder. those who reported being sexually affordable. Within primary care,
In midlife, these veterans did assaulted (Acierno et al., 2007). mental disorders in older adults
not report symptoms related to Women who sustained a sexual can be both identified and treated
any stress disorder, but later in assault up to 50 years prior to cur- (USDHHS, Office of the Surgeon
advancing years, they began to rent symptom expression report General, 1999). Co-occurrence of
reminisce about combat-related autonomic arousal and avoidance psychiatric problems with medi-
thoughts and feelings (Andrews symptoms associated with PTSD cal disorders can significantly af-
et al., 2007). Persistence of (Acierno et al., 2007). The impact fect the trajectory of a medical
PTSD symptoms has been linked of early and repeated trauma on disorder (Nakell, 2007). Sleep
to premorbid personality traits or current symptoms is critical when disturbance, a symptom associated
experiences, as shown in older treating older women and must with both aging and PTSD, can be
male combat veterans who were be considered an integral part of a further compromised by posttrau-
exposed to highly stressful events health assessment (Franco, 2007). matic nightmares and flashbacks,
either in their childhood or in which can lead to increased psy-
combat as young adults (Wein- Implications for chiatric complaints. Nakell (2007)
traub & Ruskin, 1999). Practice reported that individuals with de-
The chronic nature of PTSD Many older adults will at- pression who also screened positive
increases victims’ vulnerability to tempt to live with multiple for PTSD reported more severe
threats throughout life, especially symptoms of PTSD before seek- depression and poorer prognosis,
from midlife through old age. The ing professional help. The reason lower levels of social support, and
experience of loss generally as- for treatment avoidance may be more frequent medical visits, and
sociated with the aging process, related to shame and embarrass- were more likely to report suicide
retirement, physical changes, and ment regarding symptoms, as ideation than those with a single
recognition of one’s own mor- well as events surrounding the diagnosis of major depressive dis-
tality stimulate memory in later trauma, the need to be tough and order. Complaints related to de-

42 JPNonline.com
terioration in physical health are
evident in older women who expe- KE Y P OINTS
rienced early and repeated trauma,
especially interpersonal, during 1. Older adults exposed to trauma earlier in their lives can experience reactivation
their lifetime (Franco, 2007). of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms.
Recognition and optimal treat-
2. Primary care is a point of entry into the health care system for older adults and
ment of PTSD in primary care,
offers opportunity for early recognition of PTSD.
however, presents a challenge
because symptoms are vague and 3. Integration of physical and behavioral health services allows optimal treatment
complex and reflect intense dis- for older adults who experience PTSD reactivation.
tress (Nakell, 2007). In a 5-year
follow-up study of mental disorder Do you agree with this article? Disagree? Have a comment or questions?
recognition in primary care, Jack- Send an e-mail to Karen Stanwood, Executive Editor, at kstanwood@slackinc.com.
son, Passamonti, and Kroenke We’re waiting to hear from you!
(2007) reported that 29% of the
sample was identified at baseline
as having a mental disorder, 26% health care—and general health primary care and psychiatric nurs-
of which had more than one dis- care—depends upon the effective es to come together and shape a
order. Across the 5 years, the per- collaboration of all mental, sub- system of care that is responsive
centage diagnosed with a disorder stance-use, general health care, to patient needs. Because of their
increased to 33%. Symptoms that and other human service provid- holistic approach to patient care,
persisted over time were more ers in coordinating the care of nurses are uniquely prepared to
likely to be diagnosed. their patients. (p. 210) integrate both physical and men-
Comprehensive assessments While collaboration among tal health care and can assume
that include life histories are im- mental health and general health leadership within a collaborative
perative for PTSD and other co- care practitioners is essential, ex- interdisciplinary team.
morbid mental disorders. Several isting separation of mental and Collaboration between prima-
brief PTSD assessment scales are substance use health care from ry care and mental health provid-
available and can be used within general health care makes it dif- ers can expand available clinical
primary care settings. Breslau’s ficult (IOM, 2006). Although resources. Traditional treatment
7-item screening tool for PTSD much work is needed to actual- approaches for PTSD are either
is designed especially for use in ize delivery of integrated health pharmacology or psychotherapy.
primary care (Breslau, Peterson, care, several models already ex- Selective serotonin reuptake in-
Kessler, & Schultz, 1999). The ist. Four service delivery models hibitors have been shown to be
scale demonstrates good reliabili- for integrated care have been at- the most effective pharmacologi-
ty compared with the widely used tempted (Alfano, 2005): cal approach to address PTSD
17-item Clinician-Administered l Embedding primary care symptoms (Stein, Ipser, & Seed-
PTSD Scale (CAPS) (Blake et providers within mental health at, 2005). Primary care providers
al., 1995). Breslau’s tool offers a programs. are trained in the medical model
time-efficient and reliable meth- l Unified programs that offer of care that relies heavily on
od for assessment in primary care both mental health and primary medications, treatments, and ad-
(Kimerling et al., 2006). care under a single administration. vice. Although medication offers
l Initiatives to improve col- great opportunity for the treat-
Integrated Health Care laboration between independent, ment of mental disorders, there is
Integration of physical and be- office-based primary care and strong evidence that an effective
havioral health services can offer mental health providers. therapeutic alliance and formal
optimal treatment outcomes for l Co-location of behavioral psychotherapy are also important
older adults with PTSD. A 2006 health providers in primary care components of treatment.
report from the Institute of Med- offices. Initiation of a therapeutic al-
icine (IOM) states that: Integrated approaches are in liance with older adults can be
improving the quality of men- their infancy, but with these ini- forged by primary care or mental
tal health and substance abuse tial steps, opportunity exists for health providers. However, aug-

Journal of Psychosocial Nursing • Vol. 46, No. 11, 2008 43


mentation of pharmacotherapy these older adults and improve September 18, 2008, from the Na-
tional Academies Press Web site:
with psychotherapy falls within not only their health but also http://www.nap.edu/catalog.php?
the expertise of mental health their quality of life. record_id=11470
providers. The literature dis- Jackson, J.L., Passamonti, M., & Kroenke,
cusses multiple psychotherapy References K. (2007). Outcome and impact of
approaches for PTSD: trauma- Acierno, R., Lawyer, S.R., Rheingold, A., mental disorders in primary care at 5
Kilpatrick, D.G., Resnick, H.S., & years. Psychosomatic Medicine, 69, 270-
focused cognitive-behavioral 276.
Saunders, B.E. (2007). Current psycho-
therapy, stress management, eye pathology in previously assaulted older Kimerling, R., Ouimette, P., Prins, A.,
movement desensitization and adults. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, Nisco, P., Lawler, C., Cronkite, R., et al.
reprocessing, hypnosis, group 22, 250-258. (2006). Brief report: Utility of a short
cognitive-behavioral therapy, Alfano, E. (2005, February). Integration of screening scale for DSM-IV PTSD in
primary care and behavioral health. Report primary care. Journal of General Internal
and family therapy (Murray, Medicine, 21, 65-67.
on a roundtable discussion of strategies for
2005). Choice of therapeutic in- private health insurance. Retrieved May Murray, A. (2005). Recurrence of post
terventions for older adults with 28, 2008, from the Bazelon Center for traumatic stress disorder. Nursing Older
PTSD is largely dependent on Mental Health Law Web site: http:// People, 17(6), 24-30.
individual clinician and patient www.bazelon.org/issues/general/publi- Nakell, L. (2007). Adult post-traumatic
cations/RoundtableReport.pdf stress disorder: Screening and treating
preferences, as limited research in primary care. Primary Care, 34, 593-
American Psychiatric Association. (2000).
evidence supports use of these Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental 610.
approaches with older adults. disorders (4th ed., Text Rev.). Washing- Rauch, S.A., Morales, K.H., Zubritsky, C.,
Along with continued work ton, DC: Author. Knott, K., & Oslin, D. (2006). Post-
toward collaborative models of Andrews, B., Brewin, C.R., Philpott, R., & traumatic stress, depression, and health
Stewart, L. (2007). Delayed-onset post- among older adults in primary care.
care for older adults, further re- American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry,
traumatic stress disorder: A systematic
search is needed that addresses as- review of the evidence. American Jour- 14, 316-324.
sessment of and intervention for nal of Psychiatry, 164, 1319-1326. Stein, D.J., Ipser, J.C., & Seedat, S. (2005).
anxiety disorders in this popula- Blake, D.D., Weathers, F.W., Nagy, L.M., Pharmacotherapy for post traumatic
tion, particularly in older women. Kaloupek, D.G., Gusman, F.D., Char- stress disorder (PTSD) (Article No.
ney, D.S., et al. (1995). The develop- CD002795). Cochrane Database of Sys-
The long-term impact of the bi- tematic Reviews, Issue 4.
ment of a clinician-administered PTSD
ology of PTSD on physical and scale. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 8, U.S. Department of Health and Human
mental health is another area that 75-90. Services, Office of the Surgeon Gen-
requires further investigation. Breslau, N., Peterson, E.L., Kessler, R.C., & eral. (1999). Older adults and mental
Schultz, L.R. (1999). Short screening health. In Mental health: A report of
scale for DSM-IV posttraumatic stress the Surgeon General (pp. 336-401).
Summary Retrieved August 27, 2008, from
disorder. American Journal of Psychiatry,
Reemergence of PTSD in 156, 908-911. http://www.surgeongeneral.gov/library/
later years can challenge older Bryant, R.A. (2003). Early predictors of mentalhealth/pdfs/c5.pdf
adults’ coping resources and af- posttraumatic disorder. Biological Psy- Weintraub, D., & Ruskin, P.E. (1999). Post-
fect their physical and mental chiatry, 53, 789-795. traumatic stress disorder in the elderly:
Flannelly, K.J., Koenig, H.G., Galek, K., & A review. Harvard Review of Psychiatry,
health. Primary care serves as a 7, 144-152.
Ellison, C.G. (2007). Beliefs, mental
point of entry into the health health, and evolutionary threat assess-
care system for older adults and ment systems in the brain. Journal of Dr. Snyder is Clinical Assistant Pro-
can provide initial screening Nervous and Mental Disease, 195, 996- fessor, University of Illinois at Chicago,
and treatment of noncomplex 1003. Department of Health Systems Science,
Franco, M. (2007). Posttraumatic stress Chicago, Illinois.
mental health needs in this pop-
disorder and older women. Journal of The author discloses that she has
ulation. Older adults with physi- Women & Aging, 19, 103-117. no significant financial interests in any
cal and mental health disorders Grossman, R., Yehuda, R., Golier, J., McE- product or class of products discussed
may also experience complex wen, B., Harvey, P., & Maria, N.S. directly or indirectly in this activity,
symptoms related to late-onset (2006). Cognitive effects of intrave- including research support.
nous hydrocortisone in subjects with Address correspondence to Marsha
PTSD. These individuals can
PTSD and healthy control subjects. Snyder, PhD, PMHCNS, BC, Clinical
benefit from integrated primary Annals of the New York Academy of Sci- Assistant Professor, University of Illinois
and mental health services. In- ences, 1071, 410-421. at Chicago, Department of Health
tegrated care can provide the Institute of Medicine. (2006). Improving Systems Science, 845 South Damen
existing mental health system the quality of health care for mental and Avenue, Chicago, IL 60612-7350; e-mail:
substance-use conditions. Retrieved snyderm@uic.edu.
with a way to meet the needs of

44 JPNonline.com

You might also like