Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 35
October 3rd – Fouad Boutros – Lebanon’s Minister of Foreign Affairs in his talk to
the United Nations General Assembly, after pointing out the unusual increase of
out-of-state refugees in Lebanon, declares, “Lebanon pays for the mistakes
committed by the others!”
In Washington D.C. the Carter White House issues statement that the U.S.
policy towards Israel has not changed, --- but as usual (or) naturally this isn’t the
way that “prominent” Jewish Americans see the latest moves.
Hyman Bookbinder says, “United States policy appears that two-major powers
will decide what is best for the Middle East” and he thinks, “it is a major political
blunder for the Carter administration.” Secretary of State Cyrus Vance replies that
the declaration (US/Soviet) was intended to promote peace, but not at the expense
of Israel – continuing on he says, “embrasure of the Palestinians’ rights isn’t a new
stand for the Untied States, but the same as it has been all along.”
Carter White House releases statement, that the Administration does not favor
an “imposed” Middle East settlement, and that it will have “nothing” to do with the
PLO unless it changes its ways and recognizes Israel – and does not favor a
“separate” Palestinian state. In this statement, it is also revealed that they gave
these same assurances to Israel “before” they released the joint US/Soviet
agreement.
Secretary of State Cyrus Vance is highly surprised and disappointed at Israeli
reaction, remarking there were elements in the statement that would please them
– to no avail the American Jewish Community is very critical, Bertam Gold,
spokesperson for AJC thinks, “there will be a definitive expression(s) of concern,
directed at the Administration and at Congress.” State Department officials
believe Pro-Israeli factions in the Untied States have over-reacted to the
statement. “Expressions of concern”, translate into pulling support for
Congressional supporters, funding!
October 4th – President Carter travels to New York City to speak in-front of the
United Nations General Assembly – controversy grows amongst the Jewish
community in whether or not the Untied States has changed its policy with Israel.
Arriving in New York, he is greeted Mayor Abraham Beame and New York State
Representative “Ed Koch” (who is running for Mayor of NYC), Ed Koch gives the
November 14th – During the “last” meeting of the Arab Ministers of Interior and
Foreign Affairs (from various nations) that started in Tunis on November 12th – they
all examined the situation in Southern Lebanon, and in conclusion of their
3
http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Peace/sadat_speech.html
4
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Egyptian_Islamic_Jihad
5
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations_Security_Council_Resolution_338
December 14th – Cairo peach conference opens, Prime Minister Begin arrives in
New York City
Details of the Israeli position are partially revealed in Tel Aviv
1. Territorial considerations in Sinai, with a strategic outpost located at Sharm
el-Sheikh
2. Golan Heights negotiations with Syria
3. Plans with regard to West Bank and Palestinians
4. Consider Jordan’s special interest in Region
These are partial list – it is also noted that PM Begin has taken Israel Attorney
General with him to USA
United States’ officials’ uncertainty with regard to Begin’s proposals, as the PM
needs the endorsement of President Carter and assurances from the United States
with regard to Israel’s security if territorial concessions are proposed.
Israeli delegation leader, Ben-Elissar says, “peace must be made by countries
involved not by outsiders”, he also speaks to the meetings in Geneva, and refers
to the UNR-242, and reinstated hard positions of talks.
UN Ambassador Ahmed Abdel Meguid points out the empty seats placed in
conference for the countries that didn’t show – Syria, Jordan, Lebanon, PLO and the
USSR – and that “conference members show others their determination to save
succeeding generations from war and that ultimate goal is a comprehensive peace
with Palestinians’ rights to be restored,”
The Israeli officials in attendance objected to the honorary plaques set in place
of the absent PLO delegates, and insisted that they be changed to read "The Arabs
of Eretz Israel." Moreover, when the Israeli delegates saw that there was a
Palestinian flag flown outside the Mena House hotel (the site of the conference),
they objected to "a strange and unknown flag" and had the conference organizers
remove it.
PM Begin in interview with reporters says there have been behind the scene
developments and this is primary reason for trip to see President Carter – Sadat
says Begin trip to DC will not hurt the conference – he refers to future conferences
that will most be likely elevated to the Foreign Minister level – he also announces
1. The administration of the military government in Judea, Samaria and the Gaza district
will be abolished.
2. In Judea, Samaria and the Gaza district administrative autonomy of the residents, by
and for them, will be established.
3. The residents of Judea, Samaria and the Gaza district will elect an Administrative
Council composed of 11 members. The Administrative Council will operate in
accordance with the principles laid down in this paper.
The end of 1977 and although we seen “primarily” the cessation of hostilities in
Lebanon (with the exception of Southern Lebanon), the news around it
demonstrate the sometimes frantic applications for a solution of the Palestinian
problem – and the multiple changes of tactics by all sides and also have noticed
the lack of participation by the Lebanese government. Not by their choice I am
sure, in that the problem is basically Israel’s which has unfortunately overflowed
into Lebanon.
Leading news headlines seem to acknowledge the fact that Lebanon’s
problems stem from the formation of Israel in 1948, indirectly and directly even
though there is not a direct reference to the breakdown of Lebanon’s society
during the past two years.
At this point in time (composition of this paper – March 24th, 2007) the
headlines haven’t changed that much with regard to Palestine. It is reported by