Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
1
Hellenic Centre for Marine Research, Kapiris, K. & Thessalou-Legaki, M. 2006. Comparative fecundity and oocyte
Institute of Marine Biological Resources, size of Aristaeomorpha foliacea and Aristeus antennatus in the Greek Ionian Sea
Aghios Kosmas, Hellinikon, GR-167 77, (E. Mediterranean) (Decapoda: Aristeidae). — Acta Zoologica (Stockholm) 87:
Athens, Greece; 2Department of Zoology-
239–245
Marine Biology, School of Biology,
University of Athens, Panepistimioupolis, Absolute and relative fecundity of 49 ripe gonads (from the cephalic and the
GR-157 84, Athens, Greece abdominal sections of the same specimen) of Aristaeomorpha foliacea and 71
ripe gonads of Aristeus antennatus caught in the Ionian Sea (E. Mediterranean)
Keywords: and their oocyte size were studied. Both average absolute and relative
Aristaeomorpha foliacea, Aristeus antennatus, fecundities estimated for A. antennatus were statistically higher than those
fecundity, Ionian Sea estimated for A. foliacea; the average absolute fecundity of A. foliacea was
151 936 oocytes/female and that of A. antennatus was 200 472 oocytes/female
Accepted for publication:
8 June 2006
and the average relative fecundity of A. foliacea was 5477 oocytes/g and that of
A. antennatus was 9386 oocytes/g. Fecundity in both red shrimp species is
linearly related to carapace length, body and gonad weight, although, the most
precise estimation is provided by the relationship of body weight and fecundity.
In the present study, the oocyte size (diameter, volume) of both species could
be considered very large. In conclusion, A. foliacea shows lower fecundity than
A. antennatus, having a lower ovogenetic activity, but it produces larger
oocytes. This is in accordance with the highest value of the gonad weight and
gonad volume of A. foliacea exhibited in relation to A. antennatus.
K. Kapiris, Hellenic Centre for Marine Research, Institute of Marine
Biological Resources, Aghios Kosmas, Hellinikon, GR-167 77, Athens,
Greece. E-mail: kkapir@ath.hcmr.gr
limited to the western and central parts of the Mediterranean was removed and weighed. The ovary weight (GW, g) was
(Relini-Orsi and Pestarino 1980; Orsi Relini 1982; Orsi measured on a digital balance to an accuracy of 0.0001 g.
Relini and Semeria 1983; Demestre 1990, 1995; Yahiaoui Gonad volume (GV, mL) was also estimated using the
1994; Kao et al. 1999). This is the first attempt to estimate gravimetric method. After removal of the ovaries, double
the fecundity of both species in the Eastern Mediterranean sub-samples were taken from the cephalic and abdominal
area. The purposes of this investigation were (1) to estimate sections of the same specimen to determine whether the
the fecundity of both species as well as their oocyte size; gonad maturation was simultaneous and homogeneous in all
(2) to relate their fecundity to carapace length, body and its regions. These sampling units were enough to estimate the
gonad weight; and (3) to compare their fecundities to provide number of oocytes for each female.
basic information concerning their reproductive strategies. Because quantification of oocytes is only feasible after
separation from connective tissue, many attempts have been
made. In some cases, the use of chemicals has resulted in the
Materials and Methods
hardening of the ovary tissue which made the separation of
The individuals were collected on a monthly basis from the oocytes much more difficult. In other cases, the oocytes
December 1996 to November 1997 in the Greek Ionian Sea were destroyed, using several chemical compounds: Gilson’s
between the Peloponnisos and Zakynthos Island (Fig. 1), in solution (Simpson 1951; Staples 1975) Bouin’s solution
the frame of the research project ‘Deep waters’, in a depth (Martosubroto 1974), acetic acid (Barbin and McCleave
range from 446 to 728 m, using a commercial trawl net 1997) and other methods ( Jons and Miranda 1997). After
(18 mm at the cod end). In the laboratory, the specimens – considering the literature and after personal communication
preserved in formalin – were sexed, the size of female with several researchers the following technique was used: a
shrimps (carapace length, CL, mm) was measured to the preweighed sub-sample of gonad was transferred to a jar, to
nearest 0.01 mm using calipers, and the body weight (BW, g) which 5–10% NaClO– solution in seawater was added. After
was also measured (with 0.001 g accuracy). Four stages of that, the jars were shaken for 1 h and then the oocytes usually
gonadal development were established for female shrimp came cleanly away from the ovarian tissue. This proved to be
according to the empirical scale of Levi and Vacchi (1988) for an adequate methodology in this red shrimp fecundity study.
A. foliacea and the empirical scale of Relini-Orsi and Relini The fecundity of the species was estimated from 49 ripe
(1979) for A. antennatus. Then, only the ripe ovary (stage IV) gonads of A. foliacea and 71 ripe gonads of A. antennatus.
The absolute fecundity (AF) was estimated according to the
formula AF = number of eggs × (GW/weight of sample)
(Bagenal and Braum 1978) and the relative fecundity (RF)
was calculated using the formula: RF = (AF × 100)/BW. The
relative fecundity can be used to compare all individuals
regardless of their size. However, many studies of fecundity,
in fish, have shown that relative fecundity may vary with
the size of individuals. In this situation relative fecundity
is useful only as an indicator of maturation stage of the
individuals. To estimate the volume of the mature oocytes
(stage IV) their diameters were measured with an ocular
micrometer in 32 samples of A. foliacea and 79 samples of
A. antennatus and the oocyte volume were calculated as
spheres in A. antennatus (V = 4/3πR3) (where R is the radius)
and as cylinders in A. foliacea (V = πR2υ), where R is the
radius of the base and υ is the height of the cylinder (Orsi
Relini and Semeria 1983).
The relationship between absolute, relative fecundity/CL,
BW, GW and GW/CL, BW, GV was expressed in terms of
linear regression F = a + bX and the power regression
F = aX b, where F = fecundity or GW, X = CL, BW, GV,
a = a constant and b = an exponent (slope), which is about
3 when fecundity is related to length and about 1 when
fecundity is related to BW and GW (Rhode and Ross 1987).
Both regressions are more generally used to describe fecundity.
It was found that in all cases the linear regression fitted the
Fig. 1—Study area and the sampling stations in the Greek Ionian data better than the power function in terms of the correlation
Sea. —A. Isobath of 800 m —B. Study area. coefficient (r), so only the former were used. A logarithmic
transformation of the data was applied to satisfy the normality Table 2 Relationships between log values of absolute fecundity (AF),
assumptions (Sokal and Rohlf 1981). Differences between relative fecundity ( RF ) , gonad weight (GW) and carapace length (CL)
the slopes of the regressions were examined by analysis of
Variable b SE a n F r
covariance (). To test the slope b of the obtained
regression equations against the isometric slope of 1 or 3
Aristaeomorpha foliacea
Student’s t-test was applied. AF/CL 2.09 0.82 1.66 51 6.47 0.37**
AF/BW 0.82 0.30 3.92 51 7.38 0.39***
AF/GW 0.44 0.21 4.93 51 4.31 0.31**
Results RF/CL −1.36 0.90 5.90 42 2.31 NS
The average ovarian weight (GW) for 52 mature female RF/BW −0.46 0.33 4.31 42 186 NS
RF/GW 0.23 0.18 3.59 42 1.00 NS
A. foliacea (stage IV) was 2.65 g (range 0.8 – 5.8) and for 75
GW/CL 1.83 0.48 −2.64 51 17.27 0.47***
mature female A. antennatus was 1.76 g (range 0.47–6.72) GW/BW 0.69 0.18 −0.61 51 14.43 0.47***
(Table 1). It is worth noting that GW correlated positively GW/GV 0.81 0.04 0.08 45 328.16 0.94***
and significantly with CL, BW and GV in both species Aristeus antennatus
(Table 2). However, the median ripe GW of A. antennatus was AF/CL 1.52 0.51 2.76 65 8.76 0.35***
significantly lower than that of A. foliacea (Mann–Whitney AF/BW 0.67 0.21 4.32 65 9.74 0.37***
test, P < 0.001) and therefore the median GV of A. antennatus AF/GW 0.65 0.16 5.05 65 16.44 0.47***
(range 0.5–6 mL) was also significantly lower than that of RF/CL −0.85 0.52 7.25 65 2.71 NS
A. foliacea (range 0.5 –5 mL) (Mann–Whitney test, P < 0.001) RF/BW −0.36 0.22 6.36 65 2.84 NS
RF/GW 0.16 0.13 5.86 65 1.34 NS
(Table 1). The linear regression (Table 2) shows that the
GW/CL 2.18 0.34 −3.31 74 39.61 0.59***
ovary weight of A. foliacea increases by 0.69 g for each 1 g GW/BW 0.91 0.14 −1.03 74 40.16 0.60***
increase in BW and 1.83 g for each 1 mm increase in CL. GW/GV 0.90 0.04 0.03 65 436.17 0.93***
In A. antennatus these increases were 0.91 g and 2.18 g,
respectively. Body weight (BW), gonad weight (GW) and gonad volume (GV) for both red
Of 17 148 female A. foliacea and 7272 female A. antennatus shrimps according to the F = a + b * X model; b = regression coefficient
(slope); SE = standard error of b; a = intercept; n = number of individual
caught in the Ionian Sea (E. Mediterranean), the fecundity
females examined; F = variance ratio; r = correlation coefficient; **P < 0.05.
of 49 mature females of A. foliacea spanning 36.4 – 61.54 mm
***P < 0.01. NS = non-significant.
CL and the fecundity of 71 females of A. antennatus spanning
27.14–53.26 mm CL was studied (Fig. 2). The CL range of
specimens examined for estimation of fecundity was wide of individuals examined for fecundity encompasses most of
and representative, taking into account that the smallest the mature females in the population. The medians and
mature A. foliacea female was 36 mm and that of A. antennatus the distributions of the absolute as well as of the relative
was 25.59 mm (Kapiris 2004). This suggests that the range fecundity estimated from samples taken from the abdominal
(Baelde 1992)]. According to the regression coefficient slopes of the regressions between GW/CL, BW were higher
value, CL, BW and GW could be used to predict absolute in A. antennatus and its oocyte diameter was lower than that
fecundity of both species but the most precise estimation of of A. foliacea oocytes, it is reasonable to expect a higher
fecundity is provided by the relationship of BW with fecundity, number of oocytes for A. antennatus than for A. foliacea.
suggesting that increases of somatic weight could be accom- Calculations of fecundity of both species in this paper
panied by proportional increases of the oocyte number. The are greater than, lower than or similar to those of other
ovary weight could also be used, like BW, as an adequate studies reported in the literature and estimated for other
index of fecundity in both species because it is affected by Mediterranean regions, but, unfortunately, there are no
oocyte number and size concurrently. However, it is easier regression data. In this way, the fecundity of both species
to use BW or CL to estimate fecundity, because these are estimated in the Ligurian Sea was significantly higher than
simpler to measure than ovary weight. our estimates. Orsi Relini and Semeria (1983) found that in
Bearing in mind that both species present three successive the Ligurian Sea the fecundity of A. foliacea ranged between
spawnings in the same reproductive period (Orsi Relini 100 000 and 250 000 oocytes and that for A. antennatus
1982; Orsi Relini and Semeria 1983; Follesa et al. 1998, for ranged between 140 000–900 000 oocytes in each ovulation.
A. foliacea and Orsi Relini 1980; Demestre 1990, for A. Moreover, Orsi Relini (1982) pointed out that in the Ligurian
antennatus), the total yearly amount of oocytes in A. foliacea Sea the number of oocytes produced by A. antennatus in a
could be 458 820 oocytes/female and 16 269 oocytes/g. single ovulation ranged more frequently from 420 000 to
Similarly, in A. antennatus the absolute fecundity could be 980 000, reaching peaks of 1.5 million. Relini-Orsi and
598 584 oocytes/female and the relative fecundity could be Pestarino (1980) suggested that an A. antennatus female of
28 170 oocytes/g. The estimated fecundity for both species 56 mm CL contained 600 000 oocytes in the whole repro-
was situated among the highest estimated values of penaeid ductive period. Other studies have overestimated the fecundity
species, because the maximum reported fecundity ranges of A. antennatus in comparison to the present study. In the
from 250 000 to 950 000 oocytes (e.g. Penn 1980). Since the present study, a female A. antennatus of the same length
(56 mm) was estimated to have 269 153 oocytes. In other It is generally accepted that a higher fecundity denotes
areas the fecundity was underestimated. In Algeria, for a higher mortality rate of young and immature individuals
instance, the relative fecundity of A. antennatus was estimated (Corey 1987). If this is in force, A. antennatus would expect
to be 8000 oocytes/g (Yahiaoui 1994). Our fecundity data a high loss of young individuals and A. foliacea would have
coincide fairly well with those reported by Demestre (1990, lower juvenile mortalities. Moreover, the larger oocytes,
1995) who reported that in the Catalan Sea A. antennatus having more yolk, tend to produce larger or more advanced
released 46 000–606 000 oocytes per ovulation and, in total, larvae (Clarke 1993).
released 138 000–1 800 000 oocytes per reproductive period This study represents basic data for the two aristeids in the
(Demestre 1990, 1995). It is worth noting that the same Ionian Sea; these date were not available in the literature and
author counted a significantly higher number of oocytes in can be used in population studies. The data can be used for
A. antennatus coming from the thoracic region than the elaborating population models that will serve to assess
cephalic or the abdominal regions. It is well known that the the effect of the fishery on the reproductive output and to
fecundity and oocyte size of aquatic invertebrates vary widely establish management strategies focused to achieve optimal
and related species from different habitats or parts of the exploitation of the red shrimps stocks in this Mediterranean
world may have oocytes that vary in size (Clarke 1993). region.
Differences in estimates of fecundity among studies might be
artificial, as the result of differences in technique, or natural,
Acknowledgements
as the results of differences in fecundity with geographical
location or climatic conditions. Additionally, the different The material was collected during sampling cruises within
geomorphological, trophic and fishing efforts in the different the research programme ‘Deep Water Fisheries’ partly
areas could explain these differences (Martosubroto 1974). supported by the EU (FAIR 95-0655). Many thanks are due
However, further investigations including all Mediterranean to Dr C. Papaconstantinou and Mr G. Petrakis (Hellenic
regions are needed to deepen our knowledge of their repro- Centre for Marine Research), who are responsible for the
ductive patterns. above program in Greece. We also thank all the anonymous
The egg size of aquatic invertebrates varies widely between referees whose suggestions improved this manuscript.
even quite closely related species (McEdward 1991). Com-
parative studies of related taxa with different egg or oocyte
References
size have frequently demonstrated a covariation between egg/
oocyte size and fecundity (Clarke 1993). Since the maximum Baelde, P. 1992. Reproductive biology of commercially exploited
mean oocyte diameter of penaeids ranges from 0.25 to deep-water royal red prawns (Haliporoides sibogae, Solenoceridae)
in south-east Australia. – Marine Biology 113: 447–456.
0.35 mm (Tan-Fermin and Pudadera 1989), the size of the
Bagenal, T. B. and Braum, E. 1978. Eggs and early life history. In:
oocyte of both species of the present paper could be considered Bagenal, T. (Ed.): Methods for Assessment of Fish Production in Fresh
very large. The inverse relationship between fecundity and Waters, IBP Handbook No 3, pp. 165–210. Blackwell Scientific
oocyte size shown by these two deep-water sympatric Publications, Oxford.
shrimps of the South Ionian Sea indicates that they might Barbin, G. P. and McCleave, J. D. 1997. Fecundity of the American
follow different reproductive strategies. Thus, A. foliacea eel Anguilla rostrata at 45° N in Maine, U.S.A. – Journal of Fish
produces fewer, but bigger, oocytes than A. antennatus. This Biology 51: 840–847.
Caddy, J. F. 1990. Options of the regulation of Mediterranean
is in accordance with the highest value of the GW and GV
demersal fisheries. – Natural Resource Modeling 4: 427–475.
that the former species exhibited in relation to the latter. Ceballos-Vasquez, B. P., Racotta, I. S. and Elorduy-Garay, J. F.
The size of the mature oocytes in the present study does 2003. Qualitative and quantitative analysis of the ovarian maturation
not differ significantly from those reported by other studies. process of Pennaeus vannamei after a production cycle. – Invertebrate
Thus, Kao et al. (1999) reported that the mature oocytes of Reproduction and Development 43: 9– 18.
A. foliacea had a diameter 0.42–0.44 mm and a volume Clarke, A. 1993. Reproductive trade-offs in caridean shrimps. –
0.038–0.043 mm3. According to Orsi Relini and Semeria Functional Ecology 7: 411–419.
Company, J. B. and Sardà, F. 1997. Reproductive patterns and
(1983), the oocyte volume of A. foliacea was 0.024 mm3.
population characteristics in five deep-water pandalid shrimps in
Demestre and Fortuño (1992) reported that the diameter of the Western Mediterranean along a depth gradient (150–1100 m).
the mature oocytes of A. antennatus in the Catalan Sea – Marine Ecology Progress Series 148: 49 – 58.
ranged from 168 to 330 µm, whereas in Algeria the diameter Corey, S. 1987. Comparative fecundity of four species of crayfish in
ranged between 217 and 301 µm (Yahiaoui 1994). Since southwestern Ontario, Canada (Daecapoda, Astacidea). –
there was no difference in size for oocytes taken from two Crustaceana 52: 276–286.
Demestre, M. 1990. Biologia pesquera de la gamba Aristeus antennatus
different gonadal regions, it could be assumed that the
en el Mar Catalan. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Barcelona, Spain.
maturation of the ovary is simultaneous and similar in all Demestre, M. 1995. Moult activity-related spawning success in the
areas. The homogeneous development of ovaries is generally Mediterranean deep-water shrimp Aristeus antennatus. – Marine
assumed in penaeid shrimps, but a more detailed analysis is Ecology Progress Series 127: 57–64.
needed (Ceballos-Vasquez et al. 2003). Demestre, M. and Fortuño, J. M. 1992. Reproduction of deep-water
shrimp Aristeus antennatus (Risso, 1816) in the Mediterranean Orsi Relini, L. and Semeria, M. 1983. Oogenesis and fecundity in
Sea. – Marine Ecology Progress Series 54: 229 – 238. bathyal penaeid prawns, Aristaeus antennatus and Aristaeomorpha
Follesa, M. C., Campisi, S., Cuccu, D., Murenu, M., Sabatini, A. foliacea. – Rapport de la Commission Internationale pour la Exploration
and Cau, A. 1998. Reproductive aspects in Aristaeomorpha foliacea Scientifique de la Mer Mediterranée 28: 281–284.
and Aristeus antennatus. In: Book of Abstracts: Assessment of Demersal Papaconstantinou, C. and Kapiris, K. 2001. Distribution and
Resources by Direct Methods in the Mediterranean and the Adjacent population structure of the red shrimp (Aristeus antennatus) on an
Seas, p. 28. Pisa. unexploited fishing ground in the Greek Ionian Sea. – Aquatic Living
Jons, G. D. and Miranda, L. E. 1997. Ovarian weight as an index of Resources 14: 303–312.
fecundity, maturity, and spawning periodicity. – Journal of Fish Papaconstantinou, C. and Kapiris, K. 2003. The biology of the giant
Biology 50: 150 –156. red shrimp (Aristaeomorpha foliacea) at an unexploited fishing
Kao, H. C., Chan, T. Y. and Yu, H. P. 1999. Ovary development of the ground in the Greek Ionian Sea. – Fisheries Research 62: 37–51.
deep-water shrimp Aristaeomorpha foliacea (Risso, 1826) (Crustacea: Penn, J. W. 1980. Spawning and fecundity of the western king prawn,
Decapoda: Aristeidae) from Taiwan. – Zoology Studies 38: 373–378. Penaeus latisulcatus Kishinouye, in Western Australian waters. –
Kapiris, K. 2004. Biology and fishery of the deep water shrimps Australian Journal of Marine Freshwater Resources 3: 21–35.
Aristaeomorpha foliacea (Risso, 1827) and Aristeus antennatus Ragonese, S. and Bianchini, M. L. 1995. Size at sexual maturity in
(Risso, 1816) (Decapoda: Dendrobranchiata). Ph.D. Thesis, red shrimp females, Aristaeomorpha foliacea, from the Sicilian
University of Athens, 289 pp. Channel, Mediterranean Sea. – Crustaceana 68: 73–82.
Levi, D. and Vacchi, M. 1988. Macroscopic scale for simple and Relini-Orsi, L. 1980. Aspetti riproduttivi in Aristeus antennatus
rapid determination of sexual maturity in Aristaeomorpha foliacea (Risso, 1816) (Decapoda, Aristeidae). – Memoria della Biologia
(Risso, 1826) (Decapoda: Penaeidae). – Journal of Crustacean Marina e Oceanographia 10 (Suppl.): 285–289.
Biology 8: 532 –538. Relini-Orsi, L. and Pestarino, M. 1980. Riproduzione e distribuzione
Mantelatto, F. L. M. and Fransozo, A. 1997. Fecundity of the crab di Aristeus antennatus sui fondi batiali Liguri, nota preliminare. –
Callinectes ornatus Ordway, 1863 (Decapoda, Brachyoura, Portunidae) Quaderni di Laboratorio della Tecnologia di Pesca 3 (Suppl. 1): 123–
from the Ubatuba region, Sao Paulo, Brazil. – Crustaceana 70: 133.
214 –226. Relini-Orsi, L. and Relini, G. 1979. Pesca e riproduzione del gambero
Martosubroto, P. 1974. Fecundity of pink shrimp, Penaeus duorarum rosso Aristeus antennatus nel mare Ligure. – Quaderni Civica Stazione
Burkenroad. – Bulletin of Marine Science 24: 606 – 627. Idrobiologia Milano 7: 39 – 62.
McEdward, L. R. 1991. Interspecific relationships between egg size Rhode, F. and Ross, S. 1987. Life history of the Pinewoods Darter
and level of parental investment per offspring in echiyolerus Etheostoma mariae (Osteichthyes: Percidae), a fish endemic to the
(Abstract 526). – American Zoology 31: 105A. Carolina Sandhills. – Brimleyana 13: 1–20.
Menasveta, P., Sangpradub, S., Piyatiratitivorakul, S. and Fast, A. W. Simpson, A. C. 1951. The Fecundity of the Plaice. Fisheries Investigation.
1994. Effects of broadstock size and source on ovarian maturation II, XVII, 5, 27 p.
and spawning of Pennaeus monodon Fabricius from the Gulf of Sokal, R. R. and Rohlf, F. J. 1981. Biometry. W.H. Freeman and
Thailand. – Journal of the World Aquaculture Society 25: 41–49. company, New York.
Mori, M., Biagi, F. and De Ranieri, S. 1994. Reproductive biology Staples, D. J. 1975. Production biology of the upland bully Philypnodon
of Aristaeomorpha foliacea in the Southern Tuscany archipelago breviceps Stokell in a small New Zealand lake. – Journal of Fish
(Central Tyrrhenian Sea). In Bianchini, M. L. and Ragonese, S. Biology 7: 1–24.
(Eds): Life Cycles and Fisheries of the Deep-water Red Shrimps Tan-Fermin, J. and Pudadera, R. A. 1989. Ovarian maturation
Aristaeomorpha foliacea and Aristeus antennatus. Proceedings of the stages of the wild giant tiger prawn, Penaeus monodon Fabricius. –
International Workshop held in the Instituto di Tecnologia della Pesca e Aquaculture 77: 229–242.
del Pescato. N.T.R.-I.T.P.P., pp. 31–32. Mazara del Vallo, Sicily, Yahiaoui, M. 1994. Distribution and reproduction cycle of Aristeus
Italy. antennatus and Aristaeomorpha foliacea in Algeria. In Bianchini,
Orsi Relini, L. 1980. Aspetti riproduttivi in Aristeus antennatus M. L. and Ragonese, S. (Eds): Life Cycles and Fisheries of the
(Risso, 1816) (Decapoda, Aristeidae). – Memoria della Biologia Deep-water Red Shrimps Aristaeomorpha foliacea and Aristeus
Marina e Oceanographia 10 (Suppl.): 285 –289. antennatus. Proceedings of the International Workshop held in the
Orsi Relini, L. 1982. The spawning of Aristeus antennatus in the Gulf of Instituto di Tecnologia della Pesca e del Pescato. N.T.R.-I.T.P.P.,
Genoa. – Quaderni di Laboratorio della Tecnologia di Pesca 3: 157–162. pp. 51–52. Mazara del Vallo, Sicily, Italy.