Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Ashlyn,
Gavin, Tyler
+
Summary
Documentary by Eugene Jarecki from 2012 about Americas failed
war on drugs.
Claims it is The New Jim Crow and a war based on class and race.
Shows up close and personal accounts of the justice system, drug
dealers, ghettos, and family members.
Shows personal gains by cops and politicians.
Describes history of drugs in America and the discrimination of
minorities.
Questions the human cost and the society we want to live in.
Claim #1
Racism is involved in the War on Drugs.
Data: Cocaine vs. Crack
Warrant: Interviews with both law
enforcement and criminals
Claim #2
The U.s. is the most incarcerated country in
the world
Data: 2.3 million prisoners, 25% prisoners with
5% of the population
Warrant: Interviews
Claim #3
Tax dollars are being used to pay for the war
on drugs
Data: The total cost of the War on Drugs is $1
trillion
Warrant: Economic cycle
Claim #4
The sentencing laws for drugs are too
harsh.
Data: 100:1 rule to the 18:1 rule
Warrant: Interviews and court scenes
Call to Action
People on the outside
Not clear on how to change things
Logos
Appeals to Logic
Facts and statistics
5% of the worlds population, 25% of them
are incarcerated
45 million arrests since 1971
$1 trillion dollars
Ethos
Appeals to credibility
Journalists
Harvard Professors
Prison workers
Pathos
Appeals to emotion
Funerals
Harsh searches
Poverty
Rhetoric in---- Text
1. Entirely black background
2. Clear white charaters
3. Formal fonts
First thing comes out of he whole
movie.
Introduction to the
scene view
Data proof of the big
drug bills in The United
States.
Soothing chord
The intense
melody
Intense and scary
Basically its just about
surviving.
A small piece of folk:I was born, in
a dump. My mama died and my
father got drunk.
Cheerful music
Show the passion of president Nixon to
solve the problem of crimes caused by
drugs.
Photography
Graphic Designs
Dark
Serious
Editing
People who are serving long sentences
Presidential candidates speeches
Searches
EFFECTIVENESS
O Enlightens some
O Not very effective to some
PEOPLE AFFECTED BY THIS FILM
OCitizens in ghettos
OFamily members of drug users
OYounger generation
ODrug users
PEOPLE NOT AFFECTED BY THIS FILM
OOlder generation
OPoliticians
OWar veterans
OJail workers
ETHICS
+ Drug dealer openly selling drugs
+ Heavily one-sided argument
+ Use of credible sources
Sources
BBC
Michelle Alexander
Mark Burnett
Mike Carpenter
Richard Miller
Gabor Mate
Many more!
British Broadcasting Corporation
BBC for short
Created 1932
Reputable source
Provides impartial public service broadcasting
Michelle Alexander
Author The New Jim Crow
Racism in War on Drugs
Mark W. Bennett
Court District Judge
O Sioux City, Iowa
Lower Sentencing Laws
Mike Carpenter
Chief of Security
Lexington Corrections Center
Explains War on Drugs from inside
Richard Miller
Historian
O Expert on history of War on Drugs
Explains Racism in Drug Laws
O Opium Chinese
O Marijuana Mexicans
O Crack African Americans
Discusses Chain of Destruction
O 5 links
Dr. Gabor Mat
Hungarian Physician
Compares problem to pneumonia
Accuracy
Reliable sources
Great credentials
Real life examples
Evidence is given
Chain of Destruction
Pneumonia
Security officer inside
g One-Sided
/ Only for War on Drugs
g Poisoning the Well
/ Good things about people entering
g Proof of Assertion
/ Repeats same claim often
Fallacies
g Only discusses negatives
[ Ineffective
[ Conservatives, etc
g Leaves out positives of War on Drugs
/ Helps lower drug deals
/ Violent offenders
g Fallacy Broken by One Source
/ Gabor Mat
[ War on Drugs = success
_ Police Busy
_ Private Jails Thriving
_ Legal Establishment justified
One-Sided
g Opinion is influenced
/ Most introduced positively
g Examples
/ Nanny Jeter
[ Second Mother To narrator
[ Explained as an amazing person
_ Influences belief in her
g Bad take on drugs
/ Mike Carpenter
[ Described as most aware of pressures
[ Took narrator off guard
_ Influences belief in him
g Bad take on sentences
Poisoning The Well (Good)
g Repetitive
/ Similar stories
[ Becomes less effective
g Examples
/ Presidents speeches 5 or 6 in movie
[ Hard on drugs/crime
_ Raises polls
g Caused problems of today
/ Economy at least 5 times in movie
[ Circle of Crime
Proof of Assertion
Repeating One Claim
+
Conclusion
4Rhetorical Strategies
4Fallacies
4Choice of Information
4Ethics