Professional Documents
Culture Documents
¡
COUNY OF NEW YORK
-------------- ...----------.--------..---------------------------------l(
GENTRY T. BEACH and ROBERT A. VOLLERO,
hidel( No. 603611/08
Plaíntiffs,
IAS Par 56
- agaínst - (Lowe, J.)
TOURJI CAPITAL MAAGEMENT, LP and
PAUL TOURJI,
Defendants.
-..------------------.....-------..-----------------------------.....ool(
TOURJI CAPITAL MAAGEMENT, LP and
PAUL TOURJI,
Counterclai Plaítiffs,
- againt.
Counterclaim Defendants.
------------------_......-----------------------_...-------------------l(
TOURJI CAPITAL MAAGEMENT, LP,
DEEPROCK VENTU PARTNRS, LP and
PAUL TOURJI,
Counterclaim Plaítifs,
- aganst -
Counterclai. Defendants.
-----------------------------------...-------------------------ow_ow_owl(
I
ALLEGATIONS COMMON TO ALL CLAIS ................................................................ 5
G. Beach And V ollero Constrct And Superise An Abysmal Private Equity Effort
.....................................................................................~...................................... 12
H. Playa Oil & Gas: Beach Creates And Takes Advantage Of A Confict
Ofhiterest To Benefit His Father, And The Two Men Abscond With
hivestor Capita ................... ......... ........... ................................. ......... .................. 13
Q. Beach And Vollero Raise Capita For The Vollero Beach Parership
By Misrepresenting Their Track Record And Roles ......................................... 29
i
R. Beach And Vollero Manufactue Clais Of Improper Tradig By
Touradji Capita ................................................................................................. 31
COUNERCLAIMS..................................................................................................................34
ANSWER..................................................................................................................................44
ii
Defendant and Counterclai PlaíntiffTouradji Capital Management, LP and
.j
Counterclaím Plaintif DeepRock Venture Parners, LP (collectively "Touradji Capital") and
Defendant and Counterclaím Plaíntiff Paul Touradji ("Touradji"), for their counterclais agaíst
Plaíntiffs and Counterclai Defendants Gentr T. Beach ("Beach"), and Robert A. Vollero
("V ollero") and agaínst Counterclai Defendants V ollero Beach Capital Parers LLC, V ollero
Beach Capital Fund, LP, Vollero Beah Associates LLC, Vollero Beach Capital Offshore, Ltd.
(collectively, the "Vollero Beach Funds"), and Gar Beach, and for their answer to Plaíntiffs'
1. While they were employed at Touradji Capita, Gentr Beach and Robert Vollero
were responsible for the destrction of milions of dollars of invesr capita thugh a pattm of
fraud, breaches of fiduciar dut, mismanagement and uttr disregard for the interests of the
2. In addition, Gentr Beach and his father, Gar Beach, together stole investor
capita from one ofTouradji Capital's private equity investents, Playa Oil & Gas, LP
("Playa"). Touradji Capital's investigation has revealed that Gentr Beach's father, Gar Beach,
wired $500,000 of investor fuds from Playa to himself, and then secretly shaed that money
with Gentry Beach. Contemporaneously with these events, on September 26, 2008, Gentry
Beach claied that he was "forced to resign" from Tourdji Capital- even fiing a false police
report in which he claied he had been theatened -- when in fact he had already set up a
3. Afer these events occured, thoughout the fall of 2008, V oHero remaíed at
Touradji Capital deviously and unethically gathering confidential information about the firm and
creating a fraudulent record concerning his compensation -- all the while falsely representing that
he had ended his association with Beach. hi fact, the evidence now shows, Beach and Vollero
had ben planng to form a competing hedge fud -- called the "Vollero Beach Funds" - well
prior to their supposedly forced depares frm the firm. hideed, one of their new employees
was alreay calling Gentr Beach his "boss" while Beach was stil employed by Touradji
Capital.
4. Not content to have inicted ths har on Touradji Capital and its investors,
Beach and V ollero - who were paid milions of dollars while at Touradji Capita - have now
fied a complaint in which they demand over $50 milion dollars in additional compensation.
They base ths clai upon a supposed agreement entitling them to, among other thgs, a
majority oftke profits to be eared by Touradji Capita based upon its energy equity portfolios--
an agrement that by their own admission was never setforth in a written contract, and never
5. The reason tht ths alleged guanteed "bonus" component of Beach and
V ollero's employment agreement was never set forth in a wrtten agreement - and was never
referred to in a single email sent by these men in the three years that they worked at Touradji
Capital- is that it never el(isted. Beach and VoIlero's claím for milions of dollar in additional
greed and entitlement that has made headlines for the past year.
6. Beach and Vo!lero's clai for additional compensation is based upon the false
premise that they were hired as, and acted as, portfolio mangers throughout their employment at
Tourdji Capita, and that they alone were responsible for successfully managing Touradji
Capita's equity trading books. It is also based upon the false premise they had nothng to do
2
7. hi fact, afer Beach and Vollero were given responsibilty for portolio
management, it became clear that Beach, in parcular, was fudamentally incapable of managing
a trading portolio -- as even his co-plaítiff and closest frend, Rober V ollero, admtted on many
occasions. As VoIlero put it, Beach merely "star(ed) at tickers," acted "rashly" and in a way that
was inconsistent with weIl researched conclusions, and did not even understad "how the
portolio was actually strctued." As a reslÙt, even Vollero ultimately agreed tht Beach should
8. V oIlero also secrety confded to Beach that both of them 'Just look at ticker and
go with them when we need something to buy and when we need something to seIl." To others,
9. Put simply, the idea that Beach and VoIlero - who raísed virtally no capital and
who did not even possess the e¡¡erience or skills that they had represented to Tourdji at the
time they were hired -- would themselves be entitled to a majority of the profits to be eared by
10. Beach's arogant refusal to follow even the simplest directions, and rus disregard
for the interests of T ouradji Capita's investors, is even more evident in connection with his
1 i. Notably, Beach and V ollero now seek to misrepresent their roles in ths area, and
their complaínt makes no mention of their private equity activities. That is because that effort
was an obvious failure and could never be squaed with a demand for $50 million in additional
3
(G) entr spent a few years running our private equity practice
and, to be honest, this was not something for which he was well
suited. Our PE effort has been disappointig and chaotic and it
ha shown in the results, e.g. (Madagasca Oil, which resulted in a
hundred milion dollar write-down).
12. Beach's fudamentaly dishonest natue - and the lengths to which he will go to
generate a false record in support of his claíms - is fuher revealed by his allegation that
T ourdji thratened to "ruin (Beach's) marage and famly" even if it meant "saying thngs that
are untre." Ths false allegation was made by Beach out of a fear that his betrayals of his wife
and family - about which he had boaste withn Touradji Capital- would surace in the course
of this dispute. The trth is, Beach has for years caried on an ilicit afaír with a young
Argentinean student, a relationship which included his makg secret wire transfers to support
her financially. Beach had thus long ago "ruined" his own marage, yet now has cyncally
13. Nor were Beach and V ollero's lies and misconduct limited to their business
deaings while at Touradji Capita. For el(ample, they plainy misrepresented their own roles
while at their prior employer, Solstice, and Beach agreed to lie for his Argentinean mistrss in
connection with her visa documentation. Furhermore, Beach and V ollero are now
misrepresenting their roles at Touradji Capital and their trading strategy in the marketig of the
V ollero Beach Fuds. Gentr Beach and his father have also repeatedly lied under oath in a
separte litigation between Gar Beach and Touradji Capita in Tel(as. Beach and Vollero alo
falsely disparged Touradji and Touradji Capital in the press, in the marketplace, and in their
14. As Beach once secretly confded to Vollero, "We can overcome our weakesses
together." This statement also aptly describes ths very lawsuit: A collusive effort by two young
men to fabricate a claim for compensation when the evidence defeats such a claim absolutely.
4
15. Tourdji Capita fies the present counterclaíms and cross-claims to recover from
Beach, Vollero, the Vollero Beach Funds, and Gar Beach for their breaches of fiduciar duty,
defamtion and unair competition directed at the fir. The goal is not only to ensure that Beach
and Vollero do not wrngfly wrest additional money from Tourdji Capita, but also to ensure
that Touradji Capital's investors are made whole and to repai the damage done by the Beaches
and V ollero. Touradji Capital seeks the retu of all compensation paíd to Beach and V ollero
durng the period of their disloyalty, compensatory daages for all of the defendants'
misconduct in an amount no less than $250 millon, as well as pwutive daages in light of the
related famly of fuds (the ''TGR Funds") in January 2005, with initial commtted capital of
17. hi the spring of2005, a third par recommended that Touradji spea with Beach
and V ollero, who were then employees of Solstice Equity Management ("Solstice"). At that
time, Solstice was an advisor to the BBT Fund, LP, an entity that managed invesents on behalf
18. Touradji met with Beach and Vollero on several occsions in or around May
2005. Beah and Vollero represented to Touradji that they had been the portolio managers for
Solstice, and that they had been primarly responsible for ruing the energy equity portfolio
there. Beach and V ollero provided Touradji with a track record purortedy reflecting their
5
19. Beach informed Touradji that he (Beach) had "built" Solstice, and that he and
V ollero were leaving Solstice beause they wanted to sta their own fud and because,
according to Beach, the Bass famly "didn't know what they were doing," Touradji ha since
leaed that ths was untre: Beach was nothing more than an analyst at Solstice, and Solstice
was obligated to shut down because its pricipal investor withdrew its capita from the fud.
20. At the tie, Beach and V ollero also informed Touradji that they had made efforts
to form their own fud, and had already lined up investors willing to contrbute $500 millon of
capital.
21. Based upon these and other representations (now known to be false), Tourdji
agreed to take on Beach and Vollero, as well as several of their co-workers from Solstice, as
22. From the beginnng, Touradji made clear to Beach and Vollero that if they joined
Touradji Capita, they would be "at will" employees. Touradji told Beach and Vollero that he
was not considering an arangement where Touradji Capita would simply provide the facilties
for Beach and Vollero to ru their own fud. Intead, Tourdji inormed them that they would
be el(pected to be his eyes and ears on energy equities. Touradji fuer informed Beach and
Vollero that he el(pected them to operate as par ofa team contrbutig to the success of the
overall firm, and tht their compensation would be discretionar and would be based upon all
such contrbutions.
23. Touradji specifically informed Beach and Vollero that he would not agre to any
form of compensation "guarantee." histead, Touradji told Beach and Vollero that if they came to
the Funds and performed well overall, a potential discretonar bonus "pool" could be allocated
to the enti team. Agai however, Touradji made plaí that there were no guartees when it
6
came to compensation, apar from the $200,000 anual salar Beach and V ollero each would
receive, and that any additiona compensation would be determined in Touradji's sole discretion
based upon their entie contributions and Tourdji Capital's overall performance. Beach and
V ollero agreed to ths and stated that they were happy with ths arangement.
24. As a result, no wrtten contrct was ever entered into beteen Beach, Vollero, and
25. Contrar to the present lies tht Beach and Vollero have used to prop up their
Amended Complaint, this purely discretionar bonus arangement is reflected in due dilgence
Compensation
The (Tourdji Capita) team members receive a fil(ed salar and a
discretionar bonus which mayor may not be drven by the performance
of the Fund or the performance of the individual traders.
(emphasis supplied.)
26. Not oruy is Beach and Vollero's claim to an absolute entitlement to a majority of
the profit on certain fuds contry to fact, the claim is ludicrous as a matter of industr practice.
Paul Tourdji was the ''key man" for every Touradji Capita-related fud and portfolio, and Paul
Tourdji was responsible for briging in essentially all of the capital that Touradji Capital
managed. The idea that two individuals employed by the firm would themselves be entitled to a
majority oftke profit to be made by Touradji Capital on, among other thgs, trading portolios
for which Beach and V ollero raísed no capita and as to which Beach and V ollero were not even
27. Beach and Vollero accepted employment with Touradji Capital and reported for
duty in May 2005. Beach and Vollero helped manage investents in the TGR Fund's "OG
Book," a trading book composed of energy equity securties, under Touradji's supervision.
7
28. Consistent with this sharg of responsibilties - and contrar to their clais that
they were hired purely as portfolio managers from day one -- both Beach and V ollero were
mangers.
29. Beac and Vollero also convinced Touradji to hie other former Solstice
employees as well, including Taylor Beach, Gentr Beach's sister. Vollero in paricular told
Touradji that Taylor Beach was smar, hard working and irreplaceable. Later, afer Beach left
Touradji Capita, Vollero stated that Taylor Beach was incompetent and overpaid.
30. Whle Beach and Vollero were responsible for day-to-day tring decisions in
cOllection with the OG Book, Touradji remaíned the prima portolio manager responsible for
the book, and provided Beach and V ollero with risk maagement and directional supervsion in
31. hi late 2005, Beach and Vollero lobbied Tourdji Capita to form the ST Book,
in par upon this performance, Touradji Capita awarded Beach and V ollero cash bonuses of $2.4
millon each. hi addition, Touradji Capital awarded Beach and Vollero conditional deferred
bonuses of over $300,000 each. At the time, Beach and Vollero were very appreciative of these
amounts, and never complained that they had not been paid in accordance with a supposed
agreement.
33. Touradji DeepRock Master Fund Ltd. and its related family of fuds (the
"DeepRock Funds") were launched in Februar 2006 to focus solely on investing in energy
8
equity securties. It was anticipated that Beach and V ollero would apply the el(perience they
supposedly obtaíed managing energy equities at Solstice to assist in managing the DeepRock
Funds under Touradji's supervsion, and would bring at least $500 milion of dollars in
34. By the spring of2006, however, it became evident that Beach and Vollero did
not, as they had ealier represente, have commitments for any meagfl amount of capita.
35. Also by that tie, inormation had begu to surace suggesting tht Beach and
Vollero had misrepresented their el(perience at Solstice. Specifically, while Beach had described
himself to Tourdji, as a "founder" and portolio maager of Solstice and Vollero had simlarly
described hielf as a portolio manager, the Chief Operating Offcer of Solstice, Ken McCar,
when asked by Touradji to confrm the information provided by Beach and V ollero, stated in par
as follows:
36. When questioned about these inconsistencies, Beach and V ollero inormed
Tourdji tht McCar was out to get them for "political" reasons. Beach complaíed that
Olesky was an impediment to makng money, and insisted tht Beach and Vollero were
responsible for Solstce's track record. Beach, in parcular, stated that Olesky "didn't know
37. In light of Beach and Vollero's representations, and in light of the positive
perormance of the TGR Funds in 2005, including the OG Book, Touradji continued to allow
them a certain degree of discretion in making the day-to-day trading decisions for the energy
9
38. As it tued out, however, Beach and Vollero's misrepresentations concerning
their roles at Solstice were only the beginng of a pattern of similar lies.
39. By the sprig of2006, Touradji had become concerned about the size of the
positions that Beach and Vollero had built up in varous relatively iliqud small-cap energy
equi securties. When Tourdji el(pressed these concern to Beach and V ollero, they assured
him that they were comfortable with the size of these positions.
40. In May 2006, however, the equities markets e¡¡erienced an across-the-board sell-
off. Small cap energy equities suffered signficantly in the May sell-off and continued to
langush for the following months. As Vollero himselfIater admtted, "they became an out-of-
favor asset class. Investors generally felt trapped in these names, liquidity dred up, and the
stocks suffered to the downide when the energy sector sold off but did not paricipate in the
upside moves."
41. In addition to these substantial iliquid small-cap positions, Beach and V ollero
which also were iliquid, also suffered durg and afer the market sell-off and liquidity cruch of
May 2006.
42. As V ollero later admtted, the poor performance in these two classes of securties
43. Shorty afer the May 2006 sell-off, Touradji took control of the energy equity
book, and immediately undertok effort to liquidate as many of the small cap positions as he
could at a reasonable price. As V ollero later admitted, the Funds were able to do ths "largely
due to a very adroit view (Paul Touradji) had as to market appetite for these tyes of investments
10
44. By late 2006, Touradji had successfuly reduced DeepRock's small cap el(posure
I 45. Reducing the size of these positions at an acceptable cost, and thereby restoring
liquidity to the Funds, requied Tourdji himself to devote substatial time and effort to
46. In sumizing what had gone wrong in 2006, V ollero admitted tht he and
Beach had had limited the equity book in 2006 to "mostly illquid crap." Vollero also admtted
tht he and Beach had "totally messed up" by accumulatig such a large volume of iliquid
investments. He also flatly admitted that ths "wasn't PT's (Paul Touradji's) fault, it was ours
47. Despite Vollero's contemporaneous adissions that ¡ie and Beach were
responsible for the "small cap blow up," as he referred to it at the time, and that Touradji had
been largely responsible for getting them out of the mess they had created, he now seeks to
blare Touradji for these events io an effort to create a false record in support of his
compensation claims.
Capital nonetheless paid Beach and Vollero each a $1 milion bonus for the year in an effort to
encourge them to work toward improviog their futue performance. At the time they were
awarded these amounts, neither Beach nor V ollero complained, nor did they sugges that there
el(sted an ageement under which they were entitled to a majority of the profits of parcular
trading books they purortedly managed. Even if there had been such an agreement, by tht
II
measure they would have been entitled to nothing, or indeed less than nothing, for their
49. Yet in their Amended Complaint, Beach and V ollero now claím an entitlement to
over $5,0 minion in bonuses eared for their supposedly successful work in 2006, with no
mention at all of the small cap blow up, or the fact that their poor management forced Touradji to
place severe constraíts on their trdig discretion and tighten all risk controls.
50. After a tuultuous 2006, 2007 was a quieter year. Whe the ST Book
el(perienced sizeable losses, the OG Book and DeepRock retued respectable retu due to
"weakesses" had already become a serious issue and soure of internal debate among his co-
Plaintiff Robert V ollero and others. In parcular, these documents reflect that it had become
clear to Robert Vollero and Benjam Bram, a Tourji Capita equities trader, that Gentr
Beach simply lacked the skills and intellgence necessar to manage an equity securities
portfolio.
in parcular was responsible for a disastus series ofinvestments in Touradji Capita's private
equity portolio. Notably, Beach and Vollero do not even mention in their Amended Complaít
their key roles in building and managing the Funds' private equity portolio. That is because the
reults of that effort were so bad tht they canot be squared with an after-the-fact claim for $50
12
53. Vollero himselfhas admitted that Beach was responsible for rung private
equity at Tourji. In late 2007, Vollero wrote tht Beach "should contiue to spend a lot of
his
54. hi fact, even Gentr Beach's father has testified under oath tht Gentr Beach was
55. Yet tre to form, since fiing his lawsuit, Gentr Beach has misrepresented under
oath his role in overseeing the private equity portolio, denying that he wa responsible for that
effort. But again his co-plaintiff, Robert Vollero, admttd the trth in an e-mail wrttn in 2008:
wrte-down of over $100 milion, and Playa Oil and Gas LP tued into a vehicle by which
Gentr Beach and his father absconded with $500,000 ofinvestor capital and are now seeking
industr.
I3
58. Thus, shortly afr joinng Touradji Capita, in the sumer of2005, Gentr Beach
proposed that the TGR Funds inves in a private oil and gas parnership to be manged by Gentr
59. Prior to that time, Touradji Capital's investigation ha now revealed, Gar Beach
had been attempti without succes to locate outside investors to fud a proposed driling
project.
60. hi persuading Tourdji to approve the investent on behalf of the TGR Funds,
Gentr Beach falsely represented that his father was an experienced businessman with a history
of successfully locating and developing oil and gas propertes, and that his father was being hotly
pursued by other potential investors. He and his father also reresented that they possessed
valuable rights to oil and gas properties that would be contrbuted to the ventue.
61. Based upon Gentr Beach's representations as to his father's el(perience and
abilities, as well as their representations concerng the valuable oil and ga interests that they
owned, Playa was established in October 2005. Though afliates, Touradji Capital controls
Playa.i
62. Beach Capital Parership, 1.P. ("Beach Capita LP), a limited parnership
63. Gentr Beach and Vollero spearheaded the negotiation of the Playa LP
parnership agreement (the "Original LP Agreement"), which Gentry Beach signed on behalf of
Touradji Capita.
The name ofTourdji Capital's affliate that made the investment and acts as a limited parer in Playa is
DeepRock Ventu Parers, LP C"DeepRock Ventu"). For puroses of
this pleading, we refer to DeepRock
Ventus as ''Tourdji CapitaLn
14
64. Under that Agreement, Touradji Capita contrbuted every dollar of the capital
that went into Playa. That money, of coure, was investor capita. The Original LP Agreement
required that Touradji Capital contrbute only $8 milion of intial capita, and set a ma¡imum
capital contribution of $3 0 millon.
65. The Orginal LP Agreement required that Gar Beach contrbute "(a J II rights,
title, and interest" in a varety of oil and gas leaes, prospects and joint ventures.
66. At the time Playa was formed, and over the nel(t few years, Gar Beach
67. hi reality, and contrar to ths representation, Gar Beach contrbuted nothing of
economic value to Playa. histead, what Beah Capital appears to have "contrbuted" to Playa is
the opportwuty to pay milions of dollars to acquire and develop certin oil and gas propertes
"propertes," and no "Prospect Generation Joint Ventues" of any value were contrbuted to
Playa.
68. In fact, in an audit memo wrtten by Playa's auditor in 2007 - but not provided to
Tourdji Capital until it was subpoenaed in litigation - the auditor concluded as follows with
"Beach had no basis in the assets. There was no determinable value to the
assets. "
69. Even worse, Touradji Capita's investigation has reveaed that - in another
egregious conflict of interest -- Gentr Beach himself possessed an undisclosed personal financial
interest in one of the entities allegedly constituting these supposed propertes, an entity caled the
"Beach Energy Group." Gentr Beach flatly misrepresented to Touradji Capita at the time that
15
70. In addition, at the outset of Playa the pares contemplated that Ga Beach would
receive a porton ofthe profits of Playa only afer Touradji Capital and its investors received the
71. By early 2007, however, an employee of Touradji Capital, Holbrook Dom, had
reviewed the Original LP Agreement and concluded that it was not suffciently clear on this
point. Dam therefore spoke to Gentr Beach and Rober V ollero about the issue.
72. Beach and Vollero both specifically confined that the intent of the paries had
been that Touradji Capital should recover all of its invested capital before Ga Beach became
entitled to shar in any assets held or distrbuted by the parership. V ollero even stated to
Gentry Beach in Dorn's presence: "You need to fix this," and Beach promised that he would do
so. Dorn thereafer spoke directly with Ga Beach, who confined his agreement to these
terms.
73. Gar Beach also communicated ths agreement to Playa's auditors at around this
same tie. Specifically, in an audit work paper dated December 31, 2007 (but agaín, only
Per G. Beach. . .
involvement in the transaction and placing his family's interests directly ahead of
those of
Tourdji Capital's investors, Gentr Beach purosefully failed to obtaín his father's wrtten
acknowledgement of this arangement, aiid the two men now deny tliat Touradji Capital was
entitled to recoup its invested principal before Gary Beach would be entitled to share in profls.
16
Even more egregiously, the two men now claim in a lawsuit that Gar Beach is owed $8 millon
of investor capital that was previously distributed to Touradji Capita as a retu of principal.
75. Based upon the understading tht Touradji Capital was to receive a retu of its
invested capita prior to Gar Beach's sharing in the profits, Gentr Beach recommended, and
Touradji Capita agreed, to contiue to contribute millons of dollars to Gar Beach's oil and gas
originally committed. Touradji Capital did so, only to find that the Beaches now claim an
absolute and automatic entitment to 20 percent of that money. hi other words, the Beaches
now clai that the agreement entitled them to 20% of every investor dollar from the day that
76. In addition, as set forth in more detil below, Gar Beach later absconded with
$500,000 dollar of investor capita and was forced to admit under oath that he secretly shared
77. Under Gar Beach's management, Playa was profoundly unsuccessful in drllng
for oil and gas, losing millons of dollars on an operating basis in 2006 and 2007. Gar Beach
was so unsuccessful that, by mid-2007, he had concluded that Playa should be shut down and all
of its assets sold. On August 28,2007, Gar Beach sent Gentr Beach (but no one else) the
following email:
Gentr,
I reommend that Playa sell i 00% of each of the prospects it has
leased and not tae anymore driling risk. We should only lease a
new prospect afer we have sold a prospect and recovered our lease
costs. The money we have will be used to clea up our curent
projects so they can be sold. As soon as practical, we should sell
each producing propert. I do not plan to draw down anymore
money from Touradji. My thoughts on Playa's plan going
forward stem from our lack ofsuccess and the cost to drll wells.
17
Let's visit.
GMB
78. However, in clear breach of his fiduciar duty to Touradji Capital and its
investors, Gentr Beach did notforward this emau 01' otherwise share this information witli
,
79. Intead, Gentr Beach falsely represented to Paul Touradji that Playa was an
i
ememely successful and valuable ventue, thereby inducing Touradji Capita to contrbute
II müIions of dollars in additional capital to Playa.
80. Whle the Origial LP Agreement had obligate Touradji Capital to commt only
a minium of$8 millon to Playa, by late 2007, Touradji Capital's investors had commtted in
el(cess of over $40 milion - or five times the amount of capital required by the agrement.
81. By the end of 2007, Touradji was convinced that while the Funds had performed
well overall up to tht tie, factors withn Touradji Capital- including Gentr Beach's inerent
weakesses and poor performance - necessitate a restrctug of the Firm. hi ths connection,
on November 30, 2007, Touradji wrote to the employees ofTouradji Capital, including Beach
and Vollero, asking that they contrbute their thoughts as to how best to allocate the firm's tie
and resources going forward. A key aspec of this process was dealing with the widely
82. Vollero responded on December 5, 2007. With regard to his co-plaintiff, Gentr
Beach - a man presently seeking $25 millon based upon the fiction that he was a successfu
18
Gentr. . .
(emphasis added.)
83. Thus, by early 2008, Gentry Beach had proven to be entiely incapable of
performg the principal fuction that he claimed to be able to perform - acting as a portolio
manger.
84. hideed, V ollero also admitted to Beach - while witholding the inormation from
anyone else - that he and Beach "just look at tickers and go with them when we need something
to buy and when we nee something to selL." Ths, of course, is precisely the opposite of how
85. Based on his own observations and the additional feedback he received, Tourdji
instrcted Beach and V ollero that Beach should no longer be involved directly in portfolio
86. Then, in early 2008, Beach himself wrote: "1 am oficially (sicJ an analyst again."
Later tht year V ollero admitted that Gentr had long been "fuctioning as an analyst and not a
PM."
87. Thus, well before they fied their lawsuit based on Beach's supposed role as a
portolio manager, both Beach and V ollero admttd that Beach was, in fact, acting as a mere
19
88. At arund that same time, Tourdji organzed a meeting of all members of the
equity tea el(cept Gentr Beach, and asked them how they felt Beach had performed in
manging the team. The team members wuformly respnded that Beach was not a good
89. In Marh of 2008, Tourji leaed that the CFO of Playa had resigned weeks
earlier, but neither Beach nor anyone else on the private equity team had shared tht inormation.
90. Based upon ths investigation and other factors, including Gentr's increasingly
apparnt inabilty to manage the conflict ofinterest with his father on Playa, Touradji deterined
that it was in the best interest of the Funds to remove Gentr Beach from his role as the
manger of private equity. Thus, in March 2008, Tourdji informed Beach tht he was no longer
responsible for private equity, and should have no involvement in any private equity projects
going forward.
91. Beach blatantly ignored these instrctions. Beach continue to inject hielf into
the private equity business, accepting meetings with outside pares about potential investments
92. In June 2008, Beach received the following wrtten warg from Touradji
Capital's CFO:
20
the pratice, whether well intentioned or otherwse, is a clear violation of
our instrctions and will have severe consequences to your continued
employment at Touradji Capital.
I am writing you ths memo because you have been, yet agaín, found to
be violating these very clear instrctions. Make no mistaes tht you
have been in clear violation ofthese firm protocols, as well as
insubordinate to specific instrctions you were given. The fact that these
instructions were given to remediate your poor performance and
behavior only makes the matter more serious.
investments, Madagascar Oil and Kataga Mines, cae to light. Touradji Capital invested tens
94. In 2006, the Madagascar Oil investment had been valued at $2.50 per share.
Under Beach's watch, the value of ths investment fell to $0.01 per share, reslting in a
95. Kataga Mies also resulted in a substantial loss. Notably, Beach was drven by a
conflct of interest here as well: He pushed the investment in Kataga in par in an effort to
generate a "fider's fee" for his uncle, Jeff Gentr. Despite Beach's entreaties in support of such
a fee, Touradji Capita refused to pay one. However, Tourji Capital has now discovered that
Beach ignored ths instrction as well, and secretly agreed with his uncle Jeff Gentr to pay him
96. On June 25, 2008, Beach called the entÌIe sta ofTouradji Capital into a
conference room, and apologized to everone for dropping the ball on pnvate equity. Beach
promised to make up for every dollar ofIost P&L that he had cost the firm.
97. One employee who responded to Beach's apology by emaíl told him that it had
21
98. Now, of coure, Beach denies that the apology was sincere, and takes the position
I
that he only made the apology in order to obtan money.
!
Beach had bee strpped of responsibilty for private equity, and had been demoted to the
position of analyst.
100. In anticipation of these investor discussions, Vollero wrote down his own
GB Change
(emphasis added.)
\01. Thus, by the admssion of his own co-plaíntiffand best frend Robert
V ollero, Gentr Beach was not only fudamentaly incapable of actig as a portolio
manager, but he also had faíled at the only other role he ha held at Touradji Capital-
102. What Touradji Capital did not know at the time, but has since leaed from its
investgation, is that with VoIlero's ful knowledge and complicity, Beach also continued to trade
for the Funds' accounts afer el(plicit instrctions that he not do so. This constitutes a separate
22
M. Beach And His Father Implement Their
i
Conspiracv To Abscond With Capital From Plava
I 103. Meanwhile, Beach was in dire finacial straits as a result of his consistently living
104. hi addition, the Funds' investment in Playa - the investment brought to the Funds
by Gentr Beach and managed by his father - was in deep trouble. By May of2008, Touradji
Capital's investors had contribute $41 milion, or five times more capital than wa require
105. It was not until May 2008, however, that Touradji Capita el(ecuted amendments
to the Playa LP Agreement confirming the paries' agreement tht Touradji Capital was to
receive a retu of all of its investment capita prior to any distbutions being made to Beach
CapitaL. It did so only afer a representative ofTourji Capital discoverd that Gentr Beach
106. The Amended LP Agreement el(plicitly sets fort the paries' intent that Tourji
Capital would recover all of its invested capita before Beach Capital began to share in any
profits.
107. Ga Beach wa involved in the drafing of tht document, and signed the
i 08. Two days afer Gar Beach signed the Amended LP Agreement, he requested tht
having signed the Amended LP Agreement, the money was wird to Playa.
23
N. Beach And V ollero Invent Claims Of Constructive Dischal1e
109. By August of2008, Gentr Beach, his father, and Vollero were aleady secretly
discussing how best to concoct Beach and Vollero's frudulent claíms for additional
Are you going to pay Rob and me for 2007? If yes, when? Ifno, why
not?
If you get paid for 2007, have your lawyer put your trde in wrtig for
2008 and let hi know it's coming..
Afer you get your trade in writing or if he refuses to give you your
trade in writing, draw out all monies you have in the fund.
Dad.
110. Notably, no mention is made of alleged compensation owed for 2005 or 2006 - as
11 i. A central asect of Beach and Vollero's claim is that Beach was "compelled to
resign" from Touradji Capita as a result of theats directed at hi on September 25,2008. Ths
is false. histead, evidence uncovered afer Beach left Tourdji Capita reveals that well before
Tourdji's supposed "theats" were made, Gentr Beach had aleady made plans to leave the
fir and to sta his own fud, and had even hired an employee.
112. For el(ample, Beach's new employee, Thomas Page, wrote to Gentr on
Now that you are my boss I need some instrction on what I need to
sta learg, what to read, what networking technques I need to pursue,
and who I should be spending time with. I know we are going to tae
thgs slow, but I'd like to sta preparng for what it is we will be doing,
ie. raising capital, what deals to avoid, how to pursue and who, etc. As
24
I
we discussed I am going to be deferrng al deals presented to me your
.1 way.
i
By the way, I'm in our offce now and the new contact information is as
follows:
Tel: 214-295-3033
Tom
113. Thus, a key premise underlying Beach an Vollero's claim for compensation--
that the two men were forced to resigo and otherwise would have remaíed at Tourdji managing
capita - is false. histead, the two men never intended to remaín at T ouradji CapitaL.
1I4. As par of his claim for "intentional infiction of emotional distress," Beach also
alleges, falsely, that on September 25, 2008 Touradji theatened to "ruin (Beach's) marage,"
even if it meat "saying thngs that were untre." This contrved allegation was made, it is clear,
to anticipate the suracing of admissions by Beach showig that he, long before September of
2008, had "ruined" his own marage. The deep problems that el(isted in Mr. Beach's mariage
were of his own makg, and Beach's effort to tu ths into misconduct by Touradji is
115. On September 25, 2008, Gentr Beach approached Paul Touradji, theatened him,
and demanded money. When Touradji told Beach that he would not respond to such el(ortion,
Beach stated: "Then rny father and I will just tae it from you and your investors. You don't
25
know what we are capable of." Beach then theatened to "destroy" Touradji Capital and stormed
1 i 6. Soon afr he left Touradji, Beach fied a false police report - not because he felt
theatened, but because he was urged to do so by his Uncle, Jeff Gentr. Notably, Gentr Beach
is a hulkg former football player and an aggressive weapons collector and hunter -- once
wrtig to his friends, for el(ample, that "(tJhere is never enough death."
117. Accordingly, the idea that Beach felt theatened in a conversation with Paul
Touradji over compensation is ridiculous. And not surrisingly, Beach's police report was never
the subject of any real investigation - Tourdji Capita leaed about the report only though
118. On September 24, 2008, two days before Gentr Beach (falsely) claíms that he
was compelled to resign from Touradji Capital, his father, Gar Beach, sent an e-mail proposing
119. Touradji Capital responded imediately, instrcting Gar Beach not to distbute
120. Yet on the night of September 25, 2008, while Gentr Beach was still an
employee ofTouradji Capita, he and his father discussed by telephone makg a distbution of
Playa's capita the nel(t mornng. At the time both knew that Tourji Capital had aleady
121. Then, on September 26, 2008 - the same day that Gentr Beach resigned from
Touradji Capital- Gar Beach distbuted $500,000 from Playa LP to an account he controlled.
122. Gar Beach has admitted under oath that the distrbution violated the terms ofthe
Playa parership agreement, and that - consistent with Gentr Beach's theat on September 25,
26
2008 - that he later shared a portion of
the unauthorized $500,000 distrbution of investor fuds
123. A few days after takng the Playa capital, Gar Beach fied a lawsuit claímig that
he is entitled to 20% of all of the cash and assets tht are now, or ever have been, held by Playa.
hi other words, Gar Beach clais an automatic right to 20% of every dollar ever invested in
Playa by Tourdji Capital's investors. He denIes that the amendment that he signed in May of
124. Not surprisingly, Gentr Beach now falsely claíms that his father is correct,
125. Touradji Capita responded to ths unlawf distrbution by, among other things,
immediately demanding access to Playa's books and records, seeking to el(ercise its contractual
rights to control Playa, and by filig counterclaims. Not only did Gar Beach deny Touradji
Capital access to the records, but immediately after he was ordered by a cour to tu over the
126. Tourdji Capital has also leared that Gar Beach lied to Playa's auditors about
127. Followig Beach's contrved depare from the firm on September 26,2008,
VOiiero remained at Touradji Capital for thee additional months for the purose of gathering
inormation to assist Beach in his claíms, and to manufactue a basis for his own lawsuit againt
the fi.
27
128. Notaly, during that period, V ollero emphatically represented to Touradji and
others at the fi that he had ended any asociation with Beach, aod routinely criticized the
Beaches, callng their actions with respect to Playa "despicable." All of ths was apparently just
another set oflies that V ollero told to fuer his own interess, given that he aod Beach soon
129. In terms of his own compensation, prior to leaving the firm, Vollero came to
Touradji and demanded that he be paíd $10 millon immediately or he would go to the
newspapers in support of Gentry Beach's false story. Notwithstading VOiiero's plaín fiduciar
duty to the firm and its invesors to assist with the Playa litigation, V ollero fuer stated that if
Touradji wanted Vollero's help on that litigation, Touradji would have to pay him the $10
millon. Vollero, too, stated that if Touradji Capital did not pay hi he would destroy the firm.
130. In addition, V ollero created false "notes" of his conversations with Touradji. In.
those notes, Vollero sought to blame the 2006 small cap debacle on Touradji - despite Vollero's
having admitted in writing at the time of those events that he and Beach had been to blare for
that problem.
13 1. As set forth in more detal below, soon after leaving Touradji Capita in
December 2008, V ollero formally joined in a new investment parership, the V ollero Beach
132. Tourdji Capital has since discovered that upon leaving the finn, Beach and
Vollero took with them confdential and proprietar inormation regarding the Funds' tradig
positions, as well as Touradji Capita reseah, in breach of their duty to Touradji Capita aod its
investors.
28
133. Touradji Capital has demanded the retu of that information, yet Beach and
134. hi addition, in meetings with e¡istig Tourdji Capital investors to market their
new fud, Beach and V oller have made false statements concerng their supposed agreement
at Touradji Capital, and about Touradji Capital's dealings with Amaranth, as set fort in more
detal below. hi paricular, they have stated that Tourdji "broke his word" and breached a
contrct with them, and that Tourji Capital violated an alleged "no trade" agreement with
Amaranth durng negotiations for the purchae of Amarth's metals book. These sttements are
false.
135. As described above, Beach and Vollero left Tourdji Capital and promptly set up
136. The Vollero Beach Funds seeks the same type of investors as those who invest in
137. hi their promotional materials, Vollero and Beach have falsely and in bad faith
sought to tae sole credit for the success of the fuds they maaged under Tourdji's superision
and guidance, and now claim sole ownership of the methods they used in managing such fuds.
They also are misrepresenting Gentr Beach's role as that of a portolio maager, and are
138. The promotiona materials identif both Beach and Vollero as former "portolio
managers" for Touradji Capital. Beach and V ollero state that: "Most recently the team traded at
Touradji Capital management, where they were responsible for managing commodity equity
portolios as well as Touradji DeepRock, a fud which invested solely in energy equities." With
29
respect to "Team El(perience," they state: "Profitable - Consistent and profitable history of
trading commodity equity strategies, posting positive anual returns each year since inception of
the strategy in 2001." In their respective biographical sketches, each states that he "was an
equity Portolio Manager at Touradji Capita maiagement, a New York based commodity
139. In addition, as set fort above, by both Vollero's and Beach's admssion, Gentr
Beach did not even fuction as a portfolio manager - and was indeed incapable of doing so
because he lacked the basic skills required for that role -- and instea fuctioned as an analyst
durg an el(tended period of time at T ouradji CapitaL. It is fase and misleading and constitutes
unaír competition to portray Beach as a portolio manager but fail to disclose that he was
140. As Beach and Vollero are awar, it is the position of the SEC that "it may be
employee's prior place of employment when the employee had been one of several persons
responsible for selecting the Securities for those accounts." In re HorIZon Asset Management,
141. Contrar to SEC requirements, the promotional literatue does not inform
investors that Beach was not, in fact, acting as a portolio manager at the time he left Touradji
Capital; that both men were subordinate to and used the methods and skills developed by Paul
Touradji; that Paul Touradji was the key man responsible for managing the portfolios for which
Beach and V ollero claí sole credit; and that the two men do not have or use an el(tensive
management activities." As V ollero has admittd in e-maíls to Beach, the two men actually just
30
stare at screens and trade for the sake of tring. In fact, if the men do claim to use any
"proprietar" methods, they are methods that belong to Touradji Capital because they were
142. As set fort above, these marketing materials ar false and misleading, and
143. Notably, Beach also falsely represents to the investing public, though his
Bloomberg profie, that when he was an employee at Morgan Staney prior to Solstice, he was a
"money manager." That statement is false. Beach had no role in managing money at Morgan
Staey.
144. In addition, the Vollero Beach Funds have relied on proprietar tradng data and
investor information that V ollero and Beach misappropriated when they left Tourdji.
damage Touradji Capital by disparaging the fi in the press, in the marketplace, and in their
146. In addition, V ollero and Beach have intentionally disparged Touradji Capita in
connection with the firm's acquisition of Amaranth Advisors' metas trading book. As set fort
below, Touradji Capital's dealings with Amaranth were entirely appropriate and in full
accordance with the pares' agreement. For tht reason, no person had ever raísed a question
about Tourdji Capital's conduct in connection with that transaction unti the Beaches and
V ollero began energetically spreading false ruors about supposed misconduct afer Gentry
31
147. The facts are these: In mid-September 2006, at a time when Amaranth's
precarous position was well known publicly, Amth approached Touradji Capital in an effort
to unoad cert base meta positions. Even before entering into any agreement, Amanth had
described aspects of its metals positions to Touradji Capita, and had informed Touradji Capital
148. Touradji Capital offered to bid on the book, and was informed that it was one ofa
number of such bidders. In anticipation of the trsaction, Touradji Capita and Amarth
negotiated a wrttn confidentiality agreement. As par of that process, Touradji Capital
specifically negotiated for, and obtained, an acknowledgment by Amarth that Touradji Capita
"may hold long or short positions in derivat(iv)es or other instrents that may be the subject of
effect transactions for (its) own account. . . in such derivatives or other instrents. . . ." hi
other words, Tourdji Capital was entitled by contract to continue to trade base metals at all
times - a right it el(pressly preserved so that it could manage its e¡¡sting metals portolio.
149. Touradji Capital immediately analyzed Amaranth's metals book, assessing the
overall portolio with a thoroughness and speed that few, if any, other market paricipants were
capable of. Amaranth's metals book, Touradji Capital eventually leared, consisted of over
1,200 positions in varous base metas, including a varety of complicated option and spread
strctues. Touradji Capital worked diligently with Amaranth to sort out varous issues and
Tourdji Capita to tae on siguficant market and interest rate risk, to assess and take
responsibilty for deep-in-the-money options, to pay over a quarr of a bilion dollars of its own
cash just to purchase the options positions, to make additional margin payments for many futues
32
and options positions, and, finally, to tae on the credit risk of Amaranth, a fud that was then in
150. But most importtly, in the few trading days between the signng of the
confdentiality agreement and the close of the transaction, Touradji Capita did not in any respect
take advantage of the Amarth information in connection with its propriet trailng.
151. On September 28, 2006, the traction closed. Since that tie, Touradji Capita
has itself borne the entire risk inherent in the book. hi the thee years following the transaction,
and until it made its recent cour filing, Amaranth had never, in any contel(t, complained or
raísed any questions about Touradji Capital's conduct or its trading activites. Indeed, soon afer
the close of the transacton, Amarth asked for Touradji Capital's assistance in unwidig
adiltional positions.
152. The fit mention of any improper conduct with respect to Amaranth arose in the
litigation commenced by Gentr Beach's father in connection with Playa. In that case, Gar
Beach admitted that Gentry had told him about the Amaranth transaction, and in parcular that
153. By that conduct alone, Gentr Beach breached his fiduciar obligation to Touradji
Capital by disclosing - for his own benefit- confidential inormation about Touradji Capita's
involvement in the Amaranth transaction. Even worse, of course, is that Gentr Beach lied about
154. For years following ths trsaction, no person from Amaranth or anyone else has
ever even suggested that wrongdoing occured in connection with ths transaction. However,
after Beach and Vollero left the fi, and in connection with the lawsuit commenced by Gar
Beach, th Beaches and Vollero began saying that the trsaction with Amarth was improper.
33
;
At fist, the men staed that Touradji Capita had entered into a "no-trde" agreement that
I
prohibited it from trading Amarth's positions at all durg the period of the paries'
negotiations. That was false.
155. After these allegations got Gar Beach nowhere in Tel(as, the Beaches and
Vollero continued to state falsely to market paricipants that Touradji Capital had breached its
agreement with Amaranth and had trded improperly. These sttements were false, were made
as par of the Vollero Beach Funds' marketing efforts, and were designed to injur Touradji and
Touradji Capita.
COUNERCLAIS
COUN ONE
(Breach of Fiduciary Duty against Gentr Beach and Robert V ollero)
156. Touradji Capita repeats and releges each and every allegation set forth above as
157. As employees ofTouradji Capital, Beach and Vollero owed duties ofloyalty and
good faith to the firm, including duties to refrain from tang, disclosing or using confdential
information belonging to the firm and to treat that information with e¡¡me car and honesty for
the benefit of the firm and the Funds only. Beach and Vollero's duties to Touradji Capital also
included a duty not to tae actions diectly contrar to the interests of the firm and its investors,
and a duty not to place their own personal interests, or the interests of their famly members,
158. Beach and Vollero have violated their fiduciar obligations by, among other
thngs:
34
· Misrepresenting the performance of Playa LP and witholding
inormation from Paul Tourdji and Touradji Capita regardig
Playa LP, thereby causing Touradji Capita to invest additional
invesor fuds in Playa LP's unsuccessfu drllng program;
159. As a direct and foreseeable result of Beach and VoIlero's breaches of their
fiduciary duties, Touradji Capita is entitled to an award of all monetary damages it has incured
and is continuing to incur to its business, reputation and goodwill, as described fuher above, in
a final amount to be determined at tral. Touradji Capital is also entitled to disgorgement of any
35
il-gotten gaíns, all compensation paid to Beach and Vollero durng the period oftheir disloyalty,
and damages resulting from the loss of investors and investment capital caused by Beach and
VoIlero's actions. Touradji Capita is also entitled to recover for the costs of
the Amaranth
litigation that has been instituted and was improperly instigated by V ollero and Beach.
160. hi addition, Touradji Capita is entitled to injunctive relief requiring that Beach,
Vollero and the Vollero Beach Funds cease and desist from using the firm's confdential and
proprieta information, and that they retu that inormation imediately to the firm, including
by retung to Touradji Capita any and al hardware or other medium on which such
information is stored. Touradji Capital also is entitled to recover all el(penses incured, including
COUNT TWO
(Unfair Competition against Gentry Beach,
Robert Vollero, and the Vollero Beach Funds)
161. Touradji and Touradji Capital repeat and reallege each and every allegation
162. Beach and Vollero, in connection with their marketing of the Vollero Beach
Fuds, have lied about their responsibilty for maaging Touradji Capita's investments, and
have taken credit for performance data that belongs to Paul Touradji and Touradji Capital.
163. Beach, Vollero and the Vollero Beach Funds, individually and jointly, have
underten ths misappropriation in bad faith, in violation of SEC directives, and with ful
knowledge of the falsity oftheir statements and the wrongflness of their actions.
164. At all relevant times, Paul Touradji was listed in the Fund documents as the "key
man" responsible for managing the investments held by the Funds. The successfu performance
numbers for the Funds, including the trading books that Beach and V ollero claim to have
36
managed on their own, are the result of Paul Touradji and Touradji Capita's labor, skill and
resources.
165. Beach, Vollero and the Vollero Beach Funds' representations about theirroles are
intended to mislead, and have misled, investors into thng that Beach and V ollero are
166. In reliance on these representations, investors have invested capita in the V ollero
Beach Funds, thus resulting in unjust enrchment to Beach, V ollero and the V ollero Beach
Funds.
167. hi addition, Beach and V ollero have taen and used for their own devices the
about the firm's investors, trading positions, and the strctue of its trading portfolios, as well as
research compiled by Tourji Capita. Beach and Vollero have used this information to solicit
and reeive investments from present or potential investors ofTouradji Capita. Beach, Vollero
and the V ollero Beach Funds have also used this confidential inormation as par of their
campaígn to disparge Touradji Capital and its investent pratices, including by falsely and
with malice statig to these curent and potential investors that Tourji Capital breached a
contrct with Beach and V ollero and engaged in improper conduct in connection with the
purchase of Amaranth Advisors' metas trading book. Touradji Capital was damaged as a result
of this dispargement when investors withdrew thei capita from the Funds, or refraíned from
168. As a dirct and foreseeable result of Beach and Vollero's unair competition,
Touradji Capital is entitled to an award of all monetar damages it has incurred and is continuing
to incur to its business, reputation and goodwill, as described fuer above, in a final amount to
37
be determined at triaL. Touradji Capital is fuer entitled to disgorgement of any il-gotten
gaíns, and damges resulting from the loss ofinvestors and investment capital caused by Beach
169. Touradji Capital is also entitled to an.injunction directing Beach, Vollero and the
V ollero Beach Funds to discontinue their unaír competition and misuse of confidential and
COUN THRE
(Theft of Trade Secrets against Gentr Beach,
Robert V ollero, and the V ollero Beach Funds)
170. Touradji and Touradji Capital repeat and reallege each and every allegation
171. As employees of Touradji Capital for over thee year, Beach and Vollero
and Touradji Capita, including information rising to the level of trde secrets.
172. Specificaly, during their employment Beach and V ollero obtaíed confdential
identity of the investor's intern contact person, and detaíls regarding the investor's investment
preferences. Ths information is a closely guarded trade secret, in that (i) the identity and other
inormation concernng the investors is not known by others outside the firm; (ii) Tourdji
Capita takes steps to maíntaín the confdentiality ofthis information; (iii) competitors of
Tourdji Capita would find the inormation valuable; (iv) significant time and effort was spent
developing Touradji Capita's investor base and the corresponding investor database; and (v) the
173. Beach and V ollero also took substantial electrnic and hard copy financial,
trading and research information when they left Touradji CapitaL. That inormation included
38
confdential data reflecting Touradji Capital's trading strategies and the composition of its
trading portolios. Ths constitutes proprietay and confdential information, and also constitutes
a trade secret.
174. On information and belief, Beach and Vollero have used ths inormation to trade
175. The foregoing inormation was unown to Beach and Vollero prior to their
employment by Touradji Capita, and was acquird by them solely in their role as trste
176. Beach and VOiiero, principals of the Vollero Beach Fuds, have used Touradji
Capita's confidential investor information to solicit Touradji Capital investors on behalf of the
V ollero Beach Funds. On information and belief, certaín of these investors have invested in the
177. Touradji and Touradji Capita are entitled to an award of all moneta damages
they have incured and are continuing to incur to their business as a result of such conduct,
disgorgement of any il-gottn gains received by Beach, V oUero, and V oUero Beach Funds.
178. Touradji and Tourdji Capita also are entitled to an injunction requirg tht
Beah, V ollero and the V ollero Beach Funds ret of all of their trade secret inormation and
COUNT FOUR
(Conversion against Gentry Beach,
Robert Vollero, and the Vollero Beaeh Funds)
i 79. Touradji and Touradji Capita repeat and reallege each and every allegation
39
180. As set forth above, Beach, Vollero, and the Vollero Beach Funds took
181. Beach, Vollero and the Vollero Beach Funds' contiued possession ofthat
information is unauthorized, and Touradji Capital possesses a superior possessory right to that
information.
182. Beach and Vollero have refused to return that inormation despite demands that it
do so.
183. Touradji and Touradji Capital ar entitled to an award of all monetar damages
they have incured and are contiuing to incur to their business as a result of such conduct,
digorgement of any il-gotten gaí received by Beach, V ollero, and V ollero Beach Funds based
184. Touradji and Touradji Capital are also entitled to an injunction requirg that
v onero and Beach return of all oftheir trade secret information and cease from using that
COUNT FIVE
(Defamation against Gentry Beach, Robert Vollero,
the Vonero Beach Funds, and Gary Beach)
185. Tourji and Touradji Capital repeat and reallege each and every allegation
knowledge tht he would repeat it, and to investors and potential investors in the V onero Beach
Funds, among others, that Touradji Capital's agreement with Amaranth had a "no trade"
provision, that Touradji and Touradji Capital violated tht "no trade" provision, and that
Touradji and Touradji Capital used the information they acquired from Amaranth Advisors to
40
trade agaist Amarth's positions. On information and belief, Gar Beach repeated these
187. Gentr Beach and Robert V ollero have also stated to Tourdji Capital investors,
I
!
and other businesses in the financial industr, that Touradji Capital "broke its word" and
189. These statements by the Beaches and Vollero were knowingly fale and made
with malice.
190. As a result of the fase statements by Beach and Vollero, Touradji Capita has
been forced to el(pend tie and money defending itself against clais brought by Amaranth
Advisors. hi addition, investors have withdrawn capital from the Funds, or have refraíed from
191. hi addition, the statements by Beach and Vollero impugn Touradji and Touradji
Capital in their business and accuse them of unawfl activity, and are therefore defamation per
se.
192. As a direct and foreseeable result of the defamation by Beach and V ollero,
Touradji and Tourdji Capita are entitled to an award of all monetar daages they have
incurd and are continuing to incur to their business as a result of such conduct, as well as
disgorgement of any il-gott gaí received by Beach, V ollero, and the V ollero Beach Funds
41
COUNT SIX
(Tortous Intenerence With Business Relationships against
Gentry Beach, Rohert Vollero and the Vollero Beach Funds)
193. Tourdji and Touradji Capita repeat and reallege each and every allegation
194. Beach and Vollero tortiously interfered with Touradji Capital's relationships with
its curent and prospective investors by stating to investors and potential investors in the Vollero
Beach Funds, arong others, that Touradji Capita's agreement with Amaranth had a "no trade"
provision, that Tourdji and Touradji Capital violated that "no trade" provision, and that
Touradji and Touradji Capita used the information they acquired from Amaranth Advisors to
195. Gentr Beach and Robert Vollero have also stated to Touradji Capital investors,
and other businesses in the financial industr, that Tourdji Capita "broke its word" and
196. Beach and V ollero made these false statements verbally thoughout 2009 in
meetings with potential investors in the Beach V ollero Parership. Beach and V ollero made
these statements to the investors knowing that they were investors in the Funds managed by
Touradji CapitaL.
198. As a result of the false statements by Beach and Vollero, investors have
withdrawn capital from the Fuds, or have refraíed from investing additional amounts in the
Funds.
199. As a direct and foreseeable result of the tortous interference by Beach and
V ollero, Touradji and Touradji Capital are entitled to an award of all monetar darages they
have incured and are continuing to incur to their business as a result of such conduct, as well as
42
disgorgement of any il-gotten gain received by Beach, V oJlero, and the V olIero Beach Funds
COUNT SEVEN
(Aiding and Abettg Breach of Fiduciary Duty Against
Gentry Beach, Robert Vollero and Gary Beach)
200. Touradji and Tourji Capital repeat and reallege each and every alIegation
201. Gentr Beach, Robert Vollero, and Gar Beach, with knowledge, substatially
202. Ths conduct has daaged Tourdji Capital, including by the depletion of the
value of the investment in Playa LP and by loss of investors and investment capita.
COUNT EIGHT
(Declaratory Judgment against Gentr Beach,
Robert Vollero, and the Vollero Beach Funds)
203. Tourdji and Tourdji Capital repeat and relege each and every allegation
204. Touradji and Touradji Capital are entitled to a declaration that Beach and V ollero
are not entitled to recover any compensation or alleged bonuses and did not have a contract in
which they were entitled to any defined bonus amount, that V ollero, Gentr Beach, and the
V ollero Beach Funds have breached their fiduciar duties, aíded and abetted violations of
fiduciary duties, and engaged in unfair competition, theft of trade secrets, conversion and
defamation, and that Ga Beach aíded and abettd a breach of fiduciar duty.
43
ANSWER
hi addition to the foregoing averments, Defendants Touradji Capita and Touradji Answer
the specific allegations in Beach and Vollero's First Amended Complaint as follows, each
as vague.
4. Admt, el(cept deny that Paul Touradji, in his personal capacity, is the "Maaging
5. Deny.
6. Deny that Plaíntiffs ar entitled to any recovery whatsoever, including for the
7. Lack suffcient information to admt or deny, el(cept deny that Beach acted as a
portolio manger at Solstice and that he focused on the commodity sector thoughout his career.
8. Lack sufcient inormation to admit or deny, el(cept deny that Vollero was a
portolio manager at Solstice and that V ollero has focused on the commodity sector throughout
his caeer.
9. Admit that Touradji formed Touradji Capita in approl(imately Januar 2005, and
tht in the spring of2005, Tourdji Capital hired Beach, Vollero and certaín other former
employees of Solstice Equity Management to work for Touradji CapitaL. Deny the remainder of
44
10. Admit that Touradji Capital hied Beach and Vollero as at-wil employees in
appro¡¡mately May 2005, but deny that the pares entered into the stated agreement governg
the term and conditions of Beach and V ollero' s employment, el(cept as otherwse stated below:
a. Admt that it was anticipated that Beach and Vollero would assist in
managing a pool ofTouradji Global Resoures Fund capital in the oil and
gas sector, and that ths became known internlly as the Touradji OG
b. Admit.
c. Deny.
d. Admit that it was anticipated that Beach and V ollero would assist in
managing a yet-o-be created relative value energy equity fud. Deny the
e. Deny.
f. Deny.
1 i. Deny.
12. Deny.
13. Deny.
14. . Deny.
15. Deny.
16. Admit that Touradji Capital paíd Beach and V ollero a bonus for their serces in
2005, bringing their total compensation for the year to approl(imately $2.52 milion. Deny the
17. Deny.
45
18. Deny.
19. Deny.
20. Admt that a cert porton of Beach's and Vollero's cah bonus was defered for
21. Lack sufcient information to admit or deny the first sentence. Deny the
remaínder, el(cept admit tht, in response to a request made by V ollero tht he claímed was in
connection with an effort to purchase an aparent, Touradji Capital provided Vollero with a
letter. Defendats refer to tht letter for a full and accurate statement of its contents.
22. Deny, el(cept adit that, in response to a request made by Beach that he claímed
wa in connection with an effort to purchase an aparment, Touradji Capita provided Beach with
a reference letter in connection with his stated desir to purchase an aparent. Defendants refer
the Cour to that lettr for a ful and accuate statement of its contents.
23. Deny.
24. Deny.
25. Admit, el(cept deny any implication that Beach and Vollero contrbuted in any
26. Deny, el(cept admit that DeepRock did not show a profit, and in fact showed a
27. Deny.
28. Deny.
29. Deny.
30. Deny.
46
31. Admit that Touradji Capita paíd Beach and Vollero each a bonus of$l milion
for 2006, briging tota compensation for each of them for 2006 to $1.2 milion. Deny the
32. Admt.
33. Admt that withn the Touradji Diverified Fund, certain capita was allocated
internally to what became known as the OG Diversified Book and the ST Diversified Book.
34. Deny.
35. Deny.
36. Deny.
37. Admit that in or about November 2007, Touradji Capital paid Beach and V ollero
each $282,079.29 ($453,503.68 less ta withholding) as payment of the balance of their 2005
38. Deny.
39. Admit that 2007 was a successfu year for Touradji Capita, but that ths success
occured despite Beach and V ollero' s performance and not as a result of it. Deny the remaíder
40. Deny.
41. Deny.
42. Deny.
43. Deny.
44. Deny.
45. Deny.
46. Deny.
47
47. Deny, el(cept admit that Plaitiffs were paid no bonus for 2007.
48. Deny.
49. Admit that Touradji Capital paíd Vollero $300,000 in April 2008. Lack suffcient
inormation to admt or deny the amount ofVollero's tal bil. Deny the remainder of ths
pargraph as stated.
50. Deny.
5!. Deny.
52. Admit that Beach apologized to his coworkers for his poor perormance in
helping to manage the Funds' investments. Deny the remaider of ths pargraph.
53. Deny.
54. Deny.
55. Deny.
56. Deny.
57. Deny.
58. Deny.
59. Deny.
60. Deny.
6!. Deny.
62. Deny.
63. Deny.
64. Deny.
65. Deny.
66. Deny.
48
67. Deny.
68. Admt tht Beach gave letters to Tom Dwan describing Beach's version ofthe
events of September 5 and September 25, 2008, but deny that the events occured as described
69. Lack suffcient information to admit or deny whether Beach filed a police report
but deny tht Touradji made the theats descnbed in ths pargraph.
70. Deny.
71. Deny.
72. Deny.
73. Deny.
74. Deny.
75. Deny.
76. Deny.
77. Deny.
78. Deny.
79. Deny.
80. Deny.
81. Deny.
82. Admt that Vollero asisted in manging certaín Touradji Capital trding books
and invesents, and that 2008 was a volatile and diffcult year. Deny the remaíder of
ths
paragraph as stated.
83. Deny.
84. Deny the first and second sentences of ths paragraph, admit the thd.
85. Deny.
49
.:
;
FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
(Breach of Contract)
86. Defendants incorporate their previous responses to paragraphs I though 85.
87. Deny.
88. Deny.
89. Deny.
50
FIFH CAUSE OF ACTION
(Intentional Inflction of Emotional Diitress)
104. Deny.
105. Deny
11 i. No response is required.
AFFIRATIV DEFENSES
FIRST AFFIRMTIVE DEFENSE
163. The Complaint fails to stae a clai for which relief ca be granted.
TH AFFIRTIVE DEFENSE
165. Plaintiffs' claíms ar bared on the ground that Plaintiffs are faithess fiduciaries.
51
PRAYER FOR RELIEF
WHREFORE, Tourdji Capita and Touradji pray tht judgment be enterd in their
favor and against Gentry Beach and Robert V ollero, the V ollero Beach Funds as follows:
(i) Granting Beach and V ollero nothng on their claims and dismissing their claims in
their entirety;
(iii) Enjoing and restrnig the Defendants and each of them from representing
directly or by implication that they were more than subordinate managers of
investments while employed at Touradji Capita or that they had more than
secondar credtfor the success of Touradji Capital-managed fuds during the
period of their employment;
(iv) Awarding Touradji Capita and Touradji damages for the business lost by
Plaíntiffs as a result of Beach and Vollero's tortious misconduct;
(v) Awarding Touradji Capital the reasonable costs and disbursements of this action;
(vi) Awarding Touradji Capita any other relief tht this Cour deems just and proper;
and
(vii) Awarng Tourji Capital and Touradji all ofits attorneys' fees incured in the
defense and prosecution of the present claíms.
52