Students at the US Naval Academy designed, built, and tested the Power System Design for an electric car. The project involved converting an originally gas-powered car into a battery-powered car, whereby solar panels are used to recharge the batteries. Students used a mix of off the shelf parts and components, and homebuilt circuits.
Students at the US Naval Academy designed, built, and tested the Power System Design for an electric car. The project involved converting an originally gas-powered car into a battery-powered car, whereby solar panels are used to recharge the batteries. Students used a mix of off the shelf parts and components, and homebuilt circuits.
Students at the US Naval Academy designed, built, and tested the Power System Design for an electric car. The project involved converting an originally gas-powered car into a battery-powered car, whereby solar panels are used to recharge the batteries. Students used a mix of off the shelf parts and components, and homebuilt circuits.
Journal of Communication and Computer 10 (2013) 178-185
Power System Design for an Electric Car
Louiza Sellami, Mathew McIntyre, Linda Yin, Christian Soncini and Amanda Lowery Electrical and Computer Engineering Department, US Naval Academy, Annapolis 21402, MD USA
Received: August 21, 2012 / Accepted: August 22, 2012 / Published: February 28, 2013.
Abstract: For many years now electrical engineering students at the US Naval Academy have been involved in renewal energy types of projects, including electric boats and cars, and have participated in various competitions across the US. Of particular interest to the authors is the electric car, since it involves various aspects of electrical engineering. As part of their senior capstone project, and under the authors guidance and supervision, four students designed, built, and tested the power generation and distribution system, the motor control system for an electric car. This was accomplished by converting an originally gas-powered car into a battery-powered car, whereby solar panels are used to recharge the batteries. Towards this end, a mix of off the shelf parts and components, and homebuilt circuits were used. The design considerations include selecting an appropriate control system, choosing suitable batteries, utilizing solar panels to recharge the batteries, designing the lighting system for the vehicle, and implementing several key safety features, including an emergency shut-off switch.
Key words: Electric cars, batteries, solar panels, DC-DC conversion, DC motor control.
1. Introduction
As early as the 1830s, engineers and inventors have experimented with utilizing electric motors and battery systems as a means of powering vehicles [1-2]. These vehicles are known to have very low acoustic noise as well as zero emissions. Though they have existed for a very long time and competed favorably with the highly inefficient combustion engine vehicles, the latter gained the upper hand because of the limitations of the batteries. These included inadequate capacity, long charging time, high replacement cost, reduced passenger and cargo space, as well as a short driving range [3]. With the ever increasing cost of gasoline, the use of modern day road vehicles is constantly becoming an economic burden. With most gasoline powered vehicles, every mile driven is about 36 cents; comparatively the cost of an electric car is under 10 cents per mile [3]. Nearly 85% of people in the United
Corresponding author: Louiza Sellami, associate professor, research fields: circuits and systems, signal processing, biomedical engineering, power. E-mail: sellami@usna.edu. States own and operate motor vehicles. This number is projected to increase, along with the number of owners in other large countries. Because of this increase the world faces many growing economic and environmental problems. In the US alone, 18 million barrels of oil are consumed daily by driving cars, which emit 2.7 billion tons of carbon dioxide each year [1]. With dwindling supplies of fossil fuels and increasing environmental backlash from greenhouse gasses, the world needs to find an alternative to the conventional motor vehicle. In recent years there has been a resurgence of battery and solar powered electric vehicles which was brought about by the issues mentioned above, and the ensuing government regulations in terms of limiting carbon emissions. With this resurgence came great advancements in the research and development of deep cycle batteries, battery chargers, MOSFET motor controllers, DC-DC converters and sensors [4-5]. In turn, this led to the inclusion of concepts and designs from the green energy field in university curricula, including the US Naval Academy. This paper presents the design method and Power System Design for an Electric Car
179 considerations for building a battery-powered budget car, whereby the batteries are recharged by solar panels, as well as the test results. Examples of design constraints include: The charging time for the batteries was limited to an acceptable ratio of charge versus discharge. The amount of money spent on the project had to be within the prescribed budget of under $5,000. The car must be able to attain a reasonable mileage and speed. Finally, the design must consider the safety of the user during the operation and charging of the car. Other design considerations include selecting an appropriate control system, choosing a suitable battery, utilizing solar cells to recharge the batteries, designing the lighting system of the vehicle, and implementing several safety features, including an emergency shut-off switch. 2. Considerations and Requirements As part of the design, first the requirements (listed below) for the car had to be defined. Some of these requirements were dictated by the US Naval Academy, others by the budget constraints: (1) An ideal distance of 40 m per charge; (2) Under a budget of $5,000 (3) Ability to power the lights of the car using the power system; (4) The max sustainable weight of the chassis is 400lbs; (5) The control system must have an acceleration of 5 mph/s and a speed limit of 25 m/h; (6) The solar cell charge time for 80% of the battery capacity of 8 h; (7) The wall outlet charge time for 80% of the battery capacity of 3 h; (8) An emergency shut off switch for safety. 3. Design Overview An overview of the chassis structure is shown in Fig. 1. The motor used in the vehicle is the D&D ES-3336-48 VDC series wound single shaft, which is placed in the rear end of the chassis, as shown in Fig.2.The motor is powered by ten 12V lead acid batteries, which are placed above the motor. The batteries are connected to the other components of the chassis such as the speedometer, the temperature gauge, the controllers, and the lights. In order to charge the batteries, two solar panels are attached to the batteries at a separate station. The system that is used to control the vehicle is the All Trax programmable DC motor controller, which is shown in Fig. 3. The controller, powered by the batteries, has inputs for the accelerator pedal and the batteries and an output to the motor. Its function is to vary the motor power depending on how hard the
Fig. 1 Overall view of the budget volt car.
Fig. 2 Rear of the chassis showing the motor.
Power System Design for an Electric Car
180
Fig. 3 All Trax programmable DC motor controller.
acceleration pedal is pressed, which is attached to a potentiometer. A block diagram for the whole system is shown in Fig. 4. The corresponding circuit schematic, illustrating the primary and secondary power loops, is shown in Fig. 5. The major components of the vehicle are the motor, the charging unit, the batteries, the solar cells and the controller, which are encased in the chassis structure. The lead acid battery was chosen as the most suitable battery for the vehicle for its light weight and affordable cost. It is also the safest option. Other design alternatives were nickel metal hydride and lithium ion batteries; however, both types presented problems for the safety of the car and were not within the budget. Lithium-Iron batteries were also not chosen because there is a greater chance they will become overcharged and start a fire. 3.1 Chassis The original chassis of the car was used. All of the components are mounted on the chassis whose specifications are shown in Table 1. 3.2 Motor As with any car, propulsion requires a prime mover, which in this case is the DC motor. The latter converts the electrical energy provided by the batteries into mechanical torque. The Motor D&D ES-33 36-48 VDC series wound 7/8 single shaft, shown in Fig. 6, is used. It is 6.7 in diameter and 11.53 long, and weighs approximately 57l bs. It can output from 5 Hp at 36 V to 7.2 Hp at 48 V and can handle a current of 135-140 A. However, for the design it was found that
Fig. 4 Block diagram for the budget volt, illustrating the major systems, and the inputs and outputs for those systems.
Fig. 5 Circuit schematic of the power system, distribution, and instrumentation. Power System Design for an Electric Car
there was no need to go higher than 24 V as preliminary experimental results determined that at 16 V the car moved at the target speed.
3.3 DC Motor Controller A DC motor controller in an electric car can be compared to a carburetor or fuel injection system in a gas powered car. It is a device that controls the output power of the motor by controlling the input power drawn from the batteries. By stepping up the amount of voltage and current available to the motor it controls the speed of the motor and how quickly the motor can attain this power [6]. The All Trax programmable DC motor controller used is a durable, high tech DC motor controller. It has the advantages of being waterproof, corrosion-proof, vibration proof, and is fully programmable. Performance characteristics that can be programmed include: max output current, throttle response profile, acceleration rate, plug-brake current, under/over voltage cutback, high pedal disable, and throttle input type. The 4855 model whose specs are shown in Table 2 was selected. 3.4 Contactor Because a large amount of power is used by the electric motor and the accessories there is a need for a safe and reliable way of turning on the electrical system without either leaving the system running or reconnecting the batteries to the system. Unsafe conditions can occur as a result of a high current which can cause damage to the system, hence the use of a contactor in the design. The latter is an electromagnetic relay that, when a voltage of 12 V is applied across the solenoid end, causes a large metal plate to shift up and create an instantaneous connection between the batteries and the rest of the electrical system. This acts as a dead mans switch as it stops the car by interrupting energy flow if anything goes wrong. The white Rogers 586 shown in Fig. 7 was selected, which is capable of carrying up to 200 Aa current that is below the current at which the car operates.
Power System Design for an Electric Car
182 Table 2 AXE controller specifications. AXE model 4855 Specs Battery voltage 24-48 V Current limit: 2 Minute rating 650 A 5 Minute rating 400 A 60 Minute rating 250 A Voltage drop @ 100 A < 0.08 V
Fig. 7 White Rodgers 586 on budget volt.
3.5 Solar Panels and Solar Controller Solar panels and solar controller serve as the charging station for the car. The two available models are the MSX120 and the SX80V. Each solar panel model specifications are shown in Table 3. The Solarex SX-80 photovoltaic module is constructed of 36 polycrystalline silicon solar cells. The cells can be utilized in configurations directly with DC loads or in an inverter-equipped system for AC loads [7]. The overall dimensions of the rain-tight structure are 19.75 in by 57.31 in. Each solar cell is rated at a maximum power output of 80 watts. The voltage at maximum power is 16.8 V and the current is rated at 4.75 A. The guaranteed minimum power output is 75 W. The short circuit current is rated at 5.17 A and the open circuit voltage is rated at 21.0 V. The solar cells are utilized in configuration with the DC load of the 24 V battery array, which is used to power the motor and the auxiliary electrical systems in the car. The solar controllers used in this project are the SunSaver SS-20L-12V and the SS-20L-24V whose specifications are listed in Table 4. The solar Table 3 Solar panel specifications. Model MSX120 SX80V Pmax 125.8 80 V (V) 17 16.8 I (I) 7.41 4.75 Voc 21..4 21 Isc 8.39 5.17
Table 4 Solar controller specifications. Model SS-20L-12V SS-20L-24V Solar rating 20 A 20 A Load rating 20 A 20 A System voltage 12 V 24 V
controller utilizes switching pulse width modulation to charge batteries. 3.6 Batteries Batteries are portable sources of electrical energy which the DC motor converts to mechanical. There are many new types of batteries that are suitable for electric vehicle application. These include lead acid, various types of nickel-based (iron, cadmium, and metal hydride), lithium-based (polymer and iron), as well as sodium-based (sulfur and metal chloride) [8-9]. However, at the present time deep cycle lead acid batteries are still the most commonly used. They have the advantage of being fully recyclable and their cost is significantly lower. As a result, the use of a standard 12 V lead acid battery was the best option. In order to design the power system, it is important to find the power needs of each of the components. Obviously, the motor uses the majority of the power, but the peripherals such as lights are also important to take into consideration. Comparing current capacity, weight and cost, a pack of 10 lead acid batteries (model: CSB-GP-12260 shown in Fig. 7) each with a weight of 18.6 lbs and a current capacity of 26 Ah. They are connected in five branches with two batteries in series per branch in order to provide 24 V each. This was done to reduce the amount of current draw from each battery, since the capacity is only 26 Ah. A is a total current of 18A is drawn, and the car runs for an hour and a half before it needs to be recharged. Power System Design for an Electric Car
183 3.7 DC-DC Power Conversion and Instrumentation A DC-DC converter is necessary in order to power the lights and the other car accessories, since the latter operate at 12 V whereas the battery pack provides 24 V. The Pyle PSWNV720 shown in Fig. 8 was chosen due to its ability to sustain a 360 W output, which low enough so that it does not reduce traction power or range of the car. It has a converse efficiency of 87%, and has several safety built-in features. To fully implement a working set of turn signals and hazard lights that blink, the use of the LM555 timer is essential. Two identical timers were designed and calibrated to have an output time of 0.808 second and a shut off time of 0.503 second. This was done by using a 2 K and a 3.3 K resistor and a 220 F capacitor as seen in Fig. 9. The first timer powers the left front and back turn signals or the right front and back turn signals, depending on how the switch is pressed. The second timer powers a relay that turns on and off, which then powers all four lights based on direct input from the DC-DC converter. This was done to overcome the output current limitations of the LM555 chip, which was not sufficient to power all four lights at the same time. To keep track of the cars electrical system, a battery meter is added that to monitor the capacity of the battery pack. The battery manager 3 by BSDesigns, which is shown in Fig. 10 was selected. It determines the remaining battery capacity by way of a DC shunt through which the load current flows. The meter measures the voltage drop across the shunt and performs a comparison in order to determine the current being used by the car, and displays it in Amp-hours. 3.8 Safety Considerations There are numerous safety devices that are integrated into the power system of the car in order to prevent accidents. Aside from the contactor and dead mans switch, fuses are placed in series within each battery branch and connecting the lights on the car.
Fig. 7 Battery pack on the rear of the budget volt.
Fig. 8 DC-DC converter mounted on the chassis.
Fig. 9 555 timer circuit used for turn signals.
Also, the additional battery and passenger weight and the effects on the brakes, axles and front suspension are considered. Battery placement so as not to change the center of gravity of the car, and the safety brackets to hold the batteries in place are another safety key design that is carefully planned. 4. Testing and Design Specs Verification There were many different stages during the testing process. During the initial stage the motor was Power System Design for an Electric Car
184
Fig. 10 Battery manager 3 (top), shunt (bottom).
Fig. 11 No load and full load test results.
physically removed from the car and powered by four batteries connected in series to determine its maximum speed. A secondary test was done with a dynamometer. This is what is called the light load test, which resulted in an average current draw of 40 A (Fig. 11). Based on the results of these preliminary tests, the decision to use a 24 V battery pack was made. Once the car was fully loaded with driver and batteries there was a much larger power draw than was expected originally. There was only an introduction of about 300 lbs but the current draw was around 120 A which is much higher compared to the increase from no load to light load. With 120 A there is a draw of 24 A from each battery pack which is about twice as much as expected. The road results were verified using a standard Garmin forerunner 410 which was used to calculate the speed of the car, in mph, and the distance that the car travelled, in miles. 5. Conclusions In this paper a mechanism for converting an originally gas-powered car to a battery-powered, whereby solar panels are used to recharge the batteries was presented. Specifically the design method and considerations were defined and explained, and the selection of the various components was discussed. Also discussed are the test results and the safety features. Acknowledgments The authors wish to acknowledge receipt of funding from NAVSEA and IWS for the project and this publication. References [1] W.J Mitchell, C.E.B. Bird, L.D. Burns, Reinventing the Automobile: Personal Urban Mobility for the 21st Century, Cambridge, MIT Press, Massachusetts, 2010. [2] C.C. Chan, The state of the art of electric, hybrid, and Power System Design for an Electric Car
185 fuel cell vehicles, Proceedings of the IEEE 95 (2007) 704-718. [3] J. Anderson, C.D. Anderson, Electric and Hybrid Cars, McFarland & Co., 2005. [4] L.A Tauber, Viability and economics of building or purchasing, in: IEEE Technical Applications Conference and Workshop Driving and Maintaining an Electric Car, 1995. [5] C.C. Chan, K.T. Chan, Modern Electric Vehicle Technology, Oxford University Press, 2001. [6] R.K. Jurgen, Electric and Hybrid Vehicles Progress in Technology, Automotive Electronics Series, Edited by Published by the Society of Automotive Engineers Inc., 2002. [7] D.R. Carroll, The winning solar car: A design guide for solar car teams, SAE International, 2003. [8] S. Leitman, B. Grant, Build Your Own Electric Vehicle, McGraw Hill, 2009. [9] S. Dhameja, Electric Vehicle Battery Systems, Newnes, 2002.