Professional Documents
Culture Documents
n
i
R Ri
1
2
or d
2
1 n
Standard Deviation =
2
HDFC:
Analysis of risk:
Year Return (R )
Avg return (R
) Deviations(R-R)
Square
deviations(R-R)
d
2
2007-08 54.3 28.74 25.564 653.52
2008-09 -28.41 28.74 -57.146 3265.67
2009-10 88.38 28.74 59.644 3557.41
2010-11 20.57 28.74 -8.166 66.68
2011-12 8.84 28.74 -19.896 395.85
Total 143.68 7939.12
Variance = 1/n-1 (d
2
) = 1/5-1 (7939.12)
= 1984.78
Standard deviation=variance
=1984.78
= 44.55
57
ICICI:
Analysis of Risk:
Year Return (R ) Avg Return (R ) Deviations(R-R)
Square
deviations(R-R)
d
2
2007-08 1.48 20.77 -19.286 371.95
2008-09 -57.77 20.77 -78.536 6167.90
2009-10 166.68 20.77 145.914 21290.90
2010-11 16.31 20.77 -4.456 19.86
2011-12 -22.88 20.77 -43.646 1904.97
Total 103.83 29755.58
Variance = 1/n-1 (d
2
) = 1/5-1 (29755.58)
= 7438.89
Risk=Standard deviation=variance
=7438.89
=86.25
Interpretation: Risk associated with the investment in long run is less for the HDFC
securities when compared to ICICI. Thus, when an investor is only considering risk factor, it
is advisable to invest in HDFC securities.
58
AVERAGE RETURN OF BOTH COMPANIES:
Interpretation: From the above table and graph it can be understood by considering both
risk and return factors that the returns are more and risk is less for HDFC securities.
44.55
86.25
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
HDFC ICICI
S
h
a
r
e
s
p
r
i
c
e
Standard deviation
Standard deviation
S.No COMPANY AVERAGE RETURN STANDARD DEVIATION
1 HDFC 28.74 44.55
2 ICICI 20.77 86.25
59
CALCULATION OF COVARIANCES
COVARIANCE = COV. AB = ([RA-RA] [RB-RB]) / N
WHERE:
RA = Return on A
RB = Return on B
RA = Expected return on A
RB = Expected return on B
N = Number of securities
COVARIANCE OF BANK SECURITIES PORTFOLIO:
Cov
A
,
B
= (r
iA
-r
A
) (r
iB
-r
B
) / n-1
HDFC & ICICI
Years DEVIATIONS OF
HDFC (RA-RA)
DEVIATIONS OF
ICICI (RB-RB)
COMBINED
DEVIATIONS
2007-08 25.564 -19.286 -493.027
2008-09 -57.146 -78.536 4488.018
2009-10 59.644 145.914 8702.895
2010-11 -8.166 -4.456 36.3877
2011-12 -19.896 -43.646 868.3808
TOTAL
13602.65
COVARIANCE (COV
AB
)
= 13602.65/5
= 2720.531
60
CALCULATION OF COEFFICIENT CORRELATION
Coefficient of Correlation
Coefficient of Correlation is a statistical technique, which measures the degree or
extent to which two or more variables fluctuate with reference to one another. Correlation
analysis helps in determining the degree of relationship between two variables but correlation
does not always imply cause and effect relationship
The Coefficient of Correlation is essentially the covariance taken not as an absolute
value but relative to the standard deviations of the individual securities. It indicates, in effect,
how much x and y vary together as a proportion of their combined individual variations,
measured by SD of x multiplied by SD of Y
Coefficient of Correlation:
ICICI AND HDFC
Correlation coefficient (P
AB
) = COV
AB
(Std.A)(Std.B)
(COV
AB
) = 13602.65 /5
= 2720.531
(P
AB
) = 2720.531
(86.25)(44.55)
= 0.70802172
61
PORTFOLIO COMPANY S.D
COVARI
ANCE
COMBINED S.D
(Std.A)(Std.B)
CO-EF.
CORRELATION
(COV/C.S.D)
I.
HDFC 44.55
2720.531
3842.44
0.70802172
ICICI 86.25
CONCLUSION FOR CORRELATION:
In case of perfectly correlated securities or stocks, the risk can be reduced to a minimum
point. In case of negatively correlated securities, the risk can be reduced to a zero (which is
companys risk) but market risk prevails the same for the securities or stock in the portfolio.
Interpretation:
In case of portfolio management, negatively correlated assets are most profitable. In the
above calculated correlation, the companies correlation is 0.7080, which means both these
combinations of portfolios are at a good position to gain in future. So, the investor may
invest their money for long run.
62
BETA VALUES
SENSEX:
Years Price Returns (R
)
(In %)
Average
returns ( R
)
( R- R)
(R R)
2
2007-2008 16371.29 - - - -
2008-2009 9568.14 -41.555 10.095 -51.6504 2667.761
2009-2010 17590.17 83.841 10.095 73.74606 5438.481
2010-2011 19290.18 9.665 10.095 -0.43045 0.185291
2011-2012 17058.61 -11.568 10.095 -21.6634 469.304
Total 40.383 8575.731
Standard Deviation = Variance
Variance = 1/ (n-1) (R-R)
= 1/ (4-1) (8575.731)
= 1/3(8575.731)
= 2858.57
Standard Deviation = 2858.57
= 53.465
63
Correlation between Sensex and HDFC:
Date Deviations of sensex
D
sensex
= (R-R)
Deviations of
HDFC
D
HDFC
= (R-R)
Combined
Deviations
D
sensex
D
HDFC
2007-2008 - - -
2008-2009 -51.650 -57.146 2951.59
2009-2010 73.746 59.644 4398.50
2010-2011 -0.430 -8.166 3.5113
2011-2012 -21.663 -19.896 431.00
Total 7784.61
Correlation between Sensex and ICICI:
Date Deviations of sensex
D
sensex
= (R-R)
Deviations of
ICICI
D
ICICI
= (R-R)
Combined
Deviations
D
sensex
D
ICICI
2007-2008 - - -
2008-2009 -51.650 -78.536 4056.384
2009-2010 73.746 145.914 10760.57
2010-2011 -0.430 -4.456 1.91
2011-2012 -21.663 -43.646 945.50
Total 15764.38
64
Calculation of Beta Values:
= COV
AB
/ m
2
Where COV
AB
= 1/ n-1 (D1D2)
m
2
= Variance
sensex
1. HDFC:-
= COV
sensex, HDFC
/Variance
sensex
COV
sensex, HDFC
= 1/ 4-1 (7784.61)
= 2594.87
Variance
sensex
= 2858.57
= 2594.87/ 2858.57
= 0.907
2. ICICI:-
= COV
sensex, ICICI
/Variance
sensex
COV
sensex, ICICI
= 1/ 4-1 (15764.38)
= 5254.793
Variance
sensex
= 2858.57
= 5254.793/ 2858.57
= 1.83
65
Calculated Beta Values:
COMPANY NAME BETA VALUE
HDFC 0.907
ICICI 1.838
CONCEPT OF BETA:
It is a measure of movement of share price with the movement of market.
Beta is positive, if share price moves in the direction of the movement of market.
Beta is negative, if share price moves opposite to the direction of market.
Table Depicting All Calculated Values:
ICICI HDFC
Average returns 20.77 28.74
Standard deviation 86.25 44.55
Covariance 2720.531 2720.531
Coefficient correlation 0.708 0.708
Beta 1.838 0.907
66
HDFC Bank
Interpretation: From the above table by considering the opening and closing values it can be
clearly stated that almost in 4 years the share value is increasing whereas only in 2008-09
share price has reduced.
Profit/Loss:
Interpretation: From the above table it can be clearly stated that investor has enjoyed more
profits in 2009-10 and bears loss in 2008-09 as the opening and closing share values
fluctuate.
186
264
202.4
387.8
469.22
286.99
189
381.28
467.57
510.7
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
S
h
a
r
e
s
p
r
i
c
e
Years
Opening and closing values
opening
closing
100.99
-75
178.88
79.77
41.48
-100
-50
0
50
100
150
200
1 2 3 4 5
S
h
a
r
e
s
P
r
i
c
e
Years
Profit/loss
Profit/loss
67
Maximum Profit:
Interpretation: From the above table it can be stated that with the fluctuations in the opening
value and highest share price, 2009-10 is the most profitable year for the investor.
Maximum Loss:
Interpretation: From the above table by considering the difference between opening value
and lowest share price, it can be stated that in 2008-09 there was huge loss to investors.
179
51
184.83
115.8
68.28
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
1 2 3 4 5
S
h
a
r
e
s
P
r
i
c
e
Years
Maximum profit
Maximum profit
4
-109.2
-3.9
-30.8
-68.77
-120
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
20
2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
S
h
a
r
e
s
p
r
i
c
e
Years
Maximum loss
Maximum loss
68
ICICI bank
Interpretation: From the above table by considering the opening and closing values it can be
clearly stated that in the year 2007-08 there was a slight change in the market share value and
in 2008-09 the share value decreased to Rs.462.1 whereas in 2009-10 it again increased by
Rs.600.05. In 2010-11 it increased by Rs.155.25 and again fell down by Rs.253.95 in 2011-
12. If the investor is ready to bear more risk then, 2009-10 is favorable year with high returns.
823 799.95
360
952
1110
835.2
337.85
960.05
1107.25
856.05
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
S
h
a
r
e
s
p
r
i
c
e
Years
Opening and Closing values
opening value
closing value
69
Profit/Loss
Interpretation: From the above table it can be clearly stated that investor can enjoy more
profits in 2009-10 and bear high loss in 2008-09 as the opening and closing share values
fluctuate.
Maximum Profit
Interpretation: From the above table it can be stated that with the fluctuations in the opening
value and highest share price, 2007-08 is the most profitable year for the investor.
12.2
-462.1
600.05
155.25
-253.95
-600
-400
-200
0
200
400
600
800
2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 S
h
a
r
e
s
P
r
i
c
e
Years
Profit/loss
Profit/loss
642
160.95
608.5
325
27.9
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
S
h
a
r
e
s
p
r
i
c
e
Years
Maximum profit
Maximum profit
70
Maximum Loss
Interpretation: From the above table by considering the difference between opening value
and lowest share price, it can be stated that 2008-09 is most unfavorable year for the investor
with huge loss.
-103
-547.2
30.6
-143.9
-469
-600
-500
-400
-300
-200
-100
0
100
2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12
S
h
a
r
e
s
p
r
i
c
e
Years
Maximum loss
Maximum loss
71
CHAPTER 4:
FINDINGS
AND
SUGGESTIONS
72
FINDINGS:
As far as the returns of the selected companies is concerned, HDFC is
comparatively performing well in isolation where as ICICI is performing very
poor.
As far as the Standard deviation of the selected companies is concerned, ICICI
is very high where as HDFC is giving less risk. This means that higher the
risk, the higher the returns.
As far as the Correlation co-efficient of ICICI and HDFC is concerned, it is
0.7080.
The covariance of the ICICI and HDFC is 2720.531.
The systematic risk (Beta) of HDFC is 0.907.
The systematic risk (Beta) of ICICI is 1.838.
73
SUGGESTIONS:
The investor should consider the securities with maximum returns and minimum risk. Thus, it
is advisable to invest in HDFC securities.
Investors should hold securities which give high returns with less risk.
As an investor, see that there is a negative correlation among the securities.
Do not relay completely on technical analysis.
Investors should give importance to fundamental analysis of securities.
Industrial policy also has a major role in facilitating the growth of the economy.
Holding two or more securities reduce the unsystematic risk.
74
CONCLUSIONS:
In the recent past the market has reached great heights as a result of expansion of business
and much more of globalization, the increased percentage of Foreign Direct Investment
which has a direct affect on the demand and supply of the shares of a particular company. In
this way the index of the stock market has reached to the maximum. With the boom in the
market there are many investors who are willing to take more risk and so to cover the risk.
Financial sector is booming and the need for Risk-Return Analysis is growing. Also because
of the very tricky stock market behaviors it has become mandatory to manage portfolio so as
to reduce the risk while maximizing the returns. Taking into consideration the investors risk-
return requirements portfolio should be constructed and reviewed regularly.
75
CHAPTER: 6
BIBLIOGRAPHY
76
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Book References:
1. Financial management
- M Y Khan and P K Jain
2. Investments
- William F. Sharpe, Gordon J.Alexander & Jeffery V. Baily
3. Security Analysis and Portfolio Management
- Prasanna Chandra
4. GRIET Library
Web References:
www.nseindia.com
www.moneycontrol.com
www.indiamart.com
www.google.com
www.ventural.com