Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Debate Topics
Sociology
- The government should not spend money on the Olympics because it takes money away from more
important social causes.
- The Canadian Monarchy should be abolished.
Psychology
Anthropology
2. As a general rule, I don't think that I would ever engage the entire class in a formal debate. I think
that it would be impossible to ensure that each member participated in a meaningful way, that the
structure of a formal debate could be followed in the 50 or so minutes allotted to a class period, or that
arguments and rebuttals could be thorough and well-prepared. I would much prefer to use the U-
shaped discussion for a whole class, where students situate themselves in the U shape according to their
initial position. One arm of the U is pro, the other is con and the middle section is undecided. Students
are encouraged to move around the U as their opinions change throughout the discussion. I think this
fosters thoughtful group dialogue where people's opinions are valued, the students aren't pitted against
each other but rather are able to try to persuade one another using reasoned arguments.
3. Debate Rules
5. In order to assess the debates I would use a rubric, given to the students well in advance of the
actual debate. The audience members would each be assigned a team to assess during the debate. I
would ask that each team prepare four strong arguments to support their position, and to research the
opposing position in order to prepare rebuttals to likely arguments. I would also collect all of the
research done by the teams, including a list of sources, in order to assess how much each team member
contributed to the overall preparation for the debate. Obviously some students will be more
comfortable talking in front of the class than others and so it would be important to assess the
preparation work done. I would leave it up to the teams to decide how to divide the work as long as
they agree and it is an equitable division of labour. Students will be accountable for their learning in
that they will be required to hand in their research and to complete a rubric assessing their own
performance during the debate.
Rubric