Saudi Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume21, No. 3, July September 2007
Review Article Low Vision Rehabilitation and Diabetic Retinopathy Sarfaraz A. Khan, MD Abstract Diabetic retinopathy is emerging as a major cause of blindness. Diabetic retinopathy calls for a multidisciplinary to the patients. Management of the patient requires a team work by the internist, diabetologist, dietician, oph- thalmologist and low vision therapist. Diabetic retinopathy very often results in vision loss. It is important for ophthalmologists to recognize the importance of low vision rehabilitation in formulating appropriate treatment strategies. People with vision loss due to diabetic retinopathy usually experience difficulty in daily life. Most people with diabetic retinopathy (who have remaining useful vision) can be helped with low vision devices. However, often one low vision device may not be suitable for all purposes. A comprehensive low vision evalua- tion is required to assess the persons current visual status, identify the goals and visual needs, and then design an individualized vision rehabilitation program to meet these needs. Key Words: diabetic retinopathy, vision loss, low vision rehabilitation L ow Vision is a bilateral impairment of vision that significantly reduces the functioning of the indi- vidual and cannot be adequately corrected with medi- cal or surgical therapy, conventional eyewear or con- tact lenses. The World Health Organization (WHO) estimates that more than 180 million people world- wide have diabetes. This figure is likely to more than double by 2030. 1 There is a high potential for vision loss in persons with diabetes, and approximately two- thirds of diabetics are likely to have vision loss after 35 years of diabetes. Diabetic retinopathy very often re- sults in low vision and it is 25 times more likely to lead to blindness than other conditions. 2 Low vision rehabilitation services do not curelow vision; rather, they utilize the remaining vision to its fullest potential. Low vision does not replace the need for other concurrent treatments such as surgery or medi- cal care. Diabetic Retinopathy 3 Diabetes is unique in that it can cause visual loss in all three categories-media opacity, central field loss and peripheral field loss. Diabetics are at greater risk of developing other eye diseases, including cataract and glaucoma. Risk of heart disease, stroke and neuropa- thy also add more complexity to their treatment and vision rehabilitation. There are several ways that dia- betes contributes to visual dysfunction: Cloudy Media in Diabetes RefractiveChanges: Fluctuating blood sugars cause the lens to swell, resulting significant changes in refrac- tive error. This is a common problem before the initial diagnosis, and patients may notice frequent changes in their prescriptions in a matter of days or weeks. Once sugars are controlled, this is usually not a problem, but occasionally patients report ongoing fluctuations in vi- sion. While annoying, this does not, itself, cause irre- versible damage. Patients should be advised to have re- peated refractions and not to change their glasses until blood sugars have been stabilized for months. Vitreous Hemorrhage: Retinal ishemia causes neovascularization that can lead to vitreous hemorrhage. Correspondence to Sarfaraz A. Khan, MD, Dirctor, Low Vision Services, Ebsar Foundation, PO Box 4573, Jeddah 21412, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Telephone: +966-2-2830001 Ext. 1603; Fax +966-2-2832265; Email: sarfaraz@ebsar.org, sarfarazkhan.sak@gmail.com 162 Saudi Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume21, No. 3, July September 2007 Mild to severe hemorrhages can occur that obstruct vision by causing cloudy media. The blood may clear by itself with time, or a vitrectomy may be required to remove it. Central Vision Loss Macular Edema: Leaking blood vessels in the macula can cause retinal swelling and permanent dam- age to photoreceptors. Central vision is blurred, and a relative scotoma results. Edema may wax and wane, causing fluctuating vision. Treatment involves laser photocoagulation to stop leakage and preserve vision, although some patients do experience an improvement as well. Laser scars in the macula may affect both acu- ity and contrast sensitivity. Further more all patients with macular edema do not necessarily develop im- proved vision following treatment. Peripheral Vision Loss Retinal Detachment: In severe cases of prolifera- tive diabetic retinopathy, tractional retinal detachments may occur and cause complete blindness if left un- treated. Treatment in these cases is very difficult. Panretinal photocoagulation, although necessary, may affect vision as well. Decreased peripheral retinal sen- sitivity may result, causing poor peripheral vision, de- creased contrast sensitivity and possible mobility prob- lems at night. People with low vision due to diabetic retinopathy usually experience loss of sharpness or acu- ity, but may present with a loss of field of vision, light sensitivity, loss of contrast and metamorphopsia. Visual Problems A person with low vision due to diabetic retin- opathy usually experience difficulty in daily life. They may see dark spots or have restricted side vision due to decreased contrast sensitivity as a result of scatter laser treatment, which prevents them from being indepen- dent. Laser surgery may also slightly reduce your color and night vision. Some common problem areas are: 1. Seeing faces or reading bus numbers from a dis- tance 2. Reading fine newsprint, mails, or bills 3. Writing in a straight line 4. Reading low contrast material 5. Increased intolerance to light 6. Inability to move about alone outdoor after dusk 7. Locating food in a plate 8. Seeing the time on a wristwatch 9. Differentiating between coinsof similar dimensions 10. Seeing in dim illumination Low Vision Management Special problems unique to diabetes patients are the following: 1. Reading insulin syringe and medicine labels 2. Loss of tactile sensation leading to difficulty with learning Braille. 3. Insulin dependent diabetic patients may go into hypoglycemia due to stress during rehabilitation program mobility training or learning to use devices. Hence the training program should be in short sessions with frequent intervals.4 4. Diabetic patients are prone to injury to feet due to bumping in reduced illumination and poor contrast. Enhancing Impaired Vision Impaired vision can be enhanced in a variety of ways. Magnification isthe most obviousand common method. Improving the lighting not only adds to the effective- ness of magnification but also enhances contrast. The progressive nature of the disease and the effects of ongo- ing treatment influence the prescription of low vision optical devices. Ideally prescription should be postponed until some stability is achieved. However, one should not neglect the patients needs. The biggest disservice is to continually postpone help because vision may im- prove or another treatment may be planned by the oph- thalmologist. Patients should understand that the na- ture of their fluctuations and progression may require frequent follow-up and optical device change. Low Vision Evaluation Briefly, low vision evaluation includes history, re- fraction, functional vision assessment, determination of magnification and prescription of devices, regular follow-up and finally making appropriate referrals to other services if required. The relevant rehabilitation services include instructions in device use, activities of daily tasks, orientation and mobility, patient educa- tion, counseling, educational and vocational guidance. Prescribing Low Vision Devices Asa rule, expensive optical devicesare not prescribed for the diabetic with proliferative retinopathy, particu- larly if there is a history of recurrent hemorrhages. The good news is that most people with diabetic retinopathy (who have remaining useful vision) can be helped with low vision devices such as spectacle devices, stand mag- nifiers, hand magnifiers, absorptive lenses, adaptive de- vices like closed circuit television systems (CCTV), com- puter software magnification and screen readersand non- 163 Saudi Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume21, No. 3, July September 2007 optical devices. However, these patients also needed counseling for adjustment to the vision loss and instruc- tional training in independent living. Optical Devices 4-7 SpectacleMagnifiers (Figure1A & 1B) Patientswith moderate vision lossmay benefit from binocular half-eye prism glasseswith base-in to aid in con- vergence or simple low add spectacle devicesin powersof 6 or 8 diopters. Patientswho have undergone photoco- agulation may achieve periodsof relatively stable vision and may be given moderate addsto use during their re- missions. It must be recognized that patientswith macu- lar edema may require repeated photocoagulation treat- mentsasnew microaneurysmsand intraretinal microvas- cular abnormalitiesmay develop. Furthermore, all patients with macular edema do not necessarily develop improved vision following treatment. Spectacle devicesconsist of convex high power lenses(lenticular design); the reading material hasto be held close to the face at the focal dis- tance of the lens. The major advantage isthat they are psychologically more acceptable and ideal for long term reading tasks. The disadvantage isthat some patientsare not comfortable with the close/ fixed reading distance and difficult to use in patientswith eccentric viewing. Hand Magnifier (Figure2A) Hand magnifier also uses convex lenses mounted with a handle are useful for short-term reading tasks. They are generally inexpensive and readily available in the market. However, they may be slow and uncom- fortable for prolonged reading and less effective for pa- tients with limited dexterity or with hand tremors. FoldablePocket Magnifier (Figure2B) Foldable pocket magnifier are useful for spot read- Figure 1A and B. Spectacle Magnifiers Figure 2A. Hand magnifiers; B, Pocket magnifiers 164 Saudi Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume21, No. 3, July September 2007 ing, such as bills, medicine or price labels during shop- ping they are easy to carry. Stand Magnifier (Figure3) Stand magnifier isa fixed focusconvex lenson a rigid mount stand set by the manufacturer to focuscloser to the page than itsfocal distance to reduce peripheral aber- ration. Most stand magnifiersare designed for use with standard bifocal and/or reading glasses. They are useful for patientswith hand tremorsand in patientswith con- stricted visual field asthey provide greater stability. DistanceTelescopes (Figure4) As per our experience the distance vision telescopes are rarely preferred in diabetic patients and this could be due to cosmetic blemish. They could be prescribed as hand held or spectacle mounted. GlareControl Devices (Figure5) Glare is distracting scattered light, which is a sig- nificant problem for patients with low vision. Glare Figure 3. Stand magnifiers Figure 4. Distance telescope Figure 5. Filters can be controlled with devices such as sun wear or ab- sorptive filters, tints and ultraviolet and anti- reflective coatings. Electronic Magnification Closed Circuit Television (CCTV)(Figure 6) CCTV provides maximum contrast and uses a cam- era to capture the image and project it on to a television screen. The magnification can be as high as 60 times Non-optical Devices (Figure 7) Patients with diabetic retinopathy have impaired contrast sensitivity, which resultsin problemsin activities of daily living. Simple contrast enhancing measureslike non-optical devicescan help diabetic patientsto overcome these problems. Non-optical devicesdo not use lensesbut improve viewing conditionsthrough bright illumination and contrast. Some devicesunder thiscategory are: 1. Reading Stands are better for the posture as most optical devices have to be held at a short reading distance. Figure 6. Closed circuit television 165 Saudi Journal of Ophthalmology, Volume21, No. 3, July September 2007 Figure 7. Non-optical devices 2. Reading lamps improve the contrast and pro- vide focused illumination 3. Felt-tip pens have dark and thick writing that improves the contrast. 4. Letter writers enable a person to write in a straight line. 5. Signature guides enable a person to sign prop- erly. 6. A notex enables a person to differentiate between currency of various denominations. 7. Reading guide / Typoscope helps patients in lo- calizing the text. Computer Software Magnification and Screen Readers Individuals that are visually impaired wanting to use computers can use innovative softwares such as computer magnification software (Zoom text, Magic 8.0) and screen readers (Jaws, Kurzweil) so that they do not have to depend on vision. Non-visual Devices and Adaptive Techniques Sensesother than vision are used to perform daily activities. Examplesof non-visual devicesinclude talking books, tape recorders, talking wrist watchesand calcula- tors, folding and support canes, and tactile markings. Viewing Techniques Eccentric viewing or looking at the side of an ob- ject instead of directly is an adapted viewing useful. Orientation and Mobility Training Many people with diabetic retinopathy find it dif- ficult to navigate independently, especially in unfamil- iar areas. This is especially true of people who have undergone extensive panretinal photocoagulation. They can be taught to use the cane so that they need not depend upon others. Specific Management 1. Numerous insulin-loading devices are available to help insulin-dependent patients with low vi- sion. Large-print and talking blood glucose monitors are available and most no longer re- quire color matching. 2. Protective shoes 3. Control of Blood Sugar: Regular follow-up with physician and ophthalmologist. Most often one low vision device may not be suitable for all pur- poses. A comprehensive low vision evaluation is required to assesses the persons current visual status, identify the goals and visual needs, and then design an individualized rehabilitation pro- gram to meet these needs. Tips & Tricks Use the lowest possible magnification to solve the required visual task. Select the design of the low vision device (i.e., hand-held, stand, etc.) appropriate to the vi- sual task. Different low vision devicesneed to be used for different visual tasks. No single low vision device can of- fer a solution for all eye conditionsand all visual tasks. REFERENCES 1. King H, Aubert RE, Herman WH. Global bur- den of diabetes, 1995-2025: prevalence, numeri- cal estimates and projections. Diabetes Care 1998; 21:1414-1431. 2. Klein R, Klein BEK, Moss SE. Visual impair- ment in Diabetes. Ophthalmology 1984; 91:1- 9. 3. Eleanor E. Faye, Darren Lee Albet, Benjamin Freed, Karen R. Seidman, Michael Fischer. A new look at Low vision care. Lighthouse Inter- national 2000; 4:44-45. 4. Faye EE, ed: Clinical Low Vision. 2nd ed. Bos- ton: Little Brown & Co; 1984. 5. Eaglestin A, Rapaport S: Prediction of low vi- sion aid usage. J Visual Impair Blindness 1991; 85:31-33. 6. Fonda GE: Designing half-eye binocular spec- tacle magnifier. Surv Ophthalmol 1991; 36:149- 154. 7. Fonda GE: Optical treatment of impaired vision. J Visual Impair Blindness 1992; 86:86- 88.